Profile ID: OT26_BRYAN_MCDONNEL_NEWCASTLE_1707. Status: supported_documentary.
This tree includes proposed relationships as well as established ones. Link confidence scores are research assessments, not calibrated statistical probabilities. A person in the directory may be a research candidate rather than an ancestor. Family roots describe historical context, not additional biological parents.
Sources: Bryan McDonnel, New Castle will calendar, 1707; Frank V. McDonald, Contributions to the early history of Bryan McDonald and family (1879); Bryan McDonald will abstract, 21 May / 18 August 1757
Family roots: McDonnel
Historical context, not a parent.
Red Clay Creek, New Castle County, Delaware
The traceable line reaches Bryan McDonnel, whose New Castle estate was proved in 1707. Published land and inheritance transcripts connect him to Red Clay Creek and to his son Bryan, but the European origin remains disputed. A later pedigree names Alexander MacDonnell of Wicklow as his father; the sources examined do not yet distinguish that proposed family from the competing Scottish-origin tradition.
The strongest early geographical anchor is the New Castle landholding described below. Irish and Scottish accounts may preserve part of the family’s migration history, but their conflicting dates prevent treating either narrative as an established biography.
meaning: McDonnell is an English-language form of Gaelic Mac Domhnaill, a patronymic meaning son of Domhnall. The personal name combines elements referring to the world and rule.
origins: The surname dictionary describes McDonnell as Irish and compares the Scottish form McDonald. Both spellings belong to the wider Gaelic naming tradition. This linguistic background cannot identify Bryan’s birthplace or the route by which his family reached Delaware.
associations: The Delaware family appears as McDonnel in the will calendar and as MacDonald or MaccDonald in the published land transcript. Searches for this branch therefore need both the -donnel and -donald forms.
Bryan’s Red Clay Creek land, 1689–1706 — 18 November 1689; 21 December 1703; 8 October 1706 — New Castle County, beside Red Clay Creek and Hide Runn — Frank V. McDonald’s 1879 history prints a grant from Penn’s Newcastle Warrants, Old Book, page 209. The instrument recites a warrant of 18 November 1689 for land later measured at 239 acres, followed by an adjoining 354 acres under a warrant of 21 December 1703. The combined 593-acre tract bordered Red Clay Creek and Hide Runn. The printed instrument is dated 8 October 1706. — The recurring name, county and estate history favor identifying this landholder with the 1707 testator. This extends the documented local history of Bryan’s own household back to 1689, rather than supplying an additional ancestral generation. — An unrelated namesake is possible, but no competing landholder was identified in the material examined. A transcription error remains possible because the surviving evidence reviewed here is the published copy, not the original warrant book. — This is the leading early record identification for the branch. The 1689 date is recited in the later instrument; the 1879 author did not locate the original 1689 warrant. The acreage establishes property ownership, not military rank or noble descent.
Arklow and Glencoe: competing origin accounts — Seventeenth century; accounts published later — Arklow, County Wicklow, Ireland; Glencoe, Scotland — The pedigree reproduced by Access Genealogy calls Bryan a lieutenant from Arklow, son of Alexander MacDonnell of Wicklow, and gives migration in 1691. Elsewhere the same compilation describes his Delaware land acquisition in 1689. The 1879 history discusses a different tradition connecting the family’s departure with the Glencoe massacre of 1692. — The Irish account identifies an actual proposed father and locality, making Alexander a specific research lead. The Scottish account preserves a possible earlier geographical association, but does not establish a parent-child connection. — The stories could combine an Irish residence with older Scottish ancestry, contain a mistaken migration year, or attach another McDonnell family’s history to the Delaware household. A later return voyage could explain activity on both sides of the Atlantic, but none is documented in the records reviewed. — The 1689 land recital is stronger chronological evidence than either later migration story. It conflicts with first arrival in 1691 and with emigration caused by the 1692 massacre; it does not exclude Irish birth or an earlier Glencoe connection. The Arklow pedigree remains a lead requiring a record that connects its Bryan or Alexander to this Delaware family.
Sources: Frank V. McDonald, Contributions to the early history of Bryan McDonald and family (1879); Bryan McDonnel, New Castle will calendar, 1707; MacDonald McDonald Family Records, reproduced by Access Genealogy; Dictionary of American Family Names: McDonnell (FamilySearch)
Sources: Bryan McDonnel, New Castle will calendar, 1707; Frank V. McDonald, Contributions to the early history of Bryan McDonald and family (1879)
New Castle will calendar B:153 names wife Mary, sons John, William, James, Bryan and Richard, and daughters Mary Dangor and Anable. The 1746/47 deed Q:221 expressly identifies Bryan junior as his son and recites inheritance of the plantation. Identification of junior with Virginia Bryan, husband of Catherine, is strongly favored but inferential; parent edge 0.82. See RN_OT26_MCDONALD_DELAWARE_VIRGINIA_BRIDGE.
Dates printed 23 February and 19 March 1707; calendar style not independently resolved. No precise birth, birthplace, wife’s maiden name, officer rank or Glencoe/Irish dynastic ancestry established.
Child: Bryan McDonald — H1: Delaware son Bryan, married to Catherine and disposing of inherited land in February 1746/47, is the Virginia Bryan married to Catherine. Explicit father/son deed recital and 1707 will, paired names, chronology and family-history migration favor H1. Hypothetical different Bryan/Catherine or later relative not observed competitors. Original Q:221 residence/marks and Virginia acquisition comparison remain best tests; confidence is ordinal, not probability.