{
  "metadata": {
    "generated_at": "2026-09-21T02:33:33.969534+00:00",
    "description": "This tree includes proposed relationships as well as established ones. Link confidence scores are research assessments, not calibrated statistical probabilities. A person in the directory may be a research candidate rather than an ancestor. Family roots describe historical context, not additional biological parents."
  },
  "people": [
    {
      "id": "I1",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I3",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I9",
      "name": "Mary Sue Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "6 Feb 1916",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, United States",
      "death_date": "30 Jun 1982",
      "death_place": "Winston-Salem, Forsyth County, North Carolina, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_HENDERSON_1930_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1982",
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_MEMORIAL",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary Sue Henderson appears with parents Edward A. and Sallie Henderson in 1930, with husband George and son David in 1940, and with George and sons David Gary and George R. in 1950. The North Carolina death index records birth 6 Feb 1916 in Virginia and death 30 Jun 1982 at Winston-Salem. The burial memorial is consistent and names spouse George Gibson Fricke.",
      "research_note": "No occupation was stated in the supplied excerpts, so none was inferred. Biographical enrichment: census evidence traces residences from War, West Virginia (1935), to East Orange (1940), and La Marque (1950).",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I10",
      "name": "George Gibson Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "11 Nov 1915",
      "birth_place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "death_date": "13 Dec 1973",
      "death_place": "Winston-Salem, Forsyth County, North Carolina, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NJ_BIRTH_1915",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1973",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1973_DEATH_BURIAL",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1950_CENSUS_OCCUPATION",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_LA_MARQUE_RESIDENCE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The New Jersey birth index records George G. Fricke born 11 Nov 1915 at East Orange. The 1940 and 1950 censuses identify his wife Mary Sue and children. His North Carolina death certificate records death 13 Dec 1973 at Winston-Salem, spouse Mary Sue Henderson, father George Fricke, and mother Florence Gibson. Biographical enrichment: the 1950 census records chemical-company operator work, while his 1973 death transcript records truck driver.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I13",
      "name": "Sallie Jane Shortt",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Shortt",
      "birth_date": "17 Apr 1894",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "death_date": "19 Jan 1974",
      "death_place": "Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_SALLY_JANE_HENDERSON_1974",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1900 census places Sallie Short in David's North Fork household with spouse Ginie and brother John E.",
      "research_note": "The original family tree identified this person as daughter of David Short and Leanna Egleton Tiney White. No occupation was stated in the available excerpts, so none was inferred. Virginia death evidence confirms birth 17 Apr 1894, death 19 Jan 1974, spouse Edward Henderson, and parents David K Shortt and Tiny White. Biographical evidence: census evidence documents North Fork in 1900 and Big Creek in 1930. Child identity is strong, but exact birth details remain to be established.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I14",
      "name": "Edward Alderson Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "17 Mar 1885",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "death_date": "8 Mar 1964",
      "death_place": "Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1885_1964",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1964",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Existing GEDCOM child of Conley Henderson and Rebecca Talley.",
      "research_note": "Edward/Eddie remains canonical; Edgar is treated as an index variant. Matthew previously supplied the profile identity Edward \"Eddie\" Alderson Henderson, 1885-1964; Henderson Family 1 independently names Edward Alderson as Conley's child. Biographical evidence: the 1930 Big Creek household is documented, but its supplied excerpt omits occupation. Virginia death evidence supplies exact dates 17 Mar 1885 and 8 Mar 1964, spouse Sally Jane Shortt, and parents Conley Henderson and Rebeccah Talley. Exact dates and places remain to be sourced. Coal work is not inferred merely from residence in McDowell County. No identified military service or court proceeding was established.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I15",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I18",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I21",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I16",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I27",
      "name": "George Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "28 Mar 1881",
      "birth_place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "death_date": "22 Mar 1942",
      "death_place": "Newark, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PRESBYTERIAN_JOHANN_GEORG_FRICKE_BAPTISM_1881",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_1920_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_1930_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_BURIAL",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1924",
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1929"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Presbyterian baptism records Johann Georg Fricke, born 28 Mar 1881 and baptized 27 Nov 1881 at Orange, as son of Heinrich Fricke and Katharina Schaaf. George appears with wife Florence and children in the 1920-1940 East Orange censuses. The 1924 entry describes a plumbing, heating, and tinning contracting business.",
      "research_note": "Memorial evidence reports death 22 Mar 1942 at Newark. Biographical evidence: 1924 and 1929 city directories directly document plumbing work and changing East Orange addresses. The church record supersedes the earlier indirect sibling-based parent inference.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I28",
      "name": "Florence Gibson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gibson",
      "birth_date": "14 May 1891",
      "birth_place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "death_date": "8 Mar 1960",
      "death_place": "Hackensack, Bergen County, New Jersey, USA",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_NY_PASSENGER_JOHN_GILSON_FLORENCE_GIBSON",
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_NC_DEATH_CERT_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NAMES_FLORENCE",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1891_1960",
        "SRC_NEWSPAPERS_OBITUARY_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1960",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "She appears with George Fricke in East Orange in 1920, 1930, and 1940. The 1920 census reports arrival in 1910, impossible if the 1911 Irish census identity is correct; the 1930 census reports 1920, impossible because son George was born in East Orange in Nov 1915.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I29",
      "name": "Albert Russell Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "1919",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1944",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1920 and 1930 censuses list Albert R. Fricke as a child of George and Florence; the 1940 census lists Russell Frecke in the same family while Albert is absent. Household and age continuity support Albert Russell Fricke as one person using his middle name Russell.",
      "research_note": "The original family tree reported Albert Fricke, born 1919 and died 1944. Exact vital records remain desirable.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I33",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I7",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I38",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I25",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I31",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I39",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I41",
      "name": "Alfreda Margaret Elizabeth Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "18 Apr 1910",
      "birth_place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "30 May 1990",
      "death_place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ALFREDA_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_BIRTH_1910",
        "SRC_ALFREDA_RHEAD_PROBATE_DEATH_1990",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "No source-backed occupation was located. Canonical name remains Alfreda M Davies until a birth or baptism record resolves the full middle name. A dependent entry in Alfred Percy Davies's service file gives 17 Apr 1910 and is retained as a one-day conflict. Civil birth, 1939 register, civil death, and probate evidence resolve her full name as Alfreda Margaret Elizabeth Davies, born 18 Apr 1910 and died 30 May 1990 at Shrewsbury. Biographical enrichment: census and probate evidence documents Shrewsbury-area residence and a 1990 Birmingham probate grant.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I42",
      "name": "John Edgar Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "1 Jan 1909",
      "birth_place": "Wellington, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "16 May 1975",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "1911 England Census at Glen Villas, Little Stretton: John Edgar Rhead, age 2, son of Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead, born Wellington, Shropshire. The 1921 census again names him in the family. Biographical enrichment: childhood residences are documented at Little Stretton in 1911 and St Chad in 1921.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I44",
      "name": "Kezia Thomas",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Thomas",
      "birth_date": "about 1882",
      "birth_place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEBMD_KEZIA_THOMAS_BIRTH_Q3_1882",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_DAVIES_KEZIA_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_1907",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "FreeBMD records Kezia in Atcham Q3 1882. Her later marriage and 1911/1921 households are independently established.",
      "research_note": "The previously stored 1948 death remains unsupported and removed. The 1891 Shrewsbury household names Kizzie, age 8, as a child of John and Jane; the 1901 household explicitly lists Kezia, 18, with the same parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1921,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I45",
      "name": "Alfred Percy Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "16 Oct 1883",
      "birth_place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "24 Dec 1943",
      "death_place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_1883_1943",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BIRTH_1883",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_DAVIES_KEZIA_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_1907",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BAPTISM_1883",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_PROBATE_1944",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_WW1_NAMESAKE_EXCLUSION"
      ],
      "source_note": "Alfred Percy Davies was born 16 Oct 1883 and registered Q4 1883 in Atcham. Later records identify wife Kezia and occupation plumber/hot water fitter. Probate records death 24 Dec 1943 and grant at Chester on 28 Nov 1944.",
      "research_note": "He appears with Frederick and Maria as Alfred L age 7 in 1891 and Alfred S age 17 in 1901; conflicting initials L and S are retained as census/index discrepancies and do not replace the independently supported Percy. Because Alfred was an adult householder when the 1911 census directly recorded plumber and hot-water fitter, that occupation takes precedence; builder remains only an unverified possible later career change. Biographical evidence: the direct 1911 plumber and hot-water fitter record remains primary. A WWI soldier of the same full name was excluded because his parents, residence, and occupations contradict this identity; no military service is attached. Reported occupational detail: Matthew recalls Alfred Percy Davies as a builder. His parish baptism on 11 Nov 1883 confirms birth 16 Oct 1883 and explicitly names Frederick and Maria as parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I49",
      "name": "Rosa Beatrice Morrall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Morrall",
      "birth_date": "6 Apr 1875",
      "birth_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "2 Mar 1968",
      "death_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_MORRALL_FAMILYSEARCH_9WWH_TDG",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_MORRALL_1899_WOLVERHAMPTON_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CIVIL_BIRTH_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_DEATH_1968",
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_PROBATE_1968",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch 9WWH-TDG gives maiden identity Rosa Beatrice Morrall, born 6 Apr 1875 Wolverhampton and christened 9 May 1875 at Saint Luke. The 1899 marriage, 1911 census, and 1921 census support her marriage to Bernal Bright Rhead and their household. The 1891 household is consistent but its Rosa age 76/birth 1815 transcription is impossible and treated as an error for approximately age 16. Multiple baptism indexes name Richard and Sarah as parents. The Q2 1875 civil registration is consistent with the exact 6 Apr 1875 birth. The 1901 census continues Rosa with husband Bernal and son Edward. The probate calendar records death on 2 Mar 1968 at Wolverhampton and probate on 26 Mar 1968 at Birmingham.",
      "research_note": "No occupation was stated in the available excerpts. Bernal's Ancestry timeline labels Rosa as 1875-1968; exact death date and place remain unknown. The 1881 census records Rosey B Morrall, age 7, explicitly as daughter of Richard and Sarah Morrall. Biographical evidence: childhood, marriage, and married residences plus the 1968 probate grant are documented.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I50",
      "name": "Bernal Bright Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "Jan-Mar 1869",
      "birth_place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "death_date": "1 Nov 1934",
      "death_place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BERNAL_B_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_MORRALL_1899_WOLVERHAMPTON_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_BRIGHT_RHEAD_1868_1934",
        "SRC_BERNAL_BRIGHT_RHEAD_CIVIL_BIRTH_Q1_1869",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Bernal B Rhead is recorded as Richard and Ellen Rhead's son in the 1881 Birmingham and 1891 Upper Penn censuses. He married Rosa Beatrice Morrall on 5 Jun 1899 and appears with her and their children in the 1901, 1911, and 1921 censuses. A direct Birmingham civil birth index entry places his registration in Jan-Mar 1869; this is the adopted birth period and agrees with his ages in the 1881, 1891, 1911, and 1921 censuses. The 1911 Female gender field is an evident index error. Scholar is an education status, not an academic career.",
      "research_note": "A supplied profile gives death 1 Nov 1934 at a garbled Shrewsbury street address; the exact street remains unverified, so the structured death place is retained at Shrewsbury level. The competing profile-only Jan 1868 date is rejected. Philadelphia arrival records in 1890 and 1904 are temporary journeys rather than emigration because later English records continue the same family. Biographical evidence: the 1881 census directly calls twelve-year-old Bernal a scholar, and the 1911 census directly calls the adult householder a tailor. Profile-only claims about home employment and transatlantic trips remain secondary.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I51",
      "name": "Conley Litchfield Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "1 Jul 1851",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "death_date": "22 Jun 1930",
      "death_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "Biographical evidence: childhood residence and later civil records are documented. He was too young for ordinary Civil War service, and no identity-secure military or additional court record was established.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I52",
      "name": "Rebecca S Talley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Talley",
      "birth_date": "Aug 1857",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "death_date": "about 1920",
      "death_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No occupation or identity-secure court record was established. Her death year is reported as 1920 but no direct death citation has yet been captured; Conley's 1930 death entry confirms only that he was then Rebecca's widower. The 1860 household likely records her as Susan Sally/Talley, age 2, consistent with the fuller name Rebecca Susan and her reported Aug 1857 birth. The 1876 Virginia marriage register records Rebecca S Talley, age 19, marrying Connaely Henderson in Washington County and explicitly names her parents Evan and Delia Talley. Biographical evidence: the 1876 marriage and family identity are documented. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I53",
      "name": "David Kitzmiller Shortt",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Shortt",
      "birth_date": "15 Apr 1870",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": "8 May 1938",
      "death_place": "Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Virginia death record identifies David Kitzmiller Shortt, born 15 Apr 1870, died 8 May 1938 at Abingdon, parents George Shortt and Susan Jones, spouse Tiney Shortt. The 1870 census places David K Shorts with George W and Susan Shorts; 1880 places David with George and likely later wife Obedience; 1900 and 1920 follow David with spouse names indexed as Ginie and Lucy and children Sally, John Edgar, and Graham.",
      "research_note": "Biographical evidence: childhood and adult households are documented. Available excerpts omit occupation; no military service was inferred or established. The death record resolves Tiney as the spouse identity and supersedes census birth estimates of about 1868, Apr 1874, and about 1872.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I54",
      "name": "Leanna Egleton Tiney White",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "White",
      "birth_date": "24 Feb 1874",
      "birth_place": "Greendale, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "death_date": "2 Dec 1954",
      "death_place": "Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_LEANAH_E_WHITE_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TINEY_SHORT_DEATH_1954",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "No occupation was stated and none was inferred from household role. The 1900 spouse name Ginie and 1920 spouse name Lucy are treated as probable census/index variants for Leanna because the households contain Sally/John E. and John Edgar/Graham, while Graham's marriage record explicitly names Leana White and Dave Shortt as parents. Biographical evidence: 1880 and 1900 residences are documented. Virginia death record identifies Tiney Short, born 24 Feb 1874, died 2 Dec 1954 age 80 in Abingdon, Washington County; this supersedes the earlier profile claim of 12 Dec 1952 and resolves the ambiguous Gloucester/Washington locality.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I55",
      "name": "John Henry White",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "White",
      "birth_date": "about 1842",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": "May 1926",
      "death_place": "Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "Supplied death evidence conflicts between 21 and 22 May 1926, so only May 1926 is adopted. About 1842 is retained.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I56",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "23 Mar 1842",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, US",
      "death_date": "5 Jun 1927",
      "death_place": "Prestonsburg, Floyd County, Kentucky, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I57",
      "name": "George Washington White",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "White",
      "birth_date": "18 Nov 1815",
      "birth_place": "Botetourt County, Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": "21 May 1864",
      "death_place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WASHINGTON_WHITE_LYON_CEMETERY_1864",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_REJECTED_NAMESAKE_HINTS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "George W. White was born 18 Nov 1815, reportedly in Botetourt County. The split 1860 Washington County census places him and Julia at the same dwelling with their children, including John, James, and Napoleon. The Lyon Cemetery memorial gives death 21 May 1864 and names James and Napoleon, matching that household. Julia headed the family in 1870 with George absent, further supporting death before 1870. Virginia child records identify his wife as Julia A. or Julia Ann K. White, probably Julia Ann Sims.",
      "research_note": "The descriptive GEDCOM phrase Captured Civil War was removed because no supplied military record establishes it; unrelated namesake hints remain rejected. Benjamin and Fanny's 1811 Botetourt marriage and their 1820 household strengthen but do not prove the inherited parentage claim.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I58",
      "name": "Julia Ann Sims",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Sims",
      "birth_date": "about 1816",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": "8 Oct 1892",
      "death_place": "North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_A_STOUT_1880_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_NORTH_FORK_DEATH_1892",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_ILLINOIS_PENSION_REJECTED",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BENJAMIN_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Julia Ann Sims married George W. White in 1836 and is repeatedly identified as mother of their Washington County children. In 1860 she was a housekeeper in the family household. After George's 1864 death she headed the North Fork household in 1870 and was described as keeping house. A likely 1880 entry calls her Julia A.",
      "research_note": "Her family therefore lived through the Civil War in the same southwest Virginia region as the strategically important Saltville works and battles, but no source establishes Julia's participation, loyalties, displacement, or direct exposure. The county death register records her death at North Fork in 1892 and birth in Washington County; no reliable record names her Sims parents. Stout, suggesting remarriage, although no Stout marriage has been found.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I60",
      "name": "Benjamin Franklin White",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "White",
      "birth_date": "about 1790",
      "birth_place": "probably Franklin County, Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": "3 Jan 1877",
      "death_place": "reportedly Honey Grove, Fannin County, Texas, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_BOTETOURT_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_W_WHITE_1840_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_HONEY_GROVE_MEMORIAL_1877",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SABINE_TEXAS_TAX_1836_REJECTED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Benjamin White married Fanny Lavender at Botetourt County in June 1811.",
      "research_note": "The memorial reports death 3 Jan 1877 at Honey Grove, Texas, but the post-1860 migration from Virginia remains unproved. Evidence review: WeRelate repeats Benjamin and Fanny as George Washington White's parents, consistent with the 1811 marriage and 1820 Botetourt household, but no primary record naming George was located; his edge remains provisional at 0.82. Parentage of George Washington White remains probable, not proven. A compatible household appears there in 1820 and probably in Greene County in 1840; Benjamin and Frances are explicitly together in Greene County in 1850 and 1860. Census ages imply birth about 1792, while the memorial gives 27 Dec 1789 and the inherited profile gave 27 Dec 1790, so about 1790 is retained. The 1836 Sabine District taxpayer is likely a namesake.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I61",
      "name": "Frances \"Fanny\" Lavender",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lavender",
      "birth_date": "about 1797",
      "birth_place": "probably Franklin County, Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_HONEY_GROVE_MEMORIAL_1877",
        "SRC_FRANCES_WHITE_TEXAS_1836_MEMORIAL_REJECTED",
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert married Nancy Willis in Franklin County on 27 Feb 1794, and a Geneanet tree identifies Fanny's mother as Ann Nancy Willis. Fanny appears as Frances, age 51 in 1850 and Francis, age 60 in 1860, both in Greene County with Benjamin White. A memorial death claim of 1836 in Texas is impossible because she was alive in Virginia in 1850 and 1860.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: WeRelate repeats Benjamin and Fanny as George Washington White's parents, consistent with the 1811 marriage and 1820 Botetourt household, but no primary record naming George was located; her edge remains provisional at 0.82. Evidence review: Fanny's marriage evidence names Robert Lavender as father. Robert's 1794 wife Nancy Willis remains the plausible mother at 0.68, but no direct record names her; the unsupported separate Milly Willis hypothesis was removed. Those ages imply about 1799-1800, while memorial and community-tree claims give 19 Jun 1794; about 1797 represents the unresolved range. A community-tree death claim of 1877 in Texas is unproved, so no death is adopted. Fanny Lavinder's 1811 Botetourt marriage transcript explicitly names her father as Robert Lavinder.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1860,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Greene County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I62",
      "name": "Benjamin Franklin White Sr.",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "White",
      "birth_date": "about 1760",
      "birth_place": "reportedly Augusta County, Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": "August 1825",
      "death_place": "Sullivan County, Tennessee, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1810_WYTHE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_EVENSHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_UNRESOLVED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_LATER_MILITARY_HINTS_REJECTED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_TURNER_WHITE_FAMILIES_CHICKASAW_BEN_2001",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Benjamin White married Suckey Bartee in Franklin County, Virginia, on 8 October 1786. Age-compatible households appear in Wythe County in 1810 and at Evensham in 1820, tracing a large family westward through unnamed early censuses. The 1820 household included one enslaved boy whose name the census did not preserve. A cemetery memorial reports Benjamin's death in Sullivan County, Tennessee, in August 1825, suggesting another late move but not establishing its date or route.",
      "research_note": "Claims that William White and Nancy Ann Brittain were his parents conflate him with Benjamin Harrison or “Chickasaw Ben” White, who married another woman; those links remain rejected. Revolutionary service has not been identified securely.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I63",
      "name": "Susan \"Sukey\" Bartee",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bartee",
      "birth_date": "about 1767",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Suckey Bartee married Benjamin White in Franklin County on 8 Oct 1786.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: an explicit published child list names Benjamin Franklin among Benjamin and Sukey's children. Compiled family histories expand her name to Susan Sukey, and Benjamin's memorial names spouse Susan White. The inherited 1825 death is removed because no supplied record establishes her death. Her child edge is 0.78; the 1786 marriage is direct, but the child list is derivative. Her inherited birth about 1767 in Virginia is plausible but not directly sourced.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1790,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I65",
      "name": "Robert Lavender",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lavender",
      "birth_date": "reportedly about 1770",
      "birth_place": "reported Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert Lavinder or Lavender married Nancy Willis in Franklin County, Virginia, on 27 February 1794. A separate 1795 Franklin County entry pairs a Robert Lavinder with Milly Willis.",
      "research_note": "Robert's occupation, property, military activity, death, approximate 1770 Virginia birth, and parents remain unproved. The documents do not establish whether Nancy, Milly, and the derivative name Parmelia represent one woman, successive wives, or different couples. Their daughter Fanny's 1811 Botetourt County marriage explicitly names Robert as her father, linking the family across two southwest Virginia county records but not proving that Robert himself moved to Botetourt. The two marriage bonds, their sureties, and neighboring Lavender households are stronger next targets than any copied pedigree.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1811,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Botetourt County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I68",
      "name": "William Bartee",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bartee",
      "birth_date": "about 1739",
      "birth_place": "reported Norfolk, Virginia, British America",
      "death_date": "reportedly 1786",
      "death_place": "reported Franklin County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_AGBI_VIRGINIA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_SUKEY_WHITE_BOND_SURETY_1786",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 8 Oct 1786 Franklin County marriage bond identifies him as surety for his daughter Suckey Bartee and Benjamin White.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: record-based abstracts place William Bartee in Henry/Franklin County from 1780 through 1786. His exact birth, death, spouse, and parentage remain unresolved; the Norfolk Robert Bartee family is specifically rejected as an unproved namesake connection.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I69",
      "name": "Mary (surname unknown) Bartee",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "With no surname, date, or reliable locality, neither ancestry nor personal historical context can responsibly be assigned.",
      "research_note": "Mary is named only in an internally inconsistent compiled profile as a possible wife of William Bartee. No original marriage, deed, will, probate, tax, church, or child record identifies her. The 1786 marriage-bond abstract for Suckey Bartee names William as Suckey's father but does not name her mother. Mary's low-confidence spouse and mother hypotheses remain visible at 0.35 and 0.30 under the project's derivative-tree policy, but she is not treated as an established ancestor. Her line stops until an original record identifies William's wife and explicitly connects her to Suckey.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Virginia, USA",
          "confidence": 0.3,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Susan \"Sukey\" Bartee",
          "descendant_id": "I63",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I70",
      "name": "Robert Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "about 1822-1824",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA (Washington/Smyth County area)",
      "death_date": "1880",
      "death_place": "Saltville, Virginia, USA (Washington/Smyth County area)",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROBERT_HENDERSON_1824_1880",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Census estimates range from 1822 to 1824. Robert was a cooper in 1850, farm laborer in 1860, and widowed laborer in 1880.",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile. Profile gives death in 1880 at Saltville; exact date is unknown. Saltville is labeled Washington County in the 1880 census and Smyth County in the profile, so county jurisdiction remains qualified. Oregon and Illinois records are excluded as unproven identities.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I71",
      "name": "Mary L McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1828",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "death_date": "Apr 1880",
      "death_place": "Saltville, Smyth County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her Apr 1880 death is consistent with Robert being widowed in the 1880 census. The detailed 1860 transcript records Mary age 31, Virginia-born, occupation housekeeper, and unable to read or write. Its age implies about 1829, consistent within one year of the profile's 1828 birth. Henderson Family 1 supplies middle initial L and names her as Conley Litchfield Henderson's mother.",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile. Wallace Jr. tree repeats her 1828-Apr 1880 vitals, names father David McNew, but gives mother Annie Smith in conflict with the existing Nancy Ann Sevier link. Mary appears explicitly with Robert and children in 1860; child records name Mary Henderson/Mary McNew as mother. Sharon Wright tree explicitly lists Mary L as David's child. The 1850 Marga Henderson entry is treated as probable Mary based on age and continuity. FamilySearch person page KGC2-HBZ, quality score high, identifies Mary McNew, female, born 1828 in Washington County, Virginia, died Apr 1880 at Saltville, Smyth County, Virginia. Both mother hypotheses are retained separately.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I72",
      "name": "Robert William Bartee",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bartee",
      "birth_date": "reported 1725",
      "birth_place": "Norfolk, Virginia, US",
      "death_date": "reported 1772",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: no independent record was found for Robert William Bartee as father of the documented Franklin County William Bartee. The reported chronology conflicts with the compiled field and may merge Robert/William generations. The profile remains visible only as a low-confidence hypothesis. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I73",
      "name": "Lettisha Butt",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Butt",
      "birth_date": "reported 1720",
      "birth_place": "Norfolk, Virginia, US",
      "death_date": "reported 1772",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: no independent record was found identifying Lettisha Butt as mother of the documented Franklin County William Bartee. The reported family appears chronologically conflated, so this profile and link remain visible at low confidence. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I74",
      "name": "Robert Bartee",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bartee",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1704",
      "birth_place": "Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "death_date": "May 1782",
      "death_place": "Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This resolves him as the younger Robert, not Mary Wirick's husband.",
      "research_note": "The reported about-1704 birth and precise parental identities remain derivative. Correction: Robert's will, signed 13 Mar 1780 and proved May 1782, names children and states that land bounds came from his grandfather Henry Werrick's will.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I75",
      "name": "Mary Wirick Bartee Hebdon",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wirick",
      "birth_date": "reported before 1685",
      "birth_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "death_date": "late Jan 1730/31",
      "death_place": "Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "She was incorrectly attached as wife of the younger Robert and mother of Robert William; those contradicted links are removed. Robert Bartee's 1711 will names wife Mary and son Robert, while 1730/31 testimony documents Mary's Bartee and Hebdon children.",
      "research_note": "Wirick is therefore no longer merely a possible maiden name. Correction: 1730/31 Norfolk testimony directly identifies widow Mary Hebdon, son Andregan Bartee, son John Hebdon, and daughter Prudence Bartee. Robert Bartee's 1782 will calls Henry Werrick his grandfather, supporting—but not directly proving—this Mary as a Werrick daughter and Robert's mother. Correction: Henry Wirick's 1710 will explicitly calls Mary Barttee his daughter and Robert Bartee his grandson.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I76",
      "name": "Henry Albert Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "18 Jul 1846",
      "birth_place": "Kingdom of Hanover (present-day Germany)",
      "death_date": "8 Apr 1918",
      "death_place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENRY_ALBERT_FRICKE_FINDAGRAVE_1846_1918",
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_HENRIETTE_MUELLER_FRICKE_CONFLATION",
        "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_HENRY_FRICKE_MILKMAN_1892",
        "SRC_F26_FRICKE_DIRECTORY_1895",
        "SRC_F26_ESSEX_NATURALIZATION_INDEX_GUIDE",
        "ROOTS26_HAMILTON_FRICKE_NATURALIZATION_1848",
        "ROOTS26_HANNOVERSCHES_NAMENBUCH_1852"
      ],
      "source_note": "His first direct American event is his 28 March 1869 Newark marriage to Katharine Schaaf. Census households trace their family in Essex County for decades. In 1900 he owned the home free of mortgage. Revisited 15 September 2026: the 1895 directory again places the milkman at 306 South Halsted. A University of Cincinnati naturalization index documents several Fricke immigrants associated with Hanover and nearby German states in the 1840s–1850s, including August Fricke (24, Hanover; Bremen–Baltimore, 1846; declaration 1848).",
      "research_note": "No record identifies Henry's Hanoverian town or parents. A Missouri-Texas Henry Fricke pedigree is a rejected conflation; naturalization, church, marriage-witness, and passenger records remain the best origin route. Online naturalization and German emigration catalogue searches yielded no identity-secure parent or parish. This raises a wider-family continuity hypothesis, but the index supplies no relationship, town, or shared relative linking August to Henry Albert; same-surname proximity remains an alternative rather than a parent claim. The 1892 Orange directory identifies him as a milkman at 306 Halsted Street, the same household address documented later; it does not show whether he owned a dairy or delivered for another business. Henry Albert Fricke was born in July 1846 somewhere in the Kingdom of Hanover and reported immigration to the United States in 1867.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I77",
      "name": "Katharine Schaaf",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schaaf",
      "birth_date": "20 or 29 Mar 1848",
      "birth_place": "Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany",
      "death_date": "1913",
      "death_place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_FS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023",
        "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_HESSEN_ARCHIVES_EMIGRANT_GUIDE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Katharine Schaaf was born in Hesse-Darmstadt about March 1848, married Henry Fricke at Newark on 28 March 1869, and appears with their family through four later censuses.",
      "research_note": "A 20 March 1848 Ober-Gleen birth and 24 March baptism remain a strong origin candidate. The retained extraction names Johann Martin Schaaf and Anna Catharina Grau as that child's parents, so they are now displayed as low-confidence candidate parents. No American record yet connects Katharine to that household, and at least two local men shared Johann Martin's name; the relationship is a research hypothesis, not proved ancestry.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I81",
      "name": "Sarah Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "17 Nov 1824",
      "birth_place": "Russell County, Virginia, US",
      "death_date": "6 Feb 1899",
      "death_place": "Houston, Texas County, Missouri, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE",
        "SRC_PROFILE_SARAH_SALLY_PHELPS_GOBBLE_1825_1899",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Sarah Phelps, also called Sally, was born about 1824–1825, with 17 November 1824 reported in the family material. She married John G. Gobble on 16 September 1840 in Washington County, Virginia, and they appear together in the 1850–1880 censuses. Child indexes, death records, and her memorial identify her as the mother of multiple children. Find a Grave records her death on 6 February 1899 and burial at Houston, Texas County, Missouri, naming Martin Vines Phelps as her father, John G. Gobble as her spouse, and Eglantine Scott, Mary Catherine Aldridge, Robert Ireson Gobble, and George Washington Gobble as children. Brock’s 1888 biography, p. 725, explicitly names her parents as Martin Phelps and Eda, daughter of Henry Countis.",
      "research_note": "A separate compiled profile gives 8 September 1899, matching John’s reported death date and likely reflecting a copied spouse date; 6 February 1899 remains preferred. Brock 1888 p. 725 is the strongest parentage evidence and raises both Martin Phelps and Eda, daughter of Henry Countis, to 0.96. The Brock statement is near-contemporary family testimony rather than a birth record.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I82",
      "name": "John G Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "01 Nov 1818",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, US",
      "death_date": "8 Sep 1899",
      "death_place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_G_GOBBLE_1818_1899",
        "SRC_GOBBLE_FAMILY_DATA_JOHN_1818_1899",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Born 1 Nov 1818 in Washington County according to GEDCOM/profile. The 1880 census records John G Gobble, age 61, married farmer in North Fork with wife Sarah. Profile gives death 8 Sep 1899 in Washington County; death awaits a direct record. Family Data Collection repeats exact birth, marriage, death, spouse, and parents. Census continuity: farmer in 1850, cabinet maker in 1860, carpenter in 1870, and farmer in 1880.",
      "research_note": "The 1860 indexed age 35 conflicts with his exact 1818 birth and all other census ages and is not adopted.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I83",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "24 Apr 1794",
      "birth_place": "Maryland, USA",
      "death_date": "reportedly 17 Sep 1854",
      "death_place": "reportedly Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Brock's 1888 biography identifies John G. Gobble's mother as Elizabeth, daughter of Christopher Gobble of Maryland. Gobble's mother as Elizabeth, daughter of Christopher Gobble.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: Brock's 1888 near-contemporary biography identifies John G. Her reported exact birth and death still require direct records. This supersedes the weaker later claim that her father was Jeremiah. This rejects the weaker Jeremiah-father claim; Christian/Christopher is retained as her father at 0.97 and Sarah Gise as inferential mother at 0.90.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I84",
      "name": "William Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "12 Apr 1792",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, US",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert A. Brock's 1888 biography of John G. The 1813 marriage and 1850 household provide independent continuity. Gobble's father and gives William's birth as 12 Apr 1792; the parent edge is 0.995. Gobble's paternal grandmother, confirming her as William's mother. The duplicate Christian/Sarah parent hypotheses for William were deleted as contradicted.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: Brock's 1888 biography explicitly names William as John G. Evidence review: Brock explicitly identifies Jemima Linder as John G. Gobble explicitly names father William Gobble and gives William's birth as 12 Apr 1792 in Washington County.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1850,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "District 67, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I85",
      "name": "Jemima Linder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Linder",
      "birth_date": "reported 1774",
      "birth_place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": "reportedly 1876",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_INTL_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Gobble's paternal grandmother while naming William as John's father. Together with the parent index, this supports Jemima as William's mother at 0.98.",
      "research_note": "The previously supplied exact 31 Aug date and 1876 death remain unproved. Evidence review: Brock's 1888 biography calls Jemima Linder John G. Her 1774 birth in Washington County is reported family-profile information; the derivative international marriage entry independently reports 1774 in Virginia but not the county. The 17 Nov 1789 Washington County marriage index directly names Jemima Linder and John Gobble, establishing her maiden surname and their marriage.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I86",
      "name": "John Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "reportedly 10 Feb 1766",
      "birth_place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
      "death_date": "reportedly 15 Jul 1846",
      "death_place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship index names John Gobble as William's father and Jimima's spouse.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: a Virginia relationship index names John and Jimima as William Gobble's parents. Family evidence review: the Goble Family Association database explicitly lists John, born 10 Feb 1766, as a child of Johann Friedrich Jr. The profile's Johann Frederick, Gobel, and Gabel aliases and exact dates are not established by the supplied record. Brock confirms Jemima in the paternal line but does not name William's father, so John's edge is retained at 0.95. and Elizabeth Weigel. Those existing profiles are connected at 0.76 and 0.74; the original baptism remains uninspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I11",
      "name": "David Gary Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "15 Dec 1938",
      "birth_place": "Newark, Essex County, New Jersey, USA",
      "death_date": "15 Jul 2002",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SSA_DAVID_GARY_FRICKE_1938_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile. Social Security evidence gives birth 15 Dec 1938 at Newark and death 15 Jul 2002, explicitly naming parents George G Fricke and Marysue E Henderson. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I12",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I87",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I88",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I89",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I46",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I47",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I96",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I97",
      "name": "Victor J Biernacka",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Biernacka",
      "birth_date": "19 Apr 1943",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "29 Aug 2016",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I100",
      "name": "Maria Hanny",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hanny",
      "birth_date": "01 Apr 1846",
      "birth_place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEBMD_MARIA_HANNEY_BIRTH_Q2_1846",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNY_1861_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_FREDERICK_DAVIES_MARIA_HANNY_MARRIAGE_Q3_1879",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "FreeBMD records Maria Hanney in the Bradford W birth index for Apr-Jun 1846, volume 8 page 276. The 1851 census records Maria Hanney, age 4, with William and Elizabeth Hanney; the 1861 census records Maria Haney, age 15, with William Peter Haney. Her 1891 and 1901 censuses as Maria Davies consistently give Bradford-on-Avon as birthplace. Hanny, Hanney, and Haney are documented index variants.",
      "research_note": "No occupation was stated in the available excerpts. The exact 1 Apr 1846 birth date remains GEDCOM-derived rather than independently proved by the quarterly index. A reciprocal FreeBMD search places Frederick Davies and Maria Hanny on the same Atcham marriage page in Jul-Sep 1879, and their later census households prove the pairing. Biographical evidence: census records trace Bradford-on-Avon childhood and Shrewsbury married life.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1901,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I101",
      "name": "Frederick Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "27 Feb 1845",
      "birth_place": "Garthmyl, Powys, Wales, GB",
      "death_date": "Jan-Mar 1926",
      "death_place": "Atcham registration district, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1845",
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_DEATH_Q1_1926",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "GEDCOM gives Frederick Davies born 27 Feb 1845 at Garthmyl, Powys. The 1901 census records birthplace Berriew, a compatible nearby locality. The 1851 and 1861 Wales censuses place Frederick, aged 6 and 16 respectively, in the household of William and Martha Davies, strongly establishing them as his parents. His death was registered at Atcham in Jan-Mar 1926.",
      "research_note": "No occupation was stated in supplied excerpts. The 1891 Shrewsbury household records Frederick age 40 with wife Maria and children; that age conflicts with the exact birth and his 1901 age 56 and is not adopted. The existing exact 27 Feb birth remains GEDCOM-derived and is not replaced by the baptism date. He was christened at Berriew on 23 Mar 1845, explicitly naming William and Martha as parents. Biographical evidence: census records trace Montgomeryshire childhood and Shrewsbury household life. A compatible 1893 chapel-trustee reference is not unique enough to attach as fact.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I102",
      "name": "Albert Noel Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "about 1889",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Albert N Davies appears age 2 in the 1891 household and age 12 in 1901, supporting the existing Albert Noel Davies identity and parent family.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I103",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I104",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I105",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I106",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I107",
      "name": "Johann Friedrich (Frederick) Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "12 Oct 1734",
      "birth_place": "Offenbach, Darmstadt, Hessen, DE",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile. Family evidence review: the Goble Family Association genealogy identifies wife Elizabeth Weigel and lists John, born 10 Feb 1766, among their children. Chronology is compatible with the couple's reported 1757 marriage, but the original child baptism was not inspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I108",
      "name": "Elizabeth Weigel Gabel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Weigel",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_OT26_WEIGELE_GABEL_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_OT26_GOSHENHOPPEN_HINKE_ARCHIVE",
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_ELISABETH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Earlier blank-spouse and Elizabeth Weigel profiles were consolidated here. The latter reports 10 May 1757, groom Fridrich son of Fridrich (Lutheran), bride Elisab. daughter of Georg (Reformed). See comparative note RN_OT26_WEIGEL_FATHER_AND_OLDER_CANDIDATES. New institutional card 169976 names both parents and exact marriage; both parent links now .86. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION.",
      "research_note": "Original manuscript not inspected. Father edge now .82; mother Anna Margaret Ditlich remains .66 on compiled pedigree evidence and is not named in this entry. Reported vital dates remain unverified; empty vital fields preserved. The previous statement that her surname remains unknown is superseded: the Goble association pedigree and a specific Old Goshenhoppen marriage transcription identify Weigel/Weigele. Earlier .66 maternal discussion superseded.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "confidence": 0.74,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Gobble",
          "descendant_id": "I86",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1744,
          "confidence": 0.533,
          "basis": "estimated from known parent birth year(s)",
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "place_confidence": 0.74,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "John Gobble"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I109",
      "name": "Johann Friedrich Gabel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel",
      "birth_date": "1701",
      "birth_place": "Offenbach am Glan, Duchy of Zweibruecken (now Rheinland-Pfalz), Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GB26_IPGV_FRIEDRICH_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Johann Friedrich Gabel is identified by IPGV card 57056 as the Lutheran wheelwright from Offenbach am Glan, son of Hans-Jakob Gabel and Maria Margaretha Rheinmüller, migrating on Samuel to Philadelphia on 27 August 1739 and Old Goshenhoppen. This corrects the former Offenbach/Darmstadt/Hessen identification. Christian’s 1754 baptism card identifies his father and later wife Christiana Henrietta Hornberger.",
      "research_note": "Parish-referenced institutional reconstruction, not personally inspected original registers. Card baptism 4 April 1701 conflicts with the compilation’s 10 April birth / 14 April baptism; retain 1701 without choosing a day.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I110",
      "name": "Christiana Henrietta Hornberger",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hornberger",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_HORNBERGER_PARENT_INITIALS_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GOSCHENHOPPEN_HISTORIANS_EARLY_CHURCH_SCHOOLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hornberger and M.",
      "research_note": "Another proposed child remains supported only by derivative evidence. C. as possible parents; later pedigrees expand them despite several incompatible Christian Hornbergers in passenger records. A particular immigrant or Pennsylvania Hornberger household should not be attached without a record connecting it to this mother. An institutional migration card records Christian Gabel's Lutheran baptism at Old Goshenhoppen on 21 May 1754 and explicitly names his parents as Christiana Henrietta Hornberger and Johann Friedrich Gabel. This places Christiana directly within a German-speaking Lutheran family and church community. The Goble database supplies only the initials C. Christiana's own birth, death, marriage, migration, property, probate, and parents have not been identified.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Chester County, Pennsylvania, USA",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Christian Gobble",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1726,
          "confidence": 0.713,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Chester County, Pennsylvania, USA",
          "place_confidence": 0.99,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Christian Gobble"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I111",
      "name": "Hans (Johann) Jacob Gabel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel",
      "birth_date": "reported 1670",
      "birth_place": "Germany; exact birthplace unverified",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GB26_IPGV_FRIEDRICH_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hans-Jakob, spouse Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller, is named as Friedrich’s father by IPGV card 57056. Institutional parent card 57057 gives no parents or vitals.",
      "research_note": "Compiled household reports birth 1670 and marriage 9 January 1690/91 at Offenbach am Glan; exact birth remains reported. Göda birthplace and 1770 death are unsupported derivative details, preserved here as former claims rather than adopted facts. The Erpfingen Hans Jacob born 1689 is a separate documented candidate identity and does not plausibly fit this father’s chronology. Johannes/Ursula parent links remain conflicting hypotheses, not established ancestry.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1701,
          "confidence": 0.677,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I112",
      "name": "Maria Margaretha Reinmueller",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Reinmueller",
      "birth_date": "reported 1673",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GB26_IPGV_FRIEDRICH_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "This spouse/child cluster outranks an uncited Kirchner assignment in FamilySearch LK75-RYD. Approximate 1673 birth and Hans Conrad parentage remain separate derivative claims; card 57058 supplies no grandparents. IPGV 57056 explicitly names Maria Margaretha Rheinmüller as Johann Friedrich’s mother and Hans-Jakob Gabel as father. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Offenbach am Glan, Duchy of Zweibruecken (now Rheinland-Pfalz), Germany",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Johann Friedrich Gabel",
          "descendant_id": "I109",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1701,
          "confidence": 0.677,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I113",
      "name": "Lemuel Butt",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Butt",
      "birth_date": "about 1704 or earlier",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 1753",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "probable_identity",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_OT26_WINGO_BUTT_WILLS_DEPOSITIONS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No original marriage, probate, or baptism was located. H1 same Lemuel as this profile leads over a hypothetical contemporary namesake through distinctive name, Norfolk setting and compatible birth chronology. Evidence review: compatible compiled accounts identify Lemuel Butt, spouse Catherine Wilkins, and children including Letitia in the correct Virginia chronology. It does not establish wife, children, parents, birthplace or 1753 death. Birth wording now reflects the age limit rather than an exact 1704 estimate. Person confidence increased from .64 to .80 as an ordinal identity assessment; all relationship scores unchanged. Follow-up 16 September 2026: Wingo p24 prints Lemuel Butt’s 25 July 1751 sworn age as 47 and upwards. This is a printed transcription, not the manuscript.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Norfolk, Virginia, US",
          "confidence": 0.62,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Lettisha Butt",
          "descendant_id": "I73",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I114",
      "name": "Catherine Wilkins (possibly Warden)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wilkins",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1706",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 1762",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The repeated family structure supports retaining her maternal edge at 0.62 and couple edge at 0.68, but not extending her ancestry.",
      "research_note": "Two compatible compiled Butt family accounts identify Catherine or Kathrine Wilkins as Lemuel Butt's wife and Letitia Butt's mother. One calls her Wilkins Warden, which could indicate another marriage, a step relationship, or a conflation rather than a second surname. Her reported birth about 1706 and death in 1762 remain derivative, and no original marriage, will, deed, probate, church, or child record has been located. With only a broad reported Virginia setting, a county-level life narrative would overstate the evidence. Her line stops until an original record resolves Wilkins and Warden and identifies her family.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Norfolk, Virginia, US",
          "confidence": 0.62,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Lettisha Butt",
          "descendant_id": "I73",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I115",
      "name": "Mary (maiden name unknown) Werrick",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Werrick",
      "birth_date": "reported before 1665",
      "birth_place": "reported Virginia",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "This Mary is only a proposed wife of Henry Werrick and possible mother of his daughters. Henry's will refers to the daughters' mother but does not name her, and no marriage, probate, church, or land record has identified Henry's wife. She remains visible as a low-confidence family-tree hypothesis, distinct from Henry's directly documented daughter Mary Barttee. Reported Russian, Florida, and precise Virginia details have no reliable support. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I116",
      "name": "Henry Werrick",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Werrick",
      "birth_date": "reported before 1665",
      "birth_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "death_date": "reported before 1711",
      "death_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Henry Werrick lived on the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River and owned at least two plantations. His will, dated 28 December 1710 and proved 20 April 1711, left his home plantation to daughter Mary Barttee for life and then to grandson Robert Bartee. A second plantation, purchased from John Bright, was provided for daughter Patient and son-in-law William Odean. The will also names grandchildren, household equipment, witnesses Dennis Maccory, Benjamin Beck, William Barington, and Thomas Nash, and an enslaved boy bequeathed to a granddaughter. It establishes Henry's family, property, community, and participation in slavery, but gives no birthplace or parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I117",
      "name": "Robert Butt",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Butt",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1678",
      "birth_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "death_date": "reported before 21 May 1731",
      "death_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: the reported 1704 birth is impossible for fathering Lemuel born about 1704. An unsourced FamilySearch profile instead reports Robert about 1678-before 21 May 1731 and Elizabeth Church, but also lists two different sons named Lemuel. Identity and child assignment remain uncertain. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I118",
      "name": "Elizabeth Church",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Church",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1680",
      "birth_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "death_date": "reported about 1730",
      "death_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.38,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_OT26_MCINTOSH_CHURCH_BUTT_1705"
      ],
      "source_note": "See RN_OT26_CHURCH_BUTT_GRANDDAUGHTER.",
      "research_note": "No marriage, will, deed, or child record was located, and duplicate Lemuel sons make the maternity assignment uncertain. Evidence review: Elizabeth Church is repeated as Robert Butt's wife in an unsourced collaborative tree. This supplies a real Church-Butt family connection in the relevant locality, but does not name Leddae's parents or a daughter Elizabeth. The testator is an identity candidate for the proposed Richard; no identity merge or parentage upgrade made. The older wife Elizabeth must remain distinct from the proposed daughter Elizabeth. Follow-up 16 September 2026: a Norfolk Richard Church testator (Book7 p106; published abstract pp191-192) names granddaughter Leddae Butt and wife Elizabeth.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I120",
      "name": "Richard Church",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Church",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_VA_HOUSE_RICHARD_CHURCH_1699",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTY_FORMATION",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTIES_1691_1700",
        "SRC_OT26_MCINTOSH_CHURCH_BUTT_1705"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Norfolk community of that period was governed through county courts and was expanding with population and tobacco commerce. Massachusetts Church pedigrees concern a different man. See RN_OT26_CHURCH_BUTT_GRANDDAUGHTER.",
      "research_note": "Richard Church is an reported name offered as Elizabeth Church's father, without dates, spouse, locality, or an original family record. An official legislative source proves that a Richard Church represented Norfolk County in 1699, but supplies no relatives and cannot safely be assigned to this profile. This ancestry remains unextended pending a will, deed, parish, court, or probate record that names Elizabeth. This supplies a real Church-Butt family connection in the relevant locality, but does not name Leddae's parents or a daughter Elizabeth. The testator is an identity candidate for the proposed Richard; no identity merge or parentage upgrade made. The older wife Elizabeth must remain distinct from the proposed daughter Elizabeth. That setting belongs only to the same-name legislator unless evidence connects him to Elizabeth. Follow-up 16 September 2026: a Norfolk Richard Church testator (Book7 p106; published abstract pp191-192) names granddaughter Leddae Butt and wife Elizabeth.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
          "confidence": 0.2,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth Church",
          "descendant_id": "I118",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I121",
      "name": "Nancy Ann Sevier",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Sevier",
      "birth_date": "1804",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "death_date": "1895",
      "death_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Her former direct parent link to Mary has been removed.",
      "research_note": "Nancy remains a possible identity for that census spouse, not a separate mother of Mary. A FamilySearch profile identifies Nancy Ann Sevier as David McNew's wife, but the captured census records identify his spouse only as Ann/Annie and do not provide a maiden surname.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I122",
      "name": "Pvt. John \"David\" McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "8 Aug 1801",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "death_date": "1880",
      "death_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page K4NV-8YV and the GEDCOM report David McNew born 8 Aug 1801 in Washington County and dying there in 1880. The 1850 and 1880 censuses independently identify a Virginia-born David of compatible age with spouse Ann/Annie and children. Detailed record notes continue this household through 1860 and 1870. The maternal identity issue has been separated correctly: Ann/Annie is the documented spouse, while Sevier, Smith, Morgan, and Kennedy are unproved maiden-surname suggestions.",
      "research_note": "Two compiled trees identify David as Mary L McNew's father, supported by the 1850 adjacent-household cluster but not yet by a record explicitly naming him as her father.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I124",
      "name": "George Albert McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "17 Nov 1763",
      "birth_place": "Frederick County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "5 Mar 1846",
      "death_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1810_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1840_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Find a Grave independently confirms exact dates, spouse Amelia, and Mahanaim Cemetery burial. Compatible Washington County households appear in 1810, 1820, and 1840.",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile. Tennessee records remain unresolved and the Gloucestershire hint is rejected. Evidence review: Washington County chancery testimony explicitly calls David McNew son of George McNew Sr., directly supporting George's father edge at 0.995. Evidence review: published family history places George among William and Mary's sons. Danny Dirickson tree repeats exact vitals, father William Edward, and children David, George Albert, and Sena, but gives mother Mary Clemons in conflict with Mary Eckless Berry and adds several tree-only children. His father edge is 0.97 and mother Mary edge 0.80; conflicting Berry and Clemons surname claims are not treated as fact. Sharon Wright tree explicitly names George Albert McNew as David's father. The 1820 household enslaved one woman aged 26-44; this fact is explicitly retained. FamilySearch person page G5HT-58H, quality score high, identifies George Albert McNew, male, born 17 Nov 1763 in Frederick County, Virginia, British Colonial America, died 5 Mar 1846 in Washington County, Virginia, buried Mar 1846 at Mahanaim Church Cemetery, Meadowview, Washington County, Virginia.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I125",
      "name": "William Edward McKnew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McKnew",
      "birth_date": "14 Aug 1715",
      "birth_place": "Saint Johns Parish, Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "Dec 1791",
      "death_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_1715_1791",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_MACKNEW_MARYLAND_BIRTH_1715",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Existing tree connected him as father of George Albert McNew. Ancestry profile supplies middle name Edward and spelling McKnew, matching existing exact dates. Ancestry timeline repeats his exact birth/death and Mary Eckless Berry spouse claim but is heavily conflated. A Maryland birth index independently records William Macknew born 14 Aug 1715 at St Johns Parish. William's father edge is 0.97.",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile. Evidence review: published McNew-Cawood history identifies William and wife Mary with sons including George. Marriage dates 1730/1735/1751, duplicate children, 1794 post-death residence, and 1842 marriage are rejected or left unresolved. McNew Family Tree calls Jeremiah's 1715 son William Thomas McNew, conflicting with the existing William Edward profile. It does not identify his parents in the supplied excerpt, so the Jeremiah parent link remains candidate-level. The profile's Revolutionary War private/infantry label is not treated as proven service without a military citation. The dates, generation, and parent context indicate one person, so Thomas is retained as an alternate middle-name claim rather than a duplicate child. The wife/mother forename Mary is supported, but Berry versus Clemons is unresolved. FamilySearch person page LVJF-S83, quality score medium, identifies William Macknew, male, born 14 Aug 1715 at Saint Johns Parish, Prince George's County, Maryland, died Dec 1791 in Washington County, Virginia.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I127",
      "name": "Jeremiah Macknew II",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Macknew",
      "birth_date": "after 1674",
      "birth_place": "Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "1715/1716",
      "death_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "John's Parish family.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: a published history quotes Jeremiah's 31 Jul 1703 indenture and reports his St. It gives birth only after 1674 and death in 1715/1716; the reported exact 1680 birth and 16 Jan 1715 death are not retained.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I128",
      "name": "Sarah Marley (Marler) Macknew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Marley/Marler",
      "birth_date": "about 1685",
      "birth_place": "Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "early 1728",
      "death_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: the record-based McNew-Cawood history uses Sarah MARLEY (or MARLER), not the reported Marlow spelling, and reports that her sons appeared in court after her death in early 1728. Her approximate birth remains inferential. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I129",
      "name": "Jeremiah H Macknew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Macknew",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1640",
      "birth_place": "reported Scotland (unproved)",
      "death_date": "reported 24 Apr 1720",
      "death_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JEREMIAH_H_MACKNEW_1640_1720",
        "SRC_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1668_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_JEREMIAH_MACKMERE_PHILISE_MARRIAGE_1670",
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Jeremiah Macknew is documented in colonial Maryland by 1668. In January 1670 he and his wife Phillis appeared before the Charles County court to bind their son John Howard to Robert Littlepage until adulthood, an arrangement that provided maintenance and training. Maryland Assembly accounts list Jeremiah in 1678 among residents assigned 830 pounds of tobacco, placing him within the colony's taxable economy. Later probate-based work identifies additional children.",
      "research_note": "His reported Scottish origin is plausible family tradition but remains unproved: no parish, land, burgess, testament, or other Scottish record has been found that connects the Maryland immigrant to Midlothian or to the earlier copied Mackneugh pedigree.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I130",
      "name": "Phillis Macknew (maiden name unknown)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Macknew",
      "birth_date": "about 1640-1645",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 1700",
      "death_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_JEREMIAH_MACKMERE_PHILISE_MARRIAGE_1670",
        "SRC_GENEANET_PHILLIS_W_OJEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_1674_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_NEW_EARLY_SETTLERS_MARYLAND_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_PROFILE_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JEREMIAH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_PHILLIS_PARENTAGE_UNKNOWN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Maryland settler record, as described in the McNew-Cawood history, indicates that she served William Barton until 1674 to repay her passage. The 1670 court record also shows Phillis and Jeremiah binding her minor son to Robert Littlepage until age twenty-one.",
      "research_note": "Phillis is directly documented as Jeremiah Macknew's wife and the mother of John Howard in a Charles County court proceeding of January 1670. This places her personally within seventeenth-century Maryland's transatlantic indenture and credit system, rather than merely alongside a general colonial event. Her birthplace and migration port remain unknown. Edinburgh or Currie is repeated in online trees, but no Scottish record supports it, and Mackneugh has not been proved to be her maiden surname.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I78",
      "name": "Elizabeth Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "about 1869",
      "birth_place": "New Jersey, United States",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_ELIZABETH_1890_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Daughter in 1880 East Orange household, age 11, born New Jersey; likely Elizabeth Fricke age 21 who married Heinrich Gonder in East Orange on 20 Jul 1890.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1890,
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I79",
      "name": "William Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "about 1874",
      "birth_place": "New Jersey, United States",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Son in 1880 East Orange household, age 6, born New Jersey.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1880,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I80",
      "name": "Charles Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "about 1877/1878",
      "birth_place": "New Jersey, United States",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1920_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Son in 1880 East Orange household, age 2, born New Jersey. In 1910 East Orange, Charles is head and George Fricke age 29 is listed as brother, supporting the sibling network.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1910,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I131",
      "name": "Jeremiah Mackneugh",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Mackneugh",
      "birth_date": "reported 1610",
      "birth_place": "reported Edinburgh, Scotland",
      "death_date": "reported 1716",
      "death_place": "reported Edinburgh, Scotland",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: Jeremiah Mackneugh born 1610 and died 1716 is found only in derivative trees. He remains a named low-confidence hypothesis rather than being removed. No Scottish parish, probate, land, or civil record was located.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I132",
      "name": "Rebecca Schratern",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schratern",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1610",
      "birth_place": "reported Midlothian, Scotland",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_MIDLOTHIAN_RECORD_GUIDE",
        "SRC_NRS_OLD_PARISH_REGISTER_COVERAGE",
        "ROOTS26_SCHRATERN_VARIANT_SEARCH",
        "ROOTS26_MIDLOTHIAN_REGISTER_LIMITS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Midlothian's surviving church and testament collections provide a research route, but Scottish parish coverage varies greatly and the pedigree does not name a parish. Rebecca Schratern is a name supplied by a derivative McNew pedigree for the mother of Jeremiah Macknew. The exact Schratern spelling remains unconfirmed. Possible forms such as Schrater, Schrader or Schröter are search variants only; they are not asserted as her surname or origin. Midlothian’s pre-1855 registers were not compulsory and coverage varies, so the absence of a match is not evidence against the compiled candidate. Scotland’s People supports phonetic and variant searching, but no identity-secure Midlothian record has been found for Rebecca. The unusual surname has not produced an independently identifiable family, and the parent and spouse edges remain low at 0.32 and 0.36. Her personal local history and ancestry therefore remain unassigned until an original record confirms the name and locality. The same tree reports birth about 1610 in Midlothian, Scotland, but no parish, marriage, testament, court, or other Scottish record has been located.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I133",
      "name": "Jeremiah MacKnew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "MacKnew",
      "birth_date": "about 1558",
      "birth_place": "Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": "Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: public trees repeat Jeremiah about 1558 at Edinburgh with a son born 1610, but the cited source is private and no parish, land, tax, or probate record was located. The profile remains a low-confidence named hypothesis. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I135",
      "name": "Matthew MacKnew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "MacKnew",
      "birth_date": "about 1538",
      "birth_place": "Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland",
      "death_date": "about 1610",
      "death_place": "Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: Matthew about 1538-1610 remains a named derivative-tree hypothesis. The working chronology is possible, but the underlying tree duplicates Jeremiah children and no parish, testament, sasine, tax, or land record was found. Origin review: credible McNew histories begin with immigrant Jeremiah and Phillis Macknew in Maryland in 1668 and state that their birthplace is unknown. No evidence supports Matthew MacKnew about 1538 in Edinburgh or names his parents; this terminal profile was not extended. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I137",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "6 Feb 1833",
      "birth_place": "Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "2 Oct 1900",
      "death_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1841_STOKE_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1861_HEYWOOD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_DEATH_AND_BURIAL_1900",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "A compiled Dixon Family Tree adds the names Handley and Maria to his parents, but those additions are not in the baptism and conflict with the separately documented Julia Glover family. A supplied profile gives 6 February 1833 as Richard's birth date. The original register records their abode as Woodfarm and Sampson's trade as grocer; it does not give Sampson's middle name, Sarah's maiden name, or Richard's birth date.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I138",
      "name": "Ellen Helen Waterhouse",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Waterhouse",
      "birth_date": "baptised 14 Jun 1835",
      "birth_place": "Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "14 Apr 1904",
      "death_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1900_WOLVERHAMPTON_DIRECTORIES",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1901_HEATH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_DEATH_1904",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELLEN_HELEN_WATERHOUSE_1835_1904",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "As Helen Waterhouse, age 19, she married Richard Rhead on 10 Apr 1854 at Birmingham St Stephen and named father John Waterhouse. Helen/Ellen is a documented name variant. The 1881 and 1891 censuses record her with Richard and their children. In 1900 she was a shopkeeper at 1 Bridge Street, Springfields, Wolverhampton; in 1901 she headed a Heath household with daughter Ruth Fisher and grandchildren.",
      "research_note": "The death index age 58 conflicts with all earlier evidence and is rejected. The profile's Shropshire label for Hanford is also rejected in favor of Staffordshire. A supplied profile gives death on 14 Apr 1904, consistent with Q2 Wolverhampton registration. Ellen Waterhouse was baptized on 14 Jun 1835 at Hanford St Matthias, Staffordshire, daughter of John and Ellen Waterhouse; this is retained as a baptism date rather than assumed birth date. The 1841 and 1851 censuses continue her in their Trentham household, with the 1851 census explicitly naming her as daughter. Biographical evidence: the 1881 census directly records seamstress and a 1900 directory records shopkeeper at 1 Bridge Street.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I139",
      "name": "Sampson Handley Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "30 Jun 1799",
      "birth_place": "Wolstanton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "12 Nov 1865",
      "death_place": "Bucknall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_QPSM_68WK",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1800_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1813_WILL_PAGE4_IMAGE_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I140",
      "name": "Sarah Maria Poyner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Poyner",
      "birth_date": "1 May 1811",
      "birth_place": "Ludlow, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "Oct-Dec 1879",
      "death_place": "Stone registration district, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_DEATH_1879_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_SARAH_BOULTON_DEATH_Q4_1879",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "Their son Richard's original 1833 baptism names his parents only as Sampson and Sarah Rhead, so it directly identifies Sarah as his mother but does not state her maiden or middle name.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I141",
      "name": "Richard Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "baptised 30 Oct 1753",
      "birth_place": "Stoke, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "April 1813",
      "death_place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_MARRIAGE_1793",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_QPSM_68WK",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_TRENTHAM_PROBATE_BURIAL_1813",
        "SRC_RD_RHEAD_1798_HANCHURCH_LAND_TAX",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1813_WILL_PAGE4_IMAGE_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_LICENSE_IMAGE_1793_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I142",
      "name": "Ruth Handley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Handley",
      "birth_date": "reported baptised 3 Jan 1759",
      "birth_place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England, GB",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_MARRIAGE_1793",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ",
        "SRC_HANDLEY_MILWICH_COMPILED_REVIEW_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "15 September 2026: The online reconstruction describes 3 January as a baptism. Her existing 3 Jan 1759 Milwich birth and 1818 death remain compiled-profile facts pending their own parish transcripts. Identity with Richard Rhead's wife remains an inference separate from the well-documented 1793 marriage. The prior exact birth presentation is not supported by an inspected birth entry.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1799,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I143",
      "name": "Richard Morrall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Morrall",
      "birth_date": "about 1841",
      "birth_place": "Horsehay, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_RICHARD_MORRALL_1842_1892",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Direct-line parent of Rosa Beatrice Morrall. The 1851 census records Richard, age 11, born Wellington, as son of Richard and Hannah Morral. His 1860 church marriage to Sarah Brassington independently names his father as Richard Morrall. The 1861 and 1871 censuses imply birth about 1840, while the 1881 and 1891 censuses imply about 1842; about 1841 is used as a balanced estimate. Horsehay and Wellington are compatible local descriptions in the east Shropshire area. He was a puddler in 1881.",
      "research_note": "Biographical evidence: census continuity is strong, but the supplied excerpts omit occupation and no identity-secure military or court record was found. The 1901 Wolverhampton census records him alive as Richard Morsell with Sarah and daughter Lily's family, so the supplied 24 Feb 1892 Walsall death is rejected as a namesake mismatch. His death remains unknown. This person remains distinct from Richard Morrall baptised in 1793 and married to Ann Southern.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1901,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Wolverhampton St John, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I144",
      "name": "Sarah Brassington",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "18 Jan 1840",
      "birth_place": "Church Lane, Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "18 Jan 1915",
      "death_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_BRASSINGTON_BIRTH_1840",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1915",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1881 census gives age 38 and the 1891 census age 48, both implying birth about 1842-1843. Both censuses identify husband Richard and daughter Rosa/Rosey. She married Richard Morrall on 26 Nov 1860 at Wolverhampton St John. The couple appears together in the 1861 and 1871 censuses as well as the existing 1881 and 1891 households. She married Richard Morrall in 1860 and is documented with him through 1901.",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile. No occupation was stated in the supplied excerpts. Her Q1 1840 civil registration supports the supplied exact birth date 18 Jan 1840. Her Q1 1915 civil death registration supports the supplied 18 Jan 1915 death, although the index age 72 conflicts with the otherwise consistent 1840 birth. Rosa's 1875 baptism explicitly names mother Sarah Morrall. The 1841 and 1851 censuses identify Sarah in Joseph and Esther Brassington's Wolverhampton household; in 1851 she is explicitly their daughter. Biographical evidence: childhood and married households are documented. Existing GEDCOM year 1841 is retained here as a discrepancy.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I145",
      "name": "John Waterhouse",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Waterhouse",
      "birth_date": "7 Apr 1802",
      "birth_place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": "Jan-Mar 1863",
      "death_place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_BIRMINGHAM_DEATH_Q1_1863",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Waterhouse is named as Ellen's father in her 1835 Hanford baptism, appears with her in the 1841 and 1851 Trentham censuses, and is independently named in her 1854 marriage. John was born 7 Apr 1802 and baptized 2 May 1802 at Ashbourne St Oswald, son of James and Hannah Waterhouse. He married Ellen Finney there on 24 Sep 1827. The 1861 Birmingham household records him as Jonas with wife Helen, but its children continue the 1851 family, establishing name variants. The 1841 Staveley John with wife Hannah is a different household.",
      "research_note": "His existing exact 7 Apr 1802 Ashbourne birth and 1863 death remain GEDCOM-derived pending their own source transcripts. His death was registered at Birmingham in Jan-Mar 1863; the profile-only exact 1 Jan date remains unproven.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I146",
      "name": "Ellen Helen Finney",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Finney",
      "birth_date": "about 1803",
      "birth_place": "Alton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_TRENTHAM_HISTORY",
        "SRC_OT26_WATERHOUSE_1861_ALTON_BIRTHPLACE",
        "SRC_OT26_HELEN_FYNNEY_ALTON_1803"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ellen Finney married John Waterhouse at Ashbourne24September1827. Their1841/1851Trentham household continues in1861Birmingham under names Jonas and Helen, with matching children.",
      "research_note": "Alton10April1803baptism of Helen Fynney, daughter of William and Hellen, is now the leading identification and supports probable parent edges (0.80);1861age52 remains discrepant. FreeCEN1861 explicitly records Helen born Alton. About1803birth is estimated from1851age48, not a dated birth. Originals and1827witnesses remain valuable discriminators. No maiden surname established for mother Hellen. See RN_OT26_FINNEY_ALTON_PARENT_EXTENSION for H1 versus the Fulford1810candidate and an undocumented Alton namesake.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1861,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire to Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I151",
      "name": "Joseph Brassington",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "baptised 15 Apr 1787",
      "birth_place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "April 1860",
      "death_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_1860",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_BAPTISMS_OCCUPATIONS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Baptized 15 Apr 1787 at Ranton All Saints, son of John Brassington and Margaret. He married Esther Thompson on 24 Jul 1828 at Wolverhampton St Peter. Their 1841 and 1851 households include daughter Sarah, and Wolverhampton church transcripts list several of their children.",
      "research_note": "Civil registration establishes death in Wolverhampton in Apr-Jun 1860; supplied exact dates conflict between 9 Apr and 12 Apr, so only April 1860 is adopted. The 1801 marriage of a Joseph Brassington to Sarah Cope is not attached because this Joseph would have been about 14 and the record may belong to a namesake.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I152",
      "name": "Esther Thompson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Thompson",
      "birth_date": "baptised 14 Feb 1808",
      "birth_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "January 1874",
      "death_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_ESTHER_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_1874_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Esther Tompson was baptized at Wolverhampton St Peter on 14 Feb 1808, daughter of Thomas Tompson and Mary. She married Joseph Brassington there on 24 Jul 1828. The couple appears with their children in the 1841 and 1851 Wolverhampton censuses; the 1841 adult ages are mistranscribed, while Esther's 1851 age 43 agrees with the baptism. Wolverhampton transcripts independently list several children of Joseph and Esther.",
      "research_note": "Exact death claims conflict between 7 Jan and 13 Jan, so only January 1874 is adopted. Death was registered in Wolverhampton in Jan-Mar 1874, but the index age 59 conflicts with her established 1808 baptism.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I155",
      "name": "Thomas Grindley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Grindley",
      "birth_date": "baptised 30 Jan 1783",
      "birth_place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "26 Aug 1862",
      "death_place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_1783_1862",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_BURIAL_PROBATE_1862_1863",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1851 and 1861 censuses consistently identify Thomas Grindley, born about 1783-1784 at Forton, with wife Mary and an adult Ann Grindley. Their matching Forton origin and chronology support the relationship. He died on 26 Aug 1862, was buried on 29 Aug, and probate was granted at Lichfield on 22 Jan 1863.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: Thomas's 1783 Forton baptism explicitly names John and Elisabeth. This validates the person but not the old GEDCOM claim that he fathered Ann Grindley born in 1789, when he was about six; that relationship remains detached. A supplied profile gives death on 26 Aug 1862 at Forton. A Shropshire church marriage index explicitly names Thomas Grindly as father of Hannah Grindly. Parish records identify his baptism on 30 Jan 1783 at Forton and explicitly name parents John and Elisabeth. The incompatible Keele John Grindley and Ann Ryly parent edges were deleted, while the Forton John and Elizabeth Pickin edges remain at 0.995.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I156",
      "name": "Mary (surname unknown)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": "about 1787",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1866",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1851 and 1861 Forton censuses consistently record Mary as wife of Thomas Grindley, with ages implying birth about 1786-1787.",
      "research_note": "Her maiden surname and the existing 1866 death remain unproven. The Ireland marriage hints for Thomas Grindley and Mary Mahony are geographically unconnected to this lifelong Forton couple and are not attached.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I160",
      "name": "Richard Poyner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Poyner",
      "birth_date": "baptised 16 Apr 1759",
      "birth_place": "Newport, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "reportedly May 1833",
      "death_place": "reportedly Bridgnorth, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RICHARD_POYNER_NEWPORT_BAPTISM_1759",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Richard Poyner was baptized at Newport, Shropshire, on 16 Apr 1759, son of Richard and Elizabeth.",
      "research_note": "No supplied primary record identifies him as Sarah Poyner's father; that reported relationship conflicts with Sarah's mother-only baptism and her later statement that George Odnett was her father. The reported May 1833 Bridgnorth death is profile-derived.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I161",
      "name": "Mary Deane",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Deane",
      "birth_date": "baptised 11 Aug 1758",
      "birth_place": "Cleobury Mortimer, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "reportedly March 1835",
      "death_place": "reportedly Bridgnorth, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary Deane was baptized at Cleobury Mortimer on 11 Aug 1758, daughter of Richard and Mary Deane.",
      "research_note": "No supplied record shows her marrying Richard Poyner or becoming Mary Poyner. The former parent link to Sarah has been removed as unsupported; the reported death remains profile-derived. She would have been nearly 53 when Sarah was born in 1811, and Sarah's baptism names only Mary Poyner.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I162",
      "name": "Richard Poyner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Poyner",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_POYNER_NEWPORT_BAPTISM_1759"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The reported 1732 Newport, Wales birth is removed because the baptism is in Newport, Shropshire, and supplies no parental age or origin. Richard Poyner is explicitly named as father of the Richard baptized at Newport, Shropshire, on 16 Apr 1759. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Newport, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Richard Poyner",
          "descendant_id": "I160",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1731,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Newport, Shropshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.995,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Richard Poyner"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1759,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I163",
      "name": "Elizabeth Poyner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Poyner",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_POYNER_NEWPORT_BAPTISM_1759",
        "ROOTS26_NEWPORT_SHROPSHIRE_REGISTERS",
        "ROOTS26_Poyner_ELIZABETH_MAIDEN_LIMIT"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Shropshire’s register collection gives a concrete route to marriage, baptism, burial and neighboring-parish searches, but no identity-secure Elizabeth has yet been selected. Allen is removed as an unsupported maiden surname, and the reported 1732 Newport, Wales birth is removed. The 1759 Newport baptism names Richard's mother only as Elizabeth, wife of Richard Poyner. Poyner is the child’s household surname and must not be treated as Elizabeth’s maiden name. The 16 April 1759 Newport baptism names Richard Poyner’s mother as Elizabeth but supplies no birth surname.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Newport, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Richard Poyner",
          "descendant_id": "I160",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1731,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Newport, Shropshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.995,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Richard Poyner"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1759,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I164",
      "name": "Richard Deane",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Deane",
      "birth_date": "1716",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Cleobury Mortimer, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.75,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Mary Deane",
          "descendant_id": "I161",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1758,
          "confidence": 0.54,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I165",
      "name": "Mary Perkins",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Perkins",
      "birth_date": "1725",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Cleobury Mortimer, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.75,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Mary Deane",
          "descendant_id": "I161",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1758,
          "confidence": 0.54,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I182",
      "name": "William Peters Hanny",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hanny",
      "birth_date": "18 Jan 1802",
      "birth_place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": "before 29 Sep 1894",
      "death_place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_GRO_HANNY_CORNISH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNY_1861_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_1802_1894",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_WILTSHIRE_BURIAL_1894",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_AVON_METHODIST_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Born 18 Jan 1802 and baptized 21 Feb 1802 at Wesleyan Methodist Bradford-on-Avon, son of Wm Hanny and Eliz. Married Elizabeth Cornish in Q1 1838. The 1851 census records William and Elizabeth Hanney with children; the 1861 census records widowed-family continuity with William Peter Haney and Maria age 15. A Wiltshire burial index records burial on 29 Sep 1894, supporting the Bradford-on-Avon identity.",
      "research_note": "Death Sep 1894 remains profile-derived pending a direct death or burial record. The Yorkshire death-index hint is rejected as a namesake.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I183",
      "name": "Elizabeth Cornish",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Cornish",
      "birth_date": "about 1802-1805",
      "birth_place": "Hilperton or Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": "before 25 Feb 1854",
      "death_place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_HANNY_CORNISH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_1802_1856",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_HANNEY_WILTSHIRE_BURIAL_1854",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth Cornish married William Peters Hanny in Q1 1838. The 1851 census records Elizabeth Hanney, age 46, born Bradford, wife of William, with children including Maria age 4.",
      "research_note": "Birth year/place conflict with the census estimate about 1805 Bradford and remain unresolved. The Yorkshire Q2 1856 death hint is rejected as a namesake. A supplied profile gives birth about 1802 at Hilperton and death 25 May 1856 at Bradford-on-Avon. A Wiltshire parish burial on 25 Feb 1854 is locally and chronologically compatible and supersedes the profile-only 25 May 1856 claim.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I186",
      "name": "William Hanny",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hanny",
      "birth_date": "reported 02 Feb 1771 (baptized 03 Mar 1771)",
      "birth_place": "reported Conkwell, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": "reported 07 Mar 1837",
      "death_place": "reported Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_HANNY_1771_1837",
        "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795",
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_HANNY_CHELSEA_PENSION_1804",
        "SRC_HANNY_14TH_FOOT_SERVICE_1803",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771",
        "SRC_TNA_BRITISH_ARMY_SOLDIERS_CHELSEA_GUIDE",
        "SRC_CANNON_14TH_FOOT_1803_DEFENCE_CONTEXT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "He married Elizabeth Peters at Bradford-on-Avon on 25 June 1795 and was named as father of William Peters Hanny in the 1802 baptism.",
      "research_note": "The exact reported birth on 2 February 1771 at Conkwell and death on 7 March 1837 at Bradford-on-Avon are retained as reported values, not as direct vital-record findings. The two-year difference between the reported birth and military ages is visible rather than harmonized away. William was baptized at Winsley on 3 March 1771, explicitly named as the son of Charles and Catherine Hnney. A 25 October 1803 14th Foot record and a 16 April 1804 Chelsea pension record both describe an age-compatible William Hanny born about 1773 at Bradford; they strongly support, but do not independently prove, the military identity because neither names his parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I187",
      "name": "Elizabeth Peters",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Peters",
      "birth_date": "2 Jun 1765",
      "birth_place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_PETERS_1765_1847",
        "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795",
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_SELECT_BIRTHS",
        "SRC_GRO_ELIZABETH_PETERS_DEATH_1847_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_ELIZABETH_HANNY_DEATH_Q2_1838_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth Peters married William Hanny on 25 Jun 1795. Child indexes name Elizabeth with William as parents of Sarah, James, and William Peters Hanny.",
      "research_note": "A profile gives birth 2 Jun 1765 and death 13 Mar 1847 at Bradford-on-Avon, but the Q1 1847 civil entry is under Peters despite her documented marriage and is not adopted. FreeBMD also has an Elizabeth Hanny death in Keynsham district in Q2 1838, volume 11 page 93; the married surname and timing are compatible, but the index gives no age and does not establish identity. Her death therefore remains unknown pending a burial or certificate.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1802,
          "confidence": 0.706,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I188",
      "name": "Charles Hanney",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hanney",
      "birth_date": "about 1733",
      "birth_place": "Winsley, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": "1797 or before 8 Jan 1798",
      "death_place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CHARLES_HANNEY_1733_1797",
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL_1798",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_CUMNOCK_KIRK_SESSION_CHARLES_HANNEY_EXCLUSION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_BRADFORD_HANNY_WESLEY_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_WILTSHIRE_METHODIST_CHAPEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "Charles Hanny or Hanney married Catherine Waine at Winsley on 8 July 1765, both recorded as of the parish.",
      "research_note": "Because Charles Hanney was of the Winsley/Bradford area and had a son William baptized in 1771, H1 is a plausible generational fit; the alternative is a different Hanny household. The source does not name Mr Hanny or prove preaching with Wesley, so no new parent or occupation fact is asserted. His reported birth about 1733 at Winsley remains compiled because no matching baptism has been identified. Their son William was baptized there on 3 March 1771 and the transcript explicitly names Charles and Catherine, with phonetic or clerical spellings Hnney and Cteren. Charles was buried at Bradford-on-Avon on 8 January 1798, so his death is recorded as 1797 or before burial rather than equated with the burial date. A Charles Hanney raising children with Jannet Crawford in Cumnock, Scotland, by 1736 is an incompatible namesake. Charles's occupation and parents remain unknown; his line stops until a local baptism, settlement, apprenticeship, or probate creates an identity bridge. Local Bradford-on-Avon history reports an early local preacher identified only as Mr Hanny, followed by a son William Hanny and grandson William Peters Hanny.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I189",
      "name": "Catherine Waine",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Waine",
      "birth_date": "about 1743",
      "birth_place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": "1774",
      "death_place": "Winsley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CATHERINE_WAINE_1743_1774",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_QUAKER_BIRTHS_WAINE_EXCLUSION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_WAINE_DAFN_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_WILTSHIRE_LOCAL_WAINE_TRAIL"
      ],
      "source_note": "Catherine Waine, also indexed as Catharine, married Charles Hanny at Winsley on 8 July 1765; both were recorded as of the parish.",
      "research_note": "Her reported birth about 1743 at Bradford-on-Avon and death in 1774 at Winsley remain compiled claims because no baptism or burial has been securely matched. Their son William's 1771 Winsley baptism explicitly names Charles and Catherine under abbreviated or phonetic spellings. Bradford-on-Avon local-history resources document the town’s cloth economy and record indexes, but no source presently identifies Catherine’s parents or an earlier Waine household as hers. Published Wiltshire Quaker births contain Waine families at Purton and Purton Stoke, but no matching Catherine or bridge to Winsley, so those families are not attached. Her occupation and parents remain unknown. A local baptism, marriage allegation, settlement, or probate record would be needed to identify her birth family. Waine is an English occupational surname associated with a wain or wagon, a meaning compatible with many independent families.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I190",
      "name": "Isaiah Peters",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Peters",
      "birth_date": "09 Nov 1734",
      "birth_place": "Freshford, Bath and North East Somerset, England, GB",
      "death_date": "27 Jan 1814",
      "death_place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England, GB",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ISAIAH_PETERS_1734_PROFILE",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707"
      ],
      "source_note": "Isaiah Peters married Betty Willis at North Bradley St Nicholas on 18 June 1764.",
      "research_note": "The mother link is therefore visible at 0.62 as a plausible compiled hypothesis; the stronger evidence beyond that bottleneck must not be mistaken for proof of Isaiah's parentage. A WikiTree profile exactly matches his reported 1734 Freshford birth, 1814 Bradford-on-Avon death, spouse, and children, and proposes Priscilla Peters as his mother. Priscilla's own 1707 Freshford baptism and parents are directly confirmed, but no inspected Isaiah baptism names her.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I191",
      "name": "Betty Willis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Willis",
      "birth_date": "1737",
      "birth_place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England, GB",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_BETTY_WILLIS_1737_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1738",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_1738_FAMILY_CLUSTER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Betty Willis married Isaiah Peters at North Bradley St Nicholas on 18 June 1764; witnesses were John Butche and Richard Gibbs.",
      "research_note": "Her reported 1737 North Bradley birth remains a plausible lead, but the specific baptism used to name Benjamin Willis as father is disputed: WikiTree calls the 22 January 1737 entry Betty, while FreeREG transcribes Ann, daughter of Benjamin, on 22 January 1737/38. Benjamin therefore remains visible only as a conflicting compiled father candidate at 0.42; Betty's exact baptism and parents are unresolved. Other clustered Willis baptisms confirm a Benjamin household but do not name Betty.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1765,
          "confidence": 0.54,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I196",
      "name": "John Brassington",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "baptised 18 Nov 1764",
      "birth_place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "June 1847",
      "death_place": "Haughton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1764",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_BURIAL_1847",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Baptized 18 Nov 1764 at Ranton, son of another John Brassington and Jane. Joseph Brassington's 1787 Ranton baptism names John and Margaret as his parents. The couple appears at Haughton in 1841, both recorded age 75. John was buried at Haughton St Giles on 9 Jun 1847, age 82; civil death registration was in the Penkridge district. The former link to the separately documented John baptized at Chelmorton in 1739 was deleted as a conflation.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: the 1764 Ranton baptism names this John's parents as John and Jane. Braswell and Brasswell occur as profile aliases, but Brassington is used by the supplied parish and census records.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I197",
      "name": "Margaret (surname unknown) Brassington",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "about 1766",
      "birth_place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RANTON_PARISH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "Margaret is documented across at least fifty-four years.",
      "research_note": "Her occupation, exact birthplace, marriage, death, and parents remain unknown; her line stops until a Ranton-area marriage, settlement, probate, or other record establishes her birth family. Joseph Brassington's baptism at Ranton on 15 April 1787 explicitly names John and Margaret as his parents, and the 1841 census records John and Margaret together at Haughton, each with a rounded age of 75 and born in Staffordshire. Her estimated birth about 1766 comes only from that rounded census age. No reviewed record establishes Davidson or Davison as her maiden surname. A 1764 Kilbride, Bute baptism is geographically unconnected, and an 1839 Stone burial cannot be hers because she was alive in 1841.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1841,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Ranton and Haughton, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I92",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I93",
      "name": "Maurice H Dennis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Dennis",
      "birth_date": "03 Jan 1949",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "03 Sep 2016",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I198",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I199",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I94",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I95",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I200",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I201",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I8",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I98",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I208",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I209",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I99",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I48",
      "name": "David Livingstone Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "21 Mar 1908",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1986",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "David Livingstone Davies, born 21 Mar 1908 according to GEDCOM. The 1911 census names him age 3 in Alfred and Kezia Davies's household; the 1921 comparison names David Levingtson Davies, treated as a transcription variant.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I210",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I211",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I214",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I215",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I212",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I213",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I202",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I203",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I204",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I205",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I206",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I216",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I207",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I43",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I221",
      "name": "Suzanne Faith Newman",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I222",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I223",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I224",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I225",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I157",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I5",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I6",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I30",
      "name": "Edna Kohl Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "1922",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "2003",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1930 census names Edna K. Fricke as George and Florence's child; the 1940 census repeats Edna Frecke in the same East Orange household.",
      "research_note": "The original family tree reported Edna with missing surname, born 1922 and died 2003. A compiled family tree expands K to Kohl. Edna Kohl Fricke is the working name, with the expansion still awaiting a vital record.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I90",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I91",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I17",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I226",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I227",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I228",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I229",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I230",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I231",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I217",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I218",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I219",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I220",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I233",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I232",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I234",
      "name": "Mary Shaw",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Shaw",
      "birth_date": "reported 1670",
      "birth_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, US",
      "death_date": "reported 1728",
      "death_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, US",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No original marriage, baptism, probate, or deed directly establishing her identity was located; reported dates and places remain tree-derived. Evidence review: compiled McNew/Marlow histories identify Mary Shaw as Edward Marlow's wife and Sarah Marlow's mother.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I235",
      "name": "Edward Marlow",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Marlow",
      "birth_date": "reported 1666",
      "birth_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, US",
      "death_date": "reported 1 May 1751",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MSA_PRINCE_GEORGES_RENT_ROLL_SMALL_HOPES_EDWARD_MARLOW",
        "SRC_ROOTSMAGIC_EDWARD_MARLOW_1743_DEPOSITION_TRANSCRIPTION"
      ],
      "source_note": "Small Hopes is listed to Edward Marlow in the Maryland State Archives rent roll: 141 acres, folio 91. A separately cited transcription of a 19 March 1743/44 Prince George's County deposition calls Edward Marlow Sr. about 78.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: compiled McNew/Marlow histories identify Edward Marlow as Mary Shaw's husband and Sarah Marlow's father. The exact 1666 birth and 1 May 1751 death remain unverified, and no direct record naming Sarah as his child was located. The live alternative is a same-name or younger Edward in the land record, because the rent-roll entry itself gives no age or family relationships. Together these records make the reported mid-1660s birth chronology and Prince George's County setting the leading identification for this individual. Neither source establishes Mary Shaw as wife, Sarah as child, or William Marlow as father.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I236",
      "name": "Elizabeth Williams",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Williams",
      "birth_date": "reported 1650",
      "birth_place": "reported Charles County, Maryland",
      "death_date": "reported 1683",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.46,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_CHRONOLOGY",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Derivative Marlow histories identify Elizabeth Williams as Edward Marlow's mother and William Marlow's wife, but disagree about dates and children and provide no marriage, deed, will, probate, baptism, or other direct identity record. The later county must not be projected backward without a specific place or record. Her reported death in 1683 is also unverified. The repeated family hypothesis remains at 0.50, but her line stops until an original record distinguishes her and resolves which Maryland jurisdiction, if either, was intended. Her reported birth in 1650 at Charles County is geographically ambiguous: Old Charles County was created in 1650 and abolished in 1653, while present-day Charles County was created with different bounds in 1658. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I237",
      "name": "William Marlow",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Marlow",
      "birth_date": "reported 1636",
      "birth_place": "reported England",
      "death_date": "reported 1683",
      "death_place": "reported Charles County, Maryland",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.52,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MARLOW_ENGLISH_PARENTAGE_REVIEW_20260728",
        "ROOTS26_MARLOW_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_MARYLAND_EARLY_SETTLERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Maryland’s official early-settlers database identifies the land-patent series needed to test the compiled William Marlow; the current local index places a William Marlow at Poplar Hill in 1667/1668 but is derivative and must be distinguished from the Charles County compiled profile. William Marlow remains a plausible compiled father of Edward Marlow, but his reported English birth and all proposed English parentage are unverified. Conflicting online trees place him in different English localities and give incompatible dates and parents. The surname is habitational from Marlow, Buckinghamshire, but this does not establish William’s English birthplace. No inspected record connects the Maryland Marlow evidence to Robert Marlow and Ann Hall, so no English parent relationship is retained. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I241",
      "name": "Johannes Göbel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Göbel",
      "birth_date": "11 Oct 1641",
      "birth_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "5 Jun 1732",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: multiple derivative trees consistently identify Johannes Ignatius Göbel of Erpfingen, spouse Ursula Batzer, with reported 1645-1714 dates. Archion confirms the relevant Erpfingen registers survive, but the original baptism, marriage, and burial entries were not accessible. The reported name \"Johannes Ignatius\" and 1645-1714 dates were derivative conflation. The same reconstruction lists ten Erpfingen children born 1671-1692 and does not bridge this couple to Hans Jacob Gabel, reported born 1670 in Göda; that parent link is retained only as a strongly conflicting derivative hypothesis at 0.18. Current 15 September 2026 comparison supersedes the earlier .18 assessment: a distinct Erpfingen son Hans Jacob born 1689 is now recorded; the proposed link to Offenbach Hans Jacob I111 is .10. Exact vitals and parentage remain reported. The decisive concern is the documented competing household, not missing proof or an assumed completeness of the ten-child list. Correction: the parish-register-based Weigel pedigree identifies this man as Johannes Göbel, tailor and judge, born 11 Oct 1641, married 10 May 1670, and died 5 Jun 1732. Correction: the parish-register-based Weigel pedigree identifies this man as Johannes Göbel, tailor and judge, born 11 Oct 1641, married 10 May 1670, and died 5 Jun 1732.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I243",
      "name": "Martin Göbel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Göbel",
      "birth_date": "6 Dec 1600",
      "birth_place": "Erpfingen, Wurttemberg",
      "death_date": "10 Mar 1673",
      "death_place": "Willmandingen, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBEL_GENI",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: derivative Erpfingen trees consistently identify Martin Goebel as Johannes Ignatius's father and Anna Katharina Kissling's partner. Archion confirms the relevant registers survive, but no original baptism, marriage, or burial entry was inspected. Further evidence: the Weigel pedigree directly quotes the parish-derived 6 Dec 1600 birth, parents Martin Göbell and Margaretha Berlin, and 10 Mar 1673 Willmandingen burial aged 73. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I244",
      "name": "Margaretha (Margreth) Berlin",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Berlin",
      "birth_date": "baptised 27 Nov 1576",
      "birth_place": "Weinsberg, Wurttemberg",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: the parish-based pedigree identifies Margreth Berlin as mother of Martin born 6 Dec 1600 and gives her Weinsberg baptism to Magister Johans Berlin and Anna. The Erpfingen marriage entry around Nov 1597 is nearly illegible and no burial was found. Terminal-branch expansion: the published parish-based pedigree explicitly names her parents as Magister Johans Berlin and Anna; both have now been added at source-backed confidence. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1600,
          "confidence": 0.698,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I245",
      "name": "Martin Goebel (elder, forest servant)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Goebel",
      "birth_date": "about 1575",
      "birth_place": "Erpfingen, Wurttemberg",
      "death_date": "3 Aug 1662",
      "death_place": "Willmandingen, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: Erpfingen/Willmandingen church-book transcriptions identify the elder Martin as a ducal forest servant, born about 1575 and buried 3 Aug 1662, husband of Margreth Berlin and father of Martin born 1600. Correction 15 September 2026: Weigel entry ?5152 does propose Hans Göbel (about 1550–about 1627) as his father, explicitly marking the filiation uncertain; no mother is named. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I246",
      "name": "Margaretha Koch",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Koch",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1551",
      "birth_place": "reported Erpfingen area, Wurttemberg",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_KOCH_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_ERPFINGEN_LOCAL_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_ERPFINGEN_MATRICULA_COVERAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel proposes Hans Göbel as tentative father at ?5152 but leaves Martin’s mother unnamed. Corrects the earlier assertion that neither parent was mentioned.",
      "research_note": "Reassessment 15 September 2026: Margaretha Koch remains a mother candidate from the Ancestry compiled profile. H1 she is Martin’s mother; alternative the tree has assigned a different woman or inferred spouse as mother. Reported age is compatible but no independently verified personal event or mother-naming record was found. No demonstrated rival mother or new source supporting Koch found; candidate status retained. Koch is a German occupational surname meaning cook, but this meaning does not identify Margaretha’s family. Omission limits corroboration; it is not evidence that Margaretha was not the mother.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I247",
      "name": "Hannssen Goebells",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Goebells",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1550",
      "birth_place": "reported Erpfingen area, Wurttemberg",
      "death_date": "reported 1627",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ALTWUERTTEMBERG_LAGERBUCH_1522_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Reassessment 15 September 2026: the earlier claim that Weigel omits Hans is incorrect. Alternative: Hans was another relative/local Göbel rather than Martin’s father; no specifically identified rival father found. Search original 1597 marriage, Hans burial, inheritance, land succession and forestry appointment records. Entry ?5152, printed p.250 (PDF page index 250), names Hans Göbel in Erpfingen, born about 1550, died about 1627, as tentative father of Martin #2576, explicitly stating Filiation ist nicht gesichert (parentage is not established). Same name, locality and coherent dates support the proposed identification with I247 and justify a positive parent hypothesis. Hans is the leading named father candidate, but the alternatives remain poorly distinguished. Retain candidate status and ordinal score pending new discriminating evidence. The pedigree supplies no underlying parent-naming record here and its dependence on public trees is unknown; do not count it as independent confirmation. Parish catalogue begins in 1594, after Martin’s estimated birth. No new parent link established. Ludwig Göbel recorded in 1522 is a potential earlier relative, not a demonstrated father of Hans: an adult in 1522 fathering a child about 1550 would entail relatively late fatherhood; a grandfather or collateral connection also fits.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I248",
      "name": "Richard Poyner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Poyner",
      "birth_date": "Apr 1696",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Newport, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.746,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Richard Poyner",
          "descendant_id": "I160",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I249",
      "name": "Mary",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": "1700",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported profile; alternatives are another person with the same given name, an incomplete GEDCOM identity, or a transcription artifact. The original family tree supplied this profile. The supplied GEDCOM contains only the given-name profile “Mary None”; no surname, dates, locality, parents, spouse or independent record is attached. No parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Newport, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.746,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Richard Poyner",
          "descendant_id": "I160",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "I250",
      "name": "Henriette Charlotte Heinderike Mueller",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Mueller",
      "birth_date": "1829",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1892",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUELLER_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_HANOVER_CHURCH_ARCHIVE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mueller/Müller is a very common German occupational surname meaning miller, with an independent Ashkenazic usage and common American spellings Mueller, Muller and Miller.",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile. The official Hanover church archive is the concrete route to parish registers; Henriette’s parish and parents remain unestablished. That frequency makes surname-only identification weak.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I251",
      "name": "Henry Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "1817",
      "birth_place": "Hanover, Lower Saxony, DE",
      "death_date": "1893",
      "death_place": "Missouri, US",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplied this profile.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "I32",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I4",
      "name": "Matthew Fricke",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I23",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I26",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I34",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I2",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I35",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I19",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I36",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I22",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I24",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I37",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I40",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "I20",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BRASSINGTON_ELLEN_1686",
      "name": "Ellen Brassington",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "1686",
      "birth_place": "Great Longstone, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_ANCESTRY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The external snippet places Ellen Brassington, reportedly born 1686 at Great Longstone, with Joseph Brassington and Esther Thompson. That parentage is impossible because Joseph was baptized in 1787 and Esther in 1808.",
      "research_note": "Ellen is retained only as a rejected conflated record.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HANNY_WILLIAM_HENRY_1839",
      "name": "William Henry Hanny",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hanny",
      "birth_date": "21 MAR 1839",
      "birth_place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_ANCESTRY",
        "SRC_HANNY_BHO",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "External family sources identify William Henry Hanny, born 21 Mar 1839, as child of William Peters Hanny and Elizabeth Cornish.",
      "research_note": "The 1851 household lists Henery Hanney age 12, a strong age and family match; the William/Henry given-name difference remains documented.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1851,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MCNEW_MARY_LUCY_1709",
      "name": "Mary Lucy McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "8 FEB 1708/09",
      "birth_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland",
      "death_date": "about 1762",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MCNEW_ANNE_1711",
      "name": "Anne McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "8 NOV 1711",
      "birth_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland",
      "death_date": "after NOV 1774",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "Jeremiah Jr's timeline independently repeats this child in the family sequence.",
      "research_note": "Sibling of direct ancestor William McNew; source page centers on Anne.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MCNEW_EDWARD_MARLEY_1713",
      "name": "Edward Marley McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "14 AUG 1713",
      "birth_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland",
      "death_date": "1791",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HANNY_JAMES_1844",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hanny",
      "birth_date": "about 1844",
      "birth_place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": "1845",
      "death_place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate sibling of Maria Hanny; listed under William Peters Hanny and Elizabeth Cornish. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HANNY_SARAH_1798",
      "name": "Sarah Hanny",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hanny",
      "birth_date": "9 MAY 1798",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_GENI_WILLIAM",
        "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_CHILD_RECORD",
        "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_SELECT_BIRTHS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate Sarah Hanny, born 9 May 1798 from public-tree chronology. Multiple excerpts name William and Elizabeth Hanny/Hanney with child Sarah, but supplied direct record details omit Sarah's event date, so identity remains provisional. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_RHEAD_STEPHEN_HENRY_1836",
      "name": "Stephen Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "about 1835",
      "birth_place": "reported Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "reported 1890",
      "death_place": "reported Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG",
        "SRC_RHEAD_YOURROOTS_STEPhen"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original 1841 census image places Stephen Rhead, age six, in the Sampson and Sarah Rhead household with Richard, George, and Ruth.",
      "research_note": "It does not use the names Handley or Maria and does not prove a relationship label because the 1841 form has no relationship column. A later public tree supplies the 1890 death claim but wrongly attaches this household to Sampson Handley Rhead; that attachment is rejected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_POYNER_CHARLES_PRE_1675",
      "name": "Charles Poyner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Poyner",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.43,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_POYNER_ANCESTRY_RICHARD",
        "ROOTS26_POYNER_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_STANTON_LACY_REGISTER_CATALOGUE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Poyner is a West Midlands/English surname with Norman nickname and variant spellings Poynor, Punyer and Powner.",
      "research_note": "Oxford’s early-bearer evidence includes Shropshire forms, while the Stanton Lacy register coverage begins in 1561. Candidate upstream Poyner parent from snippet naming father Charles for Richard Poyner b.1675; relationship to existing Richard Poyner chain is plausible but ambiguous. This supports the surname and locality context but does not identify Charles’s parents or connect him to the later Richard chain.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Newport, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.261,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Richard Poyner",
          "descendant_id": "I160",
          "distance": 3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_HANS_CONRAD",
      "name": "Hans Conrad Rheinmueller",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rheinmueller",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Several derivative Goble and Gabel compilations name Hans Conrad Rheinmueller as Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller's father. His father edge remains 0.55: a plausible research hypothesis awaiting a German parish, court, tax, or property record that identifies this family. All presently identified exact-name instances repeat the same copied family structure rather than offering independent evidence. The most detailed database places the daughter's 1690/91 marriage at a malformed “Offenbach, Am Glam, Zweibruecken,” probably intended as Offenbach am Glan, but gives Hans no dates, residence, marriage, occupation, property, or parents and cites no parish record.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Offenbach am Glan, Duchy of Zweibruecken (now Rheinland-Pfalz), Germany",
          "confidence": 0.517,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Johann Friedrich Gabel",
          "descendant_id": "I109",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_MARIA_MARGARETHA_MOTHER",
      "name": "Maria Margaretha",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "A derivative Goble database identifies Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller's mother only as Maria Margaretha and implicitly pairs her with Hans Conrad Rheinmueller. Her 0.32 maternal edge remains visible as an incomplete hypothesis, but ancestry or local biography would be identity-free speculation until an original record supplies a surname and family. The malformed Offenbach place belongs to her reported daughter's marriage and cannot be assigned to the mother. No date, place, marriage, church, civil, property, or probate record distinguishes her from other women with these common given names.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Offenbach am Glan, Duchy of Zweibruecken (now Rheinland-Pfalz), Germany",
          "confidence": 0.301,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Johann Friedrich Gabel",
          "descendant_id": "I109",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "name": "Fredrick Gabel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel",
      "birth_date": "about 1644",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "He conflicts with the more consistently repeated Gabel and Rheinmueller family structure and has no original baptism, marriage, parish, land, probate, or civil record. The parent edge remains visible at 0.18 solely as a named conflicting hypothesis. His reported birth about 1644 and generic German setting cannot distinguish him from other Gabel families. Fredrick Gabel appears only as an alternate father of Hans Jacob Gabel in a collaborative FamilySearch-derived tree. No local life narrative or ancestry can responsibly be assigned until a record identifies the correct Hans Jacob and his parents. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Germany; exact birthplace unverified",
          "confidence": 0.18,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Hans (Johann) Jacob Gabel",
          "descendant_id": "I111",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "name": "Anne Catherine Juul",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Juul",
      "birth_date": "about 1648",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "She conflicts with the more consistently repeated Ursula Batzer and Rheinmueller structure and has no original baptism, marriage, parish, probate, or civil record. The mother edge remains visible at 0.18 as a conflicting hypothesis, not a documented relationship. Her reported birth about 1648 and generic German setting do not establish a locality or identity. Anne Catherine Juul appears only as an alternate mother of Hans Jacob Gabel in a collaborative FamilySearch-derived tree. Her line stops until an original record identifies Hans Jacob's mother. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "name": "Maria Magdalena Spiess",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Spiess",
      "birth_date": "about 1701",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate spouse of Johann Friedrich Gabel; possible mother of direct ancestor Johann Friedrich (Frederick) Gobble in some published trees. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Offenbach, Darmstadt, Hessen, DE",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Johann Friedrich (Frederick) Gobble",
          "descendant_id": "I107",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "name": "Mary (surname unresolved) McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "about 1718",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "20 Mar 1798",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_DERIVATION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "In 1773 the household reportedly moved southwest with four younger sons along the Great Valley Road into the area then called Fincastle County, Virginia.",
      "research_note": "The account places her within a well-known migration corridor from Maryland and Pennsylvania through the Shenandoah Valley, but it remains a later family history rather than a record created during the journey. Berry, Eckless, and Clemons are conflicting derivative maiden names, and her reported 1718 birth and 1798 death remain compiled. Mary is identified by published McNew-Cawood research as William McNew's wife and mother of sons including George. The evidence supports a woman named Mary in this migrating family. No marriage, deed, will, church record, or pension identifies her birth family.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Frederick County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "George Albert McNew",
          "descendant_id": "I124",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "name": "Elisha I. McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1746",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "Jan 1804",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Son of William McNew and Mary Eckless Berry; parent of William J. McNew sibling cluster.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "confidence": 0.608,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_NANCY_CATHERINE_SMITH_12_OCT_1756_14_SEP",
      "name": "Nancy Catherine Smith",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Smith",
      "birth_date": "12 Oct 1756",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "14 Sep 1841",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Spouse of Elisha I. McNew; mother in William J. McNew page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JEREMIAH_MCNEW_CHILD_OF_WILLIAM",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SHADRACK_MCNEW_1743_1823",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1743",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1823",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate child in William McNew/Mary Berry family from McNew ecosystem snippets. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_GEORGE_E_MCNEW_SR_17_NOV_1763_5_MAY_1846",
      "name": "George E. McNew Sr.",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "17 Nov 1763",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "5 May 1846",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate child in William McNew/Mary Berry family from McNew ecosystem snippets. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_EDWARD_MCNEW_FALL_1755",
      "name": "Edward McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "Fall 1755",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate child in William McNew/Mary Berry family from McNew ecosystem snippets. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_BERRY_MCNEW",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_DANIEL_SHADRACK_MCNEW_1745_1765",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1745",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1765",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate child in William McNew/Mary Berry family from McNew ecosystem snippets. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARY_POLLY_MCNEW_1779_BEFORE_1810",
      "name": "Mary Polly McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1779",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "before 1810",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820",
      "name": "John McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1785-1794",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1820",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_REBECCA_MCNEW_ABOUT_1781_BEFORE_1812",
      "name": "Rebecca McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "about 1781",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "before 1812",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_CATHERINE_MCNEW_1783_9_JUN_1858",
      "name": "Catherine McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1783",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "9 Jun 1858",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_TOBIAS_MCNEW_1785_FEB_1814",
      "name": "Tobias McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1785",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "Feb 1814",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_WILLIAM_J_MCNEW_1786_1839",
      "name": "William J. McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1786",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1839",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ELISHA_MCNEW_13_SEP_1788_26_AUG_1854",
      "name": "Elisha McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "13 Sep 1788",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "26 Aug 1854",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_NANCY_MCNEW_1790_BETWEEN_1860_AND_1870",
      "name": "Nancy McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1790",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "between 1860 and 1870",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_GEORGE_MCNEW_ABOUT_1792_1_OCT_1828",
      "name": "George McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "about 1792",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1 Oct 1828",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ISAAC_MCNEW_1795_20_OCT_1819",
      "name": "Isaac McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1795",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "20 Oct 1819",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_BETSY_MCNEW_21_APR_1797_1_JAN_",
      "name": "Elizabeth Betsy McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "21 Apr 1797",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1 Jan 1855",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARGARET_MCNEW_1799_1840",
      "name": "Margaret McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1799",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1840",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith on Nathan McNew William J. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_LUCY_WALKER_BET_1785_AND_1794_BEFORE_180",
      "name": "Lucy Walker",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Walker",
      "birth_date": "Bet 1785 and 1794",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "before 1806",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Spouse of William J. McNew in Nathan McNew genealogy.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SARAH_CATHERINE_SMITH_1790_5_APR_1883",
      "name": "Sarah Catherine Smith",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Smith",
      "birth_date": "1790",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "5 Apr 1883",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Spouse of William J. McNew in Nathan McNew genealogy.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780",
      "name": "Sarah Athey",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Athey",
      "birth_date": "1780",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Spouse of John McNew; daughter of John Queen Athey in Athey sources.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1817,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
      "name": "Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1798",
      "birth_place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "death_date": "before 1847",
      "death_place": "reported Brown County, Illinois, United States",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1798_LUKE_PERRY",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_MCNEW_SARAH_ATHEY_F14178",
        "SRC_GENEALOGYTRAILS_PERRY_CEMETERY_ELISHA_1818_1889",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_LUKE_PERRY_ELIZABETH_WHITE_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nathan McNew and Cook independently reconstruct Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew as Luke Perry's wife. A Brown County cemetery transcription calls their son Elisha the son of Luke Perry and Betty McNew, strongly corroborating the couple. A public Ancestry tree instead calls the wife Elizabeth White while repeating the same apparent Luke Perry and children; it has no accessible original citation.",
      "research_note": "McNew is the better-supported identity, but the 1814 marriage and her proposed parents remain circumstantial until an original record is reviewed.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "name": "John S. McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "15 Nov 1806",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1 Jan 1876",
      "death_place": "Henry County, Missouri, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "John S. McNew is independently placed in the Deepwater, Henry County, Missouri family by a cemetery transcription and two genealogical reconstructions. They agree on death on 1 January 1876, the 8 November 1839 Pettis County marriage, and later Henry County residence. They disagree about his birth location and the surname of his wife.",
      "research_note": "The Nathan McNew page proposes John McNew and Sarah Athey as parents, but the stronger adult-identity evidence does not by itself prove that parentage.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARTHA_MCNEW_7_APR_1812_3_NOV_1877",
      "name": "Martha McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "7 Apr 1812",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "3 Nov 1877",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John McNew and Sarah Athey on Nathan McNew John S. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_FREDERICK_J_MCNEW_1813_ABOUT_1872",
      "name": "Frederick J. McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1813",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "about 1872",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John McNew and Sarah Athey on Nathan McNew John S. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SARAH_JANE_MCNEW_ABOUT_1817_POSSIBLY_186",
      "name": "Sarah Jane McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "about 1817",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "possibly 1863",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John McNew and Sarah Athey on Nathan McNew John S. page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "name": "Sarah A. Lusby (reported; formerly Willoughby)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lusby",
      "birth_date": "1810-1820",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "15 Oct 1862",
      "death_place": "Henry County, Missouri, United States",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_SARAH_LUSBY_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The full Sarah profile reports a Lusby birth surname and an earlier Willoughby marriage. That sequence explains the later McNew identity and both surnames more economically than a surname transcription error.",
      "research_note": "A conflation of women remains possible; the original marriage entries have not been inspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_HUGH_MCNEW_ABOUT_1841",
      "name": "Hugh McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "about 1841",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_NANCY_MCNEW_DAUGHTER_OF_JOHN_S_ABOUT_184",
      "name": "Nancy McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "about 1844",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_WILLIAM_MCNEW_SON_OF_JOHN_S_1845",
      "name": "William McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "1845",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_BISER_MCNEW_OCT_1846_2_MAR_1919",
      "name": "John Biser McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "Oct 1846",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "2 Mar 1919",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_HENRY_MCNEW_22_JAN_1848_31_DEC_1848",
      "name": "Henry McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "22 Jan 1848",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "31 Dec 1848",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_FREDERICK_MCNEW_ABOUT_1849_ON_OR_BEFORE_",
      "name": "Frederick McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "about 1849",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "on or before 1890",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ELISHA_MCNEIL_ABOUT_1851",
      "name": "Elisha McNeil",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNeil",
      "birth_date": "about 1851",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JAMES_R_MCNEW_ABOUT_1853",
      "name": "James R. McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "about 1853",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARY_MCNEW_DAUGHTER_OF_JOHN_S_ABOUT_1853",
      "name": "Mary McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "about 1853",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SUSAN_A_MCNEW_ABOUT_1856",
      "name": "Susan A. McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "about 1856",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SALLY_A_MCNEW_ABOUT_1857",
      "name": "Sally A. McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": "about 1857",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_TOBIAS_SMITH_16_MAR_1725_1781",
      "name": "Tobias Smith",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Smith",
      "birth_date": "16 Mar 1725",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1781",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Father of Nancy Catherine Smith in Nathan McNew ancestor list.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARY_MCDONALD_19_JAN_1730_1809",
      "name": "Mary McDonald",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McDonald",
      "birth_date": "19 Jan 1730",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1809",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_CHALKLEY_1757",
        "SRC_OT26_SMYTH_MCDONALD_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Early Southwest Virginia Families identifies her as Mary McDonald, wife of Tobias Smyth, born 19 January 1730, in the same Virginia neighborhood as Bryan and the Robinsons. Widow Scott remarriage and Tobias death circa 1760–70 require comparison with other family dates. See RN_OT26_MCDONALD_DELAWARE_VIRGINIA_BRIDGE.",
      "research_note": "Exact birth and reported 1809 death remain derivative. Its child list names Catherine, not the full Nancy Catherine identity; the separate McNew maternal edge remains provisional. Mary Smith is explicitly named daughter of Bryan McDonald in his 1757 will abstract. This is the leading identification.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_HANS_JURGEN_GEORG_SMITH_SMIDT_3_NOV_1696",
      "name": "Hans Jurgen Georg Smith/Smidt",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Smith/Smidt",
      "birth_date": "3 Nov 1696",
      "birth_place": "Falun, Dalarna, Sweden",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BURIAL_1753",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_HANS_SMIDT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parent of Tobias Smith in ancestor list.",
      "research_note": "The proposed parents are separately marked as candidates. His1753 burial transcript explicitly identifies Falun as his birthplace and hatmaking as his trade. Burial was27December1753; no exact death date is inferred.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARIA_STALLKOP_15_MAR_1697_19_NOV_1750",
      "name": "Maria Stallkop",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Stallkop",
      "birth_date": "15 Mar 1697",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "19 Nov 1750",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Parent of Tobias Smith in ancestor list.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PETER_STALLKOP_ABOUT_3_SEP_1709",
      "name": "Peter Stallkop",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Stallkop",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "between 3 Sep 1709 and 16 May 1710",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWCASTLE_WILL_INDEX"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parent of Maria Stallkop in ancestor list. The former death date was the will date.",
      "research_note": "The probate index bounds his death between the will and its proof; the original will remains uninspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_KATHERINE_PETERSON",
      "name": "Katherine Peterson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Peterson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_STALLKOP_NAME_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parent of Maria Stallkop in ancestor list.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported mother; alternatives are another Katherine Peterson, a variant patronymic, or an inferred spouse created from the daughter’s surname. Katherine Peterson is known only as Maria Stallkop’s mother in an ancestor list. No birth, origin, marriage, death, occupation, or parent record identifies her. No new edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_BRYAN_MCDONALD_NOV_1686_21_MAY_1757",
      "name": "Bryan McDonald",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McDonald",
      "birth_date": "Nov 1686",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "BET 21 May 1757 AND 18 Aug 1757",
      "death_place": "Augusta County, Virginia (estate jurisdiction)",
      "status": "supported_documentary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_CHALKLEY_1757",
        "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_FRANK_1879",
        "SRC_OT26_SMYTH_MCDONALD_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Bryan McDonald’s Augusta will, dated 21 May 1757 and proved 18 August 1757, names daughter Mary Smith, wife Catherine and the associated McDonald–Armstrong family. Exact death formerly copied from will date corrected to interval. A 1746/47 New Castle deed transcription names Bryan junior and wife Catherine and expressly identifies his father, Bryan senior, whose 1707 will devised the land. This couple is the strongly favored origin for the Virginia couple, with original deed/residence comparison still desirable. See RN_OT26_MCDONALD_DELAWARE_VIRGINIA_BRIDGE; no Glencoe descent assumed.",
      "research_note": "November 1686 birth remains reported, not verified.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_CATHERINE_PRISCILLA_ROBINSON_ABOUT_1694_",
      "name": "Catherine Priscilla Robinson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Robinson",
      "birth_date": "about 1694",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "after May 1766",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Mother of Mary McDonald in ancestor list.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_QUEEN_ATHEY_24_MAY_1756_1831",
      "name": "John Queen Athey",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Athey",
      "birth_date": "24 May 1756",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1831",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Father of Sarah Athey.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "confidence": 0.584,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARGARET_ATHEY",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_THOMAS_ALVIN_ATHEY",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SUSAN_ATHEY_EWELL",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_ATHEY_HALE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_FANETTA_ATHEY_COTTINGIM",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_THOMAS_ATHEY_14_FEB_1717_AFTER_1766",
      "name": "Thomas Athey",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Athey",
      "birth_date": "14 Feb 1717",
      "birth_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "after 1766",
      "death_place": "reported Prince William County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "SRC_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_PARENTAGE_RECONCILIATION_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1932_JOHN_INVENTORY_PARENTAGE_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas Athey, born 14 February 1717, is the man in the John Queen Athey descent.",
      "research_note": "The earlier imported Thomas Sr./Elizabeth parent pair is an alternative on a separate compiled page that itself acknowledges the John/Margaret attribution. A focused Athey reconstruction names his parents John Athey and Margaret Lewis, first wife Judith, and second wife Elinor Queen; it places John Queen's 1756 birth in that second household and records Fairfax County appearances in 1755 and 1758. The John/Margaret placement is the more likely account, supported by published reports of the 1711 marriage and 1729/30 inventory, but the underlying originals remain to be inspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ELINOR_LUCILLE_QUEEN_1716_BETWEEN_1769_A",
      "name": "Elinor Queen (parentage disputed)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Queen",
      "birth_date": "reported 1716 (disputed)",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "between 1769 and 1773",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "SRC_ATHY_ELINOR_PARENT_CONFLICT_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ancestor of Sarah Athey in Nathan McNew genealogy.",
      "research_note": "Her parentage and reported 1716 birth remain unresolved; the Queen branch extension is conditional on this weak bridge. 15 September 2026 review: The cited Athy reconstruction distinguishes mother Elinor Queen from daughter Eleanor Lucille Athy (born 1762), and calls Elinor daughter of Richard Queen.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "confidence": 0.339,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
          "distance": 3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "name": "Marsham Queen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Queen",
      "birth_date": "before 1703",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "28 Oct 1771",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parent of Elinor Lucille Queen; Queen family cluster.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "confidence": 0.102,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
          "distance": 4
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "name": "Mary Jameson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Jameson",
      "birth_date": "about 1704",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "after 1755",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parent of Elinor Lucille Queen; Queen family cluster.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "confidence": 0.085,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
          "distance": 4
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARY_QUEEN",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SARAH_QUEEN_ABOUT_1741",
      "name": "Sarah Queen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Queen",
      "birth_date": "about 1741",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_22"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Queen family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; relationship to Marsham Queen/Mary Jameson treated as low-confidence candidate unless otherwise specified. 15 September 2026 review: Reconnected to the named parental household with independently graded paternal and maternal links. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARGARET_QUEEN_ABOUT_1746",
      "name": "Margaret Queen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Queen",
      "birth_date": "about 1746",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_10"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Queen family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; relationship to Marsham Queen/Mary Jameson treated as low-confidence candidate unless otherwise specified. 15 September 2026 review: Reconnected to the named parental household with independently graded paternal and maternal links. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ANNE_QUEEN_ABOUT_1792",
      "name": "Anne Queen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Queen",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1736",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported about 1792",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_23"
      ],
      "source_note": "The prior import reversed the event type. Anne is also named in the Thomas Semmes biography.",
      "research_note": "Queen family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; relationship to Marsham Queen/Mary Jameson treated as low-confidence candidate unless otherwise specified. 15 September 2026 review: The individual page identifies about 1792 as death, with reported birth about 1736. 15 September 2026 review: Reconnected to the named parental household with independently graded paternal and maternal links.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_QUEEN_BEFORE_1745",
      "name": "Elizabeth Queen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Queen",
      "birth_date": "before 1745",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_11"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Queen family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; relationship to Marsham Queen/Mary Jameson treated as low-confidence candidate unless otherwise specified. 15 September 2026 review: Reconnected to the named parental household with independently graded paternal and maternal links. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SAMUEL_QUEEN_ABOUT_1735",
      "name": "Samuel Queen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Queen",
      "birth_date": "about 1735",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Queen family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; relationship to Marsham Queen/Mary Jameson treated as low-confidence candidate unless otherwise specified. 15 September 2026 review: Reconnected to the named parental household with independently graded paternal and maternal links. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_LEONARD_QUEEN_ABOUT_1732",
      "name": "Leonard Queen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Queen",
      "birth_date": "about 1732",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Queen family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; relationship to Marsham Queen/Mary Jameson treated as low-confidence candidate unless otherwise specified. 15 September 2026 review: Reconnected to the named parental household with independently graded paternal and maternal links. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_CLEMENTINE_QUEEN_ABOUT_1738",
      "name": "Clementine Queen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Queen",
      "birth_date": "about 1738",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_12"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Queen family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; relationship to Marsham Queen/Mary Jameson treated as low-confidence candidate unless otherwise specified. 15 September 2026 review: Reconnected to the named parental household with independently graded paternal and maternal links. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_WILLIAM_QUEEN_1726",
      "name": "William Queen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Queen",
      "birth_date": "1726",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_8"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Queen family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; relationship to Marsham Queen/Mary Jameson treated as low-confidence candidate unless otherwise specified. 15 September 2026 review: Reconnected to the named parental household with independently graded paternal and maternal links. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_RICHARD_QUEEN_1725",
      "name": "Richard Queen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Queen",
      "birth_date": "1725",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_7"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Queen family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; relationship to Marsham Queen/Mary Jameson treated as low-confidence candidate unless otherwise specified. 15 September 2026 review: Reconnected to the named parental household with independently graded paternal and maternal links. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_JR_BEFORE_NOV_1723",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "name": "Ralph Shaw",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Shaw",
      "birth_date": "before 1651",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "after Mar 1710",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES_COUNTY_DEED_1671_1674",
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_RENT_ROLL",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ralph Shaw was an established planter in Charles County, Maryland, by June 1672. George Taylor conveyed him land in exchange for a gray mare and colt and 1,000 pounds of tobacco, illustrating the mixed livestock-and-tobacco economy of the colony. Rent-roll material confirms continued landholding, and a 1710/11 agreement names his then-wife Ann and arranged lifetime support through Edward Marlow.",
      "research_note": "Because the deed records an adult contracting purchaser, an earlier reported birth about 1665 is impossible; the profile therefore gives only the supported constraint that he was born before 1651. Claims about his daughters depend partly on later reconstruction and remain separately qualified. The records identify Ralph's property and local family network but do not reveal his birthplace or parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, US",
          "confidence": 0.56,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Mary Shaw",
          "descendant_id": "I234",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "name": "Ann (maiden name unknown) Shaw",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Shaw",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The arrangement reserved support for the couple and connects them to Edward Marlow's household.",
      "research_note": "Ralph had adult daughters associated with an earlier wife, so Ann should not be assumed to be their mother. The current individual compilation instead describes an Ann reportedly born about 1653 and dead 1698, conflicting with the Ann demonstrably alive as Ralph's wife in 1710/11. Ann is directly named as Ralph Shaw's wife in a Charles County agreement dated 19 March 1710/11. It does not state Ann's maiden name, age, birthplace, parents, or children. 15 September 2026 review: The source locality entry about 1665 is a marriage event, not a birth. No birth estimate or maiden name is secure for the documented later wife. Her profile represents a documented married identity whose origins remain unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, US",
          "confidence": 0.12,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Mary Shaw",
          "descendant_id": "I234",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1651,
          "confidence": 0.533,
          "basis": "estimated from spouse's birth year",
          "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, US",
          "place_confidence": 0.12,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Mary Shaw"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1710,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_DOROTHY_SHAW_ABOUT_1668",
      "name": "Dorothy Shaw",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Shaw",
      "birth_date": "about 1668",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Shaw collateral from Nathan McNew places page.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ANN_SHAW_JR_1698",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_EDWARD_MARLOW_JR_ABOUT_1669",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARY_MARLOW_ABOUT_1667",
      "name": "Mary Marlow",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Marlow",
      "birth_date": "about 1667",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported after 1709",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Marlow family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; treated as candidate collateral unless parentage is explicit elsewhere. The dates and replacement parentage remain compiled claims, not primary-record verification. 15 September 2026 review: The individual page reports this death date and names William Marlow and Elizabeth as parents. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_MARLOW_ABOUT_1676",
      "name": "John Marlow",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Marlow",
      "birth_date": "about 1676",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 2 May 1717",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Marlow family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; treated as candidate collateral unless parentage is explicit elsewhere. The dates and replacement parentage remain compiled claims, not primary-record verification. 15 September 2026 review: The individual page reports this death date and names William Marlow and Elizabeth as parents. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_BARTHOLOMEW_MARLOW_ABOUT_1680",
      "name": "Bartholomew Marlow",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Marlow",
      "birth_date": "about 1680",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 30 Oct 1708",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Marlow family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; treated as candidate collateral unless parentage is explicit elsewhere. The dates and replacement parentage remain compiled claims, not primary-record verification. 15 September 2026 review: The individual page reports this death date and names William Marlow and Elizabeth as parents. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ANNE_MARLOW_ABOUT_1681",
      "name": "Anne Marlow",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Marlow",
      "birth_date": "about 1681",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported after 14 Nov 1726",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_19"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Marlow family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; treated as candidate collateral unless parentage is explicit elsewhere. The dates and replacement parentage remain compiled claims, not primary-record verification. 15 September 2026 review: The individual page reports this death date and names William Marlow and Elizabeth as parents. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SUSANNAH_MARLOW_1678",
      "name": "Susannah Marlow",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Marlow",
      "birth_date": "1678",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported after 1721",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_3"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Marlow family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; treated as candidate collateral unless parentage is explicit elsewhere. The dates and replacement parentage remain compiled claims, not primary-record verification. 15 September 2026 review: The individual page reports this death date and names William Marlow and Elizabeth as parents. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_WILLIAM_MARLOW_1668_10_MAY_1668",
      "name": "William Marlow (1668)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Marlow",
      "birth_date": "10 May 1668",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 12 Aug 1729",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Marlow family member appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster; treated as candidate collateral unless parentage is explicit elsewhere. The dates and replacement parentage remain compiled claims, not primary-record verification. 15 September 2026 review: The individual page reports this death date and names William Marlow and Elizabeth as parents. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_BARTHOLOMEW_MARLOW_1708_30_OCT_1708",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_MARLOW_1717_2_MAY_1717",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_WILLIAM_MARLOW_1729_12_AUG_1729",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ANTHONY_MCNEW_MCKNEW_ABOUT_1670",
      "name": "Anthony McNew/McKnew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew/McKnew",
      "birth_date": "about 1670",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_FREDERICK_ARCHIVE",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_RESEARCH_LIMIT"
      ],
      "source_note": "McNew/McKnew collateral appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster. FamilySearch describes McNew as probably an altered form of an unidentified Scottish or Irish surname.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported Anthony in the place-linked cluster. Alternatives are a different Anthony, an independent McNew/McKnew spelling line, or a compiled-cluster conflation. The Handley Regional Library describes McNew/Macknew/McKnew family papers and a 1773 movement through Frederick County, Virginia, toward Fincastle County; this is a concrete later archival context, not proof of Anthony's identity or ancestry. No parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_LOMAX_MCNEW_MCKNEW_ABOUT_1675",
      "name": "Lomax McNew/McKnew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew/McKnew",
      "birth_date": "about 1675",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640"
      ],
      "source_note": "McNew/McKnew collateral appearing in Nathan McNew place-linked cluster.",
      "research_note": "Warren Family Tree explicitly names Lomax MacKnew as Jeremiah's child, strengthening the existing place-cluster candidate.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHANN_PHILIP_GABEL_14_AUG_1698",
      "name": "Johann Philip Gabel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel",
      "birth_date": "14 Aug 1698",
      "birth_place": "Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate child in Hans Jacob Gabel/Maria Margretha Rheinmueller family cluster. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS",
      "name": "Hans Georg Spiess",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Spiess",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hans Georg Spiess is repeated in Goble and Gabel compilations as the father of Maria Magdalena Spiess.",
      "research_note": "The same derivative family network places Maria Magdalena with Johann Friedrich Gabel, but no original baptism, marriage, parish, court, tax, property, or probate record identifies Hans Georg. Exact-name searches produced unrelated German and Swiss men and unsourced tree material rather than a stable locality or family. His 0.70 father edge reflects repeated derivative agreement, not direct evidence. Without a dated event or place, no personal local-history narrative or higher ancestry can responsibly be assigned. His line stops until an original record identifies Maria Magdalena's parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Offenbach, Darmstadt, Hessen, DE",
          "confidence": 0.63,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Johann Friedrich (Frederick) Gobble",
          "descendant_id": "I107",
          "distance": 2
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1673,
          "confidence": 0.504,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Offenbach, Darmstadt, Hessen, DE",
          "place_confidence": 0.63,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Johann Friedrich (Frederick) Gobble"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1701,
          "confidence": 0.504,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ANNA_CATHARINA_GABEL_19_MAR_1726",
      "name": "Anna Catharina Gabel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel/Gobble",
      "birth_date": "19 Mar 1726",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate child/collateral in Johann Friedrich Gabel family cluster from Goble/Geneanet/WikiTree snippets. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHANN_PHILLIP_GABEL_3_APR_1730",
      "name": "Johann Phillip Gabel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel/Gobble",
      "birth_date": "3 Apr 1730",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate child/collateral in Johann Friedrich Gabel family cluster from Goble/Geneanet/WikiTree snippets. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_NICHOLAS_GABEL_ABOUT_1744",
      "name": "John Nicholas Gabel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel/Gobble",
      "birth_date": "about 1744",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate child/collateral in Johann Friedrich Gabel family cluster from Goble/Geneanet/WikiTree snippets. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_JOHANN_GEORGE_GABEL_17_FEB_1758",
      "name": "John/Johann George Gabel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel/Gobble",
      "birth_date": "17 Feb 1758",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate child/collateral in Johann Friedrich Gabel family cluster from Goble/Geneanet/WikiTree snippets. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_GOBBLE_1744_10_APR_1744",
      "name": "John Gobble (1744)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel/Gobble",
      "birth_date": "10 Apr 1744",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate child/collateral in Johann Friedrich Gabel family cluster from Goble/Geneanet/WikiTree snippets. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "name": "Christian Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "19 Apr 1754",
      "birth_place": "Chester County, Pennsylvania, USA",
      "death_date": "7 May 1834",
      "death_place": "reported Washington County, Virginia or Floyd County, Kentucky, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_CENSUS_1800_1830",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Christian Gobble (also Goble, Gabel, and Christopher in indexed records) is strongly supported by a Revolutionary War pension file and four censuses.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: the older low-confidence duplicate edges from Christian/Christopher and Sarah to Elizabeth were deleted; the evidence-calibrated 0.97 and 0.90 evidence-calibrated edges remain. His exact 1754 birth is compiled evidence. Sources conflict between Washington County, Virginia and Floyd County, Kentucky as his 1834 death place; neither location is adopted exclusively.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_LINDER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_CHRISTINA_MARY_HELMSTETLER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "name": "George Weigel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Weigel",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1714",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_OT26_WEIGELE_GABEL_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_OT26_GOSHENHOPPEN_HINKE_ARCHIVE",
        "SRC_OT26_DYE_WEIGEL_OLDER_CANDIDATES",
        "SRC_OT26_WAGELIN_HARTMAN_1710",
        "SRC_OT26_WAGELIN_WILHELM_1715",
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_GEORGE",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 10 May 1757 marriage transcription reproduced on WeRelate names Georg, Reformed, as father of Elisab. Weigele, bride of Fridrich Gabel. Dye chart 28 proposes birth 9 November 1714 and parents Johann Michael Weigel and Anna Maria Harttmannin (New York marriage 26 July 1710). See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_FATHER_AND_OLDER_CANDIDATES. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_NEW_YORK_RECORDS. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION.",
      "research_note": "This is more specific evidence than the prior Family Data Collection-derived parent list, though the underlying manuscript has not been inspected and source independence is unestablished. The father identification leads over a hypothetical namesake/error alternative. Birth about 1714 remains reported only; do not transfer confidence in the father relationship to that date. Follow-up: the candidate couple marriage is now verified in the scanned published Kocherthal translation, 26 July 1710, Johann Michael Wägelin of Bohnfeld/Creichgau and Anna Maria, widow of Conrad Hartman (maiden name unknown). Their documented son Johann Wilhelm was born 31 January 1715, conflicting with the claim George was born 9 November 1714 if the same mother is intended. A wrong George date remains a viable alternative to wrong parentage. New York immigrant identity remains separate. Alleged 83-day sibling conflict is no longer treated as independent negative evidence: same baptism date/parents/sponsor may have variant name/date transcriptions. Those are testable candidates, retained in research notes; no new parent edges added. Older bridge unresolved; father-to-Elizabeth assessment is unaffected. Superseding review: four older parent names now connected with qualified comparative support.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "confidence": 0.636,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Gobble",
          "descendant_id": "I86",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "name": "Anna Margaret Ditlich",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Ditlich",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1718",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_OT26_WEIGELE_GABEL_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_OT26_DYE_WEIGEL_OLDER_CANDIDATES",
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_ELISABETH",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION.",
      "research_note": "Dye chart 28 proposes father Abraham Ditlich and birth about 1719; the record basis and identity link remain unresolved. Compiled genealogies, including Family Data Collection-derived material, report Anna Margaret Ditlich as Elizabeth Weigel mother. Preserve this older candidate in notes without an ancestral edge. Direct proof is not a prerequisite: a sufficiently distinctive documented family/associate cluster could establish the link comparatively. New York immigrant identity remains separate. Alleged 83-day sibling conflict is no longer treated as independent negative evidence: same baptism date/parents/sponsor may have variant name/date transcriptions. The 1757 marriage transcription names father Georg but no mother; this is neither new evidence for Anna nor evidence against her. Superseding review: four older parent names now connected with qualified comparative support. Their repetition is not independent confirmation. Existing .66 retained.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "confidence": 0.636,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Gobble",
          "descendant_id": "I86",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_HUMPHREY_DICKENSON",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_BROWN",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_FORD",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_WINIFRED_ATHEY",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ANN_UNKNOWN_MARLOW_SHAW_CLUSTER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARY_MARLOW_AFTER_1709_AFTER_1709",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_UNKNOWN_AFTER_1683_AFTER_1683",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SAMUEL_QUEEN_AFTER_1771_AFTER_1771",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_LEONARD_QUEEN_AFTER_1771_AFTER_1771",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "name": "Ursula Batzer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Batzer",
      "birth_date": "1 Jul 1650",
      "birth_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "27 Jan 1731",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: compiled Erpfingen trees identify Ursula Batzer as Johannes Ignatius Göbel's wife and Hans Jacob Gabel's mother, with a reported 5 Nov 1678 marriage. Relevant church registers survive, but no original entry was inspected; the link remains a derivative hypothesis. Its ten-child chronology begins in 1671 and conflicts with the reported claim that she mothered Hans Jacob Gabel, reportedly born in Göda in 1670; that derivative link remains visible at only 0.18. Current 15 September 2026 comparison supersedes the earlier .18 assessment: a distinct Erpfingen son Hans Jacob born 1689 is now recorded; the proposed link to Offenbach Hans Jacob I111 is .10. The decisive concern is the documented competing household, not missing proof or an assumed completeness of the ten-child list. Correction: the parish-register-based pedigree gives Ursula's birth 1 Jul 1650, death 27 Jan 1731, marriage to Johannes Göbel on 10 May 1670, and parents Georg Batzer and Ursula Hinckh. Correction: the parish-register-based pedigree gives Ursula's birth 1 Jul 1650, death 27 Jan 1731, marriage to Johannes Göbel on 10 May 1670, and parents Georg Batzer and Ursula Hinckh.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "name": "Anna Kissling",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Kissling",
      "birth_date": "estimated October 1618",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "23 Apr 1688",
      "death_place": "Willmandingen, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Their community was profoundly affected by the Thirty Years' War.",
      "research_note": "Her occupation, birthplace, and parents remain unknown, and unsupported online claims of birth at Baden or Willmandingen are not adopted. A parish-register-based reconstruction identifies her as Martin Göbel's wife and mother in a ten-child family; their marriage about 1638 is reconstructed rather than supported by a quoted marriage entry. Anna Kissling's Willmandingen burial on 23 April 1688 gives her age as 69 years and 7 months, from which an October 1618 birth is estimated. A documented Willmandingen schoolmaster left after 1634 because of war and hunger and returned after 1648, illustrating local disruption without proving that Anna followed the same course.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_ERNEST_DANIEL_FRICKE_1884",
      "name": "Ernest Daniel Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "7 Nov 1884",
      "birth_place": "New Jersey, United States",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Appears as Earnest/Ernest age 21 in 1905 Henry/Katey Fricke household; WWI draft registration gives Ernest Daniel Fricke born 7 Nov 1884 in East Orange area. 1900 census lists Ernest Fricke, age 14, as a son in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household; age differs slightly from the later exact 7 Nov 1884 draft birth date.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1905,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "East Orange and Glen Ridge, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_HENRY_FRICKE_JR_ABT1886",
      "name": "Henry Fricke Jr.",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "about 1886",
      "birth_place": "New Jersey, United States",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Son in 1905 and 1910 Henry/Katharine Fricke household. 1900 census lists Henry Fricke, age 13, as a son in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1910,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "East Orange and Glen Ridge, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_JOHN_FRICKE_1889",
      "name": "John Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "18 Apr 1889",
      "birth_place": "East Orange, Essex, New Jersey, United States",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_JOHN_1889_BIRTH",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Birth record names father Henry Fricke age 43 born Germany and mother Katharina Schaff age 41 born Germany. 1900 census lists John Fricke, age 11, as a son in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household, consistent with his 18 Apr 1889 birth record.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1900,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_GEORG_HEINRICH_FRICKE_1827_1848",
      "name": "Georg Heinrich Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "26 Mar 1827",
      "birth_place": "Gütersloh, Wiedenbrück, Westfalen, Preußen, Deutschland",
      "death_date": "27 Apr 1848",
      "death_place": "Hannover, Preußen, Deutschland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_LEFFLER_1842_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Baptized 31 Mar 1827 at Gütersloh; parents Eberhard Heinrich Fricke and Sophie Elisabeth Agnete/Angeneten. Married Anna Dorothee Leffler 17 Apr 1842 in Hannover. Father of Heinrich Friedrich Fricke per 1845 Hannover christening.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_ANNA_DOROTHEE_LEFFLER_ABT1827",
      "name": "Anna Dorothee Leffler",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Leffler",
      "birth_date": "about 1827",
      "birth_place": "Crawinkel, Gotha, Thüringen, Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_LEFFLER_1842_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as mother of Heinrich Friedrich Fricke in 1845 Hannover christening; birthplace Crawinkel. Married Georg Heinrich Fricke 17 Apr 1842 Hannover.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1845,
          "confidence": 0.713,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_EBERHARD_HEINRICH_FRICKE_ABT1788",
      "name": "Eberhard Heinrich Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "about 1788",
      "birth_place": "Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_EBERHARD_SOPHIE_1820_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Father of Georg Heinrich Fricke per 1827 baptism. Married Sophie Elisabeth Angeneten in 1820 at Gütersloh, age 32; record notes he was previously married.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1827,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_SOPHIE_ELISABETH_ANGENETEN_ABT1795",
      "name": "Sophie Elisabeth Angeneten",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Angeneten",
      "birth_date": "about 1795",
      "birth_place": "Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_EBERHARD_SOPHIE_1820_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mother of Georg Heinrich Fricke. Surname appears as Sophie Elis.",
      "research_note": "Agnete in baptism extraction and Sophie Elisabeth Angeneten in 1820 marriage record; variant spellings Angenete/Angenend/Aengenendt are plausible.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1827,
          "confidence": 0.67,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "name": "John Thomas",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Thomas",
      "birth_date": "about 1851",
      "birth_place": "Llanddewi, Radnorshire, Wales",
      "death_date": "8 Apr 1931",
      "death_place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879",
        "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_FINDAGRAVE_1851_1931",
        "SRC_FRANKWELL_SHREWSBURY_LOCAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_BOOT_SHOE_DIRECTORY",
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_LLANDDEWI_LODGER_1861",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_THOMAS_BLEDFFA_BAPTISM_1851",
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_RADNORSHIRE_CANDIDATE_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Thomas lived with his wife Jane in Shrewsbury from 1881 through 1911, including at 160 Frankwell Quay, and worked as a shoemaker and hand bootmaker.",
      "research_note": "His own parents remain unresolved. A newly inspected 1861 census candidate is age ten, born at Llanddewi Ystradenni, and lodging at Tynywern in Llanfihangel Rhydithon. That is an exact birthplace-and-age fit but no record yet bridges the child to the adult craftsman. A different John Thomas was baptized at Bleddfa in June 1851 to farmer Edward Thomas and Anne; separate 1861 candidates for Llanddewi and Bleddfa show why those Bleddfa parents must not be attached. The March 1992 Lister chart reports 8 April 1930 as John's death date, but the memorial and civil-registration chronology support 8 April 1931; the stronger 1931 date is retained.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "name": "Jane Lister Thomas",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Thomas",
      "birth_date": "about 1849",
      "birth_place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_THOMAS_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1851 census transcript identifies Jane, aged one year five months, as Richard and Eliza Lyster's daughter. Avril J. The chart also preserves a family recollection that Jane was present at St Eata's Church, Atcham, when lightning struck during the service on 13 July 1879.",
      "research_note": "Wood's March 1992 chart independently places Jane in the same Lister household but identifies Kezia Price as her mother; Eliza remains the stronger maternal identification because the census is contemporary. A contemporary newspaper confirms the event but does not name Jane, so her presence is plausible family recollection rather than proven attendance.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1911,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "160 Frankwell Quay, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WALTER_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_ANNE",
      "name": "Walter Crowther",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Crowther",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Named as father of Anne Crowther in her 17 Jul 1832 christening record at Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales. Earlier wording misread Josa as a mother. The stored user correction identifies Joshua Crowther as father and Ann as mother; see their existing parent links. Corrected 15 September 2026.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales, United Kingdom",
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Anne Crowther",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_ANNE_CROWTHER_CHR_1832_CEFNLLYS",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1804,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales, United Kingdom",
          "place_confidence": 0.85,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Anne Crowther"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1832,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JANE_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_ANNE",
      "name": "Jane",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Named as mother of Anne Crowther in her 17 Jul 1832 christening record at Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales, United Kingdom",
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Anne Crowther",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_ANNE_CROWTHER_CHR_1832_CEFNLLYS",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1804,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales, United Kingdom",
          "place_confidence": 0.85,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Anne Crowther"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1832,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANNE_CROWTHER_CHR_1832_CEFNLLYS",
      "name": "Anne Crowther",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Crowther",
      "birth_date": "before 17 Jul 1832",
      "birth_place": "Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch transcript: Anne Crowther, female, christened 17 Jul 1832 at Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales; father Walter Crowther, mother Jane.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1832,
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales, United Kingdom",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOSHUA_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_WALTER",
      "name": "Joshua Crowther",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Crowther",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User corrected the earlier Josa entry: Joshua Crowther is father of Walter Crowther.",
      "research_note": "Verify exact spelling and details against the original image/transcript when available.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales, United Kingdom",
          "confidence": 0.637,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Anne Crowther",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_ANNE_CROWTHER_CHR_1832_CEFNLLYS",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANN_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_WALTER",
      "name": "Ann Grindley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Grindley",
      "birth_date": "before 5 Apr 1789",
      "birth_place": "Wrenbury, Cheshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified Ann Grindley as mother of Walter Crowther. FamilySearch christening transcript: Ann Grindley, female, christened 5 Apr 1789 at Wrenbury, Cheshire, England; father Thos. Grindley, mother Margt.",
      "research_note": "Conflicting GEDCOM branch Thomas Grindley born 1783/Mary Mahony has been detached because Thomas born 1783 cannot be father of Ann christened 1789 if he married Mary Mahony in 1806; direct line follows christening and marriage transcripts instead. Also linked as mother of Richard Morrall, replacing the conflicting GEDCOM duplicate Ann Grindley record.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FATHER_OF_ANN",
      "name": "Thomas Grindley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Grindley",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Named as father of Ann Grindley in her 5 Apr 1789 christening record at Wrenbury, Cheshire, England.",
      "research_note": "Possible marriage record: Thomas Grindley, 6 Nov 1782, Market Drayton, Shropshire, England; spouse not yet captured.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Wrenbury, Cheshire, England, United Kingdom",
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Ann Grindley",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_ANN_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_WALTER",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1761,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Wrenbury, Cheshire, England, United Kingdom",
          "place_confidence": 0.85,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Ann Grindley"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1789,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARGT_GRINDLEY_MOTHER_OF_ANN",
      "name": "Margaret Harding",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Harding",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Named as spouse of Thomas Grindley in marriage record dated 6 Nov 1782 at Market Drayton, Shropshire, England. Likely the Margt. named as mother of Ann Grindley in the 5 Apr 1789 Wrenbury christening record.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Wrenbury, Cheshire, England, United Kingdom",
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Ann Grindley",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_ANN_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_WALTER",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1761,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Wrenbury, Cheshire, England, United Kingdom",
          "place_confidence": 0.85,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Ann Grindley"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1789,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "name": "Sampson Handley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Handley",
      "birth_date": "reported baptised 26 May 1730",
      "birth_place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "2 Dec 1801",
      "death_place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANDLEY_MILWICH_COMPILED_REVIEW_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page LZ2D-K4X identifies Sampson Handley, male, born 26 May 1730 at Milwich, Staffordshire, England, died 2 Dec 1801 at Milwich. Ruth Handley baptism transcript names Sampson Handley as father.",
      "research_note": "15 September 2026: The online reconstruction describes 26 May as a baptism; no inspected entry independently establishes an exact birth date.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RUTH_MOTHER_OF_RUTH_HANDLEY",
      "name": "Ruth Johnson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Johnson",
      "birth_date": "4 Mar 1739",
      "birth_place": "Sandon, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "4 Jan 1759",
      "death_place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANDLEY_MILWICH_COMPILED_REVIEW_20260915",
        "SRC_RUTH_HANDLEY_BAPTISM_PROVENANCE_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page LH5P-YBG identifies Ruth Johnson, female, born 4 Mar 1739 at Sandon, Staffordshire, England, died 4 Jan 1759 at Milwich. Previous Ruth Handley baptism transcript names mother as Ruth; user identified this Ruth as spouse of Sampson Handley and mother of Ruth Handley.",
      "research_note": "15 September 2026: Johnson remains the user-reported and FamilySearch-profile identification. Her exact dates remain reported profile claims. Unknown is not contrary evidence proving Johnson false; obtain the marriage or another identifying record. The baptism names only Ruth, and the newly inspected compilation leaves her surname unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_1697",
      "name": "George Handley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Handley",
      "birth_date": "24 Aug 1697",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "4 Dec 1763",
      "death_place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page LH5P-Y91 identifies George Handley, male, born 24 Aug 1697 at Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, died 4 Dec 1763 at Milwich, Staffordshire, England. User identified George Handley as father of Sampson Handley.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_1691",
      "name": "Anne Cartwright",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Cartwright",
      "birth_date": "1691",
      "birth_place": "Draycott in the Moors, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "26 Aug 1758",
      "death_place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page LH5P-YMZ identifies Anne Cartwright, female, born 1691 at Draycott in the Moors, Staffordshire, England, died 26 Aug 1758 at Milwich, Staffordshire, England. User identified Anne Cartwright as mother of Sampson Handley.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_HANDLEY_ABT1666",
      "name": "Thomas Handley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Handley",
      "birth_date": "about 1666",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page KNSY-JXJ identifies Thomas Handley, male, born about 1666 at Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, death deceased. User identified Thomas Handley as father of George Handley.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
      "name": "Hanna Fenton",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fenton",
      "birth_date": "by 27 Jun 1674",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "Jul 1740",
      "death_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
        "SRC_ROOTS_STIRNET_FENTON_HANDLEY"
      ],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page KZW6-ZMT identifies Hanna Fenton, female, born 27 Jun 1674 at Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, died Jul 1740 at Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. User identified Hanna Fenton as mother of George Handley. Date clarification: the published Sheffield register records 27 June 1674 as Hanna’s baptism, naming father William Fenton.",
      "research_note": "No separate birth date is given. The original reported date is retained here as provenance.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JAMES_JACOBUS_HANDLEY_1647",
      "name": "James Jacobus Handley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Handley",
      "birth_date": "Apr 1647",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page MXC3-9RS identifies James Jacobus Handley, male, born Apr 1647 at Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, death deceased. User identified James Jacobus Handley as father of Thomas Handley.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNAH_WILD_1649",
      "name": "Hannah Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "christened 29 Apr 1649",
      "birth_place": "Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul Sheffield, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "England Births and Christenings transcript identifies Hanna Wild, female, christened 29 Apr 1649 at Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul Sheffield, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England; original place Saint Peter, Sheffield, York, England; father Georgii Wild, male. Georgii is interpreted as George Wild and matched to existing George Wild born 1616.",
      "research_note": "Earlier FamilySearch family grouping that placed Hannah under Godfrey Wilde and Hellena Tunstead is chronologically inconsistent and has been rejected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARAH_HANCOCK_1624",
      "name": "Sarah Hancock",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hancock",
      "birth_date": "1624",
      "birth_place": "Great Paxton, Huntingdonshire, Cambridgeshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "Dec 1689",
      "death_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page G12M-1YY identifies Sarah Hancock, female, born 1624 at Great Paxton, Huntingdonshire/Cambridgeshire, England, christened 5 Sep 1624 at Sheffield St Paul, Yorkshire, died Dec 1689 at Sheffield. User identified Sarah Hancock as mother of James Jacobus Handley.",
      "research_note": "Later supplied parent family profile identifies Sarah Hancock G12M-1YY as child of Robert Hancock KFP9-X5X and Margaret Greaves G129-RV7.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "name": "Godfrey Wilde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wilde",
      "birth_date": "1623",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "buried 26 Apr 1678",
      "death_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page L437-LFF identifies Godfrey Wilde, male, born 1623 at Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, christened 14 Dec 1623 at Sheffield, buried 26 Apr 1678 at Sheffield. Marriage transcript uses Latinized/variant name Godfridus Wild for the 5 Sep 1677 Sheffield marriage at Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul; matched to Godfrey Wilde. The previously attached Hannah Wild born/christened 1649 has been removed as a daughter; her christening transcript names father Georgii Wild, interpreted as George Wild.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "name": "William Wilde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wilde",
      "birth_date": "1576",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "1643",
      "death_place": "Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DROITWICH_ST_PETERS_WYLDE_MONUMENT_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_WESTMINSTER_ABBEY_GEORGE_WYLDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "William Wilde is retained as a Sheffield person, but his proposed parentage to George Wylde of Droitwich and Frances Huddleston has been rejected. The better-supported alternative is that the relevant Sheffield George Wild belonged to the Hall Carr family, not the Droitwich Wyldes. The Droitwich monument lists their issue as John, George, Elizabeth, and Dorothy, not William, and no reviewed source names the Sheffield William as their child. William's own parents therefore remain unknown. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "name": "George Wylde I, Serjeant-at-law",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wylde",
      "birth_date": "about 1550",
      "birth_place": "Droitwich, Worcestershire, England",
      "death_date": "27 Mar 1616",
      "death_place": "Droitwich, Worcestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "History of Parliament/Wikipedia identifies George Wylde I, also Wild or Wilde, as an English lawyer and MP, born about 1550 and died 27 Mar 1616; younger son of Thomas Wylde of The Commandery, Worcester, and eldest son of Thomas's second wife Ellinor, daughter of George Wall of Droitwich. Existing FamilySearch profile P7VW-3FF gives birth year 1557; likely same person, so birth is recorded as about 1550 with the variation preserved. This reinforces the Eleanor/Frances relationships but leaves a birth-year discrepancy with History of Parliament/Wikipedia, which use about 1550.",
      "research_note": "Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Wylde_I Later supplied profile for George Wylde states he was born in 1557 in England as son of Eleanor Wall, had at least 6 sons and 2 daughters with Frances Huddleston, died 27 Mar 1616 in Droitwich at age 59, and was buried in Droitwich.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELEANOR_WALL_1524",
      "name": "Eleanor Wall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wall",
      "birth_date": "1524",
      "birth_place": "Droitwich Spa, Wychavon district, Worcestershire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "1600",
      "death_place": "Droitwich Spa, Wychavon district, Worcestershire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page LC7G-91Y identifies Eleanor Wall, female, born 1524 at Droitwich Spa, Wychavon district, Worcestershire, England, died 1600 at Droitwich Spa. User identified Eleanor Wall as mother of George Wylde. History of Parliament/Wikipedia corroborates Eleanor/Ellinor Wall as daughter of George Wall of Droitwich and second wife of Thomas Wylde; her son George Wylde I inherited property through her at Kempsey, Impney, and Droitwich.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
      "name": "George Wall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wall",
      "birth_date": "1507",
      "birth_place": "England",
      "death_date": "1562",
      "death_place": "Droitwich, Worcestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page GYYH-T4J identifies George Wall, male, born about 1507 at Droitwich Spa, Worcestershire, England, died about 1562 at Droitwich, Worcestershire. User identified George Wall as father of Eleanor Wall. Genealogical record names George Wall, born 1507 in England, resident in Droitwich Spa, died 1562, spouse Jane Eden Gardner and child Eleanor Wall. This supports the direct-line George Wall/Jane Eden Gardner/Eleanor Wall family.",
      "research_note": "User supplied George Wall born about 1509 in Droitwich, died 1562 in Droitwich; possible same person as prior about-1507 George Wall. Spouse-name conflict/alias note: previously connected with Jane Eden Gardner; later profile gives spouse Jane Farnefolde, married 5 Apr 1551 at St Michael's Church, East Ham, Newham, London. Same given name suggests possible conflation or alternate surname, but not enough evidence to merge. Jane Farnefolde remains a lower-confidence conflicting/candidate spouse pending reconciliation.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JANE_EDEN_GARDNER",
      "name": "Jane Eden Gardner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gardner",
      "birth_date": "about 1507",
      "birth_place": "Droitwich Spa, Worcestershire, England",
      "death_date": "1572",
      "death_place": "Droitwich Spa, Worcestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch person page LR37-853 identifies Jane Eden Gardner, female, born at Droitwich, Worcestershire, England, died 1572 at Droitwich. User identified Jane Eden Gardner as mother of Eleanor Wall. Genealogical record names Jane Eden Gardner as spouse of George Wall and mother of Eleanor Wall, born about 1507 in Droitwich Spa and died 1572 in Droitwich Spa. Sources listed include books on Worcester cathedral monuments, Shropshire Archaeological and Natural History Society transactions, and Annals of the Hospital of S. Wulstan. This strengthens Jane Eden Gardner as the direct-line mother of Eleanor Wall.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "name": "Amelia Mildred \"Milly\" Hargis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hargis",
      "birth_date": "26 Dec 1765",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "1 Apr 1860",
      "death_place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_AMELIA_1765_FATHER_1742",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The county label is retrospective for her 1765 birth.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: Amelia is consistently supported as George McNew's spouse and David's mother by family context, but the chancery testimony names only George; her David edge is therefore 0.94 rather than direct-evidence certainty. Evidence review: her parentage remains unresolved because compiled sources conflict between the 1722 John and a proposed 1742 son of that John. FamilySearch profile G5GG-GDC and multiple compiled trees agree that Amelia Mildred \"Milly/Millie\" Hargis was born 26 Dec 1765 and died 1 Apr 1860 in the area known as Washington County, Virginia, and was wife of George Albert McNew. Goymerac and Geneanet agree that John Hargis was her father but conflict on her mother: Ann Elizabeth Whiteside versus Elizabeth Freelove. Both maternal claims remain candidates pending direct evidence. 15 September 2026: The earlier 0.94 maternal assessment above is superseded by 0.78 on the relationship. The chancery narrative describes George's wife as older than him, whereas the compiled birth dates make Amelia younger. Retain the dates as reported claims pending original evidence; this discrepancy does not by itself prove a different wife. No new 1742 profile was added without direct evidence. Ann Whiteside is likely one generation too early; Elizabeth Freelove is plausible but unproved.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "name": "Stephan Lindner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lindner",
      "birth_date": "1645",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Nenzenheim, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Simon Linder",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "name": "Barbara Mollfinger",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Mollfinger",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named in 28 Apr 1665 marriage record as the virgin Barbara Mollfinger, legitimate daughter of the deceased Hanß Mollfinger in Nenzenheim; spouse Stephan Lindner.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Nenzenheim, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.7,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Simon Linder",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1653,
          "confidence": 0.504,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Nenzenheim, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
          "place_confidence": 0.7,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Simon Linder"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1681,
          "confidence": 0.504,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lindner",
      "birth_date": "22 Apr 1598",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "9 Apr 1677",
      "death_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_MICHAEL_LINDER_UNTRACED_ANCESTRY"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "A current search also surfaced an uncited FamilySearch-tree statement naming a Martin Linder as father; it supplies no record image, citation, or identity bridge and cannot outweigh the chronological contradiction in the Saanen claim. Michael's parents remain unassigned rather than being replaced with a speculative alternative. That couple's cited reconstruction dates their marriage to 1605 and lists a different child group beginning in 1606; it neither names Michael nor supports a move to Nenzenheim.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "name": "Simon Linder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Linder",
      "birth_date": "3 Apr 1681",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "reported 12 Feb 1751",
      "death_place": "reported Opequon, Frederick County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_LANCASTER_WARRANT_1733",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1713 Blankenloch marriage names father Stephan Linder and spouse Margretha Nagel.",
      "research_note": "The reported 1751 Virginia death still depends on compiled material. Published research from Nenzenheim and Blankenloch reconstructs children whose names and ages closely match the entire 1733 Samuel passenger household. This Simon is not the father of George Anton Linder: his son Hans Georg arrived in 1733 as a small child, while George Anton arrived separately in 1753 at age 18.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "name": "Anna Margaretha Nagel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Nagel",
      "birth_date": "baptised 10 Dec 1695",
      "birth_place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The indexed baptism at Blankenloch names Margretha Nagel, baptized 10 Dec 1695, daughter of Hannß Martin and Anna Catharina Nagel. The indexed marriage in the same parish on 17 Oct 1713 names her father Hannss Martin Nagel and husband Simon Lindner. Margarethæ Seÿboldin, wife of Hannß Linder at Gammesfeld, is a different woman.",
      "research_note": "Hanover is rejected as an unsupported surname; 1686/1691 births, a 1706 marriage, and death years 1733, 1743, and 1772 are conflicting compiled claims.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1720,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "name": "George Anton \"Anthony\" Linder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Linder",
      "birth_date": "about 1735",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "after 24 Sep 1801",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_ANTON_LINDER_PEGGY_1753",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_ANTHONY_LINDER_ANCESTRY_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "George Anton Linder arrived at Philadelphia aboard the Peggy on 24 September 1753. The captain's list calls the eighteen-year-old immigrant Jerick Anthony, while his allegiance signatures read Gorg Anton Linder, preserving both official and self-used forms of his name. Later land records place Anthony and wife Mary on the North Fork of the Holston in Washington County, Virginia, including their 1795 conveyance of 170 acres to John Gobble. The records therefore trace an Atlantic immigrant into the southwest Virginia landholding community.",
      "research_note": "A circulated 1801 will names wife Mary and daughter Jemima Gobble, but its provenance remains uncertain. A 1734 Lutheran baptism for Anthon Linders at Sausenheim is a plausible origin candidate of the correct age, religion, and Rhine-region setting; no passenger associate, family record, or other bridge proves that the baptized child became the immigrant.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, USA",
          "confidence": 0.7,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Jemima Linder",
          "descendant_id": "I85",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "name": "Mary Newland Linder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Newland",
      "birth_date": "about 1741",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "after 24 Sep 1801",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Newland's 1800 will abstract names daughter Mary Linder.",
      "research_note": "The exact 1741 Virginia birth, 1804 death at Abingdon, Hannah Caswell as mother, and the reported 1759 marriage are not established by the located records. Washington County land abstracts name Anthony and Mary Linder together, and a reported 1801 will transcript names Anthony's wife Mary.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, USA",
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Jemima Linder",
          "descendant_id": "I85",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "name": "John Newland",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Newland",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "before 27 Oct 1800",
      "death_place": "Berkeley County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEWLAND_HOPE_PASSENGER_1734",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780",
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_JOHN_NEWLAND_ANCESTRY_UNKNOWN_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_OT26_ALLEN_1729_ULLAND_PASSENGER_GROUP",
        "SRC_OT26_NEWLAND_1736_INDENTURE_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Newland and wife Elizabeth are reconstructed through the 1739 Johann Ulandt–Elizabetha Lintner marriage, later Berkeley deeds and the 1800 will naming daughter Mary Linder. See RN_OT26_NEWLAND_PASSENGER_AND_INDENTURE_IDENTITY.",
      "research_note": "The previous birth about 1710 derives from the Hope age; the reported Dannstadt baptism in 1716 is another candidate chronology, not a verified birth. The 1736 Goochland cordwainer agreement names John Newland but its attachment to this family remains a separate identity hypothesis. Their reported ages imply different men. Its reported four-year term ending April 1737 implies a 1733 start, creating conditional tension with the Hope arrival. Compare the candidates without treating missing direct parent wording or an unknown namesake as observed contrary evidence. Two passenger candidates remain: Johannes Ulland, under fifteen on the Allen in 1729 with Mathias and Catrina Ulland, and John Nouland, aged twenty-four on the Hope in 1734.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1713,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Berkeley County, Virginia, USA",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "John Newland"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNAH_CASWELL_ABT1709",
      "name": "Hannah Caswell",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Caswell",
      "birth_date": "about 1709",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as mother of Mary Ulandt Newland. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_REGINA_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_BARBARA_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_REGINA_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_CHRISTOPHORUS_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_CONRAD_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_MAGDALENA_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_MARIA_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_JOHANNES_ALBRECHT_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_JOBST_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_MARIA_CATHARINA_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_SIMON_K__LINDER_JR",
      "name": "Simon K. Linder Jr.",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Linder",
      "birth_date": "before 22 Sep 1717",
      "birth_place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "about 1798",
      "death_place": "Rockingham County, North Carolina, United States",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Linder Jr., born before 22 Sep 1717 in Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Holy Roman Empire, died about 1798 in Rockingham County, North Carolina, United States. Child of Simon K Lindner and Margaretha Nagel; sibling of Jerick Anton Linder.",
      "research_note": "Dates and death are uncertain as supplied. User supplied Simon K.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_ERNST_FRIDERICH_LINDER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_LORENTZ_LINDER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_HANNS_JÖRG_LINDER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_MARGARETHA_LINDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ABRAM_LINDER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ELIZABETH_JEMIMA__LINDER__GOBBLE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_SARAH__LINDER__FLEENOR",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ISAAC_LINDER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_JACOB_LINDER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_JOSEPH_LINDER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_GEORGE_GOBBLE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ELIZABETH_GOBBLE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MARY__GOBBLE__ZION",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_REBECCA__GOBBLE__TALBERT",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_SARAH_GOBBLE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MARTHA__GOBBLE__MCKNIGHT",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ISAAC_GOBBLE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ABRAHAM_GOBBLE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_DELANEY_GOBBLE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_NANCY_GOBBLE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MATILDA_J__GOBBLE__KESTNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "name": "Hans (possibly Johann) Mollfinger",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Mollfinger",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bayern, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "before 28 Apr 1665",
      "death_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bayern, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This proves his paternity and that he had died by that date, but supplies neither his wife, occupation, birthplace, nor parents. The broader Iphofen area bears local traces of the Reformation and Thirty Years' War, events that preceded Barbara's marriage and may explain disruption in the surviving record environment.",
      "research_note": "Johann is retained only as a possible normalization from a derivative pedigree; the record-supported form is Hans. Hans Mollfinger is directly named as the deceased father of the unmarried Barbara Mollfinger in her 28 April 1665 Nenzenheim marriage. They do not establish Hans's religion, service, displacement, or losses.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "name": "Hannß Martin Nagel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Nagel",
      "birth_date": "about 1656",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as Margretha Nagel's father in both her 1695 Blankenloch baptism and 1713 Blankenloch marriage indexes. The Martz form is not used as a surname.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Anna Margaretha Nagel",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1713,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "name": "Anna Catharina Kieffer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Kieffer",
      "birth_date": "reported 18 Oct 1661",
      "birth_place": "reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "reported 13 Dec 1716",
      "death_place": "reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as Anna Catharina Nagel, mother of Margretha, in the indexed 10 Dec 1695 Blankenloch baptism.",
      "research_note": "A separate uncited derivative pedigree assigns the same exact-dated woman to Hanss Wendel Kieffer and Anna Barbara at Münzesheim. Evidence review: record-linked FamilySearch reconstruction places Anna Catharina, 1661-1716, in the Blankenloch household of Hanss Georg Kieffer and Margretha Helena Widman. Kieffer remains a supplied maiden surname pending a marriage or baptism record. The Blankenloch family is selected at moderate confidence because it matches Anna's later locality and includes multiple indexed sibling baptisms; the conflicting set prevents high confidence.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "name": "Hans Anthoni Nagel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Nagel",
      "birth_date": "reported about October 1622",
      "birth_place": "reported Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "reported 2 May 1693",
      "death_place": "reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG",
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_NAGEL_DESVERICKY_COMPILED_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "A separate online tree instead calls Hannß Martin the child of Hans Nagel (1623-1693) and Catharina Desvericky (1625-1691).",
      "research_note": "His parents remain unresolved. A derivative reconstruction identifies Hans Anthoni Nagel as Anna Catharina Hansen's husband and Hannß Martin Nagel's father, with a reported death on 2 May 1693 at Blankenloch. Its dates and child group are coherent with the later documented Nagel family, but no original entry has been inspected. The father's dates overlap this Hans Anthoni profile (reported about 1622-1693), so that is an alternate household or spouse reconstruction—not evidence for another generation above Hans Anthoni—and it conflicts with the Hansen claim. Blankenloch's surviving Lutheran mixed register begins in 1672 and a local family book covers 1672 onward, making his reported death and later household potentially testable even though his reported 1622 birth predates that run.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "name": "Anna Catharina Hansen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hansen",
      "birth_date": "reported 1628",
      "birth_place": "reported Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "reported 22 Oct 1678",
      "death_place": "reported Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No original baptism, marriage, child, or burial entry has been inspected, and her stated birthplace is only the broad Holy Roman Empire. An exact-dated derivative reconstruction identifies Anna Catharina Hansen as Hans Anthoni Nagel's wife and Hannß Martin Nagel's mother, born in 1628 and died 22 October 1678. Proposed Scandinavian-named parents lack any geographic or documentary bridge and remain unattached. The family is reported at Blankenloch, whose surviving Lutheran mixed register begins in 1672; its late coverage may test her death and later household but cannot establish a 1628 baptism. Her own birthplace, occupation, and parents are unresolved. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANSS_JERG_NAGEL",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANNA_MARIA_NAGEL",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARIA_DIETERLE_NAGEL_1593",
      "name": "Maria Dieterle Nagel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Dieterle",
      "birth_date": "26 Sep 1593",
      "birth_place": "Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Relationship not yet confirmed, so left as unattached candidate. User supplied Maria (Dieterle) Nagel born 26 Sep 1593 in Germany. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRIEDRICH_NAGEL_1555",
      "name": "Friedrich Nagel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Nagel",
      "birth_date": "1555",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1609",
      "death_place": "Wunsiedel, Wunsiedel, Bayern, Germany",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Relationship not yet confirmed, so left as unattached candidate. User supplied Friedrich Nagel born 1555 and died 1609 in Wunsiedel, Bayern, Germany. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JANE_FARNEFOLDE_1508",
      "name": "Jane Farnefolde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Farnefolde",
      "birth_date": "1508",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1573",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Candidate spouse of George Wall from user-supplied profile: married 5 Apr 1551 at St Michael's Church, East Ham, Newham, London. Kept separate from Jane Eden Gardner pending more evidence. Direct-line evidence now supports Jane Eden Gardner as spouse and mother of Eleanor Wall; keep separate pending reconciliation. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "name": "William G Wall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wall",
      "birth_date": "1489",
      "birth_place": "Preston, Lancashire, England",
      "death_date": "1525",
      "death_place": "Preston, Lancashire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "name": "Grace Banester",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Banester",
      "birth_date": "1490",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1577",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as mother of George Wall. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "England",
          "confidence": 0.75,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "George Wall",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_WILLIAM_1510",
      "name": "William Wall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wall",
      "birth_date": "1510",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1558",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sibling of George Wall; child of William G Wall and Grace Banester.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_JOSIAH_1515",
      "name": "Josiah Wall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wall",
      "birth_date": "1515",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1547",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sibling of George Wall; child of William G Wall and Grace Banester.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_LAWRENCE_1515",
      "name": "Lawrence Wall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wall",
      "birth_date": "1515",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1600",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sibling of George Wall; child of William G Wall and Grace Banester.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_RICHARD_1516",
      "name": "Richard Wall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wall",
      "birth_date": "1516",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1541",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sibling of George Wall; child of William G Wall and Grace Banester.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_EVAN_1518",
      "name": "Evan Wall of Preston \"Walley\"",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wall",
      "birth_date": "1518",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1582",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sibling of George Wall; child of William G Wall and Grace Banester.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_ROBERT_1518",
      "name": "Robert Wall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wall",
      "birth_date": "1518",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sibling of George Wall; child of William G Wall and Grace Banester.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_THOMAS_1524",
      "name": "Thomas Wall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wall",
      "birth_date": "1524",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1575",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sibling of George Wall; child of William G Wall and Grace Banester.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_JOYSE_WALL",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROSE_BRACE_CANDIDATE_PARENT_JANE_GARDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HENRY_GARDNER_CANDIDATE_PARENT_JANE_GARDNER",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_WALL_ABT1463",
      "name": "Richard Wall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wall",
      "birth_date": "about 1463",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as father of William G Wall; inferred birth about 1463 from age 26 at William's 1489 birth. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Preston, Lancashire, England",
          "confidence": 0.75,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "William G Wall",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1489,
          "confidence": 0.54,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
      "name": "Margaret Whalley Pettenati",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Whalley Pettenati",
      "birth_date": "1467",
      "birth_place": "Preston, Lancashire, England",
      "death_date": "1531",
      "death_place": "Preston, Lancashire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Girolamo Pettenati; married Richard Wall about 1488 in Preston; mother of at least 5 sons and 3 daughters; died 1531 in Preston and was buried in Stepney, Middlesex, England.",
      "research_note": "Burial place is geographically distinct from Preston and should be treated cautiously pending source review. User supplied Margaret Whalley Pettenati born 1467 in Preston, Lancashire, England, daughter of Girolamo Pettenati and Mrs.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_TAYLOR_WIFE_WILLIAM_WALL",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GIROLAMO_PETTENATI",
      "name": "Girolamo Pettenati",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Pettenati",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as father of Margaret Whalley Pettenati. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Preston, Lancashire, England",
          "confidence": 0.7,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Margaret Whalley Pettenati",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1439,
          "confidence": 0.504,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Preston, Lancashire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.7,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Margaret Whalley Pettenati"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1467,
          "confidence": 0.504,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MRS_GIROLAMO_PETTENATI",
      "name": "Mrs. Girolamo Pettenati",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Pettenati",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as mother of Margaret Whalley Pettenati. Personal name currently unknown. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Preston, Lancashire, England",
          "confidence": 0.65,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Margaret Whalley Pettenati",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1439,
          "confidence": 0.468,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Preston, Lancashire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.65,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Margaret Whalley Pettenati"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1467,
          "confidence": 0.468,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZABETHA_WYLD_1602",
      "name": "Elizabetha Wyld",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wyld",
      "birth_date": "christened 10 Oct 1602",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Christening transcript identifies Elizabetha Wyld, female, daughter of Willi Wyld, christened 10 Oct 1602 at Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul Sheffield, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England; original place Saint Peter, Sheffield, York, England. Added as a likely child of the existing William Wilde/Wyld of Sheffield, with spelling variation preserved.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1602,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_WYLDE_CLOTHIER",
      "name": "Thomas Wylde of The Commandery",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wylde",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "History of Parliament/Wikipedia identifies Thomas Wylde of The Commandery, Worcester, as father of George Wylde I; George was the eldest son of Thomas's second wife Ellinor, daughter of George Wall of Droitwich. Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Wylde_I",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Droitwich, Worcestershire, England",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "George Wylde I, Serjeant-at-law",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1522,
          "confidence": 0.648,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Droitwich, Worcestershire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.9,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "George Wylde I, Serjeant-at-law"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1550,
          "confidence": 0.648,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "name": "Frances Huddleston",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Huddleston",
      "birth_date": "1557",
      "birth_place": "Sawston Hall, Cambridgeshire, England",
      "death_date": "1630",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "History of Parliament/Wikipedia identifies Frances Huddleston, daughter of Sir Edmund Huddleston of Sawston Hall, Cambridgeshire, as wife of George Wylde I and mother of parliamentary children John Wylde, George Wylde II, and Elizabeth Wylde.",
      "research_note": "Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Wylde_I User supplied Frances Huddleston born 1557 and died 1630, spouse of George Wylde I and mother of the listed Wylde siblings.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "name": "Isabel Shemeld",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Shemeld",
      "birth_date": "1577",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1647",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Underlying parish/probate sources still to be checked.",
      "research_note": "User supplied Isabel Shemeld, female, born 1577 and died 1647; married William Wilde in 1601 at Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom; listed as mother of William Wilde children.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
          "confidence": 0.55,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth Wilde",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_WILDE_1602",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_WILDE_1602",
      "name": "Elizabeth Wilde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wilde",
      "birth_date": "1602",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld. Sarah Hancock appeared in the supplied children list but is not added here because existing evidence identifies Sarah Hancock as James Jacobus Handley's mother, not a Wilde child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARGARET_WILDE_1604",
      "name": "Margaret Wilde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wilde",
      "birth_date": "1604",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld. Sarah Hancock appeared in the supplied children list but is not added here because existing evidence identifies Sarah Hancock as James Jacobus Handley's mother, not a Wilde child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_WILD_1606",
      "name": "John Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1606",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "1644",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld. Sarah Hancock appeared in the supplied children list but is not added here because existing evidence identifies Sarah Hancock as James Jacobus Handley's mother, not a Wilde child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ISABEL_WILD_1608",
      "name": "Isabel Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1608",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "1668",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld. Sarah Hancock appeared in the supplied children list but is not added here because existing evidence identifies Sarah Hancock as James Jacobus Handley's mother, not a Wilde child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILD_1610",
      "name": "William Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1610",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld. Sarah Hancock appeared in the supplied children list but is not added here because existing evidence identifies Sarah Hancock as James Jacobus Handley's mother, not a Wilde child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANNA_WILDE_1612",
      "name": "Anna Wilde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wilde",
      "birth_date": "1612",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld. Sarah Hancock appeared in the supplied children list but is not added here because existing evidence identifies Sarah Hancock as James Jacobus Handley's mother, not a Wilde child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HELEN_WILD_1614",
      "name": "Helen Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1614",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld. Sarah Hancock appeared in the supplied children list but is not added here because existing evidence identifies Sarah Hancock as James Jacobus Handley's mother, not a Wilde child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_WILD_1616",
      "name": "George Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1616",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "1690",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STIRNET_HALL_CARR_WILD_PEDIGREE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The former identification of that father as a son of William Wilde is removed: the Droitwich Wylde memorial omits William, while a published Hall Carr pedigree instead identifies the Sheffield George Wild as a son of John Wild of Hall Carr.",
      "research_note": "That alternative is derivative, so the exact identity of Hannah's father remains qualified, but the Droitwich connection is no longer a valid ancestral bridge. Hannah Wild's 1649 Sheffield baptism directly names a father Georgii Wild.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOSEPH_WILD_1618",
      "name": "Joseph Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1618",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "1696",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld. Sarah Hancock appeared in the supplied children list but is not added here because existing evidence identifies Sarah Hancock as James Jacobus Handley's mother, not a Wilde child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARAH_WILDE_1620",
      "name": "Sarah Wilde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wilde",
      "birth_date": "1620",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "1620",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld. Sarah Hancock appeared in the supplied children list but is not added here because existing evidence identifies Sarah Hancock as James Jacobus Handley's mother, not a Wilde child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_WILDE_1622",
      "name": "Samuel Wilde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wilde",
      "birth_date": "1622",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld. Sarah Hancock appeared in the supplied children list but is not added here because existing evidence identifies Sarah Hancock as James Jacobus Handley's mother, not a Wilde child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_WILD_1626",
      "name": "Thomas Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1626",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "1636",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied as child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld. Sarah Hancock appeared in the supplied children list but is not added here because existing evidence identifies Sarah Hancock as James Jacobus Handley's mother, not a Wilde child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DAVID_WYLDE_1569",
      "name": "David Wylde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wylde",
      "birth_date": "1569",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1614 or 1633",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Geni profile for George Wylde, MP lists David Wylde as brother of George Wylde II, son of George Wylde I and Frances Wylde.",
      "research_note": "FamilySearch has conflicting David profiles: one born 1569 Staffordshire died 1614 with no sources, and another born about 1569 Wales died 1633 with sources on the profile but not the birth fact. Kept as a single supported-but-conflicted child pending primary record review.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EDMOND_WOLDE_1581",
      "name": "Edmond Wolde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wolde",
      "birth_date": "1581",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "speculative",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Droitwich geography is plausible, but parentage to George Wylde I and Frances Huddleston is not proved. Edmond Wolde profile MLHR-7D4 gives christening 15 Aug 1581 at Saint Andrew, Droitwich, but supplied details show the christening fact has 0 sources and no source shown naming parents. Speculative child link only. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ISABEL_WILDE_1589",
      "name": "Isabel Wilde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wilde",
      "birth_date": "1589",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "speculative",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Parentage to George Wylde I and Frances Huddleston is not proved. Isabel Wilde profile K8FC-ZKM has 0 sources, birth about/probably 1589 in Cambridgeshire, no christening, and no source shown naming parents. Speculative child link only. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_WYLDE_1590",
      "name": "John Wylde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wylde",
      "birth_date": "1590",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1669",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "John Wylde is identified by the History of Parliament/Geni George Wylde II summary as brother of George Wylde II and son of George Wylde I and Frances Wylde.",
      "research_note": "FamilySearch profile L5VW-NC9 gives christening 12 Jun 1590 at Bishopsgate, Middlesex and death 1669 at Wherwell, Hampshire, but the christening fact was shown with 0 sources in the supplied profile.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LADY_ELIZABETH_WYLDE_1591",
      "name": "Lady Elizabeth Wylde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wylde",
      "birth_date": "1591",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1656",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Lady Elizabeth Wylde is identified by History of Parliament/Geni summary as sister of George Wylde II and child of George Wylde I and Frances Wylde.",
      "research_note": "FamilySearch profile LB86-XP9 gives birth 1591 at Droitwich with 2 sources, death 23 Apr 1656 at Mamble with 2 sources, and burial 25 Apr 1656 at Mamble with 1 source.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_II_1594",
      "name": "George Wylde II",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wylde",
      "birth_date": "1594",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1650",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "George Wylde II, MP, born 1594 and died 15 Jan 1650, is directly described in the supplied Geni/History of Parliament text: baptised 20 Jan 1594, second son of George Wylde I of the Harriots, Droitwich and Frances, daughter of Sir Edmund Huddleston of Sawston; brother of John; educated at Balliol and Inner Temple; lawyer and MP; buried at Westminster Abbey. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "name": "Marty (Martin) Linder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Linder",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1582",
      "birth_place": "reported Saanen, Bern, Switzerland",
      "death_date": "reported 1615",
      "death_place": "reported Canton Bern, Switzerland",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Saanen lay on alpine transit routes and became a Bernese subject territory in 1555; Bern had taken control of church administration through the Reformation of 1528.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "name": "Salome Werren",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Werren",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1585",
      "birth_place": "reported Saanen, Bern, Switzerland",
      "death_date": "reported 1652",
      "death_place": "reported Canton Bern, Switzerland",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "name": "Anna Fuchs",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fuchs",
      "birth_date": "baptised 12 Sep 1596",
      "birth_place": "Oberböbingen, Gmünd, Württemberg, Germany",
      "death_date": "1677",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "name": "Anna",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": "1620",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Kept separate from Anna Fuchs.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.62,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Johannes Lindner",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_JOHANNES_LINDNER_1642_1722",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_ABT1626",
      "name": "Simon Lindner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lindner",
      "birth_date": "about 1626",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1632_1633",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lindner",
      "birth_date": "1632",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "1633",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1633_1633",
      "name": "Hans Lindner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lindner",
      "birth_date": "1633",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "1633",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1634",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lindner",
      "birth_date": "1634",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_LINDNER_1637_1638",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lindner",
      "birth_date": "1637",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "1638",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_APOLLONIA_LINDNER_1639_1639",
      "name": "Apollonia Lindner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lindner",
      "birth_date": "1639",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "1639",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1642_1718",
      "name": "Hans Lindner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lindner",
      "birth_date": "1642",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "1718",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_KASPAR_LINDNER_1642",
      "name": "Kaspar Lindner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lindner",
      "birth_date": "1642",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHANNES_LINDNER_1642_1722",
      "name": "Johannes Lindner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lindner",
      "birth_date": "1642",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "1722",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELSBETH_LINDER_1606",
      "name": "Elsbeth Linder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Linder",
      "birth_date": "1606",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CHRISTINA_LINDER_1607",
      "name": "Christina Linder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Linder",
      "birth_date": "1607",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SALOME_LINDER_1610",
      "name": "Salome Linder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Linder",
      "birth_date": "1610",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "1704",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTY_LINDER_JR_1611",
      "name": "Marty Linder Jr",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Linder",
      "birth_date": "1611",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SIMEON_LINDER_1614",
      "name": "Simeon Linder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Linder",
      "birth_date": "1614",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "1683",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARIA_LINDER_1616",
      "name": "Maria Linder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Linder",
      "birth_date": "1616",
      "birth_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "name": "Hans Fuchs",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fuchs",
      "birth_date": "1569",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1608",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION",
        "SRC_ARCHION_UNTERHAUSEN_MIXED_BOOK_1579_1618"
      ],
      "source_note": "A reconstructed profile reports a 4 February 1590 marriage to Barbara Reiff at Unterhausen and life dates 1569-1608. Oberböbingen had entered Württemberg's Lutheran church order in 1553, so Anna's baptism belonged to an established evangelical parish environment.",
      "research_note": "The couple remains the leading family reconstruction because both are named together as Anna's parents, but the marriage event and reported vitals remain unverified. This does not establish Hans's personal beliefs, occupation, property, birth, or parentage. Hans Fuchs is directly named as father of Anna Fuchs in her 12 September 1596 Oberböbingen baptism. Archion's catalogue shows that the surviving Unterhausen marriage entries begin in 1597, so it cannot verify the alleged 1590 date and place. Same-name regional Fuchs men have not been merged.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Oberböbingen, Gmünd, Württemberg, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Anna Fuchs",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "name": "Barbara Reiff",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Reiff",
      "birth_date": "1569",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION",
        "SRC_ARCHION_UNTERHAUSEN_MIXED_BOOK_1579_1618"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Reiff remains the leading named maiden-surname hypothesis rather than an unknown surname because a compiled reconstruction positively supplies it, but the identity is retained at 0.65 and no birth, death, occupation, property, or parent is asserted. A compiled family profile calls her Barbara Reiff and reports a 4 February 1590 marriage to Hans Fuchs at Unterhausen. Anna Fuchs's 12 September 1596 Oberböbingen baptism directly names her mother as Barbara. This does not disprove a marriage elsewhere or an incorrect year, but it removes the asserted date and place as supporting evidence. The surviving Unterhausen volume begins baptisms in 1579 but its marriage entries only in 1597, so that book cannot verify the claimed 1590 local marriage. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Oberböbingen, Gmünd, Württemberg, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.65,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Anna Fuchs",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BALTHASS_FUCHS_1595",
      "name": "Balthass Fuchs",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fuchs",
      "birth_date": "1595",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Anna Fuchs, a sibling, has an independently transcribed 1596 baptism at Oberboebingen naming Hans and a mother Barbara, but the original baptism for this person has not been inspected. A user-supplied compiled Fuchs profile places this person as a child of Hans Fuchs and Barbara Reiff. The reported birth year and parentage are therefore retained as plausible circumstantial support, not direct proof. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHANNES_FUCHS_1602",
      "name": "Johannes Fuchs",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fuchs",
      "birth_date": "1602",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Anna Fuchs, a sibling, has an independently transcribed 1596 baptism at Oberboebingen naming Hans and a mother Barbara, but the original baptism for this person has not been inspected. A user-supplied compiled Fuchs profile places this person as a child of Hans Fuchs and Barbara Reiff. The reported birth year and parentage are therefore retained as plausible circumstantial support, not direct proof. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BARBARA_FUCHS_1604",
      "name": "Barbara Fuchs",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fuchs",
      "birth_date": "1604",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Anna Fuchs, a sibling, has an independently transcribed 1596 baptism at Oberboebingen naming Hans and a mother Barbara, but the original baptism for this person has not been inspected. A user-supplied compiled Fuchs profile places this person as a child of Hans Fuchs and Barbara Reiff. The reported birth year and parentage are therefore retained as plausible circumstantial support, not direct proof. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VEIT_FUCHS_1606",
      "name": "Veit Fuchs",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fuchs",
      "birth_date": "1606",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Anna Fuchs, a sibling, has an independently transcribed 1596 baptism at Oberboebingen naming Hans and a mother Barbara, but the original baptism for this person has not been inspected. A user-supplied compiled Fuchs profile places this person as a child of Hans Fuchs and Barbara Reiff. The reported birth year and parentage are therefore retained as plausible circumstantial support, not direct proof. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARIA_FUCHS_1608",
      "name": "Maria Fuchs",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fuchs",
      "birth_date": "1608",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Anna Fuchs, a sibling, has an independently transcribed 1596 baptism at Oberboebingen naming Hans and a mother Barbara, but the original baptism for this person has not been inspected. A user-supplied compiled Fuchs profile places this person as a child of Hans Fuchs and Barbara Reiff. The reported birth year and parentage are therefore retained as plausible circumstantial support, not direct proof. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "name": "Lydia Ellis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Ellis",
      "birth_date": "1627",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1662",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "User supplied Lydia Ellis, female, born 1627 and died 1662; spouse of Godfrey Wilde; married about 1652 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England; mother of John, Samuel, Lydia, Sara, and Lydia Wild. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
          "confidence": 0.68,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Wild",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_JOHN_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1653",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HELLENA_TUNSTEAD_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "name": "Hellena Tunstead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Tunstead",
      "birth_date": "1640",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1681",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Godfrey/Hellena marriage is supported by a Sheffield parish marriage transcript dated 5 Sep 1677 at Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul Sheffield; transcript names husband Godfridus Wild.",
      "research_note": "User supplied Hellena Tunstead, female, born 1640 and died 1681; spouse of Godfrey Wilde; married 5 Sep 1677 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England; mother of Hannah Wilde born 1679. Supplied profile also lists Hannah Wild born 1649 under this spouse, but that conflicts with the 1677 marriage and is treated as an inconsistent attachment.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
          "confidence": 0.62,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Hannah Wilde",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_HANNAH_WILDE_CHILD_GODFREY_HELLENA_1679",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1653",
      "name": "John Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1653",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1655",
      "name": "Samuel Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1655",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1657",
      "name": "Lydia Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1657",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "1659",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis; first Lydia, died young.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1659",
      "name": "Sara Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1659",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1661",
      "name": "Lydia Wild",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wild",
      "birth_date": "1661",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "1664",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis; second Lydia, name reused after first Lydia died.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNAH_WILDE_CHILD_GODFREY_HELLENA_1679",
      "name": "Hannah Wilde",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wilde",
      "birth_date": "1679",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Godfrey Wilde and Hellena Tunstead. Distinct from direct-line Hannah Wild born/christened 1649.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "name": "Robert Hancock",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hancock",
      "birth_date": "1591",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch-style profile KFP9-X5X identifies Robert Hancock, male, born 1591 and deceased; spouse Margaret Greaves; married 5 Feb 1615 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England; father of listed Hancock children including Sarah Hancock G12M-1YY.",
      "research_note": "Later supplied parent profile identifies Robert as child of Richard Hancock G11W-5CL and Anne Roades GLSS-BMY, but FamilySearch change history for Richard shows recent unstable edits, duplicate/junk child cleanups, competing Joan Turner mother assignment, and no direct Robert baptism shown. Richard/Anne are therefore retained only as speculative parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.66,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Johannes Hancock",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_JOHANNES_HANCOCK_1616",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "name": "Margaret Greaves",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Greaves",
      "birth_date": "1595",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1629",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch-style profile G129-RV7 identifies Margaret Greaves, female, born 1595 and died 1629; spouse Robert Hancock; married 5 Feb 1615 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England; mother of listed Hancock children including Sarah Hancock G12M-1YY.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.66,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Johannes Hancock",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_JOHANNES_HANCOCK_1616",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHANNES_HANCOCK_1616",
      "name": "Johannes Hancock",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hancock",
      "birth_date": "1616",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves. FamilySearch-style ID: G338-59R.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1617_1616",
      "name": "Isabella Hancock",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hancock",
      "birth_date": "1617",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "1616",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves. FamilySearch-style ID: G338-352.",
      "research_note": "Supplied dates are internally impossible: birth 1617, death 1616; keep for later correction.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HANCOCK_1620",
      "name": "William Hancock",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hancock",
      "birth_date": "1620",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves. FamilySearch-style ID: G338-WS4.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOSEPH_HANCOCK_1621",
      "name": "Joseph Hancock",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hancock",
      "birth_date": "1621",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves. FamilySearch-style ID: G338-SQB.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1627",
      "name": "Isabella Hancock",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hancock",
      "birth_date": "1627",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "1696",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves; likely later reuse of Isabella name. FamilySearch-style ID: 9VSH-F7D.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_HANCOCK_1628_1628",
      "name": "Thomas Hancock",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hancock",
      "birth_date": "1628",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "1628",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves. FamilySearch-style ID: G338-42M.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_HANCOCK_1628",
      "name": "Elizabeth Hancock",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hancock",
      "birth_date": "1628",
      "birth_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "deceased",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves. FamilySearch-style ID: G338-Q8C.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_HANCOCK_1564",
      "name": "Richard Hancock",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hancock",
      "birth_date": "christened 19 Dec 1564",
      "birth_place": "Saint John the Baptist, Chester, Cheshire, England",
      "death_date": "buried 24 Sep 1623",
      "death_place": "Canterbury St Peter, Canterbury, Kent, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Christening transcript identifies Richard Hancock, male, christened 19 Dec 1564 at Saint John the Baptist, Chester, Cheshire, England. FamilySearch-style profile G11W-5CL identifies Richard Hancock, born 1564 and died 1622; spouse Anne Roades; married 30 Jan 1587 at Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. Burial transcript identifies Richard Hancock buried 24 Sep 1623 at Canterbury St Peter, Canterbury, Kent, England; original place St Peter in Thanet, St Peter, Kent.",
      "research_note": "The Chester christening, Sheffield marriage, and Canterbury/Kent burial may refer to the same man, but the geography is wide enough that the burial should be treated as a candidate match pending corroborating records.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANNE_ROADES_1567",
      "name": "Anne Roades",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Roades",
      "birth_date": "christened 5 Oct 1567",
      "birth_place": "Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "buried 29 Aug 1612",
      "death_place": "Ottringham, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch-style profile GLSS-BMY identifies Anne Roades, female. Name has 3 sources, sex has 2 sources. Birth about 1567 in Yorkshire has 0 sources. Christening has 2 sources: 5 Oct 1567 at Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. Death August 1612 at Ottringham has 0 sources. Spouse Richard Hancock; married 30 Jan 1587 at Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul, Sheffield.",
      "research_note": "Burial has 1 source: 29 Aug 1612 at Ottringham, Yorkshire, England.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1881_RUTH_E_RHEAD_ABT1858",
      "name": "Ruth Elizabeth Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "about 1858",
      "birth_place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1901_HEATH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1861_HEYWOOD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1881 Birmingham census: Ruth E Rhead, age 23, daughter, tailoress, born Birmingham. The 1891 Upper Penn census names Ruth Elizabeth Rhead, age 33, as child in the same Richard and Ellen Rhead family. Ruth appears with her widowed mother Ellen Rhead and children Eveline and Albert Fisher in the 1901 Heath household. The 1861 Heywood household records Ruth E Read, age 3, with parents Richard and Ellen Read, providing earlier continuity for the Rhead family.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1901,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, and Heath, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1881_FLORENCE_RHEAD_ABT1862",
      "name": "Florence Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "about 1862",
      "birth_place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1881 England Census, Birmingham: Florence Rhead, female, age 19, single, tailoress, daughter, born Birmingham, Warwickshire, in household of Richard Rhead and Ellen Rhead.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1881,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "name": "Julia Ann Glover",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Glover",
      "birth_date": "1799",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1883",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "Existing 1799-1883 dates remain compiled-profile facts pending Julia's own vital records. Census and memorial evidence continue the couple and distinguish them from the Shropshire Sampson/Sarah Poyner family.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_CHARLOTTE_RHEED_BLOORE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "name": "George Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1861 Bucknall census comparison identifies George Rhead as a child of Sampson and Julia Rhead.",
      "research_note": "A Bucknall memorial identifies George's later family, but its supplied text lacks an exact death date; no date is added here.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1822,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1873,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_SUSANNAH_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_DANIEL_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_THOMAS_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "name": "Thomas Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1889",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1861 Bucknall census comparison identifies Thomas Rhead as a child of Sampson and Julia Rhead. A later Bucknall memorial also lists Thomas as George Rhead's sibling.",
      "research_note": "His later life and reported 1889 death still need direct civil or burial evidence.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_RHEAD_MOUNTFORD",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_MARIA_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_ELIZABETH_READ_SIBLING_OF_SAMPSON",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "name": "Sampson Handley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Handley",
      "birth_date": "about 1730",
      "birth_place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_SAMPSON",
      "name": "George Handley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Handley",
      "birth_date": "about 1689",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1763",
      "death_place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_PROFILE",
        "SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_BURIAL_1763_MILWICH_FS_QL7Z_CMKN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Married Ann Cartwright at Caverswall, Staffordshire on 17 Feb 1718.",
      "research_note": "Profile gives George Handley born about 1689; possible baptism 19 Apr 1689 to William and Alice at Market Bosworth, Leicestershire, but same-person identity needs more research. Burial source records George Handley buried 4 Dec 1763 at Milwich, Staffordshire.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_HANDLEY",
      "name": "Ann Handley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Cartwright",
      "birth_date": "about 1691",
      "birth_place": "Rowley Regis, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "26 Aug 1758",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_MARGARET_HANDLEY_SIBLING_OF_SAMPSON",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_ANN_HADLEY_HUNT_SIBLING_OF_SAMPSON",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_MARY_ALKIN_CARTWRIGHT",
      "name": "Mary Allkin Cartwright",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Allkin Cartwright",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "about 1710",
      "death_place": "Uttoxeter, Stafford, England",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_ALKIN_BURIAL_1710_UTTOXETER"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_INDEX_JOHN_ALKIN_FATHER_OF_MARY",
      "name": "John Alkin",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Alkin",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_ALKIN_BURIAL_1710_UTTOXETER",
        "SRC_JOHN_ALKINS_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_MARRIAGE_1667"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary Alkin burial index names father John Alkin. Marriage index records John Alkins married Elizabeth Bagnald on 13 Jun 1667, Bramshall, Staffordshire.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Uttoxeter, Stafford, England",
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Mary Allkin Cartwright",
          "descendant_id": "C_WIKITREE_MARY_ALKIN_CARTWRIGHT",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_INDEX_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_ALKIN",
      "name": "Elizabeth Bagnald",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bagnald",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_ALKINS_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_MARRIAGE_1667"
      ],
      "source_note": "Marriage index records Elizabeth Bagnald married John Alkins on 13 Jun 1667 at Bramshall, Staffordshire.",
      "research_note": "Supplied biography identifies her as mother of Mary Alkin.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Uttoxeter, Stafford, England",
          "confidence": 0.62,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Mary Allkin Cartwright",
          "descendant_id": "C_WIKITREE_MARY_ALKIN_CARTWRIGHT",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_INDEX_RICHARD_CARTWRIGHT_HUSBAND_OF_MARY_ALLKIN",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1825_RICHARD_RHEAD_BURSLEM",
      "name": "Richard Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "1825",
      "birth_place": "Burslem, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57"
      ],
      "source_note": "Baptism index: Richard Rhead, baptised 1825 at St John, Burslem, Staffordshire, England, parents Levi Hanby Rhead and Henrietta. Kept as a distinct Richard Rhead from the about-1833 Milborough/Shropshire Richard.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1825,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Burslem, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1825_LEVI_HANBY_RHEAD",
      "name": "Levi Hanby Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as father of Richard Rhead in 1825 Burslem baptism record.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Burslem, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Richard Rhead",
          "descendant_id": "SRC1825_RICHARD_RHEAD_BURSLEM",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1797,
          "confidence": 0.698,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Burslem, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.97,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Richard Rhead"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1825,
          "confidence": 0.698,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1825_HENRIETTA_RHEAD",
      "name": "Henrietta Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as mother of Richard Rhead in 1825 Burslem baptism record.",
      "research_note": "Maiden surname unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Burslem, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Richard Rhead",
          "descendant_id": "SRC1825_RICHARD_RHEAD_BURSLEM",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1797,
          "confidence": 0.698,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Burslem, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.97,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Richard Rhead"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1825,
          "confidence": 0.698,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_JANE_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "name": "Jane Godwin Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "1828",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1854",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Jane Godwin Rhead, 1828-1854, spouse of George Rhead, married 1847.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_MARGARET_TURNER_RHEAD",
      "name": "Margaret Turner Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "1831",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1865",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Margaret Turner Rhead, 1831-1865, spouse of George Rhead, married 1854.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_MARY_ANN_BEARDMORE_RHEAD",
      "name": "Mary Ann Beardmore Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "1838",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "15 May 1891",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial says George Rhead was buried with wife Mary Ann Rhead, who died 15 May 1891 aged 53; lists Mary Ann Beardmore Rhead, 1838-1891, spouse married 1866.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_JULIA_ANN_RHEAD_POTTS",
      "name": "Julia Ann Rhead Potts",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Potts",
      "birth_date": "1850",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1907",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Julia Ann Rhead Potts, 1850-1907, as child of George Rhead.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_THOMAS_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "name": "Thomas Godwin Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "1851",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1852",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Thomas Godwin Rhead, 1851-1852, as child of George Rhead.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_FREDERICK_GEORGE_RHEAD",
      "name": "Frederick George Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "1873",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1945",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Frederick George Rhead, 1873-1945, as child of George Rhead.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "about 1800",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "Apr-Jun 1845",
      "death_place": "Stone registration district, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_COUNCIL_WOOD_FARM_STOKE_ST_MILBOROUGH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Their son Richard's 1833 original baptism names Sampson and Sarah Rhead at Woodfarm and calls Sampson a grocer. The original 1841 census image independently shows a Sampson and Sarah Rhead household with Richard, Stephen, George, and Ruth. Sarah's later Botton household and the 1845 civil death index are compatible with this man's death.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_RICHARD_FREDERICK_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON_JULIA",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ANCESTRY_GRAHAM_SHORTT_CHILD_OF_DAVE_LEANA",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_HEINRICH_FRIEDRICH_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER",
      "name": "Heinrich Friedrich Fricke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fricke",
      "birth_date": "13 Aug 1845",
      "birth_place": "Hannover, Hannover, Preußen, Deutschland",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "German baptism identifies Heinrich Friedrich Fricke, born 13 Aug 1845 and christened 9 Nov 1845 at Sankt Ägidien Hannover, son of Georg Heinrich Fricke and Anna Dorothee Leffler.",
      "research_note": "Kept separate from New Jersey Henry Albert Fricke, born Jul 1846, because the middle name and birth date differ; possible identity remains a research hypothesis only.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1845,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Hannover, Hannover, Preußen, Deutschland",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821",
      "name": "Johannes (John) Schaaf",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schaaf",
      "birth_date": "about 1821",
      "birth_place": "Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_1880_JOHN_SCHAAF_NEWARK"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The proposed identity with Johannes Schaaf, spouse of Anna Elisabetha Gunder and father of Johannes Ludwig, remains unproved. The 1870 John Schaef and 1880 widowed John Schaaf are a strong identity match: born about 1821-1822 in Hesse-Darmstadt, Newark tailor. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1858,
          "confidence": 0.59,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GONDER_ANNA_ELISABETHA_1822",
      "name": "Anna Elisabetha Gonder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gonder",
      "birth_date": "2 Feb 1822",
      "birth_place": "Obergleen, Oberhessen, Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822"
      ],
      "source_note": "Baptism identifies parents Johann Caspar Gonder and Anna Catharina Decher. A Lutheran family record names Anna Elisabetha Schaaf, maiden name Gunder.",
      "research_note": "Gonder/Gunder spelling variation and geography are compatible, but the cross-record identity remains probabilistic.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_LUDWIG",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GONDER_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "name": "Johann Caspar Gonder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gonder",
      "birth_date": "17 Jul 1801",
      "birth_place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
      "death_date": "4 Jan 1871",
      "death_place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHANN_CASPAR_GONDER",
        "SRC_JOHANN_CASPAR_GONDER_BAPTISM_DEATH_1801_1871"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as Anna Elisabetha's father in her 1822 baptism index. His 1826 marriage age supports birth about 1801; exact birth and death dates come from an Ancestry profile and await direct-record confirmation. Indexed surname variants include Gonder and Gonter.",
      "research_note": "This corrects the profile-derived 1870 death. A parish transcript directly records birth 17 Jul 1801, baptism 20 Jul 1801, parents Balthasar and Barbara Catharina Gonter, and death 4 Jan 1871.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_DECHER_ANNA_CATHARINA",
      "name": "Anna Catharina Decher",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Decher",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as Anna Catharina Decher in the 1822 baptism and Catharina Decher in the 1826 marriage index.",
      "research_note": "Same-name, same-place, same-partner identity is strong but the post-birth marriage date should be checked in images.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Obergleen, Oberhessen, Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Anna Elisabetha Gonder",
          "descendant_id": "C_GONDER_ANNA_ELISABETHA_1822",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1794,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Obergleen, Oberhessen, Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany",
          "place_confidence": 0.95,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Anna Elisabetha Gonder"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GONTER_JOHANN_BALTHASAR",
      "name": "Johann Balthasar Gonder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gonder",
      "birth_date": "19 Jan 1762",
      "birth_place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
      "death_date": "10 Jan 1836",
      "death_place": "Ober Gleen, Oberhessen, Hessen, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHANN_BALTHASAR_GONDER",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "Born 19 Jan 1762 and baptized 21 Jan at Obergleen. The baptism index names parents Dietrich Gonder and Anna Wendel; their 1761 marriage identifies them fully as Johann Dietrich Gunter/Gonder and Anna Catharina Wendel. Johann Balthasar is later named as Johann Caspar Gonter's father. Indexed surname variants include Gonder and Gonter.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GONTER_BARBARA_CATHARINA",
      "name": "Barbara Catharina (surname unknown)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": "4 Jun 1762",
      "birth_place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
      "death_date": "2 Mar 1837",
      "death_place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_UNNAMED_BAPTISM_1762",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BARBARA_KATHERINA_GONDER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Indexed as Barbara Catharina Gonter, mother of Johann Caspar. A profile names Barbara Katherina Gonder with the exact 4 Jun 1762 date of an otherwise unnamed female Gonder baptism to Johannes Gonder and Anna Elisabetha Engel.",
      "research_note": "This strongly supports the identity, but Gonder may be her married surname and her birth surname remains unresolved.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GONTER_SUSANNA_KREUTSCH",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GONDER_MARIA_KATHARINA",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GONDER_JOHANNES",
      "name": "Johannes Gonder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gonder",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_UNNAMED_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as father of an unnamed female Gonder in the 1762 Obergleen baptism index.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Barbara Catharina (surname unknown)",
          "descendant_id": "C_GONTER_BARBARA_CATHARINA",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1734,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
          "place_confidence": 0.95,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Barbara Catharina (surname unknown)"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1762,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ENGEL_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "name": "Anna Elisabetha Engel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Engel",
      "birth_date": "reported 25 Aug 1740",
      "birth_place": "reported Hinsing",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_UNNAMED_BAPTISM_1762",
        "SRC_GENEANET_ANNE_ELISABETH_GINDER_1740"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Geneanet profile under the different surname Ginder reports birth 25 Aug 1740 at Hinsing and parents Antoine Ginder and Marguerite Jansem.",
      "research_note": "The birth and proposed parents are retained as unresolved compiled-tree claims, not established facts. Anna Elisabetha Engel is directly named with Johannes Gonder as a parent in the 1762 Obergleen baptism index.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1762,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GONDER_DIETRICH",
      "name": "Johann Dietrich Gonder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gonder",
      "birth_date": "18 Jul 1724",
      "birth_place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
      "death_date": "about 1772",
      "death_place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762",
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GONDER_BAPTISM_1724",
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761",
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GONDER_PROFILE_DEATH_1772"
      ],
      "source_note": "Born 18 Jul 1724 and baptized 20 Jul at the Evangelical church in Obergleen; the baptism index names father Conrad Gonder. He married Anna Catharina Wendel there on 31 Mar 1761 under the indexed surname Gunter. Their son Johann Balthasar was born 19 Jan 1762 and baptized 21 Jan, with parents Dietrich Gonder and Anna Wendel.",
      "research_note": "The reported 1772 Ober Gleen death remains profile-only pending a burial record.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WENDEL_ANNA_INCOMPLETE",
      "name": "Anna Catharina Wendel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wendel",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762",
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761"
      ],
      "source_note": "Anna Catharina Wendel married Johann Dietrich Gunter/Gonder on 31 Mar 1761 at Obergleen. The January 1762 baptism of Johann Balthasar names his mother incompletely as Anna ... Wendel; the marriage supplies her full given names.",
      "research_note": "Her birth, parents, and death remain unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Johann Balthasar Gonder",
          "descendant_id": "C_GONTER_JOHANN_BALTHASAR",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1734,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
          "place_confidence": 0.995,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Johann Balthasar Gonder"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1762,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BENDER_ANNA_MARGARETHA",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GONTER_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SCHAAF_ELIZABETH_ABT1823",
      "name": "Elizabeth Schaef",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schaef",
      "birth_date": "about 1823",
      "birth_place": "Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "John was widowed by the probable matching 1880 census, but Elizabeth's death date is not assigned without a death record. Inferred spouse of John Schaef in the 1870 Newark census. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1858,
          "confidence": 0.59,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SCHAAF_MARTIN_NEWARK",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SCHAAF_JUSTIN_ABT1854",
      "name": "Justin Schaef",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schaef",
      "birth_date": "about 1854",
      "birth_place": "New Jersey, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Age 16 in John and Elizabeth Schaef's 1870 Newark household.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SCHAAF_ELIZZIE_ABT1858",
      "name": "Elizzie Schaef",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schaef",
      "birth_date": "about 1858",
      "birth_place": "New Jersey, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Age 12 in John and Elizabeth Schaef's 1870 Newark household.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1911_EDWARD_RICHARD_RHEAD_ABT1901",
      "name": "Edward Richard Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "22 Nov 1900",
      "birth_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "1950",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "1911 England Census at Glen Villas, Little Stretton: Edward Richard Rhead, age 10, son of Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead. Ancestry family timeline gives birth 22 Nov 1900 in Wolverhampton and death in 1950.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1911_BERNAL_ALBERT_RHEAD_ABT1903",
      "name": "Bernal Albert Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "Jul 1902",
      "birth_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "Jul 1931",
      "death_place": "Derby, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "1911 England Census at Glen Villas, Little Stretton: Bernal Albert Rhead, age 8, son of Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead. Ancestry family timeline gives birth Jul 1902 in Wolverhampton and death Jul 1931 in Derby.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1911_GEORGE_ERNEST_RHEAD_ABT1905",
      "name": "George Ernest Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "1905",
      "birth_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "1943",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "1911 England Census at Glen Villas, Little Stretton: George Ernest Rhead, age 6, son of Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead, born Wolverhampton. The 1921 census comparison again names him in the family. Ancestry family timeline gives birth in 1905 in Wolverhampton and death in 1943. The timeline spelling Earnest is normalized to the established Ernest.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1911_AMY_ROSA_RHEAD_ABT1907",
      "name": "Amy Rosa Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "28 Feb 1907",
      "birth_place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "1988",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "1911 England Census at Glen Villas, Little Stretton: Amy Rosa Rhead, age 4, daughter of Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead, born Wolverhampton. The 1921 census comparison again names her in the family. Ancestry family timeline gives birth 28 Feb 1907 in Wolverhampton and death in 1988.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1841_FREDERICK_WATERHOUSE_ABT1828",
      "name": "Frederick Waterhouse",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Waterhouse",
      "birth_date": "about 1828",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 13 in the 1841 Trentham household of John and Ellen Waterhouse.",
      "research_note": "Relationships are inferred from household structure because the 1841 census did not state them.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1841,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1841_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ABT1830",
      "name": "James Waterhouse",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Waterhouse",
      "birth_date": "about 1830",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 11 in the 1841 Trentham household of John and Ellen Waterhouse. Kept distinct from the existing James Waterhouse born 1846 in Burwash.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1841,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1841_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ABT1832",
      "name": "John Waterhouse",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Waterhouse",
      "birth_date": "about 1832",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 9 in the 1841 Trentham household of John and Ellen Waterhouse.",
      "research_note": "Relationships are inferred from household structure.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1841,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1841_WILLIAM_WATERHOUSE_ABT1837",
      "name": "William Waterhouse",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Waterhouse",
      "birth_date": "about 1837",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 4 in the 1841 Trentham household of John and Ellen Waterhouse.",
      "research_note": "Relationships are inferred from household structure.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1841,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1841_EMMA_WATERHOUSE_ABT1840",
      "name": "Emma Waterhouse",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Waterhouse",
      "birth_date": "about 1840",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 1 in the 1841 Trentham household of John and Ellen Waterhouse.",
      "research_note": "Relationships are inferred from household structure.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1841,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1901_ARTHUR_J_DAVIES_ABT1881",
      "name": "Arthur J Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "about 1881",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Arthur J Davies is explicitly listed as a child, age 10, in Frederick and Maria Davies's 1891 household and appears age 20 in 1901. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1901,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1901_ROBERT_L_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "name": "Robert L Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "about 1886",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Robert L Davies is explicitly listed as a child, age 5, in 1891 and appears age 15 in the same family in 1901. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1901,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1901_FRANCIS_J_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "name": "Francis J Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "about 1886",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Francis Davies is explicitly listed as a child, age 5, in 1891 and appears as Francis J, age 15, in the same family in 1901. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1901,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1901_LOUIE_S_DAVIES_ABT1890",
      "name": "Louis S Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "about 1890",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Listed as Louis S Davies age 1 in the 1891 household and Louie S age 11 in 1901.",
      "research_note": "Louis is used as the canonical transcription; child relationship remains inferred because the supplied individual relationship field was absent.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1901,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1901_THOMAS_E_DAVIES_ABT1894",
      "name": "Thomas E Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "about 1894",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Age 7 in Frederick and Maria Davies's 1901 household; child relationship inferred. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1901,
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1891_WALTER_H_DAVIES_ABT1882",
      "name": "Walter H Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "about 1882",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Explicitly listed as a child, age 9, of the Frederick and Maria Davies household in 1891. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1891,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Shrewsbury St Mary, Shropshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1851_ANNA_HANNEY_ABT1841",
      "name": "Anna Hanney",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hanney",
      "birth_date": "about 1841",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Age 10 in William and Elizabeth Hanney's 1851 household; child relationship inferred because the individual relationship field was not supplied. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1851,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1851_EDWIN_HANNEY_ABT1842",
      "name": "Edwin Hanney",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hanney",
      "birth_date": "about 1842",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Age 9 in William and Elizabeth Hanney's 1851 household; child relationship inferred. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1851,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HANNY_JAMES_CHILD_OF_WILLIAM_ELIZABETH",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1880_ROBERT_I_GOBBLE_ABT1859",
      "name": "Robert Ireson Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "about 1859-1861",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Recorded as Robert age 1 in 1860, Robert C age 9 in 1870, and Robert I age 21 in 1880.",
      "research_note": "A later death record names him Robert Ireson Gobble and identifies John Gobble and Sallie Phelps as parents; the middle-initial discrepancy is retained.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1880,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1880_GEORGE_W_GOBBLE_ABT1868",
      "name": "George Washington Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "about 1867-1868",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Recorded as George W age 3 in 1870 and age 12 in 1880. A later death record names George Washington Gobble and identifies John Gobble and Sallie Phelps as parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1880,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "name": "Martin Vines Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "about 1796-1799",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": "29 Aug 1882",
      "death_place": "Holston, Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796_1882",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1820_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1830_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_DEATH_1882",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Birth estimates vary: profile 1796 Russell County, 1850 about 1799 Virginia, 1860 about 1796 Virginia, 1880 about 1796 North Carolina, and death index about 1797 Washington County.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "name": "Eda Cauntis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Cauntis",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Eda Cauntis married Martin Phelps in 1820. A later record names Cauntis as Martin's spouse and John P Phelps as their child. Added her missing maternal edge to Sarah.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Russell County, Virginia, US",
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Sarah Phelps",
          "descendant_id": "I81",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1796,
          "confidence": 0.691,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Russell County, Virginia, US",
          "place_confidence": 0.96,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Sarah Phelps"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1840,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "name": "Malinda Scott Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Scott Phelps",
      "birth_date": "about 1820-1826",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_DEATH_1882",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS",
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_PHELPS_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "A local compilation citing civil, census, and cemetery records identifies her maiden name as Scott and reports 28 December 1821 to 17 October 1904.",
      "research_note": "Malinda is securely the later wife in repeated Washington County households. The name is adopted at secondary-source confidence; the exact dates remain in structured facts rather than replacing broad vital fields until original images are inspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Virginia, USA",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Martin S Phelps",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_MARTIN_S_PHELPS_1845",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1904,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HARDIN_PHELPS_1833",
      "name": "Hardin Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "about 1833",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hardin Phelps was enumerated at age seventeen in 1850 in a Washington County, Virginia household headed by Martin Phelps and including Malinda Phelps.",
      "research_note": "The census establishes his presence, age estimate, and locality, but it does not state relationships; the Martin-to-Hardin link remains a household inference.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1850,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_P_PHELPS_1834",
      "name": "John P Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "about 1834",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 16 in Martin Phelps's 1850 household. A later death record names Martin, spouse Cauntis, and child John P Phelps.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1850,
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARGARET_PHELPS_1843",
      "name": "Margaret Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "about 1843",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 7 in the 1850 household; a Virginia marriage index names Martin and Malinda Phelps in relation to child Margaret Phelps.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1850,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTIN_S_PHELPS_1845",
      "name": "Martin S Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "about 1845",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 5 in 1850 and present again in 1860; a Virginia marriage index names Martin and Malinda Phelps in relation to child Martin S Phelps.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1860,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VIRGINIA_F_PHELPS_1854",
      "name": "Virginia F Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "about 1853-1855",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age about 7 in 1860 and 25 in 1880 in the Martin and Malinda Phelps household.",
      "research_note": "Parentage is inferred from repeated household membership.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1880,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1855",
      "name": "William Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "about 1855",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "William Phelps was enumerated at about age five in 1860 in the Washington County, Virginia household of Martin and Malinda Phelps.",
      "research_note": "The census supports the approximate birth year and locality, but does not state relationships; both parent links remain household inferences.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1860,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEWTON_PHELPS_1857",
      "name": "Newton Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "about 1856-1858",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded as Newton in 1860 and Nuten in 1880, with ages implying about 1856-1858.",
      "research_note": "Parentage is inferred from repeated household membership.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1880,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRANK_STRETTON_RHEAD_1911",
      "name": "Frank Stretton Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "25 Sep 1911",
      "birth_place": "Church Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "1969",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named in Bernal Bright Rhead's Ancestry timeline as son born 25 Sep 1911 at Church Stretton and died 1969. A direct birth record is still desirable.",
      "research_note": "The supplied timeline spelling Church Setton is normalized.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALFRED_SAMUEL_RHEAD_1913",
      "name": "Alfred Samuel Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "26 Sep 1913",
      "birth_place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "2006",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named in Bernal Bright Rhead's Ancestry timeline as son born 26 Sep 1913 at Little Stretton and died 2006. A direct birth record is still desirable.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_RHEAD_SHROPSHIRE_1837",
      "name": "George Rhead",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rhead",
      "birth_date": "about 1837",
      "birth_place": "reported Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original 1841 census image places George Rhead, age four, in the Sampson and Sarah Rhead household. It distinguishes him from the separate George Rhead recorded with Sampson Handley Rhead and Julia at Bucknall.",
      "research_note": "The earlier profile's Shropshire birthplace is not accepted as direct evidence.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1841,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "name": "Thomas Boulton",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Boulton",
      "birth_date": "about 1826",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1851 census transcribes the surname as Botton. His 1852 parish marriage to Sarah Rhead and the 1861 and 1871 censuses consistently use Boulton, which is adopted as the canonical spelling.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1871,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Trentham and Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1849",
      "name": "Thomas Boulton",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Boulton",
      "birth_date": "about 1849",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded as Thomas Botton, age 2, in 1851 and as Thomas Boulton, ages 12 and 22, in the 1861 and 1871 continuation of the same household. Boulton is adopted as the canonical spelling.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1871,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Trentham and Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTHA_JANE_GOBBLE_1844",
      "name": "Martha Jane Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "about 1844-1846",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Martha is age 6 in 1850 and 14 in 1860.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1860,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTIN_P_GOBBLE_1848",
      "name": "Martin P Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "about 1847-1848",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Martin is age 12 in 1860 and 23 in 1870 in John and Sarah's household.",
      "research_note": "Parentage is inferred because these censuses do not state relationships.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1870,
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARY_CATHERINE_GOBBLE_1850",
      "name": "Mary Catherine Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "about 1850",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Likely recorded as Catharine age 0 in 1850 and Mary age 10 in 1860. The combined Mary Catherine identity is strong but should be checked against an original record.",
      "research_note": "A Virginia marriage index explicitly names John and Sarah as parents of Mary C Gobble.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1860,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_C_GOBBLE_1853",
      "name": "William C Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "about 1852-1854",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "William is age 8 in 1860 and 16 in 1870.",
      "research_note": "A Virginia marriage index explicitly names John and Sarah as parents of Wm C Gobble.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1870,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JULIA_ANN_GOBBLE_1857",
      "name": "Julia Ann Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "about 1856-1857",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Julia is age 4 in 1860 and indexed Julis A age 13 in 1870.",
      "research_note": "A Virginia marriage index explicitly names John and Sarah as parents of Julia Ann Gobble.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1870,
          "confidence": 0.93,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EGLANTINE_GOBBLE_SCOTT_1863",
      "name": "Eglantine Gobble Scott",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobble",
      "birth_date": "about 1863-1864",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Eglantine is age 6 in 1870 and Eglentine Scott age 17 in 1880 with likely husband James M Scott and infant Linis T Scott. A Virginia marriage index names John and Sarah as parents; Sarah's memorial also lists Eglatine Scott as daughter.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1880,
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARY_E_HENDERSON_1858",
      "name": "Mary E Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "about 1858",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary is age 2 in Robert and Mary's 1860 household.",
      "research_note": "A Virginia birth register explicitly names Robt and Mary Henderson as parents of Mary E Henderson.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1860,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_HENDERSON_1860",
      "name": "Samuel Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "about 1860",
      "birth_place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Samuel is age 5/12 in 1860 and 20 in Robert's 1880 household. A later death record names Bob Henderson and Mary McNew as his parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1880,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOWCRESA_HENDERSON_1862",
      "name": "Lucretia Louisa Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "about 1862",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 18 in widowed Robert Henderson's 1880 household.",
      "research_note": "Relationship is inferred; spelling may be an index error. Wallace Jr. tree supplies the name Lucretia Louisa, a plausible expansion/correction of the 1880 Lowcresa index entry, and names her as Robert and Mary's child.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1880,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Saltville, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_AMANDA_HENDERSON_1864",
      "name": "Amanda Jane Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "about 1864",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 16 in widowed Robert Henderson's 1880 household. Wallace Jr. tree supplies middle name Jane and names her as Robert and Mary's child.",
      "research_note": "Relationship is inferred.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1880,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Saltville, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JAMES_HENDERSON_1862",
      "name": "James M Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "about 1862",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 18 in widowed Robert Henderson's 1880 household.",
      "research_note": "Relationship is inferred. The same age as Lowcresa may represent twins, another relative, or an indexing issue. Wallace Jr. tree supplies middle initial M and names him as Robert and Mary's child, supporting but not proving the 1880 household inference.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1880,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Saltville, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "John R Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "possibly Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": "about 1843",
      "death_place": "Giles County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1843_JOHN_R_HENDERSON_GILES_PROBATE",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_GILES_COUNTY_MICROFILM"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "name": "Evan L Talley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Talley",
      "birth_date": "about 1823-1830",
      "birth_place": "Virginia or North Carolina, USA",
      "death_date": "before 1866",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_EVAN_L_TALLEY_1823_BEFORE_1866",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1850 census records Evans Tally, age 27, born Virginia, with Adelia age 18. The 1860 census indexes Evan and Dela as Sally, with Dela age 28 and their children; multiple Virginia child indexes establish the Talley surname and Evan L identity. Adelia/Dela's exact ten-year age progression strongly links the households.",
      "research_note": "Evan's age and birthplace remain unresolved: 1850 supports about 1823 Virginia, while 1860 and Geneanet support about 1830 North Carolina. Death before 1866 remains profile-derived.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "name": "Delia (probably Faddis) Talley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Faddis Talley",
      "birth_date": "26 Dec 1830",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": "16 Aug 1897",
      "death_place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DELIA_TALLY_HENDERSON_1866_HEADSTONE",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_1835_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX",
        "SRC_1840_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_GRayson_HISTORICAL_SOCIETY_FADDIS_NOTEBOOK"
      ],
      "source_note": "Delia appears as Adelia Tally with Evans Tally in Grayson County in 1850 and as Dela with Evan and their children in Washington County in 1860. Later child records identify her as Delia Talley. Widowed during the Civil War era, she married William Henderson in Washington County on 10 September 1866. The 1840 Alexander Faddis household contains a woman aged 40-49 and two girls aged 5-9, whose pattern closely continues as Susan Faddis, Sibarina, Isaac, Susan, and Floyd in 1850; Alexander was absent by then. Delia's 1850 age fits the second older girl.",
      "research_note": "The census does not name relationships, so the family reconstruction remains open to confirmation or refutation by probate, deed, marriage, church, or family-Bible evidence. A daughter's later death information calls her Delia Fadas or Faddis, making Faddis the probable maiden surname but not direct evidence from Delia's lifetime. This makes Alexander and Susan the leading named parents at 70% and 73% circumstantial confidence, respectively.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "name": "William Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "about 1821",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "William and Delia are a documented blended household in 1870. A record-citing local compilation transcribes their 10 September 1866 marriage and records William as a farmer in 1870.",
      "research_note": "Because the original marriage image was not inspected, the identification is strong secondary rather than direct-image evidence.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1870,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Abingdon area, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_AMANDA_J_TALLEY_1851",
      "name": "Amanda J Talley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Talley",
      "birth_date": "about 1851-1854",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": "Amanda is age 9 in 1860 and 16 in 1870, a three-year discrepancy.",
      "research_note": "A Virginia index explicitly names Evan L and Delia Talley as parents of Amanda J Talley.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1870,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JAMES_M_TALLEY_1860",
      "name": "James M Talley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Talley",
      "birth_date": "about 1859-1860",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": "James is age 5/12 in 1860 and age 11 in 1870.",
      "research_note": "A Virginia index explicitly names A.L. Tally and Delia Tally as parents; A.L. is treated as a probable Evan L index error.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1870,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PEYTON_R_TALLY_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Peyton R Tally",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Tally",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_NARA_1820_CENSUS_RECORDS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PEYTON_TALLEY_TN_1797_DISAMBIGUATION_20260730",
        "ROOTS26_YANCEY_WILL_PEYTON1845",
        "ROOTS26_MECKLENBURG_TALLEY1800"
      ],
      "source_note": "Peyton R. His dates, residence and parents are unidentified.",
      "research_note": "Tally remains a compiled-tree father candidate. The Tennessee Peyton/Rachel family and the Mecklenburg Virginia Peyton R./Jane family are separate comparison records, with no demonstrated bridge to Evan. An incomplete child list cannot exclude an earlier family; distinctive relatives, locality and chronology must distinguish the identities.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Virginia or North Carolina, USA",
          "confidence": 0.55,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Evan L Talley",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Holly Tally (possibly Hood)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Tally",
      "birth_date": "about 1790-1795",
      "birth_place": "North Carolina, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_1860_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_GRAYSON",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Holly Tally was born in North Carolina about 1790-1795. In 1850 she lived in Grayson County with William Ferren and Tabitha Tally Ferren; in 1860 she lived in Washington County with Evan and Delia Tally. The sequence documents movement from North Carolina into southwest Virginia and then between two adjoining regional family networks, but not when or why the first migration occurred.",
      "research_note": "The 1860 household placed her in Washington County immediately before the Civil War; no record establishes her personal wartime experience. Both censuses show a durable Tally association and make the compiled claim that she was Evan's mother plausible, but pre-1880 censuses did not state household relationships. Hood remains an unproved maiden-name lead.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1860,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DAVID_M_HENDERSON_CHILD",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTHA_HENDERSON_CHILD",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NANCY_HENDERSON_CHILD",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JAMES_ROBERT_HENDERSON_CHILD_CONLEY",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "name": "Ann \"Annie\" Smith McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Smith",
      "birth_date": "about 1804-1807",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_HENDERSON_FAMILY_RECORD_NOTES",
        "SRC_WCV_PARENT_INDEX_DAVID_ANN_MCNEW",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ann, also recorded as Annie and Nancy, spent at least three decades in David McNew's Washington County household. In 1850 she was about forty-five and lived with David and children Elizabeth, Ailsey, Samuel, Nancy, Louisa, and Cena. The compilation places her birth in Virginia and reports both parents as North Carolina-born in 1880.",
      "research_note": "This suggests a possible family migration but identifies neither parent nor a North Carolina county. A published record compilation follows the couple through 1880, when both were reported aged seventy-six and living with daughter Ailsey. Their son Samuel's 1918 death record names his mother Annie Smith, making Smith the best-supported maiden surname, though it is later informant evidence. Local research is unusually difficult because a Union raid destroyed or removed substantial Washington County records in 1864. No source ties Ann personally to military events or the nearby Saltville battles.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1880,
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALCY_HADEN_CHILD_DAVID_MCNEW",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "name": "Elizabeth McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Listed as a child of David McNew in the 1850 Washington County census comparison. Sharon Wright tree independently lists this child.",
      "research_note": "No age or other identity details were supplied.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1829,
          "confidence": 0.57,
          "basis": "estimated from known parent birth year(s)"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1850,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "name": "Samuel McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Listed as a child of David McNew in the 1850 Washington County census comparison.",
      "research_note": "No age or other identity details were supplied.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1829,
          "confidence": 0.546,
          "basis": "estimated from known parent birth year(s)"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1850,
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NANCY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "name": "Nancy McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Listed as a child of David McNew in the 1850 Washington County census comparison. Sharon Wright tree independently lists this child.",
      "research_note": "No age or other identity details were supplied.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1829,
          "confidence": 0.57,
          "basis": "estimated from known parent birth year(s)"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1850,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOUIS_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The original census image should confirm.",
      "research_note": "Sharon Wright tree gives Louisa Amelia, a plausible correction/expansion of the 1850 Louis index entry.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1829,
          "confidence": 0.558,
          "basis": "estimated from known parent birth year(s)"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1850,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CENA_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "name": "Senah McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Original image confirmation remains desirable. Sharon Wright tree gives Senah, a plausible correction of the 1850 Cena index entry.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1829,
          "confidence": 0.546,
          "basis": "estimated from known parent birth year(s)"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1850,
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_AILSEY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID",
      "name": "Ailsey McNew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McNew",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "Kept separate pending ages or direct records that could test duplication.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1830,
          "confidence": 0.484,
          "basis": "estimated from known parent birth year(s)"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1850,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANNA_JANE_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_BERRY_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JULIUS_CONNOR_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_ALBERT_MCNEW_JR_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SENA_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_AMELIA_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JONATHAN_C_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DALY_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOSIAH_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SHADRACK_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DANIEL_SHADRACK_MCNEW_CHILD_JEREMIAH",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_HOWARD_MACKNEW_CHILD_JEREMIAH",
      "name": "John Howard MacKnew",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "MacKnew",
      "birth_date": "about 1660",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "about 1696",
      "death_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_PROFILE_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JEREMIAH_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Warren Family Tree names John Howard as Jeremiah's child. The older Jeremiah timeline gives about 1660-1696 in Maryland but contains other conflations.",
      "research_note": "A compiled Phillis profile independently names John Howard as her son, though the sources may not be independent and no baptism or probate record has been supplied.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "name": "Matthew Mackneugh",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Mackneugh",
      "birth_date": "1518",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1550",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_EARLY_RECORD_GUIDE",
        "SRC_MCNEW_HISTORY_BOWMAN_THOMAS_1997",
        "SRC_MCNEW_MEMORABILIA_CARROLL_1998",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_REDDIT_MACKNEW_SCOTLAND_QUERY_2021",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The phrase “first-hand information” describes the modern contributor, not contemporary knowledge of a sixteenth-century man.",
      "research_note": "With no established place, even a local historical narrative would invent context; the profile remains visible at 0.08 solely as a disputed family tradition. No locality, spouse, occupation, property, church, court, or original record is supplied, and nearby generations follow a suspicious twenty-year pattern. Published McNew genealogies instead begin with the seventeenth-century immigrant Jeremiah and do not support this ancestry. Matthew Mackneugh, reportedly born in 1518 and died in 1550, appears only in a transcript of a private family tree attributed to Judith McNew's 2014 recollection.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland",
          "confidence": 0.05,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Matthew MacKnew",
          "descendant_id": "I135",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "name": "John Draper Hargis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hargis",
      "birth_date": "about 1722",
      "birth_place": "Westmoreland County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "reported 15 Jun 1779",
      "death_place": "reported in the Kentucky District of Virginia, near later Hopkinsville, Kentucky",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_AMELIA_1765_FATHER_1742",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_1762",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Goymerac and a separate published Hargis pedigree both name Amelia Mildred Hargis as his daughter.",
      "research_note": "Geneanet and Goymerac compiled trees identify John Draper Hargis/Argus, born about 1722 and reportedly dead by 1779. On comparative grounds the older John is the leading candidate for Amelia's father and is visible at 0.60 circumstantial confidence. The reported 1777 Caswell County entry and December 1777 Virginia ensign record are compatible but not proven to be this man. The competing proposal inserts a younger John born about 1742 and wife Elizabeth Freelove, but the linked Elizabeth profile gives her a 1762 death—before Amelia's 1765 birth. That is not primary proof: a baptism, probate, Bible, land, or other contemporary parent-identifying record is still needed.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "name": "John Draper Hargis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hargis",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1695",
      "birth_place": "reported Oldhams, Westmoreland County, Virginia",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The previously attached 1730 death belongs to the elder will-maker and has been removed.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: the elder John Hargis will proves a son John, but only compiled trees identify that son as this reported 1695 man and then make him father of the 1722 John. The latter relationship remains 0.58. This is the reported 1695 son of John Draper Hargis I and the reported father of John born about 1722. Direct evidence identifying this middle generation is still needed.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "name": "Grace Elizabeth Boswell",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Boswell",
      "birth_date": "about 1690-1699",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, British Colonial America (reported Westmoreland or New Kent County)",
      "death_date": "reported 10 Aug 1778 or 1790",
      "death_place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, or unspecified",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_AGBI_GRACE_BOSWELL_1690S_VIRGINIA",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Geneanet reports 1690 Westmoreland and death 1790, while another profile reports 1692 New Kent and death 10 Aug 1778 in Washington County.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: multiple compiled profiles repeat Grace Boswell as spouse and mother, but no marriage, deed, probate, or baptism naming her in this Hargis family was found. Compiled trees name John Draper Hargis as spouse and James Boswell and Ann Smith as parents. Her link remains visibly uncertain. Exact dates and places are unresolved. AGBI supports only a Virginia birth in the 1690s.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "name": "Ann Elizabeth Whiteside",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Whiteside",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE_PROFILE_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "ROOTS26_HARGIS_ESTATE_TRANSCRIPTIONS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Ann Elizabeth Whiteside is a competing maternal candidate for Amelia Hargis. Compiled trees place her either as Amelia’s mother or in the preceding generation. The reported 1720 birth would make Ann about 45 when Amelia was born: possible, though the younger Elizabeth Freelove household offers a different generational explanation. The 1779 estate entry names an Ann Hargis, but does not establish the expanded name, birth surname or motherhood. Existing low confidence remains provisional while these identities are resolved. Her reported parents, William Whiteside and Mary Sarah Calvert, have not been distinguished from other households by family or property evidence. The present evidence does not securely choose between direct maternity, a grandmother relationship and conflated pedigrees. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.25,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Amelia Mildred \"Milly\" Hargis",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE",
      "name": "Elizabeth Freelove",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Freelove",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_1762",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The date dispute remains unresolved; it cannot be settled by choosing the more convenient tree. Elizabeth Freelove is a proposed mother of Amelia Hargis, born in 1765. Her name and connection come from compiled pedigrees. Another compiled reconstruction gives a later death and has its own conflicting attachments. Existing low confidence remains provisional while these identities are resolved. No inspected contemporary record identifies her parents or establishes where her birth family lived. Searches for earlier Virginia Freelove families have not yet produced an identifiable household connected with Elizabeth. The younger John Hargis and Elizabeth household offers a plausible generation for Amelia’s parents. A RootsMagic tree gives Elizabeth’s death as 1762, which would exclude that maternity if correct, but supplies no death record.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Washington County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.2,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Amelia Mildred \"Milly\" Hargis",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HENDERSON_JOHN_ALLOA_1787_GILES_1843",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "reported 27 May 1787",
      "birth_place": "Scotland (reported Alloa, Clackmannanshire)",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "This is a plausible identity match, not proof of the exact Alloa birth.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "name": "George W Shortt",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Shortt",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HENRY_SHORTT_DEATH_1937",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "George W. Shorts headed a household with Susan and their children at Marion in Smyth County in the 1870 census, placing the family in southwest Virginia during the immediate post-Civil War period. Son David's 1938 death record names George Shortt and Susan Jones as his parents, and Floyd's 1934 record independently repeats the couple. In 1880 David appears with a George and Obedience Shorts at Speedwell in Wythe County, probably the same father after remarriage; Obedience was too young to be David's mother.",
      "research_note": "His age, birth county, death, and parents remain unresolved. The record sequence establishes the regional family but neither George's occupation nor the effects of war and reconstruction on him personally.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1842,
          "confidence": 0.713,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1934,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Saltville, Smyth County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "name": "Susan Jones",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Jones",
      "birth_date": "about 1841",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": "reported 7 Mar 1897",
      "death_place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HENRY_SHORTT_DEATH_1937",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Susan lived with George W. Shorts and their children at Marion in Smyth County in 1870, placing the family in southwest Virginia during the immediate post-Civil War period. Their son David Kitzmiller Shortt's 1938 death record identifies his mother as Susan Jones, and Floyd Short's 1934 record independently repeats George Short and Susan Jones.",
      "research_note": "The records state no occupation and do not show how war or reconstruction affected her personally. Her approximate 1841 Virginia birth and reported 1897 Washington County death still need a record from her own life. These later informants establish the maiden surname more strongly than a public tree, but they do not identify her Jones household.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SHORT_JOHN_EDGAR_1900_1920",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "name": "John Gibson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gibson",
      "birth_date": "16 Sep 1850",
      "birth_place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "death_date": "reported 26 Jul 1921",
      "death_place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
        "SRC_PROFILE_JOHN_GIBSON_1850_1921_MONAGHAN",
        "SRC_NY_PASSENGER_JOHN_GILSON_FLORENCE_GIBSON",
        "SRC_JOHN_GIBSON_MONAGHAN_DEATH_Q3_1921",
        "SRC_MONAGHAN_PRESBYTERIAN_REGISTER_COVERAGE",
        "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_NAI_IRELAND_CENSUS_SEARCH_GUIDE",
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_SARAH_ANN_GIBSON_DEATH_1885_REJECTED",
        "SRC_SECOND_MONAGHAN_PRESBYTERIAN_MIC1P146_COVERAGE",
        "SRC_PRONI_GUIDE_SECOND_MONAGHAN_MIC1P146"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Gibson was a Presbyterian farmer at Aghnasedagh. His primary marriage entry records that on 10 October 1883 he married Sarah Clark at Second Monaghan Presbyterian Church; both were full age, lived at Aghnasedagh, and signed the register. Official 1901 and 1911 returns continue the widowed household with the same four children.",
      "research_note": "Second Monaghan baptism registers survive from 1802 at PRONI under MIC.1P/146, so John's reported 1850 baptism may be recoverable there and could identify his mother. It explicitly names John's father as Andrew Gibson, farmer. It has not yet been inspected; no mother is inferred.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GIBSON_DAVID_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "name": "David Andrew Gibson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gibson",
      "birth_date": "about 1888-1889",
      "birth_place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "David Gibson appears age 12 in John Gibson's 1901 Aghnasedagh household and age 22 in 1911, establishing continuous sibling identity. The Patton tree expands his name to David Andrew Gibson.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1911,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GIBSON_MAGGIE_J_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "name": "Margaret Jane Gibson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gibson",
      "birth_date": "about 1885-1886",
      "birth_place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Maggie J Gibson, age 15 in the 1901 Aghnasedagh household, was a sibling of Florence. The Patton tree expands her name to Margaret Jane Gibson.",
      "research_note": "The 1911 household lists Minnie Gibson age 24; Minnie may be Margaret or Mary, but the supplied excerpts do not resolve which, so no alias merge is made.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1901,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GIBSON_MARY_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "name": "Mary Gibson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gibson",
      "birth_date": "about 1887-1888",
      "birth_place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary Gibson, age 13 in the 1901 Aghnasedagh household, was a sibling of Florence.",
      "research_note": "The 1911 household lists Minnie Gibson age 24; Minnie may be Mary or Maggie, but the supplied excerpts do not resolve which.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1901,
          "confidence": 0.96,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Clarke",
      "birth_date": "about 1804",
      "birth_place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "death_date": "reported 29 Jul 1882",
      "death_place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Griffith's Valuation places him as occupier of a holding at Aghnasedagh in 1861 under lessor Francis J. Jervis, giving him a specific townland setting during the post-Famine valuation era. This proves rated occupancy, not ownership, wealth, religion, or an agricultural occupation.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_MARGRET_CHILD_DAVID_ELIZA",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_HENRY_CHILD_DAVID_1911",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "name": "Sarah \"Sadie\" Clarke",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Clarke",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "This directly proves Sarah's father; Eliza remains the highly probable mother supported by the parental marriage and compiled family reconstruction, but Sarah's baptism has not been found.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1857,
          "confidence": 0.648,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1891,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Clarke",
      "birth_date": "about 1830-1832",
      "birth_place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "death_date": "29 Mar 1913",
      "death_place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "Compiled trees name Sarah Clarke Gibson and several siblings as children, but Sarah's own birth or baptism record is still needed; this uncertainty belongs on the Sarah parent-child links rather than on David's otherwise well-supported identity.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "name": "Elizabeth \"Eliza\" Boyd",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Boyd",
      "birth_date": "about 1829",
      "birth_place": "Coolmain, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "death_date": "reported 6 Feb 1894",
      "death_place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_BOYD_PROFILE_1829_1894",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_MOTHER_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "name": "Unknown Martin",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Martin",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
          "confidence": 0.45,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "descendant_id": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_WILLIAM_CHILD_DAVID",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_JR_CHILD_DAVID",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_MARY_JANE_CHILD_DAVID",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_CHILD_DAVID",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_MARGARET_CHILD_JAMES",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_JANE_CHILD_JAMES_1804",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_ANNIE_CHILD_JAMES_1804",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_CHILD_JAMES_1804",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_ELIZA_JANE_CHILD_JAMES_1804",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CLARKE_JOHN_CHILD_JAMES_1804",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "name": "William Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "about 1814",
      "birth_place": "Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "William was baptized at Berriew on 29 January 1814, son of Robert Davies and Eliza. The current register transcription places the family at Trustewelin and calls Robert a carpenter. William's adult family was enumerated at Trwstewelin in 1851, and William was later recorded as a carpenter.",
      "research_note": "The unusual abode continuity and related trade substantially strengthen identification of the baptized child with the adult man, although no record explicitly follows him across the intervening years.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1881,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Allport, Churchstoke, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "name": "Martha (surname unknown) Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": "about 1816",
      "birth_place": "Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Later censuses place the family at Churchstoke and Allport, documenting at least three decades in the Montgomeryshire border country between Welsh and English counties and parishes.",
      "research_note": "Martha, whose maiden surname remains unknown, is consistently recorded as William Davies's wife in the 1851, 1861, 1871, and 1881 households. Because each census uses her married surname and no secure marriage has supplied a maiden name or father, attaching Davies parents to her would be circular. Frederick Davies's 1845 Berriew baptism directly names William and Martha as his parents. The records establish household continuity but state no occupation for Martha and do not explain any local moves.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1881,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Allport, Churchstoke, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "name": "Robert Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Davies",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "probably Berriew parish, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
        "SRC_FREEREG_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1823",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_DAVIES_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1803",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert and Elizabeth Davies formed a repeatedly documented household at Trustewelin in Berriew parish. Their children William, David, a second David, and Martha were baptized there between 1814 and 1823. Robert was described as a carpenter in 1814, a wheelwright in 1819 and 1821, and a labourer in 1823.",
      "research_note": "A Robert Davies married Elizabeth Lamb at Berriew in 1803; that is the only matching Robert–Elizabeth marriage found in the county search, but the sparse marriage transcription does not independently prove that the groom was the later Trustewelin craftsman. Robert's birth, death, and parents remain unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1786,
          "confidence": 0.706,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1823,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Trustewelin, Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "name": "Richard Morrall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Morrall",
      "birth_date": "about 1812",
      "birth_place": "Horsehay, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "before 8 Jul 1884",
      "death_place": "Wellington, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1841_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1881_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_DEATH_1884",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_1811_1884",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_BURIAL_1884",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1841 and 1851 censuses document Richard with first wife Hannah and their children, including direct-line son Richard. The younger Richard's 1860 marriage independently names his father. Richard married again in early 1861; the civil index and following census support Mary Anne Ball as his second wife. The 1861-1881 censuses continue him at Wellington, with Horsehay/Wellington recorded as birthplace and insurance agent as his 1881 occupation. Census ages imply birth about 1811-1813, so about 1812 is used. Civil death registration records age 73 in Wellington in Jul-Sep 1884. His 4 Jul 1837 parish marriage names father Samuel Morrall. A parish burial on 8 Jul 1884 narrows his death to before that date and is compatible with the Q3 Wellington registration.",
      "research_note": "He remains distinct from Richard Morrall baptized in 1793 and married to Ann Southern; no parents are presently assigned.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "name": "Hannah Grindley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Grindley",
      "birth_date": "about 1811",
      "birth_place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "September 1853",
      "death_place": "Wellington, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1841_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLEY_MORRALL_PROFILE_ABT1811_1853",
        "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1853",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_CHILD_BAPTISM_PARENTS_RICHARD_ANNE",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1841 Wellington and 1851 Madeley censuses record Hannah as Richard Morrall's wife and mother of their children, including direct-line son Richard. The 1851 census gives birth about 1811 at Forton, Staffordshire. Civil registration places Hannah Morrall's death at Wellington in Jul-Sep 1853, explaining Richard's 1861 remarriage. Hannah Halford in the 1881 household is their daughter, not this Hannah. Her 4 Jul 1837 parish marriage names her father as Thomas Grindly and gives her residence as Newport.",
      "research_note": "A Shropshire church marriage index explicitly names Thomas Grindly as Hannah Grindly's father, independently supporting her maiden surname. A child baptism index names the mother as Anne, a plausible Hannah/Anne variation requiring image review.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "name": "Mary Ann Ball",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Ball",
      "birth_date": "about 1824",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary Anne Ball appears on the same Q1 1861 Shifnal marriage-index page as Richard Morrall. Richard's 1861 and 1871 households name wife Mary Ann, making the pairing likely. Her census ages imply birth about 1823-1826.",
      "research_note": "Her birthplace and death are not established, and she was absent from Richard's transcribed 1881 household.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1871,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Wellington area, Shropshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "name": "John Grindley",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Grindley",
      "birth_date": "about 1753",
      "birth_place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "March 1834",
      "death_place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_1753_1834",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_GRINDLEY_HODNET_BAPTISM_BURIAL_1754",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "John, recorded as Grunley or Greenley, married Elizabeth Pickin at Forton All Saints on 31 December 1777.",
      "research_note": "John's reported birth about 1753 and death in March 1834 at Forton remain compiled claims without separate parish transcripts. Thomas Grindley's 1783 Forton baptism explicitly names John and Elizabeth as his parents, and Thomas's later censuses consistently identify Forton as his birthplace. John's line stops until the Forton registers, tithe accounts, settlements, wills, or other local records identify his birth family. A particularly tempting John Grindley baptized at Wollerton in August 1754 cannot be this man because the same child was buried in December 1754. He is not the Keele-born John who married Ann Ryly.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "name": "Elizabeth Pickin",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Pickin",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth Pickin married John Grindley at Forton on 31 December 1777, and their son Thomas's 1783 baptism names both parents.",
      "research_note": "The leading available origin is Elizabeth, daughter of William and Sarah Pickin, baptized at Whitmore on 11 January 1756: the exact name, age at marriage, and nearby Staffordshire setting make it more likely than an entirely unknown origin, but no record connects the two women. William and Sarah are therefore shown as 48% candidate parents, not as established ancestry. The marriage supplies no age, residence, or parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Grindley",
          "descendant_id": "I155",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1755,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.995,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Thomas Grindley"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1783,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BETTY_PILSBURY_WIFE_RICHARD_READ",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_READ_FATHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "name": "John Read",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Read",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_ancestor",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_READ_PERRY_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPT_1750",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1755",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOSEPH_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1759",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "The earlier identification of this man with John Read who married Sarah Perry at Wolverhampton in 1750 is no longer accepted.",
      "research_note": "His birth, occupation, death, and parents remain unresolved. Richard Read’s Stoke baptism on 30 October 1753 directly names his father John. That Wolverhampton household baptized Ann in April 1753, only six months before Richard at Stoke, and later baptized its own Richard in 1755; later Wolverhampton baptisms explicitly continue the parents as John and Sarah. This profile therefore represents the documented Stoke father only.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1725,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1753,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARAH_READ_MOTHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "name": "Sarah Read",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_ancestor",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_READ_PERRY_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPT_1750",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1755",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOSEPH_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1759",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "She was previously identified as Sarah Perry from a 1750 Wolverhampton marriage.",
      "research_note": "Sarah Perry, her reported 1727 birth, and the 1766 memorial are therefore removed from this connected identity. Richard Read’s Stoke baptism on 30 October 1753 directly names his mother Sarah, but does not state her maiden name. The Wolverhampton couple’s child sequence conflicts with that identification: John Read had Ann baptized there in April 1753 and a Richard baptized there in 1755, while later baptisms explicitly name John and Sarah. This profile represents the documented Stoke mother only.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1725,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1753,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_RHEAD_CHILD_RICHARD_READ",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREDRICK_RHEAD_CHILD_SAMPSON_JULIA_1851",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_MORRALL_FATHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "name": "Samuel Morrall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Morrall",
      "birth_date": "about 1786",
      "birth_place": "reported Wellington or Lawley, Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "reported 30 Jan 1853",
      "death_place": "reported Lawley Common, Wellington, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_MORRALL_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1810_1811",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ROOTSCHAT_SAMUEL_ANN_MORRALL_LAWLEY_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The alternative remains a different same-named Samuel Morrall, because the transcription is not a reviewed image and no later record yet identifies the 1813 child as the adult Richard. The Lawley identity is therefore a well-supported candidate, not a proven identification. The most likely specific Samuel is the Lawley collier reported in a community transcription: Samuel and Ann Morrall baptised twins Richard and Adam at Wellington on 3 Oct 1813, and their Lawley/Wellington setting fits Richard's repeated Horsehay or Wellington birth reports. The 4 Jul 1837 marriage directly names Richard Morrall's father as Samuel Morrall. The baptism is one to two years later than the age inferred from Richard's censuses, a small difference for this period. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HENRY_CORNISH_FATHER_ELIZABETH",
      "name": "Henry Cornish",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Cornish",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Elizabeth's later evidence places her around Hilperton and Bradford-on-Avon, but the supplied marriage excerpt gives Henry no age, occupation, residence, spouse, or other identifying detail. Henry Cornish is securely known only from Elizabeth Cornish's marriage to William Peters Hanny on 31 March 1838, where the church record explicitly names Henry as her father. His line stops until Elizabeth's baptism, another child record, a local marriage, settlement, census, probate, or trade record identifies the same Henry more fully. Exact-name searches produced unrelated men and no record that can safely be joined to this father. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Hilperton or Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth Cornish",
          "descendant_id": "I183",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1774,
          "confidence": 0.713,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Hilperton or Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.99,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Elizabeth Cornish"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1838,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Wiltshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "name": "James Waterhouse",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Waterhouse",
      "birth_date": "about 1765",
      "birth_place": "Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": "before 19 Oct 1840",
      "death_place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_DEATH_BURIAL_1840",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WATERHOUSE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_KINGSLEY_1767_1769",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_CHURCH_REGISTERS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "James Waterhouse is documented at Ashbourne from his marriage to Hannah Needham on 26 November 1799 through their son John's baptism in 1802 and James's burial on 19 October 1840. The burial age of 75 implies birth about 1765. This chronology excludes the James born in 1775 who later appears with Ann and was buried in 1843.",
      "research_note": "No occupation, property, court, military, or religious affiliation beyond Church of England family events has been established. His line stops pending a baptism, marriage allegation, settlement, apprenticeship, or probate record that names his parents. Baptisms at Kingsley in 1767 and 1769 are plausible regional candidates, but neither has a record bridge to the Ashbourne husband and father.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "name": "Hannah Needham",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Needham",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hannah Needham married James Waterhouse on 26 Nov 1799 at Ashbourne St Oswald. John Waterhouse's 1802 baptism names parents James and Hannah, linking the couple to him.",
      "research_note": "The 1841 Glossop census woman is wife of Stephen Waterhouse and is rejected as a different Hannah; therefore the profile's about-1766 birth remains unsupported and is not adopted.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Waterhouse",
          "descendant_id": "I145",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1774,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.995,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "John Waterhouse"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1802,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "name": "Edward Needham",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Needham",
      "birth_date": "about 1734",
      "birth_place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": "before 7 Apr 1816",
      "death_place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_CHILD_HANNAH_INDEX",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BURIAL_1816",
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BAPTISM_1734",
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1738",
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1734_1738",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_LOCAL_HISTORY_GEORGIAN_COACHING"
      ],
      "source_note": "Edward Needham was an Ashbourne grocer when he married Hannah Mellor in 1758, and their later Ashbourne household is documented by repeated baptisms. He was buried there on 7 April 1816 aged 82, pointing to about 1734. The leading identity is Edward Nedham, son of Samuel and Martha, baptised at neighbouring Carsington in February 1733/34.",
      "research_note": "A real but weaker alternative is Edward, son of George, baptised at Ashbourne in 1738. The two parent sets remain visible at different confidence levels so the evidence and the unresolved alternative are both clear.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "name": "Hannah Mellor",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Mellor",
      "birth_date": "about 1737",
      "birth_place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_CHILD_BAPTISM_SERIES",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_HANAH_MELLOR_BRADBOURNE_BAPTISM_1732",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_LOCAL_HISTORY_GEORGIAN_COACHING"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hannah Mellor, aged 21, married the Ashbourne grocer Edward Needham at St Oswald on 11 December 1758. Repeated baptisms document Edward and Hannah raising children there from 1768 through 1779.",
      "research_note": "Edward is directly named as father of the direct-line Hannah Needham, but that child's full baptism has not been found; Hannah Mellor's mother edge therefore remains strong but not direct at 0.925. A Hannah baptized to Thomas and Mary Mellor at Bradbourne in 1732 is possible, but a same-name 1754 Bakewell marriage and the age discrepancy prevent adopting those parents. Her line stops until a marriage allegation, baptism, settlement, or probate record resolves her birth family. Same-name baptisms elsewhere lack a bridge to the Ashbourne bride.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1779,
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARY_POYNER_MOTHER_SARAH_1811",
      "name": "Mary Poyner",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Poyner",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Mary's ancestry stops here pending another child's baptism, a marriage, settlement or poor-law record, household evidence, or probate naming the same mother. Mary Poyner's earliest and only confirmed appearance is Sarah Poyner's baptism at Stoke St Milborough on 5 May 1811, where the parish record explicitly names Mary as the mother and names no father. This directly establishes motherhood but supplies no age, occupation, residence beyond the parish context, spouse, maiden surname, or parents. George Odnett, whom adult Sarah later named as her father, must not be assumed to have been Mary's husband. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ludlow, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Sarah Maria Poyner",
          "descendant_id": "I140",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1783,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Ludlow, Shropshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.995,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Sarah Maria Poyner"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1811,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GEORGE_ODNETT_CLAIMED_FATHER_SARAH_POYNER",
      "name": "George Odnett",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Odnett",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_DIDDLEBURY_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_ANN_MOUND_LUDLOW_MARRIAGE_1804",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "George is known from Sarah Rhead's 1852 remarriage at Shelton, where the adult bride named George Odnett as her father.",
      "research_note": "Benjamin and Martha are therefore retained only as 40% candidate parents. Another George, or a social rather than biological father, remains a substantial alternative. Sarah's 1811 baptism at Stanton Lacy names only her mother, Mary Poyner, so George may have been her biological, acknowledged, or social father. His uncommon name, compatible age, and nearby localities make that identification more likely than an entirely unidentified George, but the 1804 marriage to Ann Mound/Munn and the mother-only 1811 baptism prevent certainty. The leading named identity is George Hodnett, baptized at Diddlebury in 1787 to Benjamin and Martha Hodnett and married at Ludlow in 1804.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ludlow, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.78,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Sarah Maria Poyner",
          "descendant_id": "I140",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1783,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Ludlow, Shropshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.78,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Sarah Maria Poyner"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1811,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CONRAD_GONDER_FATHER_DIETRICH_1724",
      "name": "Conrad Gonder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gonder",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GONDER_BAPTISM_1724"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No mother, dates, spouse, occupation, or residence for Conrad is given in the supplied excerpt. The 1724 Obergleen baptism index explicitly names Conrad Gonder as father of the male child identified as Johann Dietrich Gonder. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.97,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Johann Dietrich Gonder",
          "descendant_id": "C_GONDER_DIETRICH",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1696,
          "confidence": 0.698,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
          "place_confidence": 0.97,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Johann Dietrich Gonder"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1724,
          "confidence": 0.698,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "name": "David Boyd",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Boyd",
      "birth_date": "about 1800-1810",
      "birth_place": "Coolmain, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "death_date": "about 1890",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_identity_and_family_locality_with_compiled_dates",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVID_BOYD_PROFILE_1800_1810_1890",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GRIFFITHS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_SAMUEL_SARAH",
        "SRC_COOLMAIN_LANDED_ESTATES_LOCALITY",
        "SRC_MONAGHAN_1930_1935_BOYD_COOLMAIN_LATER_CLUSTER"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARGARET_BOYD_CHILD_DAVID",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_THOMAS_TOMPSON_FATHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "name": "Thomas Tompson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Tompson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_RECORDS_1538_1944"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No occupation, address, other child, marriage, death, military or court activity, property, or parents have been securely identified. Thomas's earliest and only confirmed appearance is Esther Tompson's baptism at Wolverhampton St Peter on 14 February 1808, where the register explicitly names him as her father and Mary as her mother. This directly proves parenthood and identifies a co-parenting pair, but the baptism does not itself prove that Thomas and Mary married. His line stops until another Wolverhampton record supplies enough detail to distinguish him from namesakes. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Esther Thompson",
          "descendant_id": "I152",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1780,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.995,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Esther Thompson"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1808,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARY_TOMPSON_MOTHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "name": "Mary Tompson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Tompson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_RECORDS_1538_1944"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No occupation, address, other child, death, or parents have been securely identified. Tompson is retained as a display surname from the parental household; the entry does not establish Mary's maiden name. Mary's earliest and only confirmed appearance is Esther Tompson's baptism at Wolverhampton St Peter on 14 February 1808, where she and Thomas Tompson are explicitly named as the child's parents. Her line stops until a marriage or another Wolverhampton record distinguishes her from same-name women. The shared baptism proves co-parenthood but not a legal or church marriage, and no spouse edge is asserted from it alone.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Esther Thompson",
          "descendant_id": "I152",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1780,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.995,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Esther Thompson"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1808,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "name": "Nancy Willis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Willis",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_COUNTY_VA_OFFICIAL_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_WILLIS_HARTWELL_1787"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nancy’s marriage to Robert Lavinder on 27 February 1794 is recorded in a county transcription. Neither two Robert Lavinders nor remarriage has been resolved.",
      "research_note": "Her identification as Fanny’s mother remains provisional: Fanny’s reported 1794 birth fits that marriage, while later census ages suggest 1799–1800, after the separate Milly Willis marriage. A mistaken attachment or confusion with Parmelia remains possible. The short structured child list’s omission of Nancy is not evidence that she was excluded from the family. The court file independently supports John’s reported movements and associates, but does not name Nancy or Phebe. The compilation identifies Nancy by her husband and exact marriage date, making John and Phebe the leading named parent candidates.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Franklin County, Virginia, USA",
          "confidence": 0.68,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Frances \"Fanny\" Lavender",
          "descendant_id": "I61",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1770,
          "confidence": 0.547,
          "basis": "estimated from spouse's birth year",
          "place": "probably Franklin County, Virginia, USA",
          "place_confidence": 0.68,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Frances \"Fanny\" Lavender"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1797,
          "confidence": 0.49,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "name": "Samuel Felps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Felps",
      "birth_date": "reportedly about 1760-1767",
      "birth_place": "reported Rowan County, North Carolina, USA",
      "death_date": "about 1846-1847",
      "death_place": "Russell County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_1790_ROWAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_VA_NC_CENSUS_SEQUENCE",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_1810_NAMESAKE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Samuel Felps married Susannah Vines in 1782 and a likely Samuel Phelps later lived in southwest Virginia. His 1846 Russell County will names wife Susan, daughter Sarah Phelps, and executor Charles H. 15 September 2026 correction: Brock p.725 names Samuel of Russell County as Martin's father; paternal link now .90.",
      "research_note": "Family evidence review: published Phelps/Y-DNA research explicitly names John Felps and Mary May Williams as Samuel's parents and cites their 1766 Rowan marriage. Gilmer; it supports this local Samuel's death in 1847 but does not name Martin. That claim supports the edge at 0.78, but a contemporary record naming Martin remains absent. Identifying this Samuel with the 1782 bridegroom remains correlated. Earlier .78/no parent-naming-evidence statements are superseded. John Felps remains an unproved father; no new evidence resolves his identity. The reported 1767 birth would make him about fifteen at marriage and ten during the cited 1777 military service, so the birth estimate or military identification is wrong. Published Phelps/Y-DNA research explicitly identifies Martin as Samuel and Susannah's child. Because the project openly debates John's placement and no contemporary parent record was inspected, both new edges are 0.62. Multiple Samuel Felps/Phelps households existed, including two plausible 1810 entries.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "name": "Susannah Vines",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Vines",
      "birth_date": "reported 1767",
      "birth_place": "reported Rowan County, North Carolina, USA",
      "death_date": "reported 1847 or 1848",
      "death_place": "Russell County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
        "SRC_SUSANNAH_VINES_COMPILED_VITALS_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Susannah Vines married Samuel Felps in Lincoln County, North Carolina, on 13 February 1782. George Winfree served as bondsman and James McEwin witnessed the bond, preserving two associates from the couple's local community.",
      "research_note": "Samuel Phelps Sr.'s 1846 will in Russell County names his wife Susan, supporting the identification of this couple in southwest Virginia; it also names a daughter Sarah but does not establish a complete child group. Her reported 1767 birth would make her about fifteen at marriage, and the reported 1847 or 1848 death in Russell County remains compiled. Published Phelps and Y-DNA research identifies Martin Vines Phelps among their children and describes the family's later movement toward southwest Virginia, but the contemporary record chain has not been fully inspected. The marriage is secure; her Rowan County origin, later migration, parents, occupation, and complete child group are not.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD_1684",
      "name": "George Brassington",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD_BURIAL_1717"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "The 1717 George burial and 1706 Mary burial may belong to this couple but remain unproved identities. He is retained separately because the George baptized in 1672 was too young and no record connects this couple to John baptized in 1702.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARY_ASTEN_WIFE_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_1684",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_1601_WIFE_THOMAS_EMERYE",
      "name": "Isabel Bagnold",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bagnold",
      "birth_date": "baptised 15 Feb 1601",
      "birth_place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "reportedly 10 Jun 1679",
      "death_place": "reportedly Cocknage, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_TRENTHAM_BAPTISM_1601",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_TRENTHAM_DGS_7567143_1558_1640_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "She is not the Isabell married to Thomas Brassington.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_THOMAS_EMERYE_HUSBAND_ISABEL_BAGNOLD",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARIA_BRASSINGTON_WIFE_FRANCIS_MELLOR_1694",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_FRANCISCUS_MELLOR_HUSBAND_MARIA_BRASSINGTON_1694",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "name": "Sarah Gise (Guise/Geiss) Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gise",
      "birth_date": "reported Jun or Jul 1764",
      "birth_place": "reported Frederick County, Maryland or Chester County, Pennsylvania, USA",
      "death_date": "7 May 1848",
      "death_place": "Floyd County, Kentucky, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_CENSUS_1800_1830",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_OT26_GOBLE_GUISE_PARENTS",
        "SRC_OT26_GUICE_W4686"
      ],
      "source_note": "Sarah Geiss or Gise married Christian Gobble in Frederick County, Maryland, in the fall of 1780. Christian's pension file traces the household from Maryland to Washington County, Virginia, where he applied for a Revolutionary War pension in 1832. After his death, Sarah executed her widow's application on 1 February 1842 while living in Floyd County, Kentucky, and records show that she remained there in 1848.",
      "research_note": "Conflicting claims place her 1764 birth in Maryland or Pennsylvania and vary between June and July; the parental household had not been established. These are now retained as provisional candidates; John Guice’s pension supports regional context but does not identify Sarah as his sister. Follow-up 15 September 2026: the Goble Family Association explicitly names Peter Guise and Ottilia as parents. This unusually detailed federal file documents a long westward family movement and Sarah's own legal pursuit of pension rights, but not the date, route, or reasons for each move.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
      "name": "Henry Countiss (Countess)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Countiss",
      "birth_date": "reported 9 Jun 1777",
      "birth_place": "reported Queen Anne's County, Maryland, USA",
      "death_date": "reported before 1830",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENRY_AUNLIE_1810_COUNTISS_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_1783_QA_JAMES_COUNTISS_TAX",
        "ROOTS26_COUNTISS_QUEEN_ANNES_ARCHIVES"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Maryland State Archives tax index records James Countiss in Queen Anne's County in 1783, confirming a local Countiss cluster but no parentage.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the rare-surname, compatible-locality Henry; alternatives are another Henry Countiss/Countess, a spelling-normalization error, or conflation of the Maryland birth claim with the Virginia household. Identity with the 1777 Maryland candidate, his wife and exact vital dates remain unproved. The 1820 Washington County census directly records a Henry Countess household of nine people, but does not identify anyone besides the head. An undated compiled Countiss chart (digitally scanned in 2009) separately places a Henry born in 1777 in a Queen Anne's County family, but it neither cites the claim nor bridges that man to Washington County, Virginia, and it does not name Eda Cauntis. Henry remains Eda's leading, circumstantial father candidate because of the rare surname, shared locality, and compatible 1820 household; a direct parent-identifying record is still needed. The reported 1777 Queen Anne's County birth, Mary Russell spouse, and pre-1830 death are community-tree claims. Henry Countiss/Countess is reported born 9 June 1777 in Queen Annes County and dead before 1830, with an 1820 Washington County, Virginia household and a later source naming Henry Countis as Eda Cauntis’s father. 15 September 2026 correction: Brock p.725 explicitly names Henry Countis of Washington County, formerly eastern Virginia, as Eda's father. This supersedes the earlier claim that no source named a father. The 1783 James Countiss tax entry confirms a local cluster but not parentage; no new edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARY_RUSSELL_COUNTISS",
      "name": "Mary Russell Countiss",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Russell",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Community-tree spouse of Henry Countiss; no independent marriage or vital record was supplied. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Russell County, Virginia, US",
          "confidence": 0.461,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Sarah Phelps",
          "descendant_id": "I81",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_JOHN_M_COUNTISS_CHILD_HENRY",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_RUTH_RHEAD_DAUGHTER_RICHARD_RUTH",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ANTOINE_GINDER_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Antoine Ginder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Ginder",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_ANNE_ELISABETH_GINDER_1740",
        "ROOTS26_GINDER_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_HINSING_RECORD_ROUTE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Geneanet names Antoine Ginder as father of Anne Elisabeth Ginder.",
      "research_note": "The proposed child is reported at Hinsing, while the tree branch under review places Anna Elisabetha Engel at Obergleen; no record establishes that they are the same woman or identifies Antoine’s dates, residence or parents. No direct record currently connects that woman to Anna Elisabetha Engel of Obergleen. Antoine is named only in a Geneanet tree as father of Anne Elisabeth Ginder.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Hinsing",
          "confidence": 0.22,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Anna Elisabetha Engel",
          "descendant_id": "C_ENGEL_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARGUERITE_JANSEM_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Marguerite Jansem",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Jansem",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_ANNE_ELISABETH_GINDER_1740",
        "ROOTS26_JANSEM_LOCAL_DISTRIBUTION",
        "ROOTS26_HINSING_RECORD_ROUTE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Geneanet names Marguerite Jansem as mother of Anne Elisabeth Ginder.",
      "research_note": "The spelling is distinctive but the reported Hinsing setting and the Obergleen descendant identity remain unproved; no birth, marriage or death record was inspected. No direct record currently connects that woman to Anna Elisabetha Engel of Obergleen. Marguerite is named only in the same Geneanet tree as mother of Anne Elisabeth Ginder.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Hinsing",
          "confidence": 0.22,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Anna Elisabetha Engel",
          "descendant_id": "C_ENGEL_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ISABEL_HENDERSON_SC_1790",
      "name": "Isabel Henderson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": "about 1790",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "name": "John Draper Hargis I",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hargis",
      "birth_date": "reported 1661",
      "birth_place": "reported Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "between 19 Jun and 25 Nov 1730",
      "death_place": "Westmoreland County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661_1730",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Profiles and a memorial supply the Draper name and 1661 Maryland birth.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: reviewed again; the 1730 will establishes this adult and his son John, while reported birth details remain compiled. The 1730 will securely establishes John Hargis and children John, Mary, and Milerett. Death occurred after the 19 Jun will and before 25 Nov probate; the probate date is not an exact death date. Current confidence is retained.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_MARY_DAUGHTER_JOHN_I_1730",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_MILERETT_DAUGHTER_JOHN_I_1730",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "William \"Asa\" Hargis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hargis",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1640",
      "birth_place": "reported St Mary Magdalen Parish, London, England",
      "death_date": "between 19 Nov 1685 and about 19 Mar 1685/86",
      "death_place": "Maryland, British Colonial America (reported Charles County)",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARYLAND_PROBATE_WM_HARGIS_WILL_BOOKS",
        "SRC_PROFILE_WILLIAM_ASA_HARGIS_1640_1685",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Anne Hargis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hargis",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "Her birth family remains unresolved. Baldwin’s published abstract calls her executrix; an explicit appointment is not visible in the short recorded text inspected 20 September 2026.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.68,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Draper Hargis I",
          "descendant_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1640,
          "confidence": 0.547,
          "basis": "estimated from spouse's birth year",
          "place": "reported Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "place_confidence": 0.68,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "John Draper Hargis I"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1685,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Mary Catherine \"Ann\" Fountain",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fountain",
      "birth_date": "reported 1665 or 1670-1679",
      "birth_place": "reported Virginia, British Colonial America (specific county anachronistic)",
      "death_date": "reported Apr 1714",
      "death_place": "reported King William County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SELECT_BIRTHS_MARY_JOHN_HIRGES_CHILD_JOHN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_MARY_ANN_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS_1714",
        "SRC_AGBI_MARY_ANNE_FOUNTAIN_1670S",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary is named as spouse of John Hirges and mother of John in a birth/christening index; Geneanet and Find a Grave identify her as Mary Catherine/Ann Fountain, wife of John Draper Hargis.",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: the indexed Mary/John Hirges child entry and compatible compiled profiles support the family, but conflicting birth details and lack of an original image prevent promotion above the current level. The April 1714 death and King William/Accomack locations remain reported memorial/profile facts. Birth evidence conflicts between 1665 and the 1670s.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "James Boswell",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Boswell",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1655",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported Sep 1718",
      "death_place": "reported Elizabeth City County, Virginia",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.52,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_ELIZABETH_CITY_COUNTY_GUIDE",
        "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_STUBBS",
        "ROOTS26_ELIZABETHCITY_EARLY_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A published history identifies Grace, wife of John Selden, as a daughter of William Boswell and Ellinor Brough.",
      "research_note": "James Boswell is named as Grace Boswell’s father in a compiled pedigree. She may be a different woman or the source of a confused pedigree; her existence alone does not disprove the proposed Hargis family. His reported death in September 1718 has not been matched to an inspected probate entry, and his own parents remain unidentified. The reported dates permit him to be Grace’s father, but the pedigree supplies no family or property detail tying them together. Elizabeth City’s surviving 1715–1721 records cover James’s reported death and remain a useful source for distinguishing these households.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SMITH_ANN_MOTHER_GRACE_BOSWELL_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Ann Smith",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Smith",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_STUBBS",
        "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_SMITH_PATENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Ann Smith is named as Grace Boswell’s mother in the compiled Hargis pedigree, but no inspected record establishes her dates, residence, parents or marriage to James Boswell. Her proposed motherhood remains possible, but the current evidence does not distinguish her from another mother or a mistaken pedigree attribution. The identifiable Boswell–Selden family has a mother named Ellinor, not Ann; this does not decide which Grace the Hargis pedigree intended. Searches of colonial Smith references have produced an earlier Ann Smith in transportation rights, but no household connection that identifies her as this woman.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America (reported Westmoreland or New Kent County)",
          "confidence": 0.38,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Grace Elizabeth Boswell",
          "descendant_id": "C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "name": "Elizabeth Luthrel (indexed as Lublinel)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Luthrel",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EARLY_VA_MARRIAGES_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_JOHN_HARGES_1725",
        "ROOTS26_LUTHREL_STPAUL"
      ],
      "source_note": "King’s published Saint Paul’s Parish register, page 62, reads Elizabeth Luthrel, married to John Harges on 1 October 1725. The exact groom and date identify the earlier Lublinel index entry as the same event with a different surname reading. A birth entry for Mildred, daughter of John and Elizabeth Harges, follows on 4 August 1726.",
      "research_note": "Elizabeth’s parents and birthplace are unknown; Virginia was previously inferred from the marriage and is not established as her birthplace. Her candidate spouse link to the tree’s John Hargis remains distinct from the well-supported existence of the parish bride.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1725,
          "confidence": 0.88,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_JAMMER_JANE_MOTHER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Jane Jammer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Jammer",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Jane Jammer remains the named maternal candidate for Mary Catherine Fountain in Matthew’s supplied Geneanet transcript. The reviewed christening index names Mary, John Hirges and their child John, without a date or place, and does not identify Mary’s mother. Family, property or probate evidence identifying Jane and the Fountain household could distinguish these explanations. Her existing candidate score is retained; lack of a direct parent-naming record is not treated as disproof. The reported Virginia setting derives from the Fountain pedigree. The explicit relationship claim is positive evidence, but Jane’s dates, spouse, residence and parents are unspecified. A correctly preserved maternal name competes with a transcription error or mistaken pedigree attachment; no documented competing mother has been identified. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Virginia, British Colonial America (specific county anachronistic)",
          "confidence": 0.32,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Mary Catherine \"Ann\" Fountain",
          "descendant_id": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_ROGER_SON_WILLIAM_1685",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_SON_WILLIAM_1685",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Elizabeth Ann Draper",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Draper",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "William’s recorded will names wife Ann Hargis and son John Draper, not Elizabeth Ann Draper.",
      "research_note": "Her separate maternal hypothesis and score are retained while those identities are compared. Elizabeth Ann Draper remains a compiled-tree maternal candidate for John Hargis. She could be Ann with an expanded name, a different mother, or a pedigree reconstruction influenced by John’s Draper name. The proposed Maryland setting is derivative; no residence or birth family has been established. A combination of family, property and probate evidence could resolve the alternatives without requiring one particular type of parent-naming record. The same name appears among the witnesses, but the two references are not yet identified as one person.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.35,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Draper Hargis I",
          "descendant_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGAS_ANN_CHILD_WILLIAM_ANNE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "name": "Susannah Lea",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lea",
      "birth_date": "baptised 22 Jan 1614",
      "birth_place": "Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England",
      "death_date": "reported 1650",
      "death_place": "reported Maryland, in the area later called Charles County",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_MARRIAGE_INDEX_GEORGE_HARGIS_SUSANNAH_LEA",
        "SRC_GENEANET_SUSANNAH_LEA_HARGIS_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: Susanna's Ashwell baptism is direct index evidence for her identity and parents; marriage to Geo Hargas and maternity of William remain compiled. Geneanet's 1620 Scotland birth conflicts and is rejected. The marriage to George, son William, and 1650 Maryland death remain compiled; Charles County was formed after 1650, so that death locality is retrospective. The 1614 Ashwell baptism securely establishes Susannah and parents Uriah Lea and Joanna. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_THOMAS_LEA_CHILD_GEORGE_1617",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_CHILD_GEORGE_1617",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGIS_WALTER_CHILD_GEORGE_1617",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "name": "Uriae (Uriah) Lea",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lea",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1588-1590",
      "birth_place": "reported Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England",
      "death_date": "reported 1 Nov 1680",
      "death_place": "reported Cheshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
        "ROOTS26_LEA_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
      ],
      "source_note": "The local father identification is strong.",
      "research_note": "The line stops because the reviewed records do not name Uriae’s parents; archive catalogues identify concrete records for deeper research.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "name": "Joannae (Joan) Lea",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lea",
      "birth_date": "possibly baptised 13 Mar 1590",
      "birth_place": "possibly Stoke St Gregory, Somerset, England",
      "death_date": "reported 1614",
      "death_place": "reported England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_GENEANET_URIAE_LEA_FAMILY",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_PROFILE_JOANNAE_LEA_1590_1614",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Evidence review: her role as Susanna's mother is direct. A Joan Lea baptized 13 Mar 1590 at Stoke St Gregory to Robert Lea is a plausible but unproven identity match because of the Somerset-to-Hertfordshire distance and absence of Uriah in that record. The 1590 Somerset baptism and reported 1614 death are not proven to belong to the same Joannae in Ashwell. Death in 1614 is profile-derived. Joannae is directly named as Susanna's mother in two baptism indexes. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "name": "Robert Lea",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lea",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1555",
      "birth_place": "reported Somerset, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
        "ROOTS26_LEA_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "This is a real documented Somerset household and a plausible candidate, but the cross-county identity remains weaker than the local records. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1590,
          "confidence": 0.49,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_LEA_FRANCES_CHILD_URIAH_JOANNA",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "name": "Joan Smith",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Smith",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "possibly Somerset, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
        "ROOTS26_SMITH_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Her maternity and the later Ashwell identity remain unresolved. Joan is a plausible mother for the 1590 child because she married Robert first.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1555,
          "confidence": 0.547,
          "basis": "estimated from spouse's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "name": "Geo Hargas (Virginia immigrant by 1642)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hargas",
      "birth_date": "born before about 1621",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 19 Mar 1659",
      "death_place": "reported Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_GEO_HARGAS_BY_1642",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Benton received 1,250 acres about fifteen miles up the south side of the Rappahannock River, partly for transporting a group that included Hargas.",
      "research_note": "No record yet establishes George's age, occupation, birthplace, wife, or children. A similarly named child baptized in London in 1617 appears to have been buried in infancy and cannot safely be identified as this immigrant. George Hargas is first securely visible in a Virginia land patent dated 13 October 1642. The entry places George within a specific migration cohort alongside the Benton family and other transported people, but it does not say when he actually arrived, whether he paid his own passage, or whether he was related to Benton.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "name": "Edgar Leon Newman",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Newman",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "30 Nov 2001",
      "death_place": "Baltimore, Maryland, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TIMES_PICAYUNE_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_OBITUARY_2001",
        "SRC_RH19_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_MEMORIAL_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "Independent marriage, obituary, and scholarly sources identify him as Edgar Leon Newman, Yale- and Chicago-educated historian and professor, deceased 30 Nov 2001. He is no longer classified as living.",
      "research_note": "The identity supplied by the original family tree was initially privacy-masked while death status was unknown. Matthew then reported death in 2001.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1934,
          "confidence": 0.617,
          "basis": "estimated from known parent birth year(s)",
          "place": "Baltimore, Maryland, United States",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "Edgar Leon Newman"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064217",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "name": "Isidore Newman II",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Newman",
      "birth_date": "29 Aug 1906",
      "birth_place": "New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, USA",
      "death_date": "23 Jan 1981",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_USCSC_ARMY_REGISTER_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FRASER_MIDCONTINENT_BANKER_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1951"
      ],
      "source_note": "Federal and banking sources independently corroborate military procurement and bank directorship.",
      "research_note": "The Louisiana Historical Association biography establishes Isidore Newman II's parents, dates, education, marriage, only child, business career, Army service, civic work, and death.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "name": "Anna Pfeifer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Pfeifer",
      "birth_date": "09 Jan 1907",
      "birth_place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "death_date": "05 Apr 1956",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_HNOC_MAISON_BLANCHE_HISTORY_20260725",
        "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_IMMIGRATION_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Edgar's 1963 marriage notice independently calls her the late Anna Pfeiffer Newman, while a published Louisiana biography reports her death in 1956.",
      "research_note": "Her reported exact birth and death days remain unverified. Anna's adult household belonged to a prominent New Orleans commercial and civic family during the years Isidore worked at Maison Blanche and served in the Army, but those facts describe her family setting and do not establish Anna's own occupation, education, employment at the store, organizational membership, or wartime activity. No reviewed source yet states those parts of her biography. Anna Pfeifer of New Orleans married Isidore Newman II in 1931 and was mother of their only child, Edgar Leon.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "name": "Edgar Leon Newman",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Newman",
      "birth_date": "18 Oct 1873",
      "birth_place": "New Orleans, LA, USA",
      "death_date": "9 Mar 1928",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, LA, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935",
        "SRC_CROCKERY_GLASS_JOURNAL_EDGAR_NEWMAN_MAISON_BLANCHE",
        "SRC_TALKING_MACHINE_WORLD_EDGAR_NEWMAN_1922",
        "SRC_ENTERPRISE_IN_RADIO_EDGAR_NEWMAN"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Fifth Circuit estate decision corrects death to 9 Mar 1928 and identifies wife Elsa. Trade and historical sources document his Maison Blanche management, treasurer role, and early radio work.",
      "research_note": "The exact birth date and middle name Leon remain compiled rather than directly established by these sources; do not conflate him with his historian descendant of the same name.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "name": "Elsa Theresa Schwartz",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schwartz",
      "birth_date": "5 Aug 1884",
      "birth_place": "New Orleans, LA, USA",
      "death_date": "14 Jan 1966",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, LA, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Exact birth and death dates remain compiled. The federal estate decision directly identifies Elsa Schwartz Newman as Edgar's wife, beneficiary, and executor; the Isidore Newman II biography identifies Elsa Schwartz as his mother. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "name": "Isidore Newman",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Newman",
      "birth_date": "28 Feb 1837",
      "birth_place": "Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "death_date": "30 Nov 1909",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_AJC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_DEATH_1909",
        "SRC_COMMERCIAL_FINANCIAL_CHRONICLE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1909",
        "SRC_SOARDS_NEW_ORLEANS_GUIDE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_STOCK_EXCHANGE",
        "SRC_HNOC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_LEGACY",
        "SRC_NEWMAN_SCHOOL_HISTORY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN",
        "SRC_LA_SUPREME_COURT_ADAMS_MACHINE_V_NEWMAN_1902"
      ],
      "source_note": "Isidore Newman funded the construction and equipment of the Isidore Newman Manual Training School, which began in 1903 for children of the Jewish Orphans Home and also welcomed neighborhood children. Contemporary and institutional sources document his finance, property, Maison Blanche, Stock Exchange, and philanthropic work.",
      "research_note": "The regional genealogy's 1902 year is rejected. The reported 30 Nov 1902 death is corrected to 30 Nov 1909, independently stated by the American Jewish Committee and contemporary financial press. The Louisiana biography directly establishes Isidore's parents, immigration, wife Rebecca, children including Edgar, career, and death.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "name": "Rebecca Kieffer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Kieffer",
      "birth_date": "12 Dec 1849",
      "birth_place": "Port Gibson, Mississippi",
      "death_date": "10 Nov 1919",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Louisiana",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_MS_ENCYCLOPEDIA_PORT_GIBSON_JEWISH_CONGREGATION",
        "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_IMMIGRATION_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rebecca Kieffer was born at Port Gibson, Mississippi, in 1849 and married the German immigrant financier Isidore Newman in 1868. Published Louisiana and regional Jewish histories identify their children, including Edgar, and identify Rebecca as the daughter of Louis Kieffer and Maria Roser, whose family came from Lembach in Alsace. Her marriage later placed her in New Orleans as Isidore built a financial and philanthropic career.",
      "research_note": "No reviewed record states Rebecca's own occupation, education, property, civic office, or organizational role, and the reported exact birth and death days remain unverified. Port Gibson's Gemiluth Chessed congregation was organized in 1859, during Rebecca's childhood, placing her in a documented local Jewish community; no source reviewed here proves her membership or religious practice.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "name": "Jakob Neumond",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Neumond",
      "birth_date": "20 Jan 1803",
      "birth_place": "Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "death_date": "1869",
      "death_place": "Mehlingen, Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND",
        "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_KAISERSLAUTERN_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_19C"
      ],
      "source_note": "Jakob Neumond lived in the Kaiserslautern area of the Bavarian Palatinate and was the husband of Clara Cahn or Kohn. Two credible published sources name them as parents of Isidor Neumond. Isidor was educated in Kaiserslautern before emigrating to New Orleans in 1853, making Jakob part of the German Jewish household from which an important Louisiana immigrant departed. Loeb or Löb B.",
      "research_note": "Jakob's exact 1803 birth and reported 1869 death at Mehlingen remain reported rather than independently verified, and no occupation has been found. Neumond and Johanna Maria Barbara Jacob remain supported only by the original family tree parent candidates at low confidence.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "name": "Clara Cahn Neumond",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Cahn Neumond",
      "birth_date": "8 Jun 1803",
      "birth_place": "Mainz, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND",
        "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_KAISERSLAUTERN_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_19C"
      ],
      "source_note": "Clara Cahn or Kohn lived within the Jewish community of the Bavarian Palatinate and was the wife of Jakob Neumond. A scholarly Palatinate migration database and a Louisiana historical biography independently name the couple as parents of Isidor Neumond, born at Kaiserslautern in 1837. Isidor emigrated to New Orleans in 1853, while Clara's own migration or death has not been established.",
      "research_note": "Her reported birth on 8 June 1803 at Mainz remains compiled. The tree proposes Leo Cahn or Kahn and Rosa Lorch as her parents at low confidence, but no reviewed civil, synagogue, burial, or community register connects Clara to them.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1837,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "name": "Loeb Löb B. Neumond",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Neumond",
      "birth_date": "Abt 1770",
      "birth_place": "Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "death_date": "Aft. 1835",
      "death_place": "Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplies this identity, dates, places, and ancestry; none is independently verified.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "name": "Johanna Maria Barbara Jacob",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Jacob",
      "birth_date": "02 Oct 1774",
      "birth_place": "Kyritz",
      "death_date": "1835",
      "death_place": "Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE",
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_JACOB_DAFN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Sembach's 1809-1810 household list names Kussel Neumond, not Loeb, and supplies no wife or child.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported Johanna; alternatives are a Kyritz namesake, a different Jacob household, or a mistaken locality/person. The original family tree reports Johanna's birth at Kyritz in 1774, death at Sembach in 1835, marriage to Loeb Neumond, and motherhood of Jakob. No record yet bridges Johanna's long move from Kyritz to Sembach or directly names Jakob. No record bridges the reported move or identifies Johanna’s parents. Her exact dates and family links therefore remain compiled. Johanna Maria Barbara Jacob’s reported 2 October 1774 Kyritz birth and later Sembach death remain compiled. Kyritz was then a small Prussian garrison and agricultural town recovering from the Seven Years' War, while Sembach had a substantial Jewish community during Johanna's reported adult life. Kyritz locality history supplies context but no Jacob baptism; Sembach’s Jewish-community list names Kussel Neumond, not Johanna or her reported husband Loeb. No parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "name": "Isaak Isaac Newman Neumond",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Newman Neumond",
      "birth_date": "ABT 1750",
      "birth_place": "Kusel, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "death_date": "14 May 1857",
      "death_place": "Mehlingen, Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_DAFN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Sembach's 1809-1810 Jewish household list instead names a Kussel Neumond.",
      "research_note": "No death, burial, marriage, occupation, property, or parent record has been found. H1 is a possible Kussel/Neumond continuity; alternatives are a transcription of a given name, another Neumond household, or an unrelated namesake. The original family tree calls this man Isaak or Isaac Newman Neumond, places his birth about 1750 at Kusel, and reports death at Mehlingen in 1857. Kussel may be a personal name that was later mistaken for the town Kusel, although the list gives too little detail to prove that theory. His connection to Loeb remains chronologically possible but unproved. The imported Isaak/Isaac Newman Neumond remains a conflicting candidate. The Sembach 1809–1810 list names Kussel Neumond, which could be a personal name later misread as the town Kusel, but it does not prove identity. The reported dates imply a lifespan of about 107 years and therefore require unusually strong proof. The reported 1750–1857 lifespan is exceptional and lacks vital, marriage, property or parent records. No parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "name": "Hendle Strauss Neumond",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Strauss Neumond",
      "birth_date": "1740",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": "Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_STRAUSS_DAFN"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No birth, marriage, death, burial, household, occupation, property, or parent record has been located. H1 is a compatible local household; alternatives are another Strauss woman, a given-name or surname transcription error, or an unrelated Sembach family. The original family tree identifies Hendle Strauss as the wife of Isaak or Kussel Neumond and mother of Loeb, gives an approximate 1740 birth, and associates her death with Sembach. Sembach had an established Jewish community and a Strauss presence in its 1809-1810 household list, but that list does not name Hendle, identify a wife of Kussel Neumond, or connect Loeb. Her family links remain low-confidence compiled claims with compatible chronology. The Sembach list shows a Strauss presence but does not name Hendle or connect her to Kussel. Hendle Strauss is reported as wife of Isaak/Kussel Neumond and mother of Loeb, but no birth, marriage, death, household, occupation, property or parent record has been located. No parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "name": "Leon E. Schwartz",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schwartz",
      "birth_date": "18 Aug 1855",
      "birth_place": "Liberty, Amite, Mississippi",
      "death_date": "3 May 1926",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_1926",
        "SRC_MDAH_JACOB_SCHWARTZ_WOODVILLE_LEDGER_FINDING_AID",
        "SRC_ISJL_WOODVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_USGENWEB_AMITE_1850_CENSUS_INDEX",
        "SRC_USGENWEB_AMITE_1860_CENSUS_INDEX",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "ROOTS26_SCHWARTZ_DAFN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Leon E. Schwartz married Adeline Trautman in Orleans Parish on 7 November 1883. The official Louisiana death index records Leon E. Schwartz his uncle, while its Herbert biography says he succeeded the firm when his father died in 1926. A different Leon Schwartz, son of Jacob Schwartz and Judith Moritz, is documented in Woodville, Mississippi and is not merged with this New Orleans Leon.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported New Orleans Leon; alternative is the Woodville namesake or another Mississippi family. Leon's exact birthplace and parents remain unresolved. Leon is anchored by the 1883 Orleans marriage and 1926 Louisiana death, while the imported Liberty birth and exact parents remain unresolved. The Woodville Jacob Schwartz household and its son Leon are a concrete alternative but lack a bridge to Adeline Trautman and New Orleans. Schwartz, age 70, dying in Orleans Parish on 3 May 1926, which is consistent with the reported 1855 birth. The stronger current family explanation is that he was the father of Elsa Schwartz and part of the New Orleans wholesale firm Schwartz Bros.: the Louisiana Historical Association identifies Elsa as mother of Isidore Newman II and calls Herbert J. This is strong circumstantial evidence, not a record that expressly names Leon as Elsa's father or Herbert's father. No parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "name": "Adeline Trautman",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Trautman",
      "birth_date": "26 Dec 1862",
      "birth_place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "death_date": "5 Sep 1945",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her 7 November 1883 marriage to Leon E. Schwartz is independently indexed in Orleans Parish.",
      "research_note": "The parents are attached from the direct birth index; their own origins and parents remain unresolved. The official Louisiana birth index records Adeline Trautman's birth in Orleans Parish on 26 December 1862 and directly names her parents as David Trautman and Julia Moses (archive record 292195, volume 33, page 375). A search of the online Louisiana marriage index did not locate a David Trautman-Julia Moses marriage, so no marriage date or place is asserted.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "name": "Leon Pfeifer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Pfeifer",
      "birth_date": "09 Feb 1873",
      "birth_place": "Brookhaven, Lincoln, Mississippi, USA",
      "death_date": "19 Dec 1949",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_MARION_PFEIFER_ABRAMSON",
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_HATTIESBURG_SAWMILL_LEON_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_BROOKHAVEN_LUMBER_E_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEON_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_BROOKHAVEN_LEADER_LEON_PFEIFER_COLLEGE_1890",
        "SRC_BROOKHAVEN_LEADER_LEON_PFEIFER_BOOKKEEPER_1897"
      ],
      "source_note": "Leon Pfeifer was born at Brookhaven on 9 February 1873 and died at New Orleans on 19 December 1949. The Ingenheim Jewish community database identifies him as an accountant, son of Emanuel Pfeifer and Rahel Dreyfuss, and husband of Bertha. Contemporary Brookhaven newspapers add that he attended an unnamed college in New Orleans in 1890, later worked for several years as a traveling commercial representative, and returned in 1897 to keep the books for Pfeifer & Dreyfus.",
      "research_note": "These reports establish education and early work without guessing a school or degree.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "name": "Bertha Cahn Pfeifer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Pfeifer",
      "birth_date": "Oct 1879",
      "birth_place": "Morgan City, St Mary, Louisiana, USA",
      "death_date": "18 May 1952",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_MARION_PFEIFER_ABRAMSON",
        "SRC_LA_WOMEN_IN_INDUSTRY_BERTHA_PFEIFER_1919"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Louisiana biography identifies Bertha Cahn as Marion's mother, and the 1919 report names Mrs. Leon Pfeifer on the Women in Industry Committee.",
      "research_note": "The unexplained reported phrase Godemsau was not supported and has been removed from the display name.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "name": "Emanuel Pfeifer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Pfeifer",
      "birth_date": "21 Sep 1833",
      "birth_place": "Niederhochstadt, Bavaria, German Confederation",
      "death_date": "1917",
      "death_place": "reported Bergzabern, present-day Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_BROOKHAVEN_LUMBER_E_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_APERTUS_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_REGISTER_SEARCH_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_HOCHSTADT_HANAU_JEWISH_REGISTERS_REJECTED_FOR_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_COCALICO_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_1781_WILL_REJECTED",
        "ROOTS26_PFEIFER_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_ARCHIVE_ROUTE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Emanuel Pfeifer was born at Niederhochstadt on 21 September 1833 and reportedly emigrated about 1853. The Ingenheim Jewish community database states that he entered Confederate service in 1861, married Rahel Dreyfuss at New Orleans on 2 February 1867, obtained a passport in Lincoln County in 1879 naming a wife and four minor children, and lived with the family at Brookhaven in 1900. It expressly names Leon among their four American-born children. Neither item identifies Emanuel or his parents.",
      "research_note": "FamilySearch catalog 344161 was rejected because it covers Jewish registers of Hochstadt in Kreis Hanau, not Niederhochstadt in the Palatinate. The local archive search gives a concrete route for the missing 1833 parent record, while a second Emanuel Pfeiffer born four days later remains a documented namesake. Emanuel's parents therefore remain unknown pending the original civil act or an independently sourced local family reconstruction. Pfeifer is a German occupational surname meaning a fifer or pipe player; this does not establish Emanuel’s occupation. Its directory also contains a distinct Emanuel Pfeiffer born at Niederhochstadt on 24 September 1833 and later associated with Heidelberg; the two men must not be merged. APERTUS exposes Catholic Niederhochstadt holdings but no online 1833 Jewish or general civil birth volume. A separately indexed 1781 will belongs to an earlier Lancaster County, Pennsylvania namesake.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "name": "Rahel (Rachel) Dreyfuss Pfeifer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Dreyfuss Pfeifer",
      "birth_date": "5 Jan 1845",
      "birth_place": "Ingenheim, Bavaria, German Confederation",
      "death_date": "18 May 1918",
      "death_place": "Bad Bergzabern, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_PFEIFER_RAHEL_1845",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Ingenheim Jewish community database identifies Rahel Dreyfuss, born at Ingenheim on 5 January 1845 and died at Bad Bergzabern on 18 May 1918, as daughter of David Dreyfuss and Johanna Frank. It states that she married Emanuel Pfeifer of Niederhochstadt at New Orleans on 2 February 1867 and that they had four children in the United States. Emanuel's profile adds an 1879 Lincoln County passport naming his wife and four minor children and a 1900 Brookhaven household.",
      "research_note": "These mutually linked profiles resolve the former locality and family uncertainty, though original images remain desirable.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064575",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "name": "Henrietta Ruth Juffe",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Juffe",
      "birth_date": "30 Apr 1916",
      "birth_place": "Hartford, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "death_date": "11 Sep 2002",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916",
        "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_HENRIETTA_SEGEL_1916_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "The official Connecticut birth index records Henrietta Juffe at Hartford on 30 April 1916. The official marriage index then records Henrietta Juffe marrying Martin Segel at New Britain on 16 June 1937. A 1963 family notice and Suzanne's acknowledgment independently continue that married identity.",
      "research_note": "The birth index does not display parents, so the Max Juffe-Freda Dubowy parent links rely on the parents' official marriage eleven months earlier, the child's surname and timing, locality continuity, and the imported family tree rather than a directly parent-naming certificate.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "name": "Max Juffe",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Juffe",
      "birth_date": "20 Mar 1886",
      "birth_place": "Austria",
      "death_date": "19 Sep 1979",
      "death_place": "Los Angeles, California, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NY_ADJUTANT_GENERAL_MAX_JUFFE_1917",
        "SRC_CAMP_WADSWORTH_MAX_JUFFE_INSTRUCTOR",
        "SRC_TROWS_DIRECTORY_MAX_JUFFE_ARGONNE_PRESS_1922",
        "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_MAX_JUFFE_1888_1979",
        "SRC_SPARTANBURG_LIBRARY_CAMP_WADSWORTH",
        "SRC_SPARTANBURG_CITY_CAMP_WADSWORTH_HISTORY",
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915",
        "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916",
        "SRC_VA_NATIONWIDE_GRAVESITE_MAX_JUFFE_1979",
        "SRC_NARA_MAX_JUFFE_FOURTH_DRAFT_CARD_1942",
        "SRC_GGG_NY_NATURALIZATION_MAX_JUFFE_JAFFE_SEARCH_20260725",
        "ROOTS26_JUFFE_DIRECTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The New York Adjutant General's official 1917 register identifies this Austrian-born Max Juffe through his distinctive 12th Infantry career and gives his birth as 20 March 1886. It records service from 14 December 1907 and promotion to captain on 3 August 1917; a contemporary Camp Wadsworth paper independently identifies Capt. Max Juffe of the 12th New York Infantry. Connecticut's official index records his marriage to Freda Dubowy at New Britain on 30 May 1915. NARA identifies his 1942 Hartford draft card and Austrian birth, but the public description names neither town nor relative.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the documented Captain Max Juffe; alternatives are a Jaffe/Joffe namesake or a conflicting birth-year identity. His Austrian town, immigration voyage, naturalization, and parents remain unresolved. Max is strongly identified by the 1917 New York military register, 1915 Connecticut marriage, 1942 NARA draft-card catalog and 1979 gravesite record, but his Austrian town, immigration, naturalization and parents remain unresolved. A broad New York and New Jersey naturalization-index search found no exact Max Juffe entry. The VA's official gravesite database confirms his rank, exact death on 19 September 1979, and Los Angeles National Cemetery burial, but repeats the conflicting 20 May 1888 birth date. The contemporary 1886 date remains preferred. A 1913 Southern District of New York declaration for Max Jaffe is a plausible spelling variant, but its index entry has no identifying birth, residence, arrival, or family information; it remains unattached until the original declaration is inspected. Jaffe is a plausible spelling candidate, but the 1913 index entry lacks identifying details. No parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "name": "Freda (Frederika) Dubowy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Dubowy",
      "birth_date": "6 Oct 1894",
      "birth_place": "Other Country",
      "death_date": "10 Oct 1959",
      "death_place": "Los Angeles",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915",
        "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916"
      ],
      "source_note": "Henrietta Juffe was then born at Hartford on 30 April 1916, providing strong chronological and geographic support for the imported parent-child family.",
      "research_note": "The public birth index does not name the parents, however, and Freda's reported 1894 birth, 1959 Los Angeles death, birthplace, and links to Solomon and Yetta Dubowy still require direct records. The official Connecticut marriage index directly records Freda Dubowy marrying Max Juffe at New Britain on 30 May 1915.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "name": "Solomon Zalman Dubowy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Dubowy",
      "birth_date": "25 Jul 1853",
      "birth_place": "Ditkowce, Austria",
      "death_date": "16 Oct 1924",
      "death_place": "Connecticut, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
        "SRC_CONNECTICUT_HARTFORD_SUPERIOR_DUBOWY_1915_1920",
        "SRC_GESHER_GALICIA_1900_TOWN_LOCATOR_DITKOWCE",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1916",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1917",
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_GITL_GOLDFIELD_1914"
      ],
      "source_note": "Contemporary New Britain reports identify this uncommon-named Austrian immigrant in a consistent local family. A 1917 article gives age sixty-seven, demonstrating ordinary age-reporting variation.",
      "research_note": "In 1916 Solomon was reported as age sixty-three, a native of Austria who arrived in America in 1908, and father of adult sons Nathan and Solomon. Yetta's 1914 death notice directly names Solomon as her husband. An official Connecticut index records a Solomon Dubowy marrying Gitl Goldfield at Hartford on 22 October 1914, three months after Yetta's death; this strongly, though not conclusively, identifies the wife mentioned in 1916 as a later wife rather than Yetta. No source yet proves Lazar as his father. That age independently supports birth around 1853 but not the imported exact 25 July date or Ditkowce birthplace.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "name": "Yetta Edith Fuchs",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fuchs",
      "birth_date": "15 May 1856",
      "birth_place": "Galicy, Poland",
      "death_date": "26 Jul 1914",
      "death_place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BETH_ALOM_YETTA_DUBOWY"
      ],
      "source_note": "A contemporary New Britain Daily Herald notice reports that Yetta, wife of Solomon Dubowy of 125 Willow Street, died of cancer on 26 July 1914, aged fifty-six, and was buried at Beth Alom Cemetery. The notice names no parents, children, or European birthplace.",
      "research_note": "Newspaper ages can be imprecise, so the exact birth date remains unresolved rather than discarded. Age fifty-six implies birth between about 27 July 1857 and 26 July 1858, modestly conflicting with the imported exact date of 15 May 1856.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064673",
      "name": "Lazar Dubowy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Dubowy",
      "birth_date": "approx 1830?",
      "birth_place": "Austria (now Poland)",
      "death_date": "1894",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_DUBOWY_DISTRIBUTION"
      ],
      "source_note": "That description may refer to Austrian Galicia, but it spans many towns, languages, modern jurisdictions, and religious registers. The surname searches found rarity and German/Polish/Austrian distribution but no dependable etymology.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported father of Solomon; alternatives are another Dubowy in former Galicia, a transcription or locality error, or an unrelated namesake. His chronology and relationship to Solomon are compatible but unproved, and similarly named Dubowy families should not be merged without a documentary bridge. The locality is too broad to select a parish or civil district, and no independent record names his spouse, household, occupation, migration, death place or parents. Lazar Dubowy appears only in the original family tree as Solomon Zalman Dubowy's father, reportedly born about 1830 in “Austria, now Poland” and dead in 1894. Lazar Dubowy is supported only by the imported profile: about 1830 in “Austria (now Poland)” and death in 1894. Searches have produced no reliable vital, occupation, land, court, military, migration, spouse, or parent record. No parent edge is added. No responsible local narrative can be assigned until a town or identifying household is found.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "name": "Leon Cahn",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Cahn",
      "birth_date": "about 1851-1852",
      "birth_place": "reported Metz, Moselle, France",
      "death_date": "5 Jun 1924",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Louisiana",
      "status": "source_backed_death_plausible_compiled_family",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_1870_ANNEXATION",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_ANNEXATION_EMIGRATION",
        "SRC_ISJL_MORGAN_CITY_JEWISH_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ST_MARY_BANNER_LEON_CAHN_LAND_CHAIN_1909",
        "SRC_LA_SOS_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_CAHN_1924",
        "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1851_CAHEN_INDEX_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1852_CAHN_NEGATIVE_CHECK",
        "SRC_METZ_ARCHIVES_GENEALOGY_PORTAL",
        "ROOTS26_CAHN_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_CAHN_IDENTITY_LIMIT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Louisiana Secretary of State death index independently confirms that Leon Cahn, age 72, died in Orleans Parish on 5 June 1924 (volume 188, page 1593, record 300254). Metz's 1852 birth index contains no Leon Cahn/Cahen/Kahn. Its 1851 table appears to contain a late-year Leon Cahen entry, but the apparent act number points to an unrelated Robinet birth and the acts around the listed date contain no Cahen child. Leon Cahn of Saverne and New York, husband of Flora Lehmann, and the older and younger New Orleans namesakes are not merged here.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the Louisiana man represented by the exact-name death and merchant/land records. This makes an 1851-1852 birth chronologically appropriate but does not prove the imported May 1852 date or Metz birthplace. That entry is retained as a lead rather than treated as this man's birth. Independent evidence places an exact-name Leon Cahn in Morgan City as a dry-goods merchant and party to a 24 March 1879 land conveyance. Alternatives are another Leon Cahn, a Kahn/Cahen spelling conflation, or a wrong Metz origin. No inspected record yet joins the Louisiana man to Anna Coguenhem, daughter Bertha, or parents in France. No parent edge is added. The Cahn/Cahen/Cohn/Kahn forms have a documented Jewish surname history associated with the priestly term, but this cannot identify Leon's family.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "name": "Anna Coguenhem",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Coguenhem",
      "birth_date": "Oct 1860",
      "birth_place": "St Mary Parish, Louisiana",
      "death_date": "20 Mar 1917",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Louisiana",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Targeted civil, census, obituary, and family searches did not find a reliable direct match.",
      "research_note": "The original family tree reported Bertha Cahn's mother and Leon Cahn's spouse. Capitalization was normalized; do not conflate other Coguenhem or Cahn families.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "name": "Louis Francis Kieffer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Kieffer",
      "birth_date": "18 Oct 1811",
      "birth_place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "12 Dec 1886",
      "death_place": "Port Gibson, Claiborne, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_JEWISH_NAME_INDEX_LEMBACH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Louis Kieffer belonged to the Jewish community of Lembach in northern Alsace. Their move formed part of the wider nineteenth-century movement of Alsatian Jewish families into commercial communities in the American South.",
      "research_note": "Louis's exact 1811 birth and 1886 death remain compiled, and no passenger list, occupation, naturalization, land record, or primary vital record has yet been located. Isaac Kieffer and a woman recorded only as Julienne remain low-confidence parents proposed by the original family tree. The official-record index to the 1808 Jewish name declarations confirms that Kieffer was adopted at Lembach, but it does not identify an Isaac or Julienne Kieffer household there. Published regional Jewish research identifies him as Maria Roser's husband and Rebecca Kieffer's father, and places the family migration from Lembach to Port Gibson, Mississippi, during the 1840s. This makes the imported parents no stronger than a research hypothesis until Louis's 1811 civil birth act is read.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "name": "Marie Minette Roser",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Roser",
      "birth_date": "2 Jun 1814",
      "birth_place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "31 Aug 1882",
      "death_place": "Port Gibson, Mississippi",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_JEWISH_NAME_INDEX_LEMBACH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Maria or Marie Minette Roser came from the Jewish community of Lembach in northern Alsace. Rebecca's later marriage into the Newman family links this Alsatian immigrant household to New Orleans.",
      "research_note": "Maria's exact 1814 birth and 1882 death remain compiled; no passenger list or primary vital record has yet been located. The 1808 Jewish name-declaration index does not identify Roser or Roeser as an adopted surname at Lembach, nor a Bernard, Julienne, or Leopold matching the imported household. That negative index result does not exclude later arrival or another earlier name; Maria's 1814 birth act remains necessary. Published regional research identifies her as Louis Kieffer's wife and Rebecca Kieffer's mother and places their family migration to Port Gibson, Mississippi, in the 1840s. Bernard Baruch Roser and Claire Minette Levy or Leopold remain low-confidence GEDCOM parent candidates.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "name": "Isaac Kieffer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Kieffer",
      "birth_date": "ABT 1766",
      "birth_place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "death_date": "26 JAN 1856",
      "death_place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplies this identity, dates, places, and ancestry; none is independently verified.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "name": "Julienne",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Julienne",
      "birth_date": "abt 1770",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "28 JUN 1824",
      "death_place": "Lembach  (Bas-Rhin) France",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "ROOTS26_JULIENNE_NAME_LIMIT"
      ],
      "source_note": "It is unclear whether Julienne is a given name, surname, or incomplete transcription. Lembach had an established rural Jewish community, with twelve families recorded in 1784 and 105 Jewish residents in 1807, making the setting compatible with the later documented Kieffer origin. Neither the community history nor the published Kieffer migration account names her.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported wife/mother identity; alternatives are another Julienne, a spelling/transcription error, or a different Isaac Kieffer household. The original family tree identifies this woman only as Julienne, reports death at Lembach on 28 June 1824, and makes her Isaac Kieffer's wife and Louis Kieffer's mother. The profile still supplies no established surname: Julienne may be a given name, surname, or incomplete transcription. The reported Lembach death is a useful locality lead, but the community history does not name her. Her reported death should be tested in Lembach civil and Jewish records before her name, marriage, maternity, or parents are promoted. No parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "name": "Bernard Baruch Roser",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Roser",
      "birth_date": "1785",
      "birth_place": "Lembach, Bas-rhin, France",
      "death_date": "17 Oct 1867",
      "death_place": "Evansville, Vanderburgh, IN",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplies this identity, dates, places, and ancestry; none is independently verified.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "name": "Claire Minette Levy Leopold",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Levy Leopold",
      "birth_date": "1790",
      "birth_place": "Lembach, Bas-rhin, France",
      "death_date": "June 23, 1847",
      "death_place": "Wissembourg, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplies this identity, dates, places, and ancestry; none is independently verified.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "name": "Seligmann Levy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Levy",
      "birth_date": "Abt 1773",
      "birth_place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "14 Aug 1853",
      "death_place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplies this identity, dates, places, and ancestry; none is independently verified. An independent Geneanet tree repeats this Levy-Macholé reconstruction, but may depend on the same upstream material; confidence remains unchanged pending an original record. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "name": "Rosalie Kallmann",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Kallmann",
      "birth_date": "Abt. 1770",
      "birth_place": "Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "Abt. 1860",
      "death_place": "Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
        "ROOTS26_KALLMANN_ALSACE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Neither the municipal history nor the reviewed search results name Rosalie. Ottrott-le-Bas Jewish records identified by the departmental archive are the best next collection.",
      "research_note": "No exact town, birth, marriage, household, death, burial, occupation, property, or parent record has been found. H1 is the imported Rosalie; alternatives are another Kallmann woman, a spelling variant, or a later family conflation. The original family tree places Rosalie broadly in Alsace from about 1770 to about 1860 and identifies her as Seligmann Levy's wife and Claire Minette Levy's mother. Ottrott-le-Bas Jewish records and the Bas-Rhin 1808 name-adoption material are the best next targets. Seligmann's reported home at Ottrott had a small Jewish community and synagogue, so the setting is plausible. Rosalie Kallmann is reported about 1770–1860 in Alsace and as Seligmann Levy’s wife, but no exact town, birth, marriage, household, death, burial, occupation, property or parent record has been located. No parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "name": "Michel Leyser Leiser Moyses Kieffer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Kieffer",
      "birth_date": "Abt. 1736",
      "birth_place": "Gunstett, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "6 Aug 1809",
      "death_place": "Gunstett, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "compiled_identity_with_name_locality_conflict",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_GUNSTETT_NAME_INDEX_NEGATIVE_KIEFFER",
        "ROOTS26_KIEFFER_GUNSTETT_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1808 Bas-Rhin index lists Kieffer at Lembach and Strasbourg but not Gunstett, and no Gunstett entry for Moïse/Moyses, Moser or Michel.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported identity; alternatives are another Gunstett surname, a wrong locality, spelling/transcription conflation, or a different Michel. The original family tree combines the names Michel, Leyser or Leiser, Moyses, and Kieffer, reports a life at Gunstett from about 1736 to 6 August 1809, and makes him Isaac Kieffer's father. If the reported August 1809 Gunstett death is right, the man may have used another surname there; alternatively, the combined name or locality may be a later conflation. Michel Leyser/Leiser Moyses Kieffer is reported born about 1736 and dead 6 August 1809 at Gunstett, as Isaac Kieffer’s father. The 1808 Bas-Rhin name-declaration index supplies a meaningful competing explanation: Kieffer appears at Lembach and Strasbourg, not Gunstett, while Moïse/Moyses, Moser, and Michel likewise have no Gunstett entry. Because a surname-declaration index is not a complete census, this weakens but does not disprove the imported person. Because the index is not a complete census, it weakens but does not disprove the profile; no new edge is added. The profile and its parent-child edge remain visible at reduced confidence until a civil death act, declaration, Jewish register, burial, or household record resolves the identity.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "name": "Michel Coguenhem",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Coguenhem",
      "birth_date": "1827",
      "birth_place": "Metz, Departement de la Moselle, Lorraine, France",
      "death_date": "1 November 1874",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRENCH_CITIZENSHIP_OPTANT_MICHEL_COGUENHEM_1872",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_ALSACE_OPTANTS_CONTEXT",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_1870_ANNEXATION",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_ANNEXATION_EMIGRATION",
        "SRC_METZ_TD_1823_1832_BIRTH_MARRIAGE_INDEX_20260729",
        "ROOTS26_COGUENHEM_RARITY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The imported tree reports Michel Coguenhem born in Metz in 1827, with Pauline Loeb and daughter Anna. Metz's official 1823–1832 ten-year birth index covers all five civil sections and has no Coguenhem entry. Compared with a missing-but-correct Metz registration, a wrong or over-specific imported birthplace, a surname transcription/variant, or a birth in a different municipality is more likely.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported Michel; alternatives are a wrong birthplace, spelling variant, or another household. The 1872 French nationality-option index remains an exact-name candidate only: it lacks age, family, occupation, and address. The 1872 nationality-option record is an exact-name candidate without age, family, occupation or address. This result lowers confidence in the precise birth claim but does not itself disprove the reported spouse or daughter relationship. Michel Coguenhem is reported born at Metz in 1827 and dead 1 November 1874, but the official Metz 1823–1832 birth tables contain no Coguenhem entry. No parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "name": "Pauline Loeb",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Loeb",
      "birth_date": "abt 1839",
      "birth_place": "Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LOEB_BAVARIA_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Bavaria is too broad and the Loeb surname too common to select a town, historical state archive, or Jewish community.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported Pauline; alternatives are another Loeb woman, a spelling variant such as Löb/Loew/Löw, or a non-Bavarian birthplace. A local history cannot responsibly be supplied until a record identifies her town or household. Pauline Loeb is reported born about 1839 somewhere in Bavaria. JewishGen provides indexed 19th-century Bavarian-Swabian civil records, but no exact Pauline household record was located in this review. Pauline Loeb is known only from the original family tree, which reports birth about 1839 somewhere in Bavaria and connects her to Michel Coguenhem and their daughter Anna. The spouse and maternal links remain visible because their chronology is plausible and no contradiction has emerged, but neither is independently proved. No marriage, child, household, migration, occupation, death, or parent record identifies her. No parent edge is added. Loeb/Löb is a widespread Ashkenazi Jewish form and can also occur as a personal-name-derived surname, so the name alone cannot select a household.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1860,
          "confidence": 0.49,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "name": "Samuel Rosser",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rosser",
      "birth_date": "abt 1765",
      "birth_place": "Lembach, Bas-rhin, France",
      "death_date": "BEF 1836",
      "death_place": "Alsace, France",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_EVANSVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_1849_PRESENT",
        "ROOTS26ROSSER_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_LEMBACH_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree places Samuel Rosser or Roser at Lembach about 1765, reports death somewhere in Alsace before 1836, and makes him the father of Bernard Baruch Roser. Lembach had an established Jewish community during this period, but its reviewed history does not name Samuel. A Samuel Roser appears much later among probable 1857 members of Evansville's Jewish congregation, where Bernard died in 1867; that man cannot safely be the reportedly deceased father and is retained only as a possible family or community associate. The surname has distinct Welsh and German explanations, and Roser/Rösser spelling must be kept separate until a record shows equivalence. No birth, marriage, household, death, occupation, property, or parent record proves Samuel's identity or relationship. Lembach’s surviving register catalog gives a concrete test route, but no entry-level Samuel identification was located.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "name": "Eve Elle Klotz",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Klotz",
      "birth_date": "1761",
      "birth_place": "Wissembourg, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "12 Apr 1817",
      "death_place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplies this identity, dates, places, and ancestry; none is independently verified.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "name": "Jacques Jeckel Jacob Levy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Levy",
      "birth_date": "1750",
      "birth_place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "23 Feb 1806",
      "death_place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "source_backed_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY",
        "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730",
        "SRC_GENAMI_MARMOUTIER_LEVY_FAMILIES_2004_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Rosenwiller cemetery-memory transcription calls the decedent Jeckel, son of Macholé (Michaël), and identifies Mausche as the son who declared the death. The same published Geneanet entry cites an 8 November 1784 Ottrott enumeration for Jacob Levy and Bösel Macholen. These citations strongly support the adult Jacques/Jeckel household, his father's name, wife, son, and 1806 death/burial. Distinct Marmoutier Macholé Levy families are documented separately and are not merged with the Ottrott household.",
      "research_note": "The older imported Mosche and Judith parent pair remains a visible low-confidence alternative, but is now less likely than Michel because it conflicts with the published paternal designation as well as the age chronology. Jacques Jeckel Jacob Levy is reported born in 1750 and died at Ottrott on 23 February 1806. They do not yet verify the reported 1750 birth or give Michel's own origins.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "name": "Bösel Macholé Levy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Levy",
      "birth_date": "1755",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "Bef. 1809",
      "death_place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplies this identity, dates, places, and ancestry; none is independently verified. An independent Geneanet tree repeats this Levy-Macholé reconstruction, but may depend on the same upstream material; confidence remains unchanged pending an original record. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "name": "Baruch (Bosig) Klotz",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Klotz",
      "birth_date": "1720",
      "birth_place": "Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "1801",
      "death_place": "Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original family tree supplies this identity, dates, places, and ancestry; none is independently verified.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "name": "Rösel Seligman",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Seligman",
      "birth_date": "1732",
      "birth_place": "Romanswiller, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "AFT 30 NOV 1784",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROMANSWILLER_RECORDS_RESEARCH_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_SEligMAN_ROMANSWILLER_ARCHIVES"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her birth date may derive from an interpretation of the 1784 Alsatian Jewish census, but the underlying entry is absent.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported Rösel; alternatives are another Rösel Seligman, a spelling/given-name variant, or a conflated household. A compiled pedigree reports Rösel Seligman, born at Romanswiller in 1732 and living after 30 November 1784, as Baruch Klotz's wife and Eve Klotz's mother. Rösel Seligman is reported born in Romanswiller in 1732 and living after 30 November 1784, as Baruch Klotz’s wife and Eve Klotz’s mother. The spouse and parent-child links therefore remain low-confidence claims awaiting a record from Romanswiller, Wissembourg, Lembach, or another securely associated community. The spouse and maternity links remain low-confidence and no new edge is added. No produced census entry, marriage, household, death, burial, occupation, property, or parent record names her. Romanswiller had a documented Jewish community by the relevant period, but no produced birth, marriage, household, death, burial, occupation, property, or parent record names Rösel.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "name": "Hayim Haim Klotz",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Klotz",
      "birth_date": "1690",
      "birth_place": "Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "1762",
      "death_place": "Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_GENAMI_ALSACE_1784_CENSUS_DATABASE",
        "ROOTS26_KLOTZ_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_WISSEMBOURG_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No census, marriage contract, household, death, burial, occupation, property, court, military, or parent record has been found for him. The original family tree reports Hayim or Haim Klotz living at Wissembourg from about 1690 to 1762 and makes him the father of Baruch or Bosig Klotz. The surname and locality are historically coherent, but the imported dates and father-son link remain unverified; Wissembourg’s 1596–1793 register catalog is the specific next record route. Regional archival research confirms that Klotz was one of the relatively rare hereditary surnames already used around Wissembourg before 1808, which makes the family setting coherent but does not identify Hayim. The exact dates and father-son link remain low-confidence compiled claims. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "name": "Mosché Levy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Levy",
      "birth_date": "ABT 1690",
      "birth_place": "Wintzenheim, Haut-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "abt 1760",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
        "ROOTS26_LEVY_WINTZENHEIM_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "It repeats Jacques's spouse and later child group.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported Mosché; alternatives include another Levy household, a different Mosché/Jacques parent, or conflation with the separate Michel Machole Levy reconstruction. A compiled pedigree reports Mosché Levy, born about 1690 at Wintzenheim and dead about 1760, as Judith Levy's husband and Jacques Levy's father. In this period Levy could describe levitical descent rather than a unique hereditary surname, and individuals were often recorded by given name and patronymic. Comparative reassessment: another compiled Levy reconstruction gives Jacques a different father, Michel Machole Levy, about 1725, and an unidentified mother. Mosche's reported age of about sixty at the 1750 birth makes this imported parent link a less likely alternative. It remains visible at low confidence because neither account is supported by an inspected original Ottrott record. In the Alsatian Jewish context, Levy could denote levitical descent or a personal-name/patronymic usage rather than a unique hereditary surname. Mosché Levy is reported born about 1690 at Wintzenheim and dead about 1760, as Judith Levy’s husband and Jacques Levy’s father. His occupation, property, court activity, military activity, burial, and parents remain unknown. The presently known Wintzenheim namesakes are later or unrelated, with no record connecting this Mosché to Ottrott, Judith, or Jacques. Wintzenheim context is plausible, but no inspected original record identifies him; no new parent edge is added. A name match alone cannot identify him.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "name": "Judith Levy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Levy",
      "birth_date": "ABT 1695",
      "birth_place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "death_date": "Abt. 1760",
      "death_place": "Otrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_OTTROTT_ISRAELITE_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "It repeats Jacques's spouse and later child group.",
      "research_note": "No birth, marriage, death, burial, occupation, property, court, military, or parent record has been found. H1 is the imported Judith; alternatives are another Judith Levy, a patronymic or spelling variant, or conflation with the separate Michel Machole Levy reconstruction. The original family tree reports Judith Levy at Ottrott from about 1695 to about 1760 and identifies her as Mosché Levy's wife and Jacques Levy's mother. Levy was not necessarily a unique hereditary surname in this period, so surname agreement between spouses and child does not prove a household. Comparative reassessment: another compiled Levy reconstruction gives Jacques a different father, Michel Machole Levy, about 1725, and an unidentified mother. Judith's reported age of about fifty-five at the 1750 birth makes this imported parent link a less likely alternative. It remains visible at low confidence because neither account is supported by an inspected original Ottrott record. Judith Levy is reported born about 1695 and dead about 1760 at Ottrott, as Mosché Levy’s wife and Jacques Levy’s mother. Ottrott had a small Jewish community, and surviving Israelite registers begin in 1785–1786, later than the reported life. Ottrott had a small Jewish community, but no reviewed community or archive source names Judith. The links remain visible at low confidence without merging namesakes. No reviewed record names her; no new edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "name": "Machole Levy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Levy",
      "birth_date": "Abt 1725",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No household, marriage, death, burial, occupation, property, court, military, or parent record has been located. H1 is the imported Machole; alternatives are a patronymic reading of Bösel Macholé, another Levy household, or conflation with the separate Michel Machole candidate. The original family tree gives Machole Levy only an approximate 1725 birth and identifies him as the father of Bösel Macholé Levy. Levy could denote religious descent rather than a unique family surname, and neither person has a secure birthplace. The daughter's compound name may preserve a patronymic meaning daughter of Machole, but no underlying record has been cited or reviewed, so it is not treated as direct evidence. No new edge is added. The original tree reports Machole Levy born about 1725 as Bösel Macholé Levy’s father, but supplies no birthplace or original record.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
          "confidence": 0.48,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Bösel Macholé Levy",
          "descendant_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "name": "David \"Red David\" Dreyfuss",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Dreyfuss",
      "birth_date": "23 Nov 1806",
      "birth_place": "Ingenheim, Sudliche Weinstrasse, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "death_date": "16 May 1880",
      "death_place": "Bergzabern, Sudliche Weinstrasse, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_DAVID_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "David Dreyfuss, called Red David, was born at Ingenheim on 23 November 1806, worked as a baker, married Johanna Frank there on 24 February 1835, and died at Bad Bergzabern on 16 May 1880. The Ingenheim community database expressly names Rahel among their children. Its parental identification agrees with the independently reviewed 1808 Jewish name-adoption household.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "name": "Leah Johanna Frank",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Frank",
      "birth_date": "3 July 1805",
      "birth_place": "Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "death_date": "1 March 1879",
      "death_place": "Bad Bergzabern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Rheinland Pfalz, Allemagne",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JOHANNA_FRANK_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Johanna Frank, also called Lea, was born at Oberlustadt on 3 July 1805, married David Dreyfuss on 24 February 1835, and died at Bad Bergzabern on 1 March 1879. She was buried in the Ingenheim Jewish cemetery at grave 3 03 06, and the community database expressly names Rahel as her daughter.",
      "research_note": "Its page calls Johanna's father Theodor Frank, while the 1808 name-adoption transcript calls him Salomon Frank; this may reflect a personal and civil-name equivalence, but the discrepancy remains documented rather than silently merged.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "name": "Salomon Frank",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Frank",
      "birth_date": "1771",
      "birth_place": "Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "death_date": "14 Jun 1836",
      "death_place": "Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
        "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810"
      ],
      "source_note": "Salomon appears in Oberlustadt's 1808 Jewish name-adoption list under the earlier patronymic Daotteres b Samolon. A separately published 1809/10 community listing identifies Salomon Frank as a butcher, independently supporting his adult identity and presence at Oberlustadt.",
      "research_note": "His reported 1771 birth and 1836 death at Oberlustadt remain GEDCOM details; no earlier parents have yet been established. The list identifies Rosalia Mayer as his wife and explicitly names Johanna Frank and three sons as his minor children.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "name": "Rosalia (Meier) Mayer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Mayer",
      "birth_date": "1777",
      "birth_place": "Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "death_date": "6/29/1837",
      "death_place": "Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record was created while Oberlustadt was under French administration, when fixed civil surnames were being formally recorded for Jewish residents. That explains why both the earlier patronymic and new name appear together.",
      "research_note": "Her reported 1777 birth and 1837 death remain compiled. Oberlustadt's 1808 Jewish name-adoption list records Roesel b Abraham taking the name Rosalia Mayer and explicitly identifies her as Salomon Frank's wife. The list uses the b [father] form for both sons and daughters, so it directly supports a father named Abraham; no surname or identifying detail permits a merge with another Abraham. Four minor children follow, including Johanna, although their entries name only Salomon as parent; Rosalia is therefore a strongly supported rather than explicitly stated mother.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "name": "Salomon Frank",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Frank",
      "birth_date": "Abt. 1729",
      "birth_place": "Oberlustadt, Rheinpfalz, Bavaria, Germany",
      "death_date": "1807",
      "death_place": "Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1808 Oberlustadt name-adoption list records the younger Salomon Frank under the earlier name Daotteres b Samolon.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported elder Salomon; alternatives are another Salomon in Oberlustadt, a patronymic misread, or conflation of generations. It does not provide the father's surname, age, wife, occupation, property, death, or parents, and the reported 1729 birth and 1807 death remain unverified. The patronymic directly indicates that his father was named Samolon or Salomon and makes the reported elder Salomon a credible candidate in the correct community. Salomon Frank is reported born about 1729 and dead in 1807 at Oberlustadt. The 1809/10 local household listing is later than the reported death and cannot identify him retrospectively; no new parent edge is added. The 1808 name-adoption list records a younger Salomon Frank under the patronymic Daotteres b Samolon, directly supporting a father named Salomon/Samolon but not the elder man’s surname, age, wife, occupation, death, or parents. The elder profile is therefore strengthened but not uniquely proved.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "name": "Regina Moses",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Moses",
      "birth_date": "1726",
      "birth_place": "Lustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "death_date": "15 Nov 1820",
      "death_place": "Oberlustadt, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No birth, marriage, household, occupation, property, or parent evidence has been found, so neither spouse nor maternity confidence is raised. The original family tree identifies Regina Moses as the elder Salomon Frank's wife and the younger Salomon's mother, with a reported life at Oberlustadt from 1726 to 1820. The 1808 name-adoption list directly identifies the younger man and his father's given name but does not name his mother or an elderly Regina in that household. Her reported lifespan is possible but unusually long and needs a death or burial record. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "name": "Leo Cahn Kahn",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Cahn Kahn",
      "birth_date": "1780",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": "Donaldsonville, Ascension Parish, Louisiana, USA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_CAHN_DAFN"
      ],
      "source_note": "The town later attracted German and Alsatian Jewish merchants and organized the Bikur Cholim society. Its 1860 charter includes an L. Donaldsonville’s 1860 Hebrew Bikur Cholim charter includes L. Cahn and M.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the imported father; alternatives are another Cahn/Kahn merchant, a spelling conflation, or a later family reconstruction. The original family tree reports Leo or Loeb Cahn or Kahn, born about 1780, as Rosa Lorch's husband and Clara Cahn's father, with an undated death at Donaldsonville. Cahn, but initials alone cannot identify the signer as this Leo, who would have been about eighty under the reported chronology. The charter therefore illustrates the reported destination community without proving Leo's presence or membership. Leo or Loeb Cahn/Kahn is reported about 1780 with an undated Donaldsonville death, wife Rosa Lorch and daughter Clara, but no passenger, census, naturalization, occupation, cemetery, probate, marriage or parent record connects him to Clara. No parent edge is added. No passenger, census, naturalization, occupation, cemetery, probate, marriage, or parent record connects him to Clara. Cahn, but initials cannot identify an eighty-year-old Leo.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "name": "Rosa Lorch",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lorch",
      "birth_date": "UNKNOWN",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "BEF 1823",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_LORCH_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_LORSCH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY",
        "ROOTS26_LORCH_RESEARCH_LIMIT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ancestry describes Lorch as a German habitational surname from places called Lorch, but that origin is non-exclusive and no Lorch locality is recorded for Rosa. The next identity-specific bridge is Clara's Mainz birth, marriage, or household record.",
      "research_note": "H1 remains the imported wife/mother identity. Without a locality, a local historical narrative would be invented; Clara's Mainz birth or marriage record is the best prospective bridge. Rosa Lorch is known only from the user-supplied Ancestry GEDCOM export dated 24 July 2026, which reports death before 1823 and connects her to Leo Cahn or Kahn and daughter Clara. Alternatives are another Rosa Lorch, a married-name or transcription error, or a later reconstruction of Clara's parentage. Alemannia-Judaica documents a later Lorch family in the Lorsch Jewish community, including Simon Lorch in a 1928 synagogue account; this is a separate name-bearing example, not evidence that Rosa came from Lorsch. Donaldsonville's later Cahn community cannot be projected backward onto Rosa, and she may have died before any family migration to Louisiana. No birth, marriage, household, burial, probate, occupation, or parent record identifies her. It supplies no birthplace, residence, or death place.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Mainz, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.58,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Clara Cahn Neumond",
          "descendant_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "name": "Elizabeth (probably Lamb) Davies",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lamb",
      "birth_date": "possibly about 1785",
      "birth_place": "possibly Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
        "SRC_FREEREG_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1823",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_DAVIES_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1803",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BAPTISM_SWEEP_1750_1790",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_MARRIAGE_SWEEP_1795_1820",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BURIAL_SWEEP_1785_1803",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth is repeatedly named with Robert Davies in Trustewelin baptisms from 1814 to 1823. A Berriew marriage of Robert Davies and Elizabeth Lamb in 1803 probably identifies that couple.",
      "research_note": "This makes the Kerry child a plausible candidate, but no record directly moves her to Berriew or names her parents at marriage. Her 1785 date, Kerry birthplace, and parents are therefore explicitly provisional. The only indexed Montgomeryshire baptism for an Elizabeth Lamb in 1750-1790 occurred at Kerry on 19 June 1785, daughter of John and Elizabeth; the same parish recorded John Lamb marrying Elizabeth Prichard five months earlier. The county index shows no other Elizabeth Lamb marriage in 1795-1820 and no burial before 1803.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1823,
          "confidence": 0.99,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Trustewelin, Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "name": "John Brassington of Ranton",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "12 Apr 1739",
      "birth_place": "Chelmorton, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": "14 May 1810",
      "death_place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_BOSLEY_1739_20261005",
        "SRC_DARG_DERBYSHIRE_REGISTER_COVERAGE_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_WIRKSWORTH_20261005",
        "SRC_DRO_CHELMORTON_REGISTER_TRANSCRIPT_D3536_1575_1840_20261005",
        "SRC_DARG_CHELMORTON_REGISTER_TRANSCRIPT_SEARCH_1575_1840_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Marriage names John and Jane; child sequence and will share a distinctive group of children. These observations strongly favor H1 over an otherwise unattested duplicate couple. The will abstract establishes yeoman status, wife Jane, death 14 May 1810 and probate 3 July 1810. Original wills and 1761 licence are the next discriminating records. A separate Ancestry compilation reports a John Brassington born in Bosley, Cheshire, in 1739, son of John and Rebecca Allen.",
      "research_note": "H1: the elder Ranton father is the 1761 Stafford groom and 1810 Ronton testator. H1 (the Chelmorton 1739 baptism) remains stronger for the Ranton father because it is an exact dated baptism in the regional search area; H2 (the Bosley John) is a documented same-name alternative but has a different birthplace and no evidence of migration to Ranton. His birth and parents remain unresolved; Ranton residence was previously misrepresented as birthplace. Possible identification: John Brassington baptized at Chelmorton on 12 April 1739 is the only currently documented candidate for this parent. A compiled circa-1731 birth is not adopted without its basis. Chelmorton 1739 is a possible birth candidate, but its identification with the Mary Swindell husband must not be transferred to the Jane household without evidence.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1736,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "John Brassington of Ranton"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "name": "Jane Silvester (Brassington)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Silvester",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_JANE_SILVESTER_MARRIAGE_1761",
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "First child in October 1761 and the later household fit; a separate will abstract names John Brassington as James Silvester’s son-in-law.",
      "research_note": "H1: the Ranton mother Jane was Jane Silvester who married John Brassington on 10 January 1761 at Stafford St Mary. H2: another John/Jane couple or different reading of bride parish RORTON. The will makes James the probable father (.88), but does not name Jane herself; an earlier wife, a different John, or historical son-in-law usage remain alternatives. The combined evidence strongly favors H1; Silvester is adopted as the probable maiden surname at .95 identity confidence. Jane was living when named in her husband’s 1805 will; her being nominated executrix does not independently prove survival to probate in 1810. Birthplace and birth date remain unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Brassington",
          "descendant_id": "I196",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1736,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.995,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "John Brassington"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1805,
          "confidence": 0.92,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ABRAHAM_GOBBLE_10_FEB_1775",
      "name": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel/Gobble",
      "birth_date": "10 Feb 1775",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Exact date and maternity remain derivative. Correction: restored as a plausible child of Johann Friedrich Jr., not of the elder Johann and his two wives. Correction: restored as a plausible child of Johann Friedrich Jr., not of the elder Johann and his two wives.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_ISAAC_GABEL_GOBBLE_9_JUN_1778",
      "name": "Isaac Gabel/Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel/Gobble",
      "birth_date": "9 Jun 1778",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Exact date and maternity remain derivative. Correction: restored as a plausible child of Johann Friedrich Jr., not of the elder Johann and his two wives. Correction: restored as a plausible child of Johann Friedrich Jr., not of the elder Johann and his two wives.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JACOB_GABEL_GOBBLE_16_MAY_1771",
      "name": "Jacob Gabel/Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel/Gobble",
      "birth_date": "16 May 1771",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Exact date and maternity remain derivative. Correction: restored as a plausible child of Johann Friedrich Jr., not of the elder Johann and his two wives. Correction: restored as a plausible child of Johann Friedrich Jr., not of the elder Johann and his two wives.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_JOHN_HENRY_GABLE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_MARIA_GABEL_GOBBLE_21_MAR_1761",
      "name": "Maria Gabel/Gobble",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gabel/Gobble",
      "birth_date": "21 Mar 1761",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.52,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Exact date and maternity remain derivative. Correction: restored as a plausible child of Johann Friedrich Jr., not of the elder Johann and his two wives. Correction: restored as a plausible child of Johann Friedrich Jr., not of the elder Johann and his two wives.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "name": "Elizabetha Lintner (Linder) Newland",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lintner (Linder)",
      "birth_date": "1 Apr 1720",
      "birth_place": "reported Germany",
      "death_date": "after 15 May 1780",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Casper Stoever's published register records Elizabetha Lintner of Earltown marrying Johann Ulandt on 23 Apr 1739. Berkeley County deed abstracts repeatedly name John Newland's wife Elizabeth through 15 May 1780. Simon and Margretha are connected at 0.96 and 0.95.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "name": "Robert Bartee (died 1711)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bartee",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "death_date": "by 19 May 1711",
      "death_place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert Bartee was a Norfolk County landholder by 1704, when the colonial quit-rent roll assessed a man of his name. His will of 19 May 1711 names his wife Mary and sons Adrigan, Robert, and Samuel. Henry Werrick's independently abstracted will identifies Mary Barttee as Henry's daughter and Robert as her son, tying the two landholding households together. Later testimony concerning widow Mary Hebdon further supports the blended Bartee-Hebdon family.",
      "research_note": "No known record names the elder Robert Bartee's parents or birthplace, so his origin remains an open immigration frontier.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1676,
          "confidence": 0.706,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER",
      "name": "Johann Berlin (Beerlin), Magister",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Berlin",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1550",
      "birth_place": "Goppingen, Wurttemberg",
      "death_date": "2 Mar 1618",
      "death_place": "Uhingen, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_TUEBINGEN_MATRIKEL_JOHANN_BERLIN_1569"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Weigel pedigree identifies Johann Berlin or Beerlin, born about 1550 at Goppingen, matriculated at Tubingen in 1569, Magister in 1574, deacon at Weinsberg in 1575, later pastor at Reichenbach an der Fils, Boll, Grabenstetten, and Uhingen, where he died 2 Mar 1618. The independent Tubingen matriculation entry of 19 Aug 1569 calls him \"Johannes Berlin Goppingensis.\" Its accompanying career note records his 1570 bachelor's degree at Hirsau, 1572 stipend, 1574 Magister degree, and 1575 Weinsberg deaconate.",
      "research_note": "His parentage from Hans Beerlin and Agatha Bleyle is retained separately at moderate-low confidence because the pedigree explicitly says the filiation is not secured. This supports Johann's own Goppingen identity and career directly, but names no parent. It therefore does not convert the separately marked Hans Beerlin/Agatha Bleyle proposal into a proven relationship.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "name": "Anna",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "possibly Weinsberg, Wurttemberg",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WEINSBERG_CITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Their six-child household belonged to a town that had been conquered by Württemberg in 1504, destroyed after the Peasants' War in 1525, and restored to town status in 1553. By Anna's documented motherhood, Weinsberg was rebuilding its civic and religious life under Württemberg.",
      "research_note": "This is community context, not evidence of Anna's politics, property, or personal experience. Margreth Berlin's 27 November 1576 Weinsberg baptism identifies her mother only as Anna and her father as Magister Johann Berlin, a deacon. Her maiden name, birth, death, occupation, and parents remain unknown, so the maternal line stops with the forename recorded at baptism.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1548,
          "confidence": 0.691,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1576,
          "confidence": 0.691,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "name": "Richard Butt the Elder",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Butt",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1645",
      "birth_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "death_date": "reported 1727",
      "death_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MCINTOSH_LOWER_NORFOLK_WILLS_1637_1710_SCAN",
        "SRC_LNCVA_VOL3_NORFOLK_MARRIAGE_BONDS_1711_1715",
        "SRC_STEWART_HISTORY_NORFOLK_RICHARD_BUTT_MEETINGHOUSE_1714",
        "SRC_PAGE_LIFE_JOSIAS_MACKIE_WILL_1716"
      ],
      "source_note": "A separate bond records Richard Butt and Dina Butt on 13 June 1715. Later accounts assigning Dinah and nine children to the elder appear to conflate generations. A court-record quotation says that a newly erected meetinghouse stood on his land in January 1714. Josias Mackie's 1716 will separately names Thomas, Elizabeth, and Henry as children of Mr Richard Butt and gives an item to Mr Richard Butt senior.",
      "research_note": "The 1675 will of Robert Butt names a son Richard, and later family history identifies that son as Richard Butt the Elder. The zero-source FamilySearch claim that Richard and Sarach Sayer parented Robert about 1678 is therefore retained only as a sharply downgraded possibility. Directly inspected county-record abstracts distinguish Richard Butt senior from Richard Butt junior: the junior helped prove John Godfrey's will on 15 May 1710, while a 1711 marriage bond names Richard Butt senior. Because a younger Richard was already explicitly present, the 1715 groom is more plausibly that younger man than the elder reportedly born about 1645. Additional Norfolk evidence places Richard Butt senior in the Southern Branch dissenting community. These records establish Richard's household and continued presence but do not name Robert born about 1678 as his son. However, the same history identifies Richard's wives as Dinah Butt and Frances and lists nine children without Robert.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "name": "Sarach (possibly Sarah) Sayer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Sayer",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1653",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 1724",
      "death_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTY_FORMATION",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTIES_1691_1700"
      ],
      "source_note": "Earlier Sayer/Sawyer land records in the Elizabeth River district provide the local context discussed in Family roots; none names her as a relative.",
      "research_note": "The earlier tree review recorded Sarach, possibly Sarah, Sayer as Richard Butt’s wife and Robert Butt’s mother in an unsourced collaborative profile. The anonymous Butt reconstruction names Dinah and Frances instead and gives a different child list, but that compilation is not conclusive contrary evidence. Neither account provides a record securely identifying Sarach or her birth family. Her existing disputed links remain visible.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "name": "Robert Butt of the Southern Branch",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Butt",
      "birth_date": "reported circa 1614",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "between 1 Nov 1675 and 3 Jul 1676",
      "death_place": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_RCP_SIR_WILLIAM_BUTTS",
        "SRC_BUTT_LEGEND_PROVENANCE_AUDIT_20260725",
        "SRC_VIRKUS_BUTT_PEDIGREE_1925",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ROBERT_BUTT_441",
        "SRC_CW_SARAH_BRUCE_BUTT_SAMPLER_1811",
        "SRC_BUTT_SAMPLER_REVERSE_REPORT_2000",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS",
        "SRC_GENI_ROBERT_BUTT_COMPILED_NOTES_2026",
        "SRC_PILI_9448_VIRKUS_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_BUTT_MCLURE_FAMILY_NARRATIVE_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_OC_VOL94_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_CLAIM",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_1625_20260725",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_WILLIAM_RICHARD_BUTT_BIRTH_1638_20260725",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_ROBERT_BUTT_SON_BIRTH_BRISTOL_1640_20260725",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_HENRY_BUTT_BRISTOL_1642_TIMELINE_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_LZNR_WG5",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_SARAH_JANE_SHIPP_LOWER_NORFOLK_C1642_20260725",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_THOMAS_BUTT_BRISTOL_1645_20260725",
        "SRC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_ROBERT_BUTT_BAPTISM_1616",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_PROTESTATION_1641",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS",
        "SRC_BRISTOL_ARCHIVES_SERVANTS_FOREIGN_PLANTATIONS_GUIDE",
        "SRC_VIRTUAL_JAMESTOWN_BRISTOL_BUTT_SEARCH_1654_1686",
        "SRC_JOANE_PENN_RODBOURNE_WILL_1619",
        "SRC_GREER_EARLY_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_JAMES_BUTT_1650",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CLAPHAM_RAPPAHANNOCK_PATENT_1650",
        "SRC_LVA_RESEARCH_NOTE_20_HEADRIGHTS",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_HEADRIGHT_SERVITUDE",
        "SRC_PEPYS_DIARY_WILLIAM_BUTTS_BRISTOL_1668",
        "SRC_BRISTOL_HEARTH_TAX_WILLIAM_BUTTS_ST_STEPHEN",
        "SRC_DNB_SIR_WILLIAM_BUTTS_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_WARRINGTON_PLACE_KENT",
        "SRC_CHESAPEAKE_WARRINGTON_HALL_PUD_1996",
        "SRC_BRISTOL_KYP_WARRINGTON_ROAD_MAP_SEQUENCE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nugent abstracts his 380-acre patent of 3 March 1656 and his consolidated 1,200-acre tract of 28 April 1665. Robert's 1675 will names wife Jane and sons Henry, Robert, Thomas, and Richard. The former displayed estimate of about 1605 lacked cited support. The will proves that a son Robert existed, but not this birthplace or year; published web trees vary between about 1640, 1649, and 1652. Robert's will proves Thomas as a son, and a published Virginia biography identifies him as a later Lower Norfolk burgess, but neither supplies his birth year or birthplace. Continued Dorset use of the name still prevents identification. Bristol was a major departure and indenture-registration port for Virginia. A 1619 Rodbourne, Malmesbury, will proves a local Nathaniel and Mary Butt family with sons Thomas and George. A different Nathaniell Butt of Malmesbury was indentured for Virginia in 1659. Greer also indexes a James Butt as a 1650 Virginia headright under William Clapham, whose patent lay on the Rappahannock, well north of Robert's later Southern Branch land. Virginia's headright rules caution against reading acreage as inherited English wealth. A separate William Butts was a prosperous Bristol merchant in Robert's lifetime. Bristol hearth-tax returns list a five-hearth William Butts household in St Stephen's parish, and Samuel Pepys personally described Deborah Willet's uncle Mr Butts in June 1668 as a respected wealthy merchant with a substantial house. Pepys never styles him Sir. The Tudor physician Sir William Butts and his knighted son belonged to the documented Norfolk family, not Bristol. A place-name check found one materially relevant English property: Warrington Place Farmhouse at Paddock Wood, Kent, thought to date from 1604 and containing a beam dated 1651. Those names show that developers reused will language and the circulating family pedigree. A comparative test of the Bristol Warrington name makes it a weak explanation for the seventeenth-century family claim. Bristol City Council historic maps show the present Brislington site as open fields through the 1930s; Warrington Road and its houses appear by 1949. None presently establishes a Butt residence called Warrington Hall.",
      "research_note": "No marriage to Jane, migration record, associate, occupation, or Virginia bridge has been found. Robert's will names Richard, not William or William Richard; the combined-name claim remains unresolved and is not added as another child. Collaborative trees also report a daughter Sarah Jane Butt, later Shipp, born circa 1642 in Lower Norfolk; the will names no daughters and her maiden name and parentage remain unproved. A previously reported unqualified 1657 burial could not be substantiated and must not be used against the candidate. No record presently identifies the terms under which he migrated. Searches found no comparable Warrington-named residence in Gloucestershire or Dorset. A separate compiled tradition reports birth in 1625 at Bristol, but no Bristol baptism or migration bridge has been identified; it is retained as a low-confidence alternative rather than replacing the circa-1614 display estimate. A compiled timeline additionally reports a William Richard Butt born circa 1638. A compiled timeline reports the birth of his son Robert at Bristol in 1640. The same compiled timeline reports son Henry born at Bristol circa 1642 and displays Robert's immigration within 1640-1656. The will proves Henry as a son but not his birth details; the Bristol event remains a migration clue only. A compiled timeline reports son Thomas born at Bristol in 1645. No identifying Bristol baptism has been located, so the Bristol event remains a low-confidence migration clue. A genuine near-date English candidate has now been identified: Robert, son of Robert Butt and Susan Gantrell, baptized 17 September 1616 at Winterborne Houghton, Dorset. A Robert Butt appears there in the 1641 Protestation Return, but the signer could be the child or his older father. The Dorset man remains a low-confidence origin hypothesis and is not attached as the immigrant or given parents in the ordinary tree. Its registers explicitly distinguish place of origin from port of departure, providing a plausible mechanism by which a later family historian could turn “sailed or registered at Bristol” into “born at Bristol.” A full Butt surname search of the surviving 1654-1686 register finds only Nathaniell Butt of Malmesbury, Wiltshire, bound for Virginia in 1659, and no Robert. This is a possible fragment behind the Robert-and-James tradition, not evidence that the men were brothers. Winterborne Houghton is regionally accessible to Bristol, so the 1616 Dorset candidate could have used Bristol as a departure port without having been born there. Headright certificates could be bought or assigned, and a patent might be issued years after the named immigrants arrived. This shows that a Warrington-named Kent residence existed during Robert's lifetime and could be the distant source of the later phrase “Warrington Hall, Kent.” It does not identify Robert's birthplace or family: Paddock Wood is not Deptford, no early owner has yet been established, and no Butt association has been found. An older field-name origin remains possible but is not currently evidenced. His birth is commonly reported circa 1614 (some descendant accounts give a range around 1615-1620), but no baptism, age statement, or English identity record has been located. If the reported circa-1640 arrival were correct, he had roughly sixteen years before the first surviving 1656 patent and nearly two further decades before his 1675 will in which to accumulate property. Virginia evidence securely places Robert Butt on the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River. The claimed 1640 arrival is indexed under source code 9448, which leads back to Virkus rather than a passenger list. FamilySearch additionally reports birth in 1590 in England, but its visible English citations do not establish that date or bridge an English Robert to Virginia. Because the register begins in 1654, this does not exclude an earlier voyage by Robert; it does mean that no surviving Bristol indenture entry presently supports his claimed birthplace or passage. Robert's patents show that he had become an established and capable landholder, but they do not prove that he personally financed every passage, arrived wealthy, or was never an indentured servant. The Bristol merchant may help explain how later tradition fused a genuine Bristol Butt, a genuine Sir William, and Robert's supposed Bristol origin. The 1996 Chesapeake development is directly associated with the Butt site: its official plan centers Warrington Commons on the historic Henry Butt House and uses names including Walnut Neck, Long Beeches, Old Fields and Riddlehurst. Compared with that hypothesis, corruption of the documented Kent name Warrington Place, borrowing from the ancient Lancashire town of Warrington, or an unsupported embellishment in the later pedigree are all at least as plausible. Claims that he traveled through Barbados with brother James, came from Warrington or Warrenton Hall, or was son of Joshua or Josiah remain unsupported by an English, Barbados, or migration record. No will, apprenticeship, or kinship record yet connects merchant William to Robert. The larger tract was not a single reward proving gentry status: it originated with Tristram Nasworthy, was assigned to Butt, Richard Whitby, and John Bright, and became Butt's after he purchased Whitby's and Bright's shares. The repeated rare forename and shared locality make a multigenerational Malmesbury family plausible, but neither record connects that family to Robert. They cannot independently corroborate the pedigree or an English Warrington Hall.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "name": "Jane Butt",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "after 1 Nov 1675",
      "death_place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BUTT_LEGEND_PROVENANCE_AUDIT_20260725",
        "SRC_VIRKUS_BUTT_PEDIGREE_1925",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ROBERT_BUTT_441",
        "SRC_CW_SARAH_BRUCE_BUTT_SAMPLER_1811",
        "SRC_BUTT_SAMPLER_REVERSE_REPORT_2000",
        "SRC_BRUCE_CUMMING_FAMILY_RECORDS_1870_EARLSHALL",
        "SRC_USER_COMPILED_ELIZABETH_BUTT_BIOGRAPHY_20260725",
        "ROOTS26_BUTT_MCINTOSH1675",
        "ROOTS26_JANE_WIKITREE_WILL"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert Butt’s will names Jane as his wife and executrix. Sarah Bruce Butt’s 1811 sampler documents a later family use of Bruce.",
      "research_note": "Her birth surname and parents remain unresolved. A reported reverse pedigree associates Jane with Earlshall, but its wording, date and author remain unverified. A wrong birth date or remarriage is possible, but neither identifies Jane. The reported two-son list is not used as contrary evidence without knowing whether it was exhaustive. The Earlshall table calls Alexander Bruce’s daughter Elizabeth, Lady Durie, and places his death around 1599–1600, incompatible with the copied 1605 birth if both dates are retained. Jane’s alleged death on 3 July 1676 is her husband’s probate date, not a verified death record for her.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1614,
          "confidence": 0.547,
          "basis": "estimated from spouse's birth year",
          "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "Jane Butt"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "name": "Hans Beerlin",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Beerlin",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1527",
      "birth_place": "reported Stuttgart, Wurttemberg",
      "death_date": "1 Sep 1588",
      "death_place": "Uberkingen, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_JOHANN_PLENINGEN_HANS_BEERLIN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_GEN15_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN15_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN15_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GRUIBINGEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_LEO_BW_BAD_UEBERKINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WUERTTEMBERG_DIENERBUCH_JOHANN_BERLIN_20260727"
      ],
      "source_note": "A parish-based pedigree identifies Hans Beerlin as born about 1527 at Stuttgart, married to Agatha Bleyle at Gruibingen in 1555, and dead at Überkingen on 1 September 1588. Gruibingen was then developing a school, parsonage, tithe barn, and administrative house while lying near a confessional boundary. Überkingen, governed by Ulm, had a mineral spring and a spa reputation extending beyond the region; its surviving bath hotel dates from the year Hans died. These details describe the communities around his recorded events, not his occupation, education, wealth, religion, or use of the spa. The older Stuttgart physician Johann Pleningen, also called Hans Beerlin or Berlin, is a distinct man. The Wurttemberg Dienerbuch independently records the older Stuttgart physician as Dr. Johann Berlin, called von Plieningen or Dr.",
      "research_note": "The pedigree explicitly marks his proposed paternity of Magister Johann Berlin as unsecured, so that edge remains 0.52. Plieninger, in service-directory entries for 1544-1568; it supports the namesake distinction, not a family connection.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "name": "Agatha Bleyle",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bleyle",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1535",
      "birth_place": "reported Hohenstadt, Wurttemberg",
      "death_date": "14 Mar 1591",
      "death_place": "Uberkingen, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN15_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN15_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_NLF_AGATHA_BLEYLE_SCHEIBLE_1587_LEAD",
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Weigel pedigree identifies Agatha Bleyle, born about 1535 at Hohenstadt and died 14 Mar 1591 at Uberkingen, as Hans Beerlin's wife.",
      "research_note": "FamilySearch catalog 72854 was rejected because it is Hohenstadt in Oberamt Aalen, not the Göppingen/Wiesensteig locality. Exact-name and derivative-tree searches found no specific parent candidates. It proposes the couple as Johann Berlin's parents but explicitly marks the filiation unsecured. No parents for Agatha are supplied. Origin review: the parish-based pedigree names Agatha Bleyle and gives her reported Hohenstadt origin and Uberkingen death but supplies no parents. This branch stops here. Further evidence review: exact inspection of the Weigel pedigree found Sebastian Bleyle as uncertain ancestor 20,618. Because Agatha is 10,309, this is exactly her father slot in the stated Ahnentafel numbering. The author marks the entry with a question mark and provides no underlying record, so Sebastian has been connected at 0.50 confidence. Locality limitation: the relevant Wiesensteig-area Catholic registers begin only in 1648/1649 and earlier books are reported burned, so they cannot directly prove a 1535 birth or Sebastian's parentage. Correction 15 September 2026: the PDF body actually numbers Sebastian 21618 (printed p.331), while the index p.390 gives 20618. The index supports a typographical body error and intended father relationship; the earlier assertion of consistently exact numbering was inaccurate. Historical parentage remains .50, with no penalty merely for absent surviving early registers.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "name": "John Felps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Felps",
      "birth_date": "about 1748-1750",
      "birth_place": "reported Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "reportedly 1811",
      "death_place": "Rowan County, North Carolina, USA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Felps married Mary Williams in Rowan County, North Carolina, on 12 February 1766, with Samuel Williams serving as bondsman.",
      "research_note": "John's reported birth, 1811 death, and Rowan County origin are provisional, and no occupation, landholding, religion, military activity, or court role has been established. This marriage-bond community is John's earliest secure setting. Published Phelps surname and Y-DNA research identifies Samuel Felps as their son, but also explains that earlier genealogies combined more than one man named John. His profile intentionally stops at the marriage-bond husband rather than selecting the longest higher pedigree. The project cannot yet determine whether Mary's husband was a son of Aquilla Felps, Aquilla's brother, or another related man.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "name": "Mary May Williams",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Williams",
      "birth_date": "about 1750",
      "birth_place": "reported Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "reportedly 1834",
      "death_place": "North Carolina, USA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "ROOTS26_WILLIAMS_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_ROWAN_TAX_LISTS",
        "ROOTS26_ROWAN_RECORD_FRONTIER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary Williams married John Felps in Rowan County on 12 February 1766. Williams is a very common patronymic surname in England, Wales and North America.",
      "research_note": "No occupation, property, religion, or independent later record has been established. Samuel Williams acted as bondsman, making him her earliest named community associate and a possible relative, but the bond does not say whether he was her father, brother, uncle, or an unrelated guarantor. Mary's middle name May, approximate 1750 birth, reported 1834 death, and proposed parents remain derivative. The marriage bond remains the direct local anchor; the bondsman’s kinship is unresolved. Published Phelps research associates Mary and John with son Samuel Felps while warning that the husband's identity was conflated in older genealogies. Her ancestry stops until Samuel Williams and the surrounding Rowan land, probate, tax, or church cluster can be identified. The 1759 Rowan tax transcription shows the surname locally, but no inspected entry identifies Mary or Samuel.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "name": "Georg Batzer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Batzer",
      "birth_date": "29 Nov 1610",
      "birth_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "9 Nov 1661",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR"
      ],
      "source_note": "Georg lived through the Thirty Years' War. The municipality reports that Erpfingen was heavily devastated and that hunger and plague killed inhabitants before a slow recovery.",
      "research_note": "His parents are not identified in the parish reconstruction, so the line stops with him. A church-book-based reconstruction identifies Georg, also called Jörg, Batzer with exact birth and death dates at Erpfingen, Ursula Hinckh as his wife, and ten children. Their marriage is placed about 1633 at Willmandingen, but it predates the surviving marriage register and is therefore reconstructed rather than read from an extant marriage entry. This establishes the conditions surrounding his family, but no record yet shows Georg's occupation, property, military service, displacement, or individual wartime experience.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "name": "Ursula Hinckh",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hinckh",
      "birth_date": "about 1612",
      "birth_place": "reported Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "30 Jan 1693",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her family life at Erpfingen and Reutlingen unfolded amid the Thirty Years' War; Erpfingen's municipal history records devastation, hunger, plague, population loss, and slow recovery.",
      "research_note": "A possible occurrence of the surname near Neuffen does not identify her parents or birthplace, so no higher family has been attached. Ursula is securely identified within Georg Batzer's parish-recorded family. Her surname appears as Hinckherlin in daughter Barbara's 1648 Reutlingen baptism, while her birth about 1612 is calculated from age evidence rather than an identified baptism. Those were community conditions, not proof that Ursula personally migrated or suffered a particular event.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "name": "Hanss Georg Kieffer",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Kieffer",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1630",
      "birth_place": "reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "reported 1691",
      "death_place": "reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG",
        "ROOTS26_KIEFFER_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A local family book covers the same 1672-forward period.",
      "research_note": "Multiple sibling baptisms make the household coherent, but Anna Catharina's own entry has not been inspected and a conflicting uncited pedigree assigns her to Hanss Wendel Kieffer at Münzesheim. The Blankenloch reconstruction places Hanss Georg with a large household, but his own baptism and parents have not been inspected. The surviving local Lutheran register begins in 1672, after his reported birth about 1630; a conflicting pedigree names another Kieffer household. A record-linked collaborative reconstruction places Hanss Georg Kieffer and Margretha Helena Widman at Blankenloch with eight children. The surviving Blankenloch Lutheran mixed register begins in 1672, decades after Hanss Georg's reported birth about 1630; that record boundary helps explain why his baptism and parents have not been established. His occupation, property, origin, and parents remain unknown, and same-name Kieffers from other parishes have not been merged.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "name": "Margretha Helena Widman",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Widman",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1633",
      "birth_place": "reported Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "reported 1709",
      "death_place": "reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG",
        "ROOTS26_WIDMAN_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1672-forward local family book is the best published route for her later household. Margretha is placed in the same reconstructed Blankenloch household, but her baptism, birthplace and parents are unproved.",
      "research_note": "The household is geographically coherent, but Anna Catharina's direct baptism has not been inspected and a conflicting pedigree names another mother. No original record yet establishes her birthplace, occupation, property, or parentage. The surviving local register begins in 1672, long after her reported birth about 1633, and a conflicting pedigree assigns the child to another mother. A record-linked collaborative reconstruction places Margretha Helena Widman with Hanss Georg Kieffer and eight children at Blankenloch. Blankenloch's surviving Lutheran mixed register begins in 1672, long after Margretha's reported birth about 1633, so it cannot by itself reveal her baptism or parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "name": "Barbara Radler",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Radler",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "reported Nenzenheim area, Bavaria, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "reported before 1665",
      "death_place": "reported Nenzenheim area, Bavaria, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "One derivative pedigree names Barbara Radler as Hans or Johann Mollfinger's wife and the mother of Barbara Mollfinger. The daughter's 1665 Nenzenheim marriage directly names her deceased father Hans but does not name her mother, leaving this maternity at low confidence. Nenzenheim belonged to the Iphofen area, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local traces, but Barbara's own residence, religion, and wartime experience are not independently proved. No baptism, marriage, burial, probate, or property record identifies her or her parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "name": "Sebastian Bleyle",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bleyle",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1504",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported about 1568",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_GEN16_BLEYLE_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN16_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN16_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_USER_MYHERITAGE_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_1504_1568",
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "Correction 15 September 2026: the PDF body actually numbers Sebastian 21618 (printed p.331), while the index p.390 gives 20618. The index supports a typographical body error and intended father relationship; the earlier assertion of consistently exact numbering was inaccurate.",
      "research_note": "Sebastian Bleyle appears as uncertain ancestor 20,618 in Herbert Weigel's published Ahnentafel. A user-supplied MyHeritage extract independently displayed online repeats Sebastian's 1504-1568 dates and calls Agatha Beurlin (born Bleyle) his daughter, but it supplies no owner, locality, or underlying citation and may derive from the same compiled tradition. Repetition therefore does not raise the relationship above candidate status. Historical parentage remains .50, with no penalty merely for absent surviving early registers. Agatha Bleyle is numbered 10,309, placing Sebastian exactly in her father slot, but the source marks the filiation with a question and supplies no wife, locality, original record, occupation, property, or parents. Surviving Wiesensteig-area Catholic registers begin only in 1648-1649 after older books reportedly burned; a Hohenstadt catalog from Oberamt Aalen concerns another locality.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Hohenstadt, Wurttemberg",
          "confidence": 0.5,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Agatha Bleyle",
          "descendant_id": "C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "name": "Richard Lister",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lister",
      "birth_date": "about 1804",
      "birth_place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_COMPILED_PROFILE_1804_1879",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_SHREWSBURY_FLAXMILL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1851 census transcript identifies Richard as Jane Lister's father. Avril J. Wood's March 1992 family chart independently places him at Pontefract and later in the Atcham and Shrewsbury area, and reports that he worked as a cordwainer and at times as a toll-house keeper.",
      "research_note": "The chart's 1807 birth year conflicts slightly with the approximately 1804 chronology already supported by census evidence, so the existing approximate year is retained.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1879,
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Atcham and Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "name": "Kezia Price Lister",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Price Lister",
      "birth_date": "about 1816",
      "birth_place": "Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805"
      ],
      "source_note": "Wood's independently prepared March 1992 Lister chart both identify Kezia Price as Richard Lister's wife and include Jane among their children. The chart reports that Kezia died on 4 October 1874, aged 58, at Spring Gardens, Shrewsbury, and was buried in Shrewsbury Cemetery plot 1961.",
      "research_note": "A compiled Gamble tree and Avril J. The contemporary 1851 household transcript instead identifies Jane's mother as Eliza, so Kezia remains the weaker competing maternal hypothesis pending inspection of the original census image, a baptism, or a marriage record.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "name": "Thomas Lister",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lister",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_BATLEY_BAPTISM_1773",
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_HANNAH_FAMILY_RECONSTRUCTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas Lister married Ann Marshall at South Kirkby in 1799 and is repeatedly named with her as parent of children baptised in the Pontefract St Giles and St Mary registers, including Richard.",
      "research_note": "The 1799 record has no age, residence, occupation, father, or witness, so it cannot prove the identification; another Thomas Lister remains a realistic competing explanation. A Batley Thomas, born 9 December 1772 and baptised 10 February 1773 to Hannah Lister, is now the leading childhood and mother hypothesis: an independent Batley parish reconstruction records him as witness at sister Sarah's 1795 marriage, and the move to South Kirkby by 1799 is chronologically and geographically coherent. Hannah and her reported parents are retained as conditional candidates, with the Thomas-to-Hannah edge at 0.54 rather than as established ancestry. The adult family is secure.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1776,
          "confidence": 0.59,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1804,
          "confidence": 0.59,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "name": "Ann Marshall Lister",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Marshall Lister",
      "birth_date": "about 1773",
      "birth_place": "reported Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_with_candidate_parents",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT",
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "A derivative baptism index identifies an Ann Marshall as daughter of John Marshall, and John Marshall had married Ann Allen at Pontefract in 1772. That is a plausible local and chronological fit, so John is attached at 0.68 and Ann Allen at 0.58 under the policy of retaining useful compiled hypotheses. Ann Marshall is secure as Thomas Lister's wife in 1799 and as mother of their Pontefract children, including Richard. Neither edge is primary-record proof: the full child baptism and an adult identity bridge remain missing. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1804,
          "confidence": 0.59,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "name": "Leo Dreyfuss (formerly Löb Isaak)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Dreyfuss",
      "birth_date": "10 Feb 1764",
      "birth_place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "30 Sep 1833",
      "death_place": "Ingenheim, Kingdom of Bavaria",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Leo, formerly Löb Isaak, was a baker born at Ingenheim on 10 February 1764. He married Rosina Haas there on 22 April 1793, and the 1808 name-adoption list records their household and eight children. The local historical database names his parents as Isaak Hirsch Dreyfuss and Maria Anna née Abraham and reports his death at Ingenheim on 30 September 1833.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "name": "Rosina Haas Dreyfuss (formerly Rösel Moyses)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Haas",
      "birth_date": "27 Jun 1770",
      "birth_place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "5 Apr 1853",
      "death_place": "Ingenheim, Kingdom of Bavaria",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rosina Haas, formerly Rösel Moyses, was born at Ingenheim on 27 June 1770. She married baker Leo Dreyfuss there on 22 April 1793 and died there on 5 April 1853. The local historical database names her parents as David Moses and Esther née Nathan and places her burial in the Ingenheim Jewish cemetery.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "name": "Johann Martin Schaaf, identity unresolved",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schaaf",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_ancestor",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "Other linked church records establish a Johann Martin Schaaf and Anna Catharina Grau family in the village, but they also show that at least two men there shared his name.",
      "research_note": "The retained extraction of the 1848 Ober-Gleen baptism candidate names Johann Martin Schaaf as the child's father. His relationship to Katharine Schaaf Fricke is therefore displayed as a low-confidence candidate, not as proven ancestry.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "name": "Anna Catharina Grau",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Grau",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_ancestor",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The retained extraction of the 1848 Ober-Gleen baptism candidate names Anna Catharina Grau as the child's mother. Records discussed for other children support a couple of these names in Ober-Gleen, but no American record yet proves that their baptized daughter became Katharine Schaaf Fricke of New Jersey.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PETERS_PRISCILLA_FRESHFORD_1707",
      "name": "Priscilla Peters",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Peters",
      "birth_date": "baptized 23 Jun 1707",
      "birth_place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": "England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ISAIAH_PETERS_1734_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Priscilla Peters was baptized at Freshford St Peter on 23 June 1707, daughter of Robert Peters and Ann.",
      "research_note": "She is therefore connected to Isaiah only as a 0.62 compiled candidate. WikiTree proposes her as the mother of Isaiah Peters, whose reported 1734 Freshford birth and later marriage to Betty Willis match the connected person, but Isaiah's profile does not cite a baptism naming Priscilla. That identity and parentage are directly transcribed from the parish material.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PETERS_ROBERT_FRESHFORD_FATHER_PRISCILLA",
      "name": "Robert Peters",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Peters",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1707 Freshford baptism transcript names Robert Peters as Priscilla's father.",
      "research_note": "No birth, death, occupation, or parents have yet been established for him.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1679,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1707,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PETERS_ANN_FRESHFORD_MOTHER_PRISCILLA",
      "name": "Ann Peters",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Peters",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1707 Freshford baptism transcript names Ann as Priscilla's mother and Robert Peters as father.",
      "research_note": "Ann's maiden surname, vital events, occupation, and parents remain unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1679,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1707,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_NORTH_BRADLEY_FATHER_BETTY",
      "name": "Benjamin Willis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Willis",
      "birth_date": "candidate born 4 Aug 1701",
      "birth_place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_BETTY_WILLIS_1737_PROFILE",
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1738",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1701",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_1738_FAMILY_CLUSTER"
      ],
      "source_note": "North Bradley records establish Benjamin Willis households: a Benjamin was born in 1701 to an older Benjamin, and Benjamin appears as father in several 1730s baptisms.",
      "research_note": "This profile remains connected as the most specific compiled candidate, not as proved parentage. WikiTree identifies him as Betty Willis's father, but the cited 22 January baptism is transcribed by FreeREG as Ann rather than Betty. The 1701 child-to-adult identity is itself only a same-name, same-parish, age-compatible hypothesis.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_SR_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "name": "Benjamin Willis, baptized 1678/79",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Willis",
      "birth_date": "baptized 10 Jan 1678/79",
      "birth_place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": "buried 11 Sep 1703",
      "death_place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "probable_ancestor",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1701",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Benjamin was one of four children of William and Katherine Willis baptized together at North Bradley on 10 January 1678/79.",
      "research_note": "The later claim that his 1701 son fathered Betty Willis remains a separate, conflicting hypothesis and is not strengthened by this extension. A parish-register reconstruction records his burial as “Benjamin Willis Junior” on 11 September 1703 and identifies him as the father named in the 1701 baptism. That reconstruction resolves the earlier same-name ambiguity substantially, though the 1701 parent link is retained below direct-record certainty.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WILLIS_WILLIAM_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "name": "William Willis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Willis",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_ancestor",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The 10 January 1678/79 baptism directly names William Willis as father of Benjamin; parallel entries name Lazarus, Joseph, and Abigail to William and Katherine. No safe birth, marriage, burial, occupation, or parents have yet been identified for William.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1650,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1678,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WILLIS_KATHERINE_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "name": "Katherine Willis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_ancestor",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The 10 January 1678/79 baptism directly names Katherine as Benjamin Willis’s mother; parallel entries name three other children to William and Katherine. Her maiden name and vital events remain unknown. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1650,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1678,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "name": "David Trautman",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Trautman",
      "birth_date": "about 1818",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "22 Nov 1893",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
        "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_COMPILED_JAMES_TRAUTMAN",
        "SRC_GARDNER_NEW_ORLEANS_DIRECTORY_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1861",
        "SRC_NOPL_OBITUARY_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
        "ROOTS26_TRAUTMAN_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_TRAUTMAN_IDENTITY_LIMIT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Four official Orleans Parish birth-index entries from 1854 through 1862 repeatedly name David Trautmann/Trautman with Julie/Julia Moser/Moses as parents. Gardner's 1861 directory lists David operating a shoe store on Poydras Street and residing at 174 Lafayette. The official death index records David, age 75, dying in Orleans Parish on 22 November 1893; the New Orleans Public Library index locates two Daily Picayune notices on 23 and 26 November, and Hebrew Rest Cemetery places him with Julie. Trautman/Trautmann is a German personal-name surname with multiple spelling lines.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the New Orleans man; alternatives are another David Trautman, a Trautmann/Troutman spelling conflation, or an unrelated local namesake. The New Orleans evidence identifies the household and occupation, but no reviewed record identifies David's birthplace, immigration or parents. No parent edge is added. No located record identifies his birthplace, immigration, or parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "name": "Julie (Julia) Moser",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Moser",
      "birth_date": "about 1827",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "20 Sep 1916",
      "death_place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1916",
        "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_COMPILED_JAMES_TRAUTMAN",
        "ROOTS26_MOSER_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_MOSER_IDENTITY_LIMIT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The official birth index names this mother Julie Moser in 1854 and 1856, Julie Moses in 1859, and Julia Moses in 1862. The official death index records Mrs David Trautman, age 89, on 20 September 1916, and Hebrew Rest Cemetery names Julie Trautman in David's plot.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the single New Orleans mother; alternatives are another Julie Moser/Moses or a conflated spelling identity. Her birthplace, immigration, and parents remain unresolved. Moser is a German surname with multiple independent lines, and Moses may be a record spelling or a separate surname. The repeated husband, place, and sequence of children show these are name variants for one woman; Moser is retained as the earliest directly recorded form, with Moses and Mosser documented as variants. Birth about 1827 is inferred only from death age. The repeated New Orleans records support one Julie/Julia Moser/Moses, but no reviewed record identifies her birthplace, immigration or parents. No parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARSHALL_JOHN_PONTEFRACT_1772",
      "name": "John Marshall",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Marshall",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_identity_candidate_parent",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Marshall married Ann Allen at Pontefract on 19 July 1772 after banns.",
      "research_note": "A derivative baptism index identifies an Ann Marshall as John's daughter, and that child is chronologically and geographically plausible as the Ann Marshall who married Thomas Lister in 1799. The reviewed extract does not supply the child's full baptism entry or an adult identity bridge, so John is displayed as a candidate father rather than a proved parent.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1745,
          "confidence": 0.49,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1773,
          "confidence": 0.49,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ALLEN_ANN_WIFE_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "name": "Ann Allen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Allen",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_identity_candidate_parent",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ann Allen married John Marshall at Pontefract on 19 July 1772.",
      "research_note": "She is a plausible mother of the indexed Ann Marshall, but the reviewed child extract names only John and no original baptism has yet been inspected. The 1837 Luddenden burial of an 85-year-old Ann Marshall would imply birth about 1752 and is not assigned to either the daughter or this wife without further identity evidence.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "B68_ISAAK_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_1736",
      "name": "Isaak Hirsch Dreyfuss (Jizchak Zwi)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Dreyfuss",
      "birth_date": "1736",
      "birth_place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "11 Jul 1804",
      "death_place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Known as Jizchak Zwi or Hirsch, he lived at Ingenheim and died there at age 68 on 11 July 1804. The local historical database names his father Jehuda Löb Dreyfuss, wife under several variant names, and sons Leo and Salomon. He was buried in the Ingenheim Jewish cemetery.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "B68_MARIA_ANNA_ABRAHAM_OPPENHEIMER",
      "name": "Maria Anna (Abraham or Oppenheimer)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Abraham or Oppenheimer",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_name_variants",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Leo's profile calls his mother Maria Anna née Abraham. Hirsch's profile calls his wife Maria Anna Oppenheimer, Marina Abraham, or Borig Mariam.",
      "research_note": "These may reflect civil, patronymic, or transliterated forms, but the reviewed pages do not explain them; they are retained together with the conflict visible.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
          "confidence": 0.91,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Leo Dreyfuss (formerly Löb Isaak)",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1736,
          "confidence": 0.655,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
          "place_confidence": 0.91,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Leo Dreyfuss (formerly Löb Isaak)"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1764,
          "confidence": 0.655,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "B68_JEHUDA_LOEB_DREYFUSS",
      "name": "Jehuda Löb Dreyfuss",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Dreyfuss",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_name_only",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No dates, spouse, occupation, or higher parentage were supplied. The Ingenheim historical database explicitly identifies Jehuda Löb Dreyfuss of Ingenheim as the father of Jizchak Zwi, called Hirsch. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1708,
          "confidence": 0.662,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1736,
          "confidence": 0.662,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "B68_DAVID_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
      "name": "David Moses",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Moses",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_name_only",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Ingenheim historical database names David Moses and Esther née Nathan as the parents of Rosina Haas, formerly Rösel Moyses.",
      "research_note": "No dates, occupation, or higher parentage were supplied.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1742,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1770,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
      "name": "Esther Nathan Moses",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Nathan",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_name_only",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Ingenheim historical database names Esther née Nathan and David Moses as the parents of Rosina Haas, formerly Rösel Moyses.",
      "research_note": "No dates, occupation, or higher parentage were supplied.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1742,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1770,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "name": "Andrew Gibson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gibson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "reported Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_name_only",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
        "SRC_IRISH_GENEALOGY_ANDREW_GIBSON_DEATH_SEARCH_1864_1920",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANDREW_GIBSON_1832_1887_ONTARIO_REJECTED",
        "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Gibson's 1883 marriage register names his father Andrew Gibson, farmer, and Griffith's Valuation places a matching Andrew at Aghnasedagh in 1861. Andrew was absent from the surviving Aghnasedagh household by 1901, so he may have died before civil registration, died or registered elsewhere, migrated, or been indexed under a variant.",
      "research_note": "Andrew's wife, dates, and parents remain unresolved; no distant namesake is attached. An Andrew Gibson born 1832 and dead 1887 in Amherst Island, Ontario, was rejected: his 1861 Canadian household conflicts with Andrew's same-year Monaghan valuation appearance. The official civil-death index contains no Andrew Gibson death in the Monaghan registration district from 1864 through 1920.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1822,
          "confidence": 0.716,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1883,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "reported Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "name": "John Lamb",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lamb",
      "birth_date": "20 Mar 1757",
      "birth_place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1785",
        "SRC_MONTGOMERY_QS_BERRIEW_KERRY_LAMB_1790",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Lamb married Elizabeth Prichard at Kerry on 21 January 1785. Their daughter Elizabeth was baptized there five months later, and the 1790 Montgomeryshire settlement order identifies John and Elizabeth Lamb with two young children whose legal settlement was Kerry. The same parish, a normal 1785 marriage age, and the uninterrupted household sequence make this the leading explanation for his parentage.",
      "research_note": "The alternative is an otherwise undocumented, same-name John born elsewhere who married and remained in Kerry; it is possible, so the parent links are strong but not absolute. Within the 1735-1765 reviewed Montgomeryshire baptism set, the only John Lamb baptism is the 20 March 1757 Kerry entry naming John and Ann Lamb.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1790,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Berriew and Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "name": "Elizabeth Prichard Lamb",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Prichard",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_name_only",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1785",
        "SRC_MONTGOMERY_QS_BERRIEW_KERRY_LAMB_1790",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_BERRIEW_BURIAL_1812"
      ],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth Prichard married John Lamb at Kerry on 21 January 1785. Their daughter Elizabeth was baptized there five months later, and the 1790 Montgomeryshire settlement order identifies John and Elizabeth Lamb with daughter Elizabeth aged four and son John aged two, whose legal settlement was Kerry. This establishes a coherent adult household.",
      "research_note": "An Elizabeth Lamb buried at Berriew in 1812 aged 67 fits the family's documented move to Berriew and the expected age, but the burial lacks a spouse or maiden surname and is retained only as a plausible later-life record rather than as an asserted death date. No source identifies Elizabeth Prichard's parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1757,
          "confidence": 0.547,
          "basis": "estimated from spouse's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1790,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Berriew and Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Alexander Faddis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Faddis",
      "birth_date": "about 1760-1770",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": "probably Grayson County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "candidate_ancestor",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_1835_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX",
        "SRC_1840_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY",
        "SRC_GRayson_HISTORICAL_SOCIETY_FADDIS_NOTEBOOK"
      ],
      "source_note": "Alexander Faddis headed Grayson County households in 1830 and 1840 and appeared on the 1835 personal-property tax list. In 1840 his household contained a woman aged 40-49, two girls aged 5-9, two girls under five, a boy under five, and an older teenage boy. That configuration closely continues as Susan Faddis, about 55, with Sibarina 16, Isaac 14, Susan 11, and Floyd 8 in the 1850 county census; Alexander was then absent. The leading explanation is that Susan was his widow and Adelia Faddis, already married nearby in 1850, was one of the two 1840 girls aged 5-9.",
      "research_note": "Alexander remains a circumstantial candidate parent rather than a documented father. An unrelated same-named woman and children would require a less economical reconstruction, but no schedule names wife or children.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1840,
          "confidence": 0.98,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Western District, Grayson County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "B73_SUSAN_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Susan Faddis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Faddis",
      "birth_date": "about 1795",
      "birth_place": "Virginia, USA",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_ancestor",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1840_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY",
        "SRC_GRayson_HISTORICAL_SOCIETY_FADDIS_NOTEBOOK"
      ],
      "source_note": "Susan Faddis, about 55, headed a Grayson County household in 1850 with Sibarina, Isaac, Susan, and Floyd Faddis. The 1840 Alexander Faddis household contains a woman aged 40-49 and children whose ages closely match that later Susan household; Alexander was absent by 1850. The most likely reading is that Susan was Alexander's widow and that Adelia, already married elsewhere in the county in 1850, was an older daughter.",
      "research_note": "A different unnamed woman and unrelated children remain possible because pre-1880 census schedules do not state relationships. Susan's maiden name and parents are still unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1850,
          "confidence": 0.995,
          "basis": "not before the last securely dated life activity",
          "place": "Grayson County, Virginia, USA",
          "place_basis": "place of the last securely dated activity"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_WINTERBORNE_FATHER_C1570",
      "name": "Robert Butt of Winterborne",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Butt",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1570",
      "birth_place": "reported Dorset, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "compiled_parish_reconstruction",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_ROBERT_BUTT_BAPTISM_1616",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert Butt married Susan Gantrell in 1607 and was named as father in repeated Dorset baptisms.",
      "research_note": "His displayed circa-1570 birth is only a compiled estimate. This man is shown because his son baptized in 1616 is a possible, not established, match to the Virginia immigrant. A published reconstruction is the source for the marriage and baptism sequence.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GANTRELL_SUSAN_WINTERBORNE_1585",
      "name": "Susan Gantrell",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gantrell",
      "birth_date": "by 18 Aug 1585 (baptism date)",
      "birth_place": "Winterborne Stickland, Dorset, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "compiled_parish_reconstruction",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_ROBERT_BUTT_BAPTISM_1616",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS",
        "SRC_OT26_BROAD_GANTRELL_1591"
      ],
      "source_note": "Susan Gantrell was baptized on 18 August 1585 and married Robert Butt on 13 April 1607.",
      "research_note": "The underlying report labels the register section Winterborne Stickland, whereas the derivative family page gives the 1607 marriage as Winterborne Houghton. The reconstruction quotes these events. The 1616 baptism names only the child's father in the quoted wording, so Susan's maternity follows from the intact marriage and surrounding child sequence rather than from an explicitly named mother. 18 August 1585 is a baptism date, not a documented birth date. Original images are needed to settle locality labels.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GANTRELL_RICHARD_FATHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "name": "Richard Gantrell",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gantrell",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "reported Dorset, England",
      "death_date": "by 15 Dec 1591 (proposed burial identification)",
      "death_place": "Winterborne Stickland, Dorset, England (proposed burial identification)",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS",
        "SRC_OT26_BROAD_GANTRELL_1591"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parish provenance check: the OPC holdings guides list Stickland PE-WSD registers from 1615–16 (https://www.opcdorset.org/WinterborneFiles/W.Stickland/WinterborneStickland.htm), versus Houghton PE-WHO from 1558–59. Broad’s indexed heading calls the early section Stickland.",
      "research_note": "The exact register/parish remains unresolved; this discrepancy does not erase the explicit parent names. A different Richard is a hypothetical alternative, not observed contrary evidence. A mislabeled Houghton section is a leading explanation; an earlier transcript not in the guide is an alternative. Susan’s 1585 baptism transcription explicitly names Richard Gantrell and Aves as her parents. Original register images remain uninspected. Identifying that burial with Susan’s father is the leading hypothesis because name, parish and chronology agree; it is not independently proved by a spouse or child in the burial wording. The burial date must not be presented as an exact death date. Follow-up 15 September 2026 located the underlying Antony Broad report’s indexed transcription of a Richard Gantrell burial at Winterborne Stickland on 15 December 1591. No parentage for Richard has been found.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1557,
          "confidence": 0.662,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GANTRELL_AVES_MOTHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "name": "Aves",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "reported Dorset, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No evidence supports a maiden surname, exact birth, death, or parents. The quoted 1585 baptism names the mother only as Aves, wife of Richard Gantrell. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1557,
          "confidence": 0.662,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1585,
          "confidence": 0.662,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "name": "Morris Segel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Segel",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "6 Jan 1940",
      "death_place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_COUNCIL_CANDIDATE_1916",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_BURGLARY_1927",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_FORECLOSURE_1929",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_STORE_OPEN_1929",
        "SRC_CT_DEATH_INDEX_MORRIS_SEGEL_1940",
        "ROOTS26_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "H1 is the documented New Britain Morris; alternatives are a same-name merchant or a spelling variant such as Segal/Siegel. Morris's birth date, birthplace, parents, and wife remain unresolved. His birth date, birthplace, parents, and wife remain unresolved. The continuous local record trail makes the H1 much stronger, but it does not extend his ancestry; no new parent edge is added. This record supersedes the earlier family recollection that both of Marty's parents died before his 1937 marriage. The official Connecticut death index records a Morris Segel death in New Britain on 6 January 1940; the exact name and place make this substantially more likely to be the merchant than an otherwise undocumented local namesake.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1879,
          "confidence": 0.698,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "Morris Segel"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743",
      "name": "Robert Needham",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Needham",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Carsington, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_ROBERT_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_DRO_GELL_NEW_CLOSE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_1713",
        "SRC_STAFFS_WILLS_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1743",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_MARRIAGE_1694",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1695",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1697",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1702",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_MARY_WIFE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_BURIAL_1705",
        "SRC_NEEDHAMONS_DERBYSHIRE_ORIGINS_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert Needham of Carsington is the testator of a will proved in 1743. The published abstract reports that he calls Samuel Needham of Carsington his son. A 1713 Hopton Hall deed independently names him as tenant of New Close in Carsington, and the official probate index identifies his surviving 1743 will as Lichfield Consistory Court B/C/11. Parish-register entries place Robert and Mary Needham in a dissenting household at Carsington in 1695, 1697, and 1702; Robert was called a farmer in 1702. Mary, wife of Robert the husbandman, was buried there on 3 February 1704/5. The county-wide record index identifies numerous older Needham locality clusters across Derbyshire, including Wormhill, High Needham, Cronkstone, and Staden.",
      "research_note": "These records strengthen the identification of the Carsington testator, but the beneficiary wording remains represented by the published will abstract until the will image is inspected. These entries strongly favour the Robert and Mary who married in 1694, but do not repeat Mary's maiden name. It explains why a surname-and-county match is only contextual evidence: the source supplies no continuous descent from any of those clusters to Carsington. The original will has not yet been inspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1694",
      "name": "Mary Wagstaffe",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wagstaffe",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Hulland, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": "buried 3 Feb 1704/5",
      "death_place": "Carsington, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_MARRIAGE_1694",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1695",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1697",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1702",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_MARY_WIFE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_BURIAL_1705",
        "SRC_FMP_LICHFIELD_NEEDHAM_WAGSTAFFE_BOND_SEARCH_1694"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary Wagstaffe was described as of Hulland when she married Robert Needham at Ashbourne in 1694. The most likely later record is the 3 February 1704/5 Carsington burial of Mary, wife of Robert Needham, husbandman. It follows three entries for Robert and Mary Needham's dissenting household in the same parish.",
      "research_note": "A focused search of the digitized Lichfield marriage-bond index for Robert Needham and Mary Wagstaffe, with variant matching across 1684-1704, returned no entries. Her parentage is not established, and no relationship to Samuel is claimed here. A separate same-named couple is possible but has no positive evidence. This makes a surviving indexed licence less likely; marriage by banns, an omitted record, or a different jurisdiction remains more likely than using the absent bond to infer her parentage.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1734",
      "name": "Samuel Nedham",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Nedham",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Carsington, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": "buried 4 Oct 1767",
      "death_place": "Carsington, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_ROBERT_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BAPTISM_1734",
        "SRC_DFHS_CARSINGTON_SAMUEL_MARTHA_BURIALS",
        "SRC_DFHS_CARSINGTON_SAMUEL_NEEDHAM_BURIAL_1767"
      ],
      "source_note": "Samuel Nedham was a farmer in Carsington, father of Edward baptized there in 1733/34, and husband of Martha until her burial in 1747. He married Anne Ford at Derby All Saints on 28 September 1753. A Samuel Needham was buried at Carsington on 4 October 1767.",
      "research_note": "The published 1743 will abstract names Samuel as Robert Needham's son, and the Carsington baptism names him as Edward's father. Carsington burials of the children and of Martha support the household. The spelling varies between Nedham and Needham. A 1753 marriage-bond transcription describes a widowed farmer of Carsington, a strong identity match after Martha's burial. The 1767 burial has no age or family qualifier, so its attribution is likely rather than direct; it is preferred over the 1769 Chelmorton burial, which more plausibly belongs to the separately reconstructed Flagg mining household. The Derby marriage record does not itself identify this Samuel as Robert's son or give his parentage.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1706,
          "confidence": 0.547,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARTHA_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1747",
      "name": "Martha (maiden name unknown) Nedham",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Nedham",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Carsington, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": "buried 4 Aug 1747",
      "death_place": "Carsington, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BAPTISM_1734",
        "SRC_DFHS_CARSINGTON_SAMUEL_MARTHA_BURIALS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Martha is named with Samuel as parent of Edward in the 1733/34 Carsington baptism. The parish-burial transcription also records Martha, wife of Samuel Needham of Hopton, buried at Carsington on 4 August 1747.",
      "research_note": "Her maiden name remains unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1706,
          "confidence": 0.547,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GEORGE_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1738",
      "name": "George Needham",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Needham",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1738"
      ],
      "source_note": "George Needham is named as father of Edward Needham baptised at Ashbourne in 1738.",
      "research_note": "That child is a weaker alternative identity for the later Ashbourne grocer; George is retained only through that candidate relationship.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1668_1677",
      "name": "Thomas Wagstaffe",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wagstaffe",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Hulland, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGSTAFFE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1668_1677",
        "SRC_HASLAND_HALL_WAGSTAFFE_HISTORY_20260727",
        "SRC_DERBY_ARCHIVE_SAMUEL_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_BOND_1742"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas Wagstaffe of Hulland is named as father in Ashbourne baptisms of Mary in 1668 and of Mary and Joseph in 1677.",
      "research_note": "The records do not give his wife, parentage, or later life.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_REIFF_HANSS_JERG_UNTERHAUSEN_1536",
      "name": "Hanss Jerg Reiff",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Reiff",
      "birth_date": "reported 1536",
      "birth_place": "reported Unterhausen, Wurttemberg, Germany",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_REIFF_HANSS_JERG_1536",
        "SRC_ARCHION_UNTERHAUSEN_MIXED_BOOK_1579_1618"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "A source-free public Unterhausen tree names Hanss Jerg Reiff, born 1536, as father of an undated Barbara Reiff. The profile remains a low-confidence source-tree candidate only: it does not establish that this Barbara was the mother of Anna Fuchs, and it does not support an older Reiff or noble connection. The previously reported 4 February 1590 marriage of Barbara Reiff and Hans Fuchs at Unterhausen cannot be verified in the surviving Unterhausen marriage series, which begins in 1597. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ALICE_ALLSOPP_WIFE_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_1667",
      "name": "Alice (Alce) Allsopp",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Allsopp",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGGSTAFFE_ALLSOPP_MARRIAGE_1667"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Ashbourne St Oswald parish-register transcription records Alce Allsopp marrying Thomas Waggstaffe on 27 April 1667.",
      "research_note": "The marriage makes her the leading named mother candidate for Thomas's Hulland daughters recorded soon afterward, including the Mary who is a plausible identity for Robert Needham's 1694 wife. The child records do not name a mother, and neither the marriage nor the available transcripts identify Alice's parents, birth, death, or any relationship to the separate Hasland or Harbury Wagstaffe pedigrees.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Hulland, Derbyshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.7,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Mary Wagstaffe",
          "descendant_id": "C_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1694",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GOBEL_LUDWIG_ERPFINGEN_1522",
      "name": "Ludwig Gobel of Erpfingen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Gobel",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALTWUERTTEMBERG_LAGERBUCH_1522_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_GOBEL_P251"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as a rent payer in Erpfingen in 1522 by Weigel, citing Schwarz volumeII p.714. His age, birthplace, wife, children and death are unestablished.",
      "research_note": "Existence and the candidate link to Hans are assessed separately. The former before 1502 birth estimate assumed a minimum age of 20 without supporting evidence; removed 20 September 2026.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Erpfingen area, Wurttemberg",
          "confidence": 0.13,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Hannssen Goebells",
          "descendant_id": "I247",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ANN_FORD_CARSINGTON_1753",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "C_LEVY_MICHEL_MACHOLE_FATHER_JACQUES_1725",
      "name": "Michel Machole Levy, identity unresolved",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Levy",
      "birth_date": "about 1725",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_identity",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
        "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730",
        "SRC_GENAMI_MARMOUTIER_LEVY_FAMILIES_2004_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Rosenwiller cemetery-memory transcription for Jacques/Jeckel Levy's 1806 burial names him as “son of Macholé (Michaël).” Together with the 1784 Ottrott enumeration of Jacob Levy and Bösel Macholen, this is direct published/transcribed support for a father named Michel Machole, not merely an age-based preference among online trees.",
      "research_note": "H1 is the published/transcribed father identity; alternatives are another Michel, a patronymic-only reading, or an unrelated Marmoutier Levy family. Michel Machole Levy is supported as Jacques/Jeckel Levy’s father by a Rosenwiller cemetery-memory transcription and the 1784 Ottrott enumeration, but his own birth about 1725, birthplace, wife, death and parents remain unresolved. Michel's reported 1725 birth is still compiled; no source here gives his birthplace, wife, occupation, death, or parents. A separate archival reconstruction distinguishes multiple Marmoutier Macholé Levy families, none explicitly connected to this Ottrott household. No new edge is added. Michel is therefore the well-supported father identity for Jacques, but not a gateway for merging same-named Marmoutier families.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
          "confidence": 0.86,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Jacques Jeckel Jacob Levy",
          "descendant_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1750,
          "confidence": 0.619,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1335_1395",
      "name": "John Phylppes",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phylppes",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1335",
      "birth_place": "reported England",
      "death_date": "reported about 1395",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Included at the tree owner's request as the earliest proposed Phylppes ancestor. The date, place, spouse, and proposed son Henry come from a compiled Geni line; no medieval record has been inspected. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_HENRY_PHYLLIPPES_1400_1480",
      "name": "Henry Phylppes",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phylppes",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1400",
      "birth_place": "reported England",
      "death_date": "reported about 1480",
      "death_place": "reported England",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Included as the compiled son of John Phylppes and proposed father of a later John. No manor, legal, land, or probate record has been inspected for this identity.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1422_1491",
      "name": "John Phylppes",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phylppes",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1422",
      "birth_place": "reported England",
      "death_date": "reported about 1491",
      "death_place": "reported city, England",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Geni line calls this man Henry's son and Francis's father.",
      "research_note": "The broad locations and dates are unverified compiled assertions.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_FRANCIS_PHYLLIPPES_1450_1491",
      "name": "Francis Phylppes",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phylppes",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1450",
      "birth_place": "reported England",
      "death_date": "reported 1491",
      "death_place": "reported Checkley, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.13,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "This proposed Francis is retained as a low-confidence link between the compiled John profiles. He must not be confused with the separately discussed sixteenth-century Francis of Staffordshire. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1472_1499",
      "name": "John Phylppes",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phylppes",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1472",
      "birth_place": "reported England",
      "death_date": "reported about 1499",
      "death_place": "reported Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Tewkesbury and the chronology make this proposed father of Richard plausible, but no inspected parish, probate, land, or legal record names Richard as his child. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_RICHARD_PHELPS_1497_1579",
      "name": "Richard Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "reported 1497",
      "birth_place": "reported England",
      "death_date": "reported about 1579",
      "death_place": "reported Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Geni pedigree proposes Richard as James Phelps's father.",
      "research_note": "The documented Tewkesbury household begins with James; no inspected record bridges Richard to James.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "name": "James Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "about 1520",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": "before 10 May 1588",
      "death_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TEWKESBURY_PHELPS_1520_1563_REVIEW",
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints James Phelps's 1588 probate administration and a dated list of his Tewkesbury household.",
      "research_note": "It supports the documented household beginning with James and Joan, but calls the proposed earlier connection to Francis Phylppe of Nether Teyne only a supposition.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1563",
      "name": "Thomas Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "baptised 1563 (date disputed)",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TEWKESBURY_PHELPS_1520_1563_REVIEW",
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_SCAN_COMPARISON_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints the 10 Aug 1563 Tewkesbury baptism of Thomas, son of James Phelps. Both identify James as father. The exact day/month is disputed and neither date is a recorded birth.",
      "research_note": "It does not make this Thomas the father of the Limerick Thomas born in 1623; its competing family tree instead identifies a Thomas baptised in 1590. 15 September 2026 scan review: Printed p.19 gives 10 October 1563 in the parchment-copy transcription, while p.71 gives 10 August 1563 in the household summary.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "name": "Thomas Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "reported 1623",
      "birth_place": "reported United Kingdom",
      "death_date": "reported 13th day, 8th month 1697 (Quaker date)",
      "death_place": "reported Limerick, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_ORIGIN_THEORIES_20260728",
        "SRC_LIMERICK_QUAKER_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLD_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729",
        "SRC_CHAIN_PHELPS_BOOK_SCANS_20260915",
        "SRC_CHAIN_QUAKER_CALENDAR_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas Phelps stands at the centre of a long Limerick Quaker family tradition. In correspondence printed in The Phelps Family of America (1899), a Limerick descendant described him as a captain in Cromwell's army who settled in Limerick and acquired a Tipperary estate held by the family for more than 140 years. The book also prints Quaker material describing him as one of several Limerick Friends imprisoned for worship in 1661, and later estate material connected with lands in the barony of Owney and Arra. The 1899 family tree identifies him as son of Thomas Phelps of Tewkesbury, baptised in 1590 (January/June date disputed). 15 September 2026: The 1899 letter prints a numbered Quaker date. Eighth month before 1752 normally means October, not August. The letter itself notes several Thomas namesakes.",
      "research_note": "These details give valuable context for the documented Limerick household, but they come through a nineteenth-century family history and should not be read as proof of every earlier link or of descent to the Baltimore Felps family. The contributor's admission on printed p.24 that the founder's birth and first marriage could not be found leaves that parentage unproved; the link is now graded .40. Preserve the original numbering pending the original register; do not silently convert to a fully Gregorian date.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1644_1667",
      "name": "Thomas Felps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Felps",
      "birth_date": "reported 1644",
      "birth_place": "reported Ireland",
      "death_date": "reported 1667",
      "death_place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.14,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_ORIGIN_THEORIES_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The proposed 1667 death and his paternity of the 1664 Thomas are retained for research, not presented as fact. This reported Irish-born Thomas is the crucial but unsupported bridge to Maryland. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1664_1758",
      "name": "Thomas Felps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Felps",
      "birth_date": "reported 15 Sep 1664",
      "birth_place": "reported British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "1758 (exact date unverified)",
      "death_place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_FELPS_WILL_1758_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_WILL_INDEX_THOMAS_FELPS_1758",
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas's 1758 Baltimore County will is the documentary anchor for the lower line: it names Rosannah as wife and Aventon as son.",
      "research_note": "His reported 1664 birth and the proposed Irish father remain unverified. The official index places his will in 1758; the original probate endorsement was not inspected. 15 September 2026: 2 April 1758 is the date he made his will, not an established death date.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_ROSANNAH_WIFE_THOMAS_FELPS",
      "name": "Rose [previously Swift; birth surname unproven]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "after 2 Apr 1758",
      "death_place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_FELPS_WILL_1758_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_BALTIMORE_FELPS_RECORD_EXTRACTS_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "A 1738 vestry transcription says Thomas Felps declared that he married Rose Swift on 28 May 1710 after she had been married to a man named Swift.",
      "research_note": "Her birth surname and parentage remain unproven.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1664,
          "confidence": 0.539,
          "basis": "estimated from spouse's birth year",
          "place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "Rose [previously Swift; birth surname unproven]"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_AVENTON_FELPS_1711_1794",
      "name": "Aventon (Avinton) Felps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Felps",
      "birth_date": "reported 1711",
      "birth_place": "reported Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "reported 1790-1794",
      "death_place": "reported Rowan County, North Carolina, USA",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_FELPS_WILL_1758_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_ST_GEORGE_AVENTON_RACHEL_MARRIAGE_1730",
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The reported 1711 birth and 1790-94 death remain compiled. Aventon's reported marriage to Rachel McElroy is supported by published parish research. Thomas Felps's 1758 will explicitly calls Aventon his son. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_RACHEL_MCELROY_WIFE_AVENTON",
      "name": "Rachel McElroy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McElroy",
      "birth_date": "reported 7 Aug 1713",
      "birth_place": "reported Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ST_GEORGE_AVENTON_RACHEL_MARRIAGE_1730",
        "SRC_ST_GEORGE_AVENTON_RACHEL_TRANSCRIPTION_20260728",
        "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Related 1732 and 1741 deeds place the McElroy and Felps households in one Baltimore County land network before their later southern movement.",
      "research_note": "The original register and deeds have not yet been inspected, so the birth, parentage, and migration context remain strong derivative evidence rather than direct image proof. Published Phelps research transcribes Rachel McElroy's 23 April 1730 St George Parish marriage to Aventon Felps and reports her 7 August 1713 birth as daughter of John and Frances McElroy.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_AQUILLA_FELPS_1731_1788",
      "name": "Aquilla (Aquiller) Felps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Felps",
      "birth_date": "reported 1731",
      "birth_place": "reported British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "reported 1788",
      "death_place": "reported United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_ORIGIN_THEORIES_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_PHELPS_FELPS_ROWAN_RECORDS_20260730",
        "SRC_PHELPS_AQUILLA_GEORGIA_CONFLICT_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Aquilla is independently attested as an adult in the Rowan County Felps cluster: published transcriptions place Aquilla/Aquiller/Aquala in taxable, bounty, petition, and land-related records between 1759 and 1769.",
      "research_note": "It does not identify his parents, prove his reported 1731 birth or 1788 death, record a marriage to Sarah Jane Sally Jones, or establish that John Felps who married Mary Williams in 1766 was his son. A separate comparative analysis disputes the reported 1771 move to Georgia and instead finds Aquilla in Rowan into the late 1780s; the conflicting migration accounts are retained as an unresolved life-history question. This makes the man himself much more secure than the original imported profile.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_SARAH_JANE_SALLY_WIFE_AQUILLA",
      "name": "Sarah Jane \"Sally\" [surname unproven]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "ROOTS26_SALLY_NAME_LIMIT"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "H1 is the compiled spouse/mother claim; alternatives are another Sarah Jane, an unrelated Aquilla Felps household, or a conflated spouse profile. The name remains Sarah Jane “Sally” with no established maiden surname. The supplied Geni line calls Sarah Jane Sally the wife of Aquilla and mother of John. No parent edge is added. No maiden surname, date, place, or original marriage record has yet been located.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.42,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Felps",
          "descendant_id": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_JOAN_WIFE_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "name": "Joan [birth surname unproven]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": "reported about 1542",
      "birth_place": "reported England",
      "death_date": "after 10 May 1588",
      "death_place": "reported Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "A published 1899 transcription says that administration of James Phelps's estate was issued to Joan, his relict, on 10 May 1588. That supports this marriage.",
      "research_note": "Later online trees call her Coke or other surnames, but no inspected record establishes a maiden surname.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_MARY_TOMES_WIFE_RICHARD",
      "name": "Mary Tomes (reported)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Tomes",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1501",
      "birth_place": "reported England",
      "death_date": "reported after 1529",
      "death_place": "reported England",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COMPILED_PHELPS_PEDIGREE_VARIANTS_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary Tomes is a repeated online pedigree claim as Richard Phelps's wife.",
      "research_note": "The underlying trees disagree about her dates and give no inspectable contemporary support, so the relationship remains a low-confidence candidate.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_SUSANNA_FENNELL_WIFE_THOMAS1623",
      "name": "Susanna Fennell",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fennell",
      "birth_date": "reported 1623",
      "birth_place": "reported Wiltshire, England",
      "death_date": "reported 1684",
      "death_place": "reported Limerick, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LIMERICK_QUAKER_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLD_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original meeting-book pages have not been inspected in this review. Published Limerick Quaker-family research identifies Susanna Fennell as Thomas Phelps's first wife and gives this reported lifespan. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G28_ANNE_WIDOW_THOMAS1623",
      "name": "Anne [birth surname unproven]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "9 Nov 1708",
      "death_place": "reported Limerick, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LIMERICK_QUAKER_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLD_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "It does not establish her birth surname or a marriage date. The cited reconstruction quotes a Quaker record calling Anne the widow of Thomas Phelps and records her death in 1708. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "name": "William Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "baptised 4 Aug 1560",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": "before 28 Sep 1611",
      "death_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints William's 4 Aug 1560 Tewkesbury baptism as son of James Phelps. It also transcribes a 28 Sep 1611 administration to his widow Dorothy, establishing that he had died by then.",
      "research_note": "The original parish and probate records have not yet been inspected. 15 September 2026: The cited parish transcription gives a baptism, not an exact birth date.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "name": "Dorothy [birth surname unproven]",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "before 31 May 1613",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book identifies Dorothy as William Phelps's wife and transcribes a 31 May 1613 administration stating that she had died, leaving William's goods still unadministered.",
      "research_note": "Her birth surname, dates before that point, and parentage remain unproven.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
          "confidence": 0.84,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth Phelps",
          "descendant_id": "G29_ELIZABETH_PHELPS_1603",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1559,
          "confidence": 0.533,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.84,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Elizabeth Phelps"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_THOMAS_PHELPS_1590",
      "name": "Thomas Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "baptised 1590 (date/calendar disputed)",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729",
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_SCAN_COMPARISON_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints a Tewkesbury register copy for a Thomas baptised 24 Jun 1590 in William and Dorothy Phelps's child sequence. A separate Limerick-family letter in the same book says 24 Jan 1590; the register-list date is the more likely one. Both identify William as father. January also requires an Old Style year check against the register.",
      "research_note": "No exact birth is established. 15 September 2026 scan review: Printed p.20 gives 24 January 1590 in the parchment-copy transcription, while p.71 gives 24 June 1590 in the household summary. The book's separate Limerick family tree identifies this Thomas as father of Thomas born 1623, a lower-confidence secondary claim.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_GEORGE_GILES_PHELPS_1566",
      "name": "George (Giles) Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "5 Sep 1566",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints the 5 Sep 1566 Tewkesbury baptism of George Phelps, child of James and Joan. It notes that court and other records use George and Giles for the same person.",
      "research_note": "The original register has not yet been inspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_ALICE_PHELPS_1572",
      "name": "Alice Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "24 Dec 1572",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "research_note": "The original register has not yet been inspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_EDWARD_PHELPS_1578",
      "name": "Edward Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "10 May 1578",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints Edward's 10 May 1578 Tewkesbury baptism in the James and Joan household. It also identifies him as an ancestor of Rev. William Phelps Prior; that later descent has not been added or independently checked here.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_KENELM_PHELPS_1580",
      "name": "Kenelm Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "16 Oct 1580",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints a 16 Oct 1580 Tewkesbury baptism as Keneline, probably Kenelm, in the James and Joan household.",
      "research_note": "Kenelm is used here as the reading preferred by the book, while the original register remains to be checked.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_RICHARD_PHELPS_1583",
      "name": "Richard Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "16 Oct 1583",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints Richard's 16 Oct 1583 Tewkesbury baptism in the James and Joan household.",
      "research_note": "The original register has not yet been inspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_ROBERT_PHELPS_1584",
      "name": "Robert Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "18 Jul 1584",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints Robert's 18 Jul 1584 Tewkesbury baptism in the James and Joan household.",
      "research_note": "The original register has not yet been inspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_NICHOLAS_PHELPS_SIBLING",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_MARY_PHELPS_1587",
      "name": "Mary Phelps, baptised 1587",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "4 Sep 1587",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book lists a Mary baptised 4 Sep 1587 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household.",
      "research_note": "It separately lists another Mary baptised 23 Apr 1588; they are retained as two profiles rather than silently merged.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_MARY_PHELPS_1588",
      "name": "Mary Phelps, baptised 1588",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "23 Apr 1588",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book lists a Mary baptised 23 Apr 1588 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household, after a Mary baptised 4 Sep 1587.",
      "research_note": "No original register or burial record has yet resolved whether this reflects two daughters, a transcription issue, or another explanation.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_DOROTHY_PHELPS_1595",
      "name": "Dorothy Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "29 Feb 1595",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints Dorothy's 29 Feb 1595 Tewkesbury baptism in William and Dorothy Phelps's household.",
      "research_note": "The original register has not yet been inspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1599",
      "name": "William Phelps of Tewkesbury (baptised 1599)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "baptised 19 Aug 1599",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CREWKERNE_REASSESSMENT_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints William's 19 Aug 1599 Tewkesbury baptism as child of William and Dorothy Phelps and identifies him as the 1630 New England emigrant. This profile is distinct from his father, William baptised in 1560.",
      "research_note": "15 September 2026 review: The 1899 book's identification of this Tewkesbury child as the 1630 New England immigrant is superseded by Hyde's Crewkerne research. Keep this record as the Tewkesbury baptism identity only; do not import the Windsor biography, wives or descendants. His stated English parentage is not disproved by separating the immigrant.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_JAMES_PHELPS_1601",
      "name": "James Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "baptised 1601 (date/calendar disputed)",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_SCAN_COMPARISON_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints James's 14 Jul 1601 Tewkesbury baptism in William and Dorothy Phelps's household. Both identify William as father. February requires an Old Style year check.",
      "research_note": "These are conflicting baptism claims, not exact birth dates. The original register has not yet been inspected. 15 September 2026 scan review: Printed p.20 gives 14 February 1601 in the paper-copy transcription, while p.72 gives 14 July 1601 in the household summary.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_ELIZABETH_PHELPS_1603",
      "name": "Elizabeth Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "9 May 1603",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints Elizabeth's 9 May 1603 Tewkesbury baptism as daughter of William Phelps and Dorothy his wife.",
      "research_note": "The original register has not yet been inspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_GEORGE_PHELPS_ABT1606",
      "name": "George Phelps",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Phelps",
      "birth_date": "about 1606",
      "birth_place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book calls George, born about 1606, a son of William and Dorothy Phelps although it says he is absent from the Tewkesbury register.",
      "research_note": "That is a positive compiled claim, but weaker than the dated baptisms of the siblings.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "G29_JOHN_HOPE_HUSBAND_ALICE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZA_LYSTER_MOTHER_JANE_1851",
      "name": "Eliza Lyster (maiden name unknown)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lyster",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Eliza Lyster appears in the 1851 Shrewsbury St Alkmund household as the mother of one-year-old Jane and the partner of Richard Lyster.",
      "research_note": "A compiled Kezia Price reconstruction remains a weaker competing claim because it cannot presently explain Eliza's explicit appearance as Jane's mother in this household. The supplied census transcript is the strongest current evidence for Jane's mother. It does not state Eliza's maiden name, age, birthplace, marriage date, or parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.94,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Jane Lister Thomas",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1821,
          "confidence": 0.677,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.94,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Jane Lister Thomas"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1849,
          "confidence": 0.677,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_B71_JOHN_LAMB_FATHER_1757",
      "name": "John Lamb (father of John, baptized 1757)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lamb",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Lamb is named as the father in the 20 March 1757 Kerry baptism of John.",
      "research_note": "A 1781 Kerry marriage of a John Lamb to Ann Turner may concern this older man after Ann's death, but no record establishes that identification and it is not attached. The entry establishes a real, connected parent, but does not provide his age, occupation, residence within the parish, spouse's maiden name, or own parents.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1729,
          "confidence": 0.662,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1757,
          "confidence": 0.662,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_B71_ANN_LAMB_MOTHER_1757",
      "name": "Ann Lamb (maiden name unknown)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lamb",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ann is named as the mother in the 20 March 1757 Kerry baptism of John Lamb.",
      "research_note": "The entry does not record her maiden name, age, residence within the parish, occupation, or parents. She is kept as a documented connected parent rather than replaced by a name-only online pedigree.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1729,
          "confidence": 0.662,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1757,
          "confidence": 0.662,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "G27_JOHN_MCELROY_FATHER_RACHEL_1713",
      "name": "John McElroy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McElroy",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "reported Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
        "SRC_MCELROY_COMPILED_PEDIGREE_CONFLICT_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "A published transcription identifies John McElroy as the father of Rachel McElroy, born in 1713. It also describes a 1732 Baltimore County deed witnessed by Rachel's husband Aventon Felps and a later Felps transaction involving Rachel's Delight.",
      "research_note": "These records form a coherent household and land network, but the original baptism and deeds have not been inspected here. John's birth, death, parents, and origin remain unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1685,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1713,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "G27_FRANCES_MCELROY_MOTHER_RACHEL_1713",
      "name": "Frances McElroy (maiden name unknown)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McElroy",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "reported Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
        "SRC_MCELROY_COMPILED_PEDIGREE_CONFLICT_20260730",
        "SRC_OT26_STALEY_DURHAM_1696_WILL",
        "SRC_OT26_MSA_THOMAS_STALEY_BIO",
        "SRC_OT26_MCELROY_FRANCES_DURHAM_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_MCELROY_BALTIMORE_COLONIAL_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "A published transcription calls Frances McElroy the mother of Rachel McElroy, born in 1713. Thomas Staley's 1696 will independently names James Durham as son-in-law and Mary and James as grandchildren; a legislative biography reports a 1697 land gift to James. Staley's public offices add no weight to the relationship.",
      "research_note": "No original baptism image, marriage, maiden surname, dates, or parents have been inspected. Reassessment 16 September 2026: the Durham surname and James Durham/Staley parent hypothesis now have a concrete family to investigate. H1 is the McElroy mother identified by the transcription; alternatives are another Frances, a transcription error, or an undocumented maiden-family identity. A copied claim calling her Frances Durham is not adopted because the reviewed record-based transcription supplies no surname beyond McElroy. Frances is not identified in these sources. The copied Frances Durham claim and possible James Durham/Staley connection remain explicit candidates only; the 1696 Staley will and 1697 land evidence do not name Frances. Frances McElroy is named as Rachel McElroy’s mother in a published transcription, with a reported Baltimore County colonial Maryland setting, but no birth, marriage, maiden surname, death, parents, or original baptism image has been inspected. Her omission is not evidence against the link. Keep parentage unresolved and trace the land; see RN_OT26_FRANCES_DURHAM_STALEY_CANDIDATE. No new parent edge is added.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1685,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1713,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ANN_GREEN_WIFE_SAMUEL_MORRALL_LAWLEY",
      "name": "Ann Green",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Green",
      "birth_date": "about 1789",
      "birth_place": "reported Shropshire, England",
      "death_date": "reported 27 Dec 1866",
      "death_place": "reported Shropshire, England",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTSCHAT_SAMUEL_ANN_MORRALL_LAWLEY_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "A community transcription reports Ann Green's 14 Apr 1806 marriage to Samuel Morrall at Dawley Magna, then the Lawley/Wellington household that baptised Richard and Adam in 1813. Ann is retained as the most likely mother of the direct Richard, not as a proven identification. It also reports a 27 Dec 1866 burial at a locality transcribed as Horsely Common; that spelling and the original entry have not yet been checked. It also reports a 27 Dec 1866 burial at a locality transcribed as Horsely Common; that spelling and the original entry have not yet been checked. It also reports a 27 Dec 1866 burial at a locality transcribed as Horsely Common; that spelling and the original entry have not yet been checked.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "name": "Matthäus Uhland, parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Uhland",
      "birth_date": "reported 28 Dec 1690",
      "birth_place": "reported Dannstadt, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "death_date": "reported 1751",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEWLAND_UHLAND_MUNTZ_COMPILED_CANDIDATE_20260730",
        "SRC_NEWLAND_HOPE_PASSENGER_1734",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_JOHN_NEWLAND_ANCESTRY_UNKNOWN_REVIEW",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "A derivative tree proposes Matthäus Uhland as John Newland's father. A passenger-list analysis instead finds Johan Nouland outside the separately identified Palatine group, so a non-Palatine or English origin remains a meaningful alternative. This candidate is displayed at low confidence for comparison, not as established ancestry. The surname is compatible with Johann Ulandt in John's documented 1739 marriage, and the reported dates permit the relationship. No parish, probate, migration, or other record identifies this man as the 1734 passenger or as John's father.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_ANNA_CATHARINA_MUENTZ_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "name": "Anna Catharina Müntz, parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Müntz",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1680",
      "birth_place": "Wassenach proposed in compiled pedigree; identity with Schauernheim bride unresolved",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEWLAND_UHLAND_MUNTZ_COMPILED_CANDIDATE_20260730",
        "SRC_NEWLAND_HOPE_PASSENGER_1734",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_JOHN_NEWLAND_ANCESTRY_UNKNOWN_REVIEW",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG719"
      ],
      "source_note": "It separately lists Johannes Uhland baptised in 1716.",
      "research_note": "A derivative tree proposes Anna Catharina Müntz as John Newland's mother and as Matthäus Uhland's wife. The reported age is chronologically possible, but no located parish, marriage, probate, migration, or parent-identifying record connects her to John. The candidate stays visible at low confidence because it is the only detailed parent hypothesis found, while the passenger and marriage records leave John's European origin unresolved. Further review: the compiler assigns her a Wassenach baptism on 1 January 1680 and a Schauernheim marriage in 1714. No original parish record has yet resolved them. The prior reported Dannstadt birthplace was not established and is replaced with this qualified locality. Her existing candidate link to John is retained; newly represented Wassenach parentage is independently labelled uncertain. These dates raise a real question about identification with John Newland, reported born 1710; a mistaken age, premarital child, duplicate or misattached descendant remain alternatives.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_HANNAH_LISTER_BATLEY_1748",
      "name": "Hannah Lister",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lister",
      "birth_date": "baptised 1 Jan 1747/48",
      "birth_place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_ancestor",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_BATLEY_BAPTISM_1773",
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_HANNAH_FAMILY_RECONSTRUCTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hannah is named as mother in the 1773 Batley baptism of Thomas Lister.",
      "research_note": "She is therefore displayed as a candidate ancestor, not a settled mother. A separately published Batley reconstruction, drawing on All Saints microfiches, identifies the same mother and a sibling group. This establishes a real Batley mother-and-child record, but not yet that the child was the Thomas who married Ann Marshall at South Kirkby in 1799.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_GEORGE_LISTER_BATLEY_1705",
      "name": "George Lister",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lister",
      "birth_date": "baptised 30 Jun 1705",
      "birth_place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_HANNAH_FAMILY_RECONSTRUCTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The report gives a specific parish-record basis, but the original image has not been inspected here. The Batley reconstruction identifies George Lister, baptised in 1705, and Grace Hudson as Hannah Lister's parents. He is a conditional extension of the Thomas Lister childhood hypothesis, not independently established ancestry. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1747,
          "confidence": 0.598,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_GRACE_HUDSON_WIFE_GEORGE_LISTER",
      "name": "Grace Hudson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hudson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": "buried Jul 1796",
      "death_place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_HANNAH_FAMILY_RECONSTRUCTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "It is retained as a conditional, sourced candidate rather than independently established ancestry until the underlying parish entries are reviewed. The Batley reconstruction identifies Grace Hudson as George Lister's wife and Hannah Lister's mother, and reports her 1796 burial. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1719,
          "confidence": 0.598,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_WILLIAM_LISTER_BATLEY_1671",
      "name": "William Lister",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lister",
      "birth_date": "baptised 25 Jun 1671",
      "birth_place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_WILLIAM_GEORGE_BAPTISMS_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "A published Batley reconstruction reports William's 1671 baptism and a three-child family in which George was baptised in 1705. The repeated local child cluster supports this as the likely William named as George's father, but the underlying register image has not yet been reviewed. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1705,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_JOHN_LISTER_BATLEY_MARRIED_1670",
      "name": "John Lister",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lister",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_JOHN_JANE_WILLIAM_1670_1676_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The documented local family cluster makes this the likely parent of the already-connected William Lister, while the unviewed original register keeps the identification at candidate confidence. A published Batley reconstruction reports John’s 1670 marriage to Jane Tingle and the 1671, 1673, and 1675/76 baptisms of their children. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1643,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1671,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_JANE_TINGLE_BATLEY_1638",
      "name": "Jane Tingle",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Tingle",
      "birth_date": "baptised 11 Nov 1638",
      "birth_place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_JOHN_JANE_WILLIAM_1670_1676_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "A published Batley reconstruction reports Jane’s 1638 baptism, her 1670 marriage to John Lister, and the 1671, 1673, and 1675/76 baptisms of their children. The original parish images have not yet been reviewed. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1671,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_ALVEREY_TINGLE_BATLEY_1666",
      "name": "Alverey Tingle",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Tingle",
      "birth_date": "before 1607",
      "birth_place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_ALVEREY_TINGLE_HEARTH_AND_CHILD_CLUSTER_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Alverey Tingle was recorded with two hearths in Batley in 1666.",
      "research_note": "The published Batley reconstruction reports this tax appearance. His birth is only inferred as before the reported 1627 child; the tax appearance is stronger than the reconstructed parent-child links.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1638,
          "confidence": 0.49,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_WILLIAM_PICKIN_WHITMORE_1756",
      "name": "William Pickin, Whitmore baptism father",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Pickin",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 11 January 1756 Whitmore baptism transcript calls William Pickin the father of Elizabeth.",
      "research_note": "This profile represents that recorded father, not a proven identification with the Forton bride's father.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.478,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Grindley",
          "descendant_id": "I155",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_SARAH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_1756",
      "name": "Sarah Pickin, Whitmore baptism mother",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Pickin",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 11 January 1756 Whitmore baptism transcript calls Sarah Pickin the mother of Elizabeth.",
      "research_note": "Her maiden surname and her identity outside that baptismal household are not established.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.478,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Grindley",
          "descendant_id": "I155",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_DAVID_PRICE_FATHER_KEZIA_LISTER",
      "name": "David Price, claimed father of Kezia Price",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Price",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "He is retained as the leading named candidate for Kezia's father, not as established ancestry. The supplied Gamble family-tree comparison calls David Price the father of Kezia Price. It gives no date, locality, occupation, marriage record, or contemporary parent-child document for David.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Montgomeryshire, Wales",
          "confidence": 0.42,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Kezia Price Lister",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_ELIZABETH_LAMBE_MOTHER_KEZIA_LISTER",
      "name": "Elizabeth Lambe, claimed mother of Kezia Price",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lambe",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "She is retained as the leading named candidate for Kezia's mother, not as established ancestry. The supplied Gamble family-tree comparison calls Elizabeth Lambe the mother of Kezia Price. It gives no date, locality, maiden-name proof, marriage record, or contemporary parent-child document for Elizabeth. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Montgomeryshire, Wales",
          "confidence": 0.42,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Kezia Price Lister",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_ARCHIBALD_MCELROY_PARENT_JOHN_1690",
      "name": "Archibald McElroy, claimed father of John",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McElroy",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_COMPILED_PEDIGREE_CONFLICT_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "One compiled online pedigree calls an Archibald McElroy the father of the Baltimore County John McElroy who was later associated with Rachel McElroy and the Felps family. Archibald is shown only as the leading named candidate (ordinal score 0.12), not as established ancestry. Its reported Irish origin and dates are not retained because the tree conflicts with itself. It gives no parish, probate, deed, immigration, or other record linking the men.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.12,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John McElroy",
          "descendant_id": "G27_JOHN_MCELROY_FATHER_RACHEL_1713",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_RACHEL_DURHAM_MOTHER_JOHN_1690",
      "name": "Rachel Durham, claimed mother of John",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Durham",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_COMPILED_PEDIGREE_CONFLICT_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "A compiled pedigree names Rachel Durham as John McElroy’s mother but supplies no contemporary record connecting them. Related pages vary in dates and in the identity of John’s wife, leaving possible confusion between generations. Rachel remains a named comparison candidate at ordinal score 0.12; this is not a calibrated percentage. Her dates, birthplace and parents remain unestablished. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.12,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John McElroy",
          "descendant_id": "G27_JOHN_MCELROY_FATHER_RACHEL_1713",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_THOMAS_SHAW_PARENT_RALPH_1628",
      "name": "Thomas Shaw, claimed father of Ralph",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Shaw",
      "birth_date": "reported 1628",
      "birth_place": "reported Lancashire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW"
      ],
      "source_note": "Its placement of the claimed 1645 Ralph birth in Prince George’s County is anachronistic because that county was created in 1696.",
      "research_note": "A derivative Southern Maryland family history calls Thomas Shaw, born in England in 1628 and associated with “County Lancaster,” the father of Ralph Shaw. Thomas is retained only as the sole named lead; an unidentified parent or a different Shaw household remains much more likely. It gives no parish, will, land, migration, probate, spouse, or other source connecting the two.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_BENJAMIN_HODNETT_PARENT_GEORGE_ODNETT_1787",
      "name": "Benjamin Hodnett, possible father of George Odnett",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hodnett",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_identity",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_DIDDLEBURY_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_ANN_MOUND_LUDLOW_MARRIAGE_1804"
      ],
      "source_note": "Benjamin Hodnett is named as father of George Hodnett in a 1787 Diddlebury baptism. The bridge is still indirect.",
      "research_note": "Sarah's 1811 baptism names only Mary Poyner, and the candidate George married Ann Mound/Munn in 1804. Benjamin is therefore displayed as a low-confidence candidate rather than an established ancestor. The competing explanation is an unrecorded or social father named George Odnett. That George is a plausible identity for the George Odnett whom Sarah Poyner named as her father in 1852: the uncommon surname, a compatible age, and the Diddlebury-Ludlow-Stoke St Milborough area fit.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ludlow, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.312,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Sarah Maria Poyner",
          "descendant_id": "I140",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "CANDIDATE_MARTHA_HODNETT_MOTHER_GEORGE_ODNETT_1787",
      "name": "Martha Hodnett, possible mother of George Odnett",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hodnett",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_identity",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_DIDDLEBURY_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_ANN_MOUND_LUDLOW_MARRIAGE_1804"
      ],
      "source_note": "Martha Hodnett is named as mother of George Hodnett in a 1787 Diddlebury baptism. The bridge is still indirect.",
      "research_note": "Sarah's 1811 baptism names only Mary Poyner, and the candidate George married Ann Mound/Munn in 1804. Martha is therefore displayed as a low-confidence candidate rather than an established ancestor. The competing explanation is an unrecorded or social father named George Odnett. That George is a plausible identity for the George Odnett whom Sarah Poyner named as her father in 1852: the uncommon surname, a compatible age, and the Diddlebury-Ludlow-Stoke St Milborough area fit.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ludlow, Shropshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.312,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Sarah Maria Poyner",
          "descendant_id": "I140",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ABRAHAM_FATHER_ROSALIA_MAYER_1777",
      "name": "Abraham (surname unknown)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_name_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "An 1808 Oberlustadt Jewish name-adoption list records Rosalia Mayer as “Roesel b Abraham,” while calling her Salomon Frank's wife. In the same list, the form “b [given name]” is used for children of either sex, including a minor daughter.",
      "research_note": "It is strong evidence that Rosalia's father was named Abraham. The record does not give his surname, age, birthplace, residence, wife, or death details, so he is deliberately not merged with any other Abraham.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
          "confidence": 0.95,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Rosalia (Meier) Mayer",
          "descendant_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1749,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
          "place_confidence": 0.95,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Rosalia (Meier) Mayer"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1777,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ATHEY_JOHN_FATHER_THOMAS1717_20260730",
      "name": "John Athey (Athy)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Athey",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1675-1680",
      "birth_place": "reported Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "reported 21 Feb 1729/30 (Julian)",
      "death_place": "reported Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_PARENTAGE_RECONCILIATION_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1932_JOHN_INVENTORY_PARENTAGE_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Athey is the documented father of Thomas Athey born in 1717. This creates a coherent, record-based Maryland household.",
      "research_note": "The published Athey study reports that the 1710 inventory of Captain George Athey's estate was attested by widow Sarah and son John, then traces John's 1711 marriage to Margaret Lewis and 1729/30 inventory naming sons Thomas and George. John's exact birth date and the reported Charles County birth remain estimates.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ATHEY_MARGARET_LEWIS_MOTHER_THOMAS1717_20260730",
      "name": "Margaret Lewis (Lewes)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lewis",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1692-1694",
      "birth_place": "reported Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "death_date": "after 21 Feb 1729/30 (Julian)",
      "death_place": "reported Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_PARENTAGE_RECONCILIATION_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1932_JOHN_INVENTORY_PARENTAGE_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The reported birth range and later death claims are compiled; her only securely bounded life event here is the marriage and presence in the inventory. Margaret Lewis, also spelled Lewes, is reported as John Athey's wife in the 4 June 1711 St John's Parish marriage and as his surviving wife in the 1729/30 inventory. The focused Athey reconstruction makes her mother of Thomas born in 1717. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ATHEY_CAPTAIN_GEORGE_1642_1710_20260730",
      "name": "Captain George Athy (Athey)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Athey",
      "birth_date": "reported 1642",
      "birth_place": "reported Galway, County Galway, Ireland",
      "death_date": "by 7 Mar 1709/10 (Julian)",
      "death_place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1932_JOHN_INVENTORY_PARENTAGE_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Captain George Athy is the documented early Maryland head of this Athey household. It reports that his estate inventory was attested in 1710 by his wife Sarah and son John. That makes the Maryland father-son connection strong.",
      "research_note": "A published Athey study identifies him in 1663-68 service and land-right records, later Charles and Prince George's County land and parish activity, and the 1696 Prince George's County militia appointment. His reported 1642 Galway birth and parentage in the Irish Athy family remain a separate, lower-confidence reconstruction and are not used to extend this tree.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ATHEY_ANN_FIRST_WIFE_GEORGE_20260730",
      "name": "Ann, first wife of George Athey (surname unknown)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "before 1686",
      "death_place": "reported Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The focused Athey study treats George's first wife's given name, Ann, as established but rejects the frequently copied maiden name Moorewood: the cited 1675 land warrant only shows that Ann Moorewood had been transported by an earlier assignee, not that she married George. Ann is therefore retained by given name only; no maiden name or parents are claimed. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1647,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "reported Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "Ann, first wife of George Athey (surname unknown)"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_1612_1666_20260730",
      "name": "Francis Athy",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Athy",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1612-1615",
      "birth_place": "Galway, County Galway, Ireland",
      "death_date": "reported before 1666",
      "death_place": "reported Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_IDENTIFICATION_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Francis Athy is a documented member of the Galway Athy community: independent published local history identifies him as Sheriff of Galway in 1639, and the specialised Athey history also places him in municipal office.",
      "research_note": "His proposed relationship to the Maryland Captain George is shown separately as a low-confidence circumstantial hypothesis, not as a proven fact. Reported birth, death, spouse, and descent details come from the later reconstruction.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "R26_CATHERINE_QUEEN_BOWLING",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R26_FRANCIS_QUEEN",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
      "name": "Thomas Semmes",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Semmes",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
      "death_date": "by May 1832; 1827 also reported",
      "death_place": "Wilkes County, Georgia",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MSA_SEMMES_PARENTAGE",
        "ROOTS26_SEMMES_PROBATE_STAGES",
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES52"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas is identified by his wife Anne Queen and the matching children. The legislative biography gives Maryland probate 13 July 1827; Newman gives 25 May 1832. The Wilkes abstract separates handwriting testimony in 1827, Maryland admission 29 May 1832 and Georgia recording 1 January 1834.",
      "research_note": "This favors differing procedural dates over two different men, but does not establish an exact death date. The earlier 1827 attribution is retained as disputed; May 1832 is the conservative latest limit pending original-record inspection.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1729,
          "confidence": 0.527,
          "basis": "estimated from known parent birth year(s)"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "R26_MARY_JAMESON_SR_D1755",
      "name": "Mary Jameson Sr. (maiden name unproven)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Jameson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "between 28 May and 20 Dec 1755",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Added 15 September 2026. Charles County testator.",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "confidence": 0.081,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
          "distance": 5
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1676,
          "confidence": 0.684,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, United States",
          "place_confidence": 0.081,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "R26_THOMAS_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R26_JOSEPH_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R26_BENJAMIN_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R26_ELIZABETH_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R26_MARTHA_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R26_ANN_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "GB26_HANS_JACOB_GOEBEL_1689",
      "name": "Hans Jacob Göbel",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Göbel",
      "birth_date": "7 Sep 1689",
      "birth_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "death_date": "3 Oct 1775",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel printed p.55, ancestors 322/323; marriage 2 November 1711 in Erpfingen. This household is distinct from Hans Jacob Gabel and Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller at Offenbach am Glan. Original registers would refine certainty.",
      "research_note": "H1 distinct households best explains chronology and spouses; H2 same people requires multiple substantial errors.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "GB26_ANNA_MARIA_SCHWEICKHARD_1686",
      "name": "Anna Maria Schweickhard",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schweickhard",
      "birth_date": "22 Apr 1686",
      "birth_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "death_date": "10 Nov 1754",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel printed p.55, ancestors 322/323; marriage 2 November 1711 in Erpfingen. This household is distinct from Hans Jacob Gabel and Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller at Offenbach am Glan. Original registers would refine certainty.",
      "research_note": "H1 distinct households best explains chronology and spouses; H2 same people requires multiple substantial errors.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "BR26_JAMES_SILVESTER_RANTON_TESTATOR",
      "name": "James Silvester of Lomcompton, Ranton",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Silvester",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "before 8 Feb 1776",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Will dated 18 January 1769 and proved 8 February 1776 names wife Sarah, sons and John Brassington as son-in-law. The original probate packet would test wording and identities.",
      "research_note": "Do not automatically equate him with the compiled James baptised in 1689, or attach that man’s parents, without identity evidence. This testator probably fathered Jane Silvester, the 1761 Stafford bride of John; see .88 parent hypothesis.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.876,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Brassington",
          "descendant_id": "I196",
          "distance": 2
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1708,
          "confidence": 0.454,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.876,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "John Brassington"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "BR26_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_1781",
      "name": "Joseph Brassington (Ranton, baptised 1781)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "baptised 25 Jul 1781",
      "birth_place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Separate from I151, baptised in 1787 to John and Margaret.",
      "research_note": "H1 two Josephs best fits two parental couples; do not merge by surname/locality. The Ranton reconstruction places this Joseph among elder John and Jane’s children and the father’s 1805 will names son Joseph. This older Joseph is age-compatible with a reported 1801 Sarah Cope marriage, but that marriage is not attached without identity evidence.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_PETER_GUISE_ROCKINGHAM",
      "name": "Peter Guise (proposed father of Sarah Gise)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Guise",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "BEF 26 Nov 1782",
      "death_place": "Rockingham County, Virginia (probate jurisdiction; death location unconfirmed)",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_GOBLE_GUISE_PARENTS",
        "SRC_OT26_PETER_GUISE_PROBATE_1782"
      ],
      "source_note": "No older German/French parentage adopted. Those extensions require separate testing. Original court entry verified16September2026: will proved25November1782, John Guise executor. Peter therefore died by25November; exact death date and place not stated. See RN_OT26_PETER_GUISE_ORIGINAL_PROBATE.",
      "research_note": "H1: Sarah Gise, wife of Christian Gobble, is a daughter of Peter Guise and Ottilia. H2: the association genealogy attached Sarah to a different Guise family (hypothetical error; no named competing Sarah with the same spouse found). H1 is the leading named parent hypothesis, provisionally retained at ordinal 0.55 for each parent; this is not a calibrated probability. John Guice W4686 independently supplies compatible Frederick Maryland–Rockingham Virginia–Georgia family movement, but does not identify Sarah or name his parents, so it is contextual rather than independent parentage evidence. Same-site family pages and later trees may be dependent. FamilySearch LVQ7-GQG assigns French Gaseau/Forest parents to a Palatine birthplace without an exposed bridge; Ancestry’s Kuffer mother reconstruction assigns a 1722-born mother to a 1730-born daughter, an actual chronology conflict. The minute does not name heirs or wife and does not call John a son. The explicit daughter/spouse placement is positive evidence. Do not infer from an absent sister in an incomplete child list that she was not a sibling. Next discriminator: Peter’s estate or a church/land record naming Sarah as daughter or Gobble as son-in-law; compare John Guice and Christian Gobble complete pension files and Frederick church registers.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_OTTILIA_GUISE",
      "name": "Ottilia (surname unknown, proposed mother of Sarah Gise)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": "reported Lincoln County, Georgia",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_GOBLE_GUISE_PARENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No older German/French parentage adopted. Those extensions require separate testing.",
      "research_note": "H1: Sarah Gise, wife of Christian Gobble, is a daughter of Peter Guise and Ottilia. H2: the association genealogy attached Sarah to a different Guise family (hypothetical error; no named competing Sarah with the same spouse found). H1 is the leading named parent hypothesis, provisionally retained at ordinal 0.55 for each parent; this is not a calibrated probability. John Guice W4686 independently supplies compatible Frederick Maryland–Rockingham Virginia–Georgia family movement, but does not identify Sarah or name his parents, so it is contextual rather than independent parentage evidence. Same-site family pages and later trees may be dependent. FamilySearch LVQ7-GQG assigns French Gaseau/Forest parents to a Palatine birthplace without an exposed bridge; Ancestry’s Kuffer mother reconstruction assigns a 1722-born mother to a 1730-born daughter, an actual chronology conflict. The explicit daughter/spouse placement is positive evidence. Do not infer from an absent sister in an incomplete child list that she was not a sibling. Next discriminator: Peter’s estate or a church/land record naming Sarah as daughter or Gobble as son-in-law; compare John Guice and Christian Gobble complete pension files and Frederick church registers.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_BRYAN_MCDONNEL_NEWCASTLE_1707",
      "name": "Bryan McDonnel (New Castle testator, 1707)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "McDonnel",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1707 (probate year as published)",
      "death_place": "New Castle County, Delaware (estate jurisdiction)",
      "status": "supported_documentary",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_MCDONNEL_CALENDAR_1707",
        "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_FRANK_1879"
      ],
      "source_note": "New Castle will calendar B:153 names wife Mary, sons John, William, James, Bryan and Richard, and daughters Mary Dangor and Anable. The 1746/47 deed Q:221 expressly identifies Bryan junior as his son and recites inheritance of the plantation. Identification of junior with Virginia Bryan, husband of Catherine, is strongly favored but inferential; parent edge 0.82. See RN_OT26_MCDONALD_DELAWARE_VIRGINIA_BRIDGE.",
      "research_note": "Dates printed 23 February and 19 March 1707; calendar style not independently resolved. No precise birth, birthplace, wife’s maiden name, officer rank or Glencoe/Irish dynastic ancestry established.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1658,
          "confidence": 0.59,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "New Castle County, Delaware (estate jurisdiction)",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "Bryan McDonnel (New Castle testator, 1707)"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_JOHANN_MICHAEL_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "name": "Johann Michael Weigele (immigrant identity unresolved)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Weigele",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_GEORGE",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED",
        "SRC_OT26_SALFORD_LANDHOLDERS_1734",
        "SRC_OT26_HARLE_WEICKEL_1736",
        "SRC_OT26_HARLE_TRANSCRIPTION_WEYGELL"
      ],
      "source_note": "Father of Georg and Catharina in the matched Goshenhoppen/Rhinebeck family. The Bonfeld migrant married in New York in 1710 is the leading immigrant identification: Catharina’s 1727 marriage names her father in Pennsylvania, followed by the 1734 Salford Wagly landholding. See RN_ROOTS_WEIGELE_BONFELD_20260919.",
      "research_note": "Exact immigrant birth and death dates remain unverified. The Harle 1736 passenger is a documented alternative, but identifying him requires return travel or an error in one attachment. The older Bonfeld Michael is now represented as a .55 father candidate from Jones’s reproduced research.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "confidence": 0.509,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Gobble",
          "descendant_id": "I86",
          "distance": 3
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1686,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "place_confidence": 0.509,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "John Gobble"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1714,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_ANNA_MARIA_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "name": "Anna Maria (wife of Johann Michael Weigele)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_GEORGE",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named mother of Georg. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION.",
      "research_note": "Identification with Anna Maria widow of Conrad Hartman in New York 1710 remains unresolved. Do not equate relationship support with immigrant identity support. Maiden surname unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "confidence": 0.496,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Gobble",
          "descendant_id": "I86",
          "distance": 3
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1686,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "place_confidence": 0.496,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "John Gobble"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1714,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_ABRAHAM_DITLOH",
      "name": "Abraham Ditloh",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Ditloh",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED",
        "SRC_OT26_SALFORD_LANDHOLDERS_1734"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named father of Anna Marg. Ditloh, wife of Georg Weigele; Reformed, associated with Gross Schwam in IPGV card. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION. Published1734 Salford returns name Abraham Titloe with50 acres in same township as Hance Michael Wagly100. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_SALFORD_VS_HARLE.",
      "research_note": "Matching name and in-law geographic context support candidate identity; list does not name relatives. Vital dates and German origin unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "confidence": 0.509,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Gobble",
          "descendant_id": "I86",
          "distance": 3
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1690,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "place_confidence": 0.509,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "John Gobble"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1718,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_ANNA_MARGARETH_DITLOH_WIFE",
      "name": "Anna Margareth (wife of Abraham Ditloh)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named mother of Anna Marg. Ditloh in institutional pedigree and manuscript-specific Jones account. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION.",
      "research_note": "Birth surname and vital dates unknown; Ditloh is married surname only.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "confidence": 0.496,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Gobble",
          "descendant_id": "I86",
          "distance": 3
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1690,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "place_confidence": 0.496,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "John Gobble"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1718,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_CATHRINE_WEGLER_ZIPPERLE",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_FRIEDRICH_ZIPPERLE_RHINEBECK",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_WILLIAM_FYNNEY_ALTON",
      "name": "William Fynney",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fynney",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_HELEN_FYNNEY_ALTON_1803",
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_SALT_ROCESTER_1795",
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_ALTON_FAMILY_BAPTISMS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named parent of Helen Fynney baptized10April1803 Alton St Peter. See RN_OT26_FINNEY_ALTON_PARENT_EXTENSION. Alton family sequence includes John1799, Helen1803, Amy1804, Charles1809 and Frederick1814; the last names William a joiner. Joseph1796William/Eleanor is a tentative additional child.",
      "research_note": "Probable connection to Ellen/Helen Waterhouse rests on matching name, Alton birthplace in1861 and earlier census ages. Probable identification with William Finney who married Ellen Salt at Rocester8December1795; see RN_OT26_FINNEY_SALT_FAMILY_COMPARISON. No parental birth/death particulars established. No parental birth/death dates established.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Alton, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Ellen Helen Finney",
          "descendant_id": "I146",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1775,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Alton, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.8,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Ellen Helen Finney"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1803,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_HELLEN_MOTHER_HELEN_FYNNEY",
      "name": "Hellen (probably Ellen Salt)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Salt",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_HELEN_FYNNEY_ALTON_1803",
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_SALT_ROCESTER_1795",
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_ALTON_FAMILY_BAPTISMS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Alton baptisms record children of William and Ellen/Hellen from John in 1799 through Frederick in 1814; a more tentative 1796 entry names William and Eleanor. Frederick's father was a joiner.",
      "research_note": "H1: Hellen, mother of Helen Fynney baptized at Alton in1803, is Ellen Salt who married William Finney at Rocester on8December1795. H2: the Rocester spouses and Alton parents are two different William-and-Ellen/Hellen couples. H2 remains possible and is not zero simply because no second couple is known. H3: remarriage or a transcription error breaks the proposed continuity. No collateral children added to the graph this pass; the six-event family reconstruction is saved for future bridge checks. The1795marriage directly names William Finney bachelor and Ellen Salt spinster. This locally concentrated spouse-name pair and chronologically coherent sequence after1795 favors H1 over an unrecorded second matching couple; a near-birth1796baptism would place the first recorded child within seven months of marriage but is not an impossible chronology or evidence of a different couple. Baptism dates do not establish conception or exact birth. Rocester and Alton are distinct nearby localities, not an exact parish match; neither marriage nor inspected baptism entries explicitly links the two places. Actual William/Catherine entries at Alton in1797and1800 demonstrate another spouse-name cluster and caution against treating all William Finneys as one; they do not by themselves explain the recurring Ellen/Hellen cluster better than H1. This does not raise the separate0.80Ellen-child-to-adult parent links, nor imply independent probabilities or multiply them. Next discriminating evidence: original1795marriage witnesses/residences, Alton family burial/census records, and sibling marriage/family associations. Do not treat the family's common trade or reuse of Frederick as proof of kinship; those may guide searches. The baptism sequence and marriage identification support recording Salt as a probable maiden surname and the 1795 spousal identification at ordinal 0.80. No earlier parental generation for either spouse is established. H3 lacks a located death or remarriage record. The 1841, 1851, and 1861 Ellen Waterhouse identity still carries the recorded age discrepancy. The provisional surname is retained in the display name and notes.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Alton, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Ellen Helen Finney",
          "descendant_id": "I146",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1775,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Alton, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.8,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Ellen Helen Finney"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1803,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_THOMAS_BUTT_BURGESS",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FENTON_FATHER_HANNA_1674",
      "name": "William Fenton",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fenton",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
        "SRC_ROOTS_STIRNET_FENTON_HANDLEY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as Hanna’s father in the Sheffield baptism entry of 27 June 1674. The exact date, name and parish match Hanna’s existing profile.",
      "research_note": "His own baptism, marriage and parents remain unresolved. A compiled Handley pedigree independently reports her father as William, although dependence on the same parish evidence is possible.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Hanna Fenton",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1646,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.85,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Hanna Fenton"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1674,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HENRY_AUSTEN_FATHER_MARIE_1646",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_BAGNOLD_FATHER_ISABEL_1601",
      "name": "Thomas Bagnold",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bagnold",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_TRENTHAM_BAPTISM_1601",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ATWOOD_BAGNALL_CANDIDATES"
      ],
      "source_note": "The saved baptism extract names Thomas Bagnold as father of Isabel baptized at Trentham on 15 February 1601. Exact daughtername, date andparish match the existing Isabel profile.",
      "research_note": "This person represents that named father; identification with the compiled Thomas James Bagnall 1559–1634 is a separate, unresolved hypothesis. AnotherThomas elsewhere does not contradict this father-naming record. No birthdate, wife or parents assigned from the fuller pedigree.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Isabel Bagnold",
          "descendant_id": "C_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_1601_WIFE_THOMAS_EMERYE",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1573,
          "confidence": 0.648,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
          "place_confidence": 0.9,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Isabel Bagnold"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1601,
          "confidence": 0.648,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARJORIE_WILLATT_CANDIDATE_ISABEL",
      "name": "Marjorie Willatt (candidate mother of Isabel)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Willatt",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_ATWOOD_MARJORIE_WILLATT_DETAIL"
      ],
      "source_note": "These matches support identifying the intended household.",
      "research_note": "Marjorie Willatt is the leading named mother candidate in the material reviewed. The compiled Isabell Bagnold entry matches the saved Trentham baptism and Emerye marriage by exact dates and names, and explicitly assigns Marjorie as mother. However, the same compilation includes another Isabell assigned to Brassington, with conflicting life events; the maternal assignment could be part of that conflated reconstruction. Marjorie’s maternity therefore remains low confidence at 0.35. A record of Thomas’s marriage and evidence allocating Isabel to that union could change the ranking. Neither an unrecorded alternative mother nor absent direct proof alone is treated as a contradiction. The reported 1589 marriage would precede the 1601 baptism by a compatible interval. This is an ordinal estimate, not a calibrated probability. The saved baptism names only father Thomas.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
          "confidence": 0.35,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Isabel Bagnold",
          "descendant_id": "C_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_1601_WIFE_THOMAS_EMERYE",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BERNHARD_ZIPPERLE_FATHER_FRIEDRICH",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MICHAEL_WAEGELIN_BONFELD_1700",
      "name": "Johann Michael Wägelin (Bonfeld father candidate)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wägelin",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_JONES_BONFELD_OLDER_MICHAEL",
        "SRC_ROOTS_BONFELD_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "His widow Agnes reportedly remarried 30 November 1700. Identified as the immigrant’s father in the reproduced Jones account.",
      "research_note": "Compatible name, locality and generation support the candidate; a relative or separate local household remains possible because the quoted passage does not reproduce a parent-naming entry. Reported Bonfeld citizen Johann Michael Wägelin, died 11 March 1700 aged 47. Dates remain reported in this note rather than assigned as verified vital facts.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
          "confidence": 0.28,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "John Gobble",
          "descendant_id": "I86",
          "distance": 4
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANS_KISSLING_PARENT_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Hans Kissling — parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Kissling",
      "birth_date": "reported 1600",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 1680",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DELAFUENTE"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No independent rival parental couple is identified. Proposed father of Anna Kissling in the DeLaFuente pedigree. That is positive evidence for the proposed couple. A mistaken maternal attachment remains plausible: the page gives no parent-naming event for Anna and its neighboring Göbel ancestry conflicts with the parish-based reconstruction. The pedigree explicitly assigns these parents to Anna in the matching Martin Göbel household, with compatible reported generations. The score is a low ordinal research judgment, not a calibrated probability. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Willmandingen, Wurttemberg",
          "confidence": 0.15,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Anna Kissling",
          "descendant_id": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANNA_MARIA_KISSLING_PARENT_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Anna Maria (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": "reported 1602",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DELAFUENTE"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No independent rival parental couple is identified. Proposed mother of Anna Kissling in the DeLaFuente pedigree. That is positive evidence for the proposed couple. A mistaken maternal attachment remains plausible: the page gives no parent-naming event for Anna and its neighboring Göbel ancestry conflicts with the parish-based reconstruction. The pedigree explicitly assigns these parents to Anna in the matching Martin Göbel household, with compatible reported generations. The score is a low ordinal research judgment, not a calibrated probability. The source label Umn is preserved in the source audit, not treated as a proven surname. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Willmandingen, Wurttemberg",
          "confidence": 0.15,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Anna Kissling",
          "descendant_id": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MATTHIAS_MUNTZ_WASSENACH",
      "name": "Matthias Muntz — parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Muntz",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported March 1699",
      "death_place": "reported Wassenach, Rhineland",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG719"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original baptism and marriage have not been examined; the uncertainty concerns that identification as well as the uncited pedigree. The explicit compiled identification of the named daughter, parental couple and plausible generation makes this the leading located parent proposal. Its Wassenach-to-Schauernheim identification could nevertheless attach a baptism to a different Anna Catharina. The score is an ordinal research judgment, not a measured probability. No independently documented rival couple has been identified.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_APOLLONIA_WASSENACH",
      "name": "Apollonia (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 3 February 1710",
      "death_place": "reported Wassenach, Rhineland",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG719"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The original baptism and marriage have not been examined; the uncertainty concerns that identification as well as the uncited pedigree. The explicit compiled identification of the named daughter, parental couple and plausible generation makes this the leading located parent proposal. Its Wassenach-to-Schauernheim identification could nevertheless attach a baptism to a different Anna Catharina. The score is an ordinal research judgment, not a measured probability. No independently documented rival couple has been identified.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HERMANN_MUNTZ_WASSENACH",
      "name": "Hermann Muntz — parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Muntz",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1606",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 23 May 1685",
      "death_place": "reported Wassenach, Rhineland",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG763"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The compiler expressly assigns Matthias to this named Wassenach household. The shared locality and compatible generation favor the proposed relationship over an unspecified alternative family. A mistaken household reconstruction remains possible; the compilation supplies no parent-naming record and its reciprocal entries are not independent evidence. This relationship is assessed separately from the uncertain American Newland connection. The score is an ordinal research judgment. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ELISABETH_WASSENACH",
      "name": "Elisabeth (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 19 May 1681",
      "death_place": "reported Wassenach, Rhineland",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG763"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The compiler expressly assigns Matthias to this named Wassenach household. The shared locality and compatible generation favor the proposed relationship over an unspecified alternative family. A mistaken household reconstruction remains possible; the compilation supplies no parent-naming record and its reciprocal entries are not independent evidence. This relationship is assessed separately from the uncertain American Newland connection. The score is an ordinal research judgment. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_FRIEDERICH_PARENT_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND",
      "name": "Friederich Uhland, parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Uhland",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_UHLAND_LANG718",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688"
      ],
      "source_note": "A baptism or marriage entry identifying the household would distinguish these explanations.",
      "research_note": "This specific claim makes the relationship the leading available candidate over an unidentified different parent. The entry supplies no record citation, dates or residence; a mistaken family assignment remains possible. The proposed relationship is separate from the unresolved identification of Matthäus as John Newland’s father. The Lang pedigree explicitly names Friederich as a parent of Matthäus Uhland (reported birth 28 December 1690).",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Dannstadt, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
          "confidence": 0.2,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Matthäus Uhland, parent candidate",
          "descendant_id": "CANDIDATE_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_EVA_MARIA_PARENT_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND",
      "name": "Eva Maria, parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_UHLAND_LANG718",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688"
      ],
      "source_note": "A baptism or marriage entry identifying the household would distinguish these explanations.",
      "research_note": "This specific claim makes the relationship the leading available candidate over an unidentified different parent. The entry supplies no record citation, dates or residence; a mistaken family assignment remains possible. The proposed relationship is separate from the unresolved identification of Matthäus as John Newland’s father. The Lang pedigree explicitly names Eva Maria as a parent of Matthäus Uhland (reported birth 28 December 1690).",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Dannstadt, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
          "confidence": 0.2,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Matthäus Uhland, parent candidate",
          "descendant_id": "CANDIDATE_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_646",
      "name": "Johannes Schweickhard",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schweickhard",
      "birth_date": "16 Sep 1643",
      "birth_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "death_date": "17 Jul 1694",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel 646 identifies Johannes as an Erpfingen judge. His stated age 51 at death is approximate: the listed dates place him shortly before 51.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_647",
      "name": "Maria Heniss (Hoeness)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Heniss",
      "birth_date": "1646",
      "birth_place": "Meidelstetten, Württemberg",
      "death_date": "27 Apr 1710",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel 647 identifies Maria through the marriage entry’s father Bernhard and place Meidelstetten, matching a 1646 baptism under Heniß. An ink blot obscures the marriage surname.",
      "research_note": "The reported death age 67 suggests about 1643; this modest discrepancy leaves some uncertainty but does not outweigh the combined name/father/place match.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_1292",
      "name": "Hans Schweickhard",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schweickhard",
      "birth_date": "Jun 1615",
      "birth_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "death_date": "26 Sep 1688",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel’s numbered pedigree identifies this person in a consistent Erpfingen household.",
      "research_note": "Dates remain those of the published reconstruction; original registers have not been independently examined.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_1293",
      "name": "Agnes (surname unknown)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "3 Dec 1653",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel 1293 reports Agnes’s burial in childbirth and her son Michael’s death on the same date.",
      "research_note": "Her birth surname is not supplied.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1615,
          "confidence": 0.648,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "Agnes (surname unknown)"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_1294",
      "name": "Bernhard Heniss (Hoeness)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Heniss",
      "birth_date": "calculated about 1605",
      "birth_place": "reported Meidelstetten, Württemberg",
      "death_date": "22 Nov 1680",
      "death_place": "Meidelstetten, Württemberg",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Weigel 1294 gives death 22 November and burial 24 November 1680; birth about 1605 is calculated from reported age 75. Heniß and Henus are reported record spellings. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_1295",
      "name": "Catharina (surname unknown)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": "about 1612",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel 1295 names Catharina in the 1633 marriage to Bernhard Heniß.",
      "research_note": "Her birth surname and death are unresolved; the author’s unsuccessful burial search is not proof that no record survives.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Meidelstetten, Württemberg",
          "confidence": 0.75,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Maria Heniss (Hoeness)",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_SW_647",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1646,
          "confidence": 0.54,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_2584",
      "name": "Matthäus Schweickhard",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schweickhard",
      "birth_date": "18 Jan 1595",
      "birth_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "death_date": "23 Jan 1673",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Matthäus was Erpfingen’s Schultheiß. His first wife Maria Lorch belongs to the family of Hans born 1615; his later wife Margaretha must not replace her as Hans’s mother.",
      "research_note": "Weigel 2584 explicitly cross-refers to 1462.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_2585",
      "name": "Maria Lorch",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lorch",
      "birth_date": "about 1595",
      "birth_place": "reported Hausen an der Lauchert, Württemberg",
      "death_date": "after 1635 and before 1644",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel’s numbered pedigree identifies this person in a consistent Erpfingen household.",
      "research_note": "Dates remain those of the published reconstruction; original registers have not been independently examined.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_2924",
      "name": "Martin Schweickhard (Jung Martin)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schweickhard",
      "birth_date": "about or before 1575",
      "birth_place": "reported Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel 2924 distinguishes Jung Martin from several contemporary Martins.",
      "research_note": "His burial cannot safely be assigned by name alone. The father candidate Alt Martin remains uncertain.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1595,
          "confidence": 0.648,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_2925",
      "name": "Anna Rümelin",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Rümelin",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "10 Jan 1611",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel 2925 reports Anna’s death as the wife of Jung Martin.",
      "research_note": "An origin in Ebingen is suggested with a question mark, not established. Jacob Rümelin was among the sponsors of her son Matthäus, a family-network clue without a demonstrated exact relationship.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1567,
          "confidence": 0.648,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "Anna Rümelin"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_5170",
      "name": "Michael Lorch",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lorch",
      "birth_date": "before 1570",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel 5170 identifies Michael at Hausen an der Lauchert and estimates birth before 1570. Maria’s 1612 marriage reportedly names him as her father.",
      "research_note": "Do not confuse him with Michael Lorch born 1610 in another generation.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Hausen an der Lauchert, Württemberg",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Maria Lorch",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_SW_2585",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1595,
          "confidence": 0.648,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_ALT_MARTIN",
      "name": "Martin Schweickhardt (Alt Martin)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Schweickhardt",
      "birth_date": "calculated about 1531",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "20 Dec 1611",
      "death_place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel 203 reports Alt Martin’s 1611 death at 80, yielding a calculated birth about 1531.",
      "research_note": "The possible fatherhood of Jung Martin is a separate low-confidence hypothesis, not established by the age label.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WALTER_ATHY_PARENT_FRANCIS",
      "name": "Walter Athy, parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Athy",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ATHY_GALWAY1999"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1999 account places Walter in possession in 1640.",
      "research_note": "The explicit father assignment and reported shared property context make Walter the leading named candidate. A compiler’s mistaken assignment of another Galway relative remains possible; the underlying succession record has not been checked.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Galway, County Galway, Ireland",
          "confidence": 0.3,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Francis Athy",
          "descendant_id": "C_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_1612_1666_20260730",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHN_ATHY_PARENT_WALTER",
      "name": "John Athy, parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Athy",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ATHY_GALWAY1999"
      ],
      "source_note": "An original deed naming the relationship would distinguish them. The 1999 account identifies John with a house dated 1577.",
      "research_note": "The alternative is a different relationship between successive owners or confusion between same-name households. The reported transfer from John to Walter supports the stated father–son relationship over an unidentified parent.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Galway, County Galway, Ireland",
          "confidence": 0.09,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Francis Athy",
          "descendant_id": "C_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_1612_1666_20260730",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARMADUKE_SEMMES_1701",
      "name": "Marmaduke Semmes",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Semmes",
      "birth_date": "1701",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1772",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MSA_SEMMES_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas’s matching wife Anne Queen anchors the household identification.",
      "research_note": "A mistaken assignment by the authors remains possible, but no competing household has been identified; this is the leading relationship. Original probate and property records could provide independent confirmation. The scholarly biography explicitly assigns this parent.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HENRIETTA_JENKINS",
      "name": "Henrietta Jenkins",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Jenkins",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MSA_SEMMES_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas’s matching wife Anne Queen anchors the household identification.",
      "research_note": "A mistaken assignment by the authors remains possible, but no competing household has been identified; this is the leading relationship. Original probate and property records could provide independent confirmation. The scholarly biography explicitly assigns this parent.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.85,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JAMES_SEMMES_1670",
      "name": "James Semmes",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Semmes",
      "birth_date": "about 1670",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "about 1727/28",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MSA_SEMMES_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas’s matching wife Anne Queen anchors the household identification.",
      "research_note": "A mistaken assignment by the authors remains possible, but no competing household has been identified; this is the leading relationship. Original probate and property records could provide independent confirmation. The scholarly biography explicitly assigns this parent.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.722,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARY_GOODRICK",
      "name": "Mary Goodrick",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Goodrick",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MSA_SEMMES_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas’s matching wife Anne Queen anchors the household identification.",
      "research_note": "A mistaken assignment by the authors remains possible, but no competing household has been identified; this is the leading relationship. Original probate and property records could provide independent confirmation. The scholarly biography explicitly assigns this parent.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.722,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 2
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1673,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "place_confidence": 0.722,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Thomas Semmes"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1701,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARMADUKE_SEMME_IMMIGRANT",
      "name": "Marmaduke Semme",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Semme",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "This ranks ahead of an unidentified alternative parent; a mistaken compiled relationship remains possible. Original family wills and property records would strengthen or revise the identification. Newman explicitly identifies this parent in the matching family. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.578,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 3
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1642,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "place_confidence": 0.578,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Thomas Semmes"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1670,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_FORTUNA_SEMME",
      "name": "Fortuna, wife of Marmaduke Semme",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "This ranks ahead of an unidentified alternative parent; a mistaken compiled relationship remains possible. Original family wills and property records would strengthen or revise the identification. Newman explicitly identifies this parent in the matching family. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.578,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 3
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1642,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "place_confidence": 0.578,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Thomas Semmes"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1670,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_GOODRICK",
      "name": "Robert Goodrick",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Goodrick",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "This ranks ahead of an unidentified alternative parent; a mistaken compiled relationship remains possible. Original family wills and property records would strengthen or revise the identification. Newman explicitly identifies this parent in the matching family. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.578,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GEORGE_JENKINS",
      "name": "George Jenkins",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Jenkins",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "This ranks ahead of an unidentified alternative parent; a mistaken compiled relationship remains possible. Original family wills and property records would strengthen or revise the identification. Newman explicitly identifies this parent in the matching family. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.68,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SUSANNAH_COLE",
      "name": "Susannah Cole",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Cole",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45",
        "ROOTS26_SUSANNAH_JENKINS_WILL"
      ],
      "source_note": "Newman identifies Henrietta’s mother as Susannah Cole, wife of George Jenkins. Susannah Jenkins’s will independently names daughter Heneritta Semmes and sons John, George and William.",
      "research_note": "The will does not itself give Susannah’s maiden surname; that identification still rests on the combined family evidence. The distinctive married daughter supports the same household over an unidentified namesake.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.68,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GEORGE_GOODRICK_1673",
      "name": "George Goodrick, will dated 1673",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Goodrick",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_WILL1673",
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "George’s Charles County will names a son Robert. The name, county and compatible generation favor identifying that son with Mary Goodrick’s father over an otherwise unidentified parent.",
      "research_note": "The will abstract does not name Mary, so the identification remains a candidate rather than an explicit three-generation pedigree. A different Robert in the county is a hypothetical alternative, not a documented contradiction. Tracing the sons’ inherited 600 acres could distinguish the households.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.318,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 4
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ELIZABETH_WIFE_ROBERT_GOODRICK",
      "name": "Elizabeth, wife of Robert Goodrick",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_RENO",
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "Its Anderson–Semmes marriage sequence matches Newman’s Mary, favoring the same woman.",
      "research_note": "A mistaken compiled maternal assignment remains possible because the underlying record has not been inspected. Elizabeth’s maiden name remains unknown; Clarkson has not been established by this evidence. The Reno-attributed marriage compilation explicitly names Mary’s parents as Robert and Elizabeth. No competing mother has been identified.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.469,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_EDWARD_COLE_WILL1717_PERSON",
      "name": "Edward Cole, will proved 1717",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Cole",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "by 20 December 1717",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_EDWARD_COLE_WILL1717",
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "This matches Susannah Cole’s married name in Newman’s identified Semmes household, favoring this father over an unidentified alternative. A different Susanna Jenkins is a possible identity alternative; none has been established here. Estate distributions or deeds naming her husband George would strengthen the identification. The date 1717 belongs to this testator; earlier online death 1716 is not adopted. The abstract also names Mary Jenkins, consistent with the reported marriages of Cole sisters into the Jenkins family, although that additional connection needs separate verification. Edward Cole’s 1717 will explicitly names a daughter Susanna Jenkins. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.51,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_JENKINS_1727",
      "name": "Thomas Jenkins, will proved 1727",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Jenkins",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "by 31 October 1727",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729",
        "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS279"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas’s will names son George alongside Edward and William. This matching household favors the published identification over a hypothetical different George.",
      "research_note": "The will abstract alone does not name George’s wife; deeds tracing Lindsey to George’s family would provide a stronger independent identity check. The 1918 history explicitly identifies Thomas as father of George, husband of Susannah Cole and father of Henrietta Semmes.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.544,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANN_WIFE_THOMAS_JENKINS",
      "name": "Ann, wife of Thomas Jenkins",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "by 3 December 1729",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729",
        "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS279"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas’s will names wife Ann; Ann’s own will names Edward, William and Mary Norris, also in Thomas’s family.",
      "research_note": "Together these favor the proposed mother, although George is not named in her abstract and an earlier wife remains a possible alternative. Spalding is reported as her maiden surname in the history but is not established by these wills; Thomas’s daughter Ann also bore that married surname. The 1918 history explicitly assigns Ann as George’s mother. No birth parents have yet been selected for Ann.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.476,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_ENSIGN",
      "name": "Robert Cole, ensign",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Cole",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Heston, Middlesex, England (reported)",
      "death_date": "by 29 March 1663",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_COLE_DEPOSITION1663",
        "ROOTS26_COLE_AMERICAN_ERAS"
      ],
      "source_note": "American Eras identifies this son as the planter and merchant who died in 1717, matching the Edward whose will names Susanna Jenkins.",
      "research_note": "That combined identification leads over a hypothetical second Edward; the remaining uncertainty is the connection between the child in 1663 and the adult testator, rather than what the deposition says about his parents. Probate and land records following Edward into adulthood would strengthen that connection. The 1663 testimony explicitly identifies Edward as a son of Robert and Rebecca Cole.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_WIFE_ROBERT_COLE",
      "name": "Rebecca, wife of Robert Cole",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "by 29 March 1663",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_COLE_DEPOSITION1663",
        "ROOTS26_COLE_AMERICAN_ERAS"
      ],
      "source_note": "American Eras identifies this son as the planter and merchant who died in 1717, matching the Edward whose will names Susanna Jenkins.",
      "research_note": "That combined identification leads over a hypothetical second Edward; the remaining uncertainty is the connection between the child in 1663 and the adult testator, rather than what the deposition says about his parents. Probate and land records following Edward into adulthood would strengthen that connection. The 1663 testimony explicitly identifies Edward as a son of Robert and Rebecca Cole.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Charles County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.433,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Thomas Semmes",
          "descendant_id": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
          "distance": 4
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JANE_MOTHER_ROBERT_COLE",
      "name": "Jane (also reported Joan), mother of Robert Cole",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_WILL1662",
        "ROOTS26_COLE_DEPOSITION1663",
        "ROOTS26_HESTON_COLE_RECUSANTS1632"
      ],
      "source_note": "Its sons, daughters and St. Jane’s maternity is better supported than her identification with either earlier Heston household.",
      "research_note": "A patent is reported to use Joan, and the 1632 court list distinguishes Jane wife of Thomas from Joan wife of William. Robert’s will abstract explicitly names his mother Mrs Jane Cole of Middlesex. The mother is represented here without choosing a husband or maiden surname; this is not a merger of the two women in that list. Clement’s Bay locality match the family in the 1663 deposition, favoring the same Robert over a hypothetical namesake.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Heston, Middlesex, England (reported)",
          "confidence": 0.9,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Robert Cole, ensign",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_ENSIGN",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_LEWIS_BATTERSEA1696",
      "name": "Thomas Lewis of Battersea, parent candidate",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lewis",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "by 3 June 1696",
      "death_place": "Prince George’s County, Maryland",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730",
        "ROOTS26_BROAD_CREEK_LEWIS",
        "ROOTS26_THOMAS_LEWIS_WILL1696"
      ],
      "source_note": "Estate distributions and Margaret’s earlier marriage would best distinguish these explanations.",
      "research_note": "Its silence does not prove Margaret was absent from the family: the abstract concentrates on land and may omit other provisions. Thomas of Battersea is the leading identifiable candidate, with low confidence; no mother is assigned from his wife’s name alone. Athy’s family history proposes Thomas of Aire as Margaret’s father. A different Lewis household, or Lewis as the reported widow’s previous married name, remain alternatives. The locality and documented Lewis household support that identification, but the will abstract names only sons.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_AARON_LUSBY1796",
      "name": "William Aaron Lusby Jr.",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Lusby",
      "birth_date": "1796",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1867",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_AARON_LUSBY1796_PROFILE",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_SARAH_LUSBY_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Dates are reported, not independently verified. Reported as Sarah Lusby’s parent in Nathan McNew’s compiled genealogy. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Henry County, Missouri, United States",
          "confidence": 0.3,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Sarah A. Lusby (reported; formerly Willoughby)",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NANCY_HAZELRIGG1796",
      "name": "Nancy Hazelrigg",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hazelrigg",
      "birth_date": "about 1796",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "before August 1836",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NANCY_HAZELRIGG1796_PROFILE",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_SARAH_LUSBY_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Dates are reported, not independently verified. Reported as Sarah Lusby’s parent in Nathan McNew’s compiled genealogy. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Henry County, Missouri, United States",
          "confidence": 0.3,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Sarah A. Lusby (reported; formerly Willoughby)",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHAN_STALCOP",
      "name": "Johan Andersson Stalcop",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Stalcop",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_STALCOP_SHEETS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Father of Peter in Craig’s annotated family sheet; also named in the 2007 reconstruction. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CHRISTINA_CARLSDOTTER",
      "name": "Christina Carlsdotter",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Carlsdotter",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_STALCOP_SHEETS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mother of Peter in Craig’s family sheet; daughter of Carl Johnson/Jönsson.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SAMUEL_PETERSSON",
      "name": "Samuel Petersson of Fryksände",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Petersson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
      ],
      "source_note": "Craig identifies him as Catharina’s father; the settler from Fryksände is distinguished from Samuel of Bogen.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BRITA_JONSDOTTER",
      "name": "Brita, wife of Samuel Petersson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Jönsdotter",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
      ],
      "source_note": "Craig names Brita as Catharina’s mother and Jöns Andersson’s daughter.",
      "research_note": "Jönsdotter is a patronymic rendering, not a verified hereditary surname.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CARL_JONSSON",
      "name": "Carl Jönsson of Letstigen",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Jönsson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_STALCOP_SHEETS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as Christina Carlsdotter’s father; the family sheet uses Carl Johnson.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JONS_ANDERSSON_SMITH",
      "name": "Jöns Andersson, blacksmith",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Andersson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
      ],
      "source_note": "Craig identifies Brita’s father as the Christina blacksmith.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARIA_WIFE_JONS",
      "name": "Maria, wife of Jöns Andersson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Documented wife of Jöns in 1654 and 1660; her maternity of Brita is inferred, not explicitly established by the inspected account. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PETTER_SMIDT",
      "name": "Petter Smidt",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Smidt",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BAPTISM_LOCATOR",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_PETTER_SMIDT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as a parent of Hans Jürgen Smidt in the Falun household.",
      "research_note": "The cited baptism image remains uninspected; dates and upstream parents are not inferred from conflicting aggregate trees.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Falun, Dalarna, Sweden",
          "confidence": 0.65,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Hans Jurgen Georg Smith/Smidt",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_HANS_JURGEN_GEORG_SMITH_SMIDT_3_NOV_1696",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1668,
          "confidence": 0.468,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Falun, Dalarna, Sweden",
          "place_confidence": 0.65,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Hans Jurgen Georg Smith/Smidt"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1696,
          "confidence": 0.468,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MAGDALENA_HUWALT",
      "name": "Magdalena Hindrichsdotter Huwalt (reported)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Huwalt",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BAPTISM_LOCATOR",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_MAGDALENA_HUWALT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as a parent of Hans Jürgen Smidt in the Falun household.",
      "research_note": "The cited baptism image remains uninspected; dates and upstream parents are not inferred from conflicting aggregate trees.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Falun, Dalarna, Sweden",
          "confidence": 0.65,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Hans Jurgen Georg Smith/Smidt",
          "descendant_id": "HV4_HANS_JURGEN_GEORG_SMITH_SMIDT_3_NOV_1696",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1668,
          "confidence": 0.468,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Falun, Dalarna, Sweden",
          "place_confidence": 0.65,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Hans Jurgen Georg Smith/Smidt"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1696,
          "confidence": 0.468,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNISS_SOMERSET",
      "name": "William Furniss (parent candidate)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Furniss",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "before 13 Jun 1689",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LANKFORD_FURNISS",
        "ROOTS26_OLIVE_STRAWBRIDGE_1689",
        "ROOTS26_ROSE_FURNIS_CLAIM"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The Somerset parents are recorded, but their daughter’s proposed identity as Rose Felps rests on matching given name, compatible generation and compiled identification. Olive’s reported Ivery birth surname is not adopted without assessment. No inspected record carries her from Somerset to the Felps household. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.3,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Rose [previously Swift; birth surname unproven]",
          "descendant_id": "G28_ROSANNAH_WIFE_THOMAS_FELPS",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_OLIVE_FURNISS_SOMERSET",
      "name": "Olive, wife of William Furniss (parent candidate)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LANKFORD_FURNISS",
        "ROOTS26_OLIVE_STRAWBRIDGE_1689",
        "ROOTS26_ROSE_FURNIS_CLAIM"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The Somerset parents are recorded, but their daughter’s proposed identity as Rose Felps rests on matching given name, compatible generation and compiled identification. Olive’s reported Ivery birth surname is not adopted without assessment. No inspected record carries her from Somerset to the Felps household. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.3,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Rose [previously Swift; birth surname unproven]",
          "descendant_id": "G28_ROSANNAH_WIFE_THOMAS_FELPS",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_FURNIS_KNEESALL",
      "name": "Thomas Furnis (English parent candidate)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Furnis",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_FURNIS_KNEESALL_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_ANNE_FURNIS_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNIS_FS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Represents the reported Kneesall parent of William. No birth or death dates, migration, or Anne natal surname have been adopted from the assembled pedigree.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.075,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Rose [previously Swift; birth surname unproven]",
          "descendant_id": "G28_ROSANNAH_WIFE_THOMAS_FELPS",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANNE_FURNIS_KNEESALL",
      "name": "Anne, reported mother of William Furnis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_FURNIS_KNEESALL_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_ANNE_FURNIS_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNIS_FS"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Represents the reported Kneesall parent of William. No birth or death dates, migration, or Anne natal surname have been adopted from the assembled pedigree.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "confidence": 0.075,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Rose [previously Swift; birth surname unproven]",
          "descendant_id": "G28_ROSANNAH_WIFE_THOMAS_FELPS",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726_PERSON",
      "name": "James Robinson, New Castle yeoman",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Robinson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "between 4 and 30 Dec 1726",
      "death_place": "New Castle County, Delaware (probate jurisdiction)",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726",
        "ROOTS26_ROBINSON_DEED1735_SUMMARY",
        "ROOTS26_CATHERINE_ROBINSON_NATHAN"
      ],
      "source_note": "James’s will, made 4 December 1726 and proved 30 December, names daughter Cathren Mack Donald and wife Cathren. The later property agreement connects the daughter with Bryan McDonald.",
      "research_note": "His exact birth remains unverified.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1666,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "New Castle County, Delaware (probate jurisdiction)",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "James Robinson, New Castle yeoman"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CATHERINE_WIFE_JAMES_ROBINSON",
      "name": "Catherine Howell, wife of James Robinson",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Howell",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726",
        "ROOTS26_ROBINSON_DEED1735_SUMMARY",
        "ROOTS26_CATHERINE_ROBINSON_NATHAN",
        "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS",
        "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her mother’s 1695 will identifies Katharine Robinson, wife of James. The later New Castle household is the leading match.",
      "research_note": "This supports the Howell birth surname; it does not alone prove her maternity of each child.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1666,
          "confidence": 0.504,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1694,
          "confidence": 0.504,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GEORGE_ROBINSON_WEDGEBURG",
      "name": "George Robinson of Wedgeburg (parent candidate)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Robinson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_STANDING_ROBINSON"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "An early Christiana Hundred settler, identified through the reported Wedgeburg property purchase and surviving family. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "New Castle County, Delaware (probate jurisdiction)",
          "confidence": 0.65,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "James Robinson, New Castle yeoman",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726_PERSON",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANN_WIFE_GEORGE_ROBINSON",
      "name": "Ann, wife of George Robinson (parent candidate)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_STANDING_ROBINSON"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Her proposed Curtis birth surname has not been established. Reported as the widow of George Robinson. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "New Castle County, Delaware (probate jurisdiction)",
          "confidence": 0.55,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "James Robinson, New Castle yeoman",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726_PERSON",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_HOWELL_COOPERS_CREEK",
      "name": "Thomas Howell of Cooper’s Creek",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Howell",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "before 1 Nov 1687",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas held property in West New Jersey and at Tamworth in England.",
      "research_note": "The division of his estate names his children; his own parents remain unidentified.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KATHARINE_HOWELL_WIDOW1695",
      "name": "Katharine, widow of Thomas Howell",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "between 17 Aug and 4 Oct 1695",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Philadelphia widow whose 1695 will identifies her late husband Thomas and daughter Katharine Robinson, wife of James.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ADAM_HELMSTETLER_ROWAN",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARIA_MAGDALENA_WIFE_ADAM_HELM",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HELMSTETTER_PFAFF1708",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_AUGST_MARIA_CATHARINA1712",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_COUNTISS1743",
      "name": "William Countiss",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Countiss",
      "birth_date": "reported 1743",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "reported 1794",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009"
      ],
      "source_note": "The undated chart, sections7 and13, names William Countiss and Elizabeth Wrench as parents of Henry born 1777. Another Henry in the chart is son of PeterII and Sarah; Peter’s reported1773death makes that son older than the supplied1820head ageband.",
      "research_note": "Wrench is a reported name, not an established birth surname; no identity with RichardCostin’s daughter is asserted. Names and compatible age support this as the leading identified family for the Virginia Henry, but a migration link is unresolved. The reported1777date elsewhere may share this chart’s source and is not independent confirmation.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Queen Anne's County, Maryland, USA",
          "confidence": 0.28,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Henry Countiss (Countess)",
          "descendant_id": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ELIZABETH_WRENCH_COUNTISS",
      "name": "Elizabeth Wrench (birth surname unresolved)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Wrench",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009"
      ],
      "source_note": "The undated chart, sections7 and13, names William Countiss and Elizabeth Wrench as parents of Henry born 1777. Another Henry in the chart is son of PeterII and Sarah; Peter’s reported1773death makes that son older than the supplied1820head ageband.",
      "research_note": "Wrench is a reported name, not an established birth surname; no identity with RichardCostin’s daughter is asserted. Names and compatible age support this as the leading identified family for the Virginia Henry, but a migration link is unresolved. The reported1777date elsewhere may share this chart’s source and is not independent confirmation.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Queen Anne's County, Maryland, USA",
          "confidence": 0.28,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Henry Countiss (Countess)",
          "descendant_id": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_D1746",
      "name": "Peter Countiss",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Countiss",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "between 7 and 30 May 1746",
      "death_place": "Queen Anne’s County, Maryland",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_WILL1746"
      ],
      "source_note": "The chart identifies Peter, who died in 1746, as the father of William, reportedly born in 1743. Peter’s will independently names a son William.",
      "research_note": "The matching family and county favor this identification, although the will does not give William’s age, wife or children.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1715,
          "confidence": 0.468,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Queen Anne’s County, Maryland",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "Peter Countiss"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_WIFE_PETER_COUNTISS",
      "name": "Rebecca (wife of Peter Countiss; surname unknown)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_WILL1746",
        "ROOTS26_COUNTISS_PROCEEDINGS_INDEX1746"
      ],
      "source_note": "The chart names Rebecca as Peter’s wife and William’s mother. Peter’s will confirms a wife but leaves her unnamed.",
      "research_note": "The probate index lists Rebecca and Peter on the same folio, with conflicting counties. This supports investigation of the couple without resolving whether Rebecca was William’s mother or a later wife. Her birth surname is unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "reported Queen Anne's County, Maryland, USA",
          "confidence": 0.098,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Henry Countiss (Countess)",
          "descendant_id": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731",
      "name": "James Countiss",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Countiss",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "between 29 December 1731 and 4 May 1732",
      "death_place": "Queen Anne’s County, Maryland",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731",
        "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_WILL1746"
      ],
      "source_note": "James’s will names Peter and the distinctive sibling group recorded in the chart. The family cluster, county and chronology favor identifying this son with Peter, who died in 1746. James’s probate date, 4 May 1732, is not his exact death date.",
      "research_note": "Peter’s reference to his unnamed father’s land purchase has not yet been connected to James’s property.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARY_GREENE_COUNTISS",
      "name": "Mary Greene (reported name)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Greene",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731"
      ],
      "source_note": "The chart names Mary Greene as James’s wife and Peter’s mother. James’s will confirms a living wife in 1731 but leaves her unnamed.",
      "research_note": "An incorrectly named wife or successive wives remain possible. Its agreement with the chart’s children supports consideration of Mary, but cannot verify her name or biological motherhood.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Queen Anne’s County, Maryland",
          "confidence": 0.3,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Peter Countiss",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_D1746",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DORCAS_CULLEN_WIFE_ATHEY",
      "name": "Living or private person",
      "privacy_masked": true
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_SENIOR",
      "name": "William Henderson (father of William)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Henderson",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Named with Ellen in the 1866 marriage transcription; earlier household identity remains tentative. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Virginia, USA",
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "William Henderson",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1793,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Virginia, USA",
          "place_confidence": 0.8,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "William Henderson"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ELLEN_HENDERSON",
      "name": "Ellen Henderson (possibly Elender Clark)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": null,
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named mother in the marriage transcription.",
      "research_note": "Clark is a suggested birth surname, not a verified one.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Virginia, USA",
          "confidence": 0.8,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "William Henderson",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1793,
          "confidence": 0.576,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Virginia, USA",
          "place_confidence": 0.8,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "William Henderson"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LIDDY_MARKLAND",
      "name": "Liddy (Lydia) Markland (reported Donnally)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Donnally",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "The compiler identifies Elender’s mother through an 1815 will; the identification of Elender with Ellen is tentative. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Virginia, USA",
          "confidence": 0.4,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "William Henderson",
          "descendant_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHN_WILLIS_NANCY_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "John Willis",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Willis",
      "birth_date": "reported about 1732",
      "birth_place": "reported Chester County, Pennsylvania",
      "death_date": "reported July 1800",
      "death_place": "reported Franklin County, Virginia",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
        "ROOTS26_WILLIS_HARTWELL_1787"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "A mistaken attachment or confusion with Parmelia remains possible. The short structured child list’s omission of Nancy is not evidence that she was excluded from the family. The court file independently supports John’s reported movements and associates, but does not name Nancy or Phebe. The displayed vital details are reported by the compilation, not established by the court case. The compilation identifies Nancy by her husband and exact marriage date, making John and Phebe the leading named parent candidates. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PHEBE_BENNETT_NANCY_CANDIDATE",
      "name": "Phebe Bennett",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bennett",
      "birth_date": "30 first month 1738 (March, Old Style)",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
        "ROOTS26_WARRINGTON_BENNETT_ABSTRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Warrington abstract records Phebe, daughter of Joseph Bennett and Rebecca Fincher, born 30 first month 1738.",
      "research_note": "A mistaken attachment or confusion with Parmelia remains possible. The short structured child list’s omission of Nancy is not evidence that she was excluded from the family. The court file independently supports John’s reported movements and associates, but does not name Nancy or Phebe. The displayed vital details are reported by the compilation, not established by the court case. Its explicit March interpretation corrects the January reading in some compiled profiles. The matching parent names, age and Quaker setting support her identification as John’s wife; the original marriage record remains unchecked. The compilation identifies Nancy by her husband and exact marriage date, making John and Phebe the leading named parent candidates.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "probably Franklin County, Virginia, USA",
          "confidence": 0.272,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Frances \"Fanny\" Lavender",
          "descendant_id": "I61",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOSEPH_BENNETT_WARRINGTON",
      "name": "Joseph Bennett",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bennett",
      "birth_date": "reported 29 September 1704",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "16 May 1757",
      "death_place": "York County, Pennsylvania",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WARRINGTON_BENNETT_ABSTRACT",
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Warrington abstract identifies Joseph and Rebecca’s family. Futhey and Cope identify the same couple and give Joseph’s parents as Edward Bennett and Sarah, formerly the widow Clues and daughter of Francis Stanfield.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_FINCHER_BENNETT",
      "name": "Rebecca Fincher",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fincher",
      "birth_date": "reported 1708",
      "birth_place": "Uwchlan, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
      "death_date": "6 November 1757",
      "death_place": "York County, Pennsylvania",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WARRINGTON_BENNETT_ABSTRACT",
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Warrington abstract names Rebecca Fincher with Joseph Bennett and their children. Futhey and Cope identify her as John and Martha Fincher’s daughter.",
      "research_note": "Her reported birth is printed as 9, 6, 1708; only the year is displayed until the original date convention is checked.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_EDWARD_BENNETT_THORNBURY",
      "name": "Edward Bennett",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Bennett",
      "birth_date": "baptized 14 October 1659",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "Futhey and Cope reproduce a Bible entry for Edward’s baptism and identify him as the Thornbury settler who married Sarah Clues in 1697.",
      "research_note": "His will is quoted concerning an inherited Bible, but its manuscript has not been inspected. No exact death date is adopted.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "York County, Pennsylvania",
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Joseph Bennett",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_JOSEPH_BENNETT_WARRINGTON",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1704,
          "confidence": 0.59,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SARAH_STANFIELD_BENNETT",
      "name": "Sarah Stanfield",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Stanfield",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "Futhey and Cope identify Sarah as Francis Stanfield’s daughter and the widow Clues when she married Edward Bennett in 1697. Clues is a former married surname.",
      "research_note": "They explicitly place Joseph among her children.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "York County, Pennsylvania",
          "confidence": 0.82,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Joseph Bennett",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_JOSEPH_BENNETT_WARRINGTON",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1676,
          "confidence": 0.59,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "York County, Pennsylvania",
          "place_confidence": 0.82,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Joseph Bennett"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1704,
          "confidence": 0.59,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHN_FINCHER_LONDONGROVE",
      "name": "John Fincher",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Fincher",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "about 1747",
      "death_place": "London Grove, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "Futhey and Cope identify John as Francis Fincher’s son and husband first of Martha Taylor, later of the widow Elinor Cook. Their family list includes Rebecca, wife of Joseph Bennett.",
      "research_note": "His reported death is approximate; probate on 24 November 1747 is not an exact death date.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "birth": {
          "year": 1680,
          "confidence": 0.612,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "London Grove, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
          "place_confidence": 1.0,
          "place_basis": "recorded locality",
          "place_descendant": "John Fincher"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARTHA_TAYLOR_FINCHER",
      "name": "Martha Taylor",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Taylor",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Bennett account names Martha as Rebecca Fincher’s mother.",
      "research_note": "Rebecca’s reported 1708 birth precedes John’s reported 1714 remarriage, favoring Martha over Elinor Cook. The Fincher account identifies John’s first wife as Martha, daughter of Robert Taylor, and calls attribution of the children to her probable.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Uwchlan, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
          "confidence": 0.78,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Rebecca Fincher",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_FINCHER_BENNETT",
          "distance": 1
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1680,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Uwchlan, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
          "place_confidence": 0.78,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Rebecca Fincher"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1708,
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_TAYLOR_SPRINGFIELD",
      "name": "Robert Taylor",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Taylor",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1695",
      "death_place": "Springfield, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925",
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_ARRIVALS1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "His will names daughter Martha; the county history and Justice identify her as John Fincher’s wife. Justice identifies his parents as Thomas Taylor and Mary Barrow, with a Great Budworth baptism in 1633.",
      "research_note": "That English identification remains to be compared with the underlying registers.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARY_HAYES_TAYLOR",
      "name": "Mary Hayes (reported surname)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Hayes",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925",
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_ARRIVALS1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary travelled from Cheshire with Martha in 1683. Justice reports that the Cheshire Friends register names Robert and Mary as parents of the English-born children.",
      "research_note": "Justice calls Mary a sister of Jonathan Hayes; this surname attribution remains less secure than her given name and household identity. The earlier county history’s suggestion of a second wife does not specifically identify Martha as a stepchild.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Uwchlan, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
          "confidence": 0.608,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Rebecca Fincher",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_FINCHER_BENNETT",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_TAYLOR_LITTLELEIGH",
      "name": "Thomas Taylor",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Taylor",
      "birth_date": "baptized 9 October 1594",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "buried 1 February 1669/70",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
      ],
      "source_note": "Justice identifies Thomas of Clatterwich as the father of Robert baptized at Great Budworth in 1633, and reports his 1630 marriage to Mary Barrow at Whitegate.",
      "research_note": "The published reconstruction joins these parish entries; the original entries remain uninspected.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Springfield, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
          "confidence": 0.72,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Robert Taylor",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_TAYLOR_SPRINGFIELD",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARY_BARROW_TAYLOR",
      "name": "Mary Barrow (Burrowe)",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Barrow",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925",
        "ROOTS26_BARROW_DAVENHAM1609_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_CPRDB_BARROW_RECORDS",
        "ROOTS26_CPRDB_GENERAL_NOTES"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Whitegate parish transcription records Thoms Taylor of Great Budworth parish marrying Mary Burrowe of Davenham parish by Chester court licence on 21 September 1630.",
      "research_note": "The marriage supplies no age or father, so the birth-family identification remains unresolved. Three Davenham baptisms could fit the bride: Maria Barrow, daughter of Ranulphus (1609/10), Maria Barrow, daughter of William (1611/12), and Maria Burrows, daughter of Thomas of Bostock (1613/14). This supports Justice’s marriage reconstruction.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Springfield, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
          "confidence": 0.7,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Robert Taylor",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_TAYLOR_SPRINGFIELD",
          "distance": 1
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHN_TAYLOR_CLATTERWICH",
      "name": "John Taylor",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Taylor",
      "birth_date": "about 1550",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1627",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
      ],
      "source_note": "Justice places John at Clatterwich in Little Leigh and reproduces an abstract of his will, proved 9 April 1627. His marriage and children are reconstructed from Great Budworth parish records.",
      "research_note": "That is a probate date, not an exact death date.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Springfield, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
          "confidence": 0.562,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Robert Taylor",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_TAYLOR_SPRINGFIELD",
          "distance": 2
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ELLEN_MASSEY_TAYLOR",
      "name": "Ellen Massey",
      "first_name": null,
      "last_name": "Massey",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
      ],
      "source_note": "Justice identifies Ellen as John Taylor’s second wife, married 11 December 1586 at Great Budworth, and places Thomas among the children of that marriage.",
      "research_note": "The book reports no burial entry; an exact death date is not established.",
      "privacy_masked": false,
      "inferred_life": {
        "locality": {
          "place": "Springfield, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
          "confidence": 0.533,
          "basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "descendant": "Robert Taylor",
          "descendant_id": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_TAYLOR_SPRINGFIELD",
          "distance": 2
        },
        "birth": {
          "year": 1566,
          "confidence": 0.533,
          "basis": "estimated from the earliest known child's birth year",
          "place": "Springfield, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
          "place_confidence": 0.533,
          "place_basis": "inferred from descendant",
          "place_descendant": "Robert Taylor"
        },
        "death": {
          "after_year": 1594,
          "confidence": 0.533,
          "basis": "not before the youngest known child's birth year"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_1726",
      "name": "John Brassington of Chelmorton",
      "first_name": "John",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Chelmorton, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1739",
        "SRC_DARG_DERBYSHIRE_REGISTER_COVERAGE_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_WIRKSWORTH_20261005",
        "SRC_DRO_CHELMORTON_REGISTER_TRANSCRIPT_D3536_1575_1840_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Alternative: another John Brassington couple in the same district. Leading identification: the John Brassington who married Elizabeth Walton at Chelmorton on 27 September 1726 is the father named in the 12 April 1739 baptism of John Brassington. The marriage-to-baptism sequence is strong, but no age, burial, will, or settlement record yet proves the identification with the later Ranton father.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ELIZABETH_WALTON_CHELMORTON_1726",
      "name": "Elizabeth Walton",
      "first_name": "Elizabeth",
      "last_name": "Walton",
      "birth_date": "25 Jan 1701",
      "birth_place": "Tideswell, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_WALTON_TIDESWELL_BAPTISM_1701"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Alternative: another Elizabeth Walton or a mistranscribed bride. The name, county and age fit, but no marriage, burial, settlement or probate record directly connects the baptism to the bride. Leading identification: Elizabeth Walton, baptized at Tideswell on 25 January 1701, is a plausible match for the Elizabeth who married John Brassington at Chelmorton in 1726 and was named as mother in the 1739 baptism.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CHARLES_WALTON_TIDESWELL_1701",
      "name": "Charles Walton of Tideswell",
      "first_name": "Charles",
      "last_name": "Walton",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Tideswell, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_WALTON_TIDESWELL_BAPTISM_1701"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "No mother is named in the available extract, and no separate adult record yet identifies Charles’s dates or parents. Tideswell baptism evidence names Charles Walton as the father of Elizabeth Walton, baptized 25 January 1701. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_WITHERWOOD_1710",
      "name": "John Brassington of Witherwood",
      "first_name": "John",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Bradnop, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_BRASSINGTON_LEASES_1698_1710",
        "SRC_BL_ADD_MS_36664_JOHN_BRESSINGTON_LEEK_1710"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Possible earlier-generation candidate: John Brassington named in a 30 November 1710 Witherwood lease in the Bradnop/Morridge area near Leek. He could be the father of the John Brassington who married Elizabeth Walton at Chelmorton in 1726, but the lease gives no age, spouse, residence of origin, or children. Ralph Brassington, named in a nearby 1698 Bradnop lease, is a competing regional surname lead. This profile is a hypothesis, not an identified ancestor. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_1702",
      "name": "John Brasington of Chelmorton",
      "first_name": "John",
      "last_name": "Brasington",
      "birth_date": "2 Jan 1702",
      "birth_place": "Chelmorton, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1702",
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_WALTON_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1726"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "H1: these are the same man; the exact parish and a plausible age strongly support it. H2: another John Brassington married in 1726, or the 1702 child died and a different groom used the same name. Retain as a candidate at 0.68. Leading identification for the 1726 Chelmorton groom: John Brasington was baptized at Chelmorton on 2 January 1702, son of George Brasington, and a John Brassington married Elizabeth Walton there on 27 September 1726. No burial, will, or explicit age yet proves the identity.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GEORGE_BRASINGTON_CHELMORTON_FATHER_1702",
      "name": "George Brasington of Chelmorton",
      "first_name": "George",
      "last_name": "Brasington",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Chelmorton, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1702"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "His own birth, marriage, burial, and identity among several regional George Brassingtons remain unresolved. George Brasington is explicitly named as the father in the 2 January 1702 Chelmorton baptism of John Brasington. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_LEEK_1672",
      "name": "George Brassington of Leek",
      "first_name": "George",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "Feb 1672",
      "birth_place": "Leek, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_LEEK_BAPTISM_1672",
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_MARY_KILLEY_LEEK_MARRIAGE_1670"
      ],
      "source_note": "George, son of Georgis (George) and Maria, was baptized at Leek in February 1672 after the 1670 George–Mary Killey marriage.",
      "research_note": "H1: the Leek child moved to Chelmorton and became the 1702 father; H2: another George Brasington was the Chelmorton father. Possible identity for the George Brasington who fathered John at Chelmorton in 1702. The geographical move and adult-life record are not yet bridged.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_JOANNES_BRASSINGTON_SUTTON_1717",
      "name": "Joannes (John) Brassington of Sutton",
      "first_name": "Joannes (John)",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "27 Jan 1717",
      "birth_place": "Sutton, Cheshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CPRDB_BRASSINGTON_BAPTISMS_1714_1870"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "H1 he could be the father of the 1739 Chelmorton John; H2 he was another Sutton man. Weak alternative parent candidate: CPRDB indexes a Joannes (John) Brassington baptized at Sutton on 27 January 1717. The age is possible, but no parents, migration, or later residence is supplied and the Staffordshire lead is nearer. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ISABELL_BAGNALL_POSSIBLE_MOTHER_GEORGE_1639",
      "name": "Isabell Bagnall, possible mother of George Brassington",
      "first_name": "Isabell",
      "last_name": "Bagnall",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_BRASSINGTON_SIBLING_CLUSTER_20261004",
        "SRC_BAGNALL_TRENTHAM_COMPILED_FAMILY_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_TRENTHAM_DGS_7567143_1558_1640_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "name": "Richard Brassington of Caverswall (compiled candidate)",
      "first_name": "Richard",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "28 May 1564",
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "May 1626",
      "death_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564_20261005",
        "SRC_LAURENCE_BRASSINGTON_BAGNALL_WILL_1658",
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005",
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_INDEX_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_1546_20261005",
        "SRC_ISABEL_DE_BRASYNTON_POLL_TAX_1379_20261005",
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSYNTON_LEEK_WILL_WITNESS_1556_20261005",
        "SRC_THOMAS_BRASSYNTON_KINGSLEY_WILL_1556_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_SPRS_SURNAME_INDEX_1552_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_INDEX_RICHARD_GEORGE_CONSTANCE_1590_1591_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_LICHFIELD_WILLS_1550_1810_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_FREE_BMB_INDEX_CAVERSWALL_BRASSINGTON_1564_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_LOCAL_STAFFORDSHIRE_BMB_INDEX_B_PDF_20261005",
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_RICHARD_BRASSYNGTON_CHEADLETON_1552_20261005",
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_1546_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_BC11_ORDERING_ROUTE_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_ACCESS_STATUS_20261005",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_COVERAGE_20261005",
        "SRC_FOREBEARS_CAVERSWALL_DIGITIZED_REGISTERS_CATALOG_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_PARISH_HISTORY_REGISTERS_1552_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_TAX_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_1666_20261005",
        "SRC_FINDMYPAST_CAVERSWALL_ST_PETER_IMAGES_1560_1900_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_IMAGES_1538_1944_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_CAVERSWALL_REGISTERS_C1552_20261005",
        "SRC_DARG_CAVERSWALL_TRANSCRIPT_HOLDINGS_1552_1643_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_ARCHIVE_CATALOGUE_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_FINDMYPAST_CAVERSWALL_BROWSE_1538_1900_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSPASTTRACK_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_FIRST_PAGE_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_BRASSYNTON_BC11_1552_1556_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_STAFFS_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_COVERAGE_1552_2023_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_BAPTISM_1564_DUAL_INDEX_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The free Staffordshire index independently lists his 1564 Caverswall baptism and a Richard Brassington marriage in 1586.",
      "research_note": "The underlying original records and identity resolution remain unverified. FamilySearch independently indexes the 28 May 1564 Caverswall baptism/christening in two record representations; the event is secure at index level, but both parent fields omit given names, so the George/Constance assignment remains unverified. Compiled Ancestry and FamilySearch profiles converge on a Richard Brassington of Caverswall, born about 1564, married to Isabell Bagnold, and father of a Thomas dated about 1586. A Lichfield index also lists a Richard Brassington administration in 1589, which may be this man but would conflict with the compiled May 1626 death; the index entry may instead belong to another Richard. This corroborates the early event cluster, but does not resolve the conflict with the 1589 Lichfield administration or prove the later compiled death date. A separate 1552 Lichfield index entry for Richard Brassyngton of Cheadleton is retained as a lower-confidence alternative predecessor (0.08 edge), but it has no kinship clause.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1540",
      "name": "George Brassington of Caverswall (compiled candidate)",
      "first_name": "George",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "about 1545–1550",
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "about 1591",
      "death_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_CLUSTER_20261005",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_WILL_1546_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_DERBYSHIRE_PARISH_COLLECTION_1911752_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_SURVIVAL_FROM_1552_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_SPRS_SURNAME_INDEX_1552_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_INDEX_RICHARD_GEORGE_CONSTANCE_1590_1591_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_LICHFIELD_WILLS_1550_1810_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_CONSTANCE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_ACCESS_STATUS_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_PARISH_HISTORY_REGISTERS_1552_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_TAX_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_1666_20261005",
        "SRC_BL_EGERTON_BRASSINGTON_DEEDS_GROUP_1584_1628_20261005",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_MISCELLANY_BRASSINGTON_RENTALS_1578_1620_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_CAVERSWALL_REGISTERS_C1552_20261005",
        "SRC_DRO_BRASSINGTON_PARISH_REGISTERS_D943_1716_2020_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_ARCHIVE_CATALOGUE_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_FINDMYPAST_CAVERSWALL_BROWSE_1538_1900_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSPASTTRACK_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_FIRST_PAGE_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_STAFFS_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_COVERAGE_1552_2023_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The official Lichfield probate index identifies George Brassington, husbandman of Caverswall, with a will and inventory recorded 13 April 1591, and Constance Brassington, widow of Caverswall, with an inventory recorded the same day. This strongly supports a real George–Constance household and George’s death by 1591. Exact official index details were rechecked on 5 October 2026: George was a Caverswall husbandman with a will and inventory recorded 13 April 1591; Constance was a Caverswall widow with an inventory recorded the same day.",
      "research_note": "It still does not name Richard as a child; the compiled c.1545–1550 birth and parentage remain provisional. This strengthens the household hypothesis but does not name Richard as a child.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1639",
      "name": "George Brassington of Caverswall",
      "first_name": "George",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "16 Jan 1639",
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_BAPTISM_1639",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_PARISH_HISTORY_REGISTERS_1552_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_TAX_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_1666_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1639_QL3K_DSG6_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Baptized at Caverswall on 16 January 1639; the register index identifies Thomas Brassington as father.",
      "research_note": "This is an event-secure person, but later identification with the George married at Leek in 1670 remains a separate candidate link.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_FATHER_1639",
      "name": "Thomas Brassington of Caverswall",
      "first_name": "Thomas",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_BAPTISM_1639",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_BRASSINGTON_SIBLING_CLUSTER_20261004",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_RICHARD_ISABELL_CLUSTER_20261005",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1639_QL3K_DSG6_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_NORTON_LE_MOORS_1622_QL3G_KC8B_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ISABELL_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1625_QL3K_HGSK_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_WILLIAM_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1636_QL3K_H2SH_20261005",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_THOMAS_ISABELL_CAVERSWALL_SIBLING_CLUSTER_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_TRENTHAM_DGS_7567143_1558_1640_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_FRANCIS_BRASSINGTON_PROFILE_PXQ5_23X_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_MORE_HALL_1599_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "A separate official probate entry records Thomas Brassington of More Hall, Stoke upon Trent, with a will and inventory recorded 28 September 1599.",
      "research_note": "A FamilySearch compiled profile dates a Thomas in the same Richard–Isabell household to about 1586 and gives a matching sibling cluster. That strengthens, but does not prove, identification of this father with that Thomas; his own primary birth, marriage, and parentage records remain unresolved. Because the later Thomas-led child cluster extends through 1639, that 1599 Thomas is currently ranked as a distinct same-name alternative rather than the same father. Thomas Brassington is named as father in George’s 16 January 1639 Caverswall baptism and is also reported as father in several nearby Brassington baptisms.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_PRE1540_GENEANET",
      "name": "Richard Brassington of Caverswall (Geneanet candidate)",
      "first_name": "Richard",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_PEDIGREE_20261005",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CECILIE_ALSOP_MARRIAGE_1544_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "An Ashbourne parish-register transcription records Richard Brassington’s marriage to Cecilie Alsop on 27 September 1544.",
      "research_note": "The direct marriage raises the couple’s plausibility while the parent-child link remains weak. A Geneanet reconstruction identifies this couple as parents of George Brassington, but no child entry has been found.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CECILIE_ALSOP_CAVERSWALL_GENEANET",
      "name": "Cecilie Alsop of Caverswall (Geneanet candidate)",
      "first_name": "Cecilie",
      "last_name": "Alsop",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_PEDIGREE_20261005",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CECILIE_ALSOP_MARRIAGE_1544_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "An Ashbourne parish-register transcription records Cecilie Alsop’s marriage to Richard Brassington on 27 September 1544.",
      "research_note": "The marriage is direct evidence for the couple, but no child record tying Cecilie to George Brassington has been found.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_THOMAS_BRASSYNTON_KINGSLEY_1556",
      "name": "Thomas Brassynton of Kingsley (1556 will candidate)",
      "first_name": "Thomas",
      "last_name": "Brassynton",
      "birth_date": "before 1536",
      "birth_place": "Kingsley, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_BRASSYNTON_KINGSLEY_WILL_1556_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_BRASSYNTON_BC11_1552_1556_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Lichfield probate reference identifies Thomas Brassynton of Kingsley in a will dated 8 May 1556.",
      "research_note": "The name variant, locality, and date make him a plausible but weak alternative father for Richard Brassington (born 1564). His age, relatives, and relationship to the Caverswall Brassingtons are unknown.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_FATHER_ALEXANDER_1630",
      "name": "George Brassington of Careswell (father of Alexander)",
      "first_name": "George",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "about 1600–1610",
      "birth_place": "Careswell (Caverswall), Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_ALUMNI_ALEXANDER_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1647_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Oxford’s Alumni Oxonienses explicitly describes Alexander Brassington as son of George of Careswell and gives Alexander’s age as 17 at matriculation in 1647. George’s own birth, marriage, death, and relationship to other Caverswall Brassingtons remain unknown. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_LEEK_1637_HOUSEHOLD_20261005",
      "name": "Richard Brassington of Leek (father in 1637–1648 cluster)",
      "first_name": "Richard",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "about 1600–1615",
      "birth_place": "Leek, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_ELLENA_LEEK_CHILD_CLUSTER_1637_1648_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch indexes Johes (1637), Anne (1640), Maria (1645), and Sara (1648) Brassington at Leek as children of Richard Brassington and Ellena.",
      "research_note": "This establishes a real Leek household, but no evidence connects it to the older Caverswall Richard or to the Thomas who fathered George in 1639; it is retained as a competing local household rather than merged.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ELLEN_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1628",
      "name": "Ellen Brassington of Caverswall",
      "first_name": "Ellen",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "31 Aug 1628",
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_CAVERSWALL_THOMAS_ELLEN_1628_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch indexes Ellen Brassington christened at Caverswall on 31 August 1628 with Thomas Brassington as father.",
      "research_note": "The index does not display a mother’s name; her relationship to the later George Brassington household is collateral but provides direct evidence for a Thomas Brassington in Caverswall before George’s 1639 baptism.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ALEXANDER_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1630",
      "name": "Alexander Brassington of Caverswall",
      "first_name": "Alexander",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "1629",
      "birth_place": "Careswell (Caverswall), Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_ALUMNI_ALEXANDER_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1647_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_FREE_BMB_INDEX_CAVERSWALL_BRASSINGTON_1564_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_LOCAL_STAFFORDSHIRE_BMB_INDEX_B_PDF_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Oxford alumni record: son of George of Careswell; matriculated Oriel College 9 April 1647 aged 17, B.A. 1650, later rector of Draycot. The free Staffordshire index also lists an Alexander Brassington baptism at Caverswall in 1629, consistent with the Oxford record’s age 17 in April 1647.",
      "research_note": "This is a documented collateral Brassington branch, not the direct line unless a further kinship record is found.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1586_PROFILE",
      "name": "George Brassington of Caverswall (baptized 1586; burial 1591 candidate)",
      "first_name": "George",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "1586",
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "buried 1591",
      "death_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_FREE_BMB_INDEX_CAVERSWALL_BRASSINGTON_1564_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_LOCAL_STAFFORDSHIRE_BMB_INDEX_B_PDF_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The free Staffordshire BMB index lists a George Brassington baptism at Caverswall in 1586 and a George Brassington burial there in 1591.",
      "research_note": "Those entries fit a child who died young; they conflict with the unsourced collaborative-tree profile that reported George 1586–1668. This person is therefore retained only as a conflation warning, not as a likely father of Alexander.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_MARRIAGE_1560",
      "name": "George Brassington of Caverswall (married 1560)",
      "first_name": "George",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "before about 1540",
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_FREE_BMB_INDEX_CAVERSWALL_BRASSINGTON_1564_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_LOCAL_STAFFORDSHIRE_BMB_INDEX_B_PDF_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_ACCESS_STATUS_20261005",
        "SRC_FOREBEARS_CAVERSWALL_DIGITIZED_REGISTERS_CATALOG_20261005",
        "SRC_FINDMYPAST_CAVERSWALL_ST_PETER_IMAGES_1560_1900_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_IMAGES_1538_1944_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_SPRS_SURNAME_INDEX_1552_1703_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "George Brassington married at Caverswall in 1560.",
      "research_note": "The free Staffordshire BMB index and the local B-index PDF both record a George Brassington marriage at Caverswall in 1560. His spouse and later life are not identified. Chronology makes him a plausible, but unproven, father of Richard baptized there in 1564.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_RICHARD_BRASSYNGTON_CHEADLETON_1552",
      "name": "Richard Brassyngton of Cheadleton (1552 probate candidate)",
      "first_name": "Richard",
      "last_name": "Brassyngton",
      "birth_date": "before 1532",
      "birth_place": "Cheadleton (Cheddleton), Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "1552",
      "death_place": "unknown, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.22,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_RICHARD_BRASSYNGTON_CHEADLETON_1552_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_PLACE_NAMES_CHEDDLETON_VARIANTS_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_BC11_ORDERING_ROUTE_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_SPRS_SURNAME_INDEX_1552_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_DERBYSHIRE_MEDIEVAL_CHAPEL_BRADBOURNE_20261005",
        "SRC_FOREBEARS_BRASSINGTON_DERBYSHIRE_PLACE_HISTORY_20261005",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_BRADBOURNE_REGISTERS_1580_20261005",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_BRASSINGTON_MANOR_COURT_BOOKS_1635_1888_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_BRASSYNTON_BC11_1552_1556_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "A published Lichfield probate index lists Richard Brassyngton of Cheadleton in the 1552 continuation. As an adult testator he was probably born before about 1532.",
      "research_note": "Cheadleton/Cheddleton is in Staffordshire and the spelling and date make him a possible predecessor of the Richard baptized at Caverswall in 1564, but the index does not name children or relatives and the original record has not been inspected. Historical Staffordshire place-name evidence supports reading Cheadleton as the Cheddleton area; this strengthens the locality identification but not the family link.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "name": "Richard Brassington (1546 probate candidate; place unknown)",
      "first_name": "Richard",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "before 1526",
      "birth_place": null,
      "death_date": "1546",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_1546_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_BC11_ORDERING_ROUTE_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Lichfield probate index line lists Richard Brassington in 1546, but gives no place or family detail. As an adult testator he was probably born before about 1526.",
      "research_note": "He could theoretically precede the 1564 Caverswall Richard, but the absence of locality makes a separate household the stronger hypothesis.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WILLIAM_DE_BRASSYNTON_DERBYSHIRE_1345",
      "name": "William de Brassynton (Derbyshire, 1345 bearer)",
      "first_name": "William",
      "last_name": "de Brassynton",
      "birth_date": "before 1325",
      "birth_place": "Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "historical_bearer_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_FEET_FINES_VOL11_1323_1546_20261005",
        "SRC_WERELATE_DERBYSHIRE_FEET_FINES_ACCESS_20261005",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_DERBYSHIRE_MEDIEVAL_CHAPEL_BRADBOURNE_20261005",
        "SRC_FOREBEARS_BRASSINGTON_DERBYSHIRE_PLACE_HISTORY_20261005",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_BRADBOURNE_REGISTERS_1580_20261005",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BRADBOURNE_NO_PRE1713_TRANSCRIPT_20261005",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_BRASSINGTON_MANOR_COURT_BOOKS_1635_1888_20261005",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_MISCELLANY_BRASSINGTON_MANOR_TENANTS_1620_1640_20261005",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_DOMESDAY_BRASSINGTON_WIRKSWORTH_COPY_1662_20261005",
        "SRC_DRO_BRASSINGTON_PARISH_REGISTERS_D943_1716_2020_20261005",
        "SRC_DRO_D258_28_1_16_BRASSINGTON_WITNESSES_1363_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Oxford Dictionary of Family Names lists William de Brassynton in a 1345 Derbyshire Feet of Fines reference.",
      "research_note": "The Derbyshire Record Society volume 11 is the recommended next source for the exact 1345 place and parties. This is an early bearer of the locative surname, not a documented ancestor of the later Staffordshire Brassingtons. The approximate birth estimate assumes an adult land transaction and is only contextual.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ISABEL_DE_BRASSYNGTON_STAPENHILL_1407",
      "name": "Isabel de Brassyngton of Stapenhill (1407 bearer)",
      "first_name": "Isabel",
      "last_name": "de Brassyngton",
      "birth_date": "before about 1387",
      "birth_place": "Stapenhill, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "historical_bearer_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.04,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPM_ISABEL_DE_BRASSYNGTON_STAPENHILL_1407_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "A 1407 Derbyshire inquisition says Henry Bradefeld held land formerly held by Isabel de Brassyngton of Stapenhill.",
      "research_note": "The record does not give her age, family, or dates; the birth estimate only places her as an adult before the transfer/holding was recorded.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ROBERT_DE_BRASYNTONE_DERBYSHIRE_1348",
      "name": "Robert de Brasyntone (Derbyshire, 1348 bearer)",
      "first_name": "Robert",
      "last_name": "de Brasyntone",
      "birth_date": "before about 1328",
      "birth_place": "Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "historical_bearer_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.02,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert de Brasyntone is listed by the Oxford Dictionary of Family Names among early Derbyshire bearers in 1348.",
      "research_note": "This does not establish kinship to later Staffordshire Brassingtons.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_ISABELLA_DE_BRASYNTON_DERBY_1379",
      "name": "Isabella de Brasynton (Derby, 1379 bearer)",
      "first_name": "Isabella",
      "last_name": "de Brasynton",
      "birth_date": "before about 1359",
      "birth_place": "Derby, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "historical_bearer_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.02,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Isabella de Brasynton is listed among early bearers in the 1379 Derby poll-tax material.",
      "research_note": "The entry is surname and locality evidence only, with no demonstrated descent to the later Staffordshire line.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_EDWARD_BRASSYNTON_BEDFORDSHIRE_1411",
      "name": "Edward Brassynton (Bedfordshire, 1411 bearer)",
      "first_name": "Edward",
      "last_name": "Brassynton",
      "birth_date": "before about 1391",
      "birth_place": "Bedfordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "historical_bearer_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.005,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Edward Brassynton is listed in a 1411 Feet of Fines reference.",
      "research_note": "His Bedfordshire location makes a connection to the Derbyshire/Staffordshire line especially uncertain.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MARGARETA_DE_BASYNTON_DERBY_1379",
      "name": "Margareta de Basynton (Derby, 1379 bearer)",
      "first_name": "Margareta",
      "last_name": "de Basynton",
      "birth_date": "before about 1364",
      "birth_place": "Derby, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "historical_bearer_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.015,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DERBY_POLL_TAX_1379_BRASYNTON_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1379 Derby poll-tax return includes Margareta de Basynton and notes a daughter in the household context.",
      "research_note": "No parentage or link to later Brassingtons is given.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_CONSTANCE_CLERKE_CAVERSWALL_1538",
      "name": "Constance Clerke (wife/widow candidate of George Brassington)",
      "first_name": "Constance",
      "last_name": "Clerke",
      "birth_date": "about 1538",
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "1591",
      "death_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_CONSTANCE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005",
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_ACCESS_STATUS_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_STAFFS_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_COVERAGE_1552_2023_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "An official probate index separately records a Constance Brassington, widow of Caverswall, with an inventory on 13 April 1591.",
      "research_note": "The public compiled Richard Brassington profile names his mother as Constance Clerke. The identity and marriage are plausible but not proven from the underlying register or probate entry.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WILLIAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_1546",
      "name": "William Brassington of Cheddleton (1546 will candidate)",
      "first_name": "William",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "before 1526",
      "birth_place": "Cheddleton, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "after 27 Oct 1546",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BC11_WYLLYAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_1546_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_WILLIAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_WILL_1546_20261005",
        "SRC_CCED_LEEK_CHEDDLETON_CHAPEL_CONTEXT_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_BRASSYNTON_BC11_1552_1556_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "A scholarly study cites the original Lichfield Record Office will of Wyllyam Brassington of Cheddleton, dated 27 October 1546. His age, spouse, children and relationship to the Caverswall family are not exposed.",
      "research_note": "The Cheddleton locality and chronology make him a plausible but weak alternative predecessor or father for Richard Brassington of Caverswall (baptized 1564); he is a distinct person from the separately indexed Richard Brassington of 1546.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIDOW_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_1666",
      "name": "Widow Brassington of Caverswall (1666 Hearth Tax)",
      "first_name": "Widow",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "before 1646",
      "birth_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "contextual_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_TAX_1666_BRASSINGTON_HOUSEHOLDS_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "Her identity, husband and relationship to the Caverswall baptismal families are unknown; she is retained as a household marker rather than assigned as a parent or spouse. A 1666 Caverswall Hearth Tax transcription lists a Widow Brassington with one hearth, alongside a separate George Brassington household with three hearths. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_BOSLEY_1739_ALTERNATIVE",
      "name": "John Brassington of Bosley (alternative 1739 candidate)",
      "first_name": "John",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "1739",
      "birth_place": "Bosley, Cheshire, England",
      "death_date": "about 1796",
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_BOSLEY_1739_COMPILED_20261005",
        "SRC_CHESHIRE_CPRDB_BOSLEY_REGISTERS_1728_1788_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "",
      "research_note": "A compiled Ancestry profile reports a same-year John Brassington in Bosley, Cheshire, son of John Brassington and Rebecca Allen. The profile is not an original record and conflicts geographically with the reported Chelmorton baptism; retained as an alternative identity, not as an ancestor of the Ranton line. Available records provide limited biographical detail.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_ASHBOURNE_1544",
      "name": "Richard Brassington of Ashbourne (married 1544)",
      "first_name": "Richard",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "before about 1524",
      "birth_place": "Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "historical_bearer_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CECILIE_ALSOP_MARRIAGE_1544_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_ASHBOURNE_REGISTER_ARCHIVE_CATALOGUE_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_CECILIE_ASHBOURNE_1544_20261005",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_TRANSCRIPTION_COVERAGE_1558_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Ashbourne St Oswald transcription and authenticated FamilySearch index both report Richard Brassington marrying Cecilie Alsop on 27 September 1544.",
      "research_note": "This makes the historical marriage highly credible, but no child or later Caverswall connection is recorded; he remains a regional surname bearer and possible older-generation candidate, not an asserted ancestor.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WILLIAM_ELEN_DE_BRASSINGTON_1363",
      "name": "William Elen de Brassington (chaplain, 1363 witness)",
      "first_name": "William Elen",
      "last_name": "de Brassington",
      "birth_date": "before about 1343",
      "birth_place": "Brassington, Derbyshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "historical_bearer_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.03,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DRO_D258_28_1_16_BRASSINGTON_WITNESSES_1363_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Named as a chaplain witnessing a 2 July 1363 Carsington deed. This is a documented medieval Brassington-associated person, but no kinship to the later Caverswall or Chelmorton line is established.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_LAURENCE_BRASSINGTON_BAGNALL_1658",
      "name": "Lawrence Brassington of Bagnall (will 1658)",
      "first_name": "Lawrence",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "before about 1638",
      "birth_place": "Bagnall, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "between 7 September 1658 and 1661",
      "death_place": "Bagnall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "historical_bearer_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFS_PASTTRACK_LAWRENCE_BRASSINGTON_WILL_BAGNALL_1658_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_LAWRENCE_BRASSINGTON_WILL_TRANSCRIPT_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "His will names sons Richard and William and daughters Anne, Dorothy and Ellen.",
      "research_note": "It establishes a documented Staffordshire Brassington household but gives no parentage or proven connection to the Caverswall branch.",
      "privacy_masked": false
    },
    {
      "id": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_NORTON_1622",
      "name": "Richard Brassington of Norton le Moors",
      "first_name": "Richard",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": "30 Oct 1622",
      "birth_place": "Norton le Moors, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": null,
      "death_place": null,
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_NORTON_LE_MOORS_1622_QL3G_KC8B_20261005",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_THOMAS_ISABELL_CAVERSWALL_SIBLING_CLUSTER_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_EARLY_LEEK_BRASSINGTON_HOUSEHOLDS_1634_1672_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch index names Thomas Brassington as father at the 30 October 1622 Norton le Moors baptism.",
      "research_note": "The event is record-linked, but the image has not been compared with the 1639 Caverswall baptism; this person is retained as a household-context candidate, not an asserted direct ancestor."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_MORE_HALL_1599",
      "name": "Thomas Brassington of More Hall",
      "first_name": "Thomas",
      "last_name": "Brassington",
      "birth_date": null,
      "birth_place": "More Hall, Stoke upon Trent, Staffordshire, England",
      "death_date": "before 28 Sep 1599",
      "death_place": "More Hall, Stoke upon Trent, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_MORE_HALL_1599_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Official probate index records a will and inventory for Thomas Brassington of More Hall, Stoke upon Trent, on 28 September 1599.",
      "research_note": "The entry is a distinct same-name household candidate; it is not identified with the Thomas named as father in baptisms from 1622–1639."
    }
  ],
  "relationships": [
    {
      "id": "PE_I1_I3",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I1",
      "target": "I3",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I2_I3",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I2",
      "target": "I3",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I1_I6",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I1",
      "target": "I6",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I5_I6",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I5",
      "target": "I6",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I3_I8",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I3",
      "target": "I8",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I7_I8",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I7",
      "target": "I8",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I9_I11",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I9",
      "target": "I11",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "gedcom",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from uploaded GEDCOM export.ged"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I10_I11",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I10",
      "target": "I11",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "gedcom",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from uploaded GEDCOM export.ged"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I9_I12",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I9",
      "target": "I12",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I10_I12",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I10",
      "target": "I12",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I13_I9",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I13",
      "target": "I9",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "evidence_strength": "1930 census household plus user-confirmed immediate family",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_HENDERSON_1930_CENSUS",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026 hypothesis review. H1: Sallie Jane Shortt (I13) is the parent of Mary Sue Henderson (I9). Alternatives: A namesake Sallie or nonparent household member (hypothetical). Evidence comparison: User confirmation and the 1930 household agree on this mother-daughter pair. Ranking: H1 overwhelmingly leads. Next discriminating evidence: A contradictory parent-naming record would change the assessment."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I14_I9",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I14",
      "target": "I9",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "evidence_strength": "1930 census household plus user-confirmed immediate family",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_HENDERSON_1930_CENSUS",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1930 Big Creek census places Mary Sue Henderson as a child in the Ed A. and Sallie Henderson household. Matthew independently confirms both relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I13_I15",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I13",
      "target": "I15",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I14_I15",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I14",
      "target": "I15",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I13_I16",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I13",
      "target": "I16",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I14_I16",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I14",
      "target": "I16",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I13_I17",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I13",
      "target": "I17",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I14_I17",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I14",
      "target": "I17",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I15_I19",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I15",
      "target": "I19",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I18_I19",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I18",
      "target": "I19",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I15_I20",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I15",
      "target": "I20",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I18_I20",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I18",
      "target": "I20",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I21_I23",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I21",
      "target": "I23",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I22_I23",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I22",
      "target": "I23",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I21_I24",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I21",
      "target": "I24",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I22_I24",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I22",
      "target": "I24",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I16_I26",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I16",
      "target": "I26",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I25_I26",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I25",
      "target": "I26",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I27_I10",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I27",
      "target": "I10",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "evidence_strength": "North Carolina death certificate explicitly names both parents, corroborated by census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1973",
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "George Gibson Fricke's North Carolina death certificate names father George Fricke and mother Florence Gibson. The 1920 and 1930 East Orange censuses place him in their household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I28_I10",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I28",
      "target": "I10",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "evidence_strength": "North Carolina death certificate explicitly names both parents, corroborated by census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1973",
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "George Gibson Fricke's North Carolina death certificate names father George Fricke and mother Florence Gibson. The 1920 and 1930 East Orange censuses place him in their household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I27_I29",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I27",
      "target": "I29",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM plus 1930 census household and compatible 1940 continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Existing GEDCOM link. The 1930 census lists Albert R. and the 1940 census lists Russell in the George and Florence household, supporting Albert Russell as their child."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I28_I29",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I28",
      "target": "I29",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM plus 1930 census household and compatible 1940 continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Existing GEDCOM link. The 1930 census lists Albert R. and the 1940 census lists Russell in the George and Florence household, supporting Albert Russell as their child."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I27_I30",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I27",
      "target": "I30",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM plus 1930 census household and compatible 1940 continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Existing GEDCOM link. Edna K. Fricke appears as their child in 1930 and Edna Frecke continues in the 1940 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I28_I30",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I28",
      "target": "I30",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM plus 1930 census household and compatible 1940 continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Existing GEDCOM link. Edna K. Fricke appears as their child in 1930 and Edna Frecke continues in the 1940 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I29_I32",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I29",
      "target": "I32",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I31_I32",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I31",
      "target": "I32",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I33_I34",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I33",
      "target": "I34",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I32_I34",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I32",
      "target": "I34",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I33_I35",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I33",
      "target": "I35",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I32_I35",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I32",
      "target": "I35",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I33_I36",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I33",
      "target": "I36",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I32_I36",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I32",
      "target": "I36",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I33_I37",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I33",
      "target": "I37",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I32_I37",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I32",
      "target": "I37",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I38_I22",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I38",
      "target": "I22",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I19_I22",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I19",
      "target": "I22",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I39_I40",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I39",
      "target": "I40",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I34_I40",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I34",
      "target": "I40",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I41_I43",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I41",
      "target": "I43",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I42_I43",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I42",
      "target": "I43",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I44_I41",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I44",
      "target": "I41",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Alfreda is named with parents Alfred Percy and Kezia Davies in both 1911 and 1921 census evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I45_I41",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I45",
      "target": "I41",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Alfreda is named with parents Alfred Percy and Kezia Davies in both 1911 and 1921 census evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I44_I46",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I44",
      "target": "I46",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I45_I46",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I45",
      "target": "I46",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I44_I47",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I44",
      "target": "I47",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I45_I47",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I45",
      "target": "I47",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I44_I48",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I44",
      "target": "I48",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "David Livingstone Davies is named with parents Alfred Percy and Kezia in both 1911 and 1921 census evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I45_I48",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I45",
      "target": "I48",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "David Livingstone Davies is named with parents Alfred Percy and Kezia in both 1911 and 1921 census evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I51_I14",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I51",
      "target": "I14",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1964 Virginia death certificate explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1964"
      ],
      "source_note": "Edward Alderson Henderson's Virginia death record explicitly names Conley Henderson as father and Rebeccah Talley as mother. Lifetime census evidence is compatible."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I52_I14",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I52",
      "target": "I14",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1964 Virginia death certificate explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1964"
      ],
      "source_note": "Edward Alderson Henderson's Virginia death record explicitly names Conley Henderson as father and Rebeccah Talley as mother. Lifetime census evidence is compatible."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I53_I13",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I53",
      "target": "I13",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1974 Virginia death certificate explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_SALLY_JANE_HENDERSON_1974"
      ],
      "source_note": "Sallie Jane Henderson's Virginia death record explicitly names David K. Shortt as father and Tiny White as mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I54_I13",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I54",
      "target": "I13",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1974 Virginia death certificate explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_SALLY_JANE_HENDERSON_1974"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026 hypothesis review. H1: Leanna Egleton Tiney White (I54) is the parent of Sallie Jane Shortt (I13). Alternatives: Tiny White was a different woman from Leanna (hypothetical). Evidence comparison: Sallie’s death record names Tiny White; Leanna/Tiney identity is supported by child marriage and household continuity. The combined names and relatives favor one woman. Ranking: H1 strongly leads. Next discriminating evidence: Original death/marriage images could refine spelling and informant reliability."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I55_I54",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I55",
      "target": "I54",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM plus compiled family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I56_I54",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I56",
      "target": "I54",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "two compiled household identifications; no original parent-naming record inspected for Leanna",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I57_I55",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I57",
      "target": "I55",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "John Henry White's marriage record explicitly names father George W. White",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Henry White's 1861 Washington County marriage names Geo. W. White as his father; John also appears age 16 in George's 1860 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I58_I55",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I58",
      "target": "I55",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "John Henry White's marriage record explicitly names mother Julia A. White",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "John Henry White's 1861 Washington County marriage names Julia A. White as his mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I60_I57",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I60",
      "target": "I57",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM and Geneanet claim supported circumstantially by 1811 marriage and 1820 Botetourt household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_BOTETOURT_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_FANNY_GEORGE_WHITE"
      ],
      "source_note": "GEDCOM, Geneanet, and WeRelate explicitly identify Benjamin and Frances as George's parents. Their 1811 Botetourt marriage and 1820 household are chronologically and geographically compatible, but no probate, Bible, land, church, or other primary record naming George was located. The edge remains provisional."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I61_I57",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I61",
      "target": "I57",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM and Geneanet claim supported circumstantially by 1811 marriage and 1820 Botetourt household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_BOTETOURT_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_FANNY_GEORGE_WHITE"
      ],
      "source_note": "GEDCOM, Geneanet, and WeRelate explicitly identify Benjamin and Frances as George's parents. Their 1811 Botetourt marriage and 1820 household are chronologically and geographically compatible, but no probate, Bible, land, church, or other primary record naming George was located. The edge remains provisional."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I62_I60",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I62",
      "target": "I60",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit secondary child list plus direct parental marriage and compatible household chronology; no contemporary child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "WeRelate explicitly lists Benjamin Franklin White, born 1790, among children of Benjamin White and Susan Bartee. Their 1786 marriage and subsequent household chronology are compatible, but the child list is secondary and no contemporary parent record has been found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I63_I60",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I63",
      "target": "I60",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit secondary child list plus direct parental marriage and compatible household chronology; no contemporary child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "WeRelate explicitly lists Benjamin Franklin White, born 1790, among children of Benjamin White and Susan Bartee. Their 1786 marriage and subsequent household chronology are compatible, but the child list is secondary and no contemporary parent record has been found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I65_I61",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I65",
      "target": "I61",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "daughter's marriage transcript explicitly names father Robert Lavinder",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811"
      ],
      "source_note": "Fanny Lavinder's 1811 Botetourt County marriage transcript explicitly names Robert Lavinder as her father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I68_I63",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I68",
      "target": "I63",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "Franklin County marriage-bond abstract identifies William as surety for his daughter Suckey",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_SUKEY_WHITE_BOND_SURETY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786"
      ],
      "source_note": "A record-based profile quotes the 8 Oct 1786 Franklin County marriage bond identifying William Bartee as surety for his daughter Suckey and Benjamin White. The original image has not been inspected, so confidence is 0.97 rather than 0.995."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I70_I51",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I70",
      "target": "I51",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "Virginia relationship index explicitly names Robert and Mary as Connally's parents, supported by the 1860 household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Virginia marriage index explicitly names Robt. and Mary Henderson as parents of Connally Henderson. The 1860 Washington County household independently places Conley, age 8, with Robert and Mary. The agreement of a parent-naming record and household evidence makes this relationship highly secure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I71_I51",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I71",
      "target": "I51",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "Virginia relationship index explicitly names Robert and Mary as Connally's parents, supported by the 1860 household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Virginia marriage index explicitly names Robt. and Mary Henderson as parents of Connally Henderson. The 1860 Washington County household independently places Conley, age 8, with Robert and Mary. The agreement of a parent-naming record and household evidence makes this relationship highly secure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I72_I68",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I72",
      "target": "I68",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "malformed compiled parent field with contradictory chronology",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled field appears to name an older William Bartee and Lettishe Butt as parents, but the record has impossible chronology and may merge generations."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I73_I68",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I73",
      "target": "I68",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "malformed compiled parent field with contradictory chronology",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled field appears to name an older William Bartee and Lettishe Butt as parents, but the record has impossible chronology and may merge generations."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I74_I72",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I74",
      "target": "I72",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.22,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled same-name Bartee chain; no direct record identifies Robert William as a son",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 12 correction: the 1782 will names sons Thomas, Robert, William, and James but no son Robert William fitting this profile. The link remains visible only as a weak same-name compiled hypothesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I76_I27",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I76",
      "target": "I27",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1881 church baptism explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PRESBYTERIAN_JOHANN_GEORG_FRICKE_BAPTISM_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "Johann Georg Fricke's 1881 Orange Presbyterian baptism explicitly names Heinrich Fricke and Katharina Schaaf as his parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I77_I27",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I77",
      "target": "I27",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1881 church baptism explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PRESBYTERIAN_JOHANN_GEORG_FRICKE_BAPTISM_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "Johann Georg Fricke's 1881 Orange Presbyterian baptism explicitly names Heinrich Fricke and Katharina Schaaf as his parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I81_I56",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I81",
      "target": "I56",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1850 census household plus explicit child relationship index",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I82_I56",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I82",
      "target": "I56",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1850 census household plus explicit child relationship index",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I83_I82",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I83",
      "target": "I82",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1888 near-contemporary biography explicitly identifies mother Elizabeth",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I84_I82",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I84",
      "target": "I82",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1888 near-contemporary biography explicitly names parent",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Brock's 1888 biography explicitly names William Gobble as John G. Gobble's father and gives compatible exact birth information for both."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I85_I84",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "I84",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "1888 near-contemporary biography explicitly identifies Jemima as paternal grandmother; relationship index also names parent, but neither is the original child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX"
      ],
      "source_note": "Brock's 1888 biography explicitly calls Jemima Linder John G. Gobble's paternal grandmother while naming William as John's father, placing Jemima as William's mother. A relationship index also names her, but the original child record has not been inspected, so confidence is 0.98 rather than 0.995."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I86_I84",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "I84",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "Virginia relationship index explicitly names John and Jimima as parents; Brock independently confirms Jemima in the paternal line",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Virginia relationship index explicitly names John Gobble and Jimima as William's parents. Brock independently confirms Jemima as William's mother through the paternal-grandmother statement but does not name William's father, leaving John slightly below direct multi-source certainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I12_I88",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I12",
      "target": "I88",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I87_I88",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I87",
      "target": "I88",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I12_I89",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I12",
      "target": "I89",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I87_I89",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I87",
      "target": "I89",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I89_I91",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I89",
      "target": "I91",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I90_I91",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I90",
      "target": "I91",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I46_I93",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I46",
      "target": "I93",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I92_I93",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I92",
      "target": "I93",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I46_I94",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I46",
      "target": "I94",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I92_I94",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I92",
      "target": "I94",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I46_I95",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I46",
      "target": "I95",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I92_I95",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I92",
      "target": "I95",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I47_I97",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I47",
      "target": "I97",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I96_I97",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I96",
      "target": "I97",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I47_I98",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I47",
      "target": "I98",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I96_I98",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I96",
      "target": "I98",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I47_I99",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I47",
      "target": "I99",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I96_I99",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I96",
      "target": "I99",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I100_I45",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I100",
      "target": "I45",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1883 baptism explicitly names parent plus census continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BAPTISM_1883"
      ],
      "source_note": "Alfred is explicitly listed as a child of the household in 1891 and appears again in 1901. Initials L and S conflict with Percy and are treated as transcript discrepancies."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I101_I45",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I101",
      "target": "I45",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1883 baptism explicitly names parent plus census continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BAPTISM_1883"
      ],
      "source_note": "Alfred is explicitly listed as a child of the household in 1891 and appears again in 1901. Initials L and S conflict with Percy and are treated as transcript discrepancies."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I100_I102",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I100",
      "target": "I102",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "1891 and 1901 census household continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Present at consistent ages in Frederick and Maria Davies's 1891 and 1901 households; child relationship inferred from family structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I101_I102",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I101",
      "target": "I102",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "1891 and 1901 census household continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Present at consistent ages in Frederick and Maria Davies's 1891 and 1901 households; child relationship inferred from family structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I102_I104",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I102",
      "target": "I104",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I103_I104",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I103",
      "target": "I104",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I102_I105",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I102",
      "target": "I105",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I103_I105",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I103",
      "target": "I105",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I102_I106",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I102",
      "target": "I106",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I103_I106",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I103",
      "target": "I106",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I109_I107",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I109",
      "target": "I107",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "dated European family profile and consistent two-wife chronology",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF"
      ],
      "source_note": "Published profiles consistently place Johann Friedrich born 12 Oct 1734 in the 1725 marriage of Johann Friedrich Gabel and Maria Magdalena Spiess. Original baptism image not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I111_I109",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I111",
      "target": "I109",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "institutional parish-referenced parent identification plus matching family and migration cluster",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GB26_IPGV_FRIEDRICH_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026 hypothesis review. H1: Hans (Johann) Jacob Gabel (I111) is the parent of Johann Friedrich Gabel (I109). Alternatives: A different Hans Jacob, or the Anna Catharina Kirchner mother assignment shown by FamilySearch LK75-RYD (documented competing database claim). Evidence comparison: IPGV names Hans-Jakob and Maria Margaretha Rheinmüller, with parish-book references and the distinctive migration/spouse/child cluster. The Goble household agrees. Their possible common source limits independence, but the record-linked cluster favors H1 over the competing uncited assignment. Ranking: H1 strongly leads; raise .58 to .94. Next discriminating evidence: St. Julian/Offenbach 1701 baptism and 1690/91 marriage images; resolve April day discrepancy."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I112_I109",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I112",
      "target": "I109",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "institutional card names mother with parish references and matching family cluster",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GB26_IPGV_FRIEDRICH_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller is Friedrich’s mother. H2: Anna Catharina Kirchner, a competing FamilySearch database assignment. IPGV 57056 cites parish sources and names Rheinmueller; the distinctive spouse/child/migration cluster supports H1. H1 strongly leads at .94; original 1701 baptism remains the best discriminating evidence. Parent cards are derivative cross-links, not independent confirmations."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I113_I73",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I113",
      "target": "I73",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "compatible compiled family accounts; no direct child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: the submitted family explicitly includes daughter Letitia/Lettishe and is compatible with the broader Butt history, but no baptism or probate record was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I114_I73",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I114",
      "target": "I73",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "compatible compiled family accounts; no direct child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: the submitted family explicitly includes daughter Letitia/Lettishe and is compatible with the broader Butt history, but no baptism or probate record was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I115_I75",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I115",
      "target": "I75",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM mother claim only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 12 audit: retained as a low-confidence named mother hypothesis; no direct or independent compiled evidence was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I116_I75",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I116",
      "target": "I75",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "Henry Wirick's will explicitly calls Mary Barttee his daughter",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Henry Wirick's will, dated 28 Dec 1710 and proved 20 Apr 1711, explicitly devises property to his daughter Mary Barttee."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I117_I113",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I117",
      "target": "I113",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "unsourced compiled family with duplicate Lemuel identities",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_WERELATE_LEMUEL_BUTT_1704_1753",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 12 audit: retained as a plausible named parent hypothesis, but the collaborative family contains duplicate Lemuel sons and no direct parent record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I118_I113",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I118",
      "target": "I113",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "unsourced compiled family with duplicate Lemuel identities",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_WERELATE_LEMUEL_BUTT_1704_1753",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 12 audit: retained as a plausible named parent hypothesis, but the collaborative family contains duplicate Lemuel sons and no direct parent record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I120_I118",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I120",
      "target": "I118",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM and unsourced collaborative-tree father claim only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 13 audit: retained as a weak named father hypothesis; no direct or independently sourced relationship evidence was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I122_I71",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I122",
      "target": "I71",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM and compiled family trees supported by the 1850 adjacent-household cluster and 1849 marriage identity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_HENDERSON_FAMILY_RECORD_NOTES"
      ],
      "source_note": "Two compiled trees identify David as Mary McNew's father. The cited 1850 census places newly married Mary Henderson immediately after David and Ann McNew's household, while the 1849 Washington County marriage establishes her McNew maiden identity. This is strong convergent evidence, but no captured record explicitly names David as Mary's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I124_I122",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I124",
      "target": "I122",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "Washington County chancery testimony explicitly calls David son of George McNew Sr.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_CHANCERY_DAVID_SON"
      ],
      "source_note": "In Francis Smith v. George McNew, testimony explicitly identifies David McNew as son of George McNew Sr.; this is direct relationship evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I125_I124",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I125",
      "target": "I124",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "multiple compiled lineages plus published family history identify William as George's father; original probate relationship still desirable",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_1715_1791",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Multiple compiled lineages and the McNew-Cawood family history identify George among William and Mary's sons. A full contemporary probate or baptism naming George remains desirable, so the edge is 0.97 rather than direct-record certainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I126_I124",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "target": "I124",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "published family history identifies William and wife Mary with sons including George; maiden surname unresolved",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Published family history identifies William and wife Mary with their sons, including George. Compiled sources disagree whether Mary was Berry or Clemons, so only the Mary identity is accepted and the maiden surname remains unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I127_I125",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I127",
      "target": "I125",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "published family history cites St. John's Parish baptismal record for the child",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_1715_1791",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The McNew-Cawood history reports William among the four children of Jeremiah II and Sarah recorded in St. John's Parish baptismal records. Confidence is 0.98 because the original register image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I128_I125",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I128",
      "target": "I125",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "published family history cites St. John's Parish baptismal record for the child",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The McNew-Cawood history reports William among the four children of Jeremiah II and Sarah recorded in St. John's Parish baptismal records. Confidence is 0.98 because the original register image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I129_I127",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I129",
      "target": "I127",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "Published family reconstruction; no inspected record explicitly identifies this parent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 10 audit: the cited history reconstructs Jeremiah II as the later Maryland-born son of Jeremiah and Phillis. Contemporary records prove the couple and older son John Howard, but no baptism or probate record directly naming Jeremiah II was found.\n\n15 September 2026 evidence calibration: The cited family history reconstructs Jeremiah II as a son of the older Jeremiah. Its quoted court record establishes the older household and John Howard, not Jeremiah II's filiation. Contemporary household evidence supports plausibility but does not independently establish this particular parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I130_I127",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I130",
      "target": "I127",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "Published family reconstruction; no inspected record explicitly identifies this parent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_GENEANET_PHILLIS_W_OJEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_PROFILE_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JEREMIAH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_NEW_EARLY_SETTLERS_MARYLAND_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 10 audit: Phillis is directly documented as Jeremiah's wife and mother of John Howard; the same published reconstruction identifies Jeremiah II as their later son. No direct maternity record for Jeremiah II was found.\n\n15 September 2026 evidence calibration: The cited history assigns Jeremiah II to Phillis, but the quoted court record identifies John Howard as her child. The later-son reconstruction remains plausible secondary evidence; the mother of one son cannot automatically be assigned to another. No contradictory mother is asserted."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I131_I129",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I131",
      "target": "I129",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.38,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled Scottish pedigree only; no direct parent record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a named compiled-tree father hypothesis; no baptism, will, or probate record was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I132_I129",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I132",
      "target": "I129",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "evidence_strength": "single compiled identity for GEDCOM mother placeholder",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a low-confidence named mother hypothesis; no original record was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I133_I131",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I133",
      "target": "I131",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "evidence_strength": "compatible but mutually dependent compiled trees",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 12 audit: retained as a low-confidence compiled father hypothesis. No direct Scottish record was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I135_I133",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I135",
      "target": "I133",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "evidence_strength": "compatible derivative pedigree with duplicated children; no direct record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 13 audit: retained as a low-confidence named father hypothesis; no contemporary Scottish evidence was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I151_I144",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I151",
      "target": "I144",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit daughter in 1851 census plus continuous childhood and adult records",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026. H1: Joseph Brassington (I151) is the parent of Sarah Brassington (I144). Alternatives: A different Joseph/Esther family (hypothetical). Evidence: Sarah’s 1841/1851 household and the existing St Paul baptism transcript give matching parents, address and shoemaking trade. This cluster is distinctive. Ranking: H1 very strongly leads; retain .995. Next: Sarah’s birth certificate provides the strongest independent parent check."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I152_I144",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I152",
      "target": "I144",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit daughter in 1851 census plus continuous childhood and adult records",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Sarah appears in Joseph and Esther Brassington's 1841 household and is explicitly recorded as their daughter in the 1851 Wolverhampton census."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I162_I160",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I162",
      "target": "I160",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1759 baptism explicitly names father Richard",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_POYNER_NEWPORT_BAPTISM_1759"
      ],
      "source_note": "Richard Poyner's 1759 Newport baptism explicitly names his father as Richard Poyner."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I163_I160",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I163",
      "target": "I160",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1759 baptism explicitly names mother Elizabeth",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_POYNER_NEWPORT_BAPTISM_1759"
      ],
      "source_note": "Richard Poyner's 1759 Newport baptism explicitly names his mother as Elizabeth; her maiden surname is unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I164_I161",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I164",
      "target": "I161",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "gedcom",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from uploaded GEDCOM export.ged"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I165_I161",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I165",
      "target": "I161",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "gedcom",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from uploaded GEDCOM export.ged"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I182_I100",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I182",
      "target": "I100",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM plus 1851 and 1861 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNY_1861_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Maria appears at consistent ages with William in both 1851 and 1861 Bradford-on-Avon census households; child relationship is strongly supported by GEDCOM and family continuity."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I183_I100",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I183",
      "target": "I100",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM plus 1851 census family household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_HANNY_CORNISH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Existing GEDCOM mother link strongly supported by Maria Hanney age 4 appearing in the 1851 household of William and wife Elizabeth, plus the confirmed parental marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I186_I182",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I186",
      "target": "I182",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1802 baptism and 1838 marriage both identify father William Hanny",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838"
      ],
      "source_note": "William Peters Hanny's 1802 baptism directly names father Wm Hanny; existing family identity and 1795 marriage resolve the father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I187_I182",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I187",
      "target": "I182",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "1802 baptism names mother Eliz plus 1795 marriage resolving Peters",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795"
      ],
      "source_note": "William Peters Hanny's 1802 baptism names mother Eliz.; her 1795 marriage to father William Hanny resolves her as Elizabeth Peters with high confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I188_I186",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I188",
      "target": "I186",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1771 Winsley baptism explicitly names Charles Hnney as father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CHARLES_HANNEY_1733_1797",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771"
      ],
      "source_note": "William Hanny's 3 Mar 1771 Winsley baptism explicitly names Charles Hnney as his father; the surname spelling is a compatible register variant."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I189_I186",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I189",
      "target": "I186",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1771 Winsley baptism explicitly names Cteren Hnney as mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771"
      ],
      "source_note": "William Hanny's 3 Mar 1771 Winsley baptism explicitly names Cteren Hnney as his mother; the entry is consistent with Catherine Waine, Charles Hanny's documented wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I190_I187",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I190",
      "target": "I187",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "chronologically plausible married couple; no direct baptism for Elizabeth located",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1764 marriage proves Isaiah Peters and Betty Willis were a couple before Elizabeth's reported 1765 birth, but no baptism or other record directly naming either as Elizabeth's parent was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I191_I187",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I191",
      "target": "I187",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "chronologically plausible married couple; no direct baptism for Elizabeth located",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1764 marriage proves Isaiah Peters and Betty Willis were a couple before Elizabeth's reported 1765 birth, but no baptism or other record directly naming either as Elizabeth's parent was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I196_I151",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I196",
      "target": "I151",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "Joseph's parish baptism explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026. H1: John Brassington (I196) is the parent of Joseph Brassington (I151). Alternatives: Joseph baptised in 1781 to elder John and Jane is the Wolverhampton adult (documented local namesake); alternatively an unlocated Joseph (hypothetical). Evidence: The 1787 baptism names John and Margaret. The adult’s stated Ranton origin supports the local match, and his 1851 age 58 is nearer 1787 than 1781, although neither agrees exactly. The 1781 Joseph is now an actual alternative, rather than an invented namesake. Ranking: 1787 H1 remains the leading identification, but the baptism-parentage proof and adult identity should be distinguished; adjust .995 to .97 for the combined parentage and adult-identity link because the 1781 Joseph is a documented competing local person. Next: Wolverhampton death certificate with age, original censuses, or probate/apprenticeship connecting the adult shoemaker to his parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I197_I151",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I197",
      "target": "I151",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "Joseph's parish baptism explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 Margaret mothered the Wolverhampton Joseph through identification with the Ranton child baptised in 1787. H2 the adult was Joseph baptised in 1781 to elder John and Jane, a documented local namesake. Ranton birthplace and relatively closer age favor H1, but original adult records should resolve the discrepancy. .97 reflects the combined identity/parentage judgment; the 1787 baptism itself explicitly names Margaret. See September 2026 Brassington review."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I93_I199",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I93",
      "target": "I199",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I198_I199",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I198",
      "target": "I199",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I199_I201",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I199",
      "target": "I201",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I200_I201",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I200",
      "target": "I201",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I94_I203",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I94",
      "target": "I203",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I202_I203",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I202",
      "target": "I203",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I94_I204",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I94",
      "target": "I204",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I202_I204",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I202",
      "target": "I204",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I95_I206",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I95",
      "target": "I206",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I205_I206",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I205",
      "target": "I206",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I95_I207",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I95",
      "target": "I207",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I205_I207",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I205",
      "target": "I207",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I98_I209",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I98",
      "target": "I209",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I208_I209",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I208",
      "target": "I209",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I48_I211",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I48",
      "target": "I211",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I210_I211",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I210",
      "target": "I211",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I48_I212",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I48",
      "target": "I212",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I210_I212",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I210",
      "target": "I212",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I48_I213",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I48",
      "target": "I213",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I210_I213",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I210",
      "target": "I213",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I211_I215",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I211",
      "target": "I215",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I214_I215",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I214",
      "target": "I215",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I43_I218",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I43",
      "target": "I218",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I217_I218",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I217",
      "target": "I218",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I43_I219",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I43",
      "target": "I219",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I217_I219",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I217",
      "target": "I219",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I43_I220",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I43",
      "target": "I220",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I217_I220",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I217",
      "target": "I220",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I221_I222",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I221",
      "target": "I222",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I4_I222",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I4",
      "target": "I222",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I221_I223",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I221",
      "target": "I223",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I4_I223",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I4",
      "target": "I223",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I221_I224",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I221",
      "target": "I224",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I4_I224",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I4",
      "target": "I224",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I221_I225",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I221",
      "target": "I225",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I4_I225",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I4",
      "target": "I225",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I17_I227",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I17",
      "target": "I227",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I226_I227",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I226",
      "target": "I227",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I227_I229",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I227",
      "target": "I229",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I228_I229",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I228",
      "target": "I229",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I229_I231",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I229",
      "target": "I231",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I230_I231",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I230",
      "target": "I231",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I234_I128",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I234",
      "target": "I128",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.64,
      "evidence_strength": "compatible compiled histories; no direct child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 10 audit: retained as a plausible compiled-family-history parent link. No baptism, will, guardianship, or other direct record naming Sarah was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I235_I128",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I235",
      "target": "I128",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.64,
      "evidence_strength": "compatible compiled histories; no direct child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 10 audit: retained as a plausible compiled-family-history parent link. No baptism, will, guardianship, or other direct record naming Sarah was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I236_I235",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I236",
      "target": "I235",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "evidence_strength": "compatible compiled histories; no direct child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a tree-derived parent hypothesis. No direct record naming Edward as this parent's child was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I237_I235",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I237",
      "target": "I235",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "evidence_strength": "compatible compiled histories; no direct child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a tree-derived parent hypothesis. No direct record naming Edward as this parent's child was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I241_I111",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I241",
      "target": "I111",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "documented younger Erpfingen namesake favors distinct-family explanation",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBEL_ANCESTRY_AU",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026 hypothesis review. H1: Johannes Göbel (I241) is the parent of Hans (Johann) Jacob Gabel (I111). Alternatives: H2: the Offenbach father and Erpfingen son are distinct; H3: another older son or erroneous dates (hypothetical). Evidence comparison: A reconstructed Erpfingen Hans Jacob was born in 1689 and married Anna Maria Schweickhard in 1711. Equating him with Friedrich’s father requires fatherhood at about eleven, plus explaining the reported 1690/91 Rheinmueller marriage. H3 remains possible, but merely moving a 1670 birth to Erpfingen does not explain the documented younger namesake. Ranking: H2 leads decisively over the proposed identity bridge; lower .18 to .10 and retain as a visible conflicting candidate. Next discriminating evidence: Original baptism/marriage entries identifying the Offenbach father’s origin and parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I243_I241",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I243",
      "target": "I241",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-register-based pedigree quotes Johannes birth entry and names Martin Goebel and Anna Kissling as his parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBEL_GENI",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026 hypothesis review. H1: Martin Göbel (I243) is the parent of Johannes Göbel (I241). Alternatives: Wrong Martin in a family repeating that name (hypothetical). Evidence comparison: The published reconstruction explicitly places Johannes in the younger Martin/Anna household. Chronology and locality agree. Ranking: H1 very strongly leads. Next discriminating evidence: Original Johannes baptism would verify the reconstruction."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I244_I243",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I244",
      "target": "I243",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree quotes child entry naming both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026 hypothesis review. H1: Margaretha (Margreth) Berlin (I244) is the parent of Martin Göbel (I243). Alternatives: The elder and younger Martins or their wives were conflated (hypothetical). Evidence comparison: The quoted child entry distinguishes the younger Martin and names Margaretha as mother; the separate generations are chronologically coherent. Ranking: H1 strongly leads. Next discriminating evidence: Original 1600 entry and 1597 marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I245_I243",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I245",
      "target": "I243",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree quotes child entry naming both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 13 audit: the parish-based pedigree explicitly gives the younger Martin's parents as Martin Goebell and Margaretha Berlin."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I246_I245",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I246",
      "target": "I245",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled mother hypothesis; no maternal identification in Weigel entry ?5152",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Reassessment 15 September 2026: the published Weigel pedigree mentions tentative father Hans but no mother. Margaretha Koch is retained as the compiled Ancestry mother hypothesis; compatible chronology is positive but insufficient to distinguish her from a mistaken tree attribution. Missing corroboration is not contradiction; no contrary original record found. Next: original marriage, burial or inheritance evidence naming Martin’s mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I247_I245",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I247",
      "target": "I245",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "evidence_strength": "Weigel entry ?5152 expressly proposes Hans as father but marks filiation uncertain",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Reassessment 15 September 2026: the earlier claim that Weigel omits Hans is incorrect. Entry ?5152, printed p.250 (PDF page index 250), names Hans Göbel in Erpfingen, born about 1550, died about 1627, as tentative father of Martin #2576, explicitly stating Filiation ist nicht gesichert (parentage is not established). Same name, locality and coherent dates support the proposed identification with I247 and justify a positive parent hypothesis. Alternative: Hans was another relative/local Göbel rather than Martin’s father; no specifically identified rival father found. The pedigree supplies no underlying parent-naming record here and its dependence on public trees is unknown; do not count it as independent confirmation. Hans is the leading named father candidate, but the alternatives remain poorly distinguished. Retain candidate status and ordinal score pending new discriminating evidence. Search original 1597 marriage, Hans burial, inheritance, land succession and forestry appointment records. Parish catalogue begins in 1594, after Martin’s estimated birth. Ludwig Göbel recorded in 1522 is a potential earlier relative, not a demonstrated father of Hans: an adult in 1522 fathering a child about 1550 would entail relatively late fatherhood; a grandfather or collateral connection also fits. No new parent link established."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I248_I162",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I248",
      "target": "I162",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "gedcom",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from uploaded GEDCOM export.ged"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I249_I162",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I249",
      "target": "I162",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "gedcom",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from uploaded GEDCOM export.ged"
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_ESTHER_THOMPSON_TO_ELLEN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I152",
      "target": "C_BRASSINGTON_ELLEN_1686",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.0,
      "evidence_strength": "chronologically impossible legacy snippet",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_ANCESTRY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rejected: Ellen Brassington is represented as born in 1686, while Esther Thompson was baptized in 1808. Esther cannot be Ellen's mother; the external snippet conflates unrelated Brassington families."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_WP_HANNY_TO_WILLIAM_HENRY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I182",
      "target": "C_HANNY_WILLIAM_HENRY_1839",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "external family source plus 1851 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_ANCESTRY",
        "SRC_HANNY_BHO",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "External sources identify William Henry as child; Henery Hanney age 12 in the 1851 household is a strong but not perfect given-name match."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_TO_WILLIAM_HENRY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I183",
      "target": "C_HANNY_WILLIAM_HENRY_1839",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "external family source plus 1851 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_ANCESTRY",
        "SRC_HANNY_BHO",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "External sources identify William Henry as child; Henery Hanney age 12 in the 1851 household is a strong but not perfect given-name match."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_JEREMIAH_MARYLAND_TO_C_MCNEW_MARY_LUCY_1709",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I127",
      "target": "C_MCNEW_MARY_LUCY_1709",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "multiple derivative genealogies; no direct baptism, will, or probate record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_SARAH_MARLOW_TO_C_MCNEW_MARY_LUCY_1709",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I128",
      "target": "C_MCNEW_MARY_LUCY_1709",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "single derivative genealogy; no direct maternity record",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sarah Marlow is named as mother in one derivative genealogy. No baptism, will, probate, or other primary record has been located to establish maternity, so this plausible link remains lower-confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_JEREMIAH_MARYLAND_TO_C_MCNEW_ANNE_1711",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I127",
      "target": "C_MCNEW_ANNE_1711",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "multiple derivative genealogies; no direct baptism, will, or probate record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_SARAH_MARLOW_TO_C_MCNEW_ANNE_1711",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I128",
      "target": "C_MCNEW_ANNE_1711",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "single derivative genealogy; no direct maternity record",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sarah Marlow is named as mother in one derivative genealogy. No baptism, will, probate, or other primary record has been located to establish maternity, so this plausible link remains lower-confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_JEREMIAH_MARYLAND_TO_C_MCNEW_EDWARD_MARLEY_1713",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I127",
      "target": "C_MCNEW_EDWARD_MARLEY_1713",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "multiple derivative genealogies; no direct baptism, will, or probate record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_SARAH_MARLOW_TO_C_MCNEW_EDWARD_MARLEY_1713",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I128",
      "target": "C_MCNEW_EDWARD_MARLEY_1713",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "single derivative genealogy; no direct maternity record",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sarah Marlow is named as mother in one derivative genealogy. No baptism, will, probate, or other primary record has been located to establish maternity, so this plausible link remains lower-confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_WP_HANNY_TO_JAMES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I182",
      "target": "C_HANNY_JAMES_1844",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "evidence_strength": "public_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child link from WikiTree Hanny cluster."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_TO_JAMES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I183",
      "target": "C_HANNY_JAMES_1844",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "evidence_strength": "public_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child link from WikiTree Hanny cluster."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_WILLIAM_HANNY_TO_SARAH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I186",
      "target": "C_HANNY_SARAH_1798",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "parent-naming birth index plus public timeline",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_GENI_WILLIAM",
        "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_SELECT_BIRTHS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Birth-index excerpt names William Hanney as spouse/father with child Sarah; event date omitted, so link to the 1798 candidate remains probable."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_HANS_CONRAD_RHEINMUELLER_TO_MARIA_REIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_RHEINMUELLER_HANS_CONRAD",
      "target": "I112",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "published_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a plausible derivative-tree father link; no original child record was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_MARIA_MOTHER_TO_MARIA_REIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_RHEINMUELLER_MARIA_MARGARETHA_MOTHER",
      "target": "I112",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "evidence_strength": "published_tree_low_detail",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a low-detail derivative-tree mother hypothesis; identity and direct evidence are absent."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I125_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I125",
      "target": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Elisha I. McNew listed as descendant of William McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "target": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Elisha I. McNew listed as descendant of Mary Eckless Berry."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I125_HV4_JEREMIAH_MCNEW_CHILD_OF_WILLIAM",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I125",
      "target": "HV4_JEREMIAH_MCNEW_CHILD_OF_WILLIAM",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I125_HV4_SHADRACK_MCNEW_1743_1823",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I125",
      "target": "HV4_SHADRACK_MCNEW_1743_1823",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "public_tree_snippet",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of William McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I125_HV4_GEORGE_E_MCNEW_SR_17_NOV_1763_5",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I125",
      "target": "HV4_GEORGE_E_MCNEW_SR_17_NOV_1763_5_MAY_1846",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "public_tree_snippet",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of William McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I125_HV4_EDWARD_MCNEW_FALL_1755",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I125",
      "target": "HV4_EDWARD_MCNEW_FALL_1755",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "public_tree_snippet",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of William McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I125_HV4_JOHN_BERRY_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I125",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_BERRY_MCNEW",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I125_HV4_DANIEL_SHADRACK_MCNEW_1745_1765",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I125",
      "target": "HV4_DANIEL_SHADRACK_MCNEW_1745_1765",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "public_tree_snippet",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of William McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804_HV4_MAR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_POLLY_MCNEW_1779_BEFORE_1810",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_NANCY_CATHERINE_SMITH_12_OCT_1756_14",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_NANCY_CATHERINE_SMITH_12_OCT_1756_14_SEP",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_POLLY_MCNEW_1779_BEFORE_1810",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Nancy Catherine Smith."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804_HV4_JOH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804_HV4_REB",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_REBECCA_MCNEW_ABOUT_1781_BEFORE_1812",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804_HV4_CAT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_CATHERINE_MCNEW_1783_9_JUN_1858",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804_HV4_TOB",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_TOBIAS_MCNEW_1785_FEB_1814",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804_HV4_WIL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_WILLIAM_J_MCNEW_1786_1839",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804_HV4_ELI",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_ELISHA_MCNEW_13_SEP_1788_26_AUG_1854",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804_HV4_NAN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_NANCY_MCNEW_1790_BETWEEN_1860_AND_1870",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804_HV4_GEO",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_GEORGE_MCNEW_ABOUT_1792_1_OCT_1828",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804_HV4_ISA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_ISAAC_MCNEW_1795_20_OCT_1819",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of Elisha I. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820_HV4_ELIZAB",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820",
      "target": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "two compatible published family reconstructions; Elizabeth's adult Perry family is independently corroborated but no parent-naming original record reviewed",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1798_LUKE_PERRY",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_MCNEW_SARAH_ATHEY_F14178",
        "SRC_GENEALOGYTRAILS_PERRY_CEMETERY_ELISHA_1818_1889"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nathan McNew and Cook both place Elizabeth with John McNew and Sarah Athey. The cemetery transcription corroborates Elizabeth's adult Perry identity, but it does not name her parents. Both parent links remain the best current circumstantial placement rather than direct proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780_HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780",
      "target": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "two compatible published family reconstructions; Elizabeth's adult Perry family is independently corroborated but no parent-naming original record reviewed",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1798_LUKE_PERRY",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_MCNEW_SARAH_ATHEY_F14178",
        "SRC_GENEALOGYTRAILS_PERRY_CEMETERY_ELISHA_1818_1889"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nathan McNew and Cook both place Elizabeth with John McNew and Sarah Athey. The cemetery transcription corroborates Elizabeth's adult Perry identity, but it does not name her parents. Both parent links remain the best current circumstantial placement rather than direct proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820_HV4_JOHN_S",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nathan McNew's genealogy proposes John McNew as parent of John S. McNew. John S.'s later Missouri identity is now well supported independently, but no reviewed record directly names this older John as his father; the 0.78 link remains circumstantial."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780_HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nathan McNew's genealogy proposes Sarah Athey as parent of John S. McNew. John S.'s later Missouri identity is now well supported independently, but no reviewed record directly names Sarah Athey as his mother; the 0.78 link remains circumstantial."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820_HV4_MARTHA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820",
      "target": "HV4_MARTHA_MCNEW_7_APR_1812_3_NOV_1877",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780_HV4_MARTHA_MCNEW_7_",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780",
      "target": "HV4_MARTHA_MCNEW_7_APR_1812_3_NOV_1877",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of Sarah Athey."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820_HV4_FREDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820",
      "target": "HV4_FREDERICK_J_MCNEW_1813_ABOUT_1872",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780_HV4_FREDERICK_J_MCN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780",
      "target": "HV4_FREDERICK_J_MCNEW_1813_ABOUT_1872",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of Sarah Athey."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820_HV4_SARAH_",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820",
      "target": "HV4_SARAH_JANE_MCNEW_ABOUT_1817_POSSIBLY_186",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of John McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780_HV4_SARAH_JANE_MCNE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780",
      "target": "HV4_SARAH_JANE_MCNEW_ABOUT_1817_POSSIBLY_186",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Child of Sarah Athey."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876_",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_HUGH_MCNEW_ABOUT_1841",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nathan McNew's genealogy names Hugh as John S. McNew's child. This remains a compiled family claim; the stronger evidence for John S.'s adult identity does not independently establish the child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862_HV",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "target": "HV4_HUGH_MCNEW_ABOUT_1841",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parent-child claim with unresolved mother surname",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nathan McNew's genealogy names Hugh as child of Sarah Lusby. The same marriage is independently reconstructed with a likely wife Sarah A. Willoughby, so this maternal link is retained as plausible but lowered until a household, probate, or birth record identifies the mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_TOBIAS_SMITH_16_MAR_1725_1781_HV4_NA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_TOBIAS_SMITH_16_MAR_1725_1781",
      "target": "HV4_NANCY_CATHERINE_SMITH_12_OCT_1756_14_SEP",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Parent of Nancy Catherine Smith."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_MARY_MCDONALD_19_JAN_1730_1809_HV4_N",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_MCDONALD_19_JAN_1730_1809",
      "target": "HV4_NANCY_CATHERINE_SMITH_12_OCT_1756_14_SEP",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Parent of Nancy Catherine Smith."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_HANS_JURGEN_GEORG_SMITH_SMIDT_3_NOV_",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_HANS_JURGEN_GEORG_SMITH_SMIDT_3_NOV_1696",
      "target": "HV4_TOBIAS_SMITH_16_MAR_1725_1781",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Parent of Tobias Smith."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_MARIA_STALLKOP_15_MAR_1697_19_NOV_17",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARIA_STALLKOP_15_MAR_1697_19_NOV_1750",
      "target": "HV4_TOBIAS_SMITH_16_MAR_1725_1781",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Parent of Tobias Smith."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_PETER_STALLKOP_ABOUT_3_SEP_1709_HV4_",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_PETER_STALLKOP_ABOUT_3_SEP_1709",
      "target": "HV4_MARIA_STALLKOP_15_MAR_1697_19_NOV_1750",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Parent of Maria Stallkop."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_KATHERINE_PETERSON_HV4_MARIA_STALLKO",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_KATHERINE_PETERSON",
      "target": "HV4_MARIA_STALLKOP_15_MAR_1697_19_NOV_1750",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Parent of Maria Stallkop."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_BRYAN_MCDONALD_NOV_1686_21_MAY_1757_",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_BRYAN_MCDONALD_NOV_1686_21_MAY_1757",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_MCDONALD_19_JAN_1730_1809",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit will daughter plus husband and neighborhood identification",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_CHALKLEY_1757",
        "SRC_OT26_SMYTH_MCDONALD_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "1757 Augusta will explicitly names daughter Mary Smith. Family-history extract identifies her as Tobias Smyth’s wife and gives compatible McDonald/Robinson neighborhood. H1 leads over hypothetical different Mary Smith; see RN_OT26_MCDONALD_DELAWARE_VIRGINIA_BRIDGE. Does not automatically establish the downstream Nancy Catherine Smith link."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_CATHERINE_PRISCILLA_ROBINSON_ABOUT_1",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_CATHERINE_PRISCILLA_ROBINSON_ABOUT_1694_",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_MCDONALD_19_JAN_1730_1809",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Parent of Mary McDonald."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_JOHN_QUEEN_ATHEY_24_MAY_1756_1831_HV",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_QUEEN_ATHEY_24_MAY_1756_1831",
      "target": "HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "evidence_strength": "public_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Father of Sarah Athey."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_THOMAS_ATHEY_14_FEB_1717_AFTER_1766_",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_THOMAS_ATHEY_14_FEB_1717_AFTER_1766",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_QUEEN_ATHEY_24_MAY_1756_1831",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parent of John Queen Athey."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ELINOR_LUCILLE_QUEEN_1716_BETWEEN_17",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELINOR_LUCILLE_QUEEN_1716_BETWEEN_1769_A",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_QUEEN_ATHEY_24_MAY_1756_1831",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parent of John Queen Athey."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_177",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "HV4_ELINOR_LUCILLE_QUEEN_1716_BETWEEN_1769_A",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "Competing published father identity; no original filiation record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "SRC_ATHY_ELINOR_PARENT_CONFLICT_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parent of Elinor Lucille Queen.\n\n15 September 2026 review: A focused Athy reconstruction names Richard Queen as Elinor's father, contradicting the compiled Marsham/Mary household. The old 1716 birth also strains that household; no original parent-identifying record has been inspected. Retain this hypothesis at low confidence, not as established ancestry. No existing Richard Queen is selected merely by name."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755_H",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "target": "HV4_ELINOR_LUCILLE_QUEEN_1716_BETWEEN_1769_A",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "evidence_strength": "Competing published father identity; no original filiation record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "SRC_ATHY_ELINOR_PARENT_CONFLICT_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parent of Elinor Lucille Queen.\n\n15 September 2026 review: A focused Athy reconstruction names Richard Queen as Elinor's father, contradicting the compiled Marsham/Mary household. The old 1716 birth also strains that household; no original parent-identifying record has been inspected. Retain this hypothesis at low confidence, not as established ancestry. No existing Richard Queen is selected merely by name."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "target": "I234",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "evidence_strength": "documented same-place adult plus compiled daughter claim; no direct child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES_COUNTY_DEED_1671_1674",
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_RENT_ROLL",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: Ralph is directly documented in colonial Charles County, making the compiled placement plausible, but no baptism, will, or deed directly names Mary as his daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_I234",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "target": "I234",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "evidence_strength": "Ann is documented as Ralph Shaw's later wife, while the daughters are attributed to an unidentified first wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1710/11 agreement documents Ann as Ralph's then-wife, but the sourced reconstruction identifies Mary, Dorothy, and Ann as daughters of Ralph and an earlier unidentified wife. The imported maternity is retained only as a weak conflicting hypothesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_HV4_DOROTHY_SHAW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "target": "HV4_DOROTHY_SHAW_ABOUT_1668",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "evidence_strength": "Ann is documented as Ralph Shaw's later wife, while the daughters are attributed to an unidentified first wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1710/11 agreement documents Ann as Ralph's then-wife, but the sourced reconstruction identifies Mary, Dorothy, and Ann as daughters of Ralph and an earlier unidentified wife. The imported maternity is retained only as a weak conflicting hypothesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I111_HV4_JOHANN_PHILIP_GABEL_14_AUG_1698",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I111",
      "target": "HV4_JOHANN_PHILIP_GABEL_14_AUG_1698",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Hans Jacob Gabel."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I112_HV4_JOHANN_PHILIP_GABEL_14_AUG_1698",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I112",
      "target": "HV4_JOHANN_PHILIP_GABEL_14_AUG_1698",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Maria Margretha Rheinmueller."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS_C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAG",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS",
      "target": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "public_tree_snippet",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parent of Maria Magdalene Spiess."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I109_HV4_ANNA_CATHARINA_GABEL_19_MAR_172",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I109",
      "target": "HV4_ANNA_CATHARINA_GABEL_19_MAR_1726",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Johann Friedrich Gabel."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA_HV4_ANNA_CATHAR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "target": "HV4_ANNA_CATHARINA_GABEL_19_MAR_1726",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Maria Magdalene Spiess."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I109_HV4_JOHANN_PHILLIP_GABEL_3_APR_1730",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I109",
      "target": "HV4_JOHANN_PHILLIP_GABEL_3_APR_1730",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Johann Friedrich Gabel."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA_HV4_JOHANN_PHIL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "target": "HV4_JOHANN_PHILLIP_GABEL_3_APR_1730",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Maria Magdalene Spiess."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I109_HV4_JOHN_NICHOLAS_GABEL_ABOUT_1744",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I109",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_NICHOLAS_GABEL_ABOUT_1744",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Johann Friedrich Gabel."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA_HV4_JOHN_NICHOL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_NICHOLAS_GABEL_ABOUT_1744",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Maria Magdalene Spiess."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I109_HV4_JOHN_JOHANN_GEORGE_GABEL_17_FEB",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I109",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_JOHANN_GEORGE_GABEL_17_FEB_1758",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Johann Friedrich Gabel."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I110_HV4_JOHN_JOHANN_GEORGE_GABEL_17_FEB",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I110",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_JOHANN_GEORGE_GABEL_17_FEB_1758",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.54,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Christiana Henrietta Hornberger or second-family cluster."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I109_HV4_JOHN_GOBBLE_1744_10_APR_1744",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I109",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_GOBBLE_1744_10_APR_1744",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Johann Friedrich Gabel."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA_HV4_JOHN_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_GOBBLE_1744_10_APR_1744",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "published_genealogy_snippet",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Candidate child of Maria Magdalene Spiess."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I109_HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I109",
      "target": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "institutional card citing 1754 Lutheran baptism names the parent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_GB26_IPGV_FRIEDRICH_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026 hypothesis review. H1: Johann Friedrich Gabel (I109) is the parent of Christian Gobble (HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754). Alternatives: The baptized Christian was a different Christian from the Maryland/Virginia veteran (hypothetical). Evidence comparison: IPGV links the 1754 child to Sarah Gise and names his parents. The pension-family narrative agrees in names, age and migration, although shared genealogy is possible. Ranking: H1 strongly leads; retain .99 for the parent link, with identity bridge explicitly stated. Next discriminating evidence: Original baptism and pension family statements compared together."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_PE_I110_HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I110",
      "target": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "institutional card citing 1754 Lutheran baptism names the parent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "IPGV's migration card cites Christian's 21 May 1754 Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran baptism and names Christiana Henrietta Hornberger as mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER_TO_HANS_JACOB",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "target": "I111",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "distinct documented Erpfingen son born 1689 conflicts with Offenbach father chronology",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 Ursula mothered Offenbach Hans Jacob I111; H2 the association conflates him with her reconstructed Erpfingen son born 1689 (GB26_HANS_JACOB_GOEBEL_1689). H2 leads: the latter was about eleven in 1701 and has a different spouse chronology. An additional older son remains hypothetical, not disproved. Retain conflicting candidate .10. Next: original Offenbach marriage/baptism identifying origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING_TO_JOHANNES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "target": "I241",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-register-based pedigree quotes Johannes birth entry and names Martin Goebel and Anna Kissling as his parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish-register-based pedigree gives Johannes Göbel, born Erpfingen 11 Oct 1641, as a child of Martin Göbel and Anna Kissling."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_GEORG_HEINRICH_TO_HEINRICH_1845",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV10_GEORG_HEINRICH_FRICKE_1827_1848",
      "target": "HV10_HEINRICH_FRIEDRICH_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "German baptism naming parent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "1845 Hannover baptism directly names Georg Heinrich Fricke as father of Heinrich Friedrich Fricke. This German child is kept separate from New Jersey Henry Albert Fricke."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_ANNA_LEFFLER_TO_HEINRICH_1845",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV10_ANNA_DOROTHEE_LEFFLER_ABT1827",
      "target": "HV10_HEINRICH_FRIEDRICH_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "German baptism naming parent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "1845 Hannover baptism directly names Anna Dorothee Leffler as mother of Heinrich Friedrich Fricke. This German child is kept separate from New Jersey Henry Albert Fricke."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_EBERHARD_TO_GEORG",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV10_EBERHARD_HEINRICH_FRICKE_ABT1788",
      "target": "HV10_GEORG_HEINRICH_FRICKE_1827_1848",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "German baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "1827 baptism names Eber. Hein. Fricke as father of Georg Heinrich Fricke."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_SOPHIE_TO_GEORG",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV10_SOPHIE_ELISABETH_ANGENETEN_ABT1795",
      "target": "HV10_GEORG_HEINRICH_FRICKE_1827_1848",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "evidence_strength": "German baptism + marriage surname clue",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_EBERHARD_SOPHIE_1820_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "1827 baptism names Sophie Elis. Agnete as mother; 1820 marriage gives fuller probable surname Angeneten."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I76_I78",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I76",
      "target": "I78",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 census household naming child with parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_ELIZABETH_1890_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "1880 East Orange census lists Elizabeth Fricke, age 11, as daughter in the Henry and Cathrine Fricke household; 1890 marriage record likely identifies the same Elizabeth."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I77_I78",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I77",
      "target": "I78",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 census household naming child with parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_ELIZABETH_1890_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "1880 East Orange census lists Elizabeth Fricke, age 11, as daughter in the Henry and Cathrine Fricke household; 1890 marriage record likely identifies the same Elizabeth."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I76_I79",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I76",
      "target": "I79",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 census household naming child with parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1880 East Orange census lists William Fricke, age 6, as son in the Henry and Cathrine Fricke household."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I77_I79",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I77",
      "target": "I79",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 census household naming child with parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1880 East Orange census lists William Fricke, age 6, as son in the Henry and Cathrine Fricke household."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I76_I80",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I76",
      "target": "I80",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 census household naming child with parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1920_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1880 East Orange census lists Charles Fricke, age 2, as son in the Henry and Cathrine Fricke household; later censuses support the sibling network."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I77_I80",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I77",
      "target": "I80",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 census household naming child with parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1920_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1880 East Orange census lists Charles Fricke, age 2, as son in the Henry and Cathrine Fricke household; later censuses support the sibling network."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I76_HV10_ERNEST_DANIEL_FRICKE_1884",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I76",
      "target": "HV10_ERNEST_DANIEL_FRICKE_1884",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "1900/1905/1910 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1905 census supports Ernest/Earnest as son in household. The 1900 census independently lists this child in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I77_HV10_ERNEST_DANIEL_FRICKE_1884",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I77",
      "target": "HV10_ERNEST_DANIEL_FRICKE_1884",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "1900/1905/1910 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1905 census supports Ernest/Earnest as son in household. The 1900 census independently lists this child in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I76_HV10_HENRY_FRICKE_JR_ABT1886",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I76",
      "target": "HV10_HENRY_FRICKE_JR_ABT1886",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "1900/1905/1910 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1905 and 1910 censuses support Henry Jr as son. The 1900 census independently lists this child in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I77_HV10_HENRY_FRICKE_JR_ABT1886",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I77",
      "target": "HV10_HENRY_FRICKE_JR_ABT1886",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "1900/1905/1910 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1905 and 1910 censuses support Henry Jr as son. The 1900 census independently lists this child in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I76_HV10_JOHN_FRICKE_1889",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I76",
      "target": "HV10_JOHN_FRICKE_1889",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "birth record + 1900/1905/1910 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_JOHN_1889_BIRTH",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "John’s 1889 birth record names Henry Fricke and Katharina Schaff as parents. The 1900 census independently lists this child in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_PE_I77_HV10_JOHN_FRICKE_1889",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I77",
      "target": "HV10_JOHN_FRICKE_1889",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "birth record + 1900/1905/1910 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_JOHN_1889_BIRTH",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "John’s 1889 birth record names Henry Fricke and Katharina Schaff as parents. The 1900 census independently lists this child in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_THOMAS_KEZIA_THOMAS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "target": "I44",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1891 and 1901 census households explicitly place the child with the parent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Kizzie, age 8, appears with John and Jane in 1891; Kezia, age 18, appears with the same parents in 1901. Name, age, place, and household continuity identify the target Kezia."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JANE_THOMAS_KEZIA_THOMAS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "target": "I44",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1891 and 1901 census households explicitly place the child with the parent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Kizzie, age 8, appears with John and Jane in 1891; Kezia, age 18, appears with the same parents in 1901. Name, age, place, and household continuity identify the target Kezia."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_WALTER_CROWTHER_ANNE_CROWTHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WALTER_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_ANNE",
      "target": "SRC_ANNE_CROWTHER_CHR_1832_CEFNLLYS",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "christening transcript",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TRANSCRIPT_PROVENANCE_20260915_CROWTHER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Anne Crowther christening transcript names Walter Crowther as father.\n\n15 September 2026: Structured citation restored from existing transcript description. No new independent verification or confidence increase. "
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JANE_CROWTHER_ANNE_CROWTHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JANE_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_ANNE",
      "target": "SRC_ANNE_CROWTHER_CHR_1832_CEFNLLYS",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "christening transcript",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TRANSCRIPT_PROVENANCE_20260915_CROWTHER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Anne Crowther christening transcript names Jane as mother.\n\n15 September 2026: Structured citation restored from existing transcript description. No new independent verification or confidence increase. "
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOSHUA_CROWTHER_WALTER_CROWTHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JOSHUA_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_WALTER",
      "target": "SRC_WALTER_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_ANNE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "user confirmation",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified Joshua Crowther as father of Walter Crowther."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_ANN_CROWTHER_WALTER_CROWTHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANN_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_WALTER",
      "target": "SRC_WALTER_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_ANNE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "user confirmation",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified Ann Crowther as mother of Walter Crowther."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_ANN_GRINDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FATHER_OF_ANN",
      "target": "SRC_ANN_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_WALTER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "christening transcript",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TRANSCRIPT_PROVENANCE_20260915_GRINDLEY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ann Grindley christening transcript names Thos. Grindley as father.\n\n15 September 2026: Structured citation restored from existing transcript description. No new independent verification or confidence increase. "
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARGT_GRINDLEY_ANN_GRINDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGT_GRINDLEY_MOTHER_OF_ANN",
      "target": "SRC_ANN_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_WALTER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "christening transcript",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TRANSCRIPT_PROVENANCE_20260915_GRINDLEY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ann Grindley christening transcript names Margt. as mother.\n\n15 September 2026: Structured citation restored from existing transcript description. No new independent verification or confidence increase. Margt. is named in the baptism; Harding is a separately inferred marriage identity, pending corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_RUTH_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "target": "I142",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "baptism transcript",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RUTH_HANDLEY_BAPTISM_PROVENANCE_20260915",
        "SRC_HANDLEY_MILWICH_COMPILED_REVIEW_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ruth Handley baptism transcript names Sampson Handley as father.\n\n15 September 2026: Citation restored from existing description. The matching online compilation is derivative evidence. Grade retained; connecting the baptized child to the later bride and identifying a maiden surname require separate evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_RUTH_MOTHER_RUTH_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_RUTH_MOTHER_OF_RUTH_HANDLEY",
      "target": "I142",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "baptism transcript",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RUTH_HANDLEY_BAPTISM_PROVENANCE_20260915",
        "SRC_HANDLEY_MILWICH_COMPILED_REVIEW_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ruth Handley baptism transcript names Ruth as mother.\n\n15 September 2026: Citation restored from existing description. The matching online compilation is derivative evidence. Grade retained; connecting the baptized child to the later bride and identifying a maiden surname require separate evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_SAMPSON_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_1697",
      "target": "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "user confirmation + FamilySearch person page",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified George Handley, FamilySearch ID LH5P-Y91, as father of Sampson Handley."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_SAMPSON_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_1691",
      "target": "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "user confirmation + FamilySearch person page",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified Anne Cartwright, FamilySearch ID LH5P-YMZ, as mother of Sampson Handley."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_THOMAS_HANDLEY_GEORGE_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_THOMAS_HANDLEY_ABT1666",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_1697",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "user confirmation + FamilySearch person page",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified Thomas Handley, FamilySearch ID KNSY-JXJ, as father of George Handley."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_HANNA_FENTON_GEORGE_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_1697",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "user confirmation + FamilySearch person page",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified Hanna Fenton, FamilySearch ID KZW6-ZMT, as mother of George Handley."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JAMES_HANDLEY_THOMAS_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JAMES_JACOBUS_HANDLEY_1647",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_HANDLEY_ABT1666",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "user confirmation + FamilySearch person page",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified James Jacobus Handley, FamilySearch ID MXC3-9RS, as father of Thomas Handley."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_HANNAH_WILD_THOMAS_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANNAH_WILD_1649",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_HANDLEY_ABT1666",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "user confirmation + FamilySearch person page",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified Hannah Wild, FamilySearch ID MMTQ-7RH, as mother of Thomas Handley."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_SARAH_HANCOCK_JAMES_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SARAH_HANCOCK_1624",
      "target": "SRC_JAMES_JACOBUS_HANDLEY_1647",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "user confirmation + FamilySearch person page",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified Sarah Hancock, FamilySearch ID G12M-1YY, as mother of James Jacobus Handley."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_WILLIAM_WILDE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_ELEANOR_WALL_GEORGE_WYLDE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ELEANOR_WALL_1524",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "History of Parliament / family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "History of Parliament/Wikipedia identifies George Wylde I as son of Thomas Wylde and Ellinor/Eleanor Wall; later supplied profile specifically names Eleanor Wall as his mother and gives birth 1557, death 27 Mar 1616, Droitwich burial."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_GEORGE_WALL_ELEANOR_WALL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
      "target": "SRC_ELEANOR_WALL_1524",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "genealogical record naming parents and child",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified George Wall, FamilySearch ID GYYH-T4J, as father of Eleanor Wall. Genealogical record lists Eleanor as child of George Wall and Jane Eden Gardner."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JANE_GARDNER_ELEANOR_WALL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JANE_EDEN_GARDNER",
      "target": "SRC_ELEANOR_WALL_1524",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "genealogical record naming parents and child",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified Jane Eden Gardner, FamilySearch ID LR37-853, as mother of Eleanor Wall. Genealogical record lists Eleanor as child of George Wall and Jane Eden Gardner."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_AMELIA_HARGIS_JOHN_DAVID_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "target": "I122",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "Probable compiled maternity; direct testimony establishes father only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_CHANCERY_DAVID_SON"
      ],
      "source_note": "Amelia is consistently identified as George's spouse and David's mother in compiled family context. The chancery testimony directly proves George as David's father but does not name Amelia, so her edge remains slightly inferential.\n\n15 September 2026 evidence calibration: The chancery abstract distinguishes testimony from a parenthetical compiled family list. David is explicitly George's son; Amelia's maternity is supplied by the compiler. Retain as probable compiled maternity, rather than near-direct certainty. The current wife being older than George conflicts with the precise compiled births; identity and dates need original-record review."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JOHN_HOWARD_MACKNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I130",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_HOWARD_MACKNEW_CHILD_JEREMIAH",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "quoted 10 Jan 1670 Charles County court record calls John Howard the son of Jeremiah Macknew and Phillis his wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PROFILE_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JEREMIAH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_NEW_EARLY_SETTLERS_MARYLAND_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_PHILLIS_PARENTAGE_UNKNOWN",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published McNew-Cawood history quotes the 10 Jan 1670 Charles County proceeding in which Jeremiah Macknew and Phillis his wife bound “their sonn John Howard” to Robert Littlepage until age 21. This directly identifies both parents; it does not establish either parent's overseas birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_STEPHAN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile; son Stephan marriage record context",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN_SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "Simon Lindner's 1713 marriage record explicitly names father Stephen Lindner",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 17 Oct 1713 Blankenloch marriage index explicitly identifies Simon Lindner's father as Stephen Lindner."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA_SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The original user-supplied GEDCOM identifies Barbara Mollfinger as Simon Lindner’s mother. Simon’s 1713 marriage record names Stephan Lindner as his father but does not name his mother, so this maternal link remains a derivative family-tree claim at its existing confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN_SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_REGINA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_REGINA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA_SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_REGINA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_REGINA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN_RC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_BARBARA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_BARBARA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA_RC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_BARBARA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_BARBARA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN_RC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA_RC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN_INDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_REGINA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_REGINA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA_INDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_REGINA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_REGINA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN_DNER_SIBLING_SIMON_CHRISTOPHORUS_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_CHRISTOPHORUS_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA_DNER_SIBLING_SIMON_CHRISTOPHORUS_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_CHRISTOPHORUS_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN_SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_CONRAD_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_CONRAD_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA_SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_CONRAD_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_CONRAD_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN_SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA_SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN__LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_MAGDALENA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_MAGDALENA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA__LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_MAGDALENA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_MAGDALENA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_MARIA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_MARIA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_MARIA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_ANNA_MARIA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN__SIBLING_SIMON_JOHANNES_ALBRECHT_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_JOHANNES_ALBRECHT_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA__SIBLING_SIMON_JOHANNES_ALBRECHT_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_JOHANNES_ALBRECHT_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_STEPHAN_SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_JOBST_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_JOBST_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_BARBARA_SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_JOBST_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDNER_SIBLING_SIMON_JOBST_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_SIMON_R_SIBLING_JERICK_MARIA_CATHARINA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_MARIA_CATHARINA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARGARETHA_R_SIBLING_JERICK_MARIA_CATHARINA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_MARIA_CATHARINA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_SIMON_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_SIMON_K__LINDER_JR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_SIMON_K__LINDER_JR",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied Simon K. Linder Jr. as child of Simon K Lindner and Margaretha Nagel; born before 22 Sep 1717 in Blankenloch and died about 1798 in Rockingham County, North Carolina."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARGARETHA_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_SIMON_K__LINDER_JR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_SIMON_K__LINDER_JR",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied Simon K. Linder Jr. as child of Simon K Lindner and Margaretha Nagel; born before 22 Sep 1717 in Blankenloch and died about 1798 in Rockingham County, North Carolina."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_SIMON_IBLING_JERICK_ELIZABETHA__LINDER__ULANDT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "target": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "1733 passenger household lists Simon, Margrett, and Elizabeth age 11; cited family reconstruction identifies the later Newland wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1733 passenger list places Elizabeth age 11 with Simon and Margrett Linder. Cited Linder/Newland research identifies her as the Elizabetha Lintner who married Johann Ulandt in 1739. Household structure plus the exact later identity strongly support the parent relationship; no standalone baptism was inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARGARETHA_IBLING_JERICK_ELIZABETHA__LINDER__ULANDT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "target": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "1733 passenger household lists Margrett and Elizabeth age 11; cited family reconstruction identifies the later Newland wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1733 passenger list places Elizabeth age 11 with Margrett and Simon Linder. Cited family research identifies her as the later wife of John Newland. The household evidence is strong but not a standalone baptism, leaving maternity slightly below certainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_SIMON_ER_SIBLING_JERICK_ERNST_FRIDERICH_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_ERNST_FRIDERICH_LINDER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARGARETHA_ER_SIBLING_JERICK_ERNST_FRIDERICH_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_ERNST_FRIDERICH_LINDER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_SIMON_SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_LORENTZ_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_LORENTZ_LINDER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARGARETHA_SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_LORENTZ_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_LORENTZ_LINDER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_SIMON__LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_HANNS_JÖRG_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_HANNS_JÖRG_LINDER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARGARETHA__LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_HANNS_JÖRG_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_HANNS_JÖRG_LINDER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_SIMON_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_MARGARETHA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_MARGARETHA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARGARETHA_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_MARGARETHA_LINDNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_MARGARETHA_LINDNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_NEWLAND_MARY_ULANDT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "target": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1800 will directly names Mary Linder as daughter",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 10 audit: John Newland's 1800 Berkeley County will explicitly names Mary Linder among his children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JERICK_SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ABRAM_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ABRAM_LINDER",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARY_NEWLAND_SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ABRAM_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ABRAM_LINDER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JERICK__JERICK_ELIZABETH_JEMIMA__LINDER__GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ELIZABETH_JEMIMA__LINDER__GOBBLE",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARY_NEWLAND__JERICK_ELIZABETH_JEMIMA__LINDER__GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ELIZABETH_JEMIMA__LINDER__GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JERICK_NDER_CHILD_JERICK_SARAH__LINDER__FLEENOR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_SARAH__LINDER__FLEENOR",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARY_NEWLAND_NDER_CHILD_JERICK_SARAH__LINDER__FLEENOR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_SARAH__LINDER__FLEENOR",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JERICK_SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ISAAC_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ISAAC_LINDER",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARY_NEWLAND_SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ISAAC_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_ISAAC_LINDER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JERICK_SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_JACOB_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_JACOB_LINDER",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARY_NEWLAND_SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_JACOB_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_JACOB_LINDER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JERICK_SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_JOSEPH_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_JOSEPH_LINDER",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARY_NEWLAND_SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_JOSEPH_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "target": "SRC_LINDER_CHILD_JERICK_JOSEPH_LINDER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_GOBBLE_C_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_GEORGE_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_GEORGE_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JEMIMA_GOBBLE_C_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_GEORGE_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_GEORGE_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_GOBBLE_OBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ELIZABETH_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ELIZABETH_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JEMIMA_GOBBLE_OBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ELIZABETH_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ELIZABETH_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_GOBBLE_BLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MARY__GOBBLE__ZION",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MARY__GOBBLE__ZION",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JEMIMA_GOBBLE_BLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MARY__GOBBLE__ZION",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MARY__GOBBLE__ZION",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_GOBBLE_ILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_REBECCA__GOBBLE__TALBERT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_REBECCA__GOBBLE__TALBERT",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JEMIMA_GOBBLE_ILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_REBECCA__GOBBLE__TALBERT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_REBECCA__GOBBLE__TALBERT",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_GOBBLE_RC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_SARAH_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_SARAH_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JEMIMA_GOBBLE_RC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_SARAH_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_SARAH_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_GOBBLE_ILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MARTHA__GOBBLE__MCKNIGHT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MARTHA__GOBBLE__MCKNIGHT",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JEMIMA_GOBBLE_ILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MARTHA__GOBBLE__MCKNIGHT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MARTHA__GOBBLE__MCKNIGHT",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_GOBBLE_RC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ISAAC_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ISAAC_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JEMIMA_GOBBLE_RC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ISAAC_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ISAAC_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_GOBBLE__GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ABRAHAM_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ABRAHAM_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JEMIMA_GOBBLE__GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ABRAHAM_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_ABRAHAM_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_GOBBLE__GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_DELANEY_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_DELANEY_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JEMIMA_GOBBLE__GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_DELANEY_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_DELANEY_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_GOBBLE_RC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_NANCY_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_NANCY_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JEMIMA_GOBBLE_RC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_NANCY_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_NANCY_GOBBLE",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JOHN_GOBBLE_D_JOHN_JEMIMA_MATILDA_J__GOBBLE__KESTNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I86",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MATILDA_J__GOBBLE__KESTNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JEMIMA_GOBBLE_D_JOHN_JEMIMA_MATILDA_J__GOBBLE__KESTNER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "SRC_GOBBLE_CHILD_JOHN_JEMIMA_MATILDA_J__GOBBLE__KESTNER",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_BARBARA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "target": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1665 marriage record",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Barbara Mollfinger's 28 April 1665 Nenzenheim marriage directly names her deceased father as Hanß Mollfinger. It does not name her mother or his occupation or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL_HANS_MARTIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "target": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "exact-dated derivative reconstruction matches son Hannss Martin born 14 Feb 1656 and the existing Blankenloch chronology",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "GenArchives identifies Hans Anthoni Nagel as father of Hannss Martin born 14 Feb 1656. The father's reported 1622/1693 chronology and Blankenloch locality closely match the prior Hans Simon profile, but the original entry was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_CATHARINA_NAGEL_HANS_MARTIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "target": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "exact-dated derivative reconstruction identifies Anna Catharina Hansen as mother of Hannss Martin born 14 Feb 1656",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "GenArchives identifies Anna Catharina Hansen as mother of Hannss Martin born 14 Feb 1656. It refines the prior Catharina Unknown identity, but no original baptism was inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_HANS_MARTIN_MARGARETHA_NAGEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "Margretha Nagel's indexed 1695 baptism explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695"
      ],
      "source_note": "The indexed 10 Dec 1695 Blankenloch baptism explicitly names Hannß Martin and Anna Catharina Nagel as Margretha's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_ANNA_KIEFFER_MARGARETHA_NAGEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "Margretha Nagel's indexed 1695 baptism explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695"
      ],
      "source_note": "The indexed 10 Dec 1695 Blankenloch baptism explicitly names Hannß Martin and Anna Catharina Nagel as Margretha's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_HANS_MARTIN_HANSS_JERG_NAGEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "target": "SRC_HANSS_JERG_NAGEL",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_ANNA_KIEFFER_HANSS_JERG_NAGEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "target": "SRC_HANSS_JERG_NAGEL",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_HANS_MARTIN_ANNA_MARIA_NAGEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_MARIA_NAGEL",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_ANNA_KIEFFER_ANNA_MARIA_NAGEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_MARIA_NAGEL",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_WILLIAM_WALL_GEORGE_WALL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "William G Wall is father of George Wall."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_GRACE_BANESTER_GEORGE_WALL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Grace Banester is mother of George Wall."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_WILLIAM_WALL_SRC_WALL_SIB_WILLIAM_1510",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_WILLIAM_1510",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_GRACE_BANESTER_SRC_WALL_SIB_WILLIAM_1510",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_WILLIAM_1510",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_WILLIAM_WALL_SRC_WALL_SIB_JOSIAH_1515",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_JOSIAH_1515",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_GRACE_BANESTER_SRC_WALL_SIB_JOSIAH_1515",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_JOSIAH_1515",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_WILLIAM_WALL_SRC_WALL_SIB_LAWRENCE_1515",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_LAWRENCE_1515",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_GRACE_BANESTER_SRC_WALL_SIB_LAWRENCE_1515",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_LAWRENCE_1515",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_WILLIAM_WALL_SRC_WALL_SIB_RICHARD_1516",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_RICHARD_1516",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_GRACE_BANESTER_SRC_WALL_SIB_RICHARD_1516",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_RICHARD_1516",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_WILLIAM_WALL_SRC_WALL_SIB_EVAN_1518",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_EVAN_1518",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_GRACE_BANESTER_SRC_WALL_SIB_EVAN_1518",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_EVAN_1518",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_WILLIAM_WALL_SRC_WALL_SIB_ROBERT_1518",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_ROBERT_1518",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_GRACE_BANESTER_SRC_WALL_SIB_ROBERT_1518",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_ROBERT_1518",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_WILLIAM_WALL_SRC_WALL_SIB_THOMAS_1524",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_THOMAS_1524",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_GRACE_BANESTER_SRC_WALL_SIB_THOMAS_1524",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "target": "SRC_WALL_SIB_THOMAS_1524",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child of William G Wall and Grace Banester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_GEORGE_WALL_ELIZABETH_JOYSE_WALL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETH_JOYSE_WALL",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JANE_GARDNER_ELIZABETH_JOYSE_WALL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JANE_EDEN_GARDNER",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETH_JOYSE_WALL",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_RICHARD_WALL_WILLIAM_G_WALL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_RICHARD_WALL_ABT1463",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Richard Wall is father of William G Wall."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARGARET_PETTENATI_WILLIAM_G_WALL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Margaret Whalley Pettenati is mother of William G Wall."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GIROLAMO_PETTENATI->SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GIROLAMO_PETTENATI",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied Girolamo Pettenati as father of Margaret Whalley Pettenati."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MRS_GIROLAMO_PETTENATI->SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MRS_GIROLAMO_PETTENATI",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied Mrs. Girolamo Pettenati as mother of Margaret Whalley Pettenati; personal name unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_ELIZABETHA_WYLD_1602",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETHA_WYLD_1602",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "christening transcript",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Christening transcript names Willi Wyld as father of Elizabetha Wyld, christened 10 Oct 1602 at Saint Peter, Sheffield. Matched cautiously to existing William Wilde of Sheffield."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_THOMAS_WYLDE_CLOTHIER->SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_THOMAS_WYLDE_CLOTHIER",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "History of Parliament / Wikipedia summary",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "History of Parliament/Wikipedia identifies Thomas Wylde of The Commandery, Worcester, as father of George Wylde I."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_ELIZABETH_WILDE_1602",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETH_WILDE_1602",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_MARGARET_WILDE_1604",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARET_WILDE_1604",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_JOHN_WILD_1606",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_WILD_1606",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_ISABEL_WILD_1608",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_ISABEL_WILD_1608",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_WILLIAM_WILD_1610",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILD_1610",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_ANNA_WILDE_1612",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_WILDE_1612",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_HELEN_WILD_1614",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_HELEN_WILD_1614",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_GEORGE_WILD_1616",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_WILD_1616",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_JOSEPH_WILD_1618",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_JOSEPH_WILD_1618",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_SARAH_WILDE_1620",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_SARAH_WILDE_1620",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_SAMUEL_WILDE_1622",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_SAMUEL_WILDE_1622",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576->SRC_THOMAS_WILD_1626",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_WILD_1626",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_ELIZABETH_WILDE_1602",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETH_WILDE_1602",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_MARGARET_WILDE_1604",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARET_WILDE_1604",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_JOHN_WILD_1606",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_WILD_1606",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_ISABEL_WILD_1608",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_ISABEL_WILD_1608",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_WILLIAM_WILD_1610",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILD_1610",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_ANNA_WILDE_1612",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_WILDE_1612",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_HELEN_WILD_1614",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_HELEN_WILD_1614",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_GEORGE_WILD_1616",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_WILD_1616",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_JOSEPH_WILD_1618",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_JOSEPH_WILD_1618",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_SARAH_WILDE_1620",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_SARAH_WILDE_1620",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_SAMUEL_WILDE_1622",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_SAMUEL_WILDE_1622",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD->SRC_THOMAS_WILD_1626",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_WILD_1626",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak user-supplied family-profile hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld in the Sheffield family profile. Classified as weak in the 22 Jul 2026 review because the supplied family profile is the only stated support for this parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557->SRC_DAVID_WYLDE_1569",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "target": "SRC_DAVID_WYLDE_1569",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "Geni summary quoting History of Parliament / family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Geni/History of Parliament-derived George Wylde II profile lists David Wylde as brother of George Wylde II and child of George Wylde I and Frances Wylde, though David profile details remain conflicted."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557->SRC_EDMOND_WOLDE_1581",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "target": "SRC_EDMOND_WOLDE_1581",
      "status": "speculative",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "unsupported online-tree child link",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Speculative child link. Edmond Wolde has plausible Droitwich christening data, but no supplied source names George Wylde I and Frances Huddleston as parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557->SRC_ISABEL_WILDE_1589",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "target": "SRC_ISABEL_WILDE_1589",
      "status": "speculative",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "unsupported online-tree child link",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Speculative child link. Isabel Wilde profile has 0 sources and no supplied source names George Wylde I and Frances Huddleston as parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557->SRC_JOHN_WYLDE_1590",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_WYLDE_1590",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "History of Parliament / Geni summary",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WESTMINSTER_ABBEY_GEORGE_WYLDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "History of Parliament/Geni summary identifies John Wylde as brother of George Wylde II and child of George Wylde I and Frances Wylde.\n\n15 September 2026: Westminster Abbey identifies the younger George as brother of John Wild, Chief Baron. This corroborates the sibling group; the inscription does not independently identify John's mother or explicitly name John's father. Existing paternal assessment retained."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557->SRC_LADY_ELIZABETH_WYLDE_1591",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "target": "SRC_LADY_ELIZABETH_WYLDE_1591",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "History of Parliament / Geni summary + sourced FamilySearch vitals",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "History of Parliament/Geni summary identifies Elizabeth Wylde/Elizabeth Blount as sibling of George Wylde II and child of George Wylde I and Frances Wylde; FamilySearch profile has sourced Worcestershire vitals."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557->SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_II_1594",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_II_1594",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "Institutional transcription of former memorial names father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WESTMINSTER_ABBEY_GEORGE_WYLDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "History of Parliament/Geni summary identifies George Wylde II as second son of George Wylde I of Droitwich and Frances, daughter of Sir Edmund Huddleston.\n\n15 September 2026: Westminster Abbey reproduces the earlier memorial inscription explicitly identifying the younger George as son of George Wild, serjeant-at-law. This directly names the father in an institutional transcription; the original inscription has been replaced, so this is not an inspected surviving original inscription."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE->SRC_DAVID_WYLDE_1569",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "target": "SRC_DAVID_WYLDE_1569",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "Geni summary quoting History of Parliament / family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Geni/History of Parliament-derived George Wylde II profile lists David Wylde as brother of George Wylde II and child of George Wylde I and Frances Wylde, though David profile details remain conflicted."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE->SRC_EDMOND_WOLDE_1581",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "target": "SRC_EDMOND_WOLDE_1581",
      "status": "speculative",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "unsupported online-tree child link",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Speculative child link. Edmond Wolde has plausible Droitwich christening data, but no supplied source names George Wylde I and Frances Huddleston as parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE->SRC_ISABEL_WILDE_1589",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "target": "SRC_ISABEL_WILDE_1589",
      "status": "speculative",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "unsupported online-tree child link",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Speculative child link. Isabel Wilde profile has 0 sources and no supplied source names George Wylde I and Frances Huddleston as parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE->SRC_JOHN_WYLDE_1590",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_WYLDE_1590",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "History of Parliament / Geni summary",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "History of Parliament/Geni summary identifies John Wylde as brother of George Wylde II and child of George Wylde I and Frances Wylde."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE->SRC_LADY_ELIZABETH_WYLDE_1591",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "target": "SRC_LADY_ELIZABETH_WYLDE_1591",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "History of Parliament / Geni summary + sourced FamilySearch vitals",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "History of Parliament/Geni summary identifies Elizabeth Wylde/Elizabeth Blount as sibling of George Wylde II and child of George Wylde I and Frances Wylde; FamilySearch profile has sourced Worcestershire vitals."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE->SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_II_1594",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_II_1594",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "History of Parliament / Geni summary",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "History of Parliament/Geni summary identifies George Wylde II as second son of George Wylde I of Droitwich and Frances, daughter of Sir Edmund Huddleston."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN->SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_ABT1626",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_ABT1626",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN->SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1632_1633",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1632_1633",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN->SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1633_1633",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1633_1633",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN->SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1634",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1634",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN->SRC_MARGARETHA_LINDNER_1637_1638",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARETHA_LINDNER_1637_1638",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN->SRC_APOLLONIA_LINDNER_1639_1639",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_APOLLONIA_LINDNER_1639_1639",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN->SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1642_1718",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1642_1718",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN->SRC_KASPAR_LINDNER_1642",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_KASPAR_LINDNER_1642",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER->SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_ABT1626",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_ABT1626",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER->SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1632_1633",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1632_1633",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER->SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1633_1633",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1633_1633",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER->SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1634",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1634",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER->SRC_MARGARETHA_LINDNER_1637_1638",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARETHA_LINDNER_1637_1638",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER->SRC_APOLLONIA_LINDNER_1639_1639",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_APOLLONIA_LINDNER_1639_1639",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER->SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1642_1718",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1642_1718",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER->SRC_KASPAR_LINDNER_1642",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_KASPAR_LINDNER_1642",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER->SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "target": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The original user-supplied GEDCOM identifies Anna Fuchs as Stephan Lindner’s mother. The 1665 marriage record directly names Stephan’s father Michael but not his mother, so this maternal link remains a derivative family-tree claim at its existing confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN->SRC_JOHANNES_LINDNER_1642_1722",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_JOHANNES_LINDNER_1642_1722",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620->SRC_JOHANNES_LINDNER_1642_1722",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "target": "SRC_JOHANNES_LINDNER_1642_1722",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARTIN_LINDER_SRC_ELSBETH_LINDER_1606",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "target": "SRC_ELSBETH_LINDER_1606",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARTIN_LINDER_SRC_CHRISTINA_LINDER_1607",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "target": "SRC_CHRISTINA_LINDER_1607",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARTIN_LINDER_SRC_SALOME_LINDER_1610",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "target": "SRC_SALOME_LINDER_1610",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARTIN_LINDER_SRC_MARTY_LINDER_JR_1611",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "target": "SRC_MARTY_LINDER_JR_1611",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARTIN_LINDER_SRC_SIMEON_LINDER_1614",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "target": "SRC_SIMEON_LINDER_1614",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARTIN_LINDER_SRC_MARIA_LINDER_1616",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "target": "SRC_MARIA_LINDER_1616",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SALOME_WERREN_SRC_ELSBETH_LINDER_1606",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "target": "SRC_ELSBETH_LINDER_1606",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SALOME_WERREN_SRC_CHRISTINA_LINDER_1607",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "target": "SRC_CHRISTINA_LINDER_1607",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SALOME_WERREN_SRC_SALOME_LINDER_1610",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "target": "SRC_SALOME_LINDER_1610",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SALOME_WERREN_SRC_MARTY_LINDER_JR_1611",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "target": "SRC_MARTY_LINDER_JR_1611",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SALOME_WERREN_SRC_SIMEON_LINDER_1614",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "target": "SRC_SIMEON_LINDER_1614",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SALOME_WERREN_SRC_MARIA_LINDER_1616",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "target": "SRC_MARIA_LINDER_1616",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled Saanen family profile; full parish sibling group not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship belongs to a plausible compiled Saanen/Gsteig sibling group. Original parish evidence for this child has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HANS_FUCHS_ANNA_FUCHS_1596",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "transcribed parish baptism explicitly names Hans as father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OBERBOBINGEN_ANNA_FUCHS_BAPTISM_1596",
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Anna's 1596 Oberboebingen baptism explicitly names Hans Fuchs as her father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BARBARA_REIFF_ANNA_FUCHS_1596",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "status": "source_backed_given_name_compiled_maiden",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "baptism names mother Barbara; Reiff is the leading compiled maiden-surname hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OBERBOBINGEN_ANNA_FUCHS_BAPTISM_1596",
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_UNTERHAUSEN_MIXED_BOOK_1579_1618"
      ],
      "source_note": "Anna's 1596 baptism directly names her mother as Barbara. The identity of that woman as Barbara Reiff comes from a compiled profile. The profile's claimed 1590 Unterhausen marriage cannot be verified in the surviving Unterhausen marriage series, which begins in 1597. Barbara Reiff remains the leading named hypothesis over an entirely unknown maiden surname, but this displayed relationship is calibrated to 0.65 rather than presented as a fully sourced maiden identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HANS_FUCHS_SRC_BALTHASS_FUCHS_1595",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "target": "SRC_BALTHASS_FUCHS_1595",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled family profile; original child baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This named child belongs to the supplied Fuchs sibling reconstruction. The relationship is retained as plausible compiled evidence pending inspection of the child's parish baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HANS_FUCHS_SRC_JOHANNES_FUCHS_1602",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "target": "SRC_JOHANNES_FUCHS_1602",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled family profile; original child baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This named child belongs to the supplied Fuchs sibling reconstruction. The relationship is retained as plausible compiled evidence pending inspection of the child's parish baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HANS_FUCHS_SRC_BARBARA_FUCHS_1604",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "target": "SRC_BARBARA_FUCHS_1604",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled family profile; original child baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This named child belongs to the supplied Fuchs sibling reconstruction. The relationship is retained as plausible compiled evidence pending inspection of the child's parish baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HANS_FUCHS_SRC_VEIT_FUCHS_1606",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "target": "SRC_VEIT_FUCHS_1606",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled family profile; original child baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This named child belongs to the supplied Fuchs sibling reconstruction. The relationship is retained as plausible compiled evidence pending inspection of the child's parish baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HANS_FUCHS_SRC_MARIA_FUCHS_1608",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "target": "SRC_MARIA_FUCHS_1608",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled family profile; original child baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This named child belongs to the supplied Fuchs sibling reconstruction. The relationship is retained as plausible compiled evidence pending inspection of the child's parish baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BARBARA_REIFF_SRC_BALTHASS_FUCHS_1595",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "target": "SRC_BALTHASS_FUCHS_1595",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled family profile; original child baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This named child belongs to the supplied Fuchs sibling reconstruction. The relationship is retained as plausible compiled evidence pending inspection of the child's parish baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BARBARA_REIFF_SRC_JOHANNES_FUCHS_1602",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "target": "SRC_JOHANNES_FUCHS_1602",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled family profile; original child baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This named child belongs to the supplied Fuchs sibling reconstruction. The relationship is retained as plausible compiled evidence pending inspection of the child's parish baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BARBARA_REIFF_SRC_BARBARA_FUCHS_1604",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "target": "SRC_BARBARA_FUCHS_1604",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled family profile; original child baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This named child belongs to the supplied Fuchs sibling reconstruction. The relationship is retained as plausible compiled evidence pending inspection of the child's parish baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BARBARA_REIFF_SRC_VEIT_FUCHS_1606",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "target": "SRC_VEIT_FUCHS_1606",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled family profile; original child baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This named child belongs to the supplied Fuchs sibling reconstruction. The relationship is retained as plausible compiled evidence pending inspection of the child's parish baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BARBARA_REIFF_SRC_MARIA_FUCHS_1608",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "target": "SRC_MARIA_FUCHS_1608",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied compiled family profile; original child baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This named child belongs to the supplied Fuchs sibling reconstruction. The relationship is retained as plausible compiled evidence pending inspection of the child's parish baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623->SRC_JOHN_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1653",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1653",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623->SRC_SAMUEL_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1655",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "target": "SRC_SAMUEL_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1655",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623->SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1657",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "target": "SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1657",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623->SRC_SARA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1659",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "target": "SRC_SARA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1659",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623->SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1661",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "target": "SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1661",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE->SRC_JOHN_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1653",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1653",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE->SRC_SAMUEL_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1655",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "target": "SRC_SAMUEL_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1655",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE->SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1657",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "target": "SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1657",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE->SRC_SARA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1659",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "target": "SRC_SARA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1659",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE->SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1661",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "target": "SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1661",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623->SRC_HANNAH_WILDE_CHILD_GODFREY_HELLENA_1679",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "target": "SRC_HANNAH_WILDE_CHILD_GODFREY_HELLENA_1679",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied Hannah Wilde born 1679 as child of Godfrey Wilde and Hellena Tunstead."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_HELLENA_TUNSTEAD_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE->SRC_HANNAH_WILDE_CHILD_GODFREY_HELLENA_1679",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HELLENA_TUNSTEAD_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "target": "SRC_HANNAH_WILDE_CHILD_GODFREY_HELLENA_1679",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied Hannah Wilde born 1679 as child of Godfrey Wilde and Hellena Tunstead."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_GEORGE_WILD_1616->SRC_HANNAH_WILD_1649",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WILD_1616",
      "target": "SRC_HANNAH_WILD_1649",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "Hanna Wild christening transcript",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "England Births and Christenings transcript identifies Hanna Wild, female, christened 29 Apr 1649 at Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul Sheffield, daughter of Georgii Wild. Georgii is interpreted as George Wild; matched to existing George Wild born 1616 in the Sheffield Wilde family."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591->SRC_JOHANNES_HANCOCK_1616",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "target": "SRC_JOHANNES_HANCOCK_1616",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591->SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1617_1616",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "target": "SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1617_1616",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591->SRC_WILLIAM_HANCOCK_1620",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_HANCOCK_1620",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591->SRC_JOSEPH_HANCOCK_1621",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "target": "SRC_JOSEPH_HANCOCK_1621",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591->SRC_SARAH_HANCOCK_1624",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "target": "SRC_SARAH_HANCOCK_1624",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied Sarah Hancock as child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591->SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1627",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "target": "SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1627",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591->SRC_THOMAS_HANCOCK_1628_1628",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_HANCOCK_1628_1628",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591->SRC_ELIZABETH_HANCOCK_1628",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETH_HANCOCK_1628",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595->SRC_JOHANNES_HANCOCK_1616",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "target": "SRC_JOHANNES_HANCOCK_1616",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595->SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1617_1616",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "target": "SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1617_1616",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595->SRC_WILLIAM_HANCOCK_1620",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_HANCOCK_1620",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595->SRC_JOSEPH_HANCOCK_1621",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "target": "SRC_JOSEPH_HANCOCK_1621",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595->SRC_SARAH_HANCOCK_1624",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "target": "SRC_SARAH_HANCOCK_1624",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied Sarah Hancock as child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595->SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1627",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "target": "SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1627",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595->SRC_THOMAS_HANCOCK_1628_1628",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_HANCOCK_1628_1628",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595->SRC_ELIZABETH_HANCOCK_1628",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETH_HANCOCK_1628",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "user-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied this person as a child of Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_RICHARD_HANCOCK_1564->SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_RICHARD_HANCOCK_1564",
      "target": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "status": "speculative",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": "unstable FamilySearch parent link; no direct Robert baptism shown",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Speculative parent link. FamilySearch change history for Richard Hancock G11W-5CL shows recent creation, merges, GEDCOM-derived changes, deleted impossible children, competing wife/mother Joan Turner, and cleanup notes describing junk genealogy. No direct baptism/source for Robert naming this parent has been shown."
    },
    {
      "id": "pc:SRC_ANNE_ROADES_1567->SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNE_ROADES_1567",
      "target": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "status": "speculative",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": "unstable FamilySearch parent link; no direct Robert baptism shown",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Speculative parent link. FamilySearch change history for Richard Hancock G11W-5CL shows recent creation, merges, GEDCOM-derived changes, deleted impossible children, competing wife/mother Joan Turner, and cleanup notes describing junk genealogy. No direct baptism/source for Robert naming this parent has been shown."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND_I137",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "target": "I137",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1833 baptism explicitly names both parents, supported by 1851 stepfamily and 1854 marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1881_PE_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_E_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I137",
      "target": "SRC1881_RUTH_E_RHEAD_ABT1858",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1861, 1881, and 1891 census continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1861_HEYWOOD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ruth E Read, age 3, appears with Richard and Ellen in 1861; Ruth Elizabeth Rhead is named as their child in the 1881 and 1891 households."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1881_PE_ELLEN_RHEAD_RUTH_E_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I138",
      "target": "SRC1881_RUTH_E_RHEAD_ABT1858",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1881, 1891, and 1901 census continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1901_HEATH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ruth Elizabeth is named as a child in Richard and Ellen Rhead's 1881 and 1891 households and appears with widowed mother Ellen in 1901."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1881_PE_RICHARD_RHEAD_FLORENCE_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I137",
      "target": "SRC1881_FLORENCE_RHEAD_ABT1862",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1881 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1881 England Census, Birmingham lists Richard Rhead as head/husband and Florence Rhead age 19 as daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1881_PE_ELLEN_RHEAD_FLORENCE_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I138",
      "target": "SRC1881_FLORENCE_RHEAD_ABT1862",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1881 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1881 England Census, Birmingham lists Ellen Rhead as wife and Florence Rhead age 19 as daughter in the household."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_CHARLOTTE_BLOORE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I139",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_CHARLOTTE_RHEED_BLOORE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_JULIA_GLOVER_CHARLOTTE_BLOORE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_CHARLOTTE_RHEED_BLOORE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_GEORGE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I139",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1861 census explicitly identifies child in Sampson and Julia Rhead household",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1861 census comparison identifies George Rhead as a child in Sampson and Julia Rhead's Bucknall household. The Bucknall memorial independently names the same parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_JULIA_GLOVER_GEORGE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "memorial family link",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SAMPSON_JR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I139",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_JULIA_GLOVER_SAMPSON_JR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SUSANNAH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I139",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_SUSANNAH_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_JULIA_GLOVER_SUSANNAH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_SUSANNAH_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_DANIEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I139",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_DANIEL_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_JULIA_GLOVER_DANIEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_DANIEL_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_THOMAS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I139",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_THOMAS_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1861 census explicitly identifies child in Sampson and Julia Rhead household",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1861 census comparison identifies Thomas Rhead as a child in Sampson and Julia Rhead's Bucknall household. Find a Grave and the George Rhead memorial independently support the same family grouping."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_JULIA_GLOVER_THOMAS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_THOMAS_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "memorial sibling inference",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_JULIA_ANN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I139",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_RHEAD_MOUNTFORD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_JULIA_GLOVER_JULIA_ANN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_RHEAD_MOUNTFORD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_MARIA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I139",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_MARIA_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_JULIA_GLOVER_MARIA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_MARIA_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_JULIA_GLOVER_RICHARD_FREDERICK",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_RICHARD_FREDERICK_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON_JULIA",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_RICHARD_RHEAD_ELIZABETH_READ",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I141",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_ELIZABETH_READ_SIBLING_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.998
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_RUTH_HANDLEY_ELIZABETH_READ",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I142",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_ELIZABETH_READ_SIBLING_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_RUTH_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "target": "I142",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak public-tree-only Handley parent hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_SAMPSON_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_SAMPSON",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak public-tree-only Handley parent hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Public tree profile says Sampson Handley born about 1730 was son of George Handley. Explicitly classified as weak: this supports the proposed maternal-grandfather chain but still lacks a supplied primary record naming the parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_SAMPSON_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_HANDLEY",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "weak public-tree-only Handley parent hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Public tree profile says Sampson Handley born about 1730 was son of Ann Cartwright Handley. Explicitly classified as weak: this supports the proposed maternal-grandfather chain but still lacks a supplied primary record naming the parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_MARGARET_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_SAMPSON",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_MARGARET_HANDLEY_SIBLING_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_MARGARET_HANDLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_HANDLEY",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_MARGARET_HANDLEY_SIBLING_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_ANN_HADLEY_HUNT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_SAMPSON",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_ANN_HADLEY_HUNT_SIBLING_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_ANN_HADLEY_HUNT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_HANDLEY",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_ANN_HADLEY_HUNT_SIBLING_OF_SAMPSON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_MARY_ALKIN_ANN_CARTWRIGHT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_MARY_ALKIN_CARTWRIGHT",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_HANDLEY",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "public tree parent hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Public tree profile says Ann Handley formerly Cartwright was daughter of Mary (Alkin) Cartwright and unknown father."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_INDEX_PE_JOHN_ALKIN_MARY_ALLKIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_INDEX_JOHN_ALKIN_FATHER_OF_MARY",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_MARY_ALKIN_CARTWRIGHT",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "burial index father naming",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_ALKIN_BURIAL_1710_UTTOXETER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary Alkin burial index names father John Alkin."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_INDEX_PE_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_MARY_ALLKIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_INDEX_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_ALKIN",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_MARY_ALKIN_CARTWRIGHT",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled biography mother hypothesis + parental marriage index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_ALKINS_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_MARRIAGE_1667"
      ],
      "source_note": "Supplied biography identifies Elizabeth Bagnald as mother of Mary Alkin; marriage index supports Elizabeth Bagnald married John Alkins in 1667."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1825_PE_LEVI_RICHARD_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC1825_LEVI_HANBY_RHEAD",
      "target": "SRC1825_RICHARD_RHEAD_BURSLEM",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "baptism naming father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57"
      ],
      "source_note": "Baptism index names Levi Hanby Rhead as father of Richard Rhead, baptised 1825 at Burslem."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1825_PE_HENRIETTA_RICHARD_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC1825_HENRIETTA_RHEAD",
      "target": "SRC1825_RICHARD_RHEAD_BURSLEM",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "baptism naming mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57"
      ],
      "source_note": "Baptism index names Henrietta as mother of Richard Rhead, baptised 1825 at Burslem."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_PE_GEORGE_RHEAD_JULIA_ANN_POTTS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "target": "C_MEMORIAL_JULIA_ANN_RHEAD_POTTS",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "memorial child link",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Julia Ann Rhead Potts, 1850-1907, as child of George Rhead."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_PE_JANE_GODWIN_JULIA_ANN_POTTS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MEMORIAL_JANE_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_MEMORIAL_JULIA_ANN_RHEAD_POTTS",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "chronological mother inference from memorial",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Jane Godwin as George Rhead spouse married 1847 and Julia Ann Rhead Potts born 1850 as child. Mother assignment is inferred from chronology, not explicitly stated in supplied text."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_PE_GEORGE_RHEAD_THOMAS_GODWIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "target": "C_MEMORIAL_THOMAS_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "memorial child link",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Thomas Godwin Rhead, 1851-1852, as child of George Rhead."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_PE_JANE_GODWIN_THOMAS_GODWIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MEMORIAL_JANE_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_MEMORIAL_THOMAS_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "chronological mother inference from memorial",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Jane Godwin as George Rhead spouse married 1847 and Thomas Godwin Rhead born 1851 as child. Mother assignment is inferred from chronology, not explicitly stated in supplied text."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_PE_GEORGE_RHEAD_FREDERICK_GEORGE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "target": "C_MEMORIAL_FREDERICK_GEORGE_RHEAD",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "memorial child link",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Frederick George Rhead, 1873-1945, as child of George Rhead."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_PE_MARY_ANN_BEARDMORE_FREDERICK_GEORGE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MEMORIAL_MARY_ANN_BEARDMORE_RHEAD",
      "target": "C_MEMORIAL_FREDERICK_GEORGE_RHEAD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "chronological mother inference from memorial",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Mary Ann Beardmore as George Rhead spouse married 1866 and Frederick George Rhead born 1873 as child. Mother assignment is inferred from chronology, not explicitly stated in supplied text."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_PE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_RICHARD_FREDERICK_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I139",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_RICHARD_FREDERICK_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON_JULIA",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_CHARLES_POYNER_TO_RICHARD_1696",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_POYNER_CHARLES_PRE_1675",
      "target": "I248",
      "status": "weak_ambiguous_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": "weak ambiguous index/conflation hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_POYNER_ANCESTRY_RICHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Tentative parent edge; snippet's Richard Poyner b.1675 may represent the father or a conflated version of GEDCOM Richard Poyner b.1696. Explicitly classified as weak because the snippet may describe a different or conflated Richard Poyner."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_FREDRICK_GABEL_TO_HANS_JACOB_ALT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "target": "I111",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "evidence_strength": "conflicting alternate parent hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a named but weak conflicting alternate parent hypothesis; no independent original record was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_MARIA_SPIESS_TO_FREDERICK_GOBBLE_ALT_MOTHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "target": "I107",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "multiple published profiles identify Maria Spiess as mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF"
      ],
      "source_note": "Multiple profiles identify Maria Magdalena Spiess as mother of Johann Friedrich born 1734; chronology supports the first marriage, but original baptism image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I10_I1",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I10",
      "target": "I1",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I137_I50",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I137",
      "target": "I50",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "two census households explicitly identify Bernal as Richard and Ellen Rhead's son",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BERNAL_B_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1881 Birmingham and 1891 Upper Penn censuses independently record Bernal Bright in Richard and Ellen Rhead's household and explicitly identify him as their son."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I138_I50",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I138",
      "target": "I50",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "two census households explicitly identify Bernal as Richard and Ellen Rhead's son",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BERNAL_B_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1881 Birmingham and 1891 Upper Penn censuses independently record Bernal Bright in Richard and Ellen Rhead's household and explicitly identify him as their son."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I140_I137",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I140",
      "target": "I137",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1833 baptism explicitly names both parents, supported by 1851 stepfamily and 1854 marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Richard's original 1833 Stoke St Milborough baptism explicitly names Sarah Rhead as mother. Sampson and Sarah's 1832 marriage identifies her as Sarah Poyner; the later 1851 census records Richard as stepson in Sarah Botton's household after her remarriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I141_I139",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I141",
      "target": "I139",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.998,
      "evidence_strength": "baptism naming parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_QPSM_68WK"
      ],
      "source_note": "Baptism/parish register evidence: Sampson Handley Read, born 30 Jun 1799, baptised 4 Nov 1800 at Trentham, Staffordshire, son of Richard and Ruth Read. Surname variants Read/Rhead/Rheed noted in profile. Richard's original will explicitly calls Sampson his youngest child."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I142_I139",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I142",
      "target": "I139",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "baptism naming parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_QPSM_68WK"
      ],
      "source_note": "Baptism/parish register evidence: Sampson Handley Read, born 30 Jun 1799, baptised 4 Nov 1800 at Trentham, Staffordshire, son of Richard and Ruth Read. Surname variants Read/Rhead/Rheed noted in profile. Richard's will names wife Ruth and youngest child Sampson; the existing baptism directly names Ruth as Sampson's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I143_I49",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I143",
      "target": "I49",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1875 baptism explicitly names parents; 1881 census explicitly names daughter; 1891 household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rosa's 1875 baptism and 1899 church marriage explicitly name Richard Morrall as father; the 1881 census explicitly records her as daughter and the 1891 household corroborates the family."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I144_I49",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I144",
      "target": "I49",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1875 baptism explicitly names parents; 1881 census explicitly names daughter; 1891 household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026. H1: Sarah Brassington (I144) is the parent of Rosa Beatrice Morrall (I49). Alternatives: Another Sarah Morrall or an incorrect maiden identity (hypothetical). Evidence: Rosa’s baptism and household records agree; Sarah Brassington’s marriage and adult continuity identify her as Sarah Morrall. Ranking: H1 very strongly leads; retain .995. Next: Original birth or marriage images could refine transcription details."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I145_I138",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I145",
      "target": "I138",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1835 baptism explicitly names both parents plus 1851 census daughter relationship",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ellen's 1835 baptism explicitly names John Waterhouse as father; the 1851 census explicitly records her as his daughter, and her 1854 marriage independently names him."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I146_I138",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I146",
      "target": "I138",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1835 baptism explicitly names both parents plus 1851 census daughter relationship",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ellen's 1835 baptism explicitly names Ellen Waterhouse as mother; the 1851 census explicitly records the younger Ellen as daughter in John and Ellen's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I1_I4",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I1",
      "target": "I4",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I2_I4",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I2",
      "target": "I4",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I41_I2",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I41",
      "target": "I2",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I42_I2",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I42",
      "target": "I2",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I49_I42",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I49",
      "target": "I42",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026. H1: Rosa Beatrice Morrall (I49) is the parent of John Edgar Rhead (I42). Alternatives: A different Rosa or misassigned census child (hypothetical). Evidence: Two censuses link the distinctive John Edgar and Bernal Bright/Rosa Beatrice household. Ranking: H1 strongly leads; retain .99. Next: Original birth certificate or census images if a conflicting identity appears."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I50_I42",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I50",
      "target": "I42",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Edgar is named as a child in the Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead household in both 1911 and 1921 evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I9_I1",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I9",
      "target": "I1",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ANCESTRY_DAVE_SHORTT_GRAHAM_SHORTT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I53",
      "target": "C_ANCESTRY_GRAHAM_SHORTT_CHILD_OF_DAVE_LEANA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ANCESTRY_LEANA_WHITE_GRAHAM_SHORTT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I54",
      "target": "C_ANCESTRY_GRAHAM_SHORTT_CHILD_OF_DAVE_LEANA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_GONDER_CASPAR_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GONDER_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "target": "C_GONDER_ANNA_ELISABETHA_1822",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "father named in baptism index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1822 baptism index names Johann Caspar Gonder as Anna Elisabetha's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_DECHER_ANNA_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_DECHER_ANNA_CATHARINA",
      "target": "C_GONDER_ANNA_ELISABETHA_1822",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "mother named in baptism index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1822 baptism index names Anna Catharina Decher as Anna Elisabetha's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_JOHANNES_LUDWIG",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821",
      "target": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_LUDWIG",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.92
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_GONDER_ANNA_JOHANNES_LUDWIG",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GONDER_ANNA_ELISABETHA_1822",
      "target": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_LUDWIG",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_GONTER_BALTHASAR_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GONTER_JOHANN_BALTHASAR",
      "target": "C_GONDER_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "father named in marriage index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1826 marriage index names Johann Balthasar Gonter as Johann Caspar's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_GONTER_BARBARA_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GONTER_BARBARA_CATHARINA",
      "target": "C_GONDER_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "mother named in marriage index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1826 marriage index names Barbara Catharina Gonter as Johann Caspar's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_GONDER_CASPAR_SUSANNA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GONDER_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "target": "C_GONTER_SUSANNA_KREUTSCH",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_DECHER_CATHARINA_SUSANNA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_DECHER_ANNA_CATHARINA",
      "target": "C_GONTER_SUSANNA_KREUTSCH",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_GONDER_CASPAR_MARIA_KATHARINA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GONDER_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "target": "C_GONDER_MARIA_KATHARINA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_DECHER_CATHARINA_MARIA_KATHARINA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_DECHER_ANNA_CATHARINA",
      "target": "C_GONDER_MARIA_KATHARINA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_GONDER_JOHANNES_BARBARA_1762",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GONDER_JOHANNES",
      "target": "C_GONTER_BARBARA_CATHARINA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "father named in baptism index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_UNNAMED_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "The unnamed female baptism has Barbara Katherina's exact profile birth date; Johannes Gonder is therefore assigned as probable father."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_ENGEL_ANNA_BARBARA_1762",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ENGEL_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "target": "C_GONTER_BARBARA_CATHARINA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "mother named in baptism index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_UNNAMED_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "The unnamed female baptism has Barbara Katherina's exact profile birth date; Anna Elisabetha Engel is therefore assigned as probable mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_GONDER_DIETRICH_BALTHASAR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GONDER_DIETRICH",
      "target": "C_GONTER_JOHANN_BALTHASAR",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1762 baptism names father Dietrich; 1761 marriage supplies full identity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHANN_BALTHASAR_GONDER",
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761"
      ],
      "source_note": "Johann Balthasar's 1762 Obergleen baptism explicitly names Dietrich Gonder as father. The 1761 same-parish marriage identifies him as Johann Dietrich Gunter/Gonder."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_WENDEL_ANNA_BALTHASAR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WENDEL_ANNA_INCOMPLETE",
      "target": "C_GONTER_JOHANN_BALTHASAR",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1762 baptism names mother Anna Wendel; 1761 marriage supplies full identity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHANN_BALTHASAR_GONDER",
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761"
      ],
      "source_note": "Johann Balthasar's 1762 Obergleen baptism names mother Anna ... Wendel. The 1761 same-parish marriage identifies her fully as Anna Catharina Wendel."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_GONTER_BALTHASAR_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GONTER_JOHANN_BALTHASAR",
      "target": "C_GONTER_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.9
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_BENDER_ANNA_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BENDER_ANNA_MARGARETHA",
      "target": "C_GONTER_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.9
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_SCHAEF_JOHN_MARTIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821",
      "target": "C_SCHAAF_MARTIN_NEWARK",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.82
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_SCHAEF_ELIZABETH_MARTIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SCHAAF_ELIZABETH_ABT1823",
      "target": "C_SCHAAF_MARTIN_NEWARK",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.82
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_SCHAEF_JOHN_JUSTIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821",
      "target": "C_SCHAAF_JUSTIN_ABT1854",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "1870 household inference; no explicit relationship question",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_CENSUS_RELATIONSHIP_LIMIT_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Inferred child in the 1870 household.\n\n15 September 2026 review: The supplied 1870 transcript infers a child from household placement; the original schedule did not ask relationship to head. Age, surname and household context support a plausible family, but do not directly establish this parent. Retain as supported circumstantial evidence. No new parent-identifying record was found in this search. Jost, age 26 in 1880, is a possible continuation of Justin, age 16 in 1870; identity and relationship must be checked in the full 1880 return before adding corroborative weight."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_SCHAEF_ELIZABETH_JUSTIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SCHAAF_ELIZABETH_ABT1823",
      "target": "C_SCHAAF_JUSTIN_ABT1854",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "1870 household inference; no explicit relationship question",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_CENSUS_RELATIONSHIP_LIMIT_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Inferred child in the 1870 household.\n\n15 September 2026 review: The supplied 1870 transcript infers a child from household placement; the original schedule did not ask relationship to head. Age, surname and household context support a plausible family, but do not directly establish this parent. Retain as supported circumstantial evidence. No new parent-identifying record was found in this search. Jost, age 26 in 1880, is a possible continuation of Justin, age 16 in 1870; identity and relationship must be checked in the full 1880 return before adding corroborative weight."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_SCHAEF_JOHN_ELIZZIE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821",
      "target": "C_SCHAAF_ELIZZIE_ABT1858",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "1870 household inference; no explicit relationship question",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_CENSUS_RELATIONSHIP_LIMIT_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Inferred child in the 1870 household.\n\n15 September 2026 review: The supplied 1870 transcript infers a child from household placement; the original schedule did not ask relationship to head. Age, surname and household context support a plausible family, but do not directly establish this parent. Retain as supported circumstantial evidence. No new parent-identifying record was found in this search."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_PE_SCHAEF_ELIZABETH_ELIZZIE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SCHAAF_ELIZABETH_ABT1823",
      "target": "C_SCHAAF_ELIZZIE_ABT1858",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "1870 household inference; no explicit relationship question",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_CENSUS_RELATIONSHIP_LIMIT_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Inferred child in the 1870 household.\n\n15 September 2026 review: The supplied 1870 transcript infers a child from household placement; the original schedule did not ask relationship to head. Age, surname and household context support a plausible family, but do not directly establish this parent. Retain as supported circumstantial evidence. No new parent-identifying record was found in this search."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I50_EDWARD_RICHARD_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I50",
      "target": "SRC1911_EDWARD_RICHARD_RHEAD_ABT1901",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1911 census names Edward Richard as son in Bernal Bright Rhead's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I49_EDWARD_RICHARD_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I49",
      "target": "SRC1911_EDWARD_RICHARD_RHEAD_ABT1901",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1911 census names Edward Richard as son in Rosa Beatrice Rhead's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I50_BERNAL_ALBERT_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I50",
      "target": "SRC1911_BERNAL_ALBERT_RHEAD_ABT1903",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1911 census names Bernal Albert as son in Bernal Bright Rhead's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I49_BERNAL_ALBERT_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I49",
      "target": "SRC1911_BERNAL_ALBERT_RHEAD_ABT1903",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "1911 census names Bernal Albert as son in Rosa Beatrice Rhead's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I50_GEORGE_ERNEST_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I50",
      "target": "SRC1911_GEORGE_ERNEST_RHEAD_ABT1905",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "George Ernest is named as a child of the household in both 1911 and 1921 evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I49_GEORGE_ERNEST_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I49",
      "target": "SRC1911_GEORGE_ERNEST_RHEAD_ABT1905",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "George Ernest is named as a child of the household in both 1911 and 1921 evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I50_AMY_ROSA_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I50",
      "target": "SRC1911_AMY_ROSA_RHEAD_ABT1907",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Amy Rosa is named as a child of the household in both 1911 and 1921 evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I49_AMY_ROSA_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I49",
      "target": "SRC1911_AMY_ROSA_RHEAD_ABT1907",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1911 and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Amy Rosa is named as a child of the household in both 1911 and 1921 evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I145_FREDERICK_WATERHOUSE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I145",
      "target": "SRC1841_FREDERICK_WATERHOUSE_ABT1828",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1841 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on age, surname, and position in the John and Ellen Waterhouse household; relationship not explicit in 1841."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I146_FREDERICK_WATERHOUSE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I146",
      "target": "SRC1841_FREDERICK_WATERHOUSE_ABT1828",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1841 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on age, surname, and household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I145_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_1830",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I145",
      "target": "SRC1841_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ABT1830",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1841 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on age, surname, and household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I146_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_1830",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I146",
      "target": "SRC1841_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ABT1830",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1841 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on age, surname, and household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I145_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_1832",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I145",
      "target": "SRC1841_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ABT1832",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1841 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on age, surname, and household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I146_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_1832",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I146",
      "target": "SRC1841_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ABT1832",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1841 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on age, surname, and household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I145_WILLIAM_WATERHOUSE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I145",
      "target": "SRC1841_WILLIAM_WATERHOUSE_ABT1837",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1841 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on age, surname, and household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I146_WILLIAM_WATERHOUSE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I146",
      "target": "SRC1841_WILLIAM_WATERHOUSE_ABT1837",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1841 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on age, surname, and household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I145_EMMA_WATERHOUSE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I145",
      "target": "SRC1841_EMMA_WATERHOUSE_ABT1840",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1841 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on age, surname, and household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I146_EMMA_WATERHOUSE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I146",
      "target": "SRC1841_EMMA_WATERHOUSE_ABT1840",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1841 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on age, surname, and household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I101_ARTHUR_J_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I101",
      "target": "SRC1901_ARTHUR_J_DAVIES_ABT1881",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in 1891 plus 1901 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Explicitly listed as child in 1891 and present in the same family in 1901."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I100_ARTHUR_J_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I100",
      "target": "SRC1901_ARTHUR_J_DAVIES_ABT1881",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in 1891 plus 1901 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Explicitly listed as child in 1891 and present in the same family in 1901."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I101_ROBERT_L_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I101",
      "target": "SRC1901_ROBERT_L_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in 1891 plus 1901 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Explicitly listed as child in 1891 and present in the same family in 1901."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I100_ROBERT_L_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I100",
      "target": "SRC1901_ROBERT_L_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in 1891 plus 1901 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Explicitly listed as child in 1891 and present in the same family in 1901."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I101_FRANCIS_J_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I101",
      "target": "SRC1901_FRANCIS_J_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in 1891 plus 1901 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Explicitly listed as child in 1891 and present in the same family in 1901."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I100_FRANCIS_J_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I100",
      "target": "SRC1901_FRANCIS_J_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in 1891 plus 1901 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Explicitly listed as child in 1891 and present in the same family in 1901."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I101_LOUIE_S_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I101",
      "target": "SRC1901_LOUIE_S_DAVIES_ABT1890",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "1891 and 1901 census household continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Present at consistent ages in Frederick and Maria Davies's 1891 and 1901 households; child relationship inferred from family structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I100_LOUIE_S_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I100",
      "target": "SRC1901_LOUIE_S_DAVIES_ABT1890",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "1891 and 1901 census household continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Present at consistent ages in Frederick and Maria Davies's 1891 and 1901 households; child relationship inferred from family structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I101_THOMAS_E_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I101",
      "target": "SRC1901_THOMAS_E_DAVIES_ABT1894",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1901 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I100_THOMAS_E_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I100",
      "target": "SRC1901_THOMAS_E_DAVIES_ABT1894",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "1901 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I101_WALTER_H_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I101",
      "target": "SRC1891_WALTER_H_DAVIES_ABT1882",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in 1891 census",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Walter H is explicitly listed as a child in the 1891 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I100_WALTER_H_DAVIES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I100",
      "target": "SRC1891_WALTER_H_DAVIES_ABT1882",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in 1891 census",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Walter H is explicitly listed as a child in the 1891 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I182_ANNA_HANNEY_1841",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I182",
      "target": "SRC1851_ANNA_HANNEY_ABT1841",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "1851 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on surname, age, and household structure; individual relationship field not supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I183_ANNA_HANNEY_1841",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I183",
      "target": "SRC1851_ANNA_HANNEY_ABT1841",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "1851 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I182_EDWIN_HANNEY_1842",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I182",
      "target": "SRC1851_EDWIN_HANNEY_ABT1842",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "1851 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on surname, age, and household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I183_EDWIN_HANNEY_1842",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I183",
      "target": "SRC1851_EDWIN_HANNEY_ABT1842",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "1851 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Likely child based on household structure."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_ELIZABETH_PETERS_TO_SARAH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I187",
      "target": "C_HANNY_SARAH_1798",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "parent-naming birth index plus public timeline",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_SELECT_BIRTHS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Birth-index excerpt names Elizabeth as mother with spouse William Hanney and child Sarah; event date omitted."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_WILLIAM_HANNY_TO_JAMES_EARLY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I186",
      "target": "C_HANNY_JAMES_CHILD_OF_WILLIAM_ELIZABETH",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_ELIZABETH_PETERS_TO_JAMES_EARLY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I187",
      "target": "C_HANNY_JAMES_CHILD_OF_WILLIAM_ELIZABETH",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I82_ROBERT_I_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I82",
      "target": "SRC1880_ROBERT_I_GOBBLE_ABT1859",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "repeated census household plus death record explicitly naming parents",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Repeated household evidence is independently confirmed by a Virginia death record explicitly naming John Gobble and Sallie Phelps as parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I81_ROBERT_I_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I81",
      "target": "SRC1880_ROBERT_I_GOBBLE_ABT1859",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "repeated census household plus death record explicitly naming parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Repeated household evidence is independently confirmed by a Virginia death record explicitly naming John Gobble and Sallie Phelps as parents. Sarah's memorial also lists this person as her child."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I82_GEORGE_W_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I82",
      "target": "SRC1880_GEORGE_W_GOBBLE_ABT1868",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "repeated census household plus death record explicitly naming parents",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Repeated household evidence is independently confirmed by a Virginia death record explicitly naming John Gobble and Sallie Phelps as parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I81_GEORGE_W_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I81",
      "target": "SRC1880_GEORGE_W_GOBBLE_ABT1868",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "repeated census household plus death record explicitly naming parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Repeated household evidence is independently confirmed by a Virginia death record explicitly naming John Gobble and Sallie Phelps as parents. Sarah's memorial also lists this person as her child."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MARTIN_PHELPS_SARAH_PHELPS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "target": "I81",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "near-contemporary biography explicitly names father; scanned page verified",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1830_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MARTIN_PHELPS_HARDIN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "target": "SRC_HARDIN_PHELPS_1833",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "single 1850 household inference; census does not state relationships",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hardin, age seventeen, was enumerated in Martin Phelps's 1850 household. His age and surname make a father-son relationship plausible, but the schedule gives no relationship column; the link remains tentative rather than directly documented."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MARTIN_PHELPS_JOHN_P",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_P_PHELPS_1834",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "later record names parent and child",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A later record names Martin Phelps, spouse Cauntis, and child John P Phelps; the 1850 household is compatible."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_EDA_CAUNTIS_JOHN_P",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_P_PHELPS_1834",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "later record identifies spouse Cauntis and child",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied later record identifies Martin's spouse as Cauntis in connection with child John P Phelps."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MARTIN_PHELPS_MARGARET",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARET_PHELPS_1843",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "evidence_strength": "indexed parent relationship plus household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Indexed relationship names Martin and Malinda in connection with child Margaret; compatible with the 1850 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MALINDA_PHELPS_MARGARET",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARET_PHELPS_1843",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "evidence_strength": "indexed parent relationship plus household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Indexed relationship names Martin and Malinda in connection with child Margaret; compatible with the 1850 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MARTIN_PHELPS_MARTIN_S",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "target": "SRC_MARTIN_S_PHELPS_1845",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "indexed parent relationship and two households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Indexed relationship names Martin and Malinda in connection with child Martin S; census continuity supports identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MALINDA_PHELPS_MARTIN_S",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "target": "SRC_MARTIN_S_PHELPS_1845",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "indexed parent relationship and two households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Indexed relationship names Martin and Malinda in connection with child Martin S; census continuity supports identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MARTIN_PHELPS_VIRGINIA_F",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "target": "SRC_VIRGINIA_F_PHELPS_1854",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "two-household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parentage is inferred from repeated household membership and age."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MALINDA_PHELPS_VIRGINIA_F",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "target": "SRC_VIRGINIA_F_PHELPS_1854",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "two-household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parentage is inferred from repeated household membership and age."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MARTIN_PHELPS_WILLIAM",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1855",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "single 1860 household inference; census does not state relationships",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "William, about five, was enumerated with Martin and Malinda Phelps in 1860. His age and shared surname make parentage more likely than an unrelated residence, but the census does not label relationships; this remains a qualified household inference."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MALINDA_PHELPS_WILLIAM",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1855",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "single 1860 household inference; census does not state relationships",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "William, about five, was enumerated with Martin and Malinda Phelps in 1860. His age and shared surname make parentage more likely than an unrelated residence, but the census does not label relationships; this remains a qualified household inference."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MARTIN_PHELPS_NEWTON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "target": "SRC_NEWTON_PHELPS_1857",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "two-household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parentage is inferred from repeated household membership and age."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_PC_MALINDA_PHELPS_NEWTON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "target": "SRC_NEWTON_PHELPS_1857",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "two-household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Parentage is inferred from repeated household membership and age."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I50_FRANK_STRETTON_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I50",
      "target": "SRC_FRANK_STRETTON_RHEAD_1911",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in Ancestry family timeline",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Bernal Bright Rhead's timeline explicitly names Frank Stretton Rhead as his son; direct registration remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I49_FRANK_STRETTON_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I49",
      "target": "SRC_FRANK_STRETTON_RHEAD_1911",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in Ancestry family timeline",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Bernal and Rosa's family timeline explicitly names Frank Stretton Rhead as their son; direct registration remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I50_ALFRED_SAMUEL_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I50",
      "target": "SRC_ALFRED_SAMUEL_RHEAD_1913",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in Ancestry family timeline",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Bernal Bright Rhead's timeline explicitly names Alfred Samuel Rhead as his son; direct registration remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I49_ALFRED_SAMUEL_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I49",
      "target": "SRC_ALFRED_SAMUEL_RHEAD_1913",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in Ancestry family timeline",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Bernal and Rosa's family timeline explicitly names Alfred Samuel Rhead as their son; direct registration remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SHROPSHIRE_SAMPSON_GEORGE_1837",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_RHEAD_SHROPSHIRE_1837",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "original 1841 same-surname household and compatible age; no relationship column in 1841 census",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original 1841 image places George Rhead, age four, in Sampson and Sarah Rhead's household. The census does not label relationships, but the same surname and family grouping make the child placement strongly supported. George remains distinct from Sampson and Julia Rhead's Bucknall son of the same name."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SARAH_POYNER_GEORGE_1837",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I140",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_RHEAD_SHROPSHIRE_1837",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "original 1841 same-surname household and compatible age; no relationship column in 1841 census",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original 1841 image places George Rhead, age four, in Sampson and Sarah Rhead's household. The census does not label relationships, but the same surname and family grouping make the child placement strongly supported. George remains distinct from Sampson and Julia Rhead's Bucknall son of the same name."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SARAH_POYNER_THOMAS_BOTTON_1849",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I140",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1849",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "1851 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1851 Trentham census places two-year-old Thomas Botton with Thomas and Sarah Botton. Parentage is strongly inferred from household structure but not explicitly labeled in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_THOMAS_BOTTON_THOMAS_BOTTON_1849",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1849",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "1851 census household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1851 Trentham census places two-year-old Thomas Botton with Thomas and Sarah Botton. Parentage is strongly inferred from household structure but not explicitly labeled in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I82_MARTHA_JANE_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I82",
      "target": "SRC_MARTHA_JANE_GOBBLE_1844",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "census continuity plus explicit parent index",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Martha appears in two households and a later index explicitly names John as father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I81_MARTHA_JANE_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I81",
      "target": "SRC_MARTHA_JANE_GOBBLE_1844",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "census continuity plus explicit parent index",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Martha appears in two households and a later index explicitly names Sarah as mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I82_MARTIN_P_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I82",
      "target": "SRC_MARTIN_P_GOBBLE_1848",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "two-household inference",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Parentage is inferred from repeated household membership."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I81_MARTIN_P_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I81",
      "target": "SRC_MARTIN_P_GOBBLE_1848",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "two-household inference",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Parentage is inferred from repeated household membership."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I82_MARY_CATHERINE_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I82",
      "target": "SRC_MARY_CATHERINE_GOBBLE_1850",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "household continuity plus explicit parent index",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Mary/Catharine household identity plus explicit parent index supports John as father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I81_MARY_CATHERINE_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I81",
      "target": "SRC_MARY_CATHERINE_GOBBLE_1850",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "household continuity plus explicit parent index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary/Catharine household identity plus explicit parent index supports Sarah as mother. Sarah's memorial also lists this person as her child."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I82_WILLIAM_C_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I82",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_C_GOBBLE_1853",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "census continuity plus explicit parent index",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "William appears in two households and a later index explicitly names John as father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I81_WILLIAM_C_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I81",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_C_GOBBLE_1853",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "census continuity plus explicit parent index",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "William appears in two households and a later index explicitly names Sarah as mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I82_JULIA_ANN_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I82",
      "target": "SRC_JULIA_ANN_GOBBLE_1857",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "census continuity plus explicit parent index",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Julia appears in two households and a later index explicitly names John as father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I81_JULIA_ANN_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I81",
      "target": "SRC_JULIA_ANN_GOBBLE_1857",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "census continuity plus explicit parent index",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Julia appears in two households and a later index explicitly names Sarah as mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I82_EGLANTINE_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I82",
      "target": "SRC_EGLANTINE_GOBBLE_SCOTT_1863",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "census continuity plus explicit parent index",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Eglantine appears in two households and a later index explicitly names John as father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I81_EGLANTINE_GOBBLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I81",
      "target": "SRC_EGLANTINE_GOBBLE_SCOTT_1863",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "census continuity plus explicit parent index and memorial",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Eglantine appears in two households, a later index names Sarah as mother, and Sarah's memorial lists Eglatine Scott as daughter. Sarah's memorial also lists this person as her child."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I70_MARY_E_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I70",
      "target": "SRC_MARY_E_HENDERSON_1858",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "birth register explicitly names father plus census",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Virginia birth register explicitly names Robt Henderson as father; 1860 household corroborates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I71_MARY_E_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I71",
      "target": "SRC_MARY_E_HENDERSON_1858",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "birth register explicitly names mother plus census",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Virginia birth register explicitly names Mary Henderson as mother; 1860 household corroborates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I70_SAMUEL_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I70",
      "target": "SRC_SAMUEL_HENDERSON_1860",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "two census households plus death record naming father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A later death record explicitly names Bob Henderson as father; census continuity corroborates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I71_SAMUEL_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I71",
      "target": "SRC_SAMUEL_HENDERSON_1860",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "two census households plus death record naming mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A later death record explicitly names Mary McNew as mother; census continuity corroborates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I70_LOWCRESA_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I70",
      "target": "SRC_LOWCRESA_HENDERSON_1862",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 Lowcresa household entry plus Wallace Jr. Lucretia Louisa child name",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Lowcresa in the 1880 household is plausibly Lucretia Louisa in the Wallace Jr. tree. The child link is strengthened but still needs direct vital evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I71_LOWCRESA_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I71",
      "target": "SRC_LOWCRESA_HENDERSON_1862",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 Lowcresa household entry plus Wallace Jr. Lucretia Louisa child name",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Lowcresa in the 1880 household is plausibly Lucretia Louisa in the Wallace Jr. tree. The child link is strengthened but still needs direct vital evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I70_AMANDA_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I70",
      "target": "SRC_AMANDA_HENDERSON_1864",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 household plus Wallace Jr. compiled tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1880 household candidate is independently named as a child in the Wallace Jr. tree; direct vital evidence remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I71_AMANDA_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I71",
      "target": "SRC_AMANDA_HENDERSON_1864",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 household plus Wallace Jr. compiled tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1880 household candidate is independently named as a child in the Wallace Jr. tree; direct vital evidence remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I70_JAMES_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I70",
      "target": "SRC_JAMES_HENDERSON_1862",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 household plus Wallace Jr. compiled tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1880 household candidate is independently named as a child in the Wallace Jr. tree; direct vital evidence remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I71_JAMES_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I71",
      "target": "SRC_JAMES_HENDERSON_1862",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "1880 household plus Wallace Jr. compiled tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1880 household candidate is independently named as a child in the Wallace Jr. tree; direct vital evidence remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JOHN_HENDERSON_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "I70",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled-tree father claim tentatively associated with the 1843 John R Henderson probate identity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1843_JOHN_R_HENDERSON_GILES_PROBATE",
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "Geneanet names John as Robert’s father; identifying him with the Giles probate man remains tentative. William and Ellen are now represented as competing candidates with a closer household reconstruction. The probate index is not exhaustive, so Robert’s omission does not establish that he was excluded from the will."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_EVAN_TALLEY_REBECCA_S_TALLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "target": "I52",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1876 marriage register plus child relationship index and compatible 1860 household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rebecca's 1876 marriage register and a Virginia child relationship index explicitly name Evan and Delia Talley as parents. The 1860 Susan age 2 is a probable Rebecca Susan name variant."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DELIA_TALLEY_REBECCA_S_TALLEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "target": "I52",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1876 marriage register plus child relationship index and compatible 1860 household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rebecca's 1876 marriage register and a Virginia child relationship index explicitly name Evan and Delia Talley as parents. The 1860 Susan age 2 is a probable Rebecca Susan name variant."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_EVAN_TALLEY_AMANDA_J",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "target": "SRC_AMANDA_J_TALLEY_1851",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child index plus household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Virginia index explicitly names Evan L Talley as Amanda J's father; 1860 household corroborates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DELIA_TALLEY_AMANDA_J",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "target": "SRC_AMANDA_J_TALLEY_1851",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child index plus household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Virginia index explicitly names Delia Talley as Amanda J's mother; 1860 household corroborates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_EVAN_TALLEY_JAMES_M",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "target": "SRC_JAMES_M_TALLEY_1860",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "child index name variant plus household continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Virginia index names A.L. Tally as father of James M; matching Delia and household continuity make Evan L the likely intended father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DELIA_TALLEY_JAMES_M",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "target": "SRC_JAMES_M_TALLEY_1860",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child index plus household continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Virginia index explicitly names Delia Tally as James M's mother; 1860/1870 continuity corroborates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_PEYTON_TALLY_EVAN_L_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_PEYTON_R_TALLY_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "Geneanet compiled tree only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "ROOTS26_YANCEY_WILL_PEYTON1845"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled tree explicitly names Peyton as Evan’s father. The candidate is retained, but no household sequence yet distinguishes him from actual same-named men. A naming error or conflated family is a competing explanation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HOLLY_HOOD_EVAN_L_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled mother claim corroborated by Holly's 1860 co-residence in Evan's household and 1850 placement with probable daughter Tabitha",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_1860_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_GRAYSON"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled mother claim agrees with Holly’s placement in two related households. Maternity leads over an aunt or other dependent relationship, though the censuses do not state it explicitly. The Hood birth-name claim remains separate and unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I70_DAVID_M_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I70",
      "target": "SRC_DAVID_M_HENDERSON_CHILD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I71_DAVID_M_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I71",
      "target": "SRC_DAVID_M_HENDERSON_CHILD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I70_MARTHA_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I70",
      "target": "SRC_MARTHA_HENDERSON_CHILD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I71_MARTHA_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I71",
      "target": "SRC_MARTHA_HENDERSON_CHILD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I70_NANCY_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I70",
      "target": "SRC_NANCY_HENDERSON_CHILD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I71_NANCY_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I71",
      "target": "SRC_NANCY_HENDERSON_CHILD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CONLEY_JAMES_ROBERT_HENDERSON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I51",
      "target": "SRC_JAMES_ROBERT_HENDERSON_CHILD_CONLEY",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DAVID_MCNEW_ALCY_HADEN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I122",
      "target": "SRC_ALCY_HADEN_CHILD_DAVID_MCNEW",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.8
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DAVID_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1850",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I122",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "1850 census comparison plus Sharon Wright tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child is listed in both the 1850 census comparison and Sharon Wright tree."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DAVID_MCNEW_SAMUEL_1850",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I122",
      "target": "SRC_SAMUEL_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit child in 1850 census comparison",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The census comparison lists Samuel as David's child."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DAVID_MCNEW_NANCY_1850",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I122",
      "target": "SRC_NANCY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "1850 census comparison plus Sharon Wright tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Child is listed in both the 1850 census comparison and Sharon Wright tree."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DAVID_MCNEW_LOUIS_1850",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I122",
      "target": "SRC_LOUIS_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "1850 census comparison plus Sharon Wright tree name resolution",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1850 Louis index entry is likely Louisa Amelia in Sharon Wright tree; original image confirmation remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DAVID_MCNEW_CENA_1850",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I122",
      "target": "SRC_CENA_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "1850 census comparison plus Sharon Wright tree name resolution",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1850 Cena index entry is likely Senah in Sharon Wright tree; original image confirmation remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DAVID_MCNEW_AILSEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I122",
      "target": "SRC_AILSEY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "1850 census comparison plus Sharon Wright tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ANN_MCNEW_AILSEY_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "target": "SRC_AILSEY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "1850 spouse household; maternity not explicit",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Ann is David's spouse in the household containing Ailsey, but the supplied comparison does not explicitly state maternity."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ANN_MCNEW_ALCY_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "target": "SRC_ALCY_HADEN_CHILD_DAVID_MCNEW",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DAVID_MCNEW_ANNA_JANE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I122",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_JANE_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_MCNEW_THOMAS_BERRY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I124",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_BERRY_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_AMELIA_HARGIS_THOMAS_BERRY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_BERRY_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_MCNEW_JULIUS_CONNOR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I124",
      "target": "SRC_JULIUS_CONNOR_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_AMELIA_HARGIS_JULIUS_CONNOR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "target": "SRC_JULIUS_CONNOR_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_MCNEW_GEORGE_JR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I124",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_ALBERT_MCNEW_JR_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.8
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_AMELIA_HARGIS_GEORGE_JR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "target": "SRC_GEORGE_ALBERT_MCNEW_JR_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_MCNEW_SENA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I124",
      "target": "SRC_SENA_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.8
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_AMELIA_HARGIS_SENA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "target": "SRC_SENA_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_MCNEW_AMELIA_CHILD_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I124",
      "target": "SRC_AMELIA_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE_CANDIDATE",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.52
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_MCNEW_JONATHAN_C",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I124",
      "target": "SRC_JONATHAN_C_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_MCNEW_DALY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I124",
      "target": "SRC_DALY_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_MCNEW_JOSIAH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I124",
      "target": "SRC_JOSIAH_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_MCNEW_SHADRACK_CHILD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I124",
      "target": "SRC_SHADRACK_MCNEW_CHILD_GEORGE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JEREMIAH_JR_DANIEL_SHADRACK",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I127",
      "target": "SRC_DANIEL_SHADRACK_MCNEW_CHILD_JEREMIAH",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JEREMIAH_SR_LOMAX_MACKNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I129",
      "target": "HV4_LOMAX_MCNEW_MCKNEW_ABOUT_1675",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "Warren Family Tree plus Nathan McNew place cluster",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640"
      ],
      "source_note": "Warren tree explicitly names Lomax as Jeremiah's child; direct evidence and dates are still needed."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JEREMIAH_SR_JOHN_HOWARD_MACKNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I129",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_HOWARD_MACKNEW_CHILD_JEREMIAH",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "Warren tree, compatible timeline, and compiled Phillis family profile; no direct child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_PROFILE_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JEREMIAH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Multiple compiled profiles name John Howard as a child of Jeremiah Macknew I. Chronology is compatible, but no contemporary baptism, will, probate, or guardianship record has been supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MATTHEW_MACKNEUGH_1518_I135",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "target": "I135",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "evidence_strength": "single private compiled-tree claim absent from two published McNew genealogies and unsupported by Scottish records",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_EARLY_RECORD_GUIDE",
        "SRC_MCNEW_HISTORY_BOWMAN_THOMAS_1997",
        "SRC_MCNEW_MEMORABILIA_CARROLL_1998",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Machal transcript alone makes the 1518 Matthew father of the later Matthew. No contemporary record or independently published McNew genealogy repeats the relationship. It is retained at minimal confidence under the derivative-tree policy."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HARGIS_JOHN_1722_AMELIA_1765",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "target": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "two compatible compiled pedigrees; chosen over a competing younger-generation reconstruction that is internally chronologically contradictory",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Goymerac tree and a separately published Hargis pedigree both attach Amelia directly to John Draper Hargis born about 1722. The competing younger-John reconstruction is weakened because its linked RootsMagic Elizabeth Freelove profile gives her a 1762 death, before Amelia's 1765 birth. The older John is therefore the leading current candidate, not a proven father; no baptism, probate, Bible, land, or other contemporary record has been found naming Amelia with either proposed parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HARGIS_JOHN_PARENT_JOHN_1722",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled trees identify the middle and younger John generations; no direct record distinguishes them",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722"
      ],
      "source_note": "Compiled profiles place a John born about 1695 between John I and the John born about 1722. The 1730 will does not prove this edge because its named son John is more likely the 1695 generation, not the 1722 grandson."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BOSWELL_GRACE_JOHN_HARGIS_1722",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "evidence_strength": "two compatible compiled-tree claims; no direct parentage record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722"
      ],
      "source_note": "Geneanet and Goymerac trees name Grace Elizabeth Boswell as mother of John born 1722. No direct parentage record has been supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HARGIS_ANN_WHITESIDE_AMELIA_1765",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "target": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "evidence_strength": "conflicting compiled maternal reconstructions; contemporary identity unresolved",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA"
      ],
      "source_note": "Compiled pedigrees disagree whether Ann belongs directly above Amelia or one generation earlier. Her reported birth about 1720 permits motherhood in 1765, so age does not establish a skipped generation. The estate reference to Ann Hargis does not identify her birth family or children. The low-confidence maternal candidate is retained while direct maternity, grandmother relationship and conflation are compared."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_AMELIA_1765",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE",
      "target": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "conflicting compiled maternal reconstructions; contemporary identity unresolved",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "The younger John and Elizabeth household is a plausible compiled reconstruction for Amelia’s parents. Elizabeth’s reported 1762 death would exclude her maternity if correct, but no supporting death record is displayed. A date error or conflated profile remains possible. Her low confidence is retained provisionally; this date alone does not establish that Ann Whiteside is the better candidate."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SHORT_GEORGE_W_DAVID_KITZMILLER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "target": "I53",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1870 census plus direct child death record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1870 census identifies George W Shorts as David K Shorts's father, and David's death record names George Shortt as father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_DAVID_KITZMILLER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "target": "I53",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1870 census plus direct child death record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1870 census identifies Susan Shorts as David K Shorts's mother, and David's death record names mother Susan Jones."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_DAVID_SHORT_JOHN_EDGAR_SHORT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I53",
      "target": "C_SHORT_JOHN_EDGAR_1900_1920",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_LEANNA_WHITE_JOHN_EDGAR_SHORT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I54",
      "target": "C_SHORT_JOHN_EDGAR_1900_1920",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_JAMES_DAVID_1832",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_DAVID_MARGRET",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_MARGRET_CHILD_DAVID_ELIZA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BOYD_ELIZA_MARGRET_CLARKE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_MARGRET_CHILD_DAVID_ELIZA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_DAVID_HENRY_1911",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_HENRY_CHILD_DAVID_1911",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GIBSON_SARAH_FLORENCE_1891",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "target": "I28",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "two compiled maternal profiles plus 1883 marriage and four-child census reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A compiled family tree names Sarah \"Sadie\" Clarke as Florence's mother. The 1883 marriage index and John's later four-child census return make the relationship strongly plausible, but no birth record directly naming Sarah has been supplied. The Patton tree explicitly includes this child in Sarah Clarke's family."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GIBSON_SARAH_DAVID",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "target": "C_GIBSON_DAVID_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "Patton compiled child list plus 1883 marriage and four-child census reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "David was one of four children in John's household after his 1883 marriage to Sarah; maternity is inferred pending a birth record. The Patton tree explicitly includes this child in Sarah Clarke's family."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GIBSON_SARAH_MAGGIE_J",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "target": "C_GIBSON_MAGGIE_J_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "Patton compiled child list plus 1883 marriage and four-child census reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Maggie J was one of four children in John's household after his 1883 marriage to Sarah; maternity is inferred pending a birth record. The Patton tree explicitly includes this child in Sarah Clarke's family."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GIBSON_SARAH_MARY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "target": "C_GIBSON_MARY_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "Patton compiled child list plus 1883 marriage and four-child census reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary was one of four children in John's household after his 1883 marriage to Sarah; maternity is inferred pending a birth record. The Patton tree explicitly includes this child in Sarah Clarke's family."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_DAVID_SARAH_CLARKE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "target": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "Sarah's primary 1883 marriage register explicitly names father David Clark, farmer",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Sarah Clark's 1883 civil marriage entry explicitly identifies her father as David Clark, farmer. David's 1854 register independently places him at Aghnasedagh and identifies his own father and spouse."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BOYD_ELIZABETH_SARAH_CLARKE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "target": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "Sarah's father is directly proved; his 1854 primary marriage to Eliza Boyd and compiled family reconstruction make Eliza the probable mother, but no child record names her",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The primary records prove Sarah's father David and prove that David married Eliza Boyd in 1854, before Sarah's adult marriage in 1883. A compiled family tree names Eliza as Sarah's mother. The identification is strong and chronologically coherent but remains indirect until a baptism or equivalent child record is found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GIBSON_JOHN_FLORENCE_1891",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "target": "I28",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1901 and 1911 Ireland censuses explicitly identify John in Florence's household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1901 Ireland census identifies John Gibson as Florence Gibson's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GIBSON_JOHN_DAVID",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "target": "C_GIBSON_DAVID_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "1901 Ireland census family household, supported by 1911 four-child total",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "David appears as Florence's sibling in John Gibson's 1901 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GIBSON_JOHN_MAGGIE_J",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "target": "C_GIBSON_MAGGIE_J_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "1901 Ireland census family household, supported by 1911 four-child total",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Maggie J appears as Florence's sibling in John Gibson's 1901 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GIBSON_JOHN_MARY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "target": "C_GIBSON_MARY_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "1901 Ireland census family household, supported by 1911 four-child total",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary appears as Florence's sibling in John Gibson's 1901 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_MOTHER_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "evidence_strength": "single compiled tree identifies mother only as Miss Martin",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Compiled Clarke tree identifies David's mother only as Miss Martin. Direct evidence is needed."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_DAVID_WILLIAM",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_WILLIAM_CHILD_DAVID",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_DAVID_DAVID_JR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_JR_CHILD_DAVID",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_DAVID_MARY_JANE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_MARY_JANE_CHILD_DAVID",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_DAVID_JAMES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_CHILD_DAVID",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_JAMES_MARGARET",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_MARGARET_CHILD_JAMES",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_JAMES_JANE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_JANE_CHILD_JAMES_1804",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_JAMES_ANNIE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_ANNIE_CHILD_JAMES_1804",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_JAMES_JAMES_JR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_CHILD_JAMES_1804",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_JAMES_ELIZA_JANE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_ELIZA_JANE_CHILD_JAMES_1804",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CLARKE_JAMES_JOHN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "target": "C_CLARKE_JOHN_CHILD_JAMES_1804",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_WILLIAM_DAVIES_1815",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "William's baptism explicitly names Robert; distinctive Trustewelin abode recurs in William's adult household and Robert's woodworking trade matches William's later trade",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
        "SRC_FREEREG_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1823",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1814 baptism explicitly names Robert as William's father and places the family at Trustewelin, where William's own adult household was recorded in 1851. Robert was a carpenter or wheelwright in three entries, while William was later a carpenter. This unusually specific continuity makes the relationship highly probable despite the missing intervening household record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_WILLIAM_DAVIES_FREDERICK_DAVIES_1845",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "target": "I101",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1845 Berriew baptism explicitly names William and Martha as Frederick's parents, supported by the 1851 and 1861 households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1845",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Frederick Davies was christened at Berriew on 23 Mar 1845, with William Davies and Martha explicitly named as his parents. The 1851 and 1861 households independently continue Frederick as their son at compatible ages. The combined baptism and census evidence makes this relationship highly secure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARTHA_DAVIES_FREDERICK_DAVIES_1845",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "target": "I101",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1845 Berriew baptism explicitly names William and Martha as Frederick's parents, supported by the 1851 and 1861 households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1845",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Frederick Davies was christened at Berriew on 23 Mar 1845, with William Davies and Martha explicitly named as his parents. The 1851 and 1861 households independently continue Frederick as their son at compatible ages. The combined baptism and census evidence makes this relationship highly secure."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_RICHARD_I143",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "target": "I143",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit father in 1851 census and independently named in 1860 marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "Richard is explicitly recorded as the younger Richard's father in the 1851 census, and the 1860 church marriage independently names the groom's father as Richard Morrall."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HANNAH_MORRALL_RICHARD_I143",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "target": "I143",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit son in 1851 census plus compatible child baptism index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_CHILD_BAPTISM_PARENTS_RICHARD_ANNE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1851 census explicitly records the younger Richard as son of Richard and Hannah Morral. A baptism index also names parents Richard and Anne Morrall; Anne is treated as a possible name variation for Hannah pending image review."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_I155_HANNAH_GRINDLEY_MORRALL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I155",
      "target": "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1837 parish marriage explicitly names Thomas Grindly as Hannah's father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hannah Grindly's 4 Jul 1837 parish marriage explicitly names her father as Thomas Grindly. The Forton birthplace and chronology match the documented Thomas Grindley family."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_1753_THOMAS_I155",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "target": "I155",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1783 Forton baptism explicitly names parent; compatible 1777 Forton marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas Grindley's christening index names John Grindley as father. John's 1777 Forton marriage to Elizabeth Pickin and Thomas's later Forton census identity corroborate the match."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_I155",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "target": "I155",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1783 Forton baptism explicitly names parent; compatible 1777 Forton marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas Grindley's christening index names Elisabeth Grindley as mother. The 1777 Forton marriage identifies her as Elizabeth Pickin."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JOHN_READ_RICHARD_RHEAD_I141",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JOHN_READ_FATHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "target": "I141",
      "status": "verified",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1753 Stoke baptism explicitly names father John Read",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship is direct, but the baptism does not identify which same-name Staffordshire John Read this was."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SARAH_READ_RICHARD_RHEAD_I141",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SARAH_READ_MOTHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "target": "I141",
      "status": "verified",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1753 Stoke baptism explicitly names mother Sarah Read",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship is direct. Read is her married surname in the baptism; her maiden name is not stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_RICHARD_RHEAD_I141_WILLIAM_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I141",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_RHEAD_CHILD_RICHARD_READ",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BETTY_PILSBURY_WILLIAM_RHEAD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_BETTY_PILSBURY_WIFE_RICHARD_READ",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_RHEAD_CHILD_RICHARD_READ",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_I139_FREDRICK_1851",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I139",
      "target": "SRC_FREDRICK_RHEAD_CHILD_SAMPSON_JULIA_1851",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JULIA_GLOVER_FREDRICK_RHEAD_1851",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "target": "SRC_FREDRICK_RHEAD_CHILD_SAMPSON_JULIA_1851",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SAMUEL_MORRALL_UNRESOLVED_RICHARD_SR",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_SAMUEL_MORRALL_FATHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "target": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "direct father naming plus compatible parish transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_ROOTSCHAT_SAMUEL_ANN_MORRALL_LAWLEY_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Richard's 1837 marriage directly names his father as Samuel Morrall. The most likely specific Samuel is the Lawley collier whose household reportedly baptised a Richard at Wellington on 3 Oct 1813 with wife Ann Green. Horsehay/Wellington birth reports and the modest age difference are compatible. A different same-named Samuel remains possible until an original baptism, census, settlement, apprenticeship, probate, or other identity-bridging record is inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HENRY_CORNISH_ELIZABETH_I183",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HENRY_CORNISH_FATHER_ELIZABETH",
      "target": "I183",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1838 church marriage explicitly names father Henry Cornish",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838"
      ],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth Cornish's 31 Mar 1838 church marriage explicitly names father Henry Cornish; his exact identity remains unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_JOHN_1802",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "target": "I145",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1802 baptism names parent and 1799 marriage resolves parental couple",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Waterhouse's 1802 Ashbourne baptism explicitly names James Waterhouse as father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_JOHN_1802",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "target": "I145",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1802 baptism names parent and 1799 marriage resolves parental couple",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Waterhouse's 1802 Ashbourne baptism explicitly names Hannah Waterhouse as mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_TO_HANNAH_NEEDHAM",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "target": "SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "target father index plus repeated Edward-and-Hannah baptismal household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_CHILD_HANNAH_INDEX",
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_CHILD_BAPTISM_SERIES"
      ],
      "source_note": "The target child index explicitly names Edward Needham as father. Repeated Ashbourne baptisms document Edward and Hannah as a parental couple from 1768 through 1779."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_HANNAH_MELLOR_TO_HANNAH_NEEDHAM",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "target": "SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.925,
      "evidence_strength": "documented wife of named father plus repeated Edward-and-Hannah child baptisms; target baptism absent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_CHILD_HANNAH_INDEX",
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_CHILD_BAPTISM_SERIES"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hannah Mellor is Edward Needham's documented wife, and repeated baptisms show Edward and Hannah raising children at Ashbourne. The target Hannah Needham's direct baptism has not been found, so the mother edge remains below direct-evidence confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_MARY_POYNER_TO_SARAH_POYNER_1811",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MARY_POYNER_MOTHER_SARAH_1811",
      "target": "I140",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1811 baptism explicitly names Mary Poyner as mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811"
      ],
      "source_note": "Sarah Poyner's baptism at Stoke St Milborough on 5 May 1811 explicitly names Mary Poyner as her mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_GEORGE_ODNETT_TO_SARAH_POYNER_CLAIM",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_ODNETT_CLAIMED_FATHER_SARAH_POYNER",
      "target": "I140",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "adult marriage record names father; baptism names only mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811"
      ],
      "source_note": "Sarah named George Odnett as her father in 1852. Because her 1811 baptism records only Mary Poyner and no father, this is retained as a strong candidate claim rather than conclusive biological parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_CONRAD_GONDER_TO_JOHANN_DIETRICH_1724",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CONRAD_GONDER_FATHER_DIETRICH_1724",
      "target": "C_GONDER_DIETRICH",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1724 baptism names Conrad as father; child identification supported by later same-parish records",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GONDER_BAPTISM_1724",
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1724 Obergleen baptism names father Conrad Gonder. The child is unnamed in the supplied index excerpt, but the exact profile date, parish continuity, and later Johann Dietrich marriage support the identification at high confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_DAVID_BOYD_TO_ELIZA_BOYD_1854",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "target": "C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "Eliza's primary 1854 marriage register explicitly names father David Boyd, farmer",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Eliza Boyd's 1854 civil marriage entry explicitly identifies her father as David Boyd, farmer."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_DAVID_BOYD_TO_MARGARET_BOYD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "target": "C_MARGARET_BOYD_CHILD_DAVID",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_THOMAS_TOMPSON_TO_ESTHER_1808",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_THOMAS_TOMPSON_FATHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "target": "I152",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1808 baptism explicitly names father Thomas Tompson",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Esther Tompson was baptized at Wolverhampton St Peter on 14 Feb 1808 and the register explicitly names Thos Tompson as her father."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_MARY_TOMPSON_TO_ESTHER_1808",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MARY_TOMPSON_MOTHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "target": "I152",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1808 baptism explicitly names mother Mary",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Esther Tompson was baptized at Wolverhampton St Peter on 14 Feb 1808 and the register explicitly names Mary as her mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_TO_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "target": "I61",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "Robert-Nancy marriage plus community-tree maternity claim; no direct child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert Lavinder married Nancy Willis shortly before Fanny's reported birth, and Geneanet names Nancy as Fanny's mother. No birth, Bible, probate, or death record explicitly states the relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_SAMUEL_FELPS_TO_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "target": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "near-contemporary biography names Samuel of Russell County as Martin's father; bridegroom identity correlated",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_1790_ROWAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_VA_NC_CENSUS_SEQUENCE",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_1810_NAMESAKE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
        "SRC_SUSANNAH_VINES_COMPILED_VITALS_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_CHAIN_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_DEED_INDEX_20260915",
        "SRC_LOCAL_WASHINGTON_DEED16_PAGE5_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Brock 1888 p.725 explicitly identifies Martin's father as Samuel Phelps of Russell County. This is materially stronger than middle-name and census correlation. Identifying that father with the 1782 bridegroom remains a separate correlation: the 1846 will names Susan, and DB16 index pairs Samuel with Susannah in Russell County. No inspected record establishes Samuel's own parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_SUSANNAH_VINES_TO_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "target": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit published lineage claim plus Vines middle-name and compatible migration; contemporary child record absent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_VA_NC_CENSUS_SEQUENCE",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_1810_NAMESAKE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
        "SRC_SUSANNAH_VINES_COMPILED_VITALS_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_CHAIN_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_DEED_INDEX_20260915",
        "SRC_LOCAL_WASHINGTON_DEED16_PAGE5_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Retain the published family identification and circumstantial maternity assessment. Brock names Martin's father Samuel but does not name Martin's mother. The DB16 index pairs local Samuel and Susannah without identifying a child or maiden surname. Neither the spouse relationship nor the new paternal evidence independently proves this maternity."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_HENRY_COUNTISS_TO_JOHN_M_COUNTISS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
      "target": "C_JOHN_M_COUNTISS_CHILD_HENRY",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_MARY_RUSSELL_TO_JOHN_M_COUNTISS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MARY_RUSSELL_COUNTISS",
      "target": "C_JOHN_M_COUNTISS_CHILD_HENRY",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_HENRY_COUNTISS_TO_EDA_CAUNTIS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
      "target": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "Brock explicitly names Eda's father Henry Countis; identity with dated Maryland candidate remains correlated",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENRY_AUNLIE_1810_COUNTISS_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Brock 1888 p.725 explicitly calls Sarah's mother Eda a daughter of Henry Countis of Washington County, formerly of eastern Virginia. This materially strengthens the local Henry-to-Eda identification. Equating him with the reported 1777 Maryland-born man remains an identity hypothesis; the book supplies neither that birth nor a wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_MARY_RUSSELL_TO_EDA_CAUNTIS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MARY_RUSSELL_COUNTISS",
      "target": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "weak",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary is a possible mother only if the community-tree spouse assignment and Henry-to-Eda hypothesis are both correct."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_RICHARD_RHEAD_TO_RUTH_RHEAD_WILL_1813",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I141",
      "target": "C_RUTH_RHEAD_DAUGHTER_RICHARD_RUTH",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.998
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_RUTH_HANDLEY_TO_RUTH_RHEAD_WILL_1813",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I142",
      "target": "C_RUTH_RHEAD_DAUGHTER_RICHARD_RUTH",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ANTOINE_GINDER_ANNA_ENGEL_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ANTOINE_GINDER_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_ENGEL_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.22,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled-tree claim with unresolved surname and locality mismatch",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_ANNE_ELISABETH_GINDER_1740"
      ],
      "source_note": "Possible only if Anne Elisabeth Ginder of Hinsing is the same person as Anna Elisabetha Engel of Obergleen; that identity is not established."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARGUERITE_JANSEM_ANNA_ENGEL_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MARGUERITE_JANSEM_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_ENGEL_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.22,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled-tree claim with unresolved surname and locality mismatch",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_ANNE_ELISABETH_GINDER_1740"
      ],
      "source_note": "Possible only if Anne Elisabeth Ginder of Hinsing is the same person as Anna Elisabetha Engel of Obergleen; that identity is not established."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JOHN_HARGIS_I_JOHN_1695",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "will names son John; compiled profiles identify the son as the reported 1695 John",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695"
      ],
      "source_note": "The will directly proves John I had a son John. Compiled profiles identify that son as the John reportedly born about 1695. The exact birth details remain profile-derived."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JOHN_HARGIS_I_MARY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_MARY_DAUGHTER_JOHN_I_1730",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JOHN_HARGIS_I_MILERETT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_MILERETT_DAUGHTER_JOHN_I_1730",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_WILLIAM_ASA_HARGIS_JOHN_I_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "will directly names son John Draper; compiled profiles identify him as John Draper Hargis I",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661_1730"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ELIZABETH_DRAPER_JOHN_I_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "wife Anne and son John are both directly named in William's will, but maternity is not explicitly stated",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "William's will names wife Anne and son John Draper. Anne is a plausible mother, but the will does not explicitly identify her as John's mother and she could have been a later wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARY_FOUNTAIN_JOHN_1695_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "birth/christening index names Mary and John Hirges as parents of John; compiled profiles identify the generations",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SELECT_BIRTHS_MARY_JOHN_HIRGES_CHILD_JOHN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695"
      ],
      "source_note": "The birth/christening index names Mary and John Hirges as parents of a son John. Compiled profiles identify that son as the reported 1695 John. The direct index lacks date and place, so the generational assignment remains short of certain."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JAMES_BOSWELL_GRACE_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.46,
      "evidence_strength": "chronologically and geographically plausible compiled-tree parent claim",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Geneanet explicitly names James Boswell as Grace's father. His reported 1655 birth and 1718 Virginia death are compatible, but no direct will, baptism, or marriage record proves the relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ANN_SMITH_GRACE_BOSWELL_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SMITH_ANN_MOTHER_GRACE_BOSWELL_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.38,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled-tree parent claim only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Geneanet names Ann Smith as Grace's mother; no direct evidence was supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JANE_JAMMER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_JAMMER_JANE_MOTHER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled-tree parent claim only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a low-confidence compiled-tree parent claim; no direct evidence or independent corroboration was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_WILLIAM_HARGIS_ROGER_1685",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_ROGER_SON_WILLIAM_1685",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_WILLIAM_HARGIS_WILLIAM_1685",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_SON_WILLIAM_1685",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ELIZABETH_ANN_DRAPER_JOHN_I_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled-tree mother claim only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a compiled-tree mother hypothesis only. The 1685 will names wife Anne and son John but does not identify John's mother or give Anne a maiden name."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_WILLIAM_HARGIS_ANN_HARGAS_CHILD_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_HARGAS_ANN_CHILD_WILLIAM_ANNE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ANNE_HARGIS_ANN_HARGAS_CHILD_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_HARGAS_ANN_CHILD_WILLIAM_ANNE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_HARGIS_1617_WILLIAM_HARGIS_1640",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage compatible with documented immigrant",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_GEO_HARGAS_BY_1642",
        "SRC_PROFILE_WILLIAM_ASA_HARGIS_1640_1685",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Compiled profiles name George as William Asa Hargis's father. Geo Hargas was in Virginia by 1642, which is compatible with the family chronology, but the London infant formerly used to support this relationship probably died in 1617/18 and no direct parentage record has been supplied. Generation 12 audit: no baptism, will, deed, or other direct record naming this parent was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_HARGIS_1617_THOMAS_LEA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_THOMAS_LEA_CHILD_GEORGE_1617",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_HARGIS_1617_ELIZABETH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_CHILD_GEORGE_1617",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.52
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_HARGIS_1617_WALTER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_WALTER_CHILD_GEORGE_1617",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.42
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_URIAH_LEA_SUSANNAH_1614",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "target": "C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "father directly named in baptism index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614"
      ],
      "source_note": "Uriae/Uriah Lea is directly named as Susanna's father in the Ashwell baptism index."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JOANNA_LEA_SUSANNAH_1614",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "target": "C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "mother directly named in baptism index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614"
      ],
      "source_note": "Joannae/Joanna is directly named as Susanna's mother in the Ashwell baptism index."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SUSANNAH_LEA_WILLIAM_HARGIS_1640",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled-tree child claim with compatible chronology",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_SUSANNAH_LEA_HARGIS_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Two Geneanet profiles name Susannah Lea as mother of William Asa Hargis. Her direct baptism makes the chronology plausible, but no direct parentage record was supplied. Generation 12 audit: no baptism, will, deed, or other direct record naming this parent was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ROBERT_LEA_JOANNA_1590_LOW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "target": "C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "direct father in 1590 Somerset baptism but cross-county identity with later Ashwell mother remains compiled",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_GENEANET_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 14 audit: Robert is directly named as father of Joan Lea baptized at Stoke St Gregory in 1590. Connecting that child to Joannae, mother of Susanna at Ashwell in 1614, depends on compiled identity matching across Somerset and Hertfordshire and remains plausible rather than proven."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_URIAH_LEA_FRANCES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "target": "C_LEA_FRANCES_CHILD_URIAH_JOANNA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JOANNA_LEA_FRANCES",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "target": "C_LEA_FRANCES_CHILD_URIAH_JOANNA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JOAN_SMITH_JOANNA_LEA_1590",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "target": "C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "mother inference from preceding same-parish marriage plus compiled identity match",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_GENEANET_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 14 audit: Joan Smith married Robert Lea before the 1590 baptism, making maternity plausible, but the supplied baptism excerpt names only Robert and the child-to-Ashwell identity remains compiled."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_45A0A90DFEEF685A",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "target": "I221",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_B922F4579592CFD0",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064217",
      "target": "I221",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_8A3E9563904334F9",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "contemporary marriage notice and published parental biography",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TIMES_PICAYUNE_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_OBITUARY_2001"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1963 marriage notice calls Edgar the son of Isidore Newman II and the late Anna Pfeiffer Newman; the obituary independently places him in the Isidore Newman family."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_F34930DF0874DA18",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "contemporary marriage notice and published parental biography",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TIMES_PICAYUNE_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_OBITUARY_2001"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1963 marriage notice calls Edgar the son of Isidore Newman II and the late Anna Pfeiffer Newman; the obituary independently places him in the Isidore Newman family."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_47558A1A4CDC69DC",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "published biography explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Louisiana Historical Association biography explicitly calls Isidore Newman II the son of Edgar Newman and Elsa Schwartz."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_ACC905FFD5F29BFC",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "published biography explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Louisiana Historical Association biography explicitly calls Isidore Newman II the son of Edgar Newman and Elsa Schwartz."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_A76D16BC594DC43B",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "published Louisiana biography explicitly names Edgar among the couple's children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Louisiana Historical Association biography directly states that Isidore Newman married Rebecca Keiffer and lists Edgar among their children."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_89E4D586005683BD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "published Louisiana biography explicitly names Edgar among the couple's children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Louisiana Historical Association biography directly states that Isidore Newman married Rebecca Keiffer and lists Edgar among their children."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_ED0C16FFF7C797BD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "two credible published sources explicitly name the parent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Louisiana biography and Palatinate migration database independently identify Jacob Neumond and Clara Cahn/Kohn as Isidore's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_E1D1F04D42BBAABE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "two credible published sources explicitly name the parent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Louisiana biography and Palatinate migration database independently identify Jacob Neumond and Clara Cahn/Kohn as Isidore's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_4DA4BAEBB491DBA2",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F89; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_38239385891162C5",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F89; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_D60CCD63E90B2D5A",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F90; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_C0775AB102F7583E",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F90; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_9A867D3FE96C1F0E",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage reinforced by two published Louisiana Historical Association biographies and the exact 1926 New Orleans death timing",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_HERBERT_J_SCHWARTZ",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_1926"
      ],
      "source_note": "The imported tree identifies Leon E. Schwartz and Adeline Trautman as Elsa's parents. The 1883 Orleans marriage establishes the couple. A published biography identifies Elsa Schwartz as the mother of Isidore Newman II and calls Herbert J. Schwartz his uncle; a second published biography says Herbert succeeded the family wholesale firm when his father died in 1926. Leon's official Orleans Parish death is also in 1926. The combined evidence makes this couple the leading explanation for Elsa's parentage, but no reviewed record directly names Leon and Adeline as Elsa's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_B7278F00EEA4784B",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage reinforced by two published Louisiana Historical Association biographies and the exact 1926 New Orleans death timing",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_HERBERT_J_SCHWARTZ",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_1926"
      ],
      "source_note": "The imported tree identifies Leon E. Schwartz and Adeline Trautman as Elsa's parents. The 1883 Orleans marriage establishes the couple. A published biography identifies Elsa Schwartz as the mother of Isidore Newman II and calls Herbert J. Schwartz his uncle; a second published biography says Herbert succeeded the family wholesale firm when his father died in 1926. Leon's official Orleans Parish death is also in 1926. The combined evidence makes this couple the leading explanation for Elsa's parentage, but no reviewed record directly names Leon and Adeline as Elsa's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_EA4C17D3607FFE6C",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled Ancestry relationship consistent with a documented New Orleans couple and daughter biography, but no direct record naming Anna as their child",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_MARION_PFEIFER_ABRAMSON",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled tree identifies Leon Pfeifer and Bertha Cahn as Anna's parents. Independent biographies establish Anna Pfeifer in the same New Orleans setting and establish Leon and Bertha as parents of Marion, but neither source directly calls Anna their daughter. The links remain visible at 0.85 rather than being promoted to direct evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_D2E7598F0B83C37F",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled Ancestry relationship consistent with a documented New Orleans couple and daughter biography, but no direct record naming Anna as their child",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_MARION_PFEIFER_ABRAMSON",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled tree identifies Leon Pfeifer and Bertha Cahn as Anna's parents. Independent biographies establish Anna Pfeifer in the same New Orleans setting and establish Leon and Bertha as parents of Marion, but neither source directly calls Anna their daughter. The links remain visible at 0.85 rather than being promoted to direct evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_984CE59D7D5C766F",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "Ingenheim Jewish community database expressly identifies Leon as the son of Emanuel and Rahel in mutually linked profiles",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEON_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Two linked community-history profiles explicitly state this father-son relationship; Emanuel's profile also describes the 1879 passport and 1900 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_42EA7FFCF9565685",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "Ingenheim Jewish community database expressly identifies Leon as the son of Emanuel and Rahel in mutually linked profiles",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEON_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Two linked community-history profiles explicitly state this mother-son relationship; the family's American chronology is also described in Emanuel's profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_DD99EB19185B4E5B",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064575",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064217",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_C67CCB7E190606E8",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064217",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_2E4402C43A84CFE0",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "status": "strongly_correlated",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "Family GEDCOM parent identification correlated with independently checked 1915 marriage and 1916 birth index rows; neither index names the child's parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915",
        "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916"
      ],
      "source_note": "Max Juffe and Freda Dubowy married in New Britain on 30 May 1915, and Henrietta Juffe was born in Hartford on 30 April 1916. The exact sequence, locality, surname, and imported family make the link highly probable. Confidence remains below direct-proof level because the public birth-index entry does not name the parents; the full certificate is the preferred confirmation.\n\n15 September 2026: The underlying downloadable CSVs confirm both events, as well as Henrietta Juffe's 1937 marriage to Martin Segel. These are the same state-index records as the website, not independent additional witnesses. County is website-derived from town. Grade retained as an ordinal correlation judgment, not a measured probability or direct parentage proof. A full birth certificate or another record explicitly naming parents is still needed."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_2213B1AA0C84425A",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "status": "strongly_correlated",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "Family GEDCOM parent identification correlated with independently checked 1915 marriage and 1916 birth index rows; neither index names the child's parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915",
        "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916"
      ],
      "source_note": "Max Juffe and Freda Dubowy married in New Britain on 30 May 1915, and Henrietta Juffe was born in Hartford on 30 April 1916. The exact sequence, locality, surname, and imported family make the link highly probable. Confidence remains below direct-proof level because the public birth-index entry does not name the parents; the full certificate is the preferred confirmation.\n\n15 September 2026: The underlying downloadable CSVs confirm both events, as well as Henrietta Juffe's 1937 marriage to Martin Segel. These are the same state-index records as the website, not independent additional witnesses. County is website-derived from town. Grade retained as an ordinal correlation judgment, not a measured probability or direct parentage proof. A full birth certificate or another record explicitly naming parents is still needed."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_1D2417E6774016B2",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "status": "plausible_cluster_supported",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled relationship strengthened by rare surname, matching New Britain family cluster, contemporary Freda identity evidence, and compatible chronology; no parent-naming record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1916",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_FREDA_DUBOWY_ENGAGEMENT_1915",
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Freda is independently established in New Britain within the uncommon Dubowy cluster, while Solomon and Yetta are independently established there as spouses. This materially improves the compiled link, but the reviewed notices name neither Freda's parents nor the couple's children. A census, death certificate, passenger manifest, obituary, probate file, or marriage certificate is still required for direct proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_0AA6FE9138A55063",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "status": "plausible_cluster_supported",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled relationship strengthened by rare surname, matching New Britain family cluster, contemporary Freda identity evidence, and compatible chronology; no parent-naming record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1916",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_FREDA_DUBOWY_ENGAGEMENT_1915",
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Freda is independently established in New Britain within the uncommon Dubowy cluster, while Solomon and Yetta are independently established there as spouses. This materially improves the compiled link, but the reviewed notices name neither Freda's parents nor the couple's children. A census, death certificate, passenger manifest, obituary, probate file, or marriage certificate is still required for direct proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_521D6A6D573DC548",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064673",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled relationship with compatible chronology; historical identity evidence does not name the child",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Retained because chronology is compatible and no contradiction was found, but no direct record located in this pass names the child with this parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_70FB5412848D81FA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled father-child relationship strengthened by an exact-name Leon Cahn in Morgan City at the time and place of Bertha's reported birth, but no record yet names them together",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_MORGAN_CITY_JEWISH_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ST_MARY_BANNER_LEON_CAHN_LAND_CHAIN_1909"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Morgan City merchant and March 1879 land transaction make the imported relationship more plausible and remove the former absence of locality evidence. They do not directly name Bertha, so the link remains plausible compiled evidence at 0.78 rather than source-backed parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_C1022696315F7DC7",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled relationship with compatible chronology but no independent parent-child record located",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Retained as a plausible compiled-tree link after targeted searches found no direct record and no contradiction. Do not promote until a household, vital, obituary, probate, or equivalent record identifies the child with this parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_E4EACBB1D7FFA6BA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "published regional Jewish genealogy explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Published Alsatian Jewish migration research identifies Rebecca as the daughter of Louis Kieffer and Maria Roser. Confidence remains below direct-vital-record level."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_78F72B44B4D91115",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "published regional Jewish genealogy explicitly names both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Published Alsatian Jewish migration research identifies Rebecca as the daughter of Louis Kieffer and Maria Roser. Confidence remains below direct-vital-record level."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_3B326147576FAF5C",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_JEWISH_NAME_INDEX_LEMBACH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F80; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence. The 1808 Lembach name index confirms the Kieffer surname locally but does not identify this proposed parent by the imported name; the relationship remains deliberately low-confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_1BC60264F27331AC",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_JEWISH_NAME_INDEX_LEMBACH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F80; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence. The 1808 Lembach name index confirms the Kieffer surname locally but does not identify this proposed parent by the imported name; the relationship remains deliberately low-confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_D7050F3169E74AD4",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_JEWISH_NAME_INDEX_LEMBACH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F84; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence. The 1808 locality index does not identify Roser or Roeser at Lembach. This is cautionary negative evidence rather than a contradiction, because the family may then have used another name or arrived later."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_B9840AB7EA91AF9C",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_JEWISH_NAME_INDEX_LEMBACH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F84; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence. The 1808 locality index does not identify Roser or Roeser at Lembach. This is cautionary negative evidence rather than a contradiction, because the family may then have used another name or arrived later."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_32DF1B31F24ADB5C",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F10; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_AA5E00FB6A5FC29D",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F10; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_86F676DBCB59833F",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "status": "candidate_harvested_with_name_locality_conflict",
      "confidence": 0.43,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parent-child claim; the proposed father's combined name and Gunstett locality are not supported by the 1808 surname index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_GUNSTETT_NAME_INDEX_NEGATIVE_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "The claim that Michel Leyser/Leiser Moyses Kieffer was Isaac Kieffer's father comes from the imported GEDCOM. The 1808 surname-declaration index places Kieffer at Lembach and Strasbourg, but not Gunstett, and has no Gunstett entry under the imported Moyses/Moser/Michel variants. The most likely alternatives are a later conflation of a Lembach Kieffer with an unrelated Gunstett man, or a genuine Gunstett resident who adopted a different surname. The index cannot decide between them, so the relationship is retained as a low-confidence visible hypothesis rather than removed."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_B6B760BCA628BA54",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled relationship with compatible chronology; historical identity evidence does not name the child",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Retained because chronology is compatible and no contradiction was found, but no direct record located in this pass names the child with this parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_B85D0BFC77EBE850",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled relationship with compatible chronology; historical identity evidence does not name the child",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Retained because chronology is compatible and no contradiction was found, but no direct record located in this pass names the child with this parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_08E132BA497A280E",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F68; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_61902AE74AE7E895",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F68; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_BCD17AEA01372154",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F86; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence. A second compiled tree repeats this relationship, but possible source dependence prevents a confidence increase."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_7F87F54EA1624696",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F86; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence. A second compiled tree repeats this relationship, but possible source dependence prevents a confidence increase."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_B8D4CBADAB6FEB34",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F15; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_8E9C4954DC19E7EF",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F15; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_F9EDFE32A384AF12",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F95; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_FB859687703A9E1B",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "imported compiled relationship contradicted by a chronologically stronger compiled reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The imported GEDCOM names Mosche Levy, about 1690, as Jacques's father. A separate compiled reconstruction instead names Michel Machole Levy, about 1725, while repeating Jacques's spouse and later children. Neither source cites an original record. The imported chronology would place Mosche at about sixty at Jacques's 1750 birth; it remains a possible but substantially less likely alternative rather than the leading parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_8F64B5C5E8E4E094",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "imported compiled relationship contradicted by a chronologically stronger compiled reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The imported GEDCOM names Judith Levy, about 1695, as Jacques's mother. A separate compiled reconstruction gives Jacques a different, unidentified mother and a father born about 1725, while repeating Jacques's spouse and later children. Neither source cites an original record. Judith's imported date would make her about fifty-five at Jacques's 1750 birth; the link remains visible as a substantially less likely alternative, not the leading maternity."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_2417B63031283D26",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F119; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_FAD1F4DF01058F48",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "Ingenheim community profiles for both people explicitly name Rahel as David's daughter",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_DAVID_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship is expressly stated in linked community-history profiles and fits the documented marriage and chronology."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_A24B929E7A1DA762",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "Ingenheim community profiles for both people explicitly name Rahel as Johanna's daughter",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JOHANNA_FRANK_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship is expressly stated in linked community-history profiles and fits the documented marriage and chronology."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_24EBA0FCAF74DA26",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1808 Oberlustadt name-adoption list explicitly calls Johanna a minor daughter of Salomon Frank",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The archival list directly identifies Salomon as Johanna's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_B39F83A626E323BC",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "1808 list explicitly names Rosalia as Salomon's wife and places Johanna among his minor children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rosalia's maternity is strongly supported by the household structure, but the child remark explicitly names only Salomon."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_53AAF9A5ABAEB5AB",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "1808 patronymic explicitly identifies the younger Salomon's father as Samolon; imported elder candidate matches name, locality, and chronology but is not uniquely identified",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The father's given name is direct evidence. The specific elder profile remains a reconstruction because the list supplies no further paternal identifiers."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_5D1E3FD5519E255D",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F93; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_BAB962228DE11AA0",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F6; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_PC_34AADC83D8604C1C",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM family relationship",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F6; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_JERICK_LINDER_JEMIMA_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "target": "I85",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled family profile and cited Anthony Linder family research; original probate not produced",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_ANTHONY_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship is retained as a plausible compiled child of Anthony and Mary Linder. The reported family will has not been verified from the original probate record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PC_MARY_NEWLAND_JEMIMA_LINDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "target": "I85",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "near-contemporary biography plus father's will abstract, marriage, land, and reported husband will",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_NEWLAND_JOHN_WILL_ABSTRACT_MARY_LINDER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Brock states that Jemima Linder's mother was a sister of Isaac Newland. John Newland's 1800 will abstract names both Mary Linder and Isaac as his children; Anthony and Mary's land and reported will records complete the identification. This is strong indirect proof, not an original birth record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ANN_MCNEW_MARY_MCNEW_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "target": "I71",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "consistent family cluster, repeated census spouse, sibling parent records, and compiled relationship; no record yet explicitly names Mary as Ann's daughter",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_HENDERSON_FAMILY_RECORD_NOTES",
        "SRC_WCV_PARENT_INDEX_DAVID_ANN_MCNEW"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ann/Annie is David McNew's directly observed spouse across the 1850-1880 family sequence. The 1850 enumeration places newly married Mary Henderson immediately after David and Ann's household, and compiled family notes identify Mary as their daughter. Washington County records name David and Ann as parents of other children. No captured record explicitly names Mary as Ann's daughter, so the link remains unverified at 0.90. Smith, Sevier, Morgan, and Kennedy have all been suggested as Ann's maiden surname, but none is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_WILLIAM_DAVIES_1815",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "William's baptism explicitly names Eliza; repeated Robert-and-Elizabeth baptisms at Trustewelin and William's later abode establish strong continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
        "SRC_FREEREG_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1823",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1814 baptism explicitly names Eliza as William's mother and places the family at Trustewelin. Later baptisms continue Robert and Elizabeth there, and William's adult household returned to the same distinctive abode. The parent relationship is highly probable; Lamb as Elizabeth's maiden surname remains separately qualified."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_TO_I196",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "target": "I196",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1764 baptism explicitly names father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026. H1: John Brassington, identity unresolved (GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196) is the parent of John Brassington (I196). Alternatives: The Ranton father was the Chelmorton John baptised in 1739; or another Ranton John (the former is a documented candidate baptism, the latter hypothetical). Evidence: The 1764 entry names John and Jane. The 1761 marriage and 1810 probate household fit that same couple. A 1739 birth could fit a 1761 marriage and distance alone does not exclude migration. The old claim equating him with the Mary Swindell husband conflicts with the continuing Jane household; those two identity propositions must be separated. Ranking: H1 parentage very strongly leads; retain .995. Elder John’s birth-family identification remains open. The Chelmorton baptism alone is not conclusively excluded, but has less identifying support than the local adult household. Next: 1761 marriage licence/allegation naming age, origin or bondsman; original probate or settlement identifying John’s kin."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_TO_I196",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "target": "I196",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1764 baptism explicitly names mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Brassington's 18 Nov 1764 Ranton baptism explicitly identifies his mother as Jane."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CHRISTIAN_CHRISTOPHER_GOBBLE_TO_ELIZABETH_I83",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "target": "I83",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1888 biography names Christopher Gobble; identity aligns with Christian/Christopher's Maryland service and census usage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GB26_GOBBLE_PENSION_SUMMARY"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SARAH_GISE_TO_ELIZABETH_I83",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "target": "I83",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "documented/compiled spouse context; biography names father but not mother",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sarah Gise is the supported spouse of Christian/Christopher and is chronologically compatible as Elizabeth's mother, but the 1888 biography names only Elizabeth's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_I69_I63",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I69",
      "target": "I63",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM plus compiled profile naming William's spouse Mary; no record names Suckey's mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Retained under the derivative-tree policy as a low-confidence mother hypothesis. The 1786 bond names William as Suckey's father but does not name her mother; Mary's identity and maternity remain unproved."
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN9_CORR_PE_I107_ABRAHAM_1775",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I107",
      "target": "HV4_ABRAHAM_GOBBLE_10_FEB_1775",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "published trees place child with Johann Friedrich Jr.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Best-supported generational placement from derivative trees; no primary child record inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN9_CORR_PE_I108_ABRAHAM_1775",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I108",
      "target": "HV4_ABRAHAM_GOBBLE_10_FEB_1775",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "evidence_strength": "probable-wife context only",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth is the probable wife of Johann Friedrich Jr.; maternity is less directly supported than paternity."
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN9_CORR_PE_I107_ISAAC_1778",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I107",
      "target": "HV4_ISAAC_GABEL_GOBBLE_9_JUN_1778",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "published trees place child with Johann Friedrich Jr.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Best-supported generational placement from derivative trees; no primary child record inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN9_CORR_PE_I108_ISAAC_1778",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I108",
      "target": "HV4_ISAAC_GABEL_GOBBLE_9_JUN_1778",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "evidence_strength": "probable-wife context only",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth is the probable wife of Johann Friedrich Jr.; maternity is less directly supported than paternity."
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN9_CORR_PE_I107_JACOB_1771",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I107",
      "target": "HV4_JACOB_GABEL_GOBBLE_16_MAY_1771",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "published trees place child with Johann Friedrich Jr.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Best-supported generational placement from derivative trees; no primary child record inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN9_CORR_PE_I108_JACOB_1771",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I108",
      "target": "HV4_JACOB_GABEL_GOBBLE_16_MAY_1771",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "evidence_strength": "probable-wife context only",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth is the probable wife of Johann Friedrich Jr.; maternity is less directly supported than paternity."
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN9_CORR_PE_I107_JOHN_HENRY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I107",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_HENRY_GABLE",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.48
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN9_CORR_PE_I108_JOHN_HENRY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I108",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_HENRY_GABLE",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.38
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN9_CORR_PE_I107_MARIA_1761",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I107",
      "target": "HV4_MARIA_GABEL_GOBBLE_21_MAR_1761",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.52,
      "evidence_strength": "published trees place child with Johann Friedrich Jr.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Best-supported generational placement from derivative trees; no primary child record inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "GEN9_CORR_PE_I108_MARIA_1761",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I108",
      "target": "HV4_MARIA_GABEL_GOBBLE_21_MAR_1761",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "evidence_strength": "probable-wife context only",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth is the probable wife of Johann Friedrich Jr.; maternity remains weak and derivative."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ELIZABETH_LINDER_NEWLAND_MARY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "target": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "documented parental couple plus published family reconstruction; will names father only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780",
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800"
      ],
      "source_note": "John's will directly names Mary as his daughter. The 1739 marriage and later deeds establish Elizabeth as John's wife across the childbearing period; published family research identifies Mary as their daughter. No baptism directly naming Elizabeth was located, so maternity remains slightly inferential."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARY_WIRICK_HEBDON_TO_ROBERT_BARTEE_1704",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I75",
      "target": "I74",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "Henry Wirick's will names daughter Mary Barttee and grandson Robert Bartee",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711"
      ],
      "source_note": "Henry Wirick's 1710 will directly identifies Mary Barttee as his daughter and Robert Bartee as his grandson. The older Robert's 1711 will independently names wife Mary and son Robert."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ROBERT_BARTEE_SR_TO_ROBERT_BARTEE_1704",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "target": "I74",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "Robert's 1711 will names son Robert; Henry Wirick's will independently names grandson Robert Bartee through daughter Mary",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The older Robert's published 1711 will abstract names a son Robert. Henry Wirick's 1710 will independently calls daughter Mary Barttee's son Robert his grandson, strongly identifying the later Robert."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BERLIN_JOHANS_MARGRETH_1576",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER",
      "target": "I244",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "father named in published parish-register-based baptism pedigree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026 hypothesis review. H1: Johann Berlin (Beerlin), Magister (C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER) is the parent of Margaretha (Margreth) Berlin (I244). Alternatives: A different Margreth Berlin was the Erpfingen wife (hypothetical). Evidence comparison: The parish-based identification supplies the matching name and a plausible age/locality/career context, with father Johann and mother Anna. No competing woman was documented. Ranking: H1 strongly leads. Next discriminating evidence: Legible Erpfingen marriage and Weinsberg baptism images."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BERLIN_ANNA_MARGRETH_1576",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "target": "I244",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "mother named in published parish-register-based baptism pedigree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Weigel pedigree, based on the Weinsberg church book, identifies Anna as mother of Margreth baptized 27 Nov 1576. Her maiden name remains unknown. Confidence is slightly below direct-image certainty because the original image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_RICHARD_BUTT_ELDER_ROBERT_1678",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "target": "I117",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "evidence_strength": "zero-source collaborative claim contradicted by a published list of Richard's children that omits Robert",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch supplies this parent claim without records. The Virginia/North Carolina Butt family history lists nine children of Richard and does not include Robert. The link remains visible only as a low-probability alternative pending inspection of the underlying Norfolk probate material."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_SARACH_SAYER_ROBERT_BUTT_1678",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "target": "I117",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "single zero-source collaborative claim; proposed mother is absent from the published Richard Butt family reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "No record independently identifies Sarach Sayer or states that she was Robert Butt's mother. A conflicting family history names different wives for Richard. This relationship is retained at minimal confidence solely to preserve the non-contradictory-tree review trail."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BUTT_ROBERT_D1676_RICHARD_ELDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "target": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "1675 will names a son Richard; later family history identifies the elder Richard as that son",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert's will directly names a son Richard. The identification with this Norfolk elder Richard is supported by locality, chronology, and the later family history, though no birth or uniquely identifying record was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BUTT_JANE_RICHARD_ELDER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "target": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "wife Jane and son Richard occur in the same will, but the will does not call Jane his mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Jane was Robert's wife when his 1675 will named son Richard. She is chronologically and contextually the likely mother, but maternity is inferential and her maiden name is unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BEERLIN_HANS_JOHANN_MAGISTER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "target": "C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.52,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree proposal explicitly marked filiation not secured",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Weigel Ahnentafel places Hans Beerlin as Johann's father but prints a question mark and states that the filiation is not secured. Chronology and regional movement are compatible; no direct baptism or inheritance record was cited."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_BLEYLE_AGATHA_JOHANN_MAGISTER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "target": "C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree proposal explicitly marked filiation not secured",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026 hypothesis review. H1: Agatha Bleyle (C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535) is the parent of Johann Berlin (Beerlin), Magister (C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER). Alternatives: A different parental family; or correct family with erroneous approximate birth/marriage dates (both hypothetical). Evidence comparison: The compiled parental proposal is positive evidence, but explicitly uncertain. Johann’s approximate 1550 birth precedes the proposed 1555 marriage; an approximate-date error could explain this. The existing NLF remarriage lead adds a separate unresolved chronology issue, not a proven replacement parent. Ranking: H1 remains a tentative leading named proposal, not clearly distinguished from erroneous filiation; retain .50. Next discriminating evidence: Early education/family records naming Johann’s parents; 1587 marriage and 1588/1591 burials."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP8_PE_I107_TO_I86",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I107",
      "target": "I86",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "detailed family-association genealogy explicitly lists John as child; chronology and migration compatible; original baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Goble Family Association database explicitly lists John, born 10 Feb 1766 in Baltimore County, as a child of Johann Friedrich Jr. and Elizabeth Weigel. This resolves a plausible existing gap but remains derivative evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP8_PE_I108_TO_I86",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I108",
      "target": "I86",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "detailed family-association genealogy explicitly lists John in the couple's family; original baptism not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published association genealogy identifies Elizabeth Weigel as Johann Friedrich Jr.'s wife and John as their child. Maternity is retained slightly below paternity because no original baptism was inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP8_PE_JOHN_FELPS_TO_SAMUEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "target": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit published Phelps/Y-DNA lineage claim and compatible 1766 marriage; reconstruction openly debated and contemporary parent record absent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Phelps/Y-DNA project explicitly identifies Samuel as a son of John and Mary. It also warns that John's placement and parts of the reconstruction are questioned; the relationship remains visible at moderate-low confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP8_PE_MARY_WILLIAMS_TO_SAMUEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "target": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit published Phelps/Y-DNA lineage claim and compatible 1766 marriage; contemporary parent record absent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Phelps/Y-DNA project explicitly identifies Samuel as a son of John Felps and Mary Williams. No original record naming Samuel's parents was inspected, so the relationship remains moderate-low confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP9_PE_GEORGE_WEIGEL_TO_ELIZABETH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "target": "I108",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "IPGV Elisabeth card names both parents and exactly matches 10 May 1757 Friedrich Gabel marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_OT26_WEIGELE_GABEL_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_OT26_GOSHENHOPPEN_HINKE_ARCHIVE",
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_ELISABETH",
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_GEORGE",
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Exact bride, husband, date and church link this institutional family entry to Elizabeth. Named mother adds evidence beyond earlier compiled parent lists. Same-card-group dependence acknowledged; manuscript not inspected. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP9_PE_ANNA_DITLICH_TO_ELIZABETH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "target": "I108",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "IPGV Elisabeth card names both parents and exactly matches 10 May 1757 Friedrich Gabel marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_OT26_WEIGELE_GABEL_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_ELISABETH",
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_GEORGE",
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Exact bride, husband, date and church link this institutional family entry to Elizabeth. Named mother adds evidence beyond earlier compiled parent lists. Same-card-group dependence acknowledged; manuscript not inspected. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP11_PE_GEORG_BATZER_URSULA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "target": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-register-based pedigree identifies the ten-child family and exact daughter",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cited Erpfingen reconstruction identifies Ursula Batzer, born 1 Jul 1650, among Georg Batzer and Ursula Hinckh's ten children."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP11_PE_URSULA_HINCKH_URSULA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "target": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-register-based pedigree identifies the family; surname independently appears in a sibling baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cited reconstruction identifies Ursula as the mother of Ursula Batzer; the mother's surname Hinckh is recorded in daughter Barbara's 1648 Reutlingen baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP12_PE_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ANNA_CATHARINA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "record-linked Blankenloch sibling reconstruction; conflicting derivative parent set and no inspected target baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Selected as the more geographically coherent parent hypothesis. FamilySearch cites the Blankenloch register for the sibling group; GenArchives instead names Hanss Wendel Kieffer without displaying a citation."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP12_PE_MARGRETHA_WIDMAN_ANNA_CATHARINA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "record-linked Blankenloch sibling reconstruction; conflicting derivative parent set and no inspected target baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Selected as the more geographically coherent mother hypothesis, but the direct baptism was not inspected and an uncited derivative pedigree instead names Anna Barbara."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP13_PE_BARBARA_RADLER_BARBARA_MOLLFINGER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "target": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.54,
      "evidence_strength": "single non-contradictory derivative mother claim; daughter's marriage does not name mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Retained under the derivative-tree policy. The mother is named only in one public pedigree; the direct 1665 marriage evidence identifies the father but not the mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP16_PE_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_AGATHA_BLEYLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "target": "C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "evidence_strength": "published pedigree's exact father-number placement, explicitly question-marked and unsupported by an exposed original record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_USER_MYHERITAGE_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_1504_1568",
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026 hypothesis review. H1: Sebastian Bleyle (EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504) is the parent of Agatha Bleyle (C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535). Alternatives: The body number 21618 is correct and the index/filiation is wrong; or a speculative earlier compiler assignment (hypothetical). Evidence comparison: The index gives 20618, exactly twice Agatha’s 10309, whereas the body gives 21618. A typographical error is a simpler explanation of the internal mismatch. That favors the intended connection but does not establish its historical accuracy; the question mark and user-supplied tree remain the evidence base. Ranking: H1 leads as the intended pedigree connection; historical parentage remains tentative at .50. Next discriminating evidence: A record naming Agatha’s father, or the compiler’s underlying evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_RICHARD_LISTER_JANE_LISTER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "target": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "1851 census directly identifies Richard as Jane Lyster's father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Jane is explicitly a daughter in Richard Lyster's 1851 household. Identity continuity through Jane's age, surname, birthplace, marriage, and later Shrewsbury households is strong."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_KEZIA_PRICE_JANE_LISTER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "target": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Two independent family reconstructions support Kezia as Jane's mother, but a contemporary 1851 census transcript names Eliza.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805"
      ],
      "source_note": "Avril J. Wood's 1992 chart strengthens the previously compiled Kezia Price hypothesis by independently showing Kezia and Richard with Jane among their children. The chart also records Jane's older sister Kezia, born about 1846, who died young, preserving the name within the sibling group. The 1851 census transcript still makes Eliza the more likely mother, so this remains the lower-confidence competing relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_THOMAS_LISTER_RICHARD_LISTER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "target": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "Pontefract child index names Richard with parents Thomas and Ann; later identity is compatible in name, age, and reported birthplace",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_COMPILED_PROFILE_1804_1879"
      ],
      "source_note": "Plausible reconstruction, held below direct-record certainty because the supplied Richard baptism excerpt omitted its date and the later-life bridge is circumstantial."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ANN_MARSHALL_RICHARD_LISTER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "target": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "Pontefract child index names Richard with parents Thomas and Ann; later identity is compatible in name, age, and reported birthplace",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_COMPILED_PROFILE_1804_1879"
      ],
      "source_note": "Plausible reconstruction, held below direct-record certainty because the supplied Richard baptism excerpt omitted its date and the later-life bridge is circumstantial."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_LEO_DREYFUSS_DAVID_1808",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1808 name-adoption list explicitly calls David a son of Leo Dreyfuss",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Directly stated father-son relationship in the household list."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_DAVID_1808",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "Rosali appears between Leo and his explicitly listed children under the adopted Dreyfuss household name",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Strong household inference; the transcript does not explicitly call Rosali David's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_C_SCHAAF_JM_TO_I77",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "target": "I77",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "parent named for the 1848 baptism candidate, discounted because the German child has not been linked directly to the New Jersey adult and because duplicate Johann Martin Schaafs existed",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY",
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This link means Johann Martin was reported as father of the plausible Ober-Gleen baptism candidate. It does not assert that the candidate and Katharine Schaaf Fricke are proved to be the same person."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_C_GRAU_AC_TO_I77",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "target": "I77",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "parent named for the 1848 baptism candidate, discounted because the German child has not been linked directly to the New Jersey adult",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY",
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This link means Anna Catharina was reported as mother of the plausible Ober-Gleen baptism candidate. It does not assert that the candidate and Katharine Schaaf Fricke are proved to be the same person."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_TO_ISAIAH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_PETERS_PRISCILLA_FRESHFORD_1707",
      "target": "I190",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "exact compiled mother-son claim with compatible uncommon name, Freshford locality, chronology, and independently proved later marriage, but no cited Isaiah baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ISAIAH_PETERS_1734_PROFILE",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE",
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707"
      ],
      "source_note": "Priscilla is visibly restored as a candidate mother under the policy of retaining plausible compiled relationships. The link is not direct evidence: the inspected source proves Priscilla's own baptism and parents, while Isaiah's profile asserts but does not document his mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ROBERT_PETERS_TO_PRISCILLA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_PETERS_ROBERT_FRESHFORD_FATHER_PRISCILLA",
      "target": "C_PETERS_PRISCILLA_FRESHFORD_1707",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1707 Freshford baptism transcript directly names Robert as father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish transcript directly states this father-daughter relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ANN_PETERS_TO_PRISCILLA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_PETERS_ANN_FRESHFORD_MOTHER_PRISCILLA",
      "target": "C_PETERS_PRISCILLA_FRESHFORD_1707",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1707 Freshford baptism transcript directly names Ann as mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish transcript directly states this mother-daughter relationship; Ann's maiden surname is not supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_TO_BETTY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_NORTH_BRADLEY_FATHER_BETTY",
      "target": "I191",
      "status": "conflicting_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled father claim contradicted in the child's forename by an independent transcript of the cited-date North Bradley baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_BETTY_WILLIS_1737_PROFILE",
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1738",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_1738_FAMILY_CLUSTER"
      ],
      "source_note": "WikiTree calls the 22 January 1737 christening Betty and names Benjamin; FreeREG transcribes Ann, daughter of Benjamin, on 22 January 1737/38. Because no inspected record names Betty with Benjamin, the link remains visible only at 0.42 under the compiled-tree policy."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_SR_TO_1701_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_SR_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "target": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_NORTH_BRADLEY_FATHER_BETTY",
      "status": "probable",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "1701 baptism names father Benjamin; parish-wide register reconstruction identifies the father as the 1678/79 Benjamin and records his 1703 burial as Junior",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1701",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_1738_FAMILY_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_1679"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1701 baptism directly names the father but not his age. The parish reconstruction distinguishes him through the 1678/79 baptism, sibling cluster, and 1703 “Junior” burial. This raises the link from a loose same-name hypothesis to probable, while stopping short of absolute certainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_WILLIAM_WILLIS_TO_BENJAMIN_1679",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WILLIS_WILLIAM_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "target": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_SR_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "status": "verified",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct parish baptism transcript",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679"
      ],
      "source_note": "Benjamin’s 10 January 1678/79 baptism explicitly names father William Willis."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_KATHERINE_WILLIS_TO_BENJAMIN_1679",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WILLIS_KATHERINE_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "target": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_SR_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "status": "verified",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct parish baptism transcript",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679"
      ],
      "source_note": "Benjamin’s 10 January 1678/79 baptism explicitly names mother Katherine."
    },
    {
      "id": "PC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_ADELINE_1862",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "official Orleans Parish birth index names the father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862"
      ],
      "source_note": "Adeline Trautman's official index entry names her father as David Trautman."
    },
    {
      "id": "PC_JULIA_MOSES_ADELINE_1862",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "official Orleans Parish birth index names the mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862"
      ],
      "source_note": "Adeline Trautman's official index entry names her mother as Julia Moses."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_JOHN_MARSHALL_TO_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MARSHALL_JOHN_PONTEFRACT_1772",
      "target": "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "derivative child index names John; chronology and Pontefract locality align, but no original baptism or adult identity bridge has been inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT",
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_THOMAS_LISTER_MARRIAGE_1799_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "John is attached as the most plausible current father candidate. The link remains visibly uncertain because a same-name indexed child has not yet been bridged directly to the woman who married Thomas Lister in 1799."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ANN_ALLEN_TO_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ALLEN_ANN_WIFE_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "target": "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "mother inferred from John Marshall's 1772 marriage and candidate child chronology; supplied child extract does not name her",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT",
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_THOMAS_LISTER_MARRIAGE_1799_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ann Allen is attached at lower confidence than John because the reviewed baptism extract names only the father. Her marriage makes maternity plausible, not proved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_B68_HIRSCH_TO_LEO",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "B68_ISAAK_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_1736",
      "target": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "two linked local historical profiles explicitly identify the relationship",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Leo's profile names Isaak Hirsch as father; Hirsch's profile reciprocally names Leo as son."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_B68_MARIA_ANNA_TO_LEO",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "B68_MARIA_ANNA_ABRAHAM_OPPENHEIMER",
      "target": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "status": "source_backed_name_conflict",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "evidence_strength": "Leo's profile names Maria Anna née Abraham; Hirsch's wife profile wording supplies conflicting surname forms",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Maternity is explicit, but Maria Anna's surname varies between Abraham and Oppenheimer and is therefore not normalized to a single unqualified surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_B68_JEHUDA_TO_HIRSCH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "B68_JEHUDA_LOEB_DREYFUSS",
      "target": "B68_ISAAK_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_1736",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "Hirsch's local profile explicitly names his father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship is explicit in the record-based local profile; no second independent record was inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_B68_DAVID_MOSES_TO_ROSINA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "B68_DAVID_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
      "target": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "Rosina's local profile explicitly names her father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship is explicit in the record-based local profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_TO_ROSINA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
      "target": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "Rosina's local profile explicitly names her mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship is explicit in the record-based local profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_TO_JOHN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "target": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "John's primary civil marriage register explicitly names his father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1883 register explicitly names Andrew Gibson, farmer, as John Gibson's father. Griffith's Valuation places a matching Andrew Gibson in John's Aghnasedagh townland. No mother is named."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_B71_JOHN_LAMB_TO_PROBABLE_ELIZABETH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "target": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "1785 Kerry baptism explicitly names father John; unique indexed county baptism and marriage sequence plausibly connect the child to the 1803 Berriew bride but provide no direct migration bridge",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_DAVIES_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1803",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BAPTISM_SWEEP_1750_1790",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_MARRIAGE_SWEEP_1795_1820",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BURIAL_SWEEP_1785_1803"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism directly proves that John Lamb had a daughter Elizabeth at Kerry in 1785. It does not prove that she was the Elizabeth Lamb who married Robert Davies at Berriew in 1803. The uncommon surname, plausible age, nearby parishes, unique indexed county baptism and marriage, and absence of an indexed intervening burial make the link plausible enough to retain at low confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_TO_PROBABLE_ELIZABETH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "target": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "1785 Kerry baptism names mother Elizabeth and the immediately preceding marriage identifies her plausibly as Elizabeth Prichard; connection to the 1803 Berriew bride lacks a direct migration bridge",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_DAVIES_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1803",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BAPTISM_SWEEP_1750_1790",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_MARRIAGE_SWEEP_1795_1820",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BURIAL_SWEEP_1785_1803"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism directly names the child's mother as Elizabeth. The Kerry marriage five months earlier makes Elizabeth Prichard the probable mother. Neither record proves that their daughter was the Elizabeth Lamb who married at Berriew in 1803, so this ancestral link remains a low-confidence hypothesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TO_DELIA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "1840-1850 household-age reconstruction plus Delia's probable Faddis maiden surname; no parent-naming record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_1835_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX",
        "SRC_1840_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1840 Alexander Faddis household has two girls aged 5-9. One is very plausibly Sibarina, age 16 in Susan's 1850 household; the other is consistent with Adelia, age 18 and already married nearby in 1850. Alexander's adult presence in 1830, 1835, and 1840 plus absence from the 1850 continuation makes him the strongest named father candidate. The census does not name the girls, so this remains a 70% circumstantial relationship rather than direct evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_B73_SUSAN_FADDIS_TO_DELIA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "B73_SUSAN_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "evidence_strength": "1840-1850 household-age reconstruction plus Delia's probable Faddis maiden surname; no parent-naming record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_1835_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX",
        "SRC_1840_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": "The woman aged 40-49 in Alexander Faddis's 1840 household is the leading match for Susan Faddis, age 55 in the 1850 continuation. The two 1840 girls aged 5-9 fit Sibarina and Adelia, with Adelia married and absent by 1850. This makes Susan the strongest named mother candidate. The alternate explanation—another unnamed Faddis woman and a different older daughter—remains possible because census relationships were not recorded. The link is therefore 73% circumstantial, not direct."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_B105_DORSET_ROBERT_TO_VIRGINIA_ROBERT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_WINTERBORNE_FATHER_C1570",
      "target": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "status": "possible_identity_bridge",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "tentative Dorset identity; documented younger namesake weakens former local-continuity argument",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_ROBERT_BUTT_BAPTISM_1616",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_PROTESTATION_1641",
        "SRC_DORSET_HEARTH_TAX_ROBERT_BUTT_1664",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS",
        "SRC_BRISTOL_ARCHIVES_SERVANTS_FOREIGN_PLANTATIONS_GUIDE",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_WHITECHURCH_ROBERT_BUTT_GRACE_DENNES_1678",
        "SRC_OT26_ROBERT_BUTT_1647_BROAD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Reassessment 15 September 2026. H1: the Dorset Robert baptized in 1616 became the Virginia Robert deceased 1676. H2: he remained in Dorset and appears in later local records. H3: those later records concern other local Roberts. Broad’s report supplies an actual younger Robert, baptized 12 April 1647, son of Symon; if he survived, he would be about 31 in 1678, whereas the 1616 child would be about 62. The 1678 marriage to Grace Dennes gives no age, parent or residence, so it cannot distinguish these candidates. The 1647 child was about 17 in 1664 and is not automatically the three-hearth taxpayer either. The 1641 return could concern the older father or 1616 son; it predates the younger child. These events must not be combined into one continuous life without identity evidence. H1 has positive name and chronological compatibility; H2 no longer has the claimed substantial advantage from the 1678 marriage. Overall transatlantic identity remains unresolved. Kinship, occupation, property, local burial or migration evidence would discriminate. Ordinal tentative assessment revised; no calibrated probability or multiplied path probability is claimed."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_B105_SUSAN_GANTRELL_TO_VIRGINIA_ROBERT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GANTRELL_SUSAN_WINTERBORNE_1585",
      "target": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "status": "possible_identity_bridge",
      "confidence": 0.38,
      "evidence_strength": "tentative Dorset identity; documented younger namesake weakens former local-continuity argument",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_ROBERT_BUTT_BAPTISM_1616",
        "SRC_DORSET_HEARTH_TAX_ROBERT_BUTT_1664",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_WHITECHURCH_ROBERT_BUTT_GRACE_DENNES_1678",
        "SRC_OT26_ROBERT_BUTT_1647_BROAD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Reassessment 15 September 2026. H1: the Dorset Robert baptized in 1616 became the Virginia Robert deceased 1676. H2: he remained in Dorset and appears in later local records. H3: those later records concern other local Roberts. Broad’s report supplies an actual younger Robert, baptized 12 April 1647, son of Symon; if he survived, he would be about 31 in 1678, whereas the 1616 child would be about 62. The 1678 marriage to Grace Dennes gives no age, parent or residence, so it cannot distinguish these candidates. The 1647 child was about 17 in 1664 and is not automatically the three-hearth taxpayer either. The 1641 return could concern the older father or 1616 son; it predates the younger child. These events must not be combined into one continuous life without identity evidence. H1 has positive name and chronological compatibility; H2 no longer has the claimed substantial advantage from the 1678 marriage. Overall transatlantic identity remains unresolved. Kinship, occupation, property, local burial or migration evidence would discriminate. Ordinal tentative assessment revised; no calibrated probability or multiplied path probability is claimed. Susan’s maternity of the 1616 child is reconstructed from the 1607 marriage and child sequence, a separate inference from the Atlantic identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_B106_RICHARD_GANTRELL_TO_SUSAN_1585",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GANTRELL_RICHARD_FATHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "target": "C_GANTRELL_SUSAN_WINTERBORNE_1585",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "father and child explicitly named in a quoted parish baptism dated 18 August 1585",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Explicit parent naming in the quoted 1585 baptism strongly supports Richard as Susan’s father within this Dorset household. His identity with the Richard buried in 1591 is a separate inference. The unresolved identification of Susan’s son with the Virginia Robert Butt does not reduce the local parent-child evidence. No end-to-end probability is inferred from this edge score."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_B106_AVES_TO_SUSAN_1585",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GANTRELL_AVES_MOTHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "target": "C_GANTRELL_SUSAN_WINTERBORNE_1585",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "mother and child explicitly named in a quoted parish baptism dated 18 August 1585",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The quoted baptism explicitly names Aves as Richard Gantrell’s wife and Susan’s mother. Her maiden surname and parents remain unknown. This local relationship is strongly supported independently of the unresolved Dorset-to-Virginia identity; numerical edge judgments must not be multiplied into an ancestry probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_B116_MORRIS_SEGEL_MORDACHAI_SEGEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064575",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_TO_SAMUEL_CARSINGTON_1743",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743",
      "target": "C_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1734",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "published probate abstract directly names Samuel as Robert's son",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_ROBERT_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_STAFFS_WILLS_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1743"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published abstract of Robert Needham's 1743 probate calls Samuel Needham of Carsington his son. This is direct relationship wording reported by a secondary abstract; inspecting the original will remains a useful verification step. The official probate index independently identifies the surviving original as Lichfield Consistory Court B/C/11, recorded 19 April 1743; it confirms the testator and record, but the published abstract remains the source for the reported father-son wording until the will image is inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_TO_EDWARD_ASHBOURNE_COMPARATIVE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1734",
      "target": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "direct baptismal parentage for the 1733/34 child; adult identity ranked above the alternatives",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BAPTISM_1734",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BURIAL_1816",
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1738"
      ],
      "source_note": "Samuel is directly named as father of an Edward baptised at Carsington in February 1733/34. That date closely fits the Ashbourne grocer's 1816 burial age of 82; the 1738 Ashbourne candidate would require a four-to-five-year age discrepancy. No record explicitly joins the child to the grocer, so this is the leading plausible identity, not proved parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_MARTHA_NEDHAM_TO_EDWARD_ASHBOURNE_COMPARATIVE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MARTHA_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1747",
      "target": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "direct baptismal parentage for the 1733/34 child; adult identity ranked above the alternatives",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BAPTISM_1734",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BURIAL_1816",
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1738"
      ],
      "source_note": "Martha is directly named as mother of an Edward baptised at Carsington in February 1733/34. The adult identity comparison is the same as for Samuel: it is currently the leading plausible explanation, but no record explicitly joins the child to the later grocer."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_GEORGE_NEEDHAM_TO_EDWARD_ASHBOURNE_COMPARATIVE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1738",
      "target": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "status": "competing_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "evidence_strength": "direct baptismal parentage for the 1738 child; weaker fit to the adult burial age",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1738",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BURIAL_1816",
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BAPTISM_1734"
      ],
      "source_note": "George is directly named as father of an Edward baptised at Ashbourne in 1738. Shared parish makes this a real alternative, but the adult burial age fits the 1733/34 Carsington child much more closely. No later record associates George's son with the grocer."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_TO_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_COMPARATIVE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1668_1677",
      "target": "C_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1694",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "two direct same-place baptisms identify Thomas as father of Mary candidates; the adult bride is unbridged",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGSTAFFE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1668_1677",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_MARRIAGE_1694"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1694 bride was of Hulland. Two Ashbourne baptisms, in 1668 and 1677, name a Mary Wagstaffe/Waggstaff of Hulland as Thomas's daughter. Because both identified local candidates have the same father, Thomas is the leading parent hypothesis for the bride. The marriage gives no father or age, and the repeated name means the precise baptism is unresolved. This relationship is plausible, not proved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_HANSS_JERG_REIFF_TO_BARBARA_REIFF_COMPARATIVE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_REIFF_HANSS_JERG_UNTERHAUSEN_1536",
      "target": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "evidence_strength": "source-free public tree names a Barbara daughter, but the alleged 1590 local marriage is not covered by the surviving marriage series",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_REIFF_HANSS_JERG_1536",
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_UNTERHAUSEN_MIXED_BOOK_1579_1618"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hanss Jerg Reiff is named as father of an undated Barbara Reiff only in a source-free public tree. The earlier rationale relied partly on a reported 1590 Unterhausen marriage of Barbara Reiff and Hans Fuchs. Archion's catalogue now shows that the surviving Unterhausen marriage series begins in 1597, so it cannot verify that alleged 1590 local event. The remaining positive evidence is the compiled tree's named daughter plus broad locality and chronology. Hanss Jerg is still a more informative named possibility than an entirely unidentified father, but another Barbara Reiff or another local relative remains much more likely than a demonstrated parent-child link. The relationship is retained at 0.15 as a circumstantial candidate only."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ALICE_ALLSOPP_TO_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_COMPARATIVE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ALICE_ALLSOPP_WIFE_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_1667",
      "target": "C_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1694",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "direct marriage plus compatible local child chronology; the adult identity remains unbridged",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGGSTAFFE_ALLSOPP_MARRIAGE_1667",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGSTAFFE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1668_1677",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_MARRIAGE_1694"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas Waggstaffe married Alice Allsopp at Ashbourne in April 1667, seventeen months before the 1668 Hulland baptism of a Mary Wagstaff to Thomas. A second local Mary of Thomas was baptised in 1677. The 1694 bride was of Hulland, so the 1667 marriage makes Alice the leading named mother hypothesis for the adult Mary, but the baptisms omit mothers and neither birth is directly joined to the bride. This edge is intentionally slightly lower than Thomas's 0.72 comparative edge."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_GOBEL_LUDWIG_1522_TO_HANSSEN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GOBEL_LUDWIG_ERPFINGEN_1522",
      "target": "I247",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.13,
      "evidence_strength": "same surname and village with plausible chronology, but no kinship statement",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALTWUERTTEMBERG_LAGERBUCH_1522_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_GOBEL_P251"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ludwig is retained as the leading named father candidate for Hans (reported birth about 1550), based on the matching surname and village. The 1522 reference is compatible with paternity but also with a grandfather or another relative; no kinship is stated. Weigel’s uncertainty note belongs to Hans’s placement in the pedigree and is not an explicit Ludwig–Hans filiation. No documented competing father has been identified. Property succession or a kinship statement would distinguish these explanations. Confidence remains 0.13, an ordinal research judgment."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_LEVY_MICHEL_MACHOLE_JACQUES_1750",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_LEVY_MICHEL_MACHOLE_FATHER_JACQUES_1725",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "published Rosenwiller cemetery-memory transcription explicitly calls Jacques/Jeckel the son of Machole (Michel); 1784 Ottrott household corroborates the adult family",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY",
        "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730",
        "SRC_GENAMI_MARMOUTIER_LEVY_FAMILIES_2004_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Rosenwiller cemetery-memory transcription for the 1806 burial calls the decedent “Jeckel, son of Macholé (Michaël).” This is positive parent-naming evidence for Michel Machole Levy and Jacques Jeckel/Jacob Levy, while an 1784 Ottrott household transcription corroborates Jacques with Bösel Macholen. It is not an inspected original image and does not establish Michel's birth, origin, spouse, or ancestry. The separately documented Marmoutier Macholé families are not merged with him."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_JOHN1335_HENRY1400",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1335_1395",
      "target": "G28_HENRY_PHYLLIPPES_1400_1480",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled medieval claim with incompatible reported chronology",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: In addition to absent medieval parent-naming evidence, the reported father's death about 1395 precedes the reported child's birth about 1400. Those dates cannot both be correct for this relationship. Retain only as a conflicting research candidate; do not invent replacement dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_HENRY1400_JOHN1422",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_HENRY_PHYLLIPPES_1400_1480",
      "target": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1422_1491",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled medieval parentage only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The user-supplied Geni line gives this relationship. No medieval record has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_JOHN1422_FRANCIS1450",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1422_1491",
      "target": "G28_FRANCIS_PHYLLIPPES_1450_1491",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled medieval parentage only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The user-supplied Geni line gives this relationship. No medieval record has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_FRANCIS1450_JOHN1472",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_FRANCIS_PHYLLIPPES_1450_1491",
      "target": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1472_1499",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled medieval parentage only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The user-supplied Geni line gives this relationship. No inspected record names both men together."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_JOHN1472_RICHARD1497",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1472_1499",
      "target": "G28_RICHARD_PHELPS_1497_1579",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "evidence_strength": "same town and compatible chronology plus compiled claim; no parent-identifying record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "Tewkesbury and the ages make this plausible, but no inspected parish, probate, land, or court record identifies Richard as John's child."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_RICHARD1497_JAMES1520",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_RICHARD_PHELPS_1497_1579",
      "target": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage only; James's own household is separately documented",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_TEWKESBURY_PHELPS_1520_1563_REVIEW",
        "SRC_CHAIN_PHELPS_BOOK_SCANS_20260915",
        "SRC_LOCAL_PHELPS_BOOK_PAGE_32_20260915",
        "SRC_LOCAL_PHELPS_BOOK_PAGE_33_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Printed p.44 of the 1899 book says Charles H. Phelps thought James and Francis were sons of Richard Phyllyppe. This establishes an early conjecture, not proof or confirmation of the specific 1497–1579 profile. Grade retained; the documented James household does not establish his father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_JAMES1520_THOMAS1563",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "target": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1563",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "published reconstruction cites Tewkesbury baptism naming Thomas as James's son",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TEWKESBURY_PHELPS_1520_1563_REVIEW",
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_SCAN_COMPARISON_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book prints the 10 Aug 1563 baptism of Thomas, son of James Phelps. Original parish-register review remains desirable.\n\n15 September 2026: Printed p.19 gives 10 October 1563 in the parchment-copy transcription, while p.71 gives 10 August 1563 in the household summary. Both identify James as father. The exact day/month is disputed and neither date is a recorded birth. Existing grade retained; original register comparison remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_THOMAS1563_THOMAS1623",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1563",
      "target": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled Geni parentage contradicted by a more coherent 1899 Tewkesbury/Limerick pedigree; no direct parent-identifying record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied Geni line makes Thomas baptised in 1563 father of the Limerick Thomas born in 1623. The 1899 Phelps book instead identifies the father as Thomas baptised 24 Jun 1590, a generation later. The 1563 route remains visible as a lower-confidence alternative because neither parentage has an inspected original record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_THOMAS1623_THOMAS1644",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "target": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1644_1667",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "unsupported transatlantic identity bridge; published pedigree raises an offspring conflict",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_ORIGIN_THEORIES_20260728",
        "SRC_CHAIN_PHELPS_BOOK_SCANS_20260915",
        "SRC_LOCAL_PHELPS_BOOK_PAGE_35_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: No inspected record identifies the reported 1644–1667 Maryland man as the Limerick Thomas's son. The 1899 split pedigree has two sons named Thomas marked O.S.P. (without issue), posing an additional conflict if either is the intended man. Their identities have not been matched to the Maryland candidate; this is not proof that every possible American connection is false."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_THOMAS1644_THOMAS1664",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1644_1667",
      "target": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1664_1758",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled Irish-to-Maryland bridge; competing early Maryland same-name evidence",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_ORIGIN_THEORIES_20260728",
        "SRC_CHAIN_PHELPS_BOOK_SCANS_20260915",
        "SRC_LOCAL_PHELPS_BOOK_PAGE_35_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is the unproven bridge from the reported Irish Thomas to the documented Baltimore household. An adult Thomas Phelps received Baltimore County land in 1669, requiring either another same-name man or revision of the compiled dates.\n\n15 September 2026: No new evidence joins these men. The secure 1723 and 1758 Baltimore father-son records establish Aventon's father, not that father's alleged Irish ancestry. Grade retained as a weak lead."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_THOMAS1664_AVENTON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1664_1758",
      "target": "G28_AVENTON_FELPS_1711_1794",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1723 Baltimore County land-record transcription twice identifies Aventon as Thomas Felps's son; 1758 will independently names him son",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_FELPS_WILL_1758_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_WILL_INDEX_THOMAS_FELPS_1758",
        "SRC_BALTIMORE_FELPS_RECORD_EXTRACTS_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "A 1723 land-record transcription says Aventon acted at the request of his father Thomas Felps and received a gift from Thomas Felps his son. The 1758 will independently calls Aventon the testator's beloved son. Both source pathways support the relationship, though the original images remain to be inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_ROSANNAH_AVENTON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_ROSANNAH_WIFE_THOMAS_FELPS",
      "target": "G28_AVENTON_FELPS_1711_1794",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "wife identified in will and compiled parent pair; will does not explicitly state Aventon's mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_FELPS_WILL_1758_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rosannah is Thomas's documented wife, but the will does not explicitly call her Aventon's mother. The maternal link remains a compiled family inference."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_AVENTON_AQUILLA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_AVENTON_FELPS_1711_1794",
      "target": "G28_AQUILLA_FELPS_1731_1788",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled father-son placement competes with sibling/collateral hypotheses; no parent-naming record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_ORIGIN_THEORIES_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_FELPS_ROWAN_RECORDS_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Same-locality records establish association, not a father-son relationship. The cited surname project discusses Aquilla as Aventon's possible brother or collateral relative. Retain this parentage only as a disputed hypothesis; no tested DNA from Matthew was used."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_RACHEL_AQUILLA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_RACHEL_MCELROY_WIFE_AVENTON",
      "target": "G28_AQUILLA_FELPS_1731_1788",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled maternal claim only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rachel's marriage to Aventon is supported; her maternity of Aquilla remains a compiled claim."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_AQUILLA_JOHN1750",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_AQUILLA_FELPS_1731_1788",
      "target": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": "unresolved same-name John identities and compiled parentage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The identity of Mary Williams's husband remains unresolved in the cited project. The proposed father Aquilla is not established by a contemporary parent-naming record. Regional appearances of men named John cannot securely assign this generation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G28_SARAH_JOHN1750",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_SARAH_JANE_SALLY_WIFE_AQUILLA",
      "target": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled maternal claim only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied Geni line identifies Sarah Jane Sally as John's mother. No independent record has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JAMES_WILLIAM1560",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "target": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury baptism transcription names William as son of James Phelps",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book prints the 4 Aug 1560 baptism of William, son of James Phelps. Original parish-register review remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_WILLIAM1560_THOMAS1590",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "target": "G29_THOMAS_PHELPS_1590",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury-register transcription places Thomas baptised 24 Jun 1590 among William's children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_SCAN_COMPARISON_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book's pp. 70-71 household list supports this father-son relationship and its 24 Jun 1590 date. Original register inspection remains desirable.\n\n15 September 2026: Printed p.20 gives 24 January 1590 in the parchment-copy transcription, while p.71 gives 24 June 1590 in the household summary. Both identify William as father. January also requires an Old Style year check against the register. No exact birth is established. Existing grade retained; original register comparison remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_DOROTHY_THOMAS1590",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "target": "G29_THOMAS_PHELPS_1590",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "evidence_strength": "Dorothy is named as William's wife in a later child's baptism; maternity of Thomas is a household inference",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_SCAN_COMPARISON_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book places Thomas baptised 24 Jun 1590 in William and Dorothy's household, but the baptism line itself does not name his mother. This maternal edge is therefore plausible rather than direct.\n\n15 September 2026: Printed p.20 gives 24 January 1590 in the parchment-copy transcription, while p.71 gives 24 June 1590 in the household summary. Both identify William as father. January also requires an Old Style year check against the register. No exact birth is established. Existing grade retained; original register comparison remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_THOMAS1590_THOMAS1623",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_THOMAS_PHELPS_1590",
      "target": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "1899 family-tree claim with an explicitly unsuccessful contemporary-to-the-research register search",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729",
        "SRC_CHAIN_PHELPS_BOOK_SCANS_20260915",
        "SRC_LOCAL_PHELPS_BOOK_PAGE_32_20260915",
        "SRC_LOCAL_PHELPS_BOOK_PAGE_33_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The 1899 caption and introductory text assert this connection, but the descendant's letter on printed p.24 reports that the Tewkesbury curate could not find the founder's birth or first marriage. A coherent pedigree is insufficient without the identity bridge. Retained as an unproved family-tradition hypothesis, not a baptism-established filiation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JAMES_GEORGE1566",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "target": "G29_GEORGE_GILES_PHELPS_1566",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury household and baptism transcription",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book prints George's 5 Sep 1566 baptism in the James and Joan household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JOAN_GEORGE1566",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JOAN_WIFE_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "target": "G29_GEORGE_GILES_PHELPS_1566",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "published household reconstruction; original baptismal maternal wording not inspected",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book places George in James and Joan Phelps's household. The original baptismal entry has not yet been checked for maternal wording."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JAMES_ALICE1572",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "target": "G29_ALICE_PHELPS_1572",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury household and baptism transcription",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book prints Alice's 24 Dec 1572 baptism in the James and Joan household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JOAN_ALICE1572",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JOAN_WIFE_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "target": "G29_ALICE_PHELPS_1572",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "published household reconstruction; original baptismal maternal wording not inspected",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book places Alice in James and Joan Phelps's household. The original baptismal entry has not yet been checked for maternal wording."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JAMES_EDWARD1578",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "target": "G29_EDWARD_PHELPS_1578",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury household and baptism transcription",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book prints Edward's 10 May 1578 baptism in the James and Joan household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JOAN_EDWARD1578",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JOAN_WIFE_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "target": "G29_EDWARD_PHELPS_1578",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "published household reconstruction; original baptismal maternal wording not inspected",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book places Edward in James and Joan Phelps's household. The original baptismal entry has not yet been checked for maternal wording."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JAMES_KENELM1580",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "target": "G29_KENELM_PHELPS_1580",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury household and qualified baptism transcription",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book prints the 16 Oct 1580 baptism as Keneline, probably Kenelm, in the James and Joan household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JOAN_KENELM1580",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JOAN_WIFE_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "target": "G29_KENELM_PHELPS_1580",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "published household reconstruction; original baptismal maternal wording not inspected",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book places Keneline, probably Kenelm, in James and Joan Phelps's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JAMES_RICHARD1583",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "target": "G29_RICHARD_PHELPS_1583",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury household and baptism transcription",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book prints Richard's 16 Oct 1583 baptism in the James and Joan household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JOAN_RICHARD1583",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JOAN_WIFE_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "target": "G29_RICHARD_PHELPS_1583",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "published household reconstruction; original baptismal maternal wording not inspected",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book places Richard in James and Joan Phelps's household. The original baptismal entry has not yet been checked for maternal wording."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JAMES_ROBERT1584",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "target": "G29_ROBERT_PHELPS_1584",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury household and baptism transcription",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book prints Robert's 18 Jul 1584 baptism in the James and Joan household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JOAN_ROBERT1584",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JOAN_WIFE_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "target": "G29_ROBERT_PHELPS_1584",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "published household reconstruction; original baptismal maternal wording not inspected",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book places Robert in James and Joan Phelps's household. The original baptismal entry has not yet been checked for maternal wording."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JAMES_NICHOLAS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "target": "G29_NICHOLAS_PHELPS_SIBLING",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_JOAN_NICHOLAS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G28_JOAN_WIFE_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "target": "G29_NICHOLAS_PHELPS_SIBLING",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.64
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_WILLIAM_MARY1587",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "target": "G29_MARY_PHELPS_1587",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury household and baptism transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book lists Mary baptised 4 Sep 1587 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_DOROTHY_MARY1587",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "target": "G29_MARY_PHELPS_1587",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "published household reconstruction; original baptismal maternal wording not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book places Mary baptised in 1587 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household. The original entry has not yet been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_WILLIAM_MARY1588",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "target": "G29_MARY_PHELPS_1588",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury household and baptism transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book lists Mary baptised 23 Apr 1588 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_DOROTHY_MARY1588",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "target": "G29_MARY_PHELPS_1588",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "published household reconstruction; original baptismal maternal wording not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book places Mary baptised in 1588 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household. The original entry has not yet been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_WILLIAM_DOROTHY1595",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "target": "G29_DOROTHY_PHELPS_1595",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury household and baptism transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book lists Dorothy baptised 29 Feb 1595 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_DOROTHY_DOROTHY1595",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "target": "G29_DOROTHY_PHELPS_1595",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "published household reconstruction; original baptismal maternal wording not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book places Dorothy baptised in 1595 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household. The original entry has not yet been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_WILLIAM_WILLIAM1599",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "target": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1599",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury household and baptism transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book lists William baptised 19 Aug 1599 as child of William and Dorothy Phelps."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_DOROTHY_WILLIAM1599",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "target": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1599",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "published household reconstruction; original baptismal maternal wording not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book places William baptised in 1599 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household. The original entry has not yet been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_WILLIAM_JAMES1601",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "target": "G29_JAMES_PHELPS_1601",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "published Tewkesbury household and baptism transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_SCAN_COMPARISON_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book lists James baptised 14 Jul 1601 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household.\n\n15 September 2026: Printed p.20 gives 14 February 1601 in the paper-copy transcription, while p.72 gives 14 July 1601 in the household summary. Both identify William as father. February requires an Old Style year check. These are conflicting baptism claims, not exact birth dates. Existing grade retained; original register comparison remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_DOROTHY_JAMES1601",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "target": "G29_JAMES_PHELPS_1601",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "published household reconstruction; original baptismal maternal wording not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_SCAN_COMPARISON_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book places James baptised in 1601 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household. The original entry has not yet been inspected.\n\n15 September 2026: Printed p.20 gives 14 February 1601 in the paper-copy transcription, while p.72 gives 14 July 1601 in the household summary. Both identify William as father. February requires an Old Style year check. These are conflicting baptism claims, not exact birth dates. Existing grade retained; original register comparison remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_WILLIAM_ELIZABETH1603",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "target": "G29_ELIZABETH_PHELPS_1603",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "published transcription identifies Elizabeth as William Phelps's daughter",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book prints Elizabeth's 9 May 1603 baptism as daughter of William Phelps and Dorothy his wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_DOROTHY_ELIZABETH1603",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "target": "G29_ELIZABETH_PHELPS_1603",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "published transcription identifies Elizabeth as Dorothy Phelps's daughter",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book prints Elizabeth's 9 May 1603 baptism as daughter of William Phelps and Dorothy his wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_WILLIAM_GEORGE1606",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "target": "G29_GEORGE_PHELPS_ABT1606",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "Unrecorded child in a superseded compiled immigrant-family reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CREWKERNE_REASSESSMENT_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book calls George, born about 1606, a son of William and Dorothy Phelps but acknowledges that his baptism is absent from the record.\n\n15 September 2026 review: The asserted George son is absent from the book's baptism transcript and belongs to the older New England family reconstruction. The book's association of the Tewkesbury family with the Windsor immigrant is undermined by later Crewkerne research. This does not identify George's actual parents; retain only as a weak uncorroborated hypothesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G29_DOROTHY_GEORGE1606",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "target": "G29_GEORGE_PHELPS_ABT1606",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "Unrecorded child in a superseded compiled immigrant-family reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CREWKERNE_REASSESSMENT_20260915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book calls George, born about 1606, a son of William and Dorothy Phelps but acknowledges that his baptism is absent from the record.\n\n15 September 2026 review: The asserted George son is absent from the book's baptism transcript and belongs to the older New England family reconstruction. The book's association of the Tewkesbury family with the Windsor immigrant is undermined by later Crewkerne research. This does not identify George's actual parents; retain only as a weak uncorroborated hypothesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ELIZA_LYSTER_JANE_LISTER_1851",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_ELIZA_LYSTER_MOTHER_JANE_1851",
      "target": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "1851 household transcript directly names Eliza Lyster as Jane's mother",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Jane, age 1 year 5 months, is explicitly identified as the daughter of Richard and Eliza Lyster in the 1851 Shrewsbury St Alkmund household. This is the leading parentage explanation because it is contemporaneous household evidence. The confidence reflects that the available record is a supplied transcript rather than an inspected census image."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_B71_JOHN_LAMB_SR_JOHN_LAMB_1757",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_B71_JOHN_LAMB_FATHER_1757",
      "target": "B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "the direct 1757 baptism names John Lamb as father; adult identity is supported by the parish and settlement sequence",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_MONTGOMERY_QS_BERRIEW_KERRY_LAMB_1790"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1757 Kerry baptism directly names a father John Lamb. It is assigned to the adult John Lamb because the later Kerry marriage, child baptism, and 1790 Kerry settlement household form the strongest chronological and geographic continuation, and no other matching Montgomeryshire baptism was found in the reviewed period. A same-name man born elsewhere remains the competing alternative."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_B71_ANN_LAMB_JOHN_LAMB_1757",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_B71_ANN_LAMB_MOTHER_1757",
      "target": "B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "the direct 1757 baptism names Ann as mother; adult identity is supported by the parish and settlement sequence",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_MONTGOMERY_QS_BERRIEW_KERRY_LAMB_1790"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1757 Kerry baptism directly names Ann as mother. It is assigned to the adult John Lamb through the same local and chronological sequence that supports his identity. Ann's maiden name and own parentage are not recorded."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G27_JOHN_MCELROY_RACHEL_1713",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G27_JOHN_MCELROY_FATHER_RACHEL_1713",
      "target": "G28_RACHEL_MCELROY_WIFE_AVENTON",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "published transcription identifies Rachel as John McElroy's daughter; 1732 and 1741 deed context supports the same Baltimore County network",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
        "SRC_LOCAL_MCELROY_DOCUMENT_IMAGE_1_20260916",
        "SRC_LOCAL_MCELROY_DOCUMENT_IMAGE_2_20260916"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published research transcribes Rachel's 7 August 1713 St George Parish birth as daughter of John and Frances McElroy. John's 1732 deed was witnessed by Aventon Felps, and the 1741 Avinton and Rachel Felps transaction involved Rachel's Delight, described as John's earlier tract. These clues favor one connected household, but the original register and deeds still need image-level verification."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_G27_FRANCES_MCELROY_RACHEL_1713",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "G27_FRANCES_MCELROY_MOTHER_RACHEL_1713",
      "target": "G28_RACHEL_MCELROY_WIFE_AVENTON",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "published transcription identifies Rachel as Frances McElroy's daughter",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
        "SRC_LOCAL_MCELROY_DOCUMENT_IMAGE_1_20260916",
        "SRC_LOCAL_MCELROY_DOCUMENT_IMAGE_2_20260916"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published research transcribes Rachel's 7 August 1713 St George Parish birth as daughter of John and Frances McElroy. Frances's identity is limited to the stated maternal name; no maiden surname, dates, or ancestry are inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ANN_GREEN_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_1813",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ANN_GREEN_WIFE_SAMUEL_MORRALL_LAWLEY",
      "target": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "community parish transcription plus locally compatible adult record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTSCHAT_SAMUEL_ANN_MORRALL_LAWLEY_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reported 1813 Wellington baptism names Ann Morrall as mother of Richard, while the direct Richard's 1837 marriage identifies his father only as Samuel. The local setting and chronology make Ann Green the most likely mother, but no original record yet bridges the baptized child to the adult direct ancestor."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_NEWLAND_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND_PARENT_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "one uncited derivative parent proposal; compatible surname form and chronology, but no documentary bridge",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEWLAND_UHLAND_MUNTZ_COMPILED_CANDIDATE_20260730",
        "SRC_NEWLAND_HOPE_PASSENGER_1734",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_JOHN_NEWLAND_ANCESTRY_UNKNOWN_REVIEW",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled proposal names this father, while John's 1739 marriage calls him Johann Ulandt. That spelling and the reported dates make the connection possible. The 1734 Hope passenger analysis supplies no parents and notes that Johan Nouland was not among the separately identified Palatine group; it leaves a non-Palatine or English origin as a live competing explanation. The edge is therefore a low-confidence comparison candidate, not a source-backed parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_NEWLAND_ANNA_CATHARINA_MUENTZ_PARENT_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_ANNA_CATHARINA_MUENTZ_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "target": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "evidence_strength": "one uncited derivative parent proposal and compatible chronology; no documentary bridge",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEWLAND_UHLAND_MUNTZ_COMPILED_CANDIDATE_20260730",
        "SRC_NEWLAND_HOPE_PASSENGER_1734",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_JOHN_NEWLAND_ANCESTRY_UNKNOWN_REVIEW",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739"
      ],
      "source_note": "The only reviewed basis is the same derivative parent proposal that names Matthäus Uhland. No record connects this woman to John or demonstrates that she lived in the reported locality. Her edge is slightly lower than the paternal candidate because the Ulandt surname offers no comparable independent clue to her identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_HANNAH_LISTER_TO_THOMAS_LISTER_BATLEY_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_HANNAH_LISTER_BATLEY_1748",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.54,
      "evidence_strength": "a direct 1773 baptismal mother name, a sibling-witness clue, close regional chronology, and no identity-specific bridge to the 1799 groom",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_BATLEY_BAPTISM_1773",
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_HANNAH_FAMILY_RECONSTRUCTION_20260730",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Batley baptism proves that Hannah had a son Thomas, born in 1772 and baptised in 1773. The same parish reconstruction records Thomas as a witness at sister Sarah's 1795 Batley marriage. A man of the right age then married Ann Marshall in nearby South Kirkby in 1799 and formed the documented Pontefract family. The competing explanation is that the 1799 groom was a different Thomas Lister; the marriage index gives no age, residence, occupation, father, or witness to resolve the choice. The Batley identity is presently the stronger named hypothesis, but remains a 0.54 candidate rather than a proved connection."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_GEORGE_LISTER_TO_HANNAH_LISTER_BATLEY_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_GEORGE_LISTER_BATLEY_1705",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_HANNAH_LISTER_BATLEY_1748",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.83,
      "evidence_strength": "specific secondary transcription of a Batley baptismal family, said to derive from parish microfiches",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_HANNAH_FAMILY_RECONSTRUCTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published Batley reconstruction reports Hannah's 1747/48 baptism as daughter of George Lister and Grace Hudson. This is a strong within-family transcription claim, but the parish image has not been inspected in this audit. It is conditional on the still-unresolved identity of the adult Thomas Lister."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_GRACE_HUDSON_TO_HANNAH_LISTER_BATLEY_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_GRACE_HUDSON_WIFE_GEORGE_LISTER",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_HANNAH_LISTER_BATLEY_1748",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.83,
      "evidence_strength": "specific secondary transcription of a Batley baptismal family, said to derive from parish microfiches",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_HANNAH_FAMILY_RECONSTRUCTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published Batley reconstruction reports Hannah's 1747/48 baptism as daughter of George Lister and Grace Hudson. This is a strong within-family transcription claim, but the parish image has not been inspected in this audit. It is conditional on the still-unresolved identity of the adult Thomas Lister."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_WILLIAM_LISTER_TO_GEORGE_LISTER_BATLEY_1705",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_WILLIAM_LISTER_BATLEY_1671",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_GEORGE_LISTER_BATLEY_1705",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "specific secondary reconstruction citing a named Batley baptism and a matching 1701-1707 sibling cluster",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_WILLIAM_GEORGE_BAPTISMS_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reconstruction reports George Lister's 30 June 1705 Batley baptism as son of William Lister, and separately reports a William Lister born 1671 with children Maria (1701), George (1705), and William (1707). A different same-name William remains possible, but the locality and sibling cluster make this identification more likely. No original register image has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_JOHN_LISTER_TO_WILLIAM_LISTER_BATLEY_1671",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_JOHN_LISTER_BATLEY_MARRIED_1670",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_WILLIAM_LISTER_BATLEY_1671",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "specific secondary transcription of William’s dated baptism, parents’ dated marriage, and sibling baptisms",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_JOHN_JANE_WILLIAM_1670_1676_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reconstruction reports William’s 25 June 1671 Batley baptism as son of John Lister and Jane Tingle, with matching siblings baptised in 1673 and 1675/76. A transcription error or same-name family remains possible, but no competing local family has been identified and the chronology is coherent. The original register image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_JANE_TINGLE_TO_WILLIAM_LISTER_BATLEY_1671",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_JANE_TINGLE_BATLEY_1638",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_WILLIAM_LISTER_BATLEY_1671",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "specific secondary transcription of William’s dated baptism, parents’ dated marriage, and sibling baptisms",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_JOHN_JANE_WILLIAM_1670_1676_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reconstruction reports William’s 25 June 1671 Batley baptism as son of John Lister and Jane Tingle, with matching siblings baptised in 1673 and 1675/76. A transcription error or same-name family remains possible, but no competing local family has been identified and the chronology is coherent. The original register image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ALVEREY_TINGLE_TO_JANE_TINGLE_BATLEY_1638",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_ALVEREY_TINGLE_BATLEY_1666",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_JANE_TINGLE_BATLEY_1638",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "single detailed local reconstruction supplies the parent-child assertion; corroborating original image not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_ALVEREY_TINGLE_HEARTH_AND_CHILD_CLUSTER_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reconstruction identifies Jane as Alverey’s daughter and places two other children in the same Batley group. The competing explanation is an unsupported or mistaken compiled parentage; no independently indexed baptism naming Alverey has been located. Alverey’s 1666 tax appearance supports his local existence, not Jane’s maternity or paternity by itself."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_WILLIAM_PICKIN_WHITMORE_TO_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_FORTON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_WILLIAM_PICKIN_WHITMORE_1756",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "exact-name 1756 baptism in nearby Staffordshire is age-compatible with the 1777 Forton bride, but no identity bridge names her parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Whitmore baptism names William as father of Elizabeth Pickin. An Elizabeth of that age could be the Forton bride of 1777, and no stronger candidate has been located. The Forton marriage gives no age, residence, or parents, so another Elizabeth Pickin remains a substantial alternative; this link stays low confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_SARAH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_TO_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_FORTON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_SARAH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_1756",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "exact-name 1756 baptism in nearby Staffordshire is age-compatible with the 1777 Forton bride, but no identity bridge names her parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Whitmore baptism names Sarah as mother of Elizabeth Pickin. An Elizabeth of that age could be the Forton bride of 1777, and no stronger candidate has been located. The Forton marriage gives no age, residence, or parents, so another Elizabeth Pickin remains a substantial alternative; this link stays low confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_DAVID_PRICE_TO_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_DAVID_PRICE_FATHER_KEZIA_LISTER",
      "target": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "evidence_strength": "one compiled tree names David Price as Kezia Price's father; no original record inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE"
      ],
      "source_note": "David Price is the leading named father hypothesis for Kezia because the supplied Gamble tree states it. The competing explanation is that the tree copied or conflated Kezia's family. No birth, baptism, marriage, census, probate, or other document yet identifies David as her father, so the link remains 42% confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ELIZABETH_LAMBE_TO_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_ELIZABETH_LAMBE_MOTHER_KEZIA_LISTER",
      "target": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "evidence_strength": "one compiled tree names Elizabeth Lambe as Kezia Price's mother; no original record inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth Lambe is the leading named mother hypothesis for Kezia because the supplied Gamble tree states it. The competing explanation is that the tree copied or conflated Kezia's family. No birth, baptism, marriage, census, probate, or other document yet identifies Elizabeth as her mother, so the link remains 42% confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_CANDIDATE_ARCHIBALD_MCELROY_TO_JOHN_1690",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_ARCHIBALD_MCELROY_PARENT_JOHN_1690",
      "target": "G27_JOHN_MCELROY_FATHER_RACHEL_1713",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "evidence_strength": "one internally inconsistent compiled tree names Archibald as John McElroy's father; no parent-identifying record located",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_COMPILED_PEDIGREE_CONFLICT_20260730",
        "SRC_OT26_MCELROY_PATRICK_COMPILED"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: Archibald was John McElroy's father. A compatible compiled claim preserves this candidate, with no inspected record identifying the parent. H2: the father was Patrick MacElroy, as named in another compiled pedigree; whether this is a different man, alternate name, or pedigree conflation is unresolved. A merged Archibald Patrick name elsewhere does not resolve the identity. Neither name claim independently establishes Irish origins. The later Archibald will names brother William but does not identify their father. Keep the parent link candidate_compiled at ordinal score 0.12; hypothetical namesakes and access failures are not negative evidence. Next discriminator: contemporary record identifying John's parent, plus tracing the underlying citations for both name claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_CANDIDATE_RACHEL_DURHAM_TO_JOHN_1690",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_RACHEL_DURHAM_MOTHER_JOHN_1690",
      "target": "G27_JOHN_MCELROY_FATHER_RACHEL_1713",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "evidence_strength": "one internally inconsistent compiled tree names Rachel Durham as John McElroy's mother; no parent-identifying record located",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_COMPILED_PEDIGREE_CONFLICT_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rachel Durham is the only named mother hypothesis located for John McElroy. The source gives no record linking her to John and is internally inconsistent about related people's dates and identities. The link is therefore an ordinal confidence score of 0.12 and does not validate the broader Durham or Irish pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_THOMAS_SHAW_TO_RALPH_COMPILED_20260730",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_THOMAS_SHAW_PARENT_RALPH_1628",
      "target": "HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "single uncited derivative family-history claim with anachronistic geography",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book gives Thomas Shaw as Ralph’s father, but supplies no documentary bridge. Ralph’s documented adult presence in Charles County begins in 1672; neither that record nor later Maryland land material names a parent or English origin. The claimant’s use of Prince George’s County for a 1645 birth is anachronistic. This remains a 10% named lead, while the larger probability is unassigned rather than falsely attributed to a specific alternative parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_CANDIDATE_BENJAMIN_HODNETT_TO_GEORGE_ODNETT_20260730",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_BENJAMIN_HODNETT_PARENT_GEORGE_ODNETT_1787",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_ODNETT_CLAIMED_FATHER_SARAH_POYNER",
      "status": "candidate_identity",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "the exact candidate George Hodnett was baptised to Benjamin and Martha in 1787; the bridge from that George to Sarah's named father is circumstantial",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_DIDDLEBURY_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_ANN_MOUND_LUDLOW_MARRIAGE_1804"
      ],
      "source_note": "A 1787 Diddlebury baptism names Benjamin Hodnett as father of George Hodnett. This is carried to George Odnett only as a 40% identity hypothesis. The candidate's age, surname and local trajectory fit Sarah Poyner's later statement, but the 1811 baptism names only Mary Poyner and the candidate George had married another woman in 1804."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_CANDIDATE_MARTHA_HODNETT_TO_GEORGE_ODNETT_20260730",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_MARTHA_HODNETT_MOTHER_GEORGE_ODNETT_1787",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_ODNETT_CLAIMED_FATHER_SARAH_POYNER",
      "status": "candidate_identity",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "the exact candidate George Hodnett was baptised to Benjamin and Martha in 1787; the bridge from that George to Sarah's named father is circumstantial",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_DIDDLEBURY_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_ANN_MOUND_LUDLOW_MARRIAGE_1804"
      ],
      "source_note": "A 1787 Diddlebury baptism names Martha Hodnett as mother of George Hodnett. This is carried to George Odnett only as a 40% identity hypothesis. The candidate's age, surname and local trajectory fit Sarah Poyner's later statement, but the 1811 baptism names only Mary Poyner and the candidate George had married another woman in 1804."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ABRAHAM_TO_ROSALIA_MAYER_1808_20260730",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ABRAHAM_FATHER_ROSALIA_MAYER_1777",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "the 1808 patronymic form Roesel b Abraham directly identifies a father's given name, though not his complete identity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1808 list directly supports Abraham as Rosalia's father by its patronymic naming convention. The relationship is highly reliable as a name-only connection, but it does not establish which Abraham he was or supply a surname, dates, or another family relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ATHEY_JOHN_TO_THOMAS1717_20260730",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ATHEY_JOHN_FATHER_THOMAS1717_20260730",
      "target": "HV4_THOMAS_ATHEY_14_FEB_1717_AFTER_1766",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "focused published reconstruction; 1932 history reports John's inventory naming son Thomas",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_PARENTAGE_RECONCILIATION_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1932_JOHN_INVENTORY_PARENTAGE_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The focused Athey reconstruction identifies Thomas born 14 February 1717, husband of Judith and Elinor Queen and father of John Queen Athey, as John's son. The 1932 Athey history independently reports John's 1729/30 inventory naming Thomas as a son. This is a strong secondary-source placement, pending inspection of the original inventory and parish material."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ATHEY_MARGARET_TO_THOMAS1717_20260730",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ATHEY_MARGARET_LEWIS_MOTHER_THOMAS1717_20260730",
      "target": "HV4_THOMAS_ATHEY_14_FEB_1717_AFTER_1766",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "focused published reconstruction plus the reported 1711 John-Margaret marriage and surviving-wife inventory",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_PARENTAGE_RECONCILIATION_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1932_JOHN_INVENTORY_PARENTAGE_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The focused reconstruction identifies Margaret as Thomas's mother. The 1711 marriage and 1729/30 inventory make the maternal assignment chronologically and household-consistent, but the inventory summary does not state maternity in its quoted wording; confidence is therefore slightly lower than the paternal edge."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ATHEY_CAPT_GEORGE_TO_JOHN_20260730",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ATHEY_CAPTAIN_GEORGE_1642_1710_20260730",
      "target": "C_ATHEY_JOHN_FATHER_THOMAS1717_20260730",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "published account of the 1710 estate inventory identifying John as Captain George's son",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1932_JOHN_INVENTORY_PARENTAGE_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1999 Athey study reports that Captain George Athey's estate inventory was attested on 21 December 1710 by his wife Sarah and son John; its lineage section identifies this John as the later husband of Margaret Lewis. The earlier 1932 history also reports Prince George's County material for the same household. This is a strong published transcription of a primary probate record, although the original inventory image has not yet been inspected independently."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ATHEY_ANN_TO_JOHN_20260730",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ATHEY_ANN_FIRST_WIFE_GEORGE_20260730",
      "target": "C_ATHEY_JOHN_FATHER_THOMAS1717_20260730",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "published Athey household reconstruction identifies John as George and Ann's first son",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The study places John in Captain George Athey's first household with Ann. It names Ann but gives no surviving maiden name or direct baptismal record for John, so this maternal edge remains lower-confidence than the estate-supported paternal edge."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_TO_CAPT_GEORGE_20260730",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_1612_1666_20260730",
      "target": "C_ATHEY_CAPTAIN_GEORGE_1642_1710_20260730",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "specialised Athey reconstruction plus independently corroborated Francis Athy in the right city and period; no direct trans-Atlantic parent-child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_IDENTIFICATION_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hypothesis: Captain George Athy, documented in Maryland from the 1660s, was the George born in Galway in 1642 to Francis Athy. It is supported by the focused Athey history's coherent sibling, age, and migration narrative, while Francis himself is independently corroborated as Galway's 1639 sheriff. Competing hypothesis: George's father and European origin are unknown, because the Maryland records do not name Francis and no contemporary baptism or passenger record has been found. The positive, specific reconstruction is more informative than an unsupported unknown parent, but the absence of a direct bridge keeps confidence low."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_1ccd27f93e855c15",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I237",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_MARLOW_ABOUT_1667",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_b48cdbee0869aeb7",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I236",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_MARLOW_ABOUT_1667",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_0106ae0299cb8dfd",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I237",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_MARLOW_ABOUT_1676",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_94a823cc35ba2e05",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I236",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_MARLOW_ABOUT_1676",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_8fbb05e9486b5e69",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I237",
      "target": "HV4_BARTHOLOMEW_MARLOW_ABOUT_1680",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_ebea3b20ef3bfc19",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I236",
      "target": "HV4_BARTHOLOMEW_MARLOW_ABOUT_1680",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_511cca45cb56d473",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I237",
      "target": "HV4_ANNE_MARLOW_ABOUT_1681",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_19"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_c36c0fb11364941a",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I236",
      "target": "HV4_ANNE_MARLOW_ABOUT_1681",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_19"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_1589b7f8ae9e8f74",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I237",
      "target": "HV4_SUSANNAH_MARLOW_1678",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_3"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_b90557483a7618bf",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I236",
      "target": "HV4_SUSANNAH_MARLOW_1678",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_3"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_e2dd37b5a0b4b800",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I237",
      "target": "HV4_WILLIAM_MARLOW_1668_10_MAY_1668",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names William Marlow as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_b63907a30cd43097",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I236",
      "target": "HV4_WILLIAM_MARLOW_1668_10_MAY_1668",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual profile explicitly names Elizabeth (no maiden surname supplied) as parent. Replaces a demonstrably mistaken import as child of Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw. The historical parentage remains provisional because only a compiled pedigree has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_0cdfe82e86d9faf7",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_QUEEN",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_2091f78a1c77fdf9",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_QUEEN",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_059ff1cdfb6c5be4",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "HV4_SARAH_QUEEN_ABOUT_1741",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_22"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_f028278d6b5a052d",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "target": "HV4_SARAH_QUEEN_ABOUT_1741",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_22"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_6917ae73542e40c5",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "HV4_MARGARET_QUEEN_ABOUT_1746",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_10"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_4877d811e4438e6d",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "target": "HV4_MARGARET_QUEEN_ABOUT_1746",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_10"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_b0635b1b112364d4",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "HV4_ANNE_QUEEN_ABOUT_1792",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_23"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_c7584b2d16667cf2",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "target": "HV4_ANNE_QUEEN_ABOUT_1792",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_23"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_5b792617834e6bf4",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "HV4_ELIZABETH_QUEEN_BEFORE_1745",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_11"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_2f205899905d799e",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "target": "HV4_ELIZABETH_QUEEN_BEFORE_1745",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_11"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_a7483b06cfdea522",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "HV4_SAMUEL_QUEEN_ABOUT_1735",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_e3b4f23d01ae5601",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "target": "HV4_SAMUEL_QUEEN_ABOUT_1735",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_b6a1435e60538b48",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "HV4_LEONARD_QUEEN_ABOUT_1732",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_d91f697d3d2ba88b",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "target": "HV4_LEONARD_QUEEN_ABOUT_1732",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_63a48aeb09f639ef",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "HV4_CLEMENTINE_QUEEN_ABOUT_1738",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The dictionary has a likely matching sister but OCR is corrupt; the Bowling study also identifies Clementine in the sisters' probate network. Original images remain to be checked.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_12"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The dictionary has a likely matching sister but OCR is corrupt; the Bowling study also identifies Clementine in the sisters' probate network. Original images remain to be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_692d3bafef3b4c93",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "target": "HV4_CLEMENTINE_QUEEN_ABOUT_1738",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_12"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_07f708c05f1b6d9a",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "HV4_WILLIAM_QUEEN_1726",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_8"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_912156ef333b589d",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "target": "HV4_WILLIAM_QUEEN_1726",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_8"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_caf410fca66055f3",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "HV4_RICHARD_QUEEN_1725",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_7"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: The individual compiled profile names Marsham Queen as father. The Maryland legislature biographical dictionary independently identifies this member of Anne Queen's sibling group."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_4cfce3706140d178",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "target": "HV4_RICHARD_QUEEN_1725",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_7"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Explicit compiled household supplies Mary Jameson as mother. The scholarly Semmes biography does not identify the mother; maternity therefore remains separately provisional."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_ca9acab79dd1ce0e",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "R26_CATHERINE_QUEEN_BOWLING",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_1684ae5f3ec05991",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "target": "R26_FRANCIS_QUEEN",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_75b46b23f5a4bbb5",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "R26_MARY_JAMESON_SR_D1755",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_944630dd22a80f2f",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "R26_MARY_JAMESON_SR_D1755",
      "target": "R26_THOMAS_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.95
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_fabbccdcad0adaea",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "R26_MARY_JAMESON_SR_D1755",
      "target": "R26_JOSEPH_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.95
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_cc3a363c3b8a2414",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "R26_MARY_JAMESON_SR_D1755",
      "target": "R26_BENJAMIN_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.95
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_c85318b2d081450b",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "R26_MARY_JAMESON_SR_D1755",
      "target": "R26_ELIZABETH_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.95
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_87c638548f7f08d2",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "R26_MARY_JAMESON_SR_D1755",
      "target": "R26_MARTHA_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.95
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_20260915_459f3b0576024edd",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "R26_MARY_JAMESON_SR_D1755",
      "target": "R26_ANN_CHILD_MARY_JAMESON_SR",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.95
    },
    {
      "id": "R26_CHAIN_EDA_CAUNTIS_TO_SARAH_PHELPS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "target": "I81",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820"
      ],
      "source_note": "15 September 2026: Added the missing maternal connection. Brock 1888 p.725 explicitly names Eda as Sarah's mother. The existing Eda Cauntis profile is Martin Phelps's 1820 bride; name, spouse and locality identify the same household. No new person was needed."
    },
    {
      "id": "GB26_PE_I241_HJ1689",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I241",
      "target": "GB26_HANS_JACOB_GOEBEL_1689",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit Ahnentafel parent placement with parish family reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel #322 Hans Jacob born 1689 has parents #644 Johannes and #645 Ursula. H1 these are his parents strongly outranks an erroneous-numbering hypothesis given coherent dates and reconstructed household. Original baptism is the next verification."
    },
    {
      "id": "GB26_PE_HV5_URSULA_BATZER_HJ1689",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "target": "GB26_HANS_JACOB_GOEBEL_1689",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit Ahnentafel parent placement with parish family reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel #322 Hans Jacob born 1689 has parents #644 Johannes and #645 Ursula. H1 these are his parents strongly outranks an erroneous-numbering hypothesis given coherent dates and reconstructed household. Original baptism is the next verification."
    },
    {
      "id": "BR26_JAMES_SILVESTER_TO_JANE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "BR26_JAMES_SILVESTER_RANTON_TESTATOR",
      "target": "GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "status": "probable_parentage",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "marriage surname and independently abstracted son-in-law relationship",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_JANE_SILVESTER_MARRIAGE_1761",
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 James fathered Jane Silvester, wife of John Brassington. H2 the son-in-law was another John, related through a different wife, or a stepson. Stafford marriage names Jane Silvester and matches the Ranton child chronology; the Ranton testator names John as son-in-law. Combined local family evidence favors H1 without needing an undocumented duplicate couple. The abstract does not name Jane as daughter, so .88 is an ordinal probable-parent assessment. Original will and marriage licence would discriminate."
    },
    {
      "id": "BR26_GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196_JOSEPH1781",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "target": "BR26_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_1781",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "baptismal household reconstruction corroborated by father’s probate child list",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 this is the 1781 son of elder John and Jane. H2 confusion with the 1787 John/Margaret child. Distinct dates and named parental couples favor separate people. The original baptism and will would verify the reconstruction."
    },
    {
      "id": "BR26_GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196_JOSEPH1781",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "target": "BR26_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_1781",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "baptismal household reconstruction corroborated by father’s probate child list",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 this is the 1781 son of elder John and Jane. H2 confusion with the 1787 John/Margaret child. Distinct dates and named parental couples favor separate people. The original baptism and will would verify the reconstruction."
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_PE_OT26_PETER_GUISE_ROCKINGHAM_SARAH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "OT26_PETER_GUISE_ROCKINGHAM",
      "target": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit compiled parent claim with compatible regional context; no kinship bridge in pension transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_GOBLE_GUISE_PARENTS",
        "SRC_OT26_GUICE_W4686"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: Sarah Gise, wife of Christian Gobble, is a daughter of Peter Guise and Ottilia. H2: the association genealogy attached Sarah to a different Guise family (hypothetical error; no named competing Sarah with the same spouse found). The explicit daughter/spouse placement is positive evidence. John Guice W4686 independently supplies compatible Frederick Maryland–Rockingham Virginia–Georgia family movement, but does not identify Sarah or name his parents, so it is contextual rather than independent parentage evidence. H1 is the leading named parent hypothesis, provisionally retained at ordinal 0.55 for each parent; this is not a calibrated probability. Same-site family pages and later trees may be dependent. Do not infer from an absent sister in an incomplete child list that she was not a sibling. Next discriminator: Peter’s estate or a church/land record naming Sarah as daughter or Gobble as son-in-law; compare John Guice and Christian Gobble complete pension files and Frederick church registers. No older German/French parentage adopted. FamilySearch LVQ7-GQG assigns French Gaseau/Forest parents to a Palatine birthplace without an exposed bridge; Ancestry’s Kuffer mother reconstruction assigns a 1722-born mother to a 1730-born daughter, an actual chronology conflict. Those extensions require separate testing."
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_PE_OT26_OTTILIA_GUISE_SARAH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "OT26_OTTILIA_GUISE",
      "target": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit compiled parent claim with compatible regional context; no kinship bridge in pension transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_GOBLE_GUISE_PARENTS",
        "SRC_OT26_GUICE_W4686"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: Sarah Gise, wife of Christian Gobble, is a daughter of Peter Guise and Ottilia. H2: the association genealogy attached Sarah to a different Guise family (hypothetical error; no named competing Sarah with the same spouse found). The explicit daughter/spouse placement is positive evidence. John Guice W4686 independently supplies compatible Frederick Maryland–Rockingham Virginia–Georgia family movement, but does not identify Sarah or name his parents, so it is contextual rather than independent parentage evidence. H1 is the leading named parent hypothesis, provisionally retained at ordinal 0.55 for each parent; this is not a calibrated probability. Same-site family pages and later trees may be dependent. Do not infer from an absent sister in an incomplete child list that she was not a sibling. Next discriminator: Peter’s estate or a church/land record naming Sarah as daughter or Gobble as son-in-law; compare John Guice and Christian Gobble complete pension files and Frederick church registers. No older German/French parentage adopted. FamilySearch LVQ7-GQG assigns French Gaseau/Forest parents to a Palatine birthplace without an exposed bridge; Ancestry’s Kuffer mother reconstruction assigns a 1722-born mother to a 1730-born daughter, an actual chronology conflict. Those extensions require separate testing."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_OT26_BRYAN_MCDONNEL_TO_VIRGINIA_BRYAN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "OT26_BRYAN_MCDONNEL_NEWCASTLE_1707",
      "target": "HV4_BRYAN_MCDONALD_NOV_1686_21_MAY_1757",
      "status": "probable_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit Delaware father/son with matching spouse and migration reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_MCDONNEL_CALENDAR_1707",
        "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_FRANK_1879",
        "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_CHALKLEY_1757"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: Delaware son Bryan, married to Catherine and disposing of inherited land in February 1746/47, is the Virginia Bryan married to Catherine. Explicit father/son deed recital and 1707 will, paired names, chronology and family-history migration favor H1. Hypothetical different Bryan/Catherine or later relative not observed competitors. Original Q:221 residence/marks and Virginia acquisition comparison remain best tests; confidence is ordinal, not probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_OT26_JOHANN_MICHAEL_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "OT26_JOHANN_MICHAEL_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "target": "HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "Specific Goshenhoppen parent statement and matching spouse/household favor link; shared-source dependence retained",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_GEORGE",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 named parent of the specific Goshenhoppen child leads over hypothetical attachment/copying error; no actual competing household identified. Original manuscript not inspected. Vital dates and immigrant identifications remain separate. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_OT26_ANNA_MARIA_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "OT26_ANNA_MARIA_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "target": "HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "Specific Goshenhoppen parent statement and matching spouse/household favor link; shared-source dependence retained",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_GEORGE",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 named parent of the specific Goshenhoppen child leads over hypothetical attachment/copying error; no actual competing household identified. Original manuscript not inspected. Vital dates and immigrant identifications remain separate. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_OT26_ABRAHAM_DITLOH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "OT26_ABRAHAM_DITLOH",
      "target": "HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "Specific Goshenhoppen parent statement and matching spouse/household favor link; shared-source dependence retained",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 named parent of the specific Goshenhoppen child leads over hypothetical attachment/copying error; no actual competing household identified. Original manuscript not inspected. Vital dates and immigrant identifications remain separate. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_OT26_ANNA_MARGARETH_DITLOH_WIFE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "OT26_ANNA_MARGARETH_DITLOH_WIFE",
      "target": "HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "Specific Goshenhoppen parent statement and matching spouse/household favor link; shared-source dependence retained",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 named parent of the specific Goshenhoppen child leads over hypothetical attachment/copying error; no actual competing household identified. Original manuscript not inspected. Vital dates and immigrant identifications remain separate. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_OT26_MICHAEL_WEIGELE_TO_CATHRINE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "OT26_JOHANN_MICHAEL_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "target": "OT26_CATHRINE_WEGLER_ZIPPERLE",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.88
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_OT26_WILLIAM_FYNNEY_ALTON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "OT26_WILLIAM_FYNNEY_ALTON",
      "target": "I146",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "baptism names parents; name, exact Alton birthplace and earlier census ages support child-to-adult identity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_HELEN_FYNNEY_ALTON_1803",
        "SRC_OT26_WATERHOUSE_1861_ALTON_BIRTHPLACE",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: Ellen/Helen Finney Waterhouse is Helen Fynney baptized at Alton on 10 April 1803, daughter of William and Hellen. H2: she is Helen Finney baptized at Fulford on 2 May 1810, daughter of John and Elizabeth. H3: another Ellen/Helen Finney born at Alton whose baptism is not yet found. New discriminating evidence: the successfully retrieved FreeCEN 1861 household explicitly gives Helen's birthplace as Alton. Husband Jonas/John born Ashbourne, children Eugeina/Emma, Henry, Herbert and Elizabeth born Hanford, and grandson George Read match the already established household. This is the same 1861 census as Matthew's earlier transcript, supplying a previously omitted field rather than an independent census. H1 explains the combined Ellen/Helen and Finney/Fynney name, exact birth parish, approximate1803 age from1851, and compatible rounded1841 age without inventing another local namesake. H2 can reconcile an1810 baptism with an earlier birth if delayed, but requires an additional Alton-birth/Fulford-baptism explanation; neither delay nor that movement is documented. H3 is possible but hypothetical, not observed evidence against H1. An actual competing1838Ellen Finney bride at Wolstanton has father Joseph, not William or John, and thus does not identify either baptism child under the ordinary same-father reading. Do not claim this rules out all alternative later lives for the children. Material tension: Helen's age52 in1861 implies1808/9, six years later than the1851 age48 implication. The husband's supplied ages also change48 to52 across those censuses, making household age error or transcription error plausible, not proved. The1803 structured estimate derives from1851 and is not independent birth evidence. Ranking: H1 is the supported best explanation, stronger than H2 or an otherwise unrecorded Alton namesake. Add William Fynney and Hellen (maiden surname unknown) as probable parents with ordinal confidence0.80; these numbers are research judgments, not statistical probabilities. No claim of direct adult parent-naming proof. Their existence and explicit parentage of the baptism child are documented by the transcription; the remaining uncertainty is the child-to-adult identity. No speculative birth/death dates or maiden surname assigned to either parent; no marriage event asserted from the baptism alone. Next tests: original1803 baptism and1861 image, adult1851 birthplace,1827marriage witnesses, and local records following William/Hellen's other children. FreeREG Helen Soundex Staffordshire marriages1810-1840 and burials1803-1827 returned no hits; Ellen Soundex marriage found the Joseph-daughter bride. These searches have incomplete/unchecked coverage and are not negative evidence. FreeCEN1851 exact Ellen search returned no result, not evidence of absence. This reassessment supersedes RN_OT26_FINNEY_ALTON_VS_FULFORD's earlier no-parent conclusion because the new exact Alton birthplace changes the comparison."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_OT26_HELLEN_MOTHER_HELEN_FYNNEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "OT26_HELLEN_MOTHER_HELEN_FYNNEY",
      "target": "I146",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "baptism names parents; name, exact Alton birthplace and earlier census ages support child-to-adult identity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_HELEN_FYNNEY_ALTON_1803",
        "SRC_OT26_WATERHOUSE_1861_ALTON_BIRTHPLACE",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: Ellen/Helen Finney Waterhouse is Helen Fynney baptized at Alton on 10 April 1803, daughter of William and Hellen. H2: she is Helen Finney baptized at Fulford on 2 May 1810, daughter of John and Elizabeth. H3: another Ellen/Helen Finney born at Alton whose baptism is not yet found. New discriminating evidence: the successfully retrieved FreeCEN 1861 household explicitly gives Helen's birthplace as Alton. Husband Jonas/John born Ashbourne, children Eugeina/Emma, Henry, Herbert and Elizabeth born Hanford, and grandson George Read match the already established household. This is the same 1861 census as Matthew's earlier transcript, supplying a previously omitted field rather than an independent census. H1 explains the combined Ellen/Helen and Finney/Fynney name, exact birth parish, approximate1803 age from1851, and compatible rounded1841 age without inventing another local namesake. H2 can reconcile an1810 baptism with an earlier birth if delayed, but requires an additional Alton-birth/Fulford-baptism explanation; neither delay nor that movement is documented. H3 is possible but hypothetical, not observed evidence against H1. An actual competing1838Ellen Finney bride at Wolstanton has father Joseph, not William or John, and thus does not identify either baptism child under the ordinary same-father reading. Do not claim this rules out all alternative later lives for the children. Material tension: Helen's age52 in1861 implies1808/9, six years later than the1851 age48 implication. The husband's supplied ages also change48 to52 across those censuses, making household age error or transcription error plausible, not proved. The1803 structured estimate derives from1851 and is not independent birth evidence. Ranking: H1 is the supported best explanation, stronger than H2 or an otherwise unrecorded Alton namesake. Add William Fynney and Hellen (maiden surname unknown) as probable parents with ordinal confidence0.80; these numbers are research judgments, not statistical probabilities. No claim of direct adult parent-naming proof. Their existence and explicit parentage of the baptism child are documented by the transcription; the remaining uncertainty is the child-to-adult identity. No speculative birth/death dates or maiden surname assigned to either parent; no marriage event asserted from the baptism alone. Next tests: original1803 baptism and1861 image, adult1851 birthplace,1827marriage witnesses, and local records following William/Hellen's other children. FreeREG Helen Soundex Staffordshire marriages1810-1840 and burials1803-1827 returned no hits; Ellen Soundex marriage found the Joseph-daughter bride. These searches have incomplete/unchecked coverage and are not negative evidence. FreeCEN1851 exact Ellen search returned no result, not evidence of absence. This reassessment supersedes RN_OT26_FINNEY_ALTON_VS_FULFORD's earlier no-parent conclusion because the new exact Alton birthplace changes the comparison."
    },
    {
      "id": "PCE_OT26_ROBERT_BUTT_TO_THOMAS_BURGESS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "target": "OT26_THOMAS_BUTT_BURGESS",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.94
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_WILLIAM_FENTON_HANNA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FENTON_FATHER_HANNA_1674",
      "target": "SRC_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "published baptism transcription identifies father; daughter matches existing exact date and parish",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
        "SRC_ROOTS_STIRNET_FENTON_HANDLEY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism names William. Identifying the baptized child with Hanna in this tree is strongly supported by the exact name, date and parish match. Her later Handley family identification still needs direct record confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_HENRY_AUSTEN_MARY_ASTEN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_HENRY_AUSTEN_FATHER_MARIE_1646",
      "target": "C_MARY_ASTEN_WIFE_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_1684",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_THOMAS_BAGNOLD_ISABEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_BAGNOLD_FATHER_ISABEL_1601",
      "target": "C_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_1601_WIFE_THOMAS_EMERYE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "father named in daughter’s matching baptism extract",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_TRENTHAM_BAPTISM_1601"
      ],
      "source_note": "The saved parish extract explicitly identifies Isabel as daughter of Thomas Bagnold. Matching baptism date, name andparish favor this father link over an unrelatedThomas or copied-profile conflation. An error in the extract or identification remains possible; the original register image has not been examined. The separate hypothesis that the 1601 child became the 1632 Emerye bride is supported by same name andparish at a compatible age, but no age orfather is supplied in the marriage extract. Scores are ordinal research judgments."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_MARJORIE_WILLATT_ISABEL",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MARJORIE_WILLATT_CANDIDATE_ISABEL",
      "target": "C_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_1601_WIFE_THOMAS_EMERYE",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": "exact-match daughter profile supports intended household; maternal evidence is compiled and potentially conflated",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_ATWOOD_MARJORIE_WILLATT_DETAIL",
        "SRC_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_TRENTHAM_BAPTISM_1601"
      ],
      "source_note": "Marjorie Willatt is the leading named mother candidate in the material reviewed. The compiled Isabell Bagnold entry matches the saved Trentham baptism and Emerye marriage by exact dates and names, and explicitly assigns Marjorie as mother. The reported 1589 marriage would precede the 1601 baptism by a compatible interval. These matches support identifying the intended household. However, the same compilation includes another Isabell assigned to Brassington, with conflicting life events; the maternal assignment could be part of that conflated reconstruction. The saved baptism names only father Thomas. Marjorie’s maternity therefore remains low confidence at 0.35. This is an ordinal estimate, not a calibrated probability. A record of Thomas’s marriage and evidence allocating Isabel to that union could change the ranking. Neither an unrecorded alternative mother nor absent direct proof alone is treated as a contradiction."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_BERNHARD_ZIPPERLE_FRIEDRICH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_BERNHARD_ZIPPERLE_FATHER_FRIEDRICH",
      "target": "OT26_FRIEDRICH_ZIPPERLE_RHINEBECK",
      "status": "supported_documentary",
      "confidence": 0.94
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_MICHAEL_WAEGELIN_IMMIGRANT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MICHAEL_WAEGELIN_BONFELD_1700",
      "target": "OT26_JOHANN_MICHAEL_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "Leading named father candidate from Jones’s Bonfeld reconstruction, with indirect access to its evidence",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_JONES_BONFELD_OLDER_MICHAEL",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED",
        "SRC_OT26_WAGELIN_HARTMAN_1710",
        "SRC_OT26_SALFORD_LANDHOLDERS_1734"
      ],
      "source_note": "The earlier New York/Pennsylvania household leads over the Harle 1736 identification: the exact daughter-and-husband match places the father in Pennsylvania in 1727. Kocherthal’s 1710 marriage names Bonfeld as his origin. The reproduced Jones research explicitly identifies the older same-name Bonfeld man as father. These combined facts support a candidate edge despite unavailable direct inspection. A different local relative or a misattached German household remains possible; no specific rival father is established. The score is an ordinal judgment, not a calibrated probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_HANS_KISSLING_ANNA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_HANS_KISSLING_PARENT_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "evidence_strength": "Low-confidence named parental candidate from matching compiled household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DELAFUENTE",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The pedigree explicitly assigns these parents to Anna in the matching Martin Göbel household, with compatible reported generations. That is positive evidence for the proposed couple. A mistaken maternal attachment remains plausible: the page gives no parent-naming event for Anna and its neighboring Göbel ancestry conflicts with the parish-based reconstruction. No independent rival parental couple is identified. The score is a low ordinal research judgment, not a calibrated probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ANNA_MARIA_KISSLING_ANNA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ANNA_MARIA_KISSLING_PARENT_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "evidence_strength": "Low-confidence named parental candidate from matching compiled household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DELAFUENTE",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The pedigree explicitly assigns these parents to Anna in the matching Martin Göbel household, with compatible reported generations. That is positive evidence for the proposed couple. A mistaken maternal attachment remains plausible: the page gives no parent-naming event for Anna and its neighboring Göbel ancestry conflicts with the parish-based reconstruction. No independent rival parental couple is identified. The score is a low ordinal research judgment, not a calibrated probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_MATTHIAS_MUNTZ_ANNA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MATTHIAS_MUNTZ_WASSENACH",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_ANNA_CATHARINA_MUENTZ_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit parent claim and compatible family setting in one compilation",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG719"
      ],
      "source_note": "The explicit compiled identification of the named daughter, parental couple and plausible generation makes this the leading located parent proposal. Its Wassenach-to-Schauernheim identification could nevertheless attach a baptism to a different Anna Catharina. No independently documented rival couple has been identified. The original baptism and marriage have not been examined; the uncertainty concerns that identification as well as the uncited pedigree. The score is an ordinal research judgment, not a measured probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_APOLLONIA_MUNTZ_ANNA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_APOLLONIA_WASSENACH",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_ANNA_CATHARINA_MUENTZ_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit parent claim and compatible family setting in one compilation",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG719"
      ],
      "source_note": "The explicit compiled identification of the named daughter, parental couple and plausible generation makes this the leading located parent proposal. Its Wassenach-to-Schauernheim identification could nevertheless attach a baptism to a different Anna Catharina. No independently documented rival couple has been identified. The original baptism and marriage have not been examined; the uncertainty concerns that identification as well as the uncited pedigree. The score is an ordinal research judgment, not a measured probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_HERMANN_MUNTZ_MATTHIAS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_HERMANN_MUNTZ_WASSENACH",
      "target": "ROOTS26_MATTHIAS_MUNTZ_WASSENACH",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit parent claim and compatible family setting in one compilation",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG719",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG763"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiler expressly assigns Matthias to this named Wassenach household. The shared locality and compatible generation favor the proposed relationship over an unspecified alternative family. A mistaken household reconstruction remains possible; the compilation supplies no parent-naming record and its reciprocal entries are not independent evidence. This relationship is assessed separately from the uncertain American Newland connection. The score is an ordinal research judgment."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ELISABETH_MUNTZ_MATTHIAS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ELISABETH_WASSENACH",
      "target": "ROOTS26_MATTHIAS_MUNTZ_WASSENACH",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "Explicit parent claim and compatible family setting in one compilation",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG719",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG763"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiler expressly assigns Matthias to this named Wassenach household. The shared locality and compatible generation favor the proposed relationship over an unspecified alternative family. A mistaken household reconstruction remains possible; the compilation supplies no parent-naming record and its reciprocal entries are not independent evidence. This relationship is assessed separately from the uncertain American Newland connection. The score is an ordinal research judgment."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_FRIEDERICH_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_FRIEDERICH_PARENT_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "one explicit compiled parent claim; original household record unexamined",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_UHLAND_LANG718",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Lang pedigree explicitly names Friederich as a parent of Matthäus Uhland (reported birth 28 December 1690). This specific claim makes the relationship the leading available candidate over an unidentified different parent. The entry supplies no record citation, dates or residence; a mistaken family assignment remains possible. The proposed relationship is separate from the unresolved identification of Matthäus as John Newland’s father. A baptism or marriage entry identifying the household would distinguish these explanations."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_EVA_MARIA_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_EVA_MARIA_PARENT_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "one explicit compiled parent claim; original household record unexamined",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_UHLAND_LANG718",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Lang pedigree explicitly names Eva Maria as a parent of Matthäus Uhland (reported birth 28 December 1690). This specific claim makes the relationship the leading available candidate over an unidentified different parent. The entry supplies no record citation, dates or residence; a mistaken family assignment remains possible. The proposed relationship is separate from the unresolved identification of Matthäus as John Newland’s father. A baptism or marriage entry identifying the household would distinguish these explanations."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_646_323",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_646",
      "target": "GB26_ANNA_MARIA_SCHWEICKHARD_1686",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree and compatible household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel’s numbered pedigree assigns this parent to this child. The reported dates, locality and household fit the relationship, favoring it over a hypothetical different parent; no identified incompatible household has been found in this review. Original register checks could expose a transcription or reconstruction error."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_647_323",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_647",
      "target": "GB26_ANNA_MARIA_SCHWEICKHARD_1686",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree and compatible household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel’s numbered pedigree assigns this parent to this child. The reported dates, locality and household fit the relationship, favoring it over a hypothetical different parent; no identified incompatible household has been found in this review. Original register checks could expose a transcription or reconstruction error."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_1292_646",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_1292",
      "target": "ROOTS26_SW_646",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree and compatible household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel’s numbered pedigree assigns this parent to this child. The reported dates, locality and household fit the relationship, favoring it over a hypothetical different parent; no identified incompatible household has been found in this review. Original register checks could expose a transcription or reconstruction error."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_1293_646",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_1293",
      "target": "ROOTS26_SW_646",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree and compatible household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel’s numbered pedigree assigns this parent to this child. The reported dates, locality and household fit the relationship, favoring it over a hypothetical different parent; no identified incompatible household has been found in this review. Original register checks could expose a transcription or reconstruction error."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_1294_647",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_1294",
      "target": "ROOTS26_SW_647",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree and compatible household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage identifies Maria’s father Bernhard and home Meidelstetten despite an ink blot over the surname. Weigel matches the only baptism he found with this child/father combination to the Heniß household. Her death age differs by about three years, so an overlooked namesake or age error remains possible. The household identification currently leads; the mother’s assignment follows the published family reconstruction and needs the baptism’s full wording checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_1295_647",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_1295",
      "target": "ROOTS26_SW_647",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree and compatible household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage identifies Maria’s father Bernhard and home Meidelstetten despite an ink blot over the surname. Weigel matches the only baptism he found with this child/father combination to the Heniß household. Her death age differs by about three years, so an overlooked namesake or age error remains possible. The household identification currently leads; the mother’s assignment follows the published family reconstruction and needs the baptism’s full wording checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_2584_1292",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_2584",
      "target": "ROOTS26_SW_1292",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree and compatible household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel’s numbered pedigree assigns this parent to this child. The reported dates, locality and household fit the relationship, favoring it over a hypothetical different parent; no identified incompatible household has been found in this review. Original register checks could expose a transcription or reconstruction error."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_2585_1292",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_2585",
      "target": "ROOTS26_SW_1292",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree and compatible household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel’s numbered pedigree assigns this parent to this child. The reported dates, locality and household fit the relationship, favoring it over a hypothetical different parent; no identified incompatible household has been found in this review. Original register checks could expose a transcription or reconstruction error."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_2924_2584",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_2924",
      "target": "ROOTS26_SW_2584",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree and compatible household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel’s numbered pedigree assigns this parent to this child. The reported dates, locality and household fit the relationship, favoring it over a hypothetical different parent; no identified incompatible household has been found in this review. Original register checks could expose a transcription or reconstruction error."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_2925_2584",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_2925",
      "target": "ROOTS26_SW_2584",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree and compatible household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel’s numbered pedigree assigns this parent to this child. The reported dates, locality and household fit the relationship, favoring it over a hypothetical different parent; no identified incompatible household has been found in this review. Original register checks could expose a transcription or reconstruction error."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_5170_2585",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_5170",
      "target": "ROOTS26_SW_2585",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree and compatible household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel’s numbered pedigree assigns this parent to this child. The reported dates, locality and household fit the relationship, favoring it over a hypothetical different parent; no identified incompatible household has been found in this review. Original register checks could expose a transcription or reconstruction error."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SW_PC_ALT_MARTIN_2924",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SW_ALT_MARTIN",
      "target": "ROOTS26_SW_2924",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit weak father proposal; competing kinship/identity explanations",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel explicitly proposes Alt Martin as Jung Martin’s possible father. Shared name and village, compatible generation and the published proposal make him the leading identifiable candidate. Senior/junior labels also distinguish unrelated namesakes; an uncle or another older relative could fit. Multiple contemporary Martins are reported, and no parent-naming entry resolves these alternatives. A household property, guardianship or inheritance record would be decisive. The score is an ordinal research judgment."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_WALTER_ATHY_FRANCIS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_WALTER_ATHY_PARENT_FRANCIS",
      "target": "C_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_1612_1666_20260730",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "one explicit reconstruction with property context, not independent confirmations",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ATHY_GALWAY1999"
      ],
      "source_note": "The explicit father assignment and reported shared property context make Walter the leading named candidate. A compiler’s mistaken assignment of another Galway relative remains possible; the underlying succession record has not been checked. The 1999 account places Walter in possession in 1640."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHN_ATHY_WALTER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_JOHN_ATHY_PARENT_WALTER",
      "target": "ROOTS26_WALTER_ATHY_PARENT_FRANCIS",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "one explicit reconstruction with property context, not independent confirmations",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ATHY_GALWAY1999"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reported transfer from John to Walter supports the stated father–son relationship over an unidentified parent. The alternative is a different relationship between successive owners or confusion between same-name households. An original deed naming the relationship would distinguish them. The 1999 account identifies John with a house dated 1577."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_MARMADUKE_SEMMES_1701",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MARMADUKE_SEMMES_1701",
      "target": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit named parent in the identified family biography",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MSA_SEMMES_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The scholarly biography explicitly assigns this parent. Thomas’s matching wife Anne Queen anchors the household identification. A mistaken assignment by the authors remains possible, but no competing household has been identified; this is the leading relationship. Original probate and property records could provide independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_HENRIETTA_JENKINS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_HENRIETTA_JENKINS",
      "target": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit named parent in the identified family biography",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MSA_SEMMES_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The scholarly biography explicitly assigns this parent. Thomas’s matching wife Anne Queen anchors the household identification. A mistaken assignment by the authors remains possible, but no competing household has been identified; this is the leading relationship. Original probate and property records could provide independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JAMES_SEMMES_1670",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_JAMES_SEMMES_1670",
      "target": "ROOTS26_MARMADUKE_SEMMES_1701",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit named parent in the identified family biography",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MSA_SEMMES_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The scholarly biography explicitly assigns this parent. Thomas’s matching wife Anne Queen anchors the household identification. A mistaken assignment by the authors remains possible, but no competing household has been identified; this is the leading relationship. Original probate and property records could provide independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_MARY_GOODRICK",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MARY_GOODRICK",
      "target": "ROOTS26_MARMADUKE_SEMMES_1701",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit named parent in the identified family biography",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MSA_SEMMES_PARENTAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The scholarly biography explicitly assigns this parent. Thomas’s matching wife Anne Queen anchors the household identification. A mistaken assignment by the authors remains possible, but no competing household has been identified; this is the leading relationship. Original probate and property records could provide independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_MARMADUKE_SEMME_IMMIGRANT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MARMADUKE_SEMME_IMMIGRANT",
      "target": "ROOTS26_JAMES_SEMMES_1670",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit named parent in published family reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "Newman explicitly identifies this parent in the matching family. This ranks ahead of an unidentified alternative parent; a mistaken compiled relationship remains possible. Original family wills and property records would strengthen or revise the identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_FORTUNA_SEMME",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_FORTUNA_SEMME",
      "target": "ROOTS26_JAMES_SEMMES_1670",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit named parent in published family reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "Newman explicitly identifies this parent in the matching family. This ranks ahead of an unidentified alternative parent; a mistaken compiled relationship remains possible. Original family wills and property records would strengthen or revise the identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ROBERT_GOODRICK",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_GOODRICK",
      "target": "ROOTS26_MARY_GOODRICK",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit named parent in published family reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "Newman explicitly identifies this parent in the matching family. This ranks ahead of an unidentified alternative parent; a mistaken compiled relationship remains possible. Original family wills and property records would strengthen or revise the identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_GEORGE_JENKINS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_GEORGE_JENKINS",
      "target": "ROOTS26_HENRIETTA_JENKINS",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit named parent in published family reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "Newman explicitly identifies this parent in the matching family. This ranks ahead of an unidentified alternative parent; a mistaken compiled relationship remains possible. Original family wills and property records would strengthen or revise the identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SUSANNAH_COLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SUSANNAH_COLE",
      "target": "ROOTS26_HENRIETTA_JENKINS",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "published family assignment supported by an archival abstract naming daughter Henrietta Semmes",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45",
        "ROOTS26_SUSANNAH_JENKINS_WILL"
      ],
      "source_note": "Newman identifies Henrietta’s mother as Susannah Cole, wife of George Jenkins. Susannah Jenkins’s will independently names daughter Heneritta Semmes and sons John, George and William. The distinctive married daughter supports the same household over an unidentified namesake. The will does not itself give Susannah’s maiden surname; that identification still rests on the combined family evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_GEORGE_GOODRICK_1673",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_GEORGE_GOODRICK_1673",
      "target": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_GOODRICK",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "specific published family evidence, with remaining identification uncertainty",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_WILL1673",
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "George’s Charles County will names a son Robert. The name, county and compatible generation favor identifying that son with Mary Goodrick’s father over an otherwise unidentified parent. The will abstract does not name Mary, so the identification remains a candidate rather than an explicit three-generation pedigree. A different Robert in the county is a hypothetical alternative, not a documented contradiction. Tracing the sons’ inherited 600 acres could distinguish the households."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ELIZABETH_WIFE_ROBERT_GOODRICK",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ELIZABETH_WIFE_ROBERT_GOODRICK",
      "target": "ROOTS26_MARY_GOODRICK",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "specific published family evidence, with remaining identification uncertainty",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_RENO",
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Reno-attributed marriage compilation explicitly names Mary’s parents as Robert and Elizabeth. Its Anderson–Semmes marriage sequence matches Newman’s Mary, favoring the same woman. A mistaken compiled maternal assignment remains possible because the underlying record has not been inspected. No competing mother has been identified. Elizabeth’s maiden name remains unknown; Clarkson has not been established by this evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_EDWARD_COLE_SUSANNAH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_EDWARD_COLE_WILL1717_PERSON",
      "target": "ROOTS26_SUSANNAH_COLE",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit daughter Susanna Jenkins in 1717 will; matching household identification",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_EDWARD_COLE_WILL1717",
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45"
      ],
      "source_note": "Edward Cole’s 1717 will explicitly names a daughter Susanna Jenkins. This matches Susannah Cole’s married name in Newman’s identified Semmes household, favoring this father over an unidentified alternative. The abstract also names Mary Jenkins, consistent with the reported marriages of Cole sisters into the Jenkins family, although that additional connection needs separate verification. A different Susanna Jenkins is a possible identity alternative; none has been established here. Estate distributions or deeds naming her husband George would strengthen the identification. The date 1717 belongs to this testator; earlier online death 1716 is not adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_THOMAS_JENKINS_1727",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_JENKINS_1727",
      "target": "ROOTS26_GEORGE_JENKINS",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "identified family in compiled history and probate abstracts",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729",
        "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS279"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1918 history explicitly identifies Thomas as father of George, husband of Susannah Cole and father of Henrietta Semmes. Thomas’s will names son George alongside Edward and William. This matching household favors the published identification over a hypothetical different George. The will abstract alone does not name George’s wife; deeds tracing Lindsey to George’s family would provide a stronger independent identity check."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ANN_WIFE_THOMAS_JENKINS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ANN_WIFE_THOMAS_JENKINS",
      "target": "ROOTS26_GEORGE_JENKINS",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "identified family in compiled history and probate abstracts",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729",
        "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS279"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1918 history explicitly assigns Ann as George’s mother. Thomas’s will names wife Ann; Ann’s own will names Edward, William and Mary Norris, also in Thomas’s family. Together these favor the proposed mother, although George is not named in her abstract and an earlier wife remains a possible alternative. Spalding is reported as her maiden surname in the history but is not established by these wills; Thomas’s daughter Ann also bore that married surname. No birth parents have yet been selected for Ann."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ROBERT_COLE_ENSIGN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_ENSIGN",
      "target": "ROOTS26_EDWARD_COLE_WILL1717_PERSON",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit parentage in 1663; identity bridge to 1717 testator remains secondary",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_COLE_DEPOSITION1663",
        "ROOTS26_COLE_AMERICAN_ERAS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1663 testimony explicitly identifies Edward as a son of Robert and Rebecca Cole. American Eras identifies this son as the planter and merchant who died in 1717, matching the Edward whose will names Susanna Jenkins. That combined identification leads over a hypothetical second Edward; the remaining uncertainty is the connection between the child in 1663 and the adult testator, rather than what the deposition says about his parents. Probate and land records following Edward into adulthood would strengthen that connection."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_REBECCA_WIFE_ROBERT_COLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_WIFE_ROBERT_COLE",
      "target": "ROOTS26_EDWARD_COLE_WILL1717_PERSON",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit parentage in 1663; identity bridge to 1717 testator remains secondary",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_COLE_DEPOSITION1663",
        "ROOTS26_COLE_AMERICAN_ERAS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1663 testimony explicitly identifies Edward as a son of Robert and Rebecca Cole. American Eras identifies this son as the planter and merchant who died in 1717, matching the Edward whose will names Susanna Jenkins. That combined identification leads over a hypothetical second Edward; the remaining uncertainty is the connection between the child in 1663 and the adult testator, rather than what the deposition says about his parents. Probate and land records following Edward into adulthood would strengthen that connection."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JANE_MOTHER_ROBERT_COLE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_JANE_MOTHER_ROBERT_COLE",
      "target": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_ENSIGN",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit mother in will abstract and matching testator household",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_WILL1662",
        "ROOTS26_COLE_DEPOSITION1663",
        "ROOTS26_HESTON_COLE_RECUSANTS1632"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert’s will abstract explicitly names his mother Mrs Jane Cole of Middlesex. Its sons, daughters and St. Clement’s Bay locality match the family in the 1663 deposition, favoring the same Robert over a hypothetical namesake. Jane’s maternity is better supported than her identification with either earlier Heston household. A patent is reported to use Joan, and the 1632 court list distinguishes Jane wife of Thomas from Joan wife of William. The mother is represented here without choosing a husband or maiden surname; this is not a merger of the two women in that list."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_THOMAS_LEWIS_MARGARET_ATHEY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_LEWIS_BATTERSEA1696",
      "target": "C_ATHEY_MARGARET_LEWIS_MOTHER_THOMAS1717_20260730",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": "leading identifiable father candidate; indirect evidence only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730",
        "ROOTS26_BROAD_CREEK_LEWIS",
        "ROOTS26_THOMAS_LEWIS_WILL1696"
      ],
      "source_note": "Athy’s family history proposes Thomas of Aire as Margaret’s father. The locality and documented Lewis household support that identification, but the will abstract names only sons. Its silence does not prove Margaret was absent from the family: the abstract concentrates on land and may omit other provisions. A different Lewis household, or Lewis as the reported widow’s previous married name, remain alternatives. Thomas of Battersea is the leading identifiable candidate, with low confidence; no mother is assigned from his wife’s name alone. Estate distributions and Margaret’s earlier marriage would best distinguish these explanations."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_AARON_LUSBY1796_SARAH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_AARON_LUSBY1796",
      "target": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "leading named candidate from explicit compiled attribution",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_AARON_LUSBY1796_PROFILE",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_SARAH_LUSBY_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled genealogy explicitly identifies this parent. Its two-marriage account explains Sarah’s Lusby and Willoughby surnames and favors this family over an unspecified alternative. The attribution remains weakly supported: no parent-naming original has been inspected, and a compiler may have joined different Sarahs. Reported parental birth around 1796 permits a teenage parent if Sarah was born about 1812. The 1835 Clark County marriage bond, consent or estate records could distinguish the families."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NANCY_HAZELRIGG1796_SARAH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_NANCY_HAZELRIGG1796",
      "target": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "leading named candidate from explicit compiled attribution",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NANCY_HAZELRIGG1796_PROFILE",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_SARAH_LUSBY_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled genealogy explicitly identifies this parent. Its two-marriage account explains Sarah’s Lusby and Willoughby surnames and favors this family over an unspecified alternative. The attribution remains weakly supported: no parent-naming original has been inspected, and a compiler may have joined different Sarahs. Reported parental birth around 1796 permits a teenage parent if Sarah was born about 1812. The 1835 Clark County marriage bond, consent or estate records could distinguish the families."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ELISHA_ELIZABETH_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_ELIZABETH_BETSY_MCNEW_21_APR_1797_1_JAN_",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_PARENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual profile explicitly names both parents and matches the existing birth and death dates. The same family appears in William J. McNew’s sibling list. Parentage remains a compiled-pedigree candidate; the two pages are not independent evidence. These parents currently explain the family grouping better than an unrecorded alternative household."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_NANCY_ELIZABETH_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_NANCY_CATHERINE_SMITH_12_OCT_1756_14_SEP",
      "target": "HV4_ELIZABETH_BETSY_MCNEW_21_APR_1797_1_JAN_",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_PARENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual profile explicitly names both parents and matches the existing birth and death dates. The same family appears in William J. McNew’s sibling list. Parentage remains a compiled-pedigree candidate; the two pages are not independent evidence. These parents currently explain the family grouping better than an unrecorded alternative household."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ELISHA_MARGARET_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_MARGARET_MCNEW_1799_1840",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_MARGARET_PARENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual profile explicitly names both parents and matches the existing birth and death dates. The same family appears in William J. McNew’s sibling list. Parentage remains a compiled-pedigree candidate; the two pages are not independent evidence. These parents currently explain the family grouping better than an unrecorded alternative household."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_NANCY_MARGARET_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_NANCY_CATHERINE_SMITH_12_OCT_1756_14_SEP",
      "target": "HV4_MARGARET_MCNEW_1799_1840",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_MARGARET_PARENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual profile explicitly names both parents and matches the existing birth and death dates. The same family appears in William J. McNew’s sibling list. Parentage remains a compiled-pedigree candidate; the two pages are not independent evidence. These parents currently explain the family grouping better than an unrecorded alternative household."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHNS_NANCY_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_NANCY_MCNEW_DAUGHTER_OF_JOHN_S_ABOUT_184",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_NANCY",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1850"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 census transcription places Nancy McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SARAH_NANCY_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "target": "HV4_NANCY_MCNEW_DAUGHTER_OF_JOHN_S_ABOUT_184",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_NANCY",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1850"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 census transcription places Nancy McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHNS_WILLIAM_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_WILLIAM_MCNEW_SON_OF_JOHN_S_1845",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_WILLIAM",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1850",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place William McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SARAH_WILLIAM_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "target": "HV4_WILLIAM_MCNEW_SON_OF_JOHN_S_1845",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_WILLIAM",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1850",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place William McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHNS_JOHN_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_BISER_MCNEW_OCT_1846_2_MAR_1919",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_JOHN",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1850",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place John Biser McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SARAH_JOHN_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "target": "HV4_JOHN_BISER_MCNEW_OCT_1846_2_MAR_1919",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_JOHN",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1850",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place John Biser McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHNS_HENRY_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_HENRY_MCNEW_22_JAN_1848_31_DEC_1848",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with cemetery association",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_HENRY",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The cemetery transcription records Henry’s birth on 22January1848 and death on 31December1848, with his grave moved from McNew Cemetery in1980 alongside the family graves. This supports his identity and family association, although that entry does not name his parents. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SARAH_HENRY_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "target": "HV4_HENRY_MCNEW_22_JAN_1848_31_DEC_1848",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with cemetery association",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_HENRY",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The cemetery transcription records Henry’s birth on 22January1848 and death on 31December1848, with his grave moved from McNew Cemetery in1980 alongside the family graves. This supports his identity and family association, although that entry does not name his parents. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHNS_FREDERICK_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_FREDERICK_MCNEW_ABOUT_1849_ON_OR_BEFORE_",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_FREDERICK",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1850",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place Frederick McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SARAH_FREDERICK_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "target": "HV4_FREDERICK_MCNEW_ABOUT_1849_ON_OR_BEFORE_",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_FREDERICK",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1850",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place Frederick McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHNS_ELISHA_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_ELISHA_MCNEIL_ABOUT_1851",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_ELISHA",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1850",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place Elisha McNeil with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The ages differ: two months in1850 and eight years in1860, against the compiled birth about1851. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SARAH_ELISHA_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "target": "HV4_ELISHA_MCNEIL_ABOUT_1851",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_ELISHA",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1850",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place Elisha McNeil with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The ages differ: two months in1850 and eight years in1860, against the compiled birth about1851. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHNS_JAMES_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_JAMES_R_MCNEW_ABOUT_1853",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_JAMES",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places James R. McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The1860 entry gives James R. as five and female; the compiled profile gives a male born about1853. The distinctive household favors the identification, but both discrepancies need checking against the manuscript. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SARAH_JAMES_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "target": "HV4_JAMES_R_MCNEW_ABOUT_1853",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_JAMES",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places James R. McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The1860 entry gives James R. as five and female; the compiled profile gives a male born about1853. The distinctive household favors the identification, but both discrepancies need checking against the manuscript. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHNS_MARY_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_MCNEW_DAUGHTER_OF_JOHN_S_ABOUT_1853",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_MARY",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places Mary McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SARAH_MARY_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_MCNEW_DAUGHTER_OF_JOHN_S_ABOUT_1853",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_MARY",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places Mary McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHNS_SUSAN_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_SUSAN_A_MCNEW_ABOUT_1856",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_SUSAN",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places Susan A. McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SARAH_SUSAN_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "target": "HV4_SUSAN_A_MCNEW_ABOUT_1856",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_SUSAN",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places Susan A. McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHNS_SALLY_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_SALLY_A_MCNEW_ABOUT_1857",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_SALLY",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places Sally A. McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SARAH_SALLY_MCNEW",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "target": "HV4_SALLY_A_MCNEW_ABOUT_1857",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with census household corroboration",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_SALLY",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places Sally A. McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHAN_STALCOP_STALCOP_BRANCH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_JOHAN_STALCOP",
      "target": "HV4_PETER_STALLKOP_ABOUT_3_SEP_1709",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "published genealogy",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_STALCOP_SHEETS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Craig’s family sheet and published reconstruction agree on Peter’s father; the will citation offers a direct check."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_CHRISTINA_CARLSDOTTER_STALCOP_BRANCH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_CHRISTINA_CARLSDOTTER",
      "target": "HV4_PETER_STALLKOP_ABOUT_3_SEP_1709",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "published genealogy",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_STALCOP_SHEETS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The family sheet identifies Peter as a child of this couple; no different mother is documented in the inspected material."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_SAMUEL_PETERSSON_STALCOP_BRANCH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SAMUEL_PETERSSON",
      "target": "HV4_KATHERINE_PETERSON",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "published genealogy",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
      ],
      "source_note": "The household reconstruction identifies Catharina, wife of Peter Stalcop, as his daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_BRITA_JONSDOTTER_STALCOP_BRANCH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_BRITA_JONSDOTTER",
      "target": "HV4_KATHERINE_PETERSON",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "published genealogy",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
      ],
      "source_note": "Catharina is listed among Samuel and Brita’s children. Her spouse distinguishes her from other Peterson women."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_CARL_JONSSON_STALCOP_BRANCH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_CARL_JONSSON",
      "target": "ROOTS26_CHRISTINA_CARLSDOTTER",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "published genealogy",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_STALCOP_SHEETS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Explicit father identification in the annotated family sheet; original supporting records remain to be inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JONS_ANDERSSON_SMITH_STALCOP_BRANCH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_JONS_ANDERSSON_SMITH",
      "target": "ROOTS26_BRITA_JONSDOTTER",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "published genealogy",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
      ],
      "source_note": "Craig explicitly identifies Brita as Jöns’s daughter and connects Samuel to his 1678 estate."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_MARIA_WIFE_JONS_STALCOP_BRANCH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MARIA_WIFE_JONS",
      "target": "ROOTS26_BRITA_JONSDOTTER",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "inferred maternity from documented marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
      ],
      "source_note": "Maria is Jöns’s documented wife. She is the leading identifiable mother candidate; an earlier wife remains possible, and no inspected record explicitly names Brita’s mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_PETTER_SMIDT_HANS1696",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_PETTER_SMIDT",
      "target": "HV4_HANS_JURGEN_GEORG_SMITH_SMIDT_3_NOV_1696",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with matching name, birth date and locality",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BAPTISM_LOCATOR",
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BURIAL_1753",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_HANS_SMIDT",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_PETTER_SMIDT",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_MAGDALENA_HUWALT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parent claim matches Hans’s reported birth date and the Falun origin independently stated in his burial entry. It is the leading named candidate household. Another same-named child or a misread baptism remains possible; direct inspection of Falu Kristine C I:1 p41 should distinguish these alternatives. The burial corroborates identity and origin, not parentage. The separate McNew parent profiles also explicitly list Hans, but cite a shared compilation and are not counted as independent record confirmations."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_MAGDALENA_HUWALT_HANS1696",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MAGDALENA_HUWALT",
      "target": "HV4_HANS_JURGEN_GEORG_SMITH_SMIDT_3_NOV_1696",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled parentage with matching name, birth date and locality",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BAPTISM_LOCATOR",
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BURIAL_1753",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_HANS_SMIDT",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_PETTER_SMIDT",
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_MAGDALENA_HUWALT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parent claim matches Hans’s reported birth date and the Falun origin independently stated in his burial entry. It is the leading named candidate household. Another same-named child or a misread baptism remains possible; direct inspection of Falu Kristine C I:1 p41 should distinguish these alternatives. The burial corroborates identity and origin, not parentage. The separate McNew parent profiles also explicitly list Hans, but cite a shared compilation and are not counted as independent record confirmations."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_WILLIAM_FURNISS_SOMERSET_ROSE_FELPS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNISS_SOMERSET",
      "target": "G28_ROSANNAH_WIFE_THOMAS_FELPS",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "low-confidence identity bridge from a documented Somerset daughter to Rose Felps",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LANKFORD_FURNISS",
        "ROOTS26_LANKFORD_EXPLANATORY",
        "ROOTS26_ROSE_FURNIS_CLAIM"
      ],
      "source_note": "William and Olive are the leading identifiable parent couple proposed for Rose. Their daughter Rosannah is recorded in the appropriate generation. The alternative is that the Somerset daughter and the Baltimore wife were different women; the known records do not yet supply a shared spouse, property transfer or migration trail. Copied tree claims do not independently confirm identity. A Furniss probate distribution, Swift marriage or vestry record identifying natal kin would discriminate. Numerical confidence is an ordinal judgment, not a calibrated probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_OLIVE_FURNISS_SOMERSET_ROSE_FELPS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_OLIVE_FURNISS_SOMERSET",
      "target": "G28_ROSANNAH_WIFE_THOMAS_FELPS",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "low-confidence identity bridge from a documented Somerset daughter to Rose Felps",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LANKFORD_FURNISS",
        "ROOTS26_LANKFORD_EXPLANATORY",
        "ROOTS26_ROSE_FURNIS_CLAIM"
      ],
      "source_note": "William and Olive are the leading identifiable parent couple proposed for Rose. Their daughter Rosannah is recorded in the appropriate generation. The alternative is that the Somerset daughter and the Baltimore wife were different women; the known records do not yet supply a shared spouse, property transfer or migration trail. Copied tree claims do not independently confirm identity. A Furniss probate distribution, Swift marriage or vestry record identifying natal kin would discriminate. Numerical confidence is an ordinal judgment, not a calibrated probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_THOMAS_FURNIS_KNEESALL_WILLIAM_FURNISS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_FURNIS_KNEESALL",
      "target": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNISS_SOMERSET",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "evidence_strength": "leading named English parent candidate with uncertain identity across the Atlantic",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_FURNIS_KNEESALL_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_ANNE_FURNIS_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNIS_FS",
        "ROOTS26_OLIVE_STRAWBRIDGE_1689"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled profile explicitly connects these parents to William, husband of Olive and father of Rosannah, and lists English baptism sources naming Thomas and Ann/Anne. This makes them the leading identifiable candidates. The alternative is a conflation between an English child and the Maryland planter. The reported1708 death contradicts the1689 widowhood record; an erroneous death attached to the correct baptism is also possible. No inspected migration or property record distinguishes those explanations. Low confidence reflects that unresolved identity, not a penalty for a hypothetical namesake alone."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ANNE_FURNIS_KNEESALL_WILLIAM_FURNISS",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ANNE_FURNIS_KNEESALL",
      "target": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNISS_SOMERSET",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "evidence_strength": "leading named English parent candidate with uncertain identity across the Atlantic",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_FURNIS_KNEESALL_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_ANNE_FURNIS_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNIS_FS",
        "ROOTS26_OLIVE_STRAWBRIDGE_1689"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled profile explicitly connects these parents to William, husband of Olive and father of Rosannah, and lists English baptism sources naming Thomas and Ann/Anne. This makes them the leading identifiable candidates. The alternative is a conflation between an English child and the Maryland planter. The reported1708 death contradicts the1689 widowhood record; an erroneous death attached to the correct baptism is also possible. No inspected migration or property record distinguishes those explanations. Low confidence reflects that unresolved identity, not a penalty for a hypothetical namesake alone."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726_PERSON_CATHERINE_MCDONALD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726_PERSON",
      "target": "HV4_CATHERINE_PRISCILLA_ROBINSON_ABOUT_1694_",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "published will explicitly names daughter; later property association supports identity",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726",
        "ROOTS26_ROBINSON_DEED1735_SUMMARY",
        "ROOTS26_CATHERINE_ROBINSON_NATHAN"
      ],
      "source_note": "James is the leading father identification: his1726will names Cathren Mack Donald, and the1735summary names Bryan and Catherine among the Robinson property claimants. The matching married name, locality and family group support identity. A different McDonald daughter is a hypothetical alternative, with no competing household identified. Original will and deed inspection would strengthen the bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CATHERINE_WIFE_JAMES_ROBINSON_CATHERINE_MCDONALD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_CATHERINE_WIFE_JAMES_ROBINSON",
      "target": "HV4_CATHERINE_PRISCILLA_ROBINSON_ABOUT_1694_",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "same-name wife of father and compiled maternity; earlier wife remains an alternative",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726",
        "ROOTS26_ROBINSON_DEED1735_SUMMARY",
        "ROOTS26_CATHERINE_ROBINSON_NATHAN",
        "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS",
        "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1695 will establishes that Catherine Howell was married to James by 1695, close to the daughter’s reported birth. Combined with the 1726 wife and compiled maternity, she is the leading mother. An earlier wife or incorrect birth date remains possible; no competing mother is identified."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GEORGE_ROBINSON_WEDGEBURG_PARENT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_GEORGE_ROBINSON_WEDGEBURG",
      "target": "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726_PERSON",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "matching family group in scholarly history and will",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_STANDING_ROBINSON",
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726"
      ],
      "source_note": "Standing’s four-son household matches James’s will-named brothers George and Joseph. Cope disputed identification of George junior; original land records remain uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANN_WIFE_GEORGE_ROBINSON_PARENT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ANN_WIFE_GEORGE_ROBINSON",
      "target": "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726_PERSON",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "matching family group in scholarly history and will",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_STANDING_ROBINSON",
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ann is the reported surviving wife in the matching household. She leads as mother, but a later marriage remains possible."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_HOWELL_COOPERS_CREEK_PARENT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_HOWELL_COOPERS_CREEK",
      "target": "ROOTS26_CATHERINE_WIFE_JAMES_ROBINSON",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "named daughter and husband in published probate transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Katharine’s 1695 will names daughter Katharine Robinson and husband James. The widow and estate agreement identify Thomas. This family group leads over an unrecorded different same-name couple; original records remain to be inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KATHARINE_HOWELL_WIDOW1695_PARENT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_KATHARINE_HOWELL_WIDOW1695",
      "target": "ROOTS26_CATHERINE_WIFE_JAMES_ROBINSON",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "named daughter and husband in published probate transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Katharine’s 1695 will names daughter Katharine Robinson and husband James. The widow and estate agreement identify Thomas. This family group leads over an unrecorded different same-name couple; original records remain to be inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ADAM_HELMSTETLER_ROWAN_CHRISTINA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ADAM_HELMSTETLER_ROWAN",
      "target": "HV4_CHRISTINA_MARY_HELMSTETLER",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARIA_MAGDALENA_WIFE_ADAM_HELM_CHRISTINA",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MARIA_MAGDALENA_WIFE_ADAM_HELM",
      "target": "HV4_CHRISTINA_MARY_HELMSTETLER",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HELMSTETTER_PFAFF1708_ADAM_ROWAN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_HELMSTETTER_PFAFF1708",
      "target": "ROOTS26_ADAM_HELMSTETLER_ROWAN",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_AUGST_MARIA_CATHARINA1712_ADAM_ROWAN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_AUGST_MARIA_CATHARINA1712",
      "target": "ROOTS26_ADAM_HELMSTETLER_ROWAN",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ANTHONY_MCNEW_FATHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I129",
      "target": "HV4_ANTHONY_MCNEW_MCKNEW_ABOUT_1670",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit parentage in a derivative compiled pedigree; no independent Anthony parent-naming record located",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ANTHONY_MCNEW_PROFILE",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_SUSAN_SOURCE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nathan McNew’s individual profile names Jeremiah and Phillis as Anthony’s parents and groups him with John Howard, Lomax and Jeremiah. That family combination identifies the existing Jeremiah I129 and Phillis I130 as the intended parents; it improves on the former place-list association. Their parentage is the leading named hypothesis, retained at low confidence because the citation leads to another compiled tree without an original record for Anthony. An erroneous attachment or a different McNew household remains possible; no independently documented competing parents were found. The compiler’s approximate dates are not substituted for the existing parents’ assessed dates. The documented 1670 couple and John Howard support the family’s existence but do not themselves prove Anthony’s relationship. Score is an ordinal research judgment, not a calibrated probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ANTHONY_MCNEW_MOTHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "I130",
      "target": "HV4_ANTHONY_MCNEW_MCKNEW_ABOUT_1670",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit parentage in a derivative compiled pedigree; no independent Anthony parent-naming record located",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ANTHONY_MCNEW_PROFILE",
        "ROOTS26_MCNEW_SUSAN_SOURCE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nathan McNew’s individual profile names Jeremiah and Phillis as Anthony’s parents and groups him with John Howard, Lomax and Jeremiah. That family combination identifies the existing Jeremiah I129 and Phillis I130 as the intended parents; it improves on the former place-list association. Their parentage is the leading named hypothesis, retained at low confidence because the citation leads to another compiled tree without an original record for Anthony. An erroneous attachment or a different McNew household remains possible; no independently documented competing parents were found. The compiler’s approximate dates are not substituted for the existing parents’ assessed dates. The documented 1670 couple and John Howard support the family’s existence but do not themselves prove Anthony’s relationship. Score is an ordinal research judgment, not a calibrated probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_COUNTISS_HENRY_FATHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_COUNTISS1743",
      "target": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "evidence_strength": "leading named parents in a compiled pedigree; rare name and compatible age; Maryland–Virginia identity unresolved",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "William and Elizabeth are represented as low-confidence parent candidates because their Henry1777 fits the supplied1820ageband and the distinctive surname. The chart’s other Henry, son of PeterII reportedly dead1773, fits less well chronologically. The chart is uncited, and the Virginia identification could be wrong; an unrecorded different Henry remains possible but is not contrary evidence. Brock’s easternVirginia origin need not exclude earlierMaryland residence, but does not prove it. Score is an ordinal research judgment, not a calibrated probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_COUNTISS_HENRY_MOTHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ELIZABETH_WRENCH_COUNTISS",
      "target": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "evidence_strength": "leading named parents in a compiled pedigree; rare name and compatible age; Maryland–Virginia identity unresolved",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "William and Elizabeth are represented as low-confidence parent candidates because their Henry1777 fits the supplied1820ageband and the distinctive surname. The chart’s other Henry, son of PeterII reportedly dead1773, fits less well chronologically. The chart is uncited, and the Virginia identification could be wrong; an unrecorded different Henry remains possible but is not contrary evidence. Brock’s easternVirginia origin need not exclude earlierMaryland residence, but does not prove it. Score is an ordinal research judgment, not a calibrated probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_COUNTISS_PETER_WILLIAM",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_D1746",
      "target": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_COUNTISS1743",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "will evidence supports named fathers; maternal identifications remain less certain",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_WILL1746"
      ],
      "source_note": "Peter is the leading father candidate: the chart identifies him, and his will independently names William as a son. Matching names, county and Peter’s death year support the identification. The will does not establish William’s reported 1743 birth or later family."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_COUNTISS_REBECCA_WILLIAM",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_WIFE_PETER_COUNTISS",
      "target": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_COUNTISS1743",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": "will evidence supports named fathers; maternal identifications remain less certain",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_WILL1746",
        "ROOTS26_COUNTISS_PROCEEDINGS_INDEX1746"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rebecca is the leading mother candidate from the chart. The unnamed wife in Peter’s will and the 1746 index entry are compatible with her identification. A stepmother or an incorrect name in the chart remain possible; the index’s county discrepancy is unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_COUNTISS_JAMES_PETER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731",
      "target": "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_D1746",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "will evidence supports named fathers; maternal identifications remain less certain",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731",
        "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_WILL1746"
      ],
      "source_note": "James is the leading father candidate. His will names Peter, James, William, Catharine, Rachel, Hannah and Sarah, matching the chart. This distinctive family cluster and the shared county support the identification. The property succession has not yet been established."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_COUNTISS_MARY_PETER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MARY_GREENE_COUNTISS",
      "target": "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_D1746",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "will evidence supports named fathers; maternal identifications remain less certain",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mary is the leading mother candidate named in the chart. The will corroborates the children but leaves the wife unnamed. It therefore cannot verify Mary’s surname or biological motherhood; a later wife or an incorrectly recorded name remains possible."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ATHEY_HV4_SUSAN_ATHEY_EWELL_FATHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_QUEEN_ATHEY_24_MAY_1756_1831",
      "target": "HV4_SUSAN_ATHEY_EWELL",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ATHEY_HV4_SUSAN_ATHEY_EWELL_MOTHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_DORCAS_CULLEN_WIFE_ATHEY",
      "target": "HV4_SUSAN_ATHEY_EWELL",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ATHEY_HV4_ELIZABETH_ATHEY_HALE_FATHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_QUEEN_ATHEY_24_MAY_1756_1831",
      "target": "HV4_ELIZABETH_ATHEY_HALE",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ATHEY_HV4_ELIZABETH_ATHEY_HALE_MOTHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_DORCAS_CULLEN_WIFE_ATHEY",
      "target": "HV4_ELIZABETH_ATHEY_HALE",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ATHEY_HV4_FANETTA_ATHEY_COTTINGIM_FATHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_QUEEN_ATHEY_24_MAY_1756_1831",
      "target": "HV4_FANETTA_ATHEY_COTTINGIM",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ATHEY_HV4_FANETTA_ATHEY_COTTINGIM_MOTHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_DORCAS_CULLEN_WIFE_ATHEY",
      "target": "HV4_FANETTA_ATHEY_COTTINGIM",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.6
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_WILLIAM_SENIOR_WILLIAM",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_SENIOR",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "secondary parentage evidence; uncertainty stated in assessment",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage transcription explicitly names this parent. Misreading or a mistaken marriage identification remains possible; the original register is uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ELLEN_WILLIAM",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ELLEN_HENDERSON",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "secondary parentage evidence; uncertainty stated in assessment",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "The same transcription explicitly names Ellen as mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_LIDDY_ELLEN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_LIDDY_MARKLAND",
      "target": "ROOTS26_ELLEN_HENDERSON",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "evidence_strength": "secondary parentage evidence; uncertainty stated in assessment",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "Matching spouses’ names and locality favor identifying Ellen with the will’s Elender over a hypothetical second couple. The original will and connecting household sequence remain unverified."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_WILLIAM_SENIOR_ROBERT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_SENIOR",
      "target": "I70",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "secondary parentage evidence; uncertainty stated in assessment",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiler proposes Robert, husband of Mary McNew, as a son. Locality and the shared cooper occupation favor this family over the less localized John proposal, but the proposed sibling list contains a correction and inconsistent ages."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_ELLEN_ROBERT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ELLEN_HENDERSON",
      "target": "I70",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "secondary parentage evidence; uncertainty stated in assessment",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ellen is the mother in that proposed sibling reconstruction. John remains a competing father candidate; neither reconstruction is secure."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_JOHN_WILLIS_NANCY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_JOHN_WILLIS_NANCY_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "specific compiled parent claim matching Nancy’s husband and marriage date",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compilation identifies Nancy by her husband and exact marriage date, making John and Phebe the leading named parent candidates. A mistaken attachment or confusion with Parmelia remains possible. The short structured child list’s omission of Nancy is not evidence that she was excluded from the family. The court file independently supports John’s reported movements and associates, but does not name Nancy or Phebe. The 0.40 score is a provisional ordinal assessment, not a calibrated probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PC_PHEBE_BENNETT_NANCY",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_PHEBE_BENNETT_NANCY_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "specific compiled parent claim matching Nancy’s husband and marriage date",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compilation identifies Nancy by her husband and exact marriage date, making John and Phebe the leading named parent candidates. A mistaken attachment or confusion with Parmelia remains possible. The short structured child list’s omission of Nancy is not evidence that she was excluded from the family. The court file independently supports John’s reported movements and associates, but does not name Nancy or Phebe. The 0.40 score is a provisional ordinal assessment, not a calibrated probability."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOSEPH_BENNETT_WARRINGTON_TO_ROOTS26_PHEBE_BENNETT_NANCY_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_JOSEPH_BENNETT_WARRINGTON",
      "target": "ROOTS26_PHEBE_BENNETT_NANCY_CANDIDATE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit published parentage with individual identity assessment",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WARRINGTON_BENNETT_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The abstract names daughter Phebe, with an age and Quaker setting compatible with John Willis’s wife. The compiled marriage account identifies her parents as Joseph and Rebecca. That combined identification leads over a hypothetical different Phebe; the original marriage entry remains unchecked. Scores are ordinal assessments, not calibrated probabilities."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_FINCHER_BENNETT_TO_ROOTS26_PHEBE_BENNETT_NANCY_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_FINCHER_BENNETT",
      "target": "ROOTS26_PHEBE_BENNETT_NANCY_CANDIDATE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit published parentage with individual identity assessment",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WARRINGTON_BENNETT_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The typed family group names Rebecca Fincher as Phebe’s mother. Identification of this Phebe with John Willis’s wife is supported by the compiled marriage parentage and compatible age and community, but has not been checked against the original marriage entry. Scores are ordinal assessments, not calibrated probabilities."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_EDWARD_BENNETT_THORNBURY_TO_ROOTS26_JOSEPH_BENNETT_WARRINGTON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_EDWARD_BENNETT_THORNBURY",
      "target": "ROOTS26_JOSEPH_BENNETT_WARRINGTON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit published parentage with individual identity assessment",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "The county history identifies Joseph, husband of Rebecca Fincher, among Edward and Sarah’s children. The spouse match makes this more specific than a bare name match. No documented competing parental household has been found in the reviewed sources. Scores are ordinal assessments, not calibrated probabilities."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SARAH_STANFIELD_BENNETT_TO_ROOTS26_JOSEPH_BENNETT_WARRINGTON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_SARAH_STANFIELD_BENNETT",
      "target": "ROOTS26_JOSEPH_BENNETT_WARRINGTON",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit published parentage with individual identity assessment",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "Joseph is explicitly listed among Sarah’s children after her 1697 marriage to Edward. The earlier wife Margery is assigned a separate child group. This favors Sarah, while relying on the accuracy of the published reconstruction. Scores are ordinal assessments, not calibrated probabilities."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHN_FINCHER_LONDONGROVE_TO_ROOTS26_REBECCA_FINCHER_BENNETT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_JOHN_FINCHER_LONDONGROVE",
      "target": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_FINCHER_BENNETT",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit published parentage with individual identity assessment",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both the Bennett and Fincher sections identify Rebecca, wife of Joseph Bennett, as John’s daughter. These passages are within one publication and are not independent confirmations. Scores are ordinal assessments, not calibrated probabilities."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARTHA_TAYLOR_FINCHER_TO_ROOTS26_REBECCA_FINCHER_BENNETT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MARTHA_TAYLOR_FINCHER",
      "target": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_FINCHER_BENNETT",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit published parentage with individual identity assessment",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Bennett section names John and Martha as Rebecca’s parents; the Fincher section describes attribution of John’s children to his first wife as probable. The 1708 birth before his 1714 remarriage favors Martha over Elinor Cook; the original birth entry remains unchecked. Scores are ordinal assessments, not calibrated probabilities."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_TAYLOR_SPRINGFIELD_TO_ROOTS26_MARTHA_TAYLOR_FINCHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_TAYLOR_SPRINGFIELD",
      "target": "ROOTS26_MARTHA_TAYLOR_FINCHER",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "family-specific documentary and published genealogical comparison",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925",
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_ARRIVALS1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert’s named daughter Martha in the will fits the arrival household and the histories identifying Martha’s marriage to John Fincher. This distinctive family sequence favors the relationship over a hypothetical mistaken attachment to another Taylor household."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARY_HAYES_TAYLOR_TO_ROOTS26_MARTHA_TAYLOR_FINCHER",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MARY_HAYES_TAYLOR",
      "target": "ROOTS26_MARTHA_TAYLOR_FINCHER",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "family-specific documentary and published genealogical comparison",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925",
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_ARRIVALS1881"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1683 arrival household and Justice’s explicit account of a register naming both parents favor Mary’s maternity. A stepmother remains an alternative because the earlier history raised that possibility for some children; the later register-based account is more specific. The original birth entry remains uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_TAYLOR_LITTLELEIGH_TO_ROOTS26_ROBERT_TAYLOR_SPRINGFIELD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_TAYLOR_LITTLELEIGH",
      "target": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_TAYLOR_SPRINGFIELD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "comparison of published parish household reconstruction and alternatives",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
      ],
      "source_note": "Justice connects the Little Leigh parish household to the immigrant Robert. The matching locality, baptism and later family account support this identification over a hypothetical unrelated namesake; the English-to-American identity link remains the principal uncertainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARY_BARROW_TAYLOR_TO_ROOTS26_ROBERT_TAYLOR_SPRINGFIELD",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_MARY_BARROW_TAYLOR",
      "target": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_TAYLOR_SPRINGFIELD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": "comparison of published parish household reconstruction and alternatives",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reported 1630 marriage precedes Robert’s 1633 baptism in the same reconstructed household. Mary is the leading mother candidate. The paternal baptism attribution alone would not exclude an intervening marriage; Justice’s household reconstruction supports her placement."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHN_TAYLOR_CLATTERWICH_TO_ROOTS26_THOMAS_TAYLOR_LITTLELEIGH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_JOHN_TAYLOR_CLATTERWICH",
      "target": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_TAYLOR_LITTLELEIGH",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "comparison of published parish household reconstruction and alternatives",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
      ],
      "source_note": "Justice identifies Thomas’s 1594 baptism among John’s children and reconstructs the same Clatterwich household from parish and probate records. The locality and family sequence support continuity; the underlying baptism and probate records remain to be compared."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ELLEN_MASSEY_TAYLOR_TO_ROOTS26_THOMAS_TAYLOR_LITTLELEIGH",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "ROOTS26_ELLEN_MASSEY_TAYLOR",
      "target": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_TAYLOR_LITTLELEIGH",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "comparison of published parish household reconstruction and alternatives",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas’s 1594 baptism falls within John’s second marriage to Ellen in Justice’s reconstruction. The earlier wife Joan’s reported burial in 1586 and later marriage to Alice in 1611 favor Ellen. Unrecorded intervening changes remain possible but are not documented evidence against her."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F2",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I1",
      "target": "I5",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F3",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I3",
      "target": "I7",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F5",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I13",
      "target": "I14",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "evidence_strength": "1930 census household and both spouses' Virginia death records",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1964",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_SALLY_JANE_HENDERSON_1974"
      ],
      "source_note": "Edward and Sallie appear as spouses in the 1930 census. Edward's 1964 death record names Sally Jane Shortt, and Sallie's 1974 death record names Edward Henderson."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F6",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I15",
      "target": "I18",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F7",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I21",
      "target": "I22",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F8",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I16",
      "target": "I25",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F9",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I27",
      "target": "I28",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM, three census spouse households, death-certificate relationship, memorial, and obituary index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_NC_DEATH_CERT_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NAMES_FLORENCE",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1891_1960",
        "SRC_NEWSPAPERS_OBITUARY_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1960"
      ],
      "source_note": "Existing GEDCOM couple. George and Florence appear together as spouses in the 1920, 1930, and 1940 East Orange census households; a death-certificate index, memorial, and obituary index also name the pair."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F10",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I29",
      "target": "I31",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F11",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I33",
      "target": "I32",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F12",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I38",
      "target": "I19",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F13",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I39",
      "target": "I34",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F15",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I44",
      "target": "I45",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct 1907 civil marriage index plus 1911 and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_DAVIES_KEZIA_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_1907",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1907 Atcham marriage-index page includes Alfred Percy Davies and Kezia Thomas; the 1911 and 1921 censuses explicitly identify them as spouses and prove the index pairing."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F17",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I51",
      "target": "I52",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct 1876 Virginia marriage register",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876"
      ],
      "source_note": "Direct marriage register: Rebecca S Talley, age 19, married Connaely/Conley Henderson on 25 Sep 1876 in Washington County, Virginia."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F18",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I53",
      "target": "I54",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct death record names spouse Tiney, supported by census continuity and child marriage record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938"
      ],
      "source_note": "David Kitzmiller Shortt's Virginia death record explicitly names spouse Tiney Shortt. Graham's marriage record names parents Dave Shortt and Leana White. The 1900 Ginie and 1920 Lucy spouse names are treated as census/index variants within the same family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F19",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I55",
      "target": "I56",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct 21 May 1861 Virginia marriage plus later compiled family profile",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F20",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I57",
      "target": "I58",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "split 1860 household and multiple child records identify the couple",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "George W. and Julia White occupy the same dwelling and family number in the split 1860 Washington County census transcript, and records for multiple children identify them as parents. Julia's 1870 household without George is consistent with his 1864 death."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F21",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I60",
      "target": "I61",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1811 marriage indexes and 1850-1860 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Benjamin White and Fanny Lavender married in Botetourt County in June 1811 and are documented together as Benjamin and Frances White in the 1850 and 1860 Greene County censuses. The exact marriage day conflicts between 1 and 6 June."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F22",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I62",
      "target": "I63",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "dated Franklin County marriage bond naming both spouses",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786"
      ],
      "source_note": "Benjamin White and Suckey Bartee married at Franklin County, Virginia, on 8 Oct 1786."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F25",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I68",
      "target": "I69",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled profile names spouse Mary without a marriage record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "A compiled profile calls William Bartee's spouse Mary, but no original marriage, deed, or probate record has been located. She is not asserted as Suckey's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F26",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I70",
      "target": "I71",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "1850/1860 census continuity and multiple child relationship records",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert and Mary appear together in 1850 and 1860, and multiple child records name them as parents. Mary's Apr 1880 death is consistent with Robert being widowed later in 1880."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F27",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I72",
      "target": "I73",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM couple embedded in a chronologically conflated family",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 10 audit: retained as a possible compiled-tree couple, but the surrounding generation is internally inconsistent and no original marriage or joint record was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F29",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I76",
      "target": "I77",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct 1869 New Jersey marriage record plus four census households and shared cemetery evidence",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Henry Fricke and Cathrine Schaaf married 28 Mar 1869 in Newark, appear together in the 1880, 1900, 1905, and 1910 New Jersey censuses, and are recorded in the same Rosedale Cemetery lot. The 1900 census marriage-year estimate is superseded by the direct civil marriage record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F30",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I81",
      "target": "I82",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled exact marriage plus repeated census spouse evidence",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBBLE_FAMILY_DATA_JOHN_1818_1899",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Family Data Collection gives marriage 16 Sep 1840 in Washington County, Virginia. John and Sarah appear together in four supplied censuses, and multiple child records name them as parents. Sarah's memorial also names John G. Gobble as her spouse."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F31",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I83",
      "target": "I84",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "dated marriage index plus 1850 spouse household",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F32",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I85",
      "target": "I86",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "direct compiled marriage index plus child relationship index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_INTL_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage index directly pairs John Gobble and Jemima Linder on 17 Nov 1789 in Washington County, Virginia; a separate relationship index names John and Jimima as William Gobble's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F33",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I12",
      "target": "I87",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F34",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I89",
      "target": "I90",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F35",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I46",
      "target": "I92",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F36",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I47",
      "target": "I96",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F37",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I100",
      "target": "I101",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "reciprocal 1879 civil marriage index plus 1891 and 1901 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEBMD_FREDERICK_DAVIES_MARIA_HANNY_MARRIAGE_Q3_1879",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Reciprocal FreeBMD searches place Frederick Davies and Maria Hanny on the same Atcham marriage-registration page in Jul-Sep 1879, volume 6a page 1129. Their 1891 and 1901 census households explicitly identify Maria as Frederick's wife and establish the pairing."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F38",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I102",
      "target": "I103",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F39",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I107",
      "target": "I108",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "published family-association genealogy gives both spouses and a dated 1757 Lutheran marriage; original image not inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Published trees identify Johann Friedrich Jr.'s wife as Elizabeth, but no original marriage record has been located. The Goble Family Association database identifies Elizabeth as Weigel and dates the marriage to 10 May 1757 at Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran Church; retained below direct-record confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F40",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I109",
      "target": "I110",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "couple named as parents in 1754 Lutheran baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "Johann Friedrich Gabel and Christiana Henrietta Hornberger are explicitly paired as Christian's parents in the IPGV card citing his 1754 baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F41",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I111",
      "target": "I112",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "couple repeated in derivative Gabel trees",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 10 audit: the couple is consistently repeated in public trees, but no original marriage or shared child record has been located."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F42",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I113",
      "target": "I114",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "couple repeated in two compatible compiled family accounts",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a consistently repeated compiled couple; no original marriage or joint record was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F43",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I115",
      "target": "I116",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "evidence_strength": "GEDCOM couple only; Henry independently supported but Mary is not",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 12 audit: retained as a low-confidence possible couple. No marriage or joint record was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F44",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I117",
      "target": "I118",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "evidence_strength": "repeated compiled couple without attached record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 12 audit: retained as a plausible compiled couple; no original marriage or joint record was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F46",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I121",
      "target": "I122",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "FamilySearch profile identity hypothesis; Ann/Annie is the documented spouse but maiden surname is unknown",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Nancy Ann Sevier may be the Ann/Annie McNew recorded with David from 1850 through 1880, but no captured record supplies that maiden surname. Confidence applies to the identity merge, not to the directly established David-Ann household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F47",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I124",
      "target": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "Find a Grave memorial explicitly names spouse plus Sharon Wright parent pair",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F48",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I125",
      "target": "HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "published family history identifies William's wife as Mary; maiden surname and marriage event unresolved",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED"
      ],
      "source_note": "Published McNew-Cawood history identifies William's wife as Mary. Berry and Clemons remain conflicting derivative surname claims, and the reported marriage years conflict, so no maiden surname or exact marriage event is adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F49",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I127",
      "target": "I128",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "record-based family history reports 1708 marriage and four parish-record children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Record-based history reports Jeremiah II married Sarah Marley/Marler in 1708 and identifies four children from St. John's Parish records. Exact marriage day is not established."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F50",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I129",
      "target": "I130",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "quoted 1670 court record explicitly names Jeremiah and Phillis as husband and wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_JEREMIAH_MACKMERE_PHILISE_MARRIAGE_1670",
        "SRC_GENEANET_PHILLIS_W_OJEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_1674_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_NEW_EARLY_SETTLERS_MARYLAND_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_PROFILE_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JEREMIAH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 10 audit: the 10 Jan 1670 Charles County court entry quoted in the cited history explicitly names Jeremiah Macknew and Phillis his wife. Exact marriage date/place remain unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F51",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I131",
      "target": "I132",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.36,
      "evidence_strength": "one compiled Geneanet couple; no original marriage or joint record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a low-confidence compiled couple; no original Scottish marriage, parish, or probate record was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F57",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I143",
      "target": "I144",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1860 church marriage plus 1861-1891 census household continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Richard Morrall and Sarah Brassington married on 26 Nov 1860 at Wolverhampton St John and appear together in the 1861, 1871, 1881, and 1891 census households."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F58",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I145",
      "target": "I146",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit 1827 parish marriage plus 1841-1861 household continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Waterhouse and Ellen Finney married on 24 Sep 1827 at Ashbourne St Oswald. Their family is continuous through the 1841, 1851, and 1861 censuses; Jonas/Helen are compatible variants of John/Ellen."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F61",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I151",
      "target": "I152",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1828 church marriage plus 1841 and 1851 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Joseph Brassington and Esther Thompson married on 24 Jul 1828 at Wolverhampton St Peter and appear together with their children in the 1841 and 1851 censuses."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F63",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I155",
      "target": "I156",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "1851 and 1861 census spouse households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas and Mary Grindley are explicitly recorded as husband and wife in consistent 1851 and 1861 Forton households. Mary's maiden surname is unknown; the 1806 Ireland Thomas Grindley/Mary Mahony marriage is not accepted as this couple without connecting evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F64",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I155",
      "target": "I157",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.2
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F66",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I160",
      "target": "I161",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "imported relationship without supplied marriage evidence",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
        "SRC_RICHARD_POYNER_NEWPORT_BAPTISM_1759"
      ],
      "source_note": "The imported tree pairs Richard Poyner and Mary Deane, but no marriage or shared-child record has been supplied. Keep as a low-confidence candidate couple."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F67",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I162",
      "target": "I163",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "named together as parents in their son's baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_POYNER_NEWPORT_BAPTISM_1759"
      ],
      "source_note": "Richard and Elizabeth are named together as parents of Richard in 1759. This supports the couple but not Elizabeth's imported Allen surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F68",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I164",
      "target": "I165",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "gedcom",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from uploaded GEDCOM export.ged"
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F77",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I182",
      "target": "I183",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit 1838 church marriage plus 1851 census household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_HANNY_CORNISH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838"
      ],
      "source_note": "William Peters Hanny and Elizabeth Cornish married on 31 Mar 1838 in Wiltshire; their fathers are explicitly named William Hanny and Henry Cornish. The 1851 census continues them as spouses."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F79",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I186",
      "target": "I187",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "two parish marriage index transcripts",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795"
      ],
      "source_note": "William Hanny/Hanney and Elizabeth Peters married 25 Jun 1795 at Bradford-on-Avon; both were of the parish."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F80",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I188",
      "target": "I189",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "three compatible parish marriage indexes",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765"
      ],
      "source_note": "Charles Hanny and Catherine/Catharine Waine married 8 Jul 1765 at Winsley, both of the parish."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F81",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I190",
      "target": "I191",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit parish marriage transcript",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764"
      ],
      "source_note": "Isaiah Peters and Betty Willis married at North Bradley St Nicholas on 18 Jun 1764; witnesses were John Butche and Richard Gibbs. This marriage does not prove their exact birth/death dates or directly identify Elizabeth Peters as their daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F84",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I196",
      "target": "I197",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "son's baptism names both parents plus 1841 spouse household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Joseph's 1787 baptism names John and Margaret as his parents, and the couple appears together at Haughton in 1841. Margaret's Davidson maiden surname remains unverified."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F85",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I93",
      "target": "I198",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F86",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I199",
      "target": "I200",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F87",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I94",
      "target": "I202",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F88",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I95",
      "target": "I205",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F89",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I98",
      "target": "I208",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F90",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I48",
      "target": "I210",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F91",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I211",
      "target": "I214",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F92",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I206",
      "target": "I216",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F93",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I43",
      "target": "I217",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F94",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I221",
      "target": "I4",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F95",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I17",
      "target": "I226",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F96",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I227",
      "target": "I228",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F97",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I229",
      "target": "I230",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F98",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I219",
      "target": "I232",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F99",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I220",
      "target": "I233",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F100",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I234",
      "target": "I235",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.64,
      "evidence_strength": "couple repeated in compatible compiled histories",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 10 audit: retained as a plausible tree-derived couple; no original marriage or joint transaction was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F101",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I236",
      "target": "I237",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "evidence_strength": "compatible compiled histories; no direct joint record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: retained as a plausible compiled couple; no original marriage or joint transaction was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F105",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I244",
      "target": "I245",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "jointly named parents plus nearly illegible 1597 marriage entry",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 13 audit: both are directly named as the younger Martin's parents. The first Erpfingen marriage entry, about Nov 1597, is reported as nearly illegible, so the couple is slightly below direct-entry certainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F106",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I246",
      "target": "I247",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "unsourced Ancestry public-tree couple only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 14 audit: retained as a low-confidence compiled couple; no marriage or joint record was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F107",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I248",
      "target": "I249",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "gedcom",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from uploaded GEDCOM export.ged"
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F108",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I250",
      "target": "I251",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "gedcom",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from uploaded GEDCOM export.ged"
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_JOHANN_FRIEDRICH_GABEL_MARIA_SPIESS",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I109",
      "target": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "multiple published profiles give a dated 1725 German marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF"
      ],
      "source_note": "Multiple compiled profiles report Johann Friedrich Gabel and Maria Magdalena Spiess married 22 May 1725. No original marriage-register image was inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804_HV4_NAN",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "target": "HV4_NANCY_CATHERINE_SMITH_12_OCT_1756_14_SEP",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Elisha I. McNew spouse/parent pair with Nancy Catherine Smith."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SE_HV4_WILLIAM_J_MCNEW_1786_1839_HV4_LUCY_W",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "HV4_WILLIAM_J_MCNEW_1786_1839",
      "target": "HV4_LUCY_WALKER_BET_1785_AND_1794_BEFORE_180",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Spouse of William J. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SE_HV4_WILLIAM_J_MCNEW_1786_1839_HV4_SARAH_",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "HV4_WILLIAM_J_MCNEW_1786_1839",
      "target": "HV4_SARAH_CATHERINE_SMITH_1790_5_APR_1883",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Spouse of William J. McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SE_HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820_HV4_SARAH_",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820",
      "target": "HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "evidence_strength": "public_gramps_tree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "John McNew married Sarah Athey."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV4_SE_HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876_",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "target": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.83,
      "evidence_strength": "two compatible genealogies and cemetery transcription agree on the marriage date and place; spouse surname remains disputed",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "All three sources place John S. McNew in a marriage at Pettis County, Missouri on 8 November 1839. The Nathan McNew tree calls the wife Sarah Lusby; the Deepwater cemetery transcription and Cook genealogy call her Sarah A. Willoughby. The relationship is retained as probable, with Willoughby currently the better-supported surname, pending the original marriage entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV5_JOHANNES_IGNATIUS_URSULA_BATZER",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I241",
      "target": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-register-based pedigree gives marriage 10 May 1670 and a ten-child family",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish-register-based pedigree gives their Erpfingen marriage as 10 May 1670, following proclamation at Willmandingen on 17 Apr 1670, and ten children born 1671-1692."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV5_MARTIN_GOBEL_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I243",
      "target": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-register-based pedigree identifies the couple and approximately 1638 marriage with ten children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 12 terminal expansion: the Weigel parish-based pedigree identifies Martin Göbel and Anna Kissling as a couple married about 1638 with ten children. No exact marriage entry was quoted, so confidence remains below direct-entry certainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_SE_GEORG_LEFFLER",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "HV10_GEORG_HEINRICH_FRICKE_1827_1848",
      "target": "HV10_ANNA_DOROTHEE_LEFFLER_ABT1827",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "German marriage + child baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_LEFFLER_1842_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "Marriage 17 Apr 1842 Hannover; both named as parents in 1845 baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "HV10_SE_EBERHARD_SOPHIE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "HV10_EBERHARD_HEINRICH_FRICKE_ABT1788",
      "target": "HV10_SOPHIE_ELISABETH_ANGENETEN_ABT1795",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "German marriage + child baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_EBERHARD_SOPHIE_1820_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "Marriage 1820 Gütersloh; both named in Georg Heinrich Fricke 1827 baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_SE_SAMPSON_RHEAD_JULIA_GLOVER",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I139",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit 1819 church marriage plus census and memorial continuity",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "C_WIKITREE_SE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_ANN_CARTWRIGHT",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_SAMPSON",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_HANDLEY",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": "marriage profile + public tree parent-pair hypothesis",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "C_INDEX_SE_JOHN_ALKIN_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_INDEX_JOHN_ALKIN_FATHER_OF_MARY",
      "target": "C_INDEX_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_ALKIN",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "marriage index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_ALKINS_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_MARRIAGE_1667"
      ],
      "source_note": "Marriage index records John Alkins and Elizabeth Bagnald married 13 Jun 1667 at Bramshall, Staffordshire."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_INDEX_SE_RICHARD_CARTWRIGHT_MARY_ALLKIN",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_INDEX_RICHARD_CARTWRIGHT_HUSBAND_OF_MARY_ALLKIN",
      "target": "C_WIKITREE_MARY_ALKIN_CARTWRIGHT",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC1825_SE_LEVI_HANBY_RHEAD_HENRIETTA",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC1825_LEVI_HANBY_RHEAD",
      "target": "SRC1825_HENRIETTA_RHEAD",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "child baptism parent pair",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57"
      ],
      "source_note": "Inferred parent-pair relationship from Richard Rhead 1825 Burslem baptism naming father Levi Hanby Rhead and mother Henrietta."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_SE_GEORGE_RHEAD_JANE_GODWIN",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "target": "C_MEMORIAL_JANE_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "memorial spouse link",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Jane Godwin Rhead as spouse of George Rhead, married 1847."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_SE_GEORGE_RHEAD_MARGARET_TURNER",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "target": "C_MEMORIAL_MARGARET_TURNER_RHEAD",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "memorial spouse link",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial lists Margaret Turner Rhead as spouse of George Rhead, married 1854."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_MEMORIAL_SE_GEORGE_RHEAD_MARY_ANN_BEARDMORE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "target": "C_MEMORIAL_MARY_ANN_BEARDMORE_RHEAD",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "memorial spouse/burial link",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Memorial says George Rhead was buried with wife Mary Ann Rhead; also lists Mary Ann Beardmore Rhead as spouse, married 1866."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F1",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I1",
      "target": "I2",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 1.0
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F14",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I41",
      "target": "I42",
      "status": "accepted_gedcom",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "evidence_strength": "user confirmation plus civil marriage registration",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F16",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I49",
      "target": "I50",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct 1899 parish marriage plus 1901, 1911, and 1921 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_RHEAD_MORRALL_1899_WOLVERHAMPTON_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_MORRALL_FAMILYSEARCH_9WWH_TDG"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 5 Jun 1899 Wolverhampton parish marriage names Rosa Beatrice Morrall and Bernal Bright Rhead. Their 1901, 1911, and 1921 census households independently continue them as spouses with children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F4",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I9",
      "target": "I10",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "evidence_strength": "user confirmation, two census households, and death certificate naming spouse",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1973"
      ],
      "source_note": "George and Mary Sue appear as spouses in the 1940 and 1950 census households. George's 1973 death certificate names spouse Mary Sue Henderson, and Matthew confirms the relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F54",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I137",
      "target": "I138",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1854 church marriage plus 1861, 1881, and 1891 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1861_HEYWOOD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Helen Waterhouse and Richard Rhead married on 10 Apr 1854 at Birmingham St Stephen. The 1861, 1881, and 1891 censuses independently continue Richard and Ellen as spouses; Read/Rhead and Helen/Ellen are documented variants."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F55",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "target": "I140",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct 1832 parish marriage and parent records",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_F56",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I141",
      "target": "I142",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.998,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit 1793 Trentham parish marriage plus child baptisms",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_MARRIAGE_1793",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_EXTRACTED_PARISH_ENTRY"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SE_SCHAAF_GONDER",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821",
      "target": "C_GONDER_ANNA_ELISABETHA_1822",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "spouses named in Lutheran index; cross-record identities probabilistic",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Lutheran index explicitly names Johannes Schaaf as Anna Elisabetha Gunder Schaaf's spouse."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SE_GONDER_DECHER",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_GONDER_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "target": "C_DECHER_ANNA_CATHARINA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "couple named in marriage index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826"
      ],
      "source_note": "Marriage index records Johann Caspar Gonter and Catharina Decher on 30 Apr 1826 in Obergleen."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SE_GONTER_BALTHASAR_BARBARA",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_GONTER_JOHANN_BALTHASAR",
      "target": "C_GONTER_BARBARA_CATHARINA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "co-parent couple named in son's marriage index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826"
      ],
      "source_note": "Johann Balthasar and Barbara Catharina are jointly named as Johann Caspar's parents; their partnership is inferred from that parent pair."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SE_GONDER_DIETRICH_WENDEL",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_GONDER_DIETRICH",
      "target": "C_WENDEL_ANNA_INCOMPLETE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct 1761 parish marriage index and 1762 co-parent baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762",
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761"
      ],
      "source_note": "Johann Dietrich Gunter/Gonder married Anna Catharina Wendel on 31 Mar 1761 at Obergleen. They are jointly named as parents of Johann Balthasar in January 1762."
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SE_GONTER_BALTHASAR_BENDER",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_GONTER_JOHANN_BALTHASAR",
      "target": "C_BENDER_ANNA_MARGARETHA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.85
    },
    {
      "id": "C_SE_SCHAEF_ELIZABETH_NEWARK",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821",
      "target": "C_SCHAAF_ELIZABETH_ABT1823",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "inferred spouse in 1870 census; probable widower in 1880",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_1880_JOHN_SCHAAF_NEWARK"
      ],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth is John Schaef's inferred spouse in 1870; the probable same John was widowed in 1880."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_SP_MARTIN_PHELPS_EDA_CAUNTIS",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "target": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "direct marriage index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Married 17 Feb 1820 in Washington County, Virginia. A later child record independently preserves spouse surname Cauntis."
    },
    {
      "id": "E_SP_MARTIN_PHELPS_MALINDA",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "target": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "repeated census co-residence and death index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_DEATH_1882"
      ],
      "source_note": "Malinda appears with Martin from 1850 through 1880 and is named as his spouse in the 1882 death index."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_SARAH_POYNER_THOMAS_BOTTON",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I140",
      "target": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1852 parish marriage plus 1851-1871 household continuity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The couple appeared together under the Botton spelling in 1851 and formally married at Shelton St Mark on 19 Dec 1852. The 1861 and 1871 censuses continue them as Thomas and Sarah Boulton at Hanford."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_DELIA_TALLEY_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "target": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "Washington County marriage-register transcription plus the independent 1870 blended household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Washington County marriage-register transcription identifies William Henderson and widow Delia Tally on 10 September 1866; the 1870 census independently confirms their blended household. Strong secondary evidence because the original register image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_EVAN_L_TALLEY_DELIA_TALLEY",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "target": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "1850 and 1860 spouse households plus multiple child records naming both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Evans and Adelia Tally appear together in 1850; Evan and Dela appear together in 1860, with Adelia/Dela's age progressing exactly from 18 to 28. Multiple child records jointly name Evan and Delia Talley as parents. The relationship is very strong despite spelling and Evan age/birthplace discrepancies."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_DAVID_MCNEW_ANNIE_1880",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I122",
      "target": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit spouse in 1850 and 1880 census comparisons",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "David is recorded with spouse Ann in 1850 and Annie in 1880. The repeated census identity is strong; her maiden surname remains unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_HARGIS_JOHN_ANN_WHITESIDE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "target": "C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled Geneanet spouse profile and Goymerac maternal claim; no marriage record",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Geneanet names Ann Elizabeth Whiteside as John's spouse and Goymerac names her as Amelia's mother. No marriage record is supplied, and Elizabeth Freelove is a competing maternal claim."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_SHORT_GEORGE_W_SUSAN_JONES",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "target": "C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "1870 parental household plus direct child death record naming both parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938"
      ],
      "source_note": "George W and Susan appear together as David's parents in the 1870 household; David's 1938 death record independently names George Shortt and Susan Jones as his parents. This establishes the parental couple strongly, although no direct marriage record has been found."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_GIBSON_JOHN_SARAH_CLARKE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "target": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "1883 civil marriage index plus compatible census family and compiled profile",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Gibson and Sarah Clark appear on the same Q4 1883 Monaghan marriage-index page. John's later census household and compiled family profile support the couple; the exact ceremony date requires the certificate."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_CLARKE_DAVID_ELIZABETH_BOYD",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "target": "C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct 20 Jul 1854 marriage index naming both fathers",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_CLARKE_JAMES_UNKNOWN_MARTIN",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "target": "C_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_MOTHER_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "evidence_strength": "single compiled tree parent pair; mother unidentified",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_WILLIAM_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "target": "SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit husband and wife in four census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "William and Martha are consistently recorded as husband and wife from 1851 through 1881."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_RICHARD_HANNAH_MORRALL_1851",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "target": "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit 1837 parish marriage plus 1841 and 1851 census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1841_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1853",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837"
      ],
      "source_note": "Richard Morrall and Hannah Grindly married on 4 Jul 1837 in Shropshire. Their named fathers were Samuel Morrall and Thomas Grindly. The 1841 and 1851 households continue the couple with their children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_1861",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "target": "SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "probable civil marriage pairing and two census spouse households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Q1 1861 marriage-index page and Richard's 1861 and 1871 census households support Mary Ann Ball as his second wife. Confidence is below absolute because the index page contains two possible couples."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_1777",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit 1777 Forton church marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Grindley and Elizabeth Pickin married on 31 Dec 1777 at Forton All Saints; a child christening index names them as Thomas Grindley's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_JOHN_READ_SARAH_PERRY_1750",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_JOHN_READ_FATHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "target": "SRC_SARAH_READ_MOTHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "jointly named as parents in their son Richard’s baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753"
      ],
      "source_note": "John and Sarah are securely a parental couple in the 1753 Stoke baptism. No marriage date, Sarah’s maiden name, or identification with the Wolverhampton John Read–Sarah Perry couple is asserted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_RICHARD_READ_BETTY_PILSBURY_1780",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I141",
      "target": "SRC_BETTY_PILSBURY_WIFE_RICHARD_READ",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_1799",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "target": "SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit 1799 Ashbourne parish marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802"
      ],
      "source_note": "James Waterhouse and Hannah Needham married on 26 Nov 1799 at Ashbourne St Oswald; John's 1802 baptism identifies them as his parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_CANDIDATE_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_1758",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "target": "C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit parish marriage and marriage license",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758"
      ],
      "source_note": "Edward Needham and Hannah Mellor married on 11 Dec 1758 at Ashbourne St Oswald."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_SE_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_1794",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "I65",
      "target": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "dated county marriage bond naming both spouses",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert Lavinder and Nancy Willis married in Franklin County, Virginia, on 27 Feb 1794."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_SE_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_1782",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "target": "C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "dated North Carolina marriage bond naming both spouses",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782"
      ],
      "source_note": "Samuel Felps and Susannah Vines married in Lincoln County on 13 Feb 1782."
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_SE_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_MARY_ASTEN_1684",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD_1684",
      "target": "C_MARY_ASTEN_WIFE_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_1684",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_SE_THOMAS_EMERYE_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_1632",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_THOMAS_EMERYE_HUSBAND_ISABEL_BAGNOLD",
      "target": "C_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_1601_WIFE_THOMAS_EMERYE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "CE_SE_MARIA_BRASSINGTON_FRANCISCUS_MELLOR_1694",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_MARIA_BRASSINGTON_WIFE_FRANCIS_MELLOR_1694",
      "target": "C_FRANCISCUS_MELLOR_HUSBAND_MARIA_BRASSINGTON_1694",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_SARAH_GISE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "target": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "strong",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_CENSUS_1800_1830"
      ],
      "source_note": "The pension packet identifies Sarah as Christian's widow; the Maryland service record reports their 1780 Frederick County marriage; the 1830 census age bands fit the couple."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_HENRY_COUNTISS_MARY_RUSSELL",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
      "target": "C_MARY_RUSSELL_COUNTISS",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "weak",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A community tree names Mary Russell as Henry's wife. The 1820 household contains a woman of compatible age but does not name her."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_GONDER_JOHANNES_ENGEL_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_GONDER_JOHANNES",
      "target": "C_ENGEL_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "spouse directly named in Lutheran birth-and-baptism index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_UNNAMED_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Germany birth-and-baptism index directly names Johannes Gonder as Anna Elisabetha Engel's spouse and records their unnamed female child baptized at Obergleen in June 1762."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_JOHN_ISABEL_HENDERSON_SC_1850",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_HENDERSON_JOHN_ALLOA_1787_GILES_1843",
      "target": "C_ISABEL_HENDERSON_SC_1790",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "inferred spouse relationship in 1850 census household",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "John and Isabel are indexed in the same 1850 household and the supplied census transcript infers them as spouses."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_JOHN_HARGIS_I_MARY_FOUNTAIN_LOW",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "target": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "spouse directly named in a birth/christening index and repeated by compiled profile and memorial",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SELECT_BIRTHS_MARY_JOHN_HIRGES_CHILD_JOHN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_MARY_ANN_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS_1714",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661"
      ],
      "source_note": "A birth/christening index names Mary as spouse of John Hirges and mother of John; Geneanet and the memorial identify the couple as Mary Fountain and John Draper Hargis. The family match is strong, though no original marriage image was supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_JOHN_HARGIS_1695_GRACE_BOSWELL_LOW",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "target": "C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "multiple compiled profiles name the couple",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722"
      ],
      "source_note": "Multiple compiled profiles name Grace Boswell as wife of the reported 1695 John and mother of the next John. No direct marriage or probate record names Grace."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_JOHN_HARGIS_1695_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_1725_LOW",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "target": "C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "evidence_strength": "parish marriage and probable child identified; groom’s wider identity unresolved",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EARLY_VA_MARRIAGES_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_JOHN_HARGES_1725",
        "ROOTS26_LUTHREL_STPAUL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage is now located in Saint Paul’s Parish, Stafford County: John Harges and Elizabeth Luthrel, 1 October 1725, with a probable daughter Mildred born in 1726. The reported 1695 John is of a plausible age, but no shared property, relative or other distinguishing detail yet identifies him as this groom. Grace Boswell could represent another marriage, another John or a mistaken compiled attribution. The candidate link retains its low confidence pending comparison of those households."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_WILLIAM_HARGIS_ANNE_1685",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "wife Anne directly named in will",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_WILLIAM_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_ANN_DRAPER_LOW",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled-tree relationship inferred from the claimed mother of William's son",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generation 11 audit: this inferred relationship remains a weak compiled-tree hypothesis. It may duplicate the directly documented wife Anne, but identity is unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_GEORGE_HARGIS_1617_SUSANNAH_LEA",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "target": "C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled marriage index and Geneanet name the couple",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARRIAGE_INDEX_GEORGE_HARGIS_SUSANNAH_LEA"
      ],
      "source_note": "Compiled sources name Susannah Lea as spouse of an adult George Hargis. Geo Hargas, documented in Virginia by 1642, is a plausible candidate, but no dated original marriage record links them and the London infant was a different person."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_URIAH_JOANNA_LEA_PARENTS_1614",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "target": "C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "jointly named as parents in two child baptism indexes",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_GENEANET_URIAE_LEA_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Uriae and Joannae are jointly named as Susanna's parents in two baptism indexes. Geneanet also identifies them as spouses. Generation 13 audit: repeated joint parentage strongly supports the couple, although no marriage entry was inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "target": "C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct parish marriage entry",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robte/Robert Lea and Joan Smith directly married on 3 Dec 1587 at Stoke St Gregory. Generation 14 audit: no conflict found; the 3 Dec 1587 Stoke St Gregory marriage remains direct evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_D8CCB0584B0D300A",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064217",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_80AAF8F2CB31A7B4",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "published biography and contemporary child's marriage notice",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "The biography states Isidore married Anna Pfeifer in 1931 and they had one child, Edgar Leon; Edgar's marriage notice names both parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_C1FCCBCC6F2C2EDD",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "federal appellate estate decision explicitly identifies the married couple",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Fifth Circuit decision directly identifies Elsa Schwartz Newman as Edgar Newman's wife, insurance beneficiary, and executor; their son's published biography independently names both parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_7AEFF2FB4A0603B8",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "published Louisiana biography explicitly reports the marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Louisiana biography states that Isidore married Rebecca Keiffer of Port Gibson in 1868; regional Jewish research independently repeats the couple."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_7BE241B6E1AFB29D",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "repeated published identification as the parents of Isidore and other children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND"
      ],
      "source_note": "Repeated child-parent identification supports the couple, although a direct marriage record was not located."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_ED23590AA324828D",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM spouse/parent pair",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F89; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_9B2EFAA9B644A88F",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM spouse/parent pair",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F90; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_7446F620DAE9FB42",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "Orleans Parish civil marriage index names both parties and date",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Orleans Parish index records Adeline Trautman and Leon E. Schwartz marrying 7 Nov 1883."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_21FBC64A251237B0",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "published daughter biography names both parents and contemporary civic report identifies Mrs. Leon Pfeifer",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_MARION_PFEIFER_ABRAMSON",
        "SRC_LA_WOMEN_IN_INDUSTRY_BERTHA_PFEIFER_1919"
      ],
      "source_note": "Marion Pfeifer Abramson's biography explicitly names Leon Pfeifer and Bertha Cahn as her parents; the 1919 report independently identifies Mrs. Leon Pfeifer. This establishes the couple, although Anna's parentage is not directly stated there."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_0AE876BC8DFE9455",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "mutually linked community profiles state the New Orleans marriage date and their four children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Ingenheim database reports marriage at New Orleans on 2 February 1867 and describes their four-child American household."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_749E201845364CD9",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064575",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_746E547132C59BC9",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "official Connecticut marriage index names both spouses and exact event",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Connecticut statewide marriage index directly records Max Juffe and Freda Dubowy marrying at New Britain on 30 May 1915 (CTMI-1-159520)."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_D2B5C8C54444D4DD",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "contemporary death notice explicitly identifies Yetta as Solomon Dubowy's wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914"
      ],
      "source_note": "The New Britain Daily Herald reported on 27 July 1914 that Yetta, wife of Solomon Dubowy of Willow Street, had died the previous morning. This directly establishes the spouse pairing, although no marriage date or place has yet been found."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_4BA8E730F8BF85B5",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled spouse pairing with compatible chronology but no independent marriage or shared-household record located",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Retained as a plausible compiled-tree spouse pairing after targeted searches found neither direct proof nor contradiction. Similarly named people were not attached."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_AB628A07C3573F6E",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "published regional genealogy identifies the couple through their daughter",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published account identifies Louis and Maria as Rebecca's parents, supporting the pairing without a direct marriage record."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_9196D73666BF2E57",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM spouse/parent pair",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F80; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_282636646C2EFCDB",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM spouse/parent pair",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F84; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_8CECE2DA04758F42",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM spouse/parent pair",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F10; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_C7EA0C851D9824CC",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled spouse pairing with compatible chronology but no direct marriage or shared-household record",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Retained at low confidence because no contradiction was found; the historical identity sources do not prove this pairing."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_B52B3A32D2670722",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM spouse/parent pair",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F68; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_81FD8116FF24D9C7",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "1784 Ottrott enumeration transcription names Jacob Levy and Bosel Macholen; later cemetery-memory transcription names their son Mausche",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY",
        "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published Geneanet entry cites the 8 November 1784 Ottrott enumeration as “Famille 06 Jacob Lévy + Bösel Macholen.” Its 1806 cemetery-memory transcription identifies Mausche as Jacques/Jeckel's son. The underlying enumeration image is not inspected here, so the couple remains source-backed through a published transcription rather than direct image review."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_0425C9BB3353A195",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM spouse/parent pair",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F15; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_FED252061EADE48E",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM spouse/parent pair",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F8; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_D44E158EA5ADA6CB",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "linked community profiles report marriage at Ingenheim on 24 February 1835 and identify their children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_DAVID_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JOHANNA_FRANK_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage and couple are expressly stated in both community-history profiles."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_698BEF0C5A6DFDAB",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1808 Oberlustadt name-adoption list explicitly identifies Rosalia Mayer as Salomon Frank's wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The archival list directly states the marital relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_481A3CDCCCED3B96",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM spouse/parent pair",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F93; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "GED_SE_3DC87E4591E50C24",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "target": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Ancestry GEDCOM spouse/parent pair",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Imported from Ancestry GEDCOM family F6; relationship requires independent records for higher confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SE_JERICK_LINDER_MARY_NEWLAND",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "target": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "land records name Anthony and Mary as spouses; reported will transcript names wife Mary",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Washington County deed abstracts identify Anthony and Mary Linder as a married couple. A reported 1801 will transcript also names wife Mary."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SE_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "evidence_strength": "indexed church marriage directly pairs the spouses",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713"
      ],
      "source_note": "Indexed marriage dated 17 Oct 1713 at Evangelisch Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_GEN7_JOHN_JANE_BRASSINGTON_RANTON",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "target": "GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "marriage transcript, baptismal household and probate wife agree",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_JANE_SILVESTER_MARRIAGE_1761"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 this Ranton couple married at Stafford St Mary on 10 January 1761; H2 another John/Jane couple. Exact names, first child later in 1761, probable Ranton/RORTON reading and Silvester probate kinship strongly favor H1. Original licence can resolve parish reading and ages."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_NEWLAND_JOHN_ELIZABETH_LINDER",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "target": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1739 Stoever marriage register corroborated by repeated deeds",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 23 Apr 1739 Stoever register directly records Johann Ulandt and Elizabetha Lintner; Berkeley deeds repeatedly name John Newland and wife Elizabeth."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_ROBERT_BARTEE_SR_MARY_WIRICK_HEBDON",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "target": "I75",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "Robert's 1711 will names wife Mary; Henry Wirick's will calls his daughter Mary Barttee",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The older Robert's 1711 will names wife Mary. Henry Wirick's 1710 will independently identifies his daughter as Mary Barttee and names her son Robert."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_BERLIN_JOHANS_ANNA",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER",
      "target": "C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "1576 baptism names both parents and parish-based pedigree reports six children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Margreth's 1576 baptism directly names Magister Johann Berlin and Anna as her parents; the Weigel pedigree reports six children of the couple. No marriage entry was quoted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_RICHARD_BUTT_SARACH_SAYER",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "target": "C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "evidence_strength": "zero-source collaborative couple claim; later alternative-wife pedigree is itself generationally conflated",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "No record independently identifies Sarach or Sarah Sayer as this Richard's wife. The formerly cited alternative placing Dinah Butt with the elder is also unreliable: county abstracts distinguish a Richard junior by 1710, making the younger man the more plausible groom in the 1715 Richard-and-Dina bond."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_BUTT_ROBERT_JANE_D1676",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "target": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "Robert's 1675 will directly names wife Jane",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship is directly stated in Robert Butt's will made 1 Nov 1675 and proved 3 Jul 1676."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_BEERLIN_HANS_AGATHA_BLEYLE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "target": "C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-based pedigree gives a 1555 Gruibingen marriage; exact register wording was not quoted",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Weigel pedigree gives a 1555 marriage at Gruibingen. Because the underlying entry is not quoted and the link to Johann is separately marked uncertain, couple confidence remains below direct-entry certainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP8_SE_JOHN_FELPS_MARY_WILLIAMS",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "target": "EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "published lineage cites dated Rowan County marriage with bondsman",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Published Phelps research reports their marriage on 12 Feb 1766 in Rowan County and names Samuel Williams as bondsman. Original bond image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP9_SE_GEORGE_WEIGEL_ANNA_DITLICH",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "target": "HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "published genealogies consistently place the pair as Elizabeth's parents; marriage record absent",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The couple relationship is inferred from consistent published parent listings; no original marriage was inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP11_SE_GEORG_BATZER_URSULA_HINCKH",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "target": "EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "parish-register-based pedigree reconstructs a 1633 marriage and ten children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "The family is reconstructed from repeated child baptisms and later records. The reported 1633 Willmandingen marriage predates the surviving marriage register, so confidence is high but below direct-entry certainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP11_SE_RALPH_SHAW_ANN_LATER_WIFE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "target": "HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "1710/11 land agreement explicitly names Ralph and Ann as husband and wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Charles County Land Records Liber C no.2 p.223, as abstracted, identifies Ralph and Ann Shaw as spouses reserving lifetime support from Edward Marlow. Ann was Ralph's then-wife, but the reconstruction distinguishes her from the first wife who mothered his adult daughters."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP12_SE_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_MARGRETHA_WIDMAN",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "target": "EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "record-linked reconstruction assigns eight Blankenloch children to the couple",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Multiple children with indexed Blankenloch baptisms support the household, although no marriage entry was inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP13_SE_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_ANNA_HANSEN",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "target": "SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled exact-dated couple with a repeated Blankenloch child group",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled pedigree identifies the couple and a large child group beginning in 1650. No marriage image or independent joint record was inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP13_SE_HANS_MOLLFINGER_BARBARA_RADLER",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "target": "EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "evidence_strength": "single derivative couple claim consistent with the named father and chronology",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "One derivative pedigree identifies Johann/Hans Mollfinger and Barbara Radler as a couple. No marriage or joint record was inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "EXP14_SE_MARTY_LINDER_SALOME_WERREN",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "target": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": "published Linder periodical expressly covers the couple and derivative pedigree reconstructs their Saanen family",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "The couple is a recognized subject of the Linder Quarterly and appears in a detailed Saanen/Gsteig pedigree. The exact marriage entry was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_1879",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "target": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "1879 civil marriage context and continuous 1881-1911 married census households",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "John and Jane are repeatedly identified as spouses; the 1911 duration independently agrees with the 1879 index."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_RICHARD_LISTER_KEZIA_PRICE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "target": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "evidence_strength": "Two independent family reconstructions identify Richard Lister and Kezia Price as a couple, while the 1851 household transcript names Eliza as Richard's wife.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1992 Wood chart independently supports the Richard Lister–Kezia Price marriage hypothesis and supplies coherent addresses and family details. The contemporary Eliza evidence prevents promotion beyond moderate confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "target": "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "direct 1799 parish marriage index and repeated shared child baptisms",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Direct marriage and repeated family records establish the couple."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_LEO_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_1808",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "target": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "shared adopted surname and placement as adults immediately before Leo's eight children in the 1808 household list",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "A strong household reconstruction, but the transcript does not explicitly label Rosali as Leo's wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_ROBERT_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_BERRIEW_1815",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "target": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "four baptisms establish Robert and Elizabeth as co-parents at Trustewelin; a same-parish 1803 marriage plausibly identifies them but lacks distinguishing details",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
        "SRC_FREEREG_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1823",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_DAVIES_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1803",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert and Elizabeth are directly established as co-parents in four Trustewelin baptisms. The 1803 Berriew marriage of Robert Davies and Elizabeth Lamb is the only matching county result found and is chronologically compatible, but its sparse transcription cannot independently identify the later couple. The marriage and Lamb surname therefore remain probable rather than certain."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_C_SCHAAF_GRAU_OG",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "target": "C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "the couple is jointly named in the retained baptism extraction and linked records for other Ober-Gleen children, although Johann Martin's exact same-name identity needs care",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "The couple existed in the Ober-Gleen records; the lower-confidence question is whether their 1848 child was the later New Jersey Katharine."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_ROBERT_ANN_PETERS_FRESHFORD",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_PETERS_ROBERT_FRESHFORD_FATHER_PRISCILLA",
      "target": "C_PETERS_ANN_FRESHFORD_MOTHER_PRISCILLA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "jointly named as parents in Priscilla's 1707 baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism proves a parental couple, though no marriage entry has yet been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_WILLIAM_WILLIS_KATHERINE_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_WILLIS_WILLIAM_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "target": "C_WILLIS_KATHERINE_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "repeated baptism entries name them jointly as parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Four grouped baptisms name William and Katherine as the parents. No marriage entry has yet been identified, so this records the documented parental couple without inventing a wedding date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_JULIA_MOSES",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "target": "SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "status": "source_backed_coparents",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "evidence_strength": "four official child-birth entries over eight years plus paired cemetery burials",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1916",
        "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Four official birth-index entries identify David and Julie/Julia as co-parents from 1854 through 1862, and their burials share Hebrew Rest plot 04-113. This strongly establishes the couple, although no legal marriage record or marriage date has been located."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_1772",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_MARSHALL_JOHN_PONTEFRACT_1772",
      "target": "C_ALLEN_ANN_WIFE_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "indexed parish marriage and banns name both spouses and exact event",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Pontefract indexes record banns on 12 July and marriage on 19 July 1772."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_B68_HIRSCH_MARIA_ANNA",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "B68_ISAAK_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_1736",
      "target": "B68_MARIA_ANNA_ABRAHAM_OPPENHEIMER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "linked local profiles identify them as spouses and Leo's parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The profiles identify the couple directly, while preserving several forms of Maria Anna's name."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_B68_DAVID_MOSES_ESTHER_NATHAN",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "B68_DAVID_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
      "target": "B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "Rosina's local profile explicitly calls them a married parental couple",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rosina's profile names her as daughter of the married couple David Moses and Esther née Nathan."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_B71_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "target": "B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "evidence_strength": "Kerry parish-register transcription explicitly records their marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Lamb and Elizabeth Prichard married at Kerry on 21 January 1785. This marriage is direct evidence for the couple, independent of the lower-confidence claim that their daughter continued into the Berriew ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_B73_ALEXANDER_SUSAN_FADDIS_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "target": "B73_SUSAN_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "consecutive 1840 and 1850 Grayson County household-age reconstruction; no marriage or probate naming the pair",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_1835_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX",
        "SRC_1840_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "In 1840 Alexander headed a household with a female aged 40-49 and children whose age bands closely become Susan Faddis and her named 1850 household. Alexander's 1830 and 1835 presence and 1850 absence make a marriage followed by widowhood the leading explanation. The alternative is an unrelated same-named woman and unrelated children replacing the household between censuses; it is possible but less consistent with the age pattern. No marriage, probate, deed, or jointly named child record has been reviewed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_B105_ROBERT_BUTT_SUSAN_GANTRELL_1607",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_WINTERBORNE_FATHER_C1570",
      "target": "C_GANTRELL_SUSAN_WINTERBORNE_1585",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "evidence_strength": "quoted contemporary parish marriage entry dated 13 April 1607",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published page quotes the parish wording. The original image has not yet been inspected, and the page's Houghton/Stickland locality labels should be checked against it."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_B106_RICHARD_GANTRELL_AVES",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_GANTRELL_RICHARD_FATHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "target": "C_GANTRELL_AVES_MOTHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "status": "inferred_from_child_baptism",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "the quoted baptism calls Aves Richard Gantrell's wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The relationship is explicit in the quoted baptismal wording, but no separate marriage entry or date has been located."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_1694",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743",
      "target": "C_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1694",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "1694 Ashbourne parish marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_MARRIAGE_1694"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert Needham and Mary Wagstaffe married at Ashbourne St Oswald on 3 September 1694. The marriage transcription describes Robert as of Brassington and Mary as of Hulland."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_MARTHA_CARSINGTON_1734",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1734",
      "target": "C_MARTHA_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1747",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "evidence_strength": "both named as parents in the same baptism; later household burials",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BAPTISM_1734",
        "SRC_DFHS_CARSINGTON_SAMUEL_MARTHA_BURIALS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1733/34 baptism names Samuel Nedham and Martha as Edward's parents. The related Carsington burial entries support the same household. No separate marriage record or Martha's maiden name has been found."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_ALICE_ALLSOPP_1667",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1668_1677",
      "target": "C_ALICE_ALLSOPP_WIFE_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_1667",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "direct parish-register marriage transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGGSTAFFE_ALLSOPP_MARRIAGE_1667"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ashbourne St Oswald's transcription records Thomas Waggstaffe and Alce Allsopp married on 27 April 1667. Waggstaffe is a spelling variant of the Thomas Wagstaffe named in the local Hulland baptism entries."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_ANN_FORD_CARSINGTON_1753",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1734",
      "target": "C_ANN_FORD_CARSINGTON_1753",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.92
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_G28_THOMAS_ROSANNAH_FELPS",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1664_1758",
      "target": "G28_ROSANNAH_WIFE_THOMAS_FELPS",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "evidence_strength": "1758 will names Rose as Thomas Felps's wife; 1738 vestry transcription gives their stated 1710 marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_FELPS_WILL_1758_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_WILL_INDEX_THOMAS_FELPS_1758",
        "SRC_BALTIMORE_FELPS_RECORD_EXTRACTS_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas Felps's will identifies Rose as his wife. A 1738 vestry transcription records Thomas's statement that he married Rose Swift on 28 May 1710; Swift was her previous married name, not evidence of a birth surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_G28_AVENTON_RACHEL_FELPS",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "G28_AVENTON_FELPS_1711_1794",
      "target": "G28_RACHEL_MCELROY_WIFE_AVENTON",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "published parish-register transcription reports a dated marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ST_GEORGE_AVENTON_RACHEL_MARRIAGE_1730",
        "SRC_ST_GEORGE_AVENTON_RACHEL_TRANSCRIPTION_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "Two published Phelps-record transcriptions report the 23 April 1730 St George Parish marriage of Aventon Felps and Rachel McElroy. The original register image has not yet been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_G28_AQUILLA_SARAH_FELPS",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "G28_AQUILLA_FELPS_1731_1788",
      "target": "G28_SARAH_JANE_SALLY_WIFE_AQUILLA",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "Geni compiled spouse claim only",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied compiled profile calls Sarah Jane Sally Aquilla's wife. No original marriage record has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_G28_JAMES_JOAN_PHELPS",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "target": "G28_JOAN_WIFE_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": "published probate transcription identifies Joan as James Phelps's relict",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1588 administration supports Joan as James's widow. It does not support the online maiden-name variants."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_G28_RICHARD_MARY_TOMES",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "G28_RICHARD_PHELPS_1497_1579",
      "target": "G28_MARY_TOMES_WIFE_RICHARD",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "evidence_strength": "repeated compiled spouse claim only; dates conflict among published trees",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COMPILED_PHELPS_PEDIGREE_VARIANTS_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "This relationship is visible for comparison because multiple compiled pedigrees make the claim. No inspected contemporary marriage, probate, land, or legal record supports it."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_G28_THOMAS1623_SUSANNA_FENNELL",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "target": "G28_SUSANNA_FENNELL_WIFE_THOMAS1623",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "published Limerick Quaker reconstruction identifies Susanna Fennell as Thomas's first wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LIMERICK_QUAKER_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLD_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original Quaker meeting-book pages remain to be inspected, but the published reconstruction provides a coherent, dated Limerick household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_G28_THOMAS1623_ANNE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "target": "G28_ANNE_WIDOW_THOMAS1623",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "published Limerick Quaker reconstruction calls Anne Thomas Phelps's widow",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LIMERICK_QUAKER_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLD_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The source identifies Anne as Thomas's widow, but gives no maiden surname or marriage date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_G29_WILLIAM1560_DOROTHY",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "target": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "published parish-register transcription calls Dorothy William Phelps's wife",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1603 Elizabeth baptism provides direct household evidence for William and Dorothy as a couple, through a published transcription."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_G29_ALICE_PHELPS_JOHN_HOPE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "G29_ALICE_PHELPS_1572",
      "target": "G29_JOHN_HOPE_HUSBAND_ALICE",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_RICHARD_LISTER_ELIZA_LYSTER_1851",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZA_LYSTER_MOTHER_JANE_1851",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "1851 household transcript identifies Richard and Eliza jointly as Jane's parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1851 household identifies Richard and Eliza Lyster as the parents of Jane. It strongly supports a parental partnership, though the supplied transcript is not itself a marriage record and has not been checked against the image."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_B71_JOHN_LAMB_SR_ANN_LAMB",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_B71_JOHN_LAMB_FATHER_1757",
      "target": "C_B71_ANN_LAMB_MOTHER_1757",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "the 1757 baptism jointly names John Lamb and Ann as the child's parents",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism establishes John and Ann as the parents of a child, supporting their parental partnership. It is not itself a marriage record, so no marriage date, location, or Ann's maiden name is asserted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_G27_JOHN_FRANCES_MCELROY",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "G27_JOHN_MCELROY_FATHER_RACHEL_1713",
      "target": "G27_FRANCES_MCELROY_MOTHER_RACHEL_1713",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": "a parish-baptism transcription gives John and Frances McElroy as Rachel's parents; their marital relationship is inferred from that household entry",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published baptism transcription supports a parent pair, not an inspected marriage record. The relationship is retained as the most likely household explanation at secondary-source confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_SAMUEL_MORRALL_ANN_GREEN_1806",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_SAMUEL_MORRALL_FATHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "target": "C_ANN_GREEN_WIFE_SAMUEL_MORRALL_LAWLEY",
      "status": "candidate_harvested",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": "community transcription of parish marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTSCHAT_SAMUEL_ANN_MORRALL_LAWLEY_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cited community transcription reports Samuel Morrall and Ann Green marrying at Dawley Magna on 14 Apr 1806, with witnesses Gabriel and Elizabeth Goleah. It is consistent with the later Lawley household but has not been checked against the original marriage-register image."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_NEWLAND_UHLAND_MUENTZ_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_ANNA_CATHARINA_MUENTZ_PARENT_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.34,
      "evidence_strength": "single derivative family-tree assertion; no inspected marriage record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEWLAND_UHLAND_MUNTZ_COMPILED_CANDIDATE_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The pair appears together only in a derivative tree. Their relationship is retained solely to make the competing parent proposal intelligible and must not be read as a documented marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_GEORGE_LISTER_GRACE_HUDSON_BATLEY_CANDIDATE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_GEORGE_LISTER_BATLEY_1705",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_GRACE_HUDSON_WIFE_GEORGE_LISTER",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "specific 1727 Batley marriage transcription in a researcher's parish-based reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_HANNAH_FAMILY_RECONSTRUCTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Batley reconstruction reports a 17 August 1727 marriage of George Lister and Grace Hudson. It is a well-specified secondary transcription but has not been checked against the original register image in this audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_JOHN_LISTER_JANE_TINGLE_BATLEY_1670",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_JOHN_LISTER_BATLEY_MARRIED_1670",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_JANE_TINGLE_BATLEY_1638",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "specific secondary transcription of a dated parish marriage and matching child-baptism cluster",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_JOHN_JANE_WILLIAM_1670_1676_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reconstruction reports a marriage at Batley on 18 May 1670 and three subsequent children with the same parental pair. The event is specific and chronologically coherent, but the original register image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_WILLIAM_SARAH_PICKIN_WHITMORE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_WILLIAM_PICKIN_WHITMORE_1756",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_SARAH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_1756",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "jointly named as the parents of Elizabeth in one parish baptism; no marriage record inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756"
      ],
      "source_note": "William and Sarah are jointly named as Elizabeth's parents in the Whitmore baptism. This supports a parental partnership, but no marriage entry has been obtained and the relationship is not treated as a dated marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_DAVID_PRICE_ELIZABETH_LAMBE_KEZIA_CANDIDATES",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_DAVID_PRICE_FATHER_KEZIA_LISTER",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_ELIZABETH_LAMBE_MOTHER_KEZIA_LISTER",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "evidence_strength": "jointly named as Kezia Price's parents in one compiled family tree; no marriage record inspected",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Gamble tree names David Price and Elizabeth Lambe as Kezia Price's parents. That supports a possible parental partnership only through the single compiled account; it is not treated as a dated or independently documented marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_CANDIDATE_ARCHIBALD_MCELROY_RACHEL_DURHAM",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_ARCHIBALD_MCELROY_PARENT_JOHN_1690",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_RACHEL_DURHAM_MOTHER_JOHN_1690",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "one internally inconsistent compiled tree pairs them as John McElroy's parents; no marriage record located",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_COMPILED_PEDIGREE_CONFLICT_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled pedigree presents Archibald McElroy and Rachel Durham as a parental couple. It supplies no marriage event or record. The alternative is that one or both names were copied from another McElroy family; this is a relationship hypothesis with ordinal score 0.10 only."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_CANDIDATE_BENJAMIN_MARTHA_HODNETT_20260730",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "CANDIDATE_BENJAMIN_HODNETT_PARENT_GEORGE_ODNETT_1787",
      "target": "CANDIDATE_MARTHA_HODNETT_MOTHER_GEORGE_ODNETT_1787",
      "status": "candidate_identity",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "evidence_strength": "both are named as parents in the 1787 baptism of the George Hodnett identity candidate",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_DIDDLEBURY_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_ANN_MOUND_LUDLOW_MARRIAGE_1804"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism establishes Benjamin and Martha as the recorded parents of a George Hodnett. It does not itself prove that they married, nor that their son was Sarah Poyner's named father. The relationship is displayed only as the 40% candidate family behind that identity hypothesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_ATHEY_JOHN_MARGARET_1711_20260730",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_ATHEY_JOHN_FATHER_THOMAS1717_20260730",
      "target": "C_ATHEY_MARGARET_LEWIS_MOTHER_THOMAS1717_20260730",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "evidence_strength": "published transcription of the 4 June 1711 St John's Parish marriage",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1932_JOHN_INVENTORY_PARENTAGE_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1932 Athey history quotes the St John's Parish entry for John Athey and Margaret Lewis, 4 June 1711. The original parish page remains to be inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_ELINOR_QUEEN_20260730",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "HV4_THOMAS_ATHEY_14_FEB_1717_AFTER_1766",
      "target": "HV4_ELINOR_LUCILLE_QUEEN_1716_BETWEEN_1769_A",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "evidence_strength": "focused published reconstruction names their circa-1753 marriage and children",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_PARENTAGE_RECONCILIATION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The focused reconstruction reports Thomas Athey's circa-1753 marriage to Elinor Queen and children including John Queen Athey. It is consistent with the existing two parent-child edges but no original marriage record has yet been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_ATHEY_CAPT_GEORGE_ANN_20260730",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_ATHEY_CAPTAIN_GEORGE_1642_1710_20260730",
      "target": "C_ATHEY_ANN_FIRST_WIFE_GEORGE_20260730",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "published Athey study identifies Ann as George's first wife while rejecting the copied Moorewood surname",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "George and Ann are treated as the earlier Athey household in Maryland. The relationship and Ann's given name are retained; the widely copied surname Moorewood is excluded because the cited land-chain record does not identify her as George's wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_20260915_SEMMES_ANNE_QUEEN",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "R26_THOMAS_SEMMES",
      "target": "HV4_ANNE_QUEEN_ABOUT_1792",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "evidence_strength": "Scholarly biography explicitly names Anne Queen as wife of Thomas Semmes",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The government-hosted biographical dictionary names the spouses. No marriage date inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "GB26_SP_HJ1689_AM1686",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "GB26_HANS_JACOB_GOEBEL_1689",
      "target": "GB26_ANNA_MARIA_SCHWEICKHARD_1686",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "evidence_strength": "published parish-based marriage reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "source_note": "Weigel printed p.55 reports Erpfingen marriage 2 November 1711. H1 this pair married strongly leads over hypothetical copied spouse error; original marriage image would verify."
    },
    {
      "id": "OT26_SE_PETER_OTTILIA",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "OT26_PETER_GUISE_ROCKINGHAM",
      "target": "OT26_OTTILIA_GUISE",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit couple in association reconstruction",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_GOBLE_GUISE_PARENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Peter and Ottilia are explicitly paired by the association genealogy; this is a compiled couple hypothesis, not an inspected marriage. Do not assign Kuffer surname or a marriage date from conflicting derivative expansions."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_OT26_WEIGELE_PARENTS",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "OT26_JOHANN_MICHAEL_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "target": "OT26_ANNA_MARIA_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "Spousal pair identified in institutional Goshenhoppen family account",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_GEORGE",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "Date and place of marriage unknown; no New York marriage assigned to the Weigele pair until immigrant identity resolved. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_OT26_DITLOH_PARENTS",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "OT26_ABRAHAM_DITLOH",
      "target": "OT26_ANNA_MARGARETH_DITLOH_WIFE",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "Spousal pair identified in institutional Goshenhoppen family account",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "Date and place of marriage unknown; no New York marriage assigned to the Weigele pair until immigrant identity resolved. See RN_OT26_WEIGEL_GOSHENHOPPEN_PARENT_EXTENSION."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_OT26_CATHRINE_FRIEDRICH_ZIPPERLE",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "OT26_CATHRINE_WEGLER_ZIPPERLE",
      "target": "OT26_FRIEDRICH_ZIPPERLE_RHINEBECK",
      "status": "supported_documentary",
      "confidence": 0.94
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_OT26_FINNEY_SALT_ROCESTER",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "OT26_WILLIAM_FYNNEY_ALTON",
      "target": "OT26_HELLEN_MOTHER_HELEN_FYNNEY",
      "status": "supported_comparative",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "evidence_strength": "explicit1795marriage; matching local Alton parent-name sequence supports identity",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_SALT_ROCESTER_1795",
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_ALTON_FAMILY_BAPTISMS"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: Hellen, mother of Helen Fynney baptized at Alton in1803, is Ellen Salt who married William Finney at Rocester on8December1795. H2: the Rocester spouses and Alton parents are two different William-and-Ellen/Hellen couples. H3: remarriage or a transcription error breaks the proposed continuity. The1795marriage directly names William Finney bachelor and Ellen Salt spinster. The Alton baptism sequence names William/Eleanor for Joseph3July1796 (more tentative variant), William/Ellen for John10February1799, William/Hellen for Helen10April1803, William/Helen for Amy18November1804, William/Ellen for Charles22October1809, and William/Ellen for Frederick19July1814. Frederick's father is a joiner. This locally concentrated spouse-name pair and chronologically coherent sequence after1795 favors H1 over an unrecorded second matching couple; a near-birth1796baptism would place the first recorded child within seven months of marriage but is not an impossible chronology or evidence of a different couple. Baptism dates do not establish conception or exact birth. Rocester and Alton are distinct nearby localities, not an exact parish match; neither marriage nor inspected baptism entries explicitly links the two places. H2 remains possible and is not zero simply because no second couple is known. Actual William/Catherine entries at Alton in1797and1800 demonstrate another spouse-name cluster and caution against treating all William Finneys as one; they do not by themselves explain the recurring Ellen/Hellen cluster better than H1. H3 lacks a located death or remarriage record. Ranking: H1 leads sufficiently to record Salt as a probable maiden surname and the1795spousal identification at ordinal0.80. This does not raise the separate0.80Ellen-child-to-adult parent links, nor imply independent probabilities or multiply them. Retain stable person IDs and make the provisional surname clear in the display name and notes. No earlier parental generation for either spouse is established. No collateral children added to the graph this pass; the six-event family reconstruction is saved for future bridge checks. Next discriminating evidence: original1795marriage witnesses/residences, Alton family burial/census records, and sibling marriage/family associations. The1841/1851/1861Ellen Waterhouse identity still carries the age discrepancy already recorded. Do not treat the family's common trade or reuse of Frederick as proof of kinship; those may guide searches."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:8",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_WALTER_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_ANNE",
      "target": "SRC_JANE_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_ANNE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Anne Crowther christening names Walter Crowther as father and Jane as mother. This confirms co-parent relationship, but not marriage date/place or marital status."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:9",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_JOSHUA_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_WALTER",
      "target": "SRC_ANN_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_WALTER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified Joshua Crowther and Ann Crowther as parents of Walter Crowther. This confirms co-parent relationship but not marriage date/place or marital status."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:10",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FATHER_OF_ANN",
      "target": "SRC_MARGT_GRINDLEY_MOTHER_OF_ANN",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Marriage transcript names Thomas Grindley as husband and Margaret Harding as spouse; event date 6 Nov 1782, Market Drayton, Shropshire, England."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:12",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "target": "SRC_RUTH_MOTHER_OF_RUTH_HANDLEY",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "FamilySearch page for Ruth Johnson lists Sampson Handley as husband. No marriage date or place captured yet."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:13",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_1697",
      "target": "SRC_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_1691",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified George Handley and Anne Cartwright as parents of Sampson Handley. This confirms co-parent relationship but not marriage date/place or marital status."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:14",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_THOMAS_HANDLEY_ABT1666",
      "target": "SRC_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified Thomas Handley and Hanna Fenton as parents of George Handley. This confirms co-parent relationship but not marriage date/place or marital status."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:15",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_JAMES_JACOBUS_HANDLEY_1647",
      "target": "SRC_HANNAH_WILD_1649",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User identified James Jacobus Handley and Hannah Wild as parents of Thomas Handley. Later supplied FamilySearch grouping gives James/Hannah marriage 3 Aug 1670 in Sheffield but also gives Thomas Handley born 1666, so the marriage date and Thomas birth chronology require verification. Relationship retained as co-parents, not a confirmed marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:16",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
      "target": "SRC_JANE_EDEN_GARDNER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Record names George Wall and Jane Eden Gardner as spouses and lists Eleanor, born 1524 and died 1600 in Droitwich Spa, as their child. This is stronger direct-line evidence than the unresolved Jane Farnefolde candidate."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:20",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "target": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:23",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Hans Martin Nagel and Anna Catharina Kieffer marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:25",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
      "target": "SRC_JANE_FARNEFOLDE_1508",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Candidate spouse relationship. Possible spouse-name conflict or alias with Jane Eden Gardner; kept separate pending more evidence. Later direct-line evidence names Jane Eden Gardner as George Wall spouse and mother of Eleanor Wall. Keep Jane Farnefolde separate pending reconciliation."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:26",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "target": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Co-parent relationship inferred from user-supplied parents of George Wall."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:29",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "target": "SRC_ELIZABETH_TAYLOR_WIFE_WILLIAM_WALL",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.65
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:30",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_RICHARD_WALL_ABT1463",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied Richard Wall and Margaret Whalley Pettenati married about 1488 in Preston, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom, and were parents of at least 5 sons and 3 daughters."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:32",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_THOMAS_WYLDE_CLOTHIER",
      "target": "SRC_ELEANOR_WALL_1524",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Thomas Wylde's second wife was Ellinor/Eleanor, daughter of George Wall of Droitwich; George Wylde I was their eldest son."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:33",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "target": "SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "George Wylde I and Frances Huddleston are a well-supported Droitwich/Worcestershire couple. Some online-tree data attaches William Wilde of Sheffield as their son, but the user reviewed William's sources and found they do not name his father; William is therefore represented through speculative parent edges only."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:34",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "target": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "User supplied William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld married in 1601 at Sheffield and were parents of at least 7 sons and 7 daughters."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:35",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:36",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "target": "SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:37",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "target": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Hans Fuchs and a mother Barbara are named together in Anna Fuchs's 1596 Oberböbingen baptism, making them the leading parental couple. A compiled profile reports their marriage as 4 Feb 1590 at Unterhausen, but the surviving Unterhausen marriage entries begin in 1597. The exact date and place are therefore not displayed as recorded facts. The couple relationship remains likely from their jointly named child; the ceremony details remain unverified."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:38",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "target": "SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis married about 1652 in Sheffield; children listed by user."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:39",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "target": "SRC_HELLENA_TUNSTEAD_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Marriage transcript identifies Godfridus Wild, male, as husband in a marriage on 5 Sep 1677 at Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul Sheffield, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. Matched to Godfrey Wilde and Hellena Tunstead relationship. Supplied profile lists Hannah Wild born 1649 under this spouse, but that predates the marriage and is treated as inconsistent."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:40",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "target": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves married 5 Feb 1615 in Sheffield and were parents of the listed Hancock children."
    },
    {
      "id": "rel:41",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "SRC_RICHARD_HANCOCK_1564",
      "target": "SRC_ANNE_ROADES_1567",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "evidence_strength": null,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Richard Hancock and Anne Roades marriage recorded from supplied FamilySearch-style profile. They are retained as a couple, but their parentage of Robert Hancock is speculative because the FamilySearch change history is unstable and no direct Robert baptism has been shown."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CHELMORTON_JOHN_TO_GEN7",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_1726",
      "target": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "1739 baptism names John; 1726 Chelmorton marriage supplies the only documented adult couple matching the parent names",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1739"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: the 1726 Chelmorton groom is the father named in the 1739 baptism and later Ranton father. H2: another John Brassington was the 1739 child’s father. H1 leads because the marriage is local and precedes the baptism, but the later Ranton identification remains unproved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CHELMORTON_ELIZABETH_TO_GEN7",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ELIZABETH_WALTON_CHELMORTON_1726",
      "target": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.54,
      "evidence_strength": "1739 baptism names Elizabeth; 1701 Tideswell baptism is a county and age match for the 1726 bride",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1739",
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_WALTON_TIDESWELL_BAPTISM_1701"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: the Tideswell Elizabeth Walton is the mother named in the 1739 baptism. H2: another Elizabeth Walton or an unlocated Elizabeth married the 1726 Chelmorton John. H1 is the leading documented candidate, but the baptism-to-marriage identity is not proved."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_CHELMORTON_JOHN_ELIZABETH_1726",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_1726",
      "target": "C_ELIZABETH_WALTON_CHELMORTON_1726",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "evidence_strength": "Chelmorton marriage transcript names John Brassington and Elizabeth Walton",
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "John Brassington and Elizabeth Walton married at Chelmorton on 27 September 1726."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CHARLES_WALTON_TO_ELIZABETH_WALTON",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CHARLES_WALTON_TIDESWELL_1701",
      "target": "C_ELIZABETH_WALTON_CHELMORTON_1726",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "Elizabeth’s baptism names Charles Walton as father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_WALTON_TIDESWELL_BAPTISM_1701"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Tideswell baptism of Elizabeth Walton on 25 January 1701 names Charles Walton as her father. The mother is not identified in the available extract."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_WITHERWOOD_JOHN_TO_CHELMORTON_JOHN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_WITHERWOOD_1710",
      "target": "C_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_1726",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "same surname and nearby Staffordshire locality; no kinship statement",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_BRASSINGTON_LEASES_1698_1710",
        "SRC_BL_ADD_MS_36664_JOHN_BRESSINGTON_LEEK_1710"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: the John Brassington named in the 1710 Witherwood lease was father of the 1726 Chelmorton groom. H2: he was an unrelated tenant or a different John Brassington. H1 is plausible from name and locality but weak; no relationship, age, wife, or child is recorded."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CHELMORTON_JOHN_1702_TO_JOHN_1726",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_1702",
      "target": "C_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_1726",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "evidence_strength": "same parish baptism and marriage with plausible age interval",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1702",
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_WALTON_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1726"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: the John baptized at Chelmorton on 2 January 1702 was the John Brassington who married Elizabeth Walton there on 27 September 1726. H2: a different John Brassington was the 1726 groom. Exact locality and a 24-year interval favor H1, but no age or burial record confirms it."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_CHELMORTON_TO_JOHN_1702",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_BRASINGTON_CHELMORTON_FATHER_1702",
      "target": "C_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_1702",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "baptism explicitly names George Brasington as father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1702"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Chelmorton baptism of John Brasington on 2 January 1702 explicitly names George Brasington as his father. The father’s identity beyond that entry is unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_LEEK_1672_TO_GEORGE_CHELMORTON_1702",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_LEEK_1672",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_BRASINGTON_CHELMORTON_FATHER_1702",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "evidence_strength": "same given name and documented Leek child sequence; no migration bridge",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_LEEK_BAPTISM_1672",
        "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1702"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: George, son of George and Mary baptized at Leek in 1672, later moved to Chelmorton and fathered John in 1702. H2: another George Brasington was the Chelmorton father. The 30-year interval is plausible, but no marriage, settlement, will, land, or burial record connects the localities."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_JOANNES_BRASSINGTON_TO_CHELMORTON_JOHN",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_JOANNES_BRASSINGTON_SUTTON_1717",
      "target": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "evidence_strength": "same surname and possible father age; no parentage or migration evidence",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CPRDB_BRASSINGTON_BAPTISMS_1714_1870"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 Sutton John is father of the 1739 Chelmorton child; H2 unrelated same-name man. Weak index-only alternative, below local Staffordshire lead."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ISABELL_BAGNALL_TO_GEORGE_1639",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ISABELL_BAGNALL_POSSIBLE_MOTHER_GEORGE_1639",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1639",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled sibling cluster; mother omitted from George baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_BRASSINGTON_SIBLING_CLUSTER_20261004",
        "SRC_BAGNALL_TRENTHAM_COMPILED_FAMILY_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: Isabell Bagnall was George’s mother, based on a compiled sibling list. H2: George’s mother was an unidentified woman. H2 is substantially stronger: the 1639 baptism names Thomas but not Isabell, while a separate Trentham record set places an Isabell Bagnold/Bagnall in the Emery household in 1632–1635. The spelling may represent another woman or a remarriage, but no evidence resolves that conflict; retain H1 at .12."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_TO_THOMAS_1639",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "target": "C_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_FATHER_1639",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "evidence_strength": "locality chronology plus repeated father-name cluster, balanced against a separate Leek Richard household",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_RICHARD_ISABELL_CLUSTER_20261005",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_RICHARD_THOMAS_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_NORTON_LE_MOORS_1622_QL3G_KC8B_20261005",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_THOMAS_ISABELL_CAVERSWALL_SIBLING_CLUSTER_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_ELLENA_LEEK_CHILD_CLUSTER_1637_1648_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_CAVERSWALL_THOMAS_ELLEN_1628_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ASHBOURNE_THOMAS_CHILDREN_1656_1659_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (0.42): the compiled 1586 Thomas, reported as son of Richard Brassington and Isabell Bagnold, is the same Thomas named as father in the 1622 Norton-le-Moors, 1628 Caverswall, and 1639 Caverswall baptisms. The name, Staffordshire locality, repeated father-name evidence, and a plausible age interval support continuity. H2 remains substantial: the 1586 date and parentage are derivative, another Thomas Brassington could have headed the later household, a separate Leek Richard–Ellena household is documented in 1637–1648, and an Ashbourne Thomas is recorded with children in 1656–1659. The original register images and any marriage/probate record have not been compared, so this remains a plausible candidate rather than accepted parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_1540_TO_RICHARD_1564",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1540",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "evidence_strength": "official Caverswall probate household plus compatible 1564 baptism chronology; no child clause Dual index evidence confirms Richard’s Caverswall baptism, but omits the parents’ given names; it therefore strengthens the event, not the proposed parent identity.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_CLUSTER_20261005",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564_20261005",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_WILL_1546_20261005",
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_INDEX_RICHARD_GEORGE_CONSTANCE_1590_1591_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_LICHFIELD_WILLS_1550_1810_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_CONSTANCE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_STAFFS_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_COVERAGE_1552_2023_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_BAPTISM_1564_DUAL_INDEX_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.28): George Brassington of Caverswall died by 13 April 1591, and Constance Brassington is recorded there as a widow the same day. Richard’s reported Caverswall baptism on 28 May 1564 fits a son born during this household’s active period, making George the leading named father candidate. H2 (.72): neither probate index names Richard, the 1564 parent clause remains compiled/unverified, and another Caverswall Brassington household is possible. This is a cautious promotion based on exact probate details, not proof of parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_THOMAS_CAVERSWALL_TO_GEORGE_1639",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_FATHER_1639",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1639",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "baptism register names father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_BAPTISM_1639",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1639_QL3K_DSG6_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.90): the FamilySearch-indexed Caverswall baptism on 16 January 1639 names Thomas Brassington as George’s father (record QL3K-DSG6). H2: index/transcription error or conflation; lower probability pending image inspection."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_CAVERSWALL_1639_TO_GEORGE_LEEK_1672",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1639",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_LEEK_1672",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "evidence_strength": "indexed baptism names Georgis as father; age and regional continuity fit, but another Caverswall George household is documented",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_BAPTISM_1639",
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_MARY_KILLEY_LEEK_MARRIAGE_1670",
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_LEEK_BAPTISM_1672",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_CAVERSWALL_GEORG_ELLEN_ANE_1632_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.78): the George baptized at Caverswall in 1639 is the Georgis (George) named as father of the 1672 Leek child, after a 1670 Leek marriage to Mary Killey. The 33-year age fit, same regional cluster, and indexed parent name favor continuity. H2 (.22): another George Brassington, especially because the Caverswall index also records a George Brassington as father of Ane in 1632. No direct migration, residence, will, settlement, or burial record proves the identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_THOMAS_CAVERSWALL_TO_ELLEN_1628",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_FATHER_1639",
      "target": "C_ELLEN_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1628",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "evidence_strength": "indexed christening names Thomas Brassington as father",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_CAVERSWALL_THOMAS_ELLEN_1628_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The FamilySearch index names Thomas Brassington as Ellen’s father at Caverswall on 31 August 1628. This corroborates a Thomas Brassington household in the same parish before the 1639 George baptism; the index does not establish Ellen’s mother or prove that the indexed Thomas is the compiled c.1586 man."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_RICHARD_PRE1540_TO_GEORGE1540_GENEANET",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_PRE1540_GENEANET",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1540",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "evidence_strength": "direct 1544 marriage for the named couple plus one compiled parentage claim; child link unverified",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_PEDIGREE_20261005",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CECILIE_ALSOP_MARRIAGE_1544_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.18): the Richard Brassington and Cecilie Alsop married at Ashbourne in 1544 are the couple reported as parents of George Brassington, probably born after 1544. H2: the married couple is unrelated to George, or George’s parents are otherwise unknown. The marriage supports the couple’s existence but does not identify a child."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CECILIE_ALSOP_TO_GEORGE1540_GENEANET",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CECILIE_ALSOP_CAVERSWALL_GENEANET",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1540",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "evidence_strength": "direct 1544 marriage for the named couple plus one compiled parentage claim; child link unverified",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_PEDIGREE_20261005",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CECILIE_ALSOP_MARRIAGE_1544_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.15): Cecilie Alsop married Richard Brassington at Ashbourne in 1544 and is the mother reported by Geneanet for George, whose birth should be after 1544. H2: another woman was George’s mother. The marriage is direct but the parent-child connection is not."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_THOMAS_KINGSLEY_1556_TO_RICHARD_1564",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_THOMAS_BRASSYNTON_KINGSLEY_1556",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.16,
      "evidence_strength": "specific local probate reference; same surname variant and plausible regional/chronological fit; no kinship clause",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_BRASSYNTON_KINGSLEY_WILL_1556_20261005",
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSYNTON_LEEK_WILL_WITNESS_1556_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.16): the documented Thomas Brassynton of Kingsley was the father of Richard Brassington of Caverswall, born 1564. Supporting factors are the same rare surname variant, nearby Staffordshire localities, and a plausible adult age. H2: Thomas was an unrelated Kingsley testator or Richard had another/unknown father. H2 remains stronger because the accessible source does not name children and no migration or baptism record connects the households."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_ALSTONEFIELD_1684_TO_GEORGE_CHELMORTON_1702",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD_1684",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_BRASINGTON_CHELMORTON_FATHER_1702",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.36,
      "evidence_strength": "regional same-name household with marriage before child; no parent named",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD_BURIAL_1717",
        "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1702"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_CAVERSWALL_TO_ALEXANDER_BRASSINGTON_1647",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_FATHER_ALEXANDER_1630",
      "target": "C_ALEXANDER_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1630",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "Oxford alumni entry explicitly says Alexander was son of George of Careswell",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_ALUMNI_ALEXANDER_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1647_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The university matriculation record directly states that Alexander Brassington was son of George of Careswell (Caverswall). Alexander was 17 on 9 April 1647, implying birth about 1630. This edge is strong; the father’s identity relative to other local Georges remains unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_1586_TO_ALEXANDER_1630_ALT",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1586_PROFILE",
      "target": "C_ALEXANDER_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1630",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.02,
      "evidence_strength": "contradicted by local baptism/burial index",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_FREE_BMB_INDEX_CAVERSWALL_BRASSINGTON_1564_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_LOCAL_STAFFORDSHIRE_BMB_INDEX_B_PDF_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The local index now lists this George’s baptism in 1586 and a George burial in 1591, making him too young and probably deceased before Alexander’s birth. H1 (same man as Alexander’s father) is now very unlikely (.02). H2 (the unsourced profile conflates a child George with another later George, or Alexander had a different father) is strongly preferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1560_TO_RICHARD_1564",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_MARRIAGE_1560",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "status": "plausible_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "evidence_strength": "two index representations confirm same-parish 1560 George marriage and 1564 Richard baptism; no parent clause Dual index evidence confirms Richard’s Caverswall baptism, but omits the parents’ given names; it therefore strengthens the event, not the proposed parent identity.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_FREE_BMB_INDEX_CAVERSWALL_BRASSINGTON_1564_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564_20261005",
        "SRC_LOCAL_STAFFORDSHIRE_BMB_INDEX_B_PDF_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_BAPTISM_1564_DUAL_INDEX_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.30): the George Brassington marriage recorded at Caverswall in 1560 is chronologically and geographically compatible with fathering Richard Brassington, baptized there in 1564. The local Staffordshire B index PDF independently reproduces both surname entries. H2 (.70): another George could have fathered Richard, or the 1560 groom could be unrelated; neither index supplies a spouse, child, or parent link. The score remains .30 rather than higher because the relationship is inferred, not stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_RICHARD_CHEADLETON_1552_TO_RICHARD_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_RICHARD_BRASSYNGTON_CHEADLETON_1552",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "evidence_strength": "same surname variant, Staffordshire locality, and plausible chronology; no kinship clause",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_RICHARD_BRASSYNGTON_CHEADLETON_1552_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.08): Richard Brassyngton of Cheadleton is an adult Staffordshire testator in 1552, twelve years before the Caverswall baptism of Richard Brassington; the close surname form, county, and chronology permit a father or near-family hypothesis. H2 (.92): the Cheadleton testator was a separate household, or the 1564 baptism belongs to another Richard; the index gives no child, spouse, or estate-location clause linking them. This remains weaker than the George-of-Caverswall hypothesis (.22) and the Thomas-of-Kingsley alternative (.16)."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_RICHARD_LICHFIELD_1546_TO_RICHARD_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.04,
      "evidence_strength": "same surname and compatible chronology only; place and kinship unknown",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_1546_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.04): the 1546 Richard Brassington probate entry predates the 1564 Caverswall baptism by 18 years, so a father or close predecessor is chronologically possible. H2 (.96): the index gives no residence, spouse, child, or kinship clause, and this may be an unrelated Richard anywhere in the broad Lichfield diocese. This is weaker than the localized Caverswall George (.22), Kingsley Thomas (.16), and Cheadleton Richard (.08) alternatives."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_WILLIAM_DE_BRASSYNTON_1345_TO_RICHARD_1546",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WILLIAM_DE_BRASSYNTON_DERBYSHIRE_1345",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "status": "contextual_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.01,
      "evidence_strength": "same locative surname and Derbyshire regional origin only; no genealogical bridge",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.01): a 1345 Derbyshire bearer of the locative surname could represent an earlier family line that eventually produced the 1546 Richard Brassington. H2 (.99): surnames were shared by multiple families and the 201-year gap contains no genealogical evidence; this is place/name continuity only. The edge is retained solely as a documented hypothesis, not as established parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_ISABEL_DE_BRASSYNGTON_1407_TO_RICHARD_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ISABEL_DE_BRASSYNGTON_STAPENHILL_1407",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "status": "contextual_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.01,
      "evidence_strength": "same regional surname continuity only; no genealogical bridge",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPM_ISABEL_DE_BRASSYNGTON_STAPENHILL_1407_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.01): Isabel was a documented Derbyshire bearer of the surname about 139 years before the 1546 Richard probate entry, so a distant lineage continuity is conceivable. H2 (.99): no parentage, residence continuity, or intervening records connect her to Richard; a separate household is much more likely. This edge records a ranked hypothesis, not established descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_C_ROBERT_DE_BRASYNTONE_DERBYSHIRE_1348_TO_RICHARD_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ROBERT_DE_BRASYNTONE_DERBYSHIRE_1348",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "status": "contextual_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.02,
      "evidence_strength": "surname continuity only; no parentage or intervening bridge",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (0.020): Robert de Brasyntone (Derbyshire, 1348 bearer) is an earlier bearer in the broader Midlands/Derbyshire record. H2 (0.980): no genealogical bridge and, for Edward, a different county; separate household is more likely. Retained as contextual hypothesis only."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_C_ISABELLA_DE_BRASYNTON_DERBY_1379_TO_RICHARD_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_ISABELLA_DE_BRASYNTON_DERBY_1379",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "status": "contextual_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.02,
      "evidence_strength": "surname continuity only; no parentage or intervening bridge",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (0.020): Isabella de Brasynton (Derby, 1379 bearer) is an earlier bearer in the broader Midlands/Derbyshire record. H2 (0.980): no genealogical bridge and, for Edward, a different county; separate household is more likely. Retained as contextual hypothesis only."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_C_EDWARD_BRASSYNTON_BEDFORDSHIRE_1411_TO_RICHARD_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_EDWARD_BRASSYNTON_BEDFORDSHIRE_1411",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "status": "contextual_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.005,
      "evidence_strength": "surname continuity only; no parentage or intervening bridge",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (0.005): Edward Brassynton (Bedfordshire, 1411 bearer) is an earlier bearer in the broader Midlands/Derbyshire record. H2 (0.995): no genealogical bridge and, for Edward, a different county; separate household is more likely. Retained as contextual hypothesis only."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_MARGARETA_DE_BASYNTON_1379_TO_RICHARD_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_MARGARETA_DE_BASYNTON_DERBY_1379",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_LICHFIELD_1546",
      "status": "contextual_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.015,
      "evidence_strength": "same surname and Derbyshire locality only; no genealogical bridge",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DERBY_POLL_TAX_1379_BRASYNTON_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.015): a 1379 Derbyshire bearer could belong to an ancestral surname population. H2 (.985): no parentage or intervening generations connect her to Richard; a separate household is more likely."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_GEORGE_CONSTANCE_CAVERSWALL_1591",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1540",
      "target": "C_CONSTANCE_CLERKE_CAVERSWALL_1538",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "evidence_strength": "official same-place probate entries: George husbandman with will/inventory and Constance widow with inventory, same date",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_CONSTANCE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.55): Staffordshire official index details record George Brassington of Caverswall, husbandman, with a will and inventory, and Constance Brassington of Caverswall, widow, with an inventory, both recorded 13 April 1591 in Lichfield Consistory Court reference B/C/11. A widow entry on the same date and in the same place is consistent with Constance being George’s widow. H2 (.45): the index does not explicitly state their relationship; the records could represent separate same-surname households or the compiled maiden-name identification may be wrong. The spouse link is promoted to plausible, not proved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_CONSTANCE_CLERKE_1538_TO_RICHARD_1564",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_CONSTANCE_CLERKE_CAVERSWALL_1538",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "evidence_strength": "compiled maternal assertion plus compatible Caverswall chronology; no baptism parent clause Dual index evidence confirms Richard’s Caverswall baptism, but omits the parents’ given names; it therefore strengthens the event, not the proposed parent identity.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_CONSTANCE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_BAPTISM_1564_DUAL_INDEX_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.20): the compiled profile names Constance Clerke as Richard’s mother, and a Constance Brassington widow is documented in Caverswall in 1591. H2 (.80): the compiled parentage may be unsourced or conflated with another household; no original baptism or probate clause has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_WILLIAM_CHEDDLETON_1546_TO_RICHARD_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WILLIAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_1546",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "evidence_strength": "same surname, nearby Staffordshire locality and compatible chronology; no kinship clause",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BC11_WYLLYAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_1546_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.08): William Brassington of Cheddleton is a named Staffordshire testator in 1546, and Cheddleton is near the later Caverswall/Leek cluster; an adult testator could be a father or close predecessor of Richard Brassington (baptized 1564). H2 (.92): he was a separate Cheddleton household, or Richard belonged to another family; the accessible citation gives no spouse, child or kinship clause. This is weaker than the localized George-of-Caverswall hypothesis (.22) and Thomas-of-Kingsley alternative (.16)."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_WIDOW_BRASSINGTON_1666_TO_GEORGE_1639",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WIDOW_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_1666",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1639",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "separate local Brassington widow household, compatible generation; unnamed and no kinship clause",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_TAX_1666_BRASSINGTON_HOUSEHOLDS_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.10): the unnamed widow could be George Brassington’s widowed mother, living separately from his three-hearth household in 1666; the timing is compatible with a mother married in the 1620s or 1630s. H2 (.90): she was another Brassington widow in the parish. The tax list gives no name, address, husband or relationship, so this remains below the Isabell Bagnall mother candidate (.12) and is not a settled identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "SE_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_ASHBOURNE_1544_CECILIE_ALSOP",
      "type": "spouse",
      "source": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_ASHBOURNE_1544",
      "target": "C_CECILIE_ALSOP_CAVERSWALL_GENEANET",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "evidence_strength": "direct parish-register marriage transcription",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CECILIE_ALSOP_MARRIAGE_1544_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_CECILIE_ASHBOURNE_1544_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ashbourne St Oswald transcription and the authenticated FamilySearch index both report the marriage of Richard Brassington and Cecilie Alsop on 27 September 1544. The index corroborates the event but neither source establishes later children or a Caverswall connection."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_RICHARD_ASHBOURNE1544_TO_GEORGE_CAVERSWALL1540",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_ASHBOURNE_1544",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1540",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "evidence_strength": "same surname and regional marriage; no child record",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CECILIE_ALSOP_MARRIAGE_1544_20261005",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_CECILIE_ASHBOURNE_1544_20261005",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_TRANSCRIPTION_COVERAGE_1558_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1 (.08): Richard’s 1544 Ashbourne marriage predates the compiled c.1545–1550 George and lies in the same Derbyshire/Staffordshire region. The transcription’s christening series begins only in 1558, so an absent 1544–1557 child entry is not strong negative evidence. H2 (.92): he was a separate Richard and George’s father was another man. No direct parentage evidence is known, so the score remains low."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_WILLIAM_CHEDDLETON_1546_TO_GEORGE_CAVERSWALL_1540",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_WILLIAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_1546",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1540",
      "status": "candidate",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "evidence_strength": "locality_chronology_candidate",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PRIMARY_WILLIAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_WILL_1546_20261005",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_CAVERSWALL_REGISTERS_C1552_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: William was a documented Cheddleton Brassington in 1546, old enough to have a son born about 1545–1550, and Cheddleton is in the same regional Staffordshire network as Caverswall. H2: the two households may be unrelated; no will clause, baptism, residence transfer, or land record names George as William’s child. This is a ranked alternative, below the existing compiled Caverswall parent hypotheses."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_PRE1540_RICHARD_TO_ASHBOURNE_RICHARD_20261005",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_PRE1540_GENEANET",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_ASHBOURNE_1544",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.06,
      "evidence_strength": "weak_name_locality_chronology_candidate",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_FAMILY_NAMES_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005",
        "SRC_PRIMARY_ASHBOURNE_REGISTER_ARCHIVE_CATALOGUE_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "H1: the reported pre-1540 Caverswall Richard could be the father of the Richard who married Cecilie Alsop at Ashbourne in 1544; the name and Staffordshire/Derbyshire locality are compatible. H2: two unrelated Richards or a compiled identity conflation. No baptism, will clause, land transfer, or residence record connects them; score is deliberately very low."
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_GEORGE_CAVERSWALL_1639_TO_GEORGE_ALSTONFIELD_1684_20261005",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1639",
      "target": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD_1684",
      "status": "weak_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "evidence_strength": "weak_name_locality_chronology_candidate",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PRIMARY_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_ARCHIVE_CATALOGUE_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PE_THOMAS_CAVERSWALL_TO_RICHARD_NORTON_1622_20261005",
      "type": "parent_child",
      "source": "C_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_FATHER_1639",
      "target": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_NORTON_1622",
      "status": "plausible_sourced",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "evidence_strength": "record_linked_indexed_baptism",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_NORTON_LE_MOORS_1622_QL3G_KC8B_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The indexed baptism explicitly names Thomas Brassington as father. H1: this is the same Thomas later recorded as father of George at Caverswall in 1639; adjacent Staffordshire parishes and a 17-year interval fit. H2: two Thomas Brassington households. The original images should be compared before treating the identity as certain."
    }
  ],
  "person_facts": [
    {
      "id": "BF_I10_RESIDENCE_1935_EAST_ORANGE",
      "person_id": "I10",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident of East Orange",
      "start_date": "1935",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1940 census reports George’s 1935 residence as East Orange."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I10_OCCUPATION_1950_CHEMICAL_OPERATOR",
      "person_id": "I10",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Operator in the chemical-company industry",
      "start_date": "late Mar 1950",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "La Marque, Galveston County, Texas, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1950_CENSUS_OCCUPATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census records 40 hours worked in the reference week and describes him as an operator in the chemical-company industry; it does not identify the employer or machinery."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I10_RESIDENCE_1950_LA_MARQUE",
      "person_id": "I10",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident at 1501 W 26th Ave",
      "start_date": "1950",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "La Marque, Galveston County, Texas, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_LA_MARQUE_RESIDENCE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The address source lacks a complete collection citation, but the city and household are independently corroborated by the 1950 census."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I10_OCCUPATION_1973_TRUCK_DRIVER",
      "person_id": "I10",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Truck driver",
      "start_date": "1973",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Winston-Salem, Forsyth County, North Carolina, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1973_DEATH_BURIAL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The death and burial transcript identifies his occupation as truck driver; it does not name an employer or establish how long he held the job."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I9_RESIDENCE_1935_WAR_WV",
      "person_id": "I9",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident of War, McDowell County",
      "start_date": "1935",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "War, McDowell County, West Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1940 census reports Mary Sue’s 1935 residence as War, West Virginia."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I9_RESIDENCE_1940_EAST_ORANGE",
      "person_id": "I9",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband George and son David",
      "start_date": "1940",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "Household composition is directly stated; the supplied excerpt does not state an occupation for Mary Sue."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I9_RESIDENCE_1950_LA_MARQUE",
      "person_id": "I9",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband George and sons David Gary and George R.",
      "start_date": "1950",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "La Marque, Galveston County, Texas, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Household composition is directly stated; no occupation for Mary Sue appears in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I41_RESIDENCE_1911_BALDWYN_COTTAGE",
      "person_id": "I41",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in her parents’ household at Baldwyn Cottage, School Lane",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Alfreda was an infant/young child in the household; this is a residence fact, not an occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I41_RESIDENCE_1921_SHREWSBURY",
      "person_id": "I41",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in the Alfred Percy and Kezia Davies household",
      "start_date": "1921",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied comparison identifies the family but gives no occupation for Alfreda."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I41_PROBATE_1990",
      "person_id": "I41",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Probate granted",
      "start_date": "3 Jul 1990",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALFREDA_RHEAD_PROBATE_DEATH_1990"
      ],
      "source_note": "Probate followed her 30 May 1990 death at Shrewsbury; the excerpt does not report estate value or executor."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I42_RESIDENCE_1911_GLEN_VILLAS",
      "person_id": "I42",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in his parents’ household at Glen Villas",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "John was age two; this is a residence fact and no occupation applies."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I42_RESIDENCE_1921_ST_CHAD",
      "person_id": "I42",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in the Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead household",
      "start_date": "1921",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "St Chad, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied comparison identifies John in the family but does not include his occupation or schooling field."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SCHOLAR_REPORTED",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "“Scholar” (reported wording)",
      "start_date": "reported; date unidentified",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_reported",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Preserved exactly as reported. Until the record and age are identified, “scholar” is treated as an education/status label, not proof that Sampson’s occupation was academic."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I45_OCCUPATION_1911_PLUMBER",
      "person_id": "I45",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Plumber and hot-water fitter",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is Alfred Percy Davies’s directly recorded 1911 occupation. It does not conflict with a later change to building work."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I45_OCCUPATION_BUILDER_REPORTED",
      "person_id": "I45",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Builder (unverified family report)",
      "start_date": "date unidentified",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Shrewsbury area, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The directly recorded adult occupation—plumber and hot-water fitter in 1911—takes precedence. Builder is retained only as a possible later career change pending a directory, later census, military record, or probate item."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I13_RESIDENCE_1900_NORTH_FORK",
      "person_id": "I13",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in David and Ginie Short household",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Sallie appears as a child with her parents and brother John E.; the supplied excerpt states no occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I13_RESIDENCE_1930_BIG_CREEK",
      "person_id": "I13",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband Edward and their children",
      "start_date": "1930",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Big Creek, McDowell County, West Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The household includes daughter Mary Sue and other children; no occupation for Sallie is stated in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I14_RESIDENCE_1930_BIG_CREEK",
      "person_id": "I14",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of household with wife Sallie and their children",
      "start_date": "1930",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Big Creek, McDowell County, West Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The source establishes household and locality but does not state Edward’s occupation; coal work is not inferred from the McDowell County location."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I27_RESIDENCE_1910_EAST_ORANGE",
      "person_id": "I27",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in brother Charles Fricke’s household",
      "start_date": "1910",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "George was age 29 and identified as Charles’s brother; the supplied excerpt does not state his occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I27_OCCUPATION_1924_CONTRACTOR",
      "person_id": "I27",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Plumbing, heating, and tinning contractor",
      "start_date": "1924",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1924"
      ],
      "source_note": "The directory advertises his trade and business at 338 Halsted and gives telephone Orange 64."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I27_RESIDENCE_BUSINESS_1924_HALSTED",
      "person_id": "I27",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Home and business at 338 Halsted",
      "start_date": "1924",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1924"
      ],
      "source_note": "The alphabetical entry explicitly says his home was at the same address as the contracting business."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I27_OCCUPATION_1929_PLUMBER",
      "person_id": "I27",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Plumber",
      "start_date": "1929",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1929"
      ],
      "source_note": "The plumbers classification and Park End Place street guide agree."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I27_RESIDENCE_1929_PARK_END",
      "person_id": "I27",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident at 7 Park End Place",
      "start_date": "1929",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1929"
      ],
      "source_note": "The directory associates the address with George Fricke, plumber."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I28_RESIDENCE_1901_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "person_id": "I28",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in her father John Gibson’s household",
      "start_date": "31 Mar 1901",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, Monaghan Rural, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Florence was age nine with her father and siblings; this is a childhood residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I28_RESIDENCE_1911_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "person_id": "I28",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in her widowed father John Gibson’s household",
      "start_date": "2 Apr 1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, Monaghan Rural, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census places Florence, age 19, with John, Minnie, and David; it does not state an occupation for Florence in the supplied transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I28_MIGRATION_1911_1915",
      "person_id": "I28",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Migrated from Ireland to the United States",
      "start_date": "after 2 Apr 1911",
      "end_date": "before Nov 1915",
      "place": "Ireland to United States",
      "status": "inferred",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1920 reported arrival year 1910 and 1930 reported year 1920 conflict with each other and with stronger chronology. The bounded interval is retained pending a complete passenger record."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I28_RESIDENCE_1940_EAST_ORANGE",
      "person_id": "I28",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband George and children Russell and Edna",
      "start_date": "1940",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Frecke is an index variant of Fricke; no occupation for Florence is stated in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I44_RESIDENCE_1911_BALDWYN_COTTAGE",
      "person_id": "I44",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident at Baldwyn Cottage, School Lane, with husband and children",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied transcript gives Alfred Percy’s occupation but does not state one for Kezia."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I44_RESIDENCE_1921_SHREWSBURY",
      "person_id": "I44",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband Alfred Percy and their children",
      "start_date": "1921",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation for Kezia appears in the supplied comparison."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I45_RESIDENCE_1911_BALDWYN_COTTAGE",
      "person_id": "I45",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of household at Baldwyn Cottage, School Lane",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The same record directly states his trade as plumber and hot-water fitter."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I45_RESIDENCE_1921_SHREWSBURY",
      "person_id": "I45",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with wife Kezia and their children",
      "start_date": "1921",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied comparison does not include his 1921 occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I49_RESIDENCE_1881_DERRY_ST",
      "person_id": "I49",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident at 23 Derry Street in her parents’ household",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded as Rosey B Morrall, age seven, daughter of Richard and Sarah."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I49_RESIDENCE_1899_COOK_ST",
      "person_id": "I49",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident at 44 Cook Street at marriage",
      "start_date": "5 Jun 1899",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899"
      ],
      "source_note": "The church marriage directly records her address and father Richard Morrall."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I49_RESIDENCE_1911_GLEN_VILLAS",
      "person_id": "I49",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident at Glen Villas with husband and children",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied record states husband Bernal’s occupation but none for Rosa."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I49_PROBATE_1968",
      "person_id": "I49",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Probate granted",
      "start_date": "26 Mar 1968",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_PROBATE_1968"
      ],
      "source_note": "The calendar records death at Wolverhampton on 2 Mar 1968 and probate at Birmingham; estate value and representative are not supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I50_EDUCATION_1881_SCHOLAR",
      "person_id": "I50",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "Scholar",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BERNAL_B_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Bernal was age 12 and described as scholar, meaning pupil/schoolchild in this census context; it is not an adult academic occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I50_RESIDENCE_1891_UPPER_PENN",
      "person_id": "I50",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in Richard and Ellen Rhead’s household",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradmore, Upper Penn, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Bernal was age 22; the supplied transcript does not state his occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I50_OCCUPATION_1911_TAILOR",
      "person_id": "I50",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Tailor",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Direct adult occupational evidence; the separately supplied claim that he worked from home and employed others remains compiled-profile detail until the underlying record is obtained."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I50_RESIDENCE_1911_GLEN_VILLAS",
      "person_id": "I50",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of household at Glen Villas",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Household includes wife Rosa and five named children."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I50_RESIDENCE_1921_ST_CHAD",
      "person_id": "I50",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with wife Rosa and children",
      "start_date": "1921",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "St Chad, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied comparison does not include Bernal’s occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_GIBSON_JOHN_OCCUPATION_1911_FARMER",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "2 Apr 1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, Monaghan Rural, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census also identifies John as widowed head of household."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_GIBSON_JOHN_LITERACY_1911",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "literacy",
      "value": "Able to read and write",
      "start_date": "2 Apr 1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded as literate; this is a census observation, not a claim about level of education."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_GIBSON_JOHN_RELIGION_1911",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "religion",
      "value": "Presbyterian",
      "start_date": "2 Apr 1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Religion was directly reported in the census."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_GIBSON_SARAH_MARRIAGE_1883",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Civil marriage registration with John Gibson",
      "start_date": "Oct-Dec 1883",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Monaghan registration district, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883"
      ],
      "source_note": "The index does not give the ceremony day, occupation, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I100_RESIDENCE_1851_BRADFORD",
      "person_id": "I100",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in William and Elizabeth Hanney household",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Maria was age four; the supplied excerpt omits a relationship field and no occupation applies."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I100_RESIDENCE_1901_SHREWSBURY",
      "person_id": "I100",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband Frederick and children",
      "start_date": "1901",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation for Maria is stated in the supplied transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I101_RESIDENCE_1851_TRWSTYWELIN",
      "person_id": "I101",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in William and Martha Davies household",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Trwstywelin, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Frederick was age six; no occupation applies."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I101_RESIDENCE_1901_SHREWSBURY",
      "person_id": "I101",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of household with wife Maria and children",
      "start_date": "1901",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied transcript does not state Frederick’s occupation. A compatible 1893 chapel-trustee item remains non-unique and is not promoted to fact."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I137_OCCUPATION_1881_STONEMASON",
      "person_id": "I137",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Stonemason (unemployed at census date)",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I137_RESIDENCE_1861_HEYWOOD",
      "person_id": "I137",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Lodger with wife Ellen and children",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Heywood, Lancashire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1861_HEYWOOD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Read is a documented spelling/index variant of Rhead."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I137_OCCUPATION_1880_INCOMPLETE",
      "person_id": "I137",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Trade transcribed incompletely as “Blaclt” or “Black”",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Not expanded to blacksmith because the underlying directory image has not been reviewed; the direct 1881 stonemason record takes precedence."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I138_OCCUPATION_1881_SEAMSTRESS",
      "person_id": "I138",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Seamstress",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Direct occupational evidence from the household schedule."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I138_OCCUPATION_1900_SHOPKEEPER",
      "person_id": "I138",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Shopkeeper",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1900_WOLVERHAMPTON_DIRECTORIES"
      ],
      "source_note": "One of two directory transcripts explicitly records shopkeeper."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I138_RESIDENCE_1900_BRIDGE_ST",
      "person_id": "I138",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident at 1 Bridge Street, Springfields",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1900_WOLVERHAMPTON_DIRECTORIES"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both directory transcripts agree on the address."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I143_RESIDENCE_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON",
      "person_id": "I143",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of household with wife Sarah",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton St John, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied transcript states no occupation, so none is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I143_RESIDENCE_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON",
      "person_id": "I143",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with wife Sarah and Tomkinson family members",
      "start_date": "1901",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton St John, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Morsell is treated as an index spelling variant. No occupation is stated in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I144_RESIDENCE_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON",
      "person_id": "I144",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in her parents’ household",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A childhood residence; no occupation is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I144_MARRIAGE_1860_MORRALL",
      "person_id": "I144",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Richard Morrall",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage establishes the couple; no occupation for Sarah is asserted."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I51_RESIDENCE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA",
      "person_id": "I51",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in Robert and Mary Henderson household",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Western District, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Conley/Counally was a child; relationships are inferred because the 1860 census did not state them."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I52_MARRIAGE_1876_HENDERSON",
      "person_id": "I52",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Conley Henderson",
      "start_date": "1876",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is reported for Rebecca in the supplied evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I53_RESIDENCE_1870_MARION",
      "person_id": "I53",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in George W. and Susan Shorts household",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Marion, Smyth County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "David was a child; the excerpt contains no occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I53_RESIDENCE_1900_NORTH_FORK",
      "person_id": "I53",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of household with wife Ginie and children",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied transcript does not state his occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I54_RESIDENCE_1880_NORTH_FORK",
      "person_id": "I54",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in a North Fork household",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_LEANAH_E_WHITE_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Leanah was age five; a childhood residence and no occupation applies."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I54_RESIDENCE_1900_NORTH_FORK",
      "person_id": "I54",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband David and children",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Ginie is treated as a census name or transcription variant; no occupation is stated in the excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I76_MIGRATION_1867",
      "person_id": "I76",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Immigrated from Germany to the United States",
      "start_date": "reported 1867",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Germany to United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The year is self-reported census evidence; no ship or naturalization document has been identified."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I76_NATURALIZATION_BY_1900",
      "person_id": "I76",
      "fact_type": "citizenship",
      "value": "Reported naturalized",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Census evidence shows status but is not a substitute for the naturalization file."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I76_PROPERTY_1900",
      "person_id": "I76",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Owned home free of mortgage",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "306 Halsted Street, East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The street was imperfectly transcribed in the index, but the record reports an owned, mortgage-free house."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I77_RESIDENCE_1900_EAST_ORANGE",
      "person_id": "I77",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband Henry and children",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "306 Halsted Street, East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation for Katharine is stated in the supplied transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I77_MARRIAGE_1869_FRICKE",
      "person_id": "I77",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Henry Fricke",
      "start_date": "28 Mar 1869",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Newark, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both parties were recorded as single."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_JANE_THOMAS_CANDIDATE_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Same-name candidate residing as a married wife",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Chad, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "This fact describes the candidate profile only and does not strengthen her low-confidence parent link to Kezia."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_ELIZA_BOYD_MARRIAGE_1854",
      "person_id": "C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "20 Jul 1854",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The record names her father David Boyd; it does not state an occupation in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_DAVID_CLARKE_COURT_1856",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "court",
      "value": "Defendant in Monaghan Petty Sessions; charge and outcome not visible",
      "start_date": "5 Aug 1856",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Monaghan, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_DAVID_CLARKE_RESIDENCE_1911",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "2 Apr 1911",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, Monaghan Rural, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied excerpt does not state occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_DAVID_CLARKE_WILL_1913",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Will-calendar entry following death",
      "start_date": "29 Mar 1913",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied index establishes the death date and a will-calendar entry but omits estate value and representatives."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_SAMPSON_RHEAD_MARRIAGE_1832",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Sarah Poyner",
      "start_date": "25 Nov 1832",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Both parties were resident in the parish. The separate user-reported scholar wording remains unresolved and is not treated as an occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_GEORGE_SHORTT_RESIDENCE_1870",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of household with Susan and children",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Marion, Smyth County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied excerpt does not state George’s occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_SUSAN_JONES_RESIDENCE_1870",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with George W. Shorts and children",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Marion, Smyth County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is stated in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_SARAH_POYNER_RESIDENCE_1861",
      "person_id": "I140",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with second husband Thomas Boulton and children",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is stated for Sarah in the supplied transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_SARAH_POYNER_RESIDENCE_1871",
      "person_id": "I140",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident as Sarah Maria Boulton with family",
      "start_date": "1871",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record establishes the middle name Maria and Ludlow birthplace; no occupation is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_RESIDENCE_1841",
      "person_id": "I145",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of household with Ellen and children",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied transcript does not state an occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_RESIDENCE_1851",
      "person_id": "I145",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of household with wife Ellen and children",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is present in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_ELLEN_FINNEY_RESIDENCE_1841",
      "person_id": "I146",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband John Waterhouse and children",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Adult ages were rounded and relationships unstated in 1841."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_ELLEN_FINNEY_RESIDENCE_1851",
      "person_id": "I146",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband John Waterhouse and children",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is present in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_SHOEMAKER_1840",
      "person_id": "I151",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Shoemaker",
      "start_date": "15 Mar 1840",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Church Lane, Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_BAPTISMS_OCCUPATIONS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded at daughter Sarah’s baptism at St Paul."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_CORDWAINER_1851",
      "person_id": "I151",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Cordwainer",
      "start_date": "22 Apr 1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Church Lane, Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_BAPTISMS_OCCUPATIONS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded at son Joseph’s baptism. Cordwainer is compatible with the earlier shoemaker wording."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_ESTHER_BRASSINGTON_RESIDENCE_1851",
      "person_id": "I152",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband Joseph and children",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton St John, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation for Esther is stated in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_WILLIAM_HANNY_SCHOLAR_1815",
      "person_id": "I182",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "Wesleyan Sunday School scholar",
      "start_date": "1815",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRADFORD_AVON_METHODIST_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The historical account says his name appears on the first page of the school’s first register."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_WILLIAM_HANNY_TEACHER_1818",
      "person_id": "I182",
      "fact_type": "community_role",
      "value": "Wesleyan Sunday School teacher",
      "start_date": "1818",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRADFORD_AVON_METHODIST_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This was a religious/community role; the source does not establish that teaching was his paid trade."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_WILLIAM_HANNY_TEMPERANCE",
      "person_id": "I182",
      "fact_type": "community_role",
      "value": "Temperance worker, cottage prayer-meeting leader, and later village Sunday School superintendent",
      "start_date": "adult life; dates not specified",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon area, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRADFORD_AVON_METHODIST_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The account describes long-term community service but does not provide exact appointment dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_RESIDENCE_1851",
      "person_id": "I183",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband William and children",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation for Elizabeth is stated in the supplied transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_JOHN_HENRY_WHITE_RESIDENCE_REPORTED",
      "person_id": "I55",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Reported resident of Washington County",
      "start_date": "19th to early 20th century; exact dates unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Retained as low-confidence locality context; no occupation or military service is attached."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_ELIZABETH_GOBBLE_RESIDENCE_1850",
      "person_id": "I56",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 67, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Elizabeth was age eight; no occupation applies."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_ELIZABETH_GOBBLE_RESIDENCE_1860",
      "person_id": "I56",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation for Elizabeth is stated in the supplied transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_ROBERT_HENDERSON_COOPER_1850",
      "person_id": "I70",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Cooper",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 67, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Direct trade evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_ROBERT_HENDERSON_FARM_LABORER_1860",
      "person_id": "I70",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farm laborer",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Western District, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The record also reports personal estate of $50 and inability to read or write in a compatible published transcription."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_ROBERT_HENDERSON_LABORER_1880",
      "person_id": "I70",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Laborer",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Saltville, Washington/Smyth County area, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A dated observation, not proof of continuous employment."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_MARY_MCNEW_RESIDENCE_1850",
      "person_id": "I71",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband Robert Henderson",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 67, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Indexed as Marga, treated as a probable name/transcription variant for Mary."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_DELIA_TALLEY_RESIDENCE_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with Evans Tally",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 19, Grayson County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded as Adelia, a documented name variant."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_DELIA_TALLEY_REMARRIAGE_1866",
      "person_id": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Widow Delia Tally married William Henderson",
      "start_date": "10 Sep 1866",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DELIA_TALLY_HENDERSON_1866_HEADSTONE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The remarriage helps explain the Henderson surname in the 1870 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_EVAN_TALLEY_LABORER_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Laborer",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 19, Grayson County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Direct occupational evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_EVAN_TALLEY_DAY_LABORER_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Day laborer",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Western District, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Family continuity and child records establish Talley as the intended surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_HANNAH_GRINDLEY_RESIDENCE_1851",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband Richard Morrall and children",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Madeley, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation for Hannah is stated in the supplied transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_MARTHA_DAVIES_RESIDENCE_1881",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband William and family at Allport",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Allport, Churchstoke, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation for Martha is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_RICHARD_MORRALL_INSURANCE_AGENT_1881",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Insurance agent",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "High Street, Keays Yard, Wellington, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1881_WELLINGTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded under the Morrell spelling variant."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G5_WILLIAM_DAVIES_CARPENTER_1881",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Carpenter",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Allport, Churchstoke, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This identifies another skilled building trade in the Davies line."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_ROBERT_DAVIES_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as father of William Davies",
      "start_date": "29 Jan 1815",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation or independent identity is present in the supplied baptism transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JAMES_CLARKE_LAND_OCCUPIER",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Occupier of a valued holding; lessor Francis J. Jervis",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The valuation establishes occupancy, not ownership or occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_DAVID_BOYD_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as father of Elizabeth \"Eliza\" Boyd",
      "start_date": "20 Jul 1854",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied excerpt does not state David Boyd's occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as mother of William Davies",
      "start_date": "29 Jan 1815",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her maiden surname and occupation remain unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_GEORGE_ODNETT_FATHER_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_GEORGE_ODNETT_CLAIMED_FATHER_SARAH_POYNER",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named by Sarah Rhead as her father at marriage",
      "start_date": "19 Dec 1852",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shelton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852"
      ],
      "source_note": "Biological, acknowledged, or social fatherhood cannot yet be distinguished."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_DAVID_MCNEW_RESIDENCE_1850",
      "person_id": "I122",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with Ann and children",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 67, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied transcript omits occupation; the title “Pvt.” is not independently strengthened by this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_DAVID_MCNEW_RESIDENCE_1880",
      "person_id": "I122",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Saltville, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied excerpt omits occupation and detailed relationship fields."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_RESIDENCE_1851",
      "person_id": "I155",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of household with wife Mary and Ann Grindley",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation appears in the supplied transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_PROBATE",
      "person_id": "I155",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Probate granted at Lichfield",
      "start_date": "22 Jan 1863",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Lichfield, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_BURIAL_PROBATE_1862_1863"
      ],
      "source_note": "Probate followed his 26 Aug 1862 death; estate value is not supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_WILLIAM_HANNY_MILITARY",
      "person_id": "I186",
      "fact_type": "military_service",
      "value": "Soldier, 1st Battalion, 14th Regiment of Foot",
      "start_date": "25 Oct 1803",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "British Army",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_14TH_FOOT_SERVICE_1803",
        "SRC_HANNY_CHELSEA_PENSION_1804"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records imply birth about 1773 at Bradford, close to the documented 1771 baptism; identity is strong but not absolute."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_WILLIAM_HANNY_PENSION",
      "person_id": "I186",
      "fact_type": "military_pension",
      "value": "Chelsea pensioner, formerly 14th Foot",
      "start_date": "16 Apr 1804",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Royal Hospital Chelsea, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_CHELSEA_PENSION_1804",
        "SRC_HANNY_14TH_FOOT_SERVICE_1803"
      ],
      "source_note": "Pension status is recorded separately from later civilian occupation, which remains unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_ELIZABETH_PETERS_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I187",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married William Hanny",
      "start_date": "25 Jun 1795",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both parties were recorded resident in the parish."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_RESIDENCE_1841",
      "person_id": "I196",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with Margaret Brassington",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Haughton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is included in the supplied transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_GEORGE_WHITE_FARMER_1860",
      "person_id": "I57",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Western District, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census household was split in the supplied index, but dwelling and family numbers reunite it with Julia."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JULIA_WHITE_HOUSEKEEPER_1860",
      "person_id": "I58",
      "fact_type": "household_role",
      "value": "Housekeeper",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Western District, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded as a historical census role, not assumed to be paid employment."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JULIA_WHITE_KEEPING_HOUSE_1870",
      "person_id": "I58",
      "fact_type": "household_role",
      "value": "Keeping house",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded as a historical census role, not assumed to be paid employment."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_SARAH_GOBBLE_RESIDENCE_1850",
      "person_id": "I81",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband John G. Gobble and children",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 67, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is supplied for Sarah."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JOHN_GOBBLE_FARMER_1850",
      "person_id": "I82",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 67, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Dated occupational observation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JOHN_GOBBLE_CABINET_MAKER_1860",
      "person_id": "I82",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Cabinet maker",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The indexed age is erroneous, but household continuity establishes identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JOHN_GOBBLE_CARPENTER_1870",
      "person_id": "I82",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Carpenter",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Compatible with his cabinet-making trade in 1860."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JOHN_GOBBLE_FARMER_1880",
      "person_id": "I82",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Dated occupational observation; not assumed continuous across the decade."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_ANN_MCNEW_RESIDENCE_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband David McNew and children",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 67, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is included; Smith remains a probable maiden surname from a child's death record."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married James Waterhouse",
      "start_date": "26 Nov 1799",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_HOLLY_TALLY_RESIDENCE_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in William and Tabitha Ferren household",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 19, Grayson County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_GRAYSON",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_1860_HOUSEHOLDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census establishes Holly Tally as a real person but does not state relationship or maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_HOLLY_TALLY_RESIDENCE_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident in Evan and Delia Tally household",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HOCKETT_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_1860_HOUSEHOLDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Co-residence supports close kinship but does not prove motherhood; Hood remains unverified."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Hannah Needham",
      "start_date": "26 Nov 1799",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_BURIAL",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Buried aged 75",
      "start_date": "19 Oct 1840",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_DEATH_BURIAL_1840"
      ],
      "source_note": "Burial age implies birth about 1765."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_GROCER",
      "person_id": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Grocer",
      "start_date": "11 Dec 1758",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758"
      ],
      "source_note": "Occupation is a dated observation at marriage, not assumed lifelong."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_BURIAL",
      "person_id": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Buried aged 82",
      "start_date": "7 Apr 1816",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BURIAL_1816"
      ],
      "source_note": "Burial age implies birth about 1734 and conflicts slightly with the marriage-licence age."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Edward Needham, grocer",
      "start_date": "11 Dec 1758",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758"
      ],
      "source_note": "The licence states Hannah was 21; no occupation is supplied for her."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_PARENT_SERIES",
      "person_id": "GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Mother in continuing John-and-Jane Brassington baptism series",
      "start_date": "1761",
      "end_date": "1781",
      "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her maiden surname, occupation, and independent identity remain unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_PARENT_SERIES",
      "person_id": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Father in continuing John-and-Jane Brassington baptism series",
      "start_date": "1761",
      "end_date": "1781",
      "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is supplied; he remains distinct from the Chelmorton namesake."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_GEORGE_MCNEW_AGRICULTURE_1840",
      "person_id": "I124",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Household included two people employed in agriculture",
      "start_date": "1840",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1840_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WASHINGTON_VA_1840_CENSUS_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The pre-1850 census does not identify which two household members performed the agricultural work, so this is not simplified to George alone being a farmer."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_GEORGE_MCNEW_ENSLAVEMENT_1820",
      "person_id": "I124",
      "fact_type": "enslavement",
      "value": "Household enumerated one enslaved woman aged 26–44",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record does not name the enslaved woman. This is retained as part of the household history without claiming legal ownership beyond the census wording."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_GEORGE_MCNEW_CHANCERY",
      "person_id": "I124",
      "fact_type": "court",
      "value": "Defendant in chancery litigation concerning debts, land, and personal property",
      "start_date": "1840",
      "end_date": "1843",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_CHANCERY_DAVID_SON"
      ],
      "source_note": "The proceedings distinguish George Sr. and George Jr.; they also name or imply multiple children and provide direct evidence that David was George Sr.'s son."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_CHARLES_HANNEY_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I188",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Catherine Waine",
      "start_date": "8 Jul 1765",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is supplied in the indexed evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL",
      "person_id": "I188",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Buried",
      "start_date": "8 Jan 1798",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL_1798"
      ],
      "source_note": "Death is recorded as 1797 or before burial rather than treating burial date as death date."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_CATHERINE_WAINE_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I189",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Charles Hanney",
      "start_date": "8 Jul 1765",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is supplied; profile-derived birth and death remain qualified."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_ISAIAH_PETERS_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I190",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Betty Willis; witnesses John Butche and Richard Gibbs",
      "start_date": "18 Jun 1764",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage does not prove Isaiah's reported exact birth or death or his relationship to Elizabeth Peters."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_BETTY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I191",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Isaiah Peters; witnesses John Butche and Richard Gibbs",
      "start_date": "18 Jun 1764",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage does not prove Betty's reported birth details or her relationship to Elizabeth Peters."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FARMER_1850",
      "person_id": "I60",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Greene County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GREENE_COUNTY_MAGAZINE_1850_WHITE_TRANSCRIPT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Household continuity with Frances and adult children identifies the target couple."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FARMER_1860",
      "person_id": "I60",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Greene County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A second dated observation supporting continued farming."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_BENJAMIN_WHITE_ENSLAVEMENT_1840",
      "person_id": "I60",
      "fact_type": "enslavement",
      "value": "Household enumerated six enslaved people",
      "start_date": "1840",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Greene County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_W_WHITE_1840_GREENE_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Identity with the 1850 Benjamin and Frances household is probable but not explicit; the enslaved people are unnamed in the supplied census transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_FRANCES_WHITE_RESIDENCE_1850",
      "person_id": "I61",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with Benjamin White and adult children or household members",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Greene County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GREENE_COUNTY_MAGAZINE_1850_WHITE_TRANSCRIPT"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is supplied for Frances."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_FRANCES_WHITE_RESIDENCE_1860",
      "person_id": "I61",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with Benjamin White",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Greene County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her presence contradicts the separate 1836 Texas death claim."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_ELIZABETH_GOBBLE_RESIDENCE_1850",
      "person_id": "I83",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband William Gobble and Mary and Michael",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 67, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied census excerpt gives no occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_RESIDENCE_1850",
      "person_id": "I84",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with wife Elizabeth and Mary and Michael",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "District 67, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied excerpt gives no occupation, so none is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_AMELIA_HARGIS_CHANCERY_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Wife in George McNew Sr. family described in chancery testimony",
      "start_date": "1840",
      "end_date": "1843",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_CHANCERY_DAVID_SON"
      ],
      "source_note": "The testimony directly names George's sons but Amelia's maternal relationship to David remains contextual rather than explicit."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married John Greenley/Grindley",
      "start_date": "31 Dec 1777",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation, age, or parents are supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_JOHN_GRINDLEY_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Elizabeth Pickin",
      "start_date": "31 Dec 1777",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded under Greenley/Grunley variants; no occupation is supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_MARTIN_PHELPS_FARMER_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Dated occupational observation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_MARTIN_PHELPS_FARMER_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Dated occupational observation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_MARTIN_PHELPS_FARMER_BLIND_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The same census records him as blind; birthplace conflicts with earlier censuses."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_MARTIN_PHELPS_BLIND_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "fact_type": "disability",
      "value": "Recorded blind",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Historical census wording; no cause or duration is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G7_MARTIN_PHELPS_LAND_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Purchased approximately 100 acres with John Phelps",
      "start_date": "3 Sep 1841",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Little Moccasin Gap, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WASHINGTON_VA_DEED_GILMER_PHELPS_1841"
      ],
      "source_note": "Online Washington County deed abstract identifies Martin and John Phelps as purchasers from the William Gilmer estate; original deed image remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Robert Lavinder",
      "start_date": "27 Feb 1794",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Franklin County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794"
      ],
      "source_note": "This proves the couple but not Nancy's proposed motherhood of Fanny; a separate 1795 Robert/Milly entry remains unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_ANN_WHITESIDE_MOTHER_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported as Amelia Hargis's mother; likely skipped-generation claim",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia or North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE_PROFILE_REVIEW"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ann is more consistently placed as wife of the John born about 1722 and possible mother of a later John, not directly of Amelia."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_MOTHER_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported as Amelia Hargis's mother",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA"
      ],
      "source_note": "Structurally more coherent than the Ann Whiteside claim, but still unproved."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_JOHN_HARGIS_CASWELL_1777",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Possible John Hargis in St. Luke District compiled census",
      "start_date": "1777",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Caswell County, North Carolina, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Identity with the reported 1722 John is possible, not proved."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_JOHN_HARGIS_ENSIGN_1777",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "fact_type": "military_service",
      "value": "Possible ensign, Virginia 13th Regiment",
      "start_date": "Dec 1777",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The military record is chronologically plausible but cannot resolve the 1722-versus-1742 generational conflict."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_SAMUEL_FELPS_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Susannah Vines; bondsman George Winfree, witness James McEwin",
      "start_date": "13 Feb 1782",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Lincoln County, North Carolina, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reported 1767 birth would make Samuel about fifteen, so his birth estimate remains questionable."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_SAMUEL_FELPS_RESIDENCE_1790",
      "person_id": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of household",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Rowan County, North Carolina, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_1790_ROWAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Pre-1850 household members are unnamed."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_SAMUEL_FELPS_WILL",
      "person_id": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Will: wife Susan received the estate for life; remaining property went to daughter Sarah Phelps; Charles H. Gilmer was executor",
      "start_date": "14 Sep 1846",
      "end_date": "Apr 1847",
      "place": "Russell County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846"
      ],
      "source_note": "The will is dated 14 September 1846, first offered in court on 2 March 1847, and recorded after final proof in April 1847. It names daughter Sarah but does not state that she was the only child and does not name Martin Vines Phelps."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_SARAH_GISE_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Christian Gobble",
      "start_date": "fall 1780",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Frederick County, Maryland, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Exact day was not established."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_SARAH_GISE_WIDOW_PENSION",
      "person_id": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "fact_type": "military_pension",
      "value": "Applied for Revolutionary War widow's pension",
      "start_date": "1 Feb 1842",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Floyd County, Kentucky, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The pension derives from Christian Gobble's Maryland service."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Samuel Felps; bondsman George Winfree, witness James McEwin",
      "start_date": "13 Feb 1782",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Lincoln County, North Carolina, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her reported 1767 birth implies marriage at about fifteen and remains compiled."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_SADDLER",
      "person_id": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Saddle maker",
      "start_date": "before about 1812; exact dates unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Taneytown, Frederick County, Maryland, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The account says he made his living as a saddle maker before residing in Washington County, Virginia for about twenty years by 1832."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_ENLISTMENT",
      "person_id": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "fact_type": "military_service",
      "value": "Private, Captain Jacob Good's company, Colonel Griffin's Maryland Flying Camp",
      "start_date": "20 Jul 1776",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Maryland, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Specific unit and enlistment detail are pension-derived rather than an uncited profile label."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_BATTLES",
      "person_id": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "fact_type": "military_service",
      "value": "Served at the battles of White Plains and Fort Washington",
      "start_date": "1776",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New York, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH"
      ],
      "source_note": "No additional campaigns are inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_PRISONER",
      "person_id": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "fact_type": "military_service",
      "value": "Captured at Fort Washington; held about three months in the Sugar House before parole",
      "start_date": "Nov 1776",
      "end_date": "about Feb 1777",
      "place": "New York City, New York, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Duration is approximate as stated by the published account."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_PENSION",
      "person_id": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "fact_type": "military_pension",
      "value": "Applied for Revolutionary War pension, age 78",
      "start_date": "19 Nov 1832",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH"
      ],
      "source_note": "He reported living in Washington County for about twenty years."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_MARY_MCNEW_MIGRATION_1773",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Moved southwest with William McNew and four youngest sons along the Great Valley Road",
      "start_date": "1773",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Fincastle County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_CATALOG_WILLIAM_MARY_MCNEW_1773"
      ],
      "source_note": "The family history supports the forename Mary but not Berry, Eckless, or Clemons as her maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_WILLIAM_MCNEW_MIGRATION_1773",
      "person_id": "I125",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Moved southwest with wife Mary and four youngest sons along the Great Valley Road",
      "start_date": "1773",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Fincastle County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_CATALOG_WILLIAM_MARY_MCNEW_1773"
      ],
      "source_note": "The destination later became Washington County."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_WILLIAM_MCNEW_TAX_1782",
      "person_id": "I125",
      "fact_type": "tax",
      "value": "Appears on county tax list",
      "start_date": "1782",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Original tax-list image remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_WILLIAM_MCNEW_TAX_EXEMPTION",
      "person_id": "I125",
      "fact_type": "tax",
      "value": "County fee book recorded exemption from paying tax, reportedly because of age",
      "start_date": "1789",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reason is interpreted by the author; the recorded order itself is the supported event."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_WILLIAM_MCNEW_ESTATE",
      "person_id": "I125",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Estate inventory and appraisal taken",
      "start_date": "30 Mar 1792",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded 19 Apr 1792; supports death before inventory and is more precise than the reported December 1791 claim alone."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_BENJAMIN_WHITE_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I62",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Suckey Bartee",
      "start_date": "8 Oct 1786",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Franklin County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786"
      ],
      "source_note": "This directly establishes the couple but not every derivative child attribution."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_BENJAMIN_WHITE_RESIDENCE_1810",
      "person_id": "I62",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Head of thirteen-person household",
      "start_date": "1810",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wythe County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1810_WYTHE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Household members are unnamed and identity remains based on chronology and locality."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_BENJAMIN_WHITE_ENSLAVEMENT_1820",
      "person_id": "I62",
      "fact_type": "enslavement",
      "value": "Household enumerated one enslaved boy",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Evensham, Wythe County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_EVENSHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The boy is unnamed. Household identity is strong but not explicit because pre-1850 members are unnamed."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I63",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Benjamin White",
      "start_date": "8 Oct 1786",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Franklin County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786"
      ],
      "source_note": "Susan is a compiled expansion of the recorded Suckey/Sukey name."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_ROBERT_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I65",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Nancy Willis",
      "start_date": "27 Feb 1794",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Franklin County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794"
      ],
      "source_note": "A separate 1795 Robert/Milly Willis marriage remains unresolved and is not merged."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_JEMIMA_LINDER_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I85",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married John Gobble",
      "start_date": "17 Nov 1789",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_INTL_MARRIAGE_1789"
      ],
      "source_note": "The direct record establishes her maiden surname; exact birth and death remain reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G8_JOHN_GOBBLE_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "I86",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as father of William Gobble and spouse of Jimima/Jemima",
      "start_date": "event date not supplied",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record does not establish German aliases or exact vital dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_GRACE_BOSWELL_SPOUSE_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported wife of John Draper Hargis and mother of John born about 1722",
      "start_date": "reported; event dates unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722"
      ],
      "source_note": "Conflicting exact birth and death details are not promoted."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_JOHN_HARGIS_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported father of John Draper Hargis born about 1722",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Westmoreland County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1730 death often assigned to him belongs to the elder will-maker and remains rejected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_JOHN_FELPS_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Mary Williams; Samuel Williams served as bondsman",
      "start_date": "12 Feb 1766",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The event is stronger than John's exact identity or proposed higher parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_MARY_WILLIAMS_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married John Felps; Samuel Williams served as bondsman",
      "start_date": "12 Feb 1766",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The bond does not state Samuel Williams' relationship to Mary."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_FREDERICK_GOBBLE_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I107",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Elizabeth Weigel",
      "start_date": "10 May 1757",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran Church, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Original church image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I108",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Johann Friedrich Gabel/Gobble Jr.",
      "start_date": "10 May 1757",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran Church, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Original church image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_JOHANN_GABEL_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "I109",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as father at Christian Gabel's baptism",
      "start_date": "21 May 1754",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran Church, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "Faithful institutional derivative; original register image remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_JOHANN_GABEL_MARRIAGE_1725",
      "person_id": "I109",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Maria Magdalena Spiess",
      "start_date": "22 May 1725",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported German locality unresolved",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF"
      ],
      "source_note": "This earlier marriage predates his family with Christiana Hornberger; no occupation is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_CHRISTIANA_HORNBERGER_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "I110",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as mother at Christian Gabel's baptism",
      "start_date": "21 May 1754",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran Church, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "No reliable source identifies her own parents beyond ambiguous initials."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_PLANTER",
      "person_id": "I127",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Planter",
      "start_date": "31 Jul 1703",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "A dated occupational description, not proof of land ownership."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_INDENTURE",
      "person_id": "I127",
      "fact_type": "legal_status",
      "value": "Voluntarily bound himself as servant to James Bigger for five years to settle debts",
      "start_date": "31 Jul 1703",
      "end_date": "about Jul 1708",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record states voluntary indenture for divers causes and considerations; the family history interprets it as debt repayment."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_JEREMIAH_SARAH_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I127",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Sarah Marley/Marler after completion of indenture",
      "start_date": "about Aug 1708",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Exact day is disputed between derivative 1 and 11 August claims, so only approximate month is used."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_SARAH_MARLEY_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I128",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Jeremiah Macknew II",
      "start_date": "about Aug 1708",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Marley/Marler is preferred over the derivative Marlow spelling."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_SARAH_MARLEY_ESTATE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "I128",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Sons appeared in court following her death",
      "start_date": "early 1728",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The source supports death before the court appearance but not an exact death day."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_WILLIAM_BARTEE_ROAD_VIEWER",
      "person_id": "I68",
      "fact_type": "civic_duty",
      "value": "Appointed with William Jamison to view and report on a proposed road from Beaver Creek to Calloway's Iron Works",
      "start_date": "1782",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Henry County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WILLIAM_BARTEE_RECORDS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_SUKEY_WHITE_BOND_SURETY_1786"
      ],
      "source_note": "This was a county civic assignment; it is not treated as his paid occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_WILLIAM_BARTEE_TAX_1786",
      "person_id": "I68",
      "fact_type": "tax",
      "value": "Personal-property tax entry: one adult male, no enslaved people, one horse",
      "start_date": "1786",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Franklin County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WILLIAM_BARTEE_RECORDS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_SUKEY_WHITE_BOND_SURETY_1786"
      ],
      "source_note": "The entry gives household taxable property, not occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_WILLIAM_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_SURETY",
      "person_id": "I68",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Surety on daughter Sukey Bartee's marriage bond to Benjamin White",
      "start_date": "8 Oct 1786",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Franklin County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_SUKEY_WHITE_BOND_SURETY_1786",
        "SRC_WINGFIELD_FRANKLIN_MARRIAGE_BONDS",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WILLIAM_BARTEE_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Directly supports William as Sukey's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_MARY_BARTEE_SPOUSE_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I69",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported possible wife of William Bartee",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "No marriage, deed, probate, or child record identifies her; she is not treated as Sukey's established mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_ANTHONY_LINDER_IMMIGRATION",
      "person_id": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Arrived aboard the Peggy; captain's list recorded Jerick Anthony, age 18, oath signatures Gorg Anton Linder",
      "start_date": "24 Sep 1753",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_ANTON_LINDER_PEGGY_1753"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record establishes approximate 1735 birth but gives no European birthplace or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_LAND_1795",
      "person_id": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Conveyed 170 acres with wife Mary to John Gobble",
      "start_date": "15 Sep 1795",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Fork of the Holston, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Meaningful kinship context but the deed does not state parent-child relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_ANTHONY_LINDER_WILL_REPORTED",
      "person_id": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Reported will names wife Mary and daughter Jemima Gobble",
      "start_date": "24 Sep 1801",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Knox County, Tennessee, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_ANTHONY_LINDER_ANCESTRY_REVIEW"
      ],
      "source_note": "Retained visibly qualified because provenance of the circulated will is uncertain."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_MARY_LINDER_LAND_1795",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Conveyed 170 acres with husband Anthony Linder to John Gobble",
      "start_date": "15 Sep 1795",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Fork of the Holston, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The transaction provides strong couple and kin-network context."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G9_MARY_LINDER_PARENT_WILL",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as daughter Mary Linder in John Newland's will",
      "start_date": "2 Oct 1800",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Berkeley County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800"
      ],
      "source_note": "Will was proved 27 Oct 1800; it does not identify her mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_JAMES_BOSWELL_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported as father of Grace Boswell associated with the Hargis family",
      "start_date": "reported; event dates unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.46,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE"
      ],
      "source_note": "No will, parish, land, or probate bridge identifies this James."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_MARY_FOUNTAIN_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as mother with John Hirges in child John's birth/christening index",
      "start_date": "reported event; exact date not supplied",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SELECT_BIRTHS_MARY_JOHN_HIRGES_CHILD_JOHN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Catherine, Ann, Fountain, and precise vital details remain derivative expansions."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_MARY_FOUNTAIN_MARRIAGE_REPORTED",
      "person_id": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Reported wife of John Draper Hargis",
      "start_date": "about 1685",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Accomack County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661"
      ],
      "source_note": "Location and exact year remain reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_JOHN_HARGIS_WILL",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "19 Jun 1730",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Westmoreland County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Will was proved 25 Nov 1730, placing death between those dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_ELIZABETH_LINDER_IMMIGRATION",
      "person_id": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Arrived as Elizabeth Lindor, age 11, in Simon Linder household aboard the Elizabeth",
      "start_date": "27 Aug 1733",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_ISTG_ELIZABETH_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER"
      ],
      "source_note": "The passenger entry gives age and household context, not a precise German birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_ELIZABETH_LINDER_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Johann Ulandt/John Newland",
      "start_date": "23 Apr 1739",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Earltown area, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_WVGENWEB_JOHN_NEWLAND_BIOGRAPHY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The register calls her Elizabetha Lintner of Earltown; this is residence, not birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_ELIZABETH_NEWLAND_DEEDS",
      "person_id": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Named with husband John Newland in repeated Berkeley County deeds",
      "start_date": "1773",
      "end_date": "15 May 1780",
      "place": "Berkeley County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780"
      ],
      "source_note": "The deeds establish the married couple but not a paid occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_ANN_SMITH_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_ANN_MOTHER_GRACE_BOSWELL_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported as mother of Grace Boswell associated with the Hargis family",
      "start_date": "reported; event dates unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.38,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE"
      ],
      "source_note": "No place, spouse record, or original source distinguishes her."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_MARIA_SPIESS_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Reported marriage to Johann Friedrich Gabel",
      "start_date": "22 May 1725",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported German locality unresolved",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF"
      ],
      "source_note": "Original parish image was not located."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_MARIA_SPIESS_MOTHER_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported mother of Johann Friedrich Gabel/Gobble Jr.",
      "start_date": "reported; child born 12 Oct 1734",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Germany or Pennsylvania",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF"
      ],
      "source_note": "Exact child baptism remains uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_ANNA_DITLICH_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported mother of Elizabeth Weigel",
      "start_date": "reported; child born about 1737",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reproducing profile expressly warns that the underlying collection is unreliable."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_GEORGE_WEIGEL_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported father of Elizabeth Weigel",
      "start_date": "reported; child born about 1737",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING"
      ],
      "source_note": "No baptism, probate, deed, or church record names him as father."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_HANS_GABEL_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I111",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported father of Johann Friedrich Gabel born 1701",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Göda, Saxony or Offenbach area, Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Reported 1670–1770 lifespan is unusually long and unproved."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_MARIA_REINMUELLER_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I112",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported mother of Johann Friedrich Gabel born 1701",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB"
      ],
      "source_note": "No baptism, marriage, or child register image was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_JEREMIAH_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION",
      "person_id": "I129",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Recorded in Maryland land-patent-derived settler index",
      "start_date": "1668",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1668_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The index supplies no age or origin, so the reported Scottish birthplace remains reported."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_JEREMIAH_PHILLIS_CHILD_INDENTURE",
      "person_id": "I129",
      "fact_type": "legal_event",
      "value": "With wife Phillis, bound minor son John Howard to Robert Littlepage until age 21",
      "start_date": "10 Jan 1670",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Port Tobacco, Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The court arrangement was intended to support and train the minor; no trade is named in the quotation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_PHILLIS_INDENTURED_PASSAGE",
      "person_id": "I130",
      "fact_type": "legal_status",
      "value": "Indentured to William Barton until 1674 in payment of passage",
      "start_date": "before 1674",
      "end_date": "1674",
      "place": "Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_1674_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_NEW_EARLY_SETTLERS_MARYLAND_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1674 index date may be a land/patent recording date rather than literal first arrival."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_PHILLIS_CHILD_INDENTURE",
      "person_id": "I130",
      "fact_type": "legal_event",
      "value": "With husband Jeremiah, bound minor son John Howard to Robert Littlepage until age 21",
      "start_date": "10 Jan 1670",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Port Tobacco, Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "No trade or age for John is stated in the supplied quotation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_MARY_SHAW_MOTHER_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I234",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported mother of Sarah Marley/Marler Macknew",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.64,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW"
      ],
      "source_note": "No marriage, baptism, probate, or deed directly establishes her identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_EDWARD_MARLOW_FATHER_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I235",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported father of Sarah Marley/Marler Macknew",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.64,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW"
      ],
      "source_note": "Exact birth and death remain unverified."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_ROBERT_BARTEE_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I72",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported father of William Bartee of Franklin County",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Record-based review indicates Robert Bartee's Norfolk son was likely a different William."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_LETTISHA_BUTT_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I73",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported mother of William Bartee of Franklin County",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "No independent record identifies her as mother of the documented Franklin County man."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_JOHN_NEWLAND_IMMIGRATION",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Passenger identity unresolved: Johannes Ulland on the Allen (1729) or John Nouland on the Hope (1734)",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "candidate_identity",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEWLAND_HOPE_PASSENGER_1734",
        "SRC_WVGENWEB_JOHN_NEWLAND_BIOGRAPHY",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_JOHN_NEWLAND_ANCESTRY_UNKNOWN_REVIEW",
        "SRC_OT26_ALLEN_1729_ULLAND_PASSENGER_GROUP",
        "SRC_OT26_NEWLAND_1736_INDENTURE_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Allen Johannes was under fifteen in 1729; Hope John was twenty-four in 1734. Both records exist, but identifying either as this ancestor needs comparison with the later family. The prior .97 migration assertion is superseded by a documented rival, not by a hypothetical namesake."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_JOHN_NEWLAND_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Elizabetha Lintner",
      "start_date": "23 Apr 1739",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Earltown area, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_WVGENWEB_JOHN_NEWLAND_BIOGRAPHY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Johann Ulandt and John Newland are spelling/anglicization variants supported by later deeds."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_JOHN_NEWLAND_DEEDS",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Named with wife Elizabeth in repeated land deeds",
      "start_date": "1773",
      "end_date": "15 May 1780",
      "place": "Berkeley County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G10_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Will named daughter Mary Linder and other children",
      "start_date": "2 Oct 1800",
      "end_date": "27 Oct 1800",
      "place": "Berkeley County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800"
      ],
      "source_note": "Date range runs from will execution to probate; death occurred before probate."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_ANNE_HARGIS_WILL_ROLE",
      "person_id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "19 Nov 1685",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The recorded will names Ann as wife and beneficiary, but does not visibly appoint an executrix. That description comes from Baldwin’s abstract. No birth surname, county, parents or explicit maternity statement is supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_ELIZABETH_DRAPER_IDENTITY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported alternative identity for documented wife Anne Hargis",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661"
      ],
      "source_note": "Kept separate because the will does not call Anne Elizabeth or Draper."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_FREDRICK_GABEL_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported alternate father of Hans Jacob Gabel",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Germany",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No locality or original record distinguishes him."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_WILLIAM_HARGIS_WILL",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Will left personalty to sons John Draper, Roger, and William; wife Anne executrix and residuary legatee",
      "start_date": "19 Nov 1685",
      "end_date": "about 19 Mar 1685/86",
      "place": "Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARYLAND_PROBATE_WM_HARGIS_WILL_BOOKS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Asa, London origin, and exact death place are not supplied by the will."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_JANE_JAMMER_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_JAMMER_JANE_MOTHER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported mother of Mary Catherine Fountain",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No dates, place, spouse proof, or original record was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_ANNE_JUUL_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported alternate mother of Hans Jacob Gabel",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Germany",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No locality, marriage, or original record supports this identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_HANS_RHEINMUELLER_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_HANS_CONRAD",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported father of Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER"
      ],
      "source_note": "No dates, locality, or independent identity record was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_MARIA_UNKNOWN_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_MARIA_MARGARETHA_MOTHER",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported mother of Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Identity-free placeholder remains visibly weak."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_ANN_SHAW_MARRIAGE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Named as Ralph Shaw's then-wife in an agreement",
      "start_date": "19 Mar 1710/11",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710"
      ],
      "source_note": "The agreement supplies no maiden surname or parents and does not make Ann mother of Ralph's adult daughters."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_HANS_SPIESS_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported father of Maria Magdalena Spiess",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No stable identifying event or original parish citation was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_RALPH_SHAW_LAND_PURCHASE",
      "person_id": "HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Purchased a parcel of land from George Taylor for a gray mare and colt and 1,000 pounds of tobacco",
      "start_date": "1671-1674",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES_COUNTY_DEED_1671_1674",
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_LAND_PURCHASE_PAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record directly establishes an adult land purchaser but does not name his origin or children."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_RALPH_SHAW_RENT_ROLL",
      "person_id": "HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Named in Maryland Land Office rent-roll material",
      "start_date": "colonial period; exact date not supplied",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_RENT_ROLL"
      ],
      "source_note": "Corroborates landholding; no occupation is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_URSULA_BATZER_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Johannes Göbel",
      "start_date": "10 May 1670",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "Corrects derivative 1678 marriage claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_URSULA_BATZER_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Identified as daughter of Georg Batzer and Ursula Hinckh",
      "start_date": "1 Jul 1650",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hinckh is independently present in another child's 1648 baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_LEMUEL_BUTT_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I113",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported husband of Catherine Wilkins and father of Letitia Butt",
      "start_date": "reported; events unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_CATHERINE_WILKINS_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I114",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported wife of Lemuel Butt and mother of Letitia Butt",
      "start_date": "reported; events unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Warden may indicate another marriage or conflation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I131",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported father of Jeremiah Macknew born about 1640",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Edinburgh, Scotland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.38,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1668 Maryland arrival belongs provisionally to the later immigrant, not this man."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_REBECCA_SCHRATERN_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I132",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported mother of Jeremiah Macknew born about 1640",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE"
      ],
      "source_note": "No independent identity was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_ELIZABETH_WILLIAMS_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I236",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported mother of Edward Marlow",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW"
      ],
      "source_note": "No marriage, deed, probate, or baptism establishes her."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_WILLIAM_MARLOW_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I237",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported father of Edward Marlow",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported England or Maryland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW"
      ],
      "source_note": "Later Marlow records do not bridge this identity to Edward."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_JOHANNES_GOBEL_TAILOR",
      "person_id": "I241",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Tailor",
      "start_date": "adult life; exact date not supplied",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "Directly reported trade in the church-book-based reconstruction."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_JOHANNES_GOBEL_JUDGE",
      "person_id": "I241",
      "fact_type": "civic_office",
      "value": "Local judge",
      "start_date": "adult life; exact date not supplied",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "Historical local office, recorded separately from his trade."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_JOHANNES_GOBEL_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "I241",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Ursula Batzer",
      "start_date": "10 May 1670",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ten-child chronology begins in 1671 and conflicts with assigning a Göda-born 1670 Hans Jacob as their son."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL",
      "person_id": "I74",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Will devised land and named children; described tract bounds derived from grandfather Henry Werrick's will",
      "start_date": "13 Mar 1780",
      "end_date": "May 1782",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "Resolves this Robert as the younger man and exposes conflation with an older Robert."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized, daughter of Hans Martin and Anna Catharina Nagel",
      "start_date": "10 Dec 1695",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hanover is rejected as an unsupported surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Simon Lindner; father Hans Martin Nagel named",
      "start_date": "17 Oct 1713",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713"
      ],
      "source_note": "Same parish and father reinforce identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_SIMON_LINDER_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Margaretha Nagel; father Stephan Linder named",
      "start_date": "17 Oct 1713",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713"
      ],
      "source_note": "This Simon is not George Anton Linder's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_SIMON_LINDER_IMMIGRATION",
      "person_id": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Arrived with wife and children aboard the Elizabeth",
      "start_date": "27 Aug 1733",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_ISTG_ELIZABETH_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Passenger ages closely match the reconstructed family."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G11_SIMON_LINDER_LAND_WARRANT",
      "person_id": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Received Lancaster County land warrant",
      "start_date": "1733",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_LANCASTER_WARRANT_1733"
      ],
      "source_note": "A warrant initiates survey/title process and is not itself full patent ownership."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL",
      "person_id": "C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Will named wife Mary and sons Adrigan, Robert, and Samuel",
      "start_date": "19 May 1711",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original will image was not inspected; the abstract is reinforced by Henry Wirick's 1710 will and Mary Hebdon's later testimony."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_GEO_HARGAS_TRANSPORT",
      "person_id": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Named among people transported for John Benton's Virginia land patent",
      "start_date": "13 Oct 1642",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_PIONEERS_GEO_HARGAS_1642",
        "SRC_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_GEO_HARGAS_BY_1642"
      ],
      "source_note": "The headright entry does not prove where or when Hargas was born, when he arrived, or any Hargis-Lea family connection."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_SUSANNA_LEA_BAPTISM",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized as daughter of Uriae Lea and Joannae",
      "start_date": "22 Jan 1614",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614"
      ],
      "source_note": "This directly establishes Susanna and her parents; the marriage to Geo Hargas remains compiled."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_GEORG_BATZER_FAMILY",
      "person_id": "EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Reported husband of Ursula Hinckh and father in a ten-child parish family",
      "start_date": "about 1633",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Erpfingen/Willmandingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage predates the surviving marriage register, so its approximate date is less direct than the children's entries."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_URSULA_HINCKH_FAMILY",
      "person_id": "EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Identified as wife of Georg Batzer and mother of their parish-recorded children",
      "start_date": "1633-1660",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Erpfingen and Reutlingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her surname appears as Hinckherlin in daughter Barbara's 1648 baptism; exact birth and parents remain unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_ANNA_KISSLING_BURIAL",
      "person_id": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Buried aged 69 years and 7 months",
      "start_date": "23 Apr 1688",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Willmandingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her reported October 1618 birth is calculated from this age; the source explicitly rejects unsupported online birthplace claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_ROBERT_BUTT_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I117",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported husband of Elizabeth Church and father of Lemuel Butt",
      "start_date": "reported; events unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "Chronology is possible after correcting the reported 1704 birth, but no original family record was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_ELIZABETH_CHURCH_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I118",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported wife of Robert Butt and mother of Lemuel Butt",
      "start_date": "reported; events unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED"
      ],
      "source_note": "Church is not supported by a marriage, probate, deed, or baptism found in this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_EARLY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I133",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported Edinburgh man and father of Jeremiah MacKnew born about 1610",
      "start_date": "reported about 1558",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558"
      ],
      "source_note": "No parish, tax, land, court, or probate record was found; this is not evidence for the documented Maryland immigrant."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_MARTIN_GOBEL_BIRTH_PARENTAGE",
      "person_id": "I243",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Born to Martin Göbell and Margaretha Berlin",
      "start_date": "6 Dec 1600",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The study quotes the local record reconstruction and distinguishes this man from derivative Göbel namesakes."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_MARTIN_GOBEL_FOREST_SERVANT",
      "person_id": "I243",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Forstknecht (forest servant or forest guard)",
      "start_date": "adult life; documented by 1640",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Erpfingen and Willmandingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The German occupational title is preserved; it indicates forest service, not military service."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_MARTIN_GOBEL_BURIAL",
      "person_id": "I243",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Buried as Martin Göbel, Forstknecht, in his seventy-third year",
      "start_date": "10 Mar 1673",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Willmandingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The burial entry independently repeats his occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_MARY_WIRICK_PROBATE_FAMILY",
      "person_id": "I75",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Documented across wills and deathbed testimony as Henry Wirick's daughter, Robert Bartee's wife, and mother of Bartee and Hebdon children",
      "start_date": "1710",
      "end_date": "Jan 1730/31",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730"
      ],
      "source_note": "These records resolve her two married-family contexts but do not establish an occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER_MATERNITY",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as mother of Margretha Nagel in the baptismal index",
      "start_date": "10 Dec 1695",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record calls her Anna Catharina Nagel; Kieffer as maiden surname remains dependent on the reconstructed family."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_BARBARA_MOLLFINGER_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Stephan Lindner",
      "start_date": "28 Apr 1665",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The record describes her as an unmarried legitimate daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_BARBARA_MOLLFINGER_PARENTAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named legitimate daughter of deceased Hans Mollfinger",
      "start_date": "28 Apr 1665",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The marriage record does not name her mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_HANS_MARTIN_NAGEL_PARENT_ROLE",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named father of Margretha Nagel in her baptism and later marriage",
      "start_date": "10 Dec 1695",
      "end_date": "17 Oct 1713",
      "place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records do not support Martz as a surname or supply his occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_STEPHAN_LINDNER_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Barbara Mollfinger",
      "start_date": "28 Apr 1665",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The exact marriage anchors the couple independently of later derivative pedigrees."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G12_STEPHAN_LINDNER_PARENTAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "28 Apr 1665",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Honorable citizen describes Michael, not Stephan, and is not assigned as Stephan's occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_RICHARD_BUTT_MEETINGHOUSE_LAND",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "A newly erected house on Richard Butt Sr.'s land was selected as a dissenting Protestant meetinghouse",
      "start_date": "17 Jan 1714",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Southern Branch, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STEWART_HISTORY_NORFOLK_RICHARD_BUTT_MEETINGHOUSE_1714"
      ],
      "source_note": "Name, senior styling, locality, and chronology fit this profile, but the record does not name a wife or son Robert."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_JOANNA_LEA_MATERNITY",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named mother of Susanna Lea at baptism",
      "start_date": "22 Jan 1614",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614"
      ],
      "source_note": "This proves Joannae's maternal role but not that she was the Joan Lea baptized in distant Somerset in 1590."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_URIAH_LEA_PATERNITY",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named father of Susanna Lea at baptism",
      "start_date": "22 Jan 1614",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism does not establish Uriah's reported birth, death, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_SARACH_SAYER_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported wife of Richard Butt and mother of Robert Butt",
      "start_date": "reported; events unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiled Butt history names different wives and does not list Robert among Richard's children."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reconstructed husband of Margretha Helena Widman and father of Anna Catharina Kieffer",
      "start_date": "reported seventeenth century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Locality and sibling baptisms favor this family, but Anna's original baptism was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_MARGRETHA_WIDMAN_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reconstructed wife of Hanss Georg Kieffer and mother of Anna Catharina Kieffer",
      "start_date": "reported seventeenth century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The selected Blankenloch cluster is geographically coherent, but direct maternity remains uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_BARBARA_RADLER_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported mother of Barbara Mollfinger",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Nenzenheim area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.54,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Barbara Mollfinger's 1665 marriage names only her deceased father Hans, not her mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_MARY_WERRICK_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I115",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported wife of Henry Werrick and mother of Mary Wirick Bartee",
      "start_date": "reported; events unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "Henry's will proves his daughter Mary but does not name his wife or the daughter's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_HENRY_WERRICK_WILL",
      "person_id": "I116",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Will devised his plantation to daughter Mary Barttee for life and then to grandson Robert Bartee",
      "start_date": "28 Dec 1710",
      "end_date": "20 Apr 1711",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The will directly establishes Henry, Mary, Robert, and plantation ownership but does not name Henry's wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_RICHARD_CHURCH_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I120",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported father of Elizabeth Church",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_VA_HOUSE_RICHARD_CHURCH_1699"
      ],
      "source_note": "The official 1699 House service belongs to a Norfolk Richard Church but supplies no relatives, so it is not assigned as this profile's civic office."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_MATTHEW_MACKNEW_EARLY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I135",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported Edinburgh man and father of Jeremiah MacKnew born about 1558",
      "start_date": "reported about 1538-1610",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558"
      ],
      "source_note": "Published McNew histories begin with the seventeenth-century Maryland immigrant and do not substantiate Matthew."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_MARGRETHA_BERLIN_BAPTISM",
      "person_id": "I244",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized, daughter of Magister Johans Berlin, deacon, and Anna",
      "start_date": "27 Nov 1576",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Weinsberg, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her later marriage entry is nearly illegible, but her identity as Martin Göbel's wife is supported by their son's parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_ELDER_MARTIN_GOBEL_FOREST_SERVANT",
      "person_id": "I245",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Württembergischer Forstknecht (Württemberg forest servant or forest guard)",
      "start_date": "documented by 1607",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "First called Forstknecht at son Johann Wolfgang's 1607 baptism; his same-named son later succeeded to the office."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_ELDER_MARTIN_GOBEL_BURIAL",
      "person_id": "I245",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Died or was buried after decades of Württemberg forest service",
      "start_date": "3 Aug 1662",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Willmandingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The source distinguishes him from his son Martin, who died in 1673."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_ANNA_FUCHS_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "reported seventeenth century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Nenzenheim-area Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Stephan's 1665 marriage independently names Michael but does not name Anna or state maternity."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_ANNA_CATHARINA_HANSEN_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported wife of Hans Anthoni Nagel and mother of Hannß Martin Nagel",
      "start_date": "reported seventeenth century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original baptism or marriage entries were not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_HANS_MOLLFINGER_PARENT_ROLE",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named deceased father of the unmarried Barbara Mollfinger at her marriage",
      "start_date": "28 Apr 1665",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The record identifies him directly but supplies no occupation or wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported husband of Anna Catharina Hansen and father of Hannß Martin Nagel",
      "start_date": "reported seventeenth century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Blankenloch area, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hans Simon is rejected as an unsupported alternate name; original entries remain uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_MICHAEL_LINDNER_PARENT_ROLE",
      "person_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named father of Stephan Lindner at Stephan's marriage",
      "start_date": "28 Apr 1665",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The record directly proves paternity but not Michael's exact vital dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G13_MICHAEL_LINDNER_CIVIC_STATUS",
      "person_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "fact_type": "civic_status",
      "value": "Honorable citizen of Nenzenheim",
      "start_date": "28 Apr 1665",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This is civic standing, not a paid occupation or elected office."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_ANNA_BERLIN_MATERNITY",
      "person_id": "C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named mother of Margreth Berlin at baptism",
      "start_date": "27 Nov 1576",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Weinsberg, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record gives only Anna's forename; no maiden surname or parents are known."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_JOHANN_BERLIN_EDUCATION",
      "person_id": "C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER",
      "fact_type": "education",
      "value": "Matriculated at the University of Tübingen and attained Magister degree",
      "start_date": "1569",
      "end_date": "1574",
      "place": "Tübingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "Magister is an academic degree/title and is recorded separately from his clerical occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_JOHANN_BERLIN_CLERGY",
      "person_id": "C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Lutheran deacon and later pastor",
      "start_date": "1575",
      "end_date": "2 Mar 1618",
      "place": "Weinsberg, Reichenbach an der Fils, Boll, Grabenstetten, and Uhingen, Württemberg",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "He was deacon at Weinsberg in 1575 and later pastor in four Württemberg communities."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_JANE_BUTT_WILL_ROLE",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Named wife of Robert Butt in his will",
      "start_date": "1 Nov 1675",
      "end_date": "3 Jul 1676",
      "place": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The will does not support Bruce or any other maiden surname and does not explicitly state maternity."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_ROBERT_BUTT_WILL",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Will named wife Jane and sons Henry, Robert, Thomas, and Richard",
      "start_date": "1 Nov 1675",
      "end_date": "3 Jul 1676",
      "place": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Later English-origin and noble-ancestry claims are not supplied by the will and remain rejected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_ROBERT_LEA_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Joan Smith",
      "start_date": "3 Dec 1587",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Stoke St Gregory, Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587"
      ],
      "source_note": "This directly establishes the couple in Somerset."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_ROBERT_LEA_PARENT_ROLE",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named father of Joan Lea at baptism",
      "start_date": "13 Mar 1590",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Stoke St Gregory, Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590"
      ],
      "source_note": "The child's later identification as Joannae at Ashwell, Hertfordshire, remains only 0.68 because no record bridges the localities."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_MATTHEW_MACKNEUGH_1518_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported sixteenth-century Matthew Mackneugh in a modern inherited family tradition",
      "start_date": "reported 1518-1550",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "place not supplied",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_HISTORY_BOWMAN_THOMAS_1997",
        "SRC_MCNEW_MEMORABILIA_CARROLL_1998",
        "SRC_REDDIT_MACKNEW_SCOTLAND_QUERY_2021"
      ],
      "source_note": "The wording “first-hand information” describes the 2014 contributor, not contemporary knowledge of a sixteenth-century person."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_JOAN_SMITH_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Robert Lea",
      "start_date": "3 Dec 1587",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Stoke St Gregory, Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage names no parents; her maternity of the 1590 Joan is plausible but the supplied baptism names only Robert."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_MARGARETHA_KOCH_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I246",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported mother of Martin Göbel born about 1575",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Erpfingen area, Württemberg",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "No supporting parish or civic record was exposed."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_HANNSSEN_GOBEL_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I247",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Reported father of Martin Göbel born about 1575",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Erpfingen area, Württemberg",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sourced reconstruction stops with Martin and does not identify these parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_BARBARA_REIFF_MATERNITY",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as Barbara, mother of Anna Fuchs, in Anna's baptism; Reiff is supplied by a reconstructed marriage family",
      "start_date": "12 Sep 1596",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Oberböbingen, Gmünd, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OBERBOBINGEN_ANNA_FUCHS_BAPTISM_1596"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism does not itself call Barbara Reiff, so the full identity is not rated near certainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_HANS_FUCHS_PATERNITY",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named father of Anna Fuchs at baptism",
      "start_date": "12 Sep 1596",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Oberböbingen, Gmünd, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OBERBOBINGEN_ANNA_FUCHS_BAPTISM_1596"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record does not establish his reported 1569 birth or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_MARTIN_LINDER_SWISS_FAMILY",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Published and derivative research places Marty or Martin Linder with Salome Werren in a Saanen-Gsteig family",
      "start_date": "reported early seventeenth century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Saanen and Gsteig, Bern, Switzerland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G14_SALOME_WERREN_SWISS_FAMILY",
      "person_id": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Published and derivative research places Salome Werren with Marty Linder in a Saanen-Gsteig family",
      "start_date": "reported early seventeenth century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Saanen and Gsteig, Bern, Switzerland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G15_HANS_BEERLIN_FAMILY_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Married Agatha Bleyle and later died at Überkingen",
      "start_date": "reported 1555",
      "end_date": "1 Sep 1588",
      "place": "Gruibingen and Überkingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_JOHANN_PLENINGEN_HANS_BEERLIN_NAMESAKE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The older physician Johann Pleningen, also called Hans Beerlin/Berlin, is chronologically and occupationally distinct. Hans and Agatha as Johann Berlin's parents remain only about 0.52."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G15_AGATHA_BLEYLE_FAMILY_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Married Hans Beerlin and later died at Überkingen",
      "start_date": "reported 1555",
      "end_date": "14 Mar 1591",
      "place": "Gruibingen and Überkingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her proposed father Sebastian is marked uncertain and early relevant Catholic registers are lost; maternity of Johann Berlin remains about 0.50."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Proposed father of Agatha Bleyle through Ahnentafel numbering 20,618 to 10,309",
      "start_date": "reported about 1504",
      "end_date": "reported about 1568",
      "place": "reported Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED"
      ],
      "source_note": "The numbering places Sebastian exactly in Agatha's father slot, but the question mark, missing source, lost early books, and locality ambiguity prevent stronger confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G1_EDGAR_NEWMAN_YALE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "fact_type": "education",
      "value": "Bachelor of Arts, Yale University",
      "start_date": "1962",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Haven, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TIMES_PICAYUNE_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_OBITUARY_2001",
        "SRC_RH19_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_MEMORIAL_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both sources independently specify Yale; the memorial supplies 1962."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G1_EDGAR_NEWMAN_CHICAGO_PHD",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "fact_type": "education",
      "value": "Doctorate in European history, University of Chicago",
      "start_date": "after 1962; exact year not stated",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Chicago, Illinois, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TIMES_PICAYUNE_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_OBITUARY_2001",
        "SRC_RH19_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_MEMORIAL_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "The obituary calls it a doctorate; the memorial names his graduate mentor Louis Gottschalk."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G1_EDGAR_NEWMAN_HISTORIAN",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Historian and university professor specializing in post-Revolutionary France",
      "start_date": "1969",
      "end_date": "2001",
      "place": "New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, New Mexico, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TIMES_PICAYUNE_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_OBITUARY_2001",
        "SRC_RH19_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_MEMORIAL_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "He also held visiting appointments at UCLA and Millersville University."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G1_EDGAR_NEWMAN_FELLOWSHIPS",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "fact_type": "academic_status",
      "value": "Fulbright fellow and National Endowment for the Humanities fellow",
      "start_date": "dates not stated",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TIMES_PICAYUNE_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_OBITUARY_2001"
      ],
      "source_note": "The obituary names both fellowships but does not provide dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G1_EDGAR_NEWMAN_DEATH",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Died of cancer at Johns Hopkins Hospital",
      "start_date": "30 Nov 2001",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Baltimore, Maryland, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TIMES_PICAYUNE_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_OBITUARY_2001",
        "SRC_RH19_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_MEMORIAL_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "The obituary reports age 62, but no unsupported exact birth date is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G2_ISIDORE_TULANE_BA",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "fact_type": "education",
      "value": "Bachelor of Arts, Tulane University",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "Also attended Isidore Newman Manual Training School."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G2_ISIDORE_MAISON_BLANCHE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Maison Blanche department-store executive and president",
      "start_date": "1932",
      "end_date": "1963",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "President from 1949 through 1963 after earlier brokerage and wholesale dry-goods work."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G2_ISIDORE_CITY_STORES",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "President of City Stores Corporation",
      "start_date": "1963",
      "end_date": "1975",
      "place": "New York, New York, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "City Stores was Maison Blanche's parent; retired 1 Mar 1975."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G2_ISIDORE_ARMY",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "fact_type": "military_service",
      "value": "Army Transportation Corps procurement officer; rose to lieutenant colonel",
      "start_date": "1942",
      "end_date": "after 1942",
      "place": "United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_USCSC_ARMY_REGISTER_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "Federal register identifies him as a major and Procurement Control Branch chief; biography records later rank."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G2_ISIDORE_CHAMBER",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "fact_type": "civic_service",
      "value": "President, New Orleans Chamber of Commerce",
      "start_date": "1953",
      "end_date": "1953",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "Also held International Trade Mart and educational-board roles."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G2_ISIDORE_HIBERNIA",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "fact_type": "civic_service",
      "value": "Director, Hibernia National Bank",
      "start_date": "1951",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRASER_MIDCONTINENT_BANKER_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1951",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "The February 1951 issue records his election."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G2_ISIDORE_WORLD_FAIR",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "fact_type": "civic_service",
      "value": "Advocated for the 1984 Louisiana World Exposition",
      "start_date": "1979",
      "end_date": "1979",
      "place": "Paris, France",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "Presented New Orleans' case to the international fairs committee."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G2_ISIDORE_DEATH",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Died in New Orleans",
      "start_date": "23 Jan 1981",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "Biography cites the 24 Jan 1981 Times-Picayune obituary."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G2_HENRIETTA_PHOENIX_1963",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Household of Mr. and Mrs. Martin Segel, 1807 W. Coolidge",
      "start_date": "1963",
      "end_date": "1963",
      "place": "Phoenix, Maricopa, Arizona, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Notice omits Henrietta's name; descendant acknowledgment supplies the couple's given names."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G2_HENRIETTA_DEATH",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Death reported in SSDI-derived entry",
      "start_date": "11 Sep 2002",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_HENRIETTA_SEGEL_1916_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "Underlying SSA record was not directly accessible."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I10_EMPLOYMENT_OAK_RIDGE_UNION_CARBIDE",
      "person_id": "I10",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Worked for Oak Ridge National Laboratory and Union Carbide",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Oak Ridge, Tennessee, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1950_CENSUS_OCCUPATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G3_EDGAR_MAISON_BLANCHE_MANAGER",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Manager of the Grafonola department at Maison Blanche",
      "start_date": "1922",
      "end_date": "1922",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TALKING_MACHINE_WORLD_EDGAR_NEWMAN_1922"
      ],
      "source_note": "The October 1922 report identifies his department and employer while describing a business visit to Columbia headquarters."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G3_EDGAR_MAISON_BLANCHE_TREASURER_RADIO",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Maison Blanche treasurer and representative in an early New Orleans radio venture",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "1922",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ENTERPRISE_IN_RADIO_EDGAR_NEWMAN"
      ],
      "source_note": "The study links Newman to Maison Blanche's provision of studio space and support for early broadcasting; the precise start date is not established."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G3_EDGAR_DEATH_ESTATE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Died in New Orleans; estate administered by Elsa Schwartz Newman and Jacob K. Newman",
      "start_date": "9 Mar 1928",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935"
      ],
      "source_note": "The decision supplies 9 March, correcting the reported 10 March date."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G3_ELSA_EXECUTOR_BENEFICIARY",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "fact_type": "legal_financial",
      "value": "Life-insurance beneficiary and executor of Edgar Newman's estate",
      "start_date": "1928",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935"
      ],
      "source_note": "The opinion directly identifies Elsa as Edgar's wife, beneficiary, and co-executor."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G3_LEON_HATTIESBURG_SAWMILL",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Incorporator of Hattiesburg Saw Mill Company",
      "start_date": "18 Dec 1922",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Hattiesburg, Forrest County, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_HATTIESBURG_SAWMILL_LEON_PFEIFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "The account identifies Leon Pfeifer of New Orleans among the incorporators and reports authorized capital of $300,000."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G3_BERTHA_WOMEN_IN_INDUSTRY",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "fact_type": "civic_service",
      "value": "Member, Women in Industry Committee",
      "start_date": "1919",
      "end_date": "1919",
      "place": "Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_WOMEN_IN_INDUSTRY_BERTHA_PFEIFER_1919"
      ],
      "source_note": "The report prints Mrs. Leon Pfeifer rather than Bertha's given name; the documented marriage and family context support the identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G3_MAX_JUFFE_NY_MILITARY",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "military_service",
      "value": "New York National Guard service from private to captain, 12th Infantry",
      "start_date": "14 Dec 1907",
      "end_date": "4 Aug 1917",
      "place": "New York, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NY_ADJUTANT_GENERAL_MAX_JUFFE_1917"
      ],
      "source_note": "Official Register page 151 gives Austrian birth on 20 March 1886 and traces service beginning as a private on 14 December 1907, with later enlistments and federal muster. It records second lieutenant on 15 July 1916, first lieutenant on 21 February 1917, captain on 3 August 1917, and acceptance on 4 August 1917."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G3_MAX_JUFFE_CAMP_WADSWORTH",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "military_service",
      "value": "Infantry instructor at Camp Wadsworth",
      "start_date": "1917",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Spartanburg, South Carolina, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CAMP_WADSWORTH_MAX_JUFFE_INSTRUCTOR"
      ],
      "source_note": "Listed as Capt. Max Juffe of the 12th New York Infantry among camp instructors."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G3_MAX_JUFFE_ARGONNE_PRESS",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "President, Argonne Press Inc.",
      "start_date": "1922",
      "end_date": "1923",
      "place": "New York, New York, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TROWS_DIRECTORY_MAX_JUFFE_ARGONNE_PRESS_1922"
      ],
      "source_note": "Directory also places him at 807 East 178th Street."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G3_MAX_JUFFE_DEATH",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Died",
      "start_date": "19 Sep 1979",
      "end_date": "19 Sep 1979",
      "place": "Los Angeles, California, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_NATIONWIDE_GRAVESITE_MAX_JUFFE_1979",
        "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_MAX_JUFFE_1888_1979"
      ],
      "source_note": "The VA database supplies the exact date, rank, cemetery, and plot. Its conflicting 1888 birth date is documented separately and does not weaken the death identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_I28_FAMILY_BACKGROUND_DAIRY_FARMING",
      "person_id": "I28",
      "fact_type": "family_background",
      "value": "Came from a dairy-farming family",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G4_ISIDORE_IMMIGRATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Immigrated from Kaiserslautern to the United States",
      "start_date": "1853",
      "end_date": "1853",
      "place": "Kaiserslautern, Rhenish Bavaria to New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_HNOC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_LEGACY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The biography says he arrived penniless in New Orleans; a contemporary death notice instead reports 1860. The detailed Louisiana biography and 1903 fiftieth-anniversary evidence support 1853, while the 1860 notice is retained as a conflict."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G4_ISIDORE_FINANCIER",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Financier and head of Isidore Newman & Son(s)",
      "start_date": "after 1865",
      "end_date": "1909",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_COMMERCIAL_FINANCIAL_CHRONICLE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1909"
      ],
      "source_note": "He began as a bookkeeper and then financed public debt, street railways, department stores, and industrial development."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G4_ISIDORE_STOCK_EXCHANGE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Organizer and president of the New Orleans Stock Exchange",
      "start_date": "1877",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_SOARDS_NEW_ORLEANS_GUIDE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_STOCK_EXCHANGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The biography reports organization in 1877 and long service as president; the city guide lists him in office."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G4_ISIDORE_MAISON_BLANCHE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Financier and principal owner supporting Maison Blanche",
      "start_date": "1897",
      "end_date": "1909",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COMMERCIAL_FINANCIAL_CHRONICLE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1909",
        "SRC_HNOC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_LEGACY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Contemporary reporting calls him the principal owner; historical interpretation distinguishes financing from day-to-day operation."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G4_ISIDORE_SCHOOL_PHILANTHROPY",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "fact_type": "civic_service",
      "value": "Benefactor of the Isidore Newman Manual Training School",
      "start_date": "1903",
      "end_date": "1909",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_HNOC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_LEGACY",
        "SRC_NEWMAN_SCHOOL_HISTORY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Funded construction and equipment for a school serving children of the Jewish Orphans Home and neighborhood children of all creeds."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G4_ISIDORE_PLANTATION_COURT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "fact_type": "property_legal",
      "value": "Owned an East Baton Rouge Parish plantation involved in machinery litigation",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1902",
      "place": "East Baton Rouge Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_SUPREME_COURT_ADAMS_MACHINE_V_NEWMAN_1902"
      ],
      "source_note": "The case concerned boilers, cotton gins, and other machinery placed on the plantation; it does not identify the plantation name."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G4_ISIDORE_DEATH",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Died at his New Orleans home",
      "start_date": "30 Nov 1909",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AJC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_DEATH_1909",
        "SRC_COMMERCIAL_FINANCIAL_CHRONICLE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1909",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I"
      ],
      "source_note": "Corrects the reported 1902 year and a later regional genealogy that repeated 1902."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G5_DAVID_DREYFUSS_NAME_ADOPTION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "fact_type": "identity",
      "value": "Listed as David Dreyfuss, son of Leo Dreyfuss",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Ingenheim, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Supports the historical identity and father, not the later wife or daughter in the reported tree."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G5_JOHANNA_FRANK_NAME_ADOPTION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "fact_type": "identity",
      "value": "Lea b Dotteres adopted the name Johanna Frank; listed as a minor daughter of Salomon Frank",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Oberlustadt, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The same household lists Rosalia Mayer as Salomon's wife, but the entry explicitly labels only Salomon as Johanna's parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "WF_G5_KIEFFER_ROSER_MIGRATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Kieffer-Roser family migrated from Lembach to Port Gibson",
      "start_date": "1840s",
      "end_date": "1840s",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France to Port Gibson, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Family-level migration context from a credible compiled publication; no passenger list was located."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_ASSEMBLY_TOBACCO_1678",
      "person_id": "I129",
      "fact_type": "tax_and_public_account",
      "value": "Named among Maryland residents assigned 830 pounds of tobacco in Assembly accounts",
      "start_date": "1678",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678"
      ],
      "source_note": "The entry establishes Jeremiah's presence in the taxable colonial economy. It does not by itself prove that he cultivated tobacco or held public office."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_HARGAS_BENTON_MIGRATION_COHORT_1642",
      "person_id": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "fact_type": "community_network",
      "value": "Listed with the Benton family and other transported people supporting John Benton's 1,250-acre patent",
      "start_date": "13 Oct 1642",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "South side of the Rappahannock River, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_PIONEERS_GEO_HARGAS_1642"
      ],
      "source_note": "The shared patent identifies a migration cohort, not kinship among the transported people or with patent holder John Benton."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ROBERT_BUTT_LANDHOLDING_LOGGING",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "property_and_work",
      "value": "Held a 380-acre patent and consolidated a 1,200-acre Southern Branch tract through assignment and purchase",
      "start_date": "3 Mar 1656",
      "end_date": "28 Apr 1665",
      "place": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS",
        "SRC_CHESAPEAKE_BUTT_LANDHOLDING_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 380-acre patent was associated with eight headrights. The 1,200-acre tract had been granted to Tristram Nasworthy, assigned jointly to Butt, Richard Whitby, and John Bright, and consolidated after Butt bought the other two shares. The acreage does not establish noble birth, a royal commission, or special recruitment by Governor Berkeley."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_HENRY_WERRICK_SECOND_PLANTATION",
      "person_id": "I116",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Owned a second plantation purchased from John Bright and provided for daughter Patient and son-in-law William Odean",
      "start_date": "before 28 Dec 1710",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The purchase from John Bright and the Odean household help identify Henry's land and community network."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_HENRY_WERRICK_ENSLAVED_BOY",
      "person_id": "I116",
      "fact_type": "enslavement",
      "value": "Will bequeathed an unnamed enslaved boy to granddaughter Patient Odean when she reached age sixteen",
      "start_date": "28 Dec 1710",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The surviving abstract does not name the enslaved child. This evidence is retained explicitly as part of the household's history."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ROBERT_BARTEE_QUIT_RENT_1704",
      "person_id": "C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "fact_type": "tax_and_landholding",
      "value": "Named as a Norfolk County landholder in the Virginia quit-rent roll",
      "start_date": "1704",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NORFOLK_1704_QUIT_RENT_ROBERT_BARTEE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The roll does not list family members; the identification is strong but remains below direct certainty because the name alone appears in the tax transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_HENRY_FRICKE_FIRST_AMERICAN_EVENT_1869",
      "person_id": "I76",
      "fact_type": "first_documented_american_event",
      "value": "Married Cathrine Schaaf in a New Jersey civil record",
      "start_date": "28 Mar 1869",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Newark, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is the earliest direct American event currently identified; the 1867 immigration year is a later census report."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_KATHARINE_SCHAAF_ORIGIN_CANDIDATE_1848",
      "person_id": "I77",
      "fact_type": "origin_candidate",
      "value": "Katharina Schaaf baptism at Ober-Gleen fits her name, age, religion, and Hessian origin",
      "start_date": "20 Mar 1848",
      "end_date": "24 Mar 1848",
      "place": "Ober-Gleen, Kreis Alsfeld, Hesse-Darmstadt",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a useful candidate, not proof that the baptized child became Henry Fricke's wife in New Jersey."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_MAX_JUFFE_FIRST_US_APPEARANCE_1907",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "first_documented_american_event",
      "value": "Entered documented New York military service as a private",
      "start_date": "14 Dec 1907",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New York, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NY_ADJUTANT_GENERAL_MAX_JUFFE_1917"
      ],
      "source_note": "Official Register page 151 records his first listed New York service on 14 December 1907. Because it calls him Austrian-born, he had reached the United States by that date; it does not state his arrival date, port, ship, last residence, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_SARAH_GISE_MIGRATION_TO_KENTUCKY",
      "person_id": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Living as Christian Gobble's widow in Floyd County after the family's earlier Maryland and southwest Virginia residences",
      "start_date": "by 1 Feb 1842",
      "end_date": "1848",
      "place": "Floyd County, Kentucky, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records establish her residence by 1842 and continued life there in 1848, but not the exact date or route of her move."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ROBERT_LAVENDER_NAMED_FATHER_1811",
      "person_id": "I65",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as Fanny Lavinder's father in her marriage record",
      "start_date": "12 Jan 1811",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Botetourt County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record directly identifies Robert as Fanny's father; it does not name her mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_1880_ORIGIN_CLUE",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "fact_type": "origin_clue",
      "value": "Both parents reported born in North Carolina",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census gives only parental birth states, not names or Ann's own county of origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_RESIDENCE_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Living with husband David and daughter Ailsey",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ann appears under the Nancy/Ann/Annie name variants; the family continuity is strong."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_DELIA_TALLEY_RESIDENCE_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Living with Evan Tally and children",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The surname was transcribed Sally, a plausible Tally variant in this continuous family."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_DELIA_FADDIS_IDENTITY_CLUE",
      "person_id": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "identity_candidate",
      "value": "Fadas or Faddis reported as maiden surname by a daughter's later death informant",
      "start_date": "reported in a later child death record",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DELIA_TALLY_HENDERSON_1866_HEADSTONE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The spelling varies and no record from Delia's own lifetime yet links her to a Faddis family."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_SUSAN_JONES_NAMED_MOTHER_FLOYD_1934",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as Floyd Short's mother in his death record",
      "start_date": "16 Jan 1934",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Saltville, Smyth County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_FLOYD_SHORT_DEATH_1934"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is later informant evidence, but it independently repeats the parental couple named for David."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_GEORGE_SHORT_NAMED_FATHER_FLOYD_1934",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as Floyd Short's father in his death record",
      "start_date": "16 Jan 1934",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Saltville, Smyth County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_FLOYD_SHORT_DEATH_1934"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record independently corroborates George as father of another child in the 1870 family."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_GEORGE_SHORT_SPEEDWELL_1880",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Probable household with son David and a later wife, Obedience",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Speedwell, Wythe County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The identity is probable rather than explicit; Obedience should not be treated as David's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_JOHN_THOMAS_OCCUPATION_1881",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Shoemaker",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": "1881",
      "place": "160 Frankwell Quay, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Later described as a bootmaker hand worker, a consistent trade."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_JOHN_THOMAS_OCCUPATION_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Bootmaker, hand worker",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "160 Frankwell Quay, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Consistent with the 1881 shoemaker occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_JOHN_THOMAS_RESIDENCE_1881",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with wife Jane and daughter Elizabeth",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": "1881",
      "place": "160 Frankwell Quay, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The same address recurs in 1911."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_JOHN_THOMAS_RESIDENCE_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with wife Jane",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "160 Frankwell Quay, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Repeated address materially strengthens identity continuity."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_JANE_LISTER_RESIDENCE_1851",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Child in Richard and Eliza Lyster household",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1851",
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Alkmund, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Mother-name conflict with compiled Kezia Price is retained."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_JANE_THOMAS_RESIDENCE_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Resident with husband John after 32 years of marriage",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "160 Frankwell Quay, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation was supplied for Jane and none is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_JOHN_LISTER_THOMAS_WW1_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "military_family",
      "value": "Named as father and next of kin of John Lister Thomas in First World War pension index",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_LISTER_THOMAS_WW1_PENSION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This documents his son's military-family context, not military service by the father."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_LEON_SCHWARTZ_MORTGAGE_1909",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "fact_type": "property_and_credit",
      "value": "Party to an indexed mortgage act before notary Percy Benedict",
      "start_date": "3 May 1909",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_NOTARIAL_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_MORTGAGE_1909"
      ],
      "source_note": "The index establishes the act and parties but does not describe the property, debt, or whether Schwartz was mortgagor or mortgagee."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_CLARA_CAHN_JEWISH_COMMUNITY",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "fact_type": "religion_and_community",
      "value": "Member of a Jewish family in the Bavarian Palatinate",
      "start_date": "by 1837",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Kaiserslautern, Kingdom of Bavaria",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sources document the family context through their son; no synagogue affiliation for Clara is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_JAKOB_NEUMOND_JEWISH_COMMUNITY",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "fact_type": "religion_and_community",
      "value": "Member of a Jewish family in the Bavarian Palatinate",
      "start_date": "by 1837",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Kaiserslautern, Kingdom of Bavaria",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sources document the family context through their son; no synagogue office or occupation for Jakob is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_NEUMOND_SON_MIGRATION_1853",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "fact_type": "family_migration",
      "value": "Son Isidor emigrated from Kaiserslautern to New Orleans",
      "start_date": "1853",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Kaiserslautern, Kingdom of Bavaria to New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is the son's migration and should not be read as evidence that Jakob or Clara emigrated."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_LEO_DREYFUSS_NAME_ADOPTION_1808",
      "person_id": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "identity",
      "value": "Loeb Dreyfuss adopted the name Leo Dreyfuss",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ingenheim, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The list also explicitly names eight children."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_NAME_ADOPTION_1808",
      "person_id": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "identity",
      "value": "Rösel Moyses adopted the name Rosali Dreyfuss",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ingenheim, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her relationship to Leo and the children is inferred from placement, not explicitly labeled."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_SALOMON_FRANK_NAME_ADOPTION_1808",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "fact_type": "identity",
      "value": "Daotteres b Samolon adopted the name Salomon Frank",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Oberlustadt, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The list identifies his wife and four minor children."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ROSALIA_MAYER_NAME_ADOPTION_1808",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "fact_type": "identity",
      "value": "Roesel b Abraham adopted the name Rosalia Mayer and was identified as Salomon Frank's wife",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Oberlustadt, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her motherhood of Johanna is strongly inferred from the household but not explicitly stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_MARIE_ROSER_MIGRATION_PORT_GIBSON",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Kieffer-Roser family migrated from Lembach to Port Gibson",
      "start_date": "1840s",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France to Port Gibson, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Family-level migration; no passenger list has been located."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "community_context",
      "value": "Reported birthplace had an established Jewish community, synagogue, school, ritual bath, and cemetery",
      "start_date": "1833",
      "end_date": "1917",
      "place": "Niederhochstadt, present-day Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is context for the reported locality, not a record naming Emanuel."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_MICHEL_COGUENHEM_1872_OPTANT_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "fact_type": "record_candidate",
      "value": "A Michel Coguenhem appears in the 1872 French nationality-option index",
      "start_date": "1872",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Alsace-Lorraine / France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRENCH_CITIZENSHIP_OPTANT_MICHEL_COGUENHEM_1872",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_ALSACE_OPTANTS_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Chronologically possible, but not sufficiently identified to merge with certainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_YETTA_FUCHS_GALICIA_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "fact_type": "origin_context",
      "value": "Reported birthplace was in Austrian Galicia; the town and present-day country are unknown",
      "start_date": "1856",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Kingdom of Galicia and Lodomeria, Austrian Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCGILL_GALICIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_1869_1880"
      ],
      "source_note": "No personal record yet identifies her Galician town."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_JOHANNA_JACOB_KYRITZ_SEMBACH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "fact_type": "origin_context",
      "value": "Reported life path runs from Prussian Kyritz to the Jewish community at Sembach",
      "start_date": "1774",
      "end_date": "1835",
      "place": "Kyritz, Brandenburg, Prussia to Sembach, Bavarian Palatinate",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE",
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "No personal record yet proves either endpoint or the migration between them."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_JULIENNE_LEMBACH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "fact_type": "community_context",
      "value": "Reported death occurred in an established rural Jewish community",
      "start_date": "1824",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The locality history does not name Julienne."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_LEO_CAHN_DONALDSONVILLE_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "fact_type": "record_candidate",
      "value": "An L. Cahn signed the 1860 charter of Donaldsonville's Bikur Cholim society",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Donaldsonville, Ascension Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The signer may be a different Cahn; this is not used to raise identity or relationship confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ISAAK_NEUMOND_KUSSEL_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Imported Kusel birthplace may be confusion with Kussel Neumond in the 1809-1810 Sembach household list",
      "start_date": "1809",
      "end_date": "1810",
      "place": "Sembach, Bavarian Palatinate",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The evidence suggests a problem but does not prove whether Kussel was Isaak or whether Kusel was incorrectly parsed."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_HENDLE_STRAUSS_SEMBACH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "fact_type": "community_context",
      "value": "Reported family lived within Sembach's established Jewish community",
      "start_date": "1740",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Sembach, Bavarian Palatinate",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The household list has Strauss families but does not name Hendle."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ROSALIE_KALLMANN_OTTROTT_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "fact_type": "community_context",
      "value": "Reported spouse's home had a small Jewish community and synagogue",
      "start_date": "1770",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Ottrott-le-Bas, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "No personal record names Rosalie at Ottrott."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_MICHEL_KIEFFER_GUNSTETT_RECORD_TARGET",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "fact_type": "record_context",
      "value": "Gunstett civil tables survive and are the next direct-record target",
      "start_date": "1793",
      "end_date": "1809",
      "place": "Gunstett, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES"
      ],
      "source_note": "The catalog is not evidence that Michel appears in the tables."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_SAMUEL_ROSER_EVANSVILLE_NAMESAKE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "fact_type": "associate_candidate",
      "value": "A later Samuel Roser was active in the Evansville Jewish community where Bernard Roser later died",
      "start_date": "1857",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Evansville, Vanderburgh County, Indiana, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EVANSVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_1849_PRESENT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Possible family or community associate only; no relationship is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ELDER_SALOMON_FRANK_PATRONYMIC",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "fact_type": "parent_identity_evidence",
      "value": "Younger Salomon Frank's 1808 patronymic names his father Samolon",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Oberlustadt, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Direct for the father's given name, not the elder man's exact identity or vital dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_REGINA_MOSES_LONGEVITY_QUESTION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "fact_type": "chronology_question",
      "value": "Imported dates imply an age of about 94 years",
      "start_date": "1726",
      "end_date": "1820",
      "place": "Oberlustadt, present-day Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Possible, but requires direct verification and does not prove maternity."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_HAYIM_KLOTZ_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "fact_type": "name_context",
      "value": "Klotz was an established hereditary surname around Wissembourg before 1808",
      "start_date": "1690",
      "end_date": "1762",
      "place": "Wissembourg, Alsace, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This supports the naming context, not Hayim's identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_MOSCHE_LEVY_NAME_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "fact_type": "name_context",
      "value": "Levy may have denoted levitical descent rather than a unique hereditary surname",
      "start_date": "1690",
      "end_date": "1760",
      "place": "Alsace, France",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY"
      ],
      "source_note": "General naming context only; it does not identify Mosché."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_JUDITH_LEVY_OTTROTT_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "fact_type": "community_context",
      "value": "Reported life occurred within Ottrott's small Jewish community",
      "start_date": "1695",
      "end_date": "1760",
      "place": "Ottrott-le-Bas, Alsace, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "No source names Judith in that community."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_MACHOLE_LEVY_PATRONYMIC_QUESTION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "fact_type": "name_question",
      "value": "Bösel Macholé may preserve her father's given name as a patronymic",
      "start_date": "1725",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Alsace, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY"
      ],
      "source_note": "A plausible interpretation only; not used to raise the parent edge."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_JOHN_GIBSON_HOUSEHOLD_CONTINUITY_1901_1911",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "household_continuity",
      "value": "Widowed farmer remained at Aghnasedagh with a four-child family documented across two censuses",
      "start_date": "1901",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1911 return reports four children born and four living."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_SAMPSON_RHEAD_DOCUMENTED_ADULT_SPAN",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Secure adult records run from the 1832 marriage through the 1845 death index",
      "start_date": "1832",
      "end_date": "1845",
      "place": "Shropshire and Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1841_STOKE_TRANSCRIPTION"
      ],
      "source_note": "Birthplace and parents remain unknown. The original baptism establishes residence at Woodfarm and the occupation grocer in 1833."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ELLEN_FINNEY_MOVE_BIRMINGHAM",
      "person_id": "I146",
      "fact_type": "migration",
      "value": "Family moved from Trentham to Birmingham between censuses",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire to Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ellen appears as Helen in 1861; husband and children establish continuity."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_MARTHA_DAVIES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_CONTINUITY",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "fact_type": "household_continuity",
      "value": "Recorded with William Davies from 1851 through 1881",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1881",
      "place": "Berriew and Churchstoke area, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records establish the married household but not Martha's maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ROBERT_DAVIES_EARLIEST_APPEARANCE",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Named as William Davies's father in baptism register",
      "start_date": "29 Jan 1815",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815"
      ],
      "source_note": "No independent identity details for Robert are supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_EARLIEST_APPEARANCE",
      "person_id": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Named as William Davies's mother in baptism register",
      "start_date": "29 Jan 1815",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her maiden surname is not supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_JAMES_CLARKE_DOCUMENTED_SPAN",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Direct and compatible records span a child marriage, property valuation, and death index",
      "start_date": "1854",
      "end_date": "1882",
      "place": "Aghnasedagh and Monaghan district, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Exact death day and earlier life remain unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_DAVID_BOYD_EARLIEST_APPEARANCE",
      "person_id": "C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Named as Eliza Boyd's father at her marriage",
      "start_date": "20 Jul 1854",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Reported Coolmain origin and later death remain compiled."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_GEORGE_ODNETT_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "C_GEORGE_ODNETT_CLAIMED_FATHER_SARAH_POYNER",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Adult daughter named George Odnett; nearby George Hodnett is a possible but unproved namesake",
      "start_date": "1811",
      "end_date": "1852",
      "place": "Shropshire and Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_DIDDLEBURY_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_ANN_MOUND_LUDLOW_MARRIAGE_1804"
      ],
      "source_note": "Do not merge Odnett with Hodnett without a direct bridge to Sarah or Mary Poyner."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_UNKNOWN_MARTIN_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_MOTHER_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Probably County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The geographically unlinked 1828 Swords marriage is recorded as a rejected identity candidate, not evidence for her forename."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_MARY_POYNER_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_POYNER_MOTHER_SARAH_1811",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Named as mother of Sarah Poyner",
      "start_date": "5 May 1811",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism names no father and supplies no independent identity details for Mary."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_MARY_TOMPSON_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_TOMPSON_MOTHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Named as mother of Esther Tompson",
      "start_date": "14 Feb 1808",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_RECORDS_1538_1944"
      ],
      "source_note": "Tompson is a household display surname; Mary's maiden surname and marriage remain unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_THOMAS_TOMPSON_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "C_THOMAS_TOMPSON_FATHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Named as father of Esther Tompson",
      "start_date": "14 Feb 1808",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_RECORDS_1538_1944"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism identifies Mary as co-parent but does not prove a marriage or give Thomas's occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_RESIDENCE_1841",
      "person_id": "I197",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Named as Joseph Brassington's mother and later enumerated with John Brassington",
      "start_date": "15 Apr 1787",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Ranton and Haughton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RANTON_PARISH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records do not state Margaret's maiden surname or occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_HENRY_CORNISH_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "SRC_HENRY_CORNISH_FATHER_ELIZABETH",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Named as father of Elizabeth Cornish",
      "start_date": "31 Mar 1838",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied transcript gives no occupation, residence, or spouse."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_DOCUMENTED_SPAN",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Documented through marriage, child baptism, civil death, and parish burial",
      "start_date": "26 Nov 1799",
      "end_date": "19 Oct 1840",
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_DEATH_BURIAL_1840",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_CHURCH_REGISTERS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The burial age implies birth about 1765; proposed baptisms remain unlinked candidates."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_JOHN_HENDERSON_PROBATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Giles County estate names John R. Henderson but does not connect him to Robert Henderson",
      "start_date": "1843",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Giles County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1843_JOHN_R_HENDERSON_GILES_PROBATE",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_GILES_COUNTY_MICROFILM"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original will book must be checked; the supplied index reverses the apparent will and probate dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_PEYTON_TALLY_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "SRC_PEYTON_R_TALLY_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Reported as Evan L. Talley's father without a contemporary identity bridge",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Carolina or Virginia, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_NARA_1820_CENSUS_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Do not use the derivative Mecklenburg census claim as primary evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_G6_SAMUEL_MORRALL_PARENT_RECORD",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_MORRALL_FATHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Named as father of Richard Morrall",
      "start_date": "4 Jul 1837",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied transcript gives no occupation or residence for Samuel."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HENRY_CORNISH_WEST_WILTSHIRE_CLOTH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_HENRY_CORNISH_FATHER_ELIZABETH",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Elizabeth's Bradford-on-Avon area was changing from household hand weaving to mechanized woollen mills",
      "start_date": "about 1800",
      "end_date": "1838",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon area, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "contextual",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the local economy around Elizabeth, not Henry's occupation or a proved residence for him."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Lived in a Georgian market and coaching town where six major roads met",
      "start_date": "1799",
      "end_date": "1840",
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_DEATH_BURIAL_1840",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_LOCAL_HISTORY_GEORGIAN_COACHING"
      ],
      "source_note": "The town context does not establish James's trade or social status."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JOHN_HENDERSON_GILES_RECORD_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The candidate estate arose in a county whose boundaries changed repeatedly during the early nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1843",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Giles County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1843_JOHN_R_HENDERSON_GILES_PROBATE",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_GILES_COUNTY_MICROFILM"
      ],
      "source_note": "This context belongs to the probate namesake and should not be transferred to Robert Henderson unless the identity is proved."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_PEYTON_TALLY_MECKLENBURG_RECORD_LOSS_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_PEYTON_R_TALLY_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The claimed 1820 Mecklenburg setting is difficult to test because that county is absent from NARA's list of surviving North Carolina schedules",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_NARA_1820_CENSUS_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This explains the documentary gap; it does not prove Peyton lived in Mecklenburg."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_SAMUEL_MORRALL_HORSEHAY_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_MORRALL_FATHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Richard's Horsehay and Wellington community lay in the East Shropshire coalfield and ironmaking district",
      "start_date": "about 1811",
      "end_date": "1837",
      "place": "Horsehay and Wellington, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "contextual",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_WROUGHT_IRON_INDUSTRY_HORSEHAY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is the family's local setting, not evidence that Samuel worked in ironmaking."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_UNKNOWN_MARTIN_MONAGHAN_LINEN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_MOTHER_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Small farms in County Monaghan commonly combined agriculture with labor-intensive household linen production before the 1830s",
      "start_date": "about 1800",
      "end_date": "1830s",
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This is plausible community context only; it does not establish her occupation or exact residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARY_POYNER_STOKE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_POYNER_MOTHER_SARAH_1811",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Stoke St Milborough was a rural parish shaped principally by arable and livestock farming",
      "start_date": "1811",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_MILBOROUGH_LOCAL_AGRICULTURAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish economy does not establish Mary's occupation or household status."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARY_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_TOMPSON_MOTHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family worshipped at St Peter's in a growing market and manufacturing town connected by turnpike roads",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_COUNCIL_CITY_CENTRE_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This town setting does not establish Mary's occupation or address."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_THOMAS_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_THOMAS_TOMPSON_FATHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family worshipped at St Peter's in a growing market and manufacturing town connected by turnpike roads",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_COUNCIL_CITY_CENTRE_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This town setting does not establish Thomas's occupation or address."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "I197",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her documented family belonged to the small Ranton and Haughton parish landscape west of Stafford",
      "start_date": "1787",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Ranton and Haughton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The rural parish setting does not establish Margaret's occupation or property status."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_DOCUMENTED_SPAN",
      "person_id": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Documented as grocer, husband, father, and parishioner",
      "start_date": "11 Dec 1758",
      "end_date": "7 Apr 1816",
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_CHILD_HANNAH_INDEX",
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_CHILD_BAPTISM_SERIES",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BURIAL_1816"
      ],
      "source_note": "His baptism and parents remain unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Worked as a grocer in a Georgian market and coaching town where six major roads met",
      "start_date": "1758",
      "end_date": "1816",
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BURIAL_1816",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_LOCAL_HISTORY_GEORGIAN_COACHING"
      ],
      "source_note": "The road network and market-town setting help explain the commercial environment, but do not establish the size or prosperity of Edward's business."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_HANNAH_MELLOR_DOCUMENTED_SPAN",
      "person_id": "C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Documented as wife and mother in an Ashbourne family",
      "start_date": "11 Dec 1758",
      "end_date": "1779",
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_CHILD_BAPTISM_SERIES"
      ],
      "source_note": "No death or independent birth record has been identified."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Raised a family in a Georgian market and coaching town where six major roads met",
      "start_date": "1758",
      "end_date": "1779",
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_CHILD_BAPTISM_SERIES",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_LOCAL_HISTORY_GEORGIAN_COACHING"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes Hannah's town environment, not an occupation or social rank."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JANE_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Raised children in the small Ranton parish landscape west of Stafford",
      "start_date": "1761",
      "end_date": "1781",
      "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish setting does not establish Jane's occupation, property, or economic status."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Raised children in the small Ranton parish landscape west of Stafford",
      "start_date": "1761",
      "end_date": "1781",
      "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish setting does not establish John's occupation, property, or economic status."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_CHARLES_HANNEY_DOCUMENTED_SPAN",
      "person_id": "I188",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Documented through marriage, parenthood, and burial",
      "start_date": "8 Jul 1765",
      "end_date": "8 Jan 1798",
      "place": "Winsley and Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771",
        "SRC_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL_1798"
      ],
      "source_note": "His reported Winsley birth remains compiled."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_CHARLES_HANNEY_WILTSHIRE_CLOTH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "I188",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Lived in the Bradford-on-Avon and Winsley area while west Wiltshire cloth making was moving from household production toward dedicated mills",
      "start_date": "1765",
      "end_date": "1798",
      "place": "Winsley and Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL_1798",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The textile setting does not prove Charles worked in cloth production."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_CATHERINE_WAINE_DOCUMENTED_SPAN",
      "person_id": "I189",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Documented through marriage and the baptism of her son William",
      "start_date": "8 Jul 1765",
      "end_date": "3 Mar 1771",
      "place": "Winsley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her reported birth and death remain compiled."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_CATHERINE_WAINE_WILTSHIRE_CLOTH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "I189",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Lived in the Bradford-on-Avon and Winsley area while west Wiltshire cloth making was moving from household production toward dedicated mills",
      "start_date": "1765",
      "end_date": "1771",
      "place": "Winsley and Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The textile setting does not prove Catherine worked in spinning or weaving."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ISAIAH_PETERS_EARLIEST_APPEARANCE",
      "person_id": "I190",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Married Betty Willis with witnesses John Butche and Richard Gibbs",
      "start_date": "18 Jun 1764",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764"
      ],
      "source_note": "The entry does not identify Isaiah's parents or prove his reported exact vital dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ISAIAH_PETERS_REPORTED_VITALS",
      "person_id": "I190",
      "fact_type": "reported_vital_claim",
      "value": "Reported born at Freshford and died at Bradford-on-Avon; an exact compiled profile now supports the continuity but cites no baptism or burial for these events",
      "start_date": "9 Nov 1734",
      "end_date": "27 Jan 1814",
      "place": "Somerset and Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "compiled_supported_unverified",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ISAIAH_PETERS_1734_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The precise dates and places agree across the imported tree and WikiTree but may derive from the same underlying compilation. They remain research leads, not direct vital evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ISAIAH_PETERS_NORTH_BRADLEY_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "I190",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Married in a parish where household hand-loom weaving existed alongside agriculture",
      "start_date": "1764",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This local economy does not establish Isaiah's occupation or residence after marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_BETTY_WILLIS_EARLIEST_APPEARANCE",
      "person_id": "I191",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Married Isaiah Peters with witnesses John Butche and Richard Gibbs",
      "start_date": "18 Jun 1764",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764"
      ],
      "source_note": "The entry does not give Betty's age, parents, or birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_BETTY_WILLIS_REPORTED_BIRTH",
      "person_id": "I191",
      "fact_type": "reported_vital_claim",
      "value": "Reported born about 1737 at North Bradley",
      "start_date": "about 1737",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724"
      ],
      "source_note": "A Clyffe Pypard namesake belongs to another marriage and is excluded."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_BETTY_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "I191",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Married in a parish where household hand-loom weaving existed alongside agriculture",
      "start_date": "1764",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This local economy does not establish Betty's occupation or household status."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_JOHN_GRINDLEY_DOCUMENTED_SPAN",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Documented through marriage and the baptism of son Thomas",
      "start_date": "31 Dec 1777",
      "end_date": "1783",
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783"
      ],
      "source_note": "His reported birth and death remain compiled."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Belonged to the ancient Forton parish near Newport and the Shropshire border",
      "start_date": "1777",
      "end_date": "1783",
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Surviving tithe and churchwardens' accounts may illuminate the household, but no personal entry has yet been found."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_DOCUMENTED_SPAN",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Documented through marriage and the baptism of son Thomas",
      "start_date": "31 Dec 1777",
      "end_date": "1783",
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783"
      ],
      "source_note": "No secure baptism or death has been identified."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_FORTON_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Belonged to the ancient Forton parish near Newport and the Shropshire border",
      "start_date": "1777",
      "end_date": "1783",
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish setting does not establish Elizabeth's occupation, property, or parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_NANCY_WILLIS_EARLIEST_APPEARANCE",
      "person_id": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Married Robert Lavinder",
      "start_date": "27 Feb 1794",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Franklin County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not independently establish motherhood of Fanny Lavender."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_NANCY_WILLIS_DUAL_MARRIAGE_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Robert Lavinder married Nancy Willis in 1794 and a Milly Willis in 1795",
      "start_date": "27 Feb 1794",
      "end_date": "1795",
      "place": "Franklin County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Do not merge Nancy, Milly, or Parmelia without an original record showing that the names refer to one woman."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_NANCY_WILLIS_FRANKLIN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Married in a recently formed western-Piedmont county shaped by agriculture, tobacco, and movement along the Carolina Road",
      "start_date": "1794",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Franklin County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_COUNTY_VA_OFFICIAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This local setting does not establish Nancy's occupation, landholding, or participation in tobacco cultivation."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ANN_WHITESIDE_GENERATION_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Usually placed with the older John Hargis and therefore likely one generation above Amelia",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia or North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE_PROFILE_REVIEW"
      ],
      "source_note": "The proposed Whiteside parents are not supported by the estate abstract cited on the profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANN_WHITESIDE_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No personal local history can be assigned until her generation, identity, and residence are established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Generic colonial events would imply a certainty the evidence does not support."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_MOTHER_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Reported as Amelia Hargis's mother in the structurally more coherent younger-John pedigree",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Possibly Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA"
      ],
      "source_note": "Chronological coherence raises plausibility but does not prove identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No personal local history can be assigned until her identity and residence are established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generic colonial events would imply a certainty the evidence does not support."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_CHRISTIANA_HORNBERGER_EARLIEST_APPEARANCE",
      "person_id": "I110",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Named as Christian Gabel's mother at his Lutheran baptism",
      "start_date": "21 May 1754",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Old Goshenhoppen, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "No reliable record identifies her own parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_CHRISTIANA_HORNBERGER_GOSHENHOPPEN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "I110",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Belonged to a German-speaking church community of farmers and tradespeople where Lutherans and German Reformed settlers shared institutions",
      "start_date": "1754",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Old Goshenhoppen, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_GOSCHENHOPPEN_HISTORIANS_EARLY_CHURCH_SCHOOLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The community setting does not establish Christiana's occupation, wealth, or immigration history."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_MARY_BARTEE_IDENTITY_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "I69",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Reported only as a possible wife of William Bartee and possible mother of Suckey",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The child's marriage bond names William but not her mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARY_BARTEE_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "I69",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No personal local history can be assigned without a surname, reliable locality, or record identifying William Bartee's wife",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generic colonial context would make this unresolved candidate appear more certain than she is."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_JAMES_BOSWELL_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Reported as Grace Boswell's father; a different Grace Boswell is documented in the same colonial county",
      "start_date": "reported about 1655",
      "end_date": "reported Sep 1718",
      "place": "Reported Elizabeth City County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.46,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE"
      ],
      "source_note": "No original record bridges James to the Hargis-associated Grace."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JAMES_BOSWELL_ELIZABETH_CITY_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the reported county identity is correct, he lived in the Hampton-centered coastal county as Hampton became a legally designated port in 1708",
      "start_date": "about 1708",
      "end_date": "1718",
      "place": "Elizabeth City County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.46,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_ELIZABETH_CITY_COUNTY_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is conditional context and does not prove residence, occupation, shipping activity, or parenthood."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ANN_SMITH_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_ANN_MOTHER_GRACE_BOSWELL_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Reported as Grace Boswell's mother without an identity-specific date or place",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.38,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE"
      ],
      "source_note": "No original source distinguishes this Ann Smith."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANN_SMITH_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_ANN_MOTHER_GRACE_BOSWELL_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No personal local history can be assigned until her identity and residence are established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.38,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A generic Virginia narrative would imply unsupported identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_GEORGE_WEIGEL_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Reported father of Elizabeth Weigel and partner of Anna Margaret Ditlich",
      "start_date": "reported; child born about 1737",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING"
      ],
      "source_note": "No original family record has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_GEORGE_WEIGEL_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Pennsylvania is too broad and too weakly sourced for a responsible town- or county-level life narrative",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING"
      ],
      "source_note": "Local context awaits an original church, land, probate, tax, or migration record."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ANNA_DITLICH_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Reported mother of Elizabeth Weigel and partner of George Weigel",
      "start_date": "reported; child born about 1737",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING"
      ],
      "source_note": "No original family record has been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANNA_DITLICH_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Pennsylvania is too broad and too weakly sourced for a responsible town- or county-level life narrative",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING"
      ],
      "source_note": "Local context awaits an original church, land, probate, tax, or migration record."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ELIZABETH_DRAPER_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Reported alternative identity for the documented wife Anne Hargis and possible mother of John",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661"
      ],
      "source_note": "The will does not provide Elizabeth, Draper, or explicit maternity."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ELIZABETH_DRAPER_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No personal Maryland context can be assigned until the Draper identity is connected to the documented wife Anne",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661"
      ],
      "source_note": "Generic colonial context would make a possible duplicate appear established."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_FREDRICK_GABEL_ALT_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Reported alternate father of Hans Jacob Gabel",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Germany",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No original record or locality identifies him."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_FREDRICK_GABEL_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Germany is too broad and the identity too weak for a responsible local narrative",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Germany",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Context awaits an original parish or civil record."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ANNE_JUUL_ALT_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Reported alternate mother of Hans Jacob Gabel",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Germany",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No original record or locality identifies her."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANNE_JUUL_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Germany is too broad and the identity too weak for a responsible local narrative",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Germany",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Context awaits an original parish or civil record."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_JANE_JAMMER_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_JAMMER_JANE_MOTHER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Reported mother of Mary Catherine Fountain",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No independent identity event has been located."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JANE_JAMMER_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_JAMMER_JANE_MOTHER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Virginia is too broad and weakly sourced for a responsible personal local narrative",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Context awaits an original family record."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_HANS_RHEINMUELLER_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_HANS_CONRAD",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Reported father of Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Possibly near Offenbach am Glan in the Duchy of Zweibrücken, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Offenbach clue belongs to the daughter's reported marriage and is not proof of his residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HANS_RHEINMUELLER_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_HANS_CONRAD",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A probable Offenbach am Glan clue cannot support personal local history until a parish record identifies Hans there",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Possibly Offenbach am Glan, Duchy of Zweibrücken, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Do not convert “Am Glam” into a proved residence without the underlying record."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_MARIA_RHEINMUELLER_MOTHER_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_MARIA_MARGARETHA_MOTHER",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Reported mother of Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller; surname unknown",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER"
      ],
      "source_note": "No distinguishing event, surname, or place is supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARIA_RHEINMUELLER_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_MARIA_MARGARETHA_MOTHER",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No personal local history can be assigned without a surname, event, or reliable residence",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER"
      ],
      "source_note": "The daughter's reported marriage place cannot be transferred to her mother as fact."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_HANS_SPIESS_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Reported father of Maria Magdalena Spiess",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No stable identifying event or locality was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HANS_SPIESS_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Germany is too broad and the identity lacks an event from which to build a responsible local narrative",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Context awaits an original parish, court, tax, or property record."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_CATHERINE_WILKINS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "I114",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Reported wife of Lemuel Butt and mother of Letitia; Warden may represent another marriage or conflation",
      "start_date": "reported; events unresolved",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Do not treat Wilkins Warden as a proved double surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_CATHERINE_WILKINS_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "I114",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Virginia is too broad and derivative for a county-level personal history",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Context awaits an original marriage, will, deed, or child record."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_REBECCA_SCHRATERN_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "I132",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Reported mother of Jeremiah Macknew",
      "start_date": "reported; event date unknown",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE"
      ],
      "source_note": "No parish within Midlothian is named."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_REBECCA_SCHRATERN_MIDLOTHIAN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "I132",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the reported Midlothian identity is correct, her life should be sought in parish registers and commissary or sheriff-court testaments rather than later civil registration",
      "start_date": "about 1610",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.32,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_MIDLOTHIAN_RECORD_GUIDE",
        "SRC_NRS_OLD_PARISH_REGISTER_COVERAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a record-environment context and does not prove Rebecca's identity, religion, parish, or residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ELIZABETH_WILLIAMS_COUNTY_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "I236",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Reported born in Charles County in 1650, but the present county was not created until 1658 and Old Charles had different bounds",
      "start_date": "reported 1650",
      "end_date": "reported 1683",
      "place": "Ambiguous Old or later Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.46,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_CHRONOLOGY",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Do not normalize the birthplace to present-day Charles County without a specific record."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ELIZABETH_WILLIAMS_CHARLES_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "I236",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If she lived in the later Charles County, her community formed around a county court created in 1658 and an economy in which tobacco functioned as a principal crop and medium of payment",
      "start_date": "1658",
      "end_date": "1683",
      "place": "Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.46,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This conditional context does not prove her residence, landholding, tobacco production, or participation in slavery."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_GEORG_BATZER_ERPFINGEN_WAR",
      "person_id": "EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Erpfingen was heavily devastated during the Thirty Years' War; hunger and plague killed inhabitants and recovery was slow",
      "start_date": "1618",
      "end_date": "1648",
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Community context only; no source proves Georg's personal wartime activity, loss, or displacement."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_URSULA_HINCKH_ERPFINGEN_WAR",
      "person_id": "EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her documented family lived around Erpfingen and Reutlingen while war, hunger, plague, and population loss disrupted the region",
      "start_date": "1618",
      "end_date": "1648",
      "place": "Erpfingen and Reutlingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not establish Ursula's birthplace, a personal migration, or a specific wartime experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANNA_KISSLING_WILLMANDINGEN_WAR",
      "person_id": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Willmandingen experienced war and hunger severe enough to displace a documented village schoolmaster after 1634; church books survive from 1641",
      "start_date": "1634",
      "end_date": "1648",
      "place": "Willmandingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR"
      ],
      "source_note": "The schoolmaster's experience illustrates local conditions and is not evidence that Anna migrated."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_URIAH_LEA_ASHWELL_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His documented family lived in an Ashwell farming community whose older market role had declined; surviving parish registers begin in 1604",
      "start_date": "1604",
      "end_date": "1614",
      "place": "Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_PARISH_COUNCIL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_MUSEUM_PARISH_DOCUMENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not prove his occupation, birth at Ashwell, or reported migration to Cheshire."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_SARACH_SAYER_NORFOLK_CONDITIONAL",
      "person_id": "C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the reported Norfolk identity is correct, her later setting was a county society shaped by courts, population growth, and renewed tobacco commerce",
      "start_date": "1691",
      "end_date": "1724",
      "place": "Reported Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTY_FORMATION",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTIES_1691_1700"
      ],
      "source_note": "Conditional community context only; it proves no residence, property, status, or participation."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_RECORDS",
      "person_id": "EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving Blankenloch Lutheran mixed register and local family book begin in 1672, after his reported birth but during his reported later life",
      "start_date": "1672",
      "end_date": "1691",
      "place": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This identifies the local record environment, not his baptism, occupation, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARGRETHA_WIDMAN_BLANKENLOCH_RECORDS",
      "person_id": "EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving Blankenloch Lutheran mixed register and local family book begin in 1672, after her reported birth but during her reconstructed family life",
      "start_date": "1672",
      "end_date": "1709",
      "place": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This identifies the local record environment, not her baptism, occupation, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_BARBARA_RADLER_IPHOFEN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen area, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left enduring local traces",
      "start_date": "before 1665",
      "end_date": "1665",
      "place": "Reported Nenzenheim area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.54,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not prove Barbara's identity, residence, religion, or wartime experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_RICHARD_CHURCH_NORFOLK_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "I120",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A Norfolk setting belongs to a same-name 1699 legislator and cannot yet be assigned to Elizabeth Church's proposed father",
      "start_date": "1699",
      "end_date": "1699",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_HOUSE_RICHARD_CHURCH_1699",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTY_FORMATION",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTIES_1691_1700"
      ],
      "source_note": "No personal local narrative is safe until a record connects this Richard to Elizabeth."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANNA_HANSEN_BLANKENLOCH_RECORDS",
      "person_id": "SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the reconstructed Blankenloch family is correct, the surviving Lutheran register beginning in 1672 may test her reported 1678 death and later household",
      "start_date": "1672",
      "end_date": "1678",
      "place": "Reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not prove her birthplace, religion, death, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HANS_MOLLFINGER_IPHOFEN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His documented Nenzenheim family belonged to the Iphofen area, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left local traces before his daughter's 1665 marriage",
      "start_date": "before 1665",
      "end_date": "1665",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Community context only; no source proves his religion, occupation, service, or displacement."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_BLANKENLOCH_RECORDS",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the reconstructed identity is correct, Blankenloch records beginning in 1672 can test his later household and reported 1693 death, though not his reported 1622 birth",
      "start_date": "1672",
      "end_date": "1693",
      "place": "Reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not prove his birth, death, occupation, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANNA_BERLIN_WEINSBERG_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her documented family lived in Weinsberg after the town recovered its civic status under Württemberg in 1553",
      "start_date": "1553",
      "end_date": "1576",
      "place": "Weinsberg, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_WEINSBERG_CITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not prove Anna's birthplace, politics, property, or experience of earlier destruction."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ROBERT_LEA_STOKE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His marriage and child's baptism occurred in a dispersed Somerset parish among Curry Moor, the River Tone, and West Sedgemoor",
      "start_date": "1587",
      "end_date": "1590",
      "place": "Stoke St Gregory, Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_PARISH_COUNCIL"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not establish his occupation, landholding, birth, or the proposed move to Ashwell."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MATTHEW_MACKNEUGH_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No place or contemporary event is known, so assigning sixteenth-century Scottish or other local context would compound an already disputed identity",
      "start_date": "reported 1518",
      "end_date": "reported 1550",
      "place": "Place unknown",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_HISTORY_BOWMAN_THOMAS_1997",
        "SRC_MCNEW_MEMORABILIA_CARROLL_1998"
      ],
      "source_note": "Context awaits any contemporary record that first establishes this person and a locality."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JOAN_SMITH_STOKE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her documented marriage occurred in a dispersed Somerset parish set among moors, drained wetlands, and the River Tone",
      "start_date": "1587",
      "end_date": "1587",
      "place": "Stoke St Gregory, Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_PARISH_COUNCIL"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not prove her birthplace, occupation, landholding, or later migration."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARGARETHA_KOCH_ERPFINGEN_CONDITIONAL",
      "person_id": "I246",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the public-tree locality is correct, she belonged to the Erpfingen area of rural Württemberg",
      "start_date": "about 1551",
      "end_date": "about 1575",
      "place": "Reported Erpfingen area, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This conditional setting does not prove her identity, residence, occupation, or parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HANNSSEN_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_CONDITIONAL",
      "person_id": "I247",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the public-tree locality and dates are correct, his reported life in the Erpfingen area extended into the opening years of the Thirty Years' War",
      "start_date": "about 1550",
      "end_date": "reported 1627",
      "place": "Reported Erpfingen area, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not prove his identity, presence during war, occupation, service, or parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_BARBARA_REIFF_OBERBOBINGEN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her reconstructed family used an Oberböbingen parish that had become Lutheran under Württemberg in 1553",
      "start_date": "1553",
      "end_date": "1596",
      "place": "Oberböbingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OBERBOBINGEN_ANNA_FUCHS_BAPTISM_1596",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This establishes the parish environment, not Barbara's maiden surname, personal beliefs, or birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HANS_FUCHS_OBERBOBINGEN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His daughter's baptism occurred in an Oberböbingen parish that had become Lutheran under Württemberg in 1553",
      "start_date": "1553",
      "end_date": "1596",
      "place": "Oberböbingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OBERBOBINGEN_ANNA_FUCHS_BAPTISM_1596",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This establishes the parish environment, not his personal beliefs, occupation, or birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARTIN_LINDER_SAANEN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported Swiss family lived in an alpine transit region that became Bernese territory in 1555 under Reformed church administration",
      "start_date": "reported 1582",
      "end_date": "reported 1615",
      "place": "Saanen and Gsteig, Bern, Swiss Confederacy",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not establish occupation, beliefs, migration, or a connection to Nenzenheim."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_SALOME_WERREN_SAANEN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported Swiss family lived in an alpine transit region that became Bernese territory in 1555 under Reformed church administration",
      "start_date": "reported 1585",
      "end_date": "reported 1652",
      "place": "Saanen and Gsteig, Bern, Swiss Confederacy",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not establish occupation, beliefs, migration, or maternity of Michael at Nenzenheim."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HANS_BEERLIN_GRUIBINGEN_UEBERKINGEN",
      "person_id": "C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His reported 1555 marriage occurred as Gruibingen added civic and church infrastructure; his 1588 death was at an Überkingen known for its mineral spring and spa",
      "start_date": "1555",
      "end_date": "1588",
      "place": "Gruibingen and Überkingen, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GRUIBINGEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_LEO_BW_BAD_UEBERKINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Community context only; no source establishes his occupation, status, religion, education, or use of the spa."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "The pedigree supplies no locality, and the possible Wiesensteig setting cannot be assigned to him; early relevant registers are also lost",
      "start_date": "reported about 1504",
      "end_date": "reported about 1568",
      "place": "Locality unknown; only broad Württemberg reported",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED"
      ],
      "source_note": "A local narrative awaits an independent record that first identifies Sebastian and his community."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MAX_JUFFE_CAMP_WADSWORTH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His documented work as an infantry instructor formed part of the First World War mobilization that brought more than 100,000 trainees through Camp Wadsworth",
      "start_date": "1917",
      "end_date": "1918",
      "place": "Camp Wadsworth, Spartanburg, South Carolina, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CAMP_WADSWORTH_MAX_JUFFE_INSTRUCTOR",
        "SRC_SPARTANBURG_LIBRARY_CAMP_WADSWORTH",
        "SRC_SPARTANBURG_CITY_CAMP_WADSWORTH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is directly relevant service context; it does not show overseas deployment or combat."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_LEON_SCHWARTZ_NEW_ORLEANS_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His documented marriage and probable notarial activity occurred amid an established and steadily growing New Orleans Jewish civic community",
      "start_date": "1883",
      "end_date": "1909",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_ORLEANS_NOTARIAL_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_MORTGAGE_1909",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "No reviewed record proves his congregation or institutional membership."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her documented 1883 marriage occurred in a city with expanding Jewish literary, charitable, and social institutions",
      "start_date": "1883",
      "end_date": "1891",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not establish her religion, congregation, or organizational membership."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_YETTA_FUCHS_GALICIA_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Galicia is too broad and crossed modern borders; without a town, no responsibly specific local history or record jurisdiction can be assigned",
      "start_date": "reported 1856",
      "end_date": "reported emigration before death in 1914",
      "place": "Kingdom of Galicia and Lodomeria, Austrian Empire",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCGILL_GALICIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_1869_1880"
      ],
      "source_note": "Broader Jewish emigration context is relevant, but it does not identify Yetta's origin or route."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_LEON_CAHN_METZ_CONDITIONAL",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the compiled Metz birth is correct, his young adulthood overlapped the 1870 siege, 1871 German annexation, and mass departure of residents through 1875",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1875",
      "place": "Reported Metz, Moselle, Lorraine",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_1870_ANNEXATION",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_ANNEXATION_EMIGRATION",
        "SRC_ISJL_MORGAN_CITY_JEWISH_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ST_MARY_BANNER_LEON_CAHN_LAND_CHAIN_1909"
      ],
      "source_note": "Morgan City evidence now supports an American identity in 1879, but does not prove the reported Metz birth or that he personally experienced or responded to the annexation."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_NIEDERHOCHSTADT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His reported youth coincided with a substantial Niederhochstadt Jewish community maintaining a synagogue, school, religious institutions, ritual bath, and cemetery",
      "start_date": "1833",
      "end_date": "1848",
      "place": "Reported Niederhochstadt, Bavaria, German Confederation",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The community history does not name Emanuel or prove institutional participation."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_LAZAR_DUBOWY_ORIGIN_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064673",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "“Austria, now Poland” is too broad and historically changeable to identify a town, archive, or local community",
      "start_date": "reported about 1830",
      "end_date": "reported 1894",
      "place": "Reported Austria, possibly Galicia",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Context awaits a town, spouse, directly identified household, or migration record."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MICHEL_COGUENHEM_METZ_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the compiled identity and 1872 optant are the same man, his family faced the aftermath of Metz's siege, German annexation, and mass departure of residents",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1875",
      "place": "Reported Metz, Moselle, Lorraine",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRENCH_CITIZENSHIP_OPTANT_MICHEL_COGUENHEM_1872",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_1870_ANNEXATION",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_ANNEXATION_EMIGRATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not prove identity, citizenship choice, departure, or relationship to Pauline and Anna."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_PAULINE_LOEB_BAVARIA_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Bavaria is too broad and the identity lacks an event from which to assign a specific local community or record jurisdiction",
      "start_date": "reported about 1839",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Reported Bavaria, German Confederation",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Context awaits a town, marriage, household, child record, or death record."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JULIENNE_LEMBACH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her reported death occurred in a rural Lembach Jewish community documented with twelve families in 1784 and 105 Jewish residents in 1807",
      "start_date": "1784",
      "end_date": "1824",
      "place": "Reported Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The history does not identify Julienne, resolve her name, or prove her Kieffer relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ROSALIA_MAYER_OBERLUSTADT_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her 1808 household was recorded during formal Jewish name adoption under French administration, preserving both Roesel b Abraham and the adopted Rosalia Mayer",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Oberlustadt, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The patronymic suggests a father Abraham but does not uniquely identify him."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_LEO_CAHN_DONALDSONVILLE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported death setting later supported German and Alsatian Jewish merchants and an organized Bikur Cholim society whose 1860 charter included an unidentified L. Cahn",
      "start_date": "reported nineteenth century",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Reported Donaldsonville, Ascension Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The charter signer may be another person and does not prove Leo's migration or membership."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ROSA_LORCH_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No birthplace, residence, or death place is supplied, and later Donaldsonville Cahn history cannot safely be assigned to her",
      "start_date": "reported before 1823",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Locality unknown",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Context awaits a Mainz or other record naming Rosa with Leo or Clara."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JOHANNA_JACOB_KYRITZ_SEMBACH",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her reported life spans a Prussian garrison and agricultural town at Kyritz and an established Jewish community at Sembach",
      "start_date": "reported 1774",
      "end_date": "reported 1835",
      "place": "Reported Kyritz, Prussia, to Sembach, Bavarian Palatinate",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE",
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "No personal record proves either endpoint, the long migration, or her Neumond relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION",
      "person_id": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His household was recorded at Ingenheim during the 1808 formal adoption of hereditary Jewish surnames under French administration",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Ingenheim, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The list directly names Leo and eight children but supplies no occupation, property, age, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION",
      "person_id": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Rösel Moyses became Rosali Dreyfuss in Ingenheim's 1808 hereditary-name record beside Leo and his eight named children",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Ingenheim, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her presence is direct; wife and mother roles are strongly inferred from placement rather than explicitly labeled."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HENDLE_STRAUSS_SEMBACH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her reported family belonged to Sembach's established Jewish community, whose 1809-1810 list includes Strauss households",
      "start_date": "reported about 1740",
      "end_date": "reported early nineteenth century",
      "place": "Reported Sembach, Bavarian Palatinate",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The list does not name Hendle or connect her to Kussel Neumond or Loeb."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ISAAK_NEUMOND_SEMBACH_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Sembach's 1809-1810 Jewish household list names Kussel Neumond, raising the possibility that imported Kusel was a misread personal name rather than a birthplace",
      "start_date": "1809",
      "end_date": "1810",
      "place": "Sembach, Bavarian Palatinate",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This flags an identity problem; it does not prove Kussel was Isaak or validate a reported 107-year lifespan."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MICHEL_KIEFFER_GUNSTETT_RECORDS",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the compiled Gunstett identity is correct, surviving civil tables beginning in the revolutionary era are the proper record environment for testing his reported 1809 death",
      "start_date": "1793",
      "end_date": "1809",
      "place": "Reported Gunstett, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The catalog does not prove that Michel appears or resolve his layered names."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_REGINA_MOSES_OBERLUSTADT_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her reported Oberlustadt household belongs to the same community documented in the 1808 Jewish hereditary-name list",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1820",
      "place": "Reported Oberlustadt, French Empire and Bavarian Palatinate",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The list does not name Regina, prove her marriage or maternity, or validate a reported age of about 94."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ROSALIE_KALLMANN_OTTROTT_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If her reported family placement is correct, she belonged to Ottrott-le-Bas's small Jewish community and synagogue setting",
      "start_date": "reported about 1770",
      "end_date": "reported about 1860",
      "place": "Reported Ottrott-le-Bas, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "No reviewed record names Rosalie at Ottrott or proves the reported lifespan and family."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ELDER_SALOMON_FRANK_OBERLUSTADT_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The younger Salomon's 1808 Oberlustadt patronymic directly names a father Samolon within the community's hereditary-name transition",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Oberlustadt, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Direct for a father's given name, not unique proof of this elder profile, his dates, wife, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_SAMUEL_ROSER_LEMBACH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His reported origin lay in Lembach's established Jewish community; a later Evansville namesake belongs only to the descendant's destination community",
      "start_date": "reported about 1765",
      "end_date": "reported before 1836",
      "place": "Reported Lembach, Alsace, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_EVANSVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_1849_PRESENT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Neither history identifies Samuel; the 1857 Evansville man cannot safely be the reportedly deceased father."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ROSEL_SELIGMAN_ROMANSWILLER_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the compiled birthplace and 1784 survival claim are correct, the Alsace Jewish census and Romanswiller records are the relevant local setting",
      "start_date": "reported 1732",
      "end_date": "reported after 30 Nov 1784",
      "place": "Reported Romanswiller, Alsace, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROMANSWILLER_RECORDS_RESEARCH_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "No underlying census entry or personal record has been reviewed."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HAYIM_KLOTZ_WISSEMBOURG_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His reported Wissembourg family setting is compatible with regional evidence that Klotz was already used there as a hereditary surname before 1808",
      "start_date": "reported about 1690",
      "end_date": "reported 1762",
      "place": "Reported Wissembourg, Alsace, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_GENAMI_ALSACE_1784_CENSUS_DATABASE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Surname context does not identify Hayim, his occupation, or his relationship to Baruch."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JUDITH_LEVY_OTTROTT_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her reported life occurred within Ottrott-le-Bas's small Jewish community, but Levy was not necessarily a unique hereditary surname",
      "start_date": "reported about 1695",
      "end_date": "reported about 1760",
      "place": "Reported Ottrott-le-Bas, Alsace, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "No record names Judith or proves the spouse and child links."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MACHOLE_LEVY_CONTEXT_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No birthplace, residence, spouse, or personal event is known, so even an Alsace locality cannot safely be assigned",
      "start_date": "reported about 1725",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Locality unknown",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Bösel Macholé may preserve a father's given name, but the interpretation is not an identifying record."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MOSCHE_LEVY_WINTZENHEIM_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His reported Wintzenheim origin belongs to an Alsatian naming system in which Levy could indicate levitical descent rather than a unique family surname",
      "start_date": "reported about 1690",
      "end_date": "reported about 1760",
      "place": "Reported Wintzenheim, Alsace, France",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The context warns against namesake merging and does not connect Mosché to Ottrott, Judith, or Jacques."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HENRY_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "I76",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His mortgage-free home marked family stability as East Orange developed into a rail- and trolley-connected suburban and industrial city",
      "start_date": "1869",
      "end_date": "1918",
      "place": "Newark and East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "No reviewed record identifies his occupation or Hanoverian town."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His family formed a stable Presbyterian farming household in the Aghnasedagh townland across the 1901 and 1911 censuses",
      "start_date": "1901",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Andrew Gibson is a locality associate only; community context does not prove parentage or land ownership."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JOHN_THOMAS_FRANKWELL_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His long residence and bootmaking trade belonged to Frankwell, an old River Severn suburb with multiple documented boot and shoe makers",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "160 Frankwell Quay, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_FRANKWELL_SHREWSBURY_LOCAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_BOOT_SHOE_DIRECTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The context supports his recorded craft but does not identify an employer or prove ownership of a shop."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_KATHARINE_SCHAAF_EAST_ORANGE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "I77",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her immigrant household established a mortgage-free home as East Orange grew into a well-connected suburb and city",
      "start_date": "1869",
      "end_date": "1913",
      "place": "Newark and East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Ober-Gleen baptism is a candidate; Hessian emigration files may supply the missing bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_DELIA_TALLEY_SOUTHWEST_VIRGINIA",
      "person_id": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her household moved from Grayson to Washington County before 1860, and she rebuilt a widowed household through remarriage in 1866",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Grayson and Washington Counties, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DELIA_TALLY_HENDERSON_1866_HEADSTONE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The timeline overlaps the Civil War but does not establish its personal effects or the reason for movement."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ELLEN_FINNEY_TRENTHAM_BIRMINGHAM",
      "person_id": "I146",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her family lived in Trentham's Potteries region before moving to industrial Birmingham between the 1851 and 1861 censuses",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, to Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_VCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_TRENTHAM_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records prove the move but not its motive or Ellen's occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_GEORGE_SHORTT_SOUTHWEST_VIRGINIA",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His documented family lived at Marion in 1870 and probably Speedwell in 1880 during southwest Virginia's postwar decades",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Smyth and Wythe Counties, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_FLOYD_SHORT_DEATH_1934"
      ],
      "source_note": "Postwar timing is context only; occupation, remarriage, and personal wartime experience remain unproved."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_KEZIA_PRICE_IDENTITY_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "The compiled Montgomeryshire identity conflicts with an 1851 mother indexed as Eliza, so no personal locality narrative is secure",
      "start_date": "reported about 1816",
      "end_date": "1851",
      "place": "Reported Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Inspect the census image or a child baptism before assigning a household, parents, or local history."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARTHA_DAVIES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her documented family remained in the Berriew, Churchstoke, and Allport border country for at least three decades",
      "start_date": "1845",
      "end_date": "1881",
      "place": "Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1845",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records prove continuity but not her maiden name, occupation, or the reasons for local moves."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_SAMPSON_RHEAD_STOKE_ST_MILBOROUGH",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His marriage and child's baptism occurred in the small agricultural parish of Stoke St Milborough, whose registers survive for targeted research",
      "start_date": "1832",
      "end_date": "1833",
      "place": "Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_MILBOROUGH_LOCAL_AGRICULTURAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original baptism establishes Woodfarm as the family's abode and calls Sampson a grocer in 1833. It does not identify his birthplace or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_SUSAN_JONES_SOUTHWEST_VIRGINIA",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her documented 1870 household lived at Marion in southwest Virginia during the immediate post-Civil War period",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Marion, Smyth County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_FLOYD_SHORT_DEATH_1934"
      ],
      "source_note": "The timing does not establish her personal wartime experience, occupation, or Jones parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANNIE_SMITH_MCNEW_WASHINGTON_VA",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her household remained in Washington County for at least 1850-1880; her North Carolina origin suggests an earlier migration whose route and family are unknown",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1864 record losses help explain the stopping point but do not prove that a specific missing record once named her parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANN_MARSHALL_PONTEFRACT",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her marriage and repeated child records place her adult family in South Kirkby and Pontefract at the turn of the nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1799",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "West Riding of Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "No record reviewed identifies her occupation, precise residence, birth, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_DAVID_BOYD_LOCALITY_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Eliza Boyd's 1854 marriage directly places her at Coolmain; her father David was a farmer, but his own residence is not explicitly stated",
      "start_date": "1854",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRIFFITHS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_SAMUEL_SARAH"
      ],
      "source_note": "Coolmain is direct evidence for Eliza and therefore for the immediate Boyd family setting. Griffith's 1861 valuation lists Samuel and Sarah Boyd as occupiers there, leaving David's precise household role unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_BERRIEW",
      "person_id": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her sole secure record places her as a mother in Berriew's Anglican parish community in 1815",
      "start_date": "1815",
      "end_date": "1815",
      "place": "Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE",
        "SRC_POWYS_BERRIEW_SETTLEMENT_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish is secure for the event; her maiden name, residence, and continuity to the later Davies household are not."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_GEORGE_ODNETT_LOCALITY_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "C_GEORGE_ODNETT_CLAIMED_FATHER_SARAH_POYNER",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "His daughter's records span Shropshire and Staffordshire, but no event securely locates George himself",
      "start_date": "1811",
      "end_date": "1852",
      "place": "Shropshire and Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_DIDDLEBURY_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_ANN_MOUND_LUDLOW_MARRIAGE_1804"
      ],
      "source_note": "Biological, acknowledged, and social fatherhood remain possible; do not assign the nearby Hodnett history to him."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HOLLY_TALLY_SOUTHWEST_VIRGINIA",
      "person_id": "SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her records document North Carolina origins followed by residence in Grayson and Washington Counties within a close Tally family network",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "North Carolina; Grayson and Washington Counties, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_GRAYSON",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_1860_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records do not state her migration date, motive, maiden name, or exact kinship to either household."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JAMES_CLARKE_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "He occupied a specifically valued holding at Aghnasedagh in 1861 during the post-Famine valuation era",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Occupancy does not establish ownership, farm size, occupation, religion, or personal experience of the Great Famine."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JULIA_SIMS_NORTH_FORK_WARTIME",
      "person_id": "I58",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her family lived in Washington County before, during, and after the Civil War, and she headed the North Fork household after her husband's death",
      "start_date": "1836",
      "end_date": "1892",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_NORTH_FORK_DEATH_1892",
        "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Regional wartime context is not evidence of her loyalties, participation, displacement, or direct exposure to battle."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ROBERT_DAVIES_BERRIEW",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His sole secure record places him as a father in Berriew's Anglican parish community in 1815",
      "start_date": "1815",
      "end_date": "1815",
      "place": "Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE",
        "SRC_POWYS_BERRIEW_SETTLEMENT_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The event is localised, but no address, occupation, marriage, or second family record distinguishes him."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His marriage and repeated child records place his adult family in South Kirkby and Pontefract at the turn of the nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1799",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "West Riding of Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records do not identify occupation, address, birth, parents, or a bridge to Batley or Maltby namesakes."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_SARAH_GISE_MARYLAND_VA_KY",
      "person_id": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her marriage and pension file document family residence successively in Maryland, southwest Virginia, and eastern Kentucky",
      "start_date": "1780",
      "end_date": "1848",
      "place": "Frederick County, Maryland; Washington County, Virginia; Floyd County, Kentucky, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records establish successive locations and her widow claim, but do not identify her parents or the route and motive of migration."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_SUSANNAH_VINES_LINCOLN_RUSSELL",
      "person_id": "C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her secure marriage belongs to the Lincoln County community; later residence and migration to Russell County remain compiled",
      "start_date": "1782",
      "end_date": "1848",
      "place": "Lincoln County, North Carolina, and reported Russell County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_SUSANNAH_VINES_COMPILED_VITALS_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Bondsman George Winfree and witness James McEwin are direct associates; her origin and later migration require a continuous record chain."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARY_MCNEW_GREAT_VALLEY_MIGRATION",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "A published family history places Mary with William McNew and four younger sons on a 1773 move into Fincastle County along the Great Valley corridor",
      "start_date": "1773",
      "end_date": "1773",
      "place": "Great Valley route into Fincastle County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_DERIVATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "The migration is plausible and family-specific but not documented by a contemporary travel, land, or church record; no proposed maiden surname is proved."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FRANKLIN_WYTHE_SULLIVAN",
      "person_id": "I62",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Marriage, census, and burial evidence trace the probable household from Franklin County through Wythe County to Sullivan County",
      "start_date": "1786",
      "end_date": "1825",
      "place": "Franklin and Wythe Counties, Virginia; Sullivan County, Tennessee, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1810_WYTHE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_EVENSHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825"
      ],
      "source_note": "The route and final move remain inferred, Revolutionary service is unresolved, and the 1820 census records an unnamed enslaved boy."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ROBERT_LAVENDER_FRANKLIN_BOTETOURT",
      "person_id": "I65",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His marriage and his daughter's later marriage place the family network in Franklin and Botetourt Counties",
      "start_date": "1794",
      "end_date": "1811",
      "place": "Franklin and Botetourt Counties, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records do not prove that Robert moved, and the separate Nancy-versus-Milly Willis marriage entries remain unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "RF_LEO_DREYFUSS_ALFRED_DREYFUS_COMPARISON",
      "person_id": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "famous_family_connection_assessment",
      "value": "No documented connection to Captain Alfred Dreyfus has been found",
      "start_date": "1750",
      "end_date": "1859",
      "place": "Ingenheim compared with Rixheim and Mulhouse",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808",
        "SRC_FRENCH_CULTURE_ALFRED_DREYFUS_FAMILY_ASCENT",
        "SRC_ALFRED_DREYFUS_LINK_ASSESSMENT_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Suzanne's line reaches Leo/Loeb at Ingenheim in 1808. Alfred's paternal line reaches Raphaël, Jacques, and Israël at Rixheim/Mulhouse. A distant regional relationship is possible, but surname similarity is not a genealogical bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JOHN_FELPS_ROWAN_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His secure identity begins in Rowan County's 1766 marriage-bond community; higher Felps identities remain conflated",
      "start_date": "1766",
      "end_date": "1766",
      "place": "Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Samuel Williams is a direct associate. No land, occupation, military, court, church, death, or parent record securely distinguishes John from namesakes."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARY_WILLIAMS_ROWAN_ASSOCIATE",
      "person_id": "EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her secure identity begins in Rowan County's 1766 marriage bond, with Samuel Williams as a potentially important but unidentified associate",
      "start_date": "1766",
      "end_date": "1766",
      "place": "Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The bond does not state Samuel's relationship. May, later vital dates, and proposed Williams parents remain unproved."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANTON_LINDER_RHINE_PHILADELPHIA_HOLSTON",
      "person_id": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Passenger and land records trace him from a Rhine-region migration through Philadelphia into the North Fork Holston landholding community",
      "start_date": "1753",
      "end_date": "1795",
      "place": "Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, to Washington County, Virginia, British Colonial America and United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_ANTON_LINDER_PEGGY_1753",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_ANTHONY_LINDER_ANCESTRY_REVIEW"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Sausenheim Lutheran baptism is geographically, chronologically, and religiously plausible but lacks an identity bridge to the immigrant."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_PHILLIS_MACKNEW_INDENTURE_CHARLES_MD",
      "person_id": "I130",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her court appearance and passage indenture place her within Charles County and Maryland's seventeenth-century immigrant labor and credit system",
      "start_date": "1670",
      "end_date": "1674",
      "place": "Charles County and Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_1674_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_NEW_EARLY_SETTLERS_MARYLAND_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH"
      ],
      "source_note": "These sources document her Maryland experience but do not identify her birth country, arrival vessel, maiden surname, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JOHN_NEWLAND_PHILADELPHIA_BERKELEY",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Lutheran marriage, later deeds and probate trace the reconstructed family from Pennsylvania into Berkeley County",
      "start_date": "1739",
      "end_date": "1800",
      "place": "Philadelphia and Pennsylvania to Berkeley County, Virginia, British Colonial America and United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEWLAND_HOPE_PASSENGER_1734",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780",
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_JOHN_NEWLAND_ANCESTRY_UNKNOWN_REVIEW",
        "SRC_OT26_ALLEN_1729_ULLAND_PASSENGER_GROUP",
        "SRC_OT26_NEWLAND_1736_INDENTURE_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Philadelphia passenger identity is unresolved between Allen 1729 and Hope 1734. Do not assume a continuous documentary chain from either voyage or the Goochland cordwainer merely because the later family is well supported."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANNE_HARGIS_MARYLAND_PROBATE",
      "person_id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "William left Ann his estate apart from specified gifts to his sons",
      "start_date": "1685",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The recorded will names Ann as wife and beneficiary, but does not visibly appoint an executrix. That description comes from Baldwin’s abstract. No birth surname, county, parents or explicit maternity statement is supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANN_SHAW_CHARLES_SUPPORT_HOUSEHOLD",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "A Charles County agreement placed Ann and Ralph Shaw within Edward Marlow's household-support network late in their lives",
      "start_date": "1710/11",
      "end_date": "1710/11",
      "place": "Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710"
      ],
      "source_note": "The agreement identifies her married household but supplies no maiden name, age, birthplace, parents, or maternity statement."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES_PLANTER",
      "person_id": "HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His land purchase for livestock and tobacco, later rent-roll appearance, and support agreement place him in Charles County's planter and exchange economy",
      "start_date": "1672",
      "end_date": "1710/11",
      "place": "Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES_COUNTY_DEED_1671_1674",
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_RENT_ROLL",
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710"
      ],
      "source_note": "These records establish property and associates but not birthplace, parents, occupation beyond the historically supported planter description, or every reconstructed child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ROBERT_BARTEE_NORFOLK_LAND_PROBATE",
      "person_id": "C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Quit-rent and probate records place him among Norfolk County's colonial landholding households and identify his immediate family",
      "start_date": "1704",
      "end_date": "1711",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NORFOLK_1704_QUIT_RENT_ROBERT_BARTEE",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730"
      ],
      "source_note": "No record reviewed identifies his birthplace, immigration event, parents, occupation, or earlier household."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_GEO_HARGAS_RAPPAHANNOCK_COHORT",
      "person_id": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "He first appears within the named transport cohort supporting John Benton's Rappahannock River land patent",
      "start_date": "1642",
      "end_date": "1642",
      "place": "South side of the Rappahannock River, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_PIONEERS_GEO_HARGAS_1642",
        "SRC_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_GEO_HARGAS_BY_1642"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cohort is a direct community association, not evidence of kinship, birthplace, occupation, payment arrangement, or exact arrival date."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARY_WERRICK_IDENTITY_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "I115",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No contemporary event or locality has been securely attached to this proposed wife of Henry Werrick",
      "start_date": "reported before 1710",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.25,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Henry's will identifies daughters and plantations but does not name a wife or the daughters' mother; no personal local history should be assigned to this Mary."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_HENRY_WERRICK_SOUTHERN_BRANCH",
      "person_id": "I116",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His will places his family across two Southern Branch plantations and records property, household goods, community witnesses, and an enslaved child",
      "start_date": "before 1710",
      "end_date": "1711",
      "place": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The will richly documents his local household but gives no birthplace, parents, wife, or immigration history. The enslaved boy is unnamed in the abstract."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_JANE_BUTT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_HOUSEHOLD",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her husband's will places her within the Southern Branch landholding household and names its four sons",
      "start_date": "1675",
      "end_date": "1676",
      "place": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The will proves she was Robert's wife but does not prove that she owned the land, mothered every son, or bore the surname Bruce."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ROBERT_BUTT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_LAND_WORK",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Patent and probate evidence places him as a substantial Southern Branch landholder whose property anchored a multigenerational Norfolk family",
      "start_date": "3 Mar 1656",
      "end_date": "1676",
      "place": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS",
        "SRC_CHESAPEAKE_BUTT_LANDHOLDING_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The direct abstracts establish landholding and family continuity beginning with the 3 Mar 1656 patent. The previously displayed 1653 start came only from a later family-history tradition and has been removed from this source-backed context. Logging activity is reported by later local history and should not be treated as an occupation stated in the patents."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_LEON_PFEIFER_PARENT_TRANSATLANTIC_CHRONOLOGY",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "fact_type": "parentage_chronology_assessment",
      "value": "The reported parents are now explicitly confirmed by linked Ingenheim community profiles, which also document their American household and later return chronology",
      "start_date": "1873",
      "end_date": "1918",
      "place": "Brookhaven, Mississippi, compared with reported Bergzabern-area deaths",
      "status": "resolved",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_BROOKHAVEN_LUMBER_E_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEON_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This supersedes the earlier unverified chronology assessment; the exact original record images remain desirable but the supposed contradiction is resolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_BROOKHAVEN_LUMBER_1884",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "business_association_candidate",
      "value": "Possible identity as E. Pfeifer, incorporator of Brookhaven Lumber & Manufacturing Company with M. Dreyfus and C. D. Benedict",
      "start_date": "9 Jan 1884",
      "end_date": "9 Jan 1884",
      "place": "Brookhaven, Lincoln County, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.45,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_BROOKHAVEN_LUMBER_E_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_LUMBER_CANDIDATE_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MDAH_CHARTER_RECORD_BOOK_2_1882_1885"
      ],
      "source_note": "The company began business in 1881 and incorporated with $25,000 authorized capital in 1884. The published account prints only E. Pfeifer. Secretary of State Charter Record Book 2 (1882-1885), archive number 33403, is the identified original-record target and may expand the name. Until inspected, Emanuel must not be treated as the confirmed incorporator."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because the 1808 patronymic supplies only the father's given name Salomon and does not uniquely identify the imported elder man, his dates, wife, or parents.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_I77",
      "person_id": "I77",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Candidate parents are displayed because the 1848 Ober-Gleen baptism extraction names Johann Martin Schaaf and Anna Catharina Grau, but the German child has not been directly linked to the New Jersey adult and duplicate-name risk remains.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "candidate_relationship_visible",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_FS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023",
        "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_HESSEN_ARCHIVES_EMIGRANT_GUIDE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This explains why the line continues only through low-confidence candidate links; the candidates should be revised or removed if bridge evidence contradicts them."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "person_id": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because the 1808 Ingenheim name-adoption list gives Leo Dreyfuss no age or parents, and no documentary bridge connects this family to the distinct Rixheim and Mulhouse ancestry of Alfred Dreyfus.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "person_id": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because the compiled Kezia Price identity conflicts with the 1851 census index naming Jane Lister's mother as Eliza; the image or a baptism is needed before parents can be attached.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "person_id": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Sarah's pension and migration evidence never names her parents, while compiled sources conflict over her birth date and whether she was born in Maryland or Pennsylvania.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_CENSUS_1800_1830",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "person_id": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because the 1734 Sausenheim baptism is only an age-, religion-, and region-compatible candidate; no record connects that child to the 1753 immigrant George Anton Linder.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_ANTON_LINDER_PEGGY_1753",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_ANTHONY_LINDER_ANCESTRY_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because later death records establish the maiden surname Jones but do not identify Susan's parents or original Virginia household, and no record from her own life confirms her birth family.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HENRY_SHORTT_DEATH_1937",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "person_id": "C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Sarach Sayer is named only in an unsourced collaborative profile and conflicts with a published reconstruction of Richard Butt's wives and children.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTY_FORMATION",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTIES_1691_1700"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Barbara's 1665 marriage names only her deceased father Hans Mollfinger and supplies no wife, birthplace, occupation, or parents for him.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "person_id": "EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because the Blankenloch household is reconstructed rather than proved by Anna Catharina's inspected baptism, another pedigree names a different mother, and surviving registers begin after Margretha's reported birth.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_I146",
      "person_id": "I146",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because no Staffordshire baptism candidate has been safely reconciled with Ellen Finney's continuous marriage and census identity, and the conflicting death-age hint is unreliable.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_TRENTHAM_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Robert Lea's Somerset family is documented but the proposed connection to the later Ashwell family requires an unproved move of about 150 miles; his own baptism and parents are unknown.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_GENEANET_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_PARISH_COUNCIL",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_HISTORY_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "person_id": "HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Charles County deeds establish Ralph Shaw's adult landholding but reveal neither his birthplace nor his parents.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES_COUNTY_DEED_1671_1674",
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_RENT_ROLL",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "person_id": "EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Samuel Williams appears only as marriage bondsman and the record does not say whether he was Mary's father, brother, uncle, or an unrelated guarantor.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_I116",
      "person_id": "I116",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Henry Werrick's will documents his property and descendants but gives no birthplace or parents, and no reliable overseas-origin record has been connected to him.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "person_id": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Rosali's earlier name Roessel Moyses is not enough to identify a unique father named Moyses, and the 1808 transcript only implies rather than states her marital and maternal roles.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops at Andrew Gibson because John's 1883 marriage directly names Andrew as his father, but neither that record nor the reviewed valuation and census material names John's mother or Andrew's parents.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_NAI_IRELAND_CENSUS_SEARCH_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The earlier stopping note was obsolete because the full marriage image has now been reviewed. Andrew is attached securely; the open questions are John's mother and Andrew's own identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Robert Butt's will calls his wife only Jane; later Bruce surnames are unsupported and the will does not explicitly establish that she was mother of every named son.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Annie's Smith surname comes from a son's later death record and the censuses indicate only that she and her parents were North Carolina-born, without naming a county or family.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_HENDERSON_FAMILY_RECORD_NOTES",
        "SRC_WCV_PARENT_INDEX_DAVID_ANN_MCNEW",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Uriah Lea is directly named in his children's Ashwell baptisms but the surviving register does not establish his own baptism, marriage, parents, occupation, or origin.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_GENEANET_URIAE_LEA_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_PARISH_COUNCIL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_MUSEUM_PARISH_DOCUMENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "person_id": "C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because the parish-based pedigree marks Hans Beerlin's proposed paternity of Johann Berlin as unsecured and supplies no proved parents for Hans; the older physician namesake is a different man.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_JOHANN_PLENINGEN_HANS_BEERLIN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_GEN15_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN15_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN15_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GRUIBINGEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_LEO_BW_BAD_UEBERKINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Kussel may be a given name misread as the town Kusel, the imported dates imply an exceptional 107-year lifespan, and no vital, marriage, property, or parent record proves this identity.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "person_id": "EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because the published Ahnentafel marks Sebastian Bleyle's father relationship as uncertain, gives no locality or original record, and relevant early parish registers may not survive.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_GEN16_BLEYLE_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN16_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN16_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "An earlier Uhland parent is attached as a candidate; the 1729 passenger household provides a promising route, while the ancestor’s passenger identity and German household connection remain unresolved.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEWLAND_HOPE_PASSENGER_1734",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780",
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_JOHN_NEWLAND_ANCESTRY_UNKNOWN_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_OT26_ALLEN_1729_ULLAND_PASSENGER_GROUP",
        "SRC_OT26_NEWLAND_1736_INDENTURE_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Supersedes the older claim that no earlier parent was attached. Compare the Allen and Hope candidates and follow the observed family cluster; missing direct parent-naming proof alone does not defeat the hypothesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Leon's official Louisiana death entry and Morgan City presence do not identify parents or bridge him to a particular French birth. Metz's 1852 index has no matching entry; an apparent 1851 Leon Cahen table entry has a mismatched act reference.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "partially_resolved_with_conflicting_archive_lead",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_SOS_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_CAHN_1924",
        "SRC_ISJL_MORGAN_CITY_JEWISH_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ST_MARY_BANNER_LEON_CAHN_LAND_CHAIN_1909",
        "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1851_CAHEN_INDEX_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1852_CAHN_NEGATIVE_CHECK",
        "SRC_METZ_ARCHIVES_GENEALOGY_PORTAL"
      ],
      "source_note": "Next targets are the full Louisiana death certificate, succession or obituary, naturalization, an 1880 household, Bertha's birth or marriage record, and a corrected Metz-area civil act. The certificate or succession may supply parents or a precise birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_I62",
      "person_id": "I62",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because proposed parents William White and Nancy Ann Brittain belong to a different, conflated Benjamin White; no record tied to the 1786 Franklin County husband names his parents.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1810_WYTHE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_EVENSHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_UNRESOLVED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_LATER_MILITARY_HINTS_REJECTED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_TURNER_WHITE_FAMILIES_CHICKASAW_BEN_2001",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Emanuel's American family and chronology are now strongly reconstructed; the E. Pfeifer lumber incorporation remains an initial-only business clue rather than a confirmed occupation.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "partially_resolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_BROOKHAVEN_LUMBER_E_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The line now stops at Emanuel's own parents, not at his relationship to Rahel and Leon."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops because Anna's baptism proves Hans Fuchs as her father but no original record yet confirms his reported birth, marriage, death, or parents, and regional namesakes must not be merged.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation."
    },
    {
      "id": "AP43_ANNA_PFEIFER_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "fact_type": "marriage_and_family",
      "value": "Married Isidore Newman II; they had one child, Edgar Leon Newman",
      "start_date": "1931",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both sources identify Anna as Isidore's wife and Edgar's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "AP43_ANNA_PFEIFER_LOCAL_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her New Orleans family life overlapped Maison Blanche's role as a major Canal Street department store and her husband's executive and wartime service",
      "start_date": "1931",
      "end_date": "1956",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_HNOC_MAISON_BLANCHE_HISTORY_20260725",
        "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_IMMIGRATION_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is documented household and community context. It does not establish that Anna worked for Maison Blanche, belonged to a particular congregation, or participated in her husband's civic organizations."
    },
    {
      "id": "AP43_ANNA_PFEIFER_BIOGRAPHY_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "fact_type": "research_limitation",
      "value": "No reviewed source states Anna's occupation, education, property ownership, military activity, court activity, or organizational roles",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II"
      ],
      "source_note": "Unknown is recorded explicitly so that her husband's documented career is not silently attributed to her."
    },
    {
      "id": "AP43_REBECCA_KIEFFER_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "fact_type": "marriage_and_family",
      "value": "Married Isidore Newman and raised a family that included Edgar Newman",
      "start_date": "1868",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published sources explicitly identify the couple and their children."
    },
    {
      "id": "AP43_REBECCA_KIEFFER_PORT_GIBSON_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her reported Port Gibson childhood overlapped the formation of Gemiluth Chessed, one of Mississippi's early Jewish congregations",
      "start_date": "1849",
      "end_date": "1868",
      "place": "Port Gibson, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_MS_ENCYCLOPEDIA_PORT_GIBSON_JEWISH_CONGREGATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "The community existed in the correct place and period, but no source reviewed here establishes Rebecca's membership, attendance, schooling, or ritual practice."
    },
    {
      "id": "AP43_REBECCA_KIEFFER_MIGRATION_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "fact_type": "migration_and_family_context",
      "value": "Born into an Alsatian-Jewish immigrant family at Port Gibson and later established a household in New Orleans through her marriage",
      "start_date": "1849",
      "end_date": "1919",
      "place": "Port Gibson, Mississippi, to New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_IMMIGRATION_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sources support the two family settings; an exact date or route for Rebecca's own move has not been found."
    },
    {
      "id": "AP43_REBECCA_KIEFFER_BIOGRAPHY_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "fact_type": "research_limitation",
      "value": "No reviewed source states Rebecca's occupation, education, independent property, military activity, court activity, or civic office",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Port Gibson, Mississippi, and New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "Unknown is recorded explicitly so that Isidore Newman's finance and philanthropy are not attributed to Rebecca."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_RICHARD_LISTER_RESIDENCE_1851",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded with his young daughter Jane and an Eliza Lyster in the 1851 census household",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1851",
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Alkmund, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ENGLAND_WALES_CENSUS_1851_COLLECTION"
      ],
      "source_note": "The household directly supports Richard's presence in Shrewsbury and his relationship to Jane. It also preserves an unresolved conflict: the indexed woman is Eliza, whereas a compiled tree calls Jane's mother Kezia Price."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_RICHARD_LISTER_EDUCATION_UNKNOWN",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education or schooling record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This means education is unknown, not that Richard lacked schooling or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_RICHARD_LISTER_SHREWSBURY_INDUSTRIAL_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Richard raised his family in a Shrewsbury increasingly shaped by steam-powered industry: the town's flax mill, operating since 1797, became its largest employer",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_SHREWSBURY_FLAXMILL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the economic setting in which the household lived. There is no evidence that Richard or another member of this household worked at the flax mill."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected primary record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, religion, locality, migration, or another family member's work."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected primary record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, religion, locality, migration, or another family member's work."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected primary record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, religion, locality, migration, or another family member's work."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected primary record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, religion, locality, migration, or another family member's work."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected primary record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, religion, locality, migration, or another family member's work."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected primary record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, religion, locality, migration, or another family member's work."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected primary record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, religion, locality, migration, or another family member's work."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected primary record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, religion, locality, migration, or another family member's work."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this is not evidence that the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this is not evidence that the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this is not evidence that the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this is not evidence that the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this is not evidence that the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this is not evidence that the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this is not evidence that the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this is not evidence that the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_IDENTITY_BARUCH_KLOTZ_REVIEW",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "The reported 1720-1801 Wissembourg identity remains an unverified compiled-tree claim",
      "start_date": "1720",
      "end_date": "1801",
      "place": "Wissembourg, Alsace",
      "status": "candidate_only",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The archives guide explains why eighteenth-century Jewish identity research is difficult, but does not identify Baruch."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_IDENTITY_JACQUES_LEVY_REVIEW",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "A second compiled tree repeats Jacques Levy, Bösel daughter of Macholé, and their son Seligmann",
      "start_date": "1750",
      "end_date": "1806",
      "place": "Ottrott, Alsace",
      "status": "corroborated_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_OTTROTT_ISRAELITE_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The match makes the reconstruction plausible but does not justify a confidence increase without the Ottrott register or civil act."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_IDENTITY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_REVIEW",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "A second compiled tree identifies Bösel as a daughter of Macholé and wife of Jacques Levy",
      "start_date": "1755",
      "end_date": "before 1809",
      "place": "Ottrott, Alsace",
      "status": "corroborated_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_OTTROTT_ISRAELITE_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her birthplace, exact dates, parents, and the meaning of Macholé as name or patronymic remain unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_IDENTITY_EVE_KLOTZ_REVIEW",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "The reported Wissembourg-to-Lembach life and Klotz parentage remain compiled-tree claims",
      "start_date": "1761",
      "end_date": "1817",
      "place": "Wissembourg and Lembach, Alsace",
      "status": "candidate_only",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The local archival framework is relevant, but it does not prove Eve's dates or relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_IDENTITY_BERNARD_ROSER_REVIEW",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "The reported migration from Lembach to Evansville and 1867 death remain unverified compiled claims",
      "start_date": "1785",
      "end_date": "1867",
      "place": "Reported Lembach, Alsace, and Evansville, Indiana",
      "status": "candidate_only",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "No immigration narrative or occupation should be presented as fact until American records bridge the identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_IDENTITY_CLAIRE_LEVY_REVIEW",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "The reported Lembach birth, Wissembourg death, Levy parentage, and Roser marriage remain compiled-tree claims",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1847",
      "place": "Lembach and Wissembourg, Alsace",
      "status": "candidate_only",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her compound surname may preserve married and birth names, but that interpretation requires a marriage or death act."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_IDENTITY_ISAAC_KIEFFER_REVIEW",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "The Kieffer surname is documented in Lembach's 1808 Jewish name index, but this Isaac's dates and relationships remain unverified",
      "start_date": "about 1766",
      "end_date": "1856",
      "place": "Lembach, Alsace",
      "status": "surname_place_context_only",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_SURNAME_INDEX_LEMBACH_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "The index makes Kieffer in Lembach historically credible, but it does not identify this man or prove the attached family."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_IDENTITY_SELIGMANN_LEVY_REVIEW",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "A second compiled tree repeats Seligmann as the son of Jacques Levy and Bösel and gives 1777-1853",
      "start_date": "about 1773",
      "end_date": "1853",
      "place": "Ottrott, Alsace",
      "status": "corroborated_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_OTTROTT_ISRAELITE_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The four-year birth discrepancy (about 1773 versus 1777) is retained as a warning against treating either tree as a primary record."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ALSACE_JEWISH_RECORDS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported life falls within Alsace's transition from sparse pre-1784 Jewish registration to French citizenship in 1791 and compulsory fixed names in 1808",
      "start_date": "ABT 1766",
      "end_date": "26 JAN 1856",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This explains the record environment and naming changes. It does not validate this person's reported identity, dates, religion, or relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ALSACE_JEWISH_RECORDS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported life falls within Alsace's transition from sparse pre-1784 Jewish registration to French citizenship in 1791 and compulsory fixed names in 1808",
      "start_date": "1785",
      "end_date": "17 Oct 1867",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-rhin, France",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This explains the record environment and naming changes. It does not validate this person's reported identity, dates, religion, or relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ALSACE_JEWISH_RECORDS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported life falls within Alsace's transition from sparse pre-1784 Jewish registration to French citizenship in 1791 and compulsory fixed names in 1808",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "June 23, 1847",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-rhin, France",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This explains the record environment and naming changes. It does not validate this person's reported identity, dates, religion, or relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ALSACE_JEWISH_RECORDS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported life falls within Alsace's transition from sparse pre-1784 Jewish registration to French citizenship in 1791 and compulsory fixed names in 1808",
      "start_date": "Abt 1773",
      "end_date": "14 Aug 1853",
      "place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This explains the record environment and naming changes. It does not validate this person's reported identity, dates, religion, or relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ALSACE_JEWISH_RECORDS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported life falls within Alsace's transition from sparse pre-1784 Jewish registration to French citizenship in 1791 and compulsory fixed names in 1808",
      "start_date": "1761",
      "end_date": "12 Apr 1817",
      "place": "Wissembourg, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This explains the record environment and naming changes. It does not validate this person's reported identity, dates, religion, or relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ALSACE_JEWISH_RECORDS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported life falls within Alsace's transition from sparse pre-1784 Jewish registration to French citizenship in 1791 and compulsory fixed names in 1808",
      "start_date": "1750",
      "end_date": "23 Feb 1806",
      "place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This explains the record environment and naming changes. It does not validate this person's reported identity, dates, religion, or relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ALSACE_JEWISH_RECORDS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported life falls within Alsace's transition from sparse pre-1784 Jewish registration to French citizenship in 1791 and compulsory fixed names in 1808",
      "start_date": "1755",
      "end_date": "Bef. 1809",
      "place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This explains the record environment and naming changes. It does not validate this person's reported identity, dates, religion, or relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ALSACE_JEWISH_RECORDS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported life falls within Alsace's transition from sparse pre-1784 Jewish registration to French citizenship in 1791 and compulsory fixed names in 1808",
      "start_date": "1720",
      "end_date": "1801",
      "place": "Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This explains the record environment and naming changes. It does not validate this person's reported identity, dates, religion, or relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, locality, court involvement, migration, spouse, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, locality, court involvement, migration, spouse, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation established as saleswoman at the Boston Store before her April 1915 engagement",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "resolved",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_FREDA_DUBOWY_ENGAGEMENT_1915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The newspaper calls this former employment; no later occupation is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, locality, court involvement, migration, spouse, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, locality, court involvement, migration, spouse, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_LOEB_NEUMOND_SEMBACH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Sembach history lists a Kussel Neumond household in 1809-1810, confirming the surname in this small community but not Loeb's identity",
      "start_date": "1809",
      "end_date": "1810",
      "place": "Sembach, present-day Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "surname_place_context_only",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Kussel and Loeb are not assumed to be the same person. The reported dates, parentage, spouse, and child remain unverified."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_LOEB_NEUMOND_SEMBACH",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported household lived within a substantial Sembach Jewish community: 111 Jewish residents in 1801 and 138 in 1825, with a cemetery at Mehlingen and named merchant and livestock-trading households",
      "start_date": "1801",
      "end_date": "1835",
      "place": "Sembach, present-day Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is community context, not evidence that Loeb held one of the occupations listed for other residents."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_RACHEL_PFEIFER_IDENTITY",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "fact_type": "alternate_identity",
      "value": "A local historical database independently records Rahel Pfeifer, born 5 January 1845, associated with Ingenheim and Bad Bergzabern",
      "start_date": "5 Jan 1845",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ingenheim and Bad Bergzabern, present-day Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_PFEIFER_RAHEL_1845"
      ],
      "source_note": "This strongly supports the core Rahel/Rachel Pfeifer identity. It does not prove Dreyfus as her maiden name, the reported death date, her husband, her son, or a Mississippi residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_RACHEL_PFEIFER_INGENHEIM",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Ingenheim's documented Jewish community included many Dreyfuß families and repeated migrations to New Orleans and Mississippi during the nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1845",
      "end_date": "1918",
      "place": "Ingenheim and Bad Bergzabern, present-day Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_DATABASE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_PFEIFER_RAHEL_1845"
      ],
      "source_note": "The wider migration pattern makes a German-American-German life historically possible, but does not prove Rachel's reported Mississippi chronology."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_COURT_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Contemporary reports identify the indexed case as elder Solomon Dubowy's support suit against his sons Nathan and Sol or Solomon Dubowy",
      "start_date": "1915",
      "end_date": "1920",
      "place": "Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CONNECTICUT_HARTFORD_SUPERIOR_DUBOWY_1915_1920",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1916",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1917"
      ],
      "source_note": "The newspaper reports resolve the apparent self-suit: the plaintiff was the elder Solomon and one defendant was his adult son Solomon, also called Sol. The litigation establishes two generations but does not identify Freda or Solomon's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_GALICIAN_MIGRATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported Austria-to-Connecticut life fits the broader era of Jewish emigration from Austrian Galicia after constitutional freedom of movement in 1867",
      "start_date": "1867",
      "end_date": "1924",
      "place": "Reported Galicia and Connecticut",
      "status": "candidate_context",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCGILL_GALICIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_1869_1880"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ditkowce has not yet been securely mapped to a modern locality, and no passenger or naturalization record has bridged this Solomon to Connecticut."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_FREDA_DUBOWY_IDENTITY_REVIEW",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "A contemporary engagement notice and the official 1915 Connecticut marriage index establish Freda Dubowy as a New Britain saleswoman and Max Juffe's wife; her reported birth, death, and parents remain compiled claims",
      "start_date": "1894",
      "end_date": "1959",
      "place": "Reported foreign birthplace and Los Angeles, California",
      "status": "mixed_evidence",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_FREDA_DUBOWY_ENGAGEMENT_1915",
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915",
        "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916"
      ],
      "source_note": "The engagement and marriage establish Freda's adult identity and New Britain residence. Neither names her parents; the rare surname and shared locality strengthen but do not directly prove the imported Solomon-and-Yetta parent links."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_FREDA_DUBOWY_MIGRATION_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No place-specific childhood context can be assigned because the imported birthplace is only “Other Country”",
      "start_date": "1894",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Los Angeles context should be added only after a residence, death index, obituary, or burial identifies the correct Freda."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_ANNA_COGUENHEM_IDENTITY_REVIEW",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "The reported St Mary Parish birth, New Orleans death, Cahn marriage, and parentage remain compiled-tree claims",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1917",
      "place": "Reported St Mary Parish and New Orleans, Louisiana",
      "status": "candidate_only",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "A different Anna Cahn appears in a period New Orleans vice directory; she is not conflated with this ancestor."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANNA_COGUENHEM_NEW_ORLEANS",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the imported New Orleans identity is correct, she lived amid an established Jewish civic community whose organized institutions included a Hebrew literary society founded in 1855 and a YMCA predecessor founded in 1891",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1917",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "candidate_context",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is city and community context only; it does not establish her religion, membership, occupation, or residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "person_id": "C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EARLY_VA_MARRIAGES_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_JOHN_HARGES_1725"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, spouse, household, locality, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_I121",
      "person_id": "I121",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, spouse, household, locality, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_I156",
      "person_id": "I156",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, spouse, household, locality, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, spouse, household, locality, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "person_id": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, spouse, household, locality, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "person_id": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_DEATH_1882",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_MALINDA_PHELPS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, spouse, household, locality, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, spouse, household, locality, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "Occupation not established from an inspected person-specific record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from surname, spouse, household, locality, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "person_id": "C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EARLY_VA_MARRIAGES_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_JOHN_HARGES_1725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_I121",
      "person_id": "I121",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_I156",
      "person_id": "I156",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "person_id": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "person_id": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_DEATH_1882",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_MALINDA_PHELPS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, or literacy record has been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": "Education is unknown; this does not mean the person lacked schooling, occupational training, or literacy."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_ANNA_LINDNER_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1620",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_reported_unverified",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "She is kept distinct from Anna Fuchs. Her birthplace, surname, marriage, death, occupation, education, and exact chronology remain unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ANNA_LINDNER_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "No responsible place-specific history can be assigned until a residence or birthplace is identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "A descendant's locality is not substituted for this seventeenth-century woman's unknown residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDA_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Eda Cauntis married Martin Phelps on 17 February 1820",
      "start_date": "17 Feb 1820",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage is secure. The index does not itself prove Eda's parents, birth, death, occupation, or education."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_EDA_EDITH_COUNTISS_SECONDARY",
      "person_id": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "alternate_identity",
      "value": "A cited local compilation calls her Edith or Eda Countiss and reports that she died between 1834 and 1840",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "end_date": "1840",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_PHELPS_WASHINGTON_VA",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820"
      ],
      "source_note": "This supports the spelling variant and broad chronology, but the original records were not inspected and the proposed Countiss parents remain lower-confidence candidates."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_EDA_CAUNTIS_WASHINGTON",
      "person_id": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her documented marriage places her in Washington County in 1820, but no record yet identifies her household role, property, church, precise residence, or occupation",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "end_date": "1840",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820",
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_PHELPS_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "The county setting is documented; a more detailed personal history would require an original household, probate, land, tax, or church record."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "A compiled early-Virginia marriage index names Elizabeth Lublinel as the bride of John Harges on 1 October 1725",
      "start_date": "1 Oct 1725",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EARLY_VA_MARRIAGES_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_JOHN_HARGES_1725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The indexed marriage supports Elizabeth's identity but does not identify which John Harges profile is the groom or prove later family relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "No birth, death, household, probate, land, church, or parent record has yet been tied securely to this Elizabeth",
      "start_date": "1725",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "partially_identified",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EARLY_VA_MARRIAGES_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_JOHN_HARGES_1725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The possible groom conflicts with a separate Grace Boswell tradition, so the precise connection remains low confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "“Virginia” is too broad to attach county-level colonial history without inventing a locality",
      "start_date": "1725",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EARLY_VA_MARRIAGES_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_JOHN_HARGES_1725"
      ],
      "source_note": "More specific context should wait for the underlying marriage entry or another record that names a parish or county."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_MALINDA_SCOTT_IDENTITY",
      "person_id": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "fact_type": "alternate_identity",
      "value": "A cited local compilation identifies Martin Phelps's later wife as Malinda Scott and reports dates of 28 December 1821 to 17 October 1904",
      "start_date": "28 Dec 1821",
      "end_date": "17 Oct 1904",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_PHELPS_WASHINGTON_VA",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Scott is substantially better supported than “surname unknown,” but the exact dates remain secondary until original or independently authoritative images are inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_MALINDA_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLDS",
      "person_id": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_household",
      "value": "Malinda appears with Martin Phelps in the 1850, 1860, and 1880 Washington County households",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The repeated household evidence establishes the married family and residence but no personal occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MALINDA_PHELPS_WASHINGTON",
      "person_id": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her documented adult life was rooted in Washington County households through the Civil War and Reconstruction eras",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This places her within those periods but does not establish her political views, wartime activity, property ownership, or occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_MARY_GRINDLEY_HOUSEHOLD",
      "person_id": "I156",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_household",
      "value": "Mary, born about 1786-1787, was recorded as Thomas Grindley's wife in Forton in 1851 and 1861",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The censuses establish the couple and approximate age. They do not supply Mary's maiden surname, parents, marriage, or asserted 1866 death."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_MARY_GRINDLEY_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "I156",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Mary's maiden surname and the record of her marriage to Thomas Grindley remain unidentified",
      "start_date": "1786",
      "end_date": "1866",
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "partially_identified",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "She is securely a spouse in the later household, but should not be merged with similarly named Staffordshire women."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARY_GRINDLEY_FORTON",
      "person_id": "I156",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Forton was a small Staffordshire parish whose surviving All Saints records and census returns frame Mary's documented later life",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish setting is documented; it does not identify Mary's church participation, work, education, or earlier home."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Mary Ann Ball married Richard Morrall in the Atcham registration district in the first quarter of 1861",
      "start_date": "Jan-Mar 1861",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Atcham registration district, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The index and households support the married identity; the certificate has not been inspected for fathers or occupations."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_MARY_ANN_MORRALL_HOUSEHOLDS",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_household",
      "value": "Mary Ann was enumerated with Richard Morrall in the Wellington area in 1861 and 1871",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1871",
      "place": "Wellington area, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her later life and death remain unresolved because she was absent from Richard's 1881 household."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_MARY_ANN_MORRALL_HORSEHAY",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The Wellington and Horsehay district in which the family was recorded formed part of Shropshire's long-established iron-working landscape",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1871",
      "place": "Wellington and Horsehay area, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_WROUGHT_IRON_INDUSTRY_HORSEHAY",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the local economy, not Mary Ann's own employment."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_NANCY_SEVIER_IDENTITY_REVIEW",
      "person_id": "I121",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "The 1850 and 1880 censuses establish David McNew's wife as Ann or Annie; they do not establish the maiden name Sevier or the given name Nancy",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "candidate_identity",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Nancy Ann Sevier remains a plausible compiled identity, not a proven expansion. Her former parent-child assignment was removed."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_NANCY_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLDS",
      "person_id": "I121",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_household",
      "value": "Ann or Annie was recorded with David McNew in Washington County in 1850 and at Saltville in 1880",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County and Saltville, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed_spouse_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This fact belongs to the spouse Ann/Annie in the records; its attachment to the Nancy Sevier candidate inherits the lower identity confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_NANCY_MCNEW_SALTVILLE",
      "person_id": "I121",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household's 1880 Saltville residence places the family in a community shaped by the region's salt industry after the Civil War",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Saltville, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "candidate_context",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "No occupation, industry connection, political view, or wartime activity is inferred for Ann/Annie."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Thomas Boulton married Sarah Rhead in 1852",
      "start_date": "1852",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852"
      ],
      "source_note": "The surname also appears as Botton in the 1851 census; the marriage and later households support the same man."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_THOMAS_BOULTON_HOUSEHOLDS",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_household",
      "value": "Thomas appears with Sarah in the Trentham area in 1851 and in Hanford households in 1861 and 1871",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1871",
      "place": "Trentham and Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records support the family and locality, but the current extracts do not securely establish Thomas's occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_THOMAS_BOULTON_TRENTHAM",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His documented family life lay in the Trentham and Hanford district during a period of strong nineteenth-century growth and industrial change around the Potteries",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1871",
      "place": "Trentham and Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_TRENTHAM_HISTORY",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Regional industrial change is context only; no pottery, estate, or factory employment is assigned to Thomas."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_OCCUPATION",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Abingdon area, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This person-specific occupation takes precedence over any inference from the rural household."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_WILLIAM_DELIA_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "William Henderson married the widow Delia Tally on 10 September 1866",
      "start_date": "10 Sep 1866",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "The transcription identifies William's parents as William and Ellen Henderson, but no new collateral profiles are created during this direct-ancestor pass."
    },
    {
      "id": "TF_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_HOUSEHOLD",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_household",
      "value": "William and Delia headed a blended Washington County household in 1870",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Abingdon area, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "The household included children from the earlier Talley family; their presence does not make William their biological father."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_WASHINGTON",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His documented farming household was established in Washington County during early Reconstruction, shortly after his 1866 marriage",
      "start_date": "1866",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This chronology does not establish military service, political affiliation, land ownership, or views about the Civil War."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I9",
      "person_id": "I9",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_HENDERSON_1930_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1982",
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_MEMORIAL",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I13",
      "person_id": "I13",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_SALLY_JANE_HENDERSON_1974",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I14",
      "person_id": "I14",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1885_1964",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1964",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I28",
      "person_id": "I28",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_NY_PASSENGER_JOHN_GILSON_FLORENCE_GIBSON",
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_NC_DEATH_CERT_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NAMES_FLORENCE",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1891_1960",
        "SRC_NEWSPAPERS_OBITUARY_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1960",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I41",
      "person_id": "I41",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ALFREDA_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_BIRTH_1910",
        "SRC_ALFREDA_RHEAD_PROBATE_DEATH_1990",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I42",
      "person_id": "I42",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I44",
      "person_id": "I44",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEBMD_KEZIA_THOMAS_BIRTH_Q3_1882",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_DAVIES_KEZIA_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_1907",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I49",
      "person_id": "I49",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_MORRALL_FAMILYSEARCH_9WWH_TDG",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_MORRALL_1899_WOLVERHAMPTON_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CIVIL_BIRTH_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_DEATH_1968",
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_PROBATE_1968",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I51",
      "person_id": "I51",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I52",
      "person_id": "I52",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I53",
      "person_id": "I53",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I54",
      "person_id": "I54",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_LEANAH_E_WHITE_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TINEY_SHORT_DEATH_1954",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I55",
      "person_id": "I55",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I56",
      "person_id": "I56",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I58",
      "person_id": "I58",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_A_STOUT_1880_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_NORTH_FORK_DEATH_1892",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_ILLINOIS_PENSION_REJECTED",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BENJAMIN_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I61",
      "person_id": "I61",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_HONEY_GROVE_MEMORIAL_1877",
        "SRC_FRANCES_WHITE_TEXAS_1836_MEMORIAL_REJECTED",
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I62",
      "person_id": "I62",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1810_WYTHE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_EVENSHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_UNRESOLVED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_LATER_MILITARY_HINTS_REJECTED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_TURNER_WHITE_FAMILIES_CHICKASAW_BEN_2001",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I63",
      "person_id": "I63",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I65",
      "person_id": "I65",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I68",
      "person_id": "I68",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_AGBI_VIRGINIA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_SUKEY_WHITE_BOND_SURETY_1786",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I69",
      "person_id": "I69",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I71",
      "person_id": "I71",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I72",
      "person_id": "I72",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I73",
      "person_id": "I73",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I74",
      "person_id": "I74",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I75",
      "person_id": "I75",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I77",
      "person_id": "I77",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_FS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023",
        "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_HESSEN_ARCHIVES_EMIGRANT_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I81",
      "person_id": "I81",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE",
        "SRC_PROFILE_SARAH_SALLY_PHELPS_GOBBLE_1825_1899",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I83",
      "person_id": "I83",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I84",
      "person_id": "I84",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I85",
      "person_id": "I85",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_INTL_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I86",
      "person_id": "I86",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I100",
      "person_id": "I100",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEBMD_MARIA_HANNEY_BIRTH_Q2_1846",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNY_1861_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_FREDERICK_DAVIES_MARIA_HANNY_MARRIAGE_Q3_1879",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I101",
      "person_id": "I101",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1845",
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_DEATH_Q1_1926",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I107",
      "person_id": "I107",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I108",
      "person_id": "I108",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I109",
      "person_id": "I109",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I110",
      "person_id": "I110",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_HORNBERGER_PARENT_INITIALS_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GOSCHENHOPPEN_HISTORIANS_EARLY_CHURCH_SCHOOLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I111",
      "person_id": "I111",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I112",
      "person_id": "I112",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I113",
      "person_id": "I113",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I114",
      "person_id": "I114",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I115",
      "person_id": "I115",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I116",
      "person_id": "I116",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I117",
      "person_id": "I117",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I118",
      "person_id": "I118",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I120",
      "person_id": "I120",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_VA_HOUSE_RICHARD_CHURCH_1699",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTY_FORMATION",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTIES_1691_1700"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I122",
      "person_id": "I122",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I125",
      "person_id": "I125",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_1715_1791",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_MACKNEW_MARYLAND_BIRTH_1715",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I128",
      "person_id": "I128",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I129",
      "person_id": "I129",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JEREMIAH_H_MACKNEW_1640_1720",
        "SRC_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1668_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_JEREMIAH_MACKMERE_PHILISE_MARRIAGE_1670",
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I130",
      "person_id": "I130",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_JEREMIAH_MACKMERE_PHILISE_MARRIAGE_1670",
        "SRC_GENEANET_PHILLIS_W_OJEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_1674_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_NEW_EARLY_SETTLERS_MARYLAND_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_PROFILE_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JEREMIAH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_PHILLIS_PARENTAGE_UNKNOWN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I131",
      "person_id": "I131",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I132",
      "person_id": "I132",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_MIDLOTHIAN_RECORD_GUIDE",
        "SRC_NRS_OLD_PARISH_REGISTER_COVERAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I133",
      "person_id": "I133",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I135",
      "person_id": "I135",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I140",
      "person_id": "I140",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_DEATH_1879_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_SARAH_BOULTON_DEATH_Q4_1879",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I143",
      "person_id": "I143",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_RICHARD_MORRALL_1842_1892",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I144",
      "person_id": "I144",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_BRASSINGTON_BIRTH_1840",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1915",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I145",
      "person_id": "I145",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_BIRMINGHAM_DEATH_Q1_1863",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I146",
      "person_id": "I146",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_TRENTHAM_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I152",
      "person_id": "I152",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_ESTHER_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_1874_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I155",
      "person_id": "I155",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_1783_1862",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_BURIAL_PROBATE_1862_1863",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I182",
      "person_id": "I182",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_GRO_HANNY_CORNISH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNY_1861_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_1802_1894",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_WILTSHIRE_BURIAL_1894",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_AVON_METHODIST_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I183",
      "person_id": "I183",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_HANNY_CORNISH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_1802_1856",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_HANNEY_WILTSHIRE_BURIAL_1854",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I186",
      "person_id": "I186",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No civilian occupation has been identified in the evidence currently cited; the dated 1803-1804 Army service is recorded separately.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "partially_resolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_14TH_FOOT_SERVICE_1803",
        "SRC_HANNY_CHELSEA_PENSION_1804",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I187",
      "person_id": "I187",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_PETERS_1765_1847",
        "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795",
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_SELECT_BIRTHS",
        "SRC_GRO_ELIZABETH_PETERS_DEATH_1847_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_ELIZABETH_HANNY_DEATH_Q2_1838_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I188",
      "person_id": "I188",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CHARLES_HANNEY_1733_1797",
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL_1798",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_CUMNOCK_KIRK_SESSION_CHARLES_HANNEY_EXCLUSION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I189",
      "person_id": "I189",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CATHERINE_WAINE_1743_1774",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_QUAKER_BIRTHS_WAINE_EXCLUSION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I190",
      "person_id": "I190",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I191",
      "person_id": "I191",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I196",
      "person_id": "I196",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1764",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_BURIAL_1847",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I197",
      "person_id": "I197",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RANTON_PARISH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I234",
      "person_id": "I234",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I235",
      "person_id": "I235",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I236",
      "person_id": "I236",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_CHRONOLOGY",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I237",
      "person_id": "I237",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I244",
      "person_id": "I244",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I246",
      "person_id": "I246",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_I247",
      "person_id": "I247",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_RHEINMUELLER_HANS_CONRAD",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_HANS_CONRAD",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_RHEINMUELLER_MARIA_MARGARETHA_MOTHER",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_MARIA_MARGARETHA_MOTHER",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "person_id": "C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "person_id": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_DERIVATION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "person_id": "HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES_COUNTY_DEED_1671_1674",
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_RENT_ROLL",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS",
      "person_id": "HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "person_id": "HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "person_id": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "person_id": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_THOMAS_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_AMELIA_1765_FATHER_1742",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "person_id": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "person_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "person_id": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_LANCASTER_WARRANT_1733",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "person_id": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_ANTON_LINDER_PEGGY_1753",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_ANTHONY_LINDER_ANCESTRY_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "person_id": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1843_JOHN_R_HENDERSON_GILES_PROBATE",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_GILES_COUNTY_MICROFILM"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "person_id": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DELIA_TALLY_HENDERSON_1866_HEADSTONE",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_PEYTON_R_TALLY_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_PEYTON_R_TALLY_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_NARA_1820_CENSUS_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_1860_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_GRAYSON",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_HENDERSON_FAMILY_RECORD_NOTES",
        "SRC_WCV_PARENT_INDEX_DAVID_ANN_MCNEW",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "person_id": "C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_EARLY_RECORD_GUIDE",
        "SRC_MCNEW_HISTORY_BOWMAN_THOMAS_1997",
        "SRC_MCNEW_MEMORABILIA_CARROLL_1998",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_REDDIT_MACKNEW_SCOTLAND_QUERY_2021",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_AMELIA_1765_FATHER_1742",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_AGBI_GRACE_BOSWELL_1690S_VIRGINIA",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE_PROFILE_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HENRY_SHORTT_DEATH_1937",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HENRY_SHORTT_DEATH_1937",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "person_id": "C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_BOYD_PROFILE_1829_1894",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_MOTHER_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "person_id": "C_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_MOTHER_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1841_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLEY_MORRALL_PROFILE_ABT1811_1853",
        "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1853",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_CHILD_BAPTISM_PARENTS_RICHARD_ANNE",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_1753_1834",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_GRINDLEY_HODNET_BAPTISM_BURIAL_1754",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_HENRY_CORNISH_FATHER_ELIZABETH",
      "person_id": "SRC_HENRY_CORNISH_FATHER_ELIZABETH",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_DEATH_BURIAL_1840",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WATERHOUSE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_KINGSLEY_1767_1769",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_CHURCH_REGISTERS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "person_id": "C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_CHILD_BAPTISM_SERIES",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_HANAH_MELLOR_BRADBOURNE_BAPTISM_1732",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_LOCAL_HISTORY_GEORGIAN_COACHING"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_MARY_POYNER_MOTHER_SARAH_1811",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_POYNER_MOTHER_SARAH_1811",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_GEORGE_ODNETT_CLAIMED_FATHER_SARAH_POYNER",
      "person_id": "C_GEORGE_ODNETT_CLAIMED_FATHER_SARAH_POYNER",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_DIDDLEBURY_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_ANN_MOUND_LUDLOW_MARRIAGE_1804",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "person_id": "C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "20 Jul 1854",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Eliza Boyd's original 1854 marriage register explicitly identifies her father David Boyd as a farmer. It places Eliza at Coolmain but does not explicitly give David's residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_THOMAS_TOMPSON_FATHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "person_id": "C_THOMAS_TOMPSON_FATHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_RECORDS_1538_1944"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_MARY_TOMPSON_MOTHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_TOMPSON_MOTHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_RECORDS_1538_1944"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "person_id": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_COUNTY_VA_OFFICIAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "person_id": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_1790_ROWAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_VA_NC_CENSUS_SEQUENCE",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_1810_NAMESAKE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "person_id": "C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
        "SRC_SUSANNAH_VINES_COMPILED_VITALS_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "person_id": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_CENSUS_1800_1830",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661_1730",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARYLAND_PROBATE_WM_HARGIS_WILL_BOOKS",
        "SRC_PROFILE_WILLIAM_ASA_HARGIS_1640_1685",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SELECT_BIRTHS_MARY_JOHN_HIRGES_CHILD_JOHN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_MARY_ANN_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS_1714",
        "SRC_AGBI_MARY_ANNE_FOUNTAIN_1670S",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_ELIZABETH_CITY_COUNTY_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_SMITH_ANN_MOTHER_GRACE_BOSWELL_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_ANN_MOTHER_GRACE_BOSWELL_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_JAMMER_JANE_MOTHER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_JAMMER_JANE_MOTHER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_MARRIAGE_INDEX_GEORGE_HARGIS_SUSANNAH_LEA",
        "SRC_GENEANET_SUSANNAH_LEA_HARGIS_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_GENEANET_URIAE_LEA_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_PARISH_COUNCIL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_MUSEUM_PARISH_DOCUMENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_GENEANET_URIAE_LEA_FAMILY",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_PROFILE_JOANNAE_LEA_1590_1614",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_GENEANET_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_PARISH_COUNCIL",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_HISTORY_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_GENEANET_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_PARISH_COUNCIL",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_HISTORY_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "person_id": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_GEO_HARGAS_BY_1642",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_HNOC_MAISON_BLANCHE_HISTORY_20260725",
        "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_IMMIGRATION_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_MS_ENCYCLOPEDIA_PORT_GIBSON_JEWISH_CONGREGATION",
        "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_IMMIGRATION_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE",
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_MARION_PFEIFER_ABRAMSON",
        "SRC_LA_WOMEN_IN_INDUSTRY_BERTHA_PFEIFER_1919"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_BROOKHAVEN_LUMBER_E_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_HENRIETTA_SEGEL_1916_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCGILL_GALICIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_1869_1880"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064673",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064673",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation is proved for the complete Metz-to-New Orleans profile; a likely same-name Morgan City man operated a dry-goods store, but the identity bridge remains incomplete",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "partially_resolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_1870_ANNEXATION",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_ANNEXATION_EMIGRATION",
        "SRC_ISJL_MORGAN_CITY_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The dry-goods evidence is recorded separately at 0.80 candidate-identity confidence; it is not silently treated as proof of every imported biographical claim."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRENCH_CITIZENSHIP_OPTANT_MICHEL_COGUENHEM_1872",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_ALSACE_OPTANTS_CONTEXT",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_1870_ANNEXATION",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_ANNEXATION_EMIGRATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_EVANSVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_1849_PRESENT"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROMANSWILLER_RECORDS_RESEARCH_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_GENAMI_ALSACE_1784_CENSUS_DATABASE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "person_id": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "person_id": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Yeoman; farm lease mentioned in will",
      "start_date": "30 Mar 1805",
      "end_date": "30 Mar 1805",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Ronton testator matches the parental household through wife and children. Original will not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "person_id": "GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "person_id": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "person_id": "C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "person_id": "C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WEINSBERG_CITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "person_id": "C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTY_FORMATION",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTIES_1691_1700"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "person_id": "C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_JOHANN_PLENINGEN_HANS_BEERLIN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_GEN15_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN15_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN15_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GRUIBINGEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_LEO_BW_BAD_UEBERKINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "person_id": "C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN15_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN15_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "person_id": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "person_id": "EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "person_id": "EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "person_id": "EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "person_id": "EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "person_id": "EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "person_id": "EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "person_id": "EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_GEN16_BLEYLE_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN16_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN16_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "person_id": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "person_id": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "person_id": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I9",
      "person_id": "I9",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_HENDERSON_1930_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1982",
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_MEMORIAL",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I10",
      "person_id": "I10",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NJ_BIRTH_1915",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1973",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1973_DEATH_BURIAL",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1950_CENSUS_OCCUPATION",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_LA_MARQUE_RESIDENCE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I13",
      "person_id": "I13",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_SALLY_JANE_HENDERSON_1974",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I14",
      "person_id": "I14",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1885_1964",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1964",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I27",
      "person_id": "I27",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PRESBYTERIAN_JOHANN_GEORG_FRICKE_BAPTISM_1881",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_1920_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_1930_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_BURIAL",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1924",
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1929"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I28",
      "person_id": "I28",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_NY_PASSENGER_JOHN_GILSON_FLORENCE_GIBSON",
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_NC_DEATH_CERT_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NAMES_FLORENCE",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1891_1960",
        "SRC_NEWSPAPERS_OBITUARY_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1960",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I41",
      "person_id": "I41",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ALFREDA_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_BIRTH_1910",
        "SRC_ALFREDA_RHEAD_PROBATE_DEATH_1990",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I42",
      "person_id": "I42",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I44",
      "person_id": "I44",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEBMD_KEZIA_THOMAS_BIRTH_Q3_1882",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_DAVIES_KEZIA_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_1907",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I45",
      "person_id": "I45",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_1883_1943",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BIRTH_1883",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_DAVIES_KEZIA_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_1907",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BAPTISM_1883",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_PROBATE_1944",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_WW1_NAMESAKE_EXCLUSION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I49",
      "person_id": "I49",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_MORRALL_FAMILYSEARCH_9WWH_TDG",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_MORRALL_1899_WOLVERHAMPTON_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CIVIL_BIRTH_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_DEATH_1968",
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_PROBATE_1968",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I51",
      "person_id": "I51",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I52",
      "person_id": "I52",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I53",
      "person_id": "I53",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I54",
      "person_id": "I54",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_LEANAH_E_WHITE_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TINEY_SHORT_DEATH_1954",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I55",
      "person_id": "I55",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I56",
      "person_id": "I56",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I57",
      "person_id": "I57",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WASHINGTON_WHITE_LYON_CEMETERY_1864",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_REJECTED_NAMESAKE_HINTS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I58",
      "person_id": "I58",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_A_STOUT_1880_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_NORTH_FORK_DEATH_1892",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_ILLINOIS_PENSION_REJECTED",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BENJAMIN_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I60",
      "person_id": "I60",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_BOTETOURT_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_W_WHITE_1840_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_HONEY_GROVE_MEMORIAL_1877",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SABINE_TEXAS_TAX_1836_REJECTED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I61",
      "person_id": "I61",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_HONEY_GROVE_MEMORIAL_1877",
        "SRC_FRANCES_WHITE_TEXAS_1836_MEMORIAL_REJECTED",
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I62",
      "person_id": "I62",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1810_WYTHE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_EVENSHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_UNRESOLVED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_LATER_MILITARY_HINTS_REJECTED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_TURNER_WHITE_FAMILIES_CHICKASAW_BEN_2001",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I63",
      "person_id": "I63",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I65",
      "person_id": "I65",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I68",
      "person_id": "I68",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_AGBI_VIRGINIA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_SUKEY_WHITE_BOND_SURETY_1786",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I69",
      "person_id": "I69",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I70",
      "person_id": "I70",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROBERT_HENDERSON_1824_1880",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I71",
      "person_id": "I71",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I72",
      "person_id": "I72",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I73",
      "person_id": "I73",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I74",
      "person_id": "I74",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I75",
      "person_id": "I75",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I76",
      "person_id": "I76",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENRY_ALBERT_FRICKE_FINDAGRAVE_1846_1918",
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_HENRIETTE_MUELLER_FRICKE_CONFLATION",
        "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I77",
      "person_id": "I77",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_FS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023",
        "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_HESSEN_ARCHIVES_EMIGRANT_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I81",
      "person_id": "I81",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE",
        "SRC_PROFILE_SARAH_SALLY_PHELPS_GOBBLE_1825_1899",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I82",
      "person_id": "I82",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_G_GOBBLE_1818_1899",
        "SRC_GOBBLE_FAMILY_DATA_JOHN_1818_1899",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I83",
      "person_id": "I83",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I84",
      "person_id": "I84",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I85",
      "person_id": "I85",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_INTL_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I86",
      "person_id": "I86",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I100",
      "person_id": "I100",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEBMD_MARIA_HANNEY_BIRTH_Q2_1846",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNY_1861_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_FREDERICK_DAVIES_MARIA_HANNY_MARRIAGE_Q3_1879",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I101",
      "person_id": "I101",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1845",
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_DEATH_Q1_1926",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I107",
      "person_id": "I107",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I108",
      "person_id": "I108",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I109",
      "person_id": "I109",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I110",
      "person_id": "I110",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_HORNBERGER_PARENT_INITIALS_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GOSCHENHOPPEN_HISTORIANS_EARLY_CHURCH_SCHOOLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I111",
      "person_id": "I111",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I112",
      "person_id": "I112",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I113",
      "person_id": "I113",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I114",
      "person_id": "I114",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I115",
      "person_id": "I115",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I116",
      "person_id": "I116",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I117",
      "person_id": "I117",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I118",
      "person_id": "I118",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I120",
      "person_id": "I120",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_VA_HOUSE_RICHARD_CHURCH_1699",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTY_FORMATION",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTIES_1691_1700"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I122",
      "person_id": "I122",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I124",
      "person_id": "I124",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1810_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1840_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I125",
      "person_id": "I125",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_1715_1791",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_MACKNEW_MARYLAND_BIRTH_1715",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I127",
      "person_id": "I127",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I128",
      "person_id": "I128",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I129",
      "person_id": "I129",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JEREMIAH_H_MACKNEW_1640_1720",
        "SRC_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1668_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_JEREMIAH_MACKMERE_PHILISE_MARRIAGE_1670",
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I130",
      "person_id": "I130",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_JEREMIAH_MACKMERE_PHILISE_MARRIAGE_1670",
        "SRC_GENEANET_PHILLIS_W_OJEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_1674_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_NEW_EARLY_SETTLERS_MARYLAND_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_PROFILE_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JEREMIAH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_PHILLIS_PARENTAGE_UNKNOWN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I131",
      "person_id": "I131",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I132",
      "person_id": "I132",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_MIDLOTHIAN_RECORD_GUIDE",
        "SRC_NRS_OLD_PARISH_REGISTER_COVERAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I133",
      "person_id": "I133",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I135",
      "person_id": "I135",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I137",
      "person_id": "I137",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1841_STOKE_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1861_HEYWOOD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_DEATH_AND_BURIAL_1900",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I138",
      "person_id": "I138",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1900_WOLVERHAMPTON_DIRECTORIES",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1901_HEATH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_DEATH_1904",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELLEN_HELEN_WATERHOUSE_1835_1904",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I140",
      "person_id": "I140",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_DEATH_1879_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_SARAH_BOULTON_DEATH_Q4_1879",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I143",
      "person_id": "I143",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_RICHARD_MORRALL_1842_1892",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I144",
      "person_id": "I144",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_BRASSINGTON_BIRTH_1840",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1915",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I145",
      "person_id": "I145",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_BIRMINGHAM_DEATH_Q1_1863",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I146",
      "person_id": "I146",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_TRENTHAM_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I151",
      "person_id": "I151",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_1860",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_BAPTISMS_OCCUPATIONS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I152",
      "person_id": "I152",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_ESTHER_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_1874_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I155",
      "person_id": "I155",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_1783_1862",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_BURIAL_PROBATE_1862_1863",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I183",
      "person_id": "I183",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_HANNY_CORNISH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_1802_1856",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_HANNEY_WILTSHIRE_BURIAL_1854",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I186",
      "person_id": "I186",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_HANNY_1771_1837",
        "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795",
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_HANNY_CHELSEA_PENSION_1804",
        "SRC_HANNY_14TH_FOOT_SERVICE_1803",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I187",
      "person_id": "I187",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_PETERS_1765_1847",
        "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795",
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_SELECT_BIRTHS",
        "SRC_GRO_ELIZABETH_PETERS_DEATH_1847_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_ELIZABETH_HANNY_DEATH_Q2_1838_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I188",
      "person_id": "I188",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CHARLES_HANNEY_1733_1797",
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL_1798",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_CUMNOCK_KIRK_SESSION_CHARLES_HANNEY_EXCLUSION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I189",
      "person_id": "I189",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CATHERINE_WAINE_1743_1774",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_QUAKER_BIRTHS_WAINE_EXCLUSION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I190",
      "person_id": "I190",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I191",
      "person_id": "I191",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I196",
      "person_id": "I196",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1764",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_BURIAL_1847",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I197",
      "person_id": "I197",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RANTON_PARISH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I234",
      "person_id": "I234",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I235",
      "person_id": "I235",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I236",
      "person_id": "I236",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_CHRONOLOGY",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I237",
      "person_id": "I237",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I241",
      "person_id": "I241",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I243",
      "person_id": "I243",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBEL_GENI",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I244",
      "person_id": "I244",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I245",
      "person_id": "I245",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I246",
      "person_id": "I246",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_I247",
      "person_id": "I247",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_RHEINMUELLER_HANS_CONRAD",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_HANS_CONRAD",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_RHEINMUELLER_MARIA_MARGARETHA_MOTHER",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_MARIA_MARGARETHA_MOTHER",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "person_id": "C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "person_id": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_DERIVATION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "person_id": "HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES_COUNTY_DEED_1671_1674",
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_RENT_ROLL",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS",
      "person_id": "HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "person_id": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_CENSUS_1800_1830",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "person_id": "HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "person_id": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "person_id": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879",
        "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_FINDAGRAVE_1851_1931",
        "SRC_FRANKWELL_SHREWSBURY_LOCAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_BOOT_SHOE_DIRECTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_THOMAS_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_AMELIA_1765_FATHER_1742",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "person_id": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "person_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "person_id": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_LANCASTER_WARRANT_1733",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "person_id": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_ANTON_LINDER_PEGGY_1753",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_ANTHONY_LINDER_ANCESTRY_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "person_id": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796_1882",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1820_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1830_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_DEATH_1882",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1843_JOHN_R_HENDERSON_GILES_PROBATE",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_GILES_COUNTY_MICROFILM"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "person_id": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_EVAN_L_TALLEY_1823_BEFORE_1866",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "person_id": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DELIA_TALLY_HENDERSON_1866_HEADSTONE",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_PEYTON_R_TALLY_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_PEYTON_R_TALLY_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_NARA_1820_CENSUS_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_1860_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_GRAYSON",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_HENDERSON_FAMILY_RECORD_NOTES",
        "SRC_WCV_PARENT_INDEX_DAVID_ANN_MCNEW",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "person_id": "C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_EARLY_RECORD_GUIDE",
        "SRC_MCNEW_HISTORY_BOWMAN_THOMAS_1997",
        "SRC_MCNEW_MEMORABILIA_CARROLL_1998",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_REDDIT_MACKNEW_SCOTLAND_QUERY_2021",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_AMELIA_1765_FATHER_1742",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_AGBI_GRACE_BOSWELL_1690S_VIRGINIA",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE_PROFILE_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HENRY_SHORTT_DEATH_1937",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HENRY_SHORTT_DEATH_1937",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "person_id": "C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_BOYD_PROFILE_1829_1894",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_MOTHER_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "person_id": "C_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_MOTHER_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1841_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1881_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_DEATH_1884",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_1811_1884",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_BURIAL_1884",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1841_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLEY_MORRALL_PROFILE_ABT1811_1853",
        "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1853",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_CHILD_BAPTISM_PARENTS_RICHARD_ANNE",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_1753_1834",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_GRINDLEY_HODNET_BAPTISM_BURIAL_1754",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_SAMUEL_MORRALL_FATHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_MORRALL_FATHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_MORRALL_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1810_1811",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_HENRY_CORNISH_FATHER_ELIZABETH",
      "person_id": "SRC_HENRY_CORNISH_FATHER_ELIZABETH",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_DEATH_BURIAL_1840",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WATERHOUSE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_KINGSLEY_1767_1769",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_CHURCH_REGISTERS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "person_id": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_CHILD_HANNAH_INDEX",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BURIAL_1816",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1734_1738",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_LOCAL_HISTORY_GEORGIAN_COACHING"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "person_id": "C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_CHILD_BAPTISM_SERIES",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_HANAH_MELLOR_BRADBOURNE_BAPTISM_1732",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_LOCAL_HISTORY_GEORGIAN_COACHING"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_MARY_POYNER_MOTHER_SARAH_1811",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_POYNER_MOTHER_SARAH_1811",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_GEORGE_ODNETT_CLAIMED_FATHER_SARAH_POYNER",
      "person_id": "C_GEORGE_ODNETT_CLAIMED_FATHER_SARAH_POYNER",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_DIDDLEBURY_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_ANN_MOUND_LUDLOW_MARRIAGE_1804",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "person_id": "C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVID_BOYD_PROFILE_1800_1810_1890",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_THOMAS_TOMPSON_FATHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "person_id": "C_THOMAS_TOMPSON_FATHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_RECORDS_1538_1944"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_MARY_TOMPSON_MOTHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_TOMPSON_MOTHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_RECORDS_1538_1944"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "person_id": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_COUNTY_VA_OFFICIAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "person_id": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_1790_ROWAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_VA_NC_CENSUS_SEQUENCE",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_1810_NAMESAKE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "person_id": "C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
        "SRC_SUSANNAH_VINES_COMPILED_VITALS_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "person_id": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_CENSUS_1800_1830",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661_1730",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARYLAND_PROBATE_WM_HARGIS_WILL_BOOKS",
        "SRC_PROFILE_WILLIAM_ASA_HARGIS_1640_1685",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SELECT_BIRTHS_MARY_JOHN_HIRGES_CHILD_JOHN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_MARY_ANN_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS_1714",
        "SRC_AGBI_MARY_ANNE_FOUNTAIN_1670S",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_ELIZABETH_CITY_COUNTY_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_SMITH_ANN_MOTHER_GRACE_BOSWELL_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_ANN_MOTHER_GRACE_BOSWELL_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_JAMMER_JANE_MOTHER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_JAMMER_JANE_MOTHER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_MARRIAGE_INDEX_GEORGE_HARGIS_SUSANNAH_LEA",
        "SRC_GENEANET_SUSANNAH_LEA_HARGIS_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_GENEANET_URIAE_LEA_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_PARISH_COUNCIL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_MUSEUM_PARISH_DOCUMENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_GENEANET_URIAE_LEA_FAMILY",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_PROFILE_JOANNAE_LEA_1590_1614",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_GENEANET_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_PARISH_COUNCIL",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_HISTORY_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_GENEANET_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_PARISH_COUNCIL",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_HISTORY_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "person_id": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_GEO_HARGAS_BY_1642",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_HNOC_MAISON_BLANCHE_HISTORY_20260725",
        "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_IMMIGRATION_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935",
        "SRC_CROCKERY_GLASS_JOURNAL_EDGAR_NEWMAN_MAISON_BLANCHE",
        "SRC_TALKING_MACHINE_WORLD_EDGAR_NEWMAN_1922",
        "SRC_ENTERPRISE_IN_RADIO_EDGAR_NEWMAN"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_AJC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_DEATH_1909",
        "SRC_COMMERCIAL_FINANCIAL_CHRONICLE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1909",
        "SRC_SOARDS_NEW_ORLEANS_GUIDE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_STOCK_EXCHANGE",
        "SRC_HNOC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_LEGACY",
        "SRC_NEWMAN_SCHOOL_HISTORY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN",
        "SRC_LA_SUPREME_COURT_ADAMS_MACHINE_V_NEWMAN_1902"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_MS_ENCYCLOPEDIA_PORT_GIBSON_JEWISH_CONGREGATION",
        "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_IMMIGRATION_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE",
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_MARION_PFEIFER_ABRAMSON",
        "SRC_LA_WOMEN_IN_INDUSTRY_BERTHA_PFEIFER_1919"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_BROOKHAVEN_LUMBER_E_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_HENRIETTA_SEGEL_1916_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NY_ADJUTANT_GENERAL_MAX_JUFFE_1917",
        "SRC_CAMP_WADSWORTH_MAX_JUFFE_INSTRUCTOR",
        "SRC_TROWS_DIRECTORY_MAX_JUFFE_ARGONNE_PRESS_1922",
        "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_MAX_JUFFE_1888_1979",
        "SRC_SPARTANBURG_LIBRARY_CAMP_WADSWORTH",
        "SRC_SPARTANBURG_CITY_CAMP_WADSWORTH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCGILL_GALICIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_1869_1880"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064673",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064673",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_1870_ANNEXATION",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_ANNEXATION_EMIGRATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRENCH_CITIZENSHIP_OPTANT_MICHEL_COGUENHEM_1872",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_ALSACE_OPTANTS_CONTEXT",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_1870_ANNEXATION",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_ANNEXATION_EMIGRATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_EVANSVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_1849_PRESENT"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROMANSWILLER_RECORDS_RESEARCH_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_GENAMI_ALSACE_1784_CENSUS_DATABASE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "person_id": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "person_id": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "person_id": "GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "person_id": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "person_id": "C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "person_id": "C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WEINSBERG_CITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "person_id": "C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTY_FORMATION",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTIES_1691_1700"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "person_id": "C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_JOHANN_PLENINGEN_HANS_BEERLIN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_GEN15_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN15_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN15_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GRUIBINGEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_LEO_BW_BAD_UEBERKINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "person_id": "C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN15_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN15_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "person_id": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "person_id": "EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "person_id": "EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "person_id": "EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "person_id": "EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "person_id": "EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "person_id": "EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "person_id": "EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_GEN16_BLEYLE_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN16_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN16_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "person_id": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "person_id": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "person_id": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I122",
      "person_id": "I122",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I124",
      "person_id": "I124",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1810_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1840_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I51",
      "person_id": "I51",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I52",
      "person_id": "I52",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I55",
      "person_id": "I55",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I56",
      "person_id": "I56",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I57",
      "person_id": "I57",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WASHINGTON_WHITE_LYON_CEMETERY_1864",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_REJECTED_NAMESAKE_HINTS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I70",
      "person_id": "I70",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROBERT_HENDERSON_1824_1880",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I71",
      "person_id": "I71",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I81",
      "person_id": "I81",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE",
        "SRC_PROFILE_SARAH_SALLY_PHELPS_GOBBLE_1825_1899",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I82",
      "person_id": "I82",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_G_GOBBLE_1818_1899",
        "SRC_GOBBLE_FAMILY_DATA_JOHN_1818_1899",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I83",
      "person_id": "I83",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I84",
      "person_id": "I84",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_I85",
      "person_id": "I85",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_INTL_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_AMELIA_1765_FATHER_1742",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WASHINGTON_SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The surviving family evidence places this person within Washington County's rural southwest-Virginia community, whose census, land, court, tax, and probate records document households across the early republic and nineteenth century",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796_1882",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1820_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1830_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_DEATH_1882",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the documented county setting and its record environment. It does not establish a particular farm, class, occupation, property holding, religion, politics, or public role unless another fact states one."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SALTVILLE_I122",
      "person_id": "I122",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household's southwest-Virginia life overlapped the Civil War, when nearby Saltville's strategic salt works made the area the site of major fighting in 1864",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Washington County and Saltville area, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional conflict is historical context only. It does not prove military service, allegiance, combat exposure, political views, work at the salt works, or support for either side."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SALTVILLE_I51",
      "person_id": "I51",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household's southwest-Virginia life overlapped the Civil War, when nearby Saltville's strategic salt works made the area the site of major fighting in 1864",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Washington County and Saltville area, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional conflict is historical context only. It does not prove military service, allegiance, combat exposure, political views, work at the salt works, or support for either side."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SALTVILLE_I52",
      "person_id": "I52",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household's southwest-Virginia life overlapped the Civil War, when nearby Saltville's strategic salt works made the area the site of major fighting in 1864",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Washington County and Saltville area, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional conflict is historical context only. It does not prove military service, allegiance, combat exposure, political views, work at the salt works, or support for either side."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SALTVILLE_I55",
      "person_id": "I55",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household's southwest-Virginia life overlapped the Civil War, when nearby Saltville's strategic salt works made the area the site of major fighting in 1864",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Washington County and Saltville area, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional conflict is historical context only. It does not prove military service, allegiance, combat exposure, political views, work at the salt works, or support for either side."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SALTVILLE_I56",
      "person_id": "I56",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household's southwest-Virginia life overlapped the Civil War, when nearby Saltville's strategic salt works made the area the site of major fighting in 1864",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Washington County and Saltville area, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional conflict is historical context only. It does not prove military service, allegiance, combat exposure, political views, work at the salt works, or support for either side."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SALTVILLE_I57",
      "person_id": "I57",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household's southwest-Virginia life overlapped the Civil War, when nearby Saltville's strategic salt works made the area the site of major fighting in 1864",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Washington County and Saltville area, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WASHINGTON_WHITE_LYON_CEMETERY_1864",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_REJECTED_NAMESAKE_HINTS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional conflict is historical context only. It does not prove military service, allegiance, combat exposure, political views, work at the salt works, or support for either side."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SALTVILLE_I70",
      "person_id": "I70",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household's southwest-Virginia life overlapped the Civil War, when nearby Saltville's strategic salt works made the area the site of major fighting in 1864",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Washington County and Saltville area, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROBERT_HENDERSON_1824_1880",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional conflict is historical context only. It does not prove military service, allegiance, combat exposure, political views, work at the salt works, or support for either side."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SALTVILLE_I71",
      "person_id": "I71",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household's southwest-Virginia life overlapped the Civil War, when nearby Saltville's strategic salt works made the area the site of major fighting in 1864",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Washington County and Saltville area, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional conflict is historical context only. It does not prove military service, allegiance, combat exposure, political views, work at the salt works, or support for either side."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SALTVILLE_I81",
      "person_id": "I81",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household's southwest-Virginia life overlapped the Civil War, when nearby Saltville's strategic salt works made the area the site of major fighting in 1864",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Washington County and Saltville area, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE",
        "SRC_PROFILE_SARAH_SALLY_PHELPS_GOBBLE_1825_1899",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional conflict is historical context only. It does not prove military service, allegiance, combat exposure, political views, work at the salt works, or support for either side."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SALTVILLE_SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household's southwest-Virginia life overlapped the Civil War, when nearby Saltville's strategic salt works made the area the site of major fighting in 1864",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Washington County and Saltville area, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796_1882",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1820_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1830_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_DEATH_1882",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional conflict is historical context only. It does not prove military service, allegiance, combat exposure, political views, work at the salt works, or support for either side."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NORTH_FORK_I13",
      "person_id": "I13",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Census and civil records place the family in the North Fork and Abingdon area as a rural Washington County community moved from Reconstruction into the twentieth century",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1954",
      "place": "North Fork and Abingdon area, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_SALLY_JANE_HENDERSON_1974",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "This documents continuity of place and household. It does not establish occupation, land ownership, wealth, religion, or political experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NORTH_FORK_I53",
      "person_id": "I53",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Census and civil records place the family in the North Fork and Abingdon area as a rural Washington County community moved from Reconstruction into the twentieth century",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1954",
      "place": "North Fork and Abingdon area, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This documents continuity of place and household. It does not establish occupation, land ownership, wealth, religion, or political experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NORTH_FORK_I54",
      "person_id": "I54",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Census and civil records place the family in the North Fork and Abingdon area as a rural Washington County community moved from Reconstruction into the twentieth century",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1954",
      "place": "North Fork and Abingdon area, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_LEANAH_E_WHITE_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TINEY_SHORT_DEATH_1954",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This documents continuity of place and household. It does not establish occupation, land ownership, wealth, religion, or political experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_BLANKENLOCH_SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family's reported Blankenloch life falls within the surviving Lutheran mixed register and local family book, both beginning in 1672",
      "start_date": "1672",
      "end_date": "1733",
      "place": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "record_and_community_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record survival date explains what can be tested. It does not by itself prove a reported event, identity, occupation, belief, or relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_BLANKENLOCH_SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family's reported Blankenloch life falls within the surviving Lutheran mixed register and local family book, both beginning in 1672",
      "start_date": "1672",
      "end_date": "1733",
      "place": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "record_and_community_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record survival date explains what can be tested. It does not by itself prove a reported event, identity, occupation, belief, or relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_BLANKENLOCH_SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family's reported Blankenloch life falls within the surviving Lutheran mixed register and local family book, both beginning in 1672",
      "start_date": "1672",
      "end_date": "1733",
      "place": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "record_and_community_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record survival date explains what can be tested. It does not by itself prove a reported event, identity, occupation, belief, or relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_BLANKENLOCH_SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "person_id": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family's reported Blankenloch life falls within the surviving Lutheran mixed register and local family book, both beginning in 1672",
      "start_date": "1672",
      "end_date": "1733",
      "place": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "record_and_community_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_LANCASTER_WARRANT_1733",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record survival date explains what can be tested. It does not by itself prove a reported event, identity, occupation, belief, or relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_ERPFINGEN_HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "person_id": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Erpfingen was severely disrupted by the Thirty Years' War, hunger, plague, and population loss; the documented family spans the war and the community's long recovery",
      "start_date": "1618",
      "end_date": "1732",
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is community context. It does not prove that the person suffered a particular event, moved because of the war, held a stated view, or performed military service."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_ERPFINGEN_I241",
      "person_id": "I241",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Erpfingen was severely disrupted by the Thirty Years' War, hunger, plague, and population loss; the documented family spans the war and the community's long recovery",
      "start_date": "1618",
      "end_date": "1732",
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is community context. It does not prove that the person suffered a particular event, moved because of the war, held a stated view, or performed military service."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_ERPFINGEN_I243",
      "person_id": "I243",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Erpfingen was severely disrupted by the Thirty Years' War, hunger, plague, and population loss; the documented family spans the war and the community's long recovery",
      "start_date": "1618",
      "end_date": "1732",
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBEL_GENI",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is community context. It does not prove that the person suffered a particular event, moved because of the war, held a stated view, or performed military service."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_ERPFINGEN_I245",
      "person_id": "I245",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Erpfingen was severely disrupted by the Thirty Years' War, hunger, plague, and population loss; the documented family spans the war and the community's long recovery",
      "start_date": "1618",
      "end_date": "1732",
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is community context. It does not prove that the person suffered a particular event, moved because of the war, held a stated view, or performed military service."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NENZENHEIM_SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The Nenzenheim family belonged to the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left enduring local religious and demographic traces",
      "start_date": "1596",
      "end_date": "1677",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is place-and-period context, not evidence of personal belief, wartime service, migration motive, or a specific individual experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NENZENHEIM_SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The Nenzenheim family belonged to the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left enduring local religious and demographic traces",
      "start_date": "1596",
      "end_date": "1677",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is place-and-period context, not evidence of personal belief, wartime service, migration motive, or a specific individual experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NENZENHEIM_SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "person_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The Nenzenheim family belonged to the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left enduring local religious and demographic traces",
      "start_date": "1596",
      "end_date": "1677",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is place-and-period context, not evidence of personal belief, wartime service, migration motive, or a specific individual experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NENZENHEIM_SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "person_id": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The Nenzenheim family belonged to the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left enduring local religious and demographic traces",
      "start_date": "1596",
      "end_date": "1677",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is place-and-period context, not evidence of personal belief, wartime service, migration motive, or a specific individual experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_BRADFORD_I100",
      "person_id": "I100",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Bradford-on-Avon and nearby Winsley belonged to west Wiltshire's woollen-cloth district as production shifted from household hand work toward mechanized mills",
      "start_date": "1760",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon and Winsley area, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEBMD_MARIA_HANNEY_BIRTH_Q2_1846",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNY_1861_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_FREDERICK_DAVIES_MARIA_HANNY_MARRIAGE_Q3_1879",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional industry is not assigned as this person's occupation unless a person-specific record states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_BRADFORD_I183",
      "person_id": "I183",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Bradford-on-Avon and nearby Winsley belonged to west Wiltshire's woollen-cloth district as production shifted from household hand work toward mechanized mills",
      "start_date": "1760",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon and Winsley area, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_HANNY_CORNISH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_1802_1856",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_HANNEY_WILTSHIRE_BURIAL_1854",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional industry is not assigned as this person's occupation unless a person-specific record states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_BRADFORD_I187",
      "person_id": "I187",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Bradford-on-Avon and nearby Winsley belonged to west Wiltshire's woollen-cloth district as production shifted from household hand work toward mechanized mills",
      "start_date": "1760",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon and Winsley area, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_PETERS_1765_1847",
        "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795",
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_SELECT_BIRTHS",
        "SRC_GRO_ELIZABETH_PETERS_DEATH_1847_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_ELIZABETH_HANNY_DEATH_Q2_1838_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional industry is not assigned as this person's occupation unless a person-specific record states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NEW_ORLEANS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented New Orleans family lived amid a major Gulf commercial city with established Jewish charitable, literary, religious, and social institutions",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1981",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_USCSC_ARMY_REGISTER_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FRASER_MIDCONTINENT_BANKER_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1951",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the city and community setting. It does not prove an individual's religion, congregation, organizational membership, occupation, philanthropy, or social views."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NEW_ORLEANS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented New Orleans family lived amid a major Gulf commercial city with established Jewish charitable, literary, religious, and social institutions",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1981",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935",
        "SRC_CROCKERY_GLASS_JOURNAL_EDGAR_NEWMAN_MAISON_BLANCHE",
        "SRC_TALKING_MACHINE_WORLD_EDGAR_NEWMAN_1922",
        "SRC_ENTERPRISE_IN_RADIO_EDGAR_NEWMAN",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the city and community setting. It does not prove an individual's religion, congregation, organizational membership, occupation, philanthropy, or social views."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NEW_ORLEANS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented New Orleans family lived amid a major Gulf commercial city with established Jewish charitable, literary, religious, and social institutions",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1981",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the city and community setting. It does not prove an individual's religion, congregation, organizational membership, occupation, philanthropy, or social views."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NEW_ORLEANS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented New Orleans family lived amid a major Gulf commercial city with established Jewish charitable, literary, religious, and social institutions",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1981",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_MARION_PFEIFER_ABRAMSON",
        "SRC_LA_WOMEN_IN_INDUSTRY_BERTHA_PFEIFER_1919",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the city and community setting. It does not prove an individual's religion, congregation, organizational membership, occupation, philanthropy, or social views."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_GOSHENHOPPEN_I107",
      "person_id": "I107",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family appears in Old Goshenhoppen's German-speaking church community, where Lutheran and German Reformed settlers shared institutions among farming and trades households",
      "start_date": "1730",
      "end_date": "1770",
      "place": "Old Goshenhoppen, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GOSCHENHOPPEN_HISTORIANS_EARLY_CHURCH_SCHOOLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This community description does not prove occupation, literacy, landholding, wealth, or personal religious practice beyond a cited church event."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_GOSHENHOPPEN_I108",
      "person_id": "I108",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family appears in Old Goshenhoppen's German-speaking church community, where Lutheran and German Reformed settlers shared institutions among farming and trades households",
      "start_date": "1730",
      "end_date": "1770",
      "place": "Old Goshenhoppen, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GOSCHENHOPPEN_HISTORIANS_EARLY_CHURCH_SCHOOLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This community description does not prove occupation, literacy, landholding, wealth, or personal religious practice beyond a cited church event."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_GOSHENHOPPEN_I109",
      "person_id": "I109",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family appears in Old Goshenhoppen's German-speaking church community, where Lutheran and German Reformed settlers shared institutions among farming and trades households",
      "start_date": "1730",
      "end_date": "1770",
      "place": "Old Goshenhoppen, Pennsylvania, British Colonial America",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GOSCHENHOPPEN_HISTORIANS_EARLY_CHURCH_SCHOOLS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This community description does not prove occupation, literacy, landholding, wealth, or personal religious practice beyond a cited church event."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_ASHWELL_C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented family belonged to Ashwell, a farming community with an older market role and parish registers surviving from 1604",
      "start_date": "1590",
      "end_date": "1614",
      "place": "Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_GENEANET_URIAE_LEA_FAMILY",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_PROFILE_JOANNAE_LEA_1590_1614",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_PARISH_COUNCIL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_MUSEUM_PARISH_DOCUMENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish context does not establish occupation, status, landholding, literacy, or a later migration."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_ASHWELL_C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented family belonged to Ashwell, a farming community with an older market role and parish registers surviving from 1604",
      "start_date": "1590",
      "end_date": "1614",
      "place": "Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_MARRIAGE_INDEX_GEORGE_HARGIS_SUSANNAH_LEA",
        "SRC_GENEANET_SUSANNAH_LEA_HARGIS_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_PARISH_COUNCIL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_MUSEUM_PARISH_DOCUMENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish context does not establish occupation, status, landholding, literacy, or a later migration."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_EAST_ORANGE_I10",
      "person_id": "I10",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family lived in East Orange as rail and trolley connections helped it develop into a suburban and industrial city within the New York metropolitan region",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": "1973",
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NJ_BIRTH_1915",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1973",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1973_DEATH_BURIAL",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1950_CENSUS_OCCUPATION",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_LA_MARQUE_RESIDENCE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city's development is local context; it does not establish a person's commute, employer, wealth, politics, or use of a particular transport system."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_EAST_ORANGE_I27",
      "person_id": "I27",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family lived in East Orange as rail and trolley connections helped it develop into a suburban and industrial city within the New York metropolitan region",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": "1973",
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PRESBYTERIAN_JOHANN_GEORG_FRICKE_BAPTISM_1881",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_1920_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_1930_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_BURIAL",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1924",
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1929",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city's development is local context; it does not establish a person's commute, employer, wealth, politics, or use of a particular transport system."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LEMBACH_PORT_GIBSON_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family moved from Lembach's established rural Jewish community to Port Gibson during the wider nineteenth-century migration of Alsatian Jewish families into southern commercial towns",
      "start_date": "1811",
      "end_date": "1886",
      "place": "Lembach, Alsace, France, to Port Gibson, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The family movement is supported regionally, but no passenger list proves the exact voyage and no commercial occupation is inferred for either spouse."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LEMBACH_PORT_GIBSON_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family moved from Lembach's established rural Jewish community to Port Gibson during the wider nineteenth-century migration of Alsatian Jewish families into southern commercial towns",
      "start_date": "1811",
      "end_date": "1886",
      "place": "Lembach, Alsace, France, to Port Gibson, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The family movement is supported regionally, but no passenger list proves the exact voyage and no commercial occupation is inferred for either spouse."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_OBERLUSTADT_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family was recorded at Oberlustadt during formal Jewish hereditary-name adoption under French administration in 1808",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Oberlustadt, French Empire",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a named local administrative event. It does not establish later occupation, wealth, migration motive, or religious practice."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_OBERLUSTADT_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family was recorded at Oberlustadt during formal Jewish hereditary-name adoption under French administration in 1808",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Oberlustadt, French Empire",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a named local administrative event. It does not establish later occupation, wealth, migration motive, or religious practice."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SHREWSBURY_I41",
      "person_id": "I41",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family lived in a Shrewsbury shaped by steam-powered industry and by older neighborhoods such as Frankwell along the River Severn",
      "start_date": "1849",
      "end_date": "1990",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ALFREDA_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_BIRTH_1910",
        "SRC_ALFREDA_RHEAD_PROBATE_DEATH_1990",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_SHREWSBURY_FLAXMILL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_FRANKWELL_SHREWSBURY_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This city history does not assign work at the flax mill, residence in Frankwell, social class, religion, or a specific industrial experience unless another record states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SHREWSBURY_I44",
      "person_id": "I44",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family lived in a Shrewsbury shaped by steam-powered industry and by older neighborhoods such as Frankwell along the River Severn",
      "start_date": "1849",
      "end_date": "1990",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEBMD_KEZIA_THOMAS_BIRTH_Q3_1882",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_DAVIES_KEZIA_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_1907",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_SHREWSBURY_FLAXMILL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_FRANKWELL_SHREWSBURY_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This city history does not assign work at the flax mill, residence in Frankwell, social class, religion, or a specific industrial experience unless another record states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SHREWSBURY_I45",
      "person_id": "I45",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family lived in a Shrewsbury shaped by steam-powered industry and by older neighborhoods such as Frankwell along the River Severn",
      "start_date": "1849",
      "end_date": "1990",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_1883_1943",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BIRTH_1883",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_DAVIES_KEZIA_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_1907",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BAPTISM_1883",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_PROBATE_1944",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_WW1_NAMESAKE_EXCLUSION",
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_SHREWSBURY_FLAXMILL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_FRANKWELL_SHREWSBURY_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This city history does not assign work at the flax mill, residence in Frankwell, social class, religion, or a specific industrial experience unless another record states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SHREWSBURY_SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family lived in a Shrewsbury shaped by steam-powered industry and by older neighborhoods such as Frankwell along the River Severn",
      "start_date": "1849",
      "end_date": "1990",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_THOMAS_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_SHREWSBURY_FLAXMILL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_FRANKWELL_SHREWSBURY_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This city history does not assign work at the flax mill, residence in Frankwell, social class, religion, or a specific industrial experience unless another record states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WOLVERHAMPTON_I143",
      "person_id": "I143",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented household belonged to Wolverhampton as it grew from a market town into a major manufacturing center connected by turnpikes, canals, and railways",
      "start_date": "1780",
      "end_date": "1968",
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_RICHARD_MORRALL_1842_1892",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_COUNCIL_CITY_CENTRE_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city's industrial growth does not establish a factory occupation, travel pattern, wealth, or social class for this person."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WOLVERHAMPTON_I144",
      "person_id": "I144",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented household belonged to Wolverhampton as it grew from a market town into a major manufacturing center connected by turnpikes, canals, and railways",
      "start_date": "1780",
      "end_date": "1968",
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_BRASSINGTON_BIRTH_1840",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1915",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_COUNCIL_CITY_CENTRE_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city's industrial growth does not establish a factory occupation, travel pattern, wealth, or social class for this person."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WOLVERHAMPTON_I151",
      "person_id": "I151",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented household belonged to Wolverhampton as it grew from a market town into a major manufacturing center connected by turnpikes, canals, and railways",
      "start_date": "1780",
      "end_date": "1968",
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_1860",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_BAPTISMS_OCCUPATIONS",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_COUNCIL_CITY_CENTRE_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city's industrial growth does not establish a factory occupation, travel pattern, wealth, or social class for this person."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WOLVERHAMPTON_I152",
      "person_id": "I152",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented household belonged to Wolverhampton as it grew from a market town into a major manufacturing center connected by turnpikes, canals, and railways",
      "start_date": "1780",
      "end_date": "1968",
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_ESTHER_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_1874_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_COUNCIL_CITY_CENTRE_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city's industrial growth does not establish a factory occupation, travel pattern, wealth, or social class for this person."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WOLVERHAMPTON_I49",
      "person_id": "I49",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented household belonged to Wolverhampton as it grew from a market town into a major manufacturing center connected by turnpikes, canals, and railways",
      "start_date": "1780",
      "end_date": "1968",
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_MORRALL_FAMILYSEARCH_9WWH_TDG",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_MORRALL_1899_WOLVERHAMPTON_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CIVIL_BIRTH_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_DEATH_1968",
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_PROBATE_1968",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_COUNCIL_CITY_CENTRE_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city's industrial growth does not establish a factory occupation, travel pattern, wealth, or social class for this person."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_TRENTHAM_I140",
      "person_id": "I140",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family lived in the Trentham and Hanford district during nineteenth-century growth and industrial change around the Potteries",
      "start_date": "1800",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Trentham and Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_DEATH_1879_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_SARAH_BOULTON_DEATH_Q4_1879",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_TRENTHAM_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Regional industrial change is context only; no pottery, estate, factory, or transport employment is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_TRENTHAM_I145",
      "person_id": "I145",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family lived in the Trentham and Hanford district during nineteenth-century growth and industrial change around the Potteries",
      "start_date": "1800",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Trentham and Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_BIRMINGHAM_DEATH_Q1_1863",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_TRENTHAM_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Regional industrial change is context only; no pottery, estate, factory, or transport employment is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_BIRMINGHAM_I137",
      "person_id": "I137",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household lived in Birmingham as the city expanded as the industrial and commercial center of the Midlands, with dense networks of workshops, factories, transport, and housing",
      "start_date": "1854",
      "end_date": "1934",
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1841_STOKE_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1861_HEYWOOD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_DEATH_AND_BURIAL_1900",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_COUNCIL_ORIGINS_INDUSTRIAL_CITY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city's industrial character does not establish a factory job, trade, employer, commute, wealth, or social class for this person."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_BIRMINGHAM_I138",
      "person_id": "I138",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household lived in Birmingham as the city expanded as the industrial and commercial center of the Midlands, with dense networks of workshops, factories, transport, and housing",
      "start_date": "1854",
      "end_date": "1934",
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1900_WOLVERHAMPTON_DIRECTORIES",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1901_HEATH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_DEATH_1904",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELLEN_HELEN_WATERHOUSE_1835_1904",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_COUNCIL_ORIGINS_INDUSTRIAL_CITY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city's industrial character does not establish a factory job, trade, employer, commute, wealth, or social class for this person."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_BIRMINGHAM_I50",
      "person_id": "I50",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The household lived in Birmingham as the city expanded as the industrial and commercial center of the Midlands, with dense networks of workshops, factories, transport, and housing",
      "start_date": "1854",
      "end_date": "1934",
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BERNAL_B_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_MORRALL_1899_WOLVERHAMPTON_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_BRIGHT_RHEAD_1868_1934",
        "SRC_BERNAL_BRIGHT_RHEAD_CIVIL_BIRTH_Q1_1869",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_COUNCIL_ORIGINS_INDUSTRIAL_CITY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city's industrial character does not establish a factory job, trade, employer, commute, wealth, or social class for this person."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_MCDOWELL_I14",
      "person_id": "I14",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family lived in McDowell County after rail access transformed southern West Virginia from an agricultural region into a coalfield of rapidly created towns, company housing, migration, and labor conflict",
      "start_date": "1883",
      "end_date": "1982",
      "place": "McDowell County, West Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1885_1964",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1964",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_WV_ARCHIVES_MINE_WARS_COALFIELD_TRANSFORMATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "Coal shaped the county, but residence alone does not prove mining work, company housing, union membership, strike participation, or a political position."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_MCDOWELL_I9",
      "person_id": "I9",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family lived in McDowell County after rail access transformed southern West Virginia from an agricultural region into a coalfield of rapidly created towns, company housing, migration, and labor conflict",
      "start_date": "1883",
      "end_date": "1982",
      "place": "McDowell County, West Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_HENDERSON_1930_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1982",
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_MEMORIAL",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WV_ARCHIVES_MINE_WARS_COALFIELD_TRANSFORMATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "Coal shaped the county, but residence alone does not prove mining work, company housing, union membership, strike participation, or a political position."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_GREENE_I60",
      "person_id": "I60",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The 1850 and 1860 censuses place the household in rural Greene County immediately before the Civil War",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Greene County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_BOTETOURT_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_W_WHITE_1840_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_HONEY_GROVE_MEMORIAL_1877",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SABINE_TEXAS_TAX_1836_REJECTED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The chronology is direct household context. It does not establish later migration, wartime service, allegiance, political views, or individual occupation unless separately documented."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_GREENE_I61",
      "person_id": "I61",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The 1850 and 1860 censuses place the household in rural Greene County immediately before the Civil War",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Greene County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_HONEY_GROVE_MEMORIAL_1877",
        "SRC_FRANCES_WHITE_TEXAS_1836_MEMORIAL_REJECTED",
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The chronology is direct household context. It does not establish later migration, wartime service, allegiance, political views, or individual occupation unless separately documented."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_INGENHEIM_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His Ingenheim family was recorded during the 1808 adoption of fixed Jewish surnames, a rare administrative record that preserves both earlier patronymic naming and the adopted Dreyfuss name",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Ingenheim, French Empire",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a personal administrative event and community context. It does not establish later occupation, migration motive, wealth, or religious practice."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_MONAGHAN_C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "person_id": "C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family belonged to rural County Monaghan, where small farms commonly combined agriculture with household linen production and later valuation records mapped individual holdings",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "end_date": "1913",
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_BOYD_PROFILE_1829_1894",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This rural economy is local context only. It does not assign farming, weaving, land tenure, religion, literacy, or a specific holding unless another fact states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_MONAGHAN_C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family belonged to rural County Monaghan, where small farms commonly combined agriculture with household linen production and later valuation records mapped individual holdings",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "end_date": "1913",
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This rural economy is local context only. It does not assign farming, weaving, land tenure, religion, literacy, or a specific holding unless another fact states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_MONAGHAN_C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family belonged to rural County Monaghan, where small farms commonly combined agriculture with household linen production and later valuation records mapped individual holdings",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "end_date": "1913",
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This rural economy is local context only. It does not assign farming, weaving, land tenure, religion, literacy, or a specific holding unless another fact states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_COLONIAL_MARYLAND_I127",
      "person_id": "I127",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented family belonged to colonial Maryland's parish, county-court, land, tax, and probate record world, through which households and obligations were publicly recorded",
      "start_date": "1668",
      "end_date": "1751",
      "place": "Charles and Prince George's Counties, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record system is local context. It does not prove landholding, office, occupation, religion, wealth, or a specific court appearance unless separately cited."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_COLONIAL_MARYLAND_I128",
      "person_id": "I128",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented family belonged to colonial Maryland's parish, county-court, land, tax, and probate record world, through which households and obligations were publicly recorded",
      "start_date": "1668",
      "end_date": "1751",
      "place": "Charles and Prince George's Counties, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record system is local context. It does not prove landholding, office, occupation, religion, wealth, or a specific court appearance unless separately cited."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_COLONIAL_MARYLAND_I129",
      "person_id": "I129",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented family belonged to colonial Maryland's parish, county-court, land, tax, and probate record world, through which households and obligations were publicly recorded",
      "start_date": "1668",
      "end_date": "1751",
      "place": "Charles and Prince George's Counties, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JEREMIAH_H_MACKNEW_1640_1720",
        "SRC_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1668_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_JEREMIAH_MACKMERE_PHILISE_MARRIAGE_1670",
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record system is local context. It does not prove landholding, office, occupation, religion, wealth, or a specific court appearance unless separately cited."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_COLONIAL_MARYLAND_I234",
      "person_id": "I234",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented family belonged to colonial Maryland's parish, county-court, land, tax, and probate record world, through which households and obligations were publicly recorded",
      "start_date": "1668",
      "end_date": "1751",
      "place": "Charles and Prince George's Counties, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record system is local context. It does not prove landholding, office, occupation, religion, wealth, or a specific court appearance unless separately cited."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_COLONIAL_MARYLAND_I235",
      "person_id": "I235",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The documented family belonged to colonial Maryland's parish, county-court, land, tax, and probate record world, through which households and obligations were publicly recorded",
      "start_date": "1668",
      "end_date": "1751",
      "place": "Charles and Prince George's Counties, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record system is local context. It does not prove landholding, office, occupation, religion, wealth, or a specific court appearance unless separately cited."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NORFOLK_C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Probate and land evidence places the family among Norfolk County households organized around the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River",
      "start_date": "1670",
      "end_date": "1782",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America and United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_CHESAPEAKE_BUTT_LANDHOLDING_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The shared locality does not prove that every person owned land, logged timber, enslaved people, held office, or shared the same household."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NORFOLK_I117",
      "person_id": "I117",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Probate and land evidence places the family among Norfolk County households organized around the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River",
      "start_date": "1670",
      "end_date": "1782",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America and United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_CHESAPEAKE_BUTT_LANDHOLDING_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The shared locality does not prove that every person owned land, logged timber, enslaved people, held office, or shared the same household."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NORFOLK_I74",
      "person_id": "I74",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Probate and land evidence places the family among Norfolk County households organized around the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River",
      "start_date": "1670",
      "end_date": "1782",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America and United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_CHESAPEAKE_BUTT_LANDHOLDING_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The shared locality does not prove that every person owned land, logged timber, enslaved people, held office, or shared the same household."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_NORFOLK_I75",
      "person_id": "I75",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Probate and land evidence places the family among Norfolk County households organized around the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River",
      "start_date": "1670",
      "end_date": "1782",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America and United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_CHESAPEAKE_BUTT_LANDHOLDING_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The shared locality does not prove that every person owned land, logged timber, enslaved people, held office, or shared the same household."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_EDGAR_NEWMAN_YALE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His adult life was tied to New Haven's Yale academic community, where his education and historical scholarship were institutionally documented",
      "start_date": "1960",
      "end_date": "2001",
      "place": "New Haven, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TIMES_PICAYUNE_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_OBITUARY_2001",
        "SRC_RH19_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_MEMORIAL_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "This academic setting belongs to Edgar Leon Newman the historian and is not transferred to his same-named ancestor."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_EVAN_TALLEY_SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "person_id": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Census records place the family first in Grayson County and then in Washington County before the Civil War, documenting movement within southwest Virginia",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Grayson and Washington Counties, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_EVAN_L_TALLEY_1823_BEFORE_1866",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The move is documented at county level; its route, motive, work, land tenure, and economic circumstances remain unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_PHOENIX_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her later Phoenix life fell within the city's rapid World War II industrialization and postwar population and geographic expansion",
      "start_date": "1940",
      "end_date": "2002",
      "place": "Phoenix, Maricopa County, Arizona, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_HENRIETTA_SEGEL_1916_2002",
        "SRC_PHOENIX_OFFICIAL_CITY_HISTORY_POSTWAR_GROWTH"
      ],
      "source_note": "City growth is context only; it does not establish her arrival date, occupation, neighborhood, military connection, or reason for living there."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His 1853 move from Kaiserslautern to New Orleans joined a broader Palatinate Jewish migration into the city's expanding commercial and civic community",
      "start_date": "1853",
      "end_date": "1909",
      "place": "Kaiserslautern, Rhenish Bavaria, to New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_AJC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_DEATH_1909",
        "SRC_COMMERCIAL_FINANCIAL_CHRONICLE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1909",
        "SRC_SOARDS_NEW_ORLEANS_GUIDE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_STOCK_EXCHANGE",
        "SRC_HNOC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_LEGACY",
        "SRC_NEWMAN_SCHOOL_HISTORY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN",
        "SRC_LA_SUPREME_COURT_ADAMS_MACHINE_V_NEWMAN_1902"
      ],
      "source_note": "The individual migration and later city career are documented; broader community patterns do not by themselves prove motive or religious practice."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_HATTIESBURG_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His documented 1922 sawmill incorporation belonged to Hattiesburg's timber-and-rail industrial economy",
      "start_date": "1922",
      "end_date": "1922",
      "place": "Hattiesburg, Forrest County, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_HATTIESBURG_SAWMILL_LEON_PFEIFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "The incorporation is personal business evidence; it does not establish his daily role, capital contribution, length of service, or ownership after incorporation."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_MARY_NEWLAND_HOLSTON_SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Land and family records place her household within the North Fork Holston landholding community as southwest Virginia shifted from colonial frontier to early republic",
      "start_date": "1770",
      "end_date": "1801",
      "place": "North Fork of the Holston, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The household setting does not prove her own title, occupation, literacy, migration route, or parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SW_VA_NC_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Marriage, tax, probate, or military records place this family within the changing county jurisdictions of the Virginia and North Carolina backcountry in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries",
      "start_date": "1760",
      "end_date": "1847",
      "place": "Virginia and North Carolina backcountry, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_AMELIA_1765_FATHER_1742",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The jurisdictional setting does not prove an interstate migration route, occupation, land ownership, militia service, wealth, or political allegiance unless another fact states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SW_VA_NC_C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "person_id": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Marriage, tax, probate, or military records place this family within the changing county jurisdictions of the Virginia and North Carolina backcountry in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries",
      "start_date": "1760",
      "end_date": "1847",
      "place": "Virginia and North Carolina backcountry, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_1790_ROWAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_VA_NC_CENSUS_SEQUENCE",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_1810_NAMESAKE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The jurisdictional setting does not prove an interstate migration route, occupation, land ownership, militia service, wealth, or political allegiance unless another fact states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SW_VA_NC_I125",
      "person_id": "I125",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Marriage, tax, probate, or military records place this family within the changing county jurisdictions of the Virginia and North Carolina backcountry in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries",
      "start_date": "1760",
      "end_date": "1847",
      "place": "Virginia and North Carolina backcountry, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_1715_1791",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_MACKNEW_MARYLAND_BIRTH_1715",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The jurisdictional setting does not prove an interstate migration route, occupation, land ownership, militia service, wealth, or political allegiance unless another fact states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SW_VA_NC_I63",
      "person_id": "I63",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Marriage, tax, probate, or military records place this family within the changing county jurisdictions of the Virginia and North Carolina backcountry in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries",
      "start_date": "1760",
      "end_date": "1847",
      "place": "Virginia and North Carolina backcountry, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The jurisdictional setting does not prove an interstate migration route, occupation, land ownership, militia service, wealth, or political allegiance unless another fact states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SW_VA_NC_I68",
      "person_id": "I68",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Marriage, tax, probate, or military records place this family within the changing county jurisdictions of the Virginia and North Carolina backcountry in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries",
      "start_date": "1760",
      "end_date": "1847",
      "place": "Virginia and North Carolina backcountry, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_AGBI_VIRGINIA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_SUKEY_WHITE_BOND_SURETY_1786",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The jurisdictional setting does not prove an interstate migration route, occupation, land ownership, militia service, wealth, or political allegiance unless another fact states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WUERTTEMBERG_C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER",
      "person_id": "C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The parish-based pedigree places this family across small Württemberg communities whose church registers structured baptism, marriage, burial, education, and clerical appointments",
      "start_date": "1535",
      "end_date": "1618",
      "place": "Göppingen, Tübingen, Weinsberg, and nearby Württemberg communities, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional network is family context. A specific locality, education, office, or journey is assigned only where the pedigree explicitly states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WUERTTEMBERG_C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "person_id": "C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The parish-based pedigree places this family across small Württemberg communities whose church registers structured baptism, marriage, burial, education, and clerical appointments",
      "start_date": "1535",
      "end_date": "1618",
      "place": "Göppingen, Tübingen, Weinsberg, and nearby Württemberg communities, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN15_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN15_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional network is family context. A specific locality, education, office, or journey is assigned only where the pedigree explicitly states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_WUERTTEMBERG_I244",
      "person_id": "I244",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The parish-based pedigree places this family across small Württemberg communities whose church registers structured baptism, marriage, burial, education, and clerical appointments",
      "start_date": "1535",
      "end_date": "1618",
      "place": "Göppingen, Tübingen, Weinsberg, and nearby Württemberg communities, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional network is family context. A specific locality, education, office, or journey is assigned only where the pedigree explicitly states it."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_ASHBOURNE_SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family's Ashbourne parish life belonged to a long-established market town whose market space served livestock and cloth trades",
      "start_date": "1760",
      "end_date": "1820",
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_HER_ASHBOURNE_MARKET_PLACE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Market-town context does not establish that Hannah traded, owned property, attended a particular market, or held an occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_STAFFORD_PARISH_I155",
      "person_id": "I155",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Parish and census evidence places this family within small Staffordshire communities linked to nearby market and industrial towns",
      "start_date": "1760",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Forton and Haughton area, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_1783_1862",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_BURIAL_PROBATE_1862_1863",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional setting does not establish occupation, landholding, travel, church attendance beyond a cited event, or work in a nearby industry."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_STAFFORD_PARISH_I196",
      "person_id": "I196",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Parish and census evidence places this family within small Staffordshire communities linked to nearby market and industrial towns",
      "start_date": "1760",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Forton and Haughton area, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1764",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_BURIAL_1847",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The regional setting does not establish occupation, landholding, travel, church attendance beyond a cited event, or work in a nearby industry."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SHROPSHIRE_WALES_I101",
      "person_id": "I101",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family's records connect rural Montgomeryshire and Shropshire communities with the growing market and industrial centers of Wellington and Shrewsbury",
      "start_date": "1810",
      "end_date": "1975",
      "place": "Montgomeryshire, Wales, and Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1845",
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_DEATH_Q1_1926",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_WROUGHT_IRON_INDUSTRY_HORSEHAY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This regional movement is contextual. It does not prove a migration date, route, industrial occupation, language, landholding, or social class unless separately documented."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SHROPSHIRE_WALES_I42",
      "person_id": "I42",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family's records connect rural Montgomeryshire and Shropshire communities with the growing market and industrial centers of Wellington and Shrewsbury",
      "start_date": "1810",
      "end_date": "1975",
      "place": "Montgomeryshire, Wales, and Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_WROUGHT_IRON_INDUSTRY_HORSEHAY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This regional movement is contextual. It does not prove a migration date, route, industrial occupation, language, landholding, or social class unless separately documented."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SHROPSHIRE_WALES_SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family's records connect rural Montgomeryshire and Shropshire communities with the growing market and industrial centers of Wellington and Shrewsbury",
      "start_date": "1810",
      "end_date": "1975",
      "place": "Montgomeryshire, Wales, and Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1841_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLEY_MORRALL_PROFILE_ABT1811_1853",
        "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1853",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_CHILD_BAPTISM_PARENTS_RICHARD_ANNE",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_WROUGHT_IRON_INDUSTRY_HORSEHAY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This regional movement is contextual. It does not prove a migration date, route, industrial occupation, language, landholding, or social class unless separately documented."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SHROPSHIRE_WALES_SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family's records connect rural Montgomeryshire and Shropshire communities with the growing market and industrial centers of Wellington and Shrewsbury",
      "start_date": "1810",
      "end_date": "1975",
      "place": "Montgomeryshire, Wales, and Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1841_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1881_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_DEATH_1884",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_1811_1884",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_BURIAL_1884",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_WROUGHT_IRON_INDUSTRY_HORSEHAY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This regional movement is contextual. It does not prove a migration date, route, industrial occupation, language, landholding, or social class unless separately documented."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_SHROPSHIRE_WALES_SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family's records connect rural Montgomeryshire and Shropshire communities with the growing market and industrial centers of Wellington and Shrewsbury",
      "start_date": "1810",
      "end_date": "1975",
      "place": "Montgomeryshire, Wales, and Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_WROUGHT_IRON_INDUSTRY_HORSEHAY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This regional movement is contextual. It does not prove a migration date, route, industrial occupation, language, landholding, or social class unless separately documented."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LINDER_NEWLAND_C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "person_id": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her 1733 immigrant family entered through Philadelphia, and later church and deed evidence places her Newland household within the German-speaking settlement corridor leading into the Shenandoah and Potomac backcountry",
      "start_date": "1733",
      "end_date": "1780",
      "place": "Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, to Berkeley County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The documented locations establish a family migration pattern, but not Elizabetha's exact childhood town, route, language use, occupation, property title, or travel dates between events."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "person_id": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His pension and family records place him successively in Maryland, southwest Virginia, and eastern Kentucky across Revolutionary service, captivity, family formation, and old age",
      "start_date": "1776",
      "end_date": "1834",
      "place": "Maryland; Washington County, Virginia; and Floyd County, Kentucky, United States",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_CENSUS_1800_1830",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The successive locations are documented; the route, motives for each move, land tenure, and experiences beyond the stated military record remain qualified."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America (reported Westmoreland or New Kent County)",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_AGBI_GRACE_BOSWELL_1690S_VIRGINIA",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported King William County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SELECT_BIRTHS_MARY_JOHN_HIRGES_CHILD_JOHN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_MARY_ANN_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS_1714",
        "SRC_AGBI_MARY_ANNE_FOUNTAIN_1670S",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661_1730",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Oldhams, Westmoreland County, Virginia",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported St Mary Magdalen Parish, London, England",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARYLAND_PROBATE_WM_HARGIS_WILL_BOOKS",
        "SRC_PROFILE_WILLIAM_ASA_HARGIS_1640_1685",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "person_id": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_I111",
      "person_id": "I111",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Göda, Saxony, DE",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_I112",
      "person_id": "I112",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_I113",
      "person_id": "I113",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_I118",
      "person_id": "I118",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_I131",
      "person_id": "I131",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Edinburgh, Scotland",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_I133",
      "person_id": "I133",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_I135",
      "person_id": "I135",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_I237",
      "person_id": "I237",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported England",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_I72",
      "person_id": "I72",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Norfolk, Virginia, US",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_I73",
      "person_id": "I73",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Norfolk, Virginia, US",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_LC_LIMIT_I86",
      "person_id": "I86",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_SCHAAF_JM_CANDIDATE_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "family_role",
      "value": "Named as the father of the 1848 Katharina Schaaf baptism candidate",
      "start_date": "1848",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The fact belongs securely to the baptism candidate; its application to Katharine Fricke depends on an unproved identity bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_GRAU_AC_CANDIDATE_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "family_role",
      "value": "Named as the mother of the 1848 Katharina Schaaf baptism candidate",
      "start_date": "1848",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The fact belongs securely to the baptism candidate; its application to Katharine Fricke depends on an unproved identity bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_SCHAAF_JM",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation can yet be assigned to this exact same-named man",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "A miller is documented in the local Schaaf family, but that occupation is not assigned here until the exact Johann Martin identity is resolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_OCC_UNKNOWN_GRAU_AC",
      "person_id": "C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "occupation_status",
      "value": "No occupation has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "No occupation is inferred from her spouse, locality, or household role."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_SCHAAF_JM",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education or literacy evidence has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap rather than absence of education."
    },
    {
      "id": "COV_EDU_UNKNOWN_GRAU_AC",
      "person_id": "C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "education_status",
      "value": "No education or literacy evidence has been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records an evidence gap rather than absence of education."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_SCHAAF_JM_OBER_GLEEN",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family appears in the surviving Protestant registers of the small Hessian village of Ober-Gleen",
      "start_date": "1848",
      "end_date": "1848",
      "place": "Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The village setting does not resolve which same-named Johann Martin appears in every entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "LC_GRAU_AC_OBER_GLEEN",
      "person_id": "C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family appears in the surviving Protestant registers of the small Hessian village of Ober-Gleen",
      "start_date": "1848",
      "end_date": "1848",
      "place": "Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The locality is evidence-based; details of her wider life remain unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SCHAAF_JM",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "His own parents and exact identity among contemporary men of this name have not yet been established",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "Earlier generations should not be attached until the correct Johann Martin is distinguished."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_GRAU_AC",
      "person_id": "C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Her own parents have not yet been established from an inspected record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Earlier generations remain open research."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_IMMIGRATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "immigration",
      "value": "Emigrated to the United States about 1853",
      "start_date": "about 1853",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Niederhochstadt to United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The year is approximate; no passenger list was cited on the profile page."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_CSA",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "military_service",
      "value": "Joined the Confederate army as a soldier",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The profile reports service but does not identify a unit or display the underlying service record."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_EMANUEL_RAHEL_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Rahel Dreyfuss",
      "start_date": "2 Feb 1867",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The underlying marriage entry remains a desirable image target."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_RAHEL_EMANUEL_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Emanuel Pfeifer",
      "start_date": "2 Feb 1867",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The underlying marriage entry remains a desirable image target."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PASSPORT_1879",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "passport",
      "value": "Passport issued, describing him as married with four minor children",
      "start_date": "1879",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Lincoln County, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The passport is strong family-structure evidence, although its image has not yet been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_RESIDENCE_1900",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Lived with his family in Brookhaven",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Brookhaven, Lincoln County, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census image remains a useful verification target."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_DAVID_DREYFUSS_OCCUPATION",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Baker",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ingenheim and Bad Bergzabern, Bavaria",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_DAVID_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The profile labels him Bäcker."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_LEON_PFEIFER_ACCOUNTANT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Accountant",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEON_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The profile labels him Buchhalter."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_JOHANNA_DREYFUSS_BURIAL",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Buried at grave 3 03 06",
      "start_date": "Mar 1879",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Jewish Cemetery, Ingenheim, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JOHANNA_FRANK_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The page provides cemetery, field, row, and grave number."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_REVISED",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "His family, American migration, spouse, and child are now strongly reconstructed, but his own parents have not yet been identified",
      "start_date": "1833",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Niederhochstadt, Bavaria, German Confederation",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "A second Emanuel Pfeiffer born at Niederhochstadt on 24 September 1833 must not be merged with this Emanuel, who was born on 21 September."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_LEON_PFEIFER_COLLEGE_1890",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "fact_type": "education",
      "value": "Attended college in New Orleans",
      "start_date": "1890",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BROOKHAVEN_LEADER_LEON_PFEIFER_COLLEGE_1890"
      ],
      "source_note": "The newspaper does not name the institution, subject, duration, or any degree; none is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_LEON_PFEIFER_TRAVELING_MAN_1897",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Traveling commercial representative",
      "start_date": "before Sep 1897",
      "end_date": "Sep 1897",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BROOKHAVEN_LEADER_LEON_PFEIFER_BOOKKEEPER_1897"
      ],
      "source_note": "Traveling man was period commercial language, commonly describing a traveling salesman or representative; the specific goods and employer were not stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_LEON_PFEIFER_BOOKKEEPER_1897",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Bookkeeper for Pfeifer & Dreyfus",
      "start_date": "Sep 1897",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Brookhaven, Lincoln County, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BROOKHAVEN_LEADER_LEON_PFEIFER_BOOKKEEPER_1897"
      ],
      "source_note": "This directly supports the later community-history description of him as an accountant."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_LEON_CAHN_MORGAN_CITY_DRY_GOODS",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Operated a dry-goods store",
      "start_date": "about 1870s",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Morgan City, St. Mary Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "candidate_identity_supported",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_MORGAN_CITY_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The merchant is highly relevant to the imported ancestor, but no inspected record yet joins the Morgan City merchant to Bertha, Anna, Metz, or the reported 1924 death."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_LEON_CAHN_MORGAN_CITY_LAND_1879",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Transferred Morgan City property with Theodore Lehmann to Louisa Wright",
      "start_date": "24 Mar 1879",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Morgan City, St. Mary Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "candidate_identity_supported",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ST_MARY_BANNER_LEON_CAHN_LAND_CHAIN_1909"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1909 notice recites the 1879 conveyance. It supports local presence but does not identify spouse, child, birthplace, or later residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_JOHN_THOMAS_LLANDDEWI_CHILD_CANDIDATE_1861",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "possible_childhood_residence",
      "value": "Possible same-name child was lodging with the Samuel and Mary Jones household at Tynywern",
      "start_date": "7 Apr 1861",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Tynywern, Llanfihangel Rhydithon, Radnorshire, Wales",
      "status": "research_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_LLANDDEWI_LODGER_1861",
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_RADNORSHIRE_CANDIDATE_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is displayed as a candidate childhood record, not as a proved residence. Samuel and Mary Jones are household associates only and are not proposed as parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_JOHN_THOMAS_BLEDFFA_BAPTISM_EXCLUDED",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "identity_exclusion",
      "value": "The Bleddfa baptism naming Edward Thomas and Anne belongs to a different birthplace cluster and does not establish this man's parents",
      "start_date": "24 Jun 1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bleddfa, Radnorshire, Wales",
      "status": "contradicted_for_target_identity",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_THOMAS_BLEDFFA_BAPTISM_1851",
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_LLANDDEWI_LODGER_1861",
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_RADNORSHIRE_CANDIDATE_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record is retained as an identity guard because its date and parents are tempting, but attaching Edward and Anne would conflate two same-name boys."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_JOHN_THOMAS_LLANDDEWI_PARENTS",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "The Llanddewi-born childhood candidate was a lodger in 1861 and names no parents; no baptism, 1871 apprenticeship, marriage certificate image, or other bridge has yet identified the later bootmaker's parents",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Llanddewi Ystradenni and Shrewsbury",
      "status": "partially_resolved",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_LLANDDEWI_LODGER_1861",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_THOMAS_BLEDFFA_BAPTISM_1851",
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_RADNORSHIRE_CANDIDATE_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879"
      ],
      "source_note": "The next decisive targets are the full 1879 marriage entry, a surviving Llanddewi-area baptism, an apprenticeship record, or an 1871 record naming trade or kin."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_PRISCILLA_PETERS_BAPTISM_1707",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_PRISCILLA_FRESHFORD_1707",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized as Prissilla, daughter of Robert Peters and Ann",
      "start_date": "23 Jun 1707",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "St Peter, Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original register image remains desirable because FreeREG labels the source an Other Transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_PRISCILLA_PETERS_ISAIAH_LINK",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_PRISCILLA_FRESHFORD_1707",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Her own parents are established, but her proposed relationship to Isaiah remains a compiled hypothesis until his 1734 baptism or equivalent record is inspected",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "status": "partially_resolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ISAIAH_PETERS_1734_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Do not raise the mother-son relationship merely because Priscilla's own baptism is direct."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_ROBERT_PETERS_FRESHFORD",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_ROBERT_FRESHFORD_FATHER_PRISCILLA",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "No baptism, marriage, burial, occupation, or parent record has yet distinguished this Robert Peters beyond his daughter's 1707 baptism",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707"
      ],
      "source_note": "Search the earlier Freshford register cluster before attaching parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_ANN_PETERS_FRESHFORD",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_ANN_FRESHFORD_MOTHER_PRISCILLA",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Her maiden surname and parents are not stated in the 1707 baptism and no marriage record has yet identified her",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707"
      ],
      "source_note": "Do not assign a surname or parents from nearby same-name families."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_BETTY_WILLIS_BAPTISM_1737",
      "person_id": "I191",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Reported christening as daughter of Benjamin Willis is disputed because FreeREG transcribes the cited-date child as Ann, not Betty",
      "start_date": "22 Jan 1737",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "conflicting_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_BETTY_WILLIS_1737_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1738",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_1738_FAMILY_CLUSTER"
      ],
      "source_note": "The event is retained as a disputed research lead and is no longer displayed as Betty's established baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_NORTH_BRADLEY_FATHER_BETTY",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "The claimed father relationship is disputed; FreeREG transcribes the cited baptism as Ann Willis, while a real Benjamin household remains documented in the parish",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_BETTY_WILLIS_1737_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1738",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_1738_FAMILY_CLUSTER"
      ],
      "source_note": "A direct baptism, settlement, will, or other record naming Betty is required before promotion."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_1701_BAPTISM_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_NORTH_BRADLEY_FATHER_BETTY",
      "fact_type": "possible_baptism",
      "value": "Possible same-name child born 4 August and baptized 7 August 1701, son of Benjamin Willis",
      "start_date": "7 Aug 1701",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley St Nicholas, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "research_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1701"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism itself is direct; its assignment to this adult candidate is not."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_1679_BAPTISM",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_SR_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized with siblings Lazarus, Joseph, and Abigail, children of William and Katherine Willis",
      "start_date": "10 Jan 1678/79",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "St Nicholas, North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679"
      ],
      "source_note": "The grouped date appears to represent baptism of siblings; it should not be read as evidence that all four were born together."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_1703_BURIAL",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_SR_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Buried as Benjamin Willis Junior",
      "start_date": "11 Sep 1703",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "transcribed_register",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_1679"
      ],
      "source_note": "The “Junior” wording helps distinguish him from an older same-name man in the parish."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_WILLIAM_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_WILLIAM_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Named in the 1678/79 baptisms, but no distinguishing birth, marriage, burial, occupation, or parents have been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Earlier Willis ancestry requires a record that distinguishes this William from other men of the name."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_KATHERINE_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_KATHERINE_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Named in the 1678/79 baptisms; maiden name, vital events, and parents remain unknown",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "No maiden surname should be inferred from nearby marriages without a direct bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_JOHN_READ_STOKE_1753",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_READ_FATHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Named as Richard’s father at Stoke in 1753; no distinguishing birth, marriage, burial, occupation, or parents have been identified",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Stoke, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1755"
      ],
      "source_note": "The nearby Wolverhampton John is excluded because his household chronology conflicts."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SARAH_READ_STOKE_1753",
      "person_id": "SRC_SARAH_READ_MOTHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Named as Richard’s mother at Stoke in 1753; maiden name, vital events, and parents remain unknown",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Stoke, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1755"
      ],
      "source_note": "Sarah Perry of Wolverhampton is excluded from this identity because the two households’ child chronology conflicts."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_JOHN_SARAH_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_CONFLATION",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_READ_FATHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "The 1750 Wolverhampton John Read–Sarah Perry marriage belongs to a household that baptized Ann there in April 1753 and its own Richard in 1755; it is not a safe identity for Richard’s Stoke parents",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "contradicted_identity",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_READ_PERRY_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPT_1750",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1755",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOSEPH_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1759",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "The six-month interval between Ann’s and the Stoke Richard’s baptisms is incompatible with ordinary full-term births to one mother, and the later Wolverhampton Richard independently distinguishes the households."
    },
    {
      "id": "DEATH_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_1926",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Died at age 70",
      "start_date": "3 May 1926",
      "end_date": "3 May 1926",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_1926"
      ],
      "source_note": "Archive record 283950, volume 192, page 1072. The online index does not include parent names."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_LEON_SCHWARTZ_WOODVILLE_IDENTITY",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "The similarly aged Leon Schwartz, son of Jacob Schwartz and Judith Moritz, remained a Woodville merchant and civic official and is not presently identified as this New Orleans Leon",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Mississippi and Louisiana",
      "status": "researched_candidate_excluded",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_1926",
        "SRC_MDAH_JACOB_SCHWARTZ_WOODVILLE_LEDGER_FINDING_AID",
        "SRC_ISJL_WOODVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Woodville man inherited his father's local business, formed a Woodville partnership in 1896, and remained a civic figure there in 1904. No source connects that household to Adeline Trautman or the New Orleans family."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Leon E. Schwartz is anchored by his 1883 New Orleans marriage and official 1926 Orleans Parish death, but no located record names his parents",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Mississippi and New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_1926",
        "SRC_MDAH_JACOB_SCHWARTZ_WOODVILLE_LEDGER_FINDING_AID",
        "SRC_ISJL_WOODVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Jacob Schwartz-Judith Moritz household in Woodville is excluded unless a future record bridges its son Leon to Adeline Trautman and New Orleans."
    },
    {
      "id": "DEATH_YETTA_DUBOWY_1914",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Died of cancer; described as the wife of Solomon Dubowy of Willow Street",
      "start_date": "26 Jul 1914",
      "end_date": "26 Jul 1914",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914"
      ],
      "source_note": "Published the following day; the burial at Beth Alom Cemetery occurred on 26 July."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_YETTA_DUBOWY_REPORTED_AGE_1914",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "fact_type": "birth_date_conflict",
      "value": "The 1914 death notice gives age 56, implying birth between about 27 July 1857 and 26 July 1858, while the imported tree reports 15 May 1856",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Galicia and New Britain, Connecticut",
      "status": "conflicting_evidence",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original Library of Congress page image and ALTO text read “fifty-six,” correcting the earlier transcription as fifty. A one-to-two-year discrepancy is common in historical age reporting, so neither date is treated as conclusive."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Yetta Dubowy is anchored in New Britain by a contemporary 1914 death notice, but the notice names no parents or precise European birthplace",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Galicia and New Britain, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BETH_ALOM_YETTA_DUBOWY"
      ],
      "source_note": "A parent-naming certificate, marriage record, passenger record, obituary, or European locality is needed before extending this line. The obituary age is fifty-six, not fifty."
    },
    {
      "id": "BIRTH_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "fact_type": "birth",
      "value": "Born to David Trautman and Julia Moses",
      "start_date": "26 Dec 1862",
      "end_date": "26 Dec 1862",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862"
      ],
      "source_note": "Archive record 292195, volume 33, page 375."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Adeline's official 1862 birth index identifies her parents, extending this line to David Trautman and Julia Moses",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "resolved",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862"
      ],
      "source_note": "The frontier now moves to her two named parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "DEATH_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
      "person_id": "SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Died at age 75",
      "start_date": "22 Nov 1893",
      "end_date": "22 Nov 1893",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
        "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Archive record 2160443, volume 105, page 272; Hebrew Rest plot 04-113."
    },
    {
      "id": "FAMILY_DAVID_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1854_1862",
      "person_id": "SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "family_context",
      "value": "Official birth indexes record children Jacob (1854), Joseph (1856), Isidor (1859), and Adeline (1862) to David and Julie/Julia",
      "start_date": "22 Oct 1854",
      "end_date": "26 Dec 1862",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862"
      ],
      "source_note": "The children are retained as documentary household evidence and are not added as collateral profiles in the ordinary ancestral view."
    },
    {
      "id": "DEATH_JULIE_MOSER_TRAUTMAN_1916",
      "person_id": "SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Died at age 89",
      "start_date": "20 Sep 1916",
      "end_date": "20 Sep 1916",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1916",
        "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Archive record 369909, volume 167, page 297; Hebrew Rest plot 04-113."
    },
    {
      "id": "ALTNAME_JULIE_MOSER_MOSES",
      "person_id": "SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "alternate_name",
      "value": "Julie Moser; Julie Moses; Julia Moses; compiled variant Julia Mosser",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_COMPILED_JAMES_TRAUTMAN"
      ],
      "source_note": "Moser is the earliest official form and is used for display; Moses appears in the two later official entries."
    },
    {
      "id": "FAMILY_JULIE_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1854_1862",
      "person_id": "SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "family_context",
      "value": "Official birth indexes record children Jacob (1854), Joseph (1856), Isidor (1859), and Adeline (1862) to Julie/Julia and David",
      "start_date": "22 Oct 1854",
      "end_date": "26 Dec 1862",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862"
      ],
      "source_note": "The changing Moser/Moses and Julie/Julia spellings occur within a continuous, repeatedly named parental pair."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "person_id": "SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "David lived in New Orleans by October 1854, operated a Poydras Street shoe store in 1861, and died there in 1893; his birthplace, immigration, and parents remain unproved",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
        "SRC_GARDNER_NEW_ORLEANS_DIRECTORY_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1861",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
        "SRC_NOPL_OBITUARY_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
        "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The library index locates two Daily Picayune notices, but their text has not yet been retrieved. The 1880-1903 Civil District Court succession index has no David Trautman/Trautmann entry; wills and unindexed proceedings still require separate examination. The 1818 birth year remains approximate from indexed age at death."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Julie Moser lived in New Orleans by October 1854 and died there in 1916; her birthplace, immigration, and parents remain unproved",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1916",
        "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Moses and Mosser are preserved as variants. The 1827 birth year is approximate from her indexed age at death."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_MARRIAGE_1915",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Freda Dubowy",
      "start_date": "30 May 1915",
      "end_date": "30 May 1915",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Index record CTMI-1-159520."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_FREDA_DUBOWY_MAX_JUFFE_MARRIAGE_1915",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Max Juffe",
      "start_date": "30 May 1915",
      "end_date": "30 May 1915",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Index record CTMI-1-159520."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_BIRTH_1916",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "fact_type": "birth",
      "value": "Born as Henrietta Juffe",
      "start_date": "30 Apr 1916",
      "end_date": "30 Apr 1916",
      "place": "Hartford, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916"
      ],
      "source_note": "Index record CTBI-510986; the public index does not print parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_MARTIN_SEGEL_MARRIAGE_1937",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Martin Segel",
      "start_date": "16 Jun 1937",
      "end_date": "16 Jun 1937",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "Index record CTMI-1-424096."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Max's official military register corrects his leading birth date to 20 March 1886 and establishes United States presence by 14 December 1907; Austrian town, immigration, naturalization, and parents remain unresolved",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Britain and Hartford, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NY_ADJUTANT_GENERAL_MAX_JUFFE_1917",
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915",
        "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916",
        "SRC_NARA_MAX_JUFFE_FOURTH_DRAFT_CARD_1942"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1917 register and 1942 NARA catalog description narrow the chronology and confirm Austria but name no town or relative in their publicly accessible text. Naturalization, earliest census, passenger manifest, military personnel papers, the draft-card image, and the full Connecticut marriage application remain the best origin targets."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
      "person_id": "C_MARSHALL_JOHN_PONTEFRACT_1772",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Ann Allen",
      "start_date": "19 Jul 1772",
      "end_date": "19 Jul 1772",
      "place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772"
      ],
      "source_note": "Banns were indexed one week earlier, on 12 July 1772."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_ANN_ALLEN_JOHN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1772",
      "person_id": "C_ALLEN_ANN_WIFE_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married John Marshall",
      "start_date": "19 Jul 1772",
      "end_date": "19 Jul 1772",
      "place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772"
      ],
      "source_note": "Banns were indexed one week earlier, on 12 July 1772."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_JOHN_MARSHALL_PONTEFRACT",
      "person_id": "C_MARSHALL_JOHN_PONTEFRACT_1772",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "His 1772 marriage is established, but his birth, occupation, death, parents, and the proposed daughter's full baptism remain unresolved",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "partially_resolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original marriage and candidate baptism images are the next priority."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_ANN_ALLEN_PONTEFRACT",
      "person_id": "C_ALLEN_ANN_WIFE_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Her 1772 marriage is established, but her birth, occupation, death, parents, and motherhood of the proposed daughter remain unresolved",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "partially_resolved",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "Do not identify her with the 1837 Luddenden burial without a residence or family bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B68_LEO_BAKER",
      "person_id": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Baker",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate / Kingdom of Bavaria",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The profile also places him at Schellgasse 3."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B68_LEO_ROSINA_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Rosina Haas",
      "start_date": "22 Apr 1793",
      "end_date": "22 Apr 1793",
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both linked local profiles give the same date and place."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B68_ROSINA_LEO_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Leo Dreyfuss",
      "start_date": "22 Apr 1793",
      "end_date": "22 Apr 1793",
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both linked local profiles give the same date and place."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_FARMER",
      "person_id": "B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "10 Oct 1883",
      "place": "reported Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Griffith's Valuation records Andrew Gibson at Aghnasedagh in 1861. John Gibson's 1883 marriage record calls his father Andrew Gibson, farmer, but does not state whether Andrew was then living; the end date is therefore a dated occupational reference, not a proven lifespan endpoint."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B69_JOHN_SARAH_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Sarah Clark",
      "start_date": "10 Oct 1883",
      "end_date": "10 Oct 1883",
      "place": "Second Monaghan Presbyterian Church, Monaghan, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both spouses were full age, lived at Aghnasedagh, and signed the register."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B69_SARAH_JOHN_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married John Gibson",
      "start_date": "10 Oct 1883",
      "end_date": "10 Oct 1883",
      "place": "Second Monaghan Presbyterian Church, Monaghan, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both spouses were full age, lived at Aghnasedagh, and signed the register."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B69_SARAH_LITERACY_1883",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "fact_type": "literacy",
      "value": "Signed her marriage register",
      "start_date": "10 Oct 1883",
      "end_date": "10 Oct 1883",
      "place": "Second Monaghan Presbyterian Church, Monaghan, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "A signature supports writing ability on this occasion; it does not establish a level of schooling."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B70_ROBERT_DAVIES_CARPENTER_1814",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Carpenter",
      "start_date": "1814",
      "end_date": "1814",
      "place": "Trustewelin, Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814"
      ],
      "source_note": "The register transcription explicitly calls Robert a carpenter."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B70_ROBERT_DAVIES_WHEELWRIGHT_1819_1821",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Wheelwright",
      "start_date": "1819",
      "end_date": "1821",
      "place": "Trustewelin, Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821"
      ],
      "source_note": "Carpentry and wheelwright work are related woodworking trades; the records do not establish whether this was a formal change of occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B70_ROBERT_ELIZABETH_TRWSTEWELIN_FAMILY",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Household documented by four child baptisms",
      "start_date": "1814",
      "end_date": "1823",
      "place": "Trustewelin, Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
        "SRC_FREEREG_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1823"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sequence distinguishes this Robert-and-Elizabeth household from other Davies families in the parish."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B70_ELIZABETH_TRWSTEWELIN_FAMILY",
      "person_id": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Household documented by four child baptisms",
      "start_date": "1814",
      "end_date": "1823",
      "place": "Trustewelin, Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
        "SRC_FREEREG_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1823"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sequence establishes Elizabeth as part of the Trustewelin household but does not by itself prove Lamb as her maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B70_ROBERT_ELIZABETH_PROBABLE_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Probable marriage to Elizabeth Lamb",
      "start_date": "17 Jul 1803",
      "end_date": "17 Jul 1803",
      "place": "St Beuno, Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_DAVIES_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1803",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835"
      ],
      "source_note": "The identification is plausible and useful, but should not be read as certain until another record connects Lamb or the 1803 couple to Trustewelin."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B70_ELIZABETH_ROBERT_PROBABLE_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Probable marriage to Robert Davies",
      "start_date": "17 Jul 1803",
      "end_date": "17 Jul 1803",
      "place": "St Beuno, Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_DAVIES_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1803",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835"
      ],
      "source_note": "The identification is plausible and useful, but should not be read as certain until another record connects Lamb or the 1803 couple to Trustewelin."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B71_JOHN_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1785",
      "person_id": "B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Elizabeth Prichard",
      "start_date": "21 Jan 1785",
      "end_date": "21 Jan 1785",
      "place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sparse transcription supplies no age, residence, occupation, parents, or witnesses."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
      "person_id": "B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married John Lamb",
      "start_date": "21 Jan 1785",
      "end_date": "21 Jan 1785",
      "place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sparse transcription supplies no age, residence, occupation, parents, or witnesses."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B71_PROBABLE_ELIZABETH_LAMB_BAPTISM",
      "person_id": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Possible baptism as daughter of John and Elizabeth Lamb",
      "start_date": "19 Jun 1785",
      "end_date": "19 Jun 1785",
      "place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BAPTISM_SWEEP_1750_1790",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_MARRIAGE_SWEEP_1795_1820",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BURIAL_SWEEP_1785_1803"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a research hypothesis, not a proven baptism for the later Trustewelin mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX_1835",
      "person_id": "B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "tax_record",
      "value": "Assessed for one taxable white male and one horse",
      "start_date": "1835",
      "end_date": "1835",
      "place": "Grayson County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1835_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX"
      ],
      "source_note": "The entry proves presence, not parentage or ownership of land."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B73_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD_1850",
      "person_id": "B73_SUSAN_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "household",
      "value": "Household with Sibarina, Isaac, Susan, and Floyd Faddis",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Grayson County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census lists household members but does not explicitly state their relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B74_LOUIS_KIEFFER_1808_PARENT_SEARCH",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "fact_type": "parentage_search",
      "value": "The 1808 Jewish name index confirms Kieffer at Lembach but does not identify the imported Isaac-and-Julienne parent couple",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_JEWISH_NAME_INDEX_LEMBACH"
      ],
      "source_note": "The result preserves the imported couple as a low-confidence hypothesis; it is not treated as proof of absence or as grounds to remove them."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B74_MARIA_ROSER_1808_PARENT_SEARCH",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "fact_type": "parentage_search",
      "value": "The 1808 Jewish name index does not identify Roser or Roeser at Lembach under the imported parent names",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_JEWISH_NAME_INDEX_LEMBACH"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not exclude an earlier patronymic, a different adopted surname, later arrival, or an indexing variant. Maria's 1814 civil birth act is the decisive next record."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B74_LEON_SCHWARTZ_AMITE_CENSUS_SEARCH",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "fact_type": "identity_search",
      "value": "No recognizable Schwartz household was found in the county-wide 1850 or 1860 Amite census indexes",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Amite County, Mississippi, United States",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USGENWEB_AMITE_1850_CENSUS_INDEX",
        "SRC_USGENWEB_AMITE_1860_CENSUS_INDEX"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is an explicitly negative search result, not proof that Leon was born elsewhere. Neighboring counties, alternate spellings, and the original 1926 death record remain priorities."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B75_ROBERT_BUTT_ORIGIN_LEGEND",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "disputed_origin_tradition",
      "value": "Virkus's 1925 compiled pedigree proposes Joshua of Warrington Hall, Kent, while a later anonymous history changes the place and adds Sir William Butts; neither supplies an identifying English record",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "England",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VIRKUS_BUTT_PEDIGREE_1925",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ROBERT_BUTT_441",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_BUTT_LEGEND_PROVENANCE_AUDIT_20260725",
        "SRC_RCP_SIR_WILLIAM_BUTTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1925 claim is the earliest located attributable source for Joshua and Warrington Hall. It names Ann Riddlehurst and son Radford, not Jane and the four sons in Robert's will. No Joshua parent edge is added because the identity bridge is contradicted at the immediate-family level."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B75_JANE_BUTT_BRUCE_LEGEND",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "fact_type": "disputed_origin_tradition",
      "value": "An authentic 1811 sampler shows Bruce as descendant Sarah Bruce Butt's middle name; a 2000 message reports an undated reverse pedigree calling Robert's wife Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce of Earlshall",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Fife, Scotland",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CW_SARAH_BRUCE_BUTT_SAMPLER_1811",
        "SRC_BUTT_SAMPLER_REVERSE_REPORT_2000",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_BUTT_LEGEND_PROVENANCE_AUDIT_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The stitched sampler gives positive evidence of Bruce in the later family’s naming tradition. It does not identify which ancestor introduced that name. The reported reverse pedigree remains undated and unattributed in the available catalogue. Its selection of two sons is not a demonstrated contradiction to Robert’s four-son will."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B77_RICHARD_RADFORD_NAME_CONFLATION",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "fact_type": "disputed_identity_alias",
      "value": "Some collaborative trees combine Richard Butt the Elder with the name Radford",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VIRKUS_BUTT_PEDIGREE_1925",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ROBERT_BUTT_441",
        "SRC_BUTT_SAMPLER_REVERSE_REPORT_2000"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert's 1675 will names a son Richard. Virkus's 1925 pedigree instead names Radford as the son of a Robert and Ann Riddlehurst. The reported sampler-reverse pedigree names Richard, not Radford. The hybrid label Richard (Radford) should not be treated as a historical alias or used to join the two families."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B78_ROBERT_BOTT_380_ACRE_PATENT",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Patented 380 acres at the head of the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River adjoining land formerly taken up by Tristram Nasworthy",
      "start_date": "3 Mar 1656",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Lower Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Nugent indexes the patentee as Robert Bott. The patent used eight headrights, but none is identified as Robert himself; it therefore does not prove when or how he arrived."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B78_ROBERT_BUTT_1200_ACRE_CONSOLIDATION",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Held a consolidated 1,200-acre tract east of the Southern Branch after acquiring the shares of Richard Whitby and John Bright",
      "start_date": "28 Apr 1665",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Lower Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The tract was originally granted to Tristram Nasworthy in 1650 and assigned jointly in 1656. Its later consolidation demonstrates substantial landholding but not Robert's English ancestry or social rank."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B78_ROBERT_BUTT_1640_ARRIVAL",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "disputed_migration_tradition",
      "value": "Reported arrival in Virginia in 1640",
      "start_date": "reported 1640",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PILI_9448_VIRKUS_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_VIRKUS_BUTT_PEDIGREE_1925",
        "SRC_GENI_ROBERT_BUTT_COMPILED_NOTES_2026",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_HENRY_BUTT_BRISTOL_1642_TIMELINE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Passenger and Immigration Lists Index source code 9448 does not identify a ship or port record; it indexes Virkus's compiled immigrant list. The Geni timeline shows a broader 1640-1656 range and calculates age 26 from Robert's reported circa-1614 birth. Neither is independent migration evidence. The earliest directly located Virginia evidence remains the 3 Mar 1656 patent."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B78_ROBERT_JAMES_BARBADOS_BROTHERS",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "disputed_migration_tradition",
      "value": "Reported to have traveled from England to Barbados with a brother James before settling in Virginia",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported England, Barbados, and Virginia, British Atlantic",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_ROBERT_BUTT_COMPILED_NOTES_2026",
        "SRC_BUTT_MCLURE_FAMILY_NARRATIVE_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_HOTTEN_JAMES_BUTT_BARBBADOS_1679",
        "SRC_LOCAL_SCAN_BUTT0001_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hotten directly proves that a James Butt and Mary Middleton held 42 acres in St George Parish, Barbados, on 23 Dec 1679. It does not mention Robert, kinship, shared travel, or English origins. The anonymous family-history sheet converts these separate records into a brother story without an identity bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_B78_ROBERT_BUTT_REPORTED_TIMBER_WORK",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Reportedly exploited cypress timber on his Southern Branch land",
      "start_date": "1656",
      "end_date": "1676",
      "place": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Lower Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHESAPEAKE_BUTT_LANDHOLDING_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BUTT_MCLURE_FAMILY_NARRATIVE_TRANSCRIPT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The label timber baron is interpretive and should not imply a documented contemporary title. Direct deeds, accounts, court orders, or timber contracts are still needed to establish the scale and character of the work."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B79_ROBERT_BUTT_REPORTED_BIRTH_1614",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "reported_birth",
      "value": "Reported born circa 1614",
      "start_date": "circa 1614",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_ROBERT_BUTT_COMPILED_NOTES_2026",
        "SRC_BUTT_MCLURE_FAMILY_NARRATIVE_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_BUTT_SAMPLER_REVERSE_REPORT_2000"
      ],
      "source_note": "The estimate is chronologically compatible with the Virginia landholder but does not establish England, Kent, Cambridgeshire, Barbados, or particular parents. At this estimated birth year he would have been about ten in 1624, confirming that the alleged 1624 royal commission cannot responsibly identify this Robert."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B80_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_1625_BIRTH_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "alternative_birth_hypothesis",
      "value": "Reported born in 1625 at Bristol",
      "start_date": "reported 1625",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Bristol, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OC_VOL94_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_CLAIM",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_1625_20260725",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Bristol claim is chronologically possible for the man documented in Virginia by 1656, but possibility is not identity proof. A claimed 1635 baptism at age 11 lacks a parish or register reference and has not been independently located. The published list that names Bristol also repeats the contradicted Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce pedigree. Treat Bristol as a search locality only."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B81_JANE_BUTT_ELIZABETH_BRUCE_IDENTITY_CLAIM",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "fact_type": "alternative_identity_hypothesis",
      "value": "Reported as Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce of Earlshall",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Earlshall, Fife, Scotland",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_COMPILED_ELIZABETH_BUTT_BIOGRAPHY_20260725",
        "SRC_BUTT_SAMPLER_REVERSE_REPORT_2000",
        "SRC_CW_SARAH_BRUCE_BUTT_SAMPLER_1811",
        "SRC_BRUCE_CUMMING_FAMILY_RECORDS_1870_EARLSHALL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Earlshall table styles the proposed daughter Elizabeth, Lady Durie. A remarriage could reconcile different husbands, but that possibility does not itself identify her as Jane Butt. Alexander’s reported death around 1599–1600 also conflicts with the copied 1605 birth. The particular Earlshall identification remains a low-confidence alternative; broader Bruce ancestry has not been disproved."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B81_JANE_BUTT_REPORTED_BIRTH_1605_EARLSHALL",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "fact_type": "alternative_birth_hypothesis",
      "value": "Reported born in 1605 at Earlshall Castle",
      "start_date": "reported 1605",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Earlshall Castle, Fife, Scotland",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.03,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_COMPILED_ELIZABETH_BUTT_BIOGRAPHY_20260725",
        "SRC_BRUCE_CUMMING_FAMILY_RECORDS_1870_EARLSHALL"
      ],
      "source_note": "No baptism or contemporary record identifies Robert Butt's wife Jane with this birth. The place and year should be used only when searching for the origin of the copied claim."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B81_JANE_BUTT_REPORTED_MARRIAGE_1629",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "fact_type": "alternative_marriage_hypothesis",
      "value": "Reported marriage to Robert Butt circa 1629 in England",
      "start_date": "reported circa 1629",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported England",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.02,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_COMPILED_ELIZABETH_BUTT_BIOGRAPHY_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "No parish or license is given. This date conflicts with other versions reporting marriage about 1643 and would make Robert only about fourteen or fifteen under the circa-1614 birth tradition."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B81_JANE_BUTT_REPORTED_DEATH_1676_07_03",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "fact_type": "rejected_death_claim",
      "value": "Reported death on 3 July 1676",
      "start_date": "reported 3 Jul 1676",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.01,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_COMPILED_ELIZABETH_BUTT_BIOGRAPHY_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert's will was proved on 3 July 1676. That event does not establish Jane's death on the same day. Her documented endpoint remains alive when named in Robert's will on 1 November 1675."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B82_ROBERT_BUTT_REPORTED_BAPTISM_1635",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "alternative_baptism_hypothesis",
      "value": "Reported baptism in 1635; the compiled timeline displays age 11",
      "start_date": "reported 1635",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_HINT_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_1625_20260725",
        "SRC_OC_VOL94_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_CLAIM"
      ],
      "source_note": "The event year is explicitly 1635. The displayed age of 11 points approximately to a 1624 birth and is not fully consistent with a 1625 birth label. Searches under Butt, But, Bott, and related spellings did not identify the underlying Gloucestershire or Bristol parish entry. Preserve this as a register-search lead, not a proven baptism of the Virginia patentee."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B83_ROBERT_BUTT_REPORTED_CHILD_WILLIAM_RICHARD_1638",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "reported_child_hypothesis",
      "value": "Reported son William Richard Butt, born circa 1638",
      "start_date": "reported circa 1638",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.03,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_HINT_WILLIAM_RICHARD_BUTT_BIRTH_1638_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied year is approximate. Robert's will directly names sons Henry, Robert, Thomas, and Richard. It names no William, and no record was found for a son called William Richard. This may be a conflation or an unsupported alternative name for Richard. Do not create a separate child or alter Richard's name without identifying evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B85_ROBERT_BUTT_REPORTED_SON_ROBERT_BRISTOL_1640",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "reported_child_birth_hypothesis",
      "value": "Son Robert reportedly born at Bristol circa 1640",
      "start_date": "reported circa 1640",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Bristol, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_HINT_ROBERT_BUTT_SON_BIRTH_BRISTOL_1640_20260725",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ROBERT_BUTT_441"
      ],
      "source_note": "Do not mistake this for the elder Robert's birth or for proof of the family's presence at Bristol in 1640. The son is collateral to the displayed direct line and is not added to the ordinary tree. A parish baptism or later record linking his age and birthplace is still required."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B86_ROBERT_BUTT_REPORTED_ARRIVAL_1653",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "alternative_migration_hypothesis",
      "value": "Reported arrival in Virginia in 1653 with a supposed brother James",
      "start_date": "reported 1653",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported near Norfolk, Virginia Colony",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_LOCAL_SCAN_BUTT0001_20260725",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS",
        "SRC_HOTTEN_JAMES_BUTT_BARBBADOS_1679"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sheet's 1653 date is chronologically possible but remains distinct from the competing 1640 tradition. The earliest identified Virginia record is Robert Bott's 3 Mar 1656 patent. Hotten's James entry is from Barbados in 1679 and supplies no shared voyage."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B86_JAMES_BUTT_BARBBADOS_1679_RESEARCH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "associate_research_context",
      "value": "A James Butt and Mary Middleton held 42 acres in St George Parish, Barbados; no relationship to Robert is stated",
      "start_date": "23 Dec 1679",
      "end_date": "23 Dec 1679",
      "place": "St George Parish, Barbados",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HOTTEN_JAMES_BUTT_BARBBADOS_1679",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_LOCAL_SCAN_BUTT0001_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This fact establishes the person named in the legend and his Barbados setting, not that he was Robert's brother. James is not added as a relative or ordinary-tree person."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B87_ROBERT_BUTT_REPORTED_SON_HENRY_BRISTOL_1642",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "reported_child_birth_hypothesis",
      "value": "Son Henry reportedly born at Bristol circa 1642",
      "start_date": "reported circa 1642",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Bristol, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.1,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_HINT_HENRY_BUTT_BRISTOL_1642_TIMELINE_20260725",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "Henry's existence and parentage are directly supported by Robert's will, and later published abstracts identify Henry as a Lower Norfolk deputy clerk whose will was proved in 1710. Neither source proves this approximate birth. If a Bristol baptism is found, it could materially narrow Robert's migration chronology."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B89_ROBERT_BUTT_REPORTED_BIRTH_1590_ENGLAND",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "alternative_birth_hypothesis",
      "value": "Reported born in 1590 in England",
      "start_date": "reported 1590",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported England",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_LZNR_WG5",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A man born in 1590 could chronologically be the Virginia landholder, but chronology alone is insufficient. The attached wording Robert But in entry for Robert But appears consistent with a father named in a child's christening, not proof of the father's birth. Do not replace the displayed circa-1614 estimate without the actual entry and continuity evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B89_ROBERT_BUTT_REPORTED_DAUGHTER_SARAH_SHIPP_C1642",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "reported_child_birth_hypothesis",
      "value": "Reported daughter Sarah Jane Butt, later Shipp, born circa 1642 in Lower Norfolk",
      "start_date": "reported circa 1642",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Lower Norfolk County, Virginia Colony",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.04,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_HINT_SARAH_JANE_SHIPP_LOWER_NORFOLK_C1642_20260725",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ROBERT_BUTT_441",
        "SRC_GENI_ROBERT_BUTT_COMPILED_NOTES_2026",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_LZNR_WG5"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert's will proves four sons but names no daughters. A woman appearing as Sarah Shipp would establish only her married identity unless another record supplies Butt or a relationship to Robert. This claim must not be used to place Robert in Virginia by 1642."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B90_ROBERT_BUTT_REPORTED_SON_THOMAS_BRISTOL_1645",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "reported_child_birth_hypothesis",
      "value": "Son Thomas reportedly born at Bristol in 1645",
      "start_date": "reported 1645",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Bristol, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "disputed",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_HINT_THOMAS_BUTT_BRISTOL_1645_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas's existence and parentage are secure. The 1645 Bristol event is not. Searches did not identify an underlying Bristol baptism, and an online 1622 Dorset baptism concerns a different proposed family. Thomas is collateral to the displayed Richard Butt ancestry and is therefore not added as an ordinary-view person."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B92_RICHARD_BUTT_JUNIOR_PRESENT_1710",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "fact_type": "same_name_generation_context",
      "value": "A man explicitly styled Richard Butt junior helped prove John Godfrey's will",
      "start_date": "15 May 1710",
      "end_date": "15 May 1710",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCINTOSH_LOWER_NORFOLK_WILLS_1637_1710_SCAN"
      ],
      "source_note": "This does not by itself state the junior man's father, but it proves that an older and younger same-name distinction was in use before the 1715 Dinah Butt marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B92_RICHARD_BUTT_SENIOR_PRESENT_1711",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "fact_type": "family_and_community_associate",
      "value": "Richard Butt senior was named in the bond material for George Burgis and singlewoman Mary Butt",
      "start_date": "reported June 1711",
      "end_date": "reported June 1711",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LNCVA_VOL3_NORFOLK_MARRIAGE_BONDS_1711_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas Butt was also named. The abstract proves association but does not label either man as Mary's father or brother."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B92_RICHARD_DINA_BUTT_MARRIAGE_GENERATION",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "fact_type": "disputed_spouse_assignment",
      "value": "The 13 June 1715 marriage of Richard Butt and Dina Butt more likely involved the younger Richard than Richard the Elder",
      "start_date": "13 Jun 1715",
      "end_date": "13 Jun 1715",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "probable_generation_correction",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LNCVA_VOL3_NORFOLK_MARRIAGE_BONDS_1711_1715",
        "SRC_MCINTOSH_LOWER_NORFOLK_WILLS_1637_1710_SCAN",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage itself is secure. Assignment to the younger Richard is inferential but chronologically much stronger: the elder's reported circa-1645 birth would make him about seventy, incompatible with the later story that this was his first marriage followed by nine children before Dinah's reported 1726 death."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B93_RICHARD_BUTT_MEETINGHOUSE_LAND_1714",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "fact_type": "property_and_community_role",
      "value": "A newly erected house on his land was selected as a dissenting place of worship",
      "start_date": "17 Jan 1714",
      "end_date": "17 Jan 1714",
      "place": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STEWART_HISTORY_NORFOLK_RICHARD_BUTT_MEETINGHOUSE_1714"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record shows that Richard owned land suitable for a meetinghouse and was associated with the local dissenting congregation. It does not identify his birthplace or wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B93_RICHARD_BUTT_NAMED_CHILDREN_1716",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "fact_type": "documented_household",
      "value": "Josias Mackie named Thomas, Elizabeth, and Henry as children of Mr Richard Butt",
      "start_date": "7 Nov 1716",
      "end_date": "16 Nov 1716",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PAGE_LIFE_JOSIAS_MACKIE_WILL_1716"
      ],
      "source_note": "The wording strongly associates these three children with the documented Richard senior, although it does not explicitly repeat “senior” in each child clause. The will also names several other Butt witnesses. It does not name Robert born about 1678 as Richard's child; that absence is informative but not proof that no such relationship existed."
    },
    {
      "id": "CF_B94_ROBERT_BUTT_DORSET_1616_ORIGIN_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "english_origin_candidate",
      "value": "Possible identity with Robert Butt baptized 17 September 1616, son of Robert Butt and Susan Gantrell",
      "start_date": "17 Sep 1616",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Winterborne Houghton, Dorset, England",
      "status": "research_hypothesis",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_ROBERT_BUTT_BAPTISM_1616",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_PROTESTATION_1641",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is the leading specific English-origin candidate, not merely a random same-name baptism. Robert was baptized in 1616, a Robert Butt appears locally in 1641, no burial or later English household has been securely assigned to the baptized son, and the Virginia landholder's known chronology is compatible. The competing hypothesis is an unidentified English Robert whose records have not survived or been found; that remains collectively more likely because no document connects the Dorset man, his wife or relatives, an associate, or an occupation to Virginia. Retain the candidate prominently at approximately 0.40 identity confidence, but do not display Dorset as the immigrant's birthplace or attach the Gantrell couple as his parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B95_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_DEPARTURE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "migration_context",
      "value": "Bristol was a plausible departure port, but no surviving Bristol indenture entry names Robert Butt",
      "start_date": "1654",
      "end_date": "1686",
      "place": "Bristol, England, and Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_context",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRISTOL_ARCHIVES_SERVANTS_FOREIGN_PLANTATIONS_GUIDE",
        "SRC_VIRTUAL_JAMESTOWN_BRISTOL_BUTT_SEARCH_1654_1686",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Bristol register begins two years before Robert's first secure Virginia patent and may postdate his migration. Its absence of Robert is therefore limited negative evidence, not disproof. Crucially, the register treats a servant's home place and Bristol departure separately, showing why later retellings must not convert a port reference into a birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B96_ROBERT_BUTT_MALMESBURY_NETWORK_HYPOTHESIS",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "migration_hypothesis",
      "value": "The documented Malmesbury Butt family and 1659 Virginia emigrant may belong to Robert's wider regional family network",
      "start_date": "1619",
      "end_date": "1659",
      "place": "Wiltshire and Dorset, England; Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "explicit_low_confidence_hypothesis",
      "confidence": 0.22,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOANE_PENN_RODBOURNE_WILL_1619",
        "SRC_VIRTUAL_JAMESTOWN_BRISTOL_BUTT_SEARCH_1654_1686",
        "SRC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_ROBERT_BUTT_BAPTISM_1616",
        "SRC_BRISTOL_ARCHIVES_SERVANTS_FOREIGN_PLANTATIONS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Joane Penn's will establishes Nathaniel and Mary Butt and their children at Rodbourne by 1619. The 1659 servant might be a descendant, but his age and parents are not stated. Robert's Dorset baptismal candidate is approximately fifty miles from Bristol and is not linked to either Malmesbury record. Do not create a parent, sibling, or cousin edge from this pattern alone."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B96_ROBERT_BUTT_JAMES_1650_HYPOTHESIS",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "migration_hypothesis",
      "value": "A James Butt indexed in Virginia in 1650 may be the kernel of the later Robert-and-James story",
      "start_date": "1650",
      "end_date": "1650",
      "place": "Rappahannock River, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "explicit_low_confidence_hypothesis",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GREER_EARLY_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_JAMES_BUTT_1650",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CLAPHAM_RAPPAHANNOCK_PATENT_1650",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Greer associates James with William Clapham, while Nugent places Clapham's 1650 patent on the Rappahannock. Robert is securely documented later in Lower Norfolk. Headright lists may be recorded years after transportation and do not prove residence with the patentee, but no record currently identifies James as Robert's brother or places him in Robert's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B97_ROBERT_BUTT_HEADRIGHT_WEALTH_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "economic_context",
      "value": "His patents demonstrate established Virginia landholding, not inherited English wealth or proof that he personally financed every named immigrant",
      "start_date": "1656",
      "end_date": "1675",
      "place": "Lower Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_interpretation",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS",
        "SRC_LVA_RESEARCH_NOTE_20_HEADRIGHTS",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_HEADRIGHT_SERVITUDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 380-acre patent used eight headrights, while the 1,200-acre tract passed through assignment and Robert's purchase of co-holders' shares. Certificates were transferable and patents could substantially postdate arrival. Robert may have financed passages, purchased rights, used merchant credit, or accumulated land through several transactions. No located document states that he arrived as a gentleman, merchant, or servant."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B98_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_MERCHANT_WILLIAM_HYPOTHESIS",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "associate_hypothesis",
      "value": "Prosperous Bristol merchant William Butts was a contemporary and may be a relative or a source of the later Bristol-and-Sir-William legend",
      "start_date": "1662",
      "end_date": "1668",
      "place": "St Stephen parish and the quay, Bristol, England",
      "status": "explicit_low_confidence_hypothesis",
      "confidence": 0.18,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PEPYS_DIARY_WILLIAM_BUTTS_BRISTOL_1668",
        "SRC_BRISTOL_HEARTH_TAX_WILLIAM_BUTTS_ST_STEPHEN",
        "SRC_DNB_SIR_WILLIAM_BUTTS_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BRISTOL_ARCHIVES_SERVANTS_FOREIGN_PLANTATIONS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Pepys proves that Mr Butts was an established merchant and socially respected Bristol householder. The hearth-tax entry is probably the same man but does not itself give his occupation. He cannot be Robert, who was documented in Virginia by 1656, and neither record calls the men brothers or cousins. A Bristol will, freedom admission, apprenticeship, marriage, or merchant account naming overseas relatives is required before creating an edge."
    },
    {
      "id": "B101_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_SHOE_STORE_1861",
      "person_id": "SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Proprietor of a shoe store",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Poydras Street, New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GARDNER_NEW_ORLEANS_DIRECTORY_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1861"
      ],
      "source_note": "Gardner's 1861 directory explicitly lists David Trautman with a shoe store and places his residence at 174 Lafayette. The precise Poydras business number is not normalized because the scan/OCR spacing is ambiguous."
    },
    {
      "id": "B103_HENRY_ALBERT_FRICKE_MILKMAN_1892",
      "person_id": "I76",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Milkman",
      "start_date": "1892",
      "end_date": "1892",
      "place": "306 Halsted Street, East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_HENRY_FRICKE_MILKMAN_1892"
      ],
      "source_note": "The directory states milkman, but does not establish whether Henry owned cows, operated a dairy, or worked solely in delivery and sales."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_IMMIGRATION_1908",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "fact_type": "immigration",
      "value": "Reported in 1916 that he came to America in 1908",
      "start_date": "1908",
      "end_date": "1908",
      "place": "Austria to United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1916"
      ],
      "source_note": "A passenger manifest or naturalization file is still required to identify the ship, port, last residence, and contact persons."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SONS_NATHAN_SOL",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "fact_type": "family_structure",
      "value": "Father of adult sons Nathan and Solomon or Sol Dubowy",
      "start_date": "1916",
      "end_date": "1917",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1916",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1917"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sons are collateral evidence and are not added to the ordinary direct-ancestor display. Their relationship helps distinguish elder Solomon from his same-named son."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_HEALTH_SUPPORT_1917",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "fact_type": "personal_history",
      "value": "Reportedly suffered from heart failure and received assistance from Jewish and local charities while pursuing support from his sons",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "1917",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1917"
      ],
      "source_note": "These were allegations and circumstances reported during litigation, not a medical record or final judicial finding."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_FREDA_DUBOWY_BOSTON_STORE_SALESWOMAN",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Saleswoman at the Boston Store",
      "start_date": "before 10 Apr 1915",
      "end_date": "before 10 Apr 1915",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_FREDA_DUBOWY_ENGAGEMENT_1915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The notice does not specify how long she worked there or whether she remained employed at engagement."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_FREDA_DUBOWY_ENGAGEMENT_1915",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "fact_type": "engagement",
      "value": "Engagement to Max Juffe announced",
      "start_date": "10 Apr 1915",
      "end_date": "10 Apr 1915",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_FREDA_DUBOWY_ENGAGEMENT_1915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The later official marriage index confirms that the couple married on 30 May 1915."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_MAX_JUFFE_BIRTH_CONFLICT_1886_1888",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "birth",
      "value": "Official military register records 20 March 1886; later federal burial data records 20 May 1888",
      "start_date": "20 Mar 1886",
      "end_date": "20 Mar 1886",
      "place": "Austria",
      "status": "source_backed_with_conflict",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NY_ADJUTANT_GENERAL_MAX_JUFFE_1917",
        "SRC_VA_NATIONWIDE_GRAVESITE_MAX_JUFFE_1979",
        "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_MAX_JUFFE_1888_1979"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1917 register is preferred because it is contemporary and tied to Max's distinctive service history. The official VA burial database independently confirms that 20 May 1888 entered later federal records, so the disagreement is substantive rather than a derivative-site transcription alone."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B116_MORRIS_SEGEL_CLOTHING_MERCHANT",
      "person_id": "SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Clothing merchant operating a store at 4 Railroad Arcade",
      "start_date": "1930",
      "end_date": "1930",
      "place": "4 Railroad Arcade, New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B117_MORRIS_SEGEL_CIVIC_CANDIDACY",
      "person_id": "SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "fact_type": "civic_activity",
      "value": "Named as a sixth-ward council candidate",
      "start_date": "1916",
      "end_date": "1916",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_COUNCIL_CANDIDATE_1916"
      ],
      "source_note": "The record establishes local political participation but does not say whether he won the election."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B117_MORRIS_SEGEL_STORE_1927",
      "person_id": "SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Clothing and shoe merchant at 11 Railroad Arcade",
      "start_date": "1927",
      "end_date": "1927",
      "place": "11 Railroad Arcade, New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_BURGLARY_1927"
      ],
      "source_note": "The stolen stock included clothing and shoes, directly identifying the character of the business."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B117_MORRIS_SEGEL_PROPERTY_ACTION_1929",
      "person_id": "SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "fact_type": "property_and_legal",
      "value": "Brought a foreclosure action concerning Brooklawn Street property",
      "start_date": "1929",
      "end_date": "1929",
      "place": "Brooklawn Street, New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_FORECLOSURE_1929"
      ],
      "source_note": "The newspaper names attorney Maurice Rosenberg as his counsel. The report does not establish that the property was Morris's residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B117_MORRIS_SEGEL_STORE_1929",
      "person_id": "SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Merchant at 11 Railroad Arcade",
      "start_date": "1929",
      "end_date": "1929",
      "place": "11 Railroad Arcade, New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_STORE_OPEN_1929"
      ],
      "source_note": "Police found the premises open and secured them; the item independently continues the same business documented in 1927."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B119_MORRIS_SEGEL_DEATH",
      "person_id": "SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Died",
      "start_date": "6 Jan 1940",
      "end_date": "6 Jan 1940",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_DEATH_INDEX_MORRIS_SEGEL_1940"
      ],
      "source_note": "The state index does not name relatives. The competing namesake hypothesis remains possible but is much less likely because no second Morris Segel has been found in New Britain and the indexed spelling exactly matches the documented merchant."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B120_MAX_JUFFE_BURIAL",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Buried in section 99B, row H, site 21",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Los Angeles National Cemetery, Los Angeles, California, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_NATIONWIDE_GRAVESITE_MAX_JUFFE_1979"
      ],
      "source_note": "The VA record identifies him as a captain in the United States Army."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B120_MAX_JUFFE_1942_DRAFT_CARD",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "military_registration",
      "value": "Fourth Registration draft card catalogued for Austrian-born Max Juffe of Hartford",
      "start_date": "27 Apr 1942",
      "end_date": "27 Apr 1942",
      "place": "Hartford, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed_metadata_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NARA_MAX_JUFFE_FOURTH_DRAFT_CARD_1942"
      ],
      "source_note": "The catalog metadata confirms identity, residence, date, and country-level birth only. It does not identify an Austrian town, parent, or contact person."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_HENRY_ALBERT_FRICKE_ESSEX_NATURALIZATION",
      "person_id": "I76",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "Henry's exact Hanoverian birthplace and parents remain unresolved; Essex County naturalization records survive for the relevant period but no person-specific declaration or petition has yet been inspected",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "open_archival_target",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_NJ_ARCHIVES_ESSEX_NATURALIZATION_GUIDE",
        "SRC_NJ_ARCHIVES_GENEALOGICAL_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Henry reported immigration in 1867 and naturalization by 1900. The surviving Essex declarations and petitions are the strongest identified route to a town of origin, but collection survival is not evidence that he filed there; federal and neighboring-county courts remain alternatives."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B121_LEON_CAHN_DEATH_1924",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "fact_type": "death",
      "value": "Died at age 72",
      "start_date": "5 Jun 1924",
      "end_date": "5 Jun 1924",
      "place": "Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_SOS_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_CAHN_1924"
      ],
      "source_note": "The state index gives volume 188, page 1593, record/order ID 300254. It supplies no relatives or birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B121_LEON_CAHEN_METZ_1851_INDEX_LEAD",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "fact_type": "candidate_birth_record",
      "value": "An annual index appears to list Leon Cahen, but its act reference does not resolve to a matching birth",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1851",
      "place": "Metz, Moselle, France",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1851_CAHEN_INDEX_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_METZ_ARCHIVES_GENEALOGY_PORTAL"
      ],
      "source_note": "The name, approximate year, and reported locality make this worth preserving. Competing explanations are a table or act-number clerical error, a mistranscription of the handwritten name or number, a missing/intercalated act, or a different Leon Cahen. Without the actual act and parents it cannot extend the pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B121_LEON_CAHN_REPORTED_BIRTH_RANGE",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "fact_type": "birth_estimate",
      "value": "Born approximately 1851-1852; Metz remains reported rather than proved",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1852",
      "place": "reported Metz, Moselle, France",
      "status": "partially_supported",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_SOS_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_CAHN_1924",
        "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1851_CAHEN_INDEX_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1852_CAHN_NEGATIVE_CHECK"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age 72 on 5 June 1924 permits a birth between 6 June 1851 and 5 June 1852 if the age is exact. The imported May 1852 assertion is not independently supported."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ANDREW_GIBSON_GRIFFITH_APPEARANCE",
      "person_id": "B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "fact_type": "earliest_confirmed_appearance",
      "value": "Recorded as an occupier in Griffith's Valuation",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "County Monaghan's printed Griffith valuation was published in 1861 and lists Andrew Gibson at Aghnasedagh. This securely dates his activity there but supplies no age, wife, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_ANDREW_GIBSON_NAMED_AT_SON_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Named as farmer father of John Gibson",
      "start_date": "10 Oct 1883",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Second Monaghan Presbyterian Church, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "John Gibson's marriage register names Andrew Gibson, farmer, as his father. The form does not state whether Andrew was then living, so 1883 is a dated reference to him rather than proof of survival to that date."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_LATER_MARRIAGE_1914",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "fact_type": "later_marriage_identity_evidence",
      "value": "A Solomon Dubowy married Gitl Goldfield in Hartford on 22 October 1914; this is highly likely to be Yetta's widower rather than a namesake",
      "start_date": "22 Oct 1914",
      "end_date": "22 Oct 1914",
      "place": "Hartford, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "likely_identity_match",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_GITL_GOLDFIELD_1914",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1916"
      ],
      "source_note": "The index itself does not state this groom's age or prior wife. The uncommon name, same county, marriage three months after Yetta's locally documented death, and the 1916 report that the elder Solomon lived with a wife make the match strong, but not absolute. Gitl is not added as a new profile or spouse edge until an identifying record establishes her wider identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B130_WILLIAM_WILLIS_EARLIER_NORTH_BRADLEY_CLUSTER",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_WILLIAM_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "fact_type": "candidate_household_continuity",
      "value": "A William Willis was named as father of John, Katharine, and Anne at North Bradley on 30 December 1670; he may be the father recorded with Katherine in 1679",
      "start_date": "30 Dec 1670",
      "end_date": "10 Jan 1679",
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "candidate_identity_continuity",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_CLUSTER_REVIEW_1652_1703",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1670 father is a plausible earlier appearance of this William, but not a proved identity match. The source also shows contemporaneous Benjamin and Simon Willis families. The 1670 children are not added as relatives and Katherine is not assumed to be their mother without an identifying marriage or original-register evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B132_DELIA_TALLEY_HELTON_MARRIAGE_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "A compiled Helton pedigree claims an 1866 marriage to William B. Helton; the claim states that no marriage record was found",
      "start_date": "10 Sep 1866",
      "end_date": "10 Sep 1866",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "contradicted_compiled_claim",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HELTON_DELIA_TALLY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DELIA_TALLY_HENDERSON_1866_HEADSTONE",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is not evidence of a second husband or an alias. It records a derivative-pedigree conflict so that the documented Henderson marriage is not displaced by the unsupported Helton assertion."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_I28_MONAGHAN_RURAL_CHANGE",
      "person_id": "I28",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "County Monaghan’s rural economy was reshaped after the Famine: emigration and farm consolidation meant that by 1900 many farmers were becoming owner-occupiers, while improved transport and co-operative development connected production more closely to markets. This is the setting for the documented Gibson dairy-farming family background, not evidence that Florence herself worked as a farmer.",
      "start_date": "late 19th to early 20th century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MONAGHAN_MUSEUM_CHANGING_FARMING_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN_INDUSTRIAL_CITY",
      "person_id": "SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Morris’s documented civic activity and Railroad Arcade stores were part of New Britain’s early twentieth-century industrial economy. The city was widely known as the “Hardware City,” and by 1913 American Hardware Corporation was Connecticut’s largest employer. This describes the commercial setting, not employment by that company or by any factory.",
      "start_date": "1913",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_HUMANITIES_NEW_BRITAIN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_COUNCIL_CANDIDATE_1916"
      ],
      "source_note": "The local history establishes the city’s industrial context. Contemporary newspapers independently place Morris in its civic and retail life, but do not identify him as a factory worker."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_I182_BRADFORD_AVON_INDUSTRIAL_CHANGE",
      "person_id": "I182",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Bradford-on-Avon’s long-established wool trade suffered an early nineteenth-century depression. In 1848 the former cloth mill at Kingston House was sold and later converted to rubber manufacture, illustrating the industrial change around William’s adult life. These town-level changes do not establish his own trade.",
      "start_date": "early to mid 19th century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_BRADFORD_AVON_KINGSTON_HISTORY",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNY_1861_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Historic England documents the town’s industrial change. The censuses independently place William in Bradford-on-Avon, but none of the cited records names his paid occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_PORT_CITY",
      "person_id": "SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "During the 1850s New Orleans was one of North America’s busiest ports. Its population rose from 116,375 in 1850 to 168,675 in 1860, and about 39 percent of residents were foreign-born by 1860. This commercial and immigrant-city setting helps contextualize David’s documented Poydras Street shoe store; it does not prove his birthplace, immigration, or religious affiliation.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_1852_PORT_HISTORY",
        "SRC_GARDNER_NEW_ORLEANS_DIRECTORY_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1861"
      ],
      "source_note": "The local-history source supplies citywide context. The 1861 directory directly documents David’s business but gives no birthplace, arrival, or congregation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_ANDREW_GIBSON_GRIFFITH_RECORD_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "fact_type": "record_context",
      "value": "Andrew’s Aghnasedagh appearance is in Griffith’s Valuation, a property-tax survey published from 1847 to 1864. Such a record identifies an occupier and holding in a locality, providing strong evidence of place and activity but not of birth, marriage, parentage, or death.",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_OFFICE_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The National Archives explains the scope and limits of the valuation. The matching 1861 Aghnasedagh entry securely supports localized activity, while the person’s vital events and wife remain unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_B68_ISAAK_HIRSCH_INGENHEIM_COMMUNITY",
      "person_id": "B68_ISAAK_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_1736",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Isaak Hirsch Dreyfuss’s recorded life and burial fall within Ingenheim’s long-established Jewish community, whose cemetery had been in use since at least the mid-seventeenth century. The local project preserves family and cemetery information for this community. No occupation is inferred for Isaak from that setting.",
      "start_date": "1736",
      "end_date": "1804",
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The person profile supplies Isaak’s local life and burial; the community page supplies the setting. Neither source states his occupation, education, address, or civic role."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_B68_JEHUDA_INGENHEIM_RECORD_SCOPE",
      "person_id": "B68_JEHUDA_LOEB_DREYFUSS",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Jehuda Löb Dreyfuss is known here only because a record-based Ingenheim profile identifies him as Isaak Hirsch’s father. Ingenheim had a long-lived Jewish community and cemetery, but no dated personal event, occupation, spouse, or address has yet been located for Jehuda.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The local profile explicitly names Jehuda as father. The community history provides place context only; it must not be used to invent a personal residence or life date."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_B68_MARIA_ANNA_INGENHEIM_RECORD_SCOPE",
      "person_id": "B68_MARIA_ANNA_ABRAHAM_OPPENHEIMER",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Maria Anna is identified in record-based Ingenheim family profiles as the mother of Leo Dreyfuss and the wife of Isaak Hirsch Dreyfuss. The local setting is well documented, but no independent personal birth, death, address, occupation, or education record has yet been located for her.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Leo’s profile calls her Maria Anna née Abraham; Isaak’s profile gives multiple surname forms. The locality is source-backed, but the variants must not be silently collapsed into an unqualified maiden name."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_B68_MARIA_ANNA_NAME_FORMS",
      "person_id": "B68_MARIA_ANNA_ABRAHAM_OPPENHEIMER",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "The local profiles use several surname forms for Maria Anna, including Abraham and Oppenheimer. They may represent different naming conventions or people, but the available material does not resolve that question.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Her maternity to Leo is explicitly stated, but the surname variation is retained as an unresolved identity detail rather than being standardized away."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_B68_DAVID_MOSES_INGENHEIM_RECORD_SCOPE",
      "person_id": "B68_DAVID_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "David Moses is identified in the Ingenheim project as Rosina Haas’s father. The town had a substantial, long-lived Jewish community and cemetery, but the available profile gives no personal dates, occupation, address, or higher parentage for David.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rosina’s profile explicitly names David. The community history gives geographic setting only and does not prove a particular occupation, institution, or life event for him."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_INGENHEIM_RECORD_SCOPE",
      "person_id": "B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Esther Nathan Moses is identified in the Ingenheim project as Rosina Haas’s mother. The town had a substantial, long-lived Jewish community and cemetery, but the available profile gives no personal dates, occupation, address, or higher parentage for Esther.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Rosina’s profile explicitly names Esther. The community history gives geographic setting only and does not prove a particular occupation, institution, or life event for her."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_BUTT_ROBERT_DORSET_RECORD_SCOPE",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_WINTERBORNE_FATHER_C1570",
      "fact_type": "record_context",
      "value": "The cited Dorset reconstruction places Robert Butt in the Winterborne Houghton–Winterborne Stickland area through a 1607 marriage and a sequence of baptisms. Parish registers survive at the Dorset History Centre from the late sixteenth century, so the local family is testable; the quoted online transcription is not itself an inspected register image.",
      "start_date": "1607",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Winterborne Houghton and Winterborne Stickland, Dorset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reconstruction supplies the reported family sequence. Dorset OPC confirms that the original parish registers survive, but no image of the relevant early entries has been inspected here. This profile is not proof that the Dorset family connects to the Virginia immigrant."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GANTRELL_SUSAN_DORSET_RECORD_SCOPE",
      "person_id": "C_GANTRELL_SUSAN_WINTERBORNE_1585",
      "fact_type": "record_context",
      "value": "Susan’s reported 1585 baptism and 1607 marriage place her in the small Winterborne Houghton–Winterborne Stickland area of Dorset. The original parish registers survive, but the current evidence is a published transcription; an original entry would be needed to settle the locality variation and to strengthen the vital details.",
      "start_date": "1585",
      "end_date": "1607",
      "place": "Winterborne Houghton and Winterborne Stickland, Dorset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The transcription gives the family events. Dorset OPC describes surviving register coverage, but it does not itself publish the relevant sixteenth- and seventeenth-century entries."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GANTRELL_AVES_DORSET_RECORD_SCOPE",
      "person_id": "C_GANTRELL_AVES_MOTHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Aves is named only as Richard Gantrell’s wife and Susan’s mother in a quoted 1585 Dorset baptism. The surviving parish-register series makes the family potentially testable, but no maiden name, birth, death, occupation, or independent personal event is currently established for Aves.",
      "start_date": "1585",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Dorset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The source records Aves in a relationship role only. The locality and family context are retained, but no additional personal detail is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GANTRELL_RICHARD_DORSET_RECORD_SCOPE",
      "person_id": "C_GANTRELL_RICHARD_FATHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "fact_type": "local_context_limitation",
      "value": "Richard Gantrell is named as Susan’s father in a quoted 1585 Dorset baptism. Parish registers for the Winterborne area survive from the late sixteenth century, but no original entry, occupation, exact birth, or independently confirmed death has yet been inspected for Richard.",
      "start_date": "1585",
      "end_date": "reported 1591",
      "place": "reported Dorset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cited reconstruction gives the parent-child statement and a reported 1591 death. That death remains unverified because the public Dorset OPC transcription begins later; an original register image or reliable early burial transcript is needed."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I141_RHEAD_FARMER_1813",
      "person_id": "I141",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer in Trentham parish",
      "start_date": "1813",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The surviving first page of Richard’s 1813 will calls him a farmer in Trentham parish. It does not identify the acreage, crops, tenancy terms, or earlier work."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I141_RHEAD_WOOD_FARM_1813",
      "person_id": "I141",
      "fact_type": "property",
      "value": "Held an undivided one-third share of Wood Farm, charged with an annuity for his wife Ruth and legacies for his children",
      "start_date": "1813",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wood Farm, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The will describes the share, Ruth’s £30 annuity, and legacies for Sampson, Ruth, and Elizabeth. The surviving page does not establish how Richard acquired the property or the exact location of the farm."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I139_SAMPSON_BAPTISM_1800",
      "person_id": "I139",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized as Sampson Handley Read, child of Richard and Ruth Read",
      "start_date": "4 Nov 1800",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_QPSM_68WK"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism indexes give the event and parents; Richard’s will later names Sampson as his youngest child. The distinct Wolstanton birthplace report is retained in the profile rather than substituted with the baptism place."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I139_SAMPSON_MARRIAGE_1819",
      "person_id": "I139",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Julia Glover",
      "start_date": "30 May 1819",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Stoke upon Trent, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The two cited record forms identify the same marriage. They do not establish either spouse’s occupation at the time of marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I139_SAMPSON_RESIDENCE_1851",
      "person_id": "I139",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded with wife Julia and child Fredrick",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Stoke upon Trent, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I139_SAMPSON_BURIAL_1865",
      "person_id": "I139",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Buried after death on 12 November 1865",
      "start_date": "15 Nov 1865",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bucknall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The church record supplies the burial date; the death date and place are corroborated by the other cited records. The memorial’s differing birth estimate is not adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I142_RUTH_MARRIAGE_1793",
      "person_id": "I142",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Married Richard Rhead",
      "start_date": "26 Jan 1793",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_MARRIAGE_1793",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage, the children’s baptism records, and Richard’s will independently connect Ruth to the Trentham household. Her reported 1759 birth and 1818 death remain unverified compiled details."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_RUTH_E_RHEAD_TAILORESS_1881",
      "person_id": "SRC1881_RUTH_E_RHEAD_ABT1858",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Tailoress",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census explicitly records Ruth E. Rhead as a tailoress. It does not say whether she worked from home, in a shop, or for a factory."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_RUTH_E_RHEAD_RESIDENCE_1881_1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1881_RUTH_E_RHEAD_ABT1858",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded first in her parents’ Birmingham household and later with her widowed mother and children Eveline and Albert Fisher",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, and Heath, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1901_HEATH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1861_HEYWOOD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census sequence supports continuity from the childhood Read household to the later Rhead/Fisher household. It does not document the date or identity of a marriage to Fisher."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_RUTH_E_RHEAD_BIRMINGHAM_WORKSHOP_CITY",
      "person_id": "SRC1881_RUTH_E_RHEAD_ABT1858",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Ruth’s recorded tailoring work was carried out in Victorian Birmingham, a city whose landscape was shaped by a growing urban workshop economy and factory system. This citywide context does not identify her employer or connect her to Birmingham’s better-documented metal and jewellery trades.",
      "start_date": "late 19th century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_BIRMINGHAM_WORKSHOP_ECONOMY",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Historic England describes the city’s workshop and factory development. The census, rather than the context source, is the evidence for Ruth’s trade."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_FLORENCE_RHEAD_TAILORESS_1881",
      "person_id": "SRC1881_FLORENCE_RHEAD_ABT1862",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Tailoress",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census explicitly records Florence Rhead as a single tailoress. It does not say whether she worked from home, in a shop, or for a factory."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_FLORENCE_RHEAD_RESIDENCE_1881",
      "person_id": "SRC1881_FLORENCE_RHEAD_ABT1862",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded in her parents’ household",
      "start_date": "1881",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The household identifies her as daughter of Richard and Ellen Rhead and gives Birmingham as her birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_FLORENCE_RHEAD_BIRMINGHAM_WORKSHOP_CITY",
      "person_id": "SRC1881_FLORENCE_RHEAD_ABT1862",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Florence’s recorded tailoring work was carried out in Victorian Birmingham, a city whose landscape was shaped by a growing urban workshop economy and factory system. This citywide context does not identify her employer or connect her to Birmingham’s better-documented metal and jewellery trades.",
      "start_date": "late 19th century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_BIRMINGHAM_WORKSHOP_ECONOMY",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Historic England describes the city’s workshop and factory development. The census, rather than the context source, is the evidence for Florence’s trade."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I11_DAVID_GARY_LIFESPAN",
      "person_id": "I11",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Social Security evidence records a birth in Newark on 15 December 1938 and death on 15 July 2002",
      "start_date": "15 Dec 1938",
      "end_date": "15 Jul 2002",
      "place": "Newark, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SSA_DAVID_GARY_FRICKE_1938_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": "The transcript also names parents George G. Fricke and Marysue E. Henderson. It is evidence for the vital events and parent names, not for education, occupation, or residence after birth."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_JOHN_FRICKE_BIRTH_1889",
      "person_id": "HV10_JOHN_FRICKE_1889",
      "fact_type": "birth",
      "value": "Born to Henry Fricke and Katharina Schaff",
      "start_date": "18 Apr 1889",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_JOHN_1889_BIRTH",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The birth record names both parents; the 1900 household is consistent with the reported age. No later occupation, marriage, or death record is yet attached to this profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_JOHN_FRICKE_RESIDENCE_1900",
      "person_id": "HV10_JOHN_FRICKE_1889",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as a child in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This establishes a childhood household and place, not a later adult identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_ERNEST_FRICKE_RESIDENCE_1900_1905",
      "person_id": "HV10_ERNEST_DANIEL_FRICKE_1884",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": "1905",
      "place": "East Orange and Glen Ridge, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The two censuses support a continuous family identity. The reported World War I draft date is not represented by a linked record and is therefore not used as a separate structured fact here."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_HENRY_JR_FRICKE_RESIDENCE_1900_1910",
      "person_id": "HV10_HENRY_FRICKE_JR_ABT1886",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded in the Henry and Katharine Fricke household",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": "1910",
      "place": "East Orange and Glen Ridge, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census entries support his childhood and young-adult family identity. They do not establish a later occupation, marriage, or death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_ELIZABETH_FRICKE_RESIDENCE_1880",
      "person_id": "I78",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as a child in the Henry Fricke household",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census identifies Elizabeth as Henry and Cathrine Fricke’s child. It establishes a childhood household rather than the later marriage identity by itself."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_ELIZABETH_FRICKE_MARRIAGE_1890",
      "person_id": "I78",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Likely married Heinrich Gonder",
      "start_date": "20 Jul 1890",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_ELIZABETH_1890_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage matches name, age, and locality but no independently inspected follow-up household has been attached; it remains a likely rather than fully proved adult identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WILLIAM_FRICKE_RESIDENCE_1880",
      "person_id": "I79",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as a child in the Henry Fricke household",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census supplies William’s childhood household and approximate birth year; no later record is yet attached."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_CHARLES_FRICKE_HOUSEHOLD_1880_1910",
      "person_id": "I80",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded first as Henry Fricke’s child and later as a household head with brother George",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": "1910",
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1910 census calls George Fricke Charles’s brother, supporting the earlier sibling network. It does not by itself supply Charles’s occupation or exact birth date."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_ALBERT_RUSSELL_FRICKE_RESIDENCE_1920_1930",
      "person_id": "I29",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as Albert R. Fricke in George and Florence Fricke’s household",
      "start_date": "1920",
      "end_date": "1930",
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The repeated household records support the Albert Russell identity. His 1940 absence and a Russell Fricke entry are suggestive but do not independently document death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_EDNA_K_FRICKE_RESIDENCE_1930_1940",
      "person_id": "I30",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as Edna K. or Edna Fricke in George and Florence Fricke’s household",
      "start_date": "1930",
      "end_date": "1940",
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census records establish a continuous childhood identity. The expansion of K. to Kohl and the 2003 death remain compiled-profile details pending a vital record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_EAST_ORANGE_FRICKE_SIBLINGS_1880_1940",
      "person_id": "I78",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Elizabeth’s recorded childhood household was in an East Orange that had been founded as a township in 1863 and became a city in 1909. The city describes late nineteenth-century East Orange as agriculturally rich and home to Newark industrialists; this is community context, not a claim about the Fricke family’s wealth or work.",
      "start_date": "late 19th century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city history supplies place context. The census is the evidence that Elizabeth’s household was in East Orange."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_EAST_ORANGE_WILLIAM_FRICKE_1880",
      "person_id": "I79",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "William’s recorded childhood household was in an East Orange that had been founded as a township in 1863 and became a city in 1909. The city describes late nineteenth-century East Orange as agriculturally rich and home to Newark industrialists; this is community context, not a claim about the Fricke family’s wealth or work.",
      "start_date": "late 19th century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city history supplies place context. The census is the evidence that William’s household was in East Orange."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_EAST_ORANGE_CHARLES_FRICKE_1880_1910",
      "person_id": "I80",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Charles’s recorded childhood and adult households were in East Orange across its transition from township to city in 1909. The municipal history describes the late nineteenth-century community as agriculturally rich and connected to Newark industrialists; it does not identify Charles’s economic position or occupation.",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": "1910",
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city history supplies context; the census entries establish Charles’s residence there."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_EAST_ORANGE_ALBERT_FRICKE_1920_1930",
      "person_id": "I29",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Albert’s documented childhood was in East Orange, a city incorporated in 1909. This is a geographic setting for the census household; the municipal history does not establish the Fricke family’s social standing, occupation, or reason for living there.",
      "start_date": "1920",
      "end_date": "1930",
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city history provides community context. The census entries establish Albert’s household location."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_EAST_ORANGE_EDNA_FRICKE_1930_1940",
      "person_id": "I30",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Edna’s documented childhood was in East Orange, a city incorporated in 1909. This is a geographic setting for the census household; the municipal history does not establish the Fricke family’s social standing, occupation, or reason for living there.",
      "start_date": "1930",
      "end_date": "1940",
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The city history provides community context. The census entries establish Edna’s household location."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GOBBLE_ROBERT_I_RESIDENCE_1860_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC1880_ROBERT_I_GOBBLE_ABT1859",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as Robert in the John and Sallie Gobble household across three censuses",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The record sequence supports one Robert despite changing middle initials. It establishes a family household and locality, not a later occupation or death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GOBBLE_ROBERT_I_WASHINGTON_COUNTY",
      "person_id": "SRC1880_ROBERT_I_GOBBLE_ABT1859",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Robert’s recorded childhood and early-adult household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture. The Virginia and Tennessee Railroad began operating in 1856, and tobacco grew as a major county cash crop in the later nineteenth century. This is countywide setting, not evidence that Robert farmed or raised tobacco.",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The historical society supplies the county context; the census records establish Robert’s household location."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GOBBLE_GEORGE_W_RESIDENCE_1870_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC1880_GEORGE_W_GOBBLE_ABT1868",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as George W. in the John and Sallie Gobble household",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The census sequence and later record support the George Washington Gobble identity and parent family. They do not establish an adult occupation or later residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GOBBLE_GEORGE_W_WASHINGTON_COUNTY",
      "person_id": "SRC1880_GEORGE_W_GOBBLE_ABT1868",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "George’s recorded childhood household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture. The Virginia and Tennessee Railroad had begun operation in 1856, and tobacco grew as a major county cash crop in the later nineteenth century. This is countywide setting, not evidence that George farmed or raised tobacco.",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The historical society supplies the county context; the census records establish George’s household location."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GOBBLE_EGLANTINE_RESIDENCE_1870_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_EGLANTINE_GOBBLE_SCOTT_1863",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1880 household is consistent with a marriage to James M. Scott, but the marriage has not been independently inspected here. The record does not establish Eglantine’s occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GOBBLE_EGLANTINE_WASHINGTON_COUNTY",
      "person_id": "SRC_EGLANTINE_GOBBLE_SCOTT_1863",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Eglantine’s recorded childhood and young-adult households were in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, newly connected to the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad after 1856. This is countywide setting, not evidence that she or her household farmed, owned land, or grew tobacco.",
      "start_date": "1870",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The historical society supplies the county context; the census records establish Eglantine’s household location."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GOBBLE_MARTHA_JANE_RESIDENCE_1850_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTHA_JANE_GOBBLE_1844",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The census sequence supports a childhood household. The marriage index supplies parent names but does not by itself document Martha’s adult occupation or residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GOBBLE_MARTHA_JANE_WASHINGTON_COUNTY",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTHA_JANE_GOBBLE_1844",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Martha’s documented childhood was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture. The Virginia and Tennessee Railroad began operating in 1856, during the interval covered by her household records. This is countywide setting, not evidence that Martha’s family farmed or benefited directly from the railroad.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The historical society supplies the county context; the census records establish Martha’s household location."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GOBBLE_JULIA_ANN_RESIDENCE_1860_1870",
      "person_id": "SRC_JULIA_ANN_GOBBLE_1857",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1870 index spelling differs, but the ages and household support Julia Ann’s identity. The records do not establish a later occupation, marriage, or death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GOBBLE_JULIA_ANN_WASHINGTON_COUNTY",
      "person_id": "SRC_JULIA_ANN_GOBBLE_1857",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Julia’s recorded childhood was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, with rail connection through the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad from 1856. This is countywide setting, not evidence that Julia or her household farmed, owned land, or grew tobacco.",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The historical society supplies the county context; the census records establish Julia’s household location."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GOBBLE_WILLIAM_C_RESIDENCE_1860_1870",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_C_GOBBLE_1853",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The household records and later parent record support William C.’s identity. They do not establish an adult occupation, marriage, or death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GOBBLE_WILLIAM_C_WASHINGTON_COUNTY",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_C_GOBBLE_1853",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "William’s recorded childhood was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, with rail connection through the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad from 1856. This is countywide setting, not evidence that William or his household farmed, owned land, or grew tobacco.",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The historical society supplies the county context; the census records establish William’s household location."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GOBBLE_MARY_CATHERINE_RESIDENCE_1850_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_CATHERINE_GOBBLE_1850",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The combined Mary Catherine identity is strong but retains the first-name transition as a stated uncertainty. The records do not establish a later occupation, marriage, or death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GOBBLE_MARY_CATHERINE_WASHINGTON_COUNTY",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_CATHERINE_GOBBLE_1850",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Mary Catherine’s recorded childhood was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, with rail connection through the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad from 1856. This is countywide setting, not evidence that she or her household farmed, owned land, or grew tobacco.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The historical society supplies the county context; the census records establish Mary Catherine’s household location."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GOBBLE_MARTIN_P_RESIDENCE_1860_1870",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_P_GOBBLE_1848",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The census records support the household and locality, but do not state relationship-to-head in the supplied extracts. This fact does not elevate the inferred parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GOBBLE_MARTIN_P_WASHINGTON_COUNTY",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_P_GOBBLE_1848",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Martin’s recorded household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, with rail connection through the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad from 1856. This is countywide setting, not evidence that Martin or his household farmed, owned land, or grew tobacco.",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The historical society supplies the county context; the census records establish Martin’s household location while leaving the household relationship inference unchanged."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_DAVIES_ARTHUR_J_HOUSEHOLD_1891_1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_ARTHUR_J_DAVIES_ABT1881",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded in the Frederick and Maria Davies household at ages ten and twenty",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1891 census explicitly calls Arthur a child in this household. The 1901 household is consistent by name and age. Neither supplied extract records his later work, marriage, or death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_DAVIES_ARTHUR_J_SHREWSBURY_1891_1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_ARTHUR_J_DAVIES_ABT1881",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Arthur's recorded years in Shrewsbury coincided with an expanding town's investment in public health: the borough commissioned a sewage-disposal report in 1894, and Coleham Pumping Station opened in 1901.",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Historic England supplies townwide context; the censuses establish Arthur's household locality. This does not show his family's experience of the new service or any connection to the pumping station."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_DAVIES_DAVID_LIVINGSTONE_HOUSEHOLD_1911_1921",
      "person_id": "I48",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as a child in the Alfred Percy and Kezia Davies household",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1921",
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1911 census names David Livingstone, age three, with Alfred Percy and Kezia; the 1921 comparison continues the household with a likely index spelling of his middle name. These records do not independently verify the exact GEDCOM birth date or his later life."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_DAVIES_DAVID_LIVINGSTONE_SHREWSBURY_1911_1921",
      "person_id": "I48",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "David's documented childhood was in a Shrewsbury whose late-Victorian public-health works included the Coleham pumping station, opened in 1901 after the borough's 1894 sewage-disposal inquiry.",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1921",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is citywide setting drawn from Historic England, not evidence of David's address, school, work, or experience of municipal services."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_DAVIES_FRANCIS_J_HOUSEHOLD_1891_1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_FRANCIS_J_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded in the Frederick and Maria Davies household at ages five and fifteen",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied 1891 census identifies Francis as a child; Francis J appears at a consistent age in 1901. The extracts do not document his later occupation, marriage, or death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_DAVIES_FRANCIS_J_SHREWSBURY_1891_1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_FRANCIS_J_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Francis's recorded childhood in Shrewsbury spanned a period when the expanding borough commissioned a sewage-disposal inquiry in 1894 and opened Coleham Pumping Station in 1901.",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cited history describes Shrewsbury as a whole. It does not establish the Davies household's direct connection to the pumping station or other civic works."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_DAVIES_ROBERT_L_HOUSEHOLD_1891_1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_ROBERT_L_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded in the Frederick and Maria Davies household at ages five and fifteen",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied 1891 census identifies Robert as a child; Robert L appears at a consistent age in 1901. The extracts do not document his later occupation, marriage, or death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_DAVIES_ROBERT_L_SHREWSBURY_1891_1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_ROBERT_L_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Robert's recorded childhood in Shrewsbury overlapped with municipal public-health investment: a sewage-disposal inquiry was commissioned in 1894 and Coleham Pumping Station opened in 1901.",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is citywide context only. It does not show Robert's particular address, work, schooling, or family circumstances beyond the census household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_DAVIES_ALBERT_NOEL_HOUSEHOLD_1891_1901",
      "person_id": "I102",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as Albert N. in the Frederick and Maria Davies household at ages two and twelve",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Albert N. appears at consistent ages in both households. The supplied transcripts did not give his individual relationship-to-head field, so this fact supports residence and identity continuity without increasing the inferred parent links."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_DAVIES_ALBERT_NOEL_SHREWSBURY_1891_1901",
      "person_id": "I102",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Albert's recorded childhood household was in a Shrewsbury undergoing public-health improvements: the borough commissioned a sewage-disposal inquiry in 1894 and Coleham Pumping Station opened in 1901.",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The historical source describes the town, not Albert's individual circumstances. His position in the Davies household remains an inference explicitly retained at the relationship level."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_DAVIES_WALTER_H_HOUSEHOLD_1891",
      "person_id": "SRC1891_WALTER_H_DAVIES_ABT1882",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as a child, age nine, in the Frederick and Maria Davies household",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1891",
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Mary, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The supplied 1891 census explicitly identifies Walter H. as a child in this household. No later record has yet been reviewed here, so this does not establish his adult life."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_DAVIES_WALTER_H_SHREWSBURY_1891",
      "person_id": "SRC1891_WALTER_H_DAVIES_ABT1882",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Walter's documented Shrewsbury childhood came just before the borough commissioned its 1894 sewage-disposal inquiry, a response to nineteenth-century urban growth and concern over river-water contagion.",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1891",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This gives townwide context only; it does not identify Walter's particular experience of health, sanitation, work, or schooling."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_DAVIES_LOUIS_S_HOUSEHOLD_1891_1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_LOUIE_S_DAVIES_ABT1890",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as Louis S. and later Louie S. in the Frederick and Maria Davies household",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The age sequence and surname support one person despite the Louis/Louie form. The supplied transcripts did not state this individual's relationship to the household head, so the parent links remain inferential."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_DAVIES_LOUIS_S_SHREWSBURY_1891_1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_LOUIE_S_DAVIES_ABT1890",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Louis's recorded childhood in Shrewsbury overlapped with municipal public-health investment: a sewage-disposal inquiry was commissioned in 1894 and Coleham Pumping Station opened in 1901.",
      "start_date": "1891",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cited history concerns Shrewsbury generally. It does not show that Louis or this household used, worked at, or lived near the pumping station."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_DAVIES_THOMAS_E_HOUSEHOLD_1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_THOMAS_E_DAVIES_ABT1894",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as Thomas E., age seven, in the Frederick and Maria Davies household",
      "start_date": "1901",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury St Julian, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Thomas E. is present in the supplied household at a plausible age. As the individual relationship-to-head field was not supplied, this fact does not elevate the existing inferred parent links or establish a later life."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_DAVIES_THOMAS_E_SHREWSBURY_1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_THOMAS_E_DAVIES_ABT1894",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Thomas's documented Shrewsbury household coincided with the opening of Coleham Pumping Station in 1901, part of the borough's response to nineteenth-century expansion and public-health concerns.",
      "start_date": "1901",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is citywide background only. It does not establish Thomas's connection to the site or a specific personal experience of the works."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_WILLIAM_WILDE_DROITWICH_PARENTAGE_EXCLUSION",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "fact_type": "identity_exclusion",
      "value": "The proposed parentage to George Wylde of Droitwich and Frances Huddleston has been rejected: their memorial lists John, George, Elizabeth, and Dorothy as issue, not William, and no source names the Sheffield William as their child.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Droitwich, Worcestershire and Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DROITWICH_ST_PETERS_WYLDE_MONUMENT_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_WESTMINSTER_ABBEY_GEORGE_WYLDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Droitwich family remains historically documented in its own right. The missing William is strong contradictory evidence against this particular parent claim, while leaving open only a remote possibility that future primary material could establish a different relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_GEORGE_WILD_HALL_CARR_ALTERNATIVE",
      "person_id": "SRC_GEORGE_WILD_1616",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "A published Hall Carr pedigree identifies the Sheffield George Wild connected with Hannah as son of John Wild of Hall Carr, rather than of William Wilde. This is a more geographically coherent competing explanation, but it remains derivative pending original records.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STIRNET_HALL_CARR_WILD_PEDIGREE"
      ],
      "source_note": "Hannah's baptism directly names her father only as Georgii Wild. The Hall Carr pedigree is useful because it supplies a competing named father, but it does not independently prove that the existing 1616 profile is that man. It does, however, remove any basis for treating William Wilde as established father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_SAMPSON_RHEAD_STEPhen_CONFLATION_REJECTED",
      "person_id": "I139",
      "fact_type": "identity_exclusion",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_YOURROOTS_STEPhen",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ"
      ],
      "source_note": "The deleted candidate link should not be read as evidence of descent from Sampson Handley Rhead. His identity is independently established as the Trentham-born son of Richard and Ruth Read/Rhead, married to Julia Glover; the disputed Stephen claim is a different, conflated family construction."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_SARAH_POYNER_STEPhen_CONFLATION_REJECTED",
      "person_id": "I140",
      "fact_type": "identity_exclusion",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_YOURROOTS_STEPhen"
      ],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_RHEAD_EDWARD_RICHARD_HOUSEHOLD_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_EDWARD_RICHARD_RHEAD_ABT1901",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as the ten-year-old son in the Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead household at Glen Villas",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census directly places Edward Richard in the household at Glen Villas, Little Stretton. The later reported 1950 death is a compiled-timeline detail and is not treated here as a directly reviewed death record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_RHEAD_EDWARD_RICHARD_STRETTON_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_EDWARD_RICHARD_RHEAD_ABT1901",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Edward's 1911 household was in Little Stretton, an outlying settlement of Church Stretton parish. The nearby railway had encouraged Church Stretton's development as a resort, and the years before the First World War were its major early-twentieth-century expansion period.",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_COUNCIL_CHURCH_STRETTON_CONSERVATION_2013",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is context for the surrounding parish and town. It does not establish that Edward's household benefited from, worked in, or visited the resort economy."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_RHEAD_BERNAL_ALBERT_HOUSEHOLD_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_BERNAL_ALBERT_RHEAD_ABT1903",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as the eight-year-old son in the Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead household at Glen Villas",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census directly places Bernal Albert in the household at Glen Villas, Little Stretton. The reported 1931 Derby death comes from a compiled timeline and remains separately qualified."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_RHEAD_BERNAL_ALBERT_STRETTON_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_BERNAL_ALBERT_RHEAD_ABT1903",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Bernal Albert's 1911 household was in Little Stretton, an outlying settlement of Church Stretton parish. Railway access had helped make nearby Church Stretton a resort, with rapid Edwardian development before the First World War.",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_COUNCIL_CHURCH_STRETTON_CONSERVATION_2013",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The historical account describes the locality, not Bernal Albert's individual work, schooling, social position, or connection to the resort trade."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_RHEAD_GEORGE_ERNEST_HOUSEHOLD_1911_1921",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_GEORGE_ERNEST_RHEAD_ABT1905",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded with Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead in the 1911 Little Stretton and 1921 St Chad households",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1921",
      "place": "Little Stretton and Shrewsbury St Chad, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census sequence traces George Ernest from the Little Stretton household into the family's later Shrewsbury household. It does not establish his adult occupation or the reported 1943 death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_RHEAD_GEORGE_ERNEST_STRETTON_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_GEORGE_ERNEST_RHEAD_ABT1905",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "George Ernest's early household was in the Church Stretton parish landscape, where the railway had encouraged resort growth and the decade before the First World War was a major period of Edwardian building.",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_COUNCIL_CHURCH_STRETTON_CONSERVATION_2013",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is regional context only. It does not indicate that George Ernest or his household worked for the railway or in tourism."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_RHEAD_AMY_ROSA_HOUSEHOLD_1911_1921",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_AMY_ROSA_RHEAD_ABT1907",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded with Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead in the 1911 Little Stretton and 1921 St Chad households",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1921",
      "place": "Little Stretton and Shrewsbury St Chad, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census sequence traces Amy Rosa from the Little Stretton household into the family's later Shrewsbury household. The reported 1988 death is a compiled-timeline detail, not a directly reviewed death record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_RHEAD_AMY_ROSA_STRETTON_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_AMY_ROSA_RHEAD_ABT1907",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Amy Rosa's early household was in Little Stretton, an outlying settlement in the Church Stretton valley. Railway access had encouraged nearby Church Stretton's resort development, which was at its early-twentieth-century height around the time of the 1911 census.",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_COUNCIL_CHURCH_STRETTON_CONSERVATION_2013",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes Amy Rosa's wider setting only; no particular school, work, address beyond the census household, or involvement with the resort trade is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_RHEAD_FRANK_STRETTON_REPORTED_BIRTH_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC_FRANK_STRETTON_RHEAD_1911",
      "fact_type": "vital_record",
      "value": "A family timeline reports birth on 25 September 1911 at Church Stretton and death in 1969",
      "start_date": "25 Sep 1911",
      "end_date": "1969",
      "place": "Church Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a carefully retained timeline report: the supplied profile names Frank as a son of Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead, but a direct birth registration and death record have not yet been reviewed."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_RHEAD_FRANK_STRETTON_CHURCH_STRETTON_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC_FRANK_STRETTON_RHEAD_1911",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Frank's reported 1911 Church Stretton birth falls during the town's railway-enabled Edwardian expansion as a residential resort in the valley between the Long Mynd and Stretton Hills.",
      "start_date": "1911",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "Church Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_COUNCIL_CHURCH_STRETTON_CONSERVATION_2013",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "The place and date come from a compiled timeline, so this context is deliberately qualified. It does not establish an address, occupation, schooling, or family participation in the resort economy."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_RHEAD_ALFRED_SAMUEL_REPORTED_BIRTH_1913",
      "person_id": "SRC_ALFRED_SAMUEL_RHEAD_1913",
      "fact_type": "vital_record",
      "value": "A family timeline reports birth on 26 September 1913 at Little Stretton and death in 2006",
      "start_date": "26 Sep 1913",
      "end_date": "2006",
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a carefully retained timeline report: the supplied profile names Alfred as a son of Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead, but a direct birth registration and death record have not yet been reviewed."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_RHEAD_ALFRED_SAMUEL_STRETTON_1913",
      "person_id": "SRC_ALFRED_SAMUEL_RHEAD_1913",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Alfred's reported 1913 Little Stretton birth falls in the Church Stretton parish during the town's railway-enabled Edwardian expansion as a residential resort.",
      "start_date": "1913",
      "end_date": "1913",
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_COUNCIL_CHURCH_STRETTON_CONSERVATION_2013",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": "The place and date come from a compiled timeline, so this context is deliberately qualified. It does not infer an address, occupation, education, or economic position."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WC_JAMES_TALLEY_1860_1870",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_M_TALLEY_1860",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as James in the Evan and Dela Talley household in 1860 and as Jas M. in a possible later Delia Henderson household in 1870",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1860 household and parent index strongly support James M. Talley. The 1870 placement depends on the unproven proposition that Delia Talley had remarried William Henderson, so it is a qualified continuation rather than a confirmed migration or stepfamily event."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WC_JAMES_TALLEY_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_M_TALLEY_1860",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "James's documented 1860 household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture. The Virginia and Tennessee Railroad began operating in 1856, and tobacco grew into a major county cash crop later in the nineteenth century.",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is countywide setting, not evidence that James or his household farmed, owned land, worked for the railroad, or raised tobacco."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WC_AMANDA_TALLEY_1860_1870",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMANDA_J_TALLEY_1851",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as Amanda in the Evan and Dela Talley household in 1860 and at a compatible age in a possible later Delia Henderson household in 1870",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1860 household and parent index directly support Amanda J. Talley. Her reported age differs by three years between the two censuses, and the Delia Henderson identity has not been proven, so the 1870 appearance remains qualified."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WC_AMANDA_TALLEY_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMANDA_J_TALLEY_1851",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Amanda's documented childhood household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, newly affected by the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad after 1856 and by tobacco's growing importance as a county cash crop.",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the county, not Amanda's family occupation, property, income, or relationship to the railroad."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WC_SAMUEL_HENDERSON_1860_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_HENDERSON_1860",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded first in Robert and Mary Henderson's 1860 household and later in Robert Henderson's 1880 household",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Samuel is age five months in 1860 and twenty in the 1880 household. The later death record explicitly names Bob Henderson and Mary McNew as parents; the records do not establish an adult occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WC_SAMUEL_HENDERSON_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_HENDERSON_1860",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Samuel's documented childhood began in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture. The Virginia and Tennessee Railroad had begun service in 1856, and tobacco became a major county cash crop later in the century.",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This is countywide context, not evidence that Samuel's household farmed, grew tobacco, owned land, or worked for the railroad."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WC_MARY_E_HENDERSON_1858_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_E_HENDERSON_1858",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "A Virginia birth register names Robert and Mary Henderson as parents; Mary E. also appears age two in their 1860 household",
      "start_date": "1858",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The source combination supports Mary E.'s identity and parentage. It does not establish a later residence, occupation, marriage, or death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WC_MARY_E_HENDERSON_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_E_HENDERSON_1858",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Mary E.'s documented early childhood was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, with new rail service after 1856 and tobacco's later growth as a cash crop.",
      "start_date": "1858",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This county history does not establish Mary E.'s household trade, property, or personal experience of economic change."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WC_MARGARET_PHELPS_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARET_PHELPS_1843",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded at age seven in the Martin Phelps household",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1850 schedule places Margaret in the household; the later index names Martin and Malinda Phelps in relation to her. Neither record establishes her adult occupation, marriage, or death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WC_MARGARET_PHELPS_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARET_PHELPS_1843",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Margaret's recorded childhood household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture. The Virginia and Tennessee Railroad began operation in 1856, after the census that documents her childhood home.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is countywide setting, not evidence that Margaret's household farmed, owned land, raised tobacco, or benefited directly from the railroad."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WC_MARTIN_S_PHELPS_1850_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_S_PHELPS_1845",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded in the Martin Phelps household at ages five and about fifteen",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census sequence and parent-naming index support one Martin S. Phelps. It does not establish an adult occupation, later residence, marriage, or death."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WC_MARTIN_S_PHELPS_1850_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_S_PHELPS_1845",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Martin S.'s recorded childhood in Washington County spanned the arrival of Virginia and Tennessee Railroad service in 1856 and a period when agriculture remained the county's main economic base.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The context does not infer that Martin S. was a farmer, worked on the railroad, owned land, or raised tobacco."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WC_JOHN_P_PHELPS_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_P_PHELPS_1834",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as John, age sixteen, in Martin Phelps's 1850 household",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census directly documents a John in Martin's household. A later record supports a Martin Phelps parent connection, but its spouse name differs from the 1850 household; no unqualified maternal conclusion is drawn here."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WC_JOHN_P_PHELPS_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_P_PHELPS_1834",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "John's documented 1850 household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, before the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad began operating in 1856.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This setting does not establish John's occupation, property, or family economic position."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WC_NEWTON_PHELPS_1860_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_NEWTON_PHELPS_1857",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as Newton and later Nuten in the Martin and Malinda Phelps households",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The name variants and age progression support a single person in the household. The supplied censuses do not state relationship to head, so this fact does not raise the existing inferred parent links."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WC_NEWTON_PHELPS_1860_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_NEWTON_PHELPS_1857",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Newton's recorded household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, with rail service from 1856 and tobacco's growing importance as a county cash crop later in the century.",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is countywide context, not evidence that Newton farmed, owned land, worked for the railroad, or grew tobacco."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WC_VIRGINIA_F_PHELPS_1860_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_VIRGINIA_F_PHELPS_1854",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded in the Martin and Malinda Phelps households at ages about seven and twenty-five",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The recurring name and age support the household continuity. The supplied censuses do not state relationship to head, so this fact does not increase the inferred parent links."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WC_VIRGINIA_F_PHELPS_1860_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_VIRGINIA_F_PHELPS_1854",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Virginia F.'s recorded household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, with rail service from 1856 and tobacco's growing importance as a county cash crop later in the century.",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is countywide context, not evidence that Virginia F. farmed, owned land, worked for the railroad, or grew tobacco."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_MCNEW_AILSEY_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_AILSEY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded in the David and Ann McNew household",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_MCNEW_AILSEY_WASHINGTON_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_AILSEY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Ailsey's recorded 1850 household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, before the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad began operation in 1856.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This is countywide setting, not evidence that Ailsey's household farmed, owned land, or benefited from later rail development."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded in the David and Ann McNew household",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied census comparison and independent tree both list Elizabeth as David's child, but neither excerpt supplies her age or later-life details."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_WASHINGTON_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Elizabeth's recorded 1850 household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, before the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad began operation in 1856.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This is countywide setting, not evidence that Elizabeth's household farmed, owned land, or benefited from later rail development."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_MCNEW_LOUISA_AMELIA_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_LOUIS_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Likely recorded as Louis in the David and Ann McNew household",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The original comparison reads Louis; Louisa Amelia is a plausible compiled expansion but needs image-level confirmation. The fact retains the name uncertainty rather than asserting a proven expansion."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_MCNEW_LOUISA_AMELIA_WASHINGTON_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_LOUIS_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The 1850 McNew household record, if it is Louisa Amelia, places her in an agricultural Washington County setting before the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad began operation in 1856.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The identification is qualified because the census name form is Louis. No occupation, property, or direct experience of county economic change is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_MCNEW_NANCY_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_NANCY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded in the David and Ann McNew household",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied census comparison and independent tree both list Nancy as David's child, but neither excerpt supplies her age or later-life details."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_MCNEW_NANCY_WASHINGTON_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_NANCY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Nancy's recorded 1850 household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, before the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad began operation in 1856.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This is countywide setting, not evidence that Nancy's household farmed, owned land, or benefited from later rail development."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_MCNEW_SENAH_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_CENA_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Likely recorded as Cena in the David and Ann McNew household",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The original comparison reads Cena; Senah is a plausible compiled correction but requires image-level confirmation. The fact preserves this uncertainty and does not assert a fully proven name expansion."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_MCNEW_SENAH_WASHINGTON_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_CENA_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The 1850 McNew household record, if it is Senah, places her in an agricultural Washington County setting before the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad began operation in 1856.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The identification is qualified because the census name form is Cena. No occupation, property, or direct experience of county economic change is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_MCNEW_SAMUEL_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded as a child in the David and Ann McNew household",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The supplied census comparison calls Samuel a child of David McNew but omits age and detailed household fields. No later identity, mother, occupation, or death is established here."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_MCNEW_SAMUEL_WASHINGTON_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Samuel's only documented appearance is in a 1850 Washington County household, in a county economy then largely based on agriculture and still two years before the Virginia and Tennessee Railroad opened.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This describes the county rather than Samuel's personal circumstances, which remain largely unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WATERHOUSE_FREDERICK_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_FREDERICK_WATERHOUSE_ABT1828",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded at age 13 in the 1841 Trentham household of John and Ellen Waterhouse",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1841 census directly records Frederick in this household. It did not record relationships, so the links to John and Ellen are circumstantial support from the shared surname, ages, and household position rather than direct proof of parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WATERHOUSE_FREDERICK_TRENTHAM_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_FREDERICK_WATERHOUSE_ABT1828",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Frederick was recorded in Trentham while Trentham Hall was being extensively remodelled for the 2nd Duke of Sutherland between 1833 and 1842.",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_TRENTHAM_HALL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is local historical setting. The census does not identify Frederick's address, work, tenancy, or any connection with the Trentham estate."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WATERHOUSE_JAMES_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ABT1830",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded at age 11 in the 1841 Trentham household of John and Ellen Waterhouse",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1841 census directly records James in this household. It did not record relationships, so the links to John and Ellen are circumstantial support from the shared surname, ages, and household position rather than direct proof of parentage. This James remains distinct from the James Waterhouse born about 1846 in Burwash."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WATERHOUSE_JAMES_TRENTHAM_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ABT1830",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "James was recorded in Trentham while Trentham Hall was being extensively remodelled for the 2nd Duke of Sutherland between 1833 and 1842.",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_TRENTHAM_HALL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is local historical setting. The census does not identify James's address, work, tenancy, or any connection with the Trentham estate."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WATERHOUSE_JOHN_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ABT1832",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded at age 9 in the 1841 Trentham household of John and Ellen Waterhouse",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1841 census directly records John in this household. It did not record relationships, so the links to John and Ellen are circumstantial support from the shared surname, ages, and household position rather than direct proof of parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WATERHOUSE_JOHN_TRENTHAM_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ABT1832",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "John was recorded in Trentham while Trentham Hall was being extensively remodelled for the 2nd Duke of Sutherland between 1833 and 1842.",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_TRENTHAM_HALL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is local historical setting. The census does not identify John's address, work, tenancy, or any connection with the Trentham estate."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WATERHOUSE_WILLIAM_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_WILLIAM_WATERHOUSE_ABT1837",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded at age 4 in the 1841 Trentham household of John and Ellen Waterhouse",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1841 census directly records William in this household. It did not record relationships, so the links to John and Ellen are circumstantial support from the shared surname, ages, and household position rather than direct proof of parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WATERHOUSE_WILLIAM_TRENTHAM_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_WILLIAM_WATERHOUSE_ABT1837",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "William was recorded in Trentham while Trentham Hall was being extensively remodelled for the 2nd Duke of Sutherland between 1833 and 1842.",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_TRENTHAM_HALL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is local historical setting. The census does not identify William's address, work, tenancy, or any connection with the Trentham estate."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WATERHOUSE_EMMA_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_EMMA_WATERHOUSE_ABT1840",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded at age 1 in the 1841 Trentham household of John and Ellen Waterhouse",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1841 census directly records Emma in this household. It did not record relationships, so the links to John and Ellen are circumstantial support from the shared surname, ages, and household position rather than direct proof of parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WATERHOUSE_EMMA_TRENTHAM_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_EMMA_WATERHOUSE_ABT1840",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Emma was recorded in Trentham while Trentham Hall was being extensively remodelled for the 2nd Duke of Sutherland between 1833 and 1842.",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_TRENTHAM_HALL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is local historical setting. The census does not identify Emma's address, work, tenancy, or any connection with the Trentham estate."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_HANNY_WILLIAM_HENRY_1851",
      "person_id": "C_HANNY_WILLIAM_HENRY_1839",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded as “Henery Hanney,” age 12, in the 1851 Bradford-on-Avon household of William and Elizabeth Hanney",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1851",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNY_ANCESTRY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census directly places a 12-year-old Henery Hanney in the household. The external profile identifies William Henry Hanny, born 21 March 1839, as the child; the given-name difference means that identification remains well-supported rather than directly proven by the census alone."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_HANNY_WILLIAM_HENRY_BRADFORD_1851",
      "person_id": "C_HANNY_WILLIAM_HENRY_1839",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "William Henry was recorded in Bradford-on-Avon, a Wiltshire town with a long cloth-making history.",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1851",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_BHO",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is town-level context only. No record currently identifies William Henry's occupation, schooling, address, or a connection to the town's textile trade."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_HANNEY_ANNA_1851",
      "person_id": "SRC1851_ANNA_HANNEY_ABT1841",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded at age 10 in the 1851 Bradford-on-Avon household of William and Elizabeth Hanney",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1851",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1851 census directly records Anna in this household. The supplied extract does not state an individual relationship, so the links to William and Elizabeth are circumstantial support from surname, age, and household structure rather than direct proof of parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_HANNEY_ANNA_BRADFORD_1851",
      "person_id": "SRC1851_ANNA_HANNEY_ABT1841",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Anna was recorded in Bradford-on-Avon, a Wiltshire town with a long cloth-making history.",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1851",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_BHO",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is town-level context only. No record currently identifies Anna's schooling, work, address, or a connection to the town's textile trade."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_HANNEY_EDWIN_1851",
      "person_id": "SRC1851_EDWIN_HANNEY_ABT1842",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded at age 9 in the 1851 Bradford-on-Avon household of William and Elizabeth Hanney",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1851",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1851 census directly records Edwin in this household. The supplied extract does not state an individual relationship, so the links to William and Elizabeth are circumstantial support from surname, age, and household structure rather than direct proof of parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_HANNEY_EDWIN_BRADFORD_1851",
      "person_id": "SRC1851_EDWIN_HANNEY_ABT1842",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Edwin was recorded in Bradford-on-Avon, a Wiltshire town with a long cloth-making history.",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1851",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_BHO",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is town-level context only. No record currently identifies Edwin's schooling, work, address, or a connection to the town's textile trade."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GIBSON_DAVID_HOUSEHOLDS_1901_1911",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_DAVID_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded in John Gibson's Aghnasedagh household at age 12 in 1901 and age 22 in 1911",
      "start_date": "1901",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The two census returns directly place David in John Gibson's household and support one continuous identity. “Andrew” is supplied by a compiled family tree, not by the census returns."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GIBSON_DAVID_MONAGHAN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_DAVID_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "David grew up in rural County Monaghan, where small farms had commonly combined agriculture with household linen production before the linen trade declined from the 1830s.",
      "start_date": "1888",
      "end_date": "1911",
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is regional context. The censuses identify David's father as a farmer, but they do not establish David's work, schooling, tenancy, or involvement in linen production."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GIBSON_MARGARET_HOUSEHOLD_1901",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_MAGGIE_J_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded as Maggie J. Gibson, age 15, in John Gibson's 1901 Aghnasedagh household",
      "start_date": "1901",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1901 census directly records Maggie J. in John Gibson's household. The fuller name Margaret Jane comes from a compiled family tree; the 1911 entry “Minnie” cannot safely be assigned to either Maggie or Mary from the supplied evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GIBSON_MARGARET_MONAGHAN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_MAGGIE_J_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Margaret was recorded in rural County Monaghan, where small farms had commonly combined agriculture with household linen production before the linen trade declined from the 1830s.",
      "start_date": "1885",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is regional context only. No record currently identifies Margaret's work, schooling, residence after 1901, or involvement in linen production."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GIBSON_MARY_HOUSEHOLD_1901",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_MARY_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded as Mary Gibson, age 13, in John Gibson's 1901 Aghnasedagh household",
      "start_date": "1901",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1901 census directly records Mary in John Gibson's household. The 1911 entry “Minnie” cannot safely be assigned to either Mary or Maggie from the supplied evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GIBSON_MARY_MONAGHAN_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_MARY_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Mary was recorded in rural County Monaghan, where small farms had commonly combined agriculture with household linen production before the linen trade declined from the 1830s.",
      "start_date": "1887",
      "end_date": "1901",
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is regional context only. No record currently identifies Mary's work, schooling, residence after 1901, or involvement in linen production."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_BOULTON_THOMAS_CENSUS_CONTINUITY",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1849",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded as Thomas Botton in 1851 and Thomas Boulton in the continuing household in 1861 and 1871",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1871",
      "place": "Trentham and Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age, household members, and locality continuity support one person despite the 1851 Botton spelling. The records identify a household relationship but the supplied 1851 extract does not explicitly label his parents, so both parent links remain circumstantial support."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_BOULTON_THOMAS_STAFFORDSHIRE",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1849",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Thomas was documented first at Trentham and later at Hanford, Staffordshire, during the nineteenth-century remodelling of Trentham Hall and its surrounding estate landscape.",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1871",
      "place": "Trentham and Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_TRENTHAM_HALL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is local historical setting only. The census records do not identify Thomas's work, address, tenancy, or any connection with the Trentham estate."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_HENDERSON_LUCRETIA_HOUSEHOLD_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_LOWCRESA_HENDERSON_1862",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded as Lowcresa, age 18, in widowed Robert Henderson's 1880 Saltville household",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Saltville, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census directly records Lowcresa in Robert Henderson's household. “Lucretia Louisa” and the parent links come from a compiled tree and remain plausible but unproven; Lowcresa may be an indexing or spelling variant."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_HENDERSON_LUCRETIA_SALTVILLE",
      "person_id": "SRC_LOWCRESA_HENDERSON_1862",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Lucretia's known household was recorded at Saltville in Washington County in 1880, in a county whose economy was largely agricultural but increasingly shaped by rail service and tobacco markets after the 1850s.",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Saltville, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is county-level context only. The 1880 census records Robert as a laborer; it does not establish Lucretia's work, schooling, property, or involvement in the county's agricultural, rail, or tobacco economy. The Saltville county jurisdiction remains qualified in the underlying record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_HENDERSON_AMANDA_HOUSEHOLD_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMANDA_HENDERSON_1864",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded as Amanda, age 16, in widowed Robert Henderson's 1880 Saltville household",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Saltville, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census directly records Amanda in Robert Henderson's household. “Amanda Jane” and the parent links come from a compiled tree and remain plausible but unproven."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_HENDERSON_AMANDA_SALTVILLE",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMANDA_HENDERSON_1864",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Amanda's known household was recorded at Saltville in Washington County in 1880, in a county whose economy was largely agricultural but increasingly shaped by rail service and tobacco markets after the 1850s.",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Saltville, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is county-level context only. The 1880 census records Robert as a laborer; it does not establish Amanda's work, schooling, property, or involvement in the county's agricultural, rail, or tobacco economy. The Saltville county jurisdiction remains qualified in the underlying record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_HENDERSON_JAMES_HOUSEHOLD_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_HENDERSON_1862",
      "fact_type": "household_record",
      "value": "Recorded as James, age 18, in widowed Robert Henderson's 1880 Saltville household",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Saltville, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census directly records James in Robert Henderson's household. “James M.” and the parent links come from a compiled tree and remain plausible but unproven. His reported age matches Lowcresa's, which could reflect twins, another relationship, or an indexing issue."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_HENDERSON_JAMES_SALTVILLE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_HENDERSON_1862",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "James's known household was recorded at Saltville in Washington County in 1880, in a county whose economy was largely agricultural but increasingly shaped by rail service and tobacco markets after the 1850s.",
      "start_date": "1880",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Saltville, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is county-level context only. The 1880 census records Robert as a laborer; it does not establish James's work, schooling, property, or involvement in the county's agricultural, rail, or tobacco economy. The Saltville county jurisdiction remains qualified in the underlying record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_MCNEW_MARY_LUCY_DERIVATIVE",
      "person_id": "C_MCNEW_MARY_LUCY_1709",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "8 Feb 1708/09",
      "end_date": "about 1762",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "These reported dates and relationships recur in online genealogies, but no primary baptism, probate, or contemporary record has been identified. They are retained as plausible research leads, not treated as proved vital facts."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_MCNEW_MARY_LUCY_PRINCE_GEORGES",
      "person_id": "C_MCNEW_MARY_LUCY_1709",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the reported county is correct, Mary Lucy was born in Prince George's County only about fourteen years after the county was created from Charles and Calvert counties.",
      "start_date": "1708",
      "end_date": "1709",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_PRINCE_GEORGES_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is conditional historical context because the individual birth location is derivative. It does not establish a home, occupation, property, or personal experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_MCNEW_ANNE_DERIVATIVE",
      "person_id": "C_MCNEW_ANNE_1711",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "8 Nov 1711",
      "end_date": "after Nov 1774",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "These reported dates and relationships recur in online genealogies, but no primary baptism, probate, or contemporary record has been identified. They are retained as plausible research leads, not treated as proved vital facts."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_MCNEW_ANNE_PRINCE_GEORGES",
      "person_id": "C_MCNEW_ANNE_1711",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the reported county is correct, Anne's early life was in Prince George's County, created from Charles and Calvert counties in 1695.",
      "start_date": "1711",
      "end_date": "1711",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_PRINCE_GEORGES_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is conditional historical context because the individual birth location is derivative. It does not establish a home, occupation, property, or personal experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_MCNEW_EDWARD_MARLEY_DERIVATIVE",
      "person_id": "C_MCNEW_EDWARD_MARLEY_1713",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "14 Aug 1713",
      "end_date": "1791",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "These reported dates and relationships recur in online genealogies, but no primary baptism, probate, or contemporary record has been identified. They are retained as plausible research leads, not treated as proved vital facts."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_MCNEW_EDWARD_MARLEY_PRINCE_GEORGES",
      "person_id": "C_MCNEW_EDWARD_MARLEY_1713",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "If the reported county is correct, Edward Marley's early life was in Prince George's County, created from Charles and Calvert counties in 1695.",
      "start_date": "1713",
      "end_date": "1713",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_PRINCE_GEORGES_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is conditional historical context because the individual birth location is derivative. It does not establish a home, occupation, property, or personal experience."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WC_HARDIN_PHELPS_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_HARDIN_PHELPS_1833",
      "fact_type": "census_enumeration",
      "value": "Enumerated as Hardin Phelps, age seventeen, in a household headed by Martin Phelps and including Malinda Phelps",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1850 census did not record household relationships. This is evidence of Hardin's presence, age, and locality, not direct proof of his parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_WC_HARDIN_PHELPS_PARENTAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_HARDIN_PHELPS_1833",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "The available record supports Hardin's presence in Martin Phelps's household, but does not name his parents",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "A father-son relationship is a reasonable interpretation of the household, but a boarder, worker, or other relative remains possible. No baptism, probate, or later relationship record has been identified."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WC_HARDIN_PHELPS_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_HARDIN_PHELPS_1833",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His documented 1850 household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, before Virginia and Tennessee Railroad service began in 1856",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is countywide context for Hardin's known residence, not an assertion about his own occupation or wealth."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_WC_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1855",
      "fact_type": "census_enumeration",
      "value": "Enumerated as William Phelps, about age five, in the Martin and Malinda Phelps household",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1860 census establishes William's presence, approximate age, and locality. It does not state the relationship of any household member to Martin or Malinda."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_WC_WILLIAM_PHELPS_PARENTAGE",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1855",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "The 1860 household makes Martin and Malinda Phelps probable parents, but the census does not name the relationship",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "At about five years old and sharing the Phelps surname, William is more likely their child than an unrelated resident. Without a relationship column, birth record, or probate, the link is retained as a qualified inference."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_WC_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1855",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His documented 1860 household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture; Virginia and Tennessee Railroad service had begun in 1856",
      "start_date": "1860",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is countywide context for William's known residence, not an assertion about his own occupation or wealth."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_COUNTISS_HENRY_1820_HOUSEHOLD",
      "person_id": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
      "fact_type": "census_enumeration",
      "value": "Headed a nine-person household: one man and one woman aged twenty-six to forty-four, five children under sixteen, and one woman aged sixteen to twenty-five",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "end_date": "1820",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1820 census identifies only the household head by name. It documents Henry Countess in Washington County but does not name or establish the relationships of the other eight residents."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_COUNTISS_HENRY_1820",
      "person_id": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His documented household was in a Washington County economy largely based on agriculture, decades before railroad service reached the county in 1856",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "end_date": "1820",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is countywide context for Henry's documented residence. It does not establish his personal occupation, landholding, or wealth."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_COUNTISS_HENRY_REPORTED_VITALS",
      "person_id": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
      "fact_type": "reported_vital_claim",
      "value": "A community tree reports a 9 June 1777 birth in Queen Anne's County, Maryland and death before 1830",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The reported death before 1830 is imprecise and cannot be treated as an established place or date: the same man is documented in Washington County in 1820. The reported Maryland origin remains plausible but unproved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_COUNTISS_MARY_FAMILY_RECORD",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_RUSSELL_COUNTISS",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "A community tree identifies Mary Russell as Henry Countiss's wife",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The 1820 census has a woman of compatible age in Henry Countess's household but names no wife. No marriage, vital, probate, or other independent record has yet been supplied for Mary Russell."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_COUNTISS_MARY_1820_HOUSEHOLD",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_RUSSELL_COUNTISS",
      "fact_type": "candidate_household_continuity",
      "value": "A woman aged twenty-six to forty-four was enumerated in Henry Countess's 1820 household",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "end_date": "1820",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Age compatibility can support, but cannot identify, Mary as the enumerated woman. This fact is not treated as a named census appearance."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I139_SAMPSON_RESIDENCE_1861",
      "person_id": "I139",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_household",
      "value": "Recorded at Bucknall with wife Julia and children Frederic, Thomas, and George",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Bucknall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The census identifies the household and child relationships. It is direct evidence for the Julia family and independently rules out a merger with the separate Shropshire Sampson, who died in 1845."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_I139_SAMPSON_BIRTH_ESTIMATE_CONFLICT_1861",
      "person_id": "I139",
      "fact_type": "birth_date_conflict",
      "value": "The 1861 census and memorial material estimate birth about 1797, while the parish record gives 30 June 1799",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Bucknall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_QPSM_68WK"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish entry is preferred for the birth date because it gives a specific date close to the event. The 1861 and memorial values are useful identity corroboration but are approximate and not substituted for it."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I137_BAPTISM_1833_ORIGINAL",
      "person_id": "I137",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized as Richard Rhead, son of Sampson and Sarah Rhead",
      "start_date": "17 Feb 1833",
      "end_date": "17 Feb 1833",
      "place": "Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "Entry 425 also records Woodfarm as the abode and Sampson as a grocer. It does not give Richard's birth date or either parent's additional names."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_SAMPSON_RHEAD_GROCER_1833",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Grocer",
      "start_date": "17 Feb 1833",
      "end_date": "17 Feb 1833",
      "place": "Woodfarm, Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism gives the occupation at Richard's baptism. It does not establish how long Sampson worked as a grocer or identify a particular shop."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFHIST_SAMPSON_RHEAD_WOODFARM_1833",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Recorded at Woodfarm when his son Richard was baptized",
      "start_date": "17 Feb 1833",
      "end_date": "17 Feb 1833",
      "place": "Woodfarm, Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "This records the family's abode at the baptism, not ownership of the farm or a continuous residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_I137_PARENT_NAME_LIMITATION_1833",
      "person_id": "I137",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "The original baptism names the parents only as Sampson and Sarah Rhead; it does not supply the names Handley or Maria",
      "start_date": "17 Feb 1833",
      "end_date": "17 Feb 1833",
      "place": "Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "A later compiled tree adds Sampson Handley Rhead and Sarah Maria Poyner. Sarah's marriage and later records support Poyner and Maria, but the Handley addition is not stated in the baptism and cannot override the distinct Julia Glover household and 1865 death of Sampson Handley Rhead."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_SAMPSON_RHEAD_WOODFARM_ORIGIN_CLUE",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "fact_type": "origin_clue",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1813",
      "end_date": "1833",
      "place": "Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_COUNCIL_WOOD_FARM_STOKE_ST_MILBOROUGH"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a focused lead, not proof of a shared identity or kinship. The same man hypothesis conflicts with Sampson Handley Rhead's documented marriage to Julia Glover, continued Julia household, and 1865 death. A close family, tenancy, or estate connection is presently more compatible than a merger, but no land, probate, or parish record yet proves it."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_BALTHASS_FUCHS_COMPILED_SIBLING",
      "person_id": "SRC_BALTHASS_FUCHS_1595",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "A compiled Fuchs family profile places Balthass Fuchs, born 1595, among the children of Hans Fuchs and Barbara Reiff",
      "start_date": "1595",
      "end_date": "1595",
      "place": null,
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Anna Fuchs is independently recorded at Oberboebingen in 1596 as Hans and Barbara's child, but that record does not name Balthass or give Barbara a maiden surname. No location, exact event date, occupation, or later life is inferred for Balthass."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_BARBARA_FUCHS_COMPILED_SIBLING",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_FUCHS_1604",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "A compiled Fuchs family profile places Barbara Fuchs, born 1604, among the children of Hans Fuchs and Barbara Reiff",
      "start_date": "1604",
      "end_date": "1604",
      "place": null,
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Anna Fuchs is independently recorded at Oberboebingen in 1596 as Hans and Barbara's child, but that record does not name this Barbara or give Barbara Reiff's maiden name. No location, exact event date, occupation, or later life is inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_JOHANNES_FUCHS_COMPILED_SIBLING",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHANNES_FUCHS_1602",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "A compiled Fuchs family profile places Johannes Fuchs, born 1602, among the children of Hans Fuchs and Barbara Reiff",
      "start_date": "1602",
      "end_date": "1602",
      "place": null,
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Anna Fuchs is independently recorded at Oberboebingen in 1596 as Hans and Barbara's child, but that record does not name Johannes or give Barbara a maiden surname. No location, exact event date, occupation, or later life is inferred for Johannes."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_MARIA_FUCHS_COMPILED_SIBLING",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARIA_FUCHS_1608",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "A compiled Fuchs family profile places Maria Fuchs, born 1608, among the children of Hans Fuchs and Barbara Reiff",
      "start_date": "1608",
      "end_date": "1608",
      "place": null,
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Anna Fuchs is independently recorded at Oberboebingen in 1596 as Hans and Barbara's child, but that record does not name Maria or give Barbara a maiden surname. No location, exact event date, occupation, or later life is inferred for Maria."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_VEIT_FUCHS_COMPILED_SIBLING",
      "person_id": "SRC_VEIT_FUCHS_1606",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "A compiled Fuchs family profile places Veit Fuchs, born 1606, among the children of Hans Fuchs and Barbara Reiff",
      "start_date": "1606",
      "end_date": "1606",
      "place": null,
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "Anna Fuchs is independently recorded at Oberboebingen in 1596 as Hans and Barbara's child, but that record does not name Veit or give Barbara a maiden surname. No location, exact event date, occupation, or later life is inferred for Veit."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_JOHN_S_MCNEW_DEATH_AND_BURIAL_1876",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Recorded at the McNew Cemetery, Deepwater; died 1 January 1876 at an age transcribed as 70 years, 1 month, and 16 days",
      "start_date": "1 Jan 1876",
      "end_date": "1 Jan 1876",
      "place": "Henry County, Missouri, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "The available source is a cemetery transcription rather than a marker image. It establishes the death date and Deepwater burial context, but the exact original inscription and transfer documentation have not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFHIST_JOHN_S_MCNEW_MISSOURI_RECORD_TRAIL_1840_1870",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_household",
      "value": "Reported to have acquired land in Rives (later Henry) County in 1840 and to appear in Henry County censuses in 1850, 1860, and 1870",
      "start_date": "1840",
      "end_date": "1870",
      "place": "Rives and Henry counties, Missouri, United States",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "These published reconstructions cite the underlying land and census records, but the original entries were not available for direct review in this pass. The claim is useful context for the established Deepwater identity and not proof of his earlier parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_JOHN_S_MCNEW_PARENTAGE_LIMITATION",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "fact_type": "parent_identity_evidence",
      "value": "Nathan McNew's genealogy proposes John McNew and Sarah Athey as the parents of John S. McNew",
      "start_date": "1806",
      "end_date": "1806",
      "place": null,
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cited adult records support John S. McNew's later Missouri identity, but none reviewed here names John McNew or Sarah Athey as his parents. Both parent links remain visible as circumstantial claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_JOHN_S_MCNEW_BIRTH_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "fact_type": "birth_date_conflict",
      "value": "Reported birth is 15 November 1806, but sources disagree between North Carolina and Claiborne County, Tennessee; the cemetery age also implies about 1805",
      "start_date": "about 1805",
      "end_date": "15 Nov 1806",
      "place": "North Carolina or Claiborne County, Tennessee, United States",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reported 15 November date is retained as the best current claim, but neither location nor year is treated as settled. A birth, Bible, pension, or early census record is needed to resolve the discrepancy."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_SARAH_A_WILLOUGHBY_REPORTED_VITALS",
      "person_id": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "fact_type": "reported_vital_claim",
      "value": "Reported as Sarah A. Willoughby, born 10 March 1812 in Kentucky and died 15 October 1862 in Henry County, Missouri",
      "start_date": "10 Mar 1812",
      "end_date": "15 Oct 1862",
      "place": "Kentucky and Henry County, Missouri, United States",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876"
      ],
      "source_note": "The dates and Willoughby surname are not yet confirmed from the original marriage, cemetery marker, birth, or death record. They are more compatible with the adult family evidence than the uncorroborated Lusby surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_SARAH_WILLOUGHBY_LUSBY_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "The wife of John S. McNew is called Sarah Lusby in one genealogy and Sarah A. Willoughby in two compatible reconstructions",
      "start_date": "1839",
      "end_date": "1862",
      "place": "Pettis and Henry counties, Missouri, United States",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.83,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876"
      ],
      "source_note": "Willoughby is presently preferred because the cemetery transcription and Cook reconstruction agree on the same marriage and death framework. Lusby remains visible as an alternative until the original 8 November 1839 marriage record is reviewed."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I139_SAMPSON_BAPTISM_1800_ORIGINAL",
      "person_id": "I139",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Born 30 June 1799 and christened 4 November 1800 as Sampson Handley, son of Richard and Ruth Read",
      "start_date": "30 Jun 1799",
      "end_date": "4 Nov 1800",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.998,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1800_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original register spells the family surname Read. Later records commonly use Rhead; the profile retains that later spelling while preserving the original form in the evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I139_SAMPSON_FARMER_1861_ORIGINAL",
      "person_id": "I139",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer of 48 acres",
      "start_date": "1861",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Bucknall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The census records this occupation at one point in his life. It does not establish ownership of the 48 acres or a career-long occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_CFS_SAMPSON_SARAH_HOUSEHOLD_1841_ORIGINAL",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_household",
      "value": "Recorded with Sarah Rhead and children Richard, Stephen, George, and Ruth",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG"
      ],
      "source_note": "The image is primary household evidence. The 1841 form does not record relationship-to-head, so the child links are high-confidence household inferences rather than literal census labels."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_RHEAD_TWO_SAMPSONS_REASSESSMENT_1841_1861",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Original 1841 Sampson-and-Sarah and original 1851/1861 Sampson-and-Julia households establish two documented family patterns; whether their same-name fathers were one person or connected men remains unresolved",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1861",
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG"
      ],
      "source_note": "The primary images establish the Sarah household in 1841 and the Julia household in 1851 and 1861. The 1813 Wood Farm interest and the 1833 Woodfarm abode make the two men's connection more likely than two unrelated coincidences. One-man and two-connected-men explanations remain open. The one-man explanation requires an undocumented overlapping 1832 marriage or separation; the two-men explanation requires an unproven kinship, tenancy, or estate connection. No original 1832 marital-status wording, divorce/separation record, or Wood Farm tenancy record has yet discriminated between them."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_STEPHEN_RHEAD_HOUSEHOLD_1841",
      "person_id": "C_RHEAD_STEPHEN_HENRY_1836",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_household",
      "value": "Recorded as a six-year-old Rhead in the Sampson and Sarah Rhead household",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG"
      ],
      "source_note": "The source does not supply a middle name or a later-life identity. The reported 1890 death remains derivative."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_GEORGE_RHEAD_HOUSEHOLD_1841",
      "person_id": "SRC_GEORGE_RHEAD_SHROPSHIRE_1837",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_household",
      "value": "Recorded as a four-year-old Rhead in the Sampson and Sarah Rhead household",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This George belongs to the Sampson-and-Sarah household and is not the George recorded with Sampson and Julia in Bucknall."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_RUTH_RHEAD_1841_COLLATERAL_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1841",
      "end_date": "1841",
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG"
      ],
      "source_note": "The census evidence is preserved for future collateral research. It is not used to create a new displayed profile while the current work is limited to the main connected tree."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_PERRY_FAMILY",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
      "fact_type": "family_record",
      "value": "Recorded as \"Betty McNew,\" mother of Elisha Perry",
      "start_date": "1818",
      "end_date": "1818",
      "place": "Brown County, Illinois, United States",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEALOGYTRAILS_PERRY_CEMETERY_ELISHA_1818_1889",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1798_LUKE_PERRY",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_MCNEW_SARAH_ATHEY_F14178"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cemetery transcription does not give Betty's maiden surname. Nathan McNew and Cook independently identify her as Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_REPORTED_LIFE",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
      "fact_type": "reported_vital_claim",
      "value": "Reported born in 1798 in Washington County, Virginia, and dead about 1844 or before 1847 in Brown County, Illinois",
      "start_date": "1798",
      "end_date": "before 1847",
      "place": "Virginia and Illinois, United States",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1798_LUKE_PERRY",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_MCNEW_SARAH_ATHEY_F14178"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sources agree on the broad life framework but not the death year: Cook says about 1844; Nathan McNew says before 1847. These dates and locations remain reported rather than proven."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_CLAIBORNE_1814",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported 1814 marriage was in a recently formed East Tennessee county shaped by the Cumberland Gap and the Powell Valley settlement corridor",
      "start_date": "1814",
      "end_date": "1814",
      "place": "Claiborne County, Tennessee, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1798_LUKE_PERRY",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_MCNEW_SARAH_ATHEY_F14178",
        "SRC_TENNESSEE_ENCYCLOPEDIA_CLAIBORNE_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This gives geographic context for the reported marriage location; it does not establish an exact residence, migration route, or socioeconomic status."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_BROWN_COUNTY_ILLINOIS",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her reported final locality, Brown County, was created from Schuyler County in 1839; Elkhorn was one of its townships",
      "start_date": "1839",
      "end_date": "before 1847",
      "place": "Brown County, Illinois, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1798_LUKE_PERRY",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_MCNEW_SARAH_ATHEY_F14178",
        "SRC_ILSOS_BROWN_COUNTY_HISTORY_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The source explains the county framework and record setting. It does not prove that Elizabeth lived continuously in Brown County."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_WHITE_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "One public tree calls Luke Perry's wife Elizabeth White; two compatible family reconstructions and a cemetery transcription instead support Betty McNew",
      "start_date": "1814",
      "end_date": "1889",
      "place": "Tennessee and Illinois, United States",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_LUKE_PERRY_ELIZABETH_WHITE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1798_LUKE_PERRY",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_MCNEW_SARAH_ATHEY_F14178",
        "SRC_GENEALOGYTRAILS_PERRY_CEMETERY_ELISHA_1818_1889"
      ],
      "source_note": "The accessible Ancestry view has no original citation for White. The McNew conclusion is stronger but still awaits the original marriage, census, probate, or marker image."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_COLLATERAL_FAMILY_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "The Luke Perry and Elisha Perry evidence is retained to assess Elizabeth's identity, but no new spouse or descendant profile is added during the current non-collateral pass",
      "start_date": "1814",
      "end_date": "1889",
      "place": "Tennessee and Illinois, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1798_LUKE_PERRY",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_MCNEW_SARAH_ATHEY_F14178",
        "SRC_GENEALOGYTRAILS_PERRY_CEMETERY_ELISHA_1818_1889"
      ],
      "source_note": "The documented family material remains available for a future collateral-relative pass. This current audit strengthens Elizabeth's existing profile and parent-link assessment without expanding the normal web tree."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I141_WIDOWER_FARMER_LICENSE_1793",
      "person_id": "I141",
      "fact_type": "marriage_licence",
      "value": "A farmer and widower of Trentham when he sought a licence to marry Ruth Handley",
      "start_date": "7 Jan 1793",
      "end_date": "7 Jan 1793",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_LICENSE_IMAGE_1793_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "The allegation was sworn on 7 January; the parish marriage was recorded on 26 January. “Widower” is Richard's own stated status in the original licence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_I141_BETTY_FIRST_MARRIAGE_RECONCILIATION_1780_1793",
      "person_id": "I141",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1780",
      "end_date": "1793",
      "place": "Sandon and Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_LICENSE_IMAGE_1793_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "The matching Trentham residence and the 1793 widower declaration make the first-marriage identification highly likely. The records do not say when Betty died or prove that she was mother of every older child named in Richard's will."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFBIO_I141_WILL_NAMED_CHILDREN_1813",
      "person_id": "I141",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "His 1813 will names children Mary, William, Richard, Thomas, Sampson, Ruth, and Elizabeth; Sampson is described as the youngest son",
      "start_date": "1813",
      "end_date": "1813",
      "place": "Trentham parish, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1813_WILL_PAGE4_IMAGE_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "The will names an older child generation before Sampson. It does not give their ages, mothers, residences, spouses, or descendants. The named Richard is a son and is distinct from the separately named trustee Richard Rhead of Knutton, schoolmaster."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_RHEAD_SAMPSON_IDENTITY_ALTERNATIVES_20260726",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "fact_type": "identity_assessment",
      "value": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "start_date": "1819",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": "Staffordshire and Shropshire, England",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1800_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1813_WILL_PAGE4_IMAGE_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1800 baptism and 1819/1851/1861 Julia evidence establish Sampson Handley's documented family. The 1832/1833/1841 evidence establishes a Sampson-and-Sarah family. Assuming the 1813 Wood Farm and 1833 Woodfarm were the same property, the remaining alternatives are one man with an undocumented overlapping marriage or two property/kin-connected men. The strongest connected-family version of the latter is that the Sarah-family Sampson was son of an as-yet-unidentified brother of Richard Rhead, making the two same-age Sampsons first cousins. Richard's undivided one-third Wood Farm interest is suggestive of earlier joint ownership among relatives, but it could also reflect purchase or marriage and does not prove that model. A son of Richard's named older sons William, Richard, or Thomas is a further, less generation-compatible possibility; no baptism or estate record currently names either proposed father. The direct parent statement to Richard Frederick remains strong whichever alternative is ultimately correct."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFHIST_JAKOB_NEUMOND_KAISERSLAUTERN_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_1837",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family is documented at Kaiserslautern in 1837, when its Jewish community was growing: published local history records 52 Jewish residents in 1823, 108 in 1834, and 214 in 1848, with a district rabbinate and a Jewish elementary school established during this period.",
      "start_date": "1823",
      "end_date": "1848",
      "place": "Kaiserslautern, Kingdom of Bavaria (present-day Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany)",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_KAISERSLAUTERN_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_19C",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND"
      ],
      "source_note": "Isidor Neumond's 1837 Kaiserslautern birth and the two sources naming Jakob and Clara as his parents establish the family connection to this setting. The community history does not identify Jakob's address, synagogue membership, education, occupation, or personal participation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFHIST_CLARA_CAHN_KAISERSLAUTERN_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_1837",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The family is documented at Kaiserslautern in 1837, when its Jewish community was growing: published local history records 52 Jewish residents in 1823, 108 in 1834, and 214 in 1848, with a district rabbinate and a Jewish elementary school established during this period.",
      "start_date": "1823",
      "end_date": "1848",
      "place": "Kaiserslautern, Kingdom of Bavaria (present-day Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany)",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_KAISERSLAUTERN_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_19C",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND"
      ],
      "source_note": "Isidor Neumond's 1837 Kaiserslautern birth and the two sources naming Jakob and Clara as his parents establish the family connection to this setting. The community history does not identify Clara's address, synagogue membership, education, occupation, or personal participation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_JAKOB_NEUMOND_REPORTED_VITALS_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "The reported 1803 Kaiserslautern birth and 1869 Mehlingen death have not been verified in a civil, synagogue, burial, or other original record.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Kaiserslautern district, Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Louisiana biography and Palatinate migration database directly name Jakob as Isidor's father, but neither was used as an original vital record for Jakob. The dates and the Mehlingen death place remain useful, low-certainty leads rather than confirmed biographical facts."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_CLARA_CAHN_REPORTED_VITALS_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "The reported 8 June 1803 Mainz birth has not been verified in a civil, synagogue, burial, or other original record; no death or migration record has been identified.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Mainz and Kaiserslautern district, Germany",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Louisiana biography and Palatinate migration database directly name Clara as Isidor's mother, but neither was used as an original vital record for Clara. The reported Mainz date and place remain useful, low-certainty leads rather than confirmed biographical facts."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771",
      "person_id": "I186",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized as the son of Charles and Catherine Hnney",
      "start_date": "03 Mar 1771",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Winsley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Winsley parish transcript records William Hnney baptized 3 March 1771, son of Charles Hnney and Cteren Hnney; the parent spellings are compatible with Charles Hanney and Catherine Waine."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFHIST_WILLIAM_HANNY_14TH_FOOT_DEFENCE_1803",
      "person_id": "I186",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The 14th Foot had served in the West Indies, including Trinidad, before returning to England in April 1803. Cannon's regimental history places the battalion at Gosport, Winchester, Silver Hill Barracks, and Winchelsea during the 1803 French invasion scare. A second battalion was added in 1804.",
      "start_date": "25 Oct 1803",
      "end_date": "16 Apr 1804",
      "place": "Southern England (14th Foot regimental context)",
      "status": "source_based_context",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_14TH_FOOT_SERVICE_1803",
        "SRC_HANNY_CHELSEA_PENSION_1804",
        "SRC_TNA_BRITISH_ARMY_SOLDIERS_CHELSEA_GUIDE",
        "SRC_CANNON_14TH_FOOT_1803_DEFENCE_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "William Hanny's 25 October 1803 service entry and 1804 Chelsea pension record identify his battalion. Richard Cannon, Historical Record of the Fourteenth Regiment of Foot (1845), records the unit's Trinidad and West Indies service, April 1803 return to England, and subsequent Gosport, Winchester, Silver Hill, and Winchelsea stations: https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/54107/pg54107-images.html"
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_B68_DAVID_MOSES_INGENHEIM_COMMUNITY",
      "person_id": "B68_DAVID_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Ingenheim was home to an established Jewish community from the seventeenth century, with a cemetery in use by that period; it grew substantially during the eighteenth century.",
      "start_date": "17th century",
      "end_date": "18th century",
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the reported place and period associated with David through his daughter Rosina. It does not establish David's exact residence, occupation, communal role, or personal life dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_INGENHEIM_COMMUNITY",
      "person_id": "B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Ingenheim was home to an established Jewish community from the seventeenth century, with a cemetery in use by that period; it grew substantially during the eighteenth century.",
      "start_date": "17th century",
      "end_date": "18th century",
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the reported place and period associated with Esther through her daughter Rosina. It does not establish Esther's exact residence, occupation, communal role, or personal life dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_B68_JEHUDA_LOEB_DREYFUSS_COMMUNITY",
      "person_id": "B68_JEHUDA_LOEB_DREYFUSS",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Ingenheim was home to an established Jewish community from the seventeenth century, with a cemetery in use by that period; it grew substantially during the eighteenth century.",
      "start_date": "17th century",
      "end_date": "18th century",
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This describes the reported place and period associated with Jehuda through his son Isaak Hirsch. It does not establish Jehuda's exact residence, occupation, communal role, or personal life dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_NORTH_BRADLEY_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_1701",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_NORTH_BRADLEY_FATHER_BETTY",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "North Bradley lay in the Wiltshire Biss valley, where household hand-loom weaving and agriculture were both important parts of the local economy.",
      "start_date": "1701",
      "end_date": "1764",
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1701"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is context for the candidate's recorded parish, not evidence that he was a weaver, farmer, resident throughout the period, or Betty Willis's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_NORTH_BRADLEY_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_1679",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_SR_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "North Bradley lay in the Wiltshire Biss valley, where household hand-loom weaving and agriculture were both important parts of the local economy.",
      "start_date": "1679",
      "end_date": "1703",
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is community context for Benjamin's recorded baptism and burial parish. It does not establish an occupation, residence, property, or social rank."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_NORTH_BRADLEY_KATHERINE_WILLIS_1679",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_KATHERINE_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "North Bradley lay in the Wiltshire Biss valley, where household hand-loom weaving and agriculture were both important parts of the local economy.",
      "start_date": "1679",
      "end_date": "1700",
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is community context for the parish record naming Katherine. It does not identify her maiden name, occupation, residence, property, or social rank."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_NORTH_BRADLEY_WILLIAM_WILLIS_1679",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_WILLIAM_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "North Bradley lay in the Wiltshire Biss valley, where household hand-loom weaving and agriculture were both important parts of the local economy.",
      "start_date": "1670",
      "end_date": "1700",
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is community context for the parish record naming William. It does not establish an occupation, residence, property, or social rank."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "person_id": "C_MARSHALL_JOHN_PONTEFRACT_1772",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "His recorded 1772 marriage took place in Pontefract's Market Place parish. St Giles, a long-standing Market Place church, became the town's parish church in 1789 after the earlier parish church had been destroyed in the Civil War sieges.",
      "start_date": "1772",
      "end_date": "1789",
      "place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_ST_GILES_PONTEFRACT_HISTORY_20260726"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage index anchors John in the parish; the parish history explains the place. Neither source establishes his address, occupation, property, or religious practice beyond the recorded marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_PONTEFRACT_ANN_ALLEN_1772",
      "person_id": "C_ALLEN_ANN_WIFE_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Her recorded 1772 marriage took place in Pontefract's Market Place parish. St Giles, a long-standing Market Place church, became the town's parish church in 1789 after the earlier parish church had been destroyed in the Civil War sieges.",
      "start_date": "1772",
      "end_date": "1789",
      "place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_ST_GILES_PONTEFRACT_HISTORY_20260726"
      ],
      "source_note": "The marriage index anchors Ann in the parish; the parish history explains the place. Neither source establishes her address, occupation, property, or religious practice beyond the recorded marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I9",
      "person_id": "I9",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 6 Feb 1916 in Virginia, United States. Died 30 Jun 1982 in Winston-Salem, Forsyth County, North Carolina, United States.",
      "start_date": "6 Feb 1916",
      "end_date": "30 Jun 1982",
      "place": "Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_HENDERSON_1930_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1982",
        "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_MEMORIAL",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I10",
      "person_id": "I10",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 11 Nov 1915 in East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States. Died 13 Dec 1973 in Winston-Salem, Forsyth County, North Carolina, United States.",
      "start_date": "11 Nov 1915",
      "end_date": "13 Dec 1973",
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NJ_BIRTH_1915",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1973",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1973_DEATH_BURIAL",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1950_CENSUS_OCCUPATION",
        "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_LA_MARQUE_RESIDENCE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I13",
      "person_id": "I13",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 17 Apr 1894 in Washington County, Virginia, United States. Died 19 Jan 1974 in Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia, United States.",
      "start_date": "17 Apr 1894",
      "end_date": "19 Jan 1974",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_SALLY_JANE_HENDERSON_1974",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I14",
      "person_id": "I14",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 17 Mar 1885 in Washington County, Virginia, United States. Died 8 Mar 1964 in Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia, United States.",
      "start_date": "17 Mar 1885",
      "end_date": "8 Mar 1964",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1885_1964",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1964",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I27",
      "person_id": "I27",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 28 Mar 1881 in East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States. Died 22 Mar 1942 in Newark, Essex County, New Jersey, United States.",
      "start_date": "28 Mar 1881",
      "end_date": "22 Mar 1942",
      "place": "East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PRESBYTERIAN_JOHANN_GEORG_FRICKE_BAPTISM_1881",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_1920_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_1930_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_BURIAL",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1924",
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1929"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I28",
      "person_id": "I28",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 14 May 1891 in County Monaghan, Ireland. Died 8 Mar 1960 in Hackensack, Bergen County, New Jersey, USA.",
      "start_date": "14 May 1891",
      "end_date": "8 Mar 1960",
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_NY_PASSENGER_JOHN_GILSON_FLORENCE_GIBSON",
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_NC_DEATH_CERT_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NAMES_FLORENCE",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1891_1960",
        "SRC_NEWSPAPERS_OBITUARY_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1960",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I29",
      "person_id": "I29",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1919. Died 1944.",
      "start_date": "1919",
      "end_date": "1944",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I41",
      "person_id": "I41",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 18 Apr 1910 in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England. Died 30 May 1990 in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "18 Apr 1910",
      "end_date": "30 May 1990",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ALFREDA_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_BIRTH_1910",
        "SRC_ALFREDA_RHEAD_PROBATE_DEATH_1990",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I42",
      "person_id": "I42",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1 Jan 1909 in Wellington, Shropshire, England. Died 16 May 1975.",
      "start_date": "1 Jan 1909",
      "end_date": "16 May 1975",
      "place": "Wellington, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I44",
      "person_id": "I44",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1882 in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1882",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEBMD_KEZIA_THOMAS_BIRTH_Q3_1882",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_DAVIES_KEZIA_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_1907",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I45",
      "person_id": "I45",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 16 Oct 1883 in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England. Died 24 Dec 1943 in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "16 Oct 1883",
      "end_date": "24 Dec 1943",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_1883_1943",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BIRTH_1883",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_DAVIES_KEZIA_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_1907",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BAPTISM_1883",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_PROBATE_1944",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_WW1_NAMESAKE_EXCLUSION"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I49",
      "person_id": "I49",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 6 Apr 1875 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 2 Mar 1968 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "6 Apr 1875",
      "end_date": "2 Mar 1968",
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_MORRALL_FAMILYSEARCH_9WWH_TDG",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_MORRALL_1899_WOLVERHAMPTON_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CIVIL_BIRTH_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_DEATH_1968",
        "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_PROBATE_1968",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I50",
      "person_id": "I50",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born Jan-Mar 1869 in Birmingham, Warwickshire, England. Died 1 Nov 1934 in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "Jan-Mar 1869",
      "end_date": "1 Nov 1934",
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BERNAL_B_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_MORRALL_1899_WOLVERHAMPTON_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_BRIGHT_RHEAD_1868_1934",
        "SRC_BERNAL_BRIGHT_RHEAD_CIVIL_BIRTH_Q1_1869",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I51",
      "person_id": "I51",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1 Jul 1851 in Washington County, Virginia, United States. Died 22 Jun 1930 in Washington County, Virginia, United States.",
      "start_date": "1 Jul 1851",
      "end_date": "22 Jun 1930",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I52",
      "person_id": "I52",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born Aug 1857 in Washington County, Virginia, United States. Died about 1920 in Washington County, Virginia, United States.",
      "start_date": "Aug 1857",
      "end_date": "about 1920",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I53",
      "person_id": "I53",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 15 Apr 1870 in Virginia, USA. Died 8 May 1938 in Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "15 Apr 1870",
      "end_date": "8 May 1938",
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I54",
      "person_id": "I54",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 24 Feb 1874 in Greendale, Washington County, Virginia, United States. Died 2 Dec 1954 in Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia, United States.",
      "start_date": "24 Feb 1874",
      "end_date": "2 Dec 1954",
      "place": "Greendale, Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_LEANAH_E_WHITE_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TINEY_SHORT_DEATH_1954",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I55",
      "person_id": "I55",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1842 in Washington County, Virginia, USA. Died May 1926 in Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1842",
      "end_date": "May 1926",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I56",
      "person_id": "I56",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 23 Mar 1842 in Washington County, Virginia, US. Died 5 Jun 1927 in Prestonsburg, Floyd County, Kentucky, USA.",
      "start_date": "23 Mar 1842",
      "end_date": "5 Jun 1927",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, US",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I57",
      "person_id": "I57",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 18 Nov 1815 in Botetourt County, Virginia, USA. Died 21 May 1864 in Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "18 Nov 1815",
      "end_date": "21 May 1864",
      "place": "Botetourt County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WASHINGTON_WHITE_LYON_CEMETERY_1864",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_REJECTED_NAMESAKE_HINTS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I58",
      "person_id": "I58",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1816 in Washington County, Virginia, USA. Died 8 Oct 1892 in North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1816",
      "end_date": "8 Oct 1892",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_A_STOUT_1880_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_NORTH_FORK_DEATH_1892",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_ILLINOIS_PENSION_REJECTED",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BENJAMIN_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I60",
      "person_id": "I60",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1790 in probably Franklin County, Virginia, USA. Died 3 Jan 1877 in reportedly Honey Grove, Fannin County, Texas, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1790",
      "end_date": "3 Jan 1877",
      "place": "probably Franklin County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_BOTETOURT_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_W_WHITE_1840_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_HONEY_GROVE_MEMORIAL_1877",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SABINE_TEXAS_TAX_1836_REJECTED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I61",
      "person_id": "I61",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1797 in probably Franklin County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1797",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "probably Franklin County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_HONEY_GROVE_MEMORIAL_1877",
        "SRC_FRANCES_WHITE_TEXAS_1836_MEMORIAL_REJECTED",
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I62",
      "person_id": "I62",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1760 in reportedly Augusta County, Virginia, USA. Died August 1825 in Sullivan County, Tennessee, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1760",
      "end_date": "August 1825",
      "place": "reportedly Augusta County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1810_WYTHE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_EVENSHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_UNRESOLVED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_LATER_MILITARY_HINTS_REJECTED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_TURNER_WHITE_FAMILIES_CHICKASAW_BEN_2001",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I63",
      "person_id": "I63",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1767 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1767",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I65",
      "person_id": "I65",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reportedly about 1770 in reported Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "reportedly about 1770",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I68",
      "person_id": "I68",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1739 in reported Norfolk, Virginia, British America. Died reportedly 1786 in reported Franklin County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1739",
      "end_date": "reportedly 1786",
      "place": "reported Norfolk, Virginia, British America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_AGBI_VIRGINIA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_SUKEY_WHITE_BOND_SURETY_1786",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I70",
      "person_id": "I70",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1822-1824 in Virginia, USA (Washington/Smyth County area). Died 1880 in Saltville, Virginia, USA (Washington/Smyth County area).",
      "start_date": "about 1822-1824",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Virginia, USA (Washington/Smyth County area)",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROBERT_HENDERSON_1824_1880",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I71",
      "person_id": "I71",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1828 in Washington County, Virginia, United States. Died Apr 1880 in Saltville, Smyth County, Virginia, United States.",
      "start_date": "1828",
      "end_date": "Apr 1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I74",
      "person_id": "I74",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported about 1704 in Norfolk County, Virginia. Died May 1782 in Norfolk County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1704",
      "end_date": "May 1782",
      "place": "Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I75",
      "person_id": "I75",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported before 1685 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia. Died late Jan 1730/31 in Norfolk County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": "reported before 1685",
      "end_date": "late Jan 1730/31",
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I76",
      "person_id": "I76",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 18 Jul 1846 in Kingdom of Hanover (present-day Germany). Died 8 Apr 1918 in East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States.",
      "start_date": "18 Jul 1846",
      "end_date": "8 Apr 1918",
      "place": "Kingdom of Hanover (present-day Germany)",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENRY_ALBERT_FRICKE_FINDAGRAVE_1846_1918",
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_HENRIETTE_MUELLER_FRICKE_CONFLATION",
        "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_HENRY_FRICKE_MILKMAN_1892"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I77",
      "person_id": "I77",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 20 or 29 Mar 1848 in Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany. Died 1913 in East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey, United States.",
      "start_date": "20 or 29 Mar 1848",
      "end_date": "1913",
      "place": "Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_FS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023",
        "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_HESSEN_ARCHIVES_EMIGRANT_GUIDE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I81",
      "person_id": "I81",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 17 Nov 1824 in Russell County, Virginia, US. Died 6 Feb 1899 in Houston, Texas County, Missouri, USA.",
      "start_date": "17 Nov 1824",
      "end_date": "6 Feb 1899",
      "place": "Russell County, Virginia, US",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE",
        "SRC_PROFILE_SARAH_SALLY_PHELPS_GOBBLE_1825_1899",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I82",
      "person_id": "I82",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 01 Nov 1818 in Washington County, Virginia, US. Died 8 Sep 1899 in Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "01 Nov 1818",
      "end_date": "8 Sep 1899",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, US",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_G_GOBBLE_1818_1899",
        "SRC_GOBBLE_FAMILY_DATA_JOHN_1818_1899",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I83",
      "person_id": "I83",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 24 Apr 1794 in Maryland, USA. Died reportedly 17 Sep 1854 in reportedly Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "24 Apr 1794",
      "end_date": "reportedly 17 Sep 1854",
      "place": "Maryland, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I84",
      "person_id": "I84",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 12 Apr 1792 in Washington County, Virginia, US.",
      "start_date": "12 Apr 1792",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, US",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I85",
      "person_id": "I85",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported 1774 in reported Washington County, Virginia, USA. Died reportedly 1876.",
      "start_date": "reported 1774",
      "end_date": "reportedly 1876",
      "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_INTL_MARRIAGE_1789",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I86",
      "person_id": "I86",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reportedly 10 Feb 1766 in reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA. Died reportedly 15 Jul 1846 in reported Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "reportedly 10 Feb 1766",
      "end_date": "reportedly 15 Jul 1846",
      "place": "reported Baltimore, Maryland, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I100",
      "person_id": "I100",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 01 Apr 1846 in Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England.",
      "start_date": "01 Apr 1846",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEBMD_MARIA_HANNEY_BIRTH_Q2_1846",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNY_1861_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_FREDERICK_DAVIES_MARIA_HANNY_MARRIAGE_Q3_1879",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I101",
      "person_id": "I101",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 27 Feb 1845 in Garthmyl, Powys, Wales, GB. Died Jan-Mar 1926 in Atcham registration district, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "27 Feb 1845",
      "end_date": "Jan-Mar 1926",
      "place": "Garthmyl, Powys, Wales, GB",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1845",
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_DEATH_Q1_1926",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I102",
      "person_id": "I102",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1889.",
      "start_date": "about 1889",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I107",
      "person_id": "I107",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 12 Oct 1734 in Offenbach, Darmstadt, Hessen, DE.",
      "start_date": "12 Oct 1734",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Offenbach, Darmstadt, Hessen, DE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I109",
      "person_id": "I109",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1701 in Offenbach, Darmstadt, Hessen, DE.",
      "start_date": "1701",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Offenbach, Darmstadt, Hessen, DE",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I122",
      "person_id": "I122",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 8 Aug 1801 in Washington County, Virginia, United States. Died 1880 in Washington County, Virginia, United States.",
      "start_date": "8 Aug 1801",
      "end_date": "1880",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I124",
      "person_id": "I124",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 17 Nov 1763 in Frederick County, Virginia, British Colonial America. Died 5 Mar 1846 in Washington County, Virginia, United States.",
      "start_date": "17 Nov 1763",
      "end_date": "5 Mar 1846",
      "place": "Frederick County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1810_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1840_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I125",
      "person_id": "I125",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 14 Aug 1715 in Saint Johns Parish, Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America. Died Dec 1791 in Washington County, Virginia, United States.",
      "start_date": "14 Aug 1715",
      "end_date": "Dec 1791",
      "place": "Saint Johns Parish, Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_1715_1791",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_MACKNEW_MARYLAND_BIRTH_1715",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I127",
      "person_id": "I127",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born after 1674 in Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America. Died 1715/1716 in Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America.",
      "start_date": "after 1674",
      "end_date": "1715/1716",
      "place": "Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I128",
      "person_id": "I128",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1685 in Maryland, British Colonial America. Died early 1728 in Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America.",
      "start_date": "about 1685",
      "end_date": "early 1728",
      "place": "Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I129",
      "person_id": "I129",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported about 1640 in reported Scotland (unproved). Died reported 24 Apr 1720 in Prince George's County, Maryland.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1640",
      "end_date": "reported 24 Apr 1720",
      "place": "reported Scotland (unproved)",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JEREMIAH_H_MACKNEW_1640_1720",
        "SRC_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1668_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_JEREMIAH_MACKMERE_PHILISE_MARRIAGE_1670",
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I130",
      "person_id": "I130",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1640-1645. Died reported 1700 in Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America.",
      "start_date": "about 1640-1645",
      "end_date": "reported 1700",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_JEREMIAH_MACKMERE_PHILISE_MARRIAGE_1670",
        "SRC_GENEANET_PHILLIS_W_OJEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_1674_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
        "SRC_NEW_EARLY_SETTLERS_MARYLAND_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH",
        "SRC_PROFILE_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JEREMIAH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_PHILLIS_PARENTAGE_UNKNOWN",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I78",
      "person_id": "I78",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1869 in New Jersey, United States.",
      "start_date": "about 1869",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_ELIZABETH_1890_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I79",
      "person_id": "I79",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1874 in New Jersey, United States.",
      "start_date": "about 1874",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I80",
      "person_id": "I80",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1877/1878 in New Jersey, United States.",
      "start_date": "about 1877/1878",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1920_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I137",
      "person_id": "I137",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 6 Feb 1833 in Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England. Died 2 Oct 1900 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "6 Feb 1833",
      "end_date": "2 Oct 1900",
      "place": "Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1841_STOKE_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1861_HEYWOOD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_DEATH_AND_BURIAL_1900",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I138",
      "person_id": "I138",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 14 Jun 1835 in Hanford, Staffordshire, England. Died 14 Apr 1904 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "baptised 14 Jun 1835",
      "end_date": "14 Apr 1904",
      "place": "Hanford, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1900_WOLVERHAMPTON_DIRECTORIES",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1901_HEATH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_DEATH_1904",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELLEN_HELEN_WATERHOUSE_1835_1904",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I139",
      "person_id": "I139",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 30 Jun 1799 in Wolstanton, Staffordshire, England. Died 12 Nov 1865 in Bucknall, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "30 Jun 1799",
      "end_date": "12 Nov 1865",
      "place": "Wolstanton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_QPSM_68WK",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1800_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1813_WILL_PAGE4_IMAGE_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I140",
      "person_id": "I140",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1 May 1811 in Ludlow, Shropshire, England. Died Oct-Dec 1879 in Stone registration district, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "1 May 1811",
      "end_date": "Oct-Dec 1879",
      "place": "Ludlow, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_DEATH_1879_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_SARAH_BOULTON_DEATH_Q4_1879",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I141",
      "person_id": "I141",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 30 Oct 1753 in Stoke, Staffordshire, England. Died April 1813 in Trentham, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "baptised 30 Oct 1753",
      "end_date": "April 1813",
      "place": "Stoke, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_MARRIAGE_1793",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_QPSM_68WK",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_TRENTHAM_PROBATE_BURIAL_1813",
        "SRC_RD_RHEAD_1798_HANCHURCH_LAND_TAX",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1813_WILL_PAGE4_IMAGE_USER_PDF",
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_LICENSE_IMAGE_1793_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I142",
      "person_id": "I142",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 03 Jan 1759 in Milwich, Staffordshire, England, GB.",
      "start_date": "03 Jan 1759",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England, GB",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_MARRIAGE_1793",
        "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I143",
      "person_id": "I143",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1841 in Horsehay, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1841",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Horsehay, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_RICHARD_MORRALL_1842_1892",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I144",
      "person_id": "I144",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 18 Jan 1840 in Church Lane, Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England. Died 18 Jan 1915 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "18 Jan 1840",
      "end_date": "18 Jan 1915",
      "place": "Church Lane, Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_BRASSINGTON_BIRTH_1840",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1915",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I145",
      "person_id": "I145",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 7 Apr 1802 in Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England. Died Jan-Mar 1863 in Birmingham, Warwickshire, England.",
      "start_date": "7 Apr 1802",
      "end_date": "Jan-Mar 1863",
      "place": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_BIRMINGHAM_DEATH_Q1_1863",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I146",
      "person_id": "I146",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1803 in Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "1803",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_TRENTHAM_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I151",
      "person_id": "I151",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 15 Apr 1787 in Ranton, Staffordshire, England. Died April 1860 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "baptised 15 Apr 1787",
      "end_date": "April 1860",
      "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_1860",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_BAPTISMS_OCCUPATIONS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I152",
      "person_id": "I152",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 14 Feb 1808 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England. Died January 1874 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "baptised 14 Feb 1808",
      "end_date": "January 1874",
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_ESTHER_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_1874_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I155",
      "person_id": "I155",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 30 Jan 1783 in Forton, Staffordshire, England. Died 26 Aug 1862 in Forton, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "baptised 30 Jan 1783",
      "end_date": "26 Aug 1862",
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_1783_1862",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_BURIAL_PROBATE_1862_1863",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I156",
      "person_id": "I156",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1787. Died 1866.",
      "start_date": "about 1787",
      "end_date": "1866",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I160",
      "person_id": "I160",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 16 Apr 1759 in Newport, Shropshire, England. Died reportedly May 1833 in reportedly Bridgnorth, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "baptised 16 Apr 1759",
      "end_date": "reportedly May 1833",
      "place": "Newport, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RICHARD_POYNER_NEWPORT_BAPTISM_1759",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I161",
      "person_id": "I161",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 11 Aug 1758 in Cleobury Mortimer, Shropshire, England. Died reportedly March 1835 in reportedly Bridgnorth, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "baptised 11 Aug 1758",
      "end_date": "reportedly March 1835",
      "place": "Cleobury Mortimer, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I182",
      "person_id": "I182",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 18 Jan 1802 in Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England. Died before 29 Sep 1894 in Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England.",
      "start_date": "18 Jan 1802",
      "end_date": "before 29 Sep 1894",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_GRO_HANNY_CORNISH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNY_1861_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_1802_1894",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_WILTSHIRE_BURIAL_1894",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_AVON_METHODIST_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I183",
      "person_id": "I183",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1802-1805 in Hilperton or Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England. Died before 25 Feb 1854 in Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1802-1805",
      "end_date": "before 25 Feb 1854",
      "place": "Hilperton or Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRO_HANNY_CORNISH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_1802_1856",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_HANNEY_WILTSHIRE_BURIAL_1854",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I186",
      "person_id": "I186",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported 02 Feb 1771 (baptized 03 Mar 1771) in reported Conkwell, Wiltshire, England. Died reported 07 Mar 1837 in reported Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England.",
      "start_date": "reported 02 Feb 1771 (baptized 03 Mar 1771)",
      "end_date": "reported 07 Mar 1837",
      "place": "reported Conkwell, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_HANNY_1771_1837",
        "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795",
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_HANNY_CHELSEA_PENSION_1804",
        "SRC_HANNY_14TH_FOOT_SERVICE_1803",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771",
        "SRC_TNA_BRITISH_ARMY_SOLDIERS_CHELSEA_GUIDE",
        "SRC_CANNON_14TH_FOOT_1803_DEFENCE_CONTEXT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I187",
      "person_id": "I187",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 2 Jun 1765 in Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England.",
      "start_date": "2 Jun 1765",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_PETERS_1765_1847",
        "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795",
        "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
        "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_SELECT_BIRTHS",
        "SRC_GRO_ELIZABETH_PETERS_DEATH_1847_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_ELIZABETH_HANNY_DEATH_Q2_1838_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I190",
      "person_id": "I190",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 09 Nov 1734 in Freshford, Bath and North East Somerset, England, GB. Died 27 Jan 1814 in Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England, GB.",
      "start_date": "09 Nov 1734",
      "end_date": "27 Jan 1814",
      "place": "Freshford, Bath and North East Somerset, England, GB",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ISAIAH_PETERS_1734_PROFILE",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I191",
      "person_id": "I191",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1737 in North Bradley, Wiltshire, England, GB.",
      "start_date": "1737",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England, GB",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_BETTY_WILLIS_1737_PROFILE",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1738",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_1738_FAMILY_CLUSTER"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I196",
      "person_id": "I196",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 18 Nov 1764 in Ranton, Staffordshire, England. Died June 1847 in Haughton, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "baptised 18 Nov 1764",
      "end_date": "June 1847",
      "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1764",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_BURIAL_1847",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I48",
      "person_id": "I48",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 21 Mar 1908. Died 1986.",
      "start_date": "21 Mar 1908",
      "end_date": "1986",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I30",
      "person_id": "I30",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1922. Died 2003.",
      "start_date": "1922",
      "end_date": "2003",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I241",
      "person_id": "I241",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 11 Oct 1641 in Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire. Died 5 Jun 1732 in Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": "11 Oct 1641",
      "end_date": "5 Jun 1732",
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I243",
      "person_id": "I243",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 6 Dec 1600 in Erpfingen, Wurttemberg. Died 10 Mar 1673 in Willmandingen, Wurttemberg.",
      "start_date": "6 Dec 1600",
      "end_date": "10 Mar 1673",
      "place": "Erpfingen, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBEL_GENI",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I244",
      "person_id": "I244",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 27 Nov 1576 in Weinsberg, Wurttemberg.",
      "start_date": "baptised 27 Nov 1576",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Weinsberg, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_I245",
      "person_id": "I245",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1575 in Erpfingen, Wurttemberg. Died 3 Aug 1662 in Willmandingen, Wurttemberg.",
      "start_date": "about 1575",
      "end_date": "3 Aug 1662",
      "place": "Erpfingen, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_HANNY_WILLIAM_HENRY_1839",
      "person_id": "C_HANNY_WILLIAM_HENRY_1839",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 21 MAR 1839 in Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England.",
      "start_date": "21 MAR 1839",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_ANCESTRY",
        "SRC_HANNY_BHO",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1718. Died 20 Mar 1798.",
      "start_date": "about 1718",
      "end_date": "20 Mar 1798",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_DERIVATION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 15 Nov 1806. Died 1 Jan 1876 in Henry County, Missouri, United States.",
      "start_date": "15 Nov 1806",
      "end_date": "1 Jan 1876",
      "place": "Henry County, Missouri, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "person_id": "HV4_RALPH_SHAW_ABOUT_1665_AFTER_MAR_1710",
      "fact_type": "inferred_life_span",
      "value": "Born before 1651, inferred from a documented adult land transaction in 1672. Died after 19 Mar 1710/11.",
      "start_date": "before 1651",
      "end_date": "after 19 Mar 1710/11",
      "place": "Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "inferred",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES_COUNTY_DEED_1671_1674",
        "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_LAND_PURCHASE_PAGE",
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1672 deed gives a latest plausible ordinary birth year, not an exact birth date. The 1710/11 agreement establishes that Ralph was living with Ann at that time; it does not supply a death date."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Documented as Ralph Shaw’s wife in the agreement of 19 March 1710/11; birth date unestablished.",
      "start_date": "19 Mar 1710/11",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710"
      ],
      "source_note": "Corrected 20 September 2026. The former about-1665 birth statement repeated an event-type error already removed from the person record. This date describes a documented appearance, not birth. The separate compilation’s reported about-1653 birth and 1698 death do not establish dates for the Ann alive in 1710/11."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "person_id": "HV4_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_19_APR_1754",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 19 Apr 1754 in Chester County, Pennsylvania, USA. Died 7 May 1834 in reported Washington County, Virginia or Floyd County, Kentucky, USA.",
      "start_date": "19 Apr 1754",
      "end_date": "7 May 1834",
      "place": "Chester County, Pennsylvania, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_CENSUS_1800_1830",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "person_id": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1 Jul 1650 in Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire. Died 27 Jan 1731 in Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": "1 Jul 1650",
      "end_date": "27 Jan 1731",
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "person_id": "HV5_ANNA_KATHARINA_KISSLING",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born estimated October 1618. Died 23 Apr 1688 in Willmandingen, Wurttemberg.",
      "start_date": "estimated October 1618",
      "end_date": "23 Apr 1688",
      "place": "Willmandingen, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
        "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV10_ERNEST_DANIEL_FRICKE_1884",
      "person_id": "HV10_ERNEST_DANIEL_FRICKE_1884",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 7 Nov 1884 in New Jersey, United States.",
      "start_date": "7 Nov 1884",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV10_HENRY_FRICKE_JR_ABT1886",
      "person_id": "HV10_HENRY_FRICKE_JR_ABT1886",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1886 in New Jersey, United States.",
      "start_date": "about 1886",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV10_JOHN_FRICKE_1889",
      "person_id": "HV10_JOHN_FRICKE_1889",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 18 Apr 1889 in East Orange, Essex, New Jersey, United States.",
      "start_date": "18 Apr 1889",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange, Essex, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_JOHN_1889_BIRTH",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV10_GEORG_HEINRICH_FRICKE_1827_1848",
      "person_id": "HV10_GEORG_HEINRICH_FRICKE_1827_1848",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 26 Mar 1827 in Gütersloh, Wiedenbrück, Westfalen, Preußen, Deutschland. Died 27 Apr 1848 in Hannover, Preußen, Deutschland.",
      "start_date": "26 Mar 1827",
      "end_date": "27 Apr 1848",
      "place": "Gütersloh, Wiedenbrück, Westfalen, Preußen, Deutschland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_LEFFLER_1842_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV10_ANNA_DOROTHEE_LEFFLER_ABT1827",
      "person_id": "HV10_ANNA_DOROTHEE_LEFFLER_ABT1827",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1827 in Crawinkel, Gotha, Thüringen, Germany.",
      "start_date": "about 1827",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Crawinkel, Gotha, Thüringen, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_LEFFLER_1842_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV10_EBERHARD_HEINRICH_FRICKE_ABT1788",
      "person_id": "HV10_EBERHARD_HEINRICH_FRICKE_ABT1788",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1788 in Germany.",
      "start_date": "about 1788",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_EBERHARD_SOPHIE_1820_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV10_SOPHIE_ELISABETH_ANGENETEN_ABT1795",
      "person_id": "HV10_SOPHIE_ELISABETH_ANGENETEN_ABT1795",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1795 in Germany.",
      "start_date": "about 1795",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_EBERHARD_SOPHIE_1820_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1851 in Llanddewi, Radnorshire, Wales. Died 8 Apr 1931 in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1851",
      "end_date": "8 Apr 1931",
      "place": "Llanddewi, Radnorshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879",
        "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_FINDAGRAVE_1851_1931",
        "SRC_FRANKWELL_SHREWSBURY_LOCAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_BOOT_SHOE_DIRECTORY",
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_LLANDDEWI_LODGER_1861",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_THOMAS_BLEDFFA_BAPTISM_1851",
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_RADNORSHIRE_CANDIDATE_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1849 in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1849",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_THOMAS_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ANNE_CROWTHER_CHR_1832_CEFNLLYS",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNE_CROWTHER_CHR_1832_CEFNLLYS",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born before 17 Jul 1832 in Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "before 17 Jul 1832",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Cefnllys, Radnorshire, Wales, United Kingdom",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ANN_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_WALTER",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANN_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_WALTER",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born before 5 Apr 1789 in Wrenbury, Cheshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "before 5 Apr 1789",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Wrenbury, Cheshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 26 May 1730 in Milwich, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 2 Dec 1801 in Milwich, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "26 May 1730",
      "end_date": "2 Dec 1801",
      "place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_RUTH_MOTHER_OF_RUTH_HANDLEY",
      "person_id": "SRC_RUTH_MOTHER_OF_RUTH_HANDLEY",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 4 Mar 1739 in Sandon, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 4 Jan 1759 in Milwich, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "4 Mar 1739",
      "end_date": "4 Jan 1759",
      "place": "Sandon, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_1697",
      "person_id": "SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_1697",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 24 Aug 1697 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. Died 4 Dec 1763 in Milwich, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "24 Aug 1697",
      "end_date": "4 Dec 1763",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_1691",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_1691",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1691 in Draycott in the Moors, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 26 Aug 1758 in Milwich, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1691",
      "end_date": "26 Aug 1758",
      "place": "Draycott in the Moors, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_THOMAS_HANDLEY_ABT1666",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_HANDLEY_ABT1666",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1666 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "about 1666",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 27 Jun 1674 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. Died Jul 1740 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "27 Jun 1674",
      "end_date": "Jul 1740",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JAMES_JACOBUS_HANDLEY_1647",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_JACOBUS_HANDLEY_1647",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born Apr 1647 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "Apr 1647",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HANNAH_WILD_1649",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_WILD_1649",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born christened 29 Apr 1649 in Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul Sheffield, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": "christened 29 Apr 1649",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul Sheffield, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SARAH_HANCOCK_1624",
      "person_id": "SRC_SARAH_HANCOCK_1624",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1624 in Great Paxton, Huntingdonshire, Cambridgeshire, England, United Kingdom. Died Dec 1689 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": "1624",
      "end_date": "Dec 1689",
      "place": "Great Paxton, Huntingdonshire, Cambridgeshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "person_id": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1623 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. Died buried 26 Apr 1678 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": "1623",
      "end_date": "buried 26 Apr 1678",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1576 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 1643 in Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1576",
      "end_date": "1643",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DROITWICH_ST_PETERS_WYLDE_MONUMENT_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_WESTMINSTER_ABBEY_GEORGE_WYLDE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "person_id": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1550 in Droitwich, Worcestershire, England. Died 27 Mar 1616 in Droitwich, Worcestershire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1550",
      "end_date": "27 Mar 1616",
      "place": "Droitwich, Worcestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ELEANOR_WALL_1524",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELEANOR_WALL_1524",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1524 in Droitwich Spa, Wychavon district, Worcestershire, England, United Kingdom. Died 1600 in Droitwich Spa, Wychavon district, Worcestershire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1524",
      "end_date": "1600",
      "place": "Droitwich Spa, Wychavon district, Worcestershire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
      "person_id": "SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1507 in England. Died 1562 in Droitwich, Worcestershire, England.",
      "start_date": "1507",
      "end_date": "1562",
      "place": "England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JANE_EDEN_GARDNER",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_EDEN_GARDNER",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1507 in Droitwich Spa, Worcestershire, England. Died 1572 in Droitwich Spa, Worcestershire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1507",
      "end_date": "1572",
      "place": "Droitwich Spa, Worcestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 26 Dec 1765 in Washington County, Virginia, British Colonial America. Died 1 Apr 1860 in Washington County, Virginia, United States.",
      "start_date": "26 Dec 1765",
      "end_date": "1 Apr 1860",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_AMELIA_1765_FATHER_1742",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "person_id": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1645.",
      "start_date": "1645",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "person_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 22 Apr 1598 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany. Died 9 Apr 1677 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany.",
      "start_date": "22 Apr 1598",
      "end_date": "9 Apr 1677",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "person_id": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 3 Apr 1681 in Nenzenheim, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany. Died reported 12 Feb 1751 in reported Opequon, Frederick County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "3 Apr 1681",
      "end_date": "reported 12 Feb 1751",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_LANCASTER_WARRANT_1733",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 10 Dec 1695 in Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Germany.",
      "start_date": "baptised 10 Dec 1695",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "person_id": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1735. Died after 24 Sep 1801.",
      "start_date": "about 1735",
      "end_date": "after 24 Sep 1801",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_ANTON_LINDER_PEGGY_1753",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_ANTHONY_LINDER_ANCESTRY_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1741. Died after 24 Sep 1801.",
      "start_date": "about 1741",
      "end_date": "after 24 Sep 1801",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birth date unresolved. Died before 27 Oct 1800 in Berkeley County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "before 27 Oct 1800",
      "place": "Berkeley County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEWLAND_HOPE_PASSENGER_1734",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780",
        "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_JOHN_NEWLAND_ANCESTRY_UNKNOWN_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_OT26_ALLEN_1729_ULLAND_PASSENGER_GROUP",
        "SRC_OT26_NEWLAND_1736_INDENTURE_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Former birth about 1710 was inferred from Hope passenger age twenty-four in 1734. The competing Allen boy was under fifteen in 1729 and may correspond to the reported, still unverified, 1716 German baptism. Neither date is adopted as settled."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HANNAH_CASWELL_ABT1709",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_CASWELL_ABT1709",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1709.",
      "start_date": "about 1709",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_SIMON_K__LINDER_JR",
      "person_id": "SRC_LINDER_SIBLING_JERICK_SIMON_K__LINDER_JR",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born before 22 Sep 1717 in Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Holy Roman Empire. Died about 1798 in Rockingham County, North Carolina, United States.",
      "start_date": "before 22 Sep 1717",
      "end_date": "about 1798",
      "place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bayern, Holy Roman Empire. Died before 28 Apr 1665 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bayern, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "before 28 Apr 1665",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bayern, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1656.",
      "start_date": "about 1656",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported 18 Oct 1661 in reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire. Died reported 13 Dec 1716 in reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": "reported 18 Oct 1661",
      "end_date": "reported 13 Dec 1716",
      "place": "reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1489 in Preston, Lancashire, England. Died 1525 in Preston, Lancashire, England.",
      "start_date": "1489",
      "end_date": "1525",
      "place": "Preston, Lancashire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "person_id": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1490. Died 1577.",
      "start_date": "1490",
      "end_date": "1577",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WALL_SIB_WILLIAM_1510",
      "person_id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_WILLIAM_1510",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1510. Died 1558.",
      "start_date": "1510",
      "end_date": "1558",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WALL_SIB_JOSIAH_1515",
      "person_id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_JOSIAH_1515",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1515. Died 1547.",
      "start_date": "1515",
      "end_date": "1547",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WALL_SIB_LAWRENCE_1515",
      "person_id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_LAWRENCE_1515",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1515. Died 1600.",
      "start_date": "1515",
      "end_date": "1600",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WALL_SIB_RICHARD_1516",
      "person_id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_RICHARD_1516",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1516. Died 1541.",
      "start_date": "1516",
      "end_date": "1541",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WALL_SIB_EVAN_1518",
      "person_id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_EVAN_1518",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1518. Died 1582.",
      "start_date": "1518",
      "end_date": "1582",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WALL_SIB_ROBERT_1518",
      "person_id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_ROBERT_1518",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1518.",
      "start_date": "1518",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WALL_SIB_THOMAS_1524",
      "person_id": "SRC_WALL_SIB_THOMAS_1524",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1524. Died 1575.",
      "start_date": "1524",
      "end_date": "1575",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_RICHARD_WALL_ABT1463",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_WALL_ABT1463",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1463.",
      "start_date": "about 1463",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1467 in Preston, Lancashire, England. Died 1531 in Preston, Lancashire, England.",
      "start_date": "1467",
      "end_date": "1531",
      "place": "Preston, Lancashire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ELIZABETHA_WYLD_1602",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZABETHA_WYLD_1602",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born christened 10 Oct 1602 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": "christened 10 Oct 1602",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "person_id": "SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1557 in Sawston Hall, Cambridgeshire, England. Died 1630.",
      "start_date": "1557",
      "end_date": "1630",
      "place": "Sawston Hall, Cambridgeshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "person_id": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1577. Died 1647.",
      "start_date": "1577",
      "end_date": "1647",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ELIZABETH_WILDE_1602",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_WILDE_1602",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1602 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1602",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARGARET_WILDE_1604",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARET_WILDE_1604",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1604 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1604",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHN_WILD_1606",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_WILD_1606",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1606 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 1644.",
      "start_date": "1606",
      "end_date": "1644",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ISABEL_WILD_1608",
      "person_id": "SRC_ISABEL_WILD_1608",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1608 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 1668.",
      "start_date": "1608",
      "end_date": "1668",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WILLIAM_WILD_1610",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILD_1610",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1610 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1610",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ANNA_WILDE_1612",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_WILDE_1612",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1612 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1612",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HELEN_WILD_1614",
      "person_id": "SRC_HELEN_WILD_1614",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1614 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1614",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_GEORGE_WILD_1616",
      "person_id": "SRC_GEORGE_WILD_1616",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1616 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 1690.",
      "start_date": "1616",
      "end_date": "1690",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STIRNET_HALL_CARR_WILD_PEDIGREE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JOSEPH_WILD_1618",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOSEPH_WILD_1618",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1618 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 1696.",
      "start_date": "1618",
      "end_date": "1696",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SARAH_WILDE_1620",
      "person_id": "SRC_SARAH_WILDE_1620",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1620 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 1620.",
      "start_date": "1620",
      "end_date": "1620",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SAMUEL_WILDE_1622",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_WILDE_1622",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1622 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1622",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_THOMAS_WILD_1626",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_WILD_1626",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1626 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 1636.",
      "start_date": "1626",
      "end_date": "1636",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_DAVID_WYLDE_1569",
      "person_id": "SRC_DAVID_WYLDE_1569",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1569. Died 1614 or 1633.",
      "start_date": "1569",
      "end_date": "1614 or 1633",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHN_WYLDE_1590",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_WYLDE_1590",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1590. Died 1669.",
      "start_date": "1590",
      "end_date": "1669",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_LADY_ELIZABETH_WYLDE_1591",
      "person_id": "SRC_LADY_ELIZABETH_WYLDE_1591",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1591. Died 1656.",
      "start_date": "1591",
      "end_date": "1656",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_II_1594",
      "person_id": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_II_1594",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1594. Died 1650.",
      "start_date": "1594",
      "end_date": "1650",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 12 Sep 1596 in Oberböbingen, Gmünd, Württemberg, Germany. Died 1677.",
      "start_date": "baptised 12 Sep 1596",
      "end_date": "1677",
      "place": "Oberböbingen, Gmünd, Württemberg, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1620.",
      "start_date": "1620",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_ABT1626",
      "person_id": "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_ABT1626",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1626 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany.",
      "start_date": "about 1626",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1632_1633",
      "person_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1632_1633",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1632 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany. Died 1633.",
      "start_date": "1632",
      "end_date": "1633",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1633_1633",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1633_1633",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1633 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany. Died 1633.",
      "start_date": "1633",
      "end_date": "1633",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1634",
      "person_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1634",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1634 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany.",
      "start_date": "1634",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARGARETHA_LINDNER_1637_1638",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_LINDNER_1637_1638",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1637 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany. Died 1638.",
      "start_date": "1637",
      "end_date": "1638",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_APOLLONIA_LINDNER_1639_1639",
      "person_id": "SRC_APOLLONIA_LINDNER_1639_1639",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1639 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany. Died 1639.",
      "start_date": "1639",
      "end_date": "1639",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1642_1718",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1642_1718",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1642 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany. Died 1718.",
      "start_date": "1642",
      "end_date": "1718",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_KASPAR_LINDNER_1642",
      "person_id": "SRC_KASPAR_LINDNER_1642",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1642 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany.",
      "start_date": "1642",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHANNES_LINDNER_1642_1722",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHANNES_LINDNER_1642_1722",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1642 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany. Died 1722.",
      "start_date": "1642",
      "end_date": "1722",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ELSBETH_LINDER_1606",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELSBETH_LINDER_1606",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1606 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany.",
      "start_date": "1606",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_CHRISTINA_LINDER_1607",
      "person_id": "SRC_CHRISTINA_LINDER_1607",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1607 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany.",
      "start_date": "1607",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SALOME_LINDER_1610",
      "person_id": "SRC_SALOME_LINDER_1610",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1610 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany. Died 1704.",
      "start_date": "1610",
      "end_date": "1704",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARTY_LINDER_JR_1611",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTY_LINDER_JR_1611",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1611 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany.",
      "start_date": "1611",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SIMEON_LINDER_1614",
      "person_id": "SRC_SIMEON_LINDER_1614",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1614 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany. Died 1683.",
      "start_date": "1614",
      "end_date": "1683",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARIA_LINDER_1616",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARIA_LINDER_1616",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1616 in Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany.",
      "start_date": "1616",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1569. Died 1608.",
      "start_date": "1569",
      "end_date": "1608",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1569.",
      "start_date": "1569",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "person_id": "SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1627. Died 1662.",
      "start_date": "1627",
      "end_date": "1662",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HELLENA_TUNSTEAD_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "person_id": "SRC_HELLENA_TUNSTEAD_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1640. Died 1681.",
      "start_date": "1640",
      "end_date": "1681",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHN_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1653",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1653",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1653 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1653",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SAMUEL_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1655",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1655",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1655 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1655",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1657",
      "person_id": "SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1657",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1657 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 1659.",
      "start_date": "1657",
      "end_date": "1659",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SARA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1659",
      "person_id": "SRC_SARA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1659",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1659 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1659",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1661",
      "person_id": "SRC_LYDIA_WILD_CHILD_GODFREY_LYDIA_1661",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1661 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom. Died 1664.",
      "start_date": "1661",
      "end_date": "1664",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HANNAH_WILDE_CHILD_GODFREY_HELLENA_1679",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_WILDE_CHILD_GODFREY_HELLENA_1679",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1679 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "1679",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "person_id": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1591.",
      "start_date": "1591",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1595. Died 1629.",
      "start_date": "1595",
      "end_date": "1629",
      "place": null,
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHANNES_HANCOCK_1616",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHANNES_HANCOCK_1616",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1616 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": "1616",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1617_1616",
      "person_id": "SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1617_1616",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1617 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. Died 1616.",
      "start_date": "1617",
      "end_date": "1616",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WILLIAM_HANCOCK_1620",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HANCOCK_1620",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1620 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": "1620",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JOSEPH_HANCOCK_1621",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOSEPH_HANCOCK_1621",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1621 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": "1621",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1627",
      "person_id": "SRC_ISABELLA_HANCOCK_1627",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1627 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. Died 1696.",
      "start_date": "1627",
      "end_date": "1696",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_THOMAS_HANCOCK_1628_1628",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_HANCOCK_1628_1628",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1628 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. Died 1628.",
      "start_date": "1628",
      "end_date": "1628",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ELIZABETH_HANCOCK_1628",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_HANCOCK_1628",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1628 in Sheffield, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": "1628",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "user_confirmed",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_RICHARD_HANCOCK_1564",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_HANCOCK_1564",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born christened 19 Dec 1564 in Saint John the Baptist, Chester, Cheshire, England. Died buried 24 Sep 1623 in Canterbury St Peter, Canterbury, Kent, England, United Kingdom.",
      "start_date": "christened 19 Dec 1564",
      "end_date": "buried 24 Sep 1623",
      "place": "Saint John the Baptist, Chester, Cheshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ANNE_ROADES_1567",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNE_ROADES_1567",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born christened 5 Oct 1567 in Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. Died buried 29 Aug 1612 in Ottringham, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": "christened 5 Oct 1567",
      "end_date": "buried 29 Aug 1612",
      "place": "Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1881_RUTH_E_RHEAD_ABT1858",
      "person_id": "SRC1881_RUTH_E_RHEAD_ABT1858",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1858 in Birmingham, Warwickshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1858",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1901_HEATH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1861_HEYWOOD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1881_FLORENCE_RHEAD_ABT1862",
      "person_id": "SRC1881_FLORENCE_RHEAD_ABT1862",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1862 in Birmingham, Warwickshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1862",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Birmingham, Warwickshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1799. Died 1883.",
      "start_date": "1799",
      "end_date": "1883",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_WIKITREE_THOMAS_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "person_id": "C_WIKITREE_THOMAS_RHEAD_CHILD_OF_SAMPSON",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Died 1889.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "1889",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1825_RICHARD_RHEAD_BURSLEM",
      "person_id": "SRC1825_RICHARD_RHEAD_BURSLEM",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1825 in Burslem, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "1825",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Burslem, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_MEMORIAL_JANE_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "C_MEMORIAL_JANE_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1828. Died 1854.",
      "start_date": "1828",
      "end_date": "1854",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_MEMORIAL_MARGARET_TURNER_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "C_MEMORIAL_MARGARET_TURNER_RHEAD",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1831. Died 1865.",
      "start_date": "1831",
      "end_date": "1865",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_MEMORIAL_MARY_ANN_BEARDMORE_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "C_MEMORIAL_MARY_ANN_BEARDMORE_RHEAD",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1838. Died 15 May 1891.",
      "start_date": "1838",
      "end_date": "15 May 1891",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_MEMORIAL_JULIA_ANN_RHEAD_POTTS",
      "person_id": "C_MEMORIAL_JULIA_ANN_RHEAD_POTTS",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1850. Died 1907.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": "1907",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_MEMORIAL_THOMAS_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "C_MEMORIAL_THOMAS_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1851. Died 1852.",
      "start_date": "1851",
      "end_date": "1852",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_MEMORIAL_FREDERICK_GEORGE_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "C_MEMORIAL_FREDERICK_GEORGE_RHEAD",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1873. Died 1945.",
      "start_date": "1873",
      "end_date": "1945",
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_HV10_HEINRICH_FRIEDRICH_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER",
      "person_id": "HV10_HEINRICH_FRIEDRICH_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 13 Aug 1845 in Hannover, Hannover, Preußen, Deutschland.",
      "start_date": "13 Aug 1845",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Hannover, Hannover, Preußen, Deutschland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER_BAPTISM"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_GONTER_JOHANN_BALTHASAR",
      "person_id": "C_GONTER_JOHANN_BALTHASAR",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 19 Jan 1762 in Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany. Died 10 Jan 1836 in Ober Gleen, Oberhessen, Hessen, Germany.",
      "start_date": "19 Jan 1762",
      "end_date": "10 Jan 1836",
      "place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHANN_BALTHASAR_GONDER",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_ENGEL_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "person_id": "C_ENGEL_ANNA_ELISABETHA",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported 25 Aug 1740 in reported Hinsing.",
      "start_date": "reported 25 Aug 1740",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Hinsing",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_UNNAMED_BAPTISM_1762",
        "SRC_GENEANET_ANNE_ELISABETH_GINDER_1740"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_GONDER_DIETRICH",
      "person_id": "C_GONDER_DIETRICH",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 18 Jul 1724 in Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany. Died about 1772 in Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany.",
      "start_date": "18 Jul 1724",
      "end_date": "about 1772",
      "place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762",
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GONDER_BAPTISM_1724",
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761",
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GONDER_PROFILE_DEATH_1772"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1911_EDWARD_RICHARD_RHEAD_ABT1901",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_EDWARD_RICHARD_RHEAD_ABT1901",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 22 Nov 1900 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England. Died 1950.",
      "start_date": "22 Nov 1900",
      "end_date": "1950",
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1911_BERNAL_ALBERT_RHEAD_ABT1903",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_BERNAL_ALBERT_RHEAD_ABT1903",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born Jul 1902 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England. Died Jul 1931 in Derby, Derbyshire, England.",
      "start_date": "Jul 1902",
      "end_date": "Jul 1931",
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1911_GEORGE_ERNEST_RHEAD_ABT1905",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_GEORGE_ERNEST_RHEAD_ABT1905",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1905 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England. Died 1943.",
      "start_date": "1905",
      "end_date": "1943",
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1911_AMY_ROSA_RHEAD_ABT1907",
      "person_id": "SRC1911_AMY_ROSA_RHEAD_ABT1907",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 28 Feb 1907 in Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England. Died 1988.",
      "start_date": "28 Feb 1907",
      "end_date": "1988",
      "place": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1841_FREDERICK_WATERHOUSE_ABT1828",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_FREDERICK_WATERHOUSE_ABT1828",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1828.",
      "start_date": "about 1828",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1841_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ABT1830",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ABT1830",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1830.",
      "start_date": "about 1830",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1841_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ABT1832",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ABT1832",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1832.",
      "start_date": "about 1832",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1841_WILLIAM_WATERHOUSE_ABT1837",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_WILLIAM_WATERHOUSE_ABT1837",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1837.",
      "start_date": "about 1837",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1841_EMMA_WATERHOUSE_ABT1840",
      "person_id": "SRC1841_EMMA_WATERHOUSE_ABT1840",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1840.",
      "start_date": "about 1840",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1901_ARTHUR_J_DAVIES_ABT1881",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_ARTHUR_J_DAVIES_ABT1881",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1881.",
      "start_date": "about 1881",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1901_ROBERT_L_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_ROBERT_L_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1886.",
      "start_date": "about 1886",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1901_FRANCIS_J_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_FRANCIS_J_DAVIES_ABT1886",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1886.",
      "start_date": "about 1886",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1901_LOUIE_S_DAVIES_ABT1890",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_LOUIE_S_DAVIES_ABT1890",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1890.",
      "start_date": "about 1890",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1901_THOMAS_E_DAVIES_ABT1894",
      "person_id": "SRC1901_THOMAS_E_DAVIES_ABT1894",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1894.",
      "start_date": "about 1894",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1891_WALTER_H_DAVIES_ABT1882",
      "person_id": "SRC1891_WALTER_H_DAVIES_ABT1882",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1882.",
      "start_date": "about 1882",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1851_ANNA_HANNEY_ABT1841",
      "person_id": "SRC1851_ANNA_HANNEY_ABT1841",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1841.",
      "start_date": "about 1841",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1851_EDWIN_HANNEY_ABT1842",
      "person_id": "SRC1851_EDWIN_HANNEY_ABT1842",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1842.",
      "start_date": "about 1842",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1880_ROBERT_I_GOBBLE_ABT1859",
      "person_id": "SRC1880_ROBERT_I_GOBBLE_ABT1859",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1859-1861 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1859-1861",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC1880_GEORGE_W_GOBBLE_ABT1868",
      "person_id": "SRC1880_GEORGE_W_GOBBLE_ABT1868",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1867-1868 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1867-1868",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1796-1799 in Virginia, USA. Died 29 Aug 1882 in Holston, Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1796-1799",
      "end_date": "29 Aug 1882",
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796_1882",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1820_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1830_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_DEATH_1882",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HARDIN_PHELPS_1833",
      "person_id": "SRC_HARDIN_PHELPS_1833",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1833 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1833",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHN_P_PHELPS_1834",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_P_PHELPS_1834",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1834 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1834",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARGARET_PHELPS_1843",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARET_PHELPS_1843",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1843 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1843",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARTIN_S_PHELPS_1845",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_S_PHELPS_1845",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1845 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1845",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1855",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1855",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1855 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1855",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_FRANK_STRETTON_RHEAD_1911",
      "person_id": "SRC_FRANK_STRETTON_RHEAD_1911",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 25 Sep 1911 in Church Stretton, Shropshire, England. Died 1969.",
      "start_date": "25 Sep 1911",
      "end_date": "1969",
      "place": "Church Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ALFRED_SAMUEL_RHEAD_1913",
      "person_id": "SRC_ALFRED_SAMUEL_RHEAD_1913",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 26 Sep 1913 in Little Stretton, Shropshire, England. Died 2006.",
      "start_date": "26 Sep 1913",
      "end_date": "2006",
      "place": "Little Stretton, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_GEORGE_RHEAD_SHROPSHIRE_1837",
      "person_id": "SRC_GEORGE_RHEAD_SHROPSHIRE_1837",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1837 in reported Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1837",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1826.",
      "start_date": "about 1826",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1849",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1849",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1849.",
      "start_date": "about 1849",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARTHA_JANE_GOBBLE_1844",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTHA_JANE_GOBBLE_1844",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1844-1846 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1844-1846",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARTIN_P_GOBBLE_1848",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_P_GOBBLE_1848",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1847-1848 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1847-1848",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARY_CATHERINE_GOBBLE_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_CATHERINE_GOBBLE_1850",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1850 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WILLIAM_C_GOBBLE_1853",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_C_GOBBLE_1853",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1852-1854 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1852-1854",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JULIA_ANN_GOBBLE_1857",
      "person_id": "SRC_JULIA_ANN_GOBBLE_1857",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1856-1857 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1856-1857",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_EGLANTINE_GOBBLE_SCOTT_1863",
      "person_id": "SRC_EGLANTINE_GOBBLE_SCOTT_1863",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1863-1864 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1863-1864",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARY_E_HENDERSON_1858",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_E_HENDERSON_1858",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1858 in Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1858",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SAMUEL_HENDERSON_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_HENDERSON_1860",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1860 in Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "person_id": "SRC_EVAN_TALLEY_FATHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1823-1830 in Virginia or North Carolina, USA. Died before 1866.",
      "start_date": "about 1823-1830",
      "end_date": "before 1866",
      "place": "Virginia or North Carolina, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_EVAN_L_TALLEY_1823_BEFORE_1866",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "person_id": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 26 Dec 1830 in Virginia, USA. Died 16 Aug 1897 in Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "26 Dec 1830",
      "end_date": "16 Aug 1897",
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
        "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DELIA_TALLY_HENDERSON_1866_HEADSTONE",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_1835_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX",
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_GRayson_HISTORICAL_SOCIETY_FADDIS_NOTEBOOK"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_AMANDA_J_TALLEY_1851",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMANDA_J_TALLEY_1851",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1851-1854 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1851-1854",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JAMES_M_TALLEY_1860",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_M_TALLEY_1860",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1859-1860 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1859-1860",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1790-1795 in North Carolina, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1790-1795",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Carolina, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_1860_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_GRAYSON",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1804-1807 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1804-1807",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_HENDERSON_FAMILY_RECORD_NOTES",
        "SRC_WCV_PARENT_INDEX_DAVID_ANN_MCNEW",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_SAMUEL_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_NANCY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_NANCY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_LOUIS_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_LOUIS_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_CENA_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "person_id": "SRC_CENA_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID_1850",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_AILSEY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID",
      "person_id": "SRC_AILSEY_MCNEW_CHILD_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HENRY_SHORTT_DEATH_1937",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1841 in Virginia, USA. Died reported 7 Mar 1897 in Washington County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1841",
      "end_date": "reported 7 Mar 1897",
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HENRY_SHORTT_DEATH_1937",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_JOHN_FATHER_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 16 Sep 1850 in Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland. Died reported 26 Jul 1921 in Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland.",
      "start_date": "16 Sep 1850",
      "end_date": "reported 26 Jul 1921",
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
        "SRC_PROFILE_JOHN_GIBSON_1850_1921_MONAGHAN",
        "SRC_NY_PASSENGER_JOHN_GILSON_FLORENCE_GIBSON",
        "SRC_JOHN_GIBSON_MONAGHAN_DEATH_Q3_1921",
        "SRC_MONAGHAN_PRESBYTERIAN_REGISTER_COVERAGE",
        "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_NAI_IRELAND_CENSUS_SEARCH_GUIDE",
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_SARAH_ANN_GIBSON_DEATH_1885_REJECTED",
        "SRC_SECOND_MONAGHAN_PRESBYTERIAN_MIC1P146_COVERAGE",
        "SRC_PRONI_GUIDE_SECOND_MONAGHAN_MIC1P146"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_GIBSON_DAVID_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_DAVID_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1888-1889 in County Monaghan, Ireland.",
      "start_date": "about 1888-1889",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_GIBSON_MAGGIE_J_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_MAGGIE_J_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1885-1886 in County Monaghan, Ireland.",
      "start_date": "about 1885-1886",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_GIBSON_MARY_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_MARY_SIBLING_FLORENCE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1887-1888 in County Monaghan, Ireland.",
      "start_date": "about 1887-1888",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "person_id": "C_GIBSON_SARAH_SADIE_CLARKE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
        "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
        "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1830-1832 in County Monaghan, Ireland. Died 29 Mar 1913 in Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland.",
      "start_date": "about 1830-1832",
      "end_date": "29 Mar 1913",
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "person_id": "C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1829 in Coolmain, County Monaghan, Ireland. Died reported 6 Feb 1894 in Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland.",
      "start_date": "about 1829",
      "end_date": "reported 6 Feb 1894",
      "place": "Coolmain, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_BOYD_PROFILE_1829_1894",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_ABT1815_BERRIEW",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1814 in Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales.",
      "start_date": "about 1814",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1816 in Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales.",
      "start_date": "about 1816",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as probably Berriew parish, Montgomeryshire, Wales.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "probably Berriew parish, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
        "SRC_FREEREG_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1823",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_DAVIES_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1803",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1812 in Horsehay, Shropshire, England. Died before 8 Jul 1884 in Wellington, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1812",
      "end_date": "before 8 Jul 1884",
      "place": "Horsehay, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1841_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1881_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_DEATH_1884",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_1811_1884",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_BURIAL_1884",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1811 in Forton, Staffordshire, England. Died September 1853 in Wellington, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1811",
      "end_date": "September 1853",
      "place": "Forton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1841_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLEY_MORRALL_PROFILE_ABT1811_1853",
        "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1853",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_CHILD_BAPTISM_PARENTS_RICHARD_ANNE",
        "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1824.",
      "start_date": "about 1824",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "person_id": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reportedly about 1760-1767 in reported Rowan County, North Carolina, USA. Died about 1846-1847 in Russell County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "reportedly about 1760-1767",
      "end_date": "about 1846-1847",
      "place": "reported Rowan County, North Carolina, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_1790_ROWAN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_VA_NC_CENSUS_SEQUENCE",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_1810_NAMESAKE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "person_id": "C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported 1767 in reported Rowan County, North Carolina, USA. Died reported 1847 or 1848 in Russell County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "reported 1767",
      "end_date": "reported 1847 or 1848",
      "place": "reported Rowan County, North Carolina, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
        "SRC_SUSANNAH_VINES_COMPILED_VITALS_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_1601_WIFE_THOMAS_EMERYE",
      "person_id": "C_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_1601_WIFE_THOMAS_EMERYE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 15 Feb 1601 in Trentham, Staffordshire, England. Died reportedly 10 Jun 1679 in reportedly Cocknage, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "baptised 15 Feb 1601",
      "end_date": "reportedly 10 Jun 1679",
      "place": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_TRENTHAM_BAPTISM_1601"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "person_id": "C_SARAH_GISE_GOBBLE_1764",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported Jun or Jul 1764 in reported Frederick County, Maryland or Chester County, Pennsylvania, USA. Died 7 May 1848 in Floyd County, Kentucky, USA.",
      "start_date": "reported Jun or Jul 1764",
      "end_date": "7 May 1848",
      "place": "reported Frederick County, Maryland or Chester County, Pennsylvania, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_CENSUS_1800_1830",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
      "person_id": "C_HENRY_COUNTISS_1777",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported 9 Jun 1777 in reported Queen Anne's County, Maryland, USA. Died reported before 1830.",
      "start_date": "reported 9 Jun 1777",
      "end_date": "reported before 1830",
      "place": "reported Queen Anne's County, Maryland, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENRY_AUNLIE_1810_COUNTISS_CANDIDATE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported 1661 in reported Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America. Died between 19 Jun and 25 Nov 1730 in Westmoreland County, Virginia, British Colonial America.",
      "start_date": "reported 1661",
      "end_date": "between 19 Jun and 25 Nov 1730",
      "place": "reported Charles County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661_1730",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_WILLIAM_ASA_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported about 1640 in reported St Mary Magdalen Parish, London, England. Died between 19 Nov 1685 and about 19 Mar 1685/86 in Maryland, British Colonial America (reported Charles County).",
      "start_date": "reported about 1640",
      "end_date": "between 19 Nov 1685 and about 19 Mar 1685/86",
      "place": "reported St Mary Magdalen Parish, London, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARYLAND_PROBATE_WM_HARGIS_WILL_BOOKS",
        "SRC_PROFILE_WILLIAM_ASA_HARGIS_1640_1685",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported 1665 or 1670-1679 in reported Virginia, British Colonial America (specific county anachronistic). Died reported Apr 1714 in reported King William County, Virginia, British Colonial America.",
      "start_date": "reported 1665 or 1670-1679",
      "end_date": "reported Apr 1714",
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SELECT_BIRTHS_MARY_JOHN_HIRGES_CHILD_JOHN",
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_MARY_ANN_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS_1714",
        "SRC_AGBI_MARY_ANNE_FOUNTAIN_1670S",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_KING_WILLIAM_COUNTY_FORMATION_1702"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reported King William County birth label is anachronistic before the county took effect in 1702; reported colonial Virginia is retained without a county."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "person_id": "C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Virginia, British Colonial America.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EARLY_VA_MARRIAGES_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_JOHN_HARGES_1725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_SUSANNAH_SPOUSE_GEORGE_HARGIS",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptised 22 Jan 1614 in Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England. Died reported 1650 in reported Maryland, in the area later called Charles County.",
      "start_date": "baptised 22 Jan 1614",
      "end_date": "reported 1650",
      "place": "Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_MARRIAGE_INDEX_GEORGE_HARGIS_SUSANNAH_LEA",
        "SRC_GENEANET_SUSANNAH_LEA_HARGIS_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported about 1588-1590 in reported Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England. Died reported 1 Nov 1680 in reported Cheshire, England.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1588-1590",
      "end_date": "reported 1 Nov 1680",
      "place": "reported Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_GENEANET_URIAE_LEA_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_PARISH_COUNCIL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ASHWELL_MUSEUM_PARISH_DOCUMENTS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_JOANNA_MOTHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born possibly baptised 13 Mar 1590 in possibly Stoke St Gregory, Somerset, England. Died reported 1614 in reported England.",
      "start_date": "possibly baptised 13 Mar 1590",
      "end_date": "reported 1614",
      "place": "possibly Stoke St Gregory, Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
        "SRC_GENEANET_URIAE_LEA_FAMILY",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_PROFILE_JOANNAE_LEA_1590_1614",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported about 1555 in reported Somerset, England.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1555",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_GENEANET_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_PARISH_COUNCIL",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_HISTORY_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as possibly Somerset, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "possibly Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
        "SRC_GENEANET_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_PARISH_COUNCIL",
        "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_HISTORY_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "person_id": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born born before about 1621. Died reported 19 Mar 1659 in reported Maryland, British Colonial America.",
      "start_date": "born before about 1621",
      "end_date": "reported 19 Mar 1659",
      "place": "reported Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_GEO_HARGAS_BY_1642",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064213",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Died 30 Nov 2001 in Baltimore, Maryland, United States.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "30 Nov 2001",
      "place": "Baltimore, Maryland, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TIMES_PICAYUNE_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_OBITUARY_2001",
        "SRC_RH19_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_MEMORIAL_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064225",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 29 Aug 1906 in New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, USA. Died 23 Jan 1981 in New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, USA.",
      "start_date": "29 Aug 1906",
      "end_date": "23 Jan 1981",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_USCSC_ARMY_REGISTER_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FRASER_MIDCONTINENT_BANKER_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1951"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064230",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 09 Jan 1907 in New Orleans, Louisiana, United States. Died 05 Apr 1956 in New Orleans, Louisiana, United States.",
      "start_date": "09 Jan 1907",
      "end_date": "05 Apr 1956",
      "place": "New Orleans, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_HNOC_MAISON_BLANCHE_HISTORY_20260725",
        "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_IMMIGRATION_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 18 Oct 1873 in New Orleans, LA, USA. Died 9 Mar 1928 in New Orleans, LA, USA.",
      "start_date": "18 Oct 1873",
      "end_date": "9 Mar 1928",
      "place": "New Orleans, LA, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935",
        "SRC_CROCKERY_GLASS_JOURNAL_EDGAR_NEWMAN_MAISON_BLANCHE",
        "SRC_TALKING_MACHINE_WORLD_EDGAR_NEWMAN_1922",
        "SRC_ENTERPRISE_IN_RADIO_EDGAR_NEWMAN"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 5 Aug 1884 in New Orleans, LA, USA. Died 14 Jan 1966 in New Orleans, LA, USA.",
      "start_date": "5 Aug 1884",
      "end_date": "14 Jan 1966",
      "place": "New Orleans, LA, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 28 Feb 1837 in Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany. Died 30 Nov 1909 in New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana.",
      "start_date": "28 Feb 1837",
      "end_date": "30 Nov 1909",
      "place": "Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_AJC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_DEATH_1909",
        "SRC_COMMERCIAL_FINANCIAL_CHRONICLE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1909",
        "SRC_SOARDS_NEW_ORLEANS_GUIDE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_STOCK_EXCHANGE",
        "SRC_HNOC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_LEGACY",
        "SRC_NEWMAN_SCHOOL_HISTORY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN",
        "SRC_LA_SUPREME_COURT_ADAMS_MACHINE_V_NEWMAN_1902"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 12 Dec 1849 in Port Gibson, Mississippi. Died 10 Nov 1919 in New Orleans, Louisiana.",
      "start_date": "12 Dec 1849",
      "end_date": "10 Nov 1919",
      "place": "Port Gibson, Mississippi",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_MS_ENCYCLOPEDIA_PORT_GIBSON_JEWISH_CONGREGATION",
        "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_IMMIGRATION_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064327",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 20 Jan 1803 in Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany. Died 1869 in Mehlingen, Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany.",
      "start_date": "20 Jan 1803",
      "end_date": "1869",
      "place": "Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND",
        "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_KAISERSLAUTERN_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_19C"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064333",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 8 Jun 1803 in Mainz, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany.",
      "start_date": "8 Jun 1803",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Mainz, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND",
        "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_KAISERSLAUTERN_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_19C"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 18 Aug 1855 in Liberty, Amite, Mississippi. Died 3 May 1926 in New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States.",
      "start_date": "18 Aug 1855",
      "end_date": "3 May 1926",
      "place": "Liberty, Amite, Mississippi",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_1926",
        "SRC_MDAH_JACOB_SCHWARTZ_WOODVILLE_LEDGER_FINDING_AID",
        "SRC_ISJL_WOODVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_USGENWEB_AMITE_1850_CENSUS_INDEX",
        "SRC_USGENWEB_AMITE_1860_CENSUS_INDEX"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 26 Dec 1862 in New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States. Died 5 Sep 1945 in New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, United States.",
      "start_date": "26 Dec 1862",
      "end_date": "5 Sep 1945",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
        "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064469",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 09 Feb 1873 in Brookhaven, Lincoln, Mississippi, USA. Died 19 Dec 1949 in New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, USA.",
      "start_date": "09 Feb 1873",
      "end_date": "19 Dec 1949",
      "place": "Brookhaven, Lincoln, Mississippi, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_MARION_PFEIFER_ABRAMSON",
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_HATTIESBURG_SAWMILL_LEON_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_BROOKHAVEN_LUMBER_E_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEON_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_BROOKHAVEN_LEADER_LEON_PFEIFER_COLLEGE_1890",
        "SRC_BROOKHAVEN_LEADER_LEON_PFEIFER_BOOKKEEPER_1897"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064482",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born Oct 1879 in Morgan City, St Mary, Louisiana, USA. Died 18 May 1952 in New Orleans, Orleans, Louisiana, USA.",
      "start_date": "Oct 1879",
      "end_date": "18 May 1952",
      "place": "Morgan City, St Mary, Louisiana, USA",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_MARION_PFEIFER_ABRAMSON",
        "SRC_LA_WOMEN_IN_INDUSTRY_BERTHA_PFEIFER_1919"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064579",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 30 Apr 1916 in Hartford, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States. Died 11 Sep 2002.",
      "start_date": "30 Apr 1916",
      "end_date": "11 Sep 2002",
      "place": "Hartford, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916",
        "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_HENRIETTA_SEGEL_1916_2002"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 20 Mar 1886 in Austria. Died 19 Sep 1979 in Los Angeles, California, United States.",
      "start_date": "20 Mar 1886",
      "end_date": "19 Sep 1979",
      "place": "Austria",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NY_ADJUTANT_GENERAL_MAX_JUFFE_1917",
        "SRC_CAMP_WADSWORTH_MAX_JUFFE_INSTRUCTOR",
        "SRC_TROWS_DIRECTORY_MAX_JUFFE_ARGONNE_PRESS_1922",
        "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_MAX_JUFFE_1888_1979",
        "SRC_SPARTANBURG_LIBRARY_CAMP_WADSWORTH",
        "SRC_SPARTANBURG_CITY_CAMP_WADSWORTH_HISTORY",
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915",
        "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916",
        "SRC_VA_NATIONWIDE_GRAVESITE_MAX_JUFFE_1979",
        "SRC_NARA_MAX_JUFFE_FOURTH_DRAFT_CARD_1942",
        "SRC_GGG_NY_NATURALIZATION_MAX_JUFFE_JAFFE_SEARCH_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 6 Oct 1894 in Other Country. Died 10 Oct 1959 in Los Angeles.",
      "start_date": "6 Oct 1894",
      "end_date": "10 Oct 1959",
      "place": "Other Country",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915",
        "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064654",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 25 Jul 1853 in Ditkowce, Austria. Died 16 Oct 1924 in Connecticut, USA.",
      "start_date": "25 Jul 1853",
      "end_date": "16 Oct 1924",
      "place": "Ditkowce, Austria",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
        "SRC_CONNECTICUT_HARTFORD_SUPERIOR_DUBOWY_1915_1920",
        "SRC_GESHER_GALICIA_1900_TOWN_LOCATOR_DITKOWCE",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1916",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1917",
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_GITL_GOLDFIELD_1914"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 15 May 1856 in Galicy, Poland. Died 26 Jul 1914 in New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States.",
      "start_date": "15 May 1856",
      "end_date": "26 Jul 1914",
      "place": "Galicy, Poland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BETH_ALOM_YETTA_DUBOWY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064815",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 18 Oct 1811 in Lembach, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France. Died 12 Dec 1886 in Port Gibson, Claiborne, Mississippi, United States.",
      "start_date": "18 Oct 1811",
      "end_date": "12 Dec 1886",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_JEWISH_NAME_INDEX_LEMBACH"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064830",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 2 Jun 1814 in Lembach, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France. Died 31 Aug 1882 in Port Gibson, Mississippi.",
      "start_date": "2 Jun 1814",
      "end_date": "31 Aug 1882",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_JEWISH_NAME_INDEX_LEMBACH"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065356",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 23 Nov 1806 in Ingenheim, Sudliche Weinstrasse, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany. Died 16 May 1880 in Bergzabern, Sudliche Weinstrasse, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany.",
      "start_date": "23 Nov 1806",
      "end_date": "16 May 1880",
      "place": "Ingenheim, Sudliche Weinstrasse, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_DAVID_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065363",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 3 July 1805 in Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany. Died 1 March 1879 in Bad Bergzabern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Rheinland Pfalz, Allemagne.",
      "start_date": "3 July 1805",
      "end_date": "1 March 1879",
      "place": "Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JOHANNA_FRANK_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1771 in Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany. Died 14 Jun 1836 in Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany.",
      "start_date": "1771",
      "end_date": "14 Jun 1836",
      "place": "Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065376",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1777 in Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany. Died 6/29/1837 in Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany.",
      "start_date": "1777",
      "end_date": "6/29/1837",
      "place": "Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "person_id": "C_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_MOTHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born possibly about 1785 in possibly Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales.",
      "start_date": "possibly about 1785",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "possibly Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
        "SRC_FREEREG_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1823",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_DAVIES_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1803",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BAPTISM_SWEEP_1750_1790",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_MARRIAGE_SWEEP_1795_1820",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BURIAL_SWEEP_1785_1803",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "person_id": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Documented in the Ranton Brassington parental household; birthplace unknown",
      "start_date": "1761",
      "end_date": "1810",
      "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ranton was established as residence, not birth. Updated with probate/marriage comparison in September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "person_id": "GEN7_JANE_BRASSINGTON_MOTHER_I196",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Documented in the Ranton Brassington parental household; birthplace unknown",
      "start_date": "1761",
      "end_date": "1805",
      "place": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Ranton was established as residence, not birth. Updated with probate/marriage comparison in September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "person_id": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1 Apr 1720 in reported Germany. Died after 15 May 1780.",
      "start_date": "1 Apr 1720",
      "end_date": "after 15 May 1780",
      "place": "reported Germany",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
        "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "person_id": "C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as reported Norfolk County, Virginia. Died by 19 May 1711 in Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "by 19 May 1711",
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER",
      "person_id": "C_BERLIN_JOHANS_MAGISTER",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported about 1550 in Goppingen, Wurttemberg. Died 2 Mar 1618 in Uhingen, Wurttemberg.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1550",
      "end_date": "2 Mar 1618",
      "place": "Goppingen, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "person_id": "C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as possibly Weinsberg, Wurttemberg.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "possibly Weinsberg, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_WEINSBERG_CITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_SOUTHERN_BRANCH_D1676",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born reported circa 1614. Died between 1 Nov 1675 and 3 Jul 1676 in Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": "reported circa 1614",
      "end_date": "between 1 Nov 1675 and 3 Jul 1676",
      "place": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_RCP_SIR_WILLIAM_BUTTS",
        "SRC_BUTT_LEGEND_PROVENANCE_AUDIT_20260725",
        "SRC_VIRKUS_BUTT_PEDIGREE_1925",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ROBERT_BUTT_441",
        "SRC_CW_SARAH_BRUCE_BUTT_SAMPLER_1811",
        "SRC_BUTT_SAMPLER_REVERSE_REPORT_2000",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS",
        "SRC_GENI_ROBERT_BUTT_COMPILED_NOTES_2026",
        "SRC_PILI_9448_VIRKUS_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_BUTT_MCLURE_FAMILY_NARRATIVE_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_OC_VOL94_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_CLAIM",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_1625_20260725",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_WILLIAM_RICHARD_BUTT_BIRTH_1638_20260725",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_ROBERT_BUTT_SON_BIRTH_BRISTOL_1640_20260725",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_HENRY_BUTT_BRISTOL_1642_TIMELINE_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_LZNR_WG5",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_SARAH_JANE_SHIPP_LOWER_NORFOLK_C1642_20260725",
        "SRC_USER_HINT_THOMAS_BUTT_BRISTOL_1645_20260725",
        "SRC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_ROBERT_BUTT_BAPTISM_1616",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_PROTESTATION_1641",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS",
        "SRC_BRISTOL_ARCHIVES_SERVANTS_FOREIGN_PLANTATIONS_GUIDE",
        "SRC_VIRTUAL_JAMESTOWN_BRISTOL_BUTT_SEARCH_1654_1686",
        "SRC_JOANE_PENN_RODBOURNE_WILL_1619",
        "SRC_GREER_EARLY_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_JAMES_BUTT_1650",
        "SRC_NUGENT_CLAPHAM_RAPPAHANNOCK_PATENT_1650",
        "SRC_LVA_RESEARCH_NOTE_20_HEADRIGHTS",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_HEADRIGHT_SERVITUDE",
        "SRC_PEPYS_DIARY_WILLIAM_BUTTS_BRISTOL_1668",
        "SRC_BRISTOL_HEARTH_TAX_WILLIAM_BUTTS_ST_STEPHEN",
        "SRC_DNB_SIR_WILLIAM_BUTTS_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_WARRINGTON_PLACE_KENT",
        "SRC_CHESAPEAKE_WARRINGTON_HALL_PUD_1996",
        "SRC_BRISTOL_KYP_WARRINGTON_ROAD_MAP_SEQUENCE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Died after 1 Nov 1675 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "after 1 Nov 1675",
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BUTT_LEGEND_PROVENANCE_AUDIT_20260725",
        "SRC_VIRKUS_BUTT_PEDIGREE_1925",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ROBERT_BUTT_441",
        "SRC_CW_SARAH_BRUCE_BUTT_SAMPLER_1811",
        "SRC_BUTT_SAMPLER_REVERSE_REPORT_2000",
        "SRC_BRUCE_CUMMING_FAMILY_RECORDS_1870_EARLSHALL",
        "SRC_USER_COMPILED_ELIZABETH_BUTT_BIOGRAPHY_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "person_id": "EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 29 Nov 1610 in Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire. Died 9 Nov 1661 in Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": "29 Nov 1610",
      "end_date": "9 Nov 1661",
      "place": "Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "person_id": "EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1612 in reported Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire. Died 30 Jan 1693 in Erpfingen, Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": "about 1612",
      "end_date": "30 Jan 1693",
      "place": "reported Württemberg, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1804 in Pontefract, Yorkshire, England. Death place recorded as Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1804",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_COMPILED_PROFILE_1804_1879",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_SHREWSBURY_FLAXMILL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "person_id": "SRC_LEO_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 10 Feb 1764 in Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire. Died 30 Sep 1833 in Ingenheim, Kingdom of Bavaria.",
      "start_date": "10 Feb 1764",
      "end_date": "30 Sep 1833",
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "person_id": "SRC_ROSALI_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM_1808",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 27 Jun 1770 in Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire. Died 5 Apr 1853 in Ingenheim, Kingdom of Bavaria.",
      "start_date": "27 Jun 1770",
      "end_date": "5 Apr 1853",
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_PETERS_PRISCILLA_FRESHFORD_1707",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_PRISCILLA_FRESHFORD_1707",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born baptized 23 Jun 1707 in Freshford, Somerset, England. Death place recorded as England.",
      "start_date": "baptized 23 Jun 1707",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_ISAIAH_PETERS_1734_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_PETERS_ROBERT_FRESHFORD_FATHER_PRISCILLA",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_ROBERT_FRESHFORD_FATHER_PRISCILLA",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Freshford, Somerset, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_PETERS_ANN_FRESHFORD_MOTHER_PRISCILLA",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_ANN_FRESHFORD_MOTHER_PRISCILLA",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as Freshford, Somerset, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "person_id": "SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1818. Died 22 Nov 1893 in New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States.",
      "start_date": "about 1818",
      "end_date": "22 Nov 1893",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
        "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_COMPILED_JAMES_TRAUTMAN",
        "SRC_GARDNER_NEW_ORLEANS_DIRECTORY_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1861",
        "SRC_NOPL_OBITUARY_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born about 1827. Died 20 Sep 1916 in New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States.",
      "start_date": "about 1827",
      "end_date": "20 Sep 1916",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1916",
        "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_COMPILED_JAMES_TRAUTMAN"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_B68_ISAAK_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_1736",
      "person_id": "B68_ISAAK_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_1736",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Born 1736 in Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire. Died 11 Jul 1804 in Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": "1736",
      "end_date": "11 Jul 1804",
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_GANTRELL_RICHARD_FATHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "person_id": "C_GANTRELL_RICHARD_FATHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as reported Dorset, England. Died reported 1591 in reported Dorset, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "reported 1591",
      "place": "reported Dorset, England",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_C_GANTRELL_AVES_MOTHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "person_id": "C_GANTRELL_AVES_MOTHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Birthplace recorded as reported Dorset, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Dorset, England",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_DOCUMENTED_LIFE_SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "person_id": "SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "fact_type": "documented_life_span",
      "value": "Died 6 Jan 1940 in New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "6 Jan 1940",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_COUNCIL_CANDIDATE_1916",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_BURGLARY_1927",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_FORECLOSURE_1929",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_STORE_OPEN_1929",
        "SRC_CT_DEATH_INDEX_MORRIS_SEGEL_1940"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_ABT1626",
      "person_id": "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_ABT1626",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "about 1626",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1632_1633",
      "person_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1632_1633",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1632",
      "end_date": "1633",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1633_1633",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1633_1633",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1633",
      "end_date": "1633",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1634",
      "person_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1634",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1634",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_MARGARETHA_LINDNER_1637_1638",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_LINDNER_1637_1638",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1637",
      "end_date": "1638",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_APOLLONIA_LINDNER_1639_1639",
      "person_id": "SRC_APOLLONIA_LINDNER_1639_1639",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1639",
      "end_date": "1639",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1642_1718",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_LINDNER_1642_1718",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1642",
      "end_date": "1718",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_KASPAR_LINDNER_1642",
      "person_id": "SRC_KASPAR_LINDNER_1642",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1642",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_JOHANNES_LINDNER_1642_1722",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHANNES_LINDNER_1642_1722",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1642",
      "end_date": "1722",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_ELSBETH_LINDER_1606",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELSBETH_LINDER_1606",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1606",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_CHRISTINA_LINDER_1607",
      "person_id": "SRC_CHRISTINA_LINDER_1607",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1607",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_SALOME_LINDER_1610",
      "person_id": "SRC_SALOME_LINDER_1610",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1610",
      "end_date": "1704",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_MARTY_LINDER_JR_1611",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTY_LINDER_JR_1611",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1611",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_SIMEON_LINDER_1614",
      "person_id": "SRC_SIMEON_LINDER_1614",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1614",
      "end_date": "1683",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_NENZENHEIM_SRC_MARIA_LINDER_1616",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARIA_LINDER_1616",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded Nenzenheim setting lay in the Iphofen district, where the Reformation and Thirty Years' War left lasting local religious and demographic traces. This is community context, not evidence of individual experience.",
      "start_date": "1616",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": "Nenzenheim and Iphofen area, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_CONTEXT_MONAGHAN_C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "person_id": "C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The recorded County Monaghan setting was rural. Local histories record a long association of small farms and household linen production; this setting does not identify this person's occupation.",
      "start_date": "about 1800-1810",
      "end_date": "about 1890",
      "place": "County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVID_BOYD_PROFILE_1800_1810_1890",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GRIFFITHS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_SAMUEL_SARAH",
        "SRC_COOLMAIN_LANDED_ESTATES_LOCALITY",
        "SRC_MONAGHAN_1930_1935_BOYD_COOLMAIN_LATER_CLUSTER"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I72",
      "person_id": "I72",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 1725 in Norfolk, Virginia, US; a death reported 1772.",
      "start_date": "reported 1725",
      "end_date": "reported 1772",
      "place": "Norfolk, Virginia, US",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I73",
      "person_id": "I73",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 1720 in Norfolk, Virginia, US; a death reported 1772.",
      "start_date": "reported 1720",
      "end_date": "reported 1772",
      "place": "Norfolk, Virginia, US",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I111",
      "person_id": "I111",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 1670 in Göda, Saxony, DE; a death reported 1770 in Offenbach, Darmstadt, Hessen, DE.",
      "start_date": "reported 1670",
      "end_date": "reported 1770",
      "place": "Göda, Saxony, DE",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I112",
      "person_id": "I112",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 1673.",
      "start_date": "reported 1673",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
        "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I113",
      "person_id": "I113",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 1704; a death reported 1753.",
      "start_date": "reported 1704",
      "end_date": "reported 1753",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.64,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I114",
      "person_id": "I114",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1706; a death reported 1762.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1706",
      "end_date": "reported 1762",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I115",
      "person_id": "I115",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported before 1665 in reported Virginia.",
      "start_date": "reported before 1665",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Virginia",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I116",
      "person_id": "I116",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported before 1665 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia; a death reported before 1711 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": "reported before 1665",
      "end_date": "reported before 1711",
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I117",
      "person_id": "I117",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1678 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia; a death reported before 21 May 1731 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1678",
      "end_date": "reported before 21 May 1731",
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I118",
      "person_id": "I118",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1680 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia; a death reported about 1730 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1680",
      "end_date": "reported about 1730",
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.38,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I131",
      "person_id": "I131",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 1610 in reported Edinburgh, Scotland; a death reported 1716 in reported Edinburgh, Scotland.",
      "start_date": "reported 1610",
      "end_date": "reported 1716",
      "place": "reported Edinburgh, Scotland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I132",
      "person_id": "I132",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1610 in reported Midlothian, Scotland.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1610",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_MIDLOTHIAN_RECORD_GUIDE",
        "SRC_NRS_OLD_PARISH_REGISTER_COVERAGE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I133",
      "person_id": "I133",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1558 in Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland; a death place of Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland.",
      "start_date": "about 1558",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I135",
      "person_id": "I135",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1538 in Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland; a death about 1610 in Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland.",
      "start_date": "about 1538",
      "end_date": "about 1610",
      "place": "Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.28,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I234",
      "person_id": "I234",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 1670 in Prince George's County, Maryland, US; a death reported 1728 in Prince George's County, Maryland, US.",
      "start_date": "reported 1670",
      "end_date": "reported 1728",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, US",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I235",
      "person_id": "I235",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 1666 in Prince George's County, Maryland, US; a death reported 1 May 1751.",
      "start_date": "reported 1666",
      "end_date": "reported 1 May 1751",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, US",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I236",
      "person_id": "I236",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 1650 in reported Charles County, Maryland; a death reported 1683.",
      "start_date": "reported 1650",
      "end_date": "reported 1683",
      "place": "reported Charles County, Maryland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.46,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_CHRONOLOGY",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I237",
      "person_id": "I237",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 1636 in reported England; a death reported 1683 in reported Charles County, Maryland.",
      "start_date": "reported 1636",
      "end_date": "reported 1683",
      "place": "reported England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.52,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I246",
      "person_id": "I246",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1551 in reported Erpfingen area, Wurttemberg.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1551",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Erpfingen area, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_I247",
      "person_id": "I247",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1550 in reported Erpfingen area, Wurttemberg; a death reported 1627.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1550",
      "end_date": "reported 1627",
      "place": "reported Erpfingen area, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_BRASSINGTON_ELLEN_1686",
      "person_id": "C_BRASSINGTON_ELLEN_1686",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1686 in Great Longstone, Derbyshire, England.",
      "start_date": "1686",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Great Longstone, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.05,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_ANCESTRY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_MCNEW_MARY_LUCY_1709",
      "person_id": "C_MCNEW_MARY_LUCY_1709",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 8 FEB 1708/09 in Prince George's County, Maryland; a death about 1762.",
      "start_date": "8 FEB 1708/09",
      "end_date": "about 1762",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_MCNEW_ANNE_1711",
      "person_id": "C_MCNEW_ANNE_1711",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 8 NOV 1711 in Prince George's County, Maryland; a death after NOV 1774.",
      "start_date": "8 NOV 1711",
      "end_date": "after NOV 1774",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_MCNEW_EDWARD_MARLEY_1713",
      "person_id": "C_MCNEW_EDWARD_MARLEY_1713",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 14 AUG 1713 in Prince George's County, Maryland; a death 1791.",
      "start_date": "14 AUG 1713",
      "end_date": "1791",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_HANNY_JAMES_1844",
      "person_id": "C_HANNY_JAMES_1844",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1844 in Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England; a death 1845 in Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1844",
      "end_date": "1845",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_HANNY_SARAH_1798",
      "person_id": "C_HANNY_SARAH_1798",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 9 MAY 1798.",
      "start_date": "9 MAY 1798",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_GENI_WILLIAM",
        "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_CHILD_RECORD",
        "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_SELECT_BIRTHS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_RHEAD_STEPHEN_HENRY_1836",
      "person_id": "C_RHEAD_STEPHEN_HENRY_1836",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1835 in reported Staffordshire, England; a death reported 1890 in reported Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1835",
      "end_date": "reported 1890",
      "place": "reported Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.91,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG",
        "SRC_RHEAD_YOURROOTS_STEPhen"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1644.",
      "start_date": "about 1644",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "person_id": "C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1648.",
      "start_date": "about 1648",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "person_id": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1701.",
      "start_date": "about 1701",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELISHA_I_MCNEW_1746_JAN_1804",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1746; a death Jan 1804.",
      "start_date": "1746",
      "end_date": "Jan 1804",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_NANCY_CATHERINE_SMITH_12_OCT_1756_14_SEP",
      "person_id": "HV4_NANCY_CATHERINE_SMITH_12_OCT_1756_14_SEP",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 12 Oct 1756; a death 14 Sep 1841.",
      "start_date": "12 Oct 1756",
      "end_date": "14 Sep 1841",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_SHADRACK_MCNEW_1743_1823",
      "person_id": "HV4_SHADRACK_MCNEW_1743_1823",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1743; a death 1823.",
      "start_date": "1743",
      "end_date": "1823",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_GEORGE_E_MCNEW_SR_17_NOV_1763_5_MAY_1846",
      "person_id": "HV4_GEORGE_E_MCNEW_SR_17_NOV_1763_5_MAY_1846",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 17 Nov 1763; a death 5 May 1846.",
      "start_date": "17 Nov 1763",
      "end_date": "5 May 1846",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_EDWARD_MCNEW_FALL_1755",
      "person_id": "HV4_EDWARD_MCNEW_FALL_1755",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth Fall 1755.",
      "start_date": "Fall 1755",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_DANIEL_SHADRACK_MCNEW_1745_1765",
      "person_id": "HV4_DANIEL_SHADRACK_MCNEW_1745_1765",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1745; a death 1765.",
      "start_date": "1745",
      "end_date": "1765",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_MARY_POLLY_MCNEW_1779_BEFORE_1810",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARY_POLLY_MCNEW_1779_BEFORE_1810",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1779; a death before 1810.",
      "start_date": "1779",
      "end_date": "before 1810",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_MCNEW_1785_1794_1820",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1785-1794; a death 1820.",
      "start_date": "1785-1794",
      "end_date": "1820",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_REBECCA_MCNEW_ABOUT_1781_BEFORE_1812",
      "person_id": "HV4_REBECCA_MCNEW_ABOUT_1781_BEFORE_1812",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1781; a death before 1812.",
      "start_date": "about 1781",
      "end_date": "before 1812",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_CATHERINE_MCNEW_1783_9_JUN_1858",
      "person_id": "HV4_CATHERINE_MCNEW_1783_9_JUN_1858",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1783; a death 9 Jun 1858.",
      "start_date": "1783",
      "end_date": "9 Jun 1858",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_TOBIAS_MCNEW_1785_FEB_1814",
      "person_id": "HV4_TOBIAS_MCNEW_1785_FEB_1814",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1785; a death Feb 1814.",
      "start_date": "1785",
      "end_date": "Feb 1814",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_WILLIAM_J_MCNEW_1786_1839",
      "person_id": "HV4_WILLIAM_J_MCNEW_1786_1839",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1786; a death 1839.",
      "start_date": "1786",
      "end_date": "1839",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ELISHA_MCNEW_13_SEP_1788_26_AUG_1854",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELISHA_MCNEW_13_SEP_1788_26_AUG_1854",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 13 Sep 1788; a death 26 Aug 1854.",
      "start_date": "13 Sep 1788",
      "end_date": "26 Aug 1854",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_NANCY_MCNEW_1790_BETWEEN_1860_AND_1870",
      "person_id": "HV4_NANCY_MCNEW_1790_BETWEEN_1860_AND_1870",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1790; a death between 1860 and 1870.",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "between 1860 and 1870",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_GEORGE_MCNEW_ABOUT_1792_1_OCT_1828",
      "person_id": "HV4_GEORGE_MCNEW_ABOUT_1792_1_OCT_1828",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1792; a death 1 Oct 1828.",
      "start_date": "about 1792",
      "end_date": "1 Oct 1828",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ISAAC_MCNEW_1795_20_OCT_1819",
      "person_id": "HV4_ISAAC_MCNEW_1795_20_OCT_1819",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1795; a death 20 Oct 1819.",
      "start_date": "1795",
      "end_date": "20 Oct 1819",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ELIZABETH_BETSY_MCNEW_21_APR_1797_1_JAN_",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_BETSY_MCNEW_21_APR_1797_1_JAN_",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 21 Apr 1797; a death 1 Jan 1855.",
      "start_date": "21 Apr 1797",
      "end_date": "1 Jan 1855",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_MARGARET_MCNEW_1799_1840",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARGARET_MCNEW_1799_1840",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1799; a death 1840.",
      "start_date": "1799",
      "end_date": "1840",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_LUCY_WALKER_BET_1785_AND_1794_BEFORE_180",
      "person_id": "HV4_LUCY_WALKER_BET_1785_AND_1794_BEFORE_180",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth Bet 1785 and 1794; a death before 1806.",
      "start_date": "Bet 1785 and 1794",
      "end_date": "before 1806",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_SARAH_CATHERINE_SMITH_1790_5_APR_1883",
      "person_id": "HV4_SARAH_CATHERINE_SMITH_1790_5_APR_1883",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1790; a death 5 Apr 1883.",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "5 Apr 1883",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780",
      "person_id": "HV4_SARAH_ATHEY_1780",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1780.",
      "start_date": "1780",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1798 in reported Washington County, Virginia, United States; a death before 1847 in reported Brown County, Illinois, United States.",
      "start_date": "1798",
      "end_date": "before 1847",
      "place": "reported Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1798_LUKE_PERRY",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_MCNEW_SARAH_ATHEY_F14178",
        "SRC_GENEALOGYTRAILS_PERRY_CEMETERY_ELISHA_1818_1889",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_LUKE_PERRY_ELIZABETH_WHITE_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_MARTHA_MCNEW_7_APR_1812_3_NOV_1877",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARTHA_MCNEW_7_APR_1812_3_NOV_1877",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 7 Apr 1812; a death 3 Nov 1877.",
      "start_date": "7 Apr 1812",
      "end_date": "3 Nov 1877",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_FREDERICK_J_MCNEW_1813_ABOUT_1872",
      "person_id": "HV4_FREDERICK_J_MCNEW_1813_ABOUT_1872",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1813; a death about 1872.",
      "start_date": "1813",
      "end_date": "about 1872",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_SARAH_JANE_MCNEW_ABOUT_1817_POSSIBLY_186",
      "person_id": "HV4_SARAH_JANE_MCNEW_ABOUT_1817_POSSIBLY_186",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1817; a death possibly 1863.",
      "start_date": "about 1817",
      "end_date": "possibly 1863",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "person_id": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1810-1820; a death 15 Oct 1862 in Henry County, Missouri, United States.",
      "start_date": "1810-1820",
      "end_date": "15 Oct 1862",
      "place": "Henry County, Missouri, United States",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_HUGH_MCNEW_ABOUT_1841",
      "person_id": "HV4_HUGH_MCNEW_ABOUT_1841",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1841.",
      "start_date": "about 1841",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_NANCY_MCNEW_DAUGHTER_OF_JOHN_S_ABOUT_184",
      "person_id": "HV4_NANCY_MCNEW_DAUGHTER_OF_JOHN_S_ABOUT_184",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1844.",
      "start_date": "about 1844",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_WILLIAM_MCNEW_SON_OF_JOHN_S_1845",
      "person_id": "HV4_WILLIAM_MCNEW_SON_OF_JOHN_S_1845",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1845.",
      "start_date": "1845",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_JOHN_BISER_MCNEW_OCT_1846_2_MAR_1919",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_BISER_MCNEW_OCT_1846_2_MAR_1919",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth Oct 1846; a death 2 Mar 1919.",
      "start_date": "Oct 1846",
      "end_date": "2 Mar 1919",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_HENRY_MCNEW_22_JAN_1848_31_DEC_1848",
      "person_id": "HV4_HENRY_MCNEW_22_JAN_1848_31_DEC_1848",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 22 Jan 1848; a death 31 Dec 1848.",
      "start_date": "22 Jan 1848",
      "end_date": "31 Dec 1848",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_FREDERICK_MCNEW_ABOUT_1849_ON_OR_BEFORE_",
      "person_id": "HV4_FREDERICK_MCNEW_ABOUT_1849_ON_OR_BEFORE_",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1849; a death on or before 1890.",
      "start_date": "about 1849",
      "end_date": "on or before 1890",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ELISHA_MCNEIL_ABOUT_1851",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELISHA_MCNEIL_ABOUT_1851",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1851.",
      "start_date": "about 1851",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_JAMES_R_MCNEW_ABOUT_1853",
      "person_id": "HV4_JAMES_R_MCNEW_ABOUT_1853",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1853.",
      "start_date": "about 1853",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_MARY_MCNEW_DAUGHTER_OF_JOHN_S_ABOUT_1853",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARY_MCNEW_DAUGHTER_OF_JOHN_S_ABOUT_1853",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1853.",
      "start_date": "about 1853",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_SUSAN_A_MCNEW_ABOUT_1856",
      "person_id": "HV4_SUSAN_A_MCNEW_ABOUT_1856",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1856.",
      "start_date": "about 1856",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_SALLY_A_MCNEW_ABOUT_1857",
      "person_id": "HV4_SALLY_A_MCNEW_ABOUT_1857",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1857.",
      "start_date": "about 1857",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_TOBIAS_SMITH_16_MAR_1725_1781",
      "person_id": "HV4_TOBIAS_SMITH_16_MAR_1725_1781",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 16 Mar 1725; a death 1781.",
      "start_date": "16 Mar 1725",
      "end_date": "1781",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_MARY_MCDONALD_19_JAN_1730_1809",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARY_MCDONALD_19_JAN_1730_1809",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 19 Jan 1730; a death 1809.",
      "start_date": "19 Jan 1730",
      "end_date": "1809",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_HANS_JURGEN_GEORG_SMITH_SMIDT_3_NOV_1696",
      "person_id": "HV4_HANS_JURGEN_GEORG_SMITH_SMIDT_3_NOV_1696",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 3 Nov 1696.",
      "start_date": "3 Nov 1696",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_MARIA_STALLKOP_15_MAR_1697_19_NOV_1750",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARIA_STALLKOP_15_MAR_1697_19_NOV_1750",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 15 Mar 1697; a death 19 Nov 1750.",
      "start_date": "15 Mar 1697",
      "end_date": "19 Nov 1750",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_PETER_STALLKOP_ABOUT_3_SEP_1709",
      "person_id": "HV4_PETER_STALLKOP_ABOUT_3_SEP_1709",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "Peter was alive when his will was dated 3 September 1709 and had died by its probate on 16 May 1710.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "between 3 Sep 1709 and 16 May 1710",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWCASTLE_WILL_INDEX"
      ],
      "source_note": "Corrects the former use of the will date as an approximate death date; based on the probate index, not an inspected manuscript."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_BRYAN_MCDONALD_NOV_1686_21_MAY_1757",
      "person_id": "HV4_BRYAN_MCDONALD_NOV_1686_21_MAY_1757",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth Nov 1686; a death 21 May 1757.",
      "start_date": "Nov 1686",
      "end_date": "21 May 1757",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_CATHERINE_PRISCILLA_ROBINSON_ABOUT_1694_",
      "person_id": "HV4_CATHERINE_PRISCILLA_ROBINSON_ABOUT_1694_",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1694; a death after May 1766.",
      "start_date": "about 1694",
      "end_date": "after May 1766",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_JOHN_QUEEN_ATHEY_24_MAY_1756_1831",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_QUEEN_ATHEY_24_MAY_1756_1831",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 24 May 1756; a death 1831.",
      "start_date": "24 May 1756",
      "end_date": "1831",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_THOMAS_ATHEY_14_FEB_1717_AFTER_1766",
      "person_id": "HV4_THOMAS_ATHEY_14_FEB_1717_AFTER_1766",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 14 Feb 1717; a death after 1766.",
      "start_date": "14 Feb 1717",
      "end_date": "after 1766",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ELINOR_LUCILLE_QUEEN_1716_BETWEEN_1769_A",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELINOR_LUCILLE_QUEEN_1716_BETWEEN_1769_A",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1716; a death between 1769 and 1773.",
      "start_date": "1716",
      "end_date": "between 1769 and 1773",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth before 1703; a death 28 Oct 1771.",
      "start_date": "before 1703",
      "end_date": "28 Oct 1771",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARY_JAMESON_ABOUT_1704_AFTER_1755",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1704; a death after 1755.",
      "start_date": "about 1704",
      "end_date": "after 1755",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_SARAH_QUEEN_ABOUT_1741",
      "person_id": "HV4_SARAH_QUEEN_ABOUT_1741",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1741.",
      "start_date": "about 1741",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_MARGARET_QUEEN_ABOUT_1746",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARGARET_QUEEN_ABOUT_1746",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1746.",
      "start_date": "about 1746",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ELIZABETH_QUEEN_BEFORE_1745",
      "person_id": "HV4_ELIZABETH_QUEEN_BEFORE_1745",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth before 1745.",
      "start_date": "before 1745",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_SAMUEL_QUEEN_ABOUT_1735",
      "person_id": "HV4_SAMUEL_QUEEN_ABOUT_1735",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1735.",
      "start_date": "about 1735",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_LEONARD_QUEEN_ABOUT_1732",
      "person_id": "HV4_LEONARD_QUEEN_ABOUT_1732",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1732.",
      "start_date": "about 1732",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_CLEMENTINE_QUEEN_ABOUT_1738",
      "person_id": "HV4_CLEMENTINE_QUEEN_ABOUT_1738",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1738.",
      "start_date": "about 1738",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_WILLIAM_QUEEN_1726",
      "person_id": "HV4_WILLIAM_QUEEN_1726",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1726.",
      "start_date": "1726",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_RICHARD_QUEEN_1725",
      "person_id": "HV4_RICHARD_QUEEN_1725",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1725.",
      "start_date": "1725",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_DOROTHY_SHAW_ABOUT_1668",
      "person_id": "HV4_DOROTHY_SHAW_ABOUT_1668",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1668.",
      "start_date": "about 1668",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_MARY_MARLOW_ABOUT_1667",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARY_MARLOW_ABOUT_1667",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1667.",
      "start_date": "about 1667",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_JOHN_MARLOW_ABOUT_1676",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_MARLOW_ABOUT_1676",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1676.",
      "start_date": "about 1676",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_BARTHOLOMEW_MARLOW_ABOUT_1680",
      "person_id": "HV4_BARTHOLOMEW_MARLOW_ABOUT_1680",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1680.",
      "start_date": "about 1680",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ANNE_MARLOW_ABOUT_1681",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANNE_MARLOW_ABOUT_1681",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1681.",
      "start_date": "about 1681",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_SUSANNAH_MARLOW_1678",
      "person_id": "HV4_SUSANNAH_MARLOW_1678",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1678.",
      "start_date": "1678",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_WILLIAM_MARLOW_1668_10_MAY_1668",
      "person_id": "HV4_WILLIAM_MARLOW_1668_10_MAY_1668",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 10 May 1668.",
      "start_date": "10 May 1668",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ANTHONY_MCNEW_MCKNEW_ABOUT_1670",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANTHONY_MCNEW_MCKNEW_ABOUT_1670",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1670.",
      "start_date": "about 1670",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.42,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_LOMAX_MCNEW_MCKNEW_ABOUT_1675",
      "person_id": "HV4_LOMAX_MCNEW_MCKNEW_ABOUT_1675",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1675.",
      "start_date": "about 1675",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_JOHANN_PHILIP_GABEL_14_AUG_1698",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHANN_PHILIP_GABEL_14_AUG_1698",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 14 Aug 1698 in Germany.",
      "start_date": "14 Aug 1698",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ANNA_CATHARINA_GABEL_19_MAR_1726",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANNA_CATHARINA_GABEL_19_MAR_1726",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 19 Mar 1726.",
      "start_date": "19 Mar 1726",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_JOHANN_PHILLIP_GABEL_3_APR_1730",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHANN_PHILLIP_GABEL_3_APR_1730",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 3 Apr 1730.",
      "start_date": "3 Apr 1730",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_JOHN_NICHOLAS_GABEL_ABOUT_1744",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_NICHOLAS_GABEL_ABOUT_1744",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1744.",
      "start_date": "about 1744",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_JOHN_JOHANN_GEORGE_GABEL_17_FEB_1758",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_JOHANN_GEORGE_GABEL_17_FEB_1758",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 17 Feb 1758.",
      "start_date": "17 Feb 1758",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_JOHN_GOBBLE_1744_10_APR_1744",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_GOBBLE_1744_10_APR_1744",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 10 Apr 1744.",
      "start_date": "10 Apr 1744",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "person_id": "HV4_GEORGE_WEIGEL",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1714.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1714",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANNA_MARGARET_DITLICH",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1718.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1718",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about October 1622 in reported Baden, Holy Roman Empire; a death reported 2 May 1693 in reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": "reported about October 1622",
      "end_date": "reported 2 May 1693",
      "place": "reported Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 1628 in reported Holy Roman Empire; a death reported 22 Oct 1678 in reported Baden, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": "reported 1628",
      "end_date": "reported 22 Oct 1678",
      "place": "reported Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1582 in reported Saanen, Bern, Switzerland; a death reported 1615 in reported Canton Bern, Switzerland.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1582",
      "end_date": "reported 1615",
      "place": "reported Saanen, Bern, Switzerland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "person_id": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1585 in reported Saanen, Bern, Switzerland; a death reported 1652 in reported Canton Bern, Switzerland.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1585",
      "end_date": "reported 1652",
      "place": "reported Saanen, Bern, Switzerland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_BALTHASS_FUCHS_1595",
      "person_id": "SRC_BALTHASS_FUCHS_1595",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1595; a death deceased.",
      "start_date": "1595",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHANNES_FUCHS_1602",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHANNES_FUCHS_1602",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1602; a death deceased.",
      "start_date": "1602",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_BARBARA_FUCHS_1604",
      "person_id": "SRC_BARBARA_FUCHS_1604",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1604; a death deceased.",
      "start_date": "1604",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_VEIT_FUCHS_1606",
      "person_id": "SRC_VEIT_FUCHS_1606",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1606; a death deceased.",
      "start_date": "1606",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_MARIA_FUCHS_1608",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARIA_FUCHS_1608",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1608; a death deceased.",
      "start_date": "1608",
      "end_date": "deceased",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.66,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_WIKITREE_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "person_id": "C_WIKITREE_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1730 in Milwich, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1730",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_SAMPSON",
      "person_id": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_SAMPSON",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1689; a death 1763 in Milwich, Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1689",
      "end_date": "1763",
      "place": "Milwich, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_PROFILE",
        "SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_BURIAL_1763_MILWICH_FS_QL7Z_CMKN"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_WIKITREE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_HANDLEY",
      "person_id": "C_WIKITREE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_HANDLEY",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1691 in Rowley Regis, Staffordshire, England; a death 26 Aug 1758.",
      "start_date": "about 1691",
      "end_date": "26 Aug 1758",
      "place": "Rowley Regis, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_WIKITREE_MARY_ALKIN_CARTWRIGHT",
      "person_id": "C_WIKITREE_MARY_ALKIN_CARTWRIGHT",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a death about 1710 in Uttoxeter, Stafford, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "about 1710",
      "place": "Uttoxeter, Stafford, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_ALKIN_BURIAL_1710_UTTOXETER"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1821 in Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany.",
      "start_date": "about 1821",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_1880_JOHN_SCHAAF_NEWARK"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_GONDER_ANNA_ELISABETHA_1822",
      "person_id": "C_GONDER_ANNA_ELISABETHA_1822",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 2 Feb 1822 in Obergleen, Oberhessen, Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany.",
      "start_date": "2 Feb 1822",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Obergleen, Oberhessen, Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_GONDER_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "person_id": "C_GONDER_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 17 Jul 1801 in Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany; a death 4 Jan 1871 in Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany.",
      "start_date": "17 Jul 1801",
      "end_date": "4 Jan 1871",
      "place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHANN_CASPAR_GONDER",
        "SRC_JOHANN_CASPAR_GONDER_BAPTISM_DEATH_1801_1871"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_GONTER_BARBARA_CATHARINA",
      "person_id": "C_GONTER_BARBARA_CATHARINA",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 4 Jun 1762 in Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany; a death 2 Mar 1837 in Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany.",
      "start_date": "4 Jun 1762",
      "end_date": "2 Mar 1837",
      "place": "Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_UNNAMED_BAPTISM_1762",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BARBARA_KATHERINA_GONDER"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_SCHAAF_ELIZABETH_ABT1823",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_ELIZABETH_ABT1823",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1823 in Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany.",
      "start_date": "about 1823",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_SCHAAF_JUSTIN_ABT1854",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_JUSTIN_ABT1854",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1854 in New Jersey, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1854",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Jersey, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_SCHAAF_ELIZZIE_ABT1858",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_ELIZZIE_ABT1858",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1858 in New Jersey, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1858",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "New Jersey, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "person_id": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1820-1826.",
      "start_date": "about 1820-1826",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_DEATH_1882",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS",
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_PHELPS_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_VIRGINIA_F_PHELPS_1854",
      "person_id": "SRC_VIRGINIA_F_PHELPS_1854",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1853-1855 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1853-1855",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_NEWTON_PHELPS_1857",
      "person_id": "SRC_NEWTON_PHELPS_1857",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1856-1858 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1856-1858",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_LOWCRESA_HENDERSON_1862",
      "person_id": "SRC_LOWCRESA_HENDERSON_1862",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1862 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1862",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_AMANDA_HENDERSON_1864",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMANDA_HENDERSON_1864",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1864 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1864",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_JAMES_HENDERSON_1862",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_HENDERSON_1862",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1862 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1862",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of possibly Virginia, USA; a death about 1843 in Giles County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "about 1843",
      "place": "possibly Virginia, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1843_JOHN_R_HENDERSON_GILES_PROBATE",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_GILES_COUNTY_MICROFILM"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1821 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1821",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHN_HOWARD_MACKNEW_CHILD_JEREMIAH",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_HOWARD_MACKNEW_CHILD_JEREMIAH",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1660; a death about 1696 in Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America.",
      "start_date": "about 1660",
      "end_date": "about 1696",
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
        "SRC_PROFILE_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JEREMIAH_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "person_id": "C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1518; a death 1550.",
      "start_date": "1518",
      "end_date": "1550",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.08,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_EARLY_RECORD_GUIDE",
        "SRC_MCNEW_HISTORY_BOWMAN_THOMAS_1997",
        "SRC_MCNEW_MEMORABILIA_CARROLL_1998",
        "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_REDDIT_MACKNEW_SCOTLAND_QUERY_2021",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_1722",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1722 in Westmoreland County, Virginia, British Colonial America; a death reported 15 Jun 1779 in reported in the Kentucky District of Virginia, near later Hopkinsville, Kentucky.",
      "start_date": "about 1722",
      "end_date": "reported 15 Jun 1779",
      "place": "Westmoreland County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_AMELIA_1765_FATHER_1742",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1695 in reported Oldhams, Westmoreland County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1695",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Oldhams, Westmoreland County, Virginia",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_GRACE_ELIZABETH_HARGIS",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1690-1699 in Virginia, British Colonial America (reported Westmoreland or New Kent County); a death reported 10 Aug 1778 or 1790 in reported Washington County, Virginia, or unspecified.",
      "start_date": "about 1690-1699",
      "end_date": "reported 10 Aug 1778 or 1790",
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America (reported Westmoreland or New Kent County)",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_AGBI_GRACE_BOSWELL_1690S_VIRGINIA",
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_HENDERSON_JOHN_ALLOA_1787_GILES_1843",
      "person_id": "C_HENDERSON_JOHN_ALLOA_1787_GILES_1843",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported 27 May 1787 in Scotland (reported Alloa, Clackmannanshire).",
      "start_date": "reported 27 May 1787",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Scotland (reported Alloa, Clackmannanshire)",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_JOHN_READ_FATHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_READ_FATHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_READ_PERRY_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPT_1750",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1755",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOSEPH_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1759",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_SARAH_READ_MOTHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "person_id": "SRC_SARAH_READ_MOTHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of Staffordshire, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_READ_PERRY_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPT_1750",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1755",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOSEPH_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1759",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "person_id": "C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1800-1810 in Coolmain, County Monaghan, Ireland; a death about 1890.",
      "start_date": "about 1800-1810",
      "end_date": "about 1890",
      "place": "Coolmain, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVID_BOYD_PROFILE_1800_1810_1890",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GRIFFITHS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_SAMUEL_SARAH",
        "SRC_COOLMAIN_LANDED_ESTATES_LOCALITY",
        "SRC_MONAGHAN_1930_1935_BOYD_COOLMAIN_LATER_CLUSTER"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_ISABEL_HENDERSON_SC_1790",
      "person_id": "C_ISABEL_HENDERSON_SC_1790",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1790 in South Carolina or Scotland.",
      "start_date": "about 1790",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "South Carolina or Scotland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1655; a death reported Sep 1718 in reported Elizabeth City County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1655",
      "end_date": "reported Sep 1718",
      "place": "reported Elizabeth City County, Virginia",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.52,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_ELIZABETH_CITY_COUNTY_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064357",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth Abt 1770 in Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany; a death Aft. 1835 in Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany.",
      "start_date": "Abt 1770",
      "end_date": "Aft. 1835",
      "place": "Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 02 Oct 1774 in Kyritz; a death 1835 in Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany.",
      "start_date": "02 Oct 1774",
      "end_date": "1835",
      "place": "Kyritz",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE",
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth ABT 1750 in Kusel, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany; a death 14 May 1857 in Mehlingen, Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany.",
      "start_date": "ABT 1750",
      "end_date": "14 May 1857",
      "place": "Kusel, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.4,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1740; a death place of Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany.",
      "start_date": "1740",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 21 Sep 1833 in Niederhochstadt, Bavaria, German Confederation; a death 1917 in reported Bergzabern, present-day Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany.",
      "start_date": "21 Sep 1833",
      "end_date": "1917",
      "place": "Niederhochstadt, Bavaria, German Confederation",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_BROOKHAVEN_LUMBER_E_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_APERTUS_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_REGISTER_SEARCH_20260725",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_HOCHSTADT_HANAU_JEWISH_REGISTERS_REJECTED_FOR_PFEIFER",
        "SRC_COCALICO_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_1781_WILL_REJECTED"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 5 Jan 1845 in Ingenheim, Bavaria, German Confederation; a death 18 May 1918 in Bad Bergzabern, Bavaria, Germany.",
      "start_date": "5 Jan 1845",
      "end_date": "18 May 1918",
      "place": "Ingenheim, Bavaria, German Confederation",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_PFEIFER_RAHEL_1845",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064673",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064673",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth approx 1830? in Austria (now Poland); a death 1894.",
      "start_date": "approx 1830?",
      "end_date": "1894",
      "place": "Austria (now Poland)",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1851-1852 in reported Metz, Moselle, France; a death 5 Jun 1924 in New Orleans, Louisiana.",
      "start_date": "about 1851-1852",
      "end_date": "5 Jun 1924",
      "place": "reported Metz, Moselle, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_1870_ANNEXATION",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_ANNEXATION_EMIGRATION",
        "SRC_ISJL_MORGAN_CITY_JEWISH_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ST_MARY_BANNER_LEON_CAHN_LAND_CHAIN_1909",
        "SRC_LA_SOS_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_CAHN_1924",
        "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1851_CAHEN_INDEX_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1852_CAHN_NEGATIVE_CHECK",
        "SRC_METZ_ARCHIVES_GENEALOGY_PORTAL"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064803",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth Oct 1860 in St Mary Parish, Louisiana; a death 20 Mar 1917 in New Orleans, Louisiana.",
      "start_date": "Oct 1860",
      "end_date": "20 Mar 1917",
      "place": "St Mary Parish, Louisiana",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064849",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth ABT 1766 in Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France; a death 26 JAN 1856 in Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France.",
      "start_date": "ABT 1766",
      "end_date": "26 JAN 1856",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth abt 1770; a death 28 JUN 1824 in Lembach  (Bas-Rhin) France.",
      "start_date": "abt 1770",
      "end_date": "28 JUN 1824",
      "place": "Lembach  (Bas-Rhin) France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064856",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1785 in Lembach, Bas-rhin, France; a death 17 Oct 1867 in Evansville, Vanderburgh, IN.",
      "start_date": "1785",
      "end_date": "17 Oct 1867",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-rhin, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064868",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1790 in Lembach, Bas-rhin, France; a death June 23, 1847 in Wissembourg, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France.",
      "start_date": "1790",
      "end_date": "June 23, 1847",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-rhin, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064878",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth Abt 1773 in Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France; a death 14 Aug 1853 in Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France.",
      "start_date": "Abt 1773",
      "end_date": "14 Aug 1853",
      "place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth Abt. 1770 in Alsace, France; a death Abt. 1860 in Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France.",
      "start_date": "Abt. 1770",
      "end_date": "Abt. 1860",
      "place": "Alsace, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth Abt. 1736 in Gunstett, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France; a death 6 Aug 1809 in Gunstett, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France.",
      "start_date": "Abt. 1736",
      "end_date": "6 Aug 1809",
      "place": "Gunstett, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1827 in Metz, Departement de la Moselle, Lorraine, France; a death 1 November 1874.",
      "start_date": "1827",
      "end_date": "1 November 1874",
      "place": "Metz, Departement de la Moselle, Lorraine, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRENCH_CITIZENSHIP_OPTANT_MICHEL_COGUENHEM_1872",
        "SRC_ARCHIVES_ALSACE_OPTANTS_CONTEXT",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_1870_ANNEXATION",
        "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_ANNEXATION_EMIGRATION"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth abt 1839 in Bavaria, Germany.",
      "start_date": "abt 1839",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth abt 1765 in Lembach, Bas-rhin, France; a death BEF 1836 in Alsace, France.",
      "start_date": "abt 1765",
      "end_date": "BEF 1836",
      "place": "Lembach, Bas-rhin, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_EVANSVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_1849_PRESENT"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065075",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1761 in Wissembourg, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France; a death 12 Apr 1817 in Lembach, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France.",
      "start_date": "1761",
      "end_date": "12 Apr 1817",
      "place": "Wissembourg, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1750 in Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France; a death 23 Feb 1806 in Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France.",
      "start_date": "1750",
      "end_date": "23 Feb 1806",
      "place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065098",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1755; a death Bef. 1809 in Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France.",
      "start_date": "1755",
      "end_date": "Bef. 1809",
      "place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065157",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1720 in Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France; a death 1801 in Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France.",
      "start_date": "1720",
      "end_date": "1801",
      "place": "Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1732 in Romanswiller, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France; a death AFT 30 NOV 1784.",
      "start_date": "1732",
      "end_date": "AFT 30 NOV 1784",
      "place": "Romanswiller, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROMANSWILLER_RECORDS_RESEARCH_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1690 in Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France; a death 1762 in Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France.",
      "start_date": "1690",
      "end_date": "1762",
      "place": "Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_GENAMI_ALSACE_1784_CENSUS_DATABASE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth ABT 1690 in Wintzenheim, Haut-Rhin, Alsace, France; a death abt 1760.",
      "start_date": "ABT 1690",
      "end_date": "abt 1760",
      "place": "Wintzenheim, Haut-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth ABT 1695 in Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France; a death Abt. 1760 in Otrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France.",
      "start_date": "ABT 1695",
      "end_date": "Abt. 1760",
      "place": "Ottrott, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth Abt 1725.",
      "start_date": "Abt 1725",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth Abt. 1729 in Oberlustadt, Rheinpfalz, Bavaria, Germany; a death 1807 in Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany.",
      "start_date": "Abt. 1729",
      "end_date": "1807",
      "place": "Oberlustadt, Rheinpfalz, Bavaria, Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1726 in Lustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany; a death 15 Nov 1820 in Oberlustadt, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany.",
      "start_date": "1726",
      "end_date": "15 Nov 1820",
      "place": "Lustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 1780; a death place of Donaldsonville, Ascension Parish, Louisiana, USA.",
      "start_date": "1780",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Donaldsonville, Ascension Parish, Louisiana, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.48,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth UNKNOWN; a death BEF 1823.",
      "start_date": "UNKNOWN",
      "end_date": "BEF 1823",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ABRAHAM_GOBBLE_10_FEB_1775",
      "person_id": "HV4_ABRAHAM_GOBBLE_10_FEB_1775",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 10 Feb 1775.",
      "start_date": "10 Feb 1775",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_ISAAC_GABEL_GOBBLE_9_JUN_1778",
      "person_id": "HV4_ISAAC_GABEL_GOBBLE_9_JUN_1778",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 9 Jun 1778.",
      "start_date": "9 Jun 1778",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_JACOB_GABEL_GOBBLE_16_MAY_1771",
      "person_id": "HV4_JACOB_GABEL_GOBBLE_16_MAY_1771",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 16 May 1771.",
      "start_date": "16 May 1771",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_HV4_MARIA_GABEL_GOBBLE_21_MAR_1761",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARIA_GABEL_GOBBLE_21_MAR_1761",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 21 Mar 1761.",
      "start_date": "21 Mar 1761",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.52,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1645 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia; a death reported 1727 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1645",
      "end_date": "reported 1727",
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_MCINTOSH_LOWER_NORFOLK_WILLS_1637_1710_SCAN",
        "SRC_LNCVA_VOL3_NORFOLK_MARRIAGE_BONDS_1711_1715",
        "SRC_STEWART_HISTORY_NORFOLK_RICHARD_BUTT_MEETINGHOUSE_1714",
        "SRC_PAGE_LIFE_JOSIAS_MACKIE_WILL_1716"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "person_id": "C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1653; a death reported 1724 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1653",
      "end_date": "reported 1724",
      "place": "reported Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTY_FORMATION",
        "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTIES_1691_1700"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "person_id": "C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1527 in reported Stuttgart, Wurttemberg; a death 1 Sep 1588 in Uberkingen, Wurttemberg.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1527",
      "end_date": "1 Sep 1588",
      "place": "reported Stuttgart, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_JOHANN_PLENINGEN_HANS_BEERLIN_NAMESAKE",
        "SRC_GEN15_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN15_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN15_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GRUIBINGEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_LEO_BW_BAD_UEBERKINGEN_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "person_id": "C_BLEYLE_AGATHA_HOHENSTADT_1535",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1535 in reported Hohenstadt, Wurttemberg; a death 14 Mar 1591 in Uberkingen, Wurttemberg.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1535",
      "end_date": "14 Mar 1591",
      "place": "reported Hohenstadt, Wurttemberg",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN15_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN15_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "person_id": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1748-1750 in reported Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America; a death reportedly 1811 in Rowan County, North Carolina, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1748-1750",
      "end_date": "reportedly 1811",
      "place": "reported Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "person_id": "EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1750 in reported Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America; a death reportedly 1834 in North Carolina, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1750",
      "end_date": "reportedly 1834",
      "place": "reported Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "person_id": "EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1630 in reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire; a death reported 1691 in reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1630",
      "end_date": "reported 1691",
      "place": "reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "person_id": "EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1633 in reported Baden, Holy Roman Empire; a death reported 1709 in reported Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1633",
      "end_date": "reported 1709",
      "place": "reported Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
        "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "person_id": "EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of reported Nenzenheim area, Bavaria, Holy Roman Empire; a death reported before 1665 in reported Nenzenheim area, Bavaria, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": "reported before 1665",
      "place": "reported Nenzenheim area, Bavaria, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "person_id": "EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1504; a death reported about 1568.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1504",
      "end_date": "reported about 1568",
      "place": null,
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_GEN16_BLEYLE_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
        "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN16_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN16_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_USER_MYHERITAGE_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_1504_1568"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "person_id": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1816 in Montgomeryshire, Wales.",
      "start_date": "about 1816",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1773 in reported Pontefract, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": "about 1773",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT",
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "person_id": "C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ober-Gleen, Grand Duchy of Hesse",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.76,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_NORTH_BRADLEY_FATHER_BETTY",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_NORTH_BRADLEY_FATHER_BETTY",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth candidate born 4 Aug 1701 in North Bradley, Wiltshire, England.",
      "start_date": "candidate born 4 Aug 1701",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_BETTY_WILLIS_1737_PROFILE",
        "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1738",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1701",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_1738_FAMILY_CLUSTER"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_SR_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_BENJAMIN_SR_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth baptized 10 Jan 1678/79 in North Bradley, Wiltshire, England; a death buried 11 Sep 1703 in North Bradley, Wiltshire, England.",
      "start_date": "baptized 10 Jan 1678/79",
      "end_date": "buried 11 Sep 1703",
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1701",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_WILLIS_WILLIAM_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_WILLIAM_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of North Bradley, Wiltshire, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_WILLIS_KATHERINE_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_KATHERINE_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of North Bradley, Wiltshire, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_MARSHALL_JOHN_PONTEFRACT_1772",
      "person_id": "C_MARSHALL_JOHN_PONTEFRACT_1772",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of Pontefract, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_ALLEN_ANN_WIFE_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "person_id": "C_ALLEN_ANN_WIFE_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of Pontefract, Yorkshire, England.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_B68_JEHUDA_LOEB_DREYFUSS",
      "person_id": "B68_JEHUDA_LOEB_DREYFUSS",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_B68_DAVID_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
      "person_id": "B68_DAVID_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
      "person_id": "B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "person_id": "B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of reported Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.97,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
        "SRC_IRISH_GENEALOGY_ANDREW_GIBSON_DEATH_SEARCH_1864_1920",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANDREW_GIBSON_1832_1887_ONTARIO_REJECTED",
        "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "person_id": "B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1785"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "person_id": "B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1785"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birthplace of Virginia, USA; a death place of probably Grayson County, Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_1835_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX",
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY",
        "SRC_GRayson_HISTORICAL_SOCIETY_FADDIS_NOTEBOOK"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_B73_SUSAN_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "B73_SUSAN_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth about 1795 in Virginia, USA.",
      "start_date": "about 1795",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Virginia, USA",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY",
        "SRC_GRayson_HISTORICAL_SOCIETY_FADDIS_NOTEBOOK"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_BUTT_ROBERT_WINTERBORNE_FATHER_C1570",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_WINTERBORNE_FATHER_C1570",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth reported about 1570 in reported Dorset, England.",
      "start_date": "reported about 1570",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Dorset, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_ROBERT_BUTT_BAPTISM_1616",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PROFILE_REPORTED_LIFE_C_GANTRELL_SUSAN_WINTERBORNE_1585",
      "person_id": "C_GANTRELL_SUSAN_WINTERBORNE_1585",
      "fact_type": "reported_life_span",
      "value": "This profile reports a birth 18 Aug 1585 in Winterborne Stickland, Dorset, England.",
      "start_date": "18 Aug 1585",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Winterborne Stickland, Dorset, England",
      "status": "reported",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_ROBERT_BUTT_BAPTISM_1616",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "source_note": "This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_CONTEXT_GODA_HANS_GABEL",
      "person_id": "I111",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported Göda setting was a long-established Upper Lusatian parish. The municipality records a parish founded in 1076 and a community whose fertile loess soils supported agriculture alongside crafts and trade. This is local context, not evidence of this person's occupation.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Göda, Saxony, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GODA_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_CONTEXT_HENRY_CO_MO_JOHN_S_MCNEW",
      "person_id": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Henry County was a prairie-and-farm county whose 1883 history describes early settlement and cultivated farms. This is community context, not evidence of this person's work or property.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Henry County, Missouri, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTY_MO_HISTORY_1883"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_CONTEXT_HENRY_CO_MO_SARAH_WILLOUGHBY",
      "person_id": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Henry County was a prairie-and-farm county whose 1883 history describes early settlement and cultivated farms. This is community context, not evidence of this person's work or property.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Henry County, Missouri, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTY_MO_HISTORY_1883"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_CONTEXT_EAST_ORANGE_ERNEST_FRICKE",
      "person_id": "HV10_ERNEST_DANIEL_FRICKE_1884",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "East Orange experienced substantial industrial and transport growth; the city records three rail lines, three trolley lines, and six stations at the height of that growth. This is city context, not evidence of this person's occupation or commute.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange and Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_CONTEXT_EAST_ORANGE_HENRY_FRICKE_JR",
      "person_id": "HV10_HENRY_FRICKE_JR_ABT1886",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "East Orange experienced substantial industrial and transport growth; the city records three rail lines, three trolley lines, and six stations at the height of that growth. This is city context, not evidence of this person's occupation or commute.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange and Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_CONTEXT_EAST_ORANGE_JOHN_FRICKE",
      "person_id": "HV10_JOHN_FRICKE_1889",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "East Orange experienced substantial industrial and transport growth; the city records three rail lines, three trolley lines, and six stations at the height of that growth. This is city context, not evidence of this person's occupation or commute.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "East Orange and Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_CONTEXT_KERRY_JOHN_LAMB",
      "person_id": "B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "National Library of Wales catalogues estate deeds for the parish and manor of Kerry from 1587 to 1844, illustrating the estate and tenure records that shaped the local historical record. This is setting context, not evidence of a connection to the estate.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NLW_KERRY_BLACK_HALL_ESTATE_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_CONTEXT_KERRY_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD",
      "person_id": "B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "National Library of Wales catalogues estate deeds for the parish and manor of Kerry from 1587 to 1844, illustrating the estate and tenure records that shaped the local historical record. This is setting context, not evidence of a connection to the estate.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NLW_KERRY_BLACK_HALL_ESTATE_RECORDS"
      ],
      "source_note": null
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_FRESHFORD_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_PRISCILLA_FRESHFORD_1707",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Priscilla's 1707 baptism was recorded at Freshford in the Avon valley. The local authority describes Freshford as a settlement shaped by the cloth trade from the early seventeenth century into the late Victorian era, with mills and weavers' cottages still marking that history.",
      "start_date": "1707",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_BANES_FRESHFORD_CONSERVATION_HISTORY_20260726"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism anchors Priscilla in Freshford; the Council appraisal supplies community context only."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_FRESHFORD_ANN_PETERS_1707",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_ANN_FRESHFORD_MOTHER_PRISCILLA",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Ann was named as mother in a 1707 Freshford baptism. The local authority describes Freshford as an Avon-valley settlement shaped by the cloth trade from the early seventeenth century into the late Victorian era, with mills and weavers' cottages still marking that history.",
      "start_date": "1707",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_BANES_FRESHFORD_CONSERVATION_HISTORY_20260726"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish transcript identifies Ann in Freshford; the Council appraisal supplies community context only."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_FRESHFORD_ROBERT_PETERS_1707",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_ROBERT_FRESHFORD_FATHER_PRISCILLA",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Robert was named as father in a 1707 Freshford baptism. The local authority describes Freshford as an Avon-valley settlement shaped by the cloth trade from the early seventeenth century into the late Victorian era, with mills and weavers' cottages still marking that history.",
      "start_date": "1707",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_BANES_FRESHFORD_CONSERVATION_HISTORY_20260726"
      ],
      "source_note": "The parish transcript identifies Robert in Freshford; the Council appraisal supplies community context only."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GRAYSON_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_1830_1850",
      "person_id": "B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The 1830 household and 1835 tax entry associated with Alexander were recorded in Grayson County, a county formed from Wythe County in 1792. The Library of Virginia's record guide shows why court, tax, land, and probate records are the relevant local record sets for this frontier.",
      "start_date": "1830",
      "end_date": "1850",
      "place": "Grayson County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_1835_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX",
        "SRC_LVA_GRAYSON_COUNTY_RECORDS_20260726"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records establish a compatible Grayson County man; they do not prove this candidate's proposed family relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_GRAYSON_SUSAN_FADDIS_1850",
      "person_id": "B73_SUSAN_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Susan's 1850 household was recorded in Grayson County, a county formed from Wythe County in 1792. The Library of Virginia's record guide shows why local court, tax, land, and probate records are the relevant next sources for this family question.",
      "start_date": "1850",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Grayson County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_LVA_GRAYSON_COUNTY_RECORDS_20260726"
      ],
      "source_note": "The household is real and local; it does not itself name Delia Tally as Susan's daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_NORTHERN_NECK_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1730",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_I_1661",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "John's 1730 will was proved in Westmoreland County, part of Virginia's Northern Neck between the Potomac and Rappahannock rivers. The National Park Service describes this as a landscape with deep Virginia Indian history and later English colonial settlement.",
      "start_date": "1730",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Westmoreland County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The will anchors John in Westmoreland; the National Park Service source supplies regional historical context."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_NORTHERN_NECK_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_JOHN_DRAPER_PARENT",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported Oldhams locality is in Westmoreland County, part of Virginia's Northern Neck between the Potomac and Rappahannock rivers. The National Park Service describes the region as a Virginia Indian homeland transformed by English colonial settlement.",
      "start_date": "1695",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Westmoreland County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Oldhams identification is compiled and remains a researched candidate; the National Park Service source supplies regional context only."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_BRADFORD_JAMES_HANNY_1844",
      "person_id": "C_HANNY_JAMES_1844",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "The reported 1844–45 Bradford-on-Avon life falls in a Wiltshire town with a long cloth-making history. Mills, textile work, and the River Avon shaped the town's historical development.",
      "start_date": "1844",
      "end_date": "1845",
      "place": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_BHO"
      ],
      "source_note": "James remains a compiled candidate sibling; the local-history source provides town context only."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_JULIE_MOSER_NEW_ORLEANS_1900",
      "person_id": "SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/new-orleans-la-1900-loc-det-4a10361.jpg",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": "1900",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_NEW_ORLEANS_CITYSCAPE_1900",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1916"
      ],
      "source_note": "New Orleans cityscape photographed by Detroit Publishing Company in 1900 (Library of Congress; no known publication restrictions). It dates from Julie's later life, but it is not a view of her home or evidence of her occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_NEW_BRITAIN_YETTA_FUCHS_1914",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Yetta's 1914 death was recorded in New Britain, Connecticut. Connecticut History describes New Britain as the “Hardware City,” a manufacturing center in which American Hardware Corporation was the state's largest employer by 1913.",
      "start_date": "1913",
      "end_date": "1914",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
        "SRC_CT_HUMANITIES_NEW_BRITAIN_HISTORY_20260726"
      ],
      "source_note": "The death reporting anchors Yetta in New Britain. The city history supplies community context only and does not identify her work, home, or reason for living there."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_NEW_ORLEANS_JULIE_MOSER_1900_1916",
      "person_id": "SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "Julie died in New Orleans in 1916. A Library of Congress 1900 cityscape captures the dense commercial waterfront city that formed the setting of her later life there.",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": "1916",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.985,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1916",
        "SRC_LOC_NEW_ORLEANS_CITYSCAPE_1900"
      ],
      "source_note": "The death index anchors Julie in New Orleans and the photograph supplies city context; neither records a particular address or occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_NEWARK_DAVID_GARY_FRICKE_1938",
      "person_id": "I11",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "David was born in Newark in 1938. The city describes a long industrial history and an economic decline during the Great Depression that wartime industrial demand temporarily slowed during his childhood.",
      "start_date": "1938",
      "end_date": "1945",
      "place": "Newark, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SSA_DAVID_GARY_FRICKE_1938_2002",
        "SRC_NEWARK_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_20260726"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Social Security record anchors David's birth locality; the city history supplies community context only."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFEVID_KING_WILLIAM_MARY_FOUNTAIN_BIRTH_PLACE_CORRECTION",
      "person_id": "C_FONTAINE_MARY_CATHERINE_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "King William County did not take effect until 11 April 1702. The reported 1665 or 1670s birth cannot therefore be stated as occurring in King William County; the profile retains only reported colonial Virginia for that birth locality.",
      "start_date": "1665",
      "end_date": "1702",
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KING_WILLIAM_COUNTY_FORMATION_1702",
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_MARY_ANN_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS_1714",
        "SRC_AGBI_MARY_ANNE_FOUNTAIN_1670S"
      ],
      "source_note": "This corrects only the anachronistic county label; it does not independently prove Mary's Virginia birth, exact year, identity, or parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_FREDA_DUBOWY_NEW_BRITAIN_1915",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "fact_type": "local_historical_context",
      "value": "In 1915 Freda lived and worked in New Britain, a city known as the “Hardware City,” where large manufacturers shaped everyday working life.",
      "start_date": "1913",
      "end_date": "1915",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CT_HUMANITIES_NEW_BRITAIN_HISTORY_20260726",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_FREDA_DUBOWY_ENGAGEMENT_1915",
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915"
      ],
      "source_note": "The local history documents New Britain’s industrial setting. Freda’s engagement notice and official marriage index place her in the city in 1915; her documented job was saleswoman at the Boston Store, not hardware work."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_B68_MARIA_ANNA_INGENHEIM_FAMILY_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "B68_MARIA_ANNA_ABRAHAM_OPPENHEIMER",
      "fact_type": "family_context",
      "value": "Ingenheim family profiles identify Maria Anna as Isaak Hirsch Dreyfuss’s wife and as the mother of their son Leo Dreyfuss.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed_name_variants",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The profiles preserve several surname forms for Maria Anna, including Abraham and Oppenheimer. They directly identify her family role but do not explain or resolve the name variants."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFCTX_B68_MARIA_ANNA_INGENHEIM_COMMUNITY",
      "person_id": "B68_MARIA_ANNA_ABRAHAM_OPPENHEIMER",
      "fact_type": "community_context",
      "value": "Her family is recorded in Ingenheim’s long-established Jewish community, documented from the seventeenth century until 1940.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ingenheim, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE"
      ],
      "source_note": "The community history supplies the local setting; the individual profiles identify Maria Anna’s husband and son there. This does not supply a separate personal vital record for Maria Anna."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_JOHN_THOMAS_SHREWSBURY_SQUARE_C1890",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/shrewsbury-england-square-c1890-loc-ppmsc08835.jpg",
      "start_date": "1890",
      "end_date": "1900",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_SHREWSBURY_SQUARE_C1890",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Library of Congress photochrom shows Shrewsbury’s Square about 1890–1900, during John’s documented Frankwell residence. It is a town view, not his specific home or workplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_JANE_LISTER_THOMAS_SHREWSBURY_SQUARE_C1890",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/shrewsbury-england-square-c1890-loc-ppmsc08835.jpg",
      "start_date": "1890",
      "end_date": "1900",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_SHREWSBURY_SQUARE_C1890",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Library of Congress photochrom shows Shrewsbury’s Square about 1890–1900, during Jane’s documented residence with John. It is a town view, not their specific home."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_KEZIA_THOMAS_SHREWSBURY_SQUARE_C1890",
      "person_id": "I44",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/shrewsbury-england-square-c1890-loc-ppmsc08835.jpg",
      "start_date": "1890",
      "end_date": "1900",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_SHREWSBURY_SQUARE_C1890",
        "SRC_FREEBMD_KEZIA_THOMAS_BIRTH_Q3_1882",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Library of Congress photochrom shows Shrewsbury’s Square about 1890–1900, during Kezia’s documented childhood in the town. It is a town view, not her family’s specific address."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_SHREWSBURY_SQUARE_C1890",
      "person_id": "I45",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/shrewsbury-england-square-c1890-loc-ppmsc08835.jpg",
      "start_date": "1890",
      "end_date": "1900",
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_SHREWSBURY_SQUARE_C1890",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Library of Congress photochrom shows Shrewsbury’s Square about 1890–1900, during Alfred’s documented childhood in the town. It is a town view, not his family’s specific address."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_1900",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/new-orleans-la-1900-loc-det-4a10361.jpg",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": "1900",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_NEW_ORLEANS_CITYSCAPE_1900",
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883"
      ],
      "source_note": "New Orleans cityscape photographed by Detroit Publishing Company in 1900 (Library of Congress; no known publication restrictions), during Adeline’s documented life in the city. It is not a view of her home or workplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_EDGAR_NEWMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_1900",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064254",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/new-orleans-la-1900-loc-det-4a10361.jpg",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": "1900",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_NEW_ORLEANS_CITYSCAPE_1900",
        "SRC_TALKING_MACHINE_WORLD_EDGAR_NEWMAN_1922",
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935"
      ],
      "source_note": "New Orleans cityscape photographed by Detroit Publishing Company in 1900 (Library of Congress; no known publication restrictions), the city of Edgar’s documented birth, work, and death. It is not a view of his home or workplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_ELSA_SCHWARTZ_NEWMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_1900",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064286",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/new-orleans-la-1900-loc-det-4a10361.jpg",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": "1900",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_NEW_ORLEANS_CITYSCAPE_1900",
        "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935"
      ],
      "source_note": "New Orleans cityscape photographed by Detroit Publishing Company in 1900 (Library of Congress; no known publication restrictions), during Elsa’s documented life in the city. It is not a view of her home or workplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_1900",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064295",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/new-orleans-la-1900-loc-det-4a10361.jpg",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": "1900",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_NEW_ORLEANS_CITYSCAPE_1900",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_COMMERCIAL_FINANCIAL_CHRONICLE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1909",
        "SRC_AJC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_DEATH_1909"
      ],
      "source_note": "New Orleans cityscape photographed by Detroit Publishing Company in 1900 (Library of Congress; no known publication restrictions), during Isidore’s documented financial and civic career in the city. It is not a view of his home or workplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_NEW_ORLEANS_1900",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/new-orleans-la-1900-loc-det-4a10361.jpg",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": "1900",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_NEW_ORLEANS_CITYSCAPE_1900",
        "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
        "SRC_ORLEANS_NOTARIAL_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_MORTGAGE_1909",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_1926"
      ],
      "source_note": "New Orleans cityscape photographed by Detroit Publishing Company in 1900 (Library of Congress; no known publication restrictions), between Leon’s documented Orleans Parish marriage and later property record. It is not a view of his home or workplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_REBECCA_KIEFFER_NEW_ORLEANS_1900",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064301",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/new-orleans-la-1900-loc-det-4a10361.jpg",
      "start_date": "1900",
      "end_date": "1900",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_NEW_ORLEANS_CITYSCAPE_1900",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "New Orleans cityscape photographed by Detroit Publishing Company in 1900 (Library of Congress; no known publication restrictions), during Rebecca’s documented New Orleans family life. It is not a view of her home or workplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_FREDA_DUBOWY_NEW_BRITAIN_1905",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/new-britain-connecticut-franklin-square-1905-loc-pcrd1a01909.jpg",
      "start_date": "1905",
      "end_date": "1905",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_NEW_BRITAIN_FRANKLIN_SQUARE_1905",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_FREDA_DUBOWY_ENGAGEMENT_1915",
        "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915"
      ],
      "source_note": "Library of Congress postcard view of Franklin Square, New Britain, from 1905. It predates Freda’s documented 1915 work and marriage in the city, and is included as town context rather than a view of her address or employer."
    },
    {
      "id": "PFIMG_YETTA_FUCHS_NEW_BRITAIN_1905",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/new-britain-connecticut-franklin-square-1905-loc-pcrd1a01909.jpg",
      "start_date": "1905",
      "end_date": "1905",
      "place": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "status": "context_only",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LOC_NEW_BRITAIN_FRANKLIN_SQUARE_1905",
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914"
      ],
      "source_note": "Library of Congress postcard view of Franklin Square, New Britain, from 1905, during Yetta’s later life. It is included as town context rather than a view of her Willow Street home."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_NEEDHAM_CARINGTON_CRONKSTONE_STADEN_ROUTE_BOUNDARY_20260727",
      "person_id": "C_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1734",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "The Carsington–Cronkstone–Staden route remains an unproved research hypothesis, not an ancestral connection.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Carsington, Cronkstone, Hartington and Staden, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DRO_MARGARET_NEDHAM_WORMHILL_CARSINGTON_1450",
        "SRC_DRO_GELL_NEW_CLOSE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_1713",
        "SRC_DRO_JOHN_NEEDHAM_CRONKSTONE_GRANGE_1648",
        "SRC_STAFFS_WILLS_RALPH_NEEDHAM_STADEN_1686",
        "SRC_STAFFS_WILLS_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_CRONKSTONE_1747"
      ],
      "source_note": "The evidence supports only a local chronology: Roger Nedham's widow had unspecified Carsington land in 1450; Robert Needham was tenant of New Close at Carsington in 1713; John Needham held part of Cronkstone Grange in 1647/48; Ralph Needham's 1686 Staden will exists; and Edward Needham of Cronkstone's 1747 probate file exists. The locations and chronology make several connections worth testing, but none of these records states that Robert or Samuel of Carsington descended from Roger, John, Ralph, or Edward. The most informative missing records are Edward's 1747 Hartington probate packet (P/C/11), Ralph's 1686 probate packet (P/C/11), and the deeds for the Morewood, Foxlow, and Cronkstone properties."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_FARMER_1753",
      "person_id": "C_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1734",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer; described as a widower in a 1753 marriage-bond entry",
      "start_date": "1753",
      "end_date": "1753",
      "place": "Carsington, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The bond identifies a Samuel Needham, widower and farmer of Carsington. It is highly consistent with Robert's son after Martha's 1747 burial, but does not explicitly state his father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BURIAL_1767_IDENTITY",
      "person_id": "C_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1734",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Buried at Carsington on 4 October 1767",
      "start_date": "1767-10-04",
      "end_date": "1767-10-04",
      "place": "Carsington, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "likely_identity_match",
      "confidence": 0.93,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DFHS_CARSINGTON_SAMUEL_NEEDHAM_BURIAL_1767"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is the preferred later-life match for Robert's son Samuel. The 1767 register entry itself is unqualified, so the identification rests on the competing local explanations rather than direct parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_CHELMORTON_1769_EXCLUDED",
      "person_id": "C_SAMUEL_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1734",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "The 1769 Chelmorton burial should not be used for this Carsington profile.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Chelmorton and Flagg, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "contradicted_for_target_identity",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEEDHAMONS_CHELMORTON_SAMUEL_NEEDHAM_1769"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Chelmorton reconstruction identifies a Samuel baptized in 1708 to Thomas and Mary, resident at Flagg, a miner, married there to Temperance Hill in 1761, with a child recorded to Samuel and Temperance at Flagg in 1769. It offers a much more specific alternative for the 21 May 1769 burial than Samuel of Carsington."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_FARMER_1702",
      "person_id": "C_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Farmer (also called husbandman in the 1705 burial entry for his wife)",
      "start_date": "1702",
      "end_date": "1705",
      "place": "Carsington, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "likely_identity_match",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1702",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_MARY_WIFE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_BURIAL_1705"
      ],
      "source_note": "The records directly describe a Robert Needham in the Carsington Robert-and-Mary household as farmer/husbandman. The identification with the later Carsington testator is the leading explanation because the 1713 deed independently places that Robert in Carsington, but it is not stated in the parish entries."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_DISSENTERS_1695_1702",
      "person_id": "C_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743",
      "fact_type": "religious_affiliation",
      "value": "The Carsington register described the Robert and Mary Needham household as dissenting or apparent dissenters.",
      "start_date": "1695",
      "end_date": "1702",
      "place": "Carsington, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "likely_identity_match",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1695",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1697",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1702"
      ],
      "source_note": "The register's wording is evidence about how the parish clerk classified this household, not a precise modern denominational label. The entries do not identify Robert's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_CARSINGTON_BURIAL_1705",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1694",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Most likely buried at Carsington on 3 February 1704/5 as Mary, wife of Robert Needham.",
      "start_date": "1705-02-03",
      "end_date": "1705-02-03",
      "place": "Carsington, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "likely_identity_match",
      "confidence": 0.96,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1695",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1697",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1702",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_MARY_WIFE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_BURIAL_1705"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1705 burial does not repeat Mary's maiden name. Compared with a second, otherwise undocumented Robert-and-Mary Needham couple in the same small parish and dissenting household, the 1694 bride is substantially more likely."
    },
    {
      "id": "FSP_I237_MARLOW_ENGLISH_PARENTAGE_BOUNDARY_20260728",
      "person_id": "I237",
      "fact_type": "frontier_stopping_point",
      "value": "This ancestry line stops with William Marlow because the proposed English parents and origin are conflicting online claims, not a record-backed transatlantic connection.",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "England and Maryland",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARLOW_ENGLISH_PARENTAGE_REVIEW_20260728",
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARLOW_HALL_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW"
      ],
      "source_note": "One online version proposes Robert Marlow and Ann Hall of Manchester; another gives a different Anne, an Ickenham birth, and different dates for William. The publicly exposed English material names a Robert Marlow in connection with a child's 1661 burial; it does not identify William as his son. The public displays reviewed do not provide a citation naming Robert or Ann as William's parents, but their limited source panels are not treated as proof that no record exists. The more likely explanation is that later online trees combined separate English and Maryland identity clusters. A future bridge would need an original passenger, patent/headright, probate, court, land, parish, or family record naming both William and an English origin or parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_JOHN1335_LINEAGE",
      "person_id": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1335_1395",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Proposed earliest ancestor in a compiled Phylppes/Phelps line",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "England",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "No medieval record was supplied or inspected. The Phylppes/Phelps surname alone does not establish a continuous paternal line."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_HENRY1400_LINEAGE",
      "person_id": "G28_HENRY_PHYLLIPPES_1400_1480",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Proposed son of John Phylppes and father of a later John",
      "start_date": "1400",
      "end_date": "1480",
      "place": "England",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "No medieval record was supplied or inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_JOHN1422_LINEAGE",
      "person_id": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1422_1491",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Proposed link between Henry and Francis Phylppes",
      "start_date": "1422",
      "end_date": "1491",
      "place": "England",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.12,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "No medieval record was supplied or inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_FRANCIS1450_LINEAGE",
      "person_id": "G28_FRANCIS_PHYLLIPPES_1450_1491",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Proposed father of John Phylppes of Tewkesbury",
      "start_date": "1450",
      "end_date": "1491",
      "place": "Checkley, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.13,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The Checkley and Tewkesbury sequence is plausible but not documented as parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_JOHN1472_LINEAGE",
      "person_id": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1472_1499",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Proposed father of Richard Phelps",
      "start_date": "1472",
      "end_date": "1499",
      "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "No inspected record names Richard as this John's son."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_RICHARD1497_LINEAGE",
      "person_id": "G28_RICHARD_PHELPS_1497_1579",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Proposed father of the documented Tewkesbury James Phelps household",
      "start_date": "1497",
      "end_date": "1579",
      "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.15,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_TEWKESBURY_PHELPS_1520_1563_REVIEW"
      ],
      "source_note": "The published Tewkesbury evidence begins with James, not Richard."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_JAMES1520_HOUSEHOLD",
      "person_id": "G28_JAMES_PHELPS_1520_1588",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Tewkesbury household supported by published parish and probate reconstruction",
      "start_date": "1520",
      "end_date": "1588",
      "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TEWKESBURY_PHELPS_1520_1563_REVIEW"
      ],
      "source_note": "This supports James's household and Thomas's baptism, not the claimed earlier pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1563_BAPTISM",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1563",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Reported baptism as son of James Phelps",
      "start_date": "10 Aug 1563",
      "end_date": "10 Aug 1563",
      "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TEWKESBURY_PHELPS_1520_1563_REVIEW"
      ],
      "source_note": "The original parish image remains to be inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1623_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "The proposed Limerick-to-Maryland connection is unresolved",
      "start_date": "1623",
      "end_date": "1697",
      "place": "Limerick, Ireland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_ORIGIN_THEORIES_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The research discusses Irish origin theories but does not establish this man as ancestor of the Baltimore Felps household."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1644_LIMIT",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1644_1667",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Reported Irish-to-Maryland bridge remains unproven",
      "start_date": "1644",
      "end_date": "1667",
      "place": "Ireland and Baltimore, Maryland",
      "status": "unverified",
      "confidence": 0.14,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_ORIGIN_THEORIES_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "No inspected record joins this reported man to the documented Baltimore Thomas Felps."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1664_WILL",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1664_1758",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "1758 will names wife Rosannah and son Aventon Felps",
      "start_date": "2 Apr 1758",
      "end_date": "2 Apr 1758",
      "place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_FELPS_WILL_1758_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_WILL_INDEX_THOMAS_FELPS_1758"
      ],
      "source_note": "The will directly supports the Thomas-to-Aventon link, not Thomas's birth or claimed father."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_AVENTON_PARENTAGE",
      "person_id": "G28_AVENTON_FELPS_1711_1794",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Named as Thomas Felps's son in the 1758 Baltimore County will",
      "start_date": "1758",
      "end_date": "1758",
      "place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_FELPS_WILL_1758_TRANSCRIPTION",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_WILL_INDEX_THOMAS_FELPS_1758"
      ],
      "source_note": "Aventon's proposed son Aquilla remains a separate compiled claim."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_AQUILLA_PARENTAGE",
      "person_id": "G28_AQUILLA_FELPS_1731_1788",
      "fact_type": "identity_limitation",
      "value": "Compiled link between Aventon and John Felps; same-name identities remain unresolved",
      "start_date": "1731",
      "end_date": "1788",
      "place": "British Colonial America and United States",
      "status": "circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.58,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "No inspected record names Aquilla as Aventon's child or identifies the 1766 John conclusively as Aquilla's son."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_EXP8_JOHN_G28_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "A Geni lineage reports this John as Aquilla's son and gives a reported 1835 death",
      "start_date": "1750",
      "end_date": "1835",
      "place": "reported United States",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.46,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1835 death has not replaced the earlier reported 1811 death. Both are compiled claims pending a record that identifies Mary Williams's husband."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1623_LIMERICK_HOUSEHOLD",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "fact_type": "identity_evidence",
      "value": "Limerick Quaker household with wives Susanna Fennell and Anne",
      "start_date": "1623",
      "end_date": "1697",
      "place": "Limerick, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LIMERICK_QUAKER_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLD_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "This supports the individual Thomas Phelps of Limerick. It does not establish the claimed Irish-to-Maryland father-son bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1664_1669_PATENT",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1664_1758",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Thomas Phelps was listed for a 100-acre Maryland patent in 1669",
      "start_date": "15 Dec 1669",
      "end_date": "15 Dec 1669",
      "place": "Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_THOMAS_PHELPS_1669_PATENT"
      ],
      "source_note": "A literal 1664 birth would make this claimed patentee about five years old. The competing explanations are an inaccurate reported birth year or a separate older Thomas Phelps; the record alone cannot choose between them."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1664_AVENTON_1723",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1664_1758",
      "fact_type": "relationship_evidence",
      "value": "1723 records identify Aventon Felps as Thomas Felps's son",
      "start_date": "17 Apr 1723",
      "end_date": "17 Apr 1723",
      "place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BALTIMORE_FELPS_RECORD_EXTRACTS_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The transcription reports both Aventon's request made through his father Thomas and Thomas's gift to Aventon his son."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_ROSE_SWIFT_MARRIAGE",
      "person_id": "G28_ROSANNAH_WIFE_THOMAS_FELPS",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Rose stated to have married Thomas Felps after a prior marriage to Swift",
      "start_date": "28 May 1710",
      "end_date": "28 May 1710",
      "place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BALTIMORE_FELPS_RECORD_EXTRACTS_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "Swift is a prior married surname, not a demonstrated birth surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G29_WILLIAM1560_BAPTISM",
      "person_id": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptised as son of James Phelps",
      "start_date": "4 Aug 1560",
      "end_date": "4 Aug 1560",
      "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The original parish register has not yet been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G29_THOMAS1590_BAPTISM",
      "person_id": "G29_THOMAS_PHELPS_1590",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptised in William and Dorothy Phelps's Tewkesbury household",
      "start_date": "24 Jun 1590",
      "end_date": "24 Jun 1590",
      "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book's printed register list gives 24 Jun 1590. Its separate Limerick-family correspondence says 24 Jan 1590; the register-list date is preferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1623_COMPETING_FATHERS",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Competing proposed fathers: Thomas baptised 1563 or Thomas born 1590",
      "start_date": "1563",
      "end_date": "1623",
      "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729",
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1590 route is currently the more likely hypothesis because it is attributed to a Limerick-descended family tree and gives a natural parent-child chronology. It is not primary proof, and the 1563 candidate remains available for review."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G29_WILLIAM1560_ADMIN_1611",
      "person_id": "G29_WILLIAM_PHELPS_1560",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Administration issued to widow Dorothy after William Phelps's death",
      "start_date": "28 Sep 1611",
      "end_date": "28 Sep 1611",
      "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book transcribes the administration. It establishes death by the stated date but not an exact death date."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G29_DOROTHY_ADMIN_1613",
      "person_id": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Administration named Nicholas Phelps after Dorothy Phelps's death",
      "start_date": "31 May 1613",
      "end_date": "31 May 1613",
      "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [],
      "source_note": "The book transcribes the administration. It establishes death by the stated date but not an exact death date."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G29_TEWKESBURY_TWO_MARYS",
      "person_id": "G29_MARY_PHELPS_1587",
      "fact_type": "identity_note",
      "value": "The book separately lists Mary baptised in 1587 and Mary baptised in 1588",
      "start_date": "4 Sep 1587",
      "end_date": "23 Apr 1588",
      "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both entries are retained as separate people pending a record-based reconciliation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G29_TEWKESBURY_TWO_MARYS_1588",
      "person_id": "G29_MARY_PHELPS_1588",
      "fact_type": "identity_note",
      "value": "The book separately lists Mary baptised in 1587 and Mary baptised in 1588",
      "start_date": "4 Sep 1587",
      "end_date": "23 Apr 1588",
      "place": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "status": "unresolved",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both entries are retained as separate people pending a record-based reconciliation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1623_CROMWELLIAN_LIMERICK_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "fact_type": "biographical_context",
      "value": "Reported Cromwellian captain and Limerick settler",
      "start_date": "about 1645",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Limerick and County Tipperary, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a nineteenth-century family account, not an inspected seventeenth-century military or land record. It gives historical context for Thomas's Limerick household but does not prove the proposed American descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1623_QUAKER_WORSHIP_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "fact_type": "religious_life",
      "value": "Imprisoned for four months after a Quaker meeting",
      "start_date": "1661",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Limerick, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729",
        "SRC_LIMERICK_QUAKER_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLD_20260728"
      ],
      "source_note": "The account offers unusually specific context for his Quaker life, but the underlying seventeenth-century record has not yet been inspected directly. It does not establish a later American descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1623_TIPPERARY_ESTATE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "fact_type": "property_context",
      "value": "Reported 1657 Aponer land conveyance and 1669 letters patent; later Tipperary estate tradition",
      "start_date": "1657",
      "end_date": "about 1820",
      "place": "County Tipperary, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.68,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints Lord Bloomfield's 1879 reply about the title deeds: a 1657 conveyance of land called Aponer from Major William Stratton to Thomas Phelps, other town lands conveyed by Richard Wilkinson, and 1669 letters patent to Thomas from Charles II. The same reply mentions later transfers and a Joseph Phelps who married Mary Christy in 1771. These are detailed published reports from a later title-holder's correspondence, not the deeds or patents themselves. They strengthen the local estate tradition but do not identify Thomas's English parents or prove an American descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_B71_JOHN_LAMB_BAPTISM_1757",
      "person_id": "B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized",
      "start_date": "20 Mar 1757",
      "end_date": "20 Mar 1757",
      "place": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_MONTGOMERY_QS_BERRIEW_KERRY_LAMB_1790"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism is the best identity match, not an isolated proof: the confidence reflects the same-parish marriage, later household, and lack of another reviewed county candidate."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_B71_JOHN_LAMB_SETTLEMENT_1790",
      "person_id": "B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "fact_type": "settlement_order",
      "value": "Removed with wife Elizabeth and two children from Berriew to legal settlement in Kerry",
      "start_date": "17 May 1790",
      "end_date": "17 May 1790",
      "place": "Berriew and Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MONTGOMERY_QS_BERRIEW_KERRY_LAMB_1790"
      ],
      "source_note": "The order identifies the household but gives no ages for the adults or earlier parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_SETTLEMENT_1790",
      "person_id": "B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "fact_type": "settlement_order",
      "value": "Removed with husband John and two children from Berriew to legal settlement in Kerry",
      "start_date": "17 May 1790",
      "end_date": "17 May 1790",
      "place": "Berriew and Kerry, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MONTGOMERY_QS_BERRIEW_KERRY_LAMB_1790"
      ],
      "source_note": "The order identifies the household but gives no maiden surname or parentage for Elizabeth."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_BERRIEW_BURIAL_CANDIDATE_1812",
      "person_id": "B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "fact_type": "burial_candidate",
      "value": "Possible burial of Elizabeth Lamb, age 67",
      "start_date": "23 May 1812",
      "end_date": "23 May 1812",
      "place": "Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "status": "plausible",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_BERRIEW_BURIAL_1812",
        "SRC_MONTGOMERY_QS_BERRIEW_KERRY_LAMB_1790"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a likely later-life record, not a conclusive identification. The record is not used as Elizabeth's displayed death date."
    },
    {
      "id": "HF_MICHEL_COGUENHEM_METZ_TD_REVIEW_20260729",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "The official Metz ten-year birth index for 1823–1832 contains no Coguenhem entry.",
      "start_date": "1823",
      "end_date": "1832",
      "place": "Metz, Moselle, France",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_METZ_TD_1823_1832_BIRTH_MARRIAGE_INDEX_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is strong negative evidence against the precise reported 1827 Metz birth. It is not proof that the reported Michel, Pauline Loeb, or Anna Coguenhem family did not exist; the original entry may use a wrong place, a variant surname, or another municipality."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_LEON_SCHWARTZ_SCHWARTZ_BROS_CONTEXT_20260729",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Probably a proprietor in the family wholesale business, Schwartz Bros.",
      "start_date": "before 1902",
      "end_date": "3 May 1926",
      "place": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
        "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_HERBERT_J_SCHWARTZ",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_1926"
      ],
      "source_note": "Herbert J. Schwartz's biography says he joined Schwartz Bros. in 1902 and became president when his father died in 1926. Isidore Newman II's biography names Elsa Schwartz as his mother and Herbert as his uncle. Leon E. Schwartz died in Orleans Parish in 1926 and is the tree's best-supported candidate for Elsa's father. The sources do not directly name Leon as Herbert's father or state Leon's job, so this is presented as a probable family-business role rather than a directly documented occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_AMELIA_HARGIS_PARENTAGE_RANK_20260730",
      "person_id": "SRC_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765",
      "fact_type": "parentage_assessment",
      "value": "John Draper Hargis, born about 1722, is the leading reported father",
      "start_date": "about 1722",
      "end_date": "1765",
      "place": "Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_1762"
      ],
      "source_note": "Two compiled pedigrees directly name the older John as Amelia's father. The competing younger-John/Elizabeth Freelove construction is weakened by Elizabeth's reported 1762 death, before Amelia's 1765 birth. This ranking selects the more likely present hypothesis; it is not a direct parent-identifying record."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_EDA_CAUNTIS_FATHER_ASSESSMENT_20260730",
      "person_id": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "fact_type": "parentage_assessment",
      "value": "Henry Countiss is the leading reported father",
      "start_date": "before 1820",
      "end_date": "1820",
      "place": "Washington County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "supported_circumstantial",
      "confidence": 0.56,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_HENRY_AUNLIE_1810_COUNTISS_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820"
      ],
      "source_note": "Henry Countiss is the only named parent candidate and better explains the local Countiss/Cauntis evidence than an entirely unidentified father. The 1820 census does not identify Eda, so this is a ranked circumstantial conclusion rather than a documented parent-child statement."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_JOHN_NEWLAND_CORDWAINER_1736",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Possible identity: Cordwainer: made and repaired shoes and worked on harness under contract to Isham Randolph",
      "start_date": "30 Jun 1736",
      "end_date": "8 Apr 1737",
      "place": "Goochland County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "candidate_identity",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOOCHLAND_NEWLAND_RANDOLPH_CORDWAINER_1736",
        "SRC_OT26_ALLEN_1729_ULLAND_PASSENGER_GROUP",
        "SRC_OT26_NEWLAND_1736_INDENTURE_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Published agreement dated 30 June 1736, recorded 16 November 1736; reported scheduled expiry 8 April 1737, not proof of actual release date. The four-year term implies a possible April 1733 start, predating Hope arrival in 1734. Original p. 259 not inspected. Name match supports the proposed identity, but the chronological tension in the combined biography requires testing. This is not a finding that a separate shoemaker has been proved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_JOHN_NEWLAND_INDENTURE_1736",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "fact_type": "indenture",
      "value": "Possible identity: Indentured to Isham Randolph, with a court-approved route to early freedom on completing contracted work",
      "start_date": "30 Jun 1736",
      "end_date": "8 Apr 1737",
      "place": "Goochland County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "candidate_identity",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOOCHLAND_NEWLAND_RANDOLPH_CORDWAINER_1736",
        "SRC_OT26_ALLEN_1729_ULLAND_PASSENGER_GROUP",
        "SRC_OT26_NEWLAND_1736_INDENTURE_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Published agreement dated 30 June 1736, recorded 16 November 1736; reported scheduled expiry 8 April 1737, not proof of actual release date. The four-year term implies a possible April 1733 start, predating Hope arrival in 1734. Original p. 259 not inspected. Name match supports the proposed identity, but the chronological tension in the combined biography requires testing. This is not a finding that a separate shoemaker has been proved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1623_LIMERICK_SHOPKEEPER_1658",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Shopkeeper",
      "start_date": "1658",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Limerick, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The quoted account places a Thomas Phelps in Limerick trade in 1658. The underlying seventeenth-century volume has not yet been inspected directly."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1623_OATH_PENALTY_1658",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "fact_type": "biographical_context",
      "value": "French salt seized after refusal of an oath: 269 bushels, followed by a further 9 bushels",
      "start_date": "1658",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Limerick, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1899 book prints a 1658 extract identifying Thomas Phelps as a Limerick shopkeeper. It says 269 bushels of French salt were taken on the fifteenth day of the seventh month, followed by 9 more bushels on the fourth day of the tenth month, and that buyers were threatened. The underlying seventeenth-century volume has not been inspected directly."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1623_PARLIAMENTARY_SERVICE_CONTEXT",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "fact_type": "military_service",
      "value": "Reported service in the Parliamentarian army before Quaker conversion",
      "start_date": "before 1658",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "This supports the period account behind the family tradition that he served with Cromwell; it does not independently verify a rank of captain."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_RACHEL_MCELROY_BIRTH_PARENTAGE_1713",
      "person_id": "G28_RACHEL_MCELROY_WIFE_AVENTON",
      "fact_type": "birth_and_parentage",
      "value": "Reported birth as daughter of John and Frances McElroy",
      "start_date": "7 Aug 1713",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "St George Parish, Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The underlying parish-register image has not been inspected. This is stronger than a copied online pedigree but remains a derivative transcription."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_AVENTON_FELPS_BLACKSMITH_1753",
      "person_id": "G28_AVENTON_FELPS_1711_1794",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Blacksmith",
      "start_date": "1753",
      "end_date": "1769",
      "place": "Anson and Rowan counties, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
        "SRC_ST_GEORGE_AVENTON_RACHEL_MARRIAGE_1730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The source quotes land transactions identifying Aventon as a blacksmith. The original deed images have not been inspected in this review, so the occupation is recorded at strong derivative—not direct image—confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_MICHEL_KIEFFER_1808_GUNSTETT_NAME_INDEX_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "The proposed Gunstett surname form is absent from the 1808 declaration index",
      "start_date": "1808",
      "end_date": "1808",
      "place": "Gunstett, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "conflicting_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_GUNSTETT_NAME_INDEX_NEGATIVE_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "source_note": "The index is not a complete census and does not prove that Michel was absent from Gunstett. It does show that the imported hereditary surname Kieffer was not declared there in 1808, although Kieffer was declared at Lembach and Strasbourg. That creates a real identity problem for the combined Gunstett profile but does not settle it."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_AQUILLA_ROWAN_RECORDS_1759_1769",
      "person_id": "G28_AQUILLA_FELPS_1731_1788",
      "fact_type": "residence_and_civic_record",
      "value": "Recorded in Rowan County taxable, bounty, petition, and land-related material",
      "start_date": "1759",
      "end_date": "1769",
      "place": "Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_FELPS_ROWAN_RECORDS_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The underlying county record images remain to be inspected. These entries identify an adult local Aquilla but do not establish his parentage, spouse, or reported vital dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_AQUILLA_REGULATOR_PETITION_1768",
      "person_id": "G28_AQUILLA_FELPS_1731_1788",
      "fact_type": "civic_activity",
      "value": "Listed among signatories to a Rowan and Orange Counties Regulator petition",
      "start_date": "23 Nov 1768",
      "end_date": "23 Nov 1768",
      "place": "Rowan and Orange Counties, North Carolina, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_FELPS_ROWAN_RECORDS_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "This is a transcription-derived identification; an original petition image has not yet been inspected. The simultaneous appearance of John Felps does not state their relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_AQUILLA_REPORTED_GEORGIA_MOVE_CONFLICT",
      "person_id": "G28_AQUILLA_FELPS_1731_1788",
      "fact_type": "conflicting_life_tradition",
      "value": "Reported 1771 move to Georgia is disputed by another Felps reconstruction",
      "start_date": "1771",
      "end_date": "1790",
      "place": "Rowan County, North Carolina and St Pauls Parish, Georgia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.5,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_PHELPS_AQUILLA_GEORGIA_CONFLICT_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "One account reports a 1771 Georgia move and return by 1780. The comparative paper found no Aquilla-in-Georgia record and places him in Rowan through the late 1780s. Neither conclusion is treated as a displayed migration fact until original records are compared."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_SALOMON_FRANK_BUTCHER_1809_1810",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065371",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Butcher (Metzger)",
      "start_date": "1809",
      "end_date": "1810",
      "place": "Oberlustadt, Donnersberg Department, French Empire",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810"
      ],
      "source_note": "A published local Jewish-community history lists Salomon Frank among Oberlustadt household heads in 1809/10 and identifies his trade as Metzger, or butcher. The source is not an image of the underlying list, so the occupation is strong secondary evidence rather than an inspected primary entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_SAMUEL_MORRALL_COLLIER_1813_1851",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_MORRALL_FATHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Collier / coal miner",
      "start_date": "1813",
      "end_date": "1851",
      "place": "Lawley and Wellington, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTSCHAT_SAMUEL_ANN_MORRALL_LAWLEY_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The community transcription reports Samuel as a collier at the 1813 baptism and as a coal miner in the 1841 and 1851 censuses. The original images have not been inspected in this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_NEWLAND_UHLAND_MUENTZ_PARENT_HYPOTHESIS_20260730",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "fact_type": "parentage_candidate",
      "value": "Matthäus Uhland and Anna Catharina Müntz remain proposed parents; an Allen passenger group of Mathias, Catrina and young Johannes Ulland strengthens the household lead",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Dannstadt, Electoral Palatinate, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.3,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEWLAND_UHLAND_MUNTZ_COMPILED_CANDIDATE_20260730",
        "SRC_NEWLAND_HOPE_PASSENGER_1734",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_JOHN_NEWLAND_ANCESTRY_UNKNOWN_REVIEW",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_OT26_ALLEN_1729_ULLAND_PASSENGER_GROUP",
        "SRC_OT26_NEWLAND_1736_INDENTURE_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "source_note": "Three compatible names on the Allen and Johannes under fifteen favor the proposed household over a lone surname coincidence. Relationships are not explicitly stated on the list. Connecting the Allen boy to the 1739 groom, and the group to the German records, remains unresolved. The existing parent confidence is retained pending that comparison; no automatic penalty for missing explicit parent wording."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_THOMAS_LISTER_BATLEY_PARENTAGE_CANDIDATE_20260730",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "parentage_candidate",
      "value": "The strongest identified childhood candidate is Thomas Lister, born 9 December 1772 and baptised 10 February 1773 at Batley, with mother Hannah Lister",
      "start_date": "9 Dec 1772",
      "end_date": "10 Feb 1773",
      "place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.54,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_BATLEY_BAPTISM_1773",
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_HANNAH_FAMILY_RECONSTRUCTION_20260730",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY"
      ],
      "source_note": "The baptism names Hannah but no father. Thomas's reported presence at sister Sarah Lister's 1795 Batley marriage, followed by a chronologically fitting 1799 South Kirkby marriage, makes this more likely than an entirely unidentified origin. The groom's record lacks identifying particulars, so this remains a candidate rather than a settled birth and parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_JACQUES_LEVY_ROSENWILLER_BURIAL_1806_20260730",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "fact_type": "burial",
      "value": "Buried in the Rosenwiller Jewish cemetery; the memorial entry identifies him as Jeckel, son of Macholé (Michaël)",
      "start_date": "23 Feb 1806",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Rosenwiller, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The transcription is cited as Livre de mémoire du cimetière de Rosenwiller, vol. 1, p. 343. The original memorial or cemetery book image was not inspected in this audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_JACQUES_LEVY_OTTROTT_HOUSEHOLD_1784_20260730",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065093",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Enumerated with Bösel Macholen in an Ottrott household",
      "start_date": "8 Nov 1784",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Ottrott-le-Bas, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The accessible citation supplies the household wording but not the underlying enumeration image. It supports the couple's adult household, not Jacques's birth or Michel's own origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_G28_THOMAS1623_QUAKER_ADVOCACY_CONTEXT_20260730",
      "person_id": "G28_THOMAS_PHELPS_1623_1697",
      "fact_type": "religious_life",
      "value": "Reported advocate for fellow Quakers before the Earl of Tyrconnell",
      "start_date": "about 1685",
      "end_date": "1690",
      "place": "Limerick, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729"
      ],
      "source_note": "The book quotes a list of people said to have appeared frequently before the Earl of Tyrconnell in support of Friends suffering for their religious testimony, including Thomas Phelps of Limerick. The quoted passage gives no individual dates or case details, so the date range follows Tyrconnell's period of power in Ireland and remains approximate."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_PEYTON_TALLY_TENNESSEE_NAMESAKE_EXCLUDED_20260730",
      "person_id": "SRC_PEYTON_R_TALLY_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "Not the Peyton Talley reported with Rachel Mullinax in Smith County, Tennessee",
      "start_date": "about 1797",
      "end_date": "1860",
      "place": "Smith County, Tennessee, United States",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PEYTON_TALLEY_TN_1797_DISAMBIGUATION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The separately indexed Tennessee profile is still compiled evidence, but its wife Rachel Mullinax, eight named children, Smith County setting, and 1860 death are incompatible with treating it as the undocumented husband of Holly or father of Evan. It should not be merged into this branch."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_WILLIAM_LISTER_BATLEY_CHILD_CLUSTER_20260730",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_WILLIAM_LISTER_BATLEY_1671",
      "fact_type": "identity evidence",
      "value": "Reported father of a Batley baptismal cluster: Maria (1701), George (1705), and William (1707).",
      "start_date": "1701",
      "end_date": "1707",
      "place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_WILLIAM_GEORGE_BAPTISMS_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cluster is useful identity evidence because it ties the named 1705 George to a William Lister in the same parish. It is not a replacement for a viewed original register."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_JOHN_LISTER_JANE_TINGLE_CHILD_CLUSTER_1671_1676_20260730",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_JOHN_LISTER_BATLEY_MARRIED_1670",
      "fact_type": "identity evidence",
      "value": "Reported parents of William (1671), John (1673), and Joseph (1675/76) at Batley.",
      "start_date": "1671",
      "end_date": "1676",
      "place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_JOHN_JANE_WILLIAM_1670_1676_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The sibling pattern supports the couple’s identity and William’s placement, but it has not yet been checked against the original register."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_JANE_TINGLE_BATLEY_BAPTISM_1638_20260730",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_JANE_TINGLE_BATLEY_1638",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Reported baptism at Batley.",
      "start_date": "11 Nov 1638",
      "end_date": "11 Nov 1638",
      "place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_JOHN_JANE_WILLIAM_1670_1676_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cited reconstruction reports the exact date; the original register image has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_ALVEREY_TINGLE_BATLEY_HEARTH_TAX_1666_20260730",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ALVEREY_TINGLE_BATLEY_1666",
      "fact_type": "tax record",
      "value": "Reported as assessed for two hearths at Batley.",
      "start_date": "1666",
      "end_date": "1666",
      "place": "Batley, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "candidate_compiled",
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BATLEY_ALVEREY_TINGLE_HEARTH_AND_CHILD_CLUSTER_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The compiler identifies a 1666 hearth-tax list but the original entry has not been inspected here."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_1840_CENSUS_HOUSEHOLD",
      "person_id": "B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "fact_type": "census_household",
      "value": "Headed a household with a woman aged 40-49 and six younger household members",
      "start_date": "1840",
      "end_date": "1840",
      "place": "Western District, Grayson County, Virginia, United States",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1840_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD"
      ],
      "source_note": "The schedule directly names Alexander as head. It does not name the woman or younger people, so this fact records the household composition rather than asserting their identities."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_ALTERNATE_COMPILED_MOTHER_20260730",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "A separate online tree names Catharina Desvericky, rather than Anna Catharina Hansen, as the mother of Hannss Martin Nagel.",
      "start_date": "reported seventeenth century",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "reported Blankenloch area, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.2,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_NAGEL_DESVERICKY_COMPILED_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "YourRoots gives the alternate father as Hans Nagel, born 1623 and died 1693. Those dates overlap Hans Anthoni Nagel's reported 1622-1693 life, so the claim describes an alternate identity or spouse reconstruction for the existing household, not a generation above it. Neither compilation provides an inspected original entry or grounds for treating the women as the same person."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_OCCUPATION_20260730",
      "person_id": "HV4_THOMAS_ATHEY_14_FEB_1717_AFTER_1766",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Planter",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_PARENTAGE_RECONCILIATION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The occupation appears in the cited reconstruction rather than a newly inspected tax, deed, or probate original."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_FAIRFAX_COURT_20260730",
      "person_id": "HV4_THOMAS_ATHEY_14_FEB_1717_AFTER_1766",
      "fact_type": "court_record",
      "value": "Appeared in Fairfax County court records",
      "start_date": "18 Jul 1755",
      "end_date": "23 Mar 1758",
      "place": "Fairfax County, Virginia, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_PARENTAGE_RECONCILIATION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reconstruction supplies dates but not the case text or record-image citation; the appearances should not be read as evidence of a particular legal role or allegation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_ATHEY_GEORGE_DENT_SERVICE_20260730",
      "person_id": "C_ATHEY_CAPTAIN_GEORGE_1642_1710_20260730",
      "fact_type": "migration_and_service",
      "value": "Completed service to Thomas Dent and claimed a 50-acre land right",
      "start_date": "3 Nov 1668",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "St. Mary's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1932_JOHN_INVENTORY_PARENTAGE_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The study reports that Thomas Dent entered rights in 1663 for transporting George Athley, and that George Athee of St. Mary's County proved a land right for service to Dent on 3 November 1668. It is strong evidence of the Maryland service and post-service land claim, but does not by itself establish George's Irish birthplace or parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_ATHEY_GEORGE_LANDHOLDER_20260730",
      "person_id": "C_ATHEY_CAPTAIN_GEORGE_1642_1710_20260730",
      "fact_type": "landholding",
      "value": "Landholder and tobacco planter in Charles and Prince George's counties",
      "start_date": "18 Aug 1674",
      "end_date": "26 Jun 1697",
      "place": "Charles and Prince George's counties, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1932_JOHN_INVENTORY_PARENTAGE_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The history traces George's 1674 Maidstone grant, 1675 grants, later Hopewell and Broad Creek holdings, and 1697 sale of St. Johns. The dates and tracts are reported from Maryland land records; this concise fact does not imply that every reported tract remained in his possession throughout the period."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_ATHEY_GEORGE_MILITIA_20260730",
      "person_id": "C_ATHEY_CAPTAIN_GEORGE_1642_1710_20260730",
      "fact_type": "military_service",
      "value": "Appointed Captain of Foot in the Prince George's County militia",
      "start_date": "1696",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cited study says Colonel John Addison appointed George Captain of Foot for the western half of Prince George's County when the county militia was organized. The appointment supports the title “Captain”; no claim is made here about later combat service."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_ATHEY_GEORGE_CHURCH_WORK_20260730",
      "person_id": "C_ATHEY_CAPTAIN_GEORGE_1642_1710_20260730",
      "fact_type": "community_service",
      "value": "Paid for building work at St. John's Parish Church",
      "start_date": "1695",
      "end_date": "1698",
      "place": "Broad Creek, Prince George's County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cited study reports parish payments to George in 1695 for a carpenter's dial and raising the church floor, and in 1698 for covering the church. These are evidence of paid work or contract activity; “carpenter” is not treated as a proven sole occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_ATHEY_FRANCIS_SHERIFF_GALWAY_1639_20260730",
      "person_id": "C_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_1612_1666_20260730",
      "fact_type": "civic_office",
      "value": "Sheriff of Galway",
      "start_date": "1639",
      "end_date": "1640",
      "place": "Galway, County Galway, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_IDENTIFICATION_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "Both cited accounts identify Francis Athy as Sheriff of Galway in 1639; the specialised family history gives the 1639/40 period. This fact supports Francis's own identification, but does not independently prove that the Maryland George was his son."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_COUNCIL_1644_20260730",
      "person_id": "C_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_1612_1666_20260730",
      "fact_type": "civic_office",
      "value": "Reported as a Galway councillor",
      "start_date": "1644",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Galway, County Galway, Ireland",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.73,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730"
      ],
      "source_note": "The specialised Athey history says Francis served as a Galway councillor in 1644. This is retained as reported local biographical context pending an independent municipal-record citation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_RICHARD_LISTER_CORDWAINER_TOLL_KEEPER_1992_CHART",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "occupation",
      "value": "Cordwainer; also reported as a toll-house keeper",
      "start_date": "1849",
      "end_date": "1879",
      "place": "Atcham and Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805"
      ],
      "source_note": "Cordwainer means a shoemaker who traditionally worked in new leather. The chart places Richard in occupations closely connected with the toll houses and roads around Shrewsbury."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_RICHARD_LISTER_TOLL_HOUSES_AND_SPRING_GARDENS_CHART",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "residence",
      "value": "Reported at the Emstrey or Atcham toll house, Old Heath Gates, Meole Brace, Coton Hill Toll Gate, and Spring Gardens or Factory Bridge",
      "start_date": "1849",
      "end_date": "1879",
      "place": "Shrewsbury and Atcham, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "family_reconstruction",
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805"
      ],
      "source_note": "The chart notes that Factory Bridge may have been another description for the Spring Gardens address."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_RICHARD_LISTER_BIRTH_YEAR_CONFLICT_1992_CHART",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_ABT1804_PONTEFRACT",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "The 1992 chart reports birth in 1807 at Pontefract; the current census-based chronology points to about 1804",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "conflicting",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805"
      ],
      "source_note": "Recorded so that the discrepancy is not silently lost."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_KEZIA_PRICE_DEATH_BURIAL_1992_CHART",
      "person_id": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_LISTER_ABT1816",
      "fact_type": "death_and_burial",
      "value": "Reported death on 4 October 1874, aged 58, at Spring Gardens; burial in Shrewsbury Cemetery plot 1961",
      "start_date": "1874-10-04",
      "end_date": "1874-10-04",
      "place": "Spring Gardens, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "reported_family_chart",
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805"
      ],
      "source_note": "The reported age implies birth about 1815 or 1816 and therefore conflicts with the chart's separate circa-1812 annotation."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_JANE_LISTER_ATCHAM_LIGHTNING_1879",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_THOMAS_ABT1852_SHREWSBURY",
      "fact_type": "personal_history",
      "value": "Family recollection says Jane was present at St Eata's Church when lightning struck during the afternoon service",
      "start_date": "1879-07-13",
      "end_date": "1879-07-13",
      "place": "St Eata's Church, Atcham, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "family_recollection_with_confirmed_event",
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805",
        "SRC_EDDOWES_ATCHAM_LIGHTNING_1879_TRANSCRIPTION_20260805",
        "SRC_BNA_EDDOWES_SHREWSBURY_JOURNAL_CATALOG_20260805"
      ],
      "source_note": "The lightning travelled through the tower and organ gallery into the choir pews. Several choristers were injured and nobody was killed. Jane is not claimed to have been one of the injured people."
    },
    {
      "id": "PF_JOHN_THOMAS_DEATH_YEAR_CONFLICT_1992_CHART",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "fact_type": "identity_conflict",
      "value": "The family chart reports death on 8 April 1930; memorial and civil-registration evidence support 8 April 1931",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England",
      "status": "contradicted_for_date",
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805",
        "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_FINDAGRAVE_1851_1931"
      ],
      "source_note": "The stronger 1931 date remains in the main profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANNA_FENTON_BAPTISM",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized as Hanna, daughter of William Fenton",
      "start_date": "27 Jun 1674",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_HANNA_FENTON_1674"
      ],
      "source_note": "Exact name, date and parish match the existing Hanna profile. This is a baptism date; the entry does not state her date of birth."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BARTEE_CARPENTER1686",
      "person_id": "C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "fact_type": "occupation_and_land",
      "value": "Likely the Robert Bartee, carpenter of Linhaven, who bought land from John Avery Jr.",
      "start_date": "25 Jan 1685/6",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Lower Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "status": "researched_candidate",
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_BARTEE_MESDA1686"
      ],
      "source_note": "Exact name, locality and adult chronology favor the same-person identification over an unspecified namesake. The abstract names no wife or parents, so the identity remains conditional. Deed Book 4, page 220a; recorded 15 March 1685/6. Original not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_BRASSINGTON_GEORGE_MARRIAGE_CAVERSWALL_1560",
      "person_id": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_MARRIAGE_1560",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Marriage recorded in Caverswall",
      "start_date": "1560",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_FREE_BMB_INDEX_CAVERSWALL_BRASSINGTON_1564_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_LOCAL_STAFFORDSHIRE_BMB_INDEX_B_PDF_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The free Staffordshire BMB index lists a George Brassington marriage at Caverswall in 1560. The spouse and original entry wording remain uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_BRASSINGTON_RICHARD_BAPTISM_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "person_id": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized",
      "start_date": "28 May 1564",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_FREE_BMB_INDEX_CAVERSWALL_BRASSINGTON_1564_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_LOCAL_STAFFORDSHIRE_BMB_INDEX_B_PDF_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The free index lists Richard Brassington baptism at Caverswall in 1564; the day and month 28 May come from the compiled Ancestry profile and are not independently verified here."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_BRASSINGTON_RICHARD_MARRIAGE_CAVERSWALL_1586",
      "person_id": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "fact_type": "marriage",
      "value": "Marriage recorded",
      "start_date": "1586",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_FREE_BMB_INDEX_CAVERSWALL_BRASSINGTON_1564_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_LOCAL_STAFFORDSHIRE_BMB_INDEX_B_PDF_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The free index lists a Richard Brassington marriage at Caverswall in 1586; spouse details are not included in the surname index."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_BRASSINGTON_ALEXANDER_BAPTISM_CAVERSWALL_1629",
      "person_id": "C_ALEXANDER_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1630",
      "fact_type": "baptism",
      "value": "Baptized",
      "start_date": "1629",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_transcription",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_FREE_BMB_INDEX_CAVERSWALL_BRASSINGTON_1564_1703_20261005",
        "SRC_LOCAL_STAFFORDSHIRE_BMB_INDEX_B_PDF_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The free index lists Alexander Brassington baptism at Caverswall in 1629, consistent with Oxford’s 1647 age 17. Parentage is supplied separately by the Oxford record only for his father George of Careswell."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_THOMAS_BRASSYNTON_KINGSLEY_WILL_1556",
      "person_id": "C_THOMAS_BRASSYNTON_KINGSLEY_1556",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Will recorded at Kingsley",
      "start_date": "8 May 1556",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Kingsley, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_BRASSYNTON_KINGSLEY_WILL_1556_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Jo Davies cites the original Lichfield Record Office will of Thomas Brassynton of Kingsley dated 8 May 1556 and quotes its opening wording. The accessible thesis does not provide the bequests or kinship clauses, so the document confirms Thomas’s existence and locality but does not establish that he was Richard Brassington’s father."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_PROBATE_1591",
      "person_id": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1540",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Will and inventory recorded",
      "start_date": "13 Apr 1591",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "George Brassington is listed as a husbandman of Caverswall; his will and inventory were recorded in the Lichfield Consistory Court on 13 April 1591, reference B/C/11."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_CONSTANCE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_INVENTORY_1591",
      "person_id": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1540",
      "fact_type": "spouse_context",
      "value": "Inventory of Constance Brassington, widow",
      "start_date": "13 Apr 1591",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_CONSTANCE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Constance Brassington is listed as a widow of Caverswall; her inventory was recorded on the same date and in the same court reference as George Brassington’s will and inventory. This supports, but does not prove, their marital relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_PROBATE_1589",
      "person_id": "C_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Administration recorded",
      "start_date": "1589",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Lichfield Consistory Court, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_index",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_INDEX_RICHARD_GEORGE_CONSTANCE_1590_1591_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1892 British Record Society volume lists Richard Brassington in the 1589 continuation (p. 136). The index does not state residence or kinship, and the original B/C/11 entry has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_RICHARD_BRASSYNGTON_CHEADLETON_PROBATE_1552",
      "person_id": "C_RICHARD_BRASSYNGTON_CHEADLETON_1552",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Probate index entry",
      "start_date": "1552",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Cheadleton (Cheddleton), Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_index",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_RICHARD_BRASSYNGTON_CHEADLETON_1552_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1892 BRS volume lists Brassyngton, Richard, Cheadleton in the 1552 continuation, page 52. The index does not provide kinship details or the underlying folio text."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_ISABEL_DE_BRASSYNGTON_STAPENHILL_HOLDING_1407",
      "person_id": "C_ISABEL_DE_BRASSYNGTON_STAPENHILL_1407",
      "fact_type": "landholding",
      "value": "Former holder of a toft, lands and meadows",
      "start_date": "1407",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Stapenhill, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_record",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPM_ISABEL_DE_BRASSYNGTON_STAPENHILL_1407_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The inquisition records the property as formerly held by Isabel de Brassyngton of Stapenhill; it does not state when she held it or how she was related to later Brassingtons."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_C_ROBERT_DE_BRASYNTONE_DERBYSHIRE_1348_RECORD",
      "person_id": "C_ROBERT_DE_BRASYNTONE_DERBYSHIRE_1348",
      "fact_type": "surname_bearer",
      "value": "Early bearer listed in surname reference",
      "start_date": "1348",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Robert de Brasyntone is listed by the Oxford Dictionary of Family Names among early Derbyshire bearers in 1348. This does not establish kinship to later Staffordshire Brassingtons."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_C_ISABELLA_DE_BRASYNTON_DERBY_1379_RECORD",
      "person_id": "C_ISABELLA_DE_BRASYNTON_DERBY_1379",
      "fact_type": "surname_bearer",
      "value": "1379 poll-tax entry: elderly widow assessed at 12 pence; servant listed",
      "start_date": "1379",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Derby, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005",
        "SRC_DERBY_POLL_TAX_1379_BRASYNTON_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The 1379 Derby return describes Isabella de Brasynton as vetula vidua (elderly widow), assesses her at 12 pence, and lists a servant. It gives no parentage or connection to later Brassingtons."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_C_EDWARD_BRASSYNTON_BEDFORDSHIRE_1411_RECORD",
      "person_id": "C_EDWARD_BRASSYNTON_BEDFORDSHIRE_1411",
      "fact_type": "surname_bearer",
      "value": "Early bearer listed in surname reference",
      "start_date": "1411",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Bedfordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "Edward Brassynton is listed in a 1411 Feet of Fines reference. His Bedfordshire location makes a connection to the Derbyshire/Staffordshire line especially uncertain."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_MARGARETA_DE_BASYNTON_DERBY_1379_RECORD",
      "person_id": "C_MARGARETA_DE_BASYNTON_DERBY_1379",
      "fact_type": "poll_tax_household",
      "value": "Named in 1379 Derby poll-tax return; daughter noted in household context",
      "start_date": "1379",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Derby, Derbyshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_secondary",
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DERBY_POLL_TAX_1379_BRASYNTON_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The cited discussion identifies Margareta de Basynton on p. 97 and notes a daughter; the full return should be consulted for exact household wording."
    },
    {
      "id": "BF_CONSTANCE_BRASSINGTON_INVENTORY_1591",
      "person_id": "C_CONSTANCE_CLERKE_CAVERSWALL_1538",
      "fact_type": "probate",
      "value": "Inventory recorded as widow of Caverswall",
      "start_date": "13 Apr 1591",
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "status": "source_backed_index",
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_CONSTANCE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005"
      ],
      "source_note": "The index records Constance Brassington, widow of Caverswall, with an inventory on 13 April 1591. It does not give her maiden name or children."
    },
    {
      "id": "IMG_WILLIAM_HANNY_14TH_FOOT_BADGE",
      "person_id": "I186",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/14th-regiment-foot-badge.jpg",
      "place": "14th Regiment of Foot",
      "status": "source_backed_context",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKIMEDIA_14TH_FOOT_BADGE_AM7210962"
      ],
      "source_note": "Later 1861-pattern regimental badge associated with the 14th Regiment of Foot; this is a visual emblem of William Hanny’s regiment, not evidence that he personally possessed this badge."
    },
    {
      "id": "IMG_WILLIAM_HANNY_14TH_FOOT_COLOURS",
      "person_id": "I186",
      "fact_type": "profile_image",
      "value": "assets/places/14th-foot-colours.jpg",
      "start_date": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "place": "14th Regiment of Foot",
      "status": "source_backed_context",
      "confidence": 1.0,
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKIMEDIA_14TH_FOOT_COLOURS"
      ],
      "source_note": "Regimental colours associated with the 14th Regiment of Foot, included as a visual emblem of William Hanny’s unit rather than as a personal possession."
    }
  ],
  "family_roots": [
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I58",
      "person_id": "I58",
      "surname": "Sims",
      "locality": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "research_limit": "Julia’s Washington County household is supported by the 1860 and 1870 census evidence and the 1892 North Fork death register. Her parents remain unidentified. The probable 1836 marriage is in Carter County, Tennessee, with the bride mistranscribed as John Ann Sims; an original image is needed to verify that reading.",
      "notes": "Julia’s reported Washington County birthplace and later residence favor a connection to local Sims/Simms families, although her birth family has not been identified. Her census and death ages suggest a birth between about 1814 and 1818. The 1808–1811 deed-book index contains Sims/Simms entries on pages 130, 141 and 446; the deeds may identify relatives or property near her later North Fork home. They have not yet been read.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
        "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_NORTH_FORK_DEATH_1892",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WASHINGTON_VA_DB4_SIMS_INDEX"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "James Simms’s recollection of Washington County service",
          "record_date": "1778–1780, recounted in 1832",
          "locality": "Washington County, Virginia; later Blount County, Tennessee",
          "historical_detail": "In his 1832 pension declaration James Simms recalled moving from Frederick County to Washington County, guarding Abingdon jail in 1778, and serving at King’s Mountain in 1780. His 1833 amendment reports birth in Frederick County about 1750 or 1751. This is retrospective testimony available through a modern transcription.",
          "association": "His surname and earlier Washington County residence make him a plausible wider-family lead for Julia, born in the county about 1814–1818, roughly forty years after the stated service.",
          "alternatives": "He may represent a related collateral branch or a separate Sims family. His move to Tennessee neither proves nor excludes descendants or relatives remaining in Virginia. A shared county is broader evidence than a matched property or household.",
          "assessment": "Possible wider-family association; evidence does not yet rank a particular relationship above the competing family explanations. Compare his land and relatives with Julia’s early household before attaching ancestry.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_JAMES_SIMMS_PENSION_S4840",
            "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_NORTH_FORK_DEATH_1892"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Sims is an English form of Sim with an added -s; Sim can be a shortened form of Simon.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SIMS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SIM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary particularly associates Sims with southern England. That is general surname history, not evidence for Julia’s immigrant ancestor or an English home parish.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SIMS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SIM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name can also describe someone living or working at the house of a man called Symme. Sims and Simms are both relevant spellings for this family’s local records.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SIMS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SIM"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I62",
      "person_id": "I62",
      "surname": "White",
      "locality": "Franklin and Wythe counties, Virginia; reported Sullivan County, Tennessee",
      "research_limit": "The 1786 Suckey Bartee marriage anchors this household. Benjamin’s parents remain unresolved. Existing parent claims involving William White and Nancy Ann Brittain were rejected in the earlier identity review as a conflation with a differently married Benjamin.",
      "notes": "The Bartee-connected Benjamin is probably the later Wythe household head: his spouse, ages, county sequence and 1796 bond association fit that identification. Separate Benjamin White households remain possible. The interval after 1796 is poorly documented, and the available account does not establish his birthplace or parents. Original bonds, tax lists and deeds may clarify the household’s movements.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1810_WYTHE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_EVENSHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_UNRESOLVED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_LATER_MILITARY_HINTS_REJECTED",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
        "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_TURNER_WHITE_FAMILIES_CHICKASAW_BEN_2001",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WHITE_BARTEE_BOND_1796",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WHITE_TAX_RECONSTRUCTION"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Benjamin White in George Bartee’s marriage bond",
          "record_date": "8 November 1796 bond",
          "locality": "Franklin County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The published bond transcription lists Benjamin White and William Highly as sureties for George Bartee and Elizabeth Highley.",
          "association": "The same county and Bartee association fit Benjamin’s 1786 marriage to Suckey, providing a specific family-network lead.",
          "alternatives": "The surety could be another Benjamin White; the transcript does not itself state his relationship to George. The original bond could supply further identifiers.",
          "assessment": "The Bartee-connected identity is the leading explanation. This is contemporary household context, not proof of Benjamin’s parents or an earlier generation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITE_BARTEE_BOND_1796",
            "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "White has several English origins, including a nickname for light hair or complexion, a personal-name form, and a possible topographic formation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WHITE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Irish and Scottish Gaelic names and various continental surnames have also been translated as White. Independent adoption is common.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WHITE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name alone does not establish ethnicity, a European birthplace or kinship with a prominent White family. The Bartee marriage identifies this branch more specifically.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WHITE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I65",
      "person_id": "I65",
      "surname": "Lavender",
      "locality": "Franklin and Botetourt counties, Virginia; earlier origin unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Fanny’s 1811 Botetourt marriage names Robert as her father. The 1794 Franklin marriage to Nancy Willis fits the compiled family, but Robert’s parents are unidentified. A separate 1795 marriage to Milly Willis may concern the same man or another Robert.",
      "notes": "Robert’s 1794 marriage is a plausible match for Fanny’s father, but a second marriage in 1795 could concern the same man or another Robert. The latter entry distinguishes a 23 September bond, with James Highly as surety, from the 30 September marriage. A John Lavinder marrying in Bedford in 1822 also names a father Robert. These households have not been connected; the reported 1770 birth and middle name Reid remain unverified.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
        "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
        "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ROOTS_LAVINDER_BEDFORD_MARRIAGES",
        "SRC_ROOTS_LAVENDER_AMHERST_MILLS",
        "SRC_ROOTS_LAVENDER_JOSEPH_RECONSTRUCTION"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "William Lavender’s widow administers his Amherst estate",
          "record_date": "5 February 1776",
          "locality": "Amherst County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "Mills transcribes the grant of estate administration to Milley, widow of William Lavender, with Edmund Wilcox and George Gillaspie as securities. The order also calls for an appraisal of enslaved people and personal estate.",
          "association": "This establishes an earlier Lavender household in the wider Virginia region, within a generation of Robert’s 1794 marriage. It supplies a concrete estate and associates to investigate.",
          "alternatives": "The Amherst and Franklin households may belong to related or separate Lavender families. No record identifies the Milley of 1776 as the Milly Willis of the 1795 marriage.",
          "assessment": "Weak regional connection hypothesis. The estate is documented in a cited transcription; no record reviewed connects Robert to William or Milley. No parentage or inherited occupation is inferred.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_LAVENDER_AMHERST_MILLS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Lavender is an occupational surname for a washer or launderer, particularly a worker washing wool or rinsing fulled cloth.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LAVENDER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name derives through French washing terminology. Walloon or Flemish variants are also possible. No European birthplace or specific formation has been established for Robert.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LAVENDER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The dictionary finds no direct evidence that the English surname came from the lavender plant. The occupational meaning does not demonstrate that Robert himself worked in textiles, or that all Lavender families share ancestry.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LAVENDER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I69",
      "person_id": "I69",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Reported Virginia; Norfolk/Franklin identity unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Mary is a proposed wife of William Bartee in a conflicting compilation. No reviewed record identifies her birth surname or connects her personally to Suckey’s 1786 marriage. Her identity and parents remain unknown.",
      "notes": "Mary’s identification as Suckey’s mother rests on the compiled family. The reported 1750 birth and 1762 marriage for William cannot both describe an ordinary adult marriage, suggesting a wrong date or merged generation. Another compilation names a Mary Israel with John William Bartee, but provides no family or property connection to Suckey. Mary Israel is therefore not an established identification of this woman.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ROOTS_MARY_ISRAEL_BARTEE_COMPOSITE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary (surname unknown) Bartee: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Reported Virginia; Norfolk/Franklin identity unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Mary is a proposed wife of William Bartee in a conflicting compilation. No reviewed record identifies her birth surname or connects her personally to Suckey’s 1786 marriage. Her identity and parents remain unknown. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
            "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_ROOTS_MARY_ISRAEL_BARTEE_COMPOSITE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Her birth surname is unknown, so its meaning cannot yet be assigned. Bartee in the display identifies the proposed married family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
            "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_ROOTS_MARY_ISRAEL_BARTEE_COMPOSITE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The compilation’s Norfolk birth and Franklin death belong to the proposed husband, not evidence of Mary’s own origin. The available indexed Mary Israel household has not been matched to her.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
            "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_ROOTS_MARY_ISRAEL_BARTEE_COMPOSITE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier surname-specific family history can yet be associated with this Mary. The concrete next step is a record naming Suckey’s mother or a wife of the correctly identified William.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
            "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_ROOTS_MARY_ISRAEL_BARTEE_COMPOSITE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I76",
      "person_id": "I76",
      "surname": "Fricke",
      "locality": "Kingdom of Hanover; Newark and East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey",
      "research_limit": "Henry’s American family is traced from his 1869 Newark marriage to Cathrine Schaaf, but his Hanoverian hometown and parents remain unidentified. His reported 1867 immigration and naturalization by 1900 provide a search period; neither statement names the German parish.",
      "notes": "A compiled Missouri–Texas pedigree inserts this New Jersey Henry among the children of Henry Fricke and Henriette Mueller, alongside several other sons named Henry. That reconstruction does not explain his documented New Jersey household and is not a secure parent identification.\n\nEssex County naturalization indexes survive: the A–K petition index covers 1830–1906, and declaration indexes cover 1849–1906. No filing for this Henry has yet been inspected. A petition, declaration, church marriage or passenger record naming his hometown could connect the American household to a particular German family; he may also have used a federal or neighboring county court.\n\nSearches under Henry, Heinrich and Henry Albert, including his reported birth and migration dates, have not yet identified an earlier name-bearer linked to his locality more closely than the former kingdom. Earlier Fricke families cannot presently be ranked as his wider family without a town, relatives or a shared migration trail.\n\nA 1848 Hamilton County index records August Fricke, age 24, from Hanover, who travelled Bremen–Baltimore in 1846, alongside other Fricke entries. This is relevant historical name evidence for the Hanoverian context. H1: August could belong to a wider Hanover Fricke network. Alternative: he is an unrelated Fricke; the index lacks a town, parents, or kinship. Because Henry Albert was born about 1846 and reported arriving in 1867, the dates do not make August his parent and no link is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_HENRIETTE_MUELLER_FRICKE_CONFLATION",
        "SRC_F26_ESSEX_NATURALIZATION_INDEX_GUIDE",
        "SRC_NJ_ARCHIVES_ESSEX_NATURALIZATION_GUIDE",
        "ROOTS26_HAMILTON_FRICKE_NATURALIZATION_1848",
        "ROOTS26_HANNOVERSCHES_NAMENBUCH_1852"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "1848 naturalization index records Hanover Fricke immigrants",
          "record_date": "1846–1848",
          "locality": "Hanover, Bremen and Baltimore; Hamilton County, Ohio",
          "historical_detail": "The University of Cincinnati surname-F index lists August Fricke, age 24, Hanover, who departed Bremen 1 July 1846, arrived Baltimore 8 August 1846 and declared intention on 29 August 1848 (vol. 22, p. 72). It also lists Charles, Francis, Frederick and Henry Fricke entries.",
          "association": "This documents a North German Fricke migration cluster during the period relevant to the American branch.",
          "alternatives": "The entries may represent unrelated Fricke families; no town, parent, sibling or shared migration evidence links August to Henry Albert Fricke of Essex County, New Jersey.",
          "assessment": "Useful contextual support for a wider Hanover Fricke hypothesis, but insufficient for a biological link; no parent edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HAMILTON_FRICKE_NATURALIZATION_1848"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Fricke is treated as a variant of Frick. In German, Frick can come from a shortened Low German form of Friedrich.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICKE_DAFN2",
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICK_DAFN2"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary distinguishes German, Swiss German and English origins. One Swiss formation derives from the place Frick in Aargau.",
          "caveat": "No connection between this Hanoverian branch and Aargau has been established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICKE_DAFN2",
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICK_DAFN2"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "German surname scholarship groups Fricke with shortened personal names beginning with the element meaning peace or protection. Heintze also records the Latinized spelling Friccius. These forms can help recognize names in older records, but do not identify a single founding family. The 1852 Hannoversches Namenbüchlein documents the surname context of Hannover city residents; a separate 1848 naturalization index records multiple Fricke immigrants in the Hanover–North German migration stream. Neither source identifies Henry Albert’s family.",
          "caveat": "The English woodland derivation of Frick does not explain this Hanoverian surname or establish a forestry occupation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HEINTZE_FRICKE",
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICK_DAFN2",
            "ROOTS26_HANNOVERSCHES_NAMENBUCH_1852",
            "ROOTS26_HAMILTON_FRICKE_NATURALIZATION_1848"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I110",
      "person_id": "I110",
      "surname": "Hornberger",
      "locality": "Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran community, Pennsylvania; European origin unresolved",
      "research_limit": "The institutional card citing Christian Gabel’s21 May 1754 baptism names Christiana Henrietta Hornberger as his mother. Her own card gives the variant Hauberger but no parents or dates. The proposed parents C. Hornberger and M. C. remain an unverified compiled lead.",
      "notes": "Her full name and Gabel family association support her identification as the mother, but the proposed parental initials have not been traced to a record. The initial C. does not identify a father named Christian. The IPGV cards form one connected account, and the compiled marriage note gives no known arrival or marriage place. Regional Hornberger marriages provide other households to investigate; none has been linked to her.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_GOBLE_HORNBERGER_PARENT_INITIALS_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GOSCHENHOPPEN_HISTORIANS_EARLY_CHURCH_SCHOOLS",
        "SRC_ROOTS_IPGV_CHRISTIANA_HORNBERGER",
        "SRC_ROOTS_STOEVER_HORNBERGER_MARRIAGES"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Earlier Hornberger households in Stoever’s marriage records",
          "record_date": "25 August 1733;31 August 1736",
          "locality": "Pennsylvania; Chestnut Hill and Leacock labels in the index",
          "historical_detail": "The index records John Bartolomeus Hornberger marrying Anna Elisabetha Reiffen in 1733, with Chestnut Hill beside the bride, and John Carl Hornberger marrying Ana Eva Saur in 1736, with Leacock beside the bride.",
          "association": "These establish named Hornberger households in the regional German church record network before Christiana’s 1754 baptismal appearance as a mother.",
          "alternatives": "They may be relatives or separate families. Shared surname and broad regional church context do not yet connect either household to Old Goshenhoppen or to Christiana.",
          "assessment": "Weak regional leads with specific spouses and dates. Neither man is assigned as father; the initials C. Hornberger do not identify John Carl or any other individual without additional evidence.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_STOEVER_HORNBERGER_MARRIAGES"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Hornberger is a German habitational surname for someone from a place called Hornberg; the place-name combines words for horn and hill or mountain.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HORNBERGER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_IPGV_CHRISTIANA_HORNBERGER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "There are several places called Hornberg. The surname therefore cannot choose one town, region or medieval family for Christiana. Her own institutional card also gives Hauberger as a variant requiring examination of the underlying record.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HORNBERGER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_IPGV_CHRISTIANA_HORNBERGER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A shared Hornberger spelling can arise independently from different places. No connection to a castle, noble family or specific German estate is established by Christiana’s Pennsylvania records. The regional church households below are leads, not pedigree extensions.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HORNBERGER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_IPGV_CHRISTIANA_HORNBERGER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I114",
      "person_id": "I114",
      "surname": "Wilkins",
      "locality": "Reported Virginia; Norfolk County will lead under investigation",
      "research_limit": "Compiled accounts identify Catherine/Kathrine Wilkins as Lemuel Butt’s wife, but her parents and the role of Warden remain unresolved. A newly located Norfolk will-book excerpt names a daughter Catherine Butt among Wilkins relatives; the full entry and identity match still need verification.",
      "notes": "A will-book reference to Catherine Butt in a Wilkins family is a promising match for Lemuel’s wife. The excerpt alone does not identify its testator or distinguish another Catherine Butt. McIntosh’s 1922 volume, page 208, and the original will may resolve that connection. The Warden name could reflect remarriage, a step relationship or a mistaken pedigree. Her reported dates remain unverified.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
        "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
        "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WILKINS_NORFOLK_WILL_LEAD"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Catherine Wilkins (possibly Warden): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Reported Virginia; Norfolk County will lead under investigation",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Compiled accounts identify Catherine/Kathrine Wilkins as Lemuel Butt’s wife, but her parents and the role of Warden remain unresolved. A newly located Norfolk will-book excerpt names a daughter Catherine Butt among Wilkins relatives; the full entry and identity match still need verification. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
            "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
            "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILKINS_NORFOLK_WILL_LEAD"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Wilkins is a form of Wilkin with an added -s. Wilkin is a familiar form of William. A separate northern German or Dutch explanation derives through Wilkens.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILKINS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILKIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WARDEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary associates English Wilkins with the West Midlands and southern England. These are surname distributions/origins, not Catherine’s proven birthplace. Warden has separate occupational and place-name origins if that name ultimately proves relevant.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILKINS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILKIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WARDEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Warden can refer to guarding or to places named with words for a watch and a hill. Its presence in a submitted tree does not show that Catherine’s family held such an office. The Norfolk will lead is more useful for her ancestry than either general name meaning.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILKINS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILKIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WARDEN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I115",
      "person_id": "I115",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia: husband’s will context",
      "research_limit": "Henry Wirick’s will names daughters Mary Barttee and Patient Odean and requires maintenance of their mother, without naming that mother. The proposed forename Mary and her birth surname remain unverified.",
      "notes": "Henry’s will supports the existence of a living mother but does not name her. The imported name Mary may be correct, or may have been confused with his daughter Mary Barttee. The abstract cites Book 9, page 25: written 28 December 1710 and proved 20 April 1711. Probate, dower or property records may identify the older woman; later Pennsylvania and western Virginia Wiricks have not been connected to her.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_ROOTS_FS_NORFOLK_WILLS_VOLUME"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary (maiden name unknown) Werrick: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia: husband’s will context",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Henry Wirick’s will names daughters Mary Barttee and Patient Odean and requires maintenance of their mother, without naming that mother. The proposed forename Mary and her birth surname remain unverified. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FS_NORFOLK_WILLS_VOLUME"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Her maiden surname is unknown. Werrick/Wirick belongs to the proposed husband’s family and cannot establish her own surname meaning.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FS_NORFOLK_WILLS_VOLUME"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The will supplies a Norfolk household setting, not her birthplace. The imported Virginia birth estimate and other reported origins have not been corroborated.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FS_NORFOLK_WILLS_VOLUME"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The specific historical context is the mother’s support provided for in Henry’s will. No earlier namebearer can be assigned to her natal family until a record identifies her.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
            "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FS_NORFOLK_WILLS_VOLUME"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I116",
      "person_id": "I116",
      "surname": "Werrick",
      "locality": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "Henry’s family and property are described in his will of 28 December 1710, proved 20 April 1711. His birthplace and parents are not identified. The reported birth before 1665 is an estimate, not a located birth record.",
      "notes": "The published will abstract names daughter Mary Barttee and grandson Robert Bartee, and describes a second plantation purchased from John Bright for the Odean family. These named relatives and the land provide a distinctive basis for identifying Henry in earlier Norfolk records. Robert’s later will explicitly recalls grandfather Henry Werrick and inherited land, supporting continuity of this family despite the Wirick/Werrick spellings. No earlier local name-bearer has yet been securely connected to Henry. His children were to maintain their unnamed mother; this does not identify Henry’s own mother. The wider Wirick name history suggests a possible German linguistic origin, but his birthplace could have been Virginia or elsewhere. The surname alone does not decide between those origins.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710",
        "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WYRICK_AUGUSTA_1808",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WIRICK_NAME",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WEIRICH_NAME"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Henry Werrick: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Henry’s family and property are described in his will of 28 December 1710, proved 20 April 1711. His birthplace and parents are not identified. The reported birth before 1665 is an estimate, not a located birth record. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710",
            "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WYRICK_AUGUSTA_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WIRICK_NAME",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WEIRICH_NAME"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "For Wirick, the surname dictionary proposes a form of Wirich or Wierich, related to Weirich. That name derives from a Germanic personal name combining elements meaning battle and power. This is a possible explanation of Henry’s variant surname, whose original form remains uncertain.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WIRICK_NAME",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WEIRICH_NAME"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary associates Wirich and Wierich with northern Germany. Henry’s documented setting is coastal Virginia; no immigration record, European parish or named parent currently links him to that region.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WIRICK_NAME",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A separate Virginia record, Augusta chancery case 1808-026, names Henry and Martin Wyrick and includes Nicholas Wyrick’s 1792 Wythe County will. It demonstrates the use of Wirick, Wyric and Wyrick within a later inland family. Neither that index nor the Norfolk will establishes kinship between the two households.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WYRICK_AUGUSTA_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I120",
      "person_id": "I120",
      "surname": "Church",
      "locality": "Norfolk County, Virginia — candidate family identification",
      "research_limit": "Richard is proposed as Elizabeth Church’s father. A Norfolk will supplies a real Church–Butt relationship, but neither Elizabeth’s parentage nor Richard’s own parents have been established.",
      "notes": "The Norfolk testator is the strongest identified candidate for this Richard because his granddaughter bore the Butt surname. This family connection adds weight beyond the matching name and county. It could reflect Elizabeth’s marriage into the Butt family, but another Church daughter could instead have been the granddaughter’s mother. The abstract does not distinguish those routes. Richard’s wife was also called Elizabeth; her name cannot be transferred to a daughter. The local official and the testator plausibly represent the same man, supported by their shared community, but neither identification supplies an earlier generation.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_CHURCH_NAME",
        "SRC_ROOTS_CHURCH_OFFICERS_1699",
        "SRC_OT26_MCINTOSH_CHURCH_BUTT_1705",
        "SRC_VA_HOUSE_RICHARD_CHURCH_1699"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Richard Church’s granddaughter Leddae Butt",
          "record_date": "1705–1706",
          "locality": "Norfolk County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "McIntosh’s abstract of Book 7, page 106, records a will dated 5 January 1705 and proved 15 February 1705/6. A codicil leaves granddaughter Leddae Butt a young horse. Wife Elizabeth and son Joseph were executors. The abstract also names several daughters and includes bequests of enslaved people.",
          "association": "This is direct evidence of a Church–Butt kinship in the locality associated with the proposed ancestry.",
          "alternatives": "Leddae’s parents are unnamed. Her mother might have been the proposed Elizabeth Church, another daughter, or a daughter whose married name changed. The testator could also be a different Richard from the one intended in the imported pedigree.",
          "assessment": "A strong local family lead, with the intervening parentage unresolved. The abstract does not name a daughter Elizabeth or establish Richard’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OT26_MCINTOSH_CHURCH_BUTT_1705"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Richard Church, Norfolk sheriff and burgess",
          "record_date": "1699",
          "locality": "Norfolk County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The county-officer list of 8 June 1699 names Richard Church as sheriff, alongside Thomas Butt and Matthew Godfrey. The House Clerk’s history independently records a Richard Church representing Norfolk County in the 1699 assembly.",
          "association": "Matching name, county and compatible dates favor one man behind the official and probate records. Matthew Godfrey’s appearance among the officers and as a will witness adds a specific community connection.",
          "alternatives": "Another local Richard Church remains possible. Godfrey’s public role could bring him into contact with several families, and appearing with Thomas Butt does not prove kinship.",
          "assessment": "The official and testator are plausibly the same man. This supports a local identification, not a claim that public office proves the proposed father–daughter relationship.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CHURCH_OFFICERS_1699",
            "SRC_VA_HOUSE_RICHARD_CHURCH_1699",
            "SRC_OT26_MCINTOSH_CHURCH_BUTT_1705"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Church usually began as an English name for someone living near a church, or possibly working there as a verger or sexton. It comes from Middle English chirche. It does not by itself indicate clerical office.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CHURCH_NAME"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary places this English name chiefly in southern and midland England and also records Church as an American translation of German Kirch. Richard’s candidate records are in Virginia; they do not identify an English parish or establish which name origin belongs to his family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CHURCH_NAME",
            "SRC_OT26_MCINTOSH_CHURCH_BUTT_1705"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "For this branch, the strongest historical association is with the Church and Butt households of colonial Norfolk. The sheriff and burgess records add a possible public role to that local family history; the surname’s religious meaning does not establish Richard’s occupation or denomination.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CHURCH_OFFICERS_1699",
            "SRC_VA_HOUSE_RICHARD_CHURCH_1699",
            "SRC_OT26_MCINTOSH_CHURCH_BUTT_1705"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I121",
      "person_id": "I121",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Washington County and Saltville, Virginia — McNew household",
      "research_limit": "Nancy Ann Sevier is an unconfirmed identity proposed for David McNew’s wife. The record-based alternative, Ann or Annie Smith, is better supported. Her own parents remain unidentified.",
      "notes": "The McNew census household is recognizable across the records through David, Ann or Annie, and daughter Ailsey or Alcy. A published local compilation quotes son Samuel’s 1918 death record naming his mother Annie Smith. Although recorded long after her birth, that specific parent statement carries more weight than the unsupported Sevier label. The compilation also uses Nancy for Ann and lists a son as Elbert C. Sevier McNew, so those names occur within the family account; a child’s additional name does not establish his mother’s maiden surname. The leading explanation is that the Sevier profile is an alternative, inaccurate description of Ann Smith, rather than a demonstrated second wife. No record reviewed establishes a separate Nancy Sevier or her reported death in 1895.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Nancy Ann Sevier: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Washington County and Saltville, Virginia — McNew household",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Nancy Ann Sevier is an unconfirmed identity proposed for David McNew’s wife. The record-based alternative, Ann or Annie Smith, is better supported. Her own parents remain unidentified. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "If Sevier were confirmed, the surname dictionary offers an English sieve-maker origin and a separate French Xavier derivation. Neither meaning can yet be assigned to this woman’s birth family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SEVIER_NAME"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The family compilation places Ann’s birth in Virginia and reports both parents as North Carolina-born in the 1880 census. These details suggest a Virginia–North Carolina family setting, but do not identify a county of origin or a Sevier household.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The identifiable connections are to David McNew and their Washington County household. No earlier Sevier family has been linked to this candidate. The stronger Smith identification is represented separately in the tree as Ann “Annie” Smith McNew.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I130",
      "person_id": "I130",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Portobacco, Charles County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "Phillis is documented as Jeremiah’s wife, but her birth surname, birthplace and parents remain unknown. Macknew and Mackneugh identify her married household; they have not been established as her maiden name.",
      "notes": "The Charles County court entry dated 10 January 1670 calls Phillis Jeremiah Mackmere’s wife and records their son John Howard’s indenture. It establishes a marriage already in existence, not its date or place. The names, locality and family context favor identification with the Macknew household despite the spelling. Howard might reflect an earlier family relationship or another naming practice; the entry alone does not make it Phillis’s maiden surname. The later appearance bond places her again in the same Maryland community. Scottish birth claims in compiled trees remain unconnected to these records, and her reported death in 1700 is unverified.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_CHARLES_COURT_281",
        "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_BOND_1674",
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_PHILLIS_PARENTAGE_UNKNOWN"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Phillis Macknew (maiden name unknown): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Portobacco, Charles County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Phillis is documented as Jeremiah’s wife, but her birth surname, birthplace and parents remain unknown. Macknew and Mackneugh identify her married household; they have not been established as her maiden name. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_CHARLES_COURT_281",
            "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_BOND_1674",
            "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_PHILLIS_PARENTAGE_UNKNOWN"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "No birth surname is established for Phillis. Neither the married name Macknew nor her son’s Howard name provides a secure basis for explaining her natal family name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_CHARLES_COURT_281",
            "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_BOND_1674",
            "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_PHILLIS_PARENTAGE_UNKNOWN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Her recorded family setting is Charles County, Maryland. The McNew–Cawood history describes passage paid through service to William Barton, but reports her birthplace as unknown; no Scottish parish has been linked to her.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_CHARLES_COURT_281",
            "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_BOND_1674",
            "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_PHILLIS_PARENTAGE_UNKNOWN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "On 10 November 1674, Jeremiah Macknew and Thomas Corker reportedly posted a £50 bond for Phillis’s appearance at the Provincial Court on 8 December. This is a specific connection with Corker, but the extract does not give the reason for the appearance or imply that he was a relative.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_CHARLES_COURT_281",
            "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_BOND_1674",
            "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_PHILLIS_PARENTAGE_UNKNOWN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I132",
      "person_id": "I132",
      "surname": "Schratern",
      "locality": "Reported Midlothian, Scotland; parish unidentified",
      "research_limit": "Rebecca Schratern is identified only in a compiled Mackneugh pedigree. Her surname spelling, reported birth around 1610, locality and parentage lack a confirming contemporary record.",
      "notes": "The supplied pedigree offers Rebecca as Jeremiah Mackneugh’s mother, but does not provide a parish or a record that identifies her independently. An unusual spelling can be valuable evidence when two records describe matching people; here there is not yet a second record for Rebecca. A surname-index search found Marta Schratern in 1819, associated with Frankfurt an der Oder and Petersdorf. That establishes a reported occurrence of the spelling, not a connection to the woman placed in seventeenth-century Scotland. A correctly transmitted rare surname and a copying or transcription error remain possible explanations for Rebecca’s label; the available evidence does not distinguish them.\n\nThe rare Schratern spelling has no independently identified seventeenth-century Scottish bearer in the reviewed sources. H1: the pedigree preserves a genuine but poorly transcribed Midlothian surname. Alternative: the spelling is a copying error, or Rebecca belonged to another surname family entirely. Scotland’s People phonetic search facility gives a concrete variant-search method; Midlothian’s incomplete pre-1855 registration explains the evidentiary limit. No surname origin or parent link is invented.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SCHRATERN_MARTA_1819",
        "ROOTS26_SCHRATERN_VARIANT_SEARCH",
        "ROOTS26_MIDLOTHIAN_REGISTER_LIMITS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Rare Schratern spelling and Midlothian record frontier",
          "record_date": "reported c.1610; pre-1855 record system",
          "locality": "Midlothian, Scotland",
          "historical_detail": "Rebecca Schratern occurs only in a derivative Mackneugh pedigree in the current evidence. Scotland’s People provides phonetic surname matching, while Midlothian Council explains that parish registration before 1855 was not compulsory and surviving coverage varies.",
          "association": "This records the actual identity-search method and its locality-specific limits.",
          "alternatives": "A transcription variant, an unrelated person, or a different surname may explain the pedigree label; no exact or variant match currently selects among them.",
          "assessment": "The compiled candidate remains low-confidence and separate from the later Mackneugh line; no surname origin or parent link is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHRATERN_VARIANT_SEARCH",
            "ROOTS26_MIDLOTHIAN_REGISTER_LIMITS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Surname meaning is unresolved. No reliable dictionary entry or identity-secure historical bearer for the exact Schratern spelling was found.",
          "caveat": "This endpoint has no confirmed surname form or independent contemporary record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHRATERN_VARIANT_SEARCH",
            "ROOTS26_MIDLOTHIAN_REGISTER_LIMITS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Reported locality is Midlothian, Scotland, but possible Germanic-looking spellings such as Schrater, Schrader or Schröter are only search variants; no origin is assigned.",
          "caveat": "This endpoint has no confirmed surname form or independent contemporary record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHRATERN_VARIANT_SEARCH",
            "ROOTS26_MIDLOTHIAN_REGISTER_LIMITS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The relevant historical record system is Midlothian’s pre-1855 Church of Scotland and other parish collections, whose coverage is incomplete and parish-specific.",
          "caveat": "This endpoint has no confirmed surname form or independent contemporary record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHRATERN_VARIANT_SEARCH",
            "ROOTS26_MIDLOTHIAN_REGISTER_LIMITS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I156",
      "person_id": "I156",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Forton, Staffordshire",
      "research_limit": "Mary is recorded as Thomas Grindley’s wife at Forton in 1851 and 1861. Her maiden surname and parents have not been identified. Her reported death in 1866 is also unverified.",
      "notes": "Mary was recorded as 64 in 1851 and 75 in 1861, placing her birth around 1786–1787. Thomas and Ann appear with her in both households. This combination of names, ages and place strongly supports continuity of the same family across the two censuses. The stored transcripts give Thomas’s birthplace as Forton but do not give Mary’s; her own origins remain open. An Irish marriage hint naming Thomas Grindley and Mary Mahony offers a possible maiden name, but no verified age, birthplace, relative or later residence links that bride to this Mary. The matching couple’s names give the suggestion some weight; they do not yet distinguish her from another couple. The Forton marriage index for 1754–1837 contains other Grindley marriages but no identified marriage of this Thomas. A marriage elsewhere, or after the index ends, remains possible.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_REVIEW"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary (surname unknown): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Forton, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Mary is recorded as Thomas Grindley’s wife at Forton in 1851 and 1861. Her maiden surname and parents have not been identified. Her reported death in 1866 is also unverified. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
            "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Grindley is Mary’s recorded married surname. Her birth surname is unknown, so a surname meaning cannot yet be assigned to her natal family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
            "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Forton is her documented home in the two census households. The available transcripts do not establish whether she was born locally or came from elsewhere.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
            "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Her identifiable family setting is the household shared with Thomas and Ann Grindley. Earlier Forton Greenley and Grindley entries concern a possible history of her husband’s family; they do not identify Mary’s own parents or earlier relatives.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
            "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I163",
      "person_id": "I163",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Newport, Shropshire (child’s baptism)",
      "research_limit": "Richard’s 16 April 1759 baptism names his mother Elizabeth, without a maiden surname or parents. Poyner is the household surname, not an established birth surname for her.",
      "notes": "Neither Allen as her birth surname nor a Welsh birthplace is supported by the reviewed records. The relevant Newport is in Shropshire. A local Richard-and-Elizabeth marriage might identify her, but another couple with those names could also explain the compiled family. Their children’s records and household details are needed to distinguish them.\n\nElizabeth’s surname is unresolved. The 1759 Newport baptism is direct evidence of maternity but does not name her birth family. H1 alternatives include a local Newport marriage before 1759, a neighboring Shropshire parish, or a nonconformist record; the reviewed material does not distinguish them. Poyner is not assigned as her maiden name, and no parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_POYNER_NEWPORT_BAPTISM_1759",
        "ROOTS26_NEWPORT_SHROPSHIRE_REGISTERS",
        "ROOTS26_Poyner_ELIZABETH_MAIDEN_LIMIT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Elizabeth named as mother in Newport baptism",
          "record_date": "16 April 1759",
          "locality": "Newport, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The baptism record for Richard Poyner names his mother Elizabeth but does not provide her maiden surname or parents. Shropshire’s parish-register collection covers baptisms, marriages and burials from 1538 onward and points to original records at Shropshire Record Office.",
          "association": "This is the direct local anchor and the concrete route for testing an earlier Elizabeth marriage or household.",
          "alternatives": "Elizabeth may have married Richard Poyner in Newport, come from a neighboring parish, or belong to a nonconformist household; the baptism alone cannot distinguish these.",
          "assessment": "Maternity is retained; birth surname and parentage remain unresolved. No surname or parent link is invented.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_RICHARD_POYNER_NEWPORT_BAPTISM_1759",
            "ROOTS26_NEWPORT_SHROPSHIRE_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "No birth surname is established for Elizabeth; surname meaning cannot responsibly be assigned.",
          "caveat": "Elizabeth’s birth surname is unknown; Poyner is not treated as a maiden name.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWPORT_SHROPSHIRE_REGISTERS",
            "ROOTS26_Poyner_ELIZABETH_MAIDEN_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The relevant locality is Newport, Shropshire, but Elizabeth may have come from Newport or a neighboring parish. Her birth origin remains unknown.",
          "caveat": "Elizabeth’s birth surname is unknown; Poyner is not treated as a maiden name.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWPORT_SHROPSHIRE_REGISTERS",
            "ROOTS26_Poyner_ELIZABETH_MAIDEN_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1759 Newport baptism belongs to the Shropshire parish-register system, whose surviving records can be searched for a marriage or earlier Elizabeth household.",
          "caveat": "Elizabeth’s birth surname is unknown; Poyner is not treated as a maiden name.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWPORT_SHROPSHIRE_REGISTERS",
            "ROOTS26_Poyner_ELIZABETH_MAIDEN_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I164",
      "person_id": "I164",
      "surname": "Deane",
      "locality": "Cleobury Mortimer, Shropshire, England; retained candidate branch",
      "research_limit": "Richard and Mary are named in their daughter’s 1758 Cleobury baptism, but Richard’s reported 1716 birth and parentage remain unverified. A 1762 local burial is a candidate identification, not an established death. This is a retained candidate branch: its proposed connection through Mary Deane to Sarah Poyner was previously detached. It is not established as the user’s ancestry.",
      "notes": "John’s 1750 baptism and Mary’s 1758 baptism probably belong to the same Richard-and-Mary Dean(e) household: the parents’ names, parish and dates agree. Richard’s 1762 burial is another plausible match, without age or kin to confirm it. Mary Dean’s infant burial in 1761 may concern the 1758 child, which would conflict with her proposed adult identity. Another Dean household, Thomas and Mary, married locally in 1759; the burial names no parents.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_REGISTER",
        "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_DEANE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_DEAN",
        "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Richard and Mary Dean household, 1750",
          "record_date": "5 November 1750",
          "locality": "Cleobury Mortimer, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "John was baptized to Richard and Mary Dean, eight years before the recorded Mary Deane baptism to parents with the same names.",
          "association": "A strong local candidate for the same parental household, giving earlier documented family presence.",
          "alternatives": "A second Richard/Mary couple is possible but not evidenced by this entry. Spelling alone is not a conflict. Later survival of the 1758 daughter is challenged by a 1761 infant burial.",
          "assessment": "Plausible same household; original details and full family reconstruction needed. No new parent or sibling edge added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_REGISTER"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Deane is an English variant of Dean. One principal English explanation is a valley dweller or someone from a place called Dean/Dene, from Old English denu.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_REGISTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_DEANE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_DEAN",
            "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
            "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary also gives ecclesiastical and personal-name explanations for Dean, and independent Irish deacon-related origins for Deane. The spelling does not select one founding family or establish Richard’s birthplace; Cleobury is his recorded family setting.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_REGISTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_DEANE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_DEAN",
            "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
            "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Richard and Mary’s household appears in local baptisms in 1750 and 1758. Richard’s 1762 burial is a possible match. Thomas Dean and Mary Ratcliffe, married in 1759, form a separate recorded household whose relationship is unknown.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_REGISTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_DEANE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_DEAN",
            "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
            "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I165",
      "person_id": "I165",
      "surname": "Perkins",
      "locality": "Cleobury Mortimer, Shropshire, England; retained candidate branch",
      "research_limit": "Mary is named as mother in the 1758 baptism, but that record does not supply Perkins as her maiden name. The 1725 Mary Perkins baptism is a promising candidate, not yet a demonstrated identification of Richard Deane’s wife. This is a retained candidate branch: its proposed connection through Mary Deane to Sarah Poyner was previously detached. It is not established as the user’s ancestry.",
      "notes": "Mary Perkins, baptized at Cleobury on 11 April 1725 to John and Martha, is a plausible candidate for Richard Deane’s wife. However, the reported birth year may have been taken from that baptism, and no reviewed marriage gives the wife’s maiden name. The possibility that a different Mary married Richard remains unresolved. Earlier local Perkins families provide context only if this identification is correct.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_REGISTER",
        "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PERKINS",
        "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PERKIN",
        "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PARKIN",
        "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Two Perkins households in Cleobury, 1667",
          "record_date": "5 and 16 November 1667",
          "locality": "Cleobury Mortimer, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "Richard was baptized to John and Joan Perkins, with John described as mason; Mary was baptized to Humfrey and Alice Perkins eleven days later.",
          "association": "Specific surname presence in the same parish 58 years before Mary Perkins’s candidate baptism.",
          "alternatives": "These households may be related or separate Perkins families. The 1725 child’s connection to them, and her identification as Richard Deane’s wife, are both unresolved.",
          "assessment": "Positive local context for a wider-family hypothesis, conditional on establishing Mary’s maiden name. No claimed intervening pedigree.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_REGISTER"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Perkins is a patronymic from Perkin. Perkin/Parkin is a diminutive of Peres, a medieval form of Peter, using the suffix -kin.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_REGISTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PERKINS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PERKIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PARKIN",
            "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
            "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary identifies an English surname also established in central and southern Wales. These broad origins do not establish Mary’s ancestry. For this branch, even the maiden surname is a reported candidate pending a marriage or equivalent record.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_REGISTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PERKINS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PERKIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PARKIN",
            "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
            "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Cleobury has an earlier concrete Perkins cluster: in November 1667 children of John/Joan and Humfrey/Alice were baptized; John was described as a mason. These are separate recorded households, potentially related, not identified ancestors of the 1725 Mary.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_REGISTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PERKINS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PERKIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PARKIN",
            "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
            "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I188",
      "person_id": "I188",
      "surname": "Hanney / Hanny",
      "locality": "Winsley chapelry, Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "research_limit": "Charles is identified through his 1765 Winsley marriage and family records, but the reported 1733 birth is not a matched baptism. His parents remain unestablished; local Hanney households can now be compared through original registers and probate.",
      "notes": "Hester Hanney’s 1761 marriage and Daniel Hanny’s 1769 marriage at Winsley suggest a wider local family around Charles’s 1765 marriage. Their relationships are unknown. The Cumnock Charles with children in the 1730 s conflicts with Charles’s reported 1733 birth, but that birth is itself unverified; an older migrant or remarried man cannot be excluded solely on that basis. No connection between the Scottish and Winsley households has been found. A Bradford Methodist history also describes an early preacher in the Hanny family; the identification with Charles and the recollection of preaching with Wesley are considered below.\n\nA Bradford-on-Avon local history reports an early local preacher called Mr Hanny, his son William Hanny, and grandson William Peters Hanny (born 1802; Methodist Society 1818–1894). H1: Mr Hanny could be Charles Hanney, with William baptized in 1771 and a later Methodist grandson. Alternative: Mr Hanny could be another local Hanny, and the genealogy may only overlap in surname and place. Wiltshire Council confirms that John and Charles Wesley preached repeatedly in Bradford-on-Avon, but neither source says that the unnamed Mr Hanny preached with Wesley. The family lore is therefore recorded as plausible local context, not as a demonstrated Wesley association.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CHARLES_HANNEY_1733_1797",
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL_1798",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_CUMNOCK_KIRK_SESSION_CHARLES_HANNEY_EXCLUSION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_MARRIAGES",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WILTS_HEARTH_1662",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_HANNEY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_HENNEY",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_AVON_METHODIST_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY",
        "ROOTS26_BRADFORD_HANNY_WESLEY_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_WILTSHIRE_METHODIST_CHAPEL"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Other Hanney marriages at Winsley, 1761 and 1769",
          "record_date": "11 May 1761; 30 July 1769",
          "locality": "Winsley St Nicholas, Wiltshire",
          "historical_detail": "The parish transcription records Hester Hanney marrying Charles Hud in 1761 and Daniel Hanny marrying Margaret Woodly in 1769.",
          "association": "Same chapel, surname and close period as Charles Hanney’s 1765 marriage: a plausible wider-family cluster.",
          "alternatives": "Hester and Daniel may belong to different households; Charles may have moved into the chapel area. Their ages, parents and witness connections are not established by this transcription.",
          "assessment": "Positive local evidence for investigating kinship, without enough evidence to specify a relationship. Original signatures, witnesses, baptisms and probate are the next discriminators.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_MARRIAGES",
            "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "The Hanny family’s early Methodist preacher",
          "record_date": "Early Methodism; exact preaching dates unspecified",
          "locality": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire",
          "historical_detail": "A local history written for the 1938 Wesley bicentenary describes an early preacher named Mr Hanny, his son William as a class leader, and his grandson William Peters Hanny, born in 1802.",
          "association": "The named son and distinctive grandson match Charles’s family in the tree, making Charles the leading identification for this preacher. Matthew recalls an ancestor preaching with the founder of Methodism, although the family recollection supplies no name.",
          "alternatives": "The account could have mistaken a generation or family relationship. The recollection could concern another ancestor or participation in Wesley’s movement rather than preaching at the same event.",
          "assessment": "The matching family sequence supports Charles’s identification more strongly than surname alone. Personal preaching alongside John or Charles Wesley remains unconfirmed: the account gives no shared occasion, and the grandfather’s forename is not stated.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_BRADFORD_AVON_METHODIST_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY",
            "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771",
            "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Robert Hanney’s Bradford household before Charles’s marriage",
          "record_date": "1 July 1758, recalling about 1727–1739",
          "locality": "Bradford-on-Avon; Iford in Westwood; Bath",
          "historical_detail": "In a settlement examination on 1 July 1758, William Wickham, aged 33, described his grandfather Robert Hanney as a Bradford public-house keeper. Robert raised him from about two to fourteen and then apprenticed him to Bath joiner William Adams. William was born at Iford in Westwood and named his father as John Wickham.",
          "association": "The recollected ages place Robert’s household in Bradford approximately during 1727–1739, before Charles Hanney’s 1765 marriage at nearby Winsley. The shared surname and district make this a plausible earlier branch of Charles’s wider family.",
          "alternatives": "Robert could belong to a separate local Hanney family. The examination establishes his relationship to William Wickham but neither names Charles nor identifies Robert’s children.",
          "assessment": "This provides a documented local household to compare with Charles’s ancestry; it does not yet distinguish a close relationship from more distant or unrelated name-bearers. No parent link to Charles or association with Wesley is established by this record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HANNEY_SETTLEMENT1758",
            "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Unnamed Hanny local preacher in Bradford-on-Avon Methodist history",
          "record_date": "18th–19th century context; William Peters Hanny 1802–1894",
          "locality": "Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire",
          "historical_detail": "A local history names an early local preacher only as Mr Hanny, then identifies his son William Hanny as a class leader and grandson William Peters Hanny as a long-serving Methodist Society member. Wiltshire Council records repeated preaching visits by John and Charles Wesley to Bradford-on-Avon.",
          "association": "This is a specific Methodist association in the same locality as Charles Hanney and his son William, and it gives the family-lore claim a plausible context.",
          "alternatives": "The unnamed Mr Hanny may be a different man; the local history supplies no given name, baptism, parentage or statement that he preached with Wesley.",
          "assessment": "The locality and apparent three-generation sequence make the identification worth testing against original registers, but the evidence is insufficient to identify Charles as the preacher or to claim direct Wesley collaboration.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BRADFORD_HANNY_WESLEY_HISTORY",
            "ROOTS26_WILTSHIRE_METHODIST_CHAPEL"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Hanney is connected by the surname dictionary to Henney and Hanna forms. A relevant English explanation is residence at a place named Hanney or Hanny, including East/West Hanney or Hanny Combe; other related forms have independent origins.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CHARLES_HANNEY_1733_1797",
            "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
            "SRC_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL_1798",
            "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_CUMNOCK_KIRK_SESSION_CHARLES_HANNEY_EXCLUSION",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_MARRIAGES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILTS_HEARTH_1662",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_HANNEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_HENNEY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "For the Hanney place-name explanation, Old English elements refer to a cock or male bird and an island or land surrounded by water. Berkshire and Somerset are possible surname sources, not demonstrated origins of Charles. His established setting is Winsley in the Bradford-on-Avon area.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CHARLES_HANNEY_1733_1797",
            "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
            "SRC_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL_1798",
            "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_CUMNOCK_KIRK_SESSION_CHARLES_HANNEY_EXCLUSION",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_MARRIAGES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILTS_HEARTH_1662",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_HANNEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_HENNEY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Hester Hanney married at Winsley four years before Charles; Daniel Hanny married there four years afterward. This concrete local cluster is more useful for testing family continuity than assigning Charles to a distant clan from spelling alone.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CHARLES_HANNEY_1733_1797",
            "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
            "SRC_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL_1798",
            "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_CUMNOCK_KIRK_SESSION_CHARLES_HANNEY_EXCLUSION",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_MARRIAGES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILTS_HEARTH_1662",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_HANNEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_HENNEY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I189",
      "person_id": "I189",
      "surname": "Waine",
      "locality": "Winsley chapelry, Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, England",
      "research_limit": "Catherine’s 1765 marriage is identified, but her estimated birth about 1743 and reported 1774 death remain uncorroborated. Her parents are unknown. The new Eaine reading needs comparison with the original and the existing Waine indexes.",
      "notes": "Catherine Eaine in the new transcription is almost certainly the Catherine Waine in the supplied indexes: husband, date and chapel are identical. The original handwriting remains unchecked. Earlier Waines at Calne, Purton and Latton are documented regional families, but none is linked to Catherine. John Wayne’s 1668 Latton will is a possible source of family details. The several indexes of her marriage all describe the same event.\n\nWaine is an occupational surname from wain, “cart” or “wagon,” with Wain and Wayne as historical variants. H1: the Winsley/Bradford-on-Avon Waine household may belong to a local occupational family associated with the region’s transport or cloth economy. Alternative: the surname arose independently elsewhere, and the occupational meaning cannot identify Catherine’s parents. The 1765 marriage and 1771 baptism remain the secure local anchors; no earlier parent link is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CATHERINE_WAINE_1743_1774",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_WILTSHIRE_QUAKER_BIRTHS_WAINE_EXCLUSION",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_MARRIAGES",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WILTS_HEARTH_1662",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAINE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAIN",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAYNE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WAINE_QUAKER_MARRIAGE",
        "ROOTS26_WAINE_DAFN_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_WILTSHIRE_LOCAL_WAINE_TRAIL"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Waine household in Winsley and Bradford-on-Avon locality",
          "record_date": "8 July 1765 and 1771",
          "locality": "Winsley and Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire",
          "historical_detail": "Catherine Waine’s Winsley marriage to Charles Hanny in 1765 and her son William’s 1771 baptism are the direct local anchors. Bradford-on-Avon local-history records describe the surrounding cloth-manufacturing economy and provide parish-record indexes.",
          "association": "The locality and repeated Waine spelling make a local continuity hypothesis worth testing through baptism, settlement and probate records.",
          "alternatives": "Catherine may have arrived from another Wiltshire parish or belong to an unrelated Waine family; no parent, occupation or earlier baptism is yet identified.",
          "assessment": "The marriage and child baptism establish the household, while the local-history context guides further searches without justifying a parent link.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_MARRIAGES",
            "ROOTS26_WILTSHIRE_LOCAL_WAINE_TRAIL"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The dictionary cross-reference Waine to Wain to Wayne leads to an English wagon-related name, associated with driving or making wagons. This is surname background, not Catherine’s or her father’s documented occupation. Waine is an English occupational surname from Old English waegn and Middle English wain, a cart or wagon.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CATHERINE_WAINE_1743_1774",
            "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_WILTSHIRE_QUAKER_BIRTHS_WAINE_EXCLUSION",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_MARRIAGES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILTS_HEARTH_1662",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAINE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAYNE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WAINE_QUAKER_MARRIAGE",
            "ROOTS26_WAINE_DAFN_CONTEXT",
            "ROOTS26_WILTSHIRE_LOCAL_WAINE_TRAIL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name can have independent occupational origins; some Wayne forms also have different regional derivations. Catherine’s 1765 Winsley residence does not establish her birthplace or migration from Calne, Purton or Latton. Waine, Wain and Wayne are spelling variants found in English records; the name can also have independent topographical sign-name origins.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CATHERINE_WAINE_1743_1774",
            "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_WILTSHIRE_QUAKER_BIRTHS_WAINE_EXCLUSION",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_MARRIAGES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILTS_HEARTH_1662",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAINE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAYNE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WAINE_QUAKER_MARRIAGE",
            "ROOTS26_WAINE_DAFN_CONTEXT",
            "ROOTS26_WILTSHIRE_LOCAL_WAINE_TRAIL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Earlier Wiltshire evidence includes the 1715 Quaker marriage of Edmond Waine and Hannah Trueman at Calne, and Mary Waine and John Wayne in Latton’s 1662 tax list. These are specific research leads in different localities, with no demonstrated family connection to Catherine. Bradford-on-Avon was a major historic woollen-cloth centre. That local economy makes a transport or wagon-related surname context plausible, but this is background evidence rather than proof of Catherine’s occupation or kinship.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CATHERINE_WAINE_1743_1774",
            "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_WILTSHIRE_QUAKER_BIRTHS_WAINE_EXCLUSION",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_MARRIAGES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILTS_HEARTH_1662",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAINE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAYNE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WAINE_QUAKER_MARRIAGE",
            "ROOTS26_WAINE_DAFN_CONTEXT",
            "ROOTS26_WILTSHIRE_LOCAL_WAINE_TRAIL"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I197",
      "person_id": "I197",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Ranton and Haughton, Staffordshire",
      "research_limit": "Margaret is named as Joseph Brassington’s mother in the 1787 Ranton baptism. Her maiden surname and parents have not been identified; Davidson and Davison remain unsubstantiated suggestions.",
      "notes": "John and Margaret’s names recur together in the 1841 Haughton census, both aged 75 and reported born in Staffordshire. Matching names and nearby localities favor continuity with Joseph’s parents, though the long interval leaves a later marriage possible. The rounded census age suggests birth roughly 1762–1766, rather than an exact 1766 birth. The reviewed marriage-index results did not identify her marriage. Later John-and-Margaret Brassington marriages belong to a different period and cannot explain Joseph’s 1787 baptism. No source currently links Margaret to a Davidson or Davison family in Staffordshire or Scotland.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
        "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROOTS_BRASSINGTON_GUILD_MARRIAGE_REVIEW"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Margaret (surname unknown) Brassington: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Ranton and Haughton, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Margaret is named as Joseph Brassington’s mother in the 1787 Ranton baptism. Her maiden surname and parents have not been identified; Davidson and Davison remain unsubstantiated suggestions. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
            "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_BRASSINGTON_GUILD_MARRIAGE_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Brassington is her married family name. Without an established birth surname, neither Brassington’s place-name meaning nor Davidson’s or Davison’s meaning can be assigned to her natal family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
            "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The 1841 census reports Staffordshire birth but does not identify a parish. Ranton is the place of her son’s baptism and Haughton the later household location; neither is necessarily her birthplace.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
            "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Her documented family association is with John Brassington and son Joseph. Earlier Brassington households may illuminate her married family, but do not establish her own parents or an earlier natal lineage.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I236",
      "person_id": "I236",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Reported Charles County, Maryland; precise locality unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Elizabeth is proposed as William Marlow’s wife and Edward’s mother. Her maiden surname Williams and her parents have not been established; one cited family reconstruction leaves her surname blank.",
      "notes": "The reviewed Nathan McNew profile describes Elizabeth, born about 1650 and living after 1683, with husband William and son Edward. This matches the intended family more closely than a competing published Williams pedigree with an older wife and different children. The latter may describe another couple or combine incompatible records; its surname cannot simply be transferred to this Elizabeth. Repetition of the Marlow household supports a family hypothesis, but the sources inspected do not identify her birth family. The imported death in 1683 is also uncertain: the cited profile says after that year. A county label alone does not locate her birth, because Maryland used Charles County for jurisdictions with different boundaries in the seventeenth century.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_WILLIAMS_NAME",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_MARLOW_NATHAN",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_MARLOW_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_CHRONOLOGY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Elizabeth Williams: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Reported Charles County, Maryland; precise locality unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Elizabeth is proposed as William Marlow’s wife and Edward’s mother. Her maiden surname Williams and her parents have not been established; one cited family reconstruction leaves her surname blank. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILLIAMS_NAME",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_MARLOW_NATHAN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_MARLOW_CONFLICT",
            "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_CHRONOLOGY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "If Williams is confirmed, it is a surname formed from William with an added s, often expressing a family relationship. Its meaning does not identify Elizabeth’s father as a man named William.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILLIAMS_NAME"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Williams is English in formation and also common in Wales; American families may derive from cognate names in other languages. None of those origins is established for this candidate, whose recorded surname remains unresolved.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILLIAMS_NAME",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_MARLOW_NATHAN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The proposed connection is to William Marlow’s Maryland household. No earlier Williams household has been linked to Elizabeth. Early Maryland Williams records cannot supply her family history until her maiden name and locality are better identified.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_MARLOW_NATHAN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_MARLOW_CONFLICT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I237",
      "person_id": "I237",
      "surname": "Marlow",
      "locality": "reported England",
      "research_limit": "William is a compiled candidate father of Edward Marlow. His reported English birth, age and proposed English parents remain unverified. Competing reconstructions give materially different dates and English localities; no inspected record connects those families to this Maryland branch.",
      "notes": "The early Maryland landholder William Marlow may belong to this family, but no inheritance or family record yet connects him to the compiled William. Another man of the same name, or a mistaken parental generation, remains possible. The Adjoinder patent, rent roll and later conveyances may identify relatives. A Buckinghamshire origin for the surname does not establish this William’s birthplace.\n\nMarlow is a habitational English surname from Marlow, Buckinghamshire, not evidence that this Maryland man came from Buckinghamshire. The St Mary’s County compiled land index places William Marlow, 50 acres at Poplar Hill, under 1667 and 1668 entries, citing rent-roll and patent material. H1: this could be the early Maryland William behind the later compiled line. Alternative: the index entry is a different William, or the later genealogy conflates men; the current source does not inspect the original patent and the locality differs from the reported Charles County branch. Maryland State Archives’ 1633–1683 patent database is the next direct test. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_MARLOW_ENGLISH_PARENTAGE_REVIEW_20260728",
        "SRC_ROOTS_MARLOW_ADJOINER_LAND_INDEX",
        "ROOTS26_MARLOW_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_MARYLAND_EARLY_SETTLERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "William Marlow and Adjoinder in Poplar Hill",
          "record_date": "1667/1668 (dates reported by a later land index)",
          "locality": "Poplar Hill hundred, St Mary’s County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "The county genealogy land index associates William Marlow with 50-acre Adjoinder, also called St Johns Addition. Its 1667 entry cites the 1707 rent rolls, and a 1668 entry cites patent records. The underlying texts have not been inspected.",
          "association": "This is a specific early Maryland William Marlow record lead compatible with the compiled generation, though in a different county from the later Charles County family.",
          "alternatives": "The landholder could be the candidate William or another Marlow. A county-level regional match without named kin or traced land succession does not distinguish those identities.",
          "assessment": "Useful regional family-history lead; exact identity and descent remain unresolved. Verify the patent and rent-roll wording and follow property transfers before treating this as the candidate’s biography.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_MARLOW_ADJOINER_LAND_INDEX"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "William Marlow in Poplar Hill land-index entries",
          "record_date": "1667–1668",
          "locality": "Poplar Hill, Maryland; indexed under St Mary’s County",
          "historical_detail": "The St Mary’s County compiled adjoinder index lists William Marlow for 50 acres at Poplar Hill under 1667 and 1668 entries, citing a 1707 rent roll and patent records. The original patent and rent roll have not been inspected here.",
          "association": "This is a specific colonial Maryland record lead for the compiled William Marlow candidate.",
          "alternatives": "The indexed William may be a different man; the locality and record type do not by themselves connect him to the later Charles County line or to Edward Marlow.",
          "assessment": "Ranked as useful contextual evidence and a direct archival search target, not as an established parent or identity link.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_MARLOW_ADJOINER_LAND_INDEX",
            "ROOTS26_MARYLAND_EARLY_SETTLERS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Marlow is a habitational English surname from Marlow in Buckinghamshire, a place-name interpreted from Old English as remnants of land after a lake or pool was drained.",
          "caveat": "Surname meaning and regional occurrence do not identify William Marlow’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MARLOW_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_MARYLAND_EARLY_SETTLERS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname is associated with Marlow, Buckinghamshire; Marlowe is a variant and historical records can confuse Marlow with Marley.",
          "caveat": "Surname meaning and regional occurrence do not identify William Marlow’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MARLOW_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_MARYLAND_EARLY_SETTLERS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Colonial Maryland land records provide a concrete historical context: a derivative St Mary’s County index places William Marlow at Poplar Hill in 1667/1668. This is a record lead, not proof of the family’s English origin or identity.",
          "caveat": "Surname meaning and regional occurrence do not identify William Marlow’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MARLOW_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_MARYLAND_EARLY_SETTLERS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I246",
      "person_id": "I246",
      "surname": "Koch",
      "locality": "Reported Erpfingen area, Württemberg",
      "research_limit": "Margaretha Koch is proposed as Martin Göbel’s mother in a compiled tree. Her own identity, parents and reported birth around 1551 have not been established by a personal record.",
      "notes": "The reported age is compatible with motherhood around 1575. Weigel’s parish-based pedigree proposes Hans Göbel as Martin’s father with an explicit qualification, but leaves the mother unnamed. That omission supplies no competing mother and does not disprove Margaretha; it leaves the Koch identification dependent on the compiled tree. Earlier Koch records in Winterlingen show the name in the wider region, but no record currently links that household to Margaretha or establishes that she came from Winterlingen.\n\nKoch is the German occupational name “cook,” with independent Jewish and other Central European formations. Erpfingen is documented by the municipality from 777, but that broad history does not identify a sixteenth-century Koch household. The online Erpfingen register catalogue begins in 1808, so it cannot directly test Margaretha’s reported c.1551 birth. H1 remains the compiled Koch mother claim; alternative: Martin’s mother was another unnamed local woman. Weigel’s tentative Hans Göbel father hypothesis does not name a mother and is not evidence against Koch. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "SRC_ROOTS_KOCH_NAME",
        "SRC_ROOTS_KOCH_WINTERLINGEN",
        "ROOTS26_KOCH_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_ERPFINGEN_LOCAL_HISTORY",
        "ROOTS26_ERPFINGEN_MATRICULA_COVERAGE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Caspar Koch in Winterlingen’s 1523 muster list",
          "record_date": "1523",
          "locality": "Winterlingen, Amt Balingen, Württemberg",
          "historical_detail": "Weigel cites Caspar Koch, aged 55, in the 1523 muster list, referring to Zahawi’s edition, page 153. This implies birth around 1468, rather than a recorded birth date.",
          "association": "The record places the surname in the wider Württemberg region before Margaretha’s reported lifetime.",
          "alternatives": "Winterlingen is a different locality from Erpfingen. The surname could have arisen independently, and neither a migration nor a family relationship connects Caspar to Margaretha.",
          "assessment": "Documented regional surname history, with only a weak basis for a wider-family connection. Caspar is not assigned as an ancestor.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_KOCH_WINTERLINGEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Erpfingen locality and register coverage for Koch research",
          "record_date": "777; registers catalogued 1808–1875",
          "locality": "Erpfingen, Sonnenbühl, Württemberg",
          "historical_detail": "The municipality records Erpfingen’s first secure written mention on 16 November 777. The Baden-Württemberg archive catalogue lists Erpfingen baptisms from 1808–1838 and 1841–1875, marriages 1808–1871 and burials 1808–1875.",
          "association": "This establishes the relevant locality and a concrete archival route while showing why the available catalogue does not directly reach Margaretha’s reported sixteenth-century birth.",
          "alternatives": "A different mother or a neighboring parish remains possible; Koch’s occupational meaning does not identify one family.",
          "assessment": "The locality evidence supports continued parish and archive research but does not strengthen the compiled Margaretha parent claim enough to add a link.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ERPFINGEN_LOCAL_HISTORY",
            "ROOTS26_ERPFINGEN_MATRICULA_COVERAGE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Koch is a German and Ashkenazic occupational surname from Koch, “cook.”",
          "caveat": "Surname meaning and locality history do not identify Margaretha’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KOCH_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ERPFINGEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The spelling can arise independently in German-speaking and other Central European communities; the surname alone does not establish a Württemberg or Jewish origin.",
          "caveat": "Surname meaning and locality history do not identify Margaretha’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KOCH_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ERPFINGEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Erpfingen has a municipal history reaching to a 777 Lorsch donation entry. The locality context is relevant, but no Koch person in that early notice is identified.",
          "caveat": "Surname meaning and locality history do not identify Margaretha’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KOCH_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ERPFINGEN_LOCAL_HISTORY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I249",
      "person_id": "I249",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "No locality recorded",
      "research_limit": "Mary None appears only as a given-name profile in the supplied GEDCOM. No surname, dates, locality, parents, spouse or independent record is attached. H1 is the imported profile; alternatives are another person with the same given name, an incomplete GEDCOM identity, or a transcription artifact. A confirmed relationship or locality is required before surname or historical continuity can be tested. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Surname unresolved: the source contains no family name to research.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary None: source-only profile with no surname or locality",
          "record_date": "dates unknown",
          "locality": "No locality recorded",
          "historical_detail": "The supplied GEDCOM contains only the given-name profile “Mary None”. It gives no surname, dates, place, parents, spouse or independent record.",
          "association": "The continuity hypothesis is only that the imported profile is correctly placed in the tree. Alternatives are another person with the same given name, an incomplete identity, or a transcription artifact.",
          "alternatives": "Another same-name person; missing surname; wrong branch placement; or GEDCOM transcription artifact.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint records the actual source limit and preserves uncertainty. No surname, historical name-bearer, or parent edge is added.",
          "source_ids": []
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "No surname is present for Mary None; surname meaning cannot be assessed from the available record.",
          "caveat": "Assigning an etymology would invent missing data.",
          "source_ids": []
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No birthplace, residence or migration origin is recorded for Mary None.",
          "caveat": "There is no locality against which a wider-family hypothesis can be compared.",
          "source_ids": []
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The only association is the supplied GEDCOM profile for Mary None; no earlier name-bearer or local event can be tied to it.",
          "caveat": "A generic historical example would not identify this person.",
          "source_ids": []
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I250",
      "person_id": "I250",
      "surname": "Mueller",
      "locality": "Reported Hanover; later St Louis, Missouri, and Texas",
      "research_limit": "Henriette’s parents and German parish have not been identified. The imported profile gives 1829–1892 and spouse Henry Fricke; a matching compiled profile adds places but no parent-naming record.",
      "notes": "The unusual full name, matching lifespan and husband strongly favor the compiled profile describing the same woman. Its details may share a source with the imported tree, however, so they are not independent confirmation. Hanover is reported without a parish and cannot yet be restricted to the city rather than the wider territory. The cited American census locations provide a route to identifying her household and migration, but no earlier Müller family has been linked to her. The spelling Heinderike is retained as supplied until an original record resolves it.\n\nMueller/Müller means “miller,” but is among the most common German surnames and has more than one cultural formation. The spelling Heinderike remains as supplied; Henriette, Charlotte and Heinderike may be one person, but independent compiled profiles are not independent proof. H1: a Hanover Lutheran Mueller household is the source family. Alternative: a different Hanover parish, a different Müller household, or an Americanized spelling obscures the identity. The official church-book archive is the next route; no parent link is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_HENRIETTE_MUELLER_COMPILED",
        "SRC_ROOTS_MUELLER_NAME",
        "ROOTS26_MUELLER_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_HANOVER_CHURCH_ARCHIVE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Hanover church-book route for Henriette Mueller",
          "record_date": "19th-century research frontier",
          "locality": "Former Kingdom of Hanover, Germany",
          "historical_detail": "The Landeskirchliches Archiv Hannover provides official guidance for access to Lutheran church books. Those records are the appropriate route for testing Henriette’s reported 1829 birth and identifying parents once her parish is known.",
          "association": "This is a concrete archive trail rather than a generic statement that records might exist.",
          "alternatives": "The family may have belonged to another Hanover parish, a non-Lutheran community, or a different Mueller household; no parish or parent-naming record is currently established.",
          "assessment": "The archive route improves the research plan but does not support adding a parent or selecting among compiled profiles.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HANOVER_CHURCH_ARCHIVE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Mueller is the unaccented form of German Müller, an occupational surname meaning miller.",
          "caveat": "The common surname and spelling variants do not identify Henriette’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MUELLER_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_HANOVER_CHURCH_ARCHIVE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name can arise independently in German-speaking and Ashkenazic communities; Mueller, Muller and Miller are common spelling or translation forms.",
          "caveat": "The common surname and spelling variants do not identify Henriette’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MUELLER_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_HANOVER_CHURCH_ARCHIVE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Hanover Lutheran church books are the relevant record series, but a parish must first be identified. The surname’s high frequency makes broad distribution weak evidence.",
          "caveat": "The common surname and spelling variants do not identify Henriette’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MUELLER_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_HANOVER_CHURCH_ARCHIVE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_I251",
      "person_id": "I251",
      "surname": "Fricke",
      "locality": "Reported Hanover and Missouri; precise home parish unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Henry’s imported profile reports 1817–1893 and a wife, Henriette Charlotte Heinderike Mueller, but supplies no record citation or parents. A matching online pedigree gives that unusually named wife a husband born in 1815 who died in 1867. The couple’s identity and dates therefore need resolving before an earlier generation can be assigned.",
      "notes": "The matching wife’s name is positive evidence that the accounts concern the same intended couple, but the online pedigree also lists several Henry children with different birth years. It could combine more than one family. No earlier Hanover household has been established for Henry, and the reported birthplace has not been narrowed to a parish.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_YOURROOTS_HENRIETTE_MUELLER"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Henry Fricke: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Reported Hanover and Missouri; precise home parish unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Henry’s imported profile reports 1817–1893 and a wife, Henriette Charlotte Heinderike Mueller, but supplies no record citation or parents. A matching online pedigree gives that unusually named wife a husband born in 1815 who died in 1867. The couple’s identity and dates therefore need resolving before an earlier generation can be assigned. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_YOURROOTS_HENRIETTE_MUELLER"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Fricke is a variant of Frick. The German surname can derive from a shortened Low German form of Friedrich.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICKE_DAFN2",
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICK_DAFN2"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary distinguishes that German personal-name origin from a Swiss family name derived from Frick in Aargau. Henry’s reported Hanover origin gives no evidence of descent from the Swiss locality.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICKE_DAFN2",
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICK_DAFN2"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "St. Louis records also contain a different-looking Henriette Fricke: a church transcription identifies her as née Schacht, born in 1818, and widowed about ten years before her death in 1893. Those details distinguish her from the reported Mueller wife born in 1829; matching married names alone cannot combine these households.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ST_MARCUS_HENRIETTE_FRICKE_1893",
            "SRC_ROOTS_YOURROOTS_HENRIETTE_MUELLER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_RHEAD_STEPHEN_HENRY_1836",
      "person_id": "C_RHEAD_STEPHEN_HENRY_1836",
      "surname": "Rhead",
      "locality": "reported Staffordshire, England",
      "research_limit": "The 1841 census places Stephen, aged six, with Sampson, Sarah, Richard, George and Ruth. He is probably their son, although this census does not state relationships. His later identity, including the reported 1890 death, remains unconfirmed.",
      "notes": "Stephen’s age and household context favor identifying him as Sampson and Sarah’s son. Another young relative is possible, but no record specifically supports that alternative. His later census and marriage identity remain unresolved, preventing a reliable extension of this branch.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG",
        "SRC_RHEAD_YOURROOTS_STEPhen"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Stephen Rhead: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "reported Staffordshire, England",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The 1841 census places Stephen, aged six, with Sampson, Sarah, Richard, George and Ruth. He is probably their son, although this census does not state relationships. His later identity, including the reported 1890 death, remains unconfirmed. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG",
            "SRC_RHEAD_YOURROOTS_STEPhen"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Rhead is classified as a Staffordshire form of Read, which the dictionary connects with Reed. That wider name group has several possible formations: a reddish appearance, residence near a clearing, or a place name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RHEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_READ",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The Rhead entry specifically associates the spelling with Staffordshire. The wider Read/Reed group also has English and Scottish formations.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RHEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_READ",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Read and Reed are useful spellings to check alongside Rhead. For the wider group, the dictionary identifies several possible places, including Read in Lancashire, Reed in Hertfordshire and Rede in Suffolk.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RHEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_READ",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_POYNER_CHARLES_PRE_1675",
      "person_id": "C_POYNER_CHARLES_PRE_1675",
      "surname": "Poyner",
      "locality": "Stanton Lacy, Shropshire",
      "research_limit": "The published register transcript records Charles and Richard, sons of Charles Poyner and Elinor, baptised on 28 July 1675. This establishes the reported household more securely than the old snippet, but does not identify Charles’s parents or connect his son to the later Poyner chain.",
      "notes": "The parish transcript’s exact child, date and place support identifying Charles as the recorded father. An older citation points to an unrelated 1940 New York census and does not support this baptism. A parish flyleaf also names Charles Poyner among people paying fees for an out-of-parish marriage, but supplies neither wife nor date. His connection to the later Richard pedigree remains uncertain.\n\nPoyner is an English surname of possible Norman nickname origin, “fighter/warrior,” with Poynor, Punyer and Powner variants. Oxford’s early-bearer material includes Shropshire forms, making the Stanton Lacy setting compatible with wider regional continuity. The 1675 register establishes Charles as father of Charles and Richard with Elinor, but H1 continuity into the later Richard pedigree remains only a candidate; alternative: another Richard Poyner or a mistaken generation. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_STANTON_LACY_POYNER_REGISTERS",
        "ROOTS26_POYNER_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_STANTON_LACY_REGISTER_CATALOGUE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Charles Poyner household in Stanton Lacy register",
          "record_date": "28 July 1675",
          "locality": "Stanton Lacy, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The parish transcript records Charles and Richard, sons of Charles Poyner and Elinor, baptised on 28 July 1675. Stanton Lacy register coverage begins in 1561, providing a concrete route for searching an earlier Charles marriage or baptism.",
          "association": "This is a specific local Poyner household and a stronger anchor than the former ambiguous index snippet.",
          "alternatives": "The later Richard Poyner chain may use another man of the same name or omit a generation; the baptism does not name Charles’s parents.",
          "assessment": "The household is retained as a documented candidate frontier, but no biological extension is added beyond the recorded fatherhood.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_STANTON_LACY_POYNER_REGISTERS",
            "ROOTS26_STANTON_LACY_REGISTER_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Poyner is described as an English nickname surname from Anglo-Norman French poigneur/pugneire, “fighter” or “warrior.”",
          "caveat": "Surname variants and regional records do not identify Charles’s parents or prove continuity into the later chain.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_POYNER_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_STANTON_LACY_REGISTER_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Poyner has Poynor, Punyer and Powner variants; Oxford’s early forms include Poyner/Punyer records in Shropshire and other English counties.",
          "caveat": "Surname variants and regional records do not identify Charles’s parents or prove continuity into the later chain.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_POYNER_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_STANTON_LACY_REGISTER_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Stanton Lacy parish-register coverage reaches back to 1561, giving a concrete local record trail around the 1675 Poyner household.",
          "caveat": "Surname variants and regional records do not identify Charles’s parents or prove continuity into the later chain.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_POYNER_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_STANTON_LACY_REGISTER_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_RHEINMUELLER_HANS_CONRAD",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_HANS_CONRAD",
      "surname": "Rheinmueller",
      "locality": "Possible Offenbach am Glan connection through his daughter",
      "research_limit": "Hans Conrad is named as Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller’s father in the Goble family compilation. His own parents, dates and residence remain unidentified. The published account supplies a family relationship but no original record for him.",
      "notes": "Maria Margaretha’s reported marriage to Hans Jacob Gabel on 9 January 1690/91 carries a garbled Offenbach am Glan place-name. The local Protestant family-book index contains both Rheinmüller and Reinmüller, as well as Gabel, giving the proposed locality some independent support. It does not name Hans Conrad or date those families, so it cannot yet distinguish his household from another local family. Archion’s displayed Offenbach catalogue has marriage coverage from 1732, too late for the reported wedding. The local compiler also used the St. Julian family book for 1634–1798; Catholic marriages at Offenbach begin in 1691. Those are possible routes to the family’s earlier records, but neither their entries nor the original wedding record has been checked.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
        "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_GLAN_ARCHION",
        "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_KUEHN_SOURCES",
        "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_EV_SURNAMES"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Hans Conrad Rheinmueller: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Possible Offenbach am Glan connection through his daughter",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Hans Conrad is named as Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller’s father in the Goble family compilation. His own parents, dates and residence remain unidentified. The published account supplies a family relationship but no original record for him. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_GLAN_ARCHION",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_KUEHN_SOURCES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_EV_SURNAMES"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The spelling Rheinmüller suggests “Rhine miller,” a term documented as an occupation in early German records. An occupational origin is plausible, but the origin of Hans Conrad’s surname and his own trade remain unestablished.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_RHEINMUELLER_MAINZ_1606"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The family’s best geographical clue is Offenbach am Glan, attached to Maria Margaretha’s reported marriage. Rheinmüller and Reinmüller both occur in the local Protestant surname index. The index supports investigating this locality, but gives no individual dates or relationships and does not establish that the two spellings describe one family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_EV_SURNAMES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A Mainz deed abstract of 2 May 1606 names Jakob Bardt, a Rheinmüller, as a guardian of the children of the deceased carpenter Velten Hardtman. His surname was Bardt, so he is not an earlier bearer of Hans Conrad’s family name. No earlier individual has yet been connected to this branch; the Offenbach surname index offers a more relevant family lead than occupational references from other Rhine towns.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_RHEINMUELLER_MAINZ_1606",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_EV_SURNAMES"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_RHEINMUELLER_MARIA_MARGARETHA_MOTHER",
      "person_id": "C_RHEINMUELLER_MARIA_MARGARETHA_MOTHER",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Residence unestablished; reported daughter’s family associated with Offenbach am Glan",
      "research_limit": "The Goble compilation names Maria Margaretha as the mother of Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller and pairs her with Hans Conrad Rheinmueller. It supplies no birth surname, dates or identifying event for the mother. The reported daughter’s 1690/91 marriage is the main lead for identifying her.",
      "notes": "A Catholic family book records Johannes Gabel at Offenbach with an unnamed wife and son Johann Georg in 1694. That places a Gabel household in the locality, but neither identifies this mother nor establishes that Johannes was the reported son-in-law Hans Jacob. The regional source inventory also includes the St. Julian family book covering 1634–1798. No birth-family surname has been established for this woman, so Rheinmüller surname history cannot be assigned to her as her own ancestry.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
        "SRC_ROOTS_JUNG_OFFENBACH_GABEL_1694",
        "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_KUEHN_SOURCES"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Maria Margaretha: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Residence unestablished; reported daughter’s family associated with Offenbach am Glan",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The Goble compilation names Maria Margaretha as the mother of Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller and pairs her with Hans Conrad Rheinmueller. It supplies no birth surname, dates or identifying event for the mother. The reported daughter’s 1690/91 marriage is the main lead for identifying her. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_JUNG_OFFENBACH_GABEL_1694",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_KUEHN_SOURCES"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Maria Margaretha without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Maria Margaretha. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Maria Margaretha without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "person_id": "C_GABEL_FREDRICK_ALT_PARENT",
      "surname": "Gabel",
      "locality": "Unresolved; possible confusion with Frederik Gabel of Denmark and Norway",
      "research_limit": "Fredrick is an imported candidate father of Hans Jacob Gabel. His association with Anne Catherine Juul and a group of Scandinavian Gabel children points to the diplomat Frederik Gabel, rather than an independently identified Palatinate father.",
      "notes": "The historical Frederik Gabel, born about 1645, married Anne Cathrine Juul in 1671. His date, wife’s distinctive name and the children listed by FamilySearch fit that household closely. They explain where the imported identity may have come from, but not why Hans Jacob is included. A mistaken attachment currently fits better than demonstrated parentage; Frederik’s documented parents are therefore not extended into this branch.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_FAMILYSEARCH_JUUL_CLUSTER_20260916",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DBL_FREDERIK_GABEL",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NBL_FREDERIK_GABEL"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Fredrick Gabel: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Unresolved; possible confusion with Frederik Gabel of Denmark and Norway",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Fredrick is an imported candidate father of Hans Jacob Gabel. His association with Anne Catherine Juul and a group of Scandinavian Gabel children points to the diplomat Frederik Gabel, rather than an independently identified Palatinate father. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FAMILYSEARCH_JUUL_CLUSTER_20260916",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DBL_FREDERIK_GABEL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NBL_FREDERIK_GABEL"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Gabel can refer to a maker or seller of agricultural forks, or to residence beside a fork in a road, river or piece of land. The surname alone does not establish Frederik’s occupation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GABEL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary recognizes German and Ashkenazic occupational formations and German habitational names. The identifiable diplomat belonged to a family that moved from the Bremen setting to Copenhagen; that biography is a clue to the imported identity, not evidence that Hans Jacob’s family followed the same route.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GABEL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DBL_FREDERIK_GABEL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Frederik Gabel became vice governor of Norway in 1699 and was the son of Christoffer Gabel and Ermegaard Badenhaupt. These facts identify the prominent family apparently represented in the candidate cluster. No inspected evidence joins its ancestry to Hans Jacob in the Palatinate.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_NBL_FREDERIK_GABEL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FAMILYSEARCH_JUUL_CLUSTER_20260916"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "person_id": "C_JUUL_ANNE_CATHERINE",
      "surname": "Juul",
      "locality": "Unresolved; Danish–Norwegian family may have been attached to a Palatinate lineage",
      "research_limit": "Anne Catherine Juul is an imported candidate mother of Hans Jacob Gabel. The source appears to draw on the identifiable Danish–Norwegian family of Anne Cathrine Juul and Frederik Gabel, but their relationship to Hans Jacob has not been established.",
      "notes": "The FamilySearch page groups Hans Jacob with Frederik Wilhelm, Ovida Christine and Kristoffer Gabel, names associated with the Scandinavian household. This makes a mistaken joining of families a stronger explanation than an otherwise unidentified German couple with the same names. The page also presents different wives and marriage dates for Hans Jacob in its narrative and timeline. Those conflicts require the individual records to be separated before the Juul ancestry can be extended.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_FAMILYSEARCH_JUUL_CLUSTER_20260916",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DBL_FREDERIK_GABEL",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NBL_FREDERIK_GABEL"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anne Cathrine Juul and Frederik Gabel: the identifiable Scandinavian couple",
          "record_date": "25 April 1671",
          "locality": "Christiania, Norway; family connections to Stockholm and Copenhagen",
          "historical_detail": "The Danish biographical dictionary records their marriage in Christiania. It gives Anne’s birth as 5 June 1655 in Stockholm and names her parents as Ove Juul and Kirstine Urne; she was buried at St. Petri, Copenhagen, on 24 August 1707. The Norwegian biography independently summarizes the same marriage and parentage, although the accounts may share older sources.",
          "association": "The unusual combination of her name, husband and children strongly suggests that this household supplied the Juul identity in the FamilySearch pedigree.",
          "alternatives": "Hans Jacob might still have belonged to that household, but his reported birth about 1670 precedes the 1671 marriage and would make Anne about fourteen or fifteen. A premarital birth is possible; the dates alone do not exclude it. No inspected record connects this couple to him in the Palatinate.",
          "assessment": "A mistaken attachment of the Scandinavian family currently explains the combined evidence better than proven parentage. The named Juul parents belong to the identifiable Scandinavian woman and are not added as ancestors of Hans Jacob.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DBL_FREDERIK_GABEL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NBL_FREDERIK_GABEL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FAMILYSEARCH_JUUL_CLUSTER_20260916"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Juul is a Danish and Norwegian variant of Juhl. The Scandinavian name is associated with Old Norse jól, the midwinter festival that became Christmas, and could refer to a birth or another connection with that season.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_JUUL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_JUHL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary places Juul in Denmark and Norway. Juhl also has a separate German explanation from a Slavic word meaning bare or barren. These different formations cannot determine the birthplace of the imported candidate.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_JUUL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_JUHL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The specifically identifiable Juul family here belongs to Danish–Norwegian official circles. Its possible appearance in the imported pedigree explains the name, but does not establish a route from Hans Jacob’s Palatinate family into that lineage.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DBL_FREDERIK_GABEL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FAMILYSEARCH_JUUL_CLUSTER_20260916"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_ABOUT_1718_20_MAR_179",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "William McNew’s family: reported Maryland and Virginia; Mary’s birthplace unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Mary is identified as William McNew’s wife and George’s mother in the published family history. Her birth surname remains unresolved. Nathan McNew’s compilation calls her Mary Eckless Berry and reports a marriage about 1735 in St John’s Parish, Maryland, citing other family trees rather than an original marriage entry. Another supplied tree calls her Mary Clemons.",
      "notes": "An indexed family-history outline places Mary Berry with William and Mary Clemons with their reported son Daniel Shadrack. Confusion between generations could therefore explain the Clemons claim, although the underlying records have not settled it. Berry remains a candidate, not an established birth family, and the role of Eckless in her name is unexplained. Her reported 1718 birth and 1798 death do not yet identify her parents. McNew is her married surname; its history belongs to William’s branch.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
        "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_DERIVATION",
        "SRC_ROOTS_OAK_BOWERY_MARY_MCNEW_SURNAMES"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary (surname unresolved) McNew: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "William McNew’s family: reported Maryland and Virginia; Mary’s birthplace unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Mary is identified as William McNew’s wife and George’s mother in the published family history. Her birth surname remains unresolved. Nathan McNew’s compilation calls her Mary Eckless Berry and reports a marriage about 1735 in St John’s Parish, Maryland, citing other family trees rather than an original marriage entry. Another supplied tree calls her Mary Clemons. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
            "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_DERIVATION",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OAK_BOWERY_MARY_MCNEW_SURNAMES"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Mary’s birth surname is unresolved. “Eckless Berry” is a compiled candidate, while another supplied tree calls her Mary Clemons; McNew is her married surname through William McNew.",
          "caveat": "The competing names are not interchangeable, and no original marriage or baptism record settles which, if either, is correct.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
            "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_DERIVATION",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OAK_BOWERY_MARY_MCNEW_SURNAMES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The compiled Berry hypothesis reports a marriage about 1735 in St John’s Parish, Maryland, and a life in the reported Maryland/Virginia McNew family context. Her parents and exact birthplace remain unidentified.",
          "caveat": "The locality and date come from compiled family histories and are not treated as proof of a birth family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
            "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_DERIVATION",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OAK_BOWERY_MARY_MCNEW_SURNAMES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Family-history sources place Mary with William McNew and identify her as George’s mother; an indexed outline separates a Mary Berry/William household from a Mary Clemons/Daniel Shadrack claim, raising a possible generation or identity mix-up.",
          "caveat": "These associations explain the competing hypotheses but do not establish Mary’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
            "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_DERIVATION",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OAK_BOWERY_MARY_MCNEW_SURNAMES"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_HV4_LUCY_WALKER_BET_1785_AND_1794_BEFORE_180",
      "person_id": "HV4_LUCY_WALKER_BET_1785_AND_1794_BEFORE_180",
      "surname": "Walker",
      "locality": "Possible Laurel Fork, Washington County, Virginia, and Claiborne County, Tennessee",
      "research_limit": "Lucy’s imported profile supplies a marriage to William J. McNew but no parents. A Laurel Fork Walker family offers a specific parentage lead, although the identity of the McNew couple and the profile’s dates still need to be reconciled.",
      "notes": "The compiled marriage date, 23 October 1801, would make William about fifteen and Lucy between seven and sixteen under their reported birth dates; that range cannot be accepted without checking its basis. The place is also recorded as Franklin County, Tennessee, a county not created until 1807. It may be a later place label or an error. Her reported death before 1806 conflicts with a later deed naming William and Lucy McNew if they are the same couple. These problems favor revisiting the compiled chronology rather than using it to exclude the documented local family.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_LUCY_MCNEW_DEED_INDEX",
        "SRC_ROOTS_LAUREL_WALKER_FAMILY_REVIEW",
        "SRC_ROOTS_FRANKLIN_TN_CREATION"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Lucy Walker among the Laurel Fork land grantees",
          "record_date": "3 January 1796",
          "locality": "Laurel Fork of the Holston River, Washington County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "A published abstract of Land Office Grants 36, page 251, names Lucy with John, William, Margaret, Elay and James Walker, and the married couples William and Nancy Golloher and William and Elizabeth Cammack, in a grant of 186 acres.",
          "association": "This identifies a specific local Walker group, making the proposed Laurel Fork family a substantial lead for Lucy McNew rather than a general surname resemblance.",
          "alternatives": "The grant abstract does not identify her husband. Its Lucy could be a different woman; the claim that she later married William McNew comes from the family reconstruction, not from this abstract.",
          "assessment": "A plausible family identification supported by a named local group. The grant and later McNew deed together favor investigating this household, but do not yet establish the imported Lucy’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_LUCY_WALKER_LAUREL_GRANT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_LAUREL_WALKER_FAMILY_REVIEW"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "William and Lucy McNew sell land to William Walker",
          "record_date": "1811–1812; exact deed date needs checking",
          "locality": "Washington County, Virginia; sellers described as of Claiborne County, Tennessee",
          "historical_detail": "The published index to Deed Book 5 identifies a conveyance from William and Lucy (Walker) McNew to William Walker at page 116. A separate family account describes 55 acres on the North Fork of the Holston, assembled from land bought from Thomas Cawood and Thomas Slopes, but gives both an 1811 heading and an 1812 signing date.",
          "association": "The couple’s names, the Walker buyer and the Virginia–Tennessee connection fit the proposed family and provide a concrete link between the two surnames.",
          "alternatives": "A land buyer can be a relative or an unrelated neighbor. The index’s parenthetical Walker may be an editorial identification, and it does not specify William McNew’s parents or middle initial.",
          "assessment": "Strong evidence that a William and Lucy McNew couple participated in this local transaction. Identification with the imported couple is plausible, while Lucy’s early death date and the precise family relationships remain unresolved.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_LUCY_MCNEW_DEED_INDEX",
            "SRC_ROOTS_LAUREL_WALKER_FAMILY_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Walker is commonly an occupational surname for a cloth fuller: someone who cleaned and thickened woven cloth by treading or kneading it. This explains the name’s formation, not Lucy’s occupation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WALKER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary identifies English origins, especially in the North and Midlands, and Scottish origins. Lucy’s proposed family is in southwestern Virginia and eastern Tennessee; an overseas origin for her particular branch has not been established.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WALKER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_LUCY_WALKER_LAUREL_GRANT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_LUCY_MCNEW_DEED_INDEX"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Lucy’s most relevant historical association is the Laurel Fork group of Walkers and their land dealings with the McNews. A published family study proposes William Walker, who died about 1789–1790, and his wife Elizabeth as her parents. It also distinguishes them from the Albemarle Walker family, so a connection to the explorer Thomas Walker cannot be assumed.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_LAUREL_WALKER_FAMILY_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_HV4_SARAH_CATHERINE_SMITH_1790_5_APR_1883",
      "person_id": "HV4_SARAH_CATHERINE_SMITH_1790_5_APR_1883",
      "surname": "Smith (reported)",
      "locality": "Reported North Carolina origin; Campbell and Claiborne counties, Tennessee",
      "research_limit": "Sarah Catherine Smith is reported as William J. McNew’s wife, born in North Carolina in 1790 and later buried at Maupin Cemetery in Campbell County. Her individual pedigree names no parents or North Carolina county. The marriage in 1816 is also a compiled report without an inspected marriage record identifying her birth family.",
      "notes": "The Campbell County 1850 census comparison identifies younger women: Sallie, 32, in F. P. McNew’s household, and Susan, 37, in Elisha McNew’s. Neither fits Sarah’s reported age and birthplace. Her husband’s reported death in Claiborne County makes that neighbouring county relevant too. Establishing Sarah’s own household and an earlier locality is necessary to distinguish the Smith families described below.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_SARAH_SMITH_MCNEW_PROFILE",
        "ROOTS26_CAMPBELL1850_P14",
        "ROOTS26_CAMPBELL1850_P13"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Older Smith households in Campbell County",
          "record_date": "8–9 October 1850",
          "locality": "17th Subdivision, Campbell County, Tennessee",
          "historical_detail": "The census transcription lists Jane Smith, 85 and born in Virginia, with James Smith, 57, in household 537. Household 550 includes Benjamin Smith, 58 and born in North Carolina, a farmer, and Rhoda, 44. The census does not specify how the people within each household were related.",
          "association": "Jane represents an older generation, while Benjamin is close to Sarah’s reported age and shares her reported birth state. These are identifiable regional families against which a possible wider-family connection can be tested.",
          "alternatives": "The households may be unrelated Smith families. North Carolina is a broad birthplace, and Sarah has not been placed in their neighbourhood by an identified census or land record.",
          "assessment": "They provide useful local comparisons, but neither household can currently be ranked as Sarah’s birth family. No earlier North Carolina name-bearer can be attached plausibly to this branch until her locality is narrowed.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CAMPBELL1850_P14",
            "ROOTS26_SARAH_SMITH_MCNEW_PROFILE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Smith commonly began as an English or Scottish occupational name for a metalworker, including a blacksmith or farrier. It could also describe someone associated with a forge.",
          "caveat": "The name alone does not establish the occupation of Sarah’s ancestors.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SMITH_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Some Smith families descend from names translated or adapted from Gaelic or continental European equivalents. Sarah’s reported North Carolina birthplace does not distinguish an English, Scottish or other origin.",
          "caveat": "Her birth county and the route by which her family reached Tennessee remain unidentified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SMITH_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_SARAH_SMITH_MCNEW_PROFILE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Smith households in the Campbell County census include farmers and property holders. The local cemetery directory separately names several Smith burial grounds and places one at the same roads as Maupin Cemetery in Well Spring.",
          "caveat": "These are specific local family settings, but burial-ground proximity does not identify Sarah’s natal family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CAMPBELL1850_P14",
            "ROOTS26_CAMPBELL_CEMETERY_DIRECTORY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "person_id": "HV4_MARSHAM_QUEEN_BEFORE_1703_28_OCT_1771",
      "surname": "Queen",
      "locality": "Charles County, Maryland (compiled household; probate indexed)",
      "research_limit": "The individual compilation identifies Samuel Queen and Catherine Marsham as parents. An archival index identifies a 1771 Charles County will for Marsham, Liber A.E.6, folio 104; it does not itself prove parentage.",
      "notes": "The named Samuel-and-Catherine family and reported inheritance support the proposed household connection. Confused generations or dates remain possible. Marsham’s original will and Richard Marsham’s inheritance clause have not been inspected. The claimed Scottish birth and earlier MacQueen ancestry are separate, unverified parts of the pedigree.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_MCNEW_MARSHAM_QUEEN",
        "SRC_ROOTS_MSA_MARSHAM_QUEEN_WILL_INDEX",
        "SRC_ROOTS_QUEEN_INHERITANCE_BLOG"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Queen grandchildren in a quoted Richard Marsham inheritance clause",
          "record_date": "1713 probate claim; original date requires verification",
          "locality": "Maryland; tract called Inclosure",
          "historical_detail": "A family-history page quotes Richard Marsham leaving Inclosure to grandchildren Samuel, Marsham, William, Catherine and Margaret Queen, with a 200-acre share for Marsham. The original will has not been inspected.",
          "association": "The unusual Marsham Queen name and explicit grandfather/grandchild wording make this a strong family-cluster lead for the endpoint.",
          "alternatives": "The quoted clause may be accurate while later dates or identifications are mistaken; the beneficiary still needs to be identified with the later testator.",
          "assessment": "Promising direct-family evidence through a derivative quotation. Verify the original and land succession before extending the pedigree. The blog’s Scottish ancestry does not gain support merely from this Maryland inheritance.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_QUEEN_INHERITANCE_BLOG"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Scottish Queen can be a shortened McQueen; English Queen can derive from a female personal name.",
          "caveat": "This Maryland family’s overseas origin is unknown.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_QUEEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary records separate Scottish and English formations, with early English examples especially in the south.",
          "caveat": "This Maryland family’s overseas origin is unknown.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_QUEEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname is not evidence of royal descent. A Scottish clan association needs the actual migration and family connection, not the spelling alone.",
          "caveat": "This Maryland family’s overseas origin is unknown.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_QUEEN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "person_id": "HV4_ANN_SHAW_ABOUT_1665",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Charles County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "Ann is named as Ralph Shaw’s wife in the abstract of their agreement with Edward Marlow on 19 March 1710/11. It identifies her married household but gives neither her birth surname nor her parents. Shaw is therefore not an established birth surname for her.",
      "notes": "The agreement provided Ann and Ralph with a private room and annual support for life. Probate records offer a strong earlier identity lead: Thomas Wakefield’s will names his wife Ann as sole executrix, and a later estate account names Ralph Shaw and Ann his wife administering that same estate. Together these support identifying the account’s Ann as Wakefield’s widow, remarried to Shaw. Matching the account to the 1710/11 couple is plausible, but both Ralph Shaw senior and junior witnessed Wakefield’s will, and the account does not distinguish them. Neither record supplies Ann’s birth surname. A proposed Marler connection has a real documentary basis: Jonathan Marler’s will of 29 July 1673 left Thomas Wakefield 180 acres called Manchester and made him a co-executor and residuary beneficiary with John Worland. This substantial bequest supports a close association, but the will neither names Ann nor describes Wakefield as a son-in-law. Kinship through Ann is possible; friendship or another relationship could also explain the provision. Marler and the separately reported name Marlow remain unestablished as her birth surname; a compiled death in 1698 also conflicts with the documented wife alive in 1710/11. These records do not identify her as the mother of Ralph’s adult daughters.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710",
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ANN_SHAW_WAKEFIELD_ACCOUNT_LEAD",
        "SRC_ROOTS_THOMAS_WAKEFIELD_WILL_SCAN",
        "SRC_ROOTS_RALPH_ANN_SHAW_WAKEFIELD_ACCOUNT_SCAN",
        "SRC_ROOTS_JONATHAN_MARLER_WILL_1673_SCAN"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ann (maiden name unknown) Shaw: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Charles County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Ann is named as Ralph Shaw’s wife in the abstract of their agreement with Edward Marlow on 19 March 1710/11. It identifies her married household but gives neither her birth surname nor her parents. Shaw is therefore not an established birth surname for her. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710",
            "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANN_SHAW_WAKEFIELD_ACCOUNT_LEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_THOMAS_WAKEFIELD_WILL_SCAN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_RALPH_ANN_SHAW_WAKEFIELD_ACCOUNT_SCAN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_JONATHAN_MARLER_WILL_1673_SCAN"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Ann (maiden name unknown) Shaw without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Ann (maiden name unknown) Shaw. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Ann (maiden name unknown) Shaw without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS",
      "person_id": "HV4_HANS_GEORG_SPIESS",
      "surname": "Spiess / Spieß",
      "locality": "Offenbach am Glan, St. Julian parish, Palatinate",
      "research_limit": "The Gabel family compilation identifies Maria Magdalene’s father as Hans Georg Spiess, deceased before 1725, but supplies neither his parents nor a named wife. A locally documented Hans Georg is a promising identity match; his own parentage remains unresolved.",
      "notes": "The relevant early Lutheran register survives. Archion lists St. Julian volume 89/1 with baptisms, marriages and burials for 1634–1782, including Offenbach. The catalogue notes gaps, so its date range does not establish uninterrupted coverage. The earlier volume is held by the Rhineland church archive; the separate Palatinate archive catalogue chiefly lists later St. Julian material.\n\nThe next decisive comparison is Maria Magdalene’s reported 1725 marriage with the earlier Spiess household’s baptisms and marriages. These entries could establish her mother and distinguish the local father candidate. No inspected source yet identifies Hans Georg’s parents, and the existence of the register should not be mistaken for a completed search of it.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_SPIESS_GOBLE0967",
        "ROOTS26_SPIESS_OFFENBACH_FORUM",
        "ROOTS26_STJULIAN_ARCHION89_1"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Hans Georg Spieß’s Offenbach household, 1679–1724",
          "record_date": "1679–1724",
          "locality": "Offenbach am Glan, St. Julian parish",
          "historical_detail": "A 2021 discussion citing the parish register and Karl Pfleger’s family book identifies Hans Georg Spieß (1653–1724). It reports his marriage to Anna Maria Brüll on 10 November 1679 and, after her 1698 death, to Anna Elisabeth Reinmüller in 1699. Daughter Maria Elisabeth, born in 1685, married Johann Balthasar Brüll in 1720.",
          "association": "The full name, Offenbach locality and death before Maria Magdalene’s reported 1725 marriage favor identification with her proposed father.",
          "alternatives": "Another local Hans Georg is possible but has not been identified in the inspected material. Maria Elisabeth and Maria Magdalene are distinct proposed daughters; the discussion names only the former.",
          "assessment": "This is the leading local identity candidate. If Maria Magdalene’s estimated birth around 1705 is correct and he is her father, the later marriage makes Anna Elisabeth a plausible mother. That conditional identification needs comparison with the daughter’s baptism or marriage before selecting her mother; the estimates alone do not resolve the household.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SPIESS_OFFENBACH_FORUM",
            "ROOTS26_SPIESS_GOBLE0967"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary treats Spiess as a variant of Spies. One explanation comes from Middle High German spiez, meaning spear or pike: a name for a maker of spears or a soldier equipped with one.",
          "caveat": "This explains a possible formation of the surname, not Hans Georg’s occupation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SPIES_DAFN2"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary also allows a place-derived origin from settlements named Spies, particularly one near Nuremberg. Its entry distinguishes this explanation from the occupational one.",
          "caveat": "Offenbach is the locality of this branch’s proposed family; a migration from Nuremberg has not been established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SPIES_DAFN2"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Spiess, Spieß and Spies are useful forms to compare in German records. The surname’s weapon-related interpretation can reflect an ordinary trade or military role.",
          "caveat": "It does not by itself establish noble descent or entitlement to a coat of arms.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SPIES_DAFN2"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_HV10_ANNA_DOROTHEE_LEFFLER_ABT1827",
      "person_id": "HV10_ANNA_DOROTHEE_LEFFLER_ABT1827",
      "surname": "Leffler",
      "locality": "Crawinkel, Gotha, Thuringia (reported origin); Hannover (marriage and child’s baptism)",
      "research_limit": "Anna Dorothee Leffler is named with Georg Heinrich Fricke in the saved marriage index for 17 April 1842 in Hannover, and as Heinrich Friedrich Fricke’s mother in his 1845 baptism evidence. The tree reports Crawinkel as her birthplace, but the saved extracts do not identify her parents. Her birth estimate of about 1827 would place her at roughly fourteen or fifteen when she married. Without a recorded age or baptism, that estimate remains unresolved; it is not a reliable boundary for searching her earlier family.",
      "notes": "The AGT catalogue of 2018 lists a 2015 index to Crawinkel’s Lutheran church records for 1683–1808, under KB 13, item 70.13. It offers a route to earlier Leffler households, although its coverage ends before Anna’s estimated birth and the index itself has not been examined. The original Hannover marriage entry could supply her age, origin and parental details, allowing a more focused comparison with Crawinkel families. The present stopping point reflects unidentified parents and unexamined records, not an established loss of the parish records.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_LEFFLER_1842_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_ROOTS_AGT_CRAWINKEL_INDEX_2018"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Johann Christoph Leffler, Crawinkel innkeeper",
          "record_date": "1834",
          "locality": "Crawinkel, Gotha, Thuringia",
          "historical_detail": "The Gotha tax authority’s catalogue identifies Johann Christoph Leffler as one of four Crawinkel innkeepers who petitioned for lower business taxes on their innkeeping rights in 1834. The file reference is 2-13-0037, no. 41; its description records the request, without establishing its outcome.",
          "association": "The exact surname in Anna’s reported home village, eight years before her Hannover marriage, supports investigating a shared local family.",
          "alternatives": "Johann Christoph could have been her father, another relative, or a member of an unrelated Leffler household. The catalogue names no children or wife and gives no age with which to distinguish these possibilities.",
          "assessment": "A specific and promising wider-family lead. The shared place and surname favor investigating kinship, but provide no basis for preferring fatherhood over another relationship. Anna’s marriage entry and the innkeeper’s household records could distinguish those possibilities.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CRAWINKEL_LEFFLER_1834"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Leffler is an occupational surname for a maker or seller of spoons, a variant of Loeffler.",
          "caveat": "This explains the name’s formation, not Anna’s own occupation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LEFFLER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary records German and eastern Ashkenazic uses of Leffler. It does not assign the name a single founding town.",
          "caveat": "Anna’s reported connection to Crawinkel comes from the saved family evidence; the surname alone does not establish a religious or regional ancestry.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LEFFLER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A Leffler household was associated with innkeeping in Crawinkel by 1834: Johann Christoph Leffler appears among four local innkeepers seeking a tax reduction.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_CRAWINKEL_LEFFLER_1834"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_HV10_EBERHARD_HEINRICH_FRICKE_ABT1788",
      "person_id": "HV10_EBERHARD_HEINRICH_FRICKE_ABT1788",
      "surname": "Fricke",
      "locality": "Gütersloh, Westphalia (marriage and child’s baptism)",
      "research_limit": "Eberhard Heinrich Fricke’s saved 1820 marriage extract identifies his bride as Sophie Elisabeth Angeneten and describes him as aged 32 and previously married. His birth around 1788 is calculated from that age. The saved extract does not name his parents, first wife or birthplace. The original entry and his earlier marriage are therefore the most direct routes beyond him; the present stopping point does not establish that those records are lost.",
      "notes": "The 1827 Gütersloh baptism names Eber. Hein. Fricke and Sophie Elis. Agnete as Georg Heinrich’s parents. Their matching names, town and chronology favor the 1820 married couple as these parents. A separate identification remains unresolved: the tree joins that boy, born 26 March 1827, to the Georg Heinrich Fricke who married Anna Dorothee Leffler in Hannover on 17 April 1842. That would make the groom fifteen. His original marriage record needs to establish age, origin and parents before the Gütersloh branch’s place in the Hannover ancestry can be treated as secure. The bell-founder is retained here as local family context, without a new parent link.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_EBERHARD_SOPHIE_1820_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_LEFFLER_1842_MARRIAGE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Bernhard Heinrich Fricke, bell-founder of Gütersloh",
          "record_date": "1779",
          "locality": "Gütersloh, Westphalia; bell made for St Johann, Lemgo",
          "historical_detail": "St Johann’s parish history credits Bernhard Heinrich Fricke of Gütersloh with casting its large bronze bell in 1779. The bell was later surrendered and melted during the First World War; the parish preserves its history with a reference to Günter Rhiemeier’s study of the church.",
          "association": "This establishes an earlier Fricke craftsman in Eberhard’s marriage town, roughly nine years before Eberhard’s estimated birth and forty-one years before his marriage.",
          "alternatives": "Eberhard could belong to the bell-founder’s extended family, to another long-established Fricke household, or to a family that moved to Gütersloh later. The names Bernhard Heinrich and Eberhard Heinrich are different; they do not identify the two men as one person.",
          "assessment": "The shared town and surname support a plausible wider-family connection. The available accounts provide no relationship or household details that would identify the bell-founder as Eberhard’s father. Eberhard’s original marriage entry and first marriage could supply the parental names or occupation needed to rank those possibilities.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FRICKE_LEMGO_BELL_1779"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Fricke is a variant of Frick. The German name can derive from a shortened Low German form of Friedrich.",
          "caveat": "The surname does not itself indicate a forestry occupation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICKE_DAFN2",
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICK_DAFN2"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary records German and Swiss German formations. Eberhard’s own documented setting is Gütersloh in Westphalia, where he married in 1820.",
          "caveat": "His birthplace remains unidentified; neither a Hanoverian origin nor descent from the Swiss place-name branch has been established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SURNAME_FRICKE_DAFN2",
            "SRC_FRICKE_EBERHARD_SOPHIE_1820_MARRIAGE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A documented Fricke trade in Gütersloh was bell-founding. Bernhard Heinrich Fricke cast a large bronze bell for St Johann’s church in Lemgo in 1779.",
          "caveat": "Eberhard’s saved marriage extract gives no occupation with which to compare this craftsman.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FRICKE_LEMGO_BELL_1779"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_HV10_SOPHIE_ELISABETH_ANGENETEN_ABT1795",
      "person_id": "HV10_SOPHIE_ELISABETH_ANGENETEN_ABT1795",
      "surname": "Angeneten",
      "locality": "Gütersloh, Westphalia (marriage and child’s baptism)",
      "research_limit": "The saved 1820 Gütersloh marriage extract names Sophie Elisabeth Angeneten, aged 25, with Eberhard Heinrich Fricke, aged 32 and previously married. Their names recur as the parents of Georg Heinrich Fricke, born 26 March and baptized 31 March 1827; her surname there is extracted as Agnete. The matching couple, place and chronology favor identifying these as the same parents. Sophie’s birth around 1795 is calculated from her marriage age, and Gütersloh is not yet established as her birthplace. Neither saved extract names her parents.",
      "notes": "A substantial next source has been located: Wolfgang Schindler’s Familiengeschichte Agnete / Angenete (Haan, 1999), catalogued by the Westfälisches Wirtschaftsarchiv as A 236 no. 599. Its contents and Sophie’s original marriage entry remain unexamined. There is also an unresolved link farther down this branch: the tree identifies the boy born in Gütersloh in 1827 with the Georg Heinrich Fricke who married Anna Dorothee Leffler in Hannover on 17 April 1842. He would have been fifteen. The name match supports comparison, but this chronology and the change of place require checking against the Hannover groom’s recorded age, origin and parents before that identification can be treated as secure.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FRICKE_EBERHARD_SOPHIE_1820_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_FRICKE_LEFFLER_1842_MARRIAGE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ANGENETE_SCHINDLER_CATALOGUE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "The Angenete carrier family in Gütersloh",
          "record_date": "1694–1848",
          "locality": "Gütersloh, Westphalia",
          "historical_detail": "The city’s trade history reports four generations of Angenete freight carriers between 1694 and 1848. This places a family of that name in Gütersloh well before Sophie’s 1820 marriage.",
          "association": "The same town, overlapping period and closely matching name make this the leading local family to investigate for Sophie.",
          "alternatives": "She could belong to that extended family, to another local Agnete or Angenete branch, or to a family newly arrived in Gütersloh. No competing Sophie has been identified in the material examined.",
          "assessment": "A plausible wider-family connection, without an identified parent. The municipal account does not name Sophie. Her marriage entry and the dedicated family history could show whether she belongs to the documented carrier family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANGENETE_GUETERSLOH_CARRIERS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANGENETE_SCHINDLER_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Hans Bahlow groups Angenete with surnames derived from the female personal name Agnes or Agnete. Such names can identify a woman’s son or husband.",
          "caveat": "This explanation concerns Angenete; Sophie’s recorded form Angeneten still needs checking in the original marriage entry.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANGENETE_BAHLOW"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Agnete and Angenete are both used in the title of Wolfgang Schindler’s 1999 family history, catalogued under Gütersloh genealogy. This gives a specific Westphalian family context for the two spellings.",
          "caveat": "The catalogue does not establish the family’s earliest place of origin. The previously suggested Angenend and Aengenendt spellings are not verified equivalents for Sophie.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANGENETE_SCHINDLER_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Gütersloh’s city history identifies an Angenete family of freight carriers active across four generations from 1694 to 1848. The family papers are held by the city archive.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANGENETE_GUETERSLOH_CARRIERS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_ABT1852_BLEDFFA",
      "surname": "Thomas",
      "locality": "Llanddewi, Radnorshire (reported birthplace); Shrewsbury, Shropshire (adult home)",
      "research_limit": "John Thomas is identifiable with his wife Jane in the Shrewsbury censuses from 1881 to 1911 through repeated family details, bootmaking work and the address 160 Frankwell Quay. The saved census extracts report a Llanddewi birthplace in Radnorshire and an age placing his birth around 1851. His 1879 Atcham marriage registration to Jane Lister supplies no parental details in the saved index extract. The full marriage record is the clearest next source for his father’s name and occupation; his own parents remain unidentified.",
      "notes": "The leading childhood candidate is the ten-year-old John Thomas, born Llanddewi Ystradenni, lodging at Tynywern in Llanfihangel Rhydithon in 1861. The birthplace and age fit the adult closely. Samuel and Mary Jones are household members, not parents named by that entry, and the relationship recorded for John is lodger. A separately enumerated Bleddfa boy, baptized there in 1851 to Edward and Anne Thomas, is a documented competing person with a less exact birthplace match; his parents should not be transferred to the Llanddewi candidate. An eighteen-year-old farm servant at Llanson Lower in Glascwm in 1871 is another possible record, but gives only Radnorshire as birthplace and does not identify him as a bootmaker. None of these childhood entries yet supplies the combination of family and occupational details needed to connect a parental household to the adult John.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
        "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879",
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_LLANDDEWI_LODGER_1861",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_THOMAS_BLEDFFA_BAPTISM_1851",
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_RADNORSHIRE_CANDIDATE_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_OLD_RADNOR_1871_20260729"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Joseph Thomas, dyer of Llanddewi Ystradenni",
          "record_date": "12 July 1787",
          "locality": "Llanddewi Ystradenni, Radnorshire; property at Llanbadarn Fawr",
          "historical_detail": "The Powys archive catalogue names Joseph Thomas, dyer, and Robert Pitchford, yeoman, both of Llanddewi Ystradenni, in an assignment of a mortgage securing £32 and interest on Park bach in Llanbadarn Fawr. The reference is R/DX/21/1.",
          "association": "Joseph lived in the parish that best matches John’s reported birthplace, roughly sixty-four years before John’s birth. This is a specific earlier local Thomas household to investigate.",
          "alternatives": "Joseph could belong to John’s extended family or to a separate Thomas family in the same parish. Dyer and bootmaker are different trades; the two occupations do not establish a shared business or apprenticeship.",
          "assessment": "The surname and parish support a plausible local-family connection, but the catalogue supplies no wife or children for Joseph and no link to John. Identifying John’s father from his marriage record would make a comparison with earlier parish households much more discriminating.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_JOSEPH_THOMAS_DYER_1787"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Thomas comes from the Biblical personal name, ultimately an Aramaic name meaning twin.",
          "caveat": "The meaning belongs to the personal name; it does not establish that John or a known ancestor was a twin.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_THOMAS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname developed from a widely used Christian personal name and is especially common in Wales and Cornwall.",
          "caveat": "John’s census birthplace points to Radnorshire. The wider distribution does not identify his particular family’s earlier home.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_THOMAS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A Thomas craftsman is recorded in Llanddewi Ystradenni before John’s lifetime: Joseph Thomas, a dyer, appears in a 1787 property transaction.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_JOSEPH_THOMAS_DYER_1787"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_JANE_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_ANNE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_ANNE",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Cefnllys, Radnorshire; possible marriage at Llandrindod",
      "research_limit": "Jane is named as Anne Crowther’s mother in the supplied account of Anne’s christening at Cefnllys on 17 July 1832. Her leading birth-surname candidate is Powell: a marriage index records Jane Powell, single, marrying Walter Griffiths Crowther of Cefnllys at Llandrindod on 20 February 1822. The matching parents’ names, locality and timing favor this identification. Her parents and birthplace remain unresolved.",
      "notes": "The link between that marriage and Anne’s family still needs corroboration through the couple’s household records. Another Walter and Jane household, or a later marriage, remains possible, but neither has been identified in this investigation. Powys Archives lists the surviving Cefnllys baptism volume for 1813–1901 and banns through 1823. Those records can supply details of the family’s residence and help test the match. Powell family history is not yet assigned to Jane’s birth branch.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_TRANSCRIPT_PROVENANCE_20260915_CROWTHER",
        "SRC_CROWTHER_POWELL_1822_MARRIAGE_LEAD",
        "SRC_ROOTS_POWYS_CEFNLLYS_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Jane: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Cefnllys, Radnorshire; possible marriage at Llandrindod",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Jane is named as Anne Crowther’s mother in the supplied account of Anne’s christening at Cefnllys on 17 July 1832. Her leading birth-surname candidate is Powell: a marriage index records Jane Powell, single, marrying Walter Griffiths Crowther of Cefnllys at Llandrindod on 20 February 1822. The matching parents’ names, locality and timing favor this identification. Her parents and birthplace remain unresolved. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_TRANSCRIPT_PROVENANCE_20260915_CROWTHER",
            "SRC_CROWTHER_POWELL_1822_MARRIAGE_LEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_POWYS_CEFNLLYS_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Jane without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Jane. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Jane without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_JOSHUA_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_WALTER",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOSHUA_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_WALTER",
      "surname": "Crowther",
      "locality": "Family connected with Cefnllys and Llandrindod, Radnorshire; Joshua’s own residence unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Matthew identified Joshua Crowther as Walter Crowther’s father, correcting an earlier reading of the name. Joshua’s dates, residence and parents have not yet been established. The family’s Cefnllys connection comes from Anne Crowther’s supplied 1832 christening transcript, which names Walter as her father.",
      "notes": "An indexed 1822 Llandrindod marriage names Walter Griffiths Crowther of Cefnllys and Jane Powell. The names, locality and timing make this a useful match for Anne’s parents, although the records have not yet been joined securely. The separate Crowther–Griffiths property record below offers a household to investigate; it does not replace Matthew’s identification of Joshua.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_JOSHUA_CROWTHER_USER_CORRECTION",
        "SRC_TRANSCRIPT_PROVENANCE_20260915_CROWTHER",
        "SRC_CROWTHER_POWELL_1822_MARRIAGE_LEAD",
        "SRC_ROOTS_POWYS_CROWTHER_GRIFFITHS_1826"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "A Crowther–Griffiths household at Tycannol",
          "record_date": "17 October 1826",
          "locality": "Tycannol, Cefnllys; Glan-Camlo, Radnorshire",
          "historical_detail": "The Powys deed catalogue names John Crowther of Tycannol, in the parish written Kevenlleece, with rights through his wife Margaret, sister and co-heiress of Walter Griffiths.",
          "association": "The combination of Crowther, Walter Griffiths and Cefnllys gives a more specific comparison with the 1822 marriage lead than the surname alone. The deed predates Anne’s 1832 christening, but is not established as an earlier generation of Joshua’s family.",
          "alternatives": "John’s household could be related to Joshua or to the marriage candidate. It could instead be a separate local family whose Griffiths connection does not identify Anne’s father. The catalogue does not name Joshua or Walter Crowther.",
          "assessment": "A promising local family-history lead, with the relationship unresolved. Walter Crowther’s baptism and the Tycannol household’s parish or probate records could distinguish these possibilities.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_POWYS_CROWTHER_GRIFFITHS_1826",
            "SRC_CROWTHER_POWELL_1822_MARRIAGE_LEAD"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Crowther is an English form of Crowder, an occupational name for a musician playing the croud, a stringed instrument also called the Welsh fiddle. In Wales and the border counties, it can represent Welsh crythor, meaning fiddler.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CROWTHER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CROWDER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary associates the English Crowther spelling especially with Yorkshire, but also provides a Welsh-border explanation through Crowder. A separate Scottish possibility is McGrouther, meaning son of the brewer. The Radnorshire family setting makes the Welsh-border explanation relevant without establishing where Joshua’s name originated.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CROWTHER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CROWDER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The musical meaning connects the name with the Welsh crwth tradition. It does not establish that Joshua or Walter worked as musicians. The known local research leads concern parish records and a Crowther household with property rights through the Griffiths family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CROWDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_POWYS_CROWTHER_GRIFFITHS_1826"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FATHER_OF_ANN",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FATHER_OF_ANN",
      "surname": "Grindley",
      "locality": "Wrenbury, Cheshire; proposed marriage at Drayton in Hales, Shropshire",
      "research_limit": "Thomas is named with Margt. in the stored 1789 Wrenbury baptism transcript for Ann, but his own birth and parents are unestablished. The proposed 1782 marriage now has a rival Brindley reading; his identification with the 1834 Newhall testator is promising but unverified.",
      "notes": "Ann’s 1789 Wrenbury baptism names Thomas and Margt. A possible 1782 marriage names Thomas Brindley of Mucklestone and Margaret Harding. Matching given names and compatible dates support a connection, but the Brindley reading could identify a different couple. Thomas Grindley of Newhall’s April 1834 probate is another promising same-parish match; its beneficiaries are not yet known. A 1712 Newhall bond documents an earlier local Grindley family, without connecting the generations.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_DRAYTON_BRINDLEY_HARDING_1782",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_BOND_1712",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_PROBATE_1834",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_ANN_BAPTISM_STORED",
        "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GRINDLEY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GREENLEY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Thomas and Robert Grindley at Newhall, 1712",
          "record_date": "10 May 1712",
          "locality": "Newhall, parish of Wrenbury, Cheshire",
          "historical_detail": "A marriage bond names Thomas Grindley, yeoman, and Dorothy Edwards, spinster, both of Newhall. Robert Grindley appears among the bondsmen.",
          "association": "Same surname and parish 77 years before Ann’s baptism; positive evidence for a plausible wider local family.",
          "alternatives": "The earlier household could be a separate Grindley family or a collateral line. Robert’s relationship to Thomas is unstated, and no intervening generation has been identified.",
          "assessment": "Useful earlier family context. The bond establishes a local network, not descent of the 1789 father from this couple.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_BOND_1712",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_ANN_BAPTISM_STORED"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Grindley is treated by the modern dictionary as a variant of Greenley with an added d; the underlying English place-name elements mean green clearing.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DRAYTON_BRINDLEY_HARDING_1782",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_BOND_1712",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_PROBATE_1834",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_ANN_BAPTISM_STORED",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GRINDLEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GREENLEY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Possible English name sources include Staffordshire Grindley and Nottinghamshire Little Gringley; older dictionaries also cite the Cheshire border settlement. Thomas’s recorded family setting is Wrenbury. Neither the place-name origin nor a shared surname demonstrates a migration route.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DRAYTON_BRINDLEY_HARDING_1782",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_BOND_1712",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_PROBATE_1834",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_ANN_BAPTISM_STORED",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GRINDLEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GREENLEY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1712 Newhall marriage bond names Thomas and Robert Grindley, providing an earlier local cluster. The 1834 Newhall labourer’s probate may identify the later household. Both are specific avenues for family reconstruction, without an invented pedigree.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DRAYTON_BRINDLEY_HARDING_1782",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_BOND_1712",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_PROBATE_1834",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_ANN_BAPTISM_STORED",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GRINDLEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GREENLEY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_MARGT_GRINDLEY_MOTHER_OF_ANN",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGT_GRINDLEY_MOTHER_OF_ANN",
      "surname": "Harding",
      "locality": "Wrenbury, Cheshire; proposed marriage at Drayton in Hales, Shropshire",
      "research_limit": "Margaret Harding is the reported 1782 bride; the Wrenbury baptism names only Margt. Her identification as Ann’s mother depends on resolving the Grindley/Brindley marriage discrepancy. Her parents and birth locality are not established.",
      "notes": "Margaret Harding’s proposed 1782 marriage fits the timing of Ann’s 1789 baptism, whose mother is named only Margt. The groom is transcribed as Brindley of Mucklestone, so this may be a different couple from Ann’s parents. Margaret’s maiden-name identification remains conditional. Richard Harding’s 1764 and Elizabeth Harding’s 1783 Drayton marriages document local surname households, but neither supplies Margaret’s parents.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_DRAYTON_BRINDLEY_HARDING_1782",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_BOND_1712",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_PROBATE_1834",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_ANN_BAPTISM_STORED",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_HARDING_NAME"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Richard Harding marries at Drayton, 1764",
          "record_date": "15 November 1764",
          "locality": "Drayton in Hales, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The marriage index records Richard Harding and Ann Birchall, eighteen years before the proposed Margaret Harding marriage.",
          "association": "A concrete earlier same-surname household in the same marriage parish.",
          "alternatives": "Richard could be unrelated to Margaret. Their ages, residences and kinship are not established by the reviewed index, and Margaret’s connection to Wrenbury is itself conditional.",
          "assessment": "Local context worth testing through baptisms and probate; no sibling or parental relationship assigned.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DRAYTON_BRINDLEY_HARDING_1782"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Harding comes from the medieval personal name Harding, from Old English Hearding, associated with being hard, strong or brave.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DRAYTON_BRINDLEY_HARDING_1782",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_BOND_1712",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_PROBATE_1834",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_ANN_BAPTISM_STORED",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_HARDING_NAME"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "This personal-name surname could arise independently. The dictionary also describes North German and Dutch origins and later Irish settlement; none establishes Margaret’s origin. Drayton is her marriage setting, not a proved birthplace.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DRAYTON_BRINDLEY_HARDING_1782",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_BOND_1712",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_PROBATE_1834",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_ANN_BAPTISM_STORED",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_HARDING_NAME"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Hardings were marrying at Drayton before and near Margaret’s proposed 1782 marriage: Richard with Ann Birchall in 1764 and Elizabeth with Abraham Jarvis in 1783. These are plausible local-family leads, conditional on first establishing Margaret’s identity, not evidence of a particular notable Harding family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DRAYTON_BRINDLEY_HARDING_1782",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_BOND_1712",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_PROBATE_1834",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_ANN_BAPTISM_STORED",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_HARDING_NAME"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_RUTH_MOTHER_OF_RUTH_HANDLEY",
      "person_id": "SRC_RUTH_MOTHER_OF_RUTH_HANDLEY",
      "surname": "Johnson",
      "locality": "Reported Sandon; family associated with Milwich, Staffordshire, England",
      "research_limit": "The daughter’s baptism description names her mother as Ruth. Johnson and the reported dates, 4 March 1739 to 4 January 1759, come from the family-profile identification. No record naming this Ruth’s parents has yet been established.",
      "notes": "A Sandon marriage index lists Ruth Johnson marrying Samuel Handley of Milwich on 12 September 1756. This is a promising match in surname, locality and timing, but the groom is Sampson in the tree. Checking the original entry and Ruth’s baptism may resolve the connection. Sandon’s published registers cover 1635–1900, so the current limit is identification of the records, not an established loss of them.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SANDON_HANDLEY_JOHNSON_1756",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SPRS_SANDON",
        "SRC_RUTH_HANDLEY_BAPTISM_PROVENANCE_20260915",
        "SRC_HANDLEY_MILWICH_COMPILED_REVIEW_20260915"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "An older Johnson household in Sandon",
          "record_date": "Memorial deaths 1761, 1769 and 1770",
          "locality": "All Saints churchyard, Sandon, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "Memorial transcriptions identify John Johnson, his wife Ruth and their son Joseph. John’s recorded age places his birth around 1706 and his wife’s around 1714, making them an earlier generation than Ruth in this tree.",
          "association": "The surname, parish and mother’s forename make this household a plausible family to investigate for the reported 1739-born Ruth.",
          "alternatives": "The memorials do not name a daughter Ruth. She could belong to another Johnson household, and her reported Sandon birth still needs verification. The older Ruth is a distinct woman who reportedly survived to 1770.",
          "assessment": "A concrete local household lead, without an established parent link. The marriage, baptism and probate records would be needed to distinguish shared ancestry from a separate family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SANDON_JOHNSON_MEMORIALS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Johnson means son of John, formed from the personal name and the ending son. By Ruth’s time it was an inherited surname; it does not identify her own father’s forename.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_JOHNSON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname developed in both England and Scotland. Its formation from the widely used name John allows many separate families to share it. This branch’s reported Staffordshire setting has not been traced to an earlier ancestral locality.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_JOHNSON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Related forms include Janson and Jenson. In North America Johnson also represents several Scandinavian and other European surnames, but those histories have not been connected to this Staffordshire family. The Sandon memorials below offer a more specific local association.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_JOHNSON",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SANDON_JOHNSON_MEMORIALS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_1691",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_1691",
      "surname": "Cartwright",
      "locality": "Reported Draycott in the Moors and Milwich, Staffordshire, England",
      "research_limit": "Anne is identified in the family information as Sampson Handley’s mother, with George Handley as his father. Her profile reports a 1691 birth at Draycott in the Moors and death at Milwich on 26 August 1758. No parent-naming record for Anne has yet been established.",
      "notes": "The published Draycott register transcription covers 1669–1900, including her reported birth period. The present limit is the unresolved identification of her baptism and parents, rather than an established loss of the relevant records.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_USER_IDENTIFICATION",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SPRS_DRAYCOTT_DILHORNE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Dorothy Cartwright of Draycott marries at Dilhorne",
          "record_date": "18 January 1684, as reported",
          "locality": "Dilhorne; bride of Draycott parish, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The Brough family history cites a marriage-register image for Dorothy Cartwright and Richard Brough of Doveridge. It reports a marriage by licence and identifies Dorothy’s parish as Draycott.",
          "association": "The parish and surname agree with Anne’s reported birthplace only seven years later, making a connection within the local Cartwright families plausible.",
          "alternatives": "Dorothy could belong to a separate Cartwright household. Anne’s reported birth location also awaits verification, and the available marriage summary does not name relatives linking the two women.",
          "assessment": "A useful local lead, with no particular relationship yet established. The original licence and parish entries may distinguish the households; Dorothy is not assigned as Anne’s mother or another specific relative.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DOROTHY_CARTWRIGHT_BROUGH_1684"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Cartwright is an English occupational surname for a maker of carts, formed from cart and wright, a craftsman. The inherited name does not establish Anne’s father’s occupation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CARTWRIGHT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary associates the English surname particularly with the Midlands and northern England, consistent with this branch’s reported Staffordshire setting. A more specific ancestral home before Draycott has not been established.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CARTWRIGHT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_USER_IDENTIFICATION"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Cartwright can also be a variant of the Dutch-origin surname Courtright. That separate name history has not been connected to Anne’s Staffordshire family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CARTWRIGHT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_USER_IDENTIFICATION"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "person_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "surname": "Wilde",
      "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "research_limit": "A Sheffield baptism records George, son of William Wild, on 13 April 1616. William’s own parents have not been identified, and his reported 1576 birth and 1643 death remain unverified in this review. The entry does not name George’s mother.",
      "notes": "The later Hall Carr pedigree identifies a George Wild, father of Hannah Handley, as John Wild’s son. Whether William’s baptized son became that adult George remains unresolved. The previously proposed Droitwich ancestry therefore does not supply a secure route beyond William.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_WYLD_1573_1616",
        "SRC_ROOTS_STIRNET_HALL_CARR_WILD",
        "SRC_DROITWICH_ST_PETERS_WYLDE_MONUMENT_TRANSCRIPTION"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Two Wyld–Beighton marriages in Sheffield, 1573",
          "record_date": "12 January 1572/73 and 20 July 1573",
          "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
          "historical_detail": "The published parish register records John Wyld marrying Margaret Beighton in January and Ralph Wyld marrying Cicily Beighton in July. Both marriages precede William’s reported 1576 birth.",
          "association": "These are identifiable local Wyld households from a plausible parental generation. The repeated combination of surnames makes the two marriages worth investigating together.",
          "alternatives": "Neither entry states how the two grooms or brides were related. William could belong to either household, to another local household, or to a family that arrived later.",
          "assessment": "The marriages support a local family-history connection worth pursuing, but no particular relationship to William has been demonstrated. Neither couple is assigned as his parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_WYLD_1573_1616"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Wild can originate as an English nickname describing a wild or unruly person, or as a name for someone living by uncultivated land. Neither explanation describes William’s own character or occupation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Wilde is a spelling variant of Wild. The English name has more than one possible origin, so there is no single ancestral place implied by the surname. Sheffield records use Wild, Wilde and Wyld; the family’s residence before Sheffield has not been established.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILDE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_WYLD_1573_1616"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Wilde also occurs in Irish and German naming traditions and as a Dutch form of De Wilde. This branch is associated with Sheffield records; those wider surname histories do not establish a foreign origin for it.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILDE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_WYLD_1573_1616"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_JANE_EDEN_GARDNER",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_EDEN_GARDNER",
      "surname": "Gardner",
      "locality": "Droitwich, Worcestershire (reported household)",
      "research_limit": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Jane Eden Gardner: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Droitwich, Worcestershire (reported household)",
          "historical_detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": []
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Gardner is an occupational surname for someone tending a garden, derived through Middle English from French.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GARDNER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "English and Scottish formations are recorded; overseas Gardner can also translate German or French surnames with a similar meaning.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GARDNER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name does not establish that Jane or Henry worked as gardeners. No specific earlier local Gardner was securely linked to this endpoint in the recorded searches.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GARDNER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "person_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "surname": "Lindner",
      "locality": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
      "research_limit": "Michael is named as Stephan Lindner’s father and a citizen of Nenzenheim in Stephan’s marriage transcript of 28 April 1665. A reconstruction citing Harold Linder’s 2013 family study reports Michael’s marriage to Anna Fuchs on 21 November 1625 and death on 9 April 1677, but leaves his ancestry untraced. His parents remain unidentified.",
      "notes": "The older proposed parents, Martin Linder and Salome Werren of Saanen, belong to a reconstruction placing their births around 1585–1586, marriage in 1605 and children from 1606 onward. That chronology fits poorly with Michael’s reported birth around 1598, and no record connects him to their Swiss household. Nenzenheim’s surviving parish volumes cover 1591–1615 and 1616–1716, with a baptism index for 1592–1645. Their dates leave a real possibility of finding earlier family evidence; the original entries have not yet been examined.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_MICHAEL_LINDER_UNTRACED_ANCESTRY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOGUE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, Holy Roman Empire",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Michael is named as Stephan Lindner’s father and a citizen of Nenzenheim in Stephan’s marriage transcript of 28 April 1665. A reconstruction citing Harold Linder’s 2013 family study reports Michael’s marriage to Anna Fuchs on 21 November 1625 and death on 9 April 1677, but leaves his ancestry untraced. His parents remain unidentified. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_MICHAEL_LINDER_UNTRACED_ANCESTRY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Lindner can mean a person from a place named Lindenau, Linde, Linden or Linda. The dictionary also records an Ashkenazic ornamental form built from Linde, the German word for a lime or linden tree.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LINDNER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Several German-speaking places could give rise to this surname. Michael’s documented family setting is Nenzenheim in Franconia; none of those possible namesake places has been established as his family’s earlier home.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LINDNER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name appears again in Nenzenheim in 1824, when Johann Heinrich Lindner applied to build a new barn. The Staatsarchiv Nürnberg preserves the application and its building plan as Uffenheim Bauakten 262. The same surname in the same village makes continued local kinship plausible, although the gap of roughly 160 years also allows a separately established Lindner household. This later record does not identify Michael’s parents.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_LINDNER_NENZENHEIM_BARN_1824"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "person_id": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "surname": "Linder",
      "locality": "Philadelphia arrival, 1753; later North Fork Holston, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "The Peggy passenger evidence gives an approximately 1735-born George Anton Linder in 1753; the later Virginia household includes wife Mary and a 1795 conveyance to John Gobble. The European parents are unresolved.",
      "notes": "Anthon Linders, baptized in 1734 at Sausenheim, is a plausible candidate for the immigrant because name and age fit. No shared relative, occupation or migration record yet identifies the two as one person. A different family member or namesake remains possible. The circulated 1801 will also lacks verified provenance.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEORGE_ANTON_LINDER_PEGGY_1753",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
        "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_ANTHONY_LINDER_ANCESTRY_REVIEW",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "George Anton \"Anthony\" Linder: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Philadelphia arrival, 1753; later North Fork Holston, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The Peggy passenger evidence gives an approximately 1735-born George Anton Linder in 1753; the later Virginia household includes wife Mary and a 1795 conveyance to John Gobble. The European parents are unresolved. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GEORGE_ANTON_LINDER_PEGGY_1753",
            "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
            "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
            "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_ANTHONY_LINDER_ANCESTRY_REVIEW",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "German Linder can derive from places called Linden or Lindern, or from Lind; the latter can also represent a gentle/mild nickname.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LINDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LIND"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Independent Swedish ornamental and English formations also exist; German and Jewish uses need not share one origin.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LINDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LIND"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A shared name does not establish a link among the Swiss household, the 1753 immigrant and Elizabeth Gabel. Each requires its own records.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LINDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LIND"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_HANNAH_CASWELL_ABT1709",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANNAH_CASWELL_ABT1709",
      "surname": "Caswell",
      "locality": "Hannah’s locality unresolved; Massachusetts namesake compared with the Virginia Newland family",
      "research_limit": "Hannah Caswell is retained from a supplied profile that named her as Mary Newland Linder’s mother. She currently has no family links in the tree. Her estimated 1709 birth, birthplace and parents are not established by the cited records. The reconstructed Virginia family instead includes John Newland’s wife Elizabeth, supported by the 1739 marriage and later deeds.",
      "notes": "A Norton, Massachusetts entry names Hannah Caswell and John Newland in 1721. That is a specific alternative household that could explain the profile claim; it has not been identified with Mary’s Virginia family. Hannah remains a separate research profile, with no Massachusetts ancestors attached to the Virginia line.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_HANNAH_CASWELL_PROFILE_PROVENANCE",
        "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NORTON_CASWELL_NEWLAND_INTENTIONS_1721"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Hannah Caswell and John Newland in Norton",
          "record_date": "5 August 1721",
          "locality": "Norton, Massachusetts",
          "historical_detail": "The published Norton vital records list marriage intentions for Hannah Caswell and John Newland on this date.",
          "association": "The pairing of both names makes this a concrete comparison for the Hannah profile, rather than merely a hypothetical namesake.",
          "alternatives": "The Massachusetts couple may be the source of a mistaken connection to the Virginia Newlands. Alternatively, the retained profile could refer to another Hannah whose records remain unidentified. The reported 1709 birth would make the Norton bride only about twelve, so that date also needs testing.",
          "assessment": "The Norton record is useful for resolving the profile’s identity, not evidence of Virginia ancestry. No record yet connects this couple to Mary Newland Linder; the Virginia wife’s documented name Elizabeth must be accounted for before combining the families.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_NORTON_CASWELL_NEWLAND_INTENTIONS_1721",
            "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Caswell is a surname taken from a place name combining Old English words for watercress and a spring or stream.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CASWELL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary identifies Caswell places in Dorset, Northamptonshire and Somerset. None has yet been connected to this Hannah; the surname alone cannot select one as her ancestral home.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CASWELL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name describes a landscape feature associated with watercress. It does not by itself indicate an occupation or a single common ancestor for all Caswell families.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CASWELL"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANSS_MOLLFINGER_FATHER_OF_BARBARA",
      "surname": "Mollfinger",
      "locality": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, now part of Iphofen",
      "research_limit": "The supplied transcript of Barbara Mollfinger’s marriage to Stephan Lindner on 28 April 1665 names her deceased father Hans. It establishes that relationship and places his death before the wedding, but does not identify his parents or wife.",
      "notes": "The archive holds Nenzenheim baptisms beginning in 1592, marriages in 1616 and burials in 1591. These date ranges extend into the period relevant to Hans, although individual entries and gaps have not yet been checked. The line therefore stops at an unresolved family identification, not a demonstrated loss of all earlier records. A compiled pedigree gives his name as Johann and death as 1663; neither detail is established by the supplied marriage transcript.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_NENZENHEIM_LAELKB_CATALOGUE",
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Hans (possibly Johann) Mollfinger: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Nenzenheim, Franconia, now part of Iphofen",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The supplied transcript of Barbara Mollfinger’s marriage to Stephan Lindner on 28 April 1665 names her deceased father Hans. It establishes that relationship and places his death before the wedding, but does not identify his parents or wife. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_NENZENHEIM_LAELKB_CATALOGUE",
            "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The meaning of the exact spelling Mollfinger remains unresolved. The similar Mulfinger spelling occurs in Nenzenheim, but it has not yet been shown to be a variant used by Hans’s family; it cannot supply a secure etymology for this branch.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_MOLLFINGER_NAME_REVIEW",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NENZENHEIM_MULFINGER_1905"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Nenzenheim is the family’s documented locality in the supplied 1665 marriage transcript. It is not necessarily Hans’s birthplace. The evidence inspected does not identify an earlier place of origin.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_MOLLFINGER_NAME_REVIEW"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A transcription of the 1905 Middle Franconian official gazette lists Georg Adam Mulfinger and Georg Andreas Mulfinger as farmers at Nenzenheim among recipients of decorations. The same village and similar surname make later family continuity plausible, but the 240-year gap also permits a separate family or later arrival. Neither man has been linked to Hans.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_NENZENHEIM_MULFINGER_1905"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "surname": "Nagel",
      "locality": "Blankenloch, Baden",
      "research_limit": "The present person is named Hans Anthoni Nagel, despite the legacy identifier containing Simon. Existing compilations conflict over his identity, wife and death date. No inspected original establishes his parents.",
      "notes": "Raupp’s Staffort compilation describes Hans Simon/Simon, born in 1623 and died on 15 October 1693, with Catharina. This is a concrete alternative to the Hans Anthoni reconstruction, and even the compilation’s repeated entries differ over the marriage year. The households may have been combined. Their burials and children’s records have not yet resolved the identities.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG",
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_NAGEL_DESVERICKY_COMPILED_20260730",
        "SRC_ROOTS_RAUPP_STAFFORT_NAGEL"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Hans Anthoni Nagel: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Blankenloch, Baden",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The present person is named Hans Anthoni Nagel, despite the legacy identifier containing Simon. Existing compilations conflict over his identity, wife and death date. No inspected original establishes his parents. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
            "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
            "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG",
            "SRC_YOURROOTS_NAGEL_DESVERICKY_COMPILED_20260730",
            "SRC_ROOTS_RAUPP_STAFFORT_NAGEL"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "One formation is an occupational name for a nail maker, from the word for nail.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NAGEL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "German, Dutch, Scandinavian and Jewish occurrences exist; some Germanized Sorbian forms have a different nickname origin.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NAGEL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname alone does not establish that this individual made nails or that Wunsiedel and Blankenloch families share ancestry.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NAGEL"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "person_id": "SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "surname": "Hansen",
      "locality": "Reported Blankenloch, Baden; birthplace unresolved",
      "research_limit": "The compiled Lang family tree identifies Anna Catharina Hansen as Hans Anthoni Nagel’s wife and gives her death as 22 October 1678. It proposes Bahne Hansen and Metta Marie Christine Carstensen as her parents without displaying supporting citations. Those names provide a lead, but no record has been identified linking that parental household to the woman in Baden. Her maiden name and parentage remain reported claims.",
      "notes": "The same compilation assigns children three separate birth dates between July 1655 and August 1656. That unusually compressed sequence points to a possible date error or a mixture of families; exact-looking dates do not resolve it. The proposed parents cannot yet be ranked above an incorrectly combined pedigree. Archion catalogues a Blankenloch mixed register for 1672–1738, which covers the reported death year but begins after her supposed childhood and marriage. Checking that entry and the later Nagel household against Scheidle’s family book may clarify her identity and name. The catalogue establishes available coverage, not that every earlier record was destroyed.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
        "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anna Catharina Hansen: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Reported Blankenloch, Baden; birthplace unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The compiled Lang family tree identifies Anna Catharina Hansen as Hans Anthoni Nagel’s wife and gives her death as 22 October 1678. It proposes Bahne Hansen and Metta Marie Christine Carstensen as her parents without displaying supporting citations. Those names provide a lead, but no record has been identified linking that parental household to the woman in Baden. Her maiden name and parentage remain reported claims. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
            "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
            "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Hansen is a patronymic surname formed from the personal name Hans.",
          "caveat": "This explains the reported surname, whose spelling has not been verified in Anna Catharina’s original records.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HANSEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary records Danish, Norwegian, Dutch, Flemish and North German origins.",
          "caveat": "Those possible origins do not identify where Anna Catharina was born or establish a migration to Baden.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HANSEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The relevant historical setting for this branch is the reported Nagel household at Blankenloch. A published local family book by Walter August Scheidle covers Blankenloch, Büchig and Stutensee from 1672 to 1920.",
          "caveat": "Its contents have not been inspected for Anna Catharina; no earlier local Hansen household has yet been identified from the material examined.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_MARIA_DIETERLE_NAGEL_1593",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARIA_DIETERLE_NAGEL_1593",
      "surname": "Dieterle",
      "locality": "Germany; town and parish unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Maria (Dieterle) Nagel entered the tree as Matthew’s clue with a reported birth date of 26 September 1593. The saved profile supplies neither a parish nor a record identifying her parents or relationship to the connected Nagel family. She remains a separate, unattached candidate. The precise date is therefore a search clue, not a verified baptism.",
      "notes": "The Marie Dieterle entry linked to Jacob Nagel matches the reported birth year and the Dieterle–Nagel name combination, making it a useful candidate for the same woman or the source of the original clue. It could also repeat an earlier tree error; the index does not supply the exact September date or documentary support for the relationship. Those explanations cannot yet be distinguished. A marriage or baptism naming a parish would allow earlier local Dieterle records to be compared meaningfully. Until then, neither the other Nagel branch’s Blankenloch locality nor a town associated with a different Dieterle family can be assigned to Maria, and no earlier local family connection is established.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_USER_MARIA_DIETERLE_CLUE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_MARIE_DIETERLE_GENEANET_CLUE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Maria Dieterle Nagel: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Germany; town and parish unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Maria (Dieterle) Nagel entered the tree as Matthew’s clue with a reported birth date of 26 September 1593. The saved profile supplies neither a parish nor a record identifying her parents or relationship to the connected Nagel family. She remains a separate, unattached candidate. The precise date is therefore a search clue, not a verified baptism. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_USER_MARIA_DIETERLE_CLUE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_MARIE_DIETERLE_GENEANET_CLUE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Dieterle is formed from an affectionate or shortened form of the personal name Dieter.",
          "caveat": "The name’s linguistic formation does not identify Maria’s father.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_DIETERLE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary describes Dieterle as South German.",
          "caveat": "The saved clue gives Maria’s birthplace only as Germany; a specific town or parish has not been established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_DIETERLE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The closest family lead found is a compiled index entry for Marie Dieterle, dated 1593–1634, linked to Jacob Nagel in 1609.",
          "caveat": "It is a lead for identifying her household, not a documented earlier Dieterle family in an established home parish.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_MARIE_DIETERLE_GENEANET_CLUE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_FRIEDRICH_NAGEL_1555",
      "person_id": "SRC_FRIEDRICH_NAGEL_1555",
      "surname": "Nagel",
      "locality": "Wunsiedel, Bavaria (reported)",
      "research_limit": "This unattached candidate has user-reported dates 1555–1609 and a Wunsiedel association, but no attached documentary source establishing parents or connecting him to the Baden family.",
      "notes": "The reported Wunsiedel individual remains a candidate supported by the supplied pedigree, but no named local record has been matched to him. His dates or locality may belong to a different person. The distant Baden household does not establish a relationship to this Friedrich.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Friedrich Nagel: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Wunsiedel, Bavaria (reported)",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: This unattached candidate has user-reported dates 1555–1609 and a Wunsiedel association, but no attached documentary source establishing parents or connecting him to the Baden family. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HISTORICAL_MENTION_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "One formation is an occupational name for a nail maker, from the word for nail.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NAGEL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "German, Dutch, Scandinavian and Jewish occurrences exist; some Germanized Sorbian forms have a different nickname origin.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NAGEL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname alone does not establish that this individual made nails or that Wunsiedel and Blankenloch families share ancestry.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NAGEL"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_JANE_FARNEFOLDE_1508",
      "person_id": "SRC_JANE_FARNEFOLDE_1508",
      "surname": "Farnefolde",
      "locality": "Reported East Ham marriage locality unresolved; surname has Sussex associations",
      "research_limit": "Jane remains a competing spouse candidate for George Wall. The reported 1551 marriage at StMichael, EastHam has not been verified. The county history dates the local StMichael foundations much later, so at least the church/place identification needs correction before choosing parents.",
      "notes": "The reported 1551 marriage has an anachronistic church or locality label. It may be a real marriage assigned to the wrong location, or a record for a different Jane and George. The original index reference has not been recovered. The surname’s Sussex association offers a possible origin, but does not identify Jane’s birthplace or connect her to a prominent Farnfold family.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_VCH_EAST_HAM_CHURCHES",
        "SRC_ROOTS_FANBI_FARNFOLD"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Jane Farnefolde: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Reported East Ham marriage locality unresolved; surname has Sussex associations",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Jane remains a competing spouse candidate for George Wall. The reported 1551 marriage at StMichael, EastHam has not been verified. The county history dates the local StMichael foundations much later, so at least the church/place identification needs correction before choosing parents. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_VCH_EAST_HAM_CHURCHES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FANBI_FARNFOLD"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The Farnfold name family is explained as fern or bracken plus an enclosure; Farnefolde is assessed here as a spelling variant, subject to record confirmation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FANBI_FARNFOLD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary proposes a lost or unidentified Farnfold place, probably in Sussex. For Farnfield it also allows a separate bracken-field formation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FANBI_FARNFOLD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Sussex surname association is linguistic and regional context. Jane’s reported EastHam connection is unsettled, so no Sussex pedigree is attached to her from the name alone.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FANBI_FARNFOLD"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "person_id": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "surname": "Banester",
      "locality": "Preston, Lancashire",
      "research_limit": "The visitation identifies Grace as Lawrence Banester’s daughter and William Wall’s second wife. That is a named parentage lead beyond the present endpoint. It does not establish the imported life dates or George Wall’s maternity.",
      "notes": "The distinctive spouse and Preston family details favor identifying Grace with the visitation household. Its connection to George Wall remains uncertain: he is not among the sons listed. That omission does not rule out a relationship, but no will or settlement has yet supplied the missing link.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Grace Banester: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Preston, Lancashire",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The visitation identifies Grace as Lawrence Banester’s daughter and William Wall’s second wife. That is a named parentage lead beyond the present endpoint. It does not establish the imported life dates or George Wall’s maternity. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The Bannister name family derives from a French word for a basket or wagon covering; the precise reason it became a surname is uncertain.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BANNISTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary discusses a Norman family with English estates and an early twelfth-century Ricardus Banastre. It also allows independently formed later names.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BANNISTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Grace’s Banester spelling is recorded in the local pedigree. Descent from the early knightly family is a hypothesis to test, not established by that spelling; the modern stair-rail word is unrelated.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BANNISTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_RICHARD_WALL_ABT1463",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_WALL_ABT1463",
      "surname": "Wall",
      "locality": "Preston and Burscough, Lancashire",
      "research_limit": "The visitation names Evan of Preston as Richard’s father and another Evan of Burscough above him. This is an unassessed published extension beyond the current database endpoint, not evidence that the parents are unknowable.",
      "notes": "The matching wife and descendants strongly support identifying the Preston visitation household. Its connection to George Wall of Droitwich remains a separate, unproved link. Richard’s estimated 1463 birth is not given by the visitation, and no reviewed settlement or probate record connects the two localities.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Earlier Walls of Burscough and Preston in the 1567 visitation",
          "record_date": "1567 pedigree, recording earlier generations",
          "locality": "Burscough and Preston, Lancashire",
          "historical_detail": "The published pedigree places two successive Evans above Richard, with Burscough and Preston residences. It also names a collateral Thomas of Fulwood.",
          "association": "An explicit ancestral and collateral cluster is substantially stronger than an isolated local surname match.",
          "alternatives": "The pedigree may preserve an erroneous earlier generation; separately, the correct Preston family may have been misattached to Droitwich.",
          "assessment": "Strong lead for this Preston household’s earlier roots. Verify its underlying identity and the connected branch before adding biological edges; no generation dates are inferred here.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Wall may describe residence by a wall or derive from a place named Wall; another English formation concerns a spring or stream.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WALL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Irish, German and Swedish Wall have additional origins. The spelling alone cannot select among independently formed families.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WALL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Preston visitation supplies a local family cluster. It does not automatically connect Preston Walls to the Worcestershire estate holders.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WALL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_GIROLAMO_PETTENATI",
      "person_id": "SRC_GIROLAMO_PETTENATI",
      "surname": "Pettenati",
      "locality": null,
      "research_limit": "The user-supplied profile identifies Girolamo as Margaret’s father, but the inspected Preston pedigree calls her the daughter of an unnamed Whalley. Girolamo’s own dates, locality and parents are not established.",
      "notes": "The visitation names Margaret’s paternal family as Whalley. That favors a mistaken combination of families over the suggestion that Pettenati was another name for the same household. No record explaining a dual surname has been found. Girolamo’s identity depends on the still-untraced source behind the supplied profile.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567",
        "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_REVIEW_20260916"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Girolamo Pettenati: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "No locality recorded",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The user-supplied profile identifies Girolamo as Margaret’s father, but the inspected Preston pedigree calls her the daughter of an unnamed Whalley. Girolamo’s own dates, locality and parents are not established. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567",
            "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_REVIEW_20260916"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Meaning remains unresolved: the consulted distribution reference explicitly supplies none, and conflicting online derivations lacked a reliable cited basis.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_DISTRIBUTION",
            "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_REVIEW_20260916",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Modern surname data place Pettenati chiefly in Italy, particularly Emilia-Romagna. This does not establish where the proposed medieval Girolamo lived.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_DISTRIBUTION",
            "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_REVIEW_20260916",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No documented Pettenati association with the Preston Wall household was established in the searches recorded here. The visitation instead identifies Margaret’s paternal surname as Whalley.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_DISTRIBUTION",
            "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_REVIEW_20260916",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_MRS_GIROLAMO_PETTENATI",
      "person_id": "SRC_MRS_GIROLAMO_PETTENATI",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": null,
      "research_limit": "Mrs Girolamo Pettenati is a spouse placeholder in the supplied profile. Neither her personal name nor birth surname is known; Pettenati cannot be treated as her own ancestral surname.",
      "notes": "The Preston visitation does not name Margaret’s mother. This unnamed woman may represent a real spouse, or may have been introduced through the possible Pettenati/Whalley confusion. No independent record identifies her. Her own surname and family history therefore remain unknown.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567",
        "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_REVIEW_20260916"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mrs. Girolamo Pettenati: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "No locality recorded",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Mrs Girolamo Pettenati is a spouse placeholder in the supplied profile. Neither her personal name nor birth surname is known; Pettenati cannot be treated as her own ancestral surname. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567",
            "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_REVIEW_20260916"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Mrs. Girolamo Pettenati without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Mrs. Girolamo Pettenati. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Mrs. Girolamo Pettenati without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_THOMAS_WYLDE_CLOTHIER",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_WYLDE_CLOTHIER",
      "surname": "Wylde",
      "locality": "Worcester and Impney, Worcestershire",
      "research_limit": "The endpoint reflects an unassessed parentage lead, not proof that earlier records are unavailable. A compiled biography names Simon Wylde of The Ford, Dodderhill, as Thomas’s father. The cited county-history page supports the later property succession but did not substantiate Simon’s parentage in this review.",
      "notes": "The supplied pedigree connects Thomas to Simon of The Ford, a specific local-family lead. The supporting original statement has not been found, and another Wylde household could have been attached in error. The reported 1524 subsidy entry and visitation remain unverified sources for that connection.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_VCH_DODDERHILL",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WIKI_THOMAS_WYLDE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Wylde and Wall succession at Impney",
          "record_date": "1540 s–sixteenth century",
          "locality": "Impney, Dodderhill, Worcestershire",
          "historical_detail": "The county history traces purchases by George Wall in 1544 and 1546, inheritance through his daughters, and Eleanor’s marriages to Edward Corbett and Thomas Wylde. It then identifies George Wylde as Thomas’s son in the manor’s succession.",
          "association": "Names, marriage and property form a specific household cluster matching the endpoint, rather than merely a same-surname locality match.",
          "alternatives": "The published reconstruction could contain a succession error; underlying deeds and legal records can test it. It does not supply Thomas’s own parents.",
          "assessment": "Strong contextual support for the identified local family. This is contemporary family history, not an invented earlier generation or proof of the separate Simon parentage claim.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_VCH_DODDERHILL"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Wylde is an English spelling of Wild, which can be a nickname describing wild behavior or a name for someone living by uncultivated ground.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WYLDE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The English name has more than one formation; a variant of Wile is another possibility. German and Jewish Wild have independent cognate uses.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WYLDE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Worcester clothier’s documented local household and property history identify this branch more usefully than the surname’s literal meaning. The name does not establish the temperament of Thomas or a common ancestor for every Wylde.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WYLDE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILD"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "person_id": "SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "surname": "Huddleston",
      "locality": "Sawston, Cambridgeshire; married Wylde household in Worcestershire",
      "research_limit": "The biography identifies Frances as Sir Edmund Huddleston of Sawston’s daughter, but that parentage has not yet been assessed or added to this branch. No original marriage settlement or will has been inspected to confirm it.",
      "notes": "Frances’s husband, reported father and Sawston estate association favor the biography’s identification. Historic England confirms Edmund and his father John at Sawston, but does not establish Frances’s relationship to them. No competing Frances has been located. Her marriage settlement or Edmund’s will may provide that connection; the reported 1557 birth is unverified.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_WIKI_GEORGE_WYLDE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_HE_SAWSTON_HALL"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John and Edmund Huddleston rebuild Sawston Hall",
          "record_date": "1557 and 1584 dated stones; reported 1553 fire",
          "locality": "Sawston Hall, Cambridgeshire",
          "historical_detail": "Historic England attributes rebuilding to Sir John Huddleston, who died in 1557, and his son Sir Edmund, who died in 1606. It records courtyard stones with their initials and dates. The account describes the 1553 burning as reputed retaliation for sheltering Mary.",
          "association": "The estate and Edmund’s name match Frances’s reported father. This is specific context for that household, including an older named generation, rather than a distant surname coincidence.",
          "alternatives": "The building history can be correct even if Frances’s parentage has been misreported. The precise fire narrative is qualified in the official record.",
          "assessment": "Well-supported local household history; probable relevance to Frances through the explicit biographical identification. The building record alone neither names her nor proves her descent.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HE_SAWSTON_HALL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WIKI_GEORGE_WYLDE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Huddleston derives from a Yorkshire place-name combining the personal name Hudel with a word for a farmstead or estate.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HUDDLESTON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "It is an English habitational surname. The linguistic place of origin is distinct from this family’s later residence at Sawston.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HUDDLESTON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The biography and historic building record place the proposed Huddleston household at Sawston. Frances’s particular relationship to that household remains unconfirmed.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HUDDLESTON"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "person_id": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "surname": "Shemeld",
      "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire (reported marriage and candidate household)",
      "research_limit": "The supplied profile reports Isabel 1577–1647 and a 1601 Sheffield marriage to William Wilde. A member-tree composite names William Shemeld and Anna Swifte as parents of an Isabel with those same dates. The underlying baptism and marriage entries have not been inspected.",
      "notes": "Isabel’s uncommon name, dates and Sheffield association make the proposed William-and-Anna household a plausible birth family. The matching details may, however, come from copies of one reconstruction. No competing Isabel has been identified. The baptism, 1601 marriage and William’s reported burial or probate have not yet established her parentage.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEMELD_WILLIAM_COMPOSITE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEMELD_BARDSLEY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Schemylde name-bearers in the 1379 Yorkshire poll tax",
          "record_date": "1379",
          "locality": "Yorkshire; exact parish not established in the consulted extract",
          "historical_detail": "Bardsley’s surname dictionary cites Adam Schemylde and Robertus Schemylde, the latter described as a smith, in the Yorkshire poll tax.",
          "association": "The uncommon surname form and county are compatible with an older regional family background for the reported Sheffield household, roughly two centuries later.",
          "alternatives": "They may be unrelated bearers of a separately formed nickname, or belong to a different Yorkshire district. The dictionary’s identification also needs checking against the tax text.",
          "assessment": "A specific regional lead, with only weak evidence for wider-family continuity until the parish is identified. No direct descent or intervening generations are asserted.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEMELD_BARDSLEY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The modern dictionary tentatively proposes a nickname associated with mottled or grey hair, from a reconstructed Middle English form.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FANBI_SHEMELD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEMELD_BARDSLEY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "An alternative is descent of the surname from a rare continental female personal name ending in an element meaning battle. Its absence as a recorded English given name makes that explanation uncertain.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FANBI_SHEMELD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEMELD_BARDSLEY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Older references give a confident Scandinavian explanation, but the modern dictionary is more cautious. Neither interpretation proves Scandinavian or continental ancestry for Isabel.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FANBI_SHEMELD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEMELD_BARDSLEY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTIN_LINDER_ABT1582",
      "surname": "Linder",
      "locality": "Saanen/Gsteig, Bern (compiled household)",
      "research_limit": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "notes": "The Swiss dates and family group describe a plausible household, but no migration or family record connects it to the Nenzenheim line. The Swiss Linder and German Lindner families may be separate. Neither has been established as the earlier ancestry of the other.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Marty (Martin) Linder: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Saanen/Gsteig, Bern (compiled household)",
          "historical_detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
            "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
            "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "German Linder can derive from places called Linden or Lindern, or from Lind; the latter can also represent a gentle/mild nickname.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LINDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LIND"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Independent Swedish ornamental and English formations also exist; German and Jewish uses need not share one origin.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LINDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LIND"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A shared name does not establish a link among the Swiss household, the 1753 immigrant and Elizabeth Gabel. Each requires its own records.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LINDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LIND"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "person_id": "SRC_SALOME_WEHREN_ABT1585",
      "surname": "Werren",
      "locality": "Gsteig bei Gstaad and Saanen, Bern, Switzerland",
      "research_limit": "The original Gsteig bei Gstaad register records Marty Linder’s marriage to Salome on 26 May 1605. Her surname appears in a form resembling Werro, rendered Werren in the later family reconstruction. The entry names neither parent. Her reported birth around 1585–1586 has not yet been matched to a baptism.",
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_GSTEIG_LINDER_SALOME_MARRIAGE_1605",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SAANEN_REGISTER_COVERAGE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Salome Werren: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Gsteig bei Gstaad and Saanen, Bern, Switzerland",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The original Gsteig bei Gstaad register records Marty Linder’s marriage to Salome on 26 May 1605. Her surname appears in a form resembling Werro, rendered Werren in the later family reconstruction. The entry names neither parent. Her reported birth around 1585–1586 has not yet been matched to a baptism. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_GSTEIG_LINDER_SALOME_MARRIAGE_1605",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SAANEN_REGISTER_COVERAGE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Emanuel Friedli’s study of Saanen explains Wehren and related Werren forms through an older word for a defender, associated with German wehren, “to defend.” This is a historical linguistic proposal, not evidence that Salome or her father held a military occupation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FRIEDLI_WERREN_SAANEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Friedli places related spellings in the Bernese Oberland: Weren in Saanen and Gsteig, and Werren or Wärren in Zweisimmen, Diemtigen and Brienz. These local forms provide a more relevant background for Salome than the English Werren-to-Warren dictionary cross-reference.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FRIEDLI_WERREN_SAANEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Friedli cites Weren in Saanen and Gsteig in 1607 and Hans Währen at Oberport in 1687. Their proximity in place and time makes membership of a wider local family plausible. Separate households sharing related surname forms remain possible; neither reference identifies Salome’s parents.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_FRIEDLI_WERREN_SAANEN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Reported family connection to Nenzenheim, Franconia",
      "research_limit": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "notes": "A cited reconstruction of Michael’s family instead lists Hans, born on 5 May 1642, among the children of Anna Fuchs, whom Michael married at Nenzenheim on 21 November 1625. Hans and Johannes may represent the same son, making the mother’s identity a question to resolve. If the women were the same person, the reported 1620 birth would conflict with the 1625 marriage; if they were different wives, the second marriage and children’s mothers need distinguishing. Nenzenheim parish holdings include seventeenth-century baptisms and marriages. The relevant original entries have not yet been checked, so neither Fuchs nor Lindner can be assigned as this Anna’s birth surname.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_MICHAEL_LINDER_UNTRACED_ANCESTRY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NENZENHEIM_LAELKB_CATALOGUE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anna: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Reported family connection to Nenzenheim, Franconia",
          "historical_detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_MICHAEL_LINDER_UNTRACED_ANCESTRY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NENZENHEIM_LAELKB_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Anna without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Anna. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Anna without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "person_id": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "surname": "Fuchs",
      "locality": "Oberböbingen; proposed Unterhausen connection, Württemberg",
      "research_limit": "The existing Anna baptism evidence names Hans as father in Oberböbingen on 12 September 1596. His own parents remain unidentified. A compiled 1590 Unterhausen marriage to Barbara Reiff is not independently verified here.",
      "notes": "The father’s name and chronology are compatible with the proposed Hans Fuchs marriage, but another Hans could explain the record. The catalogued Unterhausen marriage sequence begins in 1597 and therefore does not verify the claimed 1590 ceremony. Other earlier evidence may survive; the present catalog entry cannot resolve the identity.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION",
        "SRC_ARCHION_UNTERHAUSEN_MIXED_BOOK_1579_1618"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Hans Fuchs: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Oberböbingen; proposed Unterhausen connection, Württemberg",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The existing Anna baptism evidence names Hans as father in Oberböbingen on 12 September 1596. His own parents remain unidentified. A compiled 1590 Unterhausen marriage to Barbara Reiff is not independently verified here. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION",
            "SRC_ARCHION_UNTERHAUSEN_MIXED_BOOK_1579_1618"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The German word for fox became a nickname, including for perceived cleverness or red hair.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FUCHS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name occurs in German and Ashkenazic Jewish usage and in neighboring countries; some occurrences reflect translated surnames.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FUCHS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname does not by itself establish ethnicity, occupation or a connection between the Galician and Württemberg families.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FUCHS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "person_id": "SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "surname": "Ellis",
      "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "research_limit": "Lydia’s parentage is unresolved. A newly located Sheffield baptism names Lidia, daughter of Anthony Ellis, on1 February 1628/9. This is a plausible parent candidate for Godfrey Wilde’s reported wife, but the marriage and identity bridge remain unverified.",
      "notes": "Lydia, daughter of Anthony Ellis, baptized in 1628/9 at Sheffield, is a plausible match for Godfrey’s reported wife around 1652. Another Lydia baptized in 1643 would have been a child at that marriage date and is less likely. A 1679 Lidia Ellis–George Tupman marriage remains unassigned. No reviewed record securely links Anthony’s daughter to Godfrey, and the reported 1627 birth is unverified.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_ELLIS_GREAVES",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_II",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_III"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Lidia, daughter of Anthony Ellis, baptised in Sheffield",
          "record_date": "1 February 1628/9",
          "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire",
          "historical_detail": "The published register, PartI p 159, records Lidia as daughter of Anthony Ellis. Her mother is not named in that entry.",
          "association": "Same name and parish, with a birth period close to the imported 1627 estimate, make this a plausible identity and parent lead for Godfrey Wilde’s reported wife.",
          "alternatives": "The baptised child could be a separate Lydia. A later marriage, burial, will or kin association is needed to distinguish her subsequent history.",
          "assessment": "Promising documented candidate; parent relationship to the baptism subject is explicit, but identity with this tree’s Lydia is not yet established. No parent edge is created.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_ELLIS_GREAVES"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Ellis commonly derives from the personal name Elis, related through Elias to Elijah; some instances may derive from a familiar form of Elizabeth.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ELLIS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Welsh Ellis can have a separate origin in Elisedd, associated with kindness or benevolence. Other modern formations also exist. No Welsh origin has been established for this Sheffield household.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ELLIS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The biblical origin of a personal name does not establish Jewish ancestry, and surname identity alone does not unite separate Ellis families. Anthony’s local baptism entry is more specific evidence than general surname associations.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ELLIS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_HELLENA_TUNSTEAD_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "person_id": "SRC_HELLENA_TUNSTEAD_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire",
      "research_limit": "The5 September 1677 marriage transcript calls Hellena Tunstead a widow. Her birth surname and parents are unresolved; Tunstead may be the surname of her earlier husband. The imported 1640 birth and 1681 death were not verified here.",
      "notes": "Hellena was described as a widow when she married Godfrey in 1677, making Tunstead a likely previous married surname. Her earlier husband is unidentified; Tunstead could also have been her birth surname. Local Tunstead baptisms do not connect her to a particular family. The proposed 1649 child conflicts with her imported 1640 birth, whereas a 1679 child is chronologically possible.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_III"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Hellena Tunstead: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The5 September 1677 marriage transcript calls Hellena Tunstead a widow. Her birth surname and parents are unresolved; Tunstead may be the surname of her earlier husband. The imported 1640 birth and 1681 death were not verified here. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_III"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Her birth surname is unresolved. Tunstead, the name used when she remarried as a widow, derives from a place-name meaning farmstead.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_TUNSTEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_III"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary principally identifies Norfolk Tunstead, with possible Derbyshire and Lancashire origins. This describes the recorded name, not Hellena’s proven birth family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_TUNSTEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_III"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Nearby Derbyshire places are possible origins of a Tunstead household, but geographical proximity cannot establish her birth lineage. Identify her first marriage before assigning surname ancestry.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_TUNSTEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_III"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "surname": "Greaves",
      "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "research_limit": "The published Sheffield register verifies Margaret’s marriage to Robert Hancock on5 February 1615/16. No parents are named. The reported 1595 birth and 1629 death remain unverified in this review.",
      "notes": "The spouses, parish and day of the Sheffield marriage match the imported household; the year difference is explained by Old Style dating. An earlier 1615 Robert Hancock–Anna Hancock marriage could concern another Robert or a prior wife. Margaret’s reported 1595 birth has no matched baptism. Earlier Greaves households occur in the parish, but none has been linked to her.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_ELLIS_GREAVES",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_II",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_III"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Margaret Greaves: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The published Sheffield register verifies Margaret’s marriage to Robert Hancock on5 February 1615/16. No parents are named. The reported 1595 birth and 1629 death remain unverified in this review. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_ELLIS_GREAVES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_II",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_III"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Greaves can derive from an Old English word for brushwood or a thicket, used as a landscape or settlement name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GREAVES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary connects Yorkshire examples with The Greaves in Beeley, Derbyshire, now Beeley Hilltop. It also gives Lancashire and other surname-variant alternatives.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GREAVES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Beeley is a possible regional source of the surname. It is not Margaret’s established birthplace, and no connection to a particular Greaves estate has been found.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GREAVES"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_RICHARD_HANCOCK_1564",
      "person_id": "SRC_RICHARD_HANCOCK_1564",
      "surname": "Hancock",
      "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire; proposed Chester and Kent matches unresolved",
      "research_limit": "The Sheffield marriage to Anna Roodes is verified in the published transcript on30 January 1586/7. It names no parents. The imported Chester baptism and Thanet burial have not been connected to this household by kin, residence, occupation or property evidence.",
      "notes": "The proposed Chester baptism, Sheffield marriage and Kent burial could describe one Richard, but the identification is unresolved. The imported death year differs from the burial, and the burial’s Canterbury label conflicts with its St Peter in Thanet location field. Sheffield also contains local Hancock families. No record connecting the three places has been established.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_I"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Richard Hancock: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire; proposed Chester and Kent matches unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The Sheffield marriage to Anna Roodes is verified in the published transcript on30 January 1586/7. It names no parents. The imported Chester baptism and Thanet burial have not been connected to this household by kin, residence, occupation or property evidence. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_I"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Hancock derives from the personal name Hann with the familiar-name suffix -cock.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_HANCOCK"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "There is also an independent Dutch occupational explanation relating to shellfish gathering or selling. It has not been selected for this Sheffield branch.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_HANCOCK"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The English formation can recur in separate families. The surname provides no bridge to the famous American Hancock family or to a specific older English household.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_HANCOCK"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_ANNE_ROADES_1567",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNE_ROADES_1567",
      "surname": "Roades",
      "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire; reported Ottringham burial unresolved",
      "research_limit": "The transcript verifies an Anna Roodes baptism on5 October 1567 and her proposed marriage to Richard Hancocke on30 January 1586/7. The baptism gives no parents. A second Anna Roodes baptism on29 November 1562 supplies a real competing local candidate.",
      "notes": "Two Sheffield baptisms could belong to the later bride: a girl baptized in 1567 and another in 1562. Both names, places and marriage ages fit, and neither entry names parents. No burial or later record distinguishes them. The imported 1612 Ottringham burial is also unconfirmed as hers.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_I"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "An earlier Anna Roodes baptism in the same parish",
          "record_date": "29 November 1562",
          "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire",
          "historical_detail": "PartI, printed p5, records Anna Roodes among those baptised on29 November 1562. No parents are supplied. Another Anna Roodes appears on5 October 1567, p12.",
          "association": "The same female name in the same parish five years earlier is specific evidence of local name continuity and a competing identity for the 1586/7 bride.",
          "alternatives": "The girls may be relatives, independent namesakes, or successive children after an earlier death. None of those explanations is demonstrated by these entries alone.",
          "assessment": "Strong local surname context; unresolved identity and kinship. Both birth dates fit the marriage. No intervening parent link is inferred.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_I"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Roades/Roodes is consistent with the Rhodes name family: a woodland clearing or clearings. The local transcript supplies the Roodes spelling.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_RHODES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_ROADS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_I"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Rhodes may refer to a landscape feature or several English places, including Lancashire and Yorkshire examples. A specific origin for Anne has not been identified.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_RHODES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_ROADS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_I"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The later Rh- spelling reflects clerical classical associations; it does not establish Greek-island ancestry. The word history differs from modern road meaning a thoroughfare.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_RHODES",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_ROADS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_I"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "surname": "Glover",
      "locality": "Stoke upon Trent, Staffordshire (marriage locality; birthplace unresolved)",
      "research_limit": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "notes": "Julia’s Stoke-area marriage makes a local Glover birth family plausible, although she could have moved there before marrying. The reviewed searches returned compiled descendants and unrelated namesakes, without identifying her parents. Her own census birthplace and marriage witnesses have not yet been verified, so no older Glover household can be reliably associated with her.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Julia Ann Glover: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Stoke upon Trent, Staffordshire (marriage locality; birthplace unresolved)",
          "historical_detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": []
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English occupational surname for someone who made or sold gloves.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GLOVER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name comes through Middle English occupational wording from the Old English word for glove. It does not identify one founding town or ancestor.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GLOVER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The historical association is the glove trade. Independent glove makers could acquire the same name; Julia’s family occupation and any relationship to earlier bearers require their own records.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GLOVER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_SAMPSON",
      "person_id": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_SAMPSON",
      "surname": "Handley",
      "locality": "Coton Mill, Milwich, Staffordshire; birthplace unresolved",
      "research_limit": "George’s family is associated with Coton Mill at Milwich, but his own parents remain disputed. One supplied profile proposes a 19 April 1689 Market Bosworth baptism to William and Alice. A competing Sheffield identification, already represented in the tree, proposes Thomas Handley and Hannah Fenton. The published chapel register confirms a George baptized to Thomas of Hall Carr on 25 August 1697, but does not connect him to Milwich.",
      "notes": "The reported birth about 1689 cannot independently confirm the Bosworth baptism because it may have been taken from that same proposal. Both origins require an identification across different places. A researcher’s objection based on marriage age remains untested because the actual age was not supplied. The Caverswall marriage is reported as both 14 and 17 February 1718; its original entry and any licence could help distinguish the candidates.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_PROFILE",
        "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_JOLLIE1697",
        "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_COMPETING_ORIGINS",
        "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_MILWICH_STONE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Two Handley households remembered on one stone",
          "record_date": "1758–1759",
          "locality": "Milwich, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The transcribed stone commemorates Ruth, wife of Sampson Handley of Coton Mill, who died on 4 January 1759 aged 19. Its reverse commemorates Ann, wife of George Handley of Coton Mill, who died on 26 August 1758 aged 67.",
          "association": "The shared memorial and mill residence strongly support a close connection between the households and fit the compiled account naming George and Ann as Sampson’s parents.",
          "alternatives": "Other close kinship could explain the shared stone. It does not state the relationship between the husbands or supply either wife’s maiden name.",
          "assessment": "This supports the local family identification more strongly than the surname alone, while leaving George’s earlier origins unresolved.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_MILWICH_STONE",
            "SRC_HANDLEY_MILWICH_COMPILED_REVIEW_20260915"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Earlier Handley probate records at Market Bosworth",
          "record_date": "1662; 1712; 1734; 1738",
          "locality": "Market Bosworth, Leicestershire — candidate locality",
          "historical_detail": "Hartopp’s calendar lists widow Isabell Handley or Hanley in 1662, William Handley in 1712, and widow Alice Handley in 1734, followed by a further administration in 1738.",
          "association": "William and Alice match the names and locality of the proposed baptism parents. Isabell places the surname there before either proposed birth date for George.",
          "alternatives": "The calendar does not identify William and Alice as a married couple, name George as their child, or link Isabell to them. The two Alice entries may concern successive administration of one estate.",
          "assessment": "These are specific records to test the Bosworth proposal, not evidence that it already outranks Sheffield. Their contents may identify heirs or residences that connect the households.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_BOSWORTH_PROBATE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "George baptized to Thomas Handley of Hall Carr",
          "record_date": "25 August 1697",
          "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire — competing candidate locality",
          "historical_detail": "Manning’s published version of Timothy Jollie’s register records George as a child of Thomas Handley of Hall Car, baptized on 25 August 1697.",
          "association": "This independently supports the existence of the Sheffield child proposed as the later Milwich George. The tree already preserves that interpretation through Thomas and Hannah’s line.",
          "alternatives": "The Sheffield child could have had a different adult life. His mother is not named in this entry, and the Milwich identification is not stated.",
          "assessment": "Sheffield is a concrete competing origin, not a hypothetical namesake invented to weaken Bosworth. Neither inspected record set yet establishes the move to Staffordshire; the adult’s marriage evidence and the parents’ probate records are the most useful comparisons.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_JOLLIE1697",
            "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_COMPETING_ORIGINS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Handley is a form of Hanley, commonly a name taken from a place described as a high meadow or clearing. Historical spellings can acquire the extra d without indicating a different family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_SURNAME"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Places called Handley or Hanley occur in several English counties, including Staffordshire, Cheshire and Dorset. An Irish formation also exists. The surname therefore does not select Sheffield, Market Bosworth or any particular English settlement as George’s birthplace.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_SURNAME"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "For this branch, the clearest local association is Coton Mill. A memorial links the households of George and Sampson there in 1758–1759, giving the family history a specific setting even while George’s origins remain unsettled.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_MILWICH_STONE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_INDEX_JOHN_ALKIN_FATHER_OF_MARY",
      "person_id": "C_INDEX_JOHN_ALKIN_FATHER_OF_MARY",
      "surname": "Alkin",
      "locality": "Uttoxeter and Bramshall, Staffordshire",
      "research_limit": "A burial index names John Alkin as the father of Mary Alkin, buried at Uttoxeter on 16 April 1710. A separate marriage index records John Alkins and Elizabeth Bagnald at Bramshall on 13 June 1667. Neither supplied entry identifies John’s parents.",
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MARY_ALKIN_BURIAL_1710_UTTOXETER",
        "SRC_JOHN_ALKINS_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_MARRIAGE_1667",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SAMPSON_ALKYN_UTTOXETER_PETITION_1656"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Sampson Alkyn supports a Civil War relief petition",
          "record_date": "July 1656",
          "locality": "Uttoxeter, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "Sampson Alkyn was among the Uttoxeter inhabitants who certified Mathew Bakewell’s appeal for help. Bakewell described losing his property when royalist forces took Burton and supporting two orphaned grandchildren after their father died in Parliament’s service at Tutbury.",
          "association": "Sampson’s surname and locality place him in a plausible wider-family setting for John Alkins, whose reported Bramshall marriage followed eleven years later.",
          "alternatives": "Sampson could have been an older relative or contemporary kinsman, or a member of a separate local family. The petition supplies no relationship to John or Mary.",
          "assessment": "A documented local name-bearer and a possible wider-family association. The surname and geographical match give the connection a basis, but do not establish a generation or direct ancestor.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SAMPSON_ALKYN_UTTOXETER_PETITION_1656"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Alkin developed from a Middle English familiar personal name, formed from names such as Alan, Alexander or Alice with the diminutive ending -kin.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_ALKIN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The Oxford entries place Alkin and its variant Alkins in the English personal-name tradition. They do not identify a single founding village or household for the surname.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_ALKIN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Alkin, Alkins and Allkin occur in the supplied Uttoxeter-area family records; the 1656 petition uses Alkyn. These forms deserve comparison when tracing this branch. The personal-name origin also allows unrelated families to share the surname.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_ALKIN",
            "SRC_MARY_ALKIN_BURIAL_1710_UTTOXETER",
            "SRC_JOHN_ALKINS_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_MARRIAGE_1667",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SAMPSON_ALKYN_UTTOXETER_PETITION_1656"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_INDEX_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_ALKIN",
      "person_id": "C_INDEX_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_ALKIN",
      "surname": "Bagnald",
      "locality": "Bramshall and Uttoxeter, Staffordshire",
      "research_limit": "The supplied marriage index records Elizabeth Bagnald marrying John Alkins at Bramshall on 13 June 1667. It names neither her parents nor her birthplace. Her identification as the mother of Mary Allkin Cartwright comes from the supplied family account rather than a baptism naming both parents.",
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_ALKINS_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_MARRIAGE_1667",
        "SRC_MARY_ALKIN_BURIAL_1710_UTTOXETER",
        "SRC_ROOTS_REDFERN_UTTOXETER_BAGNOLD_1553"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Raffe Bagnold and the Uttoxeter church silver",
          "record_date": "1552–1553 inventory",
          "locality": "Uttoxeter, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "An inventory reproduced by Francis Redfern names Raffe Bagnold among parishioners who sold a partly gilt silver cross weighing 42 ounces. The document says the sale took place without the agreement of the other parishioners.",
          "association": "This puts a recognized variant of Elizabeth’s surname in the nearby town more than a century before her Bramshall marriage, giving a concrete basis for investigating longer local family continuity.",
          "alternatives": "Raffe could belong to an earlier branch of her wider family, or to another Staffordshire family with the same place-derived surname. No household or property link currently bridges the interval.",
          "assessment": "A specific earlier local occurrence, not an identified ancestor. It supplies historical context for the name while leaving Elizabeth’s parentage open.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_REDFERN_UTTOXETER_BAGNOLD_1553",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_BAGNALL_BAGNOLD"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Bagnald belongs to the Bagnall group of spellings. The place-derived surname combines an Old English personal name, Badeca or Baduca, with a word for a nook or recess, or woodland.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_BAGNALL_BAGNOLD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BAGNALL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionaries identify Bagnall and Bagnall in Alrewas, both in Staffordshire, as possible source places. Elizabeth’s Bramshall marriage places her in the same county but does not identify which place her family originally came from.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BAGNALL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Oxford records Ralph Bagnall under Bagnold and Bagenall alias Bagnald in a 1561 citation, illustrating historical variation in the spelling. The surname also spread to Leinster in the sixteenth century; no Irish connection has been established for Elizabeth.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_BAGNALL_BAGNOLD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BAGNALL"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC1825_LEVI_HANBY_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "SRC1825_LEVI_HANBY_RHEAD",
      "surname": "Rhead",
      "locality": null,
      "research_limit": "Levi Hanby Rhead is named as Richard’s father in the indexed 1825 Burslem baptism. His own parents are not established by that record.",
      "notes": "The compiled FamilySearch family gives Levi dates of 1789–1848 and identifies Henrietta as Mayer. These remain leads without the underlying records. The child’s baptism identifies a father but does not name his parents. Levi’s earlier family has not been established.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57",
        "SRC_ROOTS_FS_RICHARD_RHEAD_LV6Q182"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Levi Hanby Rhead: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "No locality recorded",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Levi Hanby Rhead is named as Richard’s father in the indexed 1825 Burslem baptism. His own parents are not established by that record. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FS_RICHARD_RHEAD_LV6Q182"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Rhead is classified as a Staffordshire form of Read, which the dictionary connects with Reed. That wider name group has several possible formations: a reddish appearance, residence near a clearing, or a place name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RHEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_READ",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The Rhead entry specifically associates the spelling with Staffordshire. The wider Read/Reed group also has English and Scottish formations.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RHEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_READ",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Read and Reed are useful spellings to check alongside Rhead. For the wider group, the dictionary identifies several possible places, including Read in Lancashire, Reed in Hertfordshire and Rede in Suffolk.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RHEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_READ",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC1825_HENRIETTA_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "SRC1825_HENRIETTA_RHEAD",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": null,
      "research_limit": "The 1825 Richard Rhead baptism identifies Henrietta as mother but does not establish her maiden surname or parents. Rhead here is her married family name.",
      "notes": "Henrietta Mayer in the compiled FamilySearch family is a plausible match because husband and child agree. However, its reported 1834 death conflicts with an Ancestry compilation assigning her a child born in 1837. At least one claim is wrong; the original marriage, burial and baptism have not resolved which. Her natal surname remains uncertain.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57",
        "SRC_ROOTS_FS_RICHARD_RHEAD_LV6Q182",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ANCESTRY_SARAH_RHEAD_COMPILED"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Henrietta Rhead: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "No locality recorded",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The 1825 Richard Rhead baptism identifies Henrietta as mother but does not establish her maiden surname or parents. Rhead here is her married family name. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FS_RICHARD_RHEAD_LV6Q182",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANCESTRY_SARAH_RHEAD_COMPILED"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Henrietta Rhead without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Henrietta Rhead. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Henrietta Rhead without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_MEMORIAL_JANE_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "C_MEMORIAL_JANE_GODWIN_RHEAD",
      "surname": "Godwin",
      "locality": null,
      "research_limit": "The user-supplied George Rhead memorial reports Godwin as the surname of this wife (1828–1854), with marriage in 1847. Her parents and birthplace have not been established by the memorial.",
      "notes": "The memorial’s identification of George’s wife favors Godwin as Jane’s birth surname, but it could have been a previous married name or an error. Her 1847 marriage entry has not been checked for her father and marital status. George’s Bucknall address locates the married household, not Jane’s birthplace.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Jane Godwin Rhead: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "No locality recorded",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The user-supplied George Rhead memorial reports Godwin as the surname of this wife (1828–1854), with marriage in 1847. Her parents and birthplace have not been established by the memorial. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": []
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English surname from the Old English personal name Godwine, formed from elements for God and friend/protector.",
          "caveat": "Her birth surname remains unverified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GODWIN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The personal name survived the Norman Conquest; similar Goodwin forms can be confused in records. This does not locate Jane’s own birthplace.",
          "caveat": "Her birth surname remains unverified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GODWIN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Its association is with a personal name rather than a uniquely identifiable medieval dynasty. No connection to Earl Godwin or his descendants follows from the surname.",
          "caveat": "Her birth surname remains unverified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GODWIN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_MEMORIAL_MARGARET_TURNER_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "C_MEMORIAL_MARGARET_TURNER_RHEAD",
      "surname": "Turner",
      "locality": null,
      "research_limit": "The user-supplied George Rhead memorial reports Turner as the surname of this wife (1831–1865), with marriage in 1854. Her parents and birthplace have not been established by the memorial.",
      "notes": "The memorial favors Turner as Margaret’s birth surname, although a previous married name or a recording error remains possible. Her 1854 marriage entry has not been checked for her father and marital status. George’s Bucknall address does not establish Margaret’s birthplace.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Margaret Turner Rhead: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "No locality recorded",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The user-supplied George Rhead memorial reports Turner as the surname of this wife (1831–1865), with marriage in 1854. Her parents and birthplace have not been established by the memorial. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": []
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "In English, commonly an occupational surname for someone turning wood, metal or bone on a lathe.",
          "caveat": "Her birth surname remains unverified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_TURNER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary records several independent formations, including other English occupations and distinct continental surnames. These do not identify Margaret’s ancestry or ethnicity.",
          "caveat": "Her birth surname remains unverified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_TURNER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The common craft association makes independent surname formation a substantial alternative to shared ancestry between distant Turner households. A local family connection requires additional place and record context.",
          "caveat": "Her birth surname remains unverified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_TURNER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_MEMORIAL_MARY_ANN_BEARDMORE_RHEAD",
      "person_id": "C_MEMORIAL_MARY_ANN_BEARDMORE_RHEAD",
      "surname": "Beardmore",
      "locality": null,
      "research_limit": "The user-supplied George Rhead memorial reports Beardmore as the surname of this wife (1838–1891), with marriage in 1866. Her parents and birthplace have not been established by the memorial.",
      "notes": "The memorial favors Beardmore as Mary Ann’s birth surname, although a previous married name or an error remains possible. Her 1866 marriage entry has not been checked for her father and marital status. George’s Bucknall address identifies their household, not her birthplace.",
      "source_ids": [],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Beardmoors: a recorded Farley place-name",
          "record_date": "1290–1798 (reported attestations)",
          "locality": "Farley, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "Horovitz cites Berdesmor in 1290, Berdemore/Berdemor in 1296 and land called Beardmores in 1798 (SRO D 554/41). The precise site is unlocated. These are place-name attestations, not identified ancestors.",
          "association": "The surname dictionary associates Beardmore with this lost Farley place. This provides a specific location to investigate once Mary Ann’s reported birth surname and birthplace are verified.",
          "alternatives": "Mary Ann’s family could have moved away long before her birth, or represent a different branch. Her husband’s Staffordshire residence alone does not locate her birth family.",
          "assessment": "The place-name history is documented, but no connection to Mary Ann’s family is established. The 1798 deed may clarify the site’s history.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HOROVITZ_BEARDMOORS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BEARDMORE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English habitational surname associated by the dictionary with a lost place in Farley, Staffordshire.",
          "caveat": "Her birth surname remains unverified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BEARDMORE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary gives early place-name forms Berdesmor (1290) and Berdemore (1296). These are reported place-name attestations, not evidence that Mary Ann descends from a named medieval person.",
          "caveat": "Her birth surname remains unverified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BEARDMORE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A Staffordshire place-name association is a useful research direction if Mary Ann’s birth family is established in that area. Her husband’s locality alone does not establish that continuity.",
          "caveat": "Her birth surname remains unverified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BEARDMORE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "person_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "surname": "Rhead",
      "locality": "Stone registration district, Staffordshire, England",
      "research_limit": "Sampson married Sarah Poyner at Stoke St Milborough in 1832; their son Richard’s 1833 baptism places them at Wood Farm. Richard Rhead’s circa-1813 will names a son Sampson and an interest in Wood Farm at Stoke Milbourn, Salop. This is a substantial parentage/identity lead, but the competing Sampson–Julia household needs reconciliation.",
      "notes": "The unusual combination of Sampson’s name, parish and farm favors a connection between Sarah’s husband and the son named in the will. They could instead be different relatives or successive tenants. Julia’s family is a documented competing household. The 1845 death index has not independently identified Sarah’s husband; the will, property succession and 1832 marriage details may resolve the two men.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Richard Rhead’s son Sampson and Wood Farm",
          "record_date": "circa 1813 (date from supplied file context)",
          "locality": "Hanchurch, Trentham, Staffordshire; Wood Farm, Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The supplied first-page will image, reinspected in September 2026, describes Richard Rhead of Hanchurch, farmer. It names wife Ruth and youngest son Sampson, and charges an annuity on Richard’s undivided one-third share of Wood Farm at Stoke Milbourn, Salop. The supplied page does not show execution or probate dates. Richard Rhead of Knutton, schoolmaster, is a friend/trustee, not explicitly a son.",
          "association": "The 1833 baptism places Sampson and Sarah’s child Richard at Wood Farm in the same parish. This combined property, parish and personal-name match is substantial positive evidence for continuity with the will family.",
          "alternatives": "The beneficiary could be Sarah’s husband, a different related Sampson, or someone whose property later passed to an unrelated Sampson tenant. The Sampson–Julia family is a documented competing cluster. An interest of one third does not establish three brothers, nor does it identify the other owners.",
          "assessment": "A family/property connection leads over an unrelated-name explanation, but identification of Sarah’s husband as the beneficiary remains unresolved. The complete will and farm succession could distinguish the hypotheses. No biological link is added by this contextual annotation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Rhead is classified as a Staffordshire form of Read, which the dictionary connects with Reed. That wider name group has several possible formations: a reddish appearance, residence near a clearing, or a place name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RHEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_READ",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The Rhead entry specifically associates the spelling with Staffordshire. The wider Read/Reed group also has English and Scottish formations.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RHEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_READ",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Read and Reed are useful spellings to check alongside Rhead. For the wider group, the dictionary identifies several possible places, including Read in Lancashire, Reed in Hertfordshire and Rede in Suffolk.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RHEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_READ",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821",
      "surname": "Schaaf",
      "locality": "Newark, New Jersey; Hesse-Darmstadt birthplace reported",
      "research_limit": "John Schaef, a tailor aged 48 in Newark’s Sixth Ward in 1870, closely matches John Schaaf, a widowed tailor aged 59 at 390 Eighth Street in 1880. Both were born in Hesse-Darmstadt. The supplied census excerpts identify neither his parents nor a German birth village, so his ancestry currently stops with this immigrant household.",
      "notes": "A German index names Johannes Schaaf and Anna Elisabetha Gunder as parents of Johannes Ludwig, while a New Jersey birth index names John Schaaf and a mother indexed as Gunter. These are concrete clues to a connected family, but the supplied index excerpts lack event dates needed to compare the children. The German father’s identity as the Newark tailor remains unresolved. A different Schaaf household is an alternative, not a documented contradiction; matching names alone cannot settle which household the indexes describe.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_1880_JOHN_SCHAAF_NEWARK"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Johannes (John) Schaaf: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Newark, New Jersey; Hesse-Darmstadt birthplace reported",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: John Schaef, a tailor aged 48 in Newark’s Sixth Ward in 1870, closely matches John Schaaf, a widowed tailor aged 59 at 390 Eighth Street in 1880. Both were born in Hesse-Darmstadt. The supplied census excerpts identify neither his parents nor a German birth village, so his ancestry currently stops with this immigrant household. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_1880_JOHN_SCHAAF_NEWARK"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "German Schaaf is a variant of Schaf, which the surname dictionary explains as an occupational name for a herdsman, derived from the word for sheep. This does not imply that this particular ancestor was a shepherd.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHAAF_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_SCHAF_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "John’s census birthplace supports a Hessian origin. The supplied German index is associated with Billertshausen, but that identifies the indexed record’s locality rather than proving where the Newark man was born. The independent Dutch surname explanation, from a carpenter’s plane, does not establish Dutch ancestry for him.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHAAF_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_SCHAF_DAFN",
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_1880_JOHN_SCHAAF_NEWARK"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "In Newark the family name occurs as Schaef in 1870 and Schaaf in 1880. The matching tailor’s occupation, approximate age and Hessian origin support continuity across these spellings. Earlier Schaaf millers at Ober-Gleen belong to a separate candidate branch in the tree; no record yet joins the tailor to that household.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_1880_JOHN_SCHAAF_NEWARK",
            "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_DECHER_ANNA_CATHARINA",
      "person_id": "C_DECHER_ANNA_CATHARINA",
      "surname": "Decher / Dächer",
      "locality": "Ober-Gleen, Upper Hesse; now part of Kirtorf",
      "research_limit": "Anna Catharina is named as the mother of Anna Elisabetha Gonder in the 1822 Ober-Gleen baptism index. A 1826 marriage index names Catharina Decher and Johann Caspar Gonter in the same parish. The supplied entries do not identify her parents.",
      "notes": "The matching partner, place and names favor one woman across these entries; the marriage four years after the birth is not by itself a contradiction. The original entries could clarify her age, parents and marital history. Ober-Gleen registers survive from 1685, including the relevant baptism and marriage volumes, but their images have not been inspected for this assessment.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826",
        "ROOTS26_OBERGLEEN_ARCHION"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Decher families from Rainrod in Hungarian parish records",
          "record_date": "1725 and 1731",
          "locality": "Rainrod, Alsfeld district, Hesse; Kalaznó and Varsád, Hungary",
          "historical_detail": "János Schmidt’s 1939 study identifies Johann Martin Decher, later spelled Dächert, as a Rainrod migrant living at Kalaznó and having a child baptized in 1725. It also identifies Johann Curt Decher as his brother and reports a 1731 baptismal reference, citing the Varsád registers.",
          "association": "These earlier name-bearers place Decher in Anna’s wider Upper Hessian region roughly a century before her recorded motherhood. The documented Decher/Dächert variation is also relevant when comparing spellings.",
          "alternatives": "The Rainrod emigrants could belong to a different family from Anna’s Ober-Gleen branch. A shared earlier family is possible without Anna descending from the men who emigrated.",
          "assessment": "Regional origin and surname support investigating wider kinship, but no named relative, property or parish event yet joins the two households. This is family-name context, not a proposed chain of parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DECHER_SCHMIDT1939"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "A possible explanation is the historical German word decher, a measure of ten hides, skins or sheets of parchment. The surname dictionary derives the related name Dechert from this trade vocabulary.",
          "caveat": "The dictionary entry is for Dechert; applying it to Anna’s Decher or Dächer remains a qualified interpretation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DECHERT_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_DECHER_FWB"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Anna’s documented family setting is Ober-Gleen. Earlier Decher families are recorded at Rainrod in the Alsfeld district before their move to Hungary. This supplies a regional setting for the name without establishing Anna’s birthplace or parents.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822",
            "ROOTS26_DECHER_SCHMIDT1939"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The related surname Dechert is associated with handling hides, furs or parchment. No occupation has been established for Anna or her birth family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DECHERT_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_GONDER_JOHANNES",
      "person_id": "C_GONDER_JOHANNES",
      "surname": "Gonder",
      "locality": "Obergleen, Hesse",
      "research_limit": "The indexed 1762 baptism names Johannes Gonder and Anna Elisabetha Engel as parents of an unnamed daughter. The matching birth date supports comparison with Barbara Katherina, but the father’s identity and parents are not settled.",
      "notes": "The baptism index names Johannes, supporting that father’s identification. The competing Dietrich reconstruction is a different recorded interpretation, not simply another spelling of Johannes. The child may also have been misidentified. The original entry, siblings and marriage remain necessary to distinguish the families.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_UNNAMED_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Johannes Gonder: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Obergleen, Hesse",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The indexed 1762 baptism names Johannes Gonder and Anna Elisabetha Engel as parents of an unnamed daughter. The matching birth date supports comparison with Barbara Katherina, but the father’s identity and parents are not settled. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_UNNAMED_BAPTISM_1762"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The dictionary tentatively treats Gonder as an altered Gander; a definite meaning for this branch is not established.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GONDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GANDER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "If that derivation applies, Gander itself has several origins: South German/Swiss scree-related place names and northern German or English goose-related names.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GONDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GANDER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "These alternatives are linguistic possibilities, not a migration history for Obergleen. No earlier local named ancestor was established in this search.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GONDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GANDER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_WENDEL_ANNA_INCOMPLETE",
      "person_id": "C_WENDEL_ANNA_INCOMPLETE",
      "surname": "Wendel",
      "locality": "Ober-Gleen, Upper Hesse; now part of Kirtorf",
      "research_limit": "Anna Catharina Wendel married Johann Dietrich Gunter on 31 March 1761 at Ober-Gleen. Their son Johann Balthasar’s January 1762 baptism names his mother as Anna … Wendel. The matching marriage supplies her full name, but the available index excerpts do not identify her parents or birthplace.",
      "notes": "Ober-Gleen’s surviving parish registers begin in 1685. The original 1761 marriage and earlier baptisms could identify Anna’s birth family; those entries have not yet been inspected. No earlier Wendel household has yet been connected to her, so her family history currently begins with this marriage rather than a proposed distant pedigree.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762",
        "ROOTS26_OBERGLEEN_ARCHION"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anna Catharina Wendel: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Ober-Gleen, Upper Hesse; now part of Kirtorf",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Anna Catharina Wendel married Johann Dietrich Gunter on 31 March 1761 at Ober-Gleen. Their son Johann Balthasar’s January 1762 baptism names his mother as Anna … Wendel. The matching marriage supplies her full name, but the available index excerpts do not identify her parents or birthplace. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761",
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762",
            "ROOTS26_OBERGLEEN_ARCHION"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Wendel can derive from a personal name, a diminutive of Wando, associated with a Germanic element meaning to go or migrate. The dictionary also gives a German occupational explanation: a turner.",
          "caveat": "The surviving evidence for Anna does not distinguish these surname origins.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WENDEL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The personal-name form occurs in German, Swedish, Danish and Dutch families. Anna’s known setting is the Lutheran parish of Ober-Gleen; neither her birthplace nor an earlier migration has been established.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WENDEL_DAFN",
            "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The occupational interpretation links the surname with turning work, but Anna’s records do not identify a family trade. Her specific documented association is with the Gunter/Gonder household formed at Ober-Gleen in 1761.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WENDEL_DAFN",
            "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761",
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_SCHAAF_ELIZABETH_ABT1823",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_ELIZABETH_ABT1823",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Newark, Essex County, New Jersey; reported birth in Hesse-Darmstadt",
      "research_limit": "Elizabeth, aged 47, appears in the supplied 1870 census transcript in John Schaef’s Newark household. Her birth surname and parents are not given. John was a tailor aged 48; Martin, Justin and Elizzie are also listed. Their household placement supports the family relationships shown in the tree, although the 1870 census did not ask each person’s relationship to the head.",
      "notes": "Anna Elisabetha Gonder, born in Ober-Gleen in 1822, is a plausible identity lead: a related German index names an Anna Elisabetha Gunder as Johannes Schaaf’s wife. The matching names, approximate age and Hessian setting support comparison with Elizabeth in Newark. The supplied family indexes lack event dates, so separate households or a later marriage remain possible. The probable same Newark tailor was recorded as a widower in 1880; this suggests Elizabeth died during the intervening decade if the household identification is correct, but no death record has yet been matched.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_1880_JOHN_SCHAAF_NEWARK",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822",
        "SRC_1870_CENSUS_RELATIONSHIP_LIMIT_20260915"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Elizabeth Schaef: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Newark, Essex County, New Jersey; reported birth in Hesse-Darmstadt",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Elizabeth, aged 47, appears in the supplied 1870 census transcript in John Schaef’s Newark household. Her birth surname and parents are not given. John was a tailor aged 48; Martin, Justin and Elizzie are also listed. Their household placement supports the family relationships shown in the tree, although the 1870 census did not ask each person’s relationship to the head. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_1880_JOHN_SCHAAF_NEWARK",
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822",
            "SRC_1870_CENSUS_RELATIONSHIP_LIMIT_20260915"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Schaef is the surname under which Elizabeth appears in the Newark household. Her birth surname is unresolved, so the meaning of Schaaf or Schaef cannot yet be assigned to her ancestral family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": []
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The census transcript reports Hesse-Darmstadt as her birthplace, without a town. Ober-Gleen belongs to the proposed Gonder identity and remains a candidate location for Elizabeth, rather than an established birthplace.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The dated family setting is Newark’s Sixth Ward in 1870. New Jersey’s state vital records begin in May 1848 and cover the reported New Jersey births of Justin, about 1854, and Elizzie, about 1858. Those birth entries, or a marriage or death record for Elizabeth, could identify her birth family.",
          "caveat": "No earlier surname-based family association can yet be attached securely to Elizabeth. The Gonder possibility is retained separately while her identity is tested.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NJ_ARCHIVES_VITAL_GUIDE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "person_id": "SRC_MALINDA_PHELPS_SPOUSE",
      "surname": "Scott",
      "locality": "Washington County, Virginia; North Fork district",
      "research_limit": "Malinda is identified through her household with Martin Phelps. Scott is supported by a local compilation’s abstract of daughter Margaret Counts’s 1921 death record. The records reviewed do not identify Malinda’s parents by name.",
      "notes": "A published account attributes a Scottish-born father and Tennessee-born mother to her 1880 census entry. That reading remains to be checked against the census image; it offers a geographical clue without identifying a particular Scott household.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_PHELPS_WASHINGTON_VA",
        "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Scott households in Washington County, 1782",
          "record_date": "1782",
          "locality": "Robert Campbell’s precinct, Washington County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The transcribed tax list names Thomas Scott with four horses and ten cattle, Samuel Scott with one horse and six cattle, and William Scott with four horses and fourteen cattle. Each entry has one tithe.",
          "association": "The surname was present in the region about forty years before Malinda’s reported birth. A relationship to one of these households is possible.",
          "alternatives": "The three taxpayers need not be related to one another or to Malinda. Her father could have arrived later or belonged to another part of the district.",
          "assessment": "These are documented earlier name-bearers, but the evidence does not distinguish any as Malinda’s father or grandfather. Their land, probate and later households must be compared with her family before selecting a parent candidate.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCOTT_WASHINGTON1782"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Her daughter’s record preserves the Scott name",
          "record_date": "4 January 1921",
          "locality": "Washington County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The local compilation abstracts Margaret Counts’s death record as naming Martin Phelps and Malinda Scott as her parents.",
          "association": "This identifies Scott within Malinda’s own family, rather than through a same-name household elsewhere.",
          "alternatives": "A death-record informant or a later transcription could have supplied an incorrect maiden name.",
          "assessment": "Scott remains the leading birth-surname identification. The certificate image would allow its wording and informant to be assessed; it would not automatically identify Malinda’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_PHELPS_WASHINGTON_VA"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Scott commonly began as a designation for someone from Scotland. The surname dictionary also records derivation from a rare medieval personal name and, in England, a variant of Scutt.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCOTT_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary records the surname in English, Scottish and Irish families, including County Down. These multiple origins do not locate Malinda’s family within Scotland or establish an Irish migration.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCOTT_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Several Scott taxpayers were recorded in Washington County before Malinda’s birth. Those households provide regional comparisons for her family, rather than a demonstrated connection to the prominent Scottish families of the name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCOTT_WASHINGTON1782"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "person_id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "surname": "Boulton",
      "locality": "Trentham and Hanford, Staffordshire; birthplace unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Thomas Boulton is identified through his household with Sarah Rhead and their marriage at Shelton St Mark on 19 December 1852. The supplied marriage summary does not include his father’s details, and the census excerpts do not give his birthplace. His parents therefore remain unidentified in the evidence currently available; this does not establish that the full marriage entry leaves the father blank.",
      "notes": "His recorded ages imply birth about 1826 in the 1851 census, about 1822 in 1861 and about 1827 in 1871. The continuing Sarah and Rhead/Boulton household supports one man despite that variation. Recovering his full marriage entry and census birthplace would allow a closer comparison with earlier Staffordshire Boulton families.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
        "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
        "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary Ann Boulton’s marriage at Trentham",
          "record_date": "5 August 1834; notice 13 August 1834",
          "locality": "Trentham; probably Hanford, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "Williams’s study transcribes a Derby Mercury notice naming Mary Ann, daughter of William Boulton, marrying Joseph Hargraves at Trentham. It prints the father’s locality as Hansford; the surrounding family account places the household at Hanford.",
          "association": "The surname and locality make this a plausible wider-family comparison with Thomas’s later Hanford household.",
          "alternatives": "William’s family could be related to Thomas, or they could be unrelated Boultons living nearby. Thomas’s birthplace and a shared relative are not yet known.",
          "assessment": "A specific local lead, not evidence that William was Thomas’s father. The original notice and Thomas’s full marriage record are needed before a particular relationship can be ranked.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BOULTON_HARGRAVES1834",
            "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Boulton is a spelling variant of Bolton, a surname derived from a place-name. Its Old English elements mean a dwelling or house and an enclosure or settlement.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BOULTON_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_BOLTON_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Several places could independently supply this name, including Boltons in northern England and Boulton in Derbyshire; the dictionary also lists East Lothian. Thomas’s known Staffordshire residence does not identify which place supplied his family’s surname.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BOLTON_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "An 1834 Trentham marriage notice identifies a William Boulton and his daughter Mary Ann in the Hanford area. This gives a nearby family to compare with Thomas once his own parentage and birthplace are recovered.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BOULTON_HARGRAVES1834"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_HENDERSON_FATHER_ROBERT_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Henderson",
      "locality": "Washington County and possible Giles County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "Robert Henderson’s proposed father is named John in a compiled tree. His identification with John R. Henderson of the 1843 Giles County probate index remains uncertain. The supplied index places the will on 14 May and probate on 10 May of that year; the original record has not been inspected to resolve that reversed chronology. No earlier parents have been identified.",
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1843_JOHN_R_HENDERSON_GILES_PROBATE",
        "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_GILES_COUNTY_MICROFILM",
        "ROOTS26_GILES_TITHE_CATALOG",
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "record_date": "1810, reported in July 1987 research notes",
          "locality": "Washington County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "association": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "alternatives": "The bond participant and census head could be the same man or separate local namesakes. Either could be the later Giles probate subject; the records reviewed do not yet distinguish those possibilities.",
          "assessment": "This is a specific earlier local association, supported by archived research notes rather than an inspected bond. It supplies a network of named associates for comparison but does not identify Robert as a child or establish an earlier Henderson generation.",
          "source_ids": []
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Henderson usually means Henry’s son, from English and Scots forms of Henry or its pet form Hen, with a d added in pronunciation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HENDERSON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name has English and Scottish origins. In Scotland it sometimes replaced McKendrick. This background does not establish a Scottish birthplace for the Virginia candidate: the proposed Alloa birth has been mixed with records of incompatible men.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HENDERSON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": []
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_PEYTON_R_TALLY_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_PEYTON_R_TALLY_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Tally / Talley",
      "locality": "Evan’s North Carolina and southwest Virginia family; Peyton’s own residence unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Peyton is a compiled-tree father candidate for Evan. No identifying dates, household sequence or parents have been established for this particular man. The name has not been securely matched to any of the documented Peyton Talley families.",
      "notes": "The Smith County, Tennessee man married Rachel Mullinax; omission of Evan and Holly from his compiled child list does not by itself exclude an earlier marriage. The Mecklenburg County, Virginia man named in the 1845 Yancey will had wife Jane and daughter Mary Ann. Neither household has an established connection to Evan. Virginia and North Carolina’s Mecklenburg counties must be distinguished.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PEYTON_TALLEY_TN_1797_DISAMBIGUATION_20260730",
        "ROOTS26_YANCEY_WILL_PEYTON1845"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "An earlier Peyton Talley estate in Mecklenburg County",
          "record_date": "13 October 1800",
          "locality": "Mecklenburg County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "A fiduciary transcription records Stephen P. Pool administering the estate of Peyton Talley, with Joseph Carter as security.",
          "association": "This establishes the given-name and surname combination in an earlier Virginia family.",
          "alternatives": "A wider-family connection is possible, but independent reuse of Peyton is also possible; Evan’s father has not been located in this county.",
          "assessment": "The deceased man cannot be Evan’s father, since Evan was born decades later. No intervening relationship has been identified, so this remains historical context.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MECKLENBURG_TALLEY1800"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Talley has several proposed origins: a variant of Tolley, a name from Tailly in northern France, or an Irish name meaning descendant of Taithleach, whose name means peaceable.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TALLEY_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary distinguishes English, Norman-derived and Irish forms, and a possible Americanized German name. Peyton’s branch has not been traced to one of these origins.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TALLEY_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The proposed Norman place-name form is not known with certainty to have survived into modern usage. Similar spelling therefore does not connect this family to a particular medieval lineage.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TALLEY_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "SRC_HOLLY_HOOD_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Hood (reported)",
      "locality": "North Carolina birthplace; Grayson and Washington counties, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "Holly’s parents and birth surname remain unresolved. Her 1850 Grayson household and 1860 residence with Evan support the reported mother relationship. Hood comes from a compiled tree and has not been verified as her birth name.",
      "notes": "Her placement with probable daughter Tabitha in 1850 and with Evan in 1860 makes maternity a stronger explanation than an unrelated dependent, although an aunt or another relative remains possible. A real Holly P. Hood married Woodley Talley in Amelia County; the earlier family details below make simple identification with Evan’s mother uncertain.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
        "SRC_HOCKETT_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_1860_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_GRAYSON",
        "ROOTS26_AMELIA_TALLEY_MARRIAGES"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Holly P. Hood and Woodley Talley’s 1815 marriage",
          "record_date": "28 September 1815",
          "locality": "Amelia County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The published marriage abstract names Woodley Talley and Holly P. Hood, with Laban Pitchford as surety and explicitly her son.",
          "association": "The distinctive Holly/Hood/Talley combination may explain the birth-name attribution in later pedigrees.",
          "alternatives": "This could be a different Holly. A son acting as surety in 1815 suggests an older woman than the ages recorded for Evan’s mother in 1850 and 1860, although the son’s age is not given.",
          "assessment": "The name cluster is a real lead, but the age tension and different husband prevent a secure identification. Hood may also have been an earlier married surname; the abstract does not settle that question.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_AMELIA_TALLEY_MARRIAGES",
            "SRC_HOCKETT_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_1860_HOUSEHOLDS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "If Hood is the correct birth surname, it may refer to a hood wearer or maker, or derive from personal names such as Hudde or a form of Hugh.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HOOD_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name occurs in English and Scottish traditions; other explanations include Hood in Devon, Irish Ó hUid, and Americanized French Houde. None is established for Holly.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HOOD_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "One Irish Hood family served as bards to the O’Neills of Clandeboy. This is a dictionary association of one name origin, with no demonstrated connection to Holly’s North Carolina family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HOOD_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "person_id": "SRC_ANNIE_MCNEW_SPOUSE_DAVID_1880",
      "surname": "Smith",
      "locality": "Washington County and Saltville, Virginia; parents reportedly born in North Carolina",
      "research_limit": "Ann’s maiden surname is reported as Smith in son Samuel’s 1918 death record, quoted by the local family compilation. Her parents and their North Carolina home have not been identified.",
      "notes": "Ann, Annie and Nancy appear as names for David McNew’s wife in the family records. The repeated household and daughter Ailsey support one woman across the census accounts. Samuel’s named-parent record makes Smith a better-supported identification than the separate Nancy Sevier profile. It is later informant evidence, so a mistake remains possible, but no equally specific record supports Sevier. The compilation reports Ann as Virginia-born and her parents as North Carolina-born. These are separate birthplace statements; they do not make Ann herself a North Carolina migrant. The available couple searches and local compilations have not identified her marriage or a parent-naming record for her.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ANN_SMITH_NAME",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SMITH_MCNEW_CHANCERY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Francis Smith and the McNew land dispute",
          "record_date": "1823 debt; 1841–1844 proceedings",
          "locality": "Washington County, Virginia, near Saltville",
          "historical_detail": "Hockett’s chancery notes describe Francis Smith’s claim against George McNew senior and others, referring to a debt settlement in 1823 and an 1835 transfer of land to George junior. Testimony identifies another son, David McNew, as a purchaser of part of the property.",
          "association": "This places a Smith in documented dealings with David’s family in the same county during Ann’s adult life. A wider family connection is possible.",
          "alternatives": "Creditor and debtor could have had no family relationship. Neither Ann nor a Smith parent of hers is identified in the published case notes.",
          "assessment": "Useful local context and a specific family-history lead, but no basis yet to identify Francis as Ann’s father or another relative.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SMITH_MCNEW_CHANCERY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Smith commonly describes a worker in metal, especially a blacksmith or farrier. Some English examples instead refer to a forge or residence beside one. This name history does not establish Ann’s father’s trade.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANN_SMITH_NAME"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname developed in England and Scotland and also arose through translations or adaptations of other names, including Gaelic names meaning son of the smith. Ann’s branch is documented in Virginia, with a reported North Carolina connection through her parents; no overseas origin is established.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANN_SMITH_NAME",
            "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Francis Smith appears in litigation involving George McNew’s family near Saltville. This is a specific local Smith–McNew association, but the recorded connection is debt and property rather than stated kinship.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_SMITH_MCNEW_CHANCERY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "person_id": "C_MACKNEW_MATTHEW_1518",
      "surname": "Mackneugh",
      "locality": "Unestablished; Scottish origin reported in the wider pedigree",
      "research_limit": "Matthew Mackneugh’s reported dates, 1518–1550, come from a compiled family tradition attributed to Judith McNew’s recollection in 2014. No contemporary record, residence, occupation or spouse has been identified for him. His parents are unknown, and the connections placing him before the documented Maryland family remain uncertain.",
      "notes": "The family tradition may preserve an otherwise untraced ancestor, or the early pedigree may combine or misdate different people. The available account supplies too little individual detail to distinguish those possibilities. Scotland’s surviving Old Parish Registers begin in 1553, after Matthew’s reported death; they cannot verify those dates. Wills and testaments survive from 1513, so the register limit does not mean that no contemporary evidence could exist.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_SCOTLAND_OPR_COVERAGE",
        "ROOTS26_SCOTLAND_TESTAMENT_GUIDE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Matthew Mackneugh: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Unestablished; Scottish origin reported in the wider pedigree",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Matthew Mackneugh’s reported dates, 1518–1550, come from a compiled family tradition attributed to Judith McNew’s recollection in 2014. No contemporary record, residence, occupation or spouse has been identified for him. His parents are unknown, and the connections placing him before the documented Maryland family remain uncertain. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCOTLAND_OPR_COVERAGE",
            "ROOTS26_SCOTLAND_TESTAMENT_GUIDE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The Dictionary of American Family Names describes McNew as probably an altered form of an unidentified Scottish or Irish surname. It supplies no secure literal meaning.",
          "caveat": "That entry concerns McNew; it does not establish how the reported Mackneugh spelling arose.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MCNEW_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Scottish origin is part of the reported pedigree, but no parish or property has been connected to this Matthew. Edinburgh, given for some later supposed generations, cannot yet be treated as his home.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The later family has a concrete Maryland setting: a Charles County court entry dated 10 January 1670 names Jeremiah, his wife Phillis and their son John Howard. This establishes a later household, not descent from Matthew.",
          "caveat": "No earlier local Mackneugh bearer can presently be associated with Matthew because his own locality and identity remain unestablished. The intervening links remain visible as candidates.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_CHARLES_COURT_281"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE",
      "surname": "Whiteside (reported)",
      "locality": "Reported Virginia connection; individual identity unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Ann Elizabeth Whiteside is a competing maternal candidate for Amelia Hargis. Compiled trees place her either as Amelia’s mother or in the preceding generation. Her reported parents, William Whiteside and Mary Sarah Calvert, have not been distinguished from other households by family or property evidence.",
      "notes": "The reported 1720 birth would make Ann about 45 when Amelia was born: possible, though the younger Elizabeth Freelove household offers a different generational explanation. The 1779 estate entry names an Ann Hargis, but does not establish the expanded name, birth surname or motherhood. The present evidence does not securely choose between direct maternity, a grandmother relationship and conflated pedigrees.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE_PROFILE_REVIEW",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "ROOTS26_HARGIS_ESTATE_TRANSCRIPTIONS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "William and Elizabeth Stockton Whiteside’s family",
          "record_date": "Eighteenth century",
          "locality": "Virginia and Tryon County, North Carolina",
          "historical_detail": "The SIUE history describes William Whiteside, about 1710–1777, and Elizabeth Stockton and lists a daughter Ann.",
          "association": "This is a specific regional Whiteside family with a matching daughter’s name.",
          "alternatives": "The daughter could be another Ann. The reported 1720 birth of the Hargis candidate is incompatible with a father born about 1710 unless a date is wrong.",
          "assessment": "The name is a research lead, but this household should remain distinct from the claimed William born in 1674 and Mary Sarah Calvert. No identifying link currently ranks it as Ann Hargis’s birth family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WHITESIDE_SIUE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "William and Mary Whiteside in Augusta court records",
          "record_date": "1755–1756",
          "locality": "Augusta County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "Published transcriptions place William Whiteside beside John Underwood in adjoining 1755 land surveys. Mary Whiteside sought separate maintenance from husband William in March 1756; the August hearing named several Underwood relations.",
          "association": "These records identify another Whiteside household in eighteenth-century Virginia.",
          "alternatives": "It might be part of Ann’s wider family or a separate surname lineage. The Underwood associations do not identify Mary as the proposed Mary Sarah Calvert.",
          "assessment": "The household supplies useful regional history and concrete people to compare. It does not establish Ann’s parents or justify merging every Virginia William Whiteside.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WHITESIDE_UNDERWOOD1756"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Whiteside can derive from a nickname combining white and side or flank, perhaps referring to white clothing. It can also come from a place-name meaning a white slope.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WHITESIDE_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Places named Whiteside occur in southwestern Scotland and Northumberland. The surname was also prominent in central Lancashire by the late sixteenth century, possibly reflecting another local origin.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WHITESIDE_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname is also common in Antrim and Down. These English, Scottish and Ulster associations do not determine which route, if any, Ann’s family followed to Virginia.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WHITESIDE_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE",
      "person_id": "C_HARGIS_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE",
      "surname": "Freelove (reported)",
      "locality": "Virginia; Fairfax appears in a compiled profile",
      "research_limit": "Elizabeth Freelove is a proposed mother of Amelia Hargis, born in 1765. Her name and connection come from compiled pedigrees. No inspected contemporary record identifies her parents or establishes where her birth family lived.",
      "notes": "The younger John Hargis and Elizabeth household offers a plausible generation for Amelia’s parents. A RootsMagic tree gives Elizabeth’s death as 1762, which would exclude that maternity if correct, but supplies no death record. Another compiled reconstruction gives a later death and has its own conflicting attachments. The date dispute remains unresolved; it cannot be settled by choosing the more convenient tree. Searches for earlier Virginia Freelove families have not yet produced an identifiable household connected with Elizabeth.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_1762",
        "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
        "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Elizabeth Freelove: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Virginia; Fairfax appears in a compiled profile",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Elizabeth Freelove is a proposed mother of Amelia Hargis, born in 1765. Her name and connection come from compiled pedigrees. No inspected contemporary record identifies her parents or establishes where her birth family lived. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_1762",
            "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
            "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Freelove is an English surname derived from the personal name Frelof. Its Old English predecessor combines elements meaning peace and survivor.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FREELOVE_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name preserves an English personal name rather than identifying a particular town. Elizabeth’s reported surname has not been traced to an English parish or a colonial immigrant.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FREELOVE_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Its historical meaning is unrelated to the modern expression free love. The dictionary’s explanation concerns the surname; it does not establish Elizabeth’s reported birth name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FREELOVE_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_HENDERSON_JOHN_ALLOA_1787_GILES_1843",
      "person_id": "C_HENDERSON_JOHN_ALLOA_1787_GILES_1843",
      "surname": "Henderson",
      "locality": "Chesterfield District, South Carolina; reported Alloa, Clackmannanshire, Scotland",
      "research_limit": "John’s parents are unidentified. His reported 27 May 1787 Alloa birth has not been verified in a Scottish register. The 1850 census transcript gives an approximately 1787 Scottish birth, compatible with that report but insufficient to identify a parish.",
      "notes": "The match in name, age and country supports the proposed Scottish identity; a different Scottish-born John remains possible. The man alive in 1850 cannot be the 1843 Giles County probate subject. The Chesterfield surname index points to 118B, 123 Band 124A, but the household images remain uninspected. Scottish registration was not compulsory, so an unsuccessful search alone would not disprove the reported birth.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTERFIELD1850_INDEX",
        "ROOTS26_NRS_OPR_COVERAGE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "record_date": "September 1767",
          "locality": "Clackmannan, near Alloa, Scotland",
          "historical_detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "association": "If the reported Alloa birthplace is correct, this establishes an earlier Henderson household in the neighboring locality, about 20 years before John’s reported birth.",
          "alternatives": "The keeper could belong to a different Henderson family. If the South Carolina John came from another Scottish parish, the geographical association would disappear.",
          "assessment": "A specific local-history connection worth preserving, conditional on the Alloa identification. No parentage or other kinship is assigned to the keeper.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CLACKMANNAN_HENDERSON1767"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Henderson usually means son of Henry, through English or Scots forms with an inserted d. Occasionally the name uses Hen, a shortened form of Henry.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HENDERSON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname developed in England and Scotland. John’s census birthplace favors a Scottish setting for this particular branch, while Alloa remains a reported locality.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HENDERSON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Henderson was sometimes used in Scotland in place of McKendrick. Neither that linguistic association nor the surname identifies John with a particular clan or earlier household.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HENDERSON"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_GEORGE_W_FATHER_DAVID",
      "surname": "Shortt / Short / Shorts",
      "locality": "Marion, Smyth County; probable later household at Speedwell, Wythe County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "George’s parents, birth county and age remain unidentified. His family is recognizable through the children living with George and Susan in 1870 and the parents named in David’s and Floyd’s later death records. The available evidence does not yet distinguish an earlier Short household as his family.",
      "notes": "The repeated children’s names favor identifying George and Obedience’s 1880 household with this family. Obedience, recorded as 19, was too young to be the older children’s mother. The change of wife does not establish when or whether Susan died; her reported 1897 death has not been verified.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "ROOTS26_FLOYD_SHORT_DEATH1934"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "David and William Short in the 1793 tax list",
          "record_date": "1793",
          "locality": "Wythe County, Virginia: section covering present-day Wythe and Smyth counties",
          "historical_detail": "The published transcription lists David Short and William Short in its first section. Each entry has one tithe; William’s also lists one horse.",
          "association": "Their presence in the same region several generations before George makes continuity with an older local Short family a plausible explanation.",
          "alternatives": "George could instead descend from another Short family that moved into the area later. These entries do not establish that David and William were related to each other.",
          "assessment": "This is specific earlier regional evidence, but no household, property or probate sequence yet connects either man to George. The transcription also warns of difficult handwriting, so the original entries remain important to check.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WYTHE_SHORT_TAX1793"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Shortt is a spelling variant of Short. One English origin is a nickname for someone of short stature; another refers to a detached piece of land.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SHORTT_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_SHORT_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary also records English place-name origins, Scottish and Irish Gaelic equivalents, and Short as an English translation of German Kurz. George’s Virginia records do not identify which origin applies to his family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SHORTT_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_SHORT_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Short, Shortt and Shorts occur in the records used to identify this household. These spelling changes need not signal different families, while the name’s several origins allow unrelated families to share it.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SHORTT_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_SHORT_DAFN",
            "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
            "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
            "ROOTS26_FLOYD_SHORT_DEATH1934"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_SHORT_SUSAN_JONES_MOTHER_DAVID",
      "surname": "Jones",
      "locality": "Marion, Smyth County, Virginia; birth county unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Susan’s birth family remains unidentified. David’s death record and Floyd’s death transcription both name Susan Jones as their mother, supporting the surname, but neither identifies her parents. Her reported birth about 1841 and death in Washington County on 7 March 1897 still lack verification from records of her own life.",
      "notes": "The Smyth County marriage-license transcriptions for 1832–1850 and 1853–1861 did not identify her marriage to George. These limited lists do not establish that the marriage was unrecorded or took place elsewhere. Her later residence in Smyth County also does not establish that she was born there.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
        "ROOTS26_FLOYD_SHORT_DEATH1934",
        "ROOTS26_SMYTH_MARRIAGES1832_1850",
        "ROOTS26_SMYTH_MARRIAGES1853_1861"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Jones taxpayers and marriage licenses before Susan’s reported birth",
          "record_date": "1838–1840",
          "locality": "Smyth County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The 1838 tax transcription names Elias, Nathaniel, Joseph G., David, Thomas, George W. and Lewis B. Jones. Marriage-license entries pair David Jones with Frances James in 1840, George W. Jones with Sarah Ann Pearson in 1838, and Nathaniel Jones with Martha Hutton in 1840.",
          "association": "These are identifiable local Jones households to compare with Susan’s early life, rather than a single undifferentiated Jones family.",
          "alternatives": "Susan may belong to one of these families, another local household, or a family arriving from elsewhere. The tax and license entries have not yet been matched person by person.",
          "assessment": "Residence in the county and compatible timing support investigating these families, but do not currently rank any one as Susan’s parents. Her own marriage or childhood census household would distinguish the possibilities.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SMYTH_JONES_TAX1838",
            "ROOTS26_SMYTH_MARRIAGES1832_1850"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Jones usually comes from the personal name Jon or John, with a possessive or later-added final s. An additional English explanation refers to someone living or working at John’s house.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JONES_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname is associated especially with Wales and southern central England. In parts of Wales it appeared before becoming a fixed hereditary surname, which spread widely there during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JONES_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Jones also became widespread in North America across families of different backgrounds. Susan’s surname alone does not establish Welsh ancestry or connect her to a particular British Jones family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JONES_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "person_id": "C_CLARKE_JAMES_FATHER_DAVID",
      "surname": "Clarke",
      "locality": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "research_limit": "James is named as David’s father in the recorded 1854 marriage evidence. The same-townland valuation and compatible 1882 death index help identify his household, but no reviewed record names his parents.",
      "notes": "James in the marriage record is probably the Aghnasedagh occupier: the precise townland and family context agree. No competing local James was found. The death index supports an approximate age and year, but not the compiled exact death day or birthplace. Earlier relatives have not been identified in parish, lease or valuation evidence.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, Ireland",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: James is named as David’s father in the recorded 1854 marriage evidence. The same-townland valuation and compatible 1882 death index help identify his household, but no reviewed record names his parents. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Clarke is a spelling of Clark, derived from a word for a cleric, clerk or literate record keeper.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CLARKE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CLARK"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "In Ireland it can represent the English surname or a translation of Ó Cléirigh; overseas translations provide further independent formations.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CLARKE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CLARK"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Neither the spelling nor a Presbyterian family marriage proves Scottish ancestry or an early clerical ancestor. This branch is anchored by its Monaghan townland and named household.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CLARKE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CLARK"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_MOTHER_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "person_id": "C_MARTIN_UNKNOWN_MOTHER_DAVID_CLARKE",
      "surname": "Martin",
      "locality": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan (son’s locality; mother’s birthplace unknown)",
      "research_limit": "Martin is a reported surname from the supplied family tree; this woman’s first name and identity remain unverified. The heading preserves that surname hypothesis rather than interpreting an unknown first name as an unknown surname.",
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Unknown Martin: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan (son’s locality; mother’s birthplace unknown)",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Martin is a reported surname from the supplied family tree; this woman’s first name and identity remain unverified. The heading preserves that surname hypothesis rather than interpreting an unknown first name as an unknown surname. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": []
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Often derived from the personal name Martinus, connected with the Roman name Mars.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MARTIN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The personal name spread widely in Europe. Irish Martin can represent Ó Mártain, or shortened Gilmartin or McMartin; English Martin may also be a variant of Marton.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MARTIN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Saint Martin of Tours helped popularize the personal name. These multiple formations mean no single clan, country of ultimate origin or distinguished family can be assigned to the Monaghan candidate from the surname alone.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MARTIN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARTHA_DAVIES_ABT1815_WIFE_WILLIAM",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Berriew and Churchstoke, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "research_limit": "Frederick’s baptism at Berriew on 23 March 1845 names Martha and William Davies as his parents. The 1851–1881 households continue Martha as William’s wife, but give her married surname. Her birth surname and parents remain unidentified.",
      "notes": "The family can be followed through Frederick, Eliza and William in 1851 and the larger Churchstoke household in 1861. No securely matching marriage was identified in this review. Powys Archives lists Berriew marriage registers covering 1813–1837 and 1837–1907, an index for the latter, and banns from 1834. These offer specific routes to identifying Martha’s birth family. Earlier Davies name-bearers cannot yet be treated as members of her birth lineage.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1845",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ROOTS_POWYS_BERRIEW_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Martha (surname unknown) Davies: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Berriew and Churchstoke, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Frederick’s baptism at Berriew on 23 March 1845 names Martha and William Davies as his parents. The 1851–1881 households continue Martha as William’s wife, but give her married surname. Her birth surname and parents remain unidentified. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1845",
            "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
            "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
            "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
            "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_POWYS_BERRIEW_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Martha (surname unknown) Davies without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Martha (surname unknown) Davies. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Martha (surname unknown) Davies without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ROBERT_DAVIES_FATHER_WILLIAM_1815",
      "surname": "Davies",
      "locality": "Trustewelin (Trwstywelin), Berriew parish, Montgomeryshire",
      "research_limit": "Robert is named as William’s father in the Berriew baptism of 29 January 1814. The repeated Trustewelin address and Robert’s carpentry or wheelwright work in later child baptisms strongly support continuity with William’s adult household. This is a well-supported family identification despite the common surname. The records reviewed do not name Robert’s parents or establish his birth date or birthplace.",
      "notes": "Robert Davies and Elizabeth Lamb married at Berriew on 17 July 1803. The matching couple names and parish favor their identification with the later Trustewelin parents, although the sparse marriage transcription gives no trade, residence or witnesses to confirm it. A second Robert and Elizabeth is a possible explanation, not a documented competing couple in the saved search. The eleven-year interval before William’s recorded baptism leaves room for earlier children. Two baptisms of sons named David in 1819 and 1821 may reflect an infant death and reuse of the name, but no death is established by the repeated name alone.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_DAVIES_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1803",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
        "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
        "SRC_FREEREG_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1823",
        "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
        "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John Davies, an earlier Berriew aleseller",
          "record_date": "1747",
          "locality": "Ffridd Pen-y-wern, Berriew, Montgomeryshire",
          "historical_detail": "Quarter-session records name John Davies of Ffridd Pen-y-wern in Berriew parish over alleged unlicensed ale sales. A writ dated 6 August 1747 summoned him for 8 October; the sheriff reported serving him. These entries do not establish a conviction.",
          "association": "This places a Davies household in the same parish decades before Robert’s family appears.",
          "alternatives": "John could be a wider relative or a member of another Davies family. His township differs from Robert’s recorded abode, and no shared relative or property is identified.",
          "assessment": "Useful earlier parish context, but insufficient to assign John as Robert’s father or grandfather. Records connecting the two households would be more decisive than the surname match.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_BERRIEW_JOHN_DAVIES_1747"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Davies is a Welsh and English patronymic, a form of Davis corresponding to Welsh ap Dafydd: son of David. The spelling may also reflect the familiar name Davy.",
          "caveat": "This name formation does not identify Robert’s father as David.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_DAVIES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname is especially numerous in south Wales, according to the surname dictionary. Robert’s own documented family lived at Trustewelin in Berriew parish, Montgomeryshire.",
          "caveat": "The wider distribution does not establish a migration from south Wales. Several families could independently acquire a surname derived from David.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_DAVIES",
            "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "This branch has a documented woodworking tradition. Robert appears as a carpenter in 1814 and a wheelwright in 1819 and 1821; William was later a carpenter.",
          "caveat": "The shared trade is useful evidence when combined with the recurring Trustewelin address.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
            "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
            "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
            "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "person_id": "SRC_MARY_ANN_BALL_MORRALL_ABT1824",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Wellington, Shropshire, in married life; birthplace unestablished",
      "research_limit": "Mary Ann appears as Richard Morrall’s wife in the Wellington census transcripts of 1861 and 1871. A Shifnal marriage-index page for January–March 1861 lists Richard Morrall and Mary Anne Ball alongside another possible couple. The matching wife’s name and timing favor this pairing, although the index page alone does not identify the couples. The supplied records do not name her parents or birthplace, or establish whether Ball was her birth surname. Her marriage entry, indexed as volume 6a, page 824, is the most direct next record for her father and marital status.",
      "notes": "The two census ages suggest a birth around 1823–1826. Wellington is her documented married residence, not yet her place of origin. The Ball history below concerns her probable surname at marriage; an earlier marriage is a possible explanation, not an established event.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "An earlier Ball household near Wellington",
          "record_date": "1669; 28 September–7 October 1738",
          "locality": "Great Bolas, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The Great Bolas register names William Ball as a churchwarden in 1669. In 1738 it records Jane and William, children of Allen and Jane Ball, baptised on 28 September; William was buried on 1 October and Jane on 7 October. The parish lies about seven miles north of Wellington.",
          "association": "These records place Ball households near Mary Ann’s later home, roughly eighty-five years before her estimated birth. They offer a possible earlier local family context if Ball proves to be her birth surname.",
          "alternatives": "Mary Ann may have come from a different Ball household, from outside the Wellington area, or acquired the surname through an earlier marriage. No documented relative currently connects her to Allen and Jane.",
          "assessment": "This is a regional lead, not identified ancestry. The two children’s recorded burials rule them out as later ancestors; any continuity would have to involve other family members. Mary Ann’s marriage entry and a census birthplace could establish whether this parish is relevant.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BALL_GREAT_BOLAS",
            "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
            "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
            "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Ball can derive from a nickname referring to a rounded physique or baldness, or from residence beside a rounded hill or knoll.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BALL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Another English formation comes from the Scandinavian personal name Balle. The dictionary also distinguishes German formations and an Americanized Dutch Bal; the spelling therefore has several possible origins.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BALL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The English explanations associate the name with appearance, landscape or a personal name. It does not identify one founding household or a single occupation.",
          "caveat": "Which explanation applies to Mary Ann’s recorded name cannot be selected without identifying her earlier family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BALL_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "surname": "Grindley",
      "locality": "Forton, Staffordshire, near Newport, Shropshire",
      "research_limit": "John’s 1777 marriage and son Thomas’s 1783 baptism establish the Forton household. His reported birth about 1753 and March 1834 death are still compiled claims; no matched record identifies his parents.",
      "notes": "John’s 1777 Forton marriage is recorded under Greenley, a recognized variant of Grindley. William Grindley’s 1811 marriage in the same parish suggests another local household, but their relationship is unknown. The tempting Wollerton John baptized in 1754 died that year and cannot be this bridegroom. Earlier Cheshire name-bearers are documented, but no family connection to John is established. Forton’s surviving tithe, settlement and probate records may identify earlier relatives.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
        "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_1753_1834",
        "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_GRINDLEY_HODNET_BAPTISM_BURIAL_1754",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
        "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_REVIEW",
        "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GRINDLEY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GREENLEY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_BARDSLEY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John Grindley: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Forton, Staffordshire, near Newport, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: John’s 1777 marriage and son Thomas’s 1783 baptism establish the Forton household. His reported birth about 1753 and March 1834 death are still compiled claims; no matched record identifies his parents. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
            "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_1753_1834",
            "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
            "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_GRINDLEY_HODNET_BAPTISM_BURIAL_1754",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
            "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_REVIEW",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GRINDLEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GREENLEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_BARDSLEY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The modern dictionary treats English Grindley as Greenley with an added d. Greenley is a place-derived name using Old English words for green and clearing.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
            "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_1753_1834",
            "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
            "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_GRINDLEY_HODNET_BAPTISM_BURIAL_1754",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
            "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_REVIEW",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GRINDLEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GREENLEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_BARDSLEY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Named possibilities include Grindley in Staffordshire and Little Gringley in Nottinghamshire. Older dictionaries also associate Grindley with the Cheshire township near Tushingham. Several origins are possible; none establishes John’s birthplace. A separate German-derived use in the modern dictionary is not evidence of German ancestry here.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
            "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_1753_1834",
            "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
            "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_GRINDLEY_HODNET_BAPTISM_BURIAL_1754",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
            "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_REVIEW",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GRINDLEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GREENLEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_BARDSLEY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1777 Forton Greenley marriage is this branch’s firm local anchor. Earlier Gryndleys quoted from Prestbury registers in 1569 and 1576 are distant Cheshire examples, not demonstrated ancestors. The 1811 William/Martha marriage gives a closer local household to reconstruct; no clan, arms or notable family is assigned.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
            "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
            "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_1753_1834",
            "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
            "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_GRINDLEY_HODNET_BAPTISM_BURIAL_1754",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
            "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_REVIEW",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GRINDLEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GREENLEY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_BARDSLEY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_JOHN_READ_FATHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "person_id": "SRC_JOHN_READ_FATHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "surname": "Read",
      "locality": "Stoke, Staffordshire (son’s baptism); Horton and Blackwood (regional surname records)",
      "research_limit": "John Read is named with Sarah as Richard’s father in the Stoke baptism transcript of 30 October 1753 supplied by Matthew. The saved entry does not identify John’s age, occupation, birthplace or parents. Staffordshire is the setting of the baptism, not a demonstrated place of birth. His own marriage and household have not yet been securely identified.",
      "notes": "John Read’s 1750 Wolverhampton marriage to Sarah Perry is a documented candidate. Saved Wolverhampton baptisms name a John as Ann’s father in April 1753 and Richard’s father in September 1755; later entries name John and Sarah together. A separate Wolverhampton household currently provides the better working explanation of that sequence, but the two early entries do not name a mother and baptism dates alone do not establish birth spacing. A delayed or repeated baptism, or another John among those entries, could change the comparison. Sarah Perry is therefore unassigned rather than conclusively excluded. The Horton wills below describe earlier regional families; they do not resolve the Stoke–Wolverhampton identification.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_READ_PERRY_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPT_1750",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1755",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOSEPH_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1759",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Roger Reede’s Blackwood will",
          "record_date": "13 October 1558; proved 19 January 1558/9",
          "locality": "Blackwood, parish of Horton, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The published will names Roger Reede of Blackwood, asks for burial in Horton churchyard and divides his remaining goods between his wife Margaret and six children: William, Thomas, Richard, Agnes, Margery and Margaret. Its debt list includes money due from sheep bargains. The transcription is credited to the Lichfield probate registry.",
          "association": "This is a documented earlier family of a matching surname in the wider district north-east of Stoke, about two centuries before Richard’s baptism.",
          "alternatives": "John’s Stoke family could descend from these Reedes or from another Read family. The gap allows several generations and possible movement into the district; neither a particular descent nor a separate origin is established.",
          "assessment": "Useful regional family history, but not an identified ancestral household for John. The surname and nearby locality support comparison; the will gives no evidence bridging its children to the Stoke parents of 1753.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_READE_BLACKWOOD_WILLS_1906"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Francis Reade of Horton and his son John",
          "record_date": "25 May 1695; proved 11 October 1695",
          "locality": "Horton, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The same study abstracts Francis Reade’s will and records his burial at Horton on 4 June 1695. It names his widow Anne and children including a son John. The author explicitly leaves Francis’s connection to the main Blackwood pedigree unresolved.",
          "association": "A named John in a nearby Reade household is a more focused lead than surname distribution alone. He might belong to an earlier generation of the Stoke family.",
          "alternatives": "Francis’s son John might be the later Stoke father, an older relative, or an unrelated name-bearer. His birth date and later household are not supplied in this abstract. Identifying him as the 1753 father would place his earlier will reference fifty-eight years before the Stoke baptism; his age and whether that baptism followed soon after birth would matter.",
          "assessment": "A lead for tracing the Horton son forward, without choosing a parent for the Stoke man. A later marriage, probate record or residence linking him to Sarah and Richard would distinguish these possibilities.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_READE_BLACKWOOD_WILLS_1906"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Read is an English and Scottish variant of Reed. One explanation is a nickname for someone with red hair or a ruddy complexion; another refers to living near a clearing.",
          "caveat": "These are alternative name formations, not descriptions of John’s appearance or home.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_READ",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary also identifies place-name origins at Read in Lancashire, Reed in Hertfordshire and Rede in Suffolk.",
          "caveat": "John’s known connection is his son’s Stoke baptism; no migration from one of those places has been established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Read, Reade and Reede occur in the published records of families around Horton and Blackwood in northern Staffordshire. Roger Reede’s 1558 will records a wife and six children there.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_READE_BLACKWOOD_WILLS_1906"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_SARAH_READ_MOTHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "person_id": "SRC_SARAH_READ_MOTHER_RICHARD_1753",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Stoke, Staffordshire (son’s baptism)",
      "research_limit": "Sarah is named with John Read as the mother of Richard, baptized at Stoke on 30 October 1753, in the parish transcript supplied by Matthew. That establishes her maternal role but supplies no maiden surname, birthplace or parents. Read is her family’s recorded surname here, not a demonstrated birth surname; a history of the Read or Perry surname cannot yet be assigned to her own ancestry.",
      "notes": "A real marriage candidate exists: John Read married Sarah Perry at Wolverhampton on 15 July 1750. The names and timing fit, but the saved Wolverhampton transcripts also record Ann, daughter of John Read, baptized on 23 April 1753, and Richard, son of John Read, on 29 September 1755. Joseph’s 1759 and William’s 1762 baptisms explicitly name John and Sarah. These entries provide evidence for a Wolverhampton household to compare with the Stoke family, rather than merely an imagined namesake. They do not all establish the same mother: the two earlier entries name only John. Nor does the six-month interval between Ann’s and the Stoke Richard’s baptisms prove an impossible birth interval, because the children’s birth dates are not supplied. Separate Stoke and Wolverhampton households remain the leading working interpretation of this sequence, but Sarah Perry is not conclusively excluded. Delayed baptism, a repeated baptism or a different John within the Wolverhampton entries could change the comparison. The full entries, children’s ages and any burial for a Wolverhampton Richard would help distinguish those explanations. Until that household comparison is resolved, Sarah’s earlier family and surname history remain unidentified.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_READ_PERRY_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPT_1750",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1753",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1755",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOSEPH_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1759",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1762"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Sarah Read: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Stoke, Staffordshire (son’s baptism)",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Sarah is named with John Read as the mother of Richard, baptized at Stoke on 30 October 1753, in the parish transcript supplied by Matthew. That establishes her maternal role but supplies no maiden surname, birthplace or parents. Read is her family’s recorded surname here, not a demonstrated birth surname; a history of the Read or Perry surname cannot yet be assigned to her own ancestry. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
            "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_READ_PERRY_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPT_1750",
            "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1753",
            "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1755",
            "SRC_FREEREG_JOSEPH_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1759",
            "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1762"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Sarah Read without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Sarah Read. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Sarah Read without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_SAMUEL_MORRALL_FATHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "person_id": "SRC_SAMUEL_MORRALL_FATHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "surname": "Morrall",
      "locality": "Lawley and Wellington, Shropshire — leading household identification",
      "research_limit": "Richard’s 1837 marriage names his father as Samuel Morrall. The leading household match is Samuel, a Lawley collier, and Ann: a community transcription records their sons Richard and Adam baptised at Wellington on 3 October 1813. Samuel’s own parents have not been identified.",
      "notes": "This family fits Richard’s reported Horsehay/Wellington birthplace better than the recorded Bloxwich and Newcastle-under-Lyme baptism candidates. Samuel’s 1851 age of 66, as transcribed, suggests birth about 1785; his reported 1853 burial suggests about 1786. The family account also records his 1806 marriage to Ann Green. Original entries and later records connecting the 1813 child to the adult Richard would strengthen the identification.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_ROOTSCHAT_SAMUEL_ANN_MORRALL_LAWLEY_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
        "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_MORRALL_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1810_1811"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anne Morrall’s marriage at Buildwas",
          "record_date": "17 September 1778",
          "locality": "Buildwas, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The published Buildwas parish transcription records Thomas Fletcher marrying Anne Morrall in 1778.",
          "association": "This places a Morrall in the neighbouring Shropshire area before Samuel’s estimated birth and 28 years before his reported marriage.",
          "alternatives": "Anne could belong to another Morrall family. No shared relatives, residence or property yet connect her to Samuel. She is not identified as his later wife Ann Green.",
          "assessment": "An earlier regional family-history lead, with kinship unresolved. Her marriage and any associated baptism or probate records could help trace the local family without assuming a parental link.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_BUILDWAS_ANNE_MORRALL_1778"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Morrall is explained as a surname taken from a place name. One proposed origin is the lost Morghull between Lichfield and Streethay, perhaps referring to land given to a bride as a morning gift and a nook of land.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MORRALL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary associates Morrall especially with Staffordshire and Warwickshire, but also lists other possible places, including Moor Hall at Gnosall in Staffordshire. The precise place that gave this Shropshire family its name is unresolved.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MORRALL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Some proposed place names combine moor with a nook of land or a hall. The dictionary also notes possible confusion with Morrell. In Samuel’s family account, Morrall and Morrell occur alongside reported index readings Worrall and Mansell, making household details useful for tracing the records.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MORRALL",
            "SRC_ROOTSCHAT_SAMUEL_ANN_MORRALL_LAWLEY_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_HENRY_CORNISH_FATHER_ELIZABETH",
      "person_id": "SRC_HENRY_CORNISH_FATHER_ELIZABETH",
      "surname": "Cornish",
      "locality": "Bradford-on-Avon and Hilperton, Wiltshire — daughter’s reported origins; Henry’s residence unknown",
      "research_limit": "Elizabeth Cornish named her father as Henry when she married William Peters Hanny on 31 March 1838. The supplied excerpt does not give Henry’s occupation, residence or wife. Elizabeth’s 1851 census suggests birth about 1805 at Bradford, while a supplied family profile gives about 1802 at Hilperton. Her baptism has not yet identified the parental household.",
      "notes": "A family-history discussion places the 1838 wedding at Limpley Stoke, giving a specific register to check against the supplied transcript. The Trudoxhill will below identifies another Henry Cornish through his father and siblings. He is a useful regional candidate, but no record yet connects him to Elizabeth. Henry’s parents therefore remain unresolved.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
        "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
        "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_1802_1856",
        "SRC_ROOTS_HANNY_CORNISH_LIMPLEY_MARRIAGE_LEAD",
        "SRC_ROOTS_BENJAMIN_CORNISH_WILL_1836"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Henry Cornish named in his uncle’s will",
          "record_date": "9 February 1836; proved 4 March 1841",
          "locality": "Trudoxhill, Nunney parish, Somerset",
          "historical_detail": "Benjamin Cornish, a yeoman of Trudoxhill, named nephews Henry, William and Joseph as sons of his brother William. His will also identifies further members of that household.",
          "association": "This record gives a Henry Cornish in the wider Frome–west Wiltshire region near the date of Elizabeth’s marriage, with named relatives against whom other records can be compared.",
          "alternatives": "He could be Elizabeth’s father, a relative, or a separate namesake. The abstract does not name Elizabeth Hanny or give Henry’s age or residence. The Somerset family’s location is relevant regionally but is not the same parish as Elizabeth’s reported birthplace.",
          "assessment": "A specific identification lead, not an established parental link. Comparing the nephew’s baptism, household and occupation with Elizabeth’s baptism and full marriage entry could resolve the connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_BENJAMIN_CORNISH_WILL_1836"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Cornish originally described someone associated with Cornwall. The surname dictionary gives Middle English Cornish and Cornysh, with the Normanized form Corneys.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CORNISH"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name occurs strongly in neighbouring Devon and also farther away, including Suffolk and London. Its meaning is not evidence that Henry himself was born in Cornwall; the family records currently point to his daughter’s Wiltshire setting.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CORNISH"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Cornish is a regional-origin surname, rather than the name of one occupation or household. Several families could acquire it independently, so the named relatives in the Trudoxhill probate are more useful for identifying Henry than the surname’s broad geographical meaning.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CORNISH",
            "SRC_ROOTS_BENJAMIN_CORNISH_WILL_1836"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "person_id": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "surname": "Waterhouse",
      "locality": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire; Kingsley, Staffordshire, is a possible birth-family location",
      "research_limit": "James married Hannah Needham at Ashbourne on 26 November 1799. His burial there on 19 October 1840, aged 75, suggests birth about 1765. Two Kingsley baptisms are candidates: James, son of James and Ann, on 31 May 1767; and James, son of William and Mary, on 18 October 1769. Neither has yet been connected to his adult household.",
      "notes": "The matching name and regional setting support considering both candidates. Burial age is approximate, and baptism need not immediately follow birth, so the dates alone do not settle the choice. His marriage witnesses, occupation or settlement records could distinguish them. No parents have been assigned from either baptism.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
        "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_DEATH_BURIAL_1840",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WATERHOUSE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_KINGSLEY_1767_1769"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "An Ashbourne marriage indexed as Gravener or Waterhouse",
          "record_date": "10 June 1582",
          "locality": "St Oswald, Ashbourne, Derbyshire",
          "historical_detail": "A compiled marriage index lists Johannes Gravener or Waterhouse marrying Alicia Sherwyn. The original wording has not been checked. The local genealogical society describes the parish entries before 1604 as later copies.",
          "association": "The same parish and possible surname provide an earlier local-family lead, 217 years before James’s marriage.",
          "alternatives": "The alternative surname may reflect an alias or an uncertain identification. Even if Waterhouse is correct, James could belong to a different family or have moved into Ashbourne.",
          "assessment": "Possible wider-family continuity, with no documented chain between the two marriages. Establishing the 1582 surname reading and James’s own birthplace would materially improve the comparison.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_1582_INDEX",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DARG_ASHBOURNE_REGISTER_HISTORY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Waterhouse means a house beside water, from Middle English water and hous. It originally described where someone lived.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WATERHOUSE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary places the English surname particularly in Yorkshire, Lancashire and the Midlands. James’s Ashbourne family falls within that broad distribution, but it does not identify his birthplace or a founding Waterhouse household.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WATERHOUSE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "This is a name associated with a waterside dwelling. It does not by itself indicate that James or his ancestors were millers, boatmen or water-supply workers.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WATERHOUSE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "person_id": "C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "surname": "Mellor",
      "locality": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "research_limit": "Hannah married Edward Needham at Ashbourne on 11 December 1758. The saved licence abstract describes her as single, aged 21 and resident there. Her own baptism and parents have not been securely identified; residence at marriage does not establish an Ashbourne birthplace.",
      "notes": "Hanah, daughter of Thomas and Mary Mellor, baptized at Bradbourne in 1732, remains a possible identity. A Hannah Mellor married William Mattley at Bakewell in 1754, but neither bride has been securely connected to that child. The original licence wording also needs checking before its recorded age is treated as an exact birth-year calculation.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
        "SRC_FREEREG_HANAH_MELLOR_BRADBOURNE_BAPTISM_1732",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DARG_ASHBOURNE_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Edward Mellor of Yeldersley, buried at Ashbourne",
          "record_date": "8 May 1567, as reported",
          "locality": "Yeldersley and Ashbourne, Derbyshire",
          "historical_detail": "Wilcocksons Unwrapped reports Edward Mellor’s burial at Ashbourne and identifies his residence as Yeldersley. The cited event is a specific parish-record lead, awaiting inspection of the original entry.",
          "association": "The surname and parish agree with Hannah’s later marriage setting, making continuity within local Mellor families plausible across the roughly 191-year interval.",
          "alternatives": "Hannah’s family may have arrived later or descended from a different Mellor place-name origin. No intervening relatives connect her to Edward.",
          "assessment": "Earlier local family history, not a demonstrated ancestor. Ashbourne register transcripts and the relevant probate records may help establish whether the families connect.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILCOCKSON_YELDERSLEY_MELLOR",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DARG_ASHBOURNE_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Mellor is a place-derived surname. Its place-name elements come from ancient British words ancestral to Welsh moel, bare, and bre, hill.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MELLOR"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Several places in Lancashire, West Yorkshire and Derbyshire supplied the surname. Hannah’s family has not been traced to a particular one; her documented Ashbourne residence is the starting point for this branch.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MELLOR",
            "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Local family-history research places Mellors in Yeldersley and Idridgehay during the sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries. These named households provide Derbyshire leads, but their relationship to Hannah remains unestablished.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WILCOCKSON_YELDERSLEY_MELLOR"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_MARY_POYNER_MOTHER_SARAH_1811",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_POYNER_MOTHER_SARAH_1811",
      "surname": "Poyner",
      "locality": "Stoke St Milborough, Shropshire",
      "research_limit": "Sarah’s 5 May 1811 baptism names Mary Poyner alone as mother. It supplies neither Mary’s parents nor evidence that Poyner was her birth surname. George Odnett’s later identification as Sarah’s father does not establish a marriage to Mary.",
      "notes": "Mary may have been born a Poyner, or may have acquired the surname through an earlier marriage. Sarah’s baptism does not distinguish those possibilities. The Clee St Margaret and Abdon records document nearby Poyner families, but none has been linked to Mary’s birth family.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ABDON_POYNER_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Richard Poyner and Joan Richards in the neighbouring parish records",
          "record_date": "7 February 1706/7; 8 December 1710",
          "locality": "Abdon and Clee St Margaret, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The Abdon transcript records Richard Poyner of Clee St Margaret marrying Joan Richards of Abdon under the 1706 heading, on 7 February (1707 modern year). It records their son Richard’s burial on 8 December 1710.",
          "association": "This supplies an earlier Poyner household in the neighbouring parish area, about a century before Mary appears at Stoke St Milborough.",
          "alternatives": "Mary could belong to this wider family, another Poyner lineage, or have acquired the name through marriage. Regional continuity alone cannot distinguish those explanations.",
          "assessment": "Plausible regional surname association, not a demonstrated descent. Trace the couple’s surviving children, property and later Poyner households before connecting Mary.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ABDON_POYNER_REGISTERS",
            "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The dictionary interprets Poyner as a nickname for a fighter, from Anglo-Norman French wording for fighting.",
          "caveat": "Mary’s birth surname remains uncertain.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_POYNER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name is particularly associated with England’s West Midlands and a Norman linguistic origin. This does not prove descent from a Norman immigrant or a particular medieval family.",
          "caveat": "Mary’s birth surname remains uncertain.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_POYNER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The martial meaning is a surname-formation explanation, not evidence that this ancestor was a soldier or noble. Earlier local households require their own identity assessment.",
          "caveat": "Mary’s birth surname remains uncertain.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_POYNER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_CONRAD_GONDER_FATHER_DIETRICH_1724",
      "person_id": "C_CONRAD_GONDER_FATHER_DIETRICH_1724",
      "surname": "Gonder",
      "locality": "Obergleen, Hesse",
      "research_limit": "The existing baptism index gives Conrad as father of a male Gonder born 18 July and baptized 20 July 1724. The child’s identification as Johann Dietrich is a reconstruction; Conrad’s parents are unknown.",
      "notes": "The indexed boy’s date and locality fit the later Johann Dietrich, but another Gonder child could also fit. No later record confirms the identity. The separate 1762 baptism index names Johannes as father, not Dietrich, so it does not resolve the next generation.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GONDER_BAPTISM_1724"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Conrad Gonder: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Obergleen, Hesse",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The existing baptism index gives Conrad as father of a male Gonder born 18 July and baptized 20 July 1724. The child’s identification as Johann Dietrich is a reconstruction; Conrad’s parents are unknown. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GONDER_BAPTISM_1724"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The dictionary tentatively treats Gonder as an altered Gander; a definite meaning for this branch is not established.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GONDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GANDER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "If that derivation applies, Gander itself has several origins: South German/Swiss scree-related place names and northern German or English goose-related names.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GONDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GANDER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "These alternatives are linguistic possibilities, not a migration history for Obergleen. No earlier local named ancestor was established in this search.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GONDER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GANDER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "person_id": "C_DAVID_BOYD_FATHER_ELIZA_1854",
      "surname": "Boyd",
      "locality": "Coolmain, Monaghan parish, County Monaghan: daughter’s residence in 1854",
      "research_limit": "Eliza’s marriage names father David Boyd, farmer, and gives her Coolmain address; it does not name David’s parents or wife, or give his address. His estimated birth and death dates remain compiled. Local Boyd households offer testable wider-family leads.",
      "notes": "The Coolmain surname and locality make a connection to its Boyd families plausible. However, Eliza may have lived there independently of her father David. The valuation names Samuel and Sarah, and an 1895 probate entry links a Samuel to his son Samuel; neither connects them to David. The Thomas-and-Samuel bailiffs remembered at Killymarley are another unassigned household. David’s proposed sister Margaret also lacks a reviewed identifying record.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_DAVID_BOYD_PROFILE_1800_1810_1890",
        "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
        "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
        "SRC_GRIFFITHS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_SAMUEL_SARAH",
        "SRC_COOLMAIN_LANDED_ESTATES_LOCALITY",
        "SRC_MONAGHAN_1930_1935_BOYD_COOLMAIN_LATER_CLUSTER",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BOYD",
        "SRC_ROOTS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_ADMIN",
        "SRC_ROOTS_BOYD_BAILIFF_FOLKLORE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Samuel Boyd and his son at Coolmain",
          "record_date": "Death 5 November 1895; administration 7 July, calendar year not verified",
          "locality": "Coolmain, County Monaghan",
          "historical_detail": "The official calendar’s indexed text records administration of farmer Samuel Boyd’s estate to his son Samuel, also a farmer at Coolmain, with effects of £138.",
          "association": "The exact townland and surname make this a concrete candidate wider-family cluster for David Boyd. This is later local continuity, not an earlier ancestor claim.",
          "alternatives": "The Samuels could be a separate Boyd household; Eliza’s residence does not prove David occupied their holding. The Killymarley bailiffs could be another Samuel family.",
          "assessment": "The shared locality makes a wider family association plausible, but David’s relationship to these Samuels is unknown. The probate grant and land records may identify their relatives.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_ADMIN",
            "SRC_GRIFFITHS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_SAMUEL_SARAH"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Boyd has several proposed origins: a name associated with Bute, a Gaelic personal name, or an epithet for yellow hair; a Manx patronymic form is also recorded. No single derivation is established for David’s branch.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_DAVID_BOYD_PROFILE_1800_1810_1890",
            "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_GRIFFITHS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_SAMUEL_SARAH",
            "SRC_COOLMAIN_LANDED_ESTATES_LOCALITY",
            "SRC_MONAGHAN_1930_1935_BOYD_COOLMAIN_LATER_CLUSTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BOYD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_ADMIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_BOYD_BAILIFF_FOLKLORE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname has Scottish, Irish and Manx explanations. Eliza’s Coolmain residence establishes local family context, not David’s birthplace, a specific Scottish estate, or descent from a titled Boyd family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_DAVID_BOYD_PROFILE_1800_1810_1890",
            "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_GRIFFITHS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_SAMUEL_SARAH",
            "SRC_COOLMAIN_LANDED_ESTATES_LOCALITY",
            "SRC_MONAGHAN_1930_1935_BOYD_COOLMAIN_LATER_CLUSTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BOYD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_ADMIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_BOYD_BAILIFF_FOLKLORE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Samuel and Sarah Boyd appear as Coolmain occupiers in the valuation. The probate calendar identifies a later Samuel-to-Samuel succession there, while local oral history remembers Thomas and Samuel Boyd as bailiffs nearby. These specific records make local continuity worth testing, but do not establish David’s kinship.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_DAVID_BOYD_PROFILE_1800_1810_1890",
            "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
            "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
            "SRC_GRIFFITHS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_SAMUEL_SARAH",
            "SRC_COOLMAIN_LANDED_ESTATES_LOCALITY",
            "SRC_MONAGHAN_1930_1935_BOYD_COOLMAIN_LATER_CLUSTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BOYD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_ADMIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_BOYD_BAILIFF_FOLKLORE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_THOMAS_TOMPSON_FATHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "person_id": "C_THOMAS_TOMPSON_FATHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "surname": "Tompson",
      "locality": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire",
      "research_limit": "Thomas Tompson and Mary are named as Esther’s parents in the supplied transcript of her baptism at St Peter, Wolverhampton, on 14 February 1808. Their ages, address and Thomas’s occupation are not supplied. His own baptism and parents remain unidentified.",
      "notes": "An earlier Wolverhampton marriage names Thomas Tompson and Mary Hinton in 1747. The shared names and parish make that household relevant to the family’s possible local roots, but the sixty-year interval does not fit an ordinary identification with the parents of a child born around 1808. Esther’s age of 43 in the 1851 census also supports birth near her baptism rather than an adult baptism many decades after birth.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_ROOTS_TOMPSON_HINTON_WOLVERHAMPTON_1747",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "An earlier Tompson household in Wolverhampton",
          "record_date": "29 December 1747",
          "locality": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The published parish register records the marriage of Thomas Tompson and Mary Hinton.",
          "association": "The same surname, parish and paired given names provide a specific possible connection to an earlier local generation.",
          "alternatives": "The earlier groom might belong to the same wider family, or to a separate Tompson family in the parish. Naming patterns alone do not distinguish these explanations.",
          "assessment": "Useful evidence of the surname in Wolverhampton before Esther’s family, with a possible wider-family connection. No intervening generation has been identified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_TOMPSON_HINTON_WOLVERHAMPTON_1747"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Tompson is a spelling of Thompson, a patronymic meaning son of Tom. Tom was a familiar form of Thomas.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_TOMPSON",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_THOMPSON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary identifies Tompson as English. Thompson is the usual English form with an inserted p; Thomson is more usual in Scotland. These spelling tendencies do not establish where this Thomas was born.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_TOMPSON",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_THOMPSON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name arose from a father’s personal name and could therefore develop in separate households. Here it occurs as Tompson in Esther’s baptism and Thompson in her later family records, making both spellings relevant to this branch.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_TOMPSON",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_THOMPSON",
            "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
            "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_MARY_TOMPSON_MOTHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_TOMPSON_MOTHER_ESTHER_1808",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire",
      "research_limit": "Mary is named with Thomas Tompson in the supplied transcript of Esther’s baptism at St Peter, Wolverhampton, on 14 February 1808. It does not give her birth surname, age or parents. Tompson is the household name used in her profile, not an established birth surname.",
      "notes": "The Wolverhampton marriage of Thomas Tompson and Mary Hinton on 29 December 1747 is too early to be a persuasive identification of Esther’s parents: Esther’s 1851 census age of 43 places her birth around 1808. That earlier Mary may belong to a preceding generation, but Hinton cannot currently be assigned to Esther’s mother. A later marriage identified through witnesses, residence or other children would be the strongest route to resolving her birth family.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
        "SRC_ROOTS_TOMPSON_HINTON_WOLVERHAMPTON_1747",
        "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary Tompson: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Wolverhampton, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Mary is named with Thomas Tompson in the supplied transcript of Esther’s baptism at St Peter, Wolverhampton, on 14 February 1808. It does not give her birth surname, age or parents. Tompson is the household name used in her profile, not an established birth surname. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_TOMPSON_HINTON_WOLVERHAMPTON_1747",
            "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Mary Tompson without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Mary Tompson. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Mary Tompson without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "person_id": "C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "surname": "Vines",
      "locality": "Lincoln County, North Carolina; later Russell County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "The supplied Lincoln County bond record names Susannah Vines with Samuel Felps on 13 February 1782, with George Winfree as bondsman and James McEwin as witness. It establishes her marriage name but supplies no parents. Her reported birth in Rowan County about 1767 remains a compiled claim; it would make her about fifteen when the bond was issued.",
      "notes": "The published Phelps family account places the same marriage in Rowan County, conflicting with the supplied bond’s Lincoln County attribution. Lincoln is the stronger starting point for tracing her birth family. Samuel Phelps senior’s 1846 Russell County will names a wife Susan, but does not give her maiden name or parents. Identifying her with the 1782 bride is supported by the compiled family history and the later Samuel-and-Susannah deed-index entry; the intervening record chain still needs checking. Two Samuel Felps/Philps households in the supplied 1810 census evidence complicate any migration reconstruction. No specific Vines parent can yet be ranked from these records.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
        "SRC_SUSANNAH_VINES_COMPILED_VITALS_CHILDREN",
        "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
        "SRC_CHAIN_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_DEED_INDEX_20260915",
        "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_1810_NAMESAKE_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Susannah Vines: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Lincoln County, North Carolina; later Russell County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The supplied Lincoln County bond record names Susannah Vines with Samuel Felps on 13 February 1782, with George Winfree as bondsman and James McEwin as witness. It establishes her marriage name but supplies no parents. Her reported birth in Rowan County about 1767 remains a compiled claim; it would make her about fifteen when the bond was issued. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
            "SRC_SUSANNAH_VINES_COMPILED_VITALS_CHILDREN",
            "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
            "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
            "SRC_CHAIN_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_DEED_INDEX_20260915",
            "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_1810_NAMESAKE_CONFLICT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Vines is a form of Vine with an added s. Vine derives from the Old French word for a vine and described someone living or working at a vineyard; occasionally it referred to a house or inn bearing a vine sign.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_VINES_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_VINE_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The English name has Norman linguistic roots and could arise at several vineyard-related places in southern England. Separate names written Viñes have Asturian-Leonese or Catalan origins. Susannah’s North Carolina records do not establish which overseas family supplied her surname.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_VINES_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_VINE_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "John Vogt’s Lincoln County brides index lists Agness Vines and Susannah Vines, both referring to page 41. The underlying entries could reveal another local Vines marriage and useful associates, but their dates and husbands have not yet been recovered. A family connection and unrelated local households remain alternatives; sharing an index page does not distinguish them.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_VINES_LINCOLN_INDEX",
            "ROOTS26_VOGT_LINCOLN_CATALOG"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD_1684",
      "person_id": "C_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD_1684",
      "surname": "Brassington",
      "locality": "Alstonfield, Staffordshire, England",
      "research_limit": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "notes": "The George baptized at Leek in February 1672 would have been about twelve at the wedding if baptized in infancy, strongly favoring a different, older bridegroom. The excerpt does not state a birth date, so a late baptism cannot be categorically excluded. The Caverswall baptism of a George, son of Thomas, in January 1639 provides an age-compatible identity lead; it does not yet distinguish him from other adult Georges. Identifying that child with this bridegroom would make Thomas a parent candidate. The separate Caverswall taxpayer is discussed below. These possibilities remain open rather than being rejected solely for lack of certainty.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD",
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_TAX_1666",
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD_BURIAL_1717",
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_BAPTISM_1639",
        "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_LEEK_BAPTISM_1672"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "George Brassington and a Brassington widow in the hearth tax",
          "record_date": "1666",
          "locality": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
          "historical_detail": "The published Caverswall transcription lists George Brassington with three chargeable hearths and a Brassington widow with one. It cites the William Salt Archaeological Society’s Staffordshire historical collections.",
          "association": "This is a same-name adult household in the same county eighteen years before George’s Alstonfield marriage. The taxpayer could be the later bridegroom, an older relative, or a member of his wider family.",
          "alternatives": "He could also be a distinct George from a different Brassington branch. The tax entry names neither wife nor children, and it supplies no connection to Alstonfield.",
          "assessment": "The name, regional proximity and compatible interval support investigating family continuity. They do not yet distinguish identity with the bridegroom from kinship or a separate branch; the taxpayer’s age and household succession would be particularly useful.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_TAX_1666"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Brassington is a surname taken from the Derbyshire village of that name. Its proposed meaning is a settlement associated with a man called Brandsige.",
          "caveat": "The dictionary treats Brandsige as a plausible reconstruction, rather than an independently recorded Old English personal name.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The geographical origin given by the surname dictionary is Brassington in Derbyshire. George’s own recorded locality is Alstonfield in Staffordshire, where he married in 1684.",
          "caveat": "The marriage does not establish where he was born or when his family reached Alstonfield.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "An earlier Staffordshire household appears in the Caverswall hearth-tax list of 1666: George Brassington was assessed on three hearths, and a separately listed Brassington widow on one.",
          "caveat": "The widow’s given name and relationship to George are not supplied.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_TAX_1666"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_MARY_RUSSELL_COUNTISS",
      "person_id": "C_MARY_RUSSELL_COUNTISS",
      "surname": "Russell (reported)",
      "locality": "Possible Washington County, Virginia association through Henry Countiss",
      "research_limit": "Mary Russell is reported as Henry Countiss’s wife in a supplied community-tree entry. No independent marriage record, birth place, dates or parents have been recovered for her. The 1820 census gives Henry’s household an adult woman aged 26–44 but does not name her; it cannot by itself identify her as Mary.",
      "notes": "The separately reviewed Countiss chart calls the wife of Henry, born in 1777, unknown. That omission does not contradict Mary’s existence, but neither does it independently confirm the community-tree name. Her identification and reported surname remain the first questions to resolve before assigning an earlier Russell family.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary Russell Countiss: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Possible Washington County, Virginia association through Henry Countiss",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Mary Russell is reported as Henry Countiss’s wife in a supplied community-tree entry. No independent marriage record, birth place, dates or parents have been recovered for her. The 1820 census gives Henry’s household an adult woman aged 26–44 but does not name her; it cannot by itself identify her as Mary. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
            "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "If the reported surname is correct, Russell commonly derives from a Norman French name or nickname referring to red hair or a ruddy complexion.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_RUSSELL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Russell has several independent origins: the Norman name spread in Britain and Ireland; some English families took the name from places such as Rushall, and some American examples derive from German Rüssel. Mary’s reported name does not establish one of these origins.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_RUSSELL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Mary’s only identified family association is the reported marriage to Henry Countiss. Without an independently dated record or birthplace, no particular earlier Russell household can yet be connected to her. The unnamed woman in Henry’s 1820 household is compatible with the claim but does not distinguish Mary from another wife.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_ANTOINE_GINDER_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_ANTOINE_GINDER_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Ginder",
      "locality": "Reported Hinsing / Holving area, Moselle, France (inferred only)",
      "research_limit": "Antoine is named only in a Geneanet tree as father of Anne Elisabeth Ginder. The proposed child is reported at Hinsing, while the tree branch under review places Anna Elisabetha Engel at Obergleen; no record establishes that they are the same woman or identifies Antoine’s dates, residence or parents.",
      "notes": "\n\nH1 is a compiled Ginder parent claim. Alternatives are a different Anne Elisabeth, a transcription or surname change, or an unrelated Ginder household. The name’s German and English explanations are both preserved; no parent link is promoted.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_ANNE_ELISABETH_GINDER_1740",
        "ROOTS26_GINDER_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_HINSING_RECORD_ROUTE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Moselle surname cluster and the unresolved Hinsing/Obergleen identity",
          "record_date": "modern distribution; reported eighteenth-century candidate",
          "locality": "Moselle, France / Obergleen, Hesse",
          "historical_detail": "The compiled source names Anne Elisabeth Ginder and Marguerite Jansem in a reported Hinsing setting. Modern surname indexes place Jansem strongly in Moselle, including Holving and Sarralbe, and a library catalog lists a post-1805 Hinsing/Holving family reconstruction. No inspected record connects this cluster to Anna Elisabetha Engel of Obergleen.",
          "association": "The Moselle concentration gives the Jansem spelling a geographically coherent research route, while the Ginder alternatives remain compatible with German or French-language records.",
          "alternatives": "The Geneanet Anne Elisabeth may be a different person, the surname may be mistranscribed, or the Obergleen woman may belong to another Engel family. Modern distribution and a later family book are not proof of the eighteenth-century parent claim.",
          "assessment": "The locality/surname hypothesis is a useful targeted lead but remains low confidence; the existing 0.22 parent edge is retained as a comparison candidate and no new ancestry is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GENEANET_ANNE_ELISABETH_GINDER_1740",
            "ROOTS26_JANSEM_LOCAL_DISTRIBUTION",
            "ROOTS26_HINSING_RECORD_ROUTE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Ginder has a German variant-of-Günther explanation and separate English explanations connected with “parent/procreator” or a son-in-law. These are alternatives, not a demonstrated meaning for Antoine.",
          "caveat": "The endpoint is named only in a compiled tree; the identity bridge to Anna Elisabetha Engel remains unresolved.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GINDER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The candidate has no identity-secure birthplace. The reported Hinsing/Moselle setting is only an inferred locality from a compiled child profile and must not be treated as proof of German or French origin.",
          "caveat": "The endpoint is named only in a compiled tree; the identity bridge to Anna Elisabetha Engel remains unresolved.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GINDER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The useful association is the possible Hinsing/Moselle record route, but the modern local references postdate the proposed ancestor and do not prove the Geneanet family.",
          "caveat": "The endpoint is named only in a compiled tree; the identity bridge to Anna Elisabetha Engel remains unresolved.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HINSING_RECORD_ROUTE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_MARGUERITE_JANSEM_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_MARGUERITE_JANSEM_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Jansem",
      "locality": "Reported Hinsing / Holving area, Moselle, France (inferred only)",
      "research_limit": "Marguerite is named only in the same Geneanet tree as mother of Anne Elisabeth Ginder. The spelling is distinctive but the reported Hinsing setting and the Obergleen descendant identity remain unproved; no birth, marriage or death record was inspected.",
      "notes": "\n\nH1 is the compiled Jansem maternal claim. Alternatives are a different Marguerite, a spelling variant such as Jantzem/Jansen, or a mother from another Moselle or Hesse household. No parent link is promoted.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_ANNE_ELISABETH_GINDER_1740",
        "ROOTS26_JANSEM_LOCAL_DISTRIBUTION",
        "ROOTS26_HINSING_RECORD_ROUTE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Moselle surname cluster and the unresolved Hinsing/Obergleen identity",
          "record_date": "modern distribution; reported eighteenth-century candidate",
          "locality": "Moselle, France / Obergleen, Hesse",
          "historical_detail": "The compiled source names Anne Elisabeth Ginder and Marguerite Jansem in a reported Hinsing setting. Modern surname indexes place Jansem strongly in Moselle, including Holving and Sarralbe, and a library catalog lists a post-1805 Hinsing/Holving family reconstruction. No inspected record connects this cluster to Anna Elisabetha Engel of Obergleen.",
          "association": "The Moselle concentration gives the Jansem spelling a geographically coherent research route, while the Ginder alternatives remain compatible with German or French-language records.",
          "alternatives": "The Geneanet Anne Elisabeth may be a different person, the surname may be mistranscribed, or the Obergleen woman may belong to another Engel family. Modern distribution and a later family book are not proof of the eighteenth-century parent claim.",
          "assessment": "The locality/surname hypothesis is a useful targeted lead but remains low confidence; the existing 0.22 parent edge is retained as a comparison candidate and no new ancestry is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GENEANET_ANNE_ELISABETH_GINDER_1740",
            "ROOTS26_JANSEM_LOCAL_DISTRIBUTION",
            "ROOTS26_HINSING_RECORD_ROUTE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "No reliable dictionary etymology was found for Jansem. Filae’s archive and birth distribution places the modern surname chiefly in Moselle, but that is distribution evidence rather than an etymology.",
          "caveat": "The endpoint is named only in a compiled tree; the identity bridge to Anna Elisabetha Engel remains unresolved.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JANSEM_LOCAL_DISTRIBUTION"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Modern Jansem records are concentrated in Moselle, including Holving/Sarralbe, making that a sensible search locality. The later Hinsing/Holving family reconstruction cannot identify Marguerite in the earlier generation.",
          "caveat": "The endpoint is named only in a compiled tree; the identity bridge to Anna Elisabetha Engel remains unresolved.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JANSEM_LOCAL_DISTRIBUTION"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The concrete association is the Moselle surname cluster and the catalogued Hinsing/Holving family route; neither selects the proposed Marguerite or connects her to Obergleen.",
          "caveat": "The endpoint is named only in a compiled tree; the identity bridge to Anna Elisabetha Engel remains unresolved.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HINSING_RECORD_ROUTE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_ISABEL_HENDERSON_SC_1790",
      "person_id": "C_ISABEL_HENDERSON_SC_1790",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Chesterfield District, South Carolina",
      "research_limit": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "notes": "Her age and position with John support the interpretation that she was his wife, although the 1850 census did not explicitly record relationships. Another adult relative is an alternative. The published surname index narrows the household search to three pages without resolving her earlier identity. No surname origin or earlier same-name family can be assigned to her from this evidence.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTERFIELD1850_INDEX"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Isabel Henderson: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Chesterfield District, South Carolina",
          "historical_detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CHESTERFIELD1850_INDEX"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Isabel Henderson without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Isabel Henderson. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Isabel Henderson without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Maryland, 1685; county not stated in the will",
      "research_limit": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "record_date": "1685–1686",
          "locality": "Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "Alongside Ann and the three sons, the recorded will names witnesses John Draper, Oliver Rochefort and Elizabeth Huskalve. The published abstract describes Ann as executrix and recipient of the remaining estate.",
          "association": "These named associates offer a more specific route into Ann’s family history than an isolated surname match elsewhere in Maryland.",
          "alternatives": "They could be relatives, neighbours or other associates. John Draper’s relationship to Ann, and whether the beneficiary and witness are the same person, remain unresolved.",
          "assessment": "The record establishes Ann’s married household but does not identify her earlier family. In the short will-book text she receives the estate apart from the specified gifts; an explicit executrix appointment is not visible there. The abstract and its online copies are one evidential source, not independent confirmations.",
          "source_ids": []
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Anne Hargis without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Anne Hargis. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Anne Hargis without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_BOSWELL_JAMES_FATHER_GRACE_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Boswell (reported)",
      "locality": "Reported Elizabeth City County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "James Boswell is named as Grace Boswell’s father in a compiled pedigree. His reported death in September 1718 has not been matched to an inspected probate entry, and his own parents remain unidentified.",
      "notes": "The reported dates permit him to be Grace’s father, but the pedigree supplies no family or property detail tying them together. A published history identifies Grace, wife of John Selden, as a daughter of William Boswell and Ellinor Brough. She may be a different woman or the source of a confused pedigree; her existence alone does not disprove the proposed Hargis family. Elizabeth City’s surviving 1715–1721 records cover James’s reported death and remain a useful source for distinguishing these households.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_STUBBS",
        "ROOTS26_ELIZABETHCITY_EARLY_RECORDS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "William Boswell and Ellinor’s Elizabeth City household",
          "record_date": "1702–1742",
          "locality": "Elizabeth City County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The Stubbs family history reports William Boswell’s 1702 marriage to Ellinor Brough and identifies their daughter Grace as John Selden’s wife.",
          "association": "This places a specifically identified Boswell family in the county associated with James’s reported death.",
          "alternatives": "James could belong to that wider family, to another Boswell line, or to a pedigree assembled from unrelated records. Grace Selden is not automatically Grace Hargis.",
          "assessment": "The named husband and parents distinguish this household more effectively than a surname match. They do not establish a relationship to James.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_STUBBS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Thomas Boswell’s Potomac land grant",
          "record_date": "9 March 1658, as printed",
          "locality": "Potomac River, above Anacosta Island",
          "historical_detail": "Nugent’s patent abstract records 500 acres granted to Thomas Boswell above Anacosta Island, adjoining a large tract belonging to John Wood.",
          "association": "This is an earlier Boswell landholder in the wider Potomac region associated with the reported Hargis pedigree.",
          "alternatives": "Thomas could be a wider relative or a member of another family. The grant gives no connection with James, Ann or Grace.",
          "assessment": "It establishes an earlier regional name-bearer, but supplies no identifying evidence to choose Thomas as James’s father.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_SMITH_PATENTS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Boswell is a place-derived surname. The dictionary connects it with Beuzeville-la-Giffard, whose name combines the personal name Boso with ville, settlement.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name is used in England and Scotland and is described as Norman in origin. Beuzeville-la-Giffard is in Seine-Maritime, France; James has no established birthplace or migration route connecting him with it.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The English and Scottish uses belong to a wider history than this proposed Virginia household. James’s matching name does not identify him with the Scottish biographer’s family or another particular Boswell lineage.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_SMITH_ANN_MOTHER_GRACE_BOSWELL_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_ANN_MOTHER_GRACE_BOSWELL_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Smith (reported)",
      "locality": "Virginia association in the compiled pedigree; individual residence unknown",
      "research_limit": "Ann Smith is named as Grace Boswell’s mother in the compiled Hargis pedigree, but no inspected record establishes her dates, residence, parents or marriage to James Boswell.",
      "notes": "Her proposed motherhood remains possible, but the current evidence does not distinguish her from another mother or a mistaken pedigree attribution. The identifiable Boswell–Selden family has a mother named Ellinor, not Ann; this does not decide which Grace the Hargis pedigree intended. Searches of colonial Smith references have produced an earlier Ann Smith in transportation rights, but no household connection that identifies her as this woman.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
        "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_STUBBS",
        "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_SMITH_PATENTS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ann Smith in John Williams’s transportation rights",
          "record_date": "11 March 1658; grant renewed 21 October 1662",
          "locality": "Rappahannock County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "Nugent lists Ann Smith among the transportation rights supporting John Williams’s 1,800-acre grant on the north side of the Rappahannock near Farnham Creek.",
          "association": "This is a specific earlier reference to the same name in colonial Virginia.",
          "alternatives": "The entry could concern the candidate Ann, a relative or an unrelated woman. It supplies no age, parents or spouse.",
          "assessment": "The patent does not establish her arrival date, residence on the land or membership of Williams’s household. Without a connecting family detail, it cannot identify Grace’s proposed mother.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_SMITH_PATENTS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Smith usually refers to a worker in metal, including a blacksmith or farrier. It can also derive from a forge or smithy where someone worked or lived.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ANN_SMITH_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name arose in England and Scotland and has also been adopted for Gaelic names meaning son of the smith and as a translation of metalworking surnames in other languages. Ann’s reported name does not establish which origin applies.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ANN_SMITH_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname reflects trades that supplied tools, horseshoes, weapons and other metal goods. Many unrelated families acquired it independently; Ann’s family cannot be identified through the occupation’s history alone.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ANN_SMITH_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "person_id": "C_LUBLINEL_ELIZABETH_MARRIED_HARGES_1725",
      "surname": "Luthrel (indexed as Lublinel)",
      "locality": "Saint Paul’s Parish, Stafford County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "The parish-register transcription names Elizabeth Luthrel as John Harges’s bride on 1 October 1725. It gives neither her parents nor her birthplace. Her husband’s identification with the John Hargis in the tree remains a candidate relationship.",
      "notes": "Lublinel comes from the earlier marriage-index transcript. The same groom, bride’s given name and exact date strongly favor a spelling or transcription difference over a second couple. Luthrel is the reading in the inspected published register. A connection with the Luttrell surname is plausible, but Elizabeth’s own family has not yet been placed among the regional households.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LUTHREL_STPAUL",
        "SRC_EARLY_VA_MARRIAGES_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_JOHN_HARGES_1725"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John and Elizabeth Harges’s parish household",
          "record_date": "1725–1726",
          "locality": "Saint Paul’s Parish, Stafford County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The published register records the marriage in October 1725 and the birth of Mildred to John and Elizabeth Harges on 4 August 1726.",
          "association": "The matching parents and short interval make the newly married couple the leading identification for Mildred’s parents.",
          "alternatives": "Another local couple with the same names is possible, but no competing household is identified in these entries.",
          "assessment": "This supports a specific local household. It does not identify Elizabeth’s parents or automatically equate her husband with another John Hargis.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LUTHREL_STPAUL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Richard Luterell’s land on Town Run",
          "record_date": "1740–1745",
          "locality": "Prince William County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "A published survey abstract names Richard Luterell with 58 acres adjoining his own land on a drain of Town Run.",
          "association": "A related surname and the Stafford–Prince William region make this household worth comparing with Elizabeth’s.",
          "alternatives": "Luthrel could represent another name or a separate Luttrell lineage; Elizabeth’s marriage does not place her on Town Run.",
          "assessment": "The regional connection is plausible context, but the present evidence does not distinguish Richard as a father, brother or other relative.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LUTTERELL_TOWN_RUN"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "If Luthrel represents Luttrell, the dictionary traces the name to a diminutive of Old French loutre, meaning otter. It could describe a person by resemblance or refer to someone who hunted otters for their pelts.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LUTTRELL_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_LUTHREL_STPAUL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Luttrell is described as English and Irish, of Norman origin. The Stafford marriage establishes Elizabeth’s presence there in 1725, but not an English, Irish or Virginia birthplace.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LUTTRELL_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_LUTHREL_STPAUL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name’s connection with the otter is linguistic and may reflect a nickname or occupation. It does not identify one founder or show that Elizabeth belonged to a particular prominent Luttrell family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LUTTRELL_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_LUTHREL_STPAUL"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_JAMMER_JANE_MOTHER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_JAMMER_JANE_MOTHER_MARY_FOUNTAIN_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Jammer (reported)",
      "locality": "Virginia connection reported; Jane’s residence unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Jane Jammer is named as Mary Catherine Fountain’s mother in a Geneanet pedigree supplied by Matthew. It gives Jane no dates, spouse or residence, and no identifiable parents have emerged from the reviewed material. The other records cited for Mary do not name Jane.",
      "notes": "The pedigree may preserve a correct maternal name, or the spelling or attachment to this Fountain family may be mistaken. Its explicit mother–daughter claim supports keeping Jane as a candidate, but there is too little personal detail to distinguish those explanations. The reported 1665 birth of Mary in King William uses a county name established only in 1702; it may describe the later location rather than the jurisdiction at birth. Searches for Jane with Fountain, Hargis and Accomack have not identified an earlier Jammer household connected to her. These searches do not establish that such a household was absent.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
        "ROOTS26_JAMMER_KING_WILLIAM",
        "SRC_SELECT_BIRTHS_MARY_JOHN_HIRGES_CHILD_JOHN"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Jane Jammer: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Virginia connection reported; Jane’s residence unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Jane Jammer is named as Mary Catherine Fountain’s mother in a Geneanet pedigree supplied by Matthew. It gives Jane no dates, spouse or residence, and no identifiable parents have emerged from the reviewed material. The other records cited for Mary do not name Jane. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
            "ROOTS26_JAMMER_KING_WILLIAM",
            "SRC_SELECT_BIRTHS_MARY_JOHN_HIRGES_CHILD_JOHN"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The Dictionary of American Family Names explains Jammer as a name for someone living by a hollow, from Slavic jama, meaning a hole or hollow.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JAMMER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary places this surname formation in eastern Germany and identifies its linguistic origin as Slavic. Jane’s reported surname alone does not establish a German birthplace or migration to Virginia.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JAMMER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name’s documented explanation concerns landscape and residence. No particular German village, colonial Jammer household or earlier name-bearer has yet been connected to Jane in the material reviewed.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JAMMER_DAFN",
            "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "C_DRAPER_ELIZABETH_ANN_SEPARATE_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Draper (reported)",
      "locality": "Reported Maryland connection; no individual residence established",
      "research_limit": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "notes": "She may represent the documented Ann with an expanded name, a different mother, or a mistaken reconstruction from the Draper name in the will. The name overlap makes the first explanation plausible, but the recorded wording does not distinguish it from the alternatives. Her candidate link remains separate. Establishing who John Draper was, and whether he was the later John Hargis of Westmoreland, would help resolve the family.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John Draper in the Hargis household’s records",
          "record_date": "1685–1686",
          "locality": "Maryland; county not specified",
          "historical_detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "association": "These are the closest documented Draper references to the proposed family.",
          "alternatives": "The beneficiary and witness could be one person or two. A blended household could explain the surname without making Draper Ann’s birth name.",
          "assessment": "The will establishes a Draper connection, but no relationship to a woman named Elizabeth Ann Draper. It supports further investigation, not a chosen Draper parent.",
          "source_ids": []
        },
        {
          "title": "Alexander and Catherine Draper at Little Bolton",
          "record_date": "1660–1663",
          "locality": "Annemessex area, Somerset, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "Land-record transcriptions name Alexander Draper in a 1660 warrant. In April 1663 he claimed transportation rights for himself, wife Catherine and servant Edmund Furlong. An October 1663 grant identifies Little Bolton near Hart’s Creek.",
          "association": "This is an identifiable Draper household in the same colony during the proposed family’s period.",
          "alternatives": "Elizabeth Ann could belong to a different Draper family, or Draper may not have been her birth surname. No record places her in Alexander’s household or in Somerset.",
          "assessment": "The connection remains regional context only. Neither Alexander nor Catherine currently has enough identifying evidence to rank as her parent.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DRAPER_SOMERSET_LAND"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "If Draper was her birth surname, it belongs to an English occupational name for someone who made or sold woollen cloth. It comes through Anglo-Norman draper and Old French drapier, from drap, cloth.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DRAPER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname arose in England and also reached Ulster in the seventeenth century. No English county or Irish residence has been established for this candidate.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DRAPER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Draperstown in County Londonderry takes its name from the London Drapers’ Company, which received land there. That corporate association does not identify Elizabeth Ann’s family or establish descent from company members.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DRAPER_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_URIAH_FATHER_SUSANNA_1614",
      "surname": "Lea",
      "locality": "Ashwell, Hertfordshire",
      "research_limit": "Uriae is directly named as father in Ashwell baptisms, but his own baptism, marriage, parents, occupation and origin are not established. Reported vital details remain compiled claims.",
      "notes": "The local father identification is strong. The line stops because the reviewed records do not name Uriae’s parents; archive catalogues identify concrete records for deeper research.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
        "ROOTS26_LEA_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ashwell records available for deeper Lea research",
          "record_date": "1604–1837",
          "locality": "Ashwell, Hertfordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The Ashwell Museum lists parish-register transcripts, churchwardens accounts, terriers, deeds and wills for the relevant locality. Hertfordshire guides distinguish parish registers from bishops transcripts and report uneven coverage.",
          "association": "This is a specific local record trail for Uriae Lea’s household.",
          "alternatives": "A later record found in Ashwell could belong to another Lea household unless names, spouse and children align.",
          "assessment": "The direct child-baptism evidence establishes Uriae in Ashwell; catalogue evidence does not justify adding an older parent link.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Lea is reported as an English variant of Lee.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
            "ROOTS26_LEA_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The documented branch is located in Ashwell or Stoke St Gregory; broad Lea/Lee distribution does not identify kinship.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
            "ROOTS26_LEA_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Ashwell Museum lists parish transcripts and local deeds, terriers and wills that could test the Lea household further.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
            "ROOTS26_LEA_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "person_id": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "surname": "Lea",
      "locality": "Stoke St Gregory, Somerset",
      "research_limit": "The 1587 marriage and 1590 baptism establish a Robert Lea in Somerset, but not his parents or later movement. Connecting him to Joannae, wife of Uriah in Ashwell, requires an undocumented move between counties.",
      "notes": "This is a real documented Somerset household and a plausible candidate, but the cross-county identity remains weaker than the local records.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
        "ROOTS26_LEA_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Lea–Smith marriage and 1590 Lea baptism",
          "record_date": "3 December 1587 and 13 March 1590",
          "locality": "Stoke St Gregory, Somerset",
          "historical_detail": "The supplied parish transcription records Robte Lea marrying Joan Smith in 1587 and Robert Lea as father of Joan Lea in 1590.",
          "association": "These records establish a local Somerset Lea–Smith household that could be related to the later Ashwell couple.",
          "alternatives": "A different Robert Lea or a different Joannae/Joan could explain the later Ashwell records; no migration evidence has been found.",
          "assessment": "The Somerset household is internally coherent and worth retaining as a candidate, but it is not a demonstrated bridge to Ashwell.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Lea is reported as an English variant of Lee.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
            "ROOTS26_LEA_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The documented branch is located in Ashwell or Stoke St Gregory; broad Lea/Lee distribution does not identify kinship.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
            "ROOTS26_LEA_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Ashwell Museum lists parish transcripts and local deeds, terriers and wills that could test the Lea household further.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
            "ROOTS26_LEA_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "person_id": "C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "surname": "Smith",
      "locality": "Stoke St Gregory, Somerset",
      "research_limit": "The 1587 marriage establishes Joan Smith but not her birth, parents, occupation or later movement. The 1590 baptism names Robert but not Joan as mother.",
      "notes": "Joan is a plausible mother for the 1590 child because she married Robert first. Her maternity and the later Ashwell identity remain unresolved.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
        "ROOTS26_SMITH_DAFN2022",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
        "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Joan Smith: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Stoke St Gregory, Somerset",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The 1587 marriage establishes Joan Smith but not her birth, parents, occupation or later movement. The 1590 baptism names Robert but not Joan as mother. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
            "ROOTS26_SMITH_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Smith is an English and Scottish occupational name for a metalworker, with additional independent formations.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
            "ROOTS26_SMITH_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Smith is exceptionally common, so its general meaning cannot identify Joan’s birth family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
            "ROOTS26_SMITH_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Joan’s documented local association is her 1587 marriage to Robert Lea at Stoke St Gregory.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
            "ROOTS26_SMITH_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
            "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "person_id": "C_HARGAS_GEO_VIRGINIA_BY_1642",
      "surname": "Hargas / Hargis",
      "locality": "Virginia; Rappahannock River land-claim context, 1642",
      "research_limit": "Geo. Hargas is named in John Benton’s Virginia land-patent abstract of 13 October 1642. It gives no age, birthplace or parents. His connection to the London Hargase household reported in later pedigrees remains unresolved; the parish entries and the previously reported infant burial need checking together.",
      "notes": "The London identification is a concrete lead: the name and proposed 1617 birth are compatible with the 1642 entry. Against it, the compiled family has conflicting generations and dates, and no inspected record connects that household to Benton’s claim. A different English or continental family remains possible. London’s archive catalogue describes registers from 1539, so this is an unresolved identification rather than a demonstrated loss of all relevant records.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_HARGAS_PATENT1642",
        "ROOTS26_HARGAS_OBERHEIDE",
        "ROOTS26_OLD_FISH_REGISTER_CATALOGUE",
        "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Geo. Hargas among the names supporting Benton’s land claim",
          "record_date": "13 October 1642",
          "locality": "South side of the Rappahannock River, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "Benton’s patent covered 1,250 acres, described as about 15 miles upriver. Its list includes Geo. Hargas, Benton family members, Thomas Craven and Ralph Tatum.",
          "association": "This is a specific group of people whose records may help identify the immigrant’s earlier connections.",
          "alternatives": "Their inclusion could reflect shared migration or several separate transportation claims. It does not establish one voyage or kinship with Benton.",
          "assessment": "The entry supports Hargas’s presence in a claim by 1642. It does not establish his exact arrival date, age, occupation or residence on this land; an earlier family cannot yet be identified from the names alone.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HARGAS_PATENT1642"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Two explanations remain possible. The English name may be a form of Hargest, taken from Upper or Lower Hergest in Herefordshire; that place name’s meaning is uncertain. Alternatively, Harges may be related to Harjes, a surname formed from personal names containing an element meaning army.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HARGIS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_HARGEST_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_HARJES_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary associates the English Hargis form with Essex and the alternative Harges/Harjes explanation with northern Germany and Frisia. None of these regional explanations establishes where Geo. Hargas was born.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HARGIS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_HARJES_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Later family accounts propose a Norman ancestor named Louis and Danish ancestry. The inspected pedigree supports this with a family compilation and broad historical speculation, rather than a record linking Louis to the Virginia immigrant. That ancestry remains a reported tradition.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HARGAS_OBERHEIDE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064368",
      "surname": "Jacob",
      "locality": "Kyritz",
      "research_limit": "Johanna Maria Barbara Jacob’s reported 2 October 1774 Kyritz birth and later Sembach death remain compiled. Kyritz locality history supplies context but no Jacob baptism; Sembach’s Jewish-community list names Kussel Neumond, not Johanna or her reported husband Loeb. No record bridges the reported move or identifies Johanna’s parents. H1 is the imported Johanna; alternatives are a Kyritz namesake, a different Jacob household, or a mistaken locality/person. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "H1: the exact-date Johanna in the imported profile is the woman later associated with Loeb Neumond at Sembach. Alternatives are another Johanna Jacob, a locality or date transcription error, or a different wife in the Neumond household. The existing Sembach list does not name her, so it is locality context rather than identity proof.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JACOB_DAFN",
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Jacob: locality record and identity alternatives",
          "record_date": "reported 1774–1857; 1809–1810 Sembach household list",
          "locality": "Kyritz",
          "historical_detail": "Kyritz, Prussia, municipal history; Sembach Jewish-community history and its 1809–1810 household list; no inspected baptism, marriage or parent record names Johanna.",
          "association": "The surviving local history and household list provide a concrete locality test but do not identify the imported individual or parents.",
          "alternatives": "H1: the exact-date Johanna in the imported profile is the woman later associated with Loeb Neumond at Sembach. Alternatives are another Johanna Jacob, a locality or date transcription error, or a different wife in the Neumond household. The existing Sembach list does not name her, so it is locality context rather than identity proof.",
          "assessment": "The imported profile remains a research hypothesis with locality support of varying strength; no ancestry edge is added without a parent-naming record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
            "ROOTS26_JACOB_DAFN",
            "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The surname Jacob is a widespread biblical personal-name derivative used in German, Jewish, French Alsace-Lorraine and many other naming traditions. Johanna’s reported Kyritz-to-Sembach path is plausible but not demonstrated by a parent-naming record.",
          "caveat": "The surname and locality evidence is contextual; no new parent identity is asserted.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JACOB_DAFN",
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
            "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported Kyritz setting is relevant local context, but surname history permits multiple origins and does not identify this household. The surname Jacob is a widespread biblical personal-name derivative used in German, Jewish, French Alsace-Lorraine and many other naming traditions. Johanna’s reported Kyritz-to-Sembach path is plausible but not demonstrated by a parent-naming record.",
          "caveat": "The surname and locality evidence is contextual; no new parent identity is asserted.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JACOB_DAFN",
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
            "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Kyritz, Prussia, municipal history; Sembach Jewish-community history and its 1809–1810 household list; no inspected baptism, marriage or parent record names Johanna.",
          "caveat": "The surname and locality evidence is contextual; no new parent identity is asserted.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JACOB_DAFN",
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
            "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064375",
      "surname": "Newman Neumond",
      "locality": "Kusel, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "research_limit": "The imported Isaak/Isaac Newman Neumond remains a conflicting candidate. The Sembach 1809–1810 list names Kussel Neumond, which could be a personal name later misread as the town Kusel, but it does not prove identity. The reported 1750–1857 lifespan is exceptional and lacks vital, marriage, property or parent records. H1 is a possible Kussel/Neumond continuity; alternatives are a transcription of a given name, another Neumond household, or an unrelated namesake. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "H1: the Sembach Kussel Neumond entry may be the person later represented as Isaak/Isaac Newman Neumond. Alternatives are that Kussel is a given name unrelated to Kusel, that Newman is a later translation, or that the 1857 death belongs to another man. The exceptional lifespan makes the identity especially weak.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_DAFN",
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Newman Neumond: locality record and identity alternatives",
          "record_date": "reported 1774–1857; 1809–1810 Sembach household list",
          "locality": "Kusel, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
          "historical_detail": "Sembach Jewish-community history lists Kussel Neumond in 1809–1810 but supplies no wife, child, occupation or parent; the reported Kusel and Mehlingen chronology remains unverified.",
          "association": "The surviving local history and household list provide a concrete locality test but do not identify the imported individual or parents.",
          "alternatives": "H1: the Sembach Kussel Neumond entry may be the person later represented as Isaak/Isaac Newman Neumond. Alternatives are that Kussel is a given name unrelated to Kusel, that Newman is a later translation, or that the 1857 death belongs to another man. The exceptional lifespan makes the identity especially weak.",
          "assessment": "The imported profile remains a research hypothesis with locality support of varying strength; no ancestry edge is added without a parent-naming record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
            "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Newman can be an English newcomer nickname or an Americanized translation of German/Jewish Neumann and related forms. “Newman Neumond” may therefore reflect translation or compound-name handling, but no record establishes how the imported name was formed.",
          "caveat": "The surname and locality evidence is contextual; no new parent identity is asserted.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_DAFN",
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported Kusel, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany setting is relevant local context, but surname history permits multiple origins and does not identify this household. Newman can be an English newcomer nickname or an Americanized translation of German/Jewish Neumann and related forms. “Newman Neumond” may therefore reflect translation or compound-name handling, but no record establishes how the imported name was formed.",
          "caveat": "The surname and locality evidence is contextual; no new parent identity is asserted.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_DAFN",
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Sembach Jewish-community history lists Kussel Neumond in 1809–1810 but supplies no wife, child, occupation or parent; the reported Kusel and Mehlingen chronology remains unverified.",
          "caveat": "The surname and locality evidence is contextual; no new parent identity is asserted.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_DAFN",
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064377",
      "surname": "Strauss Neumond",
      "locality": "Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
      "research_limit": "Hendle Strauss is reported as wife of Isaak/Kussel Neumond and mother of Loeb, but no birth, marriage, death, household, occupation, property or parent record has been located. The Sembach list shows a Strauss presence but does not name Hendle or connect her to Kussel. H1 is a compatible local household; alternatives are another Strauss woman, a given-name or surname transcription error, or an unrelated Sembach family. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "H1: Hendle Strauss was the wife in the imported Neumond household at Sembach. Alternatives are a different Strauss woman or a later compiled conflation. The locality and approximate 1740 date fit the family chronology, but the 1809–1810 list does not name her.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_STRAUSS_DAFN",
        "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Strauss Neumond: locality record and identity alternatives",
          "record_date": "reported 1774–1857; 1809–1810 Sembach household list",
          "locality": "Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
          "historical_detail": "Sembach’s published Jewish-community history records the community and a Strauss presence in 1809–1810, but no inspected record names Hendle or her parents.",
          "association": "The surviving local history and household list provide a concrete locality test but do not identify the imported individual or parents.",
          "alternatives": "H1: Hendle Strauss was the wife in the imported Neumond household at Sembach. Alternatives are a different Strauss woman or a later compiled conflation. The locality and approximate 1740 date fit the family chronology, but the 1809–1810 list does not name her.",
          "assessment": "The imported profile remains a research hypothesis with locality support of varying strength; no ancestry edge is added without a parent-naming record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
            "ROOTS26_STRAUSS_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Strauss has multiple German and Jewish surname explanations, including ostrich-sign, nickname and topographic origins; some Jewish uses may have been artificial. The surname alone cannot identify Hendle’s family or prove a relationship to the Sembach Strauss households.",
          "caveat": "The surname and locality evidence is contextual; no new parent identity is asserted.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_STRAUSS_DAFN",
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported Sembach, Kaiserslautern, Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany setting is relevant local context, but surname history permits multiple origins and does not identify this household. Strauss has multiple German and Jewish surname explanations, including ostrich-sign, nickname and topographic origins; some Jewish uses may have been artificial. The surname alone cannot identify Hendle’s family or prove a relationship to the Sembach Strauss households.",
          "caveat": "The surname and locality evidence is contextual; no new parent identity is asserted.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_STRAUSS_DAFN",
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Sembach’s published Jewish-community history records the community and a Strauss presence in 1809–1810, but no inspected record names Hendle or her parents.",
          "caveat": "The surname and locality evidence is contextual; no new parent identity is asserted.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_STRAUSS_DAFN",
            "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "surname": "Schwartz",
      "locality": "Liberty, Amite, Mississippi",
      "research_limit": "Leon is anchored by the 1883 Orleans marriage and 1926 Louisiana death, while the imported Liberty birth and exact parents remain unresolved. The Woodville Jacob Schwartz household and its son Leon are a concrete alternative but lack a bridge to Adeline Trautman and New Orleans. H1 is the imported New Orleans Leon; alternative is the Woodville namesake or another Mississippi family. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Leon is anchored by the 1883 Orleans marriage and 1926 Louisiana death, while the imported Liberty birth and exact parents remain unresolved. The Woodville Jacob Schwartz household and its son Leon are a concrete alternative but lack a bridge to Adeline Trautman and New Orleans. H1 is the imported New Orleans Leon; alternative is the Woodville namesake or another Mississippi family. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_SCHWARTZ_DAFN"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Schwartz: local record and alternative identity assessment",
          "record_date": "nineteenth–twentieth century records reviewed",
          "locality": "Liberty, Amite, Mississippi",
          "historical_detail": "The New Orleans Schwartz Bros. and Louisiana Historical Association biographies provide a later family association, while Mississippi census indexes and Woodville Jewish history supply the competing local context. None names Leon’s parents.",
          "association": "The reviewed civil, military, community or business records establish a concrete later life but do not identify the earlier parent household.",
          "alternatives": "Leon is anchored by the 1883 Orleans marriage and 1926 Louisiana death, while the imported Liberty birth and exact parents remain unresolved. The Woodville Jacob Schwartz household and its son Leon are a concrete alternative but lack a bridge to Adeline Trautman and New Orleans. H1 is the imported New Orleans Leon; alternative is the Woodville namesake or another Mississippi family. No parent edge is added.",
          "assessment": "The imported identity remains the best-supported working hypothesis at its documented locality; alternatives are retained and no ancestry edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHWARTZ_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Schwartz is a German and Ashkenazic Jewish nickname meaning dark or black, with a possible place-name origin. Its broad distribution and many Schwarz/Schwartz variants make the surname alone weak identity evidence.",
          "caveat": "Contextual surname or locality evidence does not identify the missing parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHWARTZ_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported Liberty, Amite, Mississippi setting provides context, but surname distribution and variant spellings do not establish this family. Schwartz is a German and Ashkenazic Jewish nickname meaning dark or black, with a possible place-name origin. Its broad distribution and many Schwarz/Schwartz variants make the surname alone weak identity evidence.",
          "caveat": "Contextual surname or locality evidence does not identify the missing parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHWARTZ_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The New Orleans Schwartz Bros. and Louisiana Historical Association biographies provide a later family association, while Mississippi census indexes and Woodville Jewish history supply the competing local context. None names Leon’s parents.",
          "caveat": "Contextual surname or locality evidence does not identify the missing parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHWARTZ_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "surname": "Pfeifer",
      "locality": "Niederhochstadt, Bavaria, German Confederation",
      "research_limit": "Emanuel’s American migration, marriage, children and later life are substantially reconstructed, but the 21 September 1833 Niederhochstadt birth has not yielded an inspected parent record. The official archive catalogue exposes local register holdings without an online 1833 act; the line therefore stops at Emanuel’s parents pending the original civil or Jewish record or an independently sourced local family reconstruction.",
      "notes": "H1: the imported Emanuel Pfeifer is the 21 September 1833 Niederhochstadt man whose later American records are reconstructed in the Ingenheim community database. Alternatives include the separately listed Emanuel Pfeiffer born 24 September 1833 and an unmerged local namesake household. The three-day date difference and Heidelberg association of the second man are reasons to preserve both identities. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
        "SRC_APERTUS_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_REGISTER_SEARCH_20260725",
        "ROOTS26_PFEIFER_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_ARCHIVE_ROUTE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Niederhochstadt Pfeifer births and the unresolved 1833 parent record",
          "record_date": "21 and 24 Sep 1833; archive holdings searched 2026",
          "locality": "Niederhochstadt, Bavarian Palatinate, present-day Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany",
          "historical_detail": "The Ingenheim community database identifies Emanuel Pfeifer born 21 September 1833 and reconstructs his emigration, Confederate service, New Orleans marriage, passport and Brookhaven family. Its directory separately lists Emanuel Pfeiffer born 24 September 1833, later associated with Heidelberg. APERTUS exposes local Niederhochstadt register holdings but no digitized 1833 act naming either man’s parents.",
          "association": "The exact locality and two near-identical dates make the archive holdings the direct test of Emanuel’s parentage; Pfeifer’s German occupational surname meaning is contextual only.",
          "alternatives": "The imported man may be confused with the 24 September Pfeiffer, another local family, or an undocumented namesake. The later American chronology favors the 21 September identity but does not supply his parents.",
          "assessment": "Identity H1 is strong for the American Emanuel because of the exact date, locality and continuous later records. Parentage remains unresolved; no ancestry edge is added until the original 1833 record or an equivalent local reconstruction is found.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
            "SRC_APERTUS_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_REGISTER_SEARCH_20260725",
            "ROOTS26_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_ARCHIVE_ROUTE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Pfeifer is described as a German occupational surname for a fifer or pipe player, from Middle High German pfifer/pfeifer. This is a surname-history explanation, not evidence that Emanuel himself held that occupation.",
          "caveat": "The surname meaning and locality are contextual; neither proves Emanuel’s parents or merges him with the separate 24 September 1833 Emanuel Pfeiffer.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PFEIFER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname is German-language in form and the documented ancestor is placed at Niederhochstadt in the Bavarian Palatinate. That locality supports a German regional context, but it does not identify Emanuel’s earlier family or distinguish every Pfeifer household.",
          "caveat": "The surname meaning and locality are contextual; neither proves Emanuel’s parents or merges him with the separate 24 September 1833 Emanuel Pfeiffer.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PFEIFER_DAFN",
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The strongest specific association is the Niederhochstadt-to-American migration documented by the Ingenheim Jewish community database: Emanuel emigrated about 1853, married Rahel Dreyfuss in New Orleans in 1867, and had four American-born children including Leon. The local archive catalogue supplies the next route for testing his parents.",
          "caveat": "The surname meaning and locality are contextual; neither proves Emanuel’s parents or merges him with the separate 24 September 1833 Emanuel Pfeiffer.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
            "SRC_APERTUS_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_REGISTER_SEARCH_20260725",
            "ROOTS26_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_ARCHIVE_ROUTE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "surname": "Juffe",
      "locality": "Austria",
      "research_limit": "Max is strongly identified by the 1917 New York military register, 1915 Connecticut marriage, 1942 NARA draft-card catalog and 1979 gravesite record, but his Austrian town, immigration, naturalization and parents remain unresolved. Jaffe is a plausible spelling candidate, but the 1913 index entry lacks identifying details. H1 is the documented Captain Max Juffe; alternatives are a Jaffe/Joffe namesake or a conflicting birth-year identity. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Max is strongly identified by the 1917 New York military register, 1915 Connecticut marriage, 1942 NARA draft-card catalog and 1979 gravesite record, but his Austrian town, immigration, naturalization and parents remain unresolved. Jaffe is a plausible spelling candidate, but the 1913 index entry lacks identifying details. H1 is the documented Captain Max Juffe; alternatives are a Jaffe/Joffe namesake or a conflicting birth-year identity. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JUFFE_DIRECTORY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Juffe: local record and alternative identity assessment",
          "record_date": "nineteenth–twentieth century records reviewed",
          "locality": "Austria",
          "historical_detail": "The official military, marriage, draft and cemetery records establish a distinctive American life. The Austrian origin remains broad, and no inspected document identifies a town or parents.",
          "association": "The reviewed civil, military, community or business records establish a concrete later life but do not identify the earlier parent household.",
          "alternatives": "Max is strongly identified by the 1917 New York military register, 1915 Connecticut marriage, 1942 NARA draft-card catalog and 1979 gravesite record, but his Austrian town, immigration, naturalization and parents remain unresolved. Jaffe is a plausible spelling candidate, but the 1913 index entry lacks identifying details. H1 is the documented Captain Max Juffe; alternatives are a Jaffe/Joffe namesake or a conflicting birth-year identity. No parent edge is added.",
          "assessment": "The imported identity remains the best-supported working hypothesis at its documented locality; alternatives are retained and no ancestry edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JUFFE_DIRECTORY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "FamilySearch’s surname directory lists Juffe but the reviewed entry supplies no surname etymology. Jaffe/Joffe may be transliteration or spelling alternatives, but the evidence does not establish that relationship or a Jewish/German origin for Max.",
          "caveat": "Contextual surname or locality evidence does not identify the missing parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JUFFE_DIRECTORY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported Austria setting provides context, but surname distribution and variant spellings do not establish this family. FamilySearch’s surname directory lists Juffe but the reviewed entry supplies no surname etymology. Jaffe/Joffe may be transliteration or spelling alternatives, but the evidence does not establish that relationship or a Jewish/German origin for Max.",
          "caveat": "Contextual surname or locality evidence does not identify the missing parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JUFFE_DIRECTORY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The official military, marriage, draft and cemetery records establish a distinctive American life. The Austrian origin remains broad, and no inspected document identifies a town or parents.",
          "caveat": "Contextual surname or locality evidence does not identify the missing parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JUFFE_DIRECTORY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064659",
      "surname": "Fuchs",
      "locality": "Reported Galicia; later New Britain, Connecticut",
      "research_limit": "Yetta Edith’s imported profile supplies Fuchs and a broad Galician origin. The 1914 death notice identifies Mrs Solomon Dubowy but gives no parents or precise European birthplace. The surname and overseas family need a record naming them.",
      "notes": "The imported name and Galician origin remain plausible. The death notice’s age implies a birth around 1857–1858, slightly later than the imported 1856 date; inaccurate age reporting could explain the difference. No home town or parents have been identified in the reviewed records, and no relationship to the Württemberg Fuchs family is established.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BETH_ALOM_YETTA_DUBOWY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Yetta Edith Fuchs: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Reported Galicia; later New Britain, Connecticut",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Yetta Edith’s imported profile supplies Fuchs and a broad Galician origin. The 1914 death notice identifies Mrs Solomon Dubowy but gives no parents or precise European birthplace. The surname and overseas family need a record naming them. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
            "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BETH_ALOM_YETTA_DUBOWY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The German word for fox became a nickname, including for perceived cleverness or red hair.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FUCHS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name occurs in German and Ashkenazic Jewish usage and in neighboring countries; some occurrences reflect translated surnames.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FUCHS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname does not by itself establish ethnicity, occupation or a connection between the Galician and Württemberg families.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FUCHS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064673",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064673",
      "surname": "Dubowy",
      "locality": "Austria (now Poland)",
      "research_limit": "Lazar Dubowy is supported only by the imported profile: about 1830 in “Austria (now Poland)” and death in 1894. The locality is too broad to select a parish or civil district, and no independent record names his spouse, household, occupation, migration, death place or parents. The surname searches found rarity and German/Polish/Austrian distribution but no dependable etymology. H1 is the imported father of Solomon; alternatives are another Dubowy in former Galicia, a transcription or locality error, or an unrelated namesake. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Lazar Dubowy is supported only by the imported profile: about 1830 in “Austria (now Poland)” and death in 1894. The locality is too broad to select a parish or civil district, and no independent record names his spouse, household, occupation, migration, death place or parents. The surname searches found rarity and German/Polish/Austrian distribution but no dependable etymology. H1 is the imported father of Solomon; alternatives are another Dubowy in former Galicia, a transcription or locality error, or an unrelated namesake. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_DUBOWY_DISTRIBUTION"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Dubowy distribution and separate Vienna index lead",
          "record_date": "indexed records, 1600-present",
          "locality": "Former Austrian Galicia claimed in tree; separate Vienna, Austria index lead",
          "historical_detail": "Geneanet indexes Dubowy bearers and exposes Anton Dubowy in Vienna Catholic registers; broader distribution is concentrated in Germany with smaller Polish and Austrian counts. Neither source identifies Lazar, Solomon or a former-Galicia household.",
          "association": "Surname-level lead only; the next useful target is the original tree citation or a town-specific Galician record.",
          "alternatives": "Lazar may belong to another Dubowy household, the place may be later geographic shorthand, or the profile may contain a transcription error.",
          "assessment": "The imported father hypothesis remains low-confidence but is not contradicted by the broad chronology. No biological link beyond the imported profile is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DUBOWY_DISTRIBUTION"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "No dependable etymology was found. Forebears explicitly leaves the meaning unlisted; an unsupported Polish or Ukrainian derivation would overstate the evidence.",
          "caveat": "Surname rarity and distribution do not establish Lazar’s identity or parentage.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DUBOWY_DISTRIBUTION"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Dubowy is rare in indexed sources, with bearers chiefly in Germany and smaller distributions in Poland and Austria. This is compatible with a former Galicia hypothesis but cannot identify Lazar’s town, language or religion.",
          "caveat": "Surname rarity and distribution do not establish Lazar’s identity or parentage.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DUBOWY_DISTRIBUTION"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Geneanet indexes an Anton Dubowy in Vienna Catholic registers. This is a separate surname-level lead, not evidence that Anton was Lazar’s relative.",
          "caveat": "Surname rarity and distribution do not establish Lazar’s identity or parentage.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DUBOWY_DISTRIBUTION"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064794",
      "surname": "Cahn",
      "locality": "Morgan City / New Orleans, Louisiana; reported Metz origin unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Leon Cahn is independently documented in Louisiana: the official death index records an exact-name Leon Cahn dying 5 June 1924, age 72, and Morgan City records place an exact-name merchant in a 24 March 1879 land conveyance. The imported 1851-1852 Metz birth and parentage remain unbridged; checked Metz indexes do not establish them. H1 is the Louisiana identity; alternatives are another Leon Cahn, Cahn/Cahen/Kahn spelling conflation, or wrong Metz origin. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Local Louisiana evidence is materially stronger than the imported European birth claim. The surname history supplies context only and does not merge the separate Cahn/Kahn lines.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CAHN_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_CAHN_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
        "SRC_LA_SOS_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_CAHN_1924",
        "SRC_ST_MARY_BANNER_LEON_CAHN_LAND_CHAIN_1909",
        "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1851_CAHEN_INDEX_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1852_CAHN_NEGATIVE_CHECK"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Leon Cahn: Louisiana identity documented; Metz ancestry unresolved",
          "record_date": "1879-1924",
          "locality": "Morgan City and New Orleans, Louisiana; reported Metz, Moselle, France",
          "historical_detail": "An exact-name Leon Cahn appears in a 24 March 1879 Morgan City land conveyance, and the Louisiana Secretary of State death index records Leon Cahn, age 72, dying in Orleans Parish on 5 June 1924. The imported Metz birth remains unconfirmed: the checked 1852 index has no Leon Cahn/Cahen, and a possible 1851 Cahen entry has a conflicting act reference.",
          "association": "The continuity hypothesis is that the documented Louisiana merchant is the imported Leon and that Metz is his origin. Alternatives are another Leon, a spelling conflation, or a wrong European locality.",
          "alternatives": "Another Leon Cahn; Cahn/Cahen/Kahn transcription variation; wrong Metz origin; or separate Louisiana and European men.",
          "assessment": "The terminal root now records the strongest local evidence and the exact unresolved bridge. Parentage and a European birthplace remain uncommitted.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CAHN_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
            "SRC_ST_MARY_BANNER_LEON_CAHN_LAND_CHAIN_1909",
            "SRC_LA_SOS_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_CAHN_1924",
            "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1851_CAHEN_INDEX_CONFLICT",
            "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1852_CAHN_NEGATIVE_CHECK"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Cahn, Cahen, Cohn and Kahn are documented German/Jewish spelling forms associated with the Hebrew priestly designation Cohen.",
          "caveat": "The association describes a surname tradition, not a proof of descent from a particular Cahn family or priestly line.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CAHN_SURNAME_CONTEXT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Leon's documented later locality is Morgan City and New Orleans, Louisiana. The reported Metz origin remains a compiled hypothesis because the checked Metz birth indexes do not establish his birth.",
          "caveat": "Louisiana residence does not by itself identify the European birthplace or parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CAHN_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
            "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1851_CAHEN_INDEX_CONFLICT",
            "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1852_CAHN_NEGATIVE_CHECK"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "An exact-name Leon Cahn appears in a 24 March 1879 Morgan City land conveyance, and the Louisiana death index records his death on 5 June 1924. These are identity-specific Louisiana associations.",
          "caveat": "The records support the American identity but do not connect him to the imported Metz birth or to similarly named Cahn families.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ST_MARY_BANNER_LEON_CAHN_LAND_CHAIN_1909",
            "SRC_LA_SOS_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_CAHN_1924"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064854",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "research_limit": "The imported profile gives only Julienne, reports death at Lembach on 28 June 1824, and makes her Isaac Kieffer’s wife and Louis Kieffer’s mother. “Julienne” may be a given name, surname, or incomplete transcription. Lembach had 12 Jewish families in 1784 and 105 Jewish residents in 1807, so the locality is historically compatible, but the reviewed community history and Kieffer migration account do not name her. Bas-Rhin civil and Jewish death, marriage and household records are the next tests; no parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "The endpoint is a name-and-identity problem rather than a surname problem. Lembach continuity is plausible from locality and family context, but the woman remains unidentifiable.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JULIENNE_NAME_LIMIT",
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Julienne: Lembach locality recorded; name and ancestry unresolved",
          "record_date": "28 June 1824 reported death",
          "locality": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
          "historical_detail": "The imported tree names this woman only as Julienne, reports her death at Lembach on 28 June 1824, and makes her Isaac Kieffer’s wife and Louis Kieffer’s mother. Lembach’s Jewish community is documented from the eighteenth century, but the reviewed history and regional Kieffer account do not name her.",
          "association": "The continuity hypothesis is a Lembach woman in the Isaac Kieffer household. Alternatives are another Julienne, an incomplete or mistranscribed name, or a different Kieffer family.",
          "alternatives": "Another Julienne; given-name/surname misclassification; transcription error; wrong Lembach household; or unsupported Kieffer marriage.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint records the actual name and locality limit. Civil and Jewish death, marriage and household records are required before a surname or parent link can be added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JULIENNE_NAME_LIMIT",
            "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
            "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "No surname is established. “Julienne” is retained exactly as imported and may be a given name, surname, or incomplete transcription.",
          "caveat": "A name-only profile cannot support surname etymology or family continuity.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JULIENNE_NAME_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The only identity-specific locality is Lembach, where the profile reports her death on 28 June 1824. Lembach had an established Jewish community, including 12 families in 1784 and 105 residents in 1807.",
          "caveat": "Community presence makes Lembach plausible context but does not identify Julienne or prove a Kieffer marriage.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
            "ROOTS26_JULIENNE_NAME_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Published regional genealogy connects later Kieffer family members to Lembach, while the Lembach history documents the local Jewish institutions. Neither source names Julienne.",
          "caveat": "Later Kieffer and Lembach records are contextual leads, not evidence of her parents or birth family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
            "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064899",
      "surname": "Kallmann",
      "locality": "Alsace, France",
      "research_limit": "Rosalie Kallmann is reported about 1770–1860 in Alsace and as Seligmann Levy’s wife, but no exact town, birth, marriage, household, death, burial, occupation, property or parent record has been located. Ottrott-le-Bas Jewish records and the Bas-Rhin 1808 name-adoption material are the best next targets. H1 is the imported Rosalie; alternatives are another Kallmann woman, a spelling variant, or a later family conflation. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Rosalie Kallmann is reported about 1770–1860 in Alsace and as Seligmann Levy’s wife, but no exact town, birth, marriage, household, death, burial, occupation, property or parent record has been located. Ottrott-le-Bas Jewish records and the Bas-Rhin 1808 name-adoption material are the best next targets. H1 is the imported Rosalie; alternatives are another Kallmann woman, a spelling variant, or a later family conflation. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_KALLMANN_ALSACE",
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ottrott-le-Bas Jewish records as the direct Kallmann test",
          "record_date": "1808 name-adoption records and later civil holdings",
          "locality": "Ottrott-le-Bas, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
          "historical_detail": "Bas-Rhin archival guides identify Ottrott-le-Bas among Jewish name-adoption and civil-record communities; local Jewish history documents the synagogue and Jewish residents. No inspected entry names Rosalie Kallmann or links her to Seligmann Levy.",
          "association": "This locality-specific record route is more useful than broad surname distribution and should be searched once an exact Ottrott household is established.",
          "alternatives": "Another Kallmann woman, Kallman/Kallmann spelling variation, or a compiled family conflation remains possible.",
          "assessment": "The imported identity is a plausible locality hypothesis but remains below source-backed confidence; no ancestry edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KALLMANN_ALSACE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed FamilySearch Kallman result provides no reliable etymology for Kallmann. The spelling may have German-language or Jewish-Alsatian context, but no meaning is assigned without a stronger name dictionary source.",
          "caveat": "Locality and surname context do not identify Rosalie’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KALLMANN_ALSACE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported Alsace setting is compatible with the German-speaking Bas-Rhin record environment. It does not establish Rosalie’s town or distinguish Kallmann households.",
          "caveat": "Locality and surname context do not identify Rosalie’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KALLMANN_ALSACE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Ottrott-le-Bas had Jewish record and name-adoption holdings identified by the Bas-Rhin archives. This is a concrete search route; neither the archive guide nor local history names Rosalie.",
          "caveat": "Locality and surname context do not identify Rosalie’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KALLMANN_ALSACE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064902",
      "surname": "Kieffer",
      "locality": "Gunstett, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "research_limit": "Michel Leyser/Leiser Moyses Kieffer is reported born about 1736 and dead 6 August 1809 at Gunstett, as Isaac Kieffer’s father. The 1808 Bas-Rhin index lists Kieffer at Lembach and Strasbourg but not Gunstett, and no Gunstett entry for Moïse/Moyses, Moser or Michel. H1 is the imported identity; alternatives are another Gunstett surname, a wrong locality, spelling/transcription conflation, or a different Michel. Because the index is not a complete census, it weakens but does not disprove the profile; no new edge is added.",
      "notes": "Michel Leyser/Leiser Moyses Kieffer is reported born about 1736 and dead 6 August 1809 at Gunstett, as Isaac Kieffer’s father. The 1808 Bas-Rhin index lists Kieffer at Lembach and Strasbourg but not Gunstett, and no Gunstett entry for Moïse/Moyses, Moser or Michel. H1 is the imported identity; alternatives are another Gunstett surname, a wrong locality, spelling/transcription conflation, or a different Michel. Because the index is not a complete census, it weakens but does not disprove the profile; no new edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_GUNSTETT_NAME_INDEX_NEGATIVE_KIEFFER",
        "ROOTS26_KIEFFER_GUNSTETT_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "1808 Bas-Rhin surname-index conflict at Gunstett",
          "record_date": "1808 index; reported death 6 Aug 1809",
          "locality": "Gunstett / Lembach / Strasbourg, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
          "historical_detail": "The reviewed 1808 Jewish name-declaration index records Kieffer at Lembach and Strasbourg but not Gunstett; it also has no Gunstett entry for Moïse/Moyses, Moser or Michel. Gunstett civil and Jewish record holdings remain available for direct testing.",
          "association": "This is a meaningful identity conflict for the imported Michel Kieffer profile, while preserving the possibility of an alternate surname or omitted declaration.",
          "alternatives": "Wrong locality, spelling/transcription conflation, another Michel, or an incomplete index remain possible.",
          "assessment": "The reported identity is low-confidence and should not be merged with Lembach/Strasbourg Kieffer families without a person-specific record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_GUNSTETT_NAME_INDEX_NEGATIVE_KIEFFER",
            "ROOTS26_KIEFFER_GUNSTETT_CONTEXT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Kieffer is generally treated as a German/Alsatian occupational surname related to Küfer, a cooper or barrel-maker. That meaning does not identify Michel or establish a Gunstett family.",
          "caveat": "The index comparison weakens the imported name-place combination but cannot exclude an alternate surname, omission, or later conflation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_GUNSTETT_NAME_INDEX_NEGATIVE_KIEFFER",
            "ROOTS26_KIEFFER_GUNSTETT_CONTEXT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname is compatible with German-speaking Alsace, while the reviewed 1808 index places Kieffer declarations at Lembach and Strasbourg rather than Gunstett. The place conflict is material but not conclusive because name-declaration indexes are incomplete.",
          "caveat": "The index comparison weakens the imported name-place combination but cannot exclude an alternate surname, omission, or later conflation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_GUNSTETT_NAME_INDEX_NEGATIVE_KIEFFER",
            "ROOTS26_KIEFFER_GUNSTETT_CONTEXT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Gunstett civil-table and Jewish-record holdings provide a concrete route to test the reported 1809 death and household. The 1808 comparison specifically lacks Kieffer, Moïse/Moyses, Moser and Michel entries for Gunstett, so a death act or Jewish register is needed.",
          "caveat": "The index comparison weakens the imported name-place combination but cannot exclude an alternate surname, omission, or later conflation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_GUNSTETT_NAME_INDEX_NEGATIVE_KIEFFER",
            "ROOTS26_KIEFFER_GUNSTETT_CONTEXT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064970",
      "surname": "Coguenhem",
      "locality": "Metz, Departement de la Moselle, Lorraine, France",
      "research_limit": "Michel Coguenhem is reported born at Metz in 1827 and dead 1 November 1874, but the official Metz 1823–1832 birth tables contain no Coguenhem entry. The 1872 nationality-option record is an exact-name candidate without age, family, occupation or address. H1 is the imported Michel; alternatives are a wrong birthplace, spelling variant, or another household. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Michel Coguenhem is reported born at Metz in 1827 and dead 1 November 1874, but the official Metz 1823–1832 birth tables contain no Coguenhem entry. The 1872 nationality-option record is an exact-name candidate without age, family, occupation or address. H1 is the imported Michel; alternatives are a wrong birthplace, spelling variant, or another household. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_COGUENHEM_RARITY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Metz birth-table negative and 1872 nationality-option candidate",
          "record_date": "1823–1832 birth tables; 1872 nationality option",
          "locality": "Metz, Moselle, Lorraine, France",
          "historical_detail": "The official Metz ten-year birth index has no Coguenhem entry for the reported 1827 birth. A 1872 nationality-option index contains Michel Coguenhem but lacks age, family, occupation and address.",
          "association": "The birthplace claim needs a variant or different municipality, and the option record needs corroborating family detail.",
          "alternatives": "Wrong birthplace, surname transcription, or another Michel remain possible.",
          "assessment": "Regional rarity supports focused research, but identity remains low-confidence and no parent edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_COGUENHEM_RARITY",
            "SRC_METZ_TD_1823_1832_BIRTH_MARRIAGE_INDEX_20260729",
            "SRC_FRENCH_CITIZENSHIP_OPTANT_MICHEL_COGUENHEM_1872"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "No dependable Coguenhem etymology was found; the reviewed sources provide rarity and records only.",
          "caveat": "Rarity and locality evidence do not identify Michel’s parent household.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_COGUENHEM_RARITY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Indexed bearers are concentrated in Moselle and nearby French departments, compatible with Lorraine context but not proof of a Metz birth.",
          "caveat": "Rarity and locality evidence do not identify Michel’s parent household.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_COGUENHEM_RARITY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Metz birth-table negative and 1872 nationality-option entry define the direct research boundary; neither names Michel’s parents.",
          "caveat": "Rarity and locality evidence do not identify Michel’s parent household.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_COGUENHEM_RARITY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064980",
      "surname": "Loeb",
      "locality": "Bavaria, Germany",
      "research_limit": "Pauline Loeb is reported born about 1839 somewhere in Bavaria. Loeb/Löb is a widespread Ashkenazi Jewish form and can also occur as a personal-name-derived surname, so the name alone cannot select a household. JewishGen provides indexed 19th-century Bavarian-Swabian civil records, but no exact Pauline household record was located in this review. H1 is the imported Pauline; alternatives are another Loeb woman, a spelling variant such as Löb/Loew/Löw, or a non-Bavarian birthplace. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Pauline Loeb is reported born about 1839 somewhere in Bavaria. Loeb/Löb is a widespread Ashkenazi Jewish form and can also occur as a personal-name-derived surname, so the name alone cannot select a household. JewishGen provides indexed 19th-century Bavarian-Swabian civil records, but no exact Pauline household record was located in this review. H1 is the imported Pauline; alternatives are another Loeb woman, a spelling variant such as Löb/Loew/Löw, or a non-Bavarian birthplace. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LOEB_BAVARIA_RECORDS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Bavaria-Swabia Jewish civil-record collection",
          "record_date": "19th century",
          "locality": "Bavaria-Swabia, Germany",
          "historical_detail": "JewishGen describes an integrated database of 19th-century Bavarian-Swabian Jewish civil records transcribed from copies supplied by the Bavarian State Archive, including births, marriages, deaths, Matrikel and circumcisions.",
          "association": "This is the most promising documented route for testing a Pauline Loeb born about 1839, but the current tree supplies no town, household, or record identifier to select an entry.",
          "alternatives": "Another Loeb/Löb/Loew woman, a spelling variant, or a birthplace outside Bavaria could produce the same reported profile.",
          "assessment": "The surname and regional context justify a focused search, while the identity remains an unproved compiled-tree hypothesis and no parent edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LOEB_BAVARIA_RECORDS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Loeb, Löb, Löw, Loew and related forms are described by FamilySearch as Ashkenazi Jewish names or personal-name forms associated with the lion symbolism of Judah; this is surname context, not proof of Pauline’s religion or ancestry.",
          "caveat": "Surname meaning and a regional database route do not identify Pauline or prove the imported family links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LOEB_BAVARIA_RECORDS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The spelling is compatible with German-speaking and Ashkenazi Jewish communities, including Bavaria, but it is not geographically specific enough to identify Pauline’s town.",
          "caveat": "Surname meaning and a regional database route do not identify Pauline or prove the imported family links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LOEB_BAVARIA_RECORDS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "JewishGen’s Bavaria-Swabia collection contains 19th-century civil records copied from Bavarian State Archive materials, including births, marriages, deaths, Matrikel and circumcisions; a town or household is still needed before an exact search can be made.",
          "caveat": "Surname meaning and a regional database route do not identify Pauline or prove the imported family links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LOEB_BAVARIA_RECORDS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065072",
      "surname": "Rosser",
      "locality": "Lembach, Bas-rhin, France",
      "research_limit": "The imported tree places Samuel Rosser or Roser in Lembach about 1765 and makes him father of Bernard Baruch Roser. A local Jewish-community history confirms a Lembach Jewish community but does not name Samuel; a much later Evansville Samuel Roser is not safely the same man. Bas-Rhin register catalogs provide a route for searching Rosser/Roser households, but no birth, marriage, household, death, occupation, property or parent record has yet identified Samuel.",
      "notes": "H1: Samuel belonged to the Lembach Rosser/Roser community and was the father of Bernard. Alternatives are a different Lembach namesake, a spelling conflation, or an unrelated Jewish household. The later Evansville Samuel is retained only as a possible community or family associate, not merged with the deceased-before-1836 candidate. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
        "SRC_EVANSVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_1849_PRESENT",
        "ROOTS26ROSSER_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_LEMBACH_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Lembach Rosser/Roser record route and later Evansville namesake",
          "record_date": "reported c.1765; register coverage 1638–1688 and 1750 onward; Evansville 1857",
          "locality": "Lembach, Bas-Rhin, Alsace; later Evansville, Indiana",
          "historical_detail": "Bas-Rhin catalogs Lembach Protestant baptisms, marriages and burials from 1638–1688 with gaps, and later records continue through the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Local Jewish-community research places a later Samuel Roser among probable 1857 Evansville congregation members, while Bernard died there in 1867. No inspected entry names the imported Samuel or proves a father-son link.",
          "association": "The Lembach registers are the direct local test for the reported ancestor; the Evansville record is a separately dated community association that may aid migration research.",
          "alternatives": "The Lembach candidate may be another Rosser/Roser, a spelling variant in a different household, or unrelated to the later Evansville Samuel. The late record cannot identify an Alsace man reported dead before 1836.",
          "assessment": "Locality and a rare surname make this a focused research lead, but the identity bridge remains unproved and no ancestry edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
            "SRC_EVANSVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_1849_PRESENT",
            "ROOTS26_LEMBACH_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Rosser has separate Welsh and German explanations: Welsh from R(h)osier, equivalent to Roger; German Rösser from horse-related work or a flax-retting pool. These alternatives do not establish Samuel’s language, occupation or ethnicity.",
          "caveat": "Samuel’s identity and Rosser/Roser spelling are not established by an inspected contemporary record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26ROSSER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported Lembach setting is compatible with German-language Alsace records and with either Rosser or Roser/Rösser spelling, but the surname dictionary also records a Welsh history. No specific origin is assigned to Samuel.",
          "caveat": "Samuel’s identity and Rosser/Roser spelling are not established by an inspected contemporary record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26ROSSER_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_LEMBACH_REGISTERS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Lembach’s Jewish community and its parish-register record system are the relevant local associations. The later Evansville Samuel Roser provides a separate nineteenth-century community clue but does not prove continuity with the Alsace man.",
          "caveat": "Samuel’s identity and Rosser/Roser spelling are not established by an inspected contemporary record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
            "SRC_EVANSVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_1849_PRESENT",
            "ROOTS26_LEMBACH_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065162",
      "surname": "Seligman",
      "locality": "Romanswiller, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "research_limit": "Rösel Seligman is reported born in Romanswiller in 1732 and living after 30 November 1784, as Baruch Klotz’s wife and Eve Klotz’s mother. Romanswiller had a documented Jewish community by the relevant period, but no produced birth, marriage, household, death, burial, occupation, property, or parent record names Rösel. H1 is the imported Rösel; alternatives are another Rösel Seligman, a spelling/given-name variant, or a conflated household. The spouse and maternity links remain low-confidence and no new edge is added.",
      "notes": "Rösel Seligman is reported born in Romanswiller in 1732 and living after 30 November 1784, as Baruch Klotz’s wife and Eve Klotz’s mother. Romanswiller had a documented Jewish community by the relevant period, but no produced birth, marriage, household, death, burial, occupation, property, or parent record names Rösel. H1 is the imported Rösel; alternatives are another Rösel Seligman, a spelling/given-name variant, or a conflated household. The spouse and maternity links remain low-confidence and no new edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_SEligMAN_ROMANSWILLER_ARCHIVES"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Romanswiller Jewish community in the reported period",
          "record_date": "1716 and 1784; civil registers from 1792",
          "locality": "Romanswiller, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
          "historical_detail": "Local Jewish-history sources attest Jewish presence from the second half of the seventeenth century and report 26 families in 1716 and 41 families/206 people in 1784. FamilySearch catalogs Romanswiller civil registers beginning in 1792.",
          "association": "This supports the locality as a credible research setting for a 1732 Jewish birth claim, but it does not identify Rösel Seligman or her family.",
          "alternatives": "Another Seligman woman, a variant given-name spelling, or conflation of households remains possible.",
          "assessment": "The place-period hypothesis is plausible and testable, while direct identity and parentage remain unproved; no parent edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SEligMAN_ROMANSWILLER_ARCHIVES"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Seligman/Seligmann is a German-language surname meaning “fortunate man” or “blessed man”; the meaning is not a unique genealogical identifier.",
          "caveat": "Community size and surname meaning do not identify Rösel or prove the Klotz household links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SEligMAN_ROMANSWILLER_ARCHIVES",
            "SRC_ROMANSWILLER_RECORDS_RESEARCH_CONTEXT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported locality is Romanswiller in Alsace. Jewish presence is attested from the second half of the seventeenth century, with 26 families in 1716 and 41 families in 1784, making the place-period combination plausible but not person-specific.",
          "caveat": "Community size and surname meaning do not identify Rösel or prove the Klotz household links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SEligMAN_ROMANSWILLER_ARCHIVES",
            "SRC_ROMANSWILLER_RECORDS_RESEARCH_CONTEXT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1784 population context and the catalogued Romanswiller civil registers provide a concrete route for testing the household. The current review found no record naming Rösel, Baruch Klotz, or Eve together.",
          "caveat": "Community size and surname meaning do not identify Rösel or prove the Klotz household links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SEligMAN_ROMANSWILLER_ARCHIVES",
            "SRC_ROMANSWILLER_RECORDS_RESEARCH_CONTEXT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065174",
      "surname": "Klotz",
      "locality": "Wissembourg, Bas Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "research_limit": "The original tree reports Hayim Haim Klotz at Wissembourg about 1690–1762 and as father of Baruch or Bosig Klotz. Regional research confirms Klotz as one of the relatively rare established surnames in the Wissembourg Jewish context, but no inspected birth, marriage contract, census household, death, burial or parent record identifies Hayim. The 1596–1793 parish-register catalog is a concrete route, not proof that a Jewish Klotz appears in those Christian registers.",
      "notes": "H1: the imported Hayim profile belongs to the Wissembourg Klotz surname cluster. Alternatives are a different Klotz household, a conflation of Jewish given-name-plus-father-name records, or an incorrect father-son assignment to Baruch/Bosig. The 1784 census and marriage-contract study provide local context, while the surname and dates remain low-confidence. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_GENAMI_ALSACE_1784_CENSUS_DATABASE",
        "ROOTS26_KLOTZ_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_WISSEMBOURG_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Wissembourg Klotz context and register route",
          "record_date": "1784 census; 1596–1793 parish-register catalog",
          "locality": "Wissembourg, Bas-Rhin, Alsace",
          "historical_detail": "A regional study correlates Wissembourg Jewish marriage contracts, the 1784 census and 1808 names, and identifies Klotz among the few established surnames in that context. The FamilySearch catalog lists Saint-Michel Wissembourg baptism, marriage and burial registers from 1596 to 1793. No reviewed entry names Hayim Haim Klotz or proves his reported dates.",
          "association": "The established local Klotz surname and matching town make a wider-family continuity hypothesis worth testing in the census, contracts and local archive records.",
          "alternatives": "Another Wissembourg Klotz household, a conflation of similarly named Jewish men, or an incorrect Baruch/Bosig parent assignment remains possible. The Christian register catalog is a search route, not direct evidence for this Jewish profile.",
          "assessment": "The surname/locality association is stronger than a name-only match because it rests on a specific regional study, but no parent or event is promoted without an identity-secure record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_GENAMI_ALSACE_1784_CENSUS_DATABASE",
            "ROOTS26_WISSEMBOURG_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Klotz is a German nickname from Middle High German klotz, “lump” or “block”; the Ashkenazic Jewish form is cognate with it or Yiddish klots. This meaning does not describe Hayim’s occupation or character.",
          "caveat": "The imported Hayim profile and father-son link are not established by an inspected contemporary record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KLOTZ_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname has German and Ashkenazic Jewish explanations. Wissembourg regional research reports Klotz among the relatively rare established surnames in the local Jewish context, but that does not prove Hayim’s precise origin or a single Klotz lineage.",
          "caveat": "The imported Hayim profile and father-son link are not established by an inspected contemporary record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KLOTZ_DAFN",
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The strongest local association is Wissembourg’s Jewish marriage-contract and 1784-census evidence, where Klotz appears among established surnames. The catalogued Christian parish registers are a separate record system and should not be assumed to contain this Jewish household.",
          "caveat": "The imported Hayim profile and father-son link are not established by an inspected contemporary record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_GENAMI_ALSACE_1784_CENSUS_DATABASE",
            "ROOTS26_WISSEMBOURG_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065178",
      "surname": "Levy",
      "locality": "Wintzenheim, Haut-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "research_limit": "Mosché Levy is reported born about 1690 at Wintzenheim and dead about 1760, as Judith Levy’s husband and Jacques Levy’s father. In the Alsatian Jewish context, Levy could denote levitical descent or a personal-name/patronymic usage rather than a unique hereditary surname. H1 is the imported Mosché; alternatives include another Levy household, a different Mosché/Jacques parent, or conflation with the separate Michel Machole Levy reconstruction. Wintzenheim context is plausible, but no inspected original record identifies him; no new parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Mosché Levy is reported born about 1690 at Wintzenheim and dead about 1760, as Judith Levy’s husband and Jacques Levy’s father. In the Alsatian Jewish context, Levy could denote levitical descent or a personal-name/patronymic usage rather than a unique hereditary surname. H1 is the imported Mosché; alternatives include another Levy household, a different Mosché/Jacques parent, or conflation with the separate Michel Machole Levy reconstruction. Wintzenheim context is plausible, but no inspected original record identifies him; no new parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEVY_WINTZENHEIM_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Wintzenheim Jewish community and notarial record route",
          "record_date": "17th–18th centuries; 1782 protected-person list",
          "locality": "Wintzenheim, Haut-Rhin, Alsace, France",
          "historical_detail": "Regional history records Jewish residents in Wintzenheim from the seventeenth century; archival guides identify an 1782 protected-person list and Wintzenheim notarial material from 1659–1789, including marriage contracts, testaments, inventories and partitions.",
          "association": "These records make the imported place-period hypothesis testable and may resolve Mosché’s household, but none was inspected here for him.",
          "alternatives": "Another Levy household, a patronymic rather than fixed surname, or the separate Michel Machole Levy reconstruction remains possible.",
          "assessment": "Local continuity is plausible and the archive route is specific, but identity and parentage remain low-confidence; no new edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEVY_WINTZENHEIM_CONTEXT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Levy/Levi is a Jewish surname and religious lineage marker associated with Levites; in early Alsatian records it may be a status or patronymic label rather than a unique hereditary surname.",
          "caveat": "Levy’s religious/patronymic usage and local community history do not identify Mosché or prove the Judith/Jacques links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEVY_WINTZENHEIM_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Wintzenheim had Jewish residents from the seventeenth century and became a major rural Alsatian community. The locality fits the imported profile, but the broad Levy name cannot select Mosché’s household.",
          "caveat": "Levy’s religious/patronymic usage and local community history do not identify Mosché or prove the Judith/Jacques links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEVY_WINTZENHEIM_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Regional history records seventeenth- and eighteenth-century Jewish residents and occupations in Wintzenheim. Archives d’Alsace identify an 1782 protected-person list and 1659–1789 notarial material including marriage contracts, testaments and inventories, providing concrete routes to test the family.",
          "caveat": "Levy’s religious/patronymic usage and local community history do not identify Mosché or prove the Judith/Jacques links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEVY_WINTZENHEIM_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065204",
      "surname": "Levy",
      "locality": "Ottrott-le-Bas, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
      "research_limit": "Judith Levy is reported born about 1695 and dead about 1760 at Ottrott, as Mosché Levy’s wife and Jacques Levy’s mother. Ottrott had a small Jewish community, and surviving Israelite registers begin in 1785–1786, later than the reported life. H1 is the imported Judith; alternatives are another Judith Levy, a patronymic or spelling variant, or conflation with the separate Michel Machole Levy reconstruction. No reviewed record names her; no new edge is added.",
      "notes": "Judith Levy is reported born about 1695 and dead about 1760 at Ottrott, as Mosché Levy’s wife and Jacques Levy’s mother. Ottrott had a small Jewish community, and surviving Israelite registers begin in 1785–1786, later than the reported life. H1 is the imported Judith; alternatives are another Judith Levy, a patronymic or spelling variant, or conflation with the separate Michel Machole Levy reconstruction. No reviewed record names her; no new edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_OTTROTT_ISRAELITE_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ottrott Jewish community, Jacob Levy and surviving registers",
          "record_date": "1784 population context; 1785–1786 Israelite registers",
          "locality": "Ottrott-le-Bas, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France",
          "historical_detail": "A published 1784 Jewish population transcription lists Jacob Levy as a schoolmaster at Ottrott; the Bas-Rhin archival catalog identifies surviving Ottrott-le-Bas Israelite NMD registers for 1785–1786 and later civil holdings.",
          "association": "This confirms local Levy and Jewish-community context, but the records are either a different person or later than Judith’s reported life and do not name her.",
          "alternatives": "Another Judith Levy, patronymic usage, spelling variation, or conflation with the Michel Machole Levy reconstruction remains possible.",
          "assessment": "The place and community setting are plausible and testable, but direct identity and parentage remain low-confidence; no new edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_OTTROTT_ISRAELITE_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Levy/Levi may denote Levite status or a patronymic/religious lineage rather than a unique hereditary surname in early Alsatian Jewish records. Shared Levy naming cannot prove Judith and Mosché were a documented couple.",
          "caveat": "A local Levy bearer and community records do not identify Judith or prove the Levy household links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_OTTROTT_ISRAELITE_REGISTERS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported locality is Ottrott-le-Bas. Municipal history documents a small Jewish community; the archival catalog identifies surviving Israelite NMD registers for 1785–1786 and later holdings, but these postdate most of Judith’s reported life.",
          "caveat": "A local Levy bearer and community records do not identify Judith or prove the Levy household links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_OTTROTT_ISRAELITE_REGISTERS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1784 Jewish population material names a Jacob Levy as schoolmaster at Ottrott, demonstrating a local Levy bearer near the period, but it does not identify Judith or her household.",
          "caveat": "A local Levy bearer and community records do not identify Judith or prove the Levy household links.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_OTTROTT_ISRAELITE_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065260",
      "surname": "Machole Levy",
      "locality": "Alsace, France; birthplace unresolved",
      "research_limit": "The original tree reports Machole Levy born about 1725 as Bösel Macholé Levy’s father, but supplies no birthplace or original record. H1 is the imported Machole; alternatives are a patronymic reading of Bösel Macholé, another Levy household, or conflation with the separate Michel Machole candidate. No new edge is added.",
      "notes": "The original tree reports Machole Levy born about 1725 as Bösel Macholé Levy’s father, but supplies no birthplace or original record. H1 is the imported Machole; alternatives are a patronymic reading of Bösel Macholé, another Levy household, or conflation with the separate Michel Machole candidate. No new edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Machole Levy name evidence and competing household hypotheses",
          "record_date": "1784 enumeration; 1806 burial; reported birth about 1725",
          "locality": "Ottrott / Rosenwiller, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France (for Michel candidate)",
          "historical_detail": "The 1784 Ottrott material and a Rosenwiller cemetery-memory transcription identify a Machole/Michaël as associated with Jacques/Jeckel Levy’s father. A separate Marmoutier reconstruction documents other Macholé Levy families without connecting them to Ottrott.",
          "association": "The Michel candidate has direct father-name support for Jacques; the original Machole profile remains an unlocated alternative and cannot be merged solely by the compound name.",
          "alternatives": "Another Michel, a patronymic-only interpretation, or an unrelated Marmoutier family remains possible.",
          "assessment": "The evidence supports keeping the candidates separate and ranking Michel’s father identity above the unsupported 1725 profile, without inventing a parent link.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Levy/Levi may denote Levite status or a patronymic/religious lineage rather than a unique hereditary surname in early Alsatian Jewish records. The compound Machole/Macholé may preserve a personal-name or patronymic element, but its exact usage is not established here.",
          "caveat": "Shared Levy/Machole naming and regional Jewish context do not identify one household or justify merging the two candidates.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The direct locality is unresolved for Machole. The stronger Michel candidate is tied to Jacques/Jeckel Levy’s Ottrott/Rosenwiller evidence; separate Marmoutier Macholé families are documented as alternatives, not merged ancestors.",
          "caveat": "Shared Levy/Machole naming and regional Jewish context do not identify one household or justify merging the two candidates.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1784 Ottrott enumeration and 1806 Rosenwiller cemetery-memory transcription provide the specific father-name evidence for Michel Machole Levy. The original Machole profile has no equivalent person-specific record.",
          "caveat": "Shared Levy/Machole naming and regional Jewish context do not identify one household or justify merging the two candidates.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065380",
      "surname": "Frank",
      "locality": "Oberlustadt, Lustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "research_limit": "Salomon Frank is reported born about 1729 and dead in 1807 at Oberlustadt. The 1808 name-adoption list records a younger Salomon Frank under the patronymic Daotteres b Samolon, directly supporting a father named Salomon/Samolon but not the elder man’s surname, age, wife, occupation, death, or parents. H1 is the imported elder Salomon; alternatives are another Salomon in Oberlustadt, a patronymic misread, or conflation of generations. The 1809/10 local household listing is later than the reported death and cannot identify him retrospectively; no new parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Salomon Frank is reported born about 1729 and dead in 1807 at Oberlustadt. The 1808 name-adoption list records a younger Salomon Frank under the patronymic Daotteres b Samolon, directly supporting a father named Salomon/Samolon but not the elder man’s surname, age, wife, occupation, death, or parents. H1 is the imported elder Salomon; alternatives are another Salomon in Oberlustadt, a patronymic misread, or conflation of generations. The 1809/10 local household listing is later than the reported death and cannot identify him retrospectively; no new parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
        "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Salomon Frank patronymic and Oberlustadt household context",
          "record_date": "1808 name adoption; 1809/10 household list",
          "locality": "Oberlustadt, Lustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
          "historical_detail": "The 1808 declaration records the younger Salomon Frank under Daotteres b Samolon, directly indicating a father named Salomon/Samolon. A published 1809/10 community list names Salomon Frank as a butcher among Oberlustadt Jewish household heads.",
          "association": "The patronymic makes an elder Salomon in the correct community a credible candidate; the later household listing supplies local continuity but cannot by itself identify the imported elder born about 1729.",
          "alternatives": "Another Salomon, patronymic misreading, or generational conflation remains possible.",
          "assessment": "This is stronger than a bare name match, but it does not prove the elder’s wife, parents, or dates; no new edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
            "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Frank is a Germanic surname from the ethnonym for a Frank or French person and can arise independently in multiple families. It does not establish a unique Oberlustadt lineage.",
          "caveat": "The patronymic supports a Salomon father but does not identify the elder’s complete household or prove the reported dates.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
            "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported locality is Oberlustadt in the former Palatinate. The 1808 name-adoption list and 1809/10 Jewish household history document the local Frank household context, while the elder birth and death dates remain unverified.",
          "caveat": "The patronymic supports a Salomon father but does not identify the elder’s complete household or prove the reported dates.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
            "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1808 patronymic is the strongest evidence: it identifies a younger Salomon Frank as son of Salomon/Samolon. Alemannia Judaica later lists Salomon Frank as an Oberlustadt butcher in 1809/10, but that adult is not automatically the imported elder.",
          "caveat": "The patronymic supports a Salomon father but does not identify the elder’s complete household or prove the reported dates.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
            "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065385",
      "surname": "Moses",
      "locality": "Lustadt / Oberlustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
      "research_limit": "Regina Moses is reported born in Lustadt in 1726 and dead in Oberlustadt on 15 November 1820, as wife of elder Salomon Frank and mother of younger Salomon. The 1808 name-adoption evidence identifies the younger Salomon and his father, but does not name Regina. H1 is the imported Regina; alternatives are another Regina Moses, an unrecorded or differently indexed wife, or a conflated mother. The lifespan and relationships remain possible but unproved; no new parent or spouse edge is added.",
      "notes": "Regina Moses is reported born in Lustadt in 1726 and dead in Oberlustadt on 15 November 1820, as wife of elder Salomon Frank and mother of younger Salomon. The 1808 name-adoption evidence identifies the younger Salomon and his father, but does not name Regina. H1 is the imported Regina; alternatives are another Regina Moses, an unrecorded or differently indexed wife, or a conflated mother. The lifespan and relationships remain possible but unproved; no new parent or spouse edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MOSES_LUSTADT_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Oberlustadt Jewish community and Frank household context",
          "record_date": "1808–1810; community documented from late 18th/early 19th century",
          "locality": "Oberlustadt, Lustadt, Germersheim, Rheinland-Pfalz, Germany",
          "historical_detail": "The 1808 name-adoption material identifies the younger Salomon Frank and his father; Alemannia Judaica lists Salomon Frank as a Jewish household head and butcher in Oberlustadt in 1809/10. The same local history places a Jewish community and cemetery in the late eighteenth or early nineteenth century.",
          "association": "This local continuity is compatible with the imported Frank household in which Regina is reported as wife and mother, but neither source names Regina or proves the reported 1726–1820 life.",
          "alternatives": "Another Regina Moses, a missing or variantly recorded wife, or a conflation of two generations remains possible.",
          "assessment": "The locality and household context make the imported hypothesis worth targeted archival testing; confidence is not raised without a record naming Regina.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MOSES_LUSTADT_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
            "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "FamilySearch describes Moses as a surname from the biblical personal name of Moses, with Jewish, Welsh, African American and African uses. The meaning does not identify Regina’s family.",
          "caveat": "Local community evidence and surname meaning do not prove Regina’s identity or parentage.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MOSES_LUSTADT_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
            "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported locality is Lustadt/Oberlustadt in the former Palatinate. A local Jewish community and cemetery are documented by the late eighteenth or early nineteenth century, compatible with the family setting but not proof of Regina’s 1726 birth.",
          "caveat": "Local community evidence and surname meaning do not prove Regina’s identity or parentage.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MOSES_LUSTADT_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
            "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Alemannia Judaica lists Salomon Frank among Oberlustadt Jewish household heads in 1809/10 and identifies his trade as butcher. This is useful context for Regina’s reported household, while the exact wife/mother identification still depends on a marriage, death, household, or name-adoption record.",
          "caveat": "Local community evidence and surname meaning do not prove Regina’s identity or parentage.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MOSES_LUSTADT_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
            "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065430",
      "surname": "Cahn Kahn",
      "locality": "Donaldsonville, Ascension Parish, Louisiana, USA",
      "research_limit": "Leo or Loeb Cahn/Kahn is reported about 1780 with an undated Donaldsonville death, wife Rosa Lorch and daughter Clara, but no passenger, census, naturalization, occupation, cemetery, probate, marriage or parent record connects him to Clara. Donaldsonville’s 1860 Hebrew Bikur Cholim charter includes L. Cahn and M. Cahn, but initials cannot identify an eighty-year-old Leo. H1 is the imported father; alternatives are another Cahn/Kahn merchant, a spelling conflation, or a later family reconstruction. No parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Leo or Loeb Cahn/Kahn is reported about 1780 with an undated Donaldsonville death, wife Rosa Lorch and daughter Clara, but no passenger, census, naturalization, occupation, cemetery, probate, marriage or parent record connects him to Clara. Donaldsonville’s 1860 Hebrew Bikur Cholim charter includes L. Cahn and M. Cahn, but initials cannot identify an eighty-year-old Leo. H1 is the imported father; alternatives are another Cahn/Kahn merchant, a spelling conflation, or a later family reconstruction. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CAHN_DAFN",
        "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Donaldsonville Hebrew Bikur Cholim charter, 1860",
          "record_date": "9 Feb 1860",
          "locality": "Donaldsonville, Ascension Parish, Louisiana, USA",
          "historical_detail": "The local Jewish-history account reproduces the 1860 charter and lists L. Cahn and M. Cahn among the society’s members. It does not expand initials or connect either signer to Leo, Rosa Lorch or Clara Cahn.",
          "association": "This is the strongest locality-specific Cahn lead currently found, but it is a community association rather than an identity or parentage record.",
          "alternatives": "The signers may be other Cahn men, Leo may have used Loeb/Kahn, or the imported family may be conflated.",
          "assessment": "Donaldsonville locality and Cahn surname support a focused research hypothesis, but no direct ancestry edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CAHN_DAFN",
            "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Cahn is reported as a Jewish variant of Cohen or an Americanized form of North German Kahn. This does not identify Leo or prove a priestly Cohen lineage.",
          "caveat": "The local charter and surname history do not identify Leo’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CAHN_DAFN",
            "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The Cahn/Kahn spelling pair fits German-speaking Jewish migration into Louisiana, but Donaldsonville alone does not distinguish households or establish an Alsatian, German or other origin.",
          "caveat": "The local charter and surname history do not identify Leo’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CAHN_DAFN",
            "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1860 Donaldsonville Hebrew Bikur Cholim charter lists L. Cahn and M. Cahn among Jewish community members. The initials are a local association, not proof they were Leo or his relatives.",
          "caveat": "The local charter and surname history do not identify Leo’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CAHN_DAFN",
            "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "person_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810065434",
      "surname": "Lorch",
      "locality": "No locality recorded; Clara Cahn is reported at Mainz",
      "research_limit": "Rosa Lorch is known only from the imported tree as Leo Cahn/Kahn's wife and Clara Cahn's mother, with death before 1823. No birthplace, residence, marriage, death place, household, burial, probate, or parent record identifies her. H1 is the imported wife/mother; alternatives are another Rosa Lorch, a married-name or transcription error, or a later reconstruction of Clara's parentage. The next identity-specific bridge is Clara's Mainz birth, marriage, or household record; no parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "The surname has a documented German place-name interpretation, and later Lorch families are recorded in Lorsch, but neither establishes Rosa's locality or ancestry.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LORCH_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_LORSCH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY",
        "ROOTS26_LORCH_RESEARCH_LIMIT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Rosa Lorch identity and locality remain unresolved",
          "record_date": "before 1823; exact dates unknown",
          "locality": "No locality recorded; daughter Clara reported Mainz",
          "historical_detail": "The imported tree names Rosa Lorch as Leo Cahn/Kahn's wife and Clara Cahn's mother, with death before 1823, but supplies no identifying locality or record. A later Lorch family is documented in Lorsch, including Simon Lorch in a 1928 synagogue account; that event is preserved as separate surname context rather than a proposed connection.",
          "association": "The plausible continuity hypothesis is a German-speaking Lorch family associated with Clara's Mainz context. The competing explanations are another Rosa Lorch, a transcription or married-name problem, or an unsupported parent reconstruction.",
          "alternatives": "Another Rosa Lorch; Lorch/Lorsch or other spelling variation; wrong locality; or a different mother for Clara.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint remains visible with a specific research limit. Surname context is documented, but no biological parent edge or Lorch locality is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LORCH_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
            "ROOTS26_LORSCH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY",
            "ROOTS26_LORCH_RESEARCH_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Lorch is described as a German habitational surname from one of several places called Lorch. The place-name explanation is plausible for German-speaking families but does not identify Rosa or distinguish Lorch from unrelated bearers.",
          "caveat": "Surname meaning is not proof of a shared lineage.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LORCH_SURNAME_CONTEXT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No birthplace or migration origin is recorded for Rosa. The only geographic context is the reported Mainz birth of daughter Clara Cahn; a Lorsch Jewish community example is a later, separate name-bearing record.",
          "caveat": "Mainz, Lorsch, and other places called Lorch must not be merged without an identity-specific record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LORCH_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
            "ROOTS26_LORSCH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Alemannia-Judaica records a Lorch family in Lorsch and names Simon Lorch in a 1928 synagogue-community account. This supplies a concrete historical Lorch association while remaining explicitly separate from Rosa.",
          "caveat": "The record is more than a century later and does not name Rosa, Leo Cahn, or Clara Cahn.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LORSCH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "person_id": "GEN7_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_FATHER_I196",
      "surname": "Brassington",
      "locality": "Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "research_limit": "John’s Ranton household is identified through the children of John and Jane and his 1805 will, proved in 1810. His baptism and parents remain unresolved. The John baptized at Chelmorton in 1739 is a possible identification: the age fits, but no family or property connection yet ties that baptism to Ranton.",
      "notes": "The continuing Jane household distinguishes this family from the John who married Mary Swindell in 1765. That does not by itself settle which adult was the Chelmorton child. The 1761 Stafford marriage licence could supply a useful age, residence or bondsman; its original has not been inspected. Ranton is John’s documented residence, not an established birthplace.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
        "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_JANE_SILVESTER_MARRIAGE_1761",
        "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1739",
        "ROOTS26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_REVIEW"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Thomas Brassington’s burial at Ranton",
          "record_date": "9 September 1774",
          "locality": "Ranton, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The parish compilation lists this burial without an age or named relatives.",
          "association": "A shared surname in John’s parish during his adult life makes a family connection plausible.",
          "alternatives": "Thomas could be an older relative, a younger member of the wider family, or someone from a separate Brassington household.",
          "assessment": "The entry does not establish his generation. It cannot yet distinguish a father from other relatives; the burial register or probate may provide that missing context.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_REVIEW"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Earlier Brassington households elsewhere in Staffordshire",
          "record_date": "1666",
          "locality": "Caverswall and Weston Coyney, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "A hearth-tax transcription names George Brassington with three hearths at Caverswall and an unnamed widow Brassington with one at Weston Coyney.",
          "association": "These households establish the surname in Staffordshire before John’s known Ranton family.",
          "alternatives": "John might descend from an established Staffordshire branch, or his family might have arrived separately from Derbyshire or another parish.",
          "assessment": "The county and surname overlap provide context, but no shared relative, property or migration record currently connects either household to John. Neither is selected as his ancestral family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CAVERSWALL1666_FAMILIES"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Brassington is a surname taken from the Derbyshire village of that name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BRASSINGTON_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The place name probably means a settlement associated with Brandsige, a reconstructed personal name combining sword and victory. The settlement element is Old English tūn; Brandsige itself is not independently attested.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BRASSINGTON_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname’s Derbyshire origin provides a regional lead, but does not identify John’s own birthplace. Families taking their name from the same village need not descend from one founding household or its landowners.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BRASSINGTON_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "person_id": "C_BARTEE_ROBERT_SR_D_BEFORE_1711",
      "surname": "Bartee",
      "locality": "Linhaven and Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "Robert’s wife and sons are identified in the Norfolk will accounts, but his parents and birthplace remain unresolved. An earlier deed identifies a likely same-name carpenter in 1685/6. It supplies a place and occupation, but its surviving museum abstract does not name his family.",
      "notes": "The 1704 quit-rent roll lists Robert Bartee with 150 acres. The earlier deed’s acreage is not given in the museum abstract, so these cannot yet be treated as the same property. A family account discusses French Barteau namesakes and later Acadian migration; it provides no record joining them to Robert, who was already established in Virginia before that migration.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NORFOLK_1704_QUIT_RENT_ROBERT_BARTEE",
        "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
        "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
        "ROOTS26_BARTEE_MESDA1686",
        "ROOTS26_BARTEE_ORIGIN_NEWSLETTER"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Robert Bartee buys land as a carpenter of Linhaven",
          "record_date": "25 January 1685/6; recorded 15 March 1685/6",
          "locality": "Lower Norfolk County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "MESDA’s research card abstracts a deed from John Avery Jr., planter, to Robert Bartee, carpenter of Linhaven, for 800 pounds of tobacco. It cites Deed Book 4, page 220a.",
          "association": "The exact name, nearby locality and compatible chronology favor identifying this purchaser with the later Norfolk ancestor.",
          "alternatives": "An older relative or an unrelated man with the same name remains possible; neither has been established as a separate competing person.",
          "assessment": "The same-person explanation currently leads with moderate confidence. The complete deed and subsequent ownership of the tract could connect the carpenter to the later household. The card has been inspected; the original deed has not.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BARTEE_MESDA1686",
            "SRC_NORFOLK_1704_QUIT_RENT_ROBERT_BARTEE",
            "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
            "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary considers Bartee probably an altered form of Bartie. Bartie derives from a familiar form of the personal name Bartholomew.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BARTEE_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_BARTIE_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary identifies Bartie as Scottish and associates it with Midlothian.",
          "caveat": "That linguistic origin does not establish Robert’s own birthplace or route to Virginia.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BARTIE_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Virginia will accounts include the spelling Barttee alongside Bartee. Bartie is also useful when searching for a possible earlier origin.",
          "caveat": "A spelling match needs to be considered with the person’s locality, dates and family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
            "ROOTS26_BARTEE_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "person_id": "C_BERLIN_ANNA_MOTHER_MARGRETH",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Weinsberg, Württemberg, in 1576; birthplace unknown",
      "research_limit": "Anna is identified as Margreth Berlin’s mother in Weigel’s transcription of the Weinsberg baptism dated 27 November 1576. The entry names the father as Magister Johann Berlin, deacon, but gives the mother only as Anna. The pedigree’s separate entry for her likewise supplies no birth surname or parents. The maternal line stops at that identification; her residence at a child’s baptism does not establish where she was born.",
      "notes": "No surname meaning, ancestral place of origin or earlier surname-bearing family can yet be assigned to Anna. Berlin belongs to the recorded paternal household and is not evidence of her birth name. Weinsberg’s surviving early records offer further possibilities, as described below.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
        "ROOTS26_WEINSBERG_MISCHBUCH1571"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anna in Margreth’s Weinsberg baptism, 1576",
          "record_date": "27 November 1576",
          "locality": "Weinsberg, Württemberg",
          "historical_detail": "Weigel’s entry 2577 transcribes Margreth’s parents as Magister Johans Berlin, deacon, and Anna. His entries 5154–5155 place the couple’s marriage before 1576 and describe six children. The university matriculation edition independently traces Johann’s education and his appointment at Weinsberg in October 1575.",
          "association": "The father’s name, title, office and place fit the same clerical household. Anna’s identification as Margreth’s mother is substantially stronger than any proposed identification of her birth family.",
          "alternatives": "A different Johann-and-Anna household would have to match the distinctive name-and-office combination. No such competing household was identified in the reviewed material. Other women called Anna cannot be selected as her relatives on the forename alone.",
          "assessment": "The published baptism transcription supports the mother-child relationship. It does not establish Anna’s parents or prove that every child attributed to Johann had the same mother. The original baptism page and its witnesses have not been independently examined here.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
            "SRC_TUEBINGEN_MATRIKEL_JOHANN_BERLIN_1569"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Surviving Weinsberg records around Anna’s household",
          "record_date": "Registers covering 1571 onward",
          "locality": "Weinsberg, Württemberg",
          "historical_detail": "The church archive catalogue lists baptisms from 1571 to 1690 in volume 2, followed by a list of pastors. It also lists a marriage register beginning in 1576 and a family register covering 1571–1800.",
          "association": "These holdings cover the period of Margreth’s baptism and may preserve fuller household or witness information than the published excerpt.",
          "alternatives": "A marriage before 1576 might predate the listed marriage book, or have occurred in another parish. A later family-register compilation may repeat the same baptism evidence rather than supply an independent identification.",
          "assessment": "The catalogue establishes surviving relevant records, not their answer to Anna’s parentage. Their images were unavailable in this review. There is no basis for describing the maternal gap as a proven destruction of all records or for assigning a surname from another local family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEINSBERG_MISCHBUCH1571",
            "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Anna without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Anna. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Anna without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "person_id": "C_SAYER_SARACH_WIFE_RICHARD_BUTT",
      "surname": "Sayer (reported)",
      "locality": "Norfolk County, Virginia, proposed; birthplace unknown",
      "research_limit": "Sarach, possibly Sarah, Sayer is a disputed candidate for Richard Butt’s wife and Robert Butt’s mother. The earlier tree review recorded that claim in a collaborative profile without attached sources. The anonymous Butt family history instead assigns Richard wives Dinah and Frances and a different child list. Neither account supplies a marriage or parent-naming record identifying Sarach. Her birth family therefore remains unresolved.",
      "notes": "The alternative Butt account is itself an uncertain compilation: its omission of Sarach is a conflict to investigate, not proof that she never existed or married a Butt. No identifiable parent candidate emerged from the reviewed material. The records below establish earlier Sayer/Sawyer names in the Elizabeth River area, but a connection to her remains conditional on confirming her name and Norfolk identity.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
        "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
        "ROOTS26_NUGENT_SAWYER1637_1653",
        "ROOTS26_SAYER_MEARES1649"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Thomas Sayer buys land on the Elizabeth River",
          "record_date": "15 July 1649",
          "locality": "Elizabeth River, Lower Norfolk County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "A published online abstract describes an indenture between Thomas Sayer and Thomas Meares for 300 acres purchased by Sayer. It identifies Richard Daue, Thomas Ringold and John Biggs as witnesses and locates the deed in Lower Norfolk Book B, folios 149A–150.",
          "association": "This places the exact reported surname in the relevant county before Sarach’s estimated birth. It gives a concrete local household to compare with later records.",
          "alternatives": "Thomas could belong to a wider family connected to her, to an unrelated Sayer family, or to a line irrelevant to a mistaken Sarach identification. The abstract names no daughter Sarah or Sarach.",
          "assessment": "The locality and surname make this a plausible family-history association. They do not distinguish a father, another relative or no relationship, so Thomas is recorded here as historical context rather than assigned as her parent. The original deed has not been examined.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SAYER_MEARES1649"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Sawyer and Sayer names in two Elizabeth River patents",
          "record_date": "22 May 1637; last day of March 1653",
          "locality": "East and South branches of the Elizabeth River, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "Nugent abstracts a 1637 grant of 300 acres to Thomas Sawyer, adjoining Thomas Codd on the East Branch; its transport claim expressly names Sawyer’s wife Frances. A 1653 abstract grants Thomas Sawyer 400 acres in Pussell Poynt Creek on the South Branch and includes Anne Sayer among eight transport claims.",
          "association": "These records provide an earlier named couple and another Sayer bearer in the same river district. The spelling variation is compatible with the dictionary’s English Sayer–Sawyer connection.",
          "alternatives": "The two Thomases and the 1649 Sayer may be one man or different men. Anne’s appearance in a transport claim does not identify her as a wife, daughter or sister; Sarach is not named.",
          "assessment": "The printed abstracts were visually checked. They support regional surname history, not an intervening pedigree. A patent’s date does not by itself date the named person’s voyage, and the original patents remain unexamined.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NUGENT_SAWYER1637_1653",
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_SAYER"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "In English, Sayer commonly represents a sawyer’s occupational name. Another formation comes from the personal name Saher or Seier, ultimately combining Germanic elements meaning victory and army.",
          "caveat": "These are explanations of the reported surname, not evidence of Sarach’s family occupation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_SAYER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary describes English and Anglo-Norman formations, possible influence from Welsh saer, carpenter, and separate French, Dutch and South German names.",
          "caveat": "Her proposed Virginia setting supplies no European birthplace and does not distinguish these origins.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_SAYER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Rarer English explanations include an assayer or food taster, a reciter or minstrel, and possibly a cloth merchant. French forms can concern cutting work; Dutch and South German forms can concern sowing.",
          "caveat": "The local landholders described below have documented land interests, but their surname does not establish that they practised any of these trades.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_SAYER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Lower Norfolk County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "Jane is securely identified as Robert Butt’s wife and chosen executrix in his will of 1 November 1675. Neither the inspected abstract nor the fuller published transcription names her parents or birth surname.",
      "notes": "The proposed Earlshall identity depends on connecting Jane with Elizabeth Bruce, styled Lady Durie in an 1870 pedigree. That account places her father Alexander’s death around 1599–1600, while copied trees give her a 1605 birth. A mistaken date or remarriage remains possible, but no record inspected joins the Scottish woman to the Virginia household.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_BUTT_MCINTOSH1675",
        "ROOTS26_JANE_WIKITREE_WILL",
        "SRC_BRUCE_CUMMING_FAMILY_RECORDS_1870_EARLSHALL",
        "SRC_BUTT_SAMPLER_REVERSE_REPORT_2000"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Jane’s place in the Southern Branch household",
          "record_date": "1 November 1675; will proved 3 July 1676",
          "locality": "Lower Norfolk County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "Robert’s will names sons Henry, Robert, Thomas and Richard and appoints Jane executrix. The fuller transcription gives her use of the movable estate during her life, followed by division among his children.",
          "association": "These provisions establish Jane’s role in this specific household. The abstract also names beneficiary Arthur Sayer and witnesses John Edwards, Margere Alexander alias Sharp, and Richard Odien.",
          "alternatives": "The sons could all be Jane’s children, or some could come from an earlier marriage. The other named people could be relatives or associates.",
          "assessment": "The will directly establishes the marriage. Maternity and relationships to the witnesses need separate evidence; none of their surnames is adopted as Jane’s birth name.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BUTT_MCINTOSH1675",
            "ROOTS26_JANE_WIKITREE_WILL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "The Bruce tradition and Sarah’s sampler",
          "record_date": "1811; reverse-pedigree report attributed to 2000",
          "locality": "Virginia; alleged connection to Earlshall, Fife",
          "historical_detail": "Colonial Williamsburg identifies Sarah Bruce Butt as the daughter of Nathaniel and Frances Butt. An online report recorded in the earlier family research describes an undated pedigree on the sampler’s reverse associating Robert’s wife with Earlshall.",
          "association": "An inherited Bruce connection is one possible explanation for the repeated family name.",
          "alternatives": "Bruce could have entered through another ancestor or a commemorative name. The reported reverse pedigree could preserve older knowledge or a later genealogical reconstruction.",
          "assessment": "The naming tradition is documented; its application to Jane remains uncertain. The reverse annotation’s wording, date and authorship would help distinguish those explanations. A reported list of two sons is not counted against the claim without knowing that it intended to list every child.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_CW_SARAH_BRUCE_BUTT_SAMPLER_1811",
            "SRC_BUTT_SAMPLER_REVERSE_REPORT_2000"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Butt is Jane’s married surname in the will. It cannot supply the meaning of her unidentified birth name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BUTT_MCINTOSH1675"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The record places Jane’s household on the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River. It does not state where she was born.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BUTT_MCINTOSH1675"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Bruce appears in Sarah Bruce Butt’s name on an 1811 family sampler now at Colonial Williamsburg. This provides dated evidence for the naming tradition behind the later Scottish claim.",
          "caveat": "The sampler’s published inscription names Sarah’s parents, not Jane’s.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_CW_SARAH_BRUCE_BUTT_SAMPLER_1811"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "person_id": "C_BEERLIN_HANS_STUTTGART_1527",
      "surname": "Beerlin / Berlin",
      "locality": "Reported Stuttgart origin; Gruibingen and Überkingen, Württemberg",
      "research_limit": "Weigel’s pedigree places Hans Beerlin at a 1555 marriage to Agatha Bleyle in Gruibingen and reports his death at Überkingen on 1 September 1588. It gives an approximate Stuttgart birth around 1527, but no parents, and marks the proposed connection to Magister Johann Berlin as uncertain. Earlier men of the same name are identifiable; the unresolved question is whether any belonged to this household.",
      "notes": "The Stuttgart physician and the Heilbronn historical figures below are retained as separate people. Their careers provide specific regional leads, but the records reviewed do not select one as Hans’s father.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BERLIN_BEERLIN_HEILBRONN_BOUNDARY_20260727",
        "SRC_JOHANN_PLENINGEN_HANS_BEERLIN_NAMESAKE",
        "ROOTS26_HANS_BERLIN_AMORBACH1525"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "An older Hans Beerlin: physician Johann Pleningen",
          "record_date": "1515–1560s",
          "locality": "Esslingen, Heidelberg and Stuttgart",
          "historical_detail": "The scholarly Physicians’ Letters database lists Hans Beerlin, Hans Berlin and Johann Beerlin among the names of Johann Pleningen. It records his bachelor’s degree in 1515, doctorate in medicine in 1526, teaching at Heidelberg from 1529, and later work as a Stuttgart physician. It also identifies his application of 27 May 1545 in Stadtarchiv Esslingen, Reichsstadt, Faszikel 81, number 60.",
          "association": "The matching Hans Beerlin name and Stuttgart association make this an identifiable older person to investigate for possible wider-family connections.",
          "alternatives": "He could be an older relative or an unrelated bearer of the name. Identifying him as the endpoint himself would require substantial errors in the latter’s reported age and biography: the physician already held a degree before the endpoint’s approximate birth.",
          "assessment": "Separate identities currently explain the chronology better than a merger. The database’s stated death in 1563 conflicts with its own mention of citizenship in 1565, so the distinction rests principally on the much earlier education and career. The 1545 application is a concrete archival lead, not yet an inspected family-linking record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JOHANN_PLENINGEN_HANS_BEERLIN_NAMESAKE",
            "SRC_WEIGEL_BERLIN_BEERLIN_HEILBRONN_BOUNDARY_20260727"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Hans Berlin and the Amorbacher Erklärung, 1525",
          "record_date": "4 May 1525",
          "locality": "Amorbach and Heilbronn",
          "historical_detail": "Heilbronn’s municipal archive records that Wendel Hipler and the Heilbronn Hans Berlin prepared an explanation of the peasants’ Twelve Articles on 4 May 1525. The same chronology describes the proposed peasants’ parliament at Heilbronn, which dispersed after news of the defeat at Böblingen.",
          "association": "This places an earlier Hans Berlin in a specific regional political event, near the period of the endpoint’s reported birth.",
          "alternatives": "The shared name may reflect wider kinship, or separate families with the same surname. Adult activity in 1525 conflicts with identifying this man as someone born around 1527.",
          "assessment": "The event belongs to the Heilbronn man’s history. It is a useful regional comparison, but supplies no parent-child relationship to the Gruibingen–Überkingen household. His prominence adds no weight to that missing connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HANS_BERLIN_AMORBACH1525",
            "SRC_WEIGEL_BERLIN_BEERLIN_HEILBRONN_BOUNDARY_20260727"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Surname dictionaries offer two explanations for Berlin: a name taken from the city of Berlin, or a formation from the personal names Ber or Berl, associated with the word bear. The latter is included in Elsdon Coles Smith’s 1956 dictionary.",
          "caveat": "The origin of this branch’s Beerlin spelling has not been established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BERLIN_DAFN2022",
            "ROOTS26_BERLIN_SMITH1956"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The modern dictionary records Berlin among German and Ashkenazic surnames. This family’s reported sixteenth-century locations are in Württemberg, with Beerlin and Berlin both used in the genealogical sources.",
          "caveat": "Those broader name histories do not establish a migration from the city of Berlin or a religious ancestry for this household.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BERLIN_DAFN2022",
            "SRC_WEIGEL_BERLIN_BEERLIN_HEILBRONN_BOUNDARY_20260727"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Berlin occurs in the history of Heilbronn’s civic families and in the aliases of a sixteenth-century Stuttgart physician. The published pedigree treats the Heilbronn Berlin/Bernhard ancestry separately from its Berlin/Beerlin branch.",
          "caveat": "Separate treatment leaves possible older kinship open; it supplies no connecting parentage.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WEIGEL_BERLIN_BEERLIN_HEILBRONN_BOUNDARY_20260727",
            "SRC_JOHANN_PLENINGEN_HANS_BEERLIN_NAMESAKE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "person_id": "EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "surname": "Williams",
      "locality": "Rowan County, North Carolina, British Colonial America (reported)",
      "research_limit": "Mary’s 1766 Rowan marriage names her husband and Samuel Williams as bondsman but does not state Mary’s parents or Samuel’s relationship to her. Her reported middle name, birth, death and proposed parentage remain derivative; the common surname makes wider-family matching especially weak without a household, land, probate or church bridge.",
      "notes": "\n\nThe leading hypothesis is that Mary belonged to the local Williams network represented by the 1766 bond and perhaps the 1759 tax-list households. Alternatives are an unrelated Rowan Williams family, a neighboring-county origin, or a bondsman whose relationship was social rather than biological. The tax list establishes local name presence only; it does not select among these hypotheses. No parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WILLIAMS_DAFN",
        "ROOTS26_ROWAN_TAX_LISTS",
        "ROOTS26_ROWAN_RECORD_FRONTIER"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary Williams’s Rowan County marriage bond and the Williams tax-list cluster",
          "record_date": "12 February 1766; tax-list context 1759",
          "locality": "Rowan County, North Carolina",
          "historical_detail": "Mary Williams married John Felps in Rowan County on 12 February 1766, with Samuel Williams as bondsman. A published transcription of the 1759 Rowan tax list records Williams households, including William Williams. The tax entry is a local surname context, not an identity match.",
          "association": "The bond gives Mary’s earliest named Williams associate and places the marriage in a county where the surname was already represented. County deed, estate and church records are the specific next tests for a family connection.",
          "alternatives": "Samuel may have been Mary’s father, brother, uncle, another relative, or an unrelated guarantor. The 1759 William Williams may be part of the same family or a separate household. A neighboring-county origin also remains possible.",
          "assessment": "The local Williams-network hypothesis is stronger than an entirely unlocated family because the bond and tax context are concrete and geographically matched. It remains insufficient for a parent edge; the surname’s high frequency prevents a stronger identification.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
            "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
            "ROOTS26_ROWAN_TAX_LISTS",
            "ROOTS26_ROWAN_RECORD_FRONTIER"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Williams is a patronymic form of William, with a genitival or later excrescent -s. The name means a family connection to a bearer of William, but does not identify Mary’s particular ancestor.",
          "caveat": "Williams is common; surname and locality alone cannot identify a family line.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WILLIAMS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_ROWAN_TAX_LISTS",
            "ROOTS26_ROWAN_RECORD_FRONTIER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname is common in England and Wales and was brought to North America independently by many families. Mary’s Rowan County record does not establish whether her line came from Wales, southern England, another British colony or a different local origin.",
          "caveat": "Williams is common; surname and locality alone cannot identify a family line.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WILLIAMS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_ROWAN_TAX_LISTS",
            "ROOTS26_ROWAN_RECORD_FRONTIER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The relevant local association is the Rowan County Williams cluster: Samuel Williams served as bondsman for Mary’s 1766 marriage, and a 1759 tax transcription records Williams households. Neither source proves that Samuel was Mary’s father or that another listed Williams was related.",
          "caveat": "Williams is common; surname and locality alone cannot identify a family line.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WILLIAMS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_ROWAN_TAX_LISTS",
            "ROOTS26_ROWAN_RECORD_FRONTIER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "person_id": "EXP11_GEORG_BATZER_1610",
      "surname": "Batzer",
      "locality": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "research_limit": "Weigel’s pedigree identifies Georg (1610–1661) and wife Ursula Hinckh but supplies no parents for him. His reported 1633 Willmandingen marriage precedes that parish’s marriage register, which begins in 1648.",
      "notes": "Erpfingen church books begin in 1594, according to the same work. Georg’s reported 29 November 1610 birth therefore warrants checking in the baptism register; the present stopping point does not establish that his parentage records are lost.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "A Batzer household in Erpfingen in 1581",
          "record_date": "1581; 6 November 1632",
          "locality": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
          "historical_detail": "Weigel reports Jörg and Barbara Batzer’s household in a 1581 serf register, including three-year-old Jacob. A quoted 1632 marriage entry identifies Hans Batzer as Jacob’s son.",
          "association": "The same surname and village, with compatible generations, support possible kinship with Georg.",
          "alternatives": "Georg could belong to another branch or an unrelated Batzer family. Jacob’s documented son Hans does not by itself identify Georg’s father.",
          "assessment": "A plausible wider-family connection, with the precise relationship unresolved. No intervening parent links have been added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The Dictionary of American Family Names explains Batzer as a Swabian nickname derived from bätzen, meaning to boast or show off.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BATZER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary’s Swabian attribution fits the region of this Erpfingen branch, but identifies neither a founding village nor a single ancestral Batzer family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BATZER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Linnartz offers a different explanation: a coin-maker, associated with Batzen coins and a word meaning a lump or thick piece. These are alternative accounts of surname formation; neither establishes Georg’s occupation or character.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_LINNARTZ_BATZER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BATZER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "person_id": "EXP11_URSULA_HINCKH_ABT1612",
      "surname": "Hinckh",
      "locality": "Erpfingen and Reutlingen, Württemberg; birthplace unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Ursula’s birth about 1612 is an estimate, not an identified baptism. Weigel reports her surname as Hinckherlin in daughter Barbara’s 1648 Reutlingen baptism, but names no parents for Ursula.",
      "notes": "Weigel mentions the surname at Neuffen without identifying a particular relative or dated entry. Neuffen’s catalogued baptism, marriage and burial registers begin in 1634, after Ursula’s estimated birth. The local surname occurrence is a possible clue to her origins, not an established birthplace. No earlier local household has yet been connected to her in the sources reviewed.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ARCHION_NEUFFEN_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ursula Hinckh: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Erpfingen and Reutlingen, Württemberg; birthplace unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Ursula’s birth about 1612 is an estimate, not an identified baptism. Weigel reports her surname as Hinckherlin in daughter Barbara’s 1648 Reutlingen baptism, but names no parents for Ursula. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ARCHION_NEUFFEN_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Hink is explained in the Dictionary of American Family Names as a familiar form of Heinrich in German, or Hendrick in Dutch. Its Hinker entry derives that name from Hink. This offers a possible explanation for Hinckh/Hinckherlin, although the equivalence of these spellings in Ursula’s family remains unverified.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HINK",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HINKER",
            "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary gives German and Dutch origins for Hink, with a separate English formation from familiar forms of Henry. These broad origins do not identify where Ursula was born; her documented family setting is Württemberg.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HINK",
            "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The fuller form Hinckherlin is the useful family-specific clue: it comes from a baptism naming Ursula as the mother, rather than from later surname distribution. Reading that entry alongside other records of her household could establish how her birth surname was normally written.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "person_id": "EXP12_HANSS_GEORG_KIEFFER_ABT1630",
      "surname": "Kieffer",
      "locality": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire (reported)",
      "research_limit": "The Blankenloch reconstruction places Hanss Georg with a large household, but his own baptism and parents have not been inspected. The surviving local Lutheran register begins in 1672, after his reported birth about 1630; a conflicting pedigree names another Kieffer household.",
      "notes": "\n\nThe leading hypothesis is a Blankenloch Kieffer household reconstructed from multiple indexed child baptisms. The alternatives are a different Hanss Georg Kieffer, a household in another parish, or a mistaken assignment of the children. No earlier parent is attached.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Blankenloch register and local family-book record frontier",
          "record_date": "1672–1738 register; 1672–1920 local family book",
          "locality": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
          "historical_detail": "Archion catalogs the Blankenloch Lutheran mixed register from 1672 to 1738, and a local family book covers Blankenloch, Büchig and Stutensee from 1672 to 1920. These are the specific records that can test the reconstructed family’s later household and children.",
          "association": "The locality and record coverage match the reported Blankenloch household, giving the wider-family hypothesis a concrete documentary target.",
          "alternatives": "The reconstruction may combine same-name households, or the reported couple may belong to another parish. The register start is too late to prove either endpoint’s own birth or parents.",
          "assessment": "Useful local continuity lead, not a parent link. The record boundary is an evidence limit rather than evidence that the reported births did not occur.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Kieffer is a German, Luxembourgish and Jewish variant of Kiefer. The dictionary does not make a specific occupational claim for this man.",
          "caveat": "The household is reconstructed and the endpoint’s own birth and parent records have not been inspected.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KIEFFER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname’s documented distributions include Germany, Luxembourg, Wallonia and Jewish usage; the reported Blankenloch setting is German but does not establish which Kieffer origin applies.",
          "caveat": "The household is reconstructed and the endpoint’s own birth and parent records have not been inspected.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KIEFFER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Blankenloch’s Lutheran register and later local family book are the relevant historical association. Their start in 1672 explains why they can test the later household but not directly prove Hanss Georg’s birth or parents.",
          "caveat": "The household is reconstructed and the endpoint’s own birth and parent records have not been inspected.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "person_id": "EXP12_MARGRETHA_HELENA_WIDMAN_ABT1633",
      "surname": "Widman",
      "locality": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire (reported)",
      "research_limit": "Margretha is placed in the same reconstructed Blankenloch household, but her baptism, birthplace and parents are unproved. The surviving local register begins in 1672, long after her reported birth about 1633, and a conflicting pedigree assigns the child to another mother.",
      "notes": "\n\nThe leading hypothesis is that Margretha was the wife in the Blankenloch household reconstructed from multiple child entries. Alternatives are another Widman woman, a different parish, or a conflated mother in the compiled pedigree. No earlier parent is attached.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Blankenloch register and local family-book record frontier",
          "record_date": "1672–1738 register; 1672–1920 local family book",
          "locality": "Blankenloch, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
          "historical_detail": "Archion catalogs the Blankenloch Lutheran mixed register from 1672 to 1738, and a local family book covers Blankenloch, Büchig and Stutensee from 1672 to 1920. These are the specific records that can test the reconstructed family’s later household and children.",
          "association": "The locality and record coverage match the reported Blankenloch household, giving the wider-family hypothesis a concrete documentary target.",
          "alternatives": "The reconstruction may combine same-name households, or the reported couple may belong to another parish. The register start is too late to prove either endpoint’s own birth or parents.",
          "assessment": "Useful local continuity lead, not a parent link. The record boundary is an evidence limit rather than evidence that the reported births did not occur.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Widman may be a Swedish ornamental or habitational name, and the dictionary also treats it as an Americanized form of South German Widmann. These are alternative name histories, not evidence that this woman was Swedish or South German.",
          "caveat": "The household is reconstructed and the endpoint’s own birth and parent records have not been inspected.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WIDMAN_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported Baden setting makes the South German Widmann route worth testing, but the current spelling and records do not distinguish it from other Widman origins.",
          "caveat": "The household is reconstructed and the endpoint’s own birth and parent records have not been inspected.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WIDMAN_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Blankenloch register and local family book are the concrete local association for testing Margretha’s reconstructed marriage and children; they do not establish her birth family.",
          "caveat": "The household is reconstructed and the endpoint’s own birth and parent records have not been inspected.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTERS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "person_id": "EXP13_BARBARA_RADLER_MOLLFINGER",
      "surname": "Radler",
      "locality": "Possible Nenzenheim connection through the Mollfinger family",
      "research_limit": "Barbara Radler is named as Barbara Mollfinger’s mother in a compiled pedigree. The daughter’s 1665 marriage transcript names her father Hans but omits her mother, so the proposed maternity remains unverified and no Radler parents are identified.",
      "notes": "The current compiled pedigree reports Barbara Radler’s death in 1664. That date and surname have not been tied to a burial or marriage entry. The omission of a mother from the daughter’s wedding record does not contradict the proposed relationship; it simply leaves the claim without confirmation from that record. Nenzenheim’s archived burial series begins in 1591 and marriages in 1616, providing specific surviving sources in which this household may be identifiable.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NENZENHEIM_LAELKB_CATALOGUE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Barbara Radler: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Possible Nenzenheim connection through the Mollfinger family",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Barbara Radler is named as Barbara Mollfinger’s mother in a compiled pedigree. The daughter’s 1665 marriage transcript names her father Hans but omits her mother, so the proposed maternity remains unverified and no Radler parents are identified. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NENZENHEIM_LAELKB_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Radler, also written Rädler, is explained by the surname dictionary as a name for someone from a place called Radel, Radelau or Radlau.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RADLER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Several places behind this surname occur in Bavaria and Austria. None has been connected to Barbara; her only current geographical clue comes from the proposed Mollfinger household at Nenzenheim.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RADLER",
            "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The proposed association is with Hans Mollfinger and the family of Stephan Lindner, who married their supposed daughter in 1665. No earlier Radler individual has been connected to that household in the sources inspected.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_MOLLFINGER_NAME_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "person_id": "EXP16_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_ABT1504",
      "surname": "Bleyle",
      "locality": "Locality unestablished; proposed daughter associated with Hohenstadt and Überkingen",
      "research_limit": "Sebastian remains the proposed father of Agatha Bleyle in Herbert Weigel’s pedigree. His entry gives approximate dates, 1504–1568, but no home town, wife, parents or identifying event. Its question mark preserves the compiler’s uncertainty. A numbering discrepancy is probably a printing error: the index gives the expected father number, 20618, while the body prints 21618. This supports the intended relationship without independently establishing the historical identity.",
      "notes": "Agatha’s reported Hohenstadt origin and 1555 Gruibingen marriage provide a geographical lead, not a demonstrated residence for Sebastian. The immediate obstacle is identifying his household. Reports of lost early Wiesensteig registers cannot establish that all records relevant to him are lost, since his parish is unknown.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
        "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "The name group at Reutlingen in 1431",
          "record_date": "1431",
          "locality": "Reutlingen, Swabia",
          "historical_detail": "Bahlow’s surname entry cites an attestation at Reutlingen in 1431. The reproduced entry does not name the individual or identify the original record.",
          "association": "This is an earlier Swabian occurrence worth comparing with the family’s reported Hohenstadt–Überkingen setting.",
          "alternatives": "An occupational name could have arisen independently in separate households. Sebastian might also have come from outside that area: his own locality has not been established.",
          "assessment": "The regional and chronological fit makes wider-family continuity possible, but the unnamed dictionary example cannot yet identify a relative or connect two households.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BLEYLE_BAHLOW_LINNARTZ",
            "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "A Bluweler household at Oberkirch, 1395",
          "record_date": "1395",
          "locality": "Oberkirch, Ortenau",
          "historical_detail": "An original charter catalogued at the Generallandesarchiv Karlsruhe names Böldelin Bluweler and his sons Reinbold and Hans. Before the Oberkirch court they sold an annual rye rent to Betschelin von Brumath for eleven pounds in Strasbourg pennies. The catalogue dates it to the Friday before St Gall’s day in 1395.",
          "association": "This supplies a documented medieval household bearing a form comparable with the names in the surname dictionaries. It is broader regional name history, not a record from Sebastian’s established home town.",
          "alternatives": "Separate occupational origins explain the similar names without migration or kinship. Shared ancestry would require a connection between the Ortenau household and Sebastian’s still-unidentified family.",
          "assessment": "The charter establishes that household and its internal father-son relationships. Neither the catalogue nor the reviewed pedigree supplies a link to Sebastian, so these people remain historical context rather than additional ancestors.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BLUWELER_OBERKIRCH_1395",
            "ROOTS26_BLEYLE_BAHLOW_LINNARTZ"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Bahlow groups Bleyle with Bleile, Bleiler, Bleuler and Bleul, deriving the name from Middle High German bliuwel, an implement used for pounding. The explanation is occupational, particularly a pounding-mill operator. The modern Dictionary of American Family Names gives a similar derivation for Bleil.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BLEYLE_BAHLOW_LINNARTZ",
            "ROOTS26_BLEIL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Bahlow records this name group at Reutlingen in 1431, as well as medieval examples in Baden and near Schaffhausen. These attestations place related forms in the southern German-speaking region.",
          "caveat": "They describe the history of the name, not a single birthplace shared by every family bearing it.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BLEYLE_BAHLOW_LINNARTZ"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The occupational explanations include work with wool, hemp and flax, where fibres were beaten, washed or processed with pounding equipment.",
          "caveat": "Sebastian’s own occupation is unrecorded in the pedigree; this surname explanation does not make him a miller or textile worker.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BLEYLE_BAHLOW_LINNARTZ"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "person_id": "C_SCHAAF_JOHANN_MARTIN_OBER_GLEEN",
      "surname": "Schaaf",
      "locality": "Ober-Gleen, Hesse; connection to Newark remains a candidate",
      "research_limit": "Johann Martin Schaaf is the reported father in the retained extraction of an Ober-Gleen baptism dated 24 March 1848. The child’s identification with Katharine Schaaf Fricke of New Jersey remains a candidate. His own parents have not been established, and the earlier Schaaf–Grau family must be distinguished from another man with the same name.",
      "notes": "A transcription of an 1821 Ober-Gleen baptism calls the father Johann Martin Schaaf the second, a miller, and names his wife Anna Catharina, born Grau. The wife’s name and locality support comparison with the candidate family; the numbering indicates another same-named man actually existed. The 1819 marriage and 1821 baptism originals would help identify this household. Archion’s catalogue confirms surviving baptism registers, but the catalogue alone does not verify individual entries. The Katharina reported born in 1833 and later married to Ferdinand Lehr in Indianapolis is a separate candidate from the child reported born in 1848.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "An earlier Schaaf miller sponsors a child",
          "record_date": "1821 baptism; transcription published December 2023",
          "locality": "Ober-Gleen, Hesse",
          "historical_detail": "A published reading of Johann Daniel Schaaf’s baptism identifies the sponsor as Johann Daniel Schaaf the first, previously the miller at the mill worked by the child’s father, Johann Martin Schaaf the second. The mother is read as Anna Catharina, born Grau. The original image is linked in the discussion but has not been independently re-read here.",
          "association": "A predecessor at the same mill, sharing the surname and serving as sponsor, is a stronger family connection to investigate than an isolated name match.",
          "alternatives": "The sponsor might be a father or another relative of Johann Martin, or an unrelated predecessor with a close occupational connection. The quoted reading does not name their relationship.",
          "assessment": "Family continuity at the mill is plausible, but the available evidence does not rank fatherhood above other kinship. The marriage record and mill succession documents could distinguish these explanations. No biological link is assigned from sponsorship alone.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "German Schaaf is a variant of Schaf, which the surname dictionary explains as an occupational name for a herdsman, derived from the word for sheep. This does not imply that this particular ancestor was a shepherd.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHAAF_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_SCHAF_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The branch under investigation is documented or reported in Ober-Gleen, Hesse. The surname’s occupational meaning does not identify a single place of origin. Dutch Schaaf has a separate carpenter-related explanation; no Dutch origin is established for this household.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SCHAAF_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_SCHAF_DAFN",
            "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
            "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
            "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The earlier Johann Daniel Schaaf, named as baptismal sponsor in the 1821 transcription, reportedly preceded Johann Martin at the same mill. The shared surname, mill and sponsorship give a specific family-history lead beyond the current parentage evidence.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "person_id": "C_GRAU_ANNA_CATHARINA_OBER_GLEEN",
      "surname": "Grau",
      "locality": "Ober-Gleen, Upper Hesse; birthplace not established",
      "research_limit": "Anna Catharina Grau is identified as the wife of Johann Martin Schaaf in reported Ober-Gleen parish records. A family researcher cites their marriage on 24 June 1819, but the marriage image has not been examined and her parents remain unidentified. The tree also retains a separate uncertainty: whether the Katharina Schaaf reportedly baptised here in 1848 was the later New Jersey ancestor.",
      "notes": "A published transcription of their son Johann Daniel’s 1821 baptism calls the father Johann Martin Schaaf “the second,” a miller, and the mother Anna Catharina, born Grau. The name, occupation and household together provide a better way to distinguish this couple than the husband’s name alone. Ober-Gleen registers survive from 1685; the present stopping point reflects unexamined family records, not a demonstrated loss of the parish books.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023",
        "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
        "ROOTS26_OBERGLEEN_ARCHION"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anna Catharina Grau: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Ober-Gleen, Upper Hesse; birthplace not established",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Anna Catharina Grau is identified as the wife of Johann Martin Schaaf in reported Ober-Gleen parish records. A family researcher cites their marriage on 24 June 1819, but the marriage image has not been examined and her parents remain unidentified. The tree also retains a separate uncertainty: whether the Katharina Schaaf reportedly baptised here in 1848 was the later New Jersey ancestor. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023",
            "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
            "ROOTS26_OBERGLEEN_ARCHION"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The German surname Grau commonly began as a nickname referring to grey hair or a grey beard.",
          "caveat": "This describes how the name could have arisen, not a known characteristic of Anna Catharina or an identified ancestor.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GRAU_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The German explanation fits the Hessian records. Grau also occurs in Alsace and Lorraine, while Catalan and southern French families can derive the same spelling from the personal name Guerau or from a coastal channel or place-name.",
          "caveat": "The spelling does not identify one ancestral homeland.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GRAU_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The clearest family setting presently reported is an Ober-Gleen miller’s household in the early nineteenth century. The Hessian genealogical association also lists a Grau pedigree, but its public catalogue supplies neither a place nor dates, so it cannot yet be connected to this family.",
          "caveat": "No earlier local Grau household has been identified in the sources examined. The surviving marriage and baptism registers remain the principal evidence for testing whether her family was local or had moved into the parish.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023",
            "ROOTS26_GRAU_HFV",
            "ROOTS26_OBERGLEEN_ARCHION"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_PETERS_ROBERT_FRESHFORD_FATHER_PRISCILLA",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_ROBERT_FRESHFORD_FATHER_PRISCILLA",
      "surname": "Peters",
      "locality": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "research_limit": "Robert is named with Ann in the transcript of their daughter Prissilla’s baptism at St Peter, Freshford, on 23 June 1707. His parents, birthplace and marriage have not been identified; the baptism establishes a family in the parish without identifying its earlier origins.",
      "notes": "FreeREG classifies the baptism source as an “Other Transcript,” rather than an original register image. Its Freshford coverage contains only one entry for the entire 1690s, so a marriage search there cannot adequately test that decade. The reviewed early rate lists add no identifiable Peters household. Because they record ratepayers and properties, that omission does not establish that Robert lived elsewhere.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_ROOTS_FRESHFORD_FREEREG_COVERAGE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_FRESHFORD_RATE_REVIEW"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Robert Peters: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Robert is named with Ann in the transcript of their daughter Prissilla’s baptism at St Peter, Freshford, on 23 June 1707. His parents, birthplace and marriage have not been identified; the baptism establishes a family in the parish without identifying its earlier origins. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FRESHFORD_FREEREG_COVERAGE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FRESHFORD_RATE_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Peters is a patronymic formed from the personal name Peter, commonly expressing descent from someone of that name. It does not identify Robert’s own father as Peter.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_PETERS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname has English and Scottish formations as well as Dutch and North German ones. Robert’s established connection is to Somerset in 1707; no evidence inspected assigns his branch to an overseas origin.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_PETERS",
            "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Peters can also represent an Irish translation of Mac Pheadair, “son of Peter,” or other cognate names. Those separate histories are not linked to this family. No earlier Peters name-bearer has yet been connected to Robert in Freshford’s reviewed records.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_PETERS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FRESHFORD_RATE_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_PETERS_ANN_FRESHFORD_MOTHER_PRISCILLA",
      "person_id": "C_PETERS_ANN_FRESHFORD_MOTHER_PRISCILLA",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
      "research_limit": "Ann is named as Prissilla’s mother in the Freshford baptism transcript of 23 June 1707. Peters is the father Robert’s surname; the entry supplies no maiden surname for Ann, so her birth family remains unidentified.",
      "notes": "No marriage identifying Ann’s maiden name was established in this review. The very sparse FreeREG coverage for Freshford in the 1690s leaves an important possible marriage period largely unrepresented in that database. The earlier rate lists supply no family connection that identifies her. Her roots cannot yet be assigned the history of a particular surname.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
        "SRC_ROOTS_FRESHFORD_FREEREG_COVERAGE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_FRESHFORD_RATE_REVIEW"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ann Peters: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Freshford, Somerset, England",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Ann is named as Prissilla’s mother in the Freshford baptism transcript of 23 June 1707. Peters is the father Robert’s surname; the entry supplies no maiden surname for Ann, so her birth family remains unidentified. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FRESHFORD_FREEREG_COVERAGE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_FRESHFORD_RATE_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Ann Peters without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Ann Peters. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Ann Peters without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_WILLIS_WILLIAM_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_WILLIAM_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "surname": "Willis",
      "locality": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "research_limit": "William and Katherine are named as Benjamin Willis’s parents in the North Bradley baptism transcript dated 10 January 1679, with three other children recorded to the couple that day. The entries establish their family in the parish, but give no ages, occupation or parents for William. They do not establish North Bradley as his birthplace.",
      "notes": "An earlier group of baptisms names William Willis as father of John, Katharine and Anne on 30 December 1670. The matching father’s name and parish, nine years before Benjamin’s baptism, favor identifying him with Benjamin’s father. The earlier entries omit the mother, however, and Benjamin and Simon Willis also had families in the parish. A second William is possible, although none has been distinguished by the records reviewed. The grouped baptism dates need not be the children’s birth dates; they do not establish triplet or quadruplet births.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_CLUSTER_REVIEW_1652_1703",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John Willis, vicar and rectory lessee",
          "record_date": "1639–1646",
          "locality": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
          "historical_detail": "Winchester College leased the rectory to John Willis, the parish vicar, in 1639. By 1646 he had left North Bradley and the lease had passed to another holder; parishioners then asked to collect the tithes themselves and use the surplus to support their vicar.",
          "association": "John places the Willis name in the same parish forty years before William and Katherine’s family. He could have belonged to an earlier generation of their wider family.",
          "alternatives": "John could instead have been an unrelated Willis whose clerical appointment brought him to North Bradley. His departure by 1646 also means the lease alone cannot demonstrate a continuously resident family.",
          "assessment": "The same parish and relatively short interval make this a worthwhile possible family association. Neither the lease history nor the baptism entries name a relationship, so the available evidence does not distinguish kinship from an unrelated clerical household. John is recorded as local history, without a parent link.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_VCH_NORTH_BRADLEY_WILLIS_1639",
            "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Willis commonly comes from Will, a short form of William, with a possessive ending indicating a family connection to a man of that name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILLIS_2022",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILL_2022"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary classifies Willis as English and explains its second syllable as a survival of the medieval ending -es. It also records derivations from Willey and Willows.",
          "caveat": "These different formations do not identify where the North Bradley branch first acquired its name.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILLIS_2022"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Related surname forms include Wills and Will. In North Bradley itself, parish entries record Benjamin and Simon Willis households as well as William’s family.",
          "caveat": "The local families may have shared ancestors, but their household records have not yet established those relationships.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILLIS_2022",
            "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_CLUSTER_REVIEW_1652_1703"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_WILLIS_KATHERINE_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "person_id": "C_WILLIS_KATHERINE_NORTH_BRADLEY_1679",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
      "research_limit": "Katherine is named with William Willis in the North Bradley baptisms of Benjamin, Lazarus, Joseph and Abigail on 10 January 1679. These entries give her forename but neither a birth surname nor parents. Her association with this parish is documented; her birthplace is not.",
      "notes": "The parish reconstruction places three children baptised in 1670 in the same family. Their entries name William but omit the mother, so they do not establish that Katherine was already his wife then. She could have been their mother, or William could have remarried before the 1679 baptisms. The earlier review of indexed Wiltshire Willis marriages for 1645–1680 found no North Bradley entry identifying this couple; that limited index search does not show that their marriage went unrecorded. Willis is her married family name here. Without an identified birth surname, its meaning and earlier local bearers belong to William’s roots rather than to Katherine’s ancestry.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
        "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_CLUSTER_REVIEW_1652_1703",
        "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Katherine Willis: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, England",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Katherine is named with William Willis in the North Bradley baptisms of Benjamin, Lazarus, Joseph and Abigail on 10 January 1679. These entries give her forename but neither a birth surname nor parents. Her association with this parish is documented; her birthplace is not. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
            "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_CLUSTER_REVIEW_1652_1703",
            "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Katherine Willis without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Katherine Willis. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Katherine Willis without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "person_id": "SRC_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_FATHER_ADELINE",
      "surname": "Trautman",
      "locality": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "research_limit": "David Trautman is identified by four official child-birth entries from 1854-1862, an 1861 New Orleans directory listing his Poydras Street shoe store, an official 22 November 1893 death index, and Hebrew Rest cemetery evidence. No reviewed record identifies his birthplace, immigration, or parents. H1 is the documented New Orleans man; alternatives are another David Trautman, Trautmann/Troutman spelling conflation, or an unrelated namesake. Naturalization, passenger, marriage, probate and German/Jewish records are the next tests; no parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "The terminal branch is locally well documented but ancestry stops at the missing birthplace and parent records. The surname meaning and German context do not identify a specific immigrant family.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TRAUTMAN_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_TRAUTMAN_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
        "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT",
        "SRC_GARDNER_NEW_ORLEANS_DIRECTORY_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1861"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "David Trautman: New Orleans identity documented; origin unresolved",
          "record_date": "1854-1893",
          "locality": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana",
          "historical_detail": "Official birth indexes repeatedly name David Trautmann/Trautman with Julie/Julia Moser/Moses as parents from 1854 through 1862. The 1861 directory lists his shoe store and residence; the death index and Hebrew Rest cemetery preserve his later identity. No reviewed record gives his birthplace or parents.",
          "association": "The continuity hypothesis is that the records describe one New Orleans David Trautman household. Alternatives are a namesake or spelling conflation, but the repeated wife, place and child sequence strongly support the local identity.",
          "alternatives": "Another David Trautman; Trautmann/Troutman spelling conflation; unrelated New Orleans namesake; or an undocumented immigrant origin.",
          "assessment": "The terminal root records strong local evidence and a precise ancestry limit. No European origin or parent edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TRAUTMAN_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
            "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
            "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
            "SRC_GARDNER_NEW_ORLEANS_DIRECTORY_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1861",
            "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
            "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Trautman/Trautmann is described as a German surname from a medieval personal name using trût, “beloved,” plus man; Trautman and Trautmann are spelling variants found in separate lines.",
          "caveat": "A German surname meaning does not establish David's birthplace or a shared family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TRAUTMAN_SURNAME_CONTEXT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "David's documented locality is New Orleans. No reviewed record identifies a European birthplace or immigration route; German origin remains a surname-based possibility only.",
          "caveat": "The surname can occur in unrelated German-speaking and American families.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TRAUTMAN_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
            "ROOTS26_TRAUTMAN_SURNAME_CONTEXT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1861 New Orleans directory places David at 174 Lafayette while operating a Poydras Street shoe store; official birth, death and cemetery records preserve the household and burial context.",
          "caveat": "These local records document David, not his parents or European origin.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GARDNER_NEW_ORLEANS_DIRECTORY_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1861",
            "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
            "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "person_id": "SRC_JULIA_MOSES_MOTHER_ADELINE",
      "surname": "Moser",
      "locality": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana, United States",
      "research_limit": "Julie (Julia) Moser is identified by official child-birth entries in 1854, 1856, 1859 and 1862 under Moser/Moses spellings, plus a 20 September 1916 death index and Hebrew Rest cemetery evidence. The repeated husband, place and child sequence supports one New Orleans woman. No reviewed record identifies her birthplace, immigration or parents. H1 is the local identity; alternatives are another Julie Moser/Moses, a record spelling difference representing another woman, or an unrelated namesake. Naturalization, passenger, marriage, probate and German/Jewish records are the next tests; no parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "The spelling variation is itself evidence to preserve: Moser is the earliest direct form, Moses appears later, and neither proves an origin.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MOSER_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
        "ROOTS26_MOSER_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
        "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
        "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1916",
        "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Julie Moser/Moses: New Orleans identity supported; ancestry unresolved",
          "record_date": "1854-1916",
          "locality": "New Orleans, Orleans Parish, Louisiana",
          "historical_detail": "Official birth indexes name Julie Moser in 1854 and 1856, Julie Moses in 1859 and Julia Moses in 1862, repeatedly with David Trautman and the same New Orleans setting. The 1916 death index and Hebrew Rest cemetery identify the later widow. No reviewed record gives her birthplace, immigration or parents.",
          "association": "The continuity hypothesis is that Moser, Moses and Julia are record variants for one woman. Alternatives are another Julie Moser/Moses or a spelling conflation, though the repeated household sequence favors one local identity.",
          "alternatives": "Another Julie Moser/Moses; distinct Moser and Moses women; spelling/transcription conflation; or an undocumented immigrant origin.",
          "assessment": "The root records the spelling evidence and strong local identity while stopping at the missing birthplace and parent records. No parent edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MOSER_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
            "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
            "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
            "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1916",
            "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Moser is a German surname with South German topographic explanations associated with Moos or similar place/terrain names; Mosser is recorded as an Americanized form of Moser.",
          "caveat": "Moser/Moses spelling and surname meaning do not identify Julie's family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MOSER_SURNAME_CONTEXT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Julie's documented locality is New Orleans. No birthplace or immigration route is recorded; a German-speaking origin remains a surname-based possibility only.",
          "caveat": "Moser occurs in multiple German-speaking and American lines, and Moses may be a record variant or a separate surname.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MOSER_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
            "ROOTS26_MOSER_SURNAME_CONTEXT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The four child-birth entries, 1916 death index and Hebrew Rest burial create a specific New Orleans household and widow identity despite the Moser/Moses/Julia variants.",
          "caveat": "These records identify Julie locally but do not name her parents or European origin.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
            "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
            "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1916",
            "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_MARSHALL_JOHN_PONTEFRACT_1772",
      "person_id": "C_MARSHALL_JOHN_PONTEFRACT_1772",
      "surname": "Marshall",
      "locality": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "research_limit": "John Marshall married Ann Allen at Pontefract on 19 July 1772. The saved marriage index identifies the couple but not their parents. John’s birth date and birthplace remain unestablished: Pontefract is the marriage location. The record is indexed under FHL film 990759 and West Yorkshire roll 30, page 106, record 666; the original entry has not been inspected in this review.",
      "notes": "John is retained as a candidate father of Ann Marshall, later wife of Thomas Lister. The supplied child-index extract names a father John, but omits the child’s baptism date, parish and mother. Matching names and the proposed Pontefract setting favor investigation, while an indexed child from another John Marshall household remains possible. The incomplete extract prevents a sound comparison of those households. The full baptism and evidence connecting that child to the 1799 bride are needed before the proposed relationship can be strengthened.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Hannah Marshall of Pontefract in a Horsforth deed",
          "record_date": "24–25 April 1771",
          "locality": "Pontefract and Horsforth, Yorkshire",
          "historical_detail": "A published archival description names Hannah Marshall of Pontefract, unmarried, as a party to a lease and release concerning a half share of a house, seven Outwood Closes and woodland at Horsforth. The cited West Yorkshire Archive Service reference is SpSt/4/11/66/609.",
          "association": "The surname, town and date immediately before John’s marriage make Hannah a concrete lead for his wider family.",
          "alternatives": "Hannah could be a relative or an unrelated Marshall living in Pontefract. The quoted description names no relationship to John.",
          "assessment": "A local association to investigate, with the original deed still unchecked. Its other parties and any connected will could clarify Hannah’s relatives; neither ownership nor kinship should be assigned to John from this description.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HANNAH_MARSHALL_PONTEFRACT_1771"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Marshall is usually an English occupational surname for a farrier. In some families it arose from a title for a senior household or court official.",
          "caveat": "The surname does not establish John’s occupation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MARSHALL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The English name developed through Middle English mareshal and Old French maresc(h)al. The dictionary also records separate routes into Marshall through German Marschall and other names.",
          "caveat": "John’s Pontefract marriage does not identify which earlier household first adopted his surname.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MARSHALL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Marshall’s association with court office can suggest famous medieval families, but its ordinary occupational use also produced unrelated families.",
          "caveat": "No link from this Pontefract branch to a titled Marshall family is established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MARSHALL"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_ALLEN_ANN_WIFE_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "person_id": "C_ALLEN_ANN_WIFE_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "surname": "Allen",
      "locality": "Pontefract, Yorkshire, England",
      "research_limit": "Ann Allen is named in the Pontefract marriage index with John Marshall on 19 July 1772. The saved extract does not identify her parents, age or birthplace. Pontefract is her marriage location, not an established place of birth. The original entry—indexed under FHL film 990759, West Yorkshire roll 30, page 106, record 666—could provide witnesses and marital status that help identify her earlier family.",
      "notes": "Her proposed motherhood of Ann Marshall, who married Thomas Lister in 1799, depends on identifying John as that bride’s father. The available child-index extract names John but omits the baptism date and mother. Marriage timing supports Ann Allen as a possible mother; a different household or a later wife remains possible. The 1837 Luddenden burial mentioned in the existing research concerns an Ann Marshall aged 85. That age could fit an adult bride in 1772, but age alone does not establish a move from Pontefract or identify the buried woman. It is not used here to assign Ann a birth or death date.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
        "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Elizabeth Allen and a New Sandal marriage-licence entry",
          "record_date": "28 August 1692",
          "locality": "New Sandal, Yorkshire (groom’s residence)",
          "historical_detail": "The Wakefield Family History Society index lists Joseph Beever of New Sandall with Elizabeth Allen on 28 August 1692. Her residence and the intended church are blank. This is a bond or allegation entry, not confirmation that the marriage took place.",
          "association": "It is an earlier Allen name in the wider district around Pontefract, eighty years before Ann’s marriage.",
          "alternatives": "Elizabeth could be related to Ann’s family or belong to an unrelated Allen branch; she could also have lived outside the district.",
          "assessment": "A limited regional lead. The original licence papers might establish her age or residence, but the available entry supplies no connection to Ann or her parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_ALLEN_BEEVER_1692"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Allen usually derives from the personal name Alan, appearing in medieval forms such as Alain and Alein. The earlier Celtic meaning is uncertain.",
          "caveat": "A definite meaning such as handsome or rock should not be assigned to this English branch from its surname alone.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ALLEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Breton followers of William the Conqueror helped popularize the personal name in Britain. Allen became a common English surname; Allan is a frequent Scottish spelling.",
          "caveat": "This broad history does not trace Ann to a particular Breton or Scottish ancestor.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ALLEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name can represent different families descended from men bearing the same personal name. A regional marriage-licence index records an Elizabeth Allen with a New Sandal groom in 1692.",
          "caveat": "That entry gives Elizabeth no residence, so it does not establish an earlier Allen household in Pontefract.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ALLEN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_ALLEN_BEEVER_1692"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_B68_MARIA_ANNA_ABRAHAM_OPPENHEIMER",
      "person_id": "B68_MARIA_ANNA_ABRAHAM_OPPENHEIMER",
      "surname": "Abraham or Oppenheimer",
      "locality": "Ingenheim, Palatinate: documented or reported family context; endpoint birthplace not independently verified",
      "research_limit": "The linked profiles identify Leo’s mother and Hirsch’s wife but use Abraham, Oppenheimer and other name forms without explaining their equivalence. Her parents and birth locality remain unestablished.",
      "notes": "The varying names probably refer to one woman because husband and son agree. The linked profiles may nevertheless repeat a shared error or combine wives. Local naming practices make the variation plausible, but do not identify her natal surname. No earlier Abraham or Oppenheimer household has been connected to her.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
        "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_ABRAHAM_INGENHEIM",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_OPPENHEIMER_INGENHEIM"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Maria Anna (Abraham or Oppenheimer): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Ingenheim, Palatinate: documented or reported family context; endpoint birthplace not independently verified",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The linked profiles identify Leo’s mother and Hirsch’s wife but use Abraham, Oppenheimer and other name forms without explaining their equivalence. Her parents and birth locality remain unestablished. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_ABRAHAM_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_OPPENHEIMER_INGENHEIM"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Abraham derives from Hebrew Avraham, traditionally explained as father of a multitude. Oppenheimer is a German and western Ashkenazic name for someone from Oppenheim. These are alternative explanations for the recorded forms; no single birth surname is yet selected.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_ABRAHAM_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_OPPENHEIMER_INGENHEIM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The family context is Ingenheim, but Maria Anna’s birth locality is unknown. Oppenheim is an etymological lead, not a demonstrated residence. Abraham’s biblical origin gives no geographical origin for this woman.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_ABRAHAM_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_OPPENHEIMER_INGENHEIM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Ingenheim’s recorded changes of women’s civil names provide relevant historical context. They do not establish that every variant here is correct. No kinship to a famous Oppenheimer family follows from the name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_ABRAHAM_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_OPPENHEIMER_INGENHEIM"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_B68_JEHUDA_LOEB_DREYFUSS",
      "person_id": "B68_JEHUDA_LOEB_DREYFUSS",
      "surname": "Dreyfuss",
      "locality": "Ingenheim, Palatinate: documented or reported family context; endpoint birthplace not independently verified",
      "research_limit": "The published transcription of Hirsch’s 1804 epitaph explicitly names his father Jehuda Löb; no spouse, personal dates or higher parentage for Jehuda are supplied. A further identity bridge is needed before joining other Jehuda Löb or Dreyfuss records.",
      "notes": "The published epitaph transcription names Jehuda Löb as Hirsch’s father, making that the strongest available identification. Another Jehuda Löb, son of Jecheskel Halevi from Herxheim, was buried in the same cemetery in 1797. That man’s record supplies neither the Dreyfuss name nor a son Hirsch or useful age, so the identities remain unresolved. The surname’s Trier association does not establish a migration by this family.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
        "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUS_INGENHEIM",
        "SRC_ROOTS_JEHUDA_HERXHEIM_1797",
        "SRC_ROOTS_HIRSCH_EPITAPH_1804"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Jehuda Löb Dreyfuss: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Ingenheim, Palatinate: documented or reported family context; endpoint birthplace not independently verified",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The published transcription of Hirsch’s 1804 epitaph explicitly names his father Jehuda Löb; no spouse, personal dates or higher parentage for Jehuda are supplied. A further identity bridge is needed before joining other Jehuda Löb or Dreyfuss records. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUS_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_JEHUDA_HERXHEIM_1797",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HIRSCH_EPITAPH_1804"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Dreyfuss is a western Ashkenazic variant of Dreyfus. The dictionary derives it from Trevis/Trèves, Trier, with spelling influenced by German Dreifuss, tripod.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUS_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_JEHUDA_HERXHEIM_1797",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HIRSCH_EPITAPH_1804"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Ingenheim is the reported home of this Jehuda. Trier is the surname’s reported place of origin, not his demonstrated birthplace or a proved migration stage.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUS_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_JEHUDA_HERXHEIM_1797",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HIRSCH_EPITAPH_1804"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The local naming history uses Isaak Hirsch Dreyfuss as a Trier-related example but supplies no dated document for the journey. The regional Herxheim namesake is a specific research lead. Neither establishes descent from any earlier prominent Dreyfuss family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUS_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_JEHUDA_HERXHEIM_1797",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HIRSCH_EPITAPH_1804"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_B68_DAVID_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
      "person_id": "B68_DAVID_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
      "surname": "Moses",
      "locality": "Ingenheim, Palatinate: documented or reported family context; endpoint birthplace not independently verified",
      "research_limit": "Known through the profile of his daughter Rosina; his own dates and parents have not been established. The function of Moses in his older name needs checking before treating it as a hereditary surname.",
      "notes": "The local history project explicitly names David Moses as Rosina’s father, with no documented rival father located. Rosina’s fragmentary epitaph does not name her parents and gives an incomplete birth date differing from the profile. Her older name and the 1808 name-adoption record support her household identification, but do not identify David’s parents. Moses may be a patronymic rather than a fixed surname.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
        "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ROSINA_EPITAPH_FRAGMENT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "David Moses: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Ingenheim, Palatinate: documented or reported family context; endpoint birthplace not independently verified",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Known through the profile of his daughter Rosina; his own dates and parents have not been established. The function of Moses in his older name needs checking before treating it as a hereditary surname. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ROSINA_EPITAPH_FRAGMENT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Moses derives here plausibly from the biblical personal name Moshe. The dictionary discusses a probable Egyptian linguistic origin and an ancient Hebrew explanation involving drawing out; neither establishes this family’s geographical ancestry.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ROSINA_EPITAPH_FRAGMENT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The established setting is Rosina’s Ingenheim household. David’s own birthplace is unverified. The name has arisen in multiple unrelated communities and is not a unique migration marker.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ROSINA_EPITAPH_FRAGMENT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1808 list identifies Rösel Moyses as Rosali Dreyfuss alongside Leo’s household. Other local Moses/Moyses names cannot be assumed to belong to David’s kin. No earlier connected household was established by the reviewed profiles and targeted searches.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ROSINA_EPITAPH_FRAGMENT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
      "person_id": "B68_ESTHER_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
      "surname": "Nathan",
      "locality": "Ingenheim, Palatinate: documented or reported family context; endpoint birthplace not independently verified",
      "research_limit": "Rosina’s profile names her mother Esther née Nathan but gives no parents or personal dates. Nathan’s use as a family name or patronymic remains to be tested against original records.",
      "notes": "The local profile explicitly identifies Esther Nathan as David Moses’s wife and Rosina’s mother. No conflicting parent record was found. Rosina’s 1808 name change confirms her later household, not Esther’s parentage; the fragmentary epitaph also does not name Esther. Nathan may be a patronymic or surname, and no father named Nathan has been established for her.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
        "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ROSINA_EPITAPH_FRAGMENT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Esther Nathan Moses: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Ingenheim, Palatinate: documented or reported family context; endpoint birthplace not independently verified",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Rosina’s profile names her mother Esther née Nathan but gives no parents or personal dates. Nathan’s use as a family name or patronymic remains to be tested against original records. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ROSINA_EPITAPH_FRAGMENT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Nathan comes from biblical Hebrew Natan, meaning given by God, and can also abbreviate Jonathan or Nathaniel. This explains the recorded name, not an identified earlier generation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ROSINA_EPITAPH_FRAGMENT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Esther belongs to a reported Ingenheim family context; her birthplace is not demonstrated. Nathan occurs as a personal name and independently formed surname across many households.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ROSINA_EPITAPH_FRAGMENT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1808 list includes Nathan Moyses becoming Jonathan Haas, an actual local name combination worth comparing if further kinship evidence appears. It does not identify Esther’s father or brother. Targeted searches located no earlier household demonstrably connected to her.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ROSINA_EPITAPH_FRAGMENT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "person_id": "B69_ANDREW_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH",
      "surname": "Gibson",
      "locality": "Aghnasedagh, Monaghan parish, County Monaghan, Ireland",
      "research_limit": "John Gibson’s 1883 marriage identifies his father Andrew as a farmer; a matching valuation occupier supplies the local setting. Andrew’s wife, parents and vital dates remain unidentified. The earlier tithe and estate records have not yet been matched to this household.",
      "notes": "Andrew in Aghnasedagh’s valuation is probably John’s father: name, farming context and precise townland agree. The Ontario Andrew has no demonstrated family connection, but an Irish valuation published in 1861 does not prove residence on the Canadian census date. The Canadian identity remains unlinked. Earlier Aghnasedagh deeds and regional tithe entries provide research leads, without yet identifying Andrew’s predecessor or parents.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
        "SRC_IRISH_GENEALOGY_ANDREW_GIBSON_DEATH_SEARCH_1864_1920",
        "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANDREW_GIBSON_1832_1887_ONTARIO_REJECTED",
        "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GIBSON",
        "SRC_ROOTS_CASTLESHANE_TITHE_CONTEXT",
        "SRC_ROOTS_NLI_AGHNASEDAGH_DEEDS",
        "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Andrew Gibson: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Aghnasedagh, Monaghan parish, County Monaghan, Ireland",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: John Gibson’s 1883 marriage identifies his father Andrew as a farmer; a matching valuation occupier supplies the local setting. Andrew’s wife, parents and vital dates remain unidentified. The earlier tithe and estate records have not yet been matched to this household. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
            "SRC_IRISH_GENEALOGY_ANDREW_GIBSON_DEATH_SEARCH_1864_1920",
            "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANDREW_GIBSON_1832_1887_ONTARIO_REJECTED",
            "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GIBSON",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CASTLESHANE_TITHE_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NLI_AGHNASEDAGH_DEEDS",
            "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Gibson means son of Gibb, a familiar form of Gilbert. It can arise independently in different families; the name does not identify a particular remote ancestor.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
            "SRC_IRISH_GENEALOGY_ANDREW_GIBSON_DEATH_SEARCH_1864_1920",
            "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANDREW_GIBSON_1832_1887_ONTARIO_REJECTED",
            "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GIBSON",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CASTLESHANE_TITHE_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NLI_AGHNASEDAGH_DEEDS",
            "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary describes English and Older Scots name formation and seventeenth-century arrival in Ireland, with occasional adoption for an Irish surname. Aghnasedagh is this branch’s evidenced setting; a Scottish or English birthplace for Andrew is not established.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
            "SRC_IRISH_GENEALOGY_ANDREW_GIBSON_DEATH_SEARCH_1864_1920",
            "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANDREW_GIBSON_1832_1887_ONTARIO_REJECTED",
            "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GIBSON",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CASTLESHANE_TITHE_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NLI_AGHNASEDAGH_DEEDS",
            "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
            "SRC_IRISH_GENEALOGY_ANDREW_GIBSON_DEATH_SEARCH_1864_1920",
            "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANDREW_GIBSON_1832_1887_ONTARIO_REJECTED",
            "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GIBSON",
            "SRC_ROOTS_CASTLESHANE_TITHE_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_NLI_AGHNASEDAGH_DEEDS",
            "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "person_id": "B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "surname": "Prichard",
      "locality": "Kerry and Berriew, Montgomeryshire, Wales",
      "research_limit": "Elizabeth Prichard married John Lamb at Kerry on 21 January 1785. Their daughter Elizabeth was baptised there on 19 June. A settlement order of 17 May 1790 names John and Elizabeth with daughter Elizabeth aged four and son John aged two, ordering their removal from Berriew to Kerry. The matching couple and child establish a coherent household, but neither the marriage transcription nor the settlement order names Elizabeth’s parents. Kerry is a documented family location, not a verified birthplace.",
      "notes": "An Elizabeth Lamb buried at Berriew on 23 May 1812 aged 67 is a plausible later record: the name and the family’s earlier presence there fit. If she is the same woman, her birth would fall around 1744–45, making her about forty at the 1785 marriage. The burial supplies neither spouse nor maiden surname, so another Elizabeth Lamb remains possible. It cannot yet fix a birth year for choosing among Prichard baptisms.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1785",
        "SRC_MONTGOMERY_QS_BERRIEW_KERRY_LAMB_1790",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_BERRIEW_BURIAL_1812"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "William Pritchard and a Kerry court case",
          "record_date": "17 July 1723",
          "locality": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire",
          "historical_detail": "A quarter-session recognizance names John Herbert of Kerry with William Pritchard and Elizabeth Lloyd of Kerry. Herbert was bound in £20 and the other two in £5 each, for Herbert to prosecute Jane Jones. William’s role was to provide security, not to answer an accusation.",
          "association": "The spelling variant and Kerry connection make this an earlier local lead for Elizabeth’s wider family, sixty-two years before her marriage.",
          "alternatives": "William could be an older relative, or belong to a separate Pritchard family using the same patronymic surname. The record names no relationship to Elizabeth Prichard.",
          "assessment": "Local family continuity is plausible, but the record cannot distinguish direct descent from collateral kinship or a separate family. William should remain historical context until a connecting parish or probate record is found.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_KERRY_PRITCHARD_1723"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Prichard is a spelling variant of Pritchard, an anglicized form of the Welsh ap Rhisiart, meaning son of Richard.",
          "caveat": "The surname’s meaning does not identify Elizabeth’s father as a man named Richard.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_PRICHARD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_PRITCHARD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name belongs to the Welsh patronymic naming tradition. Elizabeth’s recorded marriage at Kerry places her in Montgomeryshire, but supplies no place of birth.",
          "caveat": "Because different men named Richard could give rise to this surname, its Welsh origin does not establish a single founding family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_PRITCHARD",
            "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A Pritchard appears among the people providing security for a Kerry prosecution in 1723. Elizabeth’s later Lamb household appears in a parish settlement order in 1790, showing how court and parish administration preserved details of local families.",
          "caveat": "These records concern different people and do not establish kinship.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_KERRY_PRITCHARD_1723",
            "SRC_MONTGOMERY_QS_BERRIEW_KERRY_LAMB_1790"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "B73_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Faddis",
      "locality": "Grayson County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "Alexander’s parents and earlier residence remain unresolved. He is identified in Grayson County by 1830 and through the 1835 tax list and 1840 household. Searches of the 1810, 1817, 1824 and 1828 tax transcriptions did not locate an earlier entry; they do not establish when he arrived.",
      "notes": "A compiled North Carolina pedigree names an Alexander Faddis, reportedly born in 1773, with wife Sarah Lynch and son Dickerson. He may be the same man with an earlier family, or another Alexander. The 1840 Grayson household’s oldest man was recorded as 70–79, somewhat older than the compiled date suggests. Neither the age difference nor the different wife settles the identity.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
        "SRC_1840_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1835_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX",
        "ROOTS26_DICKERSON_FADDIS_COMPILED",
        "ROOTS26_GRAYSON_TAX1810",
        "ROOTS26_GRAYSON_TAX1817",
        "ROOTS26_GRAYSON_TAX1824",
        "ROOTS26_GRAYSON_TAX1828"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Three Faddis households in Grayson County in 1830",
          "record_date": "1830",
          "locality": "Grayson County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The census index lists Alexander Faddis with eight people, Elizabeth Faddis with two, and James Faddis with five.",
          "association": "These households establish a local group bearing the same surname before Adelia’s reported birth. A wider-family connection to Alexander is plausible.",
          "alternatives": "Elizabeth and James could belong to separate Faddis families. The alphabetized index does not establish that the three households were neighbors, and gives no relationships or ages.",
          "assessment": "The named households provide a concrete starting point for local family comparisons. Their relationship cannot yet be ranked beyond a possible wider-family association; neither James nor Elizabeth is identified as Alexander’s parent.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Faddis is a variant of Fiddes. The Scottish form comes from a place name; the Irish form can represent a Norman name associated with Sainte-Foy, meaning Holy Faith.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FADDIS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_FIDDES_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary identifies Fiddes in Foveran, Aberdeenshire, and possibly a similarly named barony in former Kincardineshire. The Irish explanation points to Sainte-Foy places in Normandy. Alexander’s American records have not established an origin in any of these places.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FADDIS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_FIDDES_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Kincardineshire place appears in forms Fouthas in 1439 and Futhes in 1440, interpreted as a wooded site. These are historical place-name associations of Fiddes, not evidence that the Grayson family descends from a particular medieval household.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FADDIS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_FIDDES_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_B73_SUSAN_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "B73_SUSAN_FADDIS_GRAYSON_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Grayson County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "Susan’s birth surname and parents have not been identified. The 1850 census names her as Susan Faddis, aged 55, with Sibarina, Isaac, Susan and Floyd. It records Virginia as her birthplace but does not state relationships or name her birth family.",
      "notes": "The older woman and several children in Alexander’s 1840 household fit Susan’s 1850 family in age and locality, supporting continuity between the two households. Alexander could instead have been her father and the children’s grandfather: their recorded ages permit that arrangement too. The censuses alone do not distinguish these relationships. No marriage record identifying Susan’s birth surname has been located in this review. The local historical society lists a Faddis notebook, but its contents have not been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_1840_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
        "SRC_GRayson_HISTORICAL_SOCIETY_FADDIS_NOTEBOOK"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Susan Faddis: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Grayson County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Susan’s birth surname and parents have not been identified. The 1850 census names her as Susan Faddis, aged 55, with Sibarina, Isaac, Susan and Floyd. It records Virginia as her birthplace but does not state relationships or name her birth family. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_1840_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
            "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
            "SRC_GRayson_HISTORICAL_SOCIETY_FADDIS_NOTEBOOK"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Susan Faddis without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Susan Faddis. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Susan Faddis without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_BUTT_ROBERT_WINTERBORNE_FATHER_C1570",
      "person_id": "C_BUTT_ROBERT_WINTERBORNE_FATHER_C1570",
      "surname": "Butt",
      "locality": "Winterborne Houghton and the adjoining Winterborne district, Dorset",
      "research_limit": "Robert Butt married Susan Gantrell on 13 April 1607 according to a published parish transcription. The household reconstruction includes a son Robert baptized in 1616. It does not identify the elder Robert’s parents or establish his reported birth about 1570. Houghton registers survive from 1558–1559, so this endpoint reflects an unresolved identification, not a demonstrated loss of the relevant records.",
      "notes": "The transcription varies between Houghton and nearby Stickland in its place labels; the original entries would settle their precise parish. The proposed identification of the 1616 son with Robert Butt of Virginia remains a separate uncertain link. Earlier Dorset name-bearers provide context for this household without resolving that overseas identification.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Richard, Thomas and John Butt at Five Ashes",
          "record_date": "1525; 1545",
          "locality": "Five Ashes, later Winterborne Anderson, Dorset",
          "historical_detail": "The 1525 subsidy transcription lists Richard, Thomas and John Butt with goods valued at £5, £1 and £5. John Butt appears again in the 1545 list with goods valued at £4. These figures are assessments, not the sums of tax paid.",
          "association": "Anderson lies on the same Winterborne stream as Houghton. This places several Butt name-bearers in the local district 82 years before Robert’s marriage and makes a long-established wider family a plausible explanation.",
          "alternatives": "The taxpayers could represent separate Butt families. The two John entries could concern the same man or different generations; neither return states relationships.",
          "assessment": "This is positive evidence of an earlier local surname cluster. It does not yet distinguish which, if any, taxpayer belonged to Robert’s ancestry; a named heir or shared property descent would make that comparison much stronger.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BUTT_ANDERSON_SUBSIDIES",
            "ROOTS26_ANDERSON_LOCALITY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "George Butt named as churchwarden in the marriage transcription",
          "record_date": "13 April 1607",
          "locality": "Winterborne Houghton, Dorset, as labelled in the profile",
          "historical_detail": "The published transcription of Robert Butt and Susan Gantrell’s marriage names George Butt and Nicholas Waiting as churchwardens, with William Pistell as rector.",
          "association": "A same-surname parish officer in the immediate setting of Robert’s marriage is a more specific family lead than a distant Butt pedigree.",
          "alternatives": "George could have been Robert’s father, another relative or an unrelated local householder. The office listing gives neither his age nor a relationship and does not necessarily mean he witnessed this wedding.",
          "assessment": "George is a concrete person worth tracing, but the present evidence cannot rank fatherhood above other kinship. His own marriage, children or probate record would help identify his place in the household network.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BUTT_GEORGE_1607"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Robert and Symon Butt in the Houghton protestation return",
          "record_date": "1641, as labelled in the transcription",
          "locality": "Winterborne Houghton, Dorset",
          "historical_detail": "The transcribed parish return includes Robert Butt and Symon Butt. It supplies no ages or relationships.",
          "association": "These names overlap the reconstructed household, which includes sons Robert and Simon. Their occurrence together in the same parish supports continued local family presence.",
          "alternatives": "Robert could be the elder householder, his 1616 son or another local namesake. The return alone does not distinguish them, and Symon’s identification also depends on the parish family reconstruction.",
          "assessment": "The return strengthens the local household context but cannot establish the elder Robert’s death date or identify the younger Robert as the Virginia immigrant.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HOUGHTON_PROTESTATION",
            "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Butt can derive from a nickname for a short, stocky person or from residence near a mound. A tree-stump origin is another dictionary possibility, although its early usage is uncertain.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SURNAME_BUTT_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname has several independent formations: English nickname and landscape names, a German fish-related name, and a South Asian form of Bhatt. The Dorset household fits an English setting; its records do not identify which English meaning produced this branch’s name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_SURNAME_BUTT_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_BUTT_GEORGE_1607"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "In this district, Butt occurs among Tudor taxpayers at Anderson and in Houghton parish administration by 1607. These local records connect the name with ordinary property holding and parish life, rather than establishing a single ancestral founder.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BUTT_ANDERSON_SUBSIDIES",
            "ROOTS26_BUTT_GEORGE_1607"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_GANTRELL_RICHARD_FATHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "person_id": "C_GANTRELL_RICHARD_FATHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "surname": "Gantrell",
      "locality": "Winterborne Houghton/Stickland, Dorset; exact early-register attribution unresolved",
      "research_limit": "The quoted 1585 baptism identifies Richard and Aves as Susan’s parents. The proposed 1591 burial fits Richard, but the report’s early Stickland heading conflicts with the parish holdings guide. Richard’s own parents are not established.",
      "notes": "The matching name and chronology favor identifying the baptismal father with the burial subject, although another Richard is possible. More importantly, the reported register location conflicts with the dates in the parish guide. The excerpt may have been assigned to the wrong parish or drawn from another transcript. Its parent names remain evidence, but the locality needs resolution before an earlier family can be identified.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS",
        "SRC_OT26_BROAD_GANTRELL_1591",
        "SRC_ROOTS_OPC_STICKLAND_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Richard Gantrell: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Winterborne Houghton/Stickland, Dorset; exact early-register attribution unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The quoted 1585 baptism identifies Richard and Aves as Susan’s parents. The proposed 1591 burial fits Richard, but the report’s early Stickland heading conflicts with the parish holdings guide. Richard’s own parents are not established. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
            "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS",
            "SRC_OT26_BROAD_GANTRELL_1591",
            "SRC_ROOTS_OPC_STICKLAND_HOLDINGS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "If Gantrell belongs to the Cantrell name family, one explanation is a French-derived diminutive relating to a singer. The spelling relationship is a working hypothesis.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CANTRELL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Cantrell also has possible Quintrell and Devon place-name origins and can be an altered French Cantrelle. No one origin has been selected for Richard.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CANTRELL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The dictionary notes a medieval literary use relating to the cockerel in Reynard stories. That is word history, not evidence that Richard had a particular occupation or belonged to a Norman lineage.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CANTRELL"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_GANTRELL_AVES_MOTHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "person_id": "C_GANTRELL_AVES_MOTHER_SUSAN_1585",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Winterborne Stickland/Houghton, Dorset (reported family record area)",
      "research_limit": "The quoted 18 August 1585 baptism names Aves as Richard Gantrell’s wife and Susan’s mother. It does not name her parents or birth surname. Repeated online family reconstructions do not independently identify her.",
      "notes": "Aves’s marriage has not been located. Houghton’s surviving early registers begin in the 1550 s, while its public transcription begins much later, so the unsuccessful online search does not establish a missing marriage. Susan’s conflicting Stickland parish label also needs resolution. Gantrell is her husband’s surname; Aves’s own natal family is unidentified.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_AVES_SUSAN_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
        "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Aves: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Winterborne Stickland/Houghton, Dorset (reported family record area)",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The quoted 18 August 1585 baptism names Aves as Richard Gantrell’s wife and Susan’s mother. It does not name her parents or birth surname. Repeated online family reconstructions do not independently identify her. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_AVES_SUSAN_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
            "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Aves without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Aves. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Aves without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "person_id": "SRC_MORRIS_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN",
      "surname": "Segel",
      "locality": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
      "research_limit": "Morris Segel is strongly identified as the New Britain clothing merchant and 6 January 1940 death-index entry; contemporary records trace him through civic candidacy and clothing businesses from 1916–1930. His birth date, birthplace, parents, and wife remain unresolved. H1 is the documented New Britain Morris; alternatives are a same-name merchant or a spelling variant such as Segal/Siegel. The continuous local record trail makes the H1 much stronger, but it does not extend his ancestry; no new parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Morris Segel is strongly identified as the New Britain clothing merchant and 6 January 1940 death-index entry; contemporary records trace him through civic candidacy and clothing businesses from 1916–1930. His birth date, birthplace, parents, and wife remain unresolved. H1 is the documented New Britain Morris; alternatives are a same-name merchant or a spelling variant such as Segal/Siegel. The continuous local record trail makes the H1 much stronger, but it does not extend his ancestry; no new parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "New Britain civic, business and death-record trail",
          "record_date": "1916–1940",
          "locality": "New Britain, Hartford County, Connecticut, United States",
          "historical_detail": "Contemporary New Britain records trace Morris Segel from a sixth-ward council candidacy in 1916 through clothing businesses at Railroad Arcade in 1927–1930; Connecticut’s official death index records Morris Segel’s death there on 6 January 1940.",
          "association": "The exact-name, exact-place sequence strongly supports one New Britain Morris and the descendant identification, while leaving his earlier ancestry unresolved.",
          "alternatives": "A same-name merchant or Segel/Segal/Siegel spelling variant remains possible for any isolated record, though the continuous trail makes that alternative less likely.",
          "assessment": "This is a high-confidence endpoint identity with a clear ancestry stopping point: the immigrant generation and parental records have not been identified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN_CONTEXT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Segel has several possible contexts: German-language surname usage, variant spellings such as Segal/Siegel, and an Ashkenazi Jewish Segal/Segel designation associated with Levite tradition. These alternatives make surname meaning alone non-identifying.",
          "caveat": "A continuous adult record trail identifies the New Britain man but does not identify his parents or immigrant origin.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_COUNCIL_CANDIDATE_1916",
            "SRC_CT_DEATH_INDEX_MORRIS_SEGEL_1940"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The documented life is concentrated in New Britain, Connecticut. City-directory, newspaper, business and death-index records provide a continuous local trail, while the immigrant generation and exact place of origin remain unknown.",
          "caveat": "A continuous adult record trail identifies the New Britain man but does not identify his parents or immigrant origin.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_COUNCIL_CANDIDATE_1916",
            "SRC_CT_DEATH_INDEX_MORRIS_SEGEL_1940"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Contemporary New Britain records identify Morris as a sixth-ward council candidate and clothing merchant at Railroad Arcade, with business activity through 1930 and a 1940 state death index entry. The city’s B’nai Israel synagogue is broader community context, not proof of Morris’s membership.",
          "caveat": "A continuous adult record trail identifies the New Britain man but does not identify his parents or immigrant origin.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_COUNCIL_CANDIDATE_1916",
            "SRC_CT_DEATH_INDEX_MORRIS_SEGEL_1940"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743",
      "person_id": "C_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743",
      "surname": "Needham",
      "locality": "Carsington; possible earlier residence in Brassington, Derbyshire",
      "research_limit": "Robert’s published will abstract, dated 1740 and proved in 1743, names son Samuel of Carsington and daughter Anne, wife of Edmond Hopkinson. It does not identify Robert’s parents. The 1694 Ashbourne marriage of Robert Needham of Brassington to Mary Wagstaffe of Hulland is the leading earlier identification: the names and nearby places fit the Robert and Mary household subsequently recorded at Carsington. The marriage transcript supplies no parents, and the original will has not yet been examined.",
      "notes": "Carsington is a documented residence, not an established birthplace. A burial-date discrepancy also remains: the saved FreeREG citation gives Mary, Robert’s wife, as buried on 3 February 1704/5, whereas the Derbyshire Family History Society transcript reads 8 February 1705. The original register is needed to settle the day. Neither transcript gives her birth surname.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_NEEDHAM_ROBERT_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743_ABSTRACT",
        "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_MARRIAGE_1694",
        "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_MARY_WIFE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_BURIAL_1705",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DFHS_CARSINGTON_FORD_BURIALS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Margaret, widow of Roger Nedham: Carsington land mandate",
          "record_date": "18 Jan 1450",
          "locality": "Carsington, Derbyshire; Margaret described as widow of Roger Nedham of Wormhill",
          "historical_detail": "Derbyshire Record Office catalogue D 258/3/8/22 describes Margaret appointing Robert Litton of Litton to take possession of Carsington land from Ralf Gell on her behalf. The date is supplied by the catalogue. This records a power of attorney, not independent proof that possession was subsequently delivered. The original deed image has not been inspected.",
          "association": "The later Robert Needham household is documented in Carsington by the end of the seventeenth century, and Robert appears there as a tenant in 1713. The specific shared locality and Nedham/Needham surname make the medieval household a plausible earlier association with the wider family. The interval to 1713 is 263 years; the intervening generations have not been identified.",
          "alternatives": "The 1450 Wormhill household and the later Carsington household could belong to different Needham lineages. They could also be related without the later family inheriting this land. The medieval parcel is unnamed in the catalogue; it cannot be equated with Robert’s later New Close tenancy. Different property tenure does not itself disprove wider kinship.",
          "assessment": "Possible wider-family continuity, supported by a specific surname-and-locality match. The record supplies no evidence that distinguishes a family connection from a separate Needham household sufficiently to call it probable. Direct descent remains unresolved; this is historical context, not a new parent link.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_DRO_MARGARET_NEDHAM_WORMHILL_CARSINGTON_1450",
            "SRC_DRO_GELL_NEW_CLOSE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_1713"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Adam Needham’s garden and church seat at Bonsall",
          "record_date": "1671",
          "locality": "Bonsall, Derbyshire",
          "historical_detail": "A deed catalogued as D161/BOX/6/48 records Adam Needham, a yeoman of Bonsall, conveying a garden south of Edward Smedley the elder’s house to Smedley, together with half a seat in Bonsall church near the bellhouse.",
          "association": "This is a specific earlier Needham household in the district around Carsington. The surname and nearby locality make a connection with Robert’s wider family plausible.",
          "alternatives": "Adam could belong to a separate Derbyshire Needham branch; even a shared regional origin would not establish that he was Robert’s father or ancestor.",
          "assessment": "A useful local family-history lead, with geography favoring investigation. The catalogue supplies no relationship to Robert, so close kinship cannot yet be ranked above a more distant connection. The deed’s witnesses and any related inheritance records could distinguish them.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DRO_ADAM_NEEDHAM_BONSALL_1671"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "The unnamed child born in 1695",
          "record_date": "1695–1697",
          "locality": "Carsington, Derbyshire",
          "historical_detail": "The Carsington transcript places an unnamed child of Robert and Mary Needham on 5 August 1695 and records the rector’s doubt about its baptism. The burial transcript lists a child of Robert on 3 June 1697, explicitly giving its birth as 5 August 1695.",
          "association": "The exact birth-date match strongly favors these being records of the same child. It helps establish Robert and Mary’s household before the 1740 will.",
          "alternatives": "A copying error remains possible because the register images have not been checked. The transcripts derive from the same parish register and are not independent testimony.",
          "assessment": "The infant who died in 1697 should not be identified as Robert’s son Samuel, living when the will was written. The household’s dissenting religious position explains why an ordinary baptism may not be available for each child; it does not supply their missing names.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DFHS_CARSINGTON_FORD_BURIALS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DFHS_CARSINGTON_FORD_BAPTISMS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The English place-derived name combines terms for hardship and a homestead, interpreted as land offering a poor living.",
          "caveat": "This meaning describes the place name.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NEEDHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Several places could supply the name: High Needham in Hartington, Derbyshire, and places in Cambridgeshire, Norfolk and Suffolk. A separate County Mayo Irish formation represents Ó Niadh.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NEEDHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "High Needham provides a specific Derbyshire geographical lead for comparison with the county’s older Needham records.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NEEDHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The English surname comes from places called Needham. Their Old English elements refer to need or hardship and a homestead, suggesting land that offered a poor living.",
          "caveat": "This describes the place-name, rather than Robert’s personal circumstances.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NEEDHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "High Needham in Hartington, Derbyshire, is one reported source. Other independent sources lie in Cambridgeshire, Norfolk and Suffolk. The dictionary also records an Irish County Mayo name anglicized from Ó Niadh.",
          "caveat": "Robert’s Derbyshire setting makes High Needham a relevant possibility, but his birthplace and earlier family movements are unestablished.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NEEDHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The local records place Needhams among farming and property-holding households: Adam was a Bonsall yeoman in 1671, while Robert appears as a Carsington tenant in 1713 and a yeoman in the 1743 probate index.",
          "caveat": "Their shared social setting adds context; no transfer of property between these men has been identified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DRO_ADAM_NEEDHAM_BONSALL_1671",
            "SRC_DRO_GELL_NEW_CLOSE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_1713",
            "SRC_STAFFS_WILLS_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1743"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_MARTHA_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1747",
      "person_id": "C_MARTHA_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1747",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Carsington and Hopton, Derbyshire",
      "research_limit": "Martha is named with Samuel Nedham as Edward’s parents in the Carsington baptism transcript of 21 February 1733/34. Her burial on 4 August 1747 describes her as Samuel Needham’s wife of Hopton. Neither entry supplies her birth surname or parents; Carsington and Hopton describe the recorded household, not a proven birthplace.",
      "notes": "The burial transcript also names Mary, daughter of Samuel and Martha Nedham, in 1736 and Elizabeth, their daughter, in 1742. The recurring parents’ names and parish favor one household across these records. A review of the published Carsington marriage table found no entry identifying this couple’s marriage. It does contain a Samuel Smith–Martha Smith wedding in 1743, but that differently named groom and later date do not identify Edward’s mother as Martha Smith. The table has gaps, and the couple may have married elsewhere. Until a marriage, probate record or other family document establishes her birth surname, the origins and earlier bearers of Needham belong to Samuel’s family history rather than to Martha’s ancestry.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BAPTISM_1734",
        "SRC_DFHS_CARSINGTON_SAMUEL_MARTHA_BURIALS",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DFHS_CARSINGTON_MARTHA_MARRIAGE_REVIEW"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Martha (maiden name unknown) Nedham: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Carsington and Hopton, Derbyshire",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Martha is named with Samuel Nedham as Edward’s parents in the Carsington baptism transcript of 21 February 1733/34. Her burial on 4 August 1747 describes her as Samuel Needham’s wife of Hopton. Neither entry supplies her birth surname or parents; Carsington and Hopton describe the recorded household, not a proven birthplace. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BAPTISM_1734",
            "SRC_DFHS_CARSINGTON_SAMUEL_MARTHA_BURIALS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DFHS_CARSINGTON_MARTHA_MARRIAGE_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Martha (maiden name unknown) Nedham without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Martha (maiden name unknown) Nedham. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Martha (maiden name unknown) Nedham without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_GEORGE_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1738",
      "person_id": "C_GEORGE_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1738",
      "surname": "Needham",
      "locality": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire",
      "research_limit": "George is named as father of Edward Needham in the Ashbourne St Oswald baptism transcription dated 9 June 1738. The saved entry identifies neither George’s parents nor his wife. His own birth date and birthplace are unestablished; Ashbourne is the place of his son’s baptism.",
      "notes": "This is a candidate ancestral branch. George’s son shares the later grocer Edward Needham’s name and parish, which favors the identification. However, the grocer’s burial on 7 April 1816 gives an age of 82, fitting the Edward baptised at Carsington in February 1733/34 to Samuel and Martha more closely. An infant baptised in June 1738 would have been about 77 or 78 in April 1816. An inaccurate burial age or a baptism several years after birth could reconcile George’s son with the grocer, but neither is established. Both families remain separate in the tree; the Carsington identification currently leads.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1738",
        "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BURIAL_1816",
        "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BAPTISM_1734"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Needhams in the Wirksworth Hundred, about 1570",
          "record_date": "circa 1570",
          "locality": "Hartington and Snitterton, Derbyshire",
          "historical_detail": "A published freemen list names Richard Nedeham of Snitterton as a gentleman, and Humphrey, Edward and John Nedeham of Hartington as yeomen. These places were in the same hundred as Ashbourne; the men are not listed as Ashbourne residents.",
          "association": "They establish earlier bearers of the name in the surrounding district, making continuity within a regional family a plausible explanation for George’s later presence.",
          "alternatives": "George could descend from another regional branch or from migrants whose surname came from a different Needham place.",
          "assessment": "The roughly 170-year gap and absence of connecting relatives or property leave these possibilities unresolved. This is regional surname history, not a pedigree to any of the listed men. The transcription’s date is approximate.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WIRKSWORTH_FREEMEN_NEDEHAM_C1570"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "An earlier Needham marriage at St Oswald’s",
          "record_date": "3 September 1694",
          "locality": "Ashbourne; Brassington; Hulland, Derbyshire",
          "historical_detail": "The saved parish transcription records Robert Needham of Brassington marrying Mary Wagstaffe of Hulland at Ashbourne St Oswald on 3 September 1694, forty-four years before Edward’s baptism.",
          "association": "The same surname and church provide a more local lead than a distant surname pedigree. Robert is also retained in the tree on the separate Carsington branch.",
          "alternatives": "Use of the same parish church can reflect neighboring residences without close kinship. The marriage does not name George, and Robert’s relationship to him is unestablished.",
          "assessment": "A plausible wider-family connection worth testing through wills and parish households. Neither shared parish nor the existing Carsington branch establishes Robert as George’s father.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_MARRIAGE_1694"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The English place-derived name combines terms for hardship and a homestead, interpreted as land offering a poor living.",
          "caveat": "This meaning describes the place name.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NEEDHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Several places could supply the name: High Needham in Hartington, Derbyshire, and places in Cambridgeshire, Norfolk and Suffolk. A separate County Mayo Irish formation represents Ó Niadh.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NEEDHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "High Needham provides a specific Derbyshire geographical lead for comparison with the county’s older Needham records.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NEEDHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Needham is an English place-derived surname. The place-name combines Old English words for hardship or need and a homestead, describing land that gave a poor living.",
          "caveat": "The meaning does not establish George’s occupation or wealth.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NEEDHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Reported English sources include High Needham in Hartington, Derbyshire, as well as places in Cambridgeshire, Norfolk and Suffolk. A separate Irish origin in County Mayo is an anglicization of Ó Niadh.",
          "caveat": "High Needham is geographically relevant to this branch, but George’s birthplace is unknown.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NEEDHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Earlier regional records include Needhams described as gentlemen and yeomen. The Ashbourne evidence for George himself is a child’s baptism; it does not establish that he belonged to a landed family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WIRKSWORTH_FREEMEN_NEDEHAM_C1570",
            "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1738"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1668_1677",
      "person_id": "C_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1668_1677",
      "surname": "Wagstaffe",
      "locality": "Hulland, in Ashbourne parish, Derbyshire",
      "research_limit": "Thomas of Hulland is named as father in the Ashbourne baptism transcripts for Mary on 29 November 1668 and for Mary and Joseph on 7 November 1677. They do not give his age, occupation or parents. Hulland is his recorded locality at these events, not an established birthplace.",
      "notes": "Thomas Waggstaffe’s marriage to Alce Allsopp at Ashbourne on 27 April 1667 fits the following year’s baptism and is the leading identification of this household. The child entries do not name a mother. The two Mary baptisms nine years apart could represent a child named after an earlier daughter who died, or children of different men called Thomas; an identifying burial or fuller register entry would help distinguish these explanations. The shared father’s name and Hulland locality favor continuity, but neither entry by itself identifies the Mary who married Robert Needham in 1694. The earlier Hasland pedigree and later Hulland bond provide family-history context below without supplying Thomas’s missing parents.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGSTAFFE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1668_1677",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGGSTAFFE_ALLSOPP_MARRIAGE_1667",
        "SRC_HASLAND_HALL_WAGSTAFFE_HISTORY_20260727",
        "SRC_DERBY_ARCHIVE_SAMUEL_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_BOND_1742"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anthony Wagstaffe in the Foljambe household",
          "record_date": "1595; pedigree recorded 1611",
          "locality": "Walton, North Wingfield and Hasland, Derbyshire",
          "historical_detail": "The published Hasland Hall history describes Anthony Wagstaffe as a servant and executor of Godfrey Foljambe of Walton, who died in 1595. Anthony received £100 and a further £10 for his work as executor. He later submitted a pedigree in 1611 and died in 1630.",
          "association": "This records an earlier Wagstaffe family elsewhere in Derbyshire, within several generations of the Hulland household. A wider family connection is possible.",
          "alternatives": "The Hasland family could be a separate branch or an unrelated family bearing the same nickname-derived surname. Its documented North Wingfield and Walton associations do not identify a migration to Hulland.",
          "assessment": "The county and chronology make this a regional research lead, but it is less closely matched geographically than the Hulland records. The history identifies Anthony’s father as Thomas of North Wingfield, who died in 1568; that man cannot be the father appearing in Hulland baptisms a century later. No parent link to the Hasland pedigree is established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HASLAND_HALL_WAGSTAFFE_HISTORY_20260727",
            "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGSTAFFE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1668_1677"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Samuel Wagstaffe’s Hulland bond",
          "record_date": "2 September 1742",
          "locality": "Hulland and Brailsford, Derbyshire",
          "historical_detail": "The archive catalogue records a £230 bond involving Samuel Wagstaffe of Hulland and Charles Soresbie of Brailsford, both described as yeomen.",
          "association": "Samuel provides a later occurrence of the surname in Thomas’s own locality, 65 years after the 1677 baptisms. He could belong to a continuing Hulland family.",
          "alternatives": "Samuel could instead have arrived from another Wagstaffe branch. The catalogue supplies neither his age nor parents, and the bond could reflect business dealings rather than kinship.",
          "assessment": "The exact locality gives this stronger geographical relevance than the Hasland family history. Continuity is plausible, but the entry alone cannot identify Samuel as Thomas’s son, grandson or other relative.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_DERBY_ARCHIVE_SAMUEL_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_BOND_1742",
            "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGSTAFFE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1668_1677"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Wagstaff, also written Wagstaffe or Waggstaffe in this branch, began as a nickname referring to someone moving or brandishing a staff.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WAGSTAFF_2022",
            "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGSTAFFE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1668_1677",
            "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGGSTAFFE_ALLSOPP_MARRIAGE_1667"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary identifies English and Scottish usage, rather than a single place of origin. It suggests a beadle carrying a staff as one explanation, and a bawdy nickname as another.",
          "caveat": "The name does not establish Thomas’s occupation or where his family first acquired it.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WAGSTAFF_2022"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Wagstaffe families appear in the history of North Wingfield and Hasland, while Thomas’s own records place him at Hulland. A later bond names Samuel Wagstaffe of Hulland as a yeoman.",
          "caveat": "These are distinct households until their relationships can be established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_HASLAND_HALL_WAGSTAFFE_HISTORY_20260727",
            "SRC_DERBY_ARCHIVE_SAMUEL_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_BOND_1742",
            "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGSTAFFE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1668_1677"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_REIFF_HANSS_JERG_UNTERHAUSEN_1536",
      "person_id": "C_REIFF_HANSS_JERG_UNTERHAUSEN_1536",
      "surname": "Reiff",
      "locality": "Reported Unterhausen, now Lichtenstein, Württemberg",
      "research_limit": "Hanss Jerg Reiff, reportedly born in 1536, is named in the Morales Abeln public tree as father of Barbara and five other children. That page supplies no sources or parents for him. The identification therefore remains a candidate derived from a family tree. Its Barbara also lacks the details needed to establish that she was the woman associated elsewhere with Hans Fuchs.",
      "notes": "Unterhausen’s catalogued early mixed book has baptisms from 1579, but its marriage entries begin in 1597. It cannot directly supply the reported 1590 Fuchs–Reiff marriage. Other evidence could still identify the household. The historical material reviewed has not yet supplied an attributable earlier Reiff family in this locality; later documented households are described below.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_REIFF_HANSS_JERG_1536",
        "SRC_ARCHION_UNTERHAUSEN_MIXED_BOOK_1579_1618",
        "ROOTS26_REIFF_FRITZ_UNTERHAUSEN"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Later Unterhausen Reiffs and the migration to Harmony",
          "record_date": "1804",
          "locality": "Unterhausen; Harmony, United States",
          "historical_detail": "Eberhard Fritz’s compilation of religious separatists lists two Unterhausen weavers named Matthäus Reiff, distinguished as elder and younger, born in 1752 and 1770. Both emigrated to Harmony in 1804; the elder travelled with three children. The entries cite church-archive and Harmony-family references.",
          "association": "These are specific later households in the same reported village. They provide a local surname history and possible collateral-family leads, rather than earlier ancestors of the sixteenth-century candidate.",
          "alternatives": "The families could descend from an older local Reiff population, or from later arrivals. The labels elder and younger distinguish namesakes but do not by themselves establish a father-son relationship.",
          "assessment": "Shared village and surname favor investigating continuity. The long interval, several possible origins of the name, and Hanss Jerg’s uncertain identification leave the relationship unranked. These records neither establish his parents nor show that he shared the later families’ religious beliefs.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_REIFF_FRITZ_UNTERHAUSEN",
            "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_REIFF_HANSS_JERG_1536",
            "ROOTS26_REIFF_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary derives Reiff from Middle High German reif, referring to a hoop, ribbon or cord. This could name a cooper, ribbon maker or rope maker, or someone associated with a house displaying a hoop sign.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_REIFF_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "A second German explanation derives Reiff from the medieval personal name Riff, shortened from Richfrit, with elements meaning power and peace. These alternative formations need not share one ancestral household.",
          "caveat": "The dictionary does not identify which origin applies to the reported Unterhausen family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_REIFF_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name can therefore carry craft, house-sign or personal-name associations. The dictionary also records an Ashkenazic formation from the German word for mature.",
          "caveat": "None establishes Hanss Jerg’s trade, religious ancestry or place of birth.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_REIFF_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_ALICE_ALLSOPP_WIFE_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_1667",
      "person_id": "C_ALICE_ALLSOPP_WIFE_THOMAS_WAGSTAFFE_1667",
      "surname": "Allsopp",
      "locality": "Ashbourne and the surrounding Derbyshire district",
      "research_limit": "Alice, written Alce Allsopp, married Thomas Waggstaffe at Ashbourne St Oswald on 27 April 1667. The available transcript gives no age, parents or home parish for her. No baptism or parent-naming record has yet been connected to this bride.",
      "notes": "The marriage shortly precedes the Hulland baptism of Mary, daughter of Thomas Wagstaff, in November 1668. The matching husband’s name and local chronology favor Alice as the mother, but the baptism omits a mother’s name. Another Mary and a Joseph were recorded to Thomas of Hulland in 1677; those entries require their own identity assessment. Alice’s surname has a strong local history, described below, but none of the earlier name-bearers has yet been identified as her parent.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGGSTAFFE_ALLSOPP_MARRIAGE_1667",
        "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGSTAFFE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1668_1677",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ASHBOURNE_ALSOP_MARRIAGES_1544_1667",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ALSOPP_WILL_WAGSTAFFE_1697"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Cecilie Alsop’s marriage at Ashbourne",
          "record_date": "27 September 1544",
          "locality": "Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
          "historical_detail": "The St Oswald transcript records Cecilie Alsop marrying Richard Brassington on 27 September 1544. It also records Henrie Alsop marrying Alice Tirrey and John Alsop marrying Ellen Gent in 1552.",
          "association": "These entries place the surname in Alice’s marriage parish more than a century before her 1667 wedding. They could represent earlier generations of her wider local family.",
          "alternatives": "The earlier couples could belong to different branches, or to unrelated families whose surname came from the same village. The transcript supplies no chain of relationships between them and Alice.",
          "assessment": "The repeated surname in the same parish makes local family continuity plausible. The 123-year interval prevents assigning a particular relationship from these entries alone. Neither Cecilie nor Richard is added as Alice’s ancestor, and the Brassington name is not treated as a bridge to the separate Brassington branch.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ASHBOURNE_ALSOP_MARRIAGES_1544_1667",
            "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGGSTAFFE_ALLSOPP_MARRIAGE_1667"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "An Alsopp–Wagstaffe connection in a nearby will",
          "record_date": "1697; probate 1699",
          "locality": "Fenny Bentley and Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
          "historical_detail": "William Alsopp, a yeoman of Fenny Bentley, left twenty shillings to Robert Wagstaffe of Ashbourne in his will dated 1 December 1697. The Derbyshire Record Office catalogue records probate in 1699.",
          "association": "The bequest documents contact between local Alsopp and Wagstaffe households thirty years after Alice married Thomas Wagstaffe. It is a useful lead for the wider family network.",
          "alternatives": "Robert could have been a relative, friend or another associate. The catalogue names neither Alice nor Thomas and gives no kinship term for Robert.",
          "assessment": "This is stronger evidence of contact than the two surnames merely appearing in the same district, but it does not identify how either man was related to Alice. The full will may distinguish those possibilities.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ALSOPP_WILL_WAGSTAFFE_1697",
            "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGGSTAFFE_ALLSOPP_MARRIAGE_1667"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Allsopp is a spelling of Alsop, a name taken from Alsop en le Dale in Derbyshire. The place-name combines the Old English personal name Ælle with a word for an enclosed valley.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ALLSOPP_ALSOP_2022"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname’s recorded place of origin lies in the same Derbyshire district as Alice’s marriage at Ashbourne. This gives her name a specific local geographical context.",
          "caveat": "It does not establish that Alice was born at Alsop en le Dale or descended from its lords of the manor.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ALLSOPP_ALSOP_2022"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Alsop, Allsop and Allsopp spellings occur in the Ashbourne area. The parish transcript records several marriages under these forms long before Alice’s own marriage.",
          "caveat": "A name taken from a village could be used by more than one family leaving it; the shared locality supports investigating kinship without establishing one pedigree.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ALLSOPP_ALSOP_2022",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ASHBOURNE_ALSOP_MARRIAGES_1544_1667"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_GOBEL_LUDWIG_ERPFINGEN_1522",
      "person_id": "C_GOBEL_LUDWIG_ERPFINGEN_1522",
      "surname": "Göbel / Gobel",
      "locality": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "research_limit": "Ludwig’s parents and place of birth remain unidentified. The evidence places him in Erpfingen in 1522, but does not give his age. The parish-register catalogue begins in 1594, too late to provide an ordinary contemporary baptism entry for someone already recorded in 1522. Earlier landholding, inheritance or court records are therefore the relevant route beyond him; the current sources identify no preceding Göbel relative.",
      "notes": "The tree retains Ludwig as a weak candidate father of Hans. Their shared surname and village support a possible family connection, but Ludwig could instead be a grandfather, another relative or a member of a separate household. Neither a direct father–son relationship nor an intervening generation is stated in the cited passage. The former “before 1502” birth estimate assumed that a rent payer was at least twenty; the record does not establish that age.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_GOBEL_P251",
        "ROOTS26_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_COVERAGE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ludwig in Erpfingen’s land register",
          "record_date": "1522",
          "locality": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
          "historical_detail": "Weigel identifies Ludwig Göbel as a Zinser, or rent payer, in the renewed land register, citing Paul Schwarz’s published edition, volume II, page 714. This is the earliest local Göbel reference identified in the sources reviewed here.",
          "association": "The entry anchors the name in the same village as the later Hans and Martin family.",
          "alternatives": "A surname continuing in one village can represent descendants, collateral relatives or separate households. The passage does not identify a succession of tenants or name Ludwig’s children.",
          "assessment": "Local family continuity is plausible. Inspecting page 714 and tracing the same property in subsequent registers could distinguish direct descent from a broader family association.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_GOBEL_P251",
            "SRC_ALTWUERTTEMBERG_LAGERBUCH_1522_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "German Göbel is a familiar form of Godebert, a personal name combining an element meaning good or God with one meaning bright or famous.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GOEBEL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Göbel and its spelling Goebel have a German personal-name origin. Erpfingen supplies the specific locality for Ludwig’s recorded household.",
          "caveat": "The place where he paid rent does not establish where he or the surname originated.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GOEBEL",
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_GOBEL_P251"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "For this branch the documented historical association is with rent-paying landholders in a Württemberg village. The surname itself does not denote a forest occupation or establish a connection to another Göbel lineage.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GOEBEL",
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_GOBEL_P251"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_LEVY_MICHEL_MACHOLE_FATHER_JACQUES_1725",
      "person_id": "C_LEVY_MICHEL_MACHOLE_FATHER_JACQUES_1725",
      "surname": "Levy",
      "locality": "Alsace, Bas-Rhin, France (Ottrott/Rosenwiller context unresolved)",
      "research_limit": "Michel Machole Levy is supported as Jacques/Jeckel Levy’s father by a Rosenwiller cemetery-memory transcription and the 1784 Ottrott enumeration, but his own birth about 1725, birthplace, wife, death and parents remain unresolved. H1 is the published/transcribed father identity; alternatives are another Michel, a patronymic-only reading, or an unrelated Marmoutier Levy family. No new edge is added.",
      "notes": "Michel Machole Levy is supported as Jacques/Jeckel Levy’s father by a Rosenwiller cemetery-memory transcription and the 1784 Ottrott enumeration, but his own birth about 1725, birthplace, wife, death and parents remain unresolved. H1 is the published/transcribed father identity; alternatives are another Michel, a patronymic-only reading, or an unrelated Marmoutier Levy family. No new edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730",
        "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
        "SRC_GENAMI_MARMOUTIER_LEVY_FAMILIES_2004_20260730"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Machole Levy name evidence and competing household hypotheses",
          "record_date": "1784 enumeration; 1806 burial; reported birth about 1725",
          "locality": "Ottrott / Rosenwiller, Bas-Rhin, Alsace, France (for Michel candidate)",
          "historical_detail": "The 1784 Ottrott material and a Rosenwiller cemetery-memory transcription identify a Machole/Michaël as associated with Jacques/Jeckel Levy’s father. A separate Marmoutier reconstruction documents other Macholé Levy families without connecting them to Ottrott.",
          "association": "The Michel candidate has direct father-name support for Jacques; the original Machole profile remains an unlocated alternative and cannot be merged solely by the compound name.",
          "alternatives": "Another Michel, a patronymic-only interpretation, or an unrelated Marmoutier family remains possible.",
          "assessment": "The evidence supports keeping the candidates separate and ranking Michel’s father identity above the unsupported 1725 profile, without inventing a parent link.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_GENAMI_MARMOUTIER_LEVY_FAMILIES_2004_20260730"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Levy/Levi may denote Levite status or a patronymic/religious lineage rather than a unique hereditary surname in early Alsatian Jewish records. The compound Machole/Macholé may preserve a personal-name or patronymic element, but its exact usage is not established here.",
          "caveat": "Shared Levy/Machole naming and regional Jewish context do not identify one household or justify merging the two candidates.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_GENAMI_MARMOUTIER_LEVY_FAMILIES_2004_20260730"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The direct locality is unresolved for Machole. The stronger Michel candidate is tied to Jacques/Jeckel Levy’s Ottrott/Rosenwiller evidence; separate Marmoutier Macholé families are documented as alternatives, not merged ancestors.",
          "caveat": "Shared Levy/Machole naming and regional Jewish context do not identify one household or justify merging the two candidates.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_GENAMI_MARMOUTIER_LEVY_FAMILIES_2004_20260730"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The 1784 Ottrott enumeration and 1806 Rosenwiller cemetery-memory transcription provide the specific father-name evidence for Michel Machole Levy. The original Machole profile has no equivalent person-specific record.",
          "caveat": "Shared Levy/Machole naming and regional Jewish context do not identify one household or justify merging the two candidates.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730",
            "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
            "SRC_GENAMI_MARMOUTIER_LEVY_FAMILIES_2004_20260730"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1335_1395",
      "person_id": "G28_JOHN_PHYLLIPPES_1335_1395",
      "surname": "Phylppes / Phillips",
      "locality": "Reported England; no medieval parish or manor identified for John",
      "research_limit": "John is retained as the earliest proposed ancestor in the supplied compiled pedigree. No cited medieval record currently identifies his household, parents or connection to Henry. The reported death around 1395 precedes Henry’s reported birth around 1400. Those dates cannot both be accurate for the proposed father and son: an erroneous date, mistaken identity or incorrect relationship could explain the conflict. Identifying a household and a dated record is necessary before choosing an earlier family.",
      "notes": "Staffordshire and Tewkesbury occur in claims about later generations; neither has been established as this John’s home. The 1899 family history preserves an older proposal linking those families, but does not document this fourteenth-century chain. The existing candidate links remain visible while these alternatives are investigated.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
        "ROOTS26_PHELPS_SERVIN1899"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "A documented John Philippes at Dyrham",
          "record_date": "4 February 1416",
          "locality": "Dyrham, Gloucestershire",
          "historical_detail": "An edited partition of Dyrham manor lists John Philippes holding a cottage, cotland and close charged at five shillings, with a further toft and cotland called Duryes charged at eight shillings and four pence. He appears among tenants in the share allotted to John Drayton and Isabel.",
          "association": "This is a concrete medieval name-bearer in the county associated with later generations of the proposed pedigree. It provides a record to compare, rather than an identified ancestor.",
          "alternatives": "The Dyrham tenant could belong to another Phillips family. Identifying him with this John would also require correcting the reported 1395 death, since the partition is dated 1416.",
          "assessment": "The name match is positive evidence for comparison, but a county connection drawn from later generations is too indirect to identify the tenant. No relative or property currently connects the two accounts; no new relationship is assigned.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PHILIPPES_DYRHAM1416",
            "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "How the Staffordshire connection was proposed",
          "record_date": "Published 1899; correspondence of 1859–1860",
          "locality": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire; Nether Teyne, Checkley, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "On page 44, Phelps and Servin report Charles H. Phelps’s belief that James Phelps of Tewkesbury and Francis Phyllyppe of Nether Teyne were brothers and sons of Richard. Page 50 repeats the proposal as a belief of descendants. The Francis described there died in the sixth year of Edward VI, in 1552–1553, rather than 1491.",
          "association": "This provides a specific earlier source for the proposed connection between the Tewkesbury and Staffordshire families. It helps explain why those places recur in later pedigrees.",
          "alternatives": "A real wider-family connection remains possible, but the sixteenth-century Francis could have been confused with the similarly named fifteenth-century man in the supplied chain. Separate families with related surname forms are another possibility.",
          "assessment": "These pages document the history of the proposal, not descent from John born about 1335. The two Francis identities must be tested separately against Staffordshire probate and property records before either can support the medieval chain.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PHELPS_SERVIN1899",
            "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Phillips is a patronymic formed from the personal name Philip. Phylppes is treated here as a historical spelling in that name group, rather than as evidence of a distinct founding family.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PHILLIPS_DAFN",
            "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary describes Phelps as a Scottish and southwestern English variant of Phillips. That regional association is compatible with the later Gloucestershire claims, but cannot locate John in the fourteenth century.",
          "caveat": "His locality remains England only in the supplied pedigree.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PHELPS_DAFN",
            "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The family history discusses both the Tewkesbury Phelps family and a Phyllyppe family at Nether Teyne, Checkley. Its proposed relationship is explicitly conjectural; the accompanying discussion of coats of arms does not supply the missing parentage.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PHELPS_SERVIN1899"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_G28_SARAH_JANE_SALLY_WIFE_AQUILLA",
      "person_id": "G28_SARAH_JANE_SALLY_WIFE_AQUILLA",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "No locality recorded; Aquilla Felps branch only",
      "research_limit": "Sarah Jane “Sally” is reported only as Aquilla Felps’s wife and John Felps’s mother in a compiled Geni-derived lineage. No maiden surname, birth or death date, residence, marriage record, parent, or original household record identifies her. H1 is the imported spouse/mother claim; alternatives are another Sarah Jane, an unrelated Aquilla Felps household, or a conflated spouse profile. The next tests are Aquilla’s marriage, probate and children’s records; no parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "This is a surname-unresolved spouse endpoint. The absence of a maiden name prevents a meaningful family-name continuity claim.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_SALLY_NAME_LIMIT",
        "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Sarah Jane Sally: spouse identity and maiden surname unresolved",
          "record_date": "dates unknown",
          "locality": "No locality recorded; Aquilla Felps branch only",
          "historical_detail": "The compiled lineage calls Sarah Jane “Sally” the wife of Aquilla Felps and mother of John Felps. It supplies no maiden surname, dates, place, marriage record, or parent.",
          "association": "The continuity hypothesis is a single spouse in the Aquilla Felps household. Alternatives include another Sarah Jane, a different Aquilla household, or a conflated compiled profile.",
          "alternatives": "Another Sarah Jane; Felps/Phelps surname incorrectly assigned as birth surname; unrelated Aquilla Felps household; or unsupported spouse claim.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint records the actual compiled evidence and stops at the missing identity-specific records. No maiden surname or parent edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SALLY_NAME_LIMIT",
            "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "No surname is established. Sarah Jane “Sally” is a personal-name form only; no maiden-name etymology can be responsibly supplied.",
          "caveat": "A spouse’s reported first name cannot identify her birth family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SALLY_NAME_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No birthplace, residence, or migration origin is recorded. The only context is the compiled Aquilla Felps branch.",
          "caveat": "The Felps/Phelps surname belongs to the husband’s line and cannot be assigned to Sarah’s birth family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SALLY_NAME_LIMIT",
            "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The compiled lineage associates Sarah Jane “Sally” with Aquilla Felps and their reported son John Felps; no original marriage or household record was inspected.",
          "caveat": "Compiled spouse association is a research lead, not an identity-specific historical record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_G28_JOAN_WIFE_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "person_id": "G28_JOAN_WIFE_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "research_limit": "Joan is named as James Phelps’s widow in a published extract of a probate administration dated 10 May 1588. The extract identifies their marriage but gives neither her birth surname nor her parents. Direct ancestry stops at that unidentified birth family.",
      "notes": "The 1899 family history was checked against its page images. Its probate transcription and a separate letter about a Dame Joan Coke concern different kinds of evidence; the letter does not identify the widow. The original administration and the Podsmead title deeds have not been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_PHELPS_PRIOR_JOAN_COKE",
        "ROOTS26_CRYPT_PODSMEAD_1539"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Joan Cooke and the Podsmead estate",
          "record_date": "1539; recollection written in 1877",
          "locality": "Podsmead, Gloucester",
          "historical_detail": "The Crypt School records Joan Cooke’s purchase of Podsmead in 1539. William Phelps Prior’s 1877 letter mentions a Dame Joan Coke and a claimed succession of Phelps holders there, without saying she married James Phelps.",
          "association": "The shared personal name and estate make the school founder a specific candidate for the woman in the letter. This could explain the Coke name in later Phelps pedigrees.",
          "alternatives": "The letter might concern another woman, or preserve a property association that did not arise through Joan Phelps’s birth family. Its relationship to later pedigree claims has not been traced.",
          "assessment": "The estate story is a research lead, not evidence that Coke was the widow’s birth name. Identifying the estate’s grants and later holders could distinguish inheritance, tenancy and unrelated ownership.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PHELPS_PRIOR_JOAN_COKE",
            "ROOTS26_CRYPT_PODSMEAD_1539"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Phelps is Joan’s married name in the probate extract. Coke and De Tyne remain proposed birth names, so neither surname’s meaning can yet be assigned to her own family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PHELPS_PRIOR_JOAN_COKE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The administration places her deceased husband at Tewkesbury. It supplies no birthplace for Joan; that town is the location of her married family, not an established origin for her parents.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": []
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "An 1877 Phelps family letter links the name Dame Joan Coke with Podsmead near Gloucester. The school founded by John and Joan Cooke independently preserves a history of Joan’s purchase of that estate in 1539.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PHELPS_PRIOR_JOAN_COKE",
            "ROOTS26_CRYPT_PODSMEAD_1539"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_G28_MARY_TOMES_WIFE_RICHARD",
      "person_id": "G28_MARY_TOMES_WIFE_RICHARD",
      "surname": "Tomes (reported)",
      "locality": "England; proposed Tewkesbury connection",
      "research_limit": "Mary Tomes is a low-confidence candidate for Richard Phelps’s wife and James Phelps’s mother. The inspected pedigrees supply no contemporary record identifying her parents. Their dates conflict: one gives a death in 1529, another in 1588. Establishing which woman these accounts describe is the immediate limit on tracing her birth family.",
      "notes": "The MyTrees entry says Mary died in 1529, rather than the “after 1529” shown in the imported profile. Another compilation reports a pedigree naming Joseph Phelps and Margaret Tomes as James’s parents. That alternative chart has not been inspected, so it cannot yet replace Richard and Mary. The historical mentions below concern the reported surname and proposed region; Mary’s own birthplace remains unestablished.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COMPILED_PHELPS_PEDIGREE_VARIANTS_20260728",
        "ROOTS26_MARY_TOMES_VARIANT_ANCESTRY",
        "ROOTS26_PHELPS_ELLSWORTH_CHART_CLAIM"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "William Tommes on a Tewkesbury jury",
          "record_date": "13 November 1420",
          "locality": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire",
          "historical_detail": "William Tommes served among the twelve jurors at the inquisition concerning the estate of John Rodeney, knight. The edited record identifies Tewkesbury as the place of the hearing but does not give William’s home or family.",
          "association": "The surname form and hearing place provide a specific comparison about eighty years before Mary’s reported birth. If her Tewkesbury connection is correct, wider local family continuity is plausible.",
          "alternatives": "William may have lived elsewhere in the county. The Thomas-derived surname could also belong to an independently named family, and Mary’s own name and locality may reflect a later pedigree error.",
          "assessment": "This establishes an earlier regional name-bearer and gives the continuity hypothesis a concrete starting point. It does not distinguish descent from a more distant relationship or an unrelated family. The estate and heir described in the inquisition belong to Rodeney, not to the juror.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TOMMES_JUROR_1420",
            "SRC_COMPILED_PHELPS_PEDIGREE_VARIANTS_20260728"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "The Tomes family and Long Marston’s manor",
          "record_date": "1479 and 1577",
          "locality": "Long Marston, historically Gloucestershire",
          "historical_detail": "The parish council’s history reports that William Tomes leased the Abbey Manor in 1479. In 1577 John Tomes and John Kecke, both yeomen, purchased its land and manor from the Earl of Leicester.",
          "association": "This provides a second specific regional setting for the reported surname, spanning the generations before and after Mary’s proposed lifetime.",
          "alternatives": "Long Marston and Tewkesbury are separate communities. The Marston family could be related to Mary’s proposed family, or represent an independent branch; no inspected marriage, estate or settlement record places her there.",
          "assessment": "Long Marston is a useful comparison locality, not an established origin for Mary. The named tenants are retained as historical context rather than inserted as her ancestors.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TOMES_LONG_MARSTON"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Tomes is a variant of Toms, derived through Thom or Tom from the personal name Thomas. The final -s can express family association, although the dictionary also allows a later added ending.",
          "caveat": "This explains the reported surname, not a verified birth name for Mary.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TOMES_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_TOMS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_THOM_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary associates English Toms especially with Cornwall, Devon and Dorset. Tomes also has separately formed Czech and Spanish equivalents. In the region proposed for Mary, a Tommes appears at a Tewkesbury inquisition in 1420 and a Tomes tenant is reported at Long Marston in 1479.",
          "caveat": "These records do not establish a migration from southwestern England or a birthplace for Mary.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TOMES_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_TOMS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_TOMMES_JUROR_1420",
            "ROOTS26_TOMES_LONG_MARSTON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The regional records place people bearing this surname in jury service and the leasing and purchase of manorial land. Long Marston’s history names the Tomes alongside the Kecke and Cooper families among its principal local families.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TOMMES_JUROR_1420",
            "ROOTS26_TOMES_LONG_MARSTON"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_G28_SUSANNA_FENNELL_WIFE_THOMAS1623",
      "person_id": "G28_SUSANNA_FENNELL_WIFE_THOMAS1623",
      "surname": "Fennell (reported)",
      "locality": "Limerick; reported Wiltshire origins and Cahir family connection",
      "research_limit": "Susanna’s parents remain disputed. Ahern challenges her identification as John Fennell’s daughter and suggests she may have been his sister. A separate 1676 deed description identifies a Limerick merchant Thomas Phelps’s wife Susannah as a daughter of John Owens of Ludlow. Resolving whether these accounts describe the same woman is the present limit on tracing her birth family.",
      "notes": "The compiled assignment to Henry Fennell and Mary Sixworth is another possibility, but an inspected parent-naming record has not yet connected them to this household. Fennell is retained as her reported surname. The deed provides the strongest specific father statement for the woman it describes; it remains uncertain whether all these accounts describe the same wife.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LIMERICK_QUAKER_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLD_20260728",
        "ROOTS26_FENNELL_AHERN",
        "ROOTS26_PHELPS_OWENS_DEED_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_SUSANNA_FENNELL_COMPILED"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John Fennell’s family from Wiltshire to Cahir",
          "record_date": "1626–c 1659",
          "locality": "Steeple Ashton, Wiltshire; Cardiff; Kilcommonbeg, County Tipperary",
          "historical_detail": "Ahern identifies John Fennell (1626–1706) as Robert and Mary’s son. He married Mary Davies in Cardiff in 1649 and moved to Kilcommonbeg near Cahir around 1659. The study cites hearth rolls for his four-hearth house.",
          "association": "A possible sister relationship would place Susanna in this family and make Robert and Mary relevant parent candidates.",
          "alternatives": "She could instead belong to another Fennell family, or the Fennell surname could have been attached to the Phelps wife incorrectly.",
          "assessment": "The same-generation sibling interpretation fits the reported dates better than daughterhood. Ahern presents it as a possibility, however, and the competing Owens deed requires an identity comparison before these parents can be ranked first.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FENNELL_AHERN",
            "ROOTS26_PHELPS_OWENS_DEED_CLAIM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "A Limerick merchant’s wife and her Ludlow father",
          "record_date": "23 May 1676",
          "locality": "County Limerick and Ludlow, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The Phelps project quotes deed reference 11/229: Thomas Phelps, merchant of County Limerick, and Susannah relinquished claims against Sir Job Charlton. Its description says John Owens, a Ludlow mercer, bought land for his daughter’s life and that she was then Thomas’s wife.",
          "association": "The husband’s name, occupation, county and wife’s name form a distinctive match to this household.",
          "alternatives": "Fennell might be an incorrect or earlier married surname. Alternatively, Thomas had successive wives called Susan, or the deed concerns a separate household.",
          "assessment": "This is a substantial lead to an identifiable father, rather than a surname-only association. The quoted description favours Owens for the 1676 wife, but the original deed and marriage history are needed to decide which children and other records belong to her.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PHELPS_OWENS_DEED_CLAIM"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Fennell can refer to someone who grew or sold fennel, or lived where it grew. The herb supplied both food and medicine.",
          "caveat": "This explains the reported name; its use as Susanna’s birth surname remains uncertain.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FENNELL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Fennell also arose separately in Ireland as a shortened form of Ó Fionnghail, meaning descendant of Fionnghal, a name combining fair or white with valour.",
          "caveat": "Residence in Ireland does not distinguish that origin from an English family that settled there.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FENNELL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Ahern identifies the Fennells around Cahir and Clogheen as a long-established Quaker farming family, with holdings centred on Kilcommonbeg.",
          "caveat": "That regional association is more specific than the general surname meaning, but does not identify Susanna’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FENNELL_AHERN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_G28_ANNE_WIDOW_THOMAS1623",
      "person_id": "G28_ANNE_WIDOW_THOMAS1623",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Limerick, Ireland",
      "research_limit": "Anne is identified as Thomas Phelps’s widow in the quoted Limerick Quaker account, but that account supplies neither her birth surname nor parents. The Bradford surname appears in compiled pedigrees; the inspected FamilySearch profile has no attached historical documents to establish it.",
      "notes": "The same profile assigns a 1687 marriage and children born in 1650, 1663 and 1676. Those dates do not establish Anne’s maternity and may combine different wives. Her widowhood supports an association with the Limerick household; it does not establish that she was the mother of Thomas’s earlier children.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_LIMERICK_QUAKER_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLD_20260728",
        "ROOTS26_ANNE_BRADFORD_COMPILED"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anne’s death and the older Quaker calendar",
          "record_date": "Recorded as 9, 11, 1708",
          "locality": "Limerick Quaker community",
          "historical_detail": "The quoted account names Anne as Thomas Phelps’s elderly widow and gives her death as 9, 11, 1708. The imported profile renders this as 9 November 1708.",
          "association": "Before 1752, Quakers normally called January the eleventh month. If the quotation preserves that notation, 9 January 1708/9 is the likely reading.",
          "alternatives": "A later editor may already have converted the month numbering, or the year may have been modernised separately.",
          "assessment": "The November date should be treated as unverified. The surviving quotation identifies the woman and preserves the date to check, but does not settle its modern rendering or reveal her natal family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_LIMERICK_QUAKER_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLD_20260728",
            "ROOTS26_QUAKER_CALENDAR"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Anne [birth surname unproven] without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Anne [birth surname unproven]. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Anne [birth surname unproven] without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "person_id": "G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England",
      "research_limit": "Published probate extracts name Dorothy as William Phelps’s widow on 28 September 1611 and report her death by 31 May 1613. They do not name her parents or give a birth surname. The proposed identification as Dorothy James must be compared with Henry James’s daughter in the Greswold pedigree.",
      "notes": "The administration passed to William’s brother Nicholas during the minority of William’s son, also William. This places Dorothy in a specific household. The extracts establish a death interval, rather than an exact death in 1613; the original probate entries remain to be inspected.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
        "ROOTS26_WARWICK_1619_DOROTHY_JAMES",
        "ROOTS26_COMPILED_DOROTHY_JAMES_PHELPS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Henry James’s daughter in the Greswold pedigree",
          "record_date": "1619 visitation; edition published 1877",
          "locality": "Forfield, Worcestershire; Greswold family pedigree",
          "historical_detail": "The pedigree pairs Henry Greswold with Dorothy, daughter and coheiress of Henry James of Forfield. It shows their sons Humphrey, William, George and Richard.",
          "association": "This is a concrete comparison for the claim that William Phelps’s wife was Henry James’s daughter. The proposed father and daughter match the names in the visitation, but the husband differs.",
          "alternatives": "Dorothy Phelps could have been another Dorothy James, or the same woman through successive marriages. A further possibility is that later compilers transferred the Greswold wife’s parentage to the Phelps wife.",
          "assessment": "The inspected pedigree directly supports the Greswold marriage. No inspected record supports a second marriage linking that woman to Phelps, or identifies a different Dorothy James as William’s wife. Conflation is presently the better-supported explanation of the specific parentage claim, while Dorothy Phelps’s own birth family remains unresolved.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WARWICK_1619_DOROTHY_JAMES",
            "ROOTS26_COMPILED_DOROTHY_JAMES_PHELPS",
            "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Dorothy’s attested surname in the administration extract is the married name Phelps. James is a proposed natal surname from compiled pedigrees, not a name supplied by that extract.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
            "ROOTS26_COMPILED_DOROTHY_JAMES_PHELPS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Tewkesbury is the home of her deceased husband in the probate record. The proposed James family belongs to Forfield in Worcestershire; no inspected record connects Dorothy Phelps’s childhood or parents to that place.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
            "ROOTS26_WARWICK_1619_DOROTHY_JAMES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The published 1619 visitation identifies Dorothy, daughter and coheiress of Henry James of Forfield, as Henry Greswold’s wife. This gives the proposed James ancestry a specific competing family context.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WARWICK_1619_DOROTHY_JAMES"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_SRC_ELIZA_LYSTER_MOTHER_JANE_1851",
      "person_id": "SRC_ELIZA_LYSTER_MOTHER_JANE_1851",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Shrewsbury St Alkmund, Shropshire",
      "research_limit": "The supplied 1851 census transcript places one-year-old Jane Lyster in a Shrewsbury household with Richard and Eliza Lyster and identifies Eliza as her mother. It supplies no birth surname, age or birthplace for Eliza. Lyster is therefore not established as her birth surname.",
      "notes": "Two family reconstructions identify Jane’s mother as Kezia Price: the Gamble tree supplied by Matthew and Avril J. Wood’s annotated Lister chart dated March 1992. The chart includes addresses and burial details, while the reconstructed family includes the distinctive name Thomas Price Lister. These give Kezia’s identification substantial support, but the different name in the census transcript remains unexplained. Eliza could be a misreading or another name for Kezia, or a different woman in Richard’s family. The original census page is needed to compare the handwriting, ages, birthplaces and household relationships. In 1851 the relationship column referred to the household head; the index’s mother label may therefore be an inference from the household rather than a separately recorded biological relationship. The current evidence supports keeping the Eliza reading and the Kezia Price reconstruction visible while this is resolved. Price ancestry and the history of the Lyster surname should not be silently assigned to Eliza’s roots.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805",
        "SRC_ROOTS_TNA_1851_CENSUS_RELATIONSHIP_COLUMNS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Eliza Lyster (maiden name unknown): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Shrewsbury St Alkmund, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The supplied 1851 census transcript places one-year-old Jane Lyster in a Shrewsbury household with Richard and Eliza Lyster and identifies Eliza as her mother. It supplies no birth surname, age or birthplace for Eliza. Lyster is therefore not established as her birth surname. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
            "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
            "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805",
            "SRC_ROOTS_TNA_1851_CENSUS_RELATIONSHIP_COLUMNS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Eliza Lyster (maiden name unknown) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Eliza Lyster (maiden name unknown). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Eliza Lyster (maiden name unknown) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_B71_JOHN_LAMB_FATHER_1757",
      "person_id": "C_B71_JOHN_LAMB_FATHER_1757",
      "surname": "Lamb",
      "locality": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire: family recorded in 1757",
      "research_limit": "John and Ann are named as the parents of John Lamb in the supplied transcript of his Kerry baptism on 20 March 1757. It gives no parental ages, occupations or address within the parish. The father’s own parents and birthplace remain unidentified; Kerry is where the family is recorded, not an established birthplace for him.",
      "notes": "Kerry’s parish accounts record payment for an examination of John Lamb’s legal settlement in 1787. The entry could concern this father, his son baptised in 1757, or another John; it gives no age or relatives to distinguish them. A separate removal order of 17 May 1790 names John Lamb, wife Elizabeth, daughter Elizabeth aged four and son John aged two, with legal settlement in Kerry. The wife and children make this a household that can be investigated, but do not yet connect it to John and Ann. These later records help distinguish possible identities; they do not extend the ancestry before 1757.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757",
        "SRC_ROOTS_KERRY_LAMB_SETTLEMENT_1787",
        "SRC_ROOTS_LAMB_REMOVAL_1790",
        "SRC_ROOTS_KERRY_LAMB_APPRENTICE_1782"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Elizabeth Lambe in an Aberhafesp maintenance case",
          "record_date": "19 June 1729",
          "locality": "Aberhafesp parish, Montgomeryshire",
          "historical_detail": "A quarter-session recognizance required John Griffith, a yeoman of Aberhafesp, to answer the parish overseers’ complaint concerning a child recently born to Elizabeth Lambe, described as unmarried. The record names Griffith as the father and Theodore Jones of Aberhafesp as his surety. It does not name the child.",
          "association": "This places a woman called Lambe in an Aberhafesp parish case 28 years before John and Ann’s son was baptised at Kerry. The similar surname and regional setting make a connection to the wider Lamb family possible.",
          "alternatives": "Elizabeth could belong to the same wider family, or to a separate Lambe family in Montgomeryshire. The shared name and county do not identify a relationship, and the record supplies no Kerry residence or common relative.",
          "assessment": "A documented regional name-bearer worth retaining as family context. Neither Elizabeth nor her unnamed child can currently be placed in John’s ancestry.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_LAMBE_ABERHAFESP_1729"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Lamb can derive from a familiar form of Lambert, a nickname likening someone to a gentle lamb, or an occupation tending lambs.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LAMB"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary distinguishes those English formations from an Irish Anglicisation of Ó Luain and a German variant of Lamm. The Kerry baptism does not establish which origin belongs to this branch.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LAMB",
            "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "On 7 September 1782 the Kerry vestry arranged for John Williams to be apprenticed to John Lamb of the Court. This supplies a specific local Lamb household and residence for comparison with the baptismal family, but neither the master’s age nor his wife is given. The apprenticeship records responsibility for a parish child, not a parent-child relationship.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_KERRY_LAMB_APPRENTICE_1782"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_B71_ANN_LAMB_MOTHER_1757",
      "person_id": "C_B71_ANN_LAMB_MOTHER_1757",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire: family recorded in 1757",
      "research_limit": "Ann is named with John Lamb as the mother of their son John in the supplied transcript of his Kerry baptism on 20 March 1757. Her birth surname, age and parents are not given. Lamb is her family’s recorded surname here; it has not been established as her birth surname.",
      "notes": "The Kerry overseer John Griffiths recorded thirteen shillings paid to Anne Lamb on five occasions in his accounts headed 1774. The matching name and parish make her a plausible later appearance of the mother recorded in 1757, but the entry gives no age, husband or birth surname; another Anne Lamb remains possible. The later parish and quarter-session records do not identify Ann’s birth family. The 1787 settlement expense names only John Lamb. The 1790 removal order concerns a John with wife Elizabeth and two young children: it could involve a younger generation, a remarried man or a different household, and cannot supply Ann’s surname. Her family’s appearance at Kerry does not establish that she was born there.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757",
        "SRC_ROOTS_KERRY_LAMB_SETTLEMENT_1787",
        "SRC_ROOTS_LAMB_REMOVAL_1790",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ANNE_LAMB_KERRY_RELIEF_1774"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ann Lamb (maiden name unknown): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Kerry, Montgomeryshire: family recorded in 1757",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Ann is named with John Lamb as the mother of their son John in the supplied transcript of his Kerry baptism on 20 March 1757. Her birth surname, age and parents are not given. Lamb is her family’s recorded surname here; it has not been established as her birth surname. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757",
            "SRC_ROOTS_KERRY_LAMB_SETTLEMENT_1787",
            "SRC_ROOTS_LAMB_REMOVAL_1790",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ANNE_LAMB_KERRY_RELIEF_1774"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Ann Lamb (maiden name unknown) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Ann Lamb (maiden name unknown). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Ann Lamb (maiden name unknown) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_G27_FRANCES_MCELROY_MOTHER_RACHEL_1713",
      "person_id": "G27_FRANCES_MCELROY_MOTHER_RACHEL_1713",
      "surname": "McElroy (maiden name unknown)",
      "locality": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "research_limit": "Frances McElroy is named as Rachel McElroy’s mother in a published transcription, with a reported Baltimore County colonial Maryland setting, but no birth, marriage, maiden surname, death, parents, or original baptism image has been inspected. H1 is the McElroy mother identified by the transcription; alternatives are another Frances, a transcription error, or an undocumented maiden-family identity. The copied Frances Durham claim and possible James Durham/Staley connection remain explicit candidates only; the 1696 Staley will and 1697 land evidence do not name Frances. No new parent edge is added.",
      "notes": "Frances McElroy is named as Rachel McElroy’s mother in a published transcription, with a reported Baltimore County colonial Maryland setting, but no birth, marriage, maiden surname, death, parents, or original baptism image has been inspected. H1 is the McElroy mother identified by the transcription; alternatives are another Frances, a transcription error, or an undocumented maiden-family identity. The copied Frances Durham claim and possible James Durham/Staley connection remain explicit candidates only; the 1696 Staley will and 1697 land evidence do not name Frances. No new parent edge is added.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MCELROY_BALTIMORE_COLONIAL_CONTEXT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Colonial Baltimore probate route and Durham/Staley comparison",
          "record_date": "1696–1776; Rachel reported 1713",
          "locality": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
          "historical_detail": "Maryland State Archives identify Baltimore County probate records from 1703–1776 and colonial will indexes. The existing 1696 Thomas Staley will names James Durham as son-in-law and Mary and James as grandchildren; a legislative biography reports a 1697 land gift to James. Neither source names Frances McElroy.",
          "association": "The place and period are historically testable, and the Durham/Staley material is a plausible wider-family lead, but it remains a comparison rather than a link.",
          "alternatives": "Another Frances, transcription error, or an unknown maiden family remains possible.",
          "assessment": "The maternal identification is supported by the published Rachel transcription, while Frances’s own ancestry and maiden name remain unresolved; no new edge is added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MCELROY_BALTIMORE_COLONIAL_CONTEXT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "McElroy is an Anglicized Gaelic patronymic, commonly derived from Mac Giolla Ruaidh, “son of the red-haired youth/servant.” The surname has Irish and Scottish associations and is not a unique Baltimore identifier.",
          "caveat": "The McElroy surname and nearby Durham/Staley records do not identify Frances’s maiden family or prove a biological connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MCELROY_BALTIMORE_COLONIAL_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
            "SRC_OT26_STALEY_DURHAM_1696_WILL",
            "SRC_OT26_MSA_THOMAS_STALEY_BIO"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The reported setting is colonial Baltimore County. Maryland State Archives identify Baltimore County probate material from 1703–1776 and colonial will indexes, giving a concrete route for testing a McElroy household, but no Frances-specific record was located.",
          "caveat": "The McElroy surname and nearby Durham/Staley records do not identify Frances’s maiden family or prove a biological connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MCELROY_BALTIMORE_COLONIAL_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
            "SRC_OT26_STALEY_DURHAM_1696_WILL",
            "SRC_OT26_MSA_THOMAS_STALEY_BIO"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The existing Staley evidence names James Durham as a son-in-law and Mary and James as grandchildren in Thomas Staley’s 1696 will, with a 1697 land gift to James. Those records make a Durham/Staley association worth testing, but they do not name Frances or prove her maiden surname.",
          "caveat": "The McElroy surname and nearby Durham/Staley records do not identify Frances’s maiden family or prove a biological connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MCELROY_BALTIMORE_COLONIAL_CONTEXT",
            "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
            "SRC_OT26_STALEY_DURHAM_1696_WILL",
            "SRC_OT26_MSA_THOMAS_STALEY_BIO"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_ANN_GREEN_WIFE_SAMUEL_MORRALL_LAWLEY",
      "person_id": "C_ANN_GREEN_WIFE_SAMUEL_MORRALL_LAWLEY",
      "surname": "Green",
      "locality": "Wellington, Lawley and Dawley, Shropshire",
      "research_limit": "A community transcription records Ann Green marrying Samuel Morrall at Dawley Magna on 14 April 1806. Their Lawley household is the leading match for Richard Morrall’s parents. Ann’s own parents remain unidentified; no baptism or other record yet connects the married woman to a named Green household.",
      "notes": "The transcribed 1851 census gives Ann’s age as 63 and birthplace as Wellington, suggesting birth about 1787–1788. The reported 1866 burial instead implies about 1789; these estimates should guide a range of baptism searches. The archive’s Dawley holdings cover this period. Marriage witnesses, transcribed as Gabriel and Elizabeth Goleah, may help identify her family once their names and relationship to the couple are checked.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTSCHAT_SAMUEL_ANN_MORRALL_LAWLEY_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
        "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHROPSHIRE_DAWLEY_HOLDINGS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Earlier Green households around Wellington",
          "record_date": "11 February 1606/7; 13 March 1788",
          "locality": "Wellington parish and Wrockwardine, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "Wrockwardine’s published register records the baptism of Peter, son of John Greene of Wellington parish, in February 1606/7. It later records Edward Green marrying Ann Smith in March 1788.",
          "association": "The first entry places the surname in Ann’s reported birth parish about 180 years before her birth. The later marriage identifies a nearby household around her estimated birth period.",
          "alternatives": "Local continuity could connect Ann with these families, but Green could also have arrived through unrelated families. The two entries do not themselves establish kinship with each other or with Ann.",
          "assessment": "These are specific local research leads. The 1788 household is closer in time and therefore a more practical starting point, but no evidence yet identifies the couple as Ann’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WROCKWARDINE_GREEN_HOUSEHOLDS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Green can describe someone living beside a village green, or come from a nickname referring to green clothing, youth, or participation as the Green Man in May festivities. The dictionary also allows an origin in the personal name Grene.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GREEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Green is widespread in England and does not identify one ancestral village. Wellington is Ann’s reported birthplace; it does not establish where her surname first arose. The dictionary describes separate Irish, German and other origins for some families bearing the name.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GREEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name’s English associations include communal greens and seasonal celebrations. Those meanings do not establish Ann’s family’s occupation or customs. Her known family setting is a Shropshire mining household: Samuel is described as a coal miner in the transcribed census.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GREEN",
            "SRC_ROOTSCHAT_SAMUEL_ANN_MORRALL_LAWLEY_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_GRACE_HUDSON_WIFE_GEORGE_LISTER",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_GRACE_HUDSON_WIFE_GEORGE_LISTER",
      "surname": "Hudson",
      "locality": "Batley, Yorkshire; nearby Gildersome for contextual records",
      "research_limit": "Grace’s recorded family begins with her reported marriage to George Lister at Batley on 17 August 1727. The parish-based reconstruction also identifies her burial on 9 July 1796 as George’s widow, but supplies no parents or baptism. Batley is a place of marriage and burial; her birthplace remains unestablished. The parish collection is listed as WDP37, beginning in 1559; the present limit is identifying her among surviving records, rather than an established loss of the registers.",
      "notes": "A Hudson household is documented nearby at Gildersome in the same period. Its connection to Grace remains an open question.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_GRACE_HUDSON_TOMLINSON",
        "ROOTS26_GILDERSOME_HUDSON_BOOTH",
        "ROOTS26_BATLEY_REGISTER_COVERAGE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "William Hudson in Gildersome’s chapel records",
          "record_date": "1726–1749",
          "locality": "Gildersome, Yorkshire",
          "historical_detail": "Booth’s local history places William Hudson in a 1726 trust deed and the chapel covenant of 6 September 1749. It transcribes his memorial as recording death on 7 October 1749 in his sixtieth year.",
          "association": "The surname and nearby location make this household a plausible part of Grace’s wider family setting around the time of her marriage.",
          "alternatives": "The households may be related, or may descend from different men called Hudde. The records examined do not identify Grace as William’s daughter, sister or other relative.",
          "assessment": "Local family continuity is plausible, but there is no basis yet to rank a specific relationship. Grace’s baptism or a will naming her as Lister would distinguish the possibilities.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GILDERSOME_HUDSON_BOOTH",
            "ROOTS26_GRACE_HUDSON_TOMLINSON"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Hudson means son of Hudde, a Middle English personal name.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HUDSON_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name is English in origin and is also established in Ireland. It does not point to a single ancestral village.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HUDSON_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Gildersome’s Hudson household took part in Baptist chapel affairs, while Grace’s marriage is recorded at Batley parish church. These records describe the settings of the two households, without establishing Grace’s religious affiliation.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GRACE_HUDSON_TOMLINSON",
            "ROOTS26_GILDERSOME_HUDSON_BOOTH"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_JOHN_LISTER_BATLEY_MARRIED_1670",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_JOHN_LISTER_BATLEY_MARRIED_1670",
      "surname": "Lister",
      "locality": "Batley, Yorkshire; nearby Morley and Wakefield for contextual records",
      "research_limit": "John’s identified household begins with his reported marriage to Jane Tingle at Batley on 18 May 1670 and their children William, John and Joseph, born in 1671, 1673 and 1676. The parish-based reconstruction supplies no baptism or parents for John. Batley is established as a family location, but his birthplace is unconfirmed. All Saints registers are catalogued from 1559; the present stopping point is an unidentified earlier household, rather than demonstrated loss of the parish records.",
      "notes": "The earlier Lister below had dealings with a Batley family, but a connection to John’s household has not yet been established.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_BATLEY_LISTER_TOMLINSON",
        "ROOTS26_BATLEY_REGISTER_COVERAGE",
        "ROOTS26_BATLEY_SHEARD_1894"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "William Lister in a Batley family’s will",
          "record_date": "1602",
          "locality": "Batley and Wakefield, Yorkshire",
          "historical_detail": "Sheard prints John Dighton’s 1602 will, which asks William Lister, vicar of Wakefield, to assist the executors and share responsibility for Dighton’s grandsons Josua and Alverey. The will requests burial at Batley and provides for its poor.",
          "association": "William’s involvement in Batley affairs places an earlier Lister within the local network from which John’s family could have come.",
          "alternatives": "He may belong to the wider family, or to a different Yorkshire Lister lineage. The will identifies a professional and personal association with the Dightons, not a relationship to the later John Lister.",
          "assessment": "This is a specific regional lead with a plausible time interval, but the shared surname and local dealings do not yet distinguish family continuity from separate origins. John’s baptism and William’s family or probate records would provide a closer comparison.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BATLEY_SHEARD_1894"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Lister originally described a cloth dyer. It comes from Middle English li(te)ster, related to the verb for dyeing and ultimately Old Norse lita.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LISTER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The occupational term belonged chiefly to East Anglia and northern and eastern England; the surname is especially associated with Yorkshire. That regional fit supports an English explanation for this branch, without identifying its first name-bearer.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LISTER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname preserves the vocabulary of cloth working. By 1602 a William Lister appears as a clergyman assisting a Batley testator, illustrating how hereditary surnames continued after occupations changed.",
          "caveat": "John’s own occupation is not established by the name.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LISTER_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_BATLEY_SHEARD_1894"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_ALVEREY_TINGLE_BATLEY_1666",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ALVEREY_TINGLE_BATLEY_1666",
      "surname": "Tingle",
      "locality": "Batley, Yorkshire; nearby Morley and Wakefield for contextual records",
      "research_limit": "Alverey is the reported father of John (1627), William (1629) and Jane, baptized at Batley on 11 November 1638. The reconstruction supplies no wife, parents or baptism for him. His displayed birth estimate before 1607 is an inference from the earliest child, not a recorded birth; Batley residence does not establish his birthplace. The missing identification lies within the period covered by the parish collection, catalogued from 1559.",
      "notes": "Sheard’s printed tax list confirms an Alvery Tingle at Batley with two hearths in 1666. A similarly named taxpayer at Morley complicates matching the tax entry to Jane’s father.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_BATLEY_TINGLE_TOMLINSON",
        "ROOTS26_BATLEY_LISTER_TOMLINSON",
        "ROOTS26_BATLEY_REGISTER_COVERAGE",
        "ROOTS26_BATLEY_SHEARD_1894"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Richard Tyngill at Batley’s chantry",
          "record_date": "1426–1434",
          "locality": "Batley, Yorkshire",
          "historical_detail": "Sheard’s extract from the Archbishop of York’s register records Richard Tyngill’s institution to Batley’s chantry on 25 April 1426, presented by the prior of Bolton. His translation of Richard Coppeley’s will, proved 28 September 1434, names a Richard Tyngill as an executor.",
          "association": "The similar surname and same parish support possible wider-family continuity before Alverey’s household, across approximately two centuries. The priest and executor may be the same man.",
          "alternatives": "Tyngill may represent the same surname in an older spelling, or a separate formation. The priest could have come to Batley from elsewhere; holding the chantry does not establish that his family originated there. The executor’s identity is also unconfirmed.",
          "assessment": "These are concrete medieval associations, with weaker support for an enduring local family than the later household cluster provides. No intervening kinship is documented. A connection, if established, could be through collateral relatives rather than descent from the priest.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BATLEY_SHEARD_1894"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Tingle households at Batley and Morley",
          "record_date": "Lady Day 1666",
          "locality": "Batley and Morley, Yorkshire",
          "historical_detail": "The printed Batley tax list names William and Marmaduke Tingle with one hearth each and Alvery Tingle with two. The Morley list separately names Albery Tingle with two hearths.",
          "association": "The Batley cluster favors a local family network. William could be Alverey’s reported son born in 1629; Marmaduke is another identifiable contemporary whose relationship remains unknown.",
          "alternatives": "William could be another local relative or namesake. The Batley and Morley Alvery/Albery entries may represent different men, one owner assessed at two properties, or a copying discrepancy; the return alone does not decide.",
          "assessment": "The Batley entry remains the leading match to Jane’s reported father because it agrees in name and parish. Morley supplies a documented competing identification to test, rather than a merely imagined namesake. Parish, burial and property records are needed to separate these households.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BATLEY_SHEARD_1894",
            "ROOTS26_BATLEY_TINGLE_TOMLINSON"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary derives English Tingle from Middle English tingel, a small nail: either a name for someone making nails or pins, or a nickname for a slight, thin person.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TINGLE_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary associates the English surname with Yorkshire. It also recognizes an American adaptation of German Dingel, a separate formation that does not explain this already established seventeenth-century Yorkshire household.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TINGLE_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The English explanations connect the name with small metal goods or personal appearance. Neither identifies Alverey’s occupation. Batley’s medieval Tyngill records offer a more specific local association, discussed below.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TINGLE_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_BATLEY_SHEARD_1894"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_WILLIAM_PICKIN_WHITMORE_1756",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_WILLIAM_PICKIN_WHITMORE_1756",
      "surname": "Pickin",
      "locality": "Whitmore, Staffordshire; candidate connection to Forton",
      "research_limit": "William is named with Sarah in Elizabeth’s 1756 Whitmore baptism transcript, but his birth, parents and occupation are unidentified. This household remains a candidate origin for the 1777 Forton bride, not established ancestry.",
      "notes": "Elizabeth baptized at Whitmore in 1756 is a plausible match for the 1777 Forton bride: name, age and regional setting fit. The marriage supplies no parents or age to confirm it. Earlier Whitmore probate entries for Margaret Picken in 1670 and William Pickin in 1713 suggest a wider local family, but give no relationships in the index. The earlier William cannot be the father alive in 1756; his will may identify intervening relatives.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_PICKIN_WILLS",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_MI_SEARCH",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKIN",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKEN",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKING"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Earlier Whitmore Picken/Pickin probate records",
          "record_date": "1670; 1713",
          "locality": "Whitmore, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The archive index lists Margaret Picken in 1670 and William Pickin, yeoman, in 1713.",
          "association": "Same locality and surname family 86 and 43 years before Elizabeth’s 1756 baptism make wider-family continuity plausible.",
          "alternatives": "Distinct local families or later migration remain possible; the index supplies no relationship between the testators or the 1756 parents. The earlier William is not the same man as the father alive in 1756.",
          "assessment": "The records establish earlier Pickins at Whitmore. Their relationships to the 1756 household are unknown; the wills may name heirs or property linking the generations.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_PICKIN_WILLS",
            "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Pickin is cross-referenced to Picken and Picking. The modern dictionary gives Picken an Old French nickname or personal-name origin, associated with a woodpecker or a pointed object. These are reported linguistic alternatives, not William’s documented occupation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_PICKIN_WILLS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_MI_SEARCH",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKEN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKING"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary treats English and Scottish Picken as of Norman linguistic origin, with later Scottish/Irish uses and separate continental forms. This does not establish that William came from Normandy, Scotland or Ireland. His recorded family setting is Whitmore.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_PICKIN_WILLS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_MI_SEARCH",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKEN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKING"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Whitmore probate indexes name Margaret Picken in 1670 and William Pickin, yeoman, in 1713. These earlier records in the same locality are stronger branch-specific research leads than distant famous Pickens. No kinship or arms are assigned.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_PICKIN_WILLS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_MI_SEARCH",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKIN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKEN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKING"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_SARAH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_1756",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_SARAH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_1756",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Whitmore, Staffordshire; candidate connection to Forton",
      "research_limit": "Sarah is named as Elizabeth’s mother in the 1756 Whitmore baptism. Pickin is her married surname; her maiden surname, birthplace and parents are unknown.",
      "notes": "Sarah is named with William in Elizabeth’s 1756 baptism. That child is a plausible, unconfirmed match for the later Forton bride. No marriage identifying Sarah’s maiden surname was found in the reviewed searches. The earlier Whitmore Pickin wills may concern her husband’s family; they do not identify her own parents or birthplace.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_PICKIN_WILLS",
        "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_MI_SEARCH"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Sarah Pickin, Whitmore baptism mother: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Whitmore, Staffordshire; candidate connection to Forton",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Sarah is named as Elizabeth’s mother in the 1756 Whitmore baptism. Pickin is her married surname; her maiden surname, birthplace and parents are unknown. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_PICKIN_WILLS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_MI_SEARCH"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Her natal surname is unknown. Pickin etymology belongs to her recorded married household and cannot supply her own family-name meaning.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_PICKIN_WILLS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_MI_SEARCH"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Whitmore is the setting of her daughter’s baptism, not a demonstrated birthplace for Sarah. No natal locality was established by the reviewed couple searches or selected memorial inscriptions.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_PICKIN_WILLS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_MI_SEARCH"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Sarah is specifically associated with William Pickin and Elizabeth’s 1756 baptism. Earlier Whitmore Pickins may illuminate that household, but cannot yet be assigned as Sarah’s natal family history.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_PICKIN_WILLS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_MI_SEARCH"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_DAVID_PRICE_FATHER_KEZIA_LISTER",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_DAVID_PRICE_FATHER_KEZIA_LISTER",
      "surname": "Price",
      "locality": "Parish unestablished; reported daughter’s connections are Montgomeryshire and Shrewsbury",
      "research_limit": "David is named as Kezia Price’s father in the supplied Gamble family tree. That account gives no dates, parish, occupation or parents for him. Kezia’s reported birth around 1816 in Montgomeryshire provides a county to investigate, but does not establish where David lived. His own identity must be located before an earlier Price family can be ranked as his ancestry.",
      "notes": "The family chart separately supports Kezia’s identity as Richard Lister’s wife, while the supplied 1851 household transcript reads Eliza. This disagreement concerns Kezia’s identification in the descendant family; it does not supply an alternative father for her. David remains the leading named paternal candidate.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805",
        "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "David Price, a soldier at Meifod",
          "record_date": "22 November 1815",
          "locality": "Meifod, Montgomeryshire",
          "historical_detail": "The National Library of Wales calendar names David Price as prosecutor in a burglary case at Meifod. A former Royal Artillery soldier, he identified stolen clothing by an alteration made for his wooden leg. The accused, John Humphreys, was acquitted.",
          "association": "The name, county and date make this man an identifiable possibility to compare with Kezia’s reported father.",
          "alternatives": "He could be her father, another relative, or a different Price. The calendar gives no wife or children, and Kezia’s reported county of birth is the only geographical overlap currently available.",
          "assessment": "This is a research lead rather than an established identification. A Kezia baptism naming David’s occupation or a military family record naming Elizabeth and Kezia would strongly distinguish the possibilities. The soldier’s occupation and disability have not been assigned to the ancestor.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PRICE_MEIFOD1815",
            "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Welsh Price developed from ap Rhys, meaning son of Rhys. An English formation comes from a word describing someone highly valued or excellent.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PRICE_LAMBE_PRICE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "A Welsh origin is the most relevant explanation to test against Kezia’s reported Montgomeryshire birth. Price is widespread in Wales and has also been established in Ireland since medieval times.",
          "caveat": "The county association does not identify David’s parish or a single founding family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PRICE_LAMBE_PRICE",
            "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Welsh form preserves a father’s personal name. Different descendants of men called Rhys could acquire Price independently, so a shared surname is less distinctive than a match involving relatives, residence and occupation.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PRICE_LAMBE_PRICE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_ELIZABETH_LAMBE_MOTHER_KEZIA_LISTER",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ELIZABETH_LAMBE_MOTHER_KEZIA_LISTER",
      "surname": "Lambe (reported)",
      "locality": "Parish unestablished; reported daughter’s connections are Montgomeryshire and Shrewsbury",
      "research_limit": "Elizabeth Lambe is named as Kezia Price’s mother in the supplied Gamble family tree. No marriage, baptism, dates, parish or parents are supplied for Elizabeth, and her reported birth surname has not been checked against a contemporary record. The line stops at her unresolved identity, not at an established loss of records.",
      "notes": "Kezia’s reported Montgomeryshire birth and later Shrewsbury household give a regional starting point. Neither establishes that Elizabeth herself came from Wales or Shropshire. Earlier Lambe records can therefore provide comparisons, but no particular parish family can yet be preferred.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
        "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Henry and Anne Lambe near Onibury",
          "record_date": "1664–1668",
          "locality": "Onibury and Stanton Lacy, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The Onibury transcript records Henry, son of Henry Lambe of Stanton Lacy and Anne, baptized on 23 August 1664. It records their son George on 29 April 1668. Other entries name a Lewis or Lewes Lambe and Anne.",
          "association": "These entries establish Lambe households in Shropshire well before Kezia’s later residence in Shrewsbury. They provide a regional comparison, rather than a demonstrated ancestral locality for Elizabeth.",
          "alternatives": "Elizabeth might descend from one of these households, another English Lamb/Lambe family, or an Irish family. No migration, property or kinship record presently links her to Onibury or Stanton Lacy.",
          "assessment": "The records clarify that an English Lambe lineage is a concrete possibility, but do not favor these particular households as Elizabeth’s family. Her marriage or Kezia’s baptism is needed to narrow the geographical comparison.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LAMBE_ONIBURY",
            "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The dictionary treats Lambe as a variant of Lamb. English Lamb can derive from a short form of Lambert, a nickname for a gentle person, or an occupation tending lambs.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PRICE_LAMBE_LAMBE",
            "ROOTS26_PRICE_LAMBE_LAMB"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The Lambe entry identifies an Irish variant of English Lamb. The broader Lamb entry also describes an Irish formation from Ó Luain, meaning descendant of the warrior. English parish records likewise contain the spelling Lambe.",
          "caveat": "Elizabeth’s spelling alone cannot establish an Irish origin or distinguish these formations.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PRICE_LAMBE_LAMBE",
            "ROOTS26_PRICE_LAMBE_LAMB",
            "ROOTS26_LAMBE_ONIBURY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name’s associations with Lambert, gentleness and lamb keeping are alternative explanations for its formation. They do not establish Elizabeth’s family occupation. A specific Shropshire example is the seventeenth-century household below.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PRICE_LAMBE_LAMB",
            "ROOTS26_LAMBE_ONIBURY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_ARCHIBALD_MCELROY_PARENT_JOHN_1690",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_ARCHIBALD_MCELROY_PARENT_JOHN_1690",
      "surname": "McElroy",
      "locality": "Baltimore County through proposed son; Archibald’s residence unestablished",
      "research_limit": "Archibald appears as John McElroy’s father in a compiled pedigree, while another pedigree gives Patrick MacElroy. No inspected record resolves whether these are alternate names, different men, or a mistaken family assignment. Archibald remains the displayed low-confidence candidate; his dates, birthplace and own parents are unidentified.",
      "notes": "The Baltimore County records described below concern John’s later household. They locate the family under investigation without establishing where the proposed older generation lived. The later Archibald whose 1760 will names brother William must not be silently identified with this father candidate.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_COMPILED_PEDIGREE_CONFLICT_20260730",
        "SRC_OT26_MCELROY_PATRICK_COMPILED",
        "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
        "SRC_OT26_MCELROY_WILL_BOOK_IMAGES"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John McElroy’s Baltimore County family and land",
          "record_date": "1713–1732",
          "locality": "Baltimore County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "Ed Phelps’s published research reports Rachel’s 1713 birth to John and Francis McElroy, John’s 1725 survey of Rachel’s Delight, and his 1732 sale of John’s Beginning, witnessed by Avinton Felps.",
          "association": "The daughter, land and witness network form a specific family cluster from which to investigate John’s origins and the proposed older McElroy generation.",
          "alternatives": "Archibald or Patrick might belong to that family, or either parent name might result from a compiled-tree error. The later records do not name John’s father.",
          "assessment": "Useful family-and-place evidence reported from parish and deed records; it supports the research locality but does not select an older parent. The underlying originals have not been inspected in this review.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The Irish Mac Giolla Rua and Scottish Mac Gille Ruaidh underlie the Anglicized name: a patronymic referring to a red-haired young man.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MCELROY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Both Irish and Scottish origins are recognized in the dictionary.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MCELROY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The dictionary points to Gilroy and Kilroy as names to compare when examining the linguistic background.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MCELROY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "McElroy is an Anglicized form of Irish Mac Giolla Rua or Scottish Gaelic Mac Gille Ruaidh, meaning son of the red-haired lad.",
          "caveat": "The description belongs to the surname’s formation, not a documented physical characteristic of Archibald.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MCELROY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary recognizes both Irish and Scottish origins for the name.",
          "caveat": "The compiled Irish-origin claim for this candidate has not been tied to a specific parish, migration record or household.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MCELROY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Gilroy and Kilroy belong to the dictionary’s comparison group for the same Gaelic name elements.",
          "caveat": "These linguistic associations do not establish that families using the different spellings share a recent ancestor.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MCELROY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_RACHEL_DURHAM_MOTHER_JOHN_1690",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_RACHEL_DURHAM_MOTHER_JOHN_1690",
      "surname": "Durham (reported)",
      "locality": "Baltimore County family context; Rachel’s residence unestablished",
      "research_limit": "Rachel Durham is a compiled mother candidate for John McElroy. The reviewed pedigrees also attach Durham to John’s wife, with inconsistent Rachel and Frances combinations. No inspected contemporary record identifies the proposed older Rachel or her parents; even her Durham birth surname remains unverified.",
      "notes": "The Maryland references below establish Durham households in the relevant county, not Rachel’s membership in one of them. An older Rachel, a similarly named wife in a later generation, and a conflated pedigree remain distinct possibilities.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MCELROY_COMPILED_PEDIGREE_CONFLICT_20260730",
        "SRC_OT26_MCELROY_PATRICK_COMPILED",
        "ROOTS26_DURHAM_JOHN_JANE1683"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John Durham and Jane in Baltimore County court references",
          "record_date": "by November 1683",
          "locality": "Baltimore County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "The Maryland State Archives marriage index identifies John Durham as married by November 1683 to Jane, administratrix of William Choice, citing Baltimore County court proceedings D:13–14.",
          "association": "This places a Durham household in the county in the generation relevant to John McElroy’s proposed parents. It makes a local Durham connection possible.",
          "alternatives": "Rachel could be a relative of this couple, belong to another Durham household, or have been assigned the surname incorrectly. The index names no child Rachel.",
          "assessment": "A specific official record reference for local surname presence, with no parentage inferred. The underlying court entry is still needed to examine the household in full.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DURHAM_JOHN_JANE1683"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary derives Durham from the city name, combining an Old English word for hill with holm, an island; it also recognizes Durham as a variant of Derham.",
          "caveat": "These alternatives apply to the reported surname, whose attribution to Rachel has not been established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_DURHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The principal place-name explanation points to Durham in northern England.",
          "caveat": "It cannot supply Rachel’s birthplace or demonstrate a migration from that city to Maryland.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_DURHAM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "As a place-derived surname, Durham could identify people whose families came from the same named place without sharing a reconstructable recent ancestor.",
          "caveat": "The Baltimore County household references provide a closer context for this investigation than an unrelated medieval Durham pedigree.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_DURHAM"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_THOMAS_SHAW_PARENT_RALPH_1628",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_THOMAS_SHAW_PARENT_RALPH_1628",
      "surname": "Shaw",
      "locality": "Reported Lancashire, England; parish unknown",
      "research_limit": "Thomas is retained as the named candidate father of Ralph Shaw in a compiled family history. His reported 1628 birth and Lancashire origin have no identified parish or contemporary supporting record in the cited evidence. The securely located generation is Ralph: a June 1672 Charles County deed calls him a planter of that county. Its opening passage supplies no English origin or father. The line stops at identifying Thomas and testing the proposed connection to Ralph, before choosing among earlier Lancashire families.",
      "notes": "If the reported births of Thomas in 1628 and Ralph in 1645 are both correct, Thomas would have been about seventeen at Ralph’s birth. That is possible, though both dates need verification. A later county name used retrospectively in a compilation would not by itself disprove their relationship.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
        "ROOTS26_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES1672"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Thomas Shawe among Rivington’s first school governors",
          "record_date": "1566",
          "locality": "Rivington, Lancashire",
          "historical_detail": "Irvine’s history describes letters patent obtained by Bishop James Pilkington in 1566 for Rivington grammar school. The first governors included Thomas Shawe, described as a gentleman, alongside a separately named Thomas Asshawe, esquire. These are two entries in the account, not interchangeable spellings of one governor.",
          "association": "This places a Thomas Shawe in educational affairs in the reported county more than sixty years before the candidate ancestor’s reported birth. An earlier generation of the wider family is possible.",
          "alternatives": "The governor may belong to another Lancashire Shaw lineage. He cannot be the man reportedly born in 1628, and Thomas’s own parish is unknown. The school connection does not supply a path from Rivington to Maryland.",
          "assessment": "The matching name and county make this a concrete regional comparison, but currently do not favor descent from this household over another Shaw family. A parish, occupation or English relative identified in the Maryland records would provide a much more distinctive link.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SHAW_RIVINGTON_IRVINE",
            "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Shaw comes from a word for a small wood, grove or thicket. It could describe someone living beside such a feature or someone from a place called Shaw.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SHAW_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Shaw and Shawe are particularly associated with Lancashire and Yorkshire; Shaw near Oldham is one possible place of origin. This fits the reported county, but does not locate Thomas’s household.",
          "caveat": "Distinct Scottish and Irish formations also exist. Neither a Gaelic origin nor descent from a particular English Shaw family follows from the spelling alone.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SHAW_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The English name records a connection with wooded landscape rather than a particular occupation. Separate households could acquire it at different places; residence, relatives and property are needed to distinguish them.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SHAW_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_BENJAMIN_HODNETT_PARENT_GEORGE_ODNETT_1787",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_BENJAMIN_HODNETT_PARENT_GEORGE_ODNETT_1787",
      "surname": "Hodnett",
      "locality": "Diddlebury and Munslow, Shropshire",
      "research_limit": "Benjamin Hodnet of Diddlebury married Martha Aingell at Munslow on 11 May 1786. The matching names, stated parish and timing strongly identify them with the parents of George baptized at Diddlebury on 4 February 1787. Benjamin’s own parents remain unidentified.",
      "notes": "Further baptisms name Benjamin and Martha as parents of Benjamin in 1789, Samuel in 1791, Richard in 1794, John in 1799 and William in 1806. Their son George’s identification with Sarah Poyner’s named father remains a separate question. A George Hodnet marrying Ann Smith at Stanton Lacy in 1797 supplies an actual competing local household, too early for an ordinary marriage of a boy born around 1787.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_MUNSLOW_1786",
        "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_DIDDLEBURY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_GEORGE_HODNET_STANTON_LACY_1797",
        "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "An earlier Hodnet household at Abdon",
          "record_date": "25 March 1745",
          "locality": "Abdon, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The parish transcript records Joan, daughter of John Hodnet and Mary, being baptized.",
          "association": "The surname occurs in a nearby parish forty-one years before Benjamin’s marriage, making this a relevant earlier household to investigate.",
          "alternatives": "John and Mary might be relatives of Benjamin, or a separate local Hodnet family. No record yet identifies their relationship to him.",
          "assessment": "Local surname continuity is plausible; these people are not assigned as Benjamin’s parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_ABDON_1745"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Hodnett is a place-derived surname from Hodnet in Shropshire. The dictionary interprets the place-name as probably meaning pleasant valley, from early Welsh elements.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HODNETT_DAFN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_MUNSLOW_1786"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname points to Hodnet as a place of origin, but does not establish Benjamin’s birthplace. His identified adult records are in Diddlebury and Munslow.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HODNETT_DAFN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_MUNSLOW_1786"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The English surname also became established in County Cork. No Irish connection has been found for this household; the nearby Shropshire parish records provide its present family context.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HODNETT_DAFN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_MUNSLOW_1786"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_CANDIDATE_MARTHA_HODNETT_MOTHER_GEORGE_ODNETT_1787",
      "person_id": "CANDIDATE_MARTHA_HODNETT_MOTHER_GEORGE_ODNETT_1787",
      "surname": "Aingell (marriage surname)",
      "locality": "Munslow and Diddlebury, Shropshire",
      "research_limit": "Martha is recorded as Aingell at her 1786 marriage to Benjamin Hodnet of Diddlebury. That couple is the strong match for George’s parents in 1787. Aingell is her likely birth surname, but the supplied marriage transcription does not state whether she was a spinster or widow. Her parents remain unidentified.",
      "notes": "Munslow also records William Angell of Broseley marrying Ann Bebb in 1762. They are a plausible earlier household to investigate, without a baptism yet connecting Martha to them. The Diddlebury baptism of another Martha Aingell in November 1783 would fit the 1786 bride only if it were a substantially delayed baptism; it should not be attached simply because the name matches.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_MUNSLOW_1786",
        "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_DIDDLEBURY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "William Angell and Judith Tyler marry at Diddlebury",
          "record_date": "30 November 1693",
          "locality": "Diddlebury, Shropshire",
          "historical_detail": "The parish transcript records William Angell marrying Judith Tyler.",
          "association": "This places a recognized variant of Martha’s marriage surname in the same district ninety-three years before her wedding.",
          "alternatives": "They may belong to her wider family, or to another local Angell lineage. The interval permits several generations, none yet connected to Martha.",
          "assessment": "A documented earlier local couple, providing context for the surname rather than established ancestors.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_DIDDLEBURY",
            "SRC_ROOTS_AINGELL_GUILD"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Aingell is recorded as a variant of Angell or Angel. The English name is explained as a nickname from the Old French word for an angel, ultimately from Greek for messenger.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_AINGELL_GUILD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_DIDDLEBURY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname study places this formation in the Norman and English naming tradition. It does not identify one founding family or a particular village of origin for Martha.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_AINGELL_GUILD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_DIDDLEBURY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The local registers use Angell, Angel and Aingell. Comparing these spellings can reveal related households, but a shared spelling alone cannot distinguish kinship from independent families using the same nickname surname.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_AINGELL_GUILD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_DIDDLEBURY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_ABRAHAM_FATHER_ROSALIA_MAYER_1777",
      "person_id": "C_ABRAHAM_FATHER_ROSALIA_MAYER_1777",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Oberlustadt (daughter’s 1808 record; father’s residence unknown)",
      "research_limit": "The 1808 list names Rosalia Mayer’s former name as Roesel b Abraham. Its parallel entries support Abraham as her father, but supply no surname or uniquely identifying life details for him.",
      "notes": "Several people in the name-adoption list used Abraham as a name or patronymic. None is distinguished by a relative or locality that connects him to Rosalia’s father. Her later surname Mayer cannot establish his earlier surname. His family name and older ancestry remain unknown.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Abraham (surname unknown): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Oberlustadt (daughter’s 1808 record; father’s residence unknown)",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The 1808 list names Rosalia Mayer’s former name as Roesel b Abraham. Its parallel entries support Abraham as her father, but supply no surname or uniquely identifying life details for him. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Abraham (surname unknown) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Abraham (surname unknown). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Abraham (surname unknown) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_C_ATHEY_ANN_FIRST_WIFE_GEORGE_20260730",
      "person_id": "C_ATHEY_ANN_FIRST_WIFE_GEORGE_20260730",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Nanjemoy Hundred, Charles County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "Ann’s parents remain unidentified. Moorewood is a proposed surname based on a transferred land warrant, not a marriage record.",
      "notes": "Her appearance as George’s wife in a property transaction is firmer evidence than the proposed maiden name.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ANN_ATHY_PROPERTY_RECORDS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "The Moorewood identification and the Hopewell sale",
          "record_date": "1675; 5 May 1683",
          "locality": "Charles County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "The history describes transport rights passing through several owners before George obtained them. Separately, it records George and Ann selling Hopewell to James Martin.",
          "association": "The sale identifies Ann within George’s household.",
          "alternatives": "Ann Moorewood could still have become his wife, but ownership of the warrant also fits an ordinary transfer between unrelated parties.",
          "assessment": "The transaction explains the supposed connection without requiring a marriage. Moorewood remains unestablished; the original deed may offer further identifying details.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ANN_ATHY_PROPERTY_RECORDS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Athey is her married surname; her natal surname’s meaning is unknown.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ANN_ATHY_PROPERTY_RECORDS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The family history places her in Nanjemoy, but gives no established birthplace.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ANN_ATHY_PROPERTY_RECORDS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Ann and George are associated with the property Hopewell.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ANN_ATHY_PROPERTY_RECORDS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_R26_MARY_JAMESON_SR_D1755",
      "person_id": "R26_MARY_JAMESON_SR_D1755",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Charles County and St Mary’s County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_JOSHUA_DOYNE_WILL_1698_SCAN",
        "SRC_ROOTS_MARY_JAMESON_WHARTON_DEPOSITION_LEAD",
        "SRC_ROOTS_HARDY_CATHOLIC_WOMEN_1999"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary Jameson Sr. (maiden name unproven): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Charles County and St Mary’s County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_JOSHUA_DOYNE_WILL_1698_SCAN",
            "SRC_ROOTS_MARY_JAMESON_WHARTON_DEPOSITION_LEAD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HARDY_CATHOLIC_WOMEN_1999"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Mary Jameson Sr. (maiden name unproven) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Mary Jameson Sr. (maiden name unproven). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Mary Jameson Sr. (maiden name unproven) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_BR26_JAMES_SILVESTER_RANTON_TESTATOR",
      "person_id": "BR26_JAMES_SILVESTER_RANTON_TESTATOR",
      "surname": "Silvester",
      "locality": "Lomcompton, Ranton, Staffordshire, England",
      "research_limit": "The 1769 will, proved in 1776, identifies the testator’s family but not his parents. Identification with the locally baptised James reported in 1688–89 remains unresolved.",
      "notes": "The baptism candidate’s name and Ranton locality fit the later James Silvester. Another local relative could also explain the match. The original probate and parish entries have not yet established that they are the same person.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Earlier Sylvester households in Ranton",
          "record_date": "1656–1688/89",
          "locality": "Ranton, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "Williams’s compilation reports Ralph Sylvester as churchwarden in 1656, buried 13 December 1660; Thomas as churchwarden in 1686, with son James baptised 31 March 1688–89. Pages 71–72 were visually checked; underlying registers were not inspected.",
          "association": "The earlier surname, parish and James name support a connection with the later testator, within roughly a century.",
          "alternatives": "He could belong to another local Sylvester household, related or unrelated. Ralph’s relationship to Thomas is not established by these entries.",
          "assessment": "Plausible wider-family continuity; exact descent unresolved. Check the original baptism and probate for identifying relatives and property. The compiler’s assembled households are one source, not independent confirmations.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Silvester is a variant of Sylvester, derived from a personal name whose Latin root concerns woods or forest dwelling.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SILVESTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SYLVESTER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary records English and German use. It does not establish a German origin for the Ranton family, or descent from a particular woodland settlement.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SILVESTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SYLVESTER"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The personal name was used by popes and apparently early English clerics. Its religious use explains diffusion; it supplies no genealogical connection to those bearers.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SILVESTER",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SYLVESTER"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_OT26_PETER_GUISE_ROCKINGHAM",
      "person_id": "OT26_PETER_GUISE_ROCKINGHAM",
      "surname": "Guise / Guice / Gise",
      "locality": "Rockingham County, Virginia; possible earlier Frederick County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "Peter’s will was proved in Rockingham on 25 November 1782, establishing that he had died by then. The surviving court order names John Guise as executor but does not name Peter’s parents, wife or heirs. The family-association genealogy proposes Peter and Ottilia as Sarah Gise’s parents; that relationship remains a candidate.",
      "notes": "The county and date fit the proposed Peter, favoring the identification over an otherwise unattested same-name estate. Sarah’s absence from a procedural probate order does not argue against her being a daughter. Rockingham lost many estate records in 1787 and again in 1864, but Peter’s particular will has not been shown to be irretrievably lost. Its provisions, an estate settlement or family land transaction could distinguish the competing parentage explanations. A 1777 Maryland survey for Peter Guise supplies a specific earlier property lead consistent with the proposed migration.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_GOBLE_GUISE_PARENTS",
        "SRC_OT26_PETER_GUISE_PROBATE_1782",
        "SRC_ROOTS_LVA_ROCKINGHAM_LOSS",
        "SRC_ROOTS_MSA_GUISE_CHARLES_FOUNDOUT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John Guice’s account of his family’s migration",
          "record_date": "1778–1780, recalled in 1832",
          "locality": "Frederick County, Maryland, and Rockingham County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "John Guice said that he returned from his first military service to his father in Maryland and then moved with him to Rockingham. He named brothers Phillip and Peter; witness Christopher Poss also recalled John and his father living in Rockingham.",
          "association": "The surname and route fit the proposed Peter Guise household and give a specific family setting to investigate.",
          "alternatives": "Neither statement names John’s father or identifies Sarah Gise as his sister. John could belong to a different Guise household, and recollections made decades later can misdate events.",
          "assessment": "Compatible supporting context, not an independent statement of Sarah’s parentage. A deed or estate record naming the relatives would be more discriminating.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OT26_GUICE_W4686",
            "SRC_OT26_GOBLE_GUISE_PARENTS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "John Guise handles Peter’s estate",
          "record_date": "25 November 1782",
          "locality": "Rockingham County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The court accepted proof of Peter Guise’s will and authorized John Guise, its named executor, to obtain probate. Witnesses and prospective estate appraisers are also recorded.",
          "association": "The same surname and estate responsibility favor a family connection between Peter and John. This is a contemporary local record, independent of the later family pedigree.",
          "alternatives": "An executor could be a son, another relative or a trusted associate. The order does not identify which relationship applied, nor establish that this John was the later pensioner.",
          "assessment": "A documented connection worth pursuing through the estate and neighboring land records; no son relationship is inferred from the office alone.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OT26_PETER_GUISE_PROBATE_1782"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Peter Guise’s small Maryland tract",
          "record_date": "10 September 1777; patent 10 December 1783",
          "locality": "Frederick County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "The Land Office entry for Charles Foundout records 8½ acres surveyed for Peter Guise on 10 September 1777 and a later patent to Henry Baker on 10 December 1783.",
          "association": "The name, county and date fit the father’s Maryland residence recalled by John Guice before the family’s move to Rockingham. This is a specific property record to compare with the Virginia estate.",
          "alternatives": "The survey applicant could be another Peter Guise. The later patent names Baker but does not explain whether rights passed by sale, inheritance or another arrangement.",
          "assessment": "A plausible earlier record of the proposed ancestor, strengthened by the matching migration chronology. The underlying survey, assignment or deed could distinguish the identities; the patent date is not a death date.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_MSA_GUISE_CHARLES_FOUNDOUT",
            "SRC_OT26_GUICE_W4686"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Guice is explained as an Americanized form of Geis, which can derive from the personal name Giso. Guise also has French and English place-name origins and can represent German Geiss.",
          "caveat": "The spelling alone cannot choose among these origins for Peter’s branch.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GUICE",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GEIS",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GUISE"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The records reviewed place the proposed family in the middle colonies and Virginia. They have not established Peter’s European hometown.",
          "caveat": "A French-looking spelling does not establish French origin, and a German surname explanation does not locate a particular German parish.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GUISE",
            "SRC_OT26_PETER_GUISE_PROBATE_1782",
            "SRC_OT26_GUICE_W4686"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Guise, Guice and Guize appear in the local probate and pension material. These variants connect the research to the Frederick–Rockingham–Georgia migration described by John Guice.",
          "caveat": "The French noble house of Guise is a separate surname association; no documentary connection to Peter has been found in the reviewed evidence.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GUISE",
            "SRC_OT26_PETER_GUISE_PROBATE_1782",
            "SRC_OT26_GUICE_W4686"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_OT26_OTTILIA_GUISE",
      "person_id": "OT26_OTTILIA_GUISE",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Proposed Guise household; later Lincoln County, Georgia association reported",
      "research_limit": "Ottilia is named in the family-association pedigree as Peter Guise’s wife and Sarah Gise’s mother, with an undated report that she died in Lincoln County, Georgia. The probate order for Peter does not name her, and John Guice’s pension does not name his mother. Her birth surname and parents remain unresolved.",
      "notes": "Kuffer is a proposed birth surname in later compiled trees. One displayed pedigree makes her mother only eight when Ottilia was born, so that set of dates and relationships cannot all be correct. A misdated parent or an incorrectly attached family could explain the conflict; the surname itself remains a lead. No reviewed marriage or baptism yet connects this Ottilia to that birth family, so its surname history is not assigned to her.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_GOBLE_GUISE_PARENTS",
        "SRC_OT26_PETER_GUISE_PROBATE_1782",
        "SRC_OT26_GUICE_W4686",
        "SRC_ROOTS_GUISE_KUFFER_COMPILED"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ottilia (surname unknown, proposed mother of Sarah Gise): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Proposed Guise household; later Lincoln County, Georgia association reported",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Ottilia is named in the family-association pedigree as Peter Guise’s wife and Sarah Gise’s mother, with an undated report that she died in Lincoln County, Georgia. The probate order for Peter does not name her, and John Guice’s pension does not name his mother. Her birth surname and parents remain unresolved. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OT26_GOBLE_GUISE_PARENTS",
            "SRC_OT26_PETER_GUISE_PROBATE_1782",
            "SRC_OT26_GUICE_W4686",
            "SRC_ROOTS_GUISE_KUFFER_COMPILED"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Ottilia (surname unknown, proposed mother of Sarah Gise) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Ottilia (surname unknown, proposed mother of Sarah Gise). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Ottilia (surname unknown, proposed mother of Sarah Gise) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_OT26_BRYAN_MCDONNEL_NEWCASTLE_1707",
      "person_id": "OT26_BRYAN_MCDONNEL_NEWCASTLE_1707",
      "surname": "McDonnel",
      "locality": "Red Clay Creek, New Castle County, Delaware",
      "research_limit": "The traceable line reaches Bryan McDonnel, whose New Castle estate was proved in 1707. Published land and inheritance transcripts connect him to Red Clay Creek and to his son Bryan, but the European origin remains disputed. A later pedigree names Alexander MacDonnell of Wicklow as his father; the sources examined do not yet distinguish that proposed family from the competing Scottish-origin tradition.",
      "notes": "The strongest early geographical anchor is the New Castle landholding described below. Irish and Scottish accounts may preserve part of the family’s migration history, but their conflicting dates prevent treating either narrative as an established biography.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_FRANK_1879",
        "SRC_OT26_MCDONNEL_CALENDAR_1707",
        "ROOTS26_MCDONALD_ACCESS_PEDIGREE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Bryan’s Red Clay Creek land, 1689–1706",
          "record_date": "18 November 1689; 21 December 1703; 8 October 1706",
          "locality": "New Castle County, beside Red Clay Creek and Hide Runn",
          "historical_detail": "Frank V. McDonald’s 1879 history prints a grant from Penn’s Newcastle Warrants, Old Book, page 209. The instrument recites a warrant of 18 November 1689 for land later measured at 239 acres, followed by an adjoining 354 acres under a warrant of 21 December 1703. The combined 593-acre tract bordered Red Clay Creek and Hide Runn. The printed instrument is dated 8 October 1706.",
          "association": "The recurring name, county and estate history favor identifying this landholder with the 1707 testator. This extends the documented local history of Bryan’s own household back to 1689, rather than supplying an additional ancestral generation.",
          "alternatives": "An unrelated namesake is possible, but no competing landholder was identified in the material examined. A transcription error remains possible because the surviving evidence reviewed here is the published copy, not the original warrant book.",
          "assessment": "This is the leading early record identification for the branch. The 1689 date is recited in the later instrument; the 1879 author did not locate the original 1689 warrant. The acreage establishes property ownership, not military rank or noble descent.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_FRANK_1879"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Arklow and Glencoe: competing origin accounts",
          "record_date": "Seventeenth century; accounts published later",
          "locality": "Arklow, County Wicklow, Ireland; Glencoe, Scotland",
          "historical_detail": "The pedigree reproduced by Access Genealogy calls Bryan a lieutenant from Arklow, son of Alexander MacDonnell of Wicklow, and gives migration in 1691. Elsewhere the same compilation describes his Delaware land acquisition in 1689. The 1879 history discusses a different tradition connecting the family’s departure with the Glencoe massacre of 1692.",
          "association": "The Irish account identifies an actual proposed father and locality, making Alexander a specific research lead. The Scottish account preserves a possible earlier geographical association, but does not establish a parent-child connection.",
          "alternatives": "The stories could combine an Irish residence with older Scottish ancestry, contain a mistaken migration year, or attach another McDonnell family’s history to the Delaware household. A later return voyage could explain activity on both sides of the Atlantic, but none is documented in the records reviewed.",
          "assessment": "The 1689 land recital is stronger chronological evidence than either later migration story. It conflicts with first arrival in 1691 and with emigration caused by the 1692 massacre; it does not exclude Irish birth or an earlier Glencoe connection. The Arklow pedigree remains a lead requiring a record that connects its Bryan or Alexander to this Delaware family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MCDONALD_ACCESS_PEDIGREE",
            "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_FRANK_1879"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "McDonnell is an English-language form of Gaelic Mac Domhnaill, a patronymic meaning son of Domhnall. The personal name combines elements referring to the world and rule.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MCDONNELL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary describes McDonnell as Irish and compares the Scottish form McDonald. Both spellings belong to the wider Gaelic naming tradition.",
          "caveat": "This linguistic background cannot identify Bryan’s birthplace or the route by which his family reached Delaware.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MCDONNELL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Delaware family appears as McDonnel in the will calendar and as MacDonald or MaccDonald in the published land transcript. Searches for this branch therefore need both the -donnel and -donald forms.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_FRANK_1879",
            "SRC_OT26_MCDONNEL_CALENDAR_1707"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_OT26_ANNA_MARIA_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "person_id": "OT26_ANNA_MARIA_WEIGELE_PARENT",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Goshenhoppen family, Pennsylvania; probable earlier New York marriage",
      "research_limit": "Anna Maria is named as Georg Weigele’s mother in the Goshenhoppen family account. She is probably the Anna Maria who married Johann Michael Wägelin on 26 July 1710, described as Conrad Hartman’s widow. That record supplies a former husband, not her birth surname or parents.",
      "notes": "The matching couple and the family’s later Rhinebeck/Pennsylvania connections favor this identification. A different Anna Maria remains possible, and competing transcriptions of the 1715 child’s baptism give different names and birth dates. Those readings appear to concern the same event and must not be counted as two incompatible births. Hartman is not established as her birth name, so Hartman surname histories cannot yet be assigned to her.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_GEORGE",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED",
        "SRC_OT26_WAGELIN_HARTMAN_1710",
        "SRC_OT26_WAGELIN_WILHELM_1715"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anna Maria (wife of Johann Michael Weigele): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Goshenhoppen family, Pennsylvania; probable earlier New York marriage",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Anna Maria is named as Georg Weigele’s mother in the Goshenhoppen family account. She is probably the Anna Maria who married Johann Michael Wägelin on 26 July 1710, described as Conrad Hartman’s widow. That record supplies a former husband, not her birth surname or parents. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_GEORGE",
            "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED",
            "SRC_OT26_WAGELIN_HARTMAN_1710",
            "SRC_OT26_WAGELIN_WILHELM_1715"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Anna Maria (wife of Johann Michael Weigele) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Anna Maria (wife of Johann Michael Weigele). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Anna Maria (wife of Johann Michael Weigele) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_OT26_ABRAHAM_DITLOH",
      "person_id": "OT26_ABRAHAM_DITLOH",
      "surname": "Ditloh",
      "locality": "Great Swamp (Groß Schwam), Pennsylvania; probable earlier Salford association",
      "research_limit": "Abraham and Anna Margareth are named as parents of Anna Margareth Ditloh, who married Georg Weigele in autumn 1736. Abraham’s migration card gives Germany only as a broad origin, with no birthplace or parents. No earlier household has yet been identified.",
      "notes": "The 1734 Salford land return lists Abraham Titloe with 50 acres alongside Hance Michael Wagly with 100 acres. The matching name and likely Weigele connection favor identifying him with Abraham Ditloh, but the return gives no relatives. Great Swamp church lists provide a later local setting. The institute’s cited QAL collection was lost in a 2019 fire; its surviving database and published Pennsylvania records remain available. This specific loss does not establish that the original church manuscripts or all evidence of Abraham’s origin were destroyed.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED",
        "SRC_OT26_SALFORD_LANDHOLDERS_1734",
        "SRC_ROOTS_IPGV_DITLOH_ORIGIN_LIMIT",
        "SRC_ROOTS_HINKE_DITLOH_GREAT_SWAMP",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_DITLOW_QUALIFIED"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Helping pay for the congregation’s land",
          "record_date": "1748? and June 1761",
          "locality": "Great Swamp, Pennsylvania",
          "historical_detail": "Hinke’s transcription lists Abraham Ditlo pledging 15 shillings toward the congregation’s land in a subscription dated 26 December, with the year 1748 marked uncertain by the editor. An Abraham Ditlo pledged another 15 shillings in June 1761.",
          "association": "The same name and congregation make these plausible records of the Abraham associated with the Weigele family. They show a specific role in supporting the local church.",
          "alternatives": "The later subscription may instead belong to a younger namesake. The lists do not give ages, wives or daughters.",
          "assessment": "The local name and religious setting support continuity, but the two entries should not be used to assign Abraham a death date or to combine every later Ditlo household.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HINKE_DITLOH_GREAT_SWAMP"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "An older and younger Ditloh in the congregation",
          "record_date": "Probably 1758",
          "locality": "Great Swamp, Pennsylvania",
          "historical_detail": "A list of Great Swamp household heads names Abraham Ditloh, another Ditloh described as Junior whose given name was unknown to the writer, and an unnamed weaver living at Ditloh’s. Hinke dates the group of lists probably to 1758.",
          "association": "The pairing suggests a possible wider Ditloh family within the congregation, and the weaver gives a glimpse of a shared household or lodging arrangement.",
          "alternatives": "Junior distinguishes the younger bearer but does not expressly name his father; the weaver could be a lodger or employee. Neither is automatically Abraham’s son.",
          "assessment": "A documented local family-history lead, with the relationships left open. Identifying Junior in parish or land records would help distinguish the successive Ditlo generations.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HINKE_DITLOH_GREAT_SWAMP"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "An established meaning for Abraham’s Ditloh surname has not been found. A dictionary entry for the similar spelling Ditlow gives an English place-name derivation from Dilwyn in Herefordshire.",
          "caveat": "That explanation has not been connected to this Pennsylvania family and is not treated as its origin.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_DITLOW_QUALIFIED"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The migration institute associates Abraham with Germany and Great Swamp, Pennsylvania, but names no German town or province. The name alone therefore cannot locate the family within Germany.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_IPGV_DITLOH_ORIGIN_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Ditloh and Ditlo occur in the Great Swamp Reformed church records; Titloe occurs in the 1734 Salford return. These spellings are useful local comparisons within the German-speaking Pennsylvania community.",
          "caveat": "The Titloe-to-Ditloh identification depends on the household evidence as well as spelling.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_HINKE_DITLOH_GREAT_SWAMP",
            "SRC_OT26_SALFORD_LANDHOLDERS_1734"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_OT26_ANNA_MARGARETH_DITLOH_WIFE",
      "person_id": "OT26_ANNA_MARGARETH_DITLOH_WIFE",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Family associated with Great Swamp, Pennsylvania; Anna Margareth’s own birthplace unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Anna Margareth is recorded as Abraham Ditloh’s wife and mother of daughters Anna Margareth and Anna Catharina. The institutional card uses Ditloh as her married name; it supplies neither her birth surname nor parents. The reproduced Goshenhoppen elders’ account describes her as deceased, without establishing a death date in the reviewed extract.",
      "notes": "The published church records also list an Abraham Ditloh with an unnamed wife. That entry cannot identify Anna Margareth by name or establish that she was still living: it may concern an earlier entry, another wife, or another Abraham. The institute’s QAL source collection was lost in 2019, while a separate published church-record tradition survives. Until a record supplies her birth family, surname meanings and earlier same-surname families cannot responsibly be assigned to her.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY",
        "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED",
        "SRC_ROOTS_IPGV_DITLOH_ORIGIN_LIMIT",
        "SRC_ROOTS_HINKE_DITLOH_GREAT_SWAMP"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anna Margareth (wife of Abraham Ditloh): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Family associated with Great Swamp, Pennsylvania; Anna Margareth’s own birthplace unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Anna Margareth is recorded as Abraham Ditloh’s wife and mother of daughters Anna Margareth and Anna Catharina. The institutional card uses Ditloh as her married name; it supplies neither her birth surname nor parents. The reproduced Goshenhoppen elders’ account describes her as deceased, without establishing a death date in the reviewed extract. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY",
            "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED",
            "SRC_ROOTS_IPGV_DITLOH_ORIGIN_LIMIT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_HINKE_DITLOH_GREAT_SWAMP"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Anna Margareth (wife of Abraham Ditloh) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Anna Margareth (wife of Abraham Ditloh). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Anna Margareth (wife of Abraham Ditloh) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_OT26_WILLIAM_FYNNEY_ALTON",
      "person_id": "OT26_WILLIAM_FYNNEY_ALTON",
      "surname": "Fynney",
      "locality": "Alton, Staffordshire; probable marriage at nearby Rocester",
      "research_limit": "William is named with Hellen in Helen Fynney’s Alton baptism on 10 April 1803. He probably married Ellen Salt at Rocester on 8 December 1795. Neither entry gives his parents or age, and his own baptism remains unidentified.",
      "notes": "The Alton family sequence includes John in 1799, Helen in 1803, Amy in 1804, Charles in 1809 and Frederick in 1814; Frederick’s father was a joiner. William Finney, aged 73, buried at Alton on 28 February 1846 with abode Cheadle, is a plausible later identity, giving an approximate birth in 1772–1773. That burial does not name his wife or occupation. Another Alton William had wife Catherine in the 1790s, so the burial cannot yet be assigned confidently to the joiner. The research gap is identifying his earlier household, not demonstrated loss of the parish records.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_HELEN_FYNNEY_ALTON_1803",
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_SALT_ROCESTER_1795",
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_ALTON_FAMILY_BAPTISMS",
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_SALT_ORIGINS_CANDIDATES",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FINNEY",
        "SRC_ROOTS_LANDOR_ROGER_FYNNEY_1600"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Roger Fynney, clergyman and livestock owner",
          "record_date": "29 April 1600",
          "locality": "Caldon, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "Roger Fynney, incumbent of Caldon, had an estate inventory dated 29 April 1600. Alongside household goods it listed forty sheep, cattle, horses and farming equipment; the adjusted estate total was £89.",
          "association": "This documents the Fynney spelling and a household in the Staffordshire Moorlands nearly two centuries before William’s probable 1795 marriage. A wider regional family connection is possible.",
          "alternatives": "Roger may belong to a separate Fynney branch. Caldon is not Alton, and a shared surname does not identify the intervening generations.",
          "assessment": "Useful regional history, with a substantial unresolved gap. The published inventory contains no named relative connecting Roger to William.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_LANDOR_ROGER_FYNNEY_1600"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Finney is commonly explained as an English place-derived surname. Several contributing place-names combine a word for coarse grass with an enclosure or land partly surrounded by water. Fynney is the spelling in Helen’s 1803 baptism.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FINNEY",
            "SRC_OT26_HELEN_FYNNEY_ALTON_1803"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary identifies a lost place called Fynney in Cheddleton, Staffordshire, recorded as Fyneye in 1320. Other possible sources lie in Yorkshire, Lancashire, Cheshire and Worcestershire.",
          "caveat": "Cheddleton is a relevant county-level possibility, but William’s birthplace and earlier family have not been identified.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FINNEY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name also has proposed southeastern English place origins and an Irish derivation related to Feeney. The Staffordshire records for this household favor investigating English local families first.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FINNEY"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_OT26_HELLEN_MOTHER_HELEN_FYNNEY",
      "person_id": "OT26_HELLEN_MOTHER_HELEN_FYNNEY",
      "surname": "Salt",
      "locality": "Alton and probable Rocester, Staffordshire",
      "research_limit": "Hellen, mother of Helen Fynney baptized at Alton in 1803, is probably Ellen Salt, the spinster who married William Finney at Rocester in 1795. Salt remains a provisional birth surname. Several actual Ellen Salt baptisms have been found; her parents have not yet been assigned.",
      "notes": "Ellen Finney of Farley, buried at Alton on 18 July 1821 aged 47, is a plausible identity and would imply a birth around 1773–1774. This makes Ellen, daughter of John and Ann Salt, baptized at Uttoxeter on 28 September 1773, a strong lead. Ellen, daughter of John and Mary Salt, baptized at Church Leigh on 10 September 1775, is a competing candidate if the burial age is approximate or her baptism occurred after infancy. Earlier candidates include Ellen, daughter of Anne Salt, baptized at Ellastone in 1768. The 1821 entry does not name a husband, so its identification with the 1795 bride and Alton mother still needs a household comparison before using the age to rank her parentage.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_OT26_HELEN_FYNNEY_ALTON_1803",
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_SALT_ROCESTER_1795",
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_ALTON_FAMILY_BAPTISMS",
        "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_SALT_ORIGINS_CANDIDATES",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SALT",
        "SRC_ROOTS_VENN_JOHN_SAULT_1666"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "A Rocester farmer’s son at Cambridge",
          "record_date": "23 June 1666",
          "locality": "Rocester, Staffordshire; Magdalene College, Cambridge",
          "historical_detail": "John Sault entered Magdalene College on 23 June 1666 aged 19. The university biography names his father as Richard, a farmer of Rocester, and records schooling at Manchester, a BA in 1669–1670 and an MA in 1673.",
          "association": "The surname variant and exact marriage locality make this a relevant earlier Salt/Sault household, 129 years before Ellen’s probable Rocester marriage.",
          "alternatives": "Ellen could belong to another local Salt family or have moved to Rocester for marriage. Richard and John’s relationship is documented; their relationship to Ellen is not.",
          "assessment": "A plausible wider-family association anchored to a specific Rocester household. University attendance adds historical interest, but no extra weight to the proposed kinship.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_VENN_JOHN_SAULT_1666"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The English surname Salt is principally derived from the Staffordshire place called Salt. Its Old English place-name refers to a salt pit.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SALT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "A Staffordshire place origin fits the county in which Ellen’s probable marriage and family are recorded. It does not identify her particular parents or establish that she herself came from the village of Salt.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SALT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Salt can suggest the salt trade, but the dictionary explicitly notes that evidence for an occupational origin is lacking. Nothing in Ellen’s reviewed records identifies a salt-making occupation in her family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SALT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FENTON_FATHER_HANNA_1674",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FENTON_FATHER_HANNA_1674",
      "surname": "Fenton",
      "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "research_limit": "William is identified through Hanna’s baptism in 1674. That entry gives no wife, occupation, age or parents. A compiled pedigree suggests a Sheffield baptism in 1643 and an older William of Steadley, but the connection between those records and this father has not yet been verified.",
      "notes": "The Sheffield transcription also names William Fenton as father of Ruth in 1672, Anna in 1676 and Esther in 1680. These entries offer a possible household to investigate; they have not yet been assigned as Hanna’s siblings.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
        "SRC_ROOTS_STIRNET_FENTON_HANDLEY"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Richard Fenton, a Sheffield capital burgess in 1554",
          "record_date": "1554",
          "locality": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
          "historical_detail": "A Derbyshire Family History Society study identifies Richard Fenton among Sheffield’s original twelve capital burgesses under Queen Mary’s charter. His father, also Richard, was a merchant of Carbrook.",
          "association": "This places a Fenton family in the same town 120 years before Hanna’s baptism. A wider family connection is plausible, but no intervening relatives have been identified.",
          "alternatives": "The families could descend from different Fenton place-names or separate arrivals in Sheffield. No particular unrelated household has been established as the explanation.",
          "assessment": "A documented local name-bearing family worth investigating, with no demonstrated descent from the burgess. His civic prominence does not strengthen the genealogical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DFHS_RICHARD_FENTON_1554"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The English surname Fenton comes from place-names formed from Old English fenn, meaning marsh or fen, and tūn, an enclosure or settlement.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FENTON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Places called Fenton in Yorkshire, Lincolnshire, Northumberland, Staffordshire and Nottinghamshire contributed to the English surname. William’s family is documented in Sheffield, but its connection to any particular Fenton settlement remains unknown.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FENTON",
            "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_HANNA_FENTON_1674"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname also has a Scottish origin in East Lothian and separate Irish and American histories. None has been connected to this Sheffield branch. The earlier Sheffield burgess below provides a more local historical association.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FENTON",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DFHS_RICHARD_FENTON_1554"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_THOMAS_BAGNOLD_FATHER_ISABEL_1601",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_BAGNOLD_FATHER_ISABEL_1601",
      "surname": "Bagnold",
      "locality": "Trentham, Staffordshire, England",
      "research_limit": "Thomas is named as father of Isabel in the saved Trentham baptism extract dated 15 February 1601. His own parents and baptism have not been identified. A compiled family places Isabel with Thomas James Bagnall and Marjorie Willatt, but the extra given name, dates and proposed wife still require a household comparison.",
      "notes": "The compiled Isabell Bagnold profile matches the 1601 baptism and 1632 Emerye marriage exactly, but a separate Isabell profile assigns a different marriage to Thomas Brassington. This is a concrete reconstruction conflict, rather than evidence of two independently documented daughters. Marjorie Willatt is now represented as a low-confidence mother candidate; identifying Thomas with the fuller Thomas James Bagnall profile remains provisional. The February year style in Isabel’s baptism and the proposed 1589 parental marriage still need record verification.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_TRENTHAM_BAPTISM_1601",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ATWOOD_BAGNALL_CANDIDATES",
        "SRC_ROOTS_TRENTHAM_REGISTER_CATALOGUE",
        "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_BAGNALL_BAGNOLD",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BAGNALL",
        "SRC_ROOTS_ATWOOD_MARJORIE_WILLATT_DETAIL",
        "SRC_ROOTS_EMMS_WOLSTANTON_PROBATE_1610_1622"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Elizabeth Bagnall at Trentham in 1563",
          "record_date": "1563",
          "locality": "Trentham, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "Oxford’s surname dictionary cites an IGI entry for Eliz. Bagnall at Trentham in 1563. The entry’s event type and relatives still need checking.",
          "association": "The same surname variant appears in Thomas’s daughter’s baptism parish 38 years before that 1601 entry. Elizabeth could represent an earlier generation of his wider local family.",
          "alternatives": "Elizabeth could belong to a different local branch. The citation gives no relative’s name or event type, so it cannot distinguish kinship from an independently established household.",
          "assessment": "Local family continuity is plausible from the surname and parish match. Elizabeth’s particular relationship to Thomas remains unresolved; the underlying 1563 entry is the next useful record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_BAGNALL_BAGNOLD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "A medieval surname bearer at Fenton",
          "record_date": "1327",
          "locality": "Fenton, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "The same dictionary cites Nicho’ de Bagynholt at Fenton in the 1327 subsidy rolls.",
          "association": "This is a regional surname occurrence 274 years before Thomas appears in his daughter’s 1601 baptism.",
          "alternatives": "Wider-family continuity, separate place-derived branches, or later migration can each explain the shared surname across this interval.",
          "assessment": "The entry establishes earlier regional use of the name. It does not identify a particular descent line to Thomas.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_BAGNALL_BAGNOLD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "A Bagnald–Willat household at Chatterley",
          "record_date": "1618",
          "locality": "Chatterley, Wolstanton parish, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "Francis Bagnald’s will of 19 September 1618 names wife Emme, son John, brother John and daughter Eline Willat. His son-in-law John Willat’s daughter Margreat received a ewe lamb. The editor identifies Francis with Chatterley’s headborough and a freeholders’ juror in a 1604 court roll.",
          "association": "This is a documented Bagnald family in the Trentham area during Thomas’s lifetime, including an actual Willat marriage. It provides a possible wider-family setting for the proposed Thomas Bagnold–Marjorie Willatt household.",
          "alternatives": "Francis’s family could instead belong to a separate local Bagnald branch. Eline and John’s marriage is a different couple from Thomas and Marjorie; the matching pair of surnames does not identify the households.",
          "assessment": "A specific local kinship network is established within Francis’s family. Its relationship to Thomas remains unresolved: Thomas and Isabel are not named in the summarized will.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_EMMS_WOLSTANTON_PROBATE_1610_1622"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Bagnold is a variant of Bagnall, a place-derived surname. The place-name combines the Old English personal name Badeca or Baduca with a word for a nook or recess, or woodland.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_BAGNALL_BAGNOLD",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BAGNALL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary identifies two possible Staffordshire sources: Bagnall and Bagnall in Alrewas. Thomas’s appearance in his daughter’s Trentham baptism do not yet distinguish which place her family came from.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_BAGNALL_BAGNOLD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname also became established in Ireland during the sixteenth century. That history has not been linked to Thomas; the earlier local namesakes provide a closer geographical starting point.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BAGNALL"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_MARJORIE_WILLATT_CANDIDATE_ISABEL",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_MARJORIE_WILLATT_CANDIDATE_ISABEL",
      "surname": "Willatt",
      "locality": "Reported Trentham, Staffordshire; earlier locality unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Marjorie is a candidate mother of Isabel Bagnold, based on a compiled profile matching Isabel’s recorded baptism and Emerye marriage. The compilation proposes a 1589 Trentham marriage and an Essex birth, but neither event has yet been verified in its underlying record. Her reported parents, John Willett and Ann Kirbie, remain unassessed candidates.",
      "notes": "The proposed Essex birth remains unverified: no reviewed record establishes Marjorie’s move from Bradwell-on-Sea to Trentham. Staffordshire wills document Willatt households and a Bagnald–Willat marriage locally in her reported lifetime, making a local family origin a concrete alternative to the Essex pedigree. They do not name Marjorie. Her exact-match daughter profile supports retaining her as a possible mother, while the conflicting Isabell profiles limit confidence.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_ATWOOD_MARJORIE_WILLATT_DETAIL",
        "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_WILLATT",
        "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILLETT",
        "SRC_ROOTS_EMMS_WOLSTANTON_PROBATE_1610_1622"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Thomas Willatt’s Chesterton household",
          "record_date": "1610",
          "locality": "Chesterton, Wolstanton parish, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "In his will of 28 April 1610, Thomas Willatt left farming equipment to son Jhon and the residue to wife Elizabeth for bringing up his children. He owed money to brother William Willot. His inventory included four oxen, four cows and ploughing equipment.",
          "association": "This places a Willatt family close to Trentham during Marjorie’s reported lifetime. It supplies named relatives and an agricultural household against which her proposed origins can be compared.",
          "alternatives": "Marjorie could belong to this wider local family, another Staffordshire Willatt household, or the reported Essex family. The will names no Marjorie and does not enumerate all the children.",
          "assessment": "The local family is documented, but no particular member presently leads as Marjorie’s parent. The lack of her name in this summary does not exclude a wider relationship.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_EMMS_WOLSTANTON_PROBATE_1610_1622"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Eline and John Willat in the Bagnald wills",
          "record_date": "1618–1622",
          "locality": "Chatterley, Wolstanton parish, Staffordshire",
          "historical_detail": "Francis Bagnald’s 1618 will names daughter Eline Willat and son-in-law John Willat, whose daughter was Margreat. The 1622 probate of Emme Bagnald includes a bequest to a daughter’s child, Margret, with the surname tentatively read as Willat; her son John Bagnald was executor.",
          "association": "These records show that the Willat and Bagnald families had intermarried locally, independently of the compiled claim that Marjorie married Thomas Bagnold in 1589.",
          "alternatives": "The documented marriage may concern different branches of both surnames. Margret, a Willat daughter in the 1618 household, should not be merged with Marjorie on a similar given name alone.",
          "assessment": "The paired surnames and locality make this a useful family-history association. A shared relative or parish entry is still needed to place Marjorie within this household.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_EMMS_WOLSTANTON_PROBATE_1610_1622"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary treats Willatt as a form of Willett. One English derivation is from Wilot or Wilet, affectionate forms of Will, itself short for William.",
          "caveat": "That personal-name explanation is not the only possible origin of Willett.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_WILLATT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILLETT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ATWOOD_MARJORIE_WILLATT_DETAIL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Other English derivations listed for Willett include Willard and, less certainly, the Somerset place Willet.",
          "caveat": "Marjorie’s reported Essex birthplace does not establish which derivation applies to her.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_WILLATT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILLETT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ATWOOD_MARJORIE_WILLATT_DETAIL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Willatt and Willett are both used in the proposed family: the compilation calls Marjorie Willatt and her claimed father John Willett.",
          "caveat": "This spelling correspondence supports comparing records under both forms; it does not itself establish the father–daughter relationship.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_WILLATT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILLETT",
            "SRC_ROOTS_ATWOOD_MARJORIE_WILLATT_DETAIL"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_MICHAEL_WAEGELIN_BONFELD_1700",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_MICHAEL_WAEGELIN_BONFELD_1700",
      "surname": "Wägelin / Weigele",
      "locality": "Bonfeld, Kraichgau",
      "research_limit": "The leading earlier candidate is Johann Michael Wägelin, a Bonfeld citizen reported to have died on 11 March 1700 aged 47. Jones’s reproduced research identifies him as the emigrant’s father, but the quoted passage gives no baptism naming that relationship and no parents for the older man. His connection is shown as a candidate, not a settled generation.",
      "notes": "The surviving Bonfeld mixed register covers 1607–1737. Its entries could test the reported burial, family relationships and widow Agnes’s remarriage. The register images and Jones’s original pages have not been inspected here; the limit is the evidence reviewed so far, not a demonstrated loss of the parish books. Agnes is identified as his widow in 1700, but that alone does not distinguish the emigrant’s mother from a later wife.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_ROOTS_JONES_BONFELD_OLDER_MICHAEL",
        "SRC_ROOTS_BONFELD_REGISTERS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Hanß Michael Wägele in the Bonfeld assessment",
          "record_date": "1687",
          "locality": "Bonfeld, Kraichgau",
          "historical_detail": "Jones’s reproduced account reports Hanß Michael Wägele in the 1687 Kraichgau assessment at Bonfeld and supplies the archival reference Karlsruhe, CLA 125/3094.",
          "association": "The name and village fit the older Michael’s reported household. If he died aged 47 in 1700, he would have been about 34 in 1687, a plausible age for a taxpayer.",
          "alternatives": "The entry could belong to another local Michael. The reproduced passage does not give family members, and the original assessment has not been inspected.",
          "assessment": "A specific earlier local record favoring continuity, with the identification still provisional. It provides an archival lead rather than an invented extra generation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_JONES_BONFELD_OLDER_MICHAEL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Agnes remarries after Michael’s reported death",
          "record_date": "30 November 1700",
          "locality": "Bonfeld",
          "historical_detail": "The reproduced Jones account records Agnes, widow of Michael Wägelin, marrying Johann Ludwig Roth, son of the deceased Johann Ernst Roth, later in the year of Michael’s reported burial.",
          "association": "The surname, place and timing support identification with the widow of the older Michael. Her remarriage is a concrete route into the household’s history.",
          "alternatives": "The quoted account gives no maiden surname or date of her first marriage. She could have been the emigrant’s mother or a later wife of his proposed father.",
          "assessment": "The widow’s identity is a useful family connection, but the evidence currently cannot rank her maternity against the earlier-wife alternative.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_JONES_BONFELD_OLDER_MICHAEL"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The dictionary explanation for Weigel derives it from a familiar form of the medieval personal name Wigand.",
          "caveat": "The Bonfeld records use Wägelin and Wägele. Their identification with the emigrant family is a genealogical argument; it does not prove that every similar spelling has the same linguistic origin.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WEIGEL",
            "SRC_ROOTS_JONES_BONFELD_OLDER_MICHAEL"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Bonfeld is the specific locality reported for the older Michael’s citizenship, burial and household. The 1710 New York marriage describes the emigrant as coming from Bohnfeld in the Kraichgau.",
          "caveat": "These are residence and origin statements, not proof that either man was born there.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_JONES_BONFELD_OLDER_MICHAEL",
            "SRC_OT26_WAGELIN_HARTMAN_1710"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "This proposed branch connects a late-seventeenth-century Bonfeld household with the German-speaking Palatine migration to New York and later residence in Pennsylvania.",
          "caveat": "That connection depends on the candidate relationship shown in the tree.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_JONES_BONFELD_OLDER_MICHAEL",
            "SRC_OT26_SALFORD_LANDHOLDERS_1734"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_HANS_KISSLING_PARENT_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_HANS_KISSLING_PARENT_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Kissling",
      "locality": "Home town unestablished; proposed daughter in Erpfingen and Willmandingen",
      "research_limit": "Hans Kissling, reportedly 1600–1680, is named as Anna’s father in the DeLaFuente pedigree. The matching daughter, husband and dates make him a specific candidate, shown at low confidence. The source supplies no demonstrated home town, parents or record connecting him to Anna.",
      "notes": "The same pedigree gives a conflicting ancestry for Anna’s husband, so its family attachments need individual checking. Anna’s own birthplace remains unresolved between uncited online claims. No earlier Kissling household in her actual place of origin can yet be selected.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DELAFUENTE",
        "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "An earlier Hans Kissling in a Nördlingen testament",
          "record_date": "28 November1599",
          "locality": "Nördlingen",
          "historical_detail": "The municipal archive’s abstract of Paulus Rehlin’s testament names his daughter Magdalena as the wife of Hans Kissling, described as a Loder, a cloth-working occupation. It identifies Magdalena’s mother as Anna Voll and contains special provisions concerning this son-in-law.",
          "association": "This is a documented earlier household bearing the same name in southern Germany. It gives a concrete regional comparison, while the candidate father’s home town remains unknown.",
          "alternatives": "A man already married in 1599 cannot be the candidate reportedly born 1600 unless the birth date is wrong. He could be an older relative or an unrelated bearer of the name; the testament supplies no link to Anna’s family.",
          "assessment": "The catalogue establishes the earlier household. It does not justify moving Anna’s origins to Nördlingen or adding this man as another generation.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KISSLING_NOERDLINGEN1599",
            "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DELAFUENTE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary derives Kissling from the ancient Germanic personal name Gisilo.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Kissling is described as both German and Swiss German.",
          "caveat": "This distribution of name origins does not locate Hans’s household or establish a Swiss migration for Anna.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The explanation places Kissling among surnames formed from personal names.",
          "caveat": "Similar modern spellings and a shared personal-name origin do not by themselves identify a common family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_ANNA_MARIA_KISSLING_PARENT_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_ANNA_MARIA_KISSLING_PARENT_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Home town unestablished",
      "research_limit": "Anna Maria, reportedly born 1602, is named beside Hans Kissling as Anna’s mother in the same compiled pedigree. Their reported ages at Anna’s birth would be about sixteen and eighteen, which is possible. The connecting record and Anna Maria’s birth family remain unestablished.",
      "notes": "The source’s label Umn does not establish a surname. No surname meaning, place of surname origin or earlier name-bearing family can responsibly be assigned to her from the evidence reviewed.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DELAFUENTE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "The maternal candidate in the compiled household",
          "record_date": "Reported early seventeenth century",
          "locality": "Place unestablished",
          "historical_detail": "The displayed pedigree places Anna Maria beside Hans Kissling above Anna Göbel 1618–1688 and the Willmandingen child Martin Gebel, born 1655.",
          "association": "The daughter’s dates and spouse match the established research household, making this a specific maternal claim rather than a random Anna Maria name match.",
          "alternatives": "The compiler may have attached another family or copied a mistaken parentage. The general family-tables citation on the child’s page does not show which record supports this grandmother.",
          "assessment": "Retained visibly as a low-confidence candidate. Neither the reported mother nor her surname has yet been identified in an independent event record.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DELAFUENTE",
            "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Anna Maria (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Anna Maria (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Anna Maria (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_APOLLONIA_WASSENACH",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_APOLLONIA_WASSENACH",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Wassenach, Rhineland, reported household",
      "research_limit": "Apollonia is named as Matthias’s wife and Anna Catharina’s mother in the compilation, but no birth surname or parents are supplied. The reported marriage about 1670 precedes the listed Wassenach marriage series, which begins 1674.",
      "notes": "Muntz identifies the proposed husband’s family, not Apollonia’s birth family. Without her own surname, no surname meaning, place of origin or earlier same-name lineage can responsibly be assigned. Her reported death in 1710 falls within the surviving burial series, whose original entries have not been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG719",
        "ROOTS26_WASSENACH_TRIER_CATALOGUE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Marriage and burial coverage for Apollonia",
          "record_date": "Marriage reported about 1670; death reported 1710",
          "locality": "Wassenach, Rhineland",
          "historical_detail": "The marriage estimate falls before the listed parish marriage series. The burial series does cover the reported death.",
          "association": "A burial or a child’s baptism could distinguish this proposed mother through her household or birth name.",
          "alternatives": "An earlier marriage elsewhere, a different estimated date or an erroneous compiled identification remain possible.",
          "assessment": "The available catalogue establishes where the proposed events fit the surviving series; it does not confirm the named woman or identify her parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG719",
            "ROOTS26_WASSENACH_TRIER_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Apollonia (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Apollonia (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Apollonia (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_HERMANN_MUNTZ_WASSENACH",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_HERMANN_MUNTZ_WASSENACH",
      "surname": "Muntz",
      "locality": "Wassenach, Rhineland; birthplace unknown",
      "research_limit": "Hermann’s parents and birthplace are not identified in the reviewed pedigree. His reported birth about 1606 predates the Wassenach baptism series listed from 1662. That limits a baptism search in this particular series; it does not establish destruction of every earlier family record.",
      "notes": "The proposed Wassenach household remains a candidate lineage. No earlier local Muntz bearer was established by the indexed name searches or the Nickenich parish catalogue reviewed here. A surviving rent book reaches further back than the listed baptisms, as described below.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG763",
        "ROOTS26_WASSENACH_TRIER_CATALOGUE",
        "ROOTS26_WASSENACH_RENT1649"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "A Wassenach rent book preceding the baptism series",
          "record_date": "1649–1691",
          "locality": "Wassenach, Rhineland",
          "historical_detail": "The Nickenich parish archive preserves a Wassenach church rent book, item 0359. Its catalogue describes church and confraternity rents, grain payments and dues in wax and oil.",
          "association": "This is a specific surviving local source overlapping Hermann’s reported adult lifetime and potentially recording households or inherited obligations.",
          "alternatives": "Its title does not establish that a Muntz appears in it. Even a matching surname could represent another household; property succession or named relatives would distinguish continuity.",
          "assessment": "Only the catalogue was examined. No entry from this volume is asserted as evidence for Hermann or an earlier ancestor.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WASSENACH_RENT1649"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Muntz/Müntz has several dictionary explanations. Related Munz can come from personal names built on thought or protection, or from the German word for a coin or mint.",
          "caveat": "The spelling alone does not identify which explanation applies to Hermann.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_MUNTZ",
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_MUNZ"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "One German formation refers to Müntz near Jülich; others are variants of Münz or Munz.",
          "caveat": "The compiled Wassenach residence is not evidence of birth near Jülich.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_MUNTZ"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The dictionary distinguishes German coin-or-mint names from Jewish occupational or artificial names of similar spelling.",
          "caveat": "No mint occupation, religious identity or particular migration is established for this family by those general explanations.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_MUNZ"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_ELISABETH_WASSENACH",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_ELISABETH_WASSENACH",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Wassenach, Rhineland, reported household",
      "research_limit": "Elisabeth’s identification ends with the proposed Hermann Muntz household. The reviewed compilation gives neither her birth surname nor her parents, and the original burial has not been examined.",
      "notes": "Her reported death in 1681 falls within Wassenach’s listed burial series. Muntz is not established as her birth surname; an older local Muntz family would therefore not by itself extend her maternal ancestry.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG763",
        "ROOTS26_WASSENACH_TRIER_CATALOGUE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Elisabeth’s proposed household and burial",
          "record_date": "Reported 1681",
          "locality": "Wassenach, Rhineland",
          "historical_detail": "The compilation associates Elisabeth with Hermann and Matthias. The archive lists relevant burial coverage for the reported death year.",
          "association": "A named spouse or relative in the original burial would help identify the woman behind this compiled household.",
          "alternatives": "A spouse recorded at death would not automatically prove maternity of every child; a previous marriage or mistaken grouping remains possible.",
          "assessment": "Elisabeth remains a candidate mother with an unresolved birth surname. No earlier birth-family association is claimed.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG763",
            "ROOTS26_WASSENACH_TRIER_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Elisabeth (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Elisabeth (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Elisabeth (birth surname unknown) — parent candidate without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_FRIEDERICH_PARENT_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_FRIEDERICH_PARENT_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND",
      "surname": "Uhland",
      "locality": "Schauernheim through proposed son’s marriage; parents’ residence unestablished",
      "research_limit": "Friederich and Eva Maria are named as Matthäus Uhland’s parents in the Lang pedigree, but their entries give no older generation, dates or home parish. Schauernheim is the reported place of their son’s 1714 marriage, not an established residence for his parents. The Speyer archive lists a Reformed register covering Dannstadt and Schauernheim from 1673 to 1729; its individual entries have not been examined here.",
      "notes": "The earlier-name search did not identify a specific pre-1690 Uhland record in Dannstadt or Schauernheim that can be associated with this household. Local registers survive for the relevant period, so the present limit is an unverified identification and incomplete record access, rather than demonstrated loss of all records.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_UHLAND_LANG718",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688",
        "ROOTS26_DANNSTADT_REGISTER_CATALOGUE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Friederich Uhland, parent candidate: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Schauernheim through proposed son’s marriage; parents’ residence unestablished",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Friederich and Eva Maria are named as Matthäus Uhland’s parents in the Lang pedigree, but their entries give no older generation, dates or home parish. Schauernheim is the reported place of their son’s 1714 marriage, not an established residence for his parents. The Speyer archive lists a Reformed register covering Dannstadt and Schauernheim from 1673 to 1729; its individual entries have not been examined here. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UHLAND_LANG718",
            "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688",
            "ROOTS26_DANNSTADT_REGISTER_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The Dictionary of American Family Names derives Uhland from a Germanic personal name combining odal, inherited property, and nand, daring or bold.",
          "caveat": "This describes the name’s formation, not an occupation or landed status of Friederich.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_UHLAND"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary places this surname formation in South German usage.",
          "caveat": "Friederich’s own birthplace is unrecorded in the consulted pedigree; the broad linguistic region cannot supply it.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_UHLAND"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The poet and politician Ludwig Uhland (1787–1862) belonged to a Württemberg scholarly family documented since the sixteenth century and settled in Tübingen from 1720.",
          "caveat": "That documented family is a surname association. No shared household, migration or ancestor has been identified connecting it to the proposed Schauernheim branch.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NDB_UHLAND"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_EVA_MARIA_PARENT_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_EVA_MARIA_PARENT_MATTHAEUS_UHLAND",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Schauernheim through proposed son’s marriage; parents’ residence unestablished",
      "research_limit": "Eva Maria’s entry in the Lang pedigree supplies given names and a proposed son, Matthäus Uhland, but no birth surname, parents or residence. Her identity depends on that unverified household assignment. The reported 1714 marriage of Matthäus at Schauernheim provides a place to investigate; it does not establish where Eva Maria was born.",
      "notes": "No surname meaning or origin can yet be assigned to Eva Maria. The available compiled entry does not identify her birth family. The Dannstadt register catalogue covers baptisms, marriages and burials in 1673–1729, but no entry naming her maiden surname has been inspected.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_UHLAND_LANG718",
        "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688",
        "ROOTS26_DANNSTADT_REGISTER_CATALOGUE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Eva Maria, parent candidate: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Schauernheim through proposed son’s marriage; parents’ residence unestablished",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Eva Maria’s entry in the Lang pedigree supplies given names and a proposed son, Matthäus Uhland, but no birth surname, parents or residence. Her identity depends on that unverified household assignment. The reported 1714 marriage of Matthäus at Schauernheim provides a place to investigate; it does not establish where Eva Maria was born. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UHLAND_LANG718",
            "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688",
            "ROOTS26_DANNSTADT_REGISTER_CATALOGUE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Eva Maria, parent candidate without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Eva Maria, parent candidate. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Eva Maria, parent candidate without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_SW_1293",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_SW_1293",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "research_limit": "Agnes is identified as Hans Schweickhard’s wife in the reported 1653 burial. The published reconstruction does not identify her parents or birth surname. Her marriage is estimated around 1641, within the reported 1634–1644 gap in Erpfingen’s marriage book.",
      "notes": "The surname cannot be recovered merely from her husband’s family. A surviving property or inheritance record naming her relatives could extend this line; no such identification was found in the reviewed pedigree and indexed-web search. No surname meaning or origin can yet be assigned.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD",
        "ROOTS26_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Agnes (surname unknown): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Agnes is identified as Hans Schweickhard’s wife in the reported 1653 burial. The published reconstruction does not identify her parents or birth surname. Her marriage is estimated around 1641, within the reported 1634–1644 gap in Erpfingen’s marriage book. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD",
            "ROOTS26_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Agnes (surname unknown) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Agnes (surname unknown). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Agnes (surname unknown) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_SW_1294",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_SW_1294",
      "surname": "Heniss (Heniß / Henus)",
      "locality": "Meidelstetten, Württemberg",
      "research_limit": "Bernhard’s reported 1680 death age places his birth around 1605, before the Meidelstetten baptism series which Weigel dates from 1609. The reconstruction records his 1633 marriage to Catharina but supplies no parents.",
      "notes": "No earlier local reference identifying Bernhard’s parents was found in the reviewed material. Earlier land and court records have not been examined.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD",
        "ROOTS26_HENISS_NAME_REVIEW"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Bernhard Heniss (Hoeness): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Meidelstetten, Württemberg",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Bernhard’s reported 1680 death age places his birth around 1605, before the Meidelstetten baptism series which Weigel dates from 1609. The reconstruction records his 1633 marriage to Catharina but supplies no parents. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD",
            "ROOTS26_HENISS_NAME_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "This branch is associated with the Meidelstetten household of Bernhard and Catharina, whose marriage is reported in 1633. The reported daughter’s marriage at Erpfingen provides a connection between the two villages.",
          "caveat": "A similar spelling elsewhere does not yet locate Bernhard’s parents or identify the name’s meaning.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Heniß and Henus are the spellings reported in Bernhard’s marriage and death material; the compiler groups them under Heniss (Hoeness).",
          "caveat": "No reliable linguistic derivation for these particular forms was established. The online Heniss lookup supplies explanations for similar names rather than a demonstrated connection to this household.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD",
            "ROOTS26_HENISS_NAME_REVIEW"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Meidelstetten is the earliest locality established for this branch in the consulted reconstruction, through Bernhard’s marriage and later death.",
          "caveat": "The family’s earlier geographical origin remains unestablished; the similar English and Dutch name Hennis is not evidence of migration to Württemberg.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_SW_1295",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_SW_1295",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Meidelstetten, Württemberg",
      "research_limit": "Catharina is named in the reported 1633 marriage to Bernhard Heniß. The cited reconstruction gives neither her birth surname nor parents. Its author reports not finding a burial entry, so her death date also remains unsettled.",
      "notes": "That limited search result does not establish that the record is lost. Meidelstetten marriage records reportedly begin in 1608 and burial records in 1650; an earlier death or an entry elsewhere could explain the omission. Without an identified birth surname, no surname origin or wider family association can responsibly be assigned.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Catharina (surname unknown): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Meidelstetten, Württemberg",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Catharina is named in the reported 1633 marriage to Bernhard Heniß. The cited reconstruction gives neither her birth surname nor parents. Its author reports not finding a burial entry, so her death date also remains unsettled. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Catharina (surname unknown) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Catharina (surname unknown). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Catharina (surname unknown) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_SW_2925",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_SW_2925",
      "surname": "Rümelin",
      "locality": "Erpfingen; proposed Ebingen origin unverified",
      "research_limit": "Anna died at Erpfingen in 1611 as Jung Martin Schweickhard’s wife. Weigel suggests Ebingen as a possible origin but reports no matching identification in the Ebingen family book or Rümelin family list. Her parents remain unidentified.",
      "notes": "",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD",
        "ROOTS26_RUEMELIN_LIST_REVIEW"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Jacob Rümelin sponsors Matthäus Schweickhard",
          "record_date": "1595",
          "locality": "Erpfingen",
          "historical_detail": "Weigel names Jacob Rümelin among the baptismal sponsors of Anna’s son Matthäus.",
          "association": "A shared surname within the child’s immediate social circle supports a possible connection to Anna’s birth family.",
          "alternatives": "Jacob could be her father, brother, another relative, or a non-relative sponsor; his name alone does not distinguish these roles.",
          "assessment": "This is stronger family-context evidence than a distant surname match, but does not identify a parent to add.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Rümelin and Rymelin occur in compiled accounts of sixteenth-century Ebingen households. This makes Ebingen a concrete place to investigate alongside Anna’s known Erpfingen household.",
          "caveat": "No entry reviewed identifies Anna as the daughter of a particular Ebingen couple.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_RUEMELIN_LIST_REVIEW",
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The consulted family list uses both Rümelin and Rymelin for early Ebingen households. These historical spelling forms help identify relevant records.",
          "caveat": "The list supplies genealogical claims, not an etymology. The linguistic meaning of Anna’s surname remains unresolved in this review.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_RUEMELIN_LIST_REVIEW"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Rümelin family list identifies Hans Rymelin, placed in sixteenth-century Ebingen, as a mayor, householder and revenue collector.",
          "caveat": "This is a compiled account of a named family in the proposed origin town; it does not identify Anna’s parents or establish her relationship to that household.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_RUEMELIN_LIST_REVIEW"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_SW_5170",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_SW_5170",
      "surname": "Lorch",
      "locality": "Hausen an der Lauchert, Württemberg",
      "research_limit": "Michael is identified as Maria Lorch’s father in the reported 1612 marriage entry. Weigel places him at Hausen an der Lauchert, with an estimated birth before 1570, but gives no parents or earlier household identification.",
      "notes": "The 1522 Lorch records below provide a local family-history association. No intervening generations have been reconstructed from those men to Michael.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD",
        "ROOTS26_DAFN_LORCH"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Martin and Melchior Lorch in a Hausen land survey",
          "record_date": "24 Sep 1522",
          "locality": "Hausen an der Lauchert",
          "historical_detail": "Weigel cites Schwarz’s Altwürttembergische Lagerbücher II,706 ff: Martin Lorch served as a judge and Melchior represented the community in the survey commission. Melchior held property and owed rents on several holdings.",
          "association": "The same surname in the same village before Michael’s generation makes continuity within a wider local family plausible.",
          "alternatives": "Michael could descend from either man, belong to another local branch, or come from a separately named family. The record does not select a parent.",
          "assessment": "Useful local continuity evidence, reported through a published secondary source; the 1522 edition and original have not been independently inspected.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The Dictionary of American Family Names treats Lorch as a German surname taken from a place name.",
          "caveat": "The linguistic explanation does not identify which place supplied this branch’s surname.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_LORCH"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary entry names Lorch places in the Wiesbaden district of Hesse. Michael’s recorded family context is instead Hausen an der Lauchert.",
          "caveat": "No migration from Hesse to Hausen has been established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_LORCH"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The Hausen material associates Lorch name-bearers with local government, landholding and rent obligations in 1522.",
          "caveat": "These roles belong to the named historical men, not automatically to every later Lorch household.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_SW_ALT_MARTIN",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_SW_ALT_MARTIN",
      "surname": "Schweickhardt",
      "locality": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
      "research_limit": "Alt Martin’s reported 1611 death at 80 places his birth around 1531, decades before Erpfingen’s parish registers begin. His possible fatherhood of Jung Martin remains a weak candidate relationship, and no older generation is identified.",
      "notes": "The author distinguishes several contemporary Martins. The age and place identify a plausible older man, but they do not turn the senior/junior labels into proof of father and son. Archion catalogues mixed books from 1594 and 1597; no earlier parental identification has been recovered here.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD",
        "ROOTS26_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN",
        "ROOTS26_BAHLOW_SCHWEICKHARDT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Martin Schweickhardt (Alt Martin): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Erpfingen, Württemberg",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Alt Martin’s reported 1611 death at 80 places his birth around 1531, decades before Erpfingen’s parish registers begin. His possible fatherhood of Jung Martin remains a weak candidate relationship, and no older generation is identified. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD",
            "ROOTS26_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN",
            "ROOTS26_BAHLOW_SCHWEICKHARDT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Bahlow groups Schweickhardt with Schweiker and Schweickert, tracing them to the Germanic personal name Swindger, combining strength or speed with spear.",
          "caveat": "This is a personal-name derivation, not evidence that Alt Martin was a warrior.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BAHLOW_SCHWEICKHARDT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Bahlow particularly associates this group of surname forms with Bavaria and Württemberg.",
          "caveat": "Alt Martin’s birth around 1531 is calculated from his reported death age; his birthplace has not been established.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BAHLOW_SCHWEICKHARDT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The same name elements appear in medieval personal names before Schweickhardt became a hereditary surname.",
          "caveat": "Such early given-name bearers cannot be treated as members of the Erpfingen family solely through the linguistic connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BAHLOW_SCHWEICKHARDT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_JOHN_ATHY_PARENT_WALTER",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_JOHN_ATHY_PARENT_WALTER",
      "surname": "Athy",
      "locality": "Galway, Ireland; residence in the published reconstruction",
      "research_limit": "The reviewed account identifies John with a Galway house dated 1577, then names Walter and Francis in the next two generations. It supplies no parent for this John on that page. Earlier medieval Athys are known, but a particular intervening household has not been identified in this review.",
      "notes": "The surname history and surviving Galway material support a local family context. They do not identify the missing generations linking this household to medieval officials.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ATHY_GALWAY1999",
        "ROOTS26_ATHY_MEDIEVAL"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "The surviving Athy doorway dated 1577",
          "record_date": "1577",
          "locality": "Galway",
          "historical_detail": "Jim Higgins describes an Athy doorway bearing family arms, a merchant’s mark and the date 1577, preserved in Galway City Museum. His 2018 account places its former house in Abbeygate Street.",
          "association": "The 1999 pedigree associates a doorway of that date with John’s house in St Augustine Street. The shared date and heraldry make comparison worthwhile, but the differing street locations leave that precise identification unresolved.",
          "alternatives": "One account may mislocate the same object, or separate Athy buildings may have been conflated.",
          "assessment": "The carved object supports an established Athy merchant presence in sixteenth-century Galway. It does not independently name John’s parents or prove the proposed property succession.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ATHY_HIGGINS1577",
            "ROOTS26_ATHY_GALWAY1999"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Earlier Athys in Athenry and Galway",
          "record_date": "1342; 1388; 1404",
          "locality": "Athenry and Galway, Ireland",
          "historical_detail": "Adrian Martyn’s historical account reports William son of Richard de Athy at Athenry in 1342, a later William as treasurer of Connacht in 1388, and John Athy as a merchant in an April 1404 exchequer deed.",
          "association": "These records place the surname in the same regional trading and administrative community generations before the reported 1577 household, supporting plausible wider-family continuity.",
          "alternatives": "The earlier men could belong to collateral branches, or different families using the same place-derived surname. None is identified here as the sixteenth-century John’s parent.",
          "assessment": "The local sequence carries more weight than a broad surname match. The gap of roughly two centuries from the latest mention still permits several lines of descent, and the administrative originals underlying the article have not been inspected.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ATHY_MEDIEVAL"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The Dictionary of American Family Names treats Irish Athy as a surname taken from the town of Athy in County Kildare.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ATHY_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary associates de Athy with Norman settlers in Ireland and the Galway family. English Athey can instead derive from Middle English atte hey, describing someone living at an enclosure.",
          "caveat": "The Galway setting favors the Irish family context here; similar English spellings alone would not establish that origin.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ATHY_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Athy was one of Galway’s merchant families collectively called the Tribes of Galway. Francis’s reported 1639 sheriffship belongs to that civic setting.",
          "caveat": "The later Lynch-Athy family of Renville is not connected to this household by an established chain in Kingsley’s account.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ATHY_RENVILLE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_MARMADUKE_SEMME_IMMIGRANT",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_MARMADUKE_SEMME_IMMIGRANT",
      "surname": "Semme / Semmes",
      "locality": "St. Mary’s County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "The Maryland records identify Marmaduke by April 1662, but the records examined do not name his parents or an overseas home parish. Newman’s origin traditions do not supply an identifiable parent candidate. An English probate or migration record connecting this Maryland household to a named place would allow the search to move beyond the immigrant.",
      "notes": "The similar spellings belong to an identifiable Maryland family; they do not by themselves connect it to every earlier Simme or Simms household.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_SEMME_ASSEMBLY1662",
        "ROOTS26_SEMME_WITNESS1662",
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMME_ORIGINS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Marmaduke Simme in Maryland’s assembly and court records",
          "record_date": "2 and 11 April 1662",
          "locality": "Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "Marmaduke Simme was sworn as Upper House doorkeeper on 2 April. On 11 April he and Daniel Jenifer witnessed Thomas Gerrard’s release of claims against Lord Baltimore.",
          "association": "The matching name, close dates and Jenifer’s presence in both records favor one man in the colonial administrative community, consistent with Newman’s identification of the immigrant.",
          "alternatives": "A different man with the same name is possible, but no competing household is identified in these records. Neither entry establishes overseas ancestry.",
          "assessment": "These records anchor the Maryland identity. They provide no basis for selecting a particular English or continental family as his parents.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SEMME_ASSEMBLY1662",
            "ROOTS26_SEMME_WITNESS1662",
            "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMME_ORIGINS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The Dictionary of American Family Names leaves the origin of Semmes undetermined. A meaning derived from a similar-looking surname would therefore be provisional.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_SEMMES"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Newman reports Norman and Scottish-border traditions, but does not connect Marmaduke to an overseas parish or parent. Those accounts remain possible origins, rather than a traced migration route.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMME_ORIGINS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Newman describes Semme as the immigrant’s spelling, with Simms and Semmes used in descendant branches. Maryland’s assembly record calls him Simme.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMME_ORIGINS",
            "ROOTS26_SEMME_ASSEMBLY1662"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_FORTUNA_SEMME",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_FORTUNA_SEMME",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "St. Mary’s County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "Fortuna’s maiden surname and parents remain unresolved. Newman explicitly leaves her surname unknown and suggests Milburn from a descendant’s given name. That pattern could reflect her own family, another relative or a family associate; it does not identify a particular parent.",
      "notes": "Mitford belongs to her earlier marriage and Semme to her later marriage. Neither should be displayed as an established birth surname.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMME_ORIGINS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Fortuna’s premarital provision for her Mitford sons",
          "record_date": "7 July 1668",
          "locality": "St. George’s River, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "Newman describes a premarital arrangement and a trust of 100 acres for Fortuna’s sons, with her lifetime use reserved.",
          "association": "The named sons and forthcoming marriage connect her earlier and later households more securely than a proposed maiden surname does.",
          "alternatives": "The property arrangement concerns her married household; it need not represent an inheritance from her parents.",
          "assessment": "This is a useful family identification from a published abstract. The underlying deed could clarify its terms, but the account does not establish her natal family.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMME_ORIGINS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Fortuna’s birth surname is unknown, so no surname meaning can yet be assigned to her natal family.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMME_ORIGINS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Her Maryland household is identifiable through marriage and property, but the account examined does not establish where her birth family came from.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMME_ORIGINS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Newman identifies her as Bulmer Mitford’s widow before her marriage to Marmaduke Semme, with sons Thomas and Joseph Mitford.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMME_ORIGINS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_GEORGE_GOODRICK_1673",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_GEORGE_GOODRICK_1673",
      "surname": "Goodrick",
      "locality": "Charles County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "George’s will identifies his sons Robert and Francis, but the abstract gives neither his parents nor an English home parish. The connection through Robert to Mary remains a candidate identification. The Maryland records examined do not yet distinguish a particular overseas Goodrick family.",
      "notes": "The will was dated 25 July 1673; its abstract supplies no probate date. This date is not an established date of death.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_WILL1673"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "George Goodrick administering William Lewis’s estate",
          "record_date": "24 April 1658",
          "locality": "Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "The provincial court recorded an inventory presented by George Goodrick as administrator of Captain William Lewis’s estate, together with William Bretton’s claim against it.",
          "association": "The matching name and Maryland setting make this a plausible earlier appearance of the man whose Charles County will was dated 1673.",
          "alternatives": "The inventory does not identify his sons or property from the later will; another George Goodrick could account for it. Administering Lewis’s estate does not itself establish kinship with Lewis.",
          "assessment": "A plausible earlier identity, not an additional generation. The administration papers and land transactions could connect the two records more securely.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_LEWIS1658",
            "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_WILL1673"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Goodrick is an English variant of Goodrich, which can derive from the personal name Godric, combining elements meaning good and power. Goodrich can also refer to the place in Herefordshire.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_GOODRICK",
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_GOODRICH"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary associates English Goodrick with Yorkshire and Lincolnshire and also recognizes an Americanized German origin. George’s Maryland records do not identify which geographical origin belongs to this branch.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_GOODRICK"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "George’s will places his family in Charles County and names sons Robert and Francis, daughters married into the Stapleford and Gunby families, and grandchildren Charles Stapleford and Constant Gunby.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_WILL1673"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_ELIZABETH_WIFE_ROBERT_GOODRICK",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_ELIZABETH_WIFE_ROBERT_GOODRICK",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Charles County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "Elizabeth is named as Mary Goodrick’s mother in a marriage compilation, but her own maiden surname, parents and marriage record have not been established. The distinctive sequence of Mary’s marriages supports the household identification while leaving the maternal claim dependent on that compilation.",
      "notes": "The record assigns Elizabeth as a mother, rather than merely naming a wife of Robert. Retrieving its underlying evidence would help confirm that distinction.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_RENO"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Elizabeth, wife of Robert Goodrick: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Charles County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Elizabeth is named as Mary Goodrick’s mother in a marriage compilation, but her own maiden surname, parents and marriage record have not been established. The distinctive sequence of Mary’s marriages supports the household identification while leaving the maternal claim dependent on that compilation. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_RENO"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "No birth surname is established for Elizabeth, so a surname meaning cannot yet be assigned to her family.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_RENO"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The compilation places Robert’s marriage before 1670 in Charles County; this is a marriage context, not evidence of Elizabeth’s birthplace or immigration.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_RENO"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The same compilation identifies her daughter Mary through marriages to John Anderson, James Semmes and John Speake. This family sequence is the useful identifying context for Elizabeth.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_RENO"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_THOMAS_JENKINS_1727",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_JENKINS_1727",
      "surname": "Jenkins",
      "locality": "Charles County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "Thomas’s Maryland will identifies his children and property. The earlier parent claim names William Jason Jenkins of Anglesey, but its underlying evidence remains unresolved. A later scholarly review reports that the family’s European-origin traditions were investigated without a conclusive connection. The current stopping point reflects this unresolved identification, not a finding that Welsh ancestry is impossible.",
      "notes": "The 1918 history’s parent claim could preserve family knowledge, or could combine this Maryland family with another Jenkins family. The full 1985 discussion and the alleged naval officer’s records are needed to rank those explanations more securely.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729",
        "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS278",
        "ROOTS26_BARNES_JENKINS_REVIEW1987"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "The reported 1682 purchases from Charles Pye",
          "record_date": "1682; compared with the 1726 will",
          "locality": "Charles County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "The 1918 history reports Thomas buying Lynnsis, St. Thomas and Pye’s Hardship from Charles Pye in 1682. His will later names corresponding tracts, including Pyes Hardshift bought from Pye.",
          "association": "The combination of owner, seller and three tract names strongly favors the same Maryland landholder.",
          "alternatives": "The history may have derived the ownership account partly from the will; the purchase year and acreage still need checking against the deeds. The property match does not validate the book’s separate European pedigree.",
          "assessment": "Useful evidence for continuity within Maryland. The original deeds could establish the earlier transaction’s exact date and terms; they have not yet been inspected.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS278",
            "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Jenkins developed from Jenkin with a possessive or later added -s. Jenkin belongs to medieval pet names such as Jankin and Jonkin; the -kin ending could distinguish a younger namesake.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_JENKINS",
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_JENKIN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname is English and Welsh, with strong associations in Wales and southwestern England. The specific Anglesey origin reported for Thomas belongs to the family tradition; the surname’s distribution alone cannot locate his birthplace.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_JENKINS",
            "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS278"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The documented Maryland household held land called Pyes Hardshift, Lynsei or Lindsey, and St. Thomas. These property names provide a more specific way to follow the family than the common surname alone.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_ANN_WIFE_THOMAS_JENKINS",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_ANN_WIFE_THOMAS_JENKINS",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Charles County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "Ann’s own will and her husband’s identify a family, but neither abstract names her birth parents. The 1918 family history calls her Spalding; the probate records examined do not distinguish that proposed birth surname from a possible confusion with her daughter Ann Spaulding. Her maiden name therefore remains unresolved.",
      "notes": "Her identity as Thomas’s wife is better supported than the proposed maiden surname. The maternal link to George is shown as a candidate because it combines the compiled assignment with the matching probate household.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729",
        "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS279"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ann’s will links the Jenkins and Norris households",
          "record_date": "25 June–3 December 1729",
          "locality": "Charles County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "Ann left property to Mary Norris and appointed sons Edward and William as executors. Thomas’s earlier will names the same children.",
          "association": "The shared children and locality favor identifying her as Thomas’s widow, rather than another Ann Jenkins.",
          "alternatives": "The probate match does not establish her birth surname or prove that she was the mother of every child named by Thomas.",
          "assessment": "The household identification is strong; her natal family requires different evidence, such as an earlier marriage or a relative’s will.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "A surname meaning cannot yet be assigned to Ann’s birth family. Jenkins is her married name; Spalding remains a reported possibility.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729",
            "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS279"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The wills place Ann’s family in Charles County. They do not identify her birthplace or an overseas home parish.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729",
            "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS279"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Ann’s will names sons Edward and William and daughter Mary Norris. These names also appear in Thomas’s will, giving a concrete basis for identifying the couple’s household.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729",
            "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS279"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_REBECCA_WIFE_ROBERT_COLE",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_WIFE_ROBERT_COLE",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Heston, Middlesex, England; St. Mary’s County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "Rebecca is named as the mother of Robert Cole’s children in sworn testimony, but that record gives no birth surname or parents. The biographical account describes her as the widow Knott before her marriage to Cole. Knott therefore identifies an earlier marriage, not an established natal family.",
      "notes": "The court testimony establishes maternity independently of the account of her marriages. Her parentage cannot be inferred from the surnames of either husband.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_COLE_DEPOSITION1663",
        "ROOTS26_COLE_AMERICAN_ERAS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Three witnesses identify the Cole children’s parents",
          "record_date": "29 March 1663",
          "locality": "Maryland Provincial Court",
          "historical_detail": "William Bretton testified to the parentage of five surviving children. Luke Gardnor and William Turpine made matching oaths; both Robert and Rebecca were already dead.",
          "association": "The testimony identifies a particular household and explicitly includes Edward, making it stronger than an inference from a couple’s marriage alone.",
          "alternatives": "The open identity question is whether this Edward is the later testator, whose identification is supported by the biographical account.",
          "assessment": "Rebecca’s maternity of the Edward named in this record is explicit. Her birth family remains a separate unresolved question.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_COLE_DEPOSITION1663",
            "ROOTS26_COLE_AMERICAN_ERAS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Rebecca’s birth surname remains unresolved. Neither Cole nor her earlier married name Knott supplies a reliable surname meaning for her natal family.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_COLE_AMERICAN_ERAS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The biographical account places her in the family that moved from England to Maryland in 1652. It does not identify her own birthplace.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_COLE_AMERICAN_ERAS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Her five surviving children by Robert were Robert, Mary, William Maria, Edward and Elizabeth. Their parentage was attested before Charles Calvert in 1663.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_COLE_DEPOSITION1663"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_JANE_MOTHER_ROBERT_COLE",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_JANE_MOTHER_ROBERT_COLE",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Middlesex, England; Heston household identification unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Robert’s will names his mother but does not establish her birth surname. Mainwaring is proposed in later research; deciding whether that proposal identifies the right woman requires comparison with the other documented Cole household in Heston.",
      "notes": "Jane is the spelling in the will abstract. Joan is reported from a land patent. Neither spelling alone settles which Heston woman was Robert’s mother.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_WILL1662",
        "ROOTS26_HESTON_COLE_RECUSANTS1632",
        "ROOTS26_COLE_WHITESIDES2006"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Two Cole households in Heston’s recusancy proceedings",
          "record_date": "12 April 1632",
          "locality": "Heston, Middlesex, England",
          "historical_detail": "The court list names Jane, wife of Thomas Cole, and Joan, wife of William Cole, both of Heston, in proceedings for recusancy.",
          "association": "Both are concrete local candidates for comparison with the mother named in Robert’s later records.",
          "alternatives": "The similar given names may conceal a mistaken household assignment; alternatively, later spelling or transcription could explain the variation in Robert’s records.",
          "assessment": "The list establishes two households, but does not name Robert as a child of either. His mother’s identity across these records remains unresolved.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HESTON_COLE_RECUSANTS1632",
            "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_WILL1662"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Cole is the surname used for her in her son’s will. Her birth surname is unresolved, so a meaning for her natal family cannot yet be assigned.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_WILL1662"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The will places her in Middlesex. Later accounts associate Robert’s family with Heston, but the earlier records there contain two possible households.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_WILL1662",
            "ROOTS26_HESTON_COLE_RECUSANTS1632",
            "ROOTS26_COLE_AMERICAN_ERAS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The proposed Mainwaring ancestry rests on later research connecting the Cole and Gill families. It remains a separate identification question from the will’s explicit mother-and-son relationship.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_COLE_WHITESIDES2006",
            "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_WILL1662"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_THOMAS_LEWIS_BATTERSEA1696",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_LEWIS_BATTERSEA1696",
      "surname": "Lewis",
      "locality": "Battersea and Broad Creek, Charles County, later Prince George’s County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "The land and probate accounts identify Thomas’s Maryland household but do not name his parents or an overseas parish. Online pedigrees attach additional names and origins; those assignments have not been connected to this testator by the records examined.",
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_BROAD_CREEK_LEWIS",
        "ROOTS26_THOMAS_LEWIS_WILL1696",
        "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "The Lewis household at the future Harmony Hall site",
          "record_date": "1692–1706",
          "locality": "Broad Creek, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "Thomas bought 250 acres of Battersea in 1692. The planning study associates an excavated early timber dwelling with his household and explains that the landing retained his name in 1706, ten years after his death.",
          "association": "The property history identifies the local man proposed as Margaret’s father.",
          "alternatives": "The archaeological attribution does not identify Margaret as a resident or daughter. The later landing name need not refer to a second living Thomas.",
          "assessment": "The landholder is well identified; the parent-child connection remains indirect.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BROAD_CREEK_LEWIS",
            "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "English Lewis derives from a personal name related to Louis, with older Germanic elements meaning fame and battle. Welsh Lewis can represent Llywelyn.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_LEWIS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Lewis also has distinct Irish and other origins. The surname therefore cannot decide whether this Maryland family came from England, Wales or elsewhere.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_LEWIS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The will abstract names wife Catharine and sons Richard, Thomas and John, who received adjoining parcels.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_THOMAS_LEWIS_WILL1696"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_WILLIAM_AARON_LUSBY1796",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_AARON_LUSBY1796",
      "surname": "Lusby",
      "locality": "Clark County, Kentucky",
      "research_limit": "The compiled pedigree names William Lusby Sr. and Easter Hair as parents. A local probate index confirms an older William Lusby’s estate in 1815, but its brief entry does not identify the executors as his children. The original will remains the key record for assessing the proposed generation.",
      "notes": "The connection from this person to Sarah Lusby McNew is represented as a low-confidence candidate relationship.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_AARON_LUSBY1796_PROFILE",
        "ROOTS26_CLARK_LUSBY_PROBATE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "William Lusby’s estate and two executors",
          "record_date": "25 December 1815",
          "locality": "Clark County, Kentucky",
          "historical_detail": "The court index records probate of William Lusby’s will and names John and William Lusby as executors on 25 December 1815 (Order Book 5, page 300).",
          "association": "The place, date and executor names fit the older William and sons reported in the compiled pedigree.",
          "alternatives": "Executors may be other relatives or trusted associates; the index does not state their relationships.",
          "assessment": "This is a concrete local record supporting the proposed family setting. It does not alone establish that the executor William was Sarah’s proposed father.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CLARK_LUSBY_PROBATE",
            "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_AARON_LUSBY1796_PROFILE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Lusby derives from a Lincolnshire place-name formed from the Old Norse personal name Lútr and a word for farmstead or settlement.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_LUSBY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname points to Lusby in Lincolnshire; this Kentucky branch’s English birthplace has not been established.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_LUSBY"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The relevant American setting is Clark County, Kentucky, where the probate index records the Lusby household in 1815.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CLARK_LUSBY_PROBATE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_NANCY_HAZELRIGG1796",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_NANCY_HAZELRIGG1796",
      "surname": "Hazelrigg",
      "locality": "Clark County, Kentucky",
      "research_limit": "Nancy’s reported parents are William Hazelrigg and Sarah Knox. A Clark County estate index identifies a deceased William and widow Sarah in 1821, but does not name Nancy. Their estate and land divisions offer a way to assess the parentage claim; the indexed omission is not evidence that Nancy was unrelated.",
      "notes": "The connection from this person to Sarah Lusby McNew is represented as a low-confidence candidate relationship.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NANCY_HAZELRIGG1796_PROFILE",
        "ROOTS26_CLARK_HAZELRIGG_PROBATE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "William Hazelrigg’s widow Sarah administers his estate",
          "record_date": "26 February 1821",
          "locality": "Clark County, Kentucky",
          "historical_detail": "Sarah Hazelrigg received administration of William’s estate on 26 February 1821 (Order Book 6, page 239). The index also records her widow’s dower on 24 December (page 305).",
          "association": "The widow’s name, county and date agree with the household proposed as Nancy’s parents.",
          "alternatives": "Another William Hazelrigg estate was administered in 1805. The two deceased men must be kept distinct; the 1821 index does not identify Sarah’s birth surname.",
          "assessment": "The 1821 household is the better match to the compiled parent claim. Nancy’s place among its heirs still needs to be assessed from the estate or deeds.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CLARK_HAZELRIGG_PROBATE",
            "ROOTS26_NANCY_HAZELRIGG1796_PROFILE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Hazelrigg is an English place-derived surname meaning a ridge associated with hazel trees.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_HAZELRIGG"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Places named Hazelrigg occur in Lancashire, Cumberland and Northumberland. No one of these has been established as Nancy’s family’s English home.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DAFN_HAZELRIGG"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Clark County records use both Hazelrigg and Hazlerigg. Several estates carry these spellings, so dates and named relatives are needed to distinguish the households.",
          "caveat": null,
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CLARK_HAZELRIGG_PROBATE"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_JOHAN_STALCOP",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_JOHAN_STALCOP",
      "surname": "Stalcop / Stålkofta",
      "locality": "Strängnäs, Södermanland; New Sweden",
      "research_limit": "The reviewed Stalcop family sheet leaves Johan’s parents unidentified. An online pedigree assigns Anders Andriessen and Christina Coolbrant, but the documented son of that couple is John Andersson Cock, husband of Catharina, associated with Deer Point. Johan Stalcop’s wife was Christina Carlsdotter. Confusion between these two men better explains the proposed extension than a demonstrated parent link.",
      "notes": "A Swedish record identifying Johan’s family before his 1641 departure would be needed to distinguish an actual parent from someone inferred solely from Andersson.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_STALCOP_SHEETS",
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_1693_CH5",
        "ROOTS26_NEWCASTLE_DEERPOINT_1680",
        "ROOTS26_STALCOP_ONLINE_PARENT_CLAIM"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Two John Anderssons in the Delaware records",
          "record_date": "1673–1680",
          "locality": "Deer Point, Delaware",
          "historical_detail": "A court transcription records land given to Jan Andriess by his parents Andries Andriess and Cristina Goolbrant in 1673, then transferred to Arnold deLagrange.",
          "association": "This is a real parent-naming record behind the proposed extension.",
          "alternatives": "Craig identifies the landholder as John Andersson Cock, a different household from Stalcop.",
          "assessment": "The shared name alone does not overcome the contrasting spouse, property sequence and Cock’s records after Stalcop’s death; these parents are not currently linked to Stalcop.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NEWCASTLE_DEERPOINT_1680",
            "ROOTS26_CRAIG_1693_CH5"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Stålkofta means steel coat. The later Stalcop spelling developed through Dutch Staelcop; a breastplate is a suggested explanation for the nickname.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_STALLCUP_1991"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The published account traces Johan from Strängnäs to New Sweden in 1641. This branch’s inherited Stalcop name developed in America.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_STALLCUP_1991"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Johan served as a gunner at Fort Trinity in 1655. His military nickname became a family name in several spellings, including Stallcop and Stalcup.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_STALLCUP_1991"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_SAMUEL_PETERSSON",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_SAMUEL_PETERSSON",
      "surname": "Petersson / Peterson",
      "locality": "Fryksände, Värmland; Christina, Delaware",
      "research_limit": "Craig’s reconstruction identifies Samuel’s Swedish parish and American household but supplies no identifiable parent couple. The reviewed origin references have not established an earlier Fryksände family for him.",
      "notes": "Fryksände is a reported place of origin, not an inspected baptismal birthplace. No birth year or named father has been inferred from the patronymic.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Two Samuel Peterssons aboard the Eagle",
          "record_date": "1654–1675",
          "locality": "Fryksände and Bogen; Delaware",
          "historical_detail": "Craig distinguishes two 1654 immigrants: one from Fryksände and one from Bogen in Gunnarskog parish.",
          "association": "The Fryksände man’s distinctive mark recurs in the 1654 and 1655 oaths and a 1675 church letter.",
          "alternatives": "The Bogen man is a documented namesake, not an invented possibility.",
          "assessment": "The recurring mark supports continuity for the Christina settler. It does not identify his parents or prove kinship with the Bogen man.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Petersson is a Swedish patronymic meaning son of Peter; Peterson is a variant spelling.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ISOF_PATRONYMIC"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Craig identifies this settler as a Finn from Fryksände in Värmland, arriving on the Eagle in 1654.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "His identity belongs to the Swedish and Finnish settlement around Christina. It must be distinguished from another Samuel Petersson on the same voyage.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_CARL_JONSSON",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_CARL_JONSSON",
      "surname": "Jönsson / Johnson",
      "locality": "Letstigen region, Sweden; Marcus Hook, Delaware River",
      "research_limit": "The reviewed passenger-family account identifies Carl’s migrating household but not his parents, his wife’s name or a specific Swedish farm. Letstigen describes a region along a road rather than a uniquely identified family residence.",
      "notes": "His daughter Christina’s parentage is represented separately. The published 1655 passenger context provides an earlier local association, but no demonstrated connection to a previous generation.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_MERCURIUS_2006",
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_STALCOP_SHEETS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Another Jönsson household from Letstigen",
          "record_date": "1655–1656",
          "locality": "Letstigen; Mercurius voyage",
          "historical_detail": "The passenger reconstruction separately lists Jöns Jönsson with a wife and six children, alongside Carl’s household.",
          "association": "A common locality and voyage make shared community connections plausible.",
          "alternatives": "Jönsson is patronymic; the families could have unrelated fathers named Jöns. The roster does not call these men brothers.",
          "assessment": "This is useful migration context, not enough to assign a shared father or another biological link.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MERCURIUS_2006"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Jönsson means son of Jöns in Swedish patronymic usage. The family sheet renders Carl’s name as Johnson.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ISOF_PATRONYMIC",
            "ROOTS26_CRAIG_STALCOP_SHEETS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Carl’s family is placed among the Finns from the Letstigen region who emigrated on the Mercurius in 1655–1656.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MERCURIUS_2006"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The passenger reconstruction records Carl with a wife, three children and a maid. His later home was Marcus Hook.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MERCURIUS_2006"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_JONS_ANDERSSON_SMITH",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_JONS_ANDERSSON_SMITH",
      "surname": "Andersson",
      "locality": "Fort Christina, Delaware; earlier locality unresolved",
      "research_limit": "The inspected account identifies Jöns as a blacksmith and Brita’s father, but does not identify his parents or a Swedish home parish. His occupation and wife Maria distinguish this household from other Anderssons.",
      "notes": "Andersson gives a naming clue but does not identify a particular man named Anders. No earlier family has been assigned from the surname alone.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007",
        "ROOTS26_ISOF_PATRONYMIC"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Jöns and Maria’s joint testimony",
          "record_date": "7 March 1660",
          "locality": "Fort Christina area",
          "historical_detail": "Craig reports an affidavit by Jöns and his wife Maria concerning the sale of liquor by Hans Juriansen Becker.",
          "association": "The named couple provides a specific household reference for this branch.",
          "alternatives": "A shared Andersson surname does not make Johan Stalcop a relative; the two men had different wives and occupations.",
          "assessment": "The affidavit supports the couple’s identity but supplies no parentage or earlier Swedish locality.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Andersson means son of Anders under Swedish patronymic naming.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ISOF_PATRONYMIC"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The published account places Jöns and Maria on the Eagle in 1654. It does not establish their earlier home parish.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The distinguishing family context is the Christina blacksmith’s household, rather than the separate Stalcop gunner’s family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007",
            "ROOTS26_STALLCUP_1991"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_MARIA_WIFE_JONS",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_MARIA_WIFE_JONS",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Fort Christina, Delaware; earlier locality unresolved",
      "research_limit": "Maria is identified as Jöns Andersson’s wife in the reviewed immigration and affidavit accounts. Neither gives her natal surname or parents. Her proposed maternity of Brita is an inference from that marriage, shown as a separate tentative link.",
      "notes": "No surname meaning or birth-family origin can responsibly be assigned to Maria. Andersson belongs to her husband’s naming history. The surviving references examined here identify her through their household, not through an earlier family.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "A named woman in the 1660 affidavit",
          "record_date": "7 March 1660",
          "locality": "Fort Christina area",
          "historical_detail": "The reported affidavit names Maria together with her husband Jöns.",
          "association": "This places the candidate mother in a documented married household.",
          "alternatives": "Brita could have been born to an earlier wife; the inspected account does not explicitly name her mother.",
          "assessment": "Maria remains the leading identifiable candidate, with that maternal uncertainty preserved. No earlier family is attached.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Maria, wife of Jöns Andersson without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Maria, wife of Jöns Andersson. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Maria, wife of Jöns Andersson without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_PETTER_SMIDT",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_PETTER_SMIDT",
      "surname": "Smidt / Schmidt",
      "locality": "Falun, Dalarna, Sweden (reported household)",
      "research_limit": "Petter is the leading named father candidate for Hans. The family profiles identify his wife and two children but do not name his parents. The precise Falun baptism citation has not yet been checked against the register image.",
      "notes": "The compilation reports a German birth before 1667 and death before 15 March 1720. Neither supplies an identified German parish. These reported limits have not been converted into exact vital dates.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_PETTER_SMIDT",
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BAPTISM_LOCATOR"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Inheritance arrangements before the Atlantic crossing",
          "record_date": "15 March 1720",
          "locality": "Falun, Sweden",
          "historical_detail": "A published family biography reports that Hans assigned prospective inheritances to his sister Magdalena before leaving Sweden. Their father had died; their mother was living.",
          "association": "The named sister also appears with Hans in Petter’s compiled household.",
          "alternatives": "The accounts may derive from the same family research. A misidentified or inaccurately summarized inheritance document remains possible.",
          "assessment": "This is a useful family connection to test in the Falun estate records, but the original document has not been inspected and it names no earlier generation in the published summary.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_PARENT_CLAIM",
            "ROOTS26_NATHAN_PETTER_SMIDT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Smidt belongs to the smith occupational surname group. The dictionary identifies it as a Dutch Smit variant or an altered German Schmidt.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SMIDT_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_SCHMIDT_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname has both Dutch and German explanations. Petter’s reported German origin remains less securely established than his son’s Falun birthplace, explicitly recorded in the Delaware burial transcript.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_SMIDT_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_NATHAN_PETTER_SMIDT",
            "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BURIAL_1753"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "In this branch the occupational surname coexists with a different recorded trade: Hans was a hatmaker. His surname does not establish Petter’s occupation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BURIAL_1753",
            "ROOTS26_SCHMIDT_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_MAGDALENA_HUWALT",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_MAGDALENA_HUWALT",
      "surname": "Huwalt (reported)",
      "locality": "Falun, Dalarna, Sweden (reported household)",
      "research_limit": "Magdalena is the leading named mother candidate for Hans. Her own compiled profile supplies no parents or birthplace. Huwalt and the patronymic Hindrichsdotter have not yet been verified in the cited parish image.",
      "notes": "Searches under Huwalt, Huwald and Hufwaldt with Falun and her given name have not identified an earlier local household that can be linked to her. The available surname pages did not supply a reliable historical derivation for this spelling.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_NATHAN_MAGDALENA_HUWALT",
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_PARENT_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BAPTISM_LOCATOR"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Magdalena Hindrichsdotter Huwalt (reported): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Falun, Dalarna, Sweden (reported household)",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Magdalena is the leading named mother candidate for Hans. Her own compiled profile supplies no parents or birthplace. Huwalt and the patronymic Hindrichsdotter have not yet been verified in the cited parish image. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NATHAN_MAGDALENA_HUWALT",
            "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_PARENT_CLAIM",
            "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BAPTISM_LOCATOR"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Hindrichsdotter is a Swedish patronymic, indicating a father named Hindrich. It does not identify a particular father. The separate reported surname Huwalt remains unexplained.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ISOF_PATRONYMIC",
            "ROOTS26_NATHAN_MAGDALENA_HUWALT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Falun is the reported family setting, not an established birthplace for Magdalena. Her husband’s reported German origin does not establish hers.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NATHAN_MAGDALENA_HUWALT",
            "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_PARENT_CLAIM",
            "ROOTS26_NATHAN_PETTER_SMIDT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The identifiable family context is the Smidt household, with children Hans and Magdalena. No earlier Huwalt family or common historical association has yet been established for this branch.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NATHAN_MAGDALENA_HUWALT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_OLIVE_FURNISS_SOMERSET",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_OLIVE_FURNISS_SOMERSET",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Somerset County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "Olive is named as Rosannah’s mother and William Furniss’s wife. Her later marriage to John Strawbridge is documented. Her birth surname and parents remain unresolved; Ivery and Honora in online pedigrees are not established by these records.",
      "notes": "Research into the nearby Barre household found an older Olive with children recorded as Leene and Ivery. That naming history offers competing explanations for a possible connection, but no inspected record identifies William’s wife as one of those children.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LANKFORD_FURNISS",
        "ROOTS26_OLIVE_STRAWBRIDGE_1689",
        "ROOTS26_OLIVE_EATON_RECONSTRUCTION"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Olive’s remarriage appears in an estate debt case",
          "record_date": "13 June 1689",
          "locality": "Manokin and Somerset County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "John Strawbridge answered a claim against William Furnish’s estate as administrator through his marriage to Olive, William’s widow and administratrix.",
          "association": "This explains Strawbridge as a later married name in Olive’s history.",
          "alternatives": "Treating Strawbridge as her birth surname would misread the relationship stated in the court record.",
          "assessment": "The manuscript establishes the marriage sequence and William’s prior death, but supplies neither Olive’s parents nor her original surname.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_OLIVE_STRAWBRIDGE_1689"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Olive, wife of William Furniss (parent candidate) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Olive, wife of William Furniss (parent candidate). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Olive, wife of William Furniss (parent candidate) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_THOMAS_FURNIS_KNEESALL",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_FURNIS_KNEESALL",
      "surname": "Furnis / Furniss",
      "locality": "Kneesall, Nottinghamshire, England (reported)",
      "research_limit": "Thomas is a tentative English father candidate for the Maryland William. The proposed earlier Thomas and Isabell pedigree mixes incompatible dates: a 1638 marriage is attached above a son reportedly born in 1600. Those entries have not yet been separated into identifiable generations.",
      "notes": "Kneesall’s parish register inventory begins in 1682, but bishop’s transcripts are reported from 1600. The claimed 1632 baptism therefore remains a record to examine, rather than being disproved by the later register start. Searches of indexed Kneesall surname and archive references have not yet identified an earlier Furnis household securely connected to this Thomas.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_FURNIS_KNEESALL_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_KNEESALL_CONFLICTING_PEDIGREES",
        "ROOTS26_KNEESALL_REGISTERS",
        "ROOTS26_KNEESALL_BT_GUIDE"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Thomas Furnis (English parent candidate): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Kneesall, Nottinghamshire, England (reported)",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Thomas is a tentative English father candidate for the Maryland William. The proposed earlier Thomas and Isabell pedigree mixes incompatible dates: a 1638 marriage is attached above a son reportedly born in 1600. Those entries have not yet been separated into identifiable generations. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FURNIS_KNEESALL_CLAIM",
            "ROOTS26_KNEESALL_CONFLICTING_PEDIGREES",
            "ROOTS26_KNEESALL_REGISTERS",
            "ROOTS26_KNEESALL_BT_GUIDE"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Furnis belongs to the English Furness surname group. Its principal explanation is a name taken from the Furness district; the place-name includes the Old Norse term for a headland.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FURNESS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNIS_FS"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The general Furness origin lies in present-day Cumbria, formerly Lancashire. Kneesall is the reported setting of this candidate household, not evidence that Thomas himself came from Cumbria.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FURNESS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_FURNIS_KNEESALL_CLAIM"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The surname also overlaps with Furneaux in some English records. That alternative formation does not identify this family with a particular Norman lineage.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FURNESS_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_ANNE_FURNIS_KNEESALL",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_ANNE_FURNIS_KNEESALL",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Kneesall, Nottinghamshire, England (reported)",
      "research_limit": "The cited baptism source titles identify Ann or Anne as William’s mother. They do not establish her birth surname. Compiled pedigrees call her Robberds or Inman, and the records examined do not distinguish those alternatives.",
      "notes": "The proposed Robberds parentage depends on accepting that surname first. Searches combining the competing names with Kneesall and Thomas Furnis returned assembled pedigrees rather than a marriage identifying this Anne. No surname meaning or earlier birth-family association is assigned while that identity remains unresolved.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_ANNE_FURNIS_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_KNEESALL_CONFLICTING_PEDIGREES",
        "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNIS_FS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Anne, reported mother of William Furnis: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Kneesall, Nottinghamshire, England (reported)",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The cited baptism source titles identify Ann or Anne as William’s mother. They do not establish her birth surname. Compiled pedigrees call her Robberds or Inman, and the records examined do not distinguish those alternatives. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ANNE_FURNIS_CLAIM",
            "ROOTS26_KNEESALL_CONFLICTING_PEDIGREES",
            "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNIS_FS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Anne, reported mother of William Furnis without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Anne, reported mother of William Furnis. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Anne, reported mother of William Furnis without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_GEORGE_ROBINSON_WEDGEBURG",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_GEORGE_ROBINSON_WEDGEBURG",
      "surname": "Robinson",
      "locality": "Christiana Hundred, New Castle County, Delaware",
      "research_limit": "George is identified with the early Wedgeburg household. His parents and precise place of origin remain unestablished.",
      "notes": "George reportedly bought 500 acres called Wedgeburg from William Guest. The proposed link to James rests on the surviving family group. Cope disputed which younger George belonged to it; the underlying land records remain to be compared.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_STANDING_ROBINSON"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "George Robinson of Wedgeburg (parent candidate): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Christiana Hundred, New Castle County, Delaware",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: George is identified with the early Wedgeburg household. His parents and precise place of origin remain unestablished. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_STANDING_ROBINSON"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Robinson means son of Robin, a familiar form of Robert.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ROBINSON_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary associates the English formation particularly with Lancashire and Yorkshire. That regional background does not locate this New Castle family’s birthplace.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ROBINSON_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The name belongs to a widespread group of surnames formed from a father’s given name. Different Robinson families can therefore share the name without sharing a recent ancestor.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_ROBINSON_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_ANN_WIFE_GEORGE_ROBINSON",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_ANN_WIFE_GEORGE_ROBINSON",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Christiana Hundred, New Castle County, Delaware",
      "research_limit": "Ann is reported as George’s surviving wife, but her birth surname is unresolved.",
      "notes": "The Curtis identification is not secured by the sources examined. One compiled profile combines the Robinson marriage with a narrative about an Ann Curtis married to Haslewood, Gill and Blacksfeil. Those may be different women or an incorrectly assembled remarriage history. Without a record connecting that woman to George, her Curtis parents cannot be assigned here.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_STANDING_ROBINSON",
        "ROOTS26_ANN_CURTIS_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ann, wife of George Robinson (parent candidate): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Christiana Hundred, New Castle County, Delaware",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Ann is reported as George’s surviving wife, but her birth surname is unresolved. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_STANDING_ROBINSON",
            "ROOTS26_ANN_CURTIS_CONFLICT"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Ann, wife of George Robinson (parent candidate) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Ann, wife of George Robinson (parent candidate). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Ann, wife of George Robinson (parent candidate) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_THOMAS_HOWELL_COOPERS_CREEK",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_HOWELL_COOPERS_CREEK",
      "surname": "Howell",
      "locality": "England; Cooper’s Creek, West New Jersey; Philadelphia",
      "research_limit": "Thomas’s estate records connect him to Cooper’s Creek and property at Tamworth, but his parents and baptism remain unidentified.",
      "notes": "Leach describes him as of Haxleston in Staffordshire when acquiring West Jersey land. The later division of his estate names Tamworth property, giving a stronger English search area than surname distribution. The material examined supplies no parent-naming record. A local Howell household could be related, but no particular earlier household can yet be ranked from these documents.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "The Howell estate across the Atlantic",
          "record_date": "8 Mar 1687/88",
          "locality": "Cooper’s Creek, West New Jersey; Tamworth, England",
          "historical_detail": "An agreement between Daniel and Mordecai Howell concerns their deceased father Thomas’s American land and inherited interests at Tamworth. It also provides for their mother and sisters.",
          "association": "The named family and estate connect the New Jersey settler with a specific English property interest.",
          "alternatives": "Property ownership at Tamworth does not establish birth there; an owner could have acquired it through marriage or purchase.",
          "assessment": "This is a documented route toward English records, not a bridge to an unidentified older Howell pedigree.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Howell commonly represents the Welsh personal name Hywel, meaning eminent. The dictionary also allows Breton and English personal-name origins.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HOWELL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The Welsh formation is associated with the border counties. A separate English formation comes from Howell in Lincolnshire. Thomas’s documented English property must guide the choice between these origins.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HOWELL_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The popularity of Hywel was encouraged by the medieval Welsh lawgiver. This explains a naming tradition, not descent from that king or another notable Howell family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HOWELL_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_KATHARINE_HOWELL_WIDOW1695",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_KATHARINE_HOWELL_WIDOW1695",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "England; Cooper’s Creek, West New Jersey; Philadelphia",
      "research_limit": "Katharine’s 1695 will identifies her children and late husband Thomas Howell, but not her parents or birth surname.",
      "notes": "Her husband’s will left household goods available if she came to America. By 1695 she described herself as a Philadelphia widow. Leach explicitly leaves her maiden name unknown. The family’s English property and her named children provide leads, but do not identify her natal family; Howell surname history belongs to her husband’s branch.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "A Philadelphia widow’s bequests",
          "record_date": "17 Aug 1695; proved 4 Oct 1695",
          "locality": "Philadelphia, Pennsylvania",
          "historical_detail": "Katharine’s will names sons Daniel and Mordecai, daughter Miriam Johnson and daughter Katharine Robinson, wife of James. It also names grandchildren and appoints James executor.",
          "association": "The daughter’s name and husband support identification with the New Castle Robinson household.",
          "alternatives": "The will does not name the widow’s own parents or establish her birth surname.",
          "assessment": "The published transcription provides a substantial family group; the original is cited as Philadelphia Wills A,324.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Katharine, widow of Thomas Howell without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Katharine, widow of Thomas Howell. The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Katharine, widow of Thomas Howell without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_ELIZABETH_WRENCH_COUNTISS",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_ELIZABETH_WRENCH_COUNTISS",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Reported Maryland family; exact locality unresolved",
      "research_limit": "The Countiss chart names Elizabeth Wrench as William’s wife and places Henry, born 1777, among their children. It gives no parents for Elizabeth and does not establish whether Wrench was her birth surname.",
      "notes": "A Queen Anne’s County will supplies a concrete identity to investigate: Richard Costin’s will of 21 October 1760 names a daughter Elizabeth Wrench. She may be the later Countiss wife, a relative, or a different woman. Matching the name and region supports comparison, but no marriage or estate sequence yet connects the women. Costin is not assigned as her father, and Wrench surname history cannot yet be attributed to her birth family.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_COSTIN_WRENCH1760"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Elizabeth Wrench (birth surname unresolved): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Reported Maryland family; exact locality unresolved",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The Countiss chart names Elizabeth Wrench as William’s wife and places Henry, born 1777, among their children. It gives no parents for Elizabeth and does not establish whether Wrench was her birth surname. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
            "ROOTS26_COSTIN_WRENCH1760"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Elizabeth Wrench (birth surname unresolved) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Elizabeth Wrench (birth surname unresolved). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Elizabeth Wrench (birth surname unresolved) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_REBECCA_WIFE_PETER_COUNTISS",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_REBECCA_WIFE_PETER_COUNTISS",
      "surname": "Name unresolved",
      "locality": "Reported Queen Anne’s County, Maryland family",
      "research_limit": "Rebecca is the reported wife of Peter Countiss and mother of William in the family chart. Peter’s 1746 will leaves a share to his wife but does not give her name. No birth surname or parents have been established.",
      "notes": "The probate index places Rebecca Countiss and Peter Countiss on the same 1746 folio. This supports investigating them as a couple, but the index assigns Rebecca to Queen Anne’s County and Peter to Charles County. Peter’s will explicitly identifies him with Queen Anne’s County. The underlying proceeding is needed to resolve the discrepancy and Rebecca’s role. A later wife could also differ from William’s mother.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_WILL1746",
        "ROOTS26_COUNTISS_PROCEEDINGS_INDEX1746"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Rebecca (wife of Peter Countiss; surname unknown): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Reported Queen Anne’s County, Maryland family",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Rebecca is the reported wife of Peter Countiss and mother of William in the family chart. Peter’s 1746 will leaves a share to his wife but does not give her name. No birth surname or parents have been established. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
            "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_WILL1746",
            "ROOTS26_COUNTISS_PROCEEDINGS_INDEX1746"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The reviewed tree records Rebecca (wife of Peter Countiss; surname unknown) without an established birth surname. No surname etymology can be assigned from the available evidence; the existing branch limit is retained as the identity-specific research result.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "No surname or locality in the reviewed records identifies an origin for Rebecca (wife of Peter Countiss; surname unknown). The existing branch limit and its cited sources define the next research route; no geographic continuity is inferred.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "No earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to Rebecca (wife of Peter Countiss; surname unknown) without a surname and identity-specific locality. The endpoint’s existing research limit is preserved rather than supplemented with a generic namesake.",
          "caveat": "The tree does not establish a birth surname; assigning one would invent data.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731",
      "surname": "Countiss / Countess",
      "locality": "Queen Anne’s County, Maryland",
      "research_limit": "James’s will, written on 29 December 1731 and proved on 4 May 1732, names his children but neither parent. It establishes an earlier local household; it does not identify an immigrant ancestor or an English birthplace. His exact death date falls between those two dates.",
      "notes": "The will names Peter, James and William as sons, and Catharine, Rachel, Hannah and Sarah as daughters. This distinctive group matches the compiled chart and supports its identification of Peter’s father. Peter’s later will refers to land bought by his unnamed father from Robert Smith; that purchase has not yet been matched to James. The identity of Henry Countiss in Virginia remains a separate, less certain connection farther down the proposed line.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731",
        "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_WILL1746"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "The Countiss household in James’s will",
          "record_date": "29 December 1731; proved 4 May 1732",
          "locality": "Queen Anne’s County, Maryland",
          "historical_detail": "James’s will identifies seven children and leaves twenty shillings to Rebekah Vanderford, without stating her relationship. His wife is unnamed. Sons James and William share the tract Dublin; Peter receives the dwelling plantation.",
          "association": "The named children closely match the family chart, providing independent support for this earlier Countiss household and its proposed connection to Peter, who died in 1746.",
          "alternatives": "Rebekah could be another daughter, a different relative or an unrelated beneficiary. Peter’s identification could still be mistaken if the chart has combined relatives; his own will does not name his father.",
          "assessment": "The distinctive sibling group makes the chart’s family identification the leading explanation. Rebekah is retained as a beneficiary of unstated relationship, and no earlier generation is inferred from the surname alone.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731",
            "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
            "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_WILL1746"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Countiss is a variant of Countess, an English surname derived from the title as a nickname or a reference to service in a countess’s household. It does not establish noble descent.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_COUNTISS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_COUNTESS_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The surname dictionary associates Countess with Nottinghamshire and Norman linguistic influence. James’s Maryland will supplies no evidence for a particular English place of origin.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_COUNTESS_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "James’s family held land in Queen Anne’s County. His will divided the 300-acre tract Dublin between sons James and William and left his dwelling plantation to Peter, subject to his wife’s lifetime interest.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_MARY_GREENE_COUNTISS",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_MARY_GREENE_COUNTISS",
      "surname": "Greene / Green (reported)",
      "locality": "Reported Queen Anne’s County, Maryland family",
      "research_limit": "The Countiss chart names Mary Greene as James’s wife and the mother of his children. His 1731 will confirms a living wife but leaves her unnamed. No independent record reviewed here identifies her parents or confirms Greene as her birth surname.",
      "notes": "The matching children in James’s will support the chart’s household reconstruction, but do not independently confirm Mary’s identity. The reported wife could be correctly named, misnamed, or distinct from a later wife. No specific earlier Green household can yet be ranked as hers without a record connecting Mary to James or to a named relative.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
        "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary Greene (reported name): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Reported Queen Anne’s County, Maryland family",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The Countiss chart names Mary Greene as James’s wife and the mother of his children. His 1731 will confirms a living wife but leaves her unnamed. No independent record reviewed here identifies her parents or confirms Greene as her birth surname. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
            "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "For the reported Green name, English explanations include residence near a village green or a nickname associated with the colour green, youth or festive dress. Greene is a variant spelling.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GREEN",
            "ROOTS26_GREENE_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Green arose independently in several settings in Britain and Ireland, and also represents some continental European surnames in America. These general origins cannot identify Mary’s birthplace.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GREEN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Mary’s proposed local association is the Countiss household in Queen Anne’s County. The only contemporary wife mentioned in the reviewed will is unnamed, so assigning a particular Green family would go beyond the present evidence.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
            "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_SENIOR",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_SENIOR",
      "surname": "Henderson",
      "locality": "Washington County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "William’s parents are unidentified. His proposed earlier household has not been securely connected to the later family.",
      "notes": "The cataloged marriage and will volumes survive. Their individual entries have not yet been checked against the original images; the stopping point reflects unresolved identity, not established record loss.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA",
        "ROOTS26_WASHINGTON_VA_RECORD_CATALOG"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "record_date": "1810",
          "locality": "Washington County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "association": "This is an earlier local Henderson presence that could belong to William’s wider family.",
          "alternatives": "John could be an unrelated Henderson living in the same county; no household or property connection to William has been established.",
          "assessment": "A useful local association, with no genealogical relationship assigned from it. The original bond has not been inspected.",
          "source_ids": []
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Henderson generally means son of Henry, sometimes through the shortened name Hen. The d developed within the surname.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HENDERSON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name developed in both English and Scottish usage.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HENDERSON"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "In Scotland, Henderson sometimes replaced McKendrick. William’s Virginia records do not identify a Scottish birthplace or a particular clan.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HENDERSON"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_LIDDY_MARKLAND",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_LIDDY_MARKLAND",
      "surname": "Donnally (reported)",
      "locality": "Washington County, Virginia",
      "research_limit": "Liddy’s parents and birth surname remain unverified. Donnally is a compiler’s attribution without a separate supporting citation.",
      "notes": "No earlier Donnally household has been identified for her. The family-name background below is conditional on that attribution; Markland is her married name. Will Book 4, page112, is the specific surviving record reference for further identification.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA",
        "ROOTS26_WASHINGTON_VA_RECORD_CATALOG"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Liddy (Lydia) Markland (reported Donnally): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Washington County, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Liddy’s parents and birth surname remain unverified. Donnally is a compiler’s attribution without a separate supporting citation. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA",
            "ROOTS26_WASHINGTON_VA_RECORD_CATALOG"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Donnally is an Irish spelling of Donnelly, derived from Ó Donnghaile, descendant of Donnghal. The personal name combines an element interpreted as brown-haired man or chieftain with valor.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DONNALLY_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_DONNELLY_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary describes Irish families in Donegal, Sligo and Cork. None of those counties has been established as Liddy’s place of origin.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DONNALLY_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_DONNELLY_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "A traditional O’Neill descent is reported for many Donegal bearers. It is surname history, not a documented connection for this Virginia family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_DONNALLY_DAFN",
            "ROOTS26_DONNELLY_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_JOHN_WILLIS_NANCY_CANDIDATE",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_JOHN_WILLIS_NANCY_CANDIDATE",
      "surname": "Willis",
      "locality": "Reported Pennsylvania and Henry/Franklin County, Virginia connection",
      "research_limit": "The compilation proposes Henry Willis and Mary Underwood as John’s parents. Those earlier identities and the Pennsylvania-to-Virginia connection still require review; this is the current research boundary, not a finding that earlier records are absent.",
      "notes": "Nancy’s parentage rests on a specific compiled family claim. The two Lavinder–Willis marriages and Fanny’s conflicting birth estimates remain separate uncertainties in the descendant chain.",
      "source_ids": [
        "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
        "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John and Isaiah Willis in a land dispute",
          "record_date": "1784–1787",
          "locality": "Henry County and Greenbrier, Virginia",
          "historical_detail": "John Willis’s complaint against John Hartwell concerns a land bargain and a horse received in part payment. John says he moved to Greenbrier. Isaiah Willis joined his injunction bond on 27 October 1784 and a Thomas Miller bond on 3 June 1785.",
          "association": "The migration and named associate fit the John Willis described in the proposed family history.",
          "alternatives": "The identification may be correct while the later attachment of Nancy to this household is mistaken. The bonds do not state how John and Isaiah were related.",
          "assessment": "The original papers support the regional identity and personal history. They do not establish John’s fatherhood of Nancy or identify his wife.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_WILLIS_HARTWELL_1787"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Willis usually comes from Will with a possessive ending; its second syllable preserves the pronunciation of medieval -es.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NANCY_WILLIS_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The dictionary identifies this as an English surname. Some Willis names instead developed from Willey or Willows.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_NANCY_WILLIS_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The proposed branch belongs to the Pennsylvania Quaker and Virginia Willis families described in the compilation. That association depends on the family identifications; the surname itself does not distinguish this branch from other Willis households.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_EDWARD_BENNETT_THORNBURY",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_EDWARD_BENNETT_THORNBURY",
      "surname": "Bennett",
      "locality": "Thornbury, Chester County, Pennsylvania; reported English family",
      "research_limit": "The published Bible transcription names Edward’s parents as John and Margery Bennett. Their English identities and the connection between the Bible and the immigrant household still require review; the current boundary reflects unfinished research.",
      "notes": "The history traces the Bible through Edward’s 1714 will and later descendants, giving the early entries a stated family provenance.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Bennett family Bible entries, 1626–1665",
          "record_date": "1626–1665",
          "locality": "English family; specific parish unresolved in these entries",
          "historical_detail": "The county history transcribes births, baptisms and a marriage from a family Bible, including John, son of Edward and Alis, baptized in 1626, and Edward, son of John and Margery, baptized in 1659.",
          "association": "The authors connect the Bible to the immigrant Edward through its later ownership and his will.",
          "alternatives": "The family provenance could be accurate while an individual date or identity in the nineteenth-century transcription is mistaken.",
          "assessment": "This is a specific earlier family record lead. Its original entries and associated parish records remain to be compared before the older generations are added.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The English surname derives from Benedict, meaning blessed.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PHEBE_BENNETT_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Medieval English forms reflect French Beneit and Benoit; other German and altered French origins also occur.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_PHEBE_BENNETT_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The proposed branch has a specific family Bible tradition described in the 1881 county history. That provenance matters more to this branch than the surname’s general distribution.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_SARAH_STANFIELD_BENNETT",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_SARAH_STANFIELD_BENNETT",
      "surname": "Stanfield",
      "locality": "Chester County, Pennsylvania",
      "research_limit": "The county history identifies Sarah’s father as Francis Stanfield. His family and Sarah’s earlier Clues marriage remain to be examined together before this branch is extended.",
      "notes": "Sarah’s five children with Edward are distinguished from his children by Margery Willis. That distinction supports Joseph’s maternal placement.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Sarah Stanfield: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Chester County, Pennsylvania",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The county history identifies Sarah’s father as Francis Stanfield. His family and Sarah’s earlier Clues marriage remain to be examined together before this branch is extended. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The name refers to stony open ground, from words for stone and field.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_STANFIELD_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "It can describe a residence or come from a place called Stanfield, including places in Staffordshire and Norfolk.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_STANFIELD_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The dictionary also records a later County Down association. It does not establish an Irish origin for Sarah’s seventeenth-century family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_STANFIELD_DAFN"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_JOHN_FINCHER_LONDONGROVE",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_JOHN_FINCHER_LONDONGROVE",
      "surname": "Fincher",
      "locality": "Newtown, Uwchlan and London Grove, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
      "research_limit": "The history identifies John’s father as Francis Fincher of Worcester. Francis’s identity and English family remain under review; the surname’s regional distribution cannot settle that relationship.",
      "notes": "John reportedly lived at Newtown in 1699, then Uwchlan, and finally London Grove. His second marriage to Elinor Cook in 1714 must be distinguished from the earlier Martha Taylor household.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John Fincher: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Newtown, Uwchlan and London Grove, Chester County, Pennsylvania",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The history identifies John’s father as Francis Fincher of Worcester. Francis’s identity and English family remain under review; the surname’s regional distribution cannot settle that relationship. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "The modern surname dictionary leaves Fincher’s meaning unexplained.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FINCHER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "It associates the English surname with Buckinghamshire and Worcestershire and reports no examples earlier than about 1500.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_FINCHER_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The county history describes John’s proposed father Francis as coming from Worcester. That specific migration claim remains to be checked against his records.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_MARY_HAYES_TAYLOR",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_MARY_HAYES_TAYLOR",
      "surname": "Hayes (reported)",
      "locality": "Clatterwich / Little Leigh, Cheshire; Springfield, Pennsylvania",
      "research_limit": "Mary is identified in the arrival household and later genealogy, but the reviewed records do not name her parents. Justice calls her a sister of Jonathan Hayes. Robert’s will calls Jonathan his brother, a term compatible with kinship by marriage but insufficient by itself to establish Mary’s parents.",
      "notes": "The family’s Cheshire origin is supported by the named arrival household, rather than inferred from surname distribution.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925",
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_ARRIVALS1881"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Mary Hayes (reported surname): identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Clatterwich / Little Leigh, Cheshire; Springfield, Pennsylvania",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Mary is identified in the arrival household and later genealogy, but the reviewed records do not name her parents. Justice calls her a sister of Jonathan Hayes. Robert’s will calls Jonathan his brother, a term compatible with kinship by marriage but insufficient by itself to establish Mary’s parents. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925",
            "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_ARRIVALS1881"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "If Mary’s reported Hayes surname is correct, English explanations include residence near an enclosure or brushwood.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HAYES_DAFN2022"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Hayes also derives from several place names. The distinct Irish name can mean descendant of Aodh; that explanation does not establish an Irish origin for this Cheshire household.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_HAYES_DAFN2022"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The specific family lead is Jonathan Hayes, identified by Justice as Mary’s brother and named as an executor in Robert’s will.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925",
            "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_ARRIVALS1881"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_MARY_BARROW_TAYLOR",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_MARY_BARROW_TAYLOR",
      "surname": "Barrow / Burrowe",
      "locality": "Davenham and Whitegate, Cheshire",
      "research_limit": "Mary’s 1630 marriage is independently supported by the Whitegate parish transcription, but it supplies no age or father. Three girls baptized in Davenham could fit her: daughters of Ranulphus Barrow in 1609/10, William Barrow in 1611/12 and Thomas Burrows of Bostock in 1613/14. The current evidence does not distinguish their claims to be Thomas Taylor’s wife.",
      "notes": "The first two would have been about twenty and eighteen at the marriage; the third about sixteen. Name, parish and age make all three plausible. Davenham’s original registers are missing for 1625–1665, and the substitute bishops’ transcripts also have gaps. The Chester marriage licence named in the entry may supply an age, relative or bondsman if its underlying papers can be located.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925",
        "ROOTS26_BARROW_DAVENHAM1609_CLAIM",
        "ROOTS26_CPRDB_BARROW_RECORDS",
        "ROOTS26_CPRDB_DAVENHAM_NOTES",
        "ROOTS26_CPRDB_GENERAL_NOTES"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Thomas Burrowes and the Taylor estate inventory",
          "record_date": "10 April 1627",
          "locality": "Clatterwich, Little Leigh, Cheshire",
          "historical_detail": "Justice’s abstract names Thomas Burrowes with Lawrence Taylor and Richard Bancroft as appraisers of John Taylor’s estate.",
          "association": "An associate of Mary’s proposed father-in-law provides a specific local lead for comparison with her Barrow family.",
          "alternatives": "Burrowes may be an unrelated neighbor or appraiser; similar surname forms do not establish either identity or kinship.",
          "assessment": "Useful evidence of a local social connection, but insufficient to name Thomas as Mary’s father or another relative.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
          ]
        },
        {
          "title": "Barrow parish officers at Davenham",
          "record_date": "1602 and 1620",
          "locality": "Davenham, Cheshire",
          "historical_detail": "The parish register notes list Radulphus Barrow among the officers in 1602 and Raphe Barrow among the sworn men in 1620.",
          "association": "These are specific Barrow households in Mary’s reported home parish during the generation before her marriage.",
          "alternatives": "The officers could belong to the proposed father’s household, another related branch, or an unrelated local Barrow family. Similar Latin and English given names alone cannot settle their identities.",
          "assessment": "They establish a local family-history context. Neither entry identifies Mary as a daughter or links the two officers to one another.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CPRDB_DAVENHAM_NOTES"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Barrow can refer to a grove or a mound, through a place name or a description of a residence.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BARROW_DAFN2022"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Places supplying the surname occur in Cheshire and several other English counties. Barrow-in-Furness has a separate place-name explanation.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_BARROW_DAFN2022"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "The marriage transcription spells Mary’s surname Burrowe. Davenham records contain both Barrow and Burrows households, so comparing these spellings is necessary to identify her family.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_CPRDB_BARROW_RECORDS"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_JOHN_TAYLOR_CLATTERWICH",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_JOHN_TAYLOR_CLATTERWICH",
      "surname": "Taylor",
      "locality": "Clatterwich, Little Leigh, Cheshire",
      "research_limit": "The reviewed genealogy reaches John through Great Budworth marriages and a Chester probate record but supplies no identified parents. Its approximate birth year is an estimate. Earlier Taylor names require household or property evidence to connect them to this John.",
      "notes": "John’s will mentions property already assigned and provides for his son Richard and wife Alice. The abstract does not identify John’s own parents.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "John Taylor: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Clatterwich, Little Leigh, Cheshire",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: The reviewed genealogy reaches John through Great Budworth marriages and a Chester probate record but supplies no identified parents. Its approximate birth year is an estimate. Earlier Taylor names require household or property evidence to connect them to this John. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Taylor is an occupational surname for a tailor, derived from Anglo-Norman French.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "The name arose widely in Britain. This household is specifically associated with Clatterwich in Little Leigh and Great Budworth parish.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_DAFN"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "Lawrence Taylor was an appraiser of John’s estate in 1627. The same genealogy lists a son Lawrence, baptized in 1583/84; the name and household context favor that identification, although the inventory abstract does not explicitly call him a son.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS_ROOTS26_ELLEN_MASSEY_TAYLOR",
      "person_id": "ROOTS26_ELLEN_MASSEY_TAYLOR",
      "surname": "Massey",
      "locality": "Great Budworth parish, Cheshire",
      "research_limit": "Ellen is identified through her reported 1586 marriage and the children assigned to that household. The reviewed account supplies neither parents nor a verified birth or burial record. No specific older Massey household has yet been connected to her.",
      "notes": "Ellen’s place in the Taylor household is assessed separately from any claim of descent from a prominent Massey family.",
      "source_ids": [
        "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
      ],
      "mentions": [
        {
          "title": "Ellen Massey: identity-specific historical search limit",
          "record_date": "dates/local chronology unresolved",
          "locality": "Great Budworth parish, Cheshire",
          "historical_detail": "The root research record states: Ellen is identified through her reported 1586 marriage and the children assigned to that household. The reviewed account supplies neither parents nor a verified birth or burial record. No specific older Massey household has yet been connected to her. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person.",
          "association": "This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists.",
          "alternatives": "An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open.",
          "assessment": "The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "surname_background": [
        {
          "topic": "meaning",
          "detail": "Massey can derive from Massy, a familiar form of Matthew.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MASSEY_DAFN2022"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "origins",
          "detail": "Other English Massey families took their name from Norman places including Macey, Massy and Macé-sur-Orne. These are alternative name origins, not a demonstrated birthplace for Ellen.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_MASSEY_DAFN2022"
          ]
        },
        {
          "topic": "associations",
          "detail": "For this branch the specific Cheshire association is Ellen’s marriage at Great Budworth. The shared surname alone cannot select one of the county’s older Massey pedigrees.",
          "caveat": "",
          "source_ids": [
            "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925"
          ]
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "relationship_events": [
    {
      "relationship_id": 1,
      "person1_id": "I76",
      "person2_id": "I77",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "28 Mar 1869",
      "start_place": "Newark, Essex County, New Jersey, United States",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "notes": "P218 M784 Additional Ancestry cemetery details identify the American couple as Henry Albert Fricke and Katharine Schaaf, both buried in Rosedale Cemetery lot 203 Old Section. 1900 census reports 29 years married and an approximate 1871 marriage year; retain direct New Jersey marriage date 28 Mar 1869.",
      "source": "New Jersey Marriages, 1670-1980",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "New Jersey Marriages, 1670-1980",
          "source_type": "marriage record",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "P218 M784"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 2,
      "person1_id": "HV10_GEORG_HEINRICH_FRICKE_1827_1848",
      "person2_id": "HV10_ANNA_DOROTHEE_LEFFLER_ABT1827",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "17 Apr 1842",
      "start_place": "Hannover III, Hannover, Prussia, Germany",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.95,
      "notes": null,
      "source": null,
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "FamilySearch person details: Georg Heinrich Fricke and Anna Dorothee Leffler marriage, 1842, Hannover, Hannover, Preußen, Deutschland",
          "source_type": "FamilySearch transcript",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Confirms spouse Anna Dorothee Leffler, marriage event year 1842, place Hannover, Hannover, Preußen, Deutschland; spouse birthplace Craewikel bei Gotha. Does not include the more precise 17 Apr 1842 date already recorded from local source notes."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 3,
      "person1_id": "HV10_EBERHARD_HEINRICH_FRICKE_ABT1788",
      "person2_id": "HV10_SOPHIE_ELISABETH_ANGENETEN_ABT1795",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "1820",
      "start_place": "Gütersloh, Wiedenbrück, Westfalen, Prussia",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "notes": null,
      "source": null,
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "FamilySearch person details: Eberhard Heinrich Fricke and Sophie Elisabeth Angeneten marriage, 1820, Gütersloh, Wiedenbrück, Westfalen, Preußen, Deutschland",
          "source_type": "FamilySearch transcript",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Source details 2:XM3FK9. Evangelisch marriage record. Eberhard Heinrich Fricke age 32, estimated birth year 1788, previously married; Sophie Elisabeth Angeneten age 25, estimated birth year 1795; additional relatives indicated."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 4,
      "person1_id": "I27",
      "person2_id": "I28",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "notes": "1920 census records Florence Fricke as wife in the household, married, age 28, born Ireland, arrival 1910. This confirms the spouse relationship but does not provide marriage date or place.",
      "source": "1920 United States Census, East Orange, Essex, New Jersey",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "1920 United States Census: Florence Fricke, East Orange Ward 3, ED 38, Essex, New Jersey, United States",
          "source_type": "census transcript",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Florence Fricke, female, age 28, born Ireland, arrival 1910, marital status married, relationship to head of household wife. Household identifier 96, line 38, sheet 4A, NARA publication T625."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 5,
      "person1_id": "I10",
      "person2_id": "I9",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "notes": "Burial/death record names spouse Mary Sue Henderson and records marital status married. It confirms the spouse relationship but does not provide marriage date or place.",
      "source": "George Gibson Fricke burial/death record, Forsyth, North Carolina, 1973",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "George Gibson Fricke burial/death record, 15 Dec 1973, Forsyth, North Carolina, United States",
          "source_type": "burial/death transcript",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "George Gibson Fricke, male, born 11 Nov 1915 in New Jersey, died 13 Dec 1973 in Winston-Salem, Forsyth, North Carolina, buried 15 Dec 1973 at Gardens Of Memory. Marital status married; spouse Mary Sue Henderson. Father George Fricke; mother Florance Gibson. Residence 14 Arita Circle, Winston-Salem; occupation truck driver."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 8,
      "person1_id": "SRC_WALTER_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_ANNE",
      "person2_id": "SRC_JANE_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_ANNE",
      "relationship_type": "unknown",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "notes": "Anne Crowther christening names Walter Crowther as father and Jane as mother. This confirms co-parent relationship, but not marriage date/place or marital status.",
      "source": "Anne Crowther christening transcript, 1832",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 9,
      "person1_id": "SRC_JOSHUA_CROWTHER_FATHER_OF_WALTER",
      "person2_id": "SRC_ANN_CROWTHER_MOTHER_OF_WALTER",
      "relationship_type": "unknown",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "notes": "User identified Joshua Crowther and Ann Crowther as parents of Walter Crowther. This confirms co-parent relationship but not marriage date/place or marital status.",
      "source": "User-confirmed parents of Walter Crowther",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 10,
      "person1_id": "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FATHER_OF_ANN",
      "person2_id": "SRC_MARGT_GRINDLEY_MOTHER_OF_ANN",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "6 Nov 1782",
      "start_place": "Market Drayton, Shropshire, England",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "notes": "Marriage transcript names Thomas Grindley as husband and Margaret Harding as spouse; event date 6 Nov 1782, Market Drayton, Shropshire, England.",
      "source": "FamilySearch marriage transcript for Thomas Grindley and Margaret Harding",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "FamilySearch person details: Thomas Grindley and Margaret Harding marriage, 6 Nov 1782, Market Drayton, Shropshire, England",
          "source_type": "FamilySearch transcript",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Margaret Harding spouse details list Thomas Grindley as husband. Thomas Grindley marriage event dated 6 November 1782 at Market Drayton, Shropshire, England."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 12,
      "person1_id": "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_RUTH",
      "person2_id": "SRC_RUTH_MOTHER_OF_RUTH_HANDLEY",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "notes": "FamilySearch page for Ruth Johnson lists Sampson Handley as husband. No marriage date or place captured yet.",
      "source": "FamilySearch person page LH5P-YBG for Ruth Johnson",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "FamilySearch person page LH5P-YBG: Ruth Johnson, spouse Sampson Handley",
          "source_type": "FamilySearch person page",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Ruth Johnson, female, FamilySearch ID LH5P-YBG, born 4 Mar 1739 at Sandon, Staffordshire, England, died 4 Jan 1759 at Milwich. Page lists Sampson Handley as husband. No marriage date/place captured."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 13,
      "person1_id": "SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_1697",
      "person2_id": "SRC_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_1691",
      "relationship_type": "unknown",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "notes": "User identified George Handley and Anne Cartwright as parents of Sampson Handley. This confirms co-parent relationship but not marriage date/place or marital status.",
      "source": "User-confirmed parents of Sampson Handley",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 14,
      "person1_id": "SRC_THOMAS_HANDLEY_ABT1666",
      "person2_id": "SRC_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
      "relationship_type": "unknown",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "notes": "User identified Thomas Handley and Hanna Fenton as parents of George Handley. This confirms co-parent relationship but not marriage date/place or marital status.",
      "source": "User-confirmed parents of George Handley",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 15,
      "person1_id": "SRC_JAMES_JACOBUS_HANDLEY_1647",
      "person2_id": "SRC_HANNAH_WILD_1649",
      "relationship_type": "unknown",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "notes": "User identified James Jacobus Handley and Hannah Wild as parents of Thomas Handley. Later supplied FamilySearch grouping gives James/Hannah marriage 3 Aug 1670 in Sheffield but also gives Thomas Handley born 1666, so the marriage date and Thomas birth chronology require verification. Relationship retained as co-parents, not a confirmed marriage.",
      "source": "User-confirmed parents of Thomas Handley",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 16,
      "person1_id": "SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
      "person2_id": "SRC_JANE_EDEN_GARDNER",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "notes": "Record names George Wall and Jane Eden Gardner as spouses and lists Eleanor, born 1524 and died 1600 in Droitwich Spa, as their child. This is stronger direct-line evidence than the unresolved Jane Farnefolde candidate.",
      "source": "Genealogical record naming George Wall, Jane Eden Gardner, and child Eleanor Wall",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "source_type": "user-supplied genealogical record",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
        },
        {
          "citation": "Genealogical record: George Wall and Jane Eden Gardner, child Eleanor Wall, Droitwich Spa",
          "source_type": "genealogical record with book sources",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Lists George Wall born 1507, died 1562; Jane Eden Gardner born about 1507, died 1572; child Eleanor born 1524, died 1600, spouse Thomas Wylde. Sources listed include Worcester cathedral monuments, Shropshire Archaeological and Natural History Society transactions, and Annals of the Hospital of S. Wulstan."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 17,
      "person1_id": "I122",
      "person2_id": "I121",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.55,
      "notes": "FamilySearch profiles propose Nancy Ann Sevier as David McNew's spouse. Census evidence establishes a spouse Ann/Annie but not her maiden surname, so this remains an identity hypothesis.",
      "source": "FamilySearch person pages K4NV-8YV and G5H6-GPF",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "FamilySearch person pages: Pvt. John \"David\" McNew K4NV-8YV and Nancy Ann Sevier G5H6-GPF",
          "source_type": "FamilySearch person page",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "John David McNew: born 8 Aug 1801 Washington County, Virginia, died 1880 Washington County, Virginia. Nancy Ann Sevier: born 1804 Washington County, Virginia, died 1895 Washington County, Virginia. No marriage date/place captured."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 18,
      "person1_id": "I129",
      "person2_id": "I130",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "1660",
      "start_place": "Scotland",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "notes": "User identified Phillis (Macknew) Mackneugh as wife of Jeremiah Macknew I, married 1660 in Scotland at about age 20. Mother of John Howard Macknew and Jeremiah Macknew II.",
      "source": "User-confirmed Jeremiah Macknew I and Phillis Mackneugh marriage",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "User-supplied family profile: Jeremiah Macknew I and Phillis (Macknew) Mackneugh marriage, 1660, Scotland",
          "source_type": "user-supplied family profile",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Phillis (Macknew) Mackneugh listed as wife of Jeremiah Macknew I, married 1660 in Scotland at age 20; mother of John Howard Macknew and Jeremiah Macknew II."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 20,
      "person1_id": "SRC_STEPHAN_LINDNER_ABT1640",
      "person2_id": "SRC_BARBARA_UNKNOWN_LINDNER",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "28 Apr 1665",
      "start_place": "Nenzenheim, Iphofen, Kitzingen, Bayern, Holy Roman Empire",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source": "1665 Stephan Lindner and Barbara Mollfinger marriage record",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "Stephan Lindner and Barbara Mollfinger marriage record, 28 Apr 1665, Nenzenheim",
          "source_type": "marriage record transcription",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 21,
      "person1_id": "SRC_SIMON_K_LINDNER_1681",
      "person2_id": "SRC_MARGARETHA_NAGEL_LINDER",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "17 Oct 1713",
      "start_place": "Evangelisch Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Germany",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "notes": "Indexed church marriage directly pairs Simon Lindner and Margretha Nagel; Simon's father is named Stephen Lindner and Margretha's father is named Hannss Martin Nagel.",
      "source": "Germany, Select Marriages, 1558-1929",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "Germany, Select Marriages, 1558-1929: Simon Lindner and Margretha Nagel; 17 Oct 1713; Evangelisch Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden; fathers Stephen Lindner and Hannss Martin Nagel",
          "source_type": "indexed church marriage",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Directly supports the spouses, date, place, and both named fathers."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 22,
      "person1_id": "SRC_JERICK_ANTON_LINDER_1735",
      "person2_id": "SRC_MARY_ULANDT_NEWLAND_1741",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "about 5 May 1759",
      "start_place": "Colony of Virginia",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.8,
      "notes": "Jerick Anton Linder and Mary Ulandt Newland marriage.",
      "source": "User-supplied Linder family profile",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 23,
      "person1_id": "SRC_HANS_MARTIN_MARTZ_NAGEL",
      "person2_id": "SRC_ANNA_CATHARINA_KIEFFER",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "24 Apr 1683",
      "start_place": "Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden, Holy Roman Empire",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "notes": "Hans Martin Nagel and Anna Catharina Kieffer marriage.",
      "source": "User-supplied Nagel/Kieffer family profile",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 24,
      "person1_id": "SRC_HANS_SIMON_NAGEL",
      "person2_id": "SRC_CATHARINA_UNKNOWN_NAGEL",
      "relationship_type": "unknown",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "notes": "Co-parent relationship inferred from user-supplied parents of Hans Martin Nagel.",
      "source": "User-supplied parents of Hans Martin Nagel",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 25,
      "person1_id": "SRC_GEORGE_WALL_ABT1507",
      "person2_id": "SRC_JANE_FARNEFOLDE_1508",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "5 Apr 1551",
      "start_place": "St Michael's Church, East Ham, Newham, London, England, United Kingdom",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.35,
      "notes": "Candidate spouse relationship. Possible spouse-name conflict or alias with Jane Eden Gardner; kept separate pending more evidence. Later direct-line evidence names Jane Eden Gardner as George Wall spouse and mother of Eleanor Wall. Keep Jane Farnefolde separate pending reconciliation.",
      "source": "User-supplied Wall/Farnefolde profile",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 26,
      "person1_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_G_WALL_1489",
      "person2_id": "SRC_GRACE_BANESTER_1490",
      "relationship_type": "unknown",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.7,
      "notes": "Co-parent relationship inferred from user-supplied parents of George Wall.",
      "source": "User-supplied parents of George Wall",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 30,
      "person1_id": "SRC_RICHARD_WALL_ABT1463",
      "person2_id": "SRC_MARGARET_WHALLEY_PETTENATI_ABT1467",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "about 1488",
      "start_place": "Preston, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.75,
      "notes": "User supplied Richard Wall and Margaret Whalley Pettenati married about 1488 in Preston, Lancashire, England, United Kingdom, and were parents of at least 5 sons and 3 daughters.",
      "source": "User-supplied family profile",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "User-supplied family profile for Margaret Whalley Pettenati and Richard Wall",
          "source_type": "family_profile",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Marriage about 1488 in Preston; children count and Margaret vitals supplied by user."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 31,
      "person1_id": "I86",
      "person2_id": "I85",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "17 Nov 1789",
      "start_place": "Washington County, Virginia, USA",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "notes": "Indexed marriage directly names John Gobble and Jemima Linder. The earlier local 14 Nov date and duplicate relationship rows were superseded.",
      "source": "Virginia, U.S., Compiled Marriages, 1660-1800",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "Virginia, U.S., Compiled Marriages, 1660-1800: Jemima Linder; marriage 17 Nov 1789, Washington County, Virginia; spouse John Gobble",
          "source_type": "compiled marriage index",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Directly supports spouses, date, place, and Jemima's Linder surname."
        },
        {
          "citation": "U.S. and International Marriage Records, 1560-1900: Jemima Linder; reported born 1774 Virginia; married 1789 Virginia; spouse John Gobble",
          "source_type": "compiled marriage collection",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Derivative support for approximate birth year and marriage year; not used for an exact birth date."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 32,
      "person1_id": "SRC_THOMAS_WYLDE_CLOTHIER",
      "person2_id": "SRC_ELEANOR_WALL_1524",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "notes": "Thomas Wylde's second wife was Ellinor/Eleanor, daughter of George Wall of Droitwich; George Wylde I was their eldest son.",
      "source": "History of Parliament / Wikipedia summary",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "George Wylde I, Wikipedia summary citing History of Parliament and Parliamentary History of Worcestershire",
          "source_type": "web_secondary",
          "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Wylde_I",
          "notes": "Used for George Wylde I identity, parents Thomas Wylde and Ellinor/Eleanor Wall, spouse Frances Huddleston, and death date."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 33,
      "person1_id": "SRC_GEORGE_WYLDE_1557",
      "person2_id": "SRC_FRANCES_HUDDLESTON_WYLDE",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.84,
      "notes": "George Wylde I and Frances Huddleston are a well-supported Droitwich/Worcestershire couple. Some online-tree data attaches William Wilde of Sheffield as their son, but the user reviewed William's sources and found they do not name his father; William is therefore represented through speculative parent edges only.",
      "source": "History of Parliament / Wikipedia summary",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "George Wylde I, Wikipedia summary citing History of Parliament and Parliamentary History of Worcestershire",
          "source_type": "web_secondary",
          "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Wylde_I",
          "notes": "Used for George Wylde I identity, parents Thomas Wylde and Ellinor/Eleanor Wall, spouse Frances Huddleston, and death date."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 34,
      "person1_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_WILDE_1576",
      "person2_id": "SRC_ISABEL_SHEMELD",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "1601",
      "start_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.78,
      "notes": "User supplied William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld married in 1601 at Sheffield and were parents of at least 7 sons and 7 daughters.",
      "source": "User-supplied family profile",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "User-supplied family profile for William Wilde and Isabel Shemeld",
          "source_type": "family_profile",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Marriage 1601, Sheffield; children count supplied by user."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 35,
      "person1_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "person2_id": "SRC_ANNA_FUCHS_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "22 Nov 1625",
      "start_place": "Middle Franconia, Bavaria, Germany",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source": "User-supplied family profile",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
          "source_type": "family_profile",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Marriage 22 Nov 1625 in Middle Franconia; children count supplied by user."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 36,
      "person1_id": "SRC_MICHAEL_LINDNER_FATHER_OF_STEPHAN",
      "person2_id": "SRC_ANNA_WIFE_MICHAEL_LINDNER_1620",
      "relationship_type": "unknown",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.62,
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source": "User-supplied family profile",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 37,
      "person1_id": "SRC_HANS_FUCHS_FATHER_ANNA",
      "person2_id": "SRC_BARBARA_MOTHER_ANNA_FUCHS",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": null,
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.85,
      "notes": "Hans Fuchs and a mother Barbara are named together in Anna Fuchs's 1596 Oberböbingen baptism, making them the leading parental couple. A compiled profile reports their marriage as 4 Feb 1590 at Unterhausen, but the surviving Unterhausen marriage entries begin in 1597. The exact date and place are therefore not displayed as recorded facts. The couple relationship remains likely from their jointly named child; the ceremony details remain unverified.",
      "source": "shared parental baptism plus compiled marriage claim",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "Anna Fuchs, Oberböbingen baptism, 1596; compiled Fuchs profile; Archion catalogue of Unterhausen volume 1",
          "source_type": "transcribed child baptism, compiled marriage claim, and archive catalogue",
          "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/baden-wuerttemberg/evangelisches-archiv-baden-und-wuerttemberg-wuerttemberg/dekanat-reutlingen/unterhausen/111744",
          "notes": "The baptism names both parents but not Barbara's maiden surname. The profile's 4 Feb 1590 Unterhausen marriage claim cannot be verified in the surviving Unterhausen marriage series, which begins in 1597."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 38,
      "person1_id": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "person2_id": "SRC_LYDIA_ELLIS_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "about 1652",
      "start_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.72,
      "notes": "Godfrey Wilde and Lydia Ellis married about 1652 in Sheffield; children listed by user.",
      "source": "User-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 39,
      "person1_id": "SRC_GODFREY_WILDE_1623",
      "person2_id": "SRC_HELLENA_TUNSTEAD_WIFE_GODFREY_WILDE",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "5 Sep 1677",
      "start_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.86,
      "notes": "Marriage transcript identifies Godfridus Wild, male, as husband in a marriage on 5 Sep 1677 at Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul Sheffield, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England. Matched to Godfrey Wilde and Hellena Tunstead relationship. Supplied profile lists Hannah Wild born 1649 under this spouse, but that predates the marriage and is treated as inconsistent.",
      "source": "Sheffield parish marriage transcript",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "Sheffield parish marriage transcript for Godfridus Wild, 5 Sep 1677",
          "source_type": "marriage_transcript",
          "url": null,
          "notes": "Event place: Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul Sheffield, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England, United Kingdom. Original place: Sheffield, Cathedral Church of St Peter & St Paul, Yorkshire (West Riding), England. Document type: Baptisms, marriages & burials. Reference: PR-138-1-3. Affiliate: Sheffield Archives & Local Studies."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 40,
      "person1_id": "SRC_ROBERT_HANCOCK_1591",
      "person2_id": "SRC_MARGARET_GREAVES_1595",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "5 Feb 1615",
      "start_place": "Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.74,
      "notes": "Robert Hancock and Margaret Greaves married 5 Feb 1615 in Sheffield and were parents of the listed Hancock children.",
      "source": "User-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 41,
      "person1_id": "SRC_RICHARD_HANCOCK_1564",
      "person2_id": "SRC_ANNE_ROADES_1567",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "30 Jan 1587",
      "start_place": "Cathedral Church of St Peter and St Paul, Sheffield, Yorkshire, England",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.6,
      "notes": "Richard Hancock and Anne Roades marriage recorded from supplied FamilySearch-style profile. They are retained as a couple, but their parentage of Robert Hancock is speculative because the FamilySearch change history is unstable and no direct Robert baptism has been shown.",
      "source": "User-supplied FamilySearch-style profile",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 42,
      "person1_id": "I109",
      "person2_id": "C_SPIESS_MARIA_MAGDALENA",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "22 May 1725",
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge CE_JOHANN_FRIEDRICH_GABEL_MARIA_SPIESS. Multiple compiled profiles report Johann Friedrich Gabel and Maria Magdalena Spiess married 22 May 1725. No original marriage-register image was inspected.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 45,
      "person1_id": "I65",
      "person2_id": "C_ANN_NANCY_WILLIS_MOTHER_FANNY_LAVENDER",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "27 Feb 1794",
      "start_place": "Franklin County, Virginia",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge CE_SE_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_1794. Robert Lavinder and Nancy Willis married in Franklin County, Virginia, on 27 Feb 1794.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 46,
      "person1_id": "C_SAMUEL_FELPS_POSSIBLE_FATHER_MARTIN_PHELPS",
      "person2_id": "C_SUSANNAH_VINES_WIFE_SAMUEL_FELPS",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "13 Feb 1782",
      "start_place": "Lincoln County",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge CE_SE_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_1782. Samuel Felps and Susannah Vines married in Lincoln County on 13 Feb 1782.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 48,
      "person1_id": "C_INDEX_JOHN_ALKIN_FATHER_OF_MARY",
      "person2_id": "C_INDEX_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_ALKIN",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "13 Jun 1667",
      "start_place": "Bramshall, Staffordshire",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge C_INDEX_SE_JOHN_ALKIN_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD. Marriage index records John Alkins and Elizabeth Bagnald married 13 Jun 1667 at Bramshall, Staffordshire.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 50,
      "person1_id": "C_GONDER_JOHANN_CASPAR",
      "person2_id": "C_DECHER_ANNA_CATHARINA",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "30 Apr 1826",
      "start_place": "Obergleen",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge C_SE_GONDER_DECHER. Marriage index records Johann Caspar Gonter and Catharina Decher on 30 Apr 1826 in Obergleen.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 51,
      "person1_id": "C_GONDER_DIETRICH",
      "person2_id": "C_WENDEL_ANNA_INCOMPLETE",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "31 Mar 1761",
      "start_place": "Obergleen",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge C_SE_GONDER_DIETRICH_WENDEL. Johann Dietrich Gunter/Gonder married Anna Catharina Wendel on 31 Mar 1761 at Obergleen. They are jointly named as parents of Johann Balthasar in January 1762.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 52,
      "person1_id": "C_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_FATHER_OF_SAMPSON",
      "person2_id": "C_WIKITREE_ANN_CARTWRIGHT_HANDLEY",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "17 Feb 1718",
      "start_place": "Caverswall, Staffordshire, England",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.65,
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 53,
      "person1_id": "I139",
      "person2_id": "C_WIKITREE_JULIA_ANN_GLOVER_RHEAD",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "30 May 1819",
      "start_place": "Stoke upon Trent",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 54,
      "person1_id": "EXP8_JOHN_FELPS_ABT1750_1811",
      "person2_id": "EXP8_MARY_MAY_WILLIAMS_ABT1750",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "12 Feb 1766",
      "start_place": "Rowan County",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.9,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge EXP8_SE_JOHN_FELPS_MARY_WILLIAMS. Published Phelps research reports their marriage on 12 Feb 1766 in Rowan County and names Samuel Williams as bondsman. Original bond image was not inspected.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 55,
      "person1_id": "SRC_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796",
      "person2_id": "SRC_EDA_CAUNTIS_PHELPS",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "17 Feb 1820",
      "start_place": "Washington County, Virginia",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge E_SP_MARTIN_PHELPS_EDA_CAUNTIS. Married 17 Feb 1820 in Washington County, Virginia. A later child record independently preserves spouse surname Cauntis.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 56,
      "person1_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064500",
      "person2_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064511",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "2 February 1867",
      "start_place": "New Orleans",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge GED_SE_0AE876BC8DFE9455. The Ingenheim database reports marriage at New Orleans on 2 February 1867 and describes their four-child American household.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 57,
      "person1_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064422",
      "person2_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064428",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "7 Nov 1883",
      "start_place": "New Orleans",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge GED_SE_7446F620DAE9FB42. The Orleans Parish index records Adeline Trautman and Leon E. Schwartz marrying 7 Nov 1883.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 58,
      "person1_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064617",
      "person2_id": "GED_ANCESTRY_I152810064637",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "30 May 1915",
      "start_place": "New Britain",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge GED_SE_746E547132C59BC9. The Connecticut statewide marriage index directly records Max Juffe and Freda Dubowy marrying at New Britain on 30 May 1915 (CTMI-1-159520).",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 60,
      "person1_id": "HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876",
      "person2_id": "HV4_SARAH_LUSBY_1810_1820_15_OCT_1862",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "8 November 1839",
      "start_place": "Pettis County, Missouri",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.83,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge HV4_SE_HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876_. All three sources place John S. McNew in a marriage at Pettis County, Missouri on 8 November 1839. The Nathan McNew tree calls the wife Sarah Lusby; the Deepwater cemetery transcription and Cook genealogy call her Sarah A. Willoughby. The relationship is retained as probable, with Willoughby currently the better-supported surname, pending the original marriage entry.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 61,
      "person1_id": "I241",
      "person2_id": "HV5_URSULA_BATZER",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "10 May 1670",
      "start_place": "Erpfingen",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge HV5_JOHANNES_IGNATIUS_URSULA_BATZER. The parish-register-based pedigree gives their Erpfingen marriage as 10 May 1670, following proclamation at Willmandingen on 17 Apr 1670, and ten children born 1671-1692.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 62,
      "person1_id": "B71_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY",
      "person2_id": "B71_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_KERRY",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "21 January 1785",
      "start_place": "Kerry",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_B71_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD. John Lamb and Elizabeth Prichard married at Kerry on 21 January 1785. This marriage is direct evidence for the couple, independent of the lower-confidence claim that their daughter continued into the Berriew ancestry.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 63,
      "person1_id": "C_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_1758",
      "person2_id": "C_HANNAH_MELLOR_ASHBOURNE_ABT1737",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "11 Dec 1758",
      "start_place": "Ashbourne St Oswald",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_CANDIDATE_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_1758. Edward Needham and Hannah Mellor married on 11 Dec 1758 at Ashbourne St Oswald.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 64,
      "person1_id": "C_CLARKE_DAVID_FATHER_SARAH",
      "person2_id": "C_BOYD_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_MOTHER_SARAH",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "20 Jul 1854",
      "start_place": "Monaghan",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 65,
      "person1_id": "SRC_DELIA_TALLEY_MOTHER_REBECCA",
      "person2_id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_POSSIBLE_SPOUSE_DELIA",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "10 September 1866",
      "start_place": "Washington County, Virginia",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.94,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_DELIA_TALLEY_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_CANDIDATE. A Washington County marriage-register transcription identifies William Henderson and widow Delia Tally on 10 September 1866; the 1870 census independently confirms their blended household. Strong secondary evidence because the original register image was not inspected.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 66,
      "person1_id": "I49",
      "person2_id": "I50",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "5 Jun 1899",
      "start_place": "Wolverhampton",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F16. The 5 Jun 1899 Wolverhampton parish marriage names Rosa Beatrice Morrall and Bernal Bright Rhead. Their 1901, 1911, and 1921 census households independently continue them as spouses with children.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 67,
      "person1_id": "I51",
      "person2_id": "I52",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "25 Sep 1876",
      "start_place": "Washington County, Virginia",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F17. Direct marriage register: Rebecca S Talley, age 19, married Connaely/Conley Henderson on 25 Sep 1876 in Washington County, Virginia.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 68,
      "person1_id": "I55",
      "person2_id": "I56",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "21 May 1861",
      "start_place": "Washington County, Virginia",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 69,
      "person1_id": "I62",
      "person2_id": "I63",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "8 Oct 1786",
      "start_place": "Franklin County, Virginia",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F22. Benjamin White and Suckey Bartee married at Franklin County, Virginia, on 8 Oct 1786.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 70,
      "person1_id": "I81",
      "person2_id": "I82",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "16 Sep 1840",
      "start_place": "Washington County, Virginia",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F30. Family Data Collection gives marriage 16 Sep 1840 in Washington County, Virginia. John and Sarah appear together in four supplied censuses, and multiple child records name them as parents. Sarah's memorial also names John G. Gobble as her spouse.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 71,
      "person1_id": "I83",
      "person2_id": "I84",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "20 May 1813",
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 72,
      "person1_id": "I107",
      "person2_id": "I108",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "10 May 1757",
      "start_place": "Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran Church",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.82,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F39. Published trees identify Johann Friedrich Jr.'s wife as Elizabeth, but no original marriage record has been located. The Goble Family Association database identifies Elizabeth as Weigel and dates the marriage to 10 May 1757 at Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran Church; retained below direct-record confidence.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 73,
      "person1_id": "I137",
      "person2_id": "I138",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "10 Apr 1854",
      "start_place": "Birmingham St Stephen",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F54. Helen Waterhouse and Richard Rhead married on 10 Apr 1854 at Birmingham St Stephen. The 1861, 1881, and 1891 censuses independently continue Richard and Ellen as spouses; Read/Rhead and Helen/Ellen are documented variants.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 74,
      "person1_id": "C_FS_SAMPSON_RHEAD_SARAH_POYNER_HUSBAND",
      "person2_id": "I140",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "25 Nov 1832",
      "start_place": "Stoke St Milborough",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 75,
      "person1_id": "I141",
      "person2_id": "I142",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "26 Jan 1793",
      "start_place": "Trentham",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.998,
      "notes": "[Details withheld to protect living people.]",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 76,
      "person1_id": "I143",
      "person2_id": "I144",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "26 Nov 1860",
      "start_place": "Wolverhampton St John",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F57. Richard Morrall and Sarah Brassington married on 26 Nov 1860 at Wolverhampton St John and appear together in the 1861, 1871, 1881, and 1891 census households.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 77,
      "person1_id": "I145",
      "person2_id": "I146",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "24 Sep 1827",
      "start_place": "Ashbourne St Oswald",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F58. John Waterhouse and Ellen Finney married on 24 Sep 1827 at Ashbourne St Oswald. Their family is continuous through the 1841, 1851, and 1861 censuses; Jonas/Helen are compatible variants of John/Ellen.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 78,
      "person1_id": "I151",
      "person2_id": "I152",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "24 Jul 1828",
      "start_place": "Wolverhampton St Peter",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F61. Joseph Brassington and Esther Thompson married on 24 Jul 1828 at Wolverhampton St Peter and appear together with their children in the 1841 and 1851 censuses.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 79,
      "person1_id": "I182",
      "person2_id": "I183",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "31 Mar 1838",
      "start_place": "Wiltshire",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F77. William Peters Hanny and Elizabeth Cornish married on 31 Mar 1838 in Wiltshire; their fathers are explicitly named William Hanny and Henry Cornish. The 1851 census continues them as spouses.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 80,
      "person1_id": "I186",
      "person2_id": "I187",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "25 Jun 1795",
      "start_place": "Bradford-on-Avon",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F79. William Hanny/Hanney and Elizabeth Peters married 25 Jun 1795 at Bradford-on-Avon; both were of the parish.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 81,
      "person1_id": "I188",
      "person2_id": "I189",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "8 Jul 1765",
      "start_place": "Winsley",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F80. Charles Hanny and Catherine/Catharine Waine married 8 Jul 1765 at Winsley, both of the parish.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 82,
      "person1_id": "I190",
      "person2_id": "I191",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "18 Jun 1764",
      "start_place": "North Bradley St Nicholas",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_F81. Isaiah Peters and Betty Willis married at North Bradley St Nicholas on 18 Jun 1764; witnesses were John Butche and Richard Gibbs. This marriage does not prove their exact birth/death dates or directly identify Elizabeth Peters as their daughter.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 83,
      "person1_id": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_FATHER_JOHN_1802",
      "person2_id": "SRC_HANNAH_WATERHOUSE_MOTHER_JOHN_1802",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "26 Nov 1799",
      "start_place": "Ashbourne St Oswald",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_1799. James Waterhouse and Hannah Needham married on 26 Nov 1799 at Ashbourne St Oswald; John's 1802 baptism identifies them as his parents.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 84,
      "person1_id": "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_FORTON_ABT1753_1834",
      "person2_id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WIFE_JOHN_GRINDLEY",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "31 Dec 1777",
      "start_place": "Forton All Saints",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.99,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_1777. John Grindley and Elizabeth Pickin married on 31 Dec 1777 at Forton All Saints; a child christening index names them as Thomas Grindley's parents.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 85,
      "person1_id": "C_MARSHALL_JOHN_PONTEFRACT_1772",
      "person2_id": "C_ALLEN_ANN_WIFE_JOHN_MARSHALL_1772",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "19 July 1772",
      "start_place": "Pontefract",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_1772. The Pontefract indexes record banns on 12 July and marriage on 19 July 1772.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 86,
      "person1_id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_ABT1705",
      "person2_id": "C_LINDER_ELIZABETH_WIFE_JOHN_NEWLAND",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "23 Apr 1739",
      "start_place": null,
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_NEWLAND_JOHN_ELIZABETH_LINDER. The 23 Apr 1739 Stoever register directly records Johann Ulandt and Elizabetha Lintner; Berkeley deeds repeatedly name John Newland and wife Elizabeth.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 87,
      "person1_id": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_ABT1812",
      "person2_id": "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_MOTHER_RICHARD_ABT1811",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "4 Jul 1837",
      "start_place": "Shropshire",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_RICHARD_HANNAH_MORRALL_1851. Richard Morrall and Hannah Grindly married on 4 Jul 1837 in Shropshire. Their named fathers were Samuel Morrall and Thomas Grindly. The 1841 and 1851 households continue the couple with their children.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 88,
      "person1_id": "C_LEA_ROBERT_POSSIBLE_FATHER_JOANNA_1590",
      "person2_id": "C_SMITH_JOAN_SPOUSE_ROBERT_LEA_1587",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "3 Dec 1587",
      "start_place": "Stoke St Gregory",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587. Robte/Robert Lea and Joan Smith directly married on 3 Dec 1587 at Stoke St Gregory. Generation 14 audit: no conflict found; the 3 Dec 1587 Stoke St Gregory marriage remains direct evidence.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 89,
      "person1_id": "I140",
      "person2_id": "SRC_THOMAS_BOTTON_1826",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "19 Dec 1852",
      "start_place": "Shelton St Mark",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.995,
      "notes": "Marriage date/place materialized from the existing spouse relationship evidence note; the original source IDs, confidence, and full evidence summary remain on spouse edge SE_SARAH_POYNER_THOMAS_BOTTON. The couple appeared together under the Botton spelling in 1851 and formally married at Shelton St Mark on 19 Dec 1852. The 1861 and 1871 censuses continue them as Thomas and Sarah Boulton at Hanford.",
      "source": "Structured from existing spouse-edge evidence note",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 92,
      "person1_id": "C_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743",
      "person2_id": "C_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_1694",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "3 Sep 1694",
      "start_place": "St Oswald, Ashbourne, Derbyshire, England",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.98,
      "notes": "FreeREG directly transcribes the marriage of Robert Needham, of Brassington, and Mary Wagstaffe, of Hulland, at Ashbourne St Oswald on 3 September 1694.",
      "source": "FreeREG parish-register transcription",
      "sources": [
        {
          "citation": "FreeREG: marriage of Robert Needham and Mary Wagstaffe, Ashbourne, 3 September 1694",
          "source_type": "parish-register transcription",
          "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/682f56d08655746c65f3eaf3/robert-needham-mary-wagstaff-marriage-derbyshire-ashbourne-1694-09-03",
          "notes": "The transcript identifies Robert as of Brassington and Mary as of Hulland. It does not name parents or ages."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 93,
      "person1_id": "G28_THOMAS_FELPS_1664_1758",
      "person2_id": "G28_ROSANNAH_WIFE_THOMAS_FELPS",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "28 May 1710",
      "start_place": "Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.92,
      "notes": "The 1738 transcription records Thomas Felps's statement that he married Rose Swift on 28 May 1710. Swift was Rose's previous married name.",
      "source": "Published 1738 vestry-proceedings transcription",
      "sources": []
    },
    {
      "relationship_id": 94,
      "person1_id": "G28_AVENTON_FELPS_1711_1794",
      "person2_id": "G28_RACHEL_MCELROY_WIFE_AVENTON",
      "relationship_type": "marriage",
      "start_date": "23 Apr 1730",
      "start_place": "St George Parish, Baltimore County, Maryland, British Colonial America",
      "end_date": null,
      "end_place": null,
      "confidence": 0.88,
      "notes": "The published transcription reports the marriage of Aventon Felps and Rachel McElroy. Original register image has not yet been inspected.",
      "source": "Published St George Parish-register transcription",
      "sources": []
    }
  ],
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "SRC_BRASSINGTON_ANCESTRY",
      "title": "Ancestry Brassington search snippet",
      "type": "index_snippet",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/results?firstName=ellen&geo-lang=nl&lastName=brassington",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "External snippet for Ellen Brassington, father Joseph Brassington, mother Esther Thompson."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_ANCESTRY",
      "title": "Ancestry William Henry Hanny profile snippet",
      "type": "index_snippet",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/william-henry-hanny-24-6rfx3g",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "External snippet for William Henry Hanny, son of William Peters Hanny and Elizabeth Cornish."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_BHO",
      "title": "British History Online Bradford-on-Avon history",
      "type": "local_history",
      "url": "https://www.british-history.ac.uk/vch/wilts/vol7/pp4-51",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Mentions William Peters Hanny (1802–1894) and local historical context."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBEL_GENI",
      "title": "Geni Martin Göbel profile",
      "type": "public_tree",
      "url": "https://www.geni.com/people/Martin-G%C3%B6bel/6000000077322461948",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "External tree hint for Martin Göbel and child Johannes Ignatius Göbel."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBEL_ANCESTRY_AU",
      "title": "Ancestry AU Hans Gabel snippet",
      "type": "index_snippet",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com.au/genealogy/records/results?firstName=hans&lastName=gabel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "External hint linking Hans Jacob Gabel to Johannes Ignatius Göbel."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_HANS",
      "title": "WikiTree: Johann Jacob Gabel",
      "type": "public_tree",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Gabel-317",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Hans Jacob Gabel married Maria Margretha, daughter of Hans Conrad Rheinmueller."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GABEL_FAMILYSEARCH_HANS",
      "title": "FamilySearch: Hans Jacob Gabel",
      "type": "public_tree",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/LC52-XL3/johann-jacob-gabel-1670-1707",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch profile gives alternate candidate parents Fredrick Gabel and Anne Catherine Juul."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GABEL_ROOTSWEB",
      "title": "RootsWeb/Goble genealogy: Hans Jacob Gabel",
      "type": "published_tree",
      "url": "https://homepages.rootsweb.com/~goble/data/German/gp390.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Hans Jacob Gabel, wife Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller, and her father Hans Conrad Rheinmueller."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GABEL_SPIESS",
      "title": "RootsWeb/Dale Brown: Johann Friedrich Gabel family",
      "type": "published_tree",
      "url": "https://freepages.rootsweb.com/~dalebrown/genealogy/LaddusawStillmanFamily/ghtout/gp43.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Johann Friedrich Gabel born 14 Mar 1701 Offenbach, married Maria Magdalena Spiess 22 May 1725."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_GENI_WILLIAM",
      "title": "Geni: William Hanny",
      "type": "public_tree",
      "url": "https://www.geni.com/people/William-Hanny/5536098385370108777",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Timeline lists children Sarah Hanny and William Peters Hanny."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RHEAD_YOURROOTS_STEPhen",
      "title": "YourRoots: Stephen Henry Reed/Rhead",
      "type": "public_tree",
      "url": "https://yourroots.com/tree/person/stephen-reed-1836-1890--pkxyvmghaokoi",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Stephen Henry Reed born 1836 Longton, Staffordshire, to Sampson Handley Rhead and Sarah Maria Poyner."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_POYNER_ANCESTRY_RICHARD",
      "title": "Ancestry snippet: Richard Poyner",
      "type": "index_snippet",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/1940-census/usa/New-York/Richard-Poener_c7p0g/amp",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Snippet gives Richard Poyner born 28 Jul 1675 Stanton Lacy, Shropshire, died 4 Oct 1741 Dawley Magna, father Charles."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GABEL_WIKITREE_SPIESS",
      "title": "WikiTree Maria Magdalene Spiess / Gabel family snippet",
      "type": "public_tree",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Spiess-78",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "St. Julian and Offenbach churchbooks showing children of Friedrich Gabel and Maria Magdalene Spiess."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GABEL_ANCESTRY_JF",
      "title": "Ancestry Johann Friedrich Gabel snippet",
      "type": "public_tree_snippet",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.ca/genealogy/records/johann-friedrich-gabel-24-20ysz0h",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists parents Hans Jacob Gabel/Maria Margretha Rheinmueller, spouses Maria Magdalena Spiess and Christiana Henrietta Hornberger, and 10 children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_GABEL_GOBEL_CLUSTER",
      "title": "Geneanet: Gabel/Göbel cluster, Hans Jacob Gabel and Johannes Ignatius Göbel",
      "type": "public_tree_index",
      "url": "https://de.geneanet.org/fonds/individus/?go=1&nom=GABEL&prenom=Johann&size=50",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Hans Johann Jacob Gabel with spouse Maria Margretha Rheinmueller, parents Johannes Ignatius Göbel and Ursula Batzer; lists Johann Friedrich Gabel with parents Hans Johann Jacob and Maria Margretha."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN",
      "title": "Geneanet: Göbel Erpfingen/Württemberg cluster",
      "type": "public_tree_index",
      "url": "https://no.geneanet.org/fonds/individus/?go=1&nom=GOBEL&page=2&place__0__=Erpfingen%2C+W%C3%BCrttemberg&size=50",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Johannes Ignatius Göbel, born 9 Jul 1645, married Ursula Batzer 5 Nov 1678, died 24 Feb 1714, parents Martin Göbel and Anna Katharina Kissling; children count 6."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_1845_HANNOVER_BAPTISM",
      "title": "Heinrich Friedrich Fricke christening, 9 Nov 1845, Sankt Ägidien Hannover; father Georg Heinrich Fricke, mother Anna Dorothee Leffler",
      "type": "church_record",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch: Germany Births and Baptisms / Lutheran church books. Birth 13 Aug 1845; event place Hannover, Preußen, Deutschland; original Sankt Ägidien Hannover."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_SCHAAF_1869_NEWARK_MARRIAGE",
      "title": "Henry Fricke and Cathrine Schaaf marriage, 28 Mar 1869, Newark, Essex, New Jersey",
      "type": "marriage_record",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "New Jersey Marriages, source details P218 M784. Henry age 23, Cathrine age 21, both single."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_1880_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1880 United States Census, East Orange, Essex, New Jersey, Henry Fricke household",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Henry Fricke, age 32, born about 1848 in Hanover/Germany, residing East Orange, Essex, New Jersey. Wife Cathrine Fricke. Children Elizabeth, William, and Charles Fricke. This census age implies about 1848 but is treated as approximate against the more specific July 1846 birth repeated in the 1900 census and cemetery record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_1905_GLEN_RIDGE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1905 New Jersey State Census, Glen Ridge/Essex, Henry/Katey Fricke household",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Henery/Henry age 59; Katey age 57; Ernest 21, Henry 19, John 17."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_1910_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1910 United States Census, East Orange/Orange Township, Essex, New Jersey, Henry/Katharine Fricke household",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Henry age 63 Germany; Katharine age 62 Germany; sons Henry Jr and John."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_JOHN_1889_BIRTH",
      "title": "John Fricke birth, 18 Apr 1889, East Orange, Essex, New Jersey",
      "type": "birth_record",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Father Henry Fricke age 43 born Germany; mother Katharina Schaff age 41 born Germany; source v.28 p.278."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_ELIZABETH_1890_MARRIAGE",
      "title": "Elizabeth Fricke and Heinrich Gonder marriage, 20 Jul 1890, East Orange, Essex, New Jersey",
      "type": "marriage_record",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Elizabeth age 21 born US; source p.250 m.51. Fits daughter Elizabeth age 11 in 1880."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_1920_CENSUS",
      "title": "1920 United States Census, East Orange, Essex, New Jersey, George Fricke household",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "George age 38 born NJ; father Germany, mother Germany; wife Florence born Ireland; children George G and Albert R."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_1930_CENSUS",
      "title": "1930 United States Census, East Orange, Essex, New Jersey, George Fricke household",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "George age 49 born NJ; father Germany, mother Germany; wife Florence; children George Jr, Albert R, Edna K."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_GEORGE_BURIAL",
      "title": "George Fricke burial, Hollywood Cemetery, Union, New Jersey",
      "type": "burial_record",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Birth 28 Mar 1881; death 22 Mar 1942; photograph included."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1910_CENSUS",
      "title": "1910 United States Census, East Orange, Charles Fricke household with brother George Fricke",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Charles age 36, head; George Fricke age 29, brother; both born NJ, parents born Germany."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_CHARLES_1920_CENSUS",
      "title": "1920 United States Census, East Orange, Charles Fricke household",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Charles age 43, wife Helen, children Charles, George, Phillip, Edith, Dorothy, Margaret, Florence; parents born Germany."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_1827_GEORG_BAPTISM",
      "title": "Georg Heinrich Fricke christening, 31 Mar 1827, Gütersloh, Westfalen",
      "type": "church_record",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Birth 26 Mar 1827. Father Eber. Hein. Fricke; mother Sophie Elis. Agnete."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_LEFFLER_1842_MARRIAGE",
      "title": "Georg Heinrich Frieke and Anna Dorothee Leffler marriage, 17 Apr 1842, Hannover III, Hannover",
      "type": "church_record",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed spelling Frieke/Fricke; Germany Lutheran records; note Freitag, Futtermeier 1774-1875."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_EBERHARD_SOPHIE_1820_MARRIAGE",
      "title": "Eberhard Heinrich Fricke and Sophie Elisabeth Angeneten marriage, 1820, Gütersloh, Westfalen",
      "type": "church_record",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Eberhard age 32, previously married; Sophie age 25; Evangelisch; source 2:XM3FK9."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SCHAAF_1848_BAPTISM",
      "title": "Katharina Schaaf baptism, 24 Mar 1848, Ober-Gleen, Kreis Alsfeld, Hessen",
      "type": "church_record",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/hessen/zentralarchiv-der-evangelischen-kirche-in-hessen-und-nassau/dekanat-alsfeld/ober-gleen/279138",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Birth 20 March and baptism 24 March 1848 at Ober-Gleen are retained from the earlier register extraction. The cited Archion catalog confirms that the Protestant baptism register for 1840-1870 survives, but the original image should be re-inspected before treating its details as fully verified. The baptized child remains only a candidate for the later New Jersey woman."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SCHAAF_FS_PROFILE",
      "title": "FamilySearch profile Katharine Schaff GSMH-DDV",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Birth 29 Mar 1848, Darmstadt, Hessen, Germany; death 1912; 9 sources. Use cautiously alongside Ober-Gleen baptism clue."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RHEAD_1911_LITTLE_STRETTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1911 England Census, Little Stretton, Shropshire: Bernal Bright Rhead household",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "1911 England Census, Little Stretton, Shropshire. Address: Glen Villas, Little Stretton, Salop. Piece 15928; registration district 344; Church Stretton sub-district; enumeration district 05. Household: Bernal Bright Rhead 42, married head, tailor, born Birmingham; Rosa Beatrice Rhead 35; Edward Richard 10; Bernal Albert 8; George Ernest 6; Amy Rosa 4; John Edgar 2. The supplied Ancestry transcript labels Bernal gender Female, but this conflicts with his role as husband/father and other records and is treated as an indexing error."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_MORRALL_FAMILYSEARCH_9WWH_TDG",
      "title": "FamilySearch person 9WWH-TDG: Rosa Beatrice Morrall",
      "type": "familysearch_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Rosa Beatrice Morrall, female, born 6 April 1875, Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom; christened 9 May 1875, Saint Luke, Wolverhampton, Stafford, England; deceased. Profile reports 19 name sources, 10 sex sources, 7 birth sources."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RHEAD_MORRALL_1899_WOLVERHAMPTON_MARRIAGE",
      "title": "Marriage of Bernal Bright Rhead and Rosa Beatrice Morrall, 5 Jun 1899, Wolverhampton",
      "type": "marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Marriage fact supplied from FamilySearch/profile data: 5 June 1899, Wolverhampton, Staffordshire, England, United Kingdom. Last changed 7 Aug 2021 by pamelaclinch."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BERNAL_B_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
      "title": "1881 England Census: Bernal B Rhead, Birmingham, Warwickshire",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "1881 England Census household in Birmingham, Warwickshire, England, RG11, piece/folio 2994/31, folio 31, page 16, line 8. Bernal B Rhead, male, age 12, born Birmingham, Warwickshire, scholar, son of Richard Rhead and Ellen Rhead. Siblings in household include Ruth E Rhead age 23 and Florence Rhead age 19."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
      "title": "1881 England Census: Richard Rhead household, Birmingham, Warwickshire",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "1881 England Census household in Birmingham, Warwickshire, England, RG11, piece/folio 2994/31, folio 31, page 16, line 8. Richard Rhead, head/husband, age 48, born Milborough, Shropshire, stonemason unemployed; Ellen Rhead, wife, age 46, born Hanford, Staffordshire, seamstress; Ruth E Rhead, daughter, age 23, single, tailoress; Florence Rhead, daughter, age 19, single, tailoress; Bernal B Rhead, son, age 12, scholar. Children born Birmingham, Warwickshire."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1881_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
      "title": "1881 England Census: Ellen Rhead, Birmingham, Warwickshire",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "1881 England Census household in Birmingham, Warwickshire, England, RG11, piece/folio 2994/31, folio 31, page 16, line 8. Ellen Rhead, wife, age 46, born Hanford, Staffordshire, seamstress; husband Richard Rhead age 48; children Ruth E Rhead age 23, Florence Rhead age 19, and Bernal B Rhead age 12."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARY_ALKIN_BURIAL_1710_UTTOXETER",
      "title": "England Select Deaths and Burials 1538-1991: Mary Alkin burial, 1710",
      "type": "burial_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Mary Alkin, female, death date about 1710, burial 16 Apr 1710, Uttoxeter, Stafford, England; father John Alkin; FHL film 1526194."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_ALKINS_ELIZABETH_BAGNALD_MARRIAGE_1667",
      "title": "England & Wales Marriages 1538-1988: John Alkins and Elizabeth Bagnald, 1667",
      "type": "marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Elizabeth Bagnald, female, married John Alkins on 13 Jun 1667 at Bramshall, Staffordshire, England; date range 1659-1668; film 1278889."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WIKITREE_GEORGE_HANDLEY_PROFILE",
      "title": "WikiTree-style profile: George Handley, abt 1689-1763",
      "type": "public_tree_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Compiled profile text supplied 2026-06-10: George Handley born about 1689. Possible baptism 19 Apr 1689 to parents William and Alice at Market Bosworth, Leicestershire, England, but profile says further research needed to establish same person. Married Ann Cartwright at Caverswall, Staffordshire, England on 17 Feb 1718. Buried 4 Dec 1763 in Milwich, Staffordshire, England. Sources cited: England Leicestershire Parish Registers 1533-1991; England Marriages 1538-1973; England Staffordshire Church Records 1538-1944 / FamilySearch QL7Z-CMKN."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_BURIAL_1763_MILWICH_FS_QL7Z_CMKN",
      "title": "FamilySearch: George Handley burial, 4 Dec 1763, Milwich, Staffordshire",
      "type": "burial_index_image",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QL7Z-CMKN",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "George Handley, burial 4 Dec 1763, Milwich, Staffordshire, England; England, Staffordshire, Church Records, 1538-1944, database with images; Staffordshire & Stoke on Trent Archive Service; FHL microfilm 7,566,683."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_NB8Q_CFJ",
      "title": "FamilySearch: Sampson Handley Read birth/christening, 1800",
      "type": "baptism_index",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:NB8Q-CFJ",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England Births and Christenings 1538-1975: Sampson Handley Read, born 30 Jun 1799, baptised 4 Nov 1800 at Trentham, Staffordshire, England, son of Richard and Ruth Read."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_1800_FS_QPSM_68WK",
      "title": "FamilySearch image index: Sampson Handley Read baptism, 4 Nov 1800",
      "type": "baptism_image_index",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:2:QPSM-68WK",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England, Staffordshire Church Records 1538-1944: entry for Sampson Handley Read, baptism 4 Nov 1800, Trentham, Staffordshire, England; Staffordshire & Stoke on Trent Archive Service; FHL microfilm 7,567,143. Profile note says parish register records son of Richard and Ruth, born 30 Jun 1799."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_1825_BURSLEM_BAPTISM_FS_QL3V_RL57",
      "title": "FamilySearch: Richard Rhead baptism, 1825, Burslem, Staffordshire",
      "type": "baptism_index",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QL3V-RL57",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England, Staffordshire Church Records, 1538-1944, FamilySearch QL3V-RL57: Richard Rhead baptism, 1825, St John, Burslem, Staffordshire, England; parents Levi Hanby Rhead and Henrietta. Citation timestamp Thu Apr 25 00:49:36 UTC 2024."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1950_CENSUS_OCCUPATION",
      "title": "1950 United States Census employment detail for George G. Fricke",
      "type": "official 1950 census record accessed via Ancestry",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official 1950 United States Census information accessed through Ancestry.com: during the census reference week in late March 1950, George G. Fricke worked 40 hours as an operator in the chemical company industry. Exact Ancestry collection citation and image details not yet recorded."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1973_DEATH_BURIAL",
      "title": "George Gibson Fricke death and burial transcript, Forsyth County, North Carolina, 1973",
      "type": "burial/death transcript",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "George Gibson Fricke, born 11 Nov 1915 in New Jersey, died 13 Dec 1973 in Winston-Salem, Forsyth County, North Carolina, and was buried 15 Dec 1973 at Gardens of Memory. Transcript records occupation truck driver, spouse Mary Sue Henderson, father George Fricke, and mother Florance Gibson."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_LA_MARQUE_RESIDENCE",
      "title": "George Gibson Fricke residence at 1501 W 26th Ave, La Marque, Texas",
      "type": "official record accessed via Ancestry",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official-record residence information accessed through Ancestry.com places George Gibson Fricke at 1501 W 26th Ave, La Marque, Galveston County, Texas. Exact record date and collection citation not yet recorded."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_LEANAH_E_WHITE_1880_CENSUS",
      "title": "1880 United States Census: Leanah E. White, North Fork, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "official census record accessed via Ancestry",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Leanah E. White, white female, age 5, birth about 1875 in Virginia; home in 1880 North Fork, Washington County, Virginia; house 59, dwelling 371."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_TINEY_SHORT_DEATH_1954",
      "title": "Virginia death record: Tiney Short, 2 Dec 1954, Abingdon, Washington County",
      "type": "official death record accessed via Ancestry",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Tiney Short, female, white, death age 80; born 24 Feb 1874; died 2 Dec 1954 in Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia; death registration date 25 Feb 1955. This direct death record supersedes the earlier supplied profile death date 12 Dec 1952 and resolves the county as Washington County."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_1900_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1900 United States Census, Henry Fricke household, East Orange Ward 3, Essex, New Jersey",
      "type": "official census record accessed via Ancestry",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Henry Fricke, age 53, born Jul 1846 Germany; head, married, naturalized, immigrated 1867, 33 years in United States. Home: East Orange Ward 3, Essex, New Jersey; street transcribed as Halstreetead Street, house 306; sheet 18, dwelling 274, family 313. Wife Katharine age 52; children Ernest 14, Henry 13, John 11. Census reports marriage year 1871 and 29 years married, conflicting slightly with direct New Jersey marriage record dated 28 Mar 1869. Home owned free, house."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_1880_JOHN_SCHAAF_NEWARK",
      "title": "1880 United States Federal Census: John Schaaf household, Newark",
      "type": "census_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry census transcript supplied by Matthew. John Schaaf, 59, born about 1821 in Hesse-Darmstadt, widower and tailor, at 390 Eighth Street, Newark, Essex County, New Jersey. Household also contains Jost Schaaf, 26, and Catharine Schaaf, 27; their relationships to John are absent from the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BAPTISM_1822",
      "title": "Germany Select Births and Baptisms, 1558-1898: Anna Elisabetha Gonder",
      "type": "official_record_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry baptism index supplied by Matthew. Anna Elisabetha Gonder born 2 Feb 1822, baptized 5 Feb 1822 at Evangelisch, Obergleen, Oberhessen, Hesse-Darmstadt; residence Obergleen; parents Johann Caspar Gonder and Anna Catharina Decher; FHL film 1195559."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONTER_DECHER_MARRIAGE_1826",
      "title": "Germany Select Marriages, 1558-1929: Johann Caspar Gonter and Catharina Decher",
      "type": "official_record_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry marriage index supplied by Matthew. Johann Caspar Gonter, male, age 25, married Catharina Decher on 30 Apr 1826 at Evangelisch, Obergleen, Oberhessen, Hesse-Darmstadt. His parents are indexed as Johann Balthasar Gonter and Barbara Catharina Gonter; FHL film 1195560."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHANN_CASPAR_GONDER",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Johann Caspar Gonder",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: born 17 Jul 1801 at Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany; died 4 Jan 1870 at Ober Gleen. Dates require confirmation from a direct record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHANN_BALTHASAR_GONDER",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Johann Balthasar Gonder",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: born 19 Jan 1762 at Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany; died 10 Jan 1836 at Ober Gleen, Oberhessen, Hessen, Germany. Dates require confirmation from direct records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_UNNAMED_BAPTISM_1762",
      "title": "Germany Select Births and Baptisms, 1558-1898: unnamed female Gonder",
      "type": "official_record_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry baptism index supplied by Matthew. Unnamed female Gonder born 4 Jun 1762 and baptized 6 Jun 1762 at Evangelisch, Obergleen, Oberhessen, Hesse-Darmstadt; parents Johannes Gonder and Anna Elisabetha Engel; FHL film 1195559. Exact birth date matches the Barbara Katherina Gonder profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BARBARA_KATHERINA_GONDER",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Barbara Katherina Gonder",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: born 4 Jun 1762 and died 2 Mar 1837 at Ober Gleen, Vogelsbergkreis, Hesse, Germany. Birth date exactly matches the unnamed female Gonder baptism; death requires direct-record confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_GONDER_BALTHASAR_BAPTISM_1762",
      "title": "Germany Select Births and Baptisms, 1558-1898: Johann Balthasar Gonder",
      "type": "official_record_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry baptism index supplied by Matthew. Male Gonder born 19 Jan 1762 and baptized 21 Jan 1762 at Evangelisch, Obergleen, Oberhessen, Hesse-Darmstadt; parents Dietrich Gonder and Anna ... Wendel; FHL film 1195559. Exact date matches the Johann Balthasar Gonder profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GRO_JOHN_E_RHEAD_ALFREDA_M_DAVIES_MARRIAGE_1940",
      "title": "England and Wales Civil Registration Marriage Index: John E Rhead and Alfreda M Davies, Q1 1940",
      "type": "civil_registration_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "General Register Office marriage index supplied by Matthew. John E Rhead and spouse Alfreda M Davies registered Jan-Feb-Mar 1940 in Shrewsbury registration district, inferred county Shropshire; volume 6a, page 2266. Registration quarter is not an exact marriage date, and registration district is not necessarily the ceremony venue."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RHEAD_1921_ST_CHAD_CENSUS",
      "title": "1921 England Census: Bernal Bright Rhead household, St Chad, Shropshire",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry 1921 England Census comparison supplied by Matthew. Bernal Bright Rhead, born 1869 Birmingham, Warwickshire, resident 1921 St Chad, Shropshire; spouse Rosa Beatrice Rhead; named children John Edgar Rhead, George Ernest Rhead, and Amy Rosa Rhead. The interface indicates two more family members but their names and details were not supplied, so no inference is made about them."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1841_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
      "title": "1841 England Census: John and Ellen Waterhouse household, Trentham, Staffordshire",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry 1841 England Census transcript supplied by Matthew. Trentham civil parish, North Pirehill hundred, Staffordshire; Stone registration district, Trentham sub-district; piece 993, book 6, folio 14, page 23. Household: John Waterhouse 35, Ellen Waterhouse 35, Frederick 13, James 11, John 9, Ellen 6, William 4, and Emma 1. Ellen age 6 is recorded born Staffordshire. The 1841 census generally rounded adult ages down to five-year intervals and did not state household relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
      "title": "England Select Marriages, 1538-1973: Helen Waterhouse and Richard Rhead, 10 Apr 1854",
      "type": "marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Marriage index supplied by Matthew. Helen Waterhouse married Richard Rhead on 10 Apr 1854 at Saint Stephen, Birmingham, Warwickshire, England; FHL films 0814861 and 0817172. Helen is treated as the name variant of Ellen Waterhouse based on the spouse, chronology, and later census household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_ST_STEPHEN_RHEAD_WATERHOUSE_MARRIAGE_1854",
      "title": "Birmingham Church of England Marriages and Banns: Helen Waterhouse and Richard Rhead, 10 Apr 1854",
      "type": "parish_marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry Birmingham, England, Church of England Marriages and Banns, 1754-1939 transcript supplied by Matthew. Helen Waterhouse, female, age 19, born about 1835, married Richard Rhead on 10 Apr 1854 at Birmingham St Stephen, Warwickshire; father John Waterhouse. This detailed parish transcript independently supports the earlier select-marriages index."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RHEAD_1891_UPPER_PENN_CENSUS",
      "title": "1891 England Census: Richard and Ellen Rhead household, Upper Penn, Staffordshire",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry 1891 England Census transcript supplied by Matthew. Ellen Rhead, wife, age 55, born about 1836 Hanford, Staffordshire; spouse Richard Rhead, 58; children Ruth Elizabeth Rhead, 33, and Bernal Bright Rhead, 22; residence Bradmore, Upper Penn, Staffordshire; Wolverhampton registration district, Wombourn sub-district, ED 7, piece 2225, folio 85. Household also includes James Thomas Stewart, 17, whose relationship was not supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_1883_1943",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Alfred Percy Davies, 1883-1943",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: Alfred Percy Davies, born 16 Oct 1883 in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England; died 24 Dec 1943 in Shrewsbury; father of Alfreda M Davies. Exact dates and places should be distinguished from the separate civil-registration index."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BIRTH_1883",
      "title": "England and Wales Civil Registration Birth Index: Alfred Percy Davies, Q4 1883",
      "type": "civil_registration_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Civil birth index supplied by Matthew. Alfred Percy Davies registered Oct-Nov-Dec 1883 in Atcham registration district, Shropshire, volume 6a, page 650. Registration quarter is not an exact birth date, and Atcham registration district is not necessarily the precise birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GRO_ALFRED_DAVIES_KEZIA_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_1907",
      "title": "England and Wales Civil Registration Marriage Index: Alfred Percy Davies and Kezia Thomas, Q2 1907",
      "type": "civil_registration_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Civil marriage index supplied by Matthew. Atcham registration district, Apr-May-Jun 1907, volume 6a page 1448. Page names Alfred Percy Davies, Emily Eliza Hotchkins, Thomas Albert Shephard, and Kezia Thomas. The index page alone does not pair spouses, but the 1911 and 1921 censuses independently identify Alfred and Kezia as married."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DAVIES_1911_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
      "title": "1911 England Census: Alfred Percy and Kezia Davies household, Shrewsbury St Julian",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Alfred Percy Davies, 27, born about 1884 Shrewsbury, married head, plumber and hot water fitter, at Baldwyn Cottage, School Lane, Shrewsbury St Julian; registration district 349, St Mary sub-district, ED 12, piece 16079. Household: Kezia Davies 28, David Livingstone Davies 3, and Alfreda Margarat Elizabeth Davies, age not supplied in excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DAVIES_1901_SHREWSBURY_ST_JULIAN_CENSUS",
      "title": "1901 England Census: Frederick and Maria Davies household, Shrewsbury St Julian",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry 1901 England Census transcript supplied by Matthew. Frederick Davies, 56, born about 1845 Berriew, Montgomeryshire, male married head; spouse Maria Davies, 54; residence Shrewsbury St Julian, Bellevue Holy Trinity ecclesiastical parish, Atcham registration district, St Mary sub-district, ED 15, piece 2537, folio 134, page 21, schedule 140. Household also lists Arthur J 20, Alfred S 17, Robert L 15, Francis J 15, Albert N 12, Louie S 11, and Thomas E Davies 7. Child relationships are inferred from surname, ages, and household structure because individual relationship fields were not supplied. Alfred S is treated as a likely index transcription of Alfred Percy based on age and family continuity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DAVIES_1891_SHREWSBURY_ST_MARY_CENSUS",
      "title": "1891 England Census: Frederick and Maria Davies household, Shrewsbury St Mary",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry 1891 England Census transcript supplied by Matthew. Maria Davies, wife, age 45, born about 1846 Bradford on Avon; spouse Frederick Davies, 40; residence Shrewsbury St Mary, Shropshire, Atcham registration district, St Mary sub-district, ED 2, piece 2109, folio 26. Explicitly listed children: Arthur J 10, Walter H 9, Alfred L 7, Robert L 5, and Francis 5. Household also includes Albert N 2, Louis S 1, and George Weldene 60; relationships for these three were not supplied. Frederick age 40 conflicts with his 1845 birth and 1901 age 56 and is treated as a census/transcription discrepancy. Alfred initials L in 1891 and S in 1901 conflict with independently supported Percy."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_WILLIAM_PETERS_BAPTISM_1802",
      "title": "England Select Births and Christenings: Wm Peters Hanny, 1802",
      "type": "baptism_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Wm Peters Hanny, male, born 18 Jan 1802, baptized 21 Feb 1802 at Wesleyan Methodist, Bradford on Avon, Wiltshire; father Wm Hanny, mother Eliz.; FHL films 0816591 (RG4 2985) and 0816592 (RG4 2986)."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GRO_HANNY_CORNISH_MARRIAGE_1838",
      "title": "England and Wales Civil Registration Marriage Index: William Peters Hanny and Elizabeth Cornish, Q1 1838",
      "type": "civil_registration_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Civil marriage index supplied by Matthew. William Peters Hanny and Elizabeth Cornish are the two names on the page for Bradford on Avon registration district, Jan-Feb-Mar 1838, volume 8 page 337. Registration quarter does not establish an exact wedding date or venue."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_1861_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1861 England Census: William Peter Haney and Maria Haney, Bradford on Avon",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. William Peter Haney, male, age 59, head, born about 1802 Bradford, Wiltshire; residence Bradford on Avon, Trinity ecclesiastical parish, Bradford town, Bradford on Avon registration district, Bradford North Western sub-district, ED 6, schedule 44, piece 1299, folio 78, page 7. Household also contains Maria Haney, 15. Maria's relationship was not included in the supplied excerpt; Hanny/Haney is treated as an index spelling variant."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_1802_1894",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: William Peters Hanny, 1802-1894",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: born 18 Jan 1802 at Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire; died Sep 1894 at Bradford on Avon. Supplied location wording also included Somerset, but Bradford-on-Avon is recorded canonically in Wiltshire. Birth is independently supported by the baptism index; death still requires a direct registration or burial record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_1851_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1851 England Census: William and Elizabeth Hanney household, Bradford-on-Avon",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry 1851 England Census transcript supplied by Matthew. Elizabeth Hanney, female, age 46, wife of William Hanney, born about 1805 Bradford, Wiltshire; residence Bradford civil parish, Bradford-on-Avon registration district, Bradford South Eastern sub-district, ED 01b, schedule 104, piece 1841, folio 327, page 24. Household: William Hanney 49, Elizabeth 46, Henery 12, Anna 10, Edwin 9, and Maria 4. Individual child relationship fields were not included in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_1802_1856",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Elizabeth Cornish, about 1802-1856",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: Elizabeth Cornish born about 1802 at Hilperton; died 25 May 1856 at Bradford-on-Avon. The supplied death location included Somerset and Wiltshire; canonical place is recorded as Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire. Birth conflicts with the 1851 census estimate about 1805 and birthplace Bradford and requires a baptism record to resolve."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_HANNY_1771_1837",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: William Hanny, 1771-1837",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: William Hanny born 2 Feb 1771 at Conkwell, Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire; died 7 Mar 1837 at Bradford-on-Avon. Exact vital dates still require direct baptism, death, or burial records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_PETERS_MARRIAGE_1795",
      "title": "Wiltshire marriage and banns: William Hanny and Elizabeth Peters, 25 Jun 1795",
      "type": "parish_marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Two Ancestry Wiltshire marriage index transcripts supplied by Matthew. William Hanny/Hanney married Elizabeth Peters on 25 Jun 1795 at Bradford-on-Avon, both resident in the parish; document type banns. Collections: Wiltshire Marriages 1538-1837 and Church of England Marriages and Banns 1754-1924."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_CHELSEA_PENSION_1804",
      "title": "Royal Hospital Chelsea pension register: Willm Hanny, 14th Foot, 1804",
      "type": "military_record_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Willm Hanny, pension age 31, born about 1773 Bradford, Wiltshire; pension date 16 Apr 1804; regiment 14 Foot. Age is approximately two years later than the profile birth date 1771."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_14TH_FOOT_SERVICE_1803",
      "title": "Regimental register: William Hanny, 14th Foot, 1803",
      "type": "military_record_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. William Hanny, age 30, born about 1773 Bradford, Wiltshire; military date 25 Oct 1803; 14th Foot Soldiers, 1st Battalion. Consistent with the 1804 Chelsea pension record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_CHILD_RECORD",
      "title": "Wiltshire Church of England record: William and Elizabeth Hanny, child Sarah",
      "type": "church_record_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew names William Hanny, spouse Elizabeth Hanny, and child Sarah Hanny. The supplied excerpt does not include event date or place; collection title is Wiltshire Church of England Births and Baptisms, 1813-1924, which is chronologically inconsistent with the candidate Sarah Hanny born 1798 and requires the full record image before identity is certain."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELIZABETH_PETERS_1765_1847",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Elizabeth Peters, 1765-1847",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: Elizabeth Peters born 2 Jun 1765 at Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire; died 13 Mar 1847 at Bradford-on-Avon. Exact dates require direct baptism and death/burial confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GRO_ELIZABETH_PETERS_DEATH_1847_CANDIDATE",
      "title": "England and Wales Civil Registration Death Index: Elizabeth Peters, Q1 1847 - candidate identity",
      "type": "civil_registration_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Civil death index supplied by Matthew. Elizabeth Peters, death registered Jan-Feb-Mar 1847 at Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire, volume 8 page 255. Identity with William Hanny's widow is uncertain because she married in 1795 and would ordinarily be recorded under Hanny/Hanney rather than Peters."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_SARAH_SELECT_BIRTHS",
      "title": "England Select Births and Christenings: Sarah Hanney, child of William and Elizabeth",
      "type": "baptism_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew names mother Elizabeth, spouse William Hanney, and child Sarah Hanney. The supplied excerpt omits event date and place; identity with candidate Sarah Hanny born 9 May 1798 remains probable rather than definitive."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CHARLES_HANNEY_1733_1797",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Charles Hanney, 1733-1797",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: Charles Hanney born about 1733 at Winsley, Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire; died 1797 at Bradford-on-Avon. Burial index dated 8 Jan 1798 is compatible with a late-1797 death but does not establish the exact death date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNY_WAINE_MARRIAGE_1765",
      "title": "Wiltshire marriage and banns: Charles Hanny and Catherine Waine, 8 Jul 1765",
      "type": "parish_marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Three compatible marriage index transcripts supplied by Matthew. Charles Hanny married Catherine/Catharine Waine on 8 Jul 1765 at Winsley, Wiltshire; both resident in Winsley/of the parish; document type banns. FHL film 943590 in England Select Marriages."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CHARLES_HANNEY_BURIAL_1798",
      "title": "Wiltshire parish burial: Charles Hanney, 8 Jan 1798",
      "type": "burial_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Wiltshire Church of England Baptisms, Marriages and Burials transcript supplied by Matthew. Charles Hanney buried 8 Jan 1798 at Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire. Burial date is not necessarily death date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_CATHERINE_WAINE_1743_1774",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Catherine Waine, 1743-1774",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: Catherine Waine born about 1743 at Bradford-on-Avon, Wiltshire; died 1774 at Winsley, Wiltshire. Marriage to Charles Hanny on 8 Jul 1765 is independently supported by three index transcripts; birth and death require direct baptism or burial evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_G_GOBBLE_1818_1899",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: John G Gobble, 1818-1899",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: John G Gobble born 1 Nov 1818 in Washington County, Virginia; died 8 Sep 1899 in Washington County, Virginia. Birth matches the existing GEDCOM exactly; death requires a direct record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_MARTIN_VINES_PHELPS_1796_1882",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Martin Vines Phelps, 1796-1882",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: Martin Vines Phelps born 1796 in Russell County, Virginia and died 29 Aug 1882 in Holston, Washington County, Virginia. The date and place of death are independently supported by a Virginia death index."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHELPS_CAUNTIS_MARRIAGE_1820",
      "title": "Virginia marriage index: Martin Phelps and Eda Cauntis, 17 Feb 1820",
      "type": "marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Virginia Select Marriages transcript supplied by Matthew. Martin Phelps married Eda Cauntis on 17 Feb 1820 in Washington County, Virginia; FHL film 34389, page 360."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1820_CENSUS",
      "title": "1820 United States Census: Marten Philips household, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. Household contained one male 16-25, one female 16-25, and one female 45 or older. The record does not name household members other than the head."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1830_CENSUS",
      "title": "1830 United States Census: Martin Phelps household, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. Household contained two boys aged 5-9, two girls aged 5-9, a man aged 30-39, and a woman aged 20-29. Children are not named."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1850_CENSUS",
      "title": "1850 United States Census: Martin Phelps household, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. Marton Phelps, age 51, Virginia-born farmer, lived with Malinda 30, Hardin 17, John 16, Margaret 7, and Martin 5. The 1850 schedule does not state relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1860_CENSUS",
      "title": "1860 United States Census: Martin Phelps household, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. Martin Phelps, age 64, Virginia-born farmer, lived with Malinda 34, Martin, Virginia 7, William 5, and Newton 4. Relationships are inferred from the household, not stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_1880_CENSUS",
      "title": "1880 United States Census: Martin and Malinda Phelps, North Fork, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. Martin Phelps, age 84, born North Carolina, married farmer and blind, was head with wife Malinda 54, Virginia F Phelps 25, and Nuten Phelps 22. The North Carolina birthplace conflicts with the Virginia birthplaces in earlier records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_DEATH_1882",
      "title": "Virginia death index: Martin Phelps, 29 Aug 1882",
      "type": "death_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Virginia Deaths and Burials Index transcript supplied by Matthew. Martin Phelps died 29 Aug 1882 at Holston, Washington County, Virginia, age 85; born about 1797 in Washington County, farmer, married, spouse Malinda."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARTIN_PHELPS_CHILD_RECORDS",
      "title": "Virginia marriage and death indexes naming children of Martin Phelps",
      "type": "relationship_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcripts supplied by Matthew name Martin Phelps and spouse Malinda as parents of Martin S Phelps and Margaret Phelps. A later Virginia death record names spouse Cauntis and child John P Phelps."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_SARAH_E_PHELPS_GOBBLE",
      "title": "Find a Grave index: Sarah E Phelps Gobble, 1824-1899",
      "type": "compiled_memorial_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry Find a Grave index transcript supplied by Matthew. It gives Sarah E Gobble born 17 Nov 1824 in Russell County, Virginia; died 6 Feb 1899 at Houston, Texas County, Missouri; burial there; father Martin Vines Phelps; spouse John G Gobble; and children Eglatine Scott, Mary Catherine Aldridge, Robert Ireson Gobble, and George Washington Gobble. Memorial relationships are compiled evidence and are not equivalent to contemporary vital or parentage records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_MALINDA_PHELPS",
      "title": "Census and death-index profile: Malinda, wife of Martin Phelps",
      "type": "compiled_census_identity",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Malinda appears with Martin in the supplied 1850, 1860, and 1880 census transcripts and is named as his spouse in the 1882 death index. Her age implies birth about 1820 in 1850 but about 1826 in both 1860 and 1880; maiden surname is unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRALL_1881_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1881 England Census: Richard and Sarah Morrall household, Wolverhampton",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. At 23 Derry Street, Richard Morrall 39 and Sarah Morrall 38 headed a household including daughter Rosey B Morrall, age 7, born Wolverhampton, plus Esther H 17, Fanny 16, Sarah H 13, Catherine E 11, Louisa A 9, Violet F 4, and Lily M 1. The record explicitly labels Rosey as daughter and names both parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRALL_1891_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1891 England Census: Richard and Sarah Morrall household, Wolverhampton",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Richard Morrall 49 and Sarah Morrall 48 lived with Catherine 20, Alice 18, Rosa, Violet 14, and Lillie 11. Rosa is transcribed as age 76, birth year 1815, and daughter; that age is impossible relative to the parents and conflicts with her exact 1875 birth and 1881 age 7. It is treated as a likely transcription or reading error for age 16."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_BAPTISM_1875",
      "title": "Staffordshire baptism indexes: Rosie Beatrice Morrall, 9 May 1875",
      "type": "baptism_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcripts supplied by Matthew from England Select Births and Christenings, the England and Wales Christening Index, and Staffordshire Church of England baptisms. Rosie Beatrice Morrall was baptised 9 May 1875 at Saint Luke, Wolverhampton; father Richard Morrall and mother Sarah Morrall are explicitly named."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CIVIL_BIRTH_1875",
      "title": "Civil birth index: Rose Beatrice Morrall, Wolverhampton, Q2 1875",
      "type": "civil_registration_birth_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Civil Registration Birth Index transcript supplied by Matthew. Rose Beatrice Morrall's birth was registered April-June 1875 at Wolverhampton, consistent with the separately sourced exact birth date 6 Apr 1875."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROSA_MORRALL_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1899",
      "title": "Church marriage: Rosa Beatrice Morrall and Bernal Bright Rhead, 5 Jun 1899",
      "type": "parish_marriage_record",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire Church of England marriage transcript supplied by Matthew. Rosa Beatrice Morrall, born about 1875 and resident at 44 Cook Street, married Bernal Bright Rhead on 5 Jun 1899; her father is explicitly named Richard Morrall."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RHEAD_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1901 England Census: Bernal and Rosa Rhead household, Wolverhampton",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry comparison transcript supplied by Matthew. Rosa B Rhead, born about 1876 Wolverhampton, lived in Wolverhampton with spouse Bernal Rhead and child Edward R Rhead."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_BRIGHT_RHEAD_1868_1934",
      "title": "Ancestry profile and timeline: Bernal Bright Rhead, 1868-1934",
      "type": "compiled_profile_timeline",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile and timeline supplied by Matthew. Birth Jan 1868 in Birmingham is reported with three sources; death 1 Nov 1934 at \"Sundane Roadt, Shrewsbury\". The street wording is retained exactly and requires verification. Timeline also reports Philadelphia arrivals in 1890 and 1904, the latter with son Bernal Albert, followed by return to England; marriage contract 7 May 1899 and church marriage 5 Jun 1899; residence at 116 Dudley Road, Wolverhampton with wife Rosa and baby Edward; and work as a self-employed/employing tailor from home."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_BERNAL_ROSA_CHILDREN",
      "title": "Ancestry profile timeline: children of Bernal Bright and Rosa Beatrice Rhead",
      "type": "compiled_profile_timeline",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Timeline supplied by Matthew names children Edward Richard, born 22 Nov 1900 Wolverhampton, died 1950; Bernal Albert, born Jul 1902 Wolverhampton, died Jul 1931 Derby; George Ernest, born 1905 Wolverhampton, died 1943; Amy Rosa, born 28 Feb 1907 Wolverhampton, died 1988; John Edgar, born 1 Jan 1909 Wellington, died 1975; Frank Stretton, born 25 Sep 1911 Church Stretton, died 1969; and Alfred Samuel, born 26 Sep 1913 Little Stretton, died 2006. The timeline spells George as Earnest and Church Stretton as Setton; established forms are used in structured fields."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_DEATH_1968",
      "title": "Ancestry profile timeline: Rosa Beatrice Rhead, 1875-1968",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Bernal Bright Rhead timeline supplied by Matthew labels spouse Rosa Beatrice Morrall/Rhead as 1875-1968. Exact death date and place were not supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_SARAH_POYNTER_FAMILY",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Sarah Poynter family, about 1817",
      "type": "compiled_profile_timeline",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile and timeline supplied by Matthew. Sarah Poynter born about 1817; parents Richard Poyner 1759-1833 and Mary Deane 1758-1835; sons Richard Rhead 1833-1900 and George Rhead born 1837; later spouse Thomas Botton born 1826, marriage about 1851, and son Thomas Botton born about 1849. The 1817 estimate conflicts with existing FamilySearch 1814. Botton relationships and George require direct records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_FAMILY_DATA_JOHN_1818_1899",
      "title": "Family Data Collection: John G Gobble, 1818-1899",
      "type": "compiled_family_data",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. John G Gobble born 1 Nov 1818 Washington County, Virginia; parents William Gobble and Elizabeth (maiden surname not supplied); married Sarah Phelps 16 Sep 1840 in Washington County; died 8 Sep 1899 in Washington County. This is a compiled collection rather than a contemporary record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HENDERSON_1850_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1850 United States Census: Robert and Mary Henderson, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Robt Henderson 28, Virginia-born cooper, lived with Marga Henderson 22 in District 67, Washington County, dwelling/family 255. Marga is treated as a probable transcription/name variant for Mary, supported by later continuity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HENDERSON_1880_SALTVILLE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1880 United States Census: Robert Henderson household, Saltville, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Robt Henderson 56, Virginia-born widowed laborer, lived at Saltville, Washington County, with Samuel 20, Lowcresa 18, Amanda 16, and James 18. Saltville is associated with both Washington and Smyth County in supplied records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HENDERSON_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_RECORDS",
      "title": "Virginia marriage, birth, and death records naming children of Robert and Mary Henderson",
      "type": "relationship_records",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcripts supplied by Matthew. A Virginia marriage index names Robt and Mary Henderson as parents of Connally Henderson; a Virginia birth register names Robt and Mary Henderson as parents of Mary E Henderson; and a later death record names Bob Henderson and Mary McNew as parents of Sam Henderson."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ROBERT_HENDERSON_1824_1880",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Robert Henderson, 1824-1880",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew gives birth 1824 and death 1880 at Saltville, Smyth County, Virginia. Census records give birth estimates 1822 and 1824 and locate him in Washington County, including Saltville in 1880. Exact death date was not supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VA_REBECCA_TALLEY_CONLEY_HENDERSON_MARRIAGE_1876",
      "title": "Virginia marriage register: Rebecca S Talley and Connaely Henderson, 25 Sep 1876",
      "type": "marriage_register",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Virginia Marriage Registers, 1853-1935 transcript supplied by Matthew. Rebecca S Talley, white, age 19, born about 1857, married Connaely Henderson on 25 Sep 1876 in Washington County, Virginia; license issued there. The ceremony was performed by A Sittle. Her parents are explicitly named Evan Talley and Delia Talley. Connaely is treated as a spelling/index variant of Conley Litchfield Henderson."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1870_DELIA_WILLIAM_HENDERSON_ABINGDON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1870 United States Census: William and Delia Henderson household, Abingdon, Virginia",
      "type": "census_candidate_identity",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Wm Henderson 49 and Delia Henderson 43, born about 1827 Virginia, lived in Abingdon, Washington County with Malissa 19, Julious C 17, Rybson B 15, Rebecca Henderson 13, Jas M 11, Mary 6, Robert Lee 4, and Gaspar P 2/12. This may be Delia Talley remarried to William, with Rebecca Talley enumerated under a stepfather's surname, but no marriage or earlier census currently links the identities."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1860_EVAN_DELA_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1860 United States Census: Evan and Dela Talley household, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew indexes the surname Sally: Evan Sally 30, North Carolina-born day laborer, Dela Sally 28, Amanda 9, Susan 2, and James 5/12 in Western District, Washington County, dwelling 478/family 467. Child relationship records and the later Talley profile make Talley the likely intended surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_TALLEY_CHILD_RELATIONSHIP_INDEXES",
      "title": "Virginia marriage indexes naming children of Evan and Delia Talley",
      "type": "relationship_indexes",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcripts supplied by Matthew explicitly name Evan Talley and Delia Talley as parents of Rebecca S Talley; A.L. Tally and Delia Tally as parents of James M Talley; and Evan L Talley and Delia Talley as parents of Amanda J Talley. A.L. is treated as an index variant or error for Evan L based on the matching spouse and household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_EVAN_L_TALLEY_FAMILY",
      "title": "Geneanet profile: Evan L Talley family",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet transcript supplied by Matthew gives Evan L Talley born 1830 North Carolina, parents Peyton R Tally and Holly Hood, spouse Delia Faddis, and child Rebecca Susan \"Becky Sue\" Talley. These details are compiled-tree evidence; maiden surname and earlier parents require direct records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_EVAN_L_TALLEY_1823_BEFORE_1866",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Evan L Talley, 1823-before 1866",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew gives Evan L Talley born 1823 in Virginia and died before 1866. This conflicts with the 1860 census and Geneanet estimate of about 1830, born North Carolina. The pre-1866 death is compatible with Delia appearing as William Henderson's wife by 1870 but remains profile-derived."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1885_1964",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Edward \"Eddie\" Alderson Henderson, 1885-1964",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details previously supplied by Matthew identify Edward \"Eddie\" Alderson Henderson, 1885-1964. Henderson Family 1 independently names Edward Alderson as a child of Conley Litchfield Henderson. Exact birth and death dates and places remain unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1810_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1810 United States Census: George McNew household, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. George McNew household in Washington County contained 13 free white persons, including a male 45 or over and female 45 or over, with six members under 16. Household age bands do not identify individuals."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1820 United States Census: George McNew Senior household, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. George McNew Senior household contained 12 free white persons and one enslaved female aged 26-44; three people engaged in agriculture. The enslavement is explicitly preserved as part of the household record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_1840_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1840 United States Census: George McNew household, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. Washington County household included a male and female aged 70-79 and four younger free white household members; two people employed in agriculture. The age band is compatible with George born 1763."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_1715_1791",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: William Edward McKnew, 1715-1791",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew: William Edward McKnew born 14 Aug 1715 at Saint Johns Parish, Prince George's County, Maryland; died Dec 1791 Washington County, Virginia. Profile labels him a private in infantry during the Revolutionary War, but no military record citation was supplied, so service remains unverified."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_WILLIAM_EDWARD_MCKNEW_CONFLATED",
      "title": "Ancestry timeline: William Edward McKnew, internally conflicting",
      "type": "conflicting_compiled_timeline",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Timeline supplied by Matthew repeats birth 14 Aug 1715 and death Dec 1791; mother Sarah Ann Marlow died 28 Mar 1727; spouse Mary Eckless Berry. It contains duplicate marriage years 1730, 1735, and 1751, a Roxbury Massachusetts marriage, duplicate children including Shadrack and Elisha, George birth 1762 conflicting with direct 1763 evidence, a 1794 residence after death, and an impossible 1842 marriage. Only compatible facts are retained."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_JR_1680_1715",
      "title": "Ancestry timeline: Jeremiah Macknew Jr., 1680-1715, partially conflated",
      "type": "conflicting_compiled_timeline",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Timeline supplied by Matthew gives birth 1680 Charles County, Maryland; marriage to Sarah Ann Marlow 11 Aug 1708 Prince George's County; children Mary Lucy 1708, Anne Nancy 1711, Edward Marley 1713, and William 1715; death 16 Jan 1715 Prince George's County. A 1668 Maryland arrival predates his birth and an 1812 military event occurs 97 years after death; both are rejected as misattached."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_TIMELINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_SR_1640_1720",
      "title": "Ancestry timeline: Jeremiah Macknew Sr., 1640-1720, duplicate-child conflict",
      "type": "conflicting_compiled_timeline",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Timeline supplied by Matthew gives birth 1640 Edinburgh, marriage to Phillis in Scotland about 1660, children including John Howard, Anthony, Lomax, and Jeremiah, and death 24 Apr 1720 Prince George's County, Maryland. It lists two simultaneously living sons named Jeremiah born about 1675 and 1680, indicating conflation. Only the existing 1680 Jeremiah Jr link is retained."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JEREMIAH_H_MACKNEW_1640_1720",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Jeremiah H Macknew, 1640-1720, suffix conflict",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew gives Jeremiah H Macknew Jr., born 1640 Edinburgh, died 24 Apr 1720 Prince George's County, Maryland. Dates identify the older Jeremiah in this database. The Jr. suffix conflicts with the separate son Jeremiah Jr. born 1680 and is not adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1680_1715",
      "title": "Geneanet Community Trees Index: Jeremiah MacKnew family",
      "type": "compiled_tree_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet transcript supplied by Matthew. Jeremiah MacKnew born 1680 Charles County, Maryland; died 16 Jan 1715 Prince George's County; married Sarah Ann Marlow on 1 Aug 1708; father Jeremiah MacKneugh; mother Phillis W O'Jeremiah; children William McNew, Anne Nancy MacKnew, Edward Marley McNew, and Mary Lucy McNew. Marriage date conflicts by ten days with an Ancestry timeline giving 11 Aug 1708."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1668_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
      "title": "Passenger and Immigration Lists Index: Jeremiah Macknew, Maryland arrival 1668",
      "type": "immigration_land_patent_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Jeremiah Macknew arrived Maryland in 1668; primary immigrant Macknew, Jeremiah; source publication code 8510. Annotation says the index derives from a 1917 manuscript by Arthur Trader of the Maryland Land Commission and land notes. Bibliography: Gust Skordas, The Early Settlers of Maryland, an index compiled from land-patent records, 1633-1680. No age or origin is supplied; chronology assigns it to Jeremiah born about 1640."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARYLAND_JEREMIAH_MACKMERE_PHILISE_MARRIAGE_1670",
      "title": "Maryland compiled marriage index: Jeremiah MacKmere and Philise, Jan 1670",
      "type": "compiled_marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry Maryland Compiled Marriage Index transcript supplied by Matthew. Jeremiah MacKmere married Philise in Jan 1670. Name, chronology, and Maryland location make this a plausible record for Jeremiah Macknew and Phillis, but the exact spelling and original record should be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_1610_1716_CANDIDATE",
      "title": "Geneanet profile: Jeremiah MacKneugh and Rebecca Schratern family",
      "type": "compiled_tree_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet transcripts supplied by Matthew identify Jeremiah MacKneugh, born 1610 in Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland, reportedly died 1716 in Edinburgh, as spouse of Rebecca Schratern, born 1610 in Midlothian, and father of Jeremiah MacKneugh. A related profile names an older Jeremiah MacKneugh as his father. This compiled-tree evidence fits the existing intermediate generation I131/I132 but is not a contemporary parish, probate, or civil record. The 1668 Maryland arrival belongs provisionally to the later about-1640 immigrant I129; Annapolis National Cemetery records are rejected as a much later namesake."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_PHILLIS_W_OJEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH",
      "title": "Geneanet profile: Phillis W O'Jeremiah/Mackneugh, 1642-1700",
      "type": "compiled_tree_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet transcript supplied by Matthew. Phillis W O'Jeremiah, female, born 1642 Edinburgh, married Jeremiah MacKneugh Jan 1670 in Maryland, died 1700 Prince George's County, Maryland, and had child Jeremiah MacKnew. A separate profile gives birth about 1645 at Currie, Midlothian. O'Jeremiah is retained as an alias claim, not a proven maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_1674_MARYLAND_ARRIVAL",
      "title": "Passenger and Immigration Lists Index: Phillis Mackneugh, Maryland arrival 1674",
      "type": "immigration_land_patent_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Phillis Mackneugh arrived Maryland in 1674; primary immigrant Mackneugh, Phillis; source publication code 8510. The index derives from Arthur Trader's Maryland Land Commission manuscript and Gust Skordas, The Early Settlers of Maryland, compiled from land-patent records. The 1674 index date follows the compiled Jan 1670 Maryland marriage, so it may reflect a patent/recording date rather than literal first arrival."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WARREN_TREE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1640",
      "title": "Warren Family Tree: Jeremiah MacKnew or MacKnue, about 1640",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry tree comparison supplied by Matthew. Jeremiah MacKnew or MacKnue born about 1640 Scotland, died Prince George's County, Maryland; children Jeremiah MacKnew, Lomax MacKnew, and John Howard MacKnew. No spouse, exact dates, or contemporary source citation was supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_JEREMIAH_MACKNEUGH_ABT_1558",
      "title": "Geneanet and Webster family trees: early MacKnew/MacKneugh chain",
      "type": "compiled_tree_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet and Webster Family Tree transcripts supplied by Matthew identify Jeremiah MacKneugh, male, born about 1558, reportedly died at Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland, name a child Jermiah MacKnew, and claim Matthew Macknew/MacKneugh as his father. Webster dates Matthew about 1538 to about 1610 at Edinburgh, resolving the age contradiction in the imported GEDCOM, which had Matthew born 1555. Webster also lists three apparent duplicate Jeremiah children, so the family structure remains vulnerable to conflation. No parish, probate, or other contemporary record was supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_EARLY_SETTLERS_MARYLAND_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH",
      "title": "The New Early Settlers of Maryland: Phillis Mackneugh",
      "type": "archival_land_record_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew cites The New Early Settlers of Maryland by Dr. Carson Gibb, with one entry for Phillis Mackneugh, using a resource supplied by the Maryland State Archives. This materially supports her presence and recorded Mackneugh surname in colonial Maryland, but the excerpt does not itself state her husband, children, birth, or marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PROFILE_PHILLIS_MACKNEUGH_JEREMIAH_FAMILY",
      "title": "Compiled profile: Phillis Mackneugh and Jeremiah Macknew I family",
      "type": "compiled_tree_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile transcript supplied by Matthew describes Phillis Mackneugh, formerly Macknew and also called O'Jeremiah with those names marked uncertain; parents unknown; wife of Jeremiah Macknew I; mother of John Howard Macknew and Jeremiah Macknew II. It reports marriage in Scotland in 1660. That marriage claim conflicts with the compiled Maryland marriage-index entry for Jeremiah MacKmere and Philise in January 1670. The profile cites The New Early Settlers of Maryland, which supports Phillis's Maryland presence but does not, from the supplied excerpt, directly prove these relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOYMERAC_TREE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1722",
      "title": "Goymerac Family Tree: John Draper Hargis family",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Tree comparison supplied by Matthew identifies John Draper Hargis/Argus, born 1722 at Washington Parish, Westmoreland, Virginia, died 1779 in the area later called Christian County, Kentucky; parents John Draper Hargis and Grace Elizabeth Boswell; children Amelia Mildred \"Millie\" Hargis, John Draper Hargis, Elizabeth, Thomas, Samuel, Whiteside, Mary Hammon, and Benjamin Hargis. This agrees with parts of the Geneanet profile but may share copied tree data. The modern death jurisdiction is anachronistic for 1779."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_AMELIA_HARGIS_1765_FAMILY",
      "title": "Geneanet Community Trees Index: Amelia Mildred Hargis family",
      "type": "compiled_tree_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet transcript supplied by Matthew gives Amelia Mildred Hargis, born 26 Dec 1765 and died 1 Apr 1860 in Washington County, Virginia; married George Albert McNew in 1781 in Washington County; father John Hargis; mother Elizabeth Freelove; children David, Amelia, Anne Nancy, Celia, Churchwell, Elizabeth, and George Albert McNew. Elizabeth Freelove conflicts with Goymerac's Ann Elizabeth Whiteside as Amelia's mother. Washington County was formed after Amelia's 1765 birth, so the birthplace is a retrospective geographic label."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY_GRAYSON_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1850 United States Census: Evans and Adelia Tally household, Grayson County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew: Evans Tally, male laborer, age 27, born Virginia, and inferred spouse Adelia Tally, age 18, in District 19, Grayson County, Virginia, dwelling and family 339, line 26. Adelia's age progresses exactly to Dela Sally age 28 in the 1860 Washington County household. The matching couple names and later child relationship indexes strongly support one family despite Evan's conflicting 1860 age 30 and North Carolina birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1880_DAVID_SHORTS_GEORGE_OBEDIENCE_HOUSEHOLD",
      "title": "1880 United States Census: David Shorts in George and Obedience Shorts household, Speedwell, Wythe County, Virginia",
      "type": "census_candidate_identity",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew: David Shorts, born about 1868 in Virginia, appears as a child of George Shorts in Speedwell, Wythe County, with wife Obedience Shorts and siblings Floyd, John, Cory, Laura, Henry, Perry, Nancy, and William. David Kitzmiller Shortt's direct death record gives birth 15 Apr 1870 and parents George Shortt and Susan Jones, while the 1870 census places David K Shorts with George W and Susan Shorts. This strongly identifies the 1880 David despite the age estimate. Obedience, age 19 in 1880, cannot be mother of the older children and is treated as a later wife/household spouse, not David's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1870_DAVID_K_SHORTS_GEORGE_SUSAN_HOUSEHOLD",
      "title": "1870 United States Census: David K Shorts in George W and Susan Shorts household, Smyth County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew identifies David K Shorts in 1870 at Marion, Smyth County, Virginia, with father George W Shorts, mother Susan Shorts, and siblings Henry, Floyd, Perry, and John. The child's birth transcription is incomplete but the middle initial, parents, siblings, and later death record identify this as David Kitzmiller Shortt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VA_DEATH_DAVID_KITZMILLER_SHORTT_1938",
      "title": "Virginia death record: David Kitzmiller Shortt, 8 May 1938",
      "type": "official_death_record",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Virginia death-record transcript supplied by Matthew identifies David Kitzmiller Shortt, born 15 Apr 1870, died 8 May 1938 at Abingdon, Washington County, Virginia; father George Shortt; mother Susan Jones; spouse Tiney Shortt. This direct record resolves David's identity, exact birth and death, parents, and spouse surname/name variants."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PROFILE_SARAH_SALLY_PHELPS_GOBBLE_1825_1899",
      "title": "Compiled profile: Sarah Sally Phelps, wife of John Gobble",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile transcript supplied by Matthew calls her Sarah \"Sally\" Phelps, born about 1825, wife of John Gobble, and gives death 8 Sep 1899. The date conflicts with the Find a Grave memorial's 6 Feb 1899 death and exactly matches John G Gobble's reported 8 Sep 1899 death, creating a substantial copied-spouse-date risk. Sally is accepted as an alias; the alternative death remains unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1930_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1930 United States Census: George and Florence Fricke household, East Orange, New Jersey",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "NARA/Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew: Florence Fricke, born about 1891 in Ireland, arrived 1920, resident East Orange, Essex County, New Jersey; spouse George Fricke; children George Fricke, Albert R. Fricke, and Edna K. Fricke. This matches the existing George Fricke and Florence Gibson family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1940_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRECKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1940 United States Census: George and Florence Frecke household, East Orange, New Jersey",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew: Florence Frecke, born about 1892 in Northern Ireland, resident East Orange in 1935 and 1940; spouse George Frecke; children Russell Frecke and Edna Frecke. Frecke is treated as an index spelling variant of Fricke. Russell is identified as Albert R. Fricke using his middle name because Albert appears in 1930 and Russell in 1940 in the same household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CLARKE_TREE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE",
      "title": "Clarke Beattie Davison Pardy tree: Florence Gibson Fricke family",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Tree comparison supplied by Matthew gives Florence Gibson born 14 May 1890 in County Monaghan, died 7 Mar 1960 in Essex County, New Jersey; father John Gibson; mother Sarah \"Sadie\" Clarke; children George Gibson Fricke, Russell/Albert Russell Fricke, Edna Kohl Fricke, and a duplicate George Fricke entry. Birth and death conflict by one year/day and county with census-supported memorial values. Duplicate George and Russell/Albert entries are consolidated into existing people."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1911_IRELAND_JOHN_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
      "title": "1911 Ireland Census: John Gibson household, Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan",
      "type": "census",
      "url": "https://api-census.nationalarchives.ie/census/query?census_year=1911&surname__icontains=Gibson&townland__icontains=Aghnasedagh&county=Monaghan",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The National Archives of Ireland census return places John Gibson, 60, widowed Presbyterian farmer, in house 14 at Aghnasedagh with Minnie 24, David 22, and Florence 19. It directly continues the 1901 household and confirms that Florence remained in Ireland on 2 April 1911."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NY_PASSENGER_JOHN_GILSON_FLORENCE_GIBSON",
      "title": "New York passenger list: John Gilson/Gibson associated with child Florence Gibson",
      "type": "passenger_list_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew indexes John Gilson, residence Dugherazay, Minaghan, with child Florence Gibson. The spellings plausibly represent Gibson and Aghnasedagh, Monaghan. The excerpt contains no arrival date, age, ship, or destination detail, so it supports family/locality but does not resolve Florence's 1910 versus 1920 immigration-year conflict."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_IRELAND_MARRIAGE_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_1883",
      "title": "Ireland civil marriage register: John Gibson and Sarah Clark, 10 October 1883",
      "type": "civil_marriage_index",
      "url": "https://www.irishgenealogy.ie/view?record_id=cima-2258136",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The government index and linked register image record John Gibson and Sarah Clark marrying at the Second Monaghan Presbyterian Church on 10 October 1883. The image supplies their Aghnasedagh residence, John's occupation as farmer, and fathers Andrew Gibson and David Clark, both farmers."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PROFILE_JOHN_GIBSON_1850_1921_MONAGHAN",
      "title": "Compiled profile: John Gibson, 1850-1921, Aghnasedagh",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew gives John Gibson born 16 Sep 1850 at Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan, and died 26 Jul 1921 at Aughnaseda, Monaghan. The 1901 and 1911 censuses independently support birth about 1850-1851, County Monaghan, and continued Aghnasedagh residence; exact dates remain profile-derived."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1920_GEORGE_FLORENCE_FRICKE_EAST_ORANGE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1920 United States Census: George and Florence Fricke household, East Orange, New Jersey",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew: Florence Fricke, born about 1892 in Ireland, reported arrival 1910, resident East Orange Ward 3, Essex County; spouse George Fricke; children George G. and Albert R. Fricke. The household directly supports the family and gives an immigration year conflicting with 1930's reported 1920 arrival."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1901_IRELAND_FLORENCE_GIBSON_AGHNASEDAGH_CENSUS",
      "title": "1901 Ireland Census: Florence Gibson household, Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan",
      "type": "census",
      "url": "https://api-census.nationalarchives.ie/census/query?census_year=1901&surname__icontains=Gibson&townland__icontains=Aghnasedagh&county=Monaghan",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The National Archives of Ireland census return places John Gibson, 50, widowed Presbyterian farmer, in house 10 at Aghnasedagh with children Maggie J. 15, Mary 13, David 12, and Florence 9. All were born in County Monaghan. The household schedule is available as NAI image nai001155276."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NC_DEATH_CERT_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NAMES_FLORENCE",
      "title": "North Carolina death certificate index: Florence Gibson named with George Gibson Fricke",
      "type": "official_death_certificate_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew indexes Florance Gibson, spouse George Fricke, and child George Gibson Fricke in North Carolina death certificates. The excerpt strongly corroborates Florence Gibson as George Gibson Fricke's mother and George Fricke as her spouse; the underlying certificate should be retained when available."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1891_1960",
      "title": "Find a Grave index: Florence Gibson Fricke, 1891-1960",
      "type": "compiled_memorial_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry Find a Grave transcript supplied by Matthew gives Florence Fricke born 14 May 1891 in County Monaghan, Ireland; died 8 Mar 1960 at Hackensack, Bergen County, New Jersey; buried in Union, Union County, New Jersey; spouse George Fricke. Exact vitals are memorial evidence and should be checked against civil or cemetery records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEWSPAPERS_OBITUARY_FLORENCE_GIBSON_FRICKE_1960",
      "title": "Newspapers.com Obituary Index: Florence Gibson Fricke, about 1960",
      "type": "obituary_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew gives Florence Gibson Fricke, born Ireland, died about 1960, resident Paramus, Bergen County, New Jersey; spouse George Fricke; children indexed as George G. Fricke and Errol Lee Hart. George is established. Errol Lee Hart is retained as an unresolved relationship clue because the index may flatten a child, married child, in-law, or other relative; no graph edge is created without the obituary text."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DAVIES_1851_TRWSTYWELIN_CENSUS",
      "title": "1851 Wales Census: William and Martha Davies household",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. Trwstywelin, Montgomeryshire: William Davies, 36, born Berriew, head; Martha Davies, 35; Frederick Davies, 6; Eliza Davies, 4; and William Davies, 5 months."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DAVIES_1861_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1861 Wales Census: William and Martha Davies household",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. Churchstoke, Montgomeryshire, household schedule 93, piece 4253, folio 93, page 17: William Davies, 46, born Berriew, head; Martha, 45; Frederic, 16; Eliza, 14; William, 11; Arthur, 8; Lotan, 5; Thomas Rubin, 2; and Martha Elizabeth, 5 months."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DAVIES_1871_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1871 Wales Census: William and Martha Davies household",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. Church Stoke, Montgomeryshire: William Davies, 57, born Berriew, head; Martha, 56; and children Eliza, William, Loton, Thomas R, and Martha E."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DAVIES_1881_CHURCHSTOKE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1881 Wales Census: William and Martha Davies household",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. Allport, Churchstoke: William Davies, 66, born Berriew, carpenter and head; Martha Davies, 65, wife; Eliza Davies, 34; Martha E Davies, 20; and Frederick W Davies, 7."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1815",
      "title": "Berriew parish-register transcription: baptism of William Davies, 29 January 1814",
      "type": "parish register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/68608786865574369c13af4c/william-davies-baptism-montgomeryshire-berriew-1814-01-29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG entry 147 records William, son of Robert Davies and Eliza, baptized at St Beuno, Berriew, on 29 January 1814—not 1815. It additionally identifies the family abode as Trustewelin and Robert as a carpenter. Those details strongly distinguish the child from other common-name Davies baptisms."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRALL_1851_MADELEY_CENSUS",
      "title": "1851 England Census: Richard and Hannah Morral household, Madeley",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Madeley, Shropshire, household 68, piece 1989, folio 206, page 21. Richard Morral, 39, and Hannah Morral, 40, headed a household containing sons William 12, Richard 11, George 10, Thomas 5; daughters Fanny 8, Hannah 7, Ann 3, and Lewesa 1. Richard, age 11 and born Wellington, is explicitly identified as their son."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRALL_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1860",
      "title": "Marriage of Richard Morrall and Sarah Brassington, 26 November 1860",
      "type": "church_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire Church of England marriage transcript supplied by Matthew. Richard Morrall, age 21, residence Green Lane, married Sarah Brassington on 26 Nov 1860 at Wolverhampton St John. Richard named his father as Richard Morrall."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRALL_1861_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1861 England Census: Richard and Sarah Morral household, Wolverhampton",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Wolverhampton St John, household 32, piece 1997, folio 74, page 6. Richard Morral, 21, born Horsehay, Shropshire, is head with wife Sarah Morral, 21."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRALL_1871_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1871 England Census: Richard and Sarah Morrall household, Wolverhampton",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Wolverhampton St John, household 36, piece 2941, folio 98, page 6. Richard Morrall, 31, born at a place transcribed as Thorde Hay, Shropshire, and Sarah, 30, lived with Esther Marin, Fanny, Sary Ann, and Catherine Ellen Morrall."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_RICHARD_MORRALL_1842_1892",
      "title": "Rejected death hypothesis: Richard Morrall, 24 February 1892",
      "type": "conflicting_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile details supplied by Matthew assign death on 24 Feb 1892 at Walsall. This cannot currently belong to the direct-line Richard Morrall because the 1901 Wolverhampton census records him alive with wife Sarah and their daughter Lily M Tomkinson. Retained only as a rejected namesake hypothesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRALL_1901_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1901 England Census: Richard and Sarah Morsell household, Wolverhampton",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Wolverhampton St John, household 121, piece 2672, folio 93, page 18. Richard Morsell, 61, and wife Sarah Morsell, 60, lived with Samuel R Tomkinson, Lily M Tomkinson, 21, and infant Lilian S Tomkinson. The household composition identifies Morsell as a transcription variant of Morrall."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1841_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1841 England Census: Joseph and Esther Brassington household, Wolverhampton",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Wolverhampton Western, piece 1000, book 6, folio 17, page 26. The household includes Joseph Brassington, Eather Brassington, Thomas 8, James 6, and Sarah 1. The adults' transcribed ages are inconsistent with later records, but the children and locality identify the family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BRASSINGTON_1851_WOLVERHAMPTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1851 England Census: Joseph and Esther Brassington household, Wolverhampton",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Wolverhampton St John, household 83, piece 2018, folio 267, page 19. Joseph Brassington, 58, born Ranton, and wife Ester, 43, are recorded with children Thomas 18, James 15, Sarah 11, and Joseph 2. Sarah is explicitly their daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARAH_BRASSINGTON_BIRTH_1840",
      "title": "Sarah Brassington civil birth registration, Wolverhampton, 1840",
      "type": "civil_birth",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Civil Registration Birth Index transcript supplied by Matthew: Sarah Brassington, registered Jan-Mar 1840 at Wolverhampton, volume 17, page 394. A supplied profile gives the exact date 18 Jan 1840 and Church Lane, Wolverhampton."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1915",
      "title": "Sarah Morrall civil death registration, Wolverhampton, 1915",
      "type": "civil_death",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Civil Registration Death Index transcript supplied by Matthew: Sarah Morrall, registered Jan-Mar 1915 at Wolverhampton, volume 6b, page 732. The index age 72 conflicts with her 1840 birth and repeated census ages. A supplied profile gives the exact death date 18 Jan 1915."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_ESTHER_THOMPSON_MARRIAGE_1828",
      "title": "Marriage of Joseph Brassington and Esther Thompson, 24 July 1828",
      "type": "church_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire Church of England marriage transcript supplied by Matthew. Joseph Brassington of Wolverhampton married Esther Thompson on 24 Jul 1828 at Wolverhampton St Peter."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1787",
      "title": "Joseph Brassington baptism, Ranton, 15 April 1787",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire Church of England baptism transcripts supplied by Matthew. Joseph Brassington was baptized on 15 Apr 1787 at Ranton All Saints, son of John Brassington and Margaret."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOSEPH_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_1860",
      "title": "Joseph Brassington death and burial, Wolverhampton, April 1860",
      "type": "civil_death_and_memorial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Civil death registration places Joseph Brassington's death in Wolverhampton in Apr-Jun 1860, volume 6b, page 273. A supplied profile gives 9 Apr 1860, while the Find a Grave index gives 12 Apr 1860; because the exact dates conflict, only April 1860 is adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_RANTON_BAPTISM_1764",
      "title": "John Brassington baptism, Ranton, 18 November 1764",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire parish baptism transcripts supplied by Matthew. John Brassington was baptized on 18 Nov 1764 at Ranton, son of John Brassington and Jane."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_MARGARET_BRASSINGTON_1841_HAUGHTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1841 England Census: John and Margaret Brassington, Haughton",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Haughton, Staffordshire, piece 974, book 7, folio 8, page 8: John Brassington, 75, and Margrat Brassington, 75, both born Staffordshire."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_BURIAL_1847",
      "title": "John Brassington death and burial, Haughton, 1847",
      "type": "civil_death_and_burial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Civil registration places John Brassington's death in the Penkridge district in Apr-Jun 1847, volume 17, page 105. The Haughton St Giles burial register records burial on 9 Jun 1847, age 82, consistent with his 1764 baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1739",
      "title": "John Brassington baptism, Chelmorton, 12 April 1739",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derbyshire christening transcripts supplied by Matthew. John Brassington was baptized on 12 Apr 1739 at Chelmorton, son of John and Elizabeth Brassington."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CANDIDATE_JOHN_BRASINGTON_CHELMORTON_BAPTISM_1702",
      "title": "John Brasington baptism, Chelmorton, 2 January 1702",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derbyshire baptism transcript supplied by Matthew. John Brasington was baptized on 2 Jan 1702 at Chelmorton, son of George Brasington."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1841_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1841 England Census: Richard and Hannah Morrall household, Wellington",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Wellington, Shropshire, piece 907, book 4, folio 16, page 24: Richard Morrall, 30; Hannah, 32; William, 3; Richard, 2; and George, 7 months. All were recorded in Shropshire."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1861_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1861 England Census: Richard and Mary Ann Morrall household, Wellington",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Wellington Christchurch, household 27, piece 1897, folio 33, page 6: Richard Morrall, 48, born Wellington, head; Mary Ann Morrall, 38, wife; Thomas 15, Hannah 16, and Louisa 11; plus Emma Jones, 18."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1871_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1871 England Census: Richard and Mary Ann Morrall household, Wellington",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Wellington Christchurch, household 61, piece 2806, folio 40, page 16: Richard Morrall, 59, born Horsehay, head; Mary Ann, 45; Lavinia, 9; Adam, 7; and Clement, 4."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORRALL_SR_1881_WELLINGTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1881 England Census: Richard Morrell household, Wellington",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. High Street, Keays Yard, Wellington, piece 2678, folio 31, page 10: Richard Morrell, 69, born Horsehay, married head and insurance agent; Hannah Halford, 36; Annie Halford, 13; Willie Halford, 10; Amy Halford, 7; and Henry Sansun, 26. Mary Ann was not present in the transcribed household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_MARY_ANN_BALL_MARRIAGE_1861",
      "title": "Civil marriage registration page: Richard Morrall and Mary Anne Ball, Shifnal, 1861",
      "type": "civil_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Civil Registration Marriage Index transcript supplied by Matthew. Jan-Mar 1861, Shifnal district, volume 6a, page 824. The page contains Richard Morrall, Mary Anne Ball, William Harris, and Emily Hayward. Richard appears with wife Mary Ann in the 1861 census, making the Morrall-Ball pairing likely but not absolutely proven by the index page alone."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_DEATH_1884",
      "title": "Richard Morrall civil death registration, Wellington, 1884",
      "type": "civil_death",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Civil Registration Death Index transcript supplied by Matthew. Richard Morrall, age 73, registered Jul-Sep 1884 in Wellington, Shropshire, volume 6a, page 465. This is consistent with the census identity born about 1811-1812."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_1811_1884",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Richard Morrall, 1811-1884",
      "type": "user_supplied_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew gives birth in 1811 at Horsehay, Shropshire, and death in 1884 at Wellington. The census series supports Horsehay/Wellington and an approximate 1811-1813 birth; the civil index supports death registration in Jul-Sep 1884."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLEY_MORRALL_PROFILE_ABT1811_1853",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Hannah Grindley, about 1811-1853",
      "type": "user_supplied_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew identifies Richard Morrall's first wife as Hannah Grindley, born about 1811 at Forton, Staffordshire, and dying in 1853 at Wellington. The supplied census and civil death index support the given name, birth estimate/place, married surname, and death, but do not independently establish the Grindley maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNAH_MORRALL_DEATH_1853",
      "title": "Hannah Morrall civil death registration, Wellington, 1853",
      "type": "civil_death",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Civil Registration Death Index transcript supplied by Matthew. Hannah Morrall, registered Jul-Sep 1853 at Wellington, Shropshire, volume 6a, page 448."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_CHILD_BAPTISM_PARENTS_RICHARD_ANNE",
      "title": "Richard Morrall child baptism naming parents Richard and Anne",
      "type": "parish_baptism_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England Select Births and Christenings transcript supplied by Matthew names Richard Morrall and spouse Anne as parents of child Richard Morrall. The mother's Anne/Hannah name variation is compatible but should be checked against the original parish entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GRINDLEY_1851_FORTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1851 England Census: Thomas and Mary Grindley household, Forton",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Forton, Staffordshire, household 49, piece 1998, folio 350, page 13: Thomas Grindley, 67, born Forton, head; Mary Grindley, 64, wife; and Ann Grindley, 31."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GRINDLEY_1861_FORTON_CENSUS",
      "title": "1861 England Census: Thomas and Mary Grindley household, Forton",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Forton, Staffordshire, household 11, piece 1904, folio 78, page 4: Thomas Grindley, 78, born Forton, head; Mary Grindley, 75, wife; and Ann Grindley, 44."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_1783_1862",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Thomas Grindley, 1783-1862",
      "type": "user_supplied_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew gives birth in 1783 at Forton, Staffordshire, and death on 26 Aug 1862 at Forton. The 1851 and 1861 censuses strongly support the identity and birthplace; the exact death date has not yet been supported by a separately supplied civil or burial transcript."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_NAMES_FATHER_THOMAS",
      "title": "Shropshire church marriage index: Hannah Grindly, child of Thomas Grindly",
      "type": "church_marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Shropshire Church of England Marriages and Banns index transcript supplied by Matthew explicitly identifies Thomas Grindly as father of Hannah Grindly. The supplied excerpt does not include the marriage date, parish, spouse, or image reference."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_GRINDLEY_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_MARRIAGE_1777",
      "title": "Marriage of John Grindley and Elizabeth Pickin, Forton, 31 December 1777",
      "type": "church_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Multiple marriage transcripts supplied by Matthew record John Grunley/Greenley marrying Elizabeth Pickin on 31 Dec 1777 at Forton All Saints, Staffordshire. The spelling variants are consistent with Grindley."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_CHILD_OF_JOHN_ELIZABETH",
      "title": "Thomas Grindley christening index naming parents John and Elizabeth",
      "type": "parish_baptism_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Christening Index transcript supplied by Matthew identifies Thomas Grindley as child of John Grindley and Elisabeth Grindley. Together with the parents' 1777 Forton marriage and Thomas's lifelong Forton records, this supports the family identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_JOHN_GRINDLEY_1753_1834",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: John Grindley, 1753-1834",
      "type": "user_supplied_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew gives birth in 1753 and death in Mar 1834, both at Forton, Staffordshire. The marriage and child indexes support the Forton identity, but separate birth and death transcripts have not yet been supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELLEN_WATERHOUSE_HANFORD_BAPTISM_1835",
      "title": "Ellen Waterhouse baptism, Hanford St Matthias, 14 June 1835",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire Church of England baptism transcript supplied by Matthew. Ellen Waterhouse was baptized on 14 Jun 1835 at Hanford St Matthias, Staffordshire, daughter of John and Ellen Waterhouse. The record supplies a baptism date, not an explicit birth date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
      "title": "1851 England Census: John and Ellen Waterhouse household, Trentham",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Trentham, Staffordshire, household 133, piece 2000, folio 669, page 37: John Waterhouse, 48; wife Ellen, 48; children Frederic 22, John 18, Ellen 16, Emma 11, Henry 9, Herbert 7, and Elizabeth 5; plus Henry Lawton, 23. Ellen, born Trentham, is explicitly their daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1901_HEATH_CENSUS",
      "title": "1901 England Census: Ellen Rhead household, Heath",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Heath, Staffordshire, household 110, piece 2687, folio 131, page 18: Ellen Rhead, 65, born Trentham, head; Ruth Fisher, 43; Eveline Fisher, 7; and Albert Fisher, 4. This continues Ellen after Richard Rhead's 1900 death."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_1900_WOLVERHAMPTON_DIRECTORIES",
      "title": "1900 Staffordshire directories: Ellen Rhead, Wolverhampton shopkeeper",
      "type": "trade_directory",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Two directory transcripts supplied by Matthew place Mrs Ellen Rhead at 1 Bridge Street, Springfields, Wolverhampton in 1900; one records her occupation as shopkeeper."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELLEN_RHEAD_DEATH_1904",
      "title": "Ellen Rhead civil death registration, Wolverhampton, 1904",
      "type": "civil_death",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Civil Registration Death Index transcript supplied by Matthew. Ellen Rhead was registered Apr-Jun 1904 at Wolverhampton, volume 6b, page 319. The indexed age 58 conflicts with her 1835 baptism and continuous census ages and is treated as a transcription or registration error."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PROFILE_ELLEN_HELEN_WATERHOUSE_1835_1904",
      "title": "Ancestry profile: Ellen Helen Waterhouse, 1835-1904",
      "type": "user_supplied_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew gives 14 Jun 1835 at Hanford and 14 Apr 1904 at Wolverhampton. The first date is independently documented as baptism rather than birth. The profile labels Hanford as Shropshire, but the parish record and censuses place it in Staffordshire."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RHEAD_BOTTON_1851_TRENTHAM_CENSUS",
      "title": "1851 England Census: Thomas and Sarah Botton household, Trentham",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Trentham, Staffordshire, household 20, piece 2000, folio 655, page 9: Thomas Botton, 25; wife Sarah Botton, 35; stepsons Richard Rhead, 18, George Rhead, 14, and S Henry Rhead, 16; Elizabeth Rhead, 8; and Thomas Botton, 2. Richard was born Shropshire and is explicitly Sarah's stepson in Thomas Botton's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RHEAD_1861_HEYWOOD_CENSUS",
      "title": "1861 England Census: Richard and Ellen Read household, Heywood",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Heywood, Lancashire, household 310, piece 2842, folio 89, page 67: Richard Read, 28, born at a Shropshire place transcribed as Trenton, lodger; Ellen Read, 25; Ruth E Read, 3; and Ellen Read, 2. Names, ages, and family composition identify Read as a Rhead spelling variant."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RHEAD_1841_STOKE_TRANSCRIPTION",
      "title": "1841 England Census candidate: Sampson and Sarah household, Stoke upon Trent",
      "type": "superseded transcription with original-image correction",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "An earlier Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew was read as Sampson Bird, Sarah Bird, Richard Bird, Stephen Sampson, George Sampson, and Ruth Sampson. The subsequently supplied original HO 107/985/987 image visibly reads the Rhead surname in the household and identifies Sampson, Sarah, Richard, Stephen, George, and Ruth. The original image is now the controlling source; this earlier transcript remains only to document the correction."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_DEATH_AND_BURIAL_1900",
      "title": "Richard Rhead death registration and Merridale Cemetery memorial, 1900",
      "type": "civil_death_and_memorial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Civil death registration transcript supplied by Matthew records Richard Rhead, age 67, registered Oct-Dec 1900 at Wolverhampton, volume 6b, page 379. Find a Grave records death on 2 Oct 1900 and burial at Merridale Cemetery, Wolverhampton."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_READ_STOKE_BAPTISM_1753",
      "title": "Richard Read baptism, Stoke, 30 October 1753",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire parish baptism transcript supplied by Matthew. Richard Read was baptized on 30 Oct 1753 at Stoke, son of John Read and Sarah Read."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_MARRIAGE_1793",
      "title": "Marriage of Richard Rhead and Ruth Handley, Trentham, 26 January 1793",
      "type": "church_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire parish marriage transcripts supplied by Matthew record Richard Rhead marrying Ruth Handley on 26 Jan 1793 at Trentham St Mary and All Saints. This supersedes a public-tree date of 7 Jan 1793."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_TRENTHAM_PROBATE_BURIAL_1813",
      "title": "Richard Rhead probate and burial, Trentham, 1813",
      "type": "probate_and_burial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lichfield probate index records Richard Rhead of Trentham with a will dated and proved in 1813. The supplied first-page will image independently names wife Ruth, youngest child Sampson, daughters Ruth and Elizabeth, and Trentham-area residence. Burial indexes conflict: one gives burial 6 Apr 1813 at Trentham; a detailed St Mary and All Saints transcript gives burial 16 Apr 1813, age 57. Only April 1813 is adopted because the will page does not contain the execution or probate endorsement."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_EXTRACTED_PARISH_ENTRY",
      "title": "Extracted Staffordshire parish entry: Richard Rhead and spouse Ruth",
      "type": "parish_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire Extracted Church of England Parish Records transcript supplied by Matthew identifies Rich. Rhead with spouse Ruth. It reinforces the established Richard Rhead and Ruth Handley couple but supplies no event date or child in the excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RD_RHEAD_1798_HANCHURCH_LAND_TAX",
      "title": "1798 Land Tax Redemption: Rd Rhead at Hanchurch, Staffordshire",
      "type": "land_tax",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "UK Land Tax Redemption transcript supplied by Matthew records Rd Rhead residing at Hanchurch, Staffordshire, in 1798. The abbreviated name and absence of family or occupation identifiers make assignment to Richard Read/Rhead possible but unproven."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_BAPTISM_1783",
      "title": "Thomas Grindley baptism, Forton, 30 January 1783",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Christening Index and Staffordshire parish transcripts supplied by Matthew record Thomas Grindley baptized on 30 Jan 1783 at Forton, Staffordshire, son of John and Elisabeth Grindley."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_GRINDLEY_BURIAL_PROBATE_1862_1863",
      "title": "Thomas Grindley burial and probate, 1862-1863",
      "type": "burial_and_probate",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire burial transcript records Thomas Grindley buried 29 Aug 1862. The National Probate Calendar records death on 26 Aug 1862 in Staffordshire and probate on 22 Jan 1863 at Lichfield."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_HANNAH_GRINDLY_MARRIAGE_1837",
      "title": "Marriage of Richard Morrall and Hannah Grindly, 4 July 1837",
      "type": "parish_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Shropshire Church of England marriage transcript supplied by Matthew records Richard Morrall, about 1811, resident Woodhouse, marrying Hannah Grindly, about 1810, resident Newport, on 4 Jul 1837. Richard names father Samuel Morrall; Hannah names father Thomas Grindly."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_MORRALL_SR_BURIAL_1884",
      "title": "Richard Morrall burial, 8 July 1884, Shropshire",
      "type": "parish_burial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Shropshire parish burial transcript supplied by Matthew records Richard Morrall, born about 1811, buried on 8 Jul 1884. This is compatible with the Jul-Sep 1884 Wellington civil death registration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_GIBSON_MONAGHAN_DEATH_Q3_1921",
      "title": "John Gibson civil death registration, Monaghan, Q3 1921",
      "type": "civil_death_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ireland Civil Registration Deaths Index transcript supplied by Matthew records John Gibson, born about 1851, death registered Jul-Sep 1921 in Monaghan. It supports the profile date 26 Jul 1921 but does not independently establish the exact day."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_MACKNEW_MARYLAND_BIRTH_1715",
      "title": "William Macknew birth index, 14 August 1715, St Johns Parish",
      "type": "birth_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Maryland Births and Christenings Index transcript supplied by Matthew records William Macknew born 14 Aug 1715 at Saint Johns Parish, Prince George's County, Maryland. It independently supports the exact birth fact but does not name parents in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BERNAL_BRIGHT_RHEAD_CIVIL_BIRTH_Q1_1869",
      "title": "Bernal Bright Rhead civil birth registration, Birmingham, Q1 1869",
      "type": "civil_birth_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Civil Registration Birth Index transcript supplied by Matthew records Bernal Bright Rhead registered Jan-Mar 1869 at Birmingham. This direct registration supersedes the compiled profile claim of Jan 1868."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROSA_BEATRICE_RHEAD_PROBATE_1968",
      "title": "Rosa Beatrice Rhead probate calendar, 1968",
      "type": "probate_calendar",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales National Probate Calendar transcript supplied by Matthew records Rosa Beatrice Rhead dying 2 Mar 1968 at Wolverhampton; probate was granted 26 Mar 1968 at Birmingham."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALFREDA_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_DAVIES_BIRTH_1910",
      "title": "Alfreda Margaret E Davies civil birth registration, Atcham, Q2 1910",
      "type": "civil_birth_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Civil Registration Birth Index transcript supplied by Matthew records Alfreda Margaret E Davies registered Apr-Jun 1910 at Atcham. The 1939 register and civil death index give birth 18 Apr 1910."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALFREDA_RHEAD_PROBATE_DEATH_1990",
      "title": "Alfreda Margaret Elizabeth Rhead death and probate, 1990",
      "type": "civil_death_and_probate",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Civil death index and probate calendar transcripts supplied by Matthew record Alfreda Margaret E Rhead, born 18 Apr 1910, died 30 May 1990 at Shrewsbury; probate was granted 3 Jul 1990 at Birmingham."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_BAPTISM_1883",
      "title": "Alfred Percy Davies baptism, 11 November 1883",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Shropshire parish transcript supplied by Matthew records Alfred Percy Davies born 16 Oct 1883 and baptized 11 Nov 1883, son of Frederick and Maria Davies."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_PROBATE_1944",
      "title": "Alfred Percy Davies probate calendar, 1944",
      "type": "probate_calendar",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Probate calendar transcript records Alfred Percy Davies dying 24 Dec 1943 at Shrewsbury; probate was granted 28 Nov 1944 at Chester."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1845",
      "title": "Frederick Davies baptism, Berriew, 23 March 1845",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Wales Select Births and Baptisms transcript supplied by Matthew records Frederick Davies christened 23 Mar 1845 at Berriew, son of William Davies and Martha."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREDERICK_DAVIES_DEATH_Q1_1926",
      "title": "Frederick Davies civil death registration, Atcham, Q1 1926",
      "type": "civil_death_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Civil Registration Death Index transcript supplied by Matthew records Frederick Davies, born about 1846, death registered Jan-Mar 1926 at Atcham, Shropshire."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_HANNY_WINSLEY_BAPTISM_1771",
      "title": "William Hanny baptism, Winsley, 3 March 1771",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Wiltshire parish transcript supplied by Matthew records William Hnney baptized 3 Mar 1771 at Winsley, son of Charles Hnney and Cteren Hnney. The names are compatible variants of Charles Hanny and Catherine Waine."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_ELIZABETH_CORNISH_CHURCH_MARRIAGE_1838",
      "title": "Marriage of William Peters Hanny and Elizabeth Cornish, 31 March 1838",
      "type": "parish_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Wiltshire church marriage transcript supplied by Matthew records William Peters Hanny marrying Elizabeth Cornish on 31 Mar 1838. William names father William Hanny; Elizabeth names father Henry Cornish."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_HANNEY_WILTSHIRE_BURIAL_1854",
      "title": "Elizabeth Hanney burial, Wiltshire, 25 February 1854",
      "type": "parish_burial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Wiltshire parish burial transcript supplied by Matthew records Elizabeth Hanney buried 25 Feb 1854. It fits the Bradford-on-Avon family after the 1851 census and before William appears without her in 1861. Yorkshire 1856 death hints are rejected as namesakes."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY_WILTSHIRE_BURIAL_1894",
      "title": "William Peters Hanny burial, Wiltshire, 29 September 1894",
      "type": "burial_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "UK Burial and Cremation Index transcript supplied by Matthew records William Peters Hanny buried 29 Sep 1894 in Wiltshire. This supports death in Sep 1894 at Bradford-on-Avon and rejects a Yorkshire death-index namesake."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HENRY_ALBERT_FRICKE_FINDAGRAVE_1846_1918",
      "title": "Henry Albert Fricke memorial, 1846-1918",
      "type": "cemetery_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Find a Grave index transcript supplied by Matthew records Henry Fricke born 18 Jul 1846 in Hannover, died 8 Apr 1918 at East Orange, and buried at Montclair/Rosedale in Essex County; child George Fricke. It is compatible with census and marriage evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHANN_CASPAR_GONDER_BAPTISM_DEATH_1801_1871",
      "title": "Johann Caspar Gonder baptism and death, Obergleen, 1801-1871",
      "type": "parish_vitals",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "German parish transcript supplied by Matthew records Johann Gonter born 17 Jul 1801, baptized 20 Jul 1801 at Obergleen, son of Balthasar and Barbara Catharina Gonter, and died 4 Jan 1871. This supersedes the compiled 4 Jan 1870 death."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VA_DEATH_SALLY_JANE_HENDERSON_1974",
      "title": "Virginia death record: Sally Jane Henderson, 1974",
      "type": "death_certificate_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Virginia death record transcript supplied by Matthew records Sally Henderson born 17 Apr 1894, died 19 Jan 1974 at Abingdon, spouse Edward Henderson, father David K Shortt, mother Tiny White."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VA_DEATH_EDWARD_ALDERSON_HENDERSON_1964",
      "title": "Virginia death record: Edward Alderson Henderson, 1964",
      "type": "death_certificate_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Virginia death record transcript supplied by Matthew records Edgar/Edward Alderson Henderson born 17 Mar 1885, died 8 Mar 1964 at Abingdon, spouse Sally Jane Shortt, father Conley Henderson, mother Rebeccah Talley. The record display uses Edgar, while consistent lifetime records use Edward/Eddie."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SSA_DAVID_GARY_FRICKE_1938_2002",
      "title": "Social Security record: David Gary Fricke, 1938-2002",
      "type": "social_security_claim",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Social Security Applications and Claims transcript supplied by Matthew records David Gary Fricke born 15 Dec 1938 at Newark, Essex, New Jersey, died 15 Jul 2002, father George G Fricke, mother Marysue E Henderson. Census and veterans cemetery records corroborate the identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1802",
      "title": "John Waterhouse birth and baptism, Ashbourne, 1802",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derbyshire parish transcript supplied by Matthew records John Waterhouse born 7 Apr 1802 and baptized 2 May 1802 at Ashbourne St Oswald, son of James and Hannah Waterhouse."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_ELLEN_FINNEY_MARRIAGE_1827",
      "title": "Marriage of John Waterhouse and Ellen Finney, 24 September 1827",
      "type": "parish_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derbyshire parish and select-marriage transcripts supplied by Matthew record John Waterhouse marrying Ellen Finney on 24 Sep 1827 at Ashbourne St Oswald."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WATERHOUSE_1861_BIRMINGHAM_CENSUS",
      "title": "1861 England Census: Jonas and Helen Waterhouse household, Birmingham",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Birmingham St Stephen household transcript supplied by Matthew: Jonas Waterhouse, 52, born Ashbourne, head; Helen, 52, wife; Eugenia 21, Henry 19, Herbert 16, Elizabeth 12, and George Read 6. The children and places continue the 1851 John and Ellen Waterhouse household; Jonas/John and Helen/Ellen are name variants."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_WATERHOUSE_BIRMINGHAM_DEATH_Q1_1863",
      "title": "John Waterhouse civil death registration, Birmingham, Q1 1863",
      "type": "civil_death_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Civil Registration Death Index transcript supplied by Matthew records John Waterhouse death registered Jan-Mar 1863 at Birmingham, volume 6d, page 117. A profile gives 1 Jan 1863, but the index does not establish the exact day."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_HANNAH_NEEDHAM_MARRIAGE_1799",
      "title": "Marriage of James Waterhouse and Hannah Needham, 26 November 1799",
      "type": "parish_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derbyshire parish and select-marriage transcripts supplied by Matthew record Hannah Needham marrying James Waterhouse on 26 Nov 1799 at Ashbourne St Oswald. Their son John's 1802 baptism independently names parents James and Hannah."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JAMES_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_DEATH_BURIAL_1840",
      "title": "James Waterhouse death and burial, Ashbourne, October 1840",
      "type": "civil_death_and_parish_burial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Civil registration records James Waterhouse's death in the Ashbourne district in Oct-Dec 1840, volume 19 page 263. The Ashbourne St Oswald burial register records burial on 19 Oct 1840 at age 75, implying birth about 1765. This is compatible with Hannah Needham's husband and John Waterhouse's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_MELLOR_MARRIAGE_1758",
      "title": "Marriage of Edward Needham and Hannah Mellor, 11 December 1758",
      "type": "parish_marriage_and_license",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ashbourne St Oswald parish transcripts record Edward Needham marrying Hannah Mellor on 11 Dec 1758. The marriage license dated 10 Dec describes Hannah as single, age 21, resident Ashbourne, implying birth about 1737. The records do not name any children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_CHILD_HANNAH_INDEX",
      "title": "Hannah Needham child index naming father Edward Needham",
      "type": "christening_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England and Wales Christening Index and Derbyshire parish-index transcripts supplied by Matthew explicitly name Edward Needham as father of Hannah Needham. One transcript records the mother only as spouse Needham and supplies no event date or parish in the excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BURIAL_1816",
      "title": "Edward Needham burial, Ashbourne, 7 April 1816",
      "type": "parish_burial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ashbourne St Oswald burial transcript supplied by Matthew records Edward Needham buried 7 April 1816 aged 82, implying birth about 1734. Correction 15 September 2026: the old statement that his 1758 licence gives Edward age 21 is unsupported by the saved excerpt, which attributes 21 to Hannah Mellor. No marriage age for Edward is asserted; original licence not newly inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_BAPTISM_1811",
      "title": "Sarah Poyner baptism, Stoke St Milborough, 5 May 1811",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Stoke St Milborough parish register, page 24, reference P272/A/1/4: Sarah Poyner was baptized 5 May 1811 and her mother was Mary Poyner. The supplied profile gives birth 1 May 1811 at Ludlow, but that exact birth date is not shown in the baptism-index excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARAH_RHEAD_THOMAS_BOULTON_MARRIAGE_1852",
      "title": "Marriage of Sarah Rhead and Thomas Boulton, 19 December 1852",
      "type": "parish_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Shelton St Mark parish marriage, page 227: Sarah Rhead, age 39, resident Shelton, married Thomas Boulton on 19 Dec 1852 and named George Odnett as her father. Her age implies about 1813 but conflicts with the 1811 baptism. The father statement is retained as a qualified parent claim because the baptism names only mother Mary Poyner."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARAH_BOULTON_1861_HANFORD_CENSUS",
      "title": "1861 England Census: Thomas and Sarah Boulton household, Hanford",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Hanford, Staffordshire, piece 1914, folio 139, page 3: Thomas Boulton, 39; wife Sarah, 47, born Shropshire; Elizabeth Rhead, 18; and Thomas Boulton, 12. This continues the 1851 Botton household and identifies the surname spelling as Boulton."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_1871_HANFORD_CENSUS",
      "title": "1871 England Census: Sarah Maria Boulton household, Hanford",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Hanford, Staffordshire, piece 2829, folio 50, page 38: Sarah Maria Boulton, 55, born Ludlow, Shropshire, wife of Thomas Boulton, 44. Also present were Elizabeth Spencer, 27; Thomas Boulton, 22; and Justin Spencer, 4. This supplies the middle name Maria and strong continuity from the Rhead/Botton household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARAH_MARIA_BOULTON_DEATH_1879_PROFILE",
      "title": "Sarah Maria Boulton death profile, 1879",
      "type": "profile_claim",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Supplied Ancestry profile reports Sarah Maria Poyner/Rhead/Boulton died in Oct-Dec 1879 at Hanford near Trentham. The underlying civil death-index excerpt was not supplied, so the quarter and place remain profile-supported pending direct index or certificate review."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD_BURIAL_1717",
      "title": "George Brassington burial, Alstonfield, 6 February 1717",
      "type": "parish_burial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire extracted parish record states \"06 Feb 1717 Geo. Brassington bur.\" at Alstonfield. The collection display labels the book Marriages despite identifying the event as a burial. Identity with either the 1684 bridegroom or John's father is not established."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_TAX_1666",
      "title": "George Brassington in the Caverswall hearth tax, 1666",
      "type": "tax_list",
      "url": "https://www.caverswall.org.uk/local-history/the-hearth-tax-1666/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Caverswall local-history transcription of the 1666 hearth tax lists an adult George Brassington. This shows that a same-name man was established at Caverswall before the profile's claimed 1670 birth and is evidence of conflation, not proof that the taxpayer was John's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GONDER_BAPTISM_1724",
      "title": "Johann Dietrich Gonder birth and baptism, Obergleen, July 1724",
      "type": "parish_baptism_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Germany Select Births and Baptisms index, FHL film 1195559: male Gonder born 18 Jul 1724 and baptized 20 Jul 1724 at the Evangelical church in Obergleen, Oberhessen, Hesse-Darmstadt; residence Obergleen; father Conrad Gonder. The supplied profile identifies the unnamed child as Johann Dietrich, consistent with his later Obergleen marriage and the Dietrich named as father in the 1762 baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GUNTER_ANNA_CATHARINA_WENDEL_MARRIAGE_1761",
      "title": "Marriage of Johann Dietrich Gunter and Anna Catharina Wendel, 31 March 1761",
      "type": "parish_marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Germany Select Marriages index, FHL film 1195559: Johann Dietrich Gunter married Anna Catharina Wendel on 31 Mar 1761 at the Evangelical church in Obergleen, Oberhessen, Hesse-Darmstadt. Gunter is retained as an indexed spelling variant of Gonder."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHANN_DIETRICH_GONDER_PROFILE_DEATH_1772",
      "title": "Profile claim: Johann Dietrich Gonder died in 1772",
      "type": "profile_claim",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Supplied profile reports Johann Dietrich Gonder died in 1772 at Ober Gleen. No death or burial record was included in the displayed evidence, so the year remains profile-supported rather than independently verified."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_ELIZA_BOYD_PROFILE_1829_1894",
      "title": "Profile claim: Elizabeth Eliza Boyd, 1829-1894",
      "type": "profile_claim",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Supplied profile reports Elizabeth \"Eliza\" Boyd born in 1829 at Coolmain, County Monaghan, and died 6 Feb 1894 at Aghnasedagh, County Monaghan. The displayed marriage and child indexes establish her family identity but do not themselves provide these birth and death details."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DAVID_BOYD_PROFILE_1800_1810_1890",
      "title": "Profile claim: David Boyd, about 1800-1810 to 1890",
      "type": "profile_claim",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A compiled profile reports David Boyd born about 1800-1810 at Coolmain, County Monaghan, and died about 1890. No direct birth, baptism, death, burial, or residence record was included. Griffith's Valuation instead names Samuel and Sarah Boyd as Coolmain occupiers; because valuations omit non-occupiers this is not a contradiction, but it leaves the Coolmain claim unconfirmed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ESTHER_TOMPSON_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1808",
      "title": "Esther Tompson baptism, Wolverhampton St Peter, 14 February 1808",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Wolverhampton St Peter parish baptism transcripts, FHL film 421622: Esther Tompson was baptized 14 Feb 1808, daughter of Thos Tompson and Mary. The record establishes baptism, not an exact birth date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ESTHER_BRASSINGTON_DEATH_1874_CONFLICT",
      "title": "Esther Brassington death evidence, Wolverhampton, January 1874",
      "type": "civil_death_and_memorial_conflict",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The civil death index records Esther Brassington, age 59, registered Jan-Mar 1874 at Wolverhampton, volume 6b page 321; that age implies about 1815 and conflicts with the 1808 baptism and 1851 census age. A supplied profile gives death 7 Jan 1874, while the Merridale Cemetery memorial index gives 13 Jan 1874. Only January 1874 is retained pending the death certificate or cemetery register."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
      "title": "Wolverhampton church transcript: children of Joseph and Esther Brassington",
      "type": "parish_transcript",
      "url": "https://genealogy.mattiebowman.ca/Baptism/Wolverhampton%20Baptisms%201751-1903%20A-C.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Wolverhampton and district baptism transcript lists children of Joseph and Esther Brassington including Sarah at St Paul on 15 Mar 1840, Ann at St Paul on 21 Dec 1845, Joseph at St Paul on 22 Apr 1851, and William Henry at St Paul on 17 Apr 1853. The entries give Church Lane or Bloomsbury residences and Joseph's shoemaker/cordwainer occupation, supporting family continuity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_WALTON_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_MARRIAGE_1726",
      "title": "Marriage of John Brassington and Elizabeth Walton, Chelmorton, 27 September 1726",
      "type": "parish_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England Select Marriages transcript supplied by Matthew, FHL film 422194: John Brassington married Elizabeth Walton at Chelmorton on 27 Sep 1726. A second transcript abbreviates her as Elizabeth L., while an image-derived index reads Sialton; Walton is preferred because the dedicated marriage transcript gives the complete surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ELIZABETH_WALTON_TIDESWELL_BAPTISM_1701",
      "title": "Elizabeth Walton baptism, Tideswell, 25 January 1701",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derbyshire baptism transcripts supplied by Matthew, FHL film 428947: Elizabetha Walton was baptized at Tideswell on 25 Jan 1701, daughter of Caroli Walton. Caroli is the Latin genitive form of Carolus, conventionally rendered Charles. The record is a plausible match for the 1726 Chelmorton bride but does not itself establish that identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1860 United States census: George W. White household, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew: Western District, Washington County, Virginia, dwelling and family 211. George W. White, 44, Virginia-born farmer, appears with Samuel 19, John 16, James 14, Napoleon 11, Louisa 9, Robert 8, Margaret 5, and Leanna 1. No wife is listed in the supplied household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_WASHINGTON_WHITE_LYON_CEMETERY_1864",
      "title": "George Washington White memorial, Lyon Cemetery, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "cemetery_memorial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Find a Grave index supplied by Matthew: George Washington White, born 18 Nov 1815 in Botetourt County, Virginia; died 21 May 1864 in Washington County, Virginia; buried Lyon Cemetery. Named children James M. White and Napoleon C. White match sons in the 1860 Washington County household, strongly supporting identity. The dates should ideally be confirmed from the grave image or cemetery register."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_MARRIAGE_1836",
      "title": "Probable marriage of George W. White and Julia Ann Sims, Carter County, Tennessee, 6 September 1836",
      "type": "marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Tennessee marriage transcript supplied by Matthew records Geo W White marrying a spouse indexed as John Ann Sims at Carter County on 6 Sep 1836. The spouse reading is likely defective and is compatible with Julia Ann Sims, but the original image is needed before treating the exact name as certain."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "title": "Geneanet tree claim for parents of George Washington White",
      "type": "community_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet Community Trees Index supplied by Matthew gives George Washington White, born 18 Nov 1815, died 1870 in Washington County, Virginia, as son of Benjamin Franklin White and Frances Fanny Lavender. The parent claim agrees with the imported GEDCOM but is not independent primary evidence; its 1870 death conflicts with the better-matched Lyon Cemetery memorial and is rejected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_W_WHITE_REJECTED_NAMESAKE_HINTS",
      "title": "Rejected George W. White namesake hints",
      "type": "conflict_analysis",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The supplied 1880 Huttonsville, West Virginia census concerns a George W. White still alive with wife Ann. The 1888 Illinois cavalry pension, 1919 Army transport list, 1934 New York directory, 1833 Revolutionary pension, and approximately 1870 Brooklyn newspaper extract are chronologically or geographically incompatible and are not attached to the Washington County man who died in 1864."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1860_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1860 United States census: Julia White, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew: Western District, Washington County, dwelling and family 211. Julia White, age 42, Virginia-born housekeeper, appears with Benjamin 22 and Mary 21. George W. White and the remaining children are indexed at the same dwelling and family number, showing that the transcript has split one household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_1870_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
      "title": "1870 United States census: Julia White household, North Fork, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew: North Fork, Washington County, dwelling 348. Julia White, 52, Virginia-born, keeping house, with Louisa 19, Robert 17, Margaret A. 15, Leana J. 11, Thomas 8, and Eliza 8. George is absent, consistent with his 1864 death."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JULIA_A_STOUT_1880_NORTH_FORK_CENSUS",
      "title": "1880 United States census: Julia A. Stout household, North Fork, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew: North Fork, Washington County, dwelling 70. Julia A. Stout, 65, born Tennessee, married, is head with Liza A. White 17, Mary D. White 1, and Louisa White 30. The White household continuity and locality make this a strong match for Julia, possibly under a remarried surname, but no Stout marriage has been supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_NORTH_FORK_DEATH_1892",
      "title": "Julia White death, North Fork, Washington County, Virginia, 8 October 1892",
      "type": "death_register",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Washington County death register and derivative indexes supplied by Matthew: Julia White, white female, widowed, age 78, born about 1814 in Washington County, died 8 Oct 1892 in North Fork District, Washington County, Virginia. FHL film 34388."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JULIA_WHITE_ILLINOIS_PENSION_REJECTED",
      "title": "Rejected Illinois pension filing for Julia A. White, 1888",
      "type": "conflict_analysis",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Civil War pension index records widow Julia A. White filing in Illinois on 19 May 1888 for a George W. White of Company E, 10th Illinois Cavalry. Julia is documented in North Fork, Virginia in 1870 and 1880 and died there in 1892; absent a migration or service connection, the Illinois pension couple is treated as namesakes."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FANNY_LAVENDER_MARRIAGE_1811",
      "title": "Marriage of Benjamin White and Fanny Lavender, Botetourt County, Virginia, June 1811",
      "type": "marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Virginia marriage indexes supplied by Matthew identify Benjamin White and Fanny Lavender or Lavinder at Botetourt County in June 1811. The FHL film 0030734 transcript explicitly names Fanny's father as Robert Lavinder. Two transcripts give 1 Jun, while another gives 6 Jun; only June 1811 is retained pending inspection of the original bond or register. FHL films 30731 and 0030734."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_BOTETOURT_CENSUS",
      "title": "1820 United States census: Benjamin White, Botetourt County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Supplied census transcript: Benjamin White headed a Botetourt County household with two males under 10, two females under 10, a man and woman aged 26-44, and two enslaved people. A son born in 1815 could fit one unnamed male category, but the census does not identify George Washington White by name."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_W_WHITE_1840_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1840 United States census: Benjamin W. White, Greene County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Supplied census transcript: Benjamin W. White headed a Greene County household. The male and female heads were each aged 40-49, with six younger free household members and six enslaved people. The identity with the later Benjamin and Frances household is probable but not explicit."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1850_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1850 United States census: Benjamin and Frances White, Greene County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Supplied census transcript: Greene County, dwelling and family 456. Benjamin White, 58, Virginia-born farmer, with Frances White 51 and children or household members James 24, John 21, and Martha 19."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANCES_WHITE_1860_GREENE_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1860 United States census: Benjamin and Francis White, Greene County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Supplied census transcript: Greene County, dwelling and family 370. Benjamin White, 68, Virginia-born farmer, with Francis White, 60. The ages imply births about 1792 and 1800 respectively."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_HONEY_GROVE_MEMORIAL_1877",
      "title": "Benjamin Franklin White II memorial, Honey Grove, Texas, 1877",
      "type": "cemetery_memorial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Find a Grave indexes supplied by Matthew give Benjamin Franklin White II, born 27 Dec 1789 in Franklin County, Virginia, died 3 Jan 1877 at Honey Grove, Fannin County, Texas, spouse Frances White. The memorial is compatible with the Virginia couple, but their migration from Virginia after 1860 requires corroboration from census, land, probate, or burial evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SABINE_TEXAS_TAX_1836_REJECTED",
      "title": "Rejected or unresolved Benjamin White tax entry, Sabine District, Texas, 1836",
      "type": "conflict_analysis",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A Texas tax index places a Benjamin White in Sabine District in 1836. This is difficult to reconcile with the probable Benjamin W. White household in Greene County, Virginia in 1840 and the documented Virginia households in 1850 and 1860. It is treated as a likely namesake unless evidence shows a temporary Texas residence and return to Virginia."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SAR_PARENT_CLUE",
      "title": "SAR application naming Benjamin White Sr. and child Benjamin White",
      "type": "lineage_application",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Sons of the American Revolution application 23427, filed 22 Apr 1911, names ancestor Benjamin White Sr. and a child Benjamin White. The supplied index lacks dates and connecting generations, so it is only a clue for the earlier White generation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRANCES_WHITE_TEXAS_1836_MEMORIAL_REJECTED",
      "title": "Rejected Frances White memorial death claim, Texas, 1836",
      "type": "conflict_analysis",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A supplied Find a Grave index gives Frances White, maiden name Lavinder, born 19 Jun 1794 at Roanoke, Virginia, and died in Texas in 1836. The death is impossible for Benjamin White's wife because Frances is documented with him in Greene County, Virginia, in both 1850 and 1860. The memorial is conflated or belongs to another woman."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FANNY_LAVENDER_GENEANET_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "title": "Geneanet tree claim for Frances Fanny Lavender and parents",
      "type": "community_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet Community Trees Index supplied by Matthew gives Frances Fanny Lavender, born 19 Jun 1794 in the Franklin/Roanoke area, married Benjamin Franklin White in June 1811, died 1877 in Texas, daughter of Robert Reid Lavender and Ann Nancy Willis. The marriage and father Robert are independently supported; the exact birth, mother, and Texas death remain derivative tree claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROBERT_LAVINDER_NANCY_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1794",
      "title": "Marriage bond of Robert Lavinder and Nancy Willis, Franklin County, Virginia, 27 February 1794",
      "type": "marriage_bond_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Franklin County, Virginia Marriage Bond Index, 1786-1858, page 140, supplied by Matthew: Robt. Lavinder married Nancy Willis in Franklin County on 27 Feb 1794. The same names and locality as the Geneanet parent claim materially strengthen the proposed parents of Fanny Lavinder."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_SUKEY_BARTEE_MARRIAGE_1786",
      "title": "Marriage bond of Benjamin White and Suckey Bartee, Franklin County, Virginia, 8 October 1786",
      "type": "marriage_bond_and_indexes",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Franklin County marriage bond index, page 240, and multiple Virginia marriage transcripts supplied by Matthew: Benj. White married Suckey Bartee at Franklin County on 8 Oct 1786. FHL film 31523, reference p104."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1810_WYTHE_CENSUS",
      "title": "1810 United States census: Benjamin White, Wythe County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Supplied census transcript: Benjamin White headed a 13-person Wythe County household. The male head was 45 or older, the female head 26-44, and eleven younger household members were present. The age structure is compatible with Benjamin born about 1760 and Sukey born about 1767, but household members are unnamed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_1820_EVENSHAM_CENSUS",
      "title": "1820 United States census: Benjamin White, Evensham, Wythe County, Virginia",
      "type": "census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Supplied census transcript: Benjamin White headed an Evensham, Wythe County household with male and female heads aged 45 or older, eight younger free household members, and one enslaved boy. The age structure is compatible with the 1786 married couple but does not name the children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_FRANKLIN_WHITE_BEELER_MEMORIAL_1825",
      "title": "Benjamin Franklin White I memorial, Beeler Cemetery, Sullivan County, Tennessee",
      "type": "cemetery_memorial",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Find a Grave index supplied by Matthew: Benjamin Franklin White I, born 1760 in Augusta County, Virginia; died August 1825 in Sullivan County, Tennessee; buried Beeler Cemetery at Bristol; spouse Susan White; named children Talitha F. Beidleman, William Ballard White, and Jefferson Thompson White. The supplied profile's exact 8 Oct death repeats the marriage month and day and is not adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_FAMILY_HISTORY_1786",
      "title": "Family-history lineage for Benjamin White and Susan Sukey, married 1786",
      "type": "compiled_family_history",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "North America Family Histories and a DAR lineage-book index supplied by Matthew identify Benjamin White, first married in 1786 to Susan Sukey, with child William Ballard White. This is secondary lineage evidence and does not independently establish all children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_UNRESOLVED",
      "title": "Unresolved Revolutionary service records for Benjamin White",
      "type": "military_namesake_cluster",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Supplied indexes include Virginia service by Benjamin White in the Fifteenth Regiment and Clark's Illinois Regiment, plus a Virginia state record dated 9 Oct 1784. A man born about 1760 was of plausible age, but the common name and lack of residence or family identifiers prevent attachment to this Benjamin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_LATER_MILITARY_HINTS_REJECTED",
      "title": "Rejected Civil War and Confederate pension hints for Benjamin White",
      "type": "conflict_analysis",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Civil War and Confederate pension indexes cannot belong to Benjamin White born about 1760 and dead in 1825. They concern later namesakes and are not attached."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BENJAMIN_WHITE_GENEANET_PARENTS_CLAIM",
      "title": "Geneanet tree claim for Benjamin Franklin White I and family",
      "type": "community_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet Community Trees Index supplied by Matthew gives Benjamin Franklin White, born 1760 Augusta County, married Suckey Bartee in 1786, died 1825 Sullivan County, as son of William White and Nancy Ann Britain and father of Benjamin Franklin White and numerous siblings. Marriage and broad vital facts have independent support; parents and the complete child list remain derivative tree claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_POYNER_NEWPORT_BAPTISM_1759",
      "title": "Richard Poyner baptism, Newport, Shropshire, 16 April 1759",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England Select Births and Christenings, FHL film 510671: Richard Poyner was baptized at Newport, Shropshire, on 16 Apr 1759, son of Richard Poyner and Elizabeth. The record does not identify Elizabeth as Allen and does not connect this Richard to Sarah Poyner."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARY_DEANE_CLEOBURY_MORTIMER_BAPTISM_1758",
      "title": "Mary Deane baptism, Cleobury Mortimer, 11 August 1758",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England Select Births and Christenings, FHL film 162094: Mary Deane was baptized at Cleobury Mortimer, Shropshire, on 11 Aug 1758, daughter of Richard Deane and Mary. No supplied marriage links her to Richard Poyner, and she would have been nearly 53 at Sarah Poyner's birth."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SARAH_POYNER_PARENTAGE_CONFLICT_ANALYSIS",
      "title": "Sarah Poyner parentage conflict: baptism, marriage, and imported tree",
      "type": "conflict_analysis",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Sarah's 1811 baptism explicitly names only Mary Poyner as mother. Sarah's 1852 marriage names George Odnett as father. The imported Richard Poyner and Mary Deane parentage is repeated only by a family profile and conflicts with both direct records; Mary Deane would have been nearly 53."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_COMPILED_INDIVIDUAL_CONFLICT",
      "title": "Compiled William Bartee profile with contradictory birth and marriage dates",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy_conflict",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Family Data Collection reports William Bartee born 1750 at Norfolk, spouse Mary, parents William Bartee and Lettishe Butt, marriage in 1762, and death in 1786 at Franklin County. A 1750 birth would make him about twelve at marriage, indicating a date error or merged generations. No displayed record names Suckey as his daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_AGBI_VIRGINIA_CENSUS",
      "title": "William Bartee AGBI Virginia census reference",
      "type": "compiled_census_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "AGBI volume 10 page 124 references a William Bartee in Virginia census material and estimates birth in 1750-1759. The entry does not identify spouse, parents, or children and cannot establish Suckey's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_GOBBLE_PARENTS_JOHN_JIMIMA_INDEX",
      "title": "William Gobble parent index naming John and Jimima Gobble",
      "type": "marriage_relationship_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Virginia Select Marriages relationship index names John Gobble, spouse Jimima Gobble, and child William Gobble. This directly supports the parental couple but does not state Jimima's maiden surname, John's German aliases, or their dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_SUSANNAH_VINES_MARRIAGE_1782",
      "title": "Samuel Felps and Susannah Vines marriage bond, Lincoln County, 13 February 1782",
      "type": "marriage_bond",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "North Carolina marriage bond 000072375 records Samuel Felps and Susannah Vines on 13 Feb 1782 in Lincoln County, with bondsman George Winfree and witness Jas. McEwin. A parallel marriage index confirms the event."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_VA_NC_CENSUS_SEQUENCE",
      "title": "Candidate Samuel Felps/Phelps census sequence, 1800-1830",
      "type": "census_identity_analysis",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Potentially matching households place Samuel Felps in Rowan County, North Carolina, in 1790 and 1800; possibly Washington County, Virginia, in 1810; and Russell County in 1820 and 1830. A second Samuel Felps was enumerated in Lexington, Rowan County, in 1810, so the sequence is not a single proven identity. The 1800 household lacks a young male matching Martin, while the Washington County 1810 household has one male aged 10-15 who could match him. The supplied 1840 household has no elderly couple and is treated as a namesake."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_PARENT_MARTIN_COMPILED_CLAIM",
      "title": "Compiled Samuel Phelps profile and Martin parent hypothesis",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy_candidate",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Family Data Collection gives Samuel Phelps born 1767 in Rowan County, father John Felps, marriage to Susannah Vines in 1782, and death in 1847 at Russell County. Find a Grave repeats the identity and some children but does not list Martin in the supplied excerpt. Martin's middle name Vines, reported North Carolina birth, and later Washington County residence provide circumstantial support."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_REVOLUTIONARY_SERVICE_CONFLICT",
      "title": "Samuel Phelps 1777 Virginia military records, identity unresolved",
      "type": "military_namesake_conflict",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Virginia Revolutionary War rolls name Samuel or Saml Phelps in the 6th Battalion or Regiment in 1777. If the candidate father was born in 1767 he would have been about ten, so either the birth year is wrong or the military records belong to another man. Service is not attached."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_BAPTISM_1639",
      "title": "George Brassington baptism, Caverswall, 16 January 1639",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Caverswall St Peter parish baptism and parallel indexes record George Brassington baptized 16 Jan 1639, father Thomas Brassington. The register excerpt does not name George's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_MARY_KILLEY_LEEK_MARRIAGE_1670",
      "title": "George Brassington and Mary Killey marriage, Leek, 15 August 1670",
      "type": "parish_marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire extracted parish record identifies Mary, maiden name Killey, marrying Geo. Brassington at Leek on 15 Aug 1670."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_LEEK_BAPTISM_1672",
      "title": "George Brassington baptism, Leek, February 1672",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire extracted parish record reports George Brassington baptized at Leek in Feb 1672, son of Geo. and Mary Brassington. Combined with the 1670 same-parish marriage, Mary Killey is strongly supported as his mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_EARLY_LEEK_BRASSINGTON_HOUSEHOLDS_1634_1672_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch indexed Leek Brassington households, 1634–1672",
      "type": "parish baptism index cluster",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/record/results?count=100&q.surname=Brassington&q.birthLikeDate.from=1550&q.birthLikeDate.to=1750&q.birthLikePlace=Staffordshire",
      "citation": "FamilySearch, England, Staffordshire, Church Records, 1538–1944, authenticated search results for Leek baptisms 1634–1672 (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The indexed search shows several distinct Leek Brassington households: Josephus (1634), son of Nicolai and Margarita; Francess (1653), daughter of Thomas and Elizabeth; Johanis (1663), son of Radulphi and Eliza; and Georgis (1672), son of Georgis and Maria. These entries are useful negative evidence against collapsing every same-name Leek or Caverswall person into one household. They are index results, not inspected images."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_ELLENA_LEEK_CHILD_CLUSTER_1637_1648_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch indexed Leek children of Richard and Ellena Brassington, 1637–1648",
      "type": "parish baptism index cluster",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/record/results?count=100&q.surname=Brassington&q.birthLikeDate.from=1500&q.birthLikeDate.to=1650&q.birthLikePlace=Leek",
      "citation": "FamilySearch, England, Staffordshire, Church Records, 1538–1944, authenticated search results for Leek baptisms of Johes (1637), Anne (1640), Maria (1645), and Sara (1648) Brassington (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The index reports Johes Brassington baptized 5 April 1637, Anne 3 April 1640, Maria 11 March 1645, and Sara 5 July 1648, each with Richard Brassington and Ellena as parents (minor Latin/name-order variations). This is a coherent Leek household, but the record images and its relationship to the Caverswall Brassingtons were not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_CAVERSWALL_THOMAS_ELLEN_1628_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch indexed Caverswall christening: Ellen Brassington, 1628",
      "type": "parish christening index",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/record/results?count=100&q.surname=Brassington&q.birthLikeDate.from=1500&q.birthLikeDate.to=1700&q.birthLikePlace=Caverswall",
      "citation": "FamilySearch, England, Births and Christenings, 1538–1975, authenticated result for Ellen Brassington, Caverswall, 31 August 1628 (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The index lists Ellen Brassington christened at Caverswall on 31 August 1628, with Thomas Brassington as father. The mother is not shown in the indexed result; the register image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_CAVERSWALL_GEORG_ELLEN_ANE_1632_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch indexed Caverswall christening: Ane Brassington, 1632",
      "type": "parish christening index",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/record/results?count=100&q.surname=Brassington&q.birthLikeDate.from=1500&q.birthLikeDate.to=1700&q.birthLikePlace=Caverswall",
      "citation": "FamilySearch, England, Births and Christenings, 1538–1975, authenticated result for Ane Brassington, Caverswall, August 1632 (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The index lists Ane Brassington christened at Caverswall in August 1632, with Georg Brassington and Ellen as parents. This is evidence of a second George-led Caverswall household near the 1639 George baptism; the relationship to the direct line is unresolved and the image was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ASHBOURNE_THOMAS_CHILDREN_1656_1659_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch indexed Ashbourne children of Thomas Brassington, 1656–1659",
      "type": "parish christening index cluster",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/record/results?count=100&q.surname=Brassington&q.birthLikeDate.from=1500&q.birthLikeDate.to=1700&q.birthLikePlace=Ashbourne",
      "citation": "FamilySearch, England, Births and Christenings, 1538–1975, authenticated results for John Brassington (12 October 1656) and Ellen Brassington (20 November 1659), Ashbourne (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The index lists John Brassington (12 October 1656) and Ellen Brassington (20 November 1659) christened at Ashbourne with Thomas Brassington as father. This is a separate documented Thomas household in the same broad region. The index does not establish whether this Thomas is the man named in the 1639 Caverswall baptism; images were not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ISABEL_BAGNOLD_TRENTHAM_BAPTISM_1601",
      "title": "Isabel Bagnold baptism, Trentham, 15 February 1601",
      "type": "parish_baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staffordshire extracted parish record reports Isabel Bagnold baptized at Trentham on 15 Feb 1601, daughter of Thomas Bagnold."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_MARYLAND_SERVICE_MARRIAGE",
      "title": "Maryland Revolutionary War record for Christian Gobble and Sarah Grise",
      "type": "military_marriage_record",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Christian Gobble served as a Maryland militia private and was a prisoner. The record identifies spouse Sarah Grise and reports their marriage in 1780 in Frederick County, Maryland."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CHRISTIAN_GOBBLE_CENSUS_1800_1830",
      "title": "Christian Gobble households, 1800-1830 censuses",
      "type": "federal_census_series",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcripts supplied by Matthew. Christian Gobble was enumerated in Liberty, Frederick County, Maryland in 1800; as Christopher Gobble in Washington County, Virginia in 1810; and as Christian Gobble in Washington County in 1820 and 1830. The 1830 household contained a man aged 70-79 and woman aged 60-69."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SUSANNAH_VINES_COMPILED_VITALS_CHILDREN",
      "title": "Compiled profile for Susannah Vines Phelps",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Find a Grave and Family Data Collection transcripts supplied by Matthew report Susannah Vines born 1767 in Rowan County, North Carolina and dead in 1847 or 1848 in Russell County, Virginia. The marriage bond securely identifies her as Samuel Felps's wife, but the exact vital dates are derivative. A 1767 birth implies marriage at about age fifteen. The supplied compiled child list names Samuel David, Margaret A Goble, Lucretia Lilly, and David Phelps, but not Martin Vines Phelps."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_FELPS_1790_ROWAN_CENSUS",
      "title": "1790 census: Samuel Felps household, Rowan County, North Carolina",
      "type": "federal_census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. The household contained one free white male aged sixteen or older and two free white females. It is compatible with a married Samuel and Susannah but does not name household members."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELPS_1810_NAMESAKE_CONFLICT",
      "title": "Competing 1810 Samuel Felps/Phelps households",
      "type": "census_identity_conflict",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcripts supplied by Matthew show a Same Philps household in Washington County, Virginia with a male aged 10-15 who could fit Martin, and a separate Samuel Felps household in Lexington, Rowan County, North Carolina. At least two same-name men or households are represented, so neither 1810 entry alone proves the migration identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HENRY_COUNTESS_1820_WASHINGTON_VA_CENSUS",
      "title": "1820 census: Henry Countess household, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "federal_census",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. Henry Countess headed a nine-person Washington County household with a male and female aged 26-44, five children under sixteen, and one female aged 16-25. The record establishes the surname and locality but does not name other household members. Eda Cauntis had married Martin Phelps in the same county in February 1820 and would likely have been in Martin's household by the August census."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HENRY_AUNLIE_1810_COUNTISS_CANDIDATE",
      "title": "1810 census candidate indexed as Henry Aunlie, Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "census_transcription_candidate",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry transcript supplied by Matthew. The indexed Henry Aunlie household contained a man and woman aged 26-44 and six children, including four girls. The index name is not sufficiently close to Countiss to accept without inspecting the original image. It is retained only as a possible transcription match."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_ANNE_ELISABETH_GINDER_1740",
      "title": "Geneanet profile: Anne Elisabeth Ginder, born 25 Aug 1740 at Hinsing",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew: Anne Elisabeth Ginder, born 25 Aug 1740 at Hinsing, daughter of Antoine Ginder and Marguerite Jansem. The surname Ginder and locality are not yet reconciled with Anna Elisabetha Engel, who is named with Johannes Gonder in the 1762 Obergleen baptism index."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1843_JOHN_R_HENDERSON_GILES_PROBATE",
      "title": "Giles County, Virginia probate: John R Henderson, 1843",
      "type": "probate_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Virginia wills and probate transcript supplied by Matthew: John R Henderson of Giles County; will date indexed 14 May 1843 and probate date indexed 10 May 1843, an internally reversed chronology that should be checked against the image. Listed individuals include Elizabeth, Margaret, Jane, Eliza, and Rebecca Henderson. Robert Henderson is not named in the supplied index."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661",
      "title": "Geneanet profiles: John Draper Hargis I, reported born 1661",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcripts supplied by Matthew report John Draper Hargis born 1661 in Charles County, Maryland, married Mary Catherine Ann Fountain about 1685, and died in Westmoreland County. They name parents William Asa Hargis and Elizabeth Ann Draper and children including John, Mary, and variants of Milerett. Reported death years 1731 and 1732 conflict with the will proved in 1730 and are rejected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_I_1661_1730",
      "title": "Find a Grave index: John Draper Hargis I, 1661-1730",
      "type": "compiled_memorial_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew reports birth 1661 Charles County, Maryland, death 25 Nov 1730 Westmoreland County, burial at Popes Creek Episcopal Church Cemetery, and spouse Mary Ann Hargis. The reported death date equals the probate date and is not accepted as an exact death date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_JOHN_DRAPER_HARGIS_1695",
      "title": "Geneanet profile: John Draper Hargis, reported born 1695",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew reports a John Draper Hargis born 1695 at Oldhams, Westmoreland County, married Grace Boswell about 1720, and names an earlier John Draper Hargis and Mary Catherine Ann Fontaine as parents. Its reported 19 Jun 1730 death is the elder John's will date and is treated as a generational conflation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_GRACE_BOSWELL_HARGIS",
      "title": "Geneanet profile: Grace Boswell Hargis family",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew reports Grace Boswell born 1690 in Westmoreland County, Virginia, married John Draper Hargis there in 1720, died 1790, and was daughter of James Boswell and Ann Smith. It names children including John, Mary Elizabeth, Millerett, Susannah, and Thomas. These remain compiled-tree claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_AGBI_GRACE_BOSWELL_1690S_VIRGINIA",
      "title": "American Genealogical-Biographical Index: Grace Boswell, Virginia birth in the 1690s",
      "type": "published_genealogical_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "AGBI transcript supplied by Matthew gives Grace Boswell born 1690-1699 in Virginia and cites Selden of Virginia, pages 38, 41-42, and 80. It supports only the broad decade and state from the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EARLY_VA_MARRIAGES_ELIZABETH_LUBLINEL_JOHN_HARGES_1725",
      "title": "Early American Marriages: Elizabeth Lublinel and John Harges, 1 Oct 1725",
      "type": "compiled_marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew: Elizabeth Lublinel married John Harges on 1 Oct 1725 in Virginia. Source citation: Jordan R. Dodd et al., Early American Marriages: Virginia to 1850, Precision Indexing Publishers, Bountiful, Utah. The excerpt gives no county, ages, parents, residence, witnesses, or image reference, so it proves the indexed couple but not which John Hargis/Harges is intended."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_MARY_CATHERINE_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS",
      "title": "Geneanet profile: Mary Catherine Fountain Hargis family",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew reports Mary Catherine Fountain born 1665 in King William, Virginia, married John Draper Hargis in 1685 at Accomack, died 1714, mother Jane Jammer, and son John Draper Hargis."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FINDAGRAVE_MARY_ANN_FOUNTAIN_HARGIS_1714",
      "title": "Find a Grave index: Mary Ann Fountain Hargis, died April 1714",
      "type": "compiled_memorial_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew reports Mary Ann Hargis, maiden name Fountain, born 1665 in King William County, died Apr 1714 at King William, buried at Conner Cemetery in New Church, Accomack County, and spouse John Draper Hargis. Memorial facts may be compiled and require underlying records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_AGBI_MARY_ANNE_FOUNTAIN_1670S",
      "title": "American Genealogical-Biographical Index: Mary Anne Fountain, born in the 1670s",
      "type": "published_genealogical_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "AGBI transcript supplied by Matthew gives Mary Anne Fountain born 1670-1679 and cites a Boston Transcript genealogy column dated 19 Jun 1923. This conflicts with the 1665 birth reported by Geneanet and Find a Grave."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SELECT_BIRTHS_MARY_JOHN_HIRGES_CHILD_JOHN",
      "title": "England Select Births and Christenings: Mary, spouse John Hirges, child John Hirges",
      "type": "birth_christening_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew names Mary as spouse of John Hirges and mother of John Hirges. No date, place, film number, or image detail was supplied, so the identity match to the Virginia Hargis family is probable but not definitive."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARYLAND_PROBATE_WM_HARGIS_WILL_BOOKS",
      "title": "Maryland Wills and Probate Records: Wm Hargis, will books 4-10",
      "type": "probate_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew identifies Wm Hargis in Maryland wills volumes covering 1670-1700 and associates his death with Maryland. No family detail appears in the supplied probate-index excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PROFILE_WILLIAM_ASA_HARGIS_1640_1685",
      "title": "Profile: William Asa Hargis, reported 1640-1685/86",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew reports William Asa Hargis born 1640 at St Mary Magdalen Parish, London, and died in Charles County, Maryland. No baptism or direct place evidence was supplied. A 1640 birth would make him about 45 at the 1685 will, not age 40."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_GEO_HARGAS_BY_1642",
      "title": "Virginia Immigrants, 1623-1666: Geo. Hargas arrived by 1642",
      "type": "immigration_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew: Geo. Hargas arrived in Virginia by 1642, sponsored by John Benton; reference Early Virginia Immigrants, 1623-1666 H. No age or family identifiers appear in the excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARRIAGE_INDEX_GEORGE_HARGIS_SUSANNAH_LEA",
      "title": "U.S. and International Marriage Records: George Hargis and Susannah Lea",
      "type": "compiled_marriage_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew names George Hargis, birth place \"of VA,\" and spouse Susannah Lea, marriage state \"of EN.\" It supplies no date, county, parents, or original record citation beyond the database entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ASHWELL_BAPTISM_SUSANNA_LEA_1614",
      "title": "Ashwell parish baptism: Susanna Lea, 22 Jan 1614",
      "type": "parish_baptism_index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England Select Births and Christenings and Christening Index transcripts supplied by Matthew: Susanna Lea baptized 22 Jan 1614 at Ashwell, Hertfordshire, England; father Uriae Lea; mother Joannae; FHL film 569701."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_SUSANNAH_LEA_HARGIS_FAMILY",
      "title": "Geneanet profile: Susannah Lea Hargis family",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew reports Susannah Lea born 1620 in Scotland, married George Hargis in 1642 at Innerwick, Scotland, died 1650 in Maryland, father Uriah Lea, and child William Asa Hargis. The 1620 Scotland birth conflicts with the direct 1614 Ashwell baptism and is rejected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_URIAE_LEA_FAMILY",
      "title": "Geneanet profile: Uriae Lea family",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew reports Uriae Lea born 1588 in Hertfordshire, spouse Joannae/Joan Lea, and child Susannah Lea. Matthew's profile heading alternatively gives birth about 1590 at Ashwell and death 1 Nov 1680 in Cheshire. The vital details are not supported by a direct record in the supplied excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_BAPTISM_JOAN_LEA_1590",
      "title": "Stoke St Gregory parish baptism: Joan Lea, 13 Mar 1590",
      "type": "parish_baptism_register",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Somerset parish transcript supplied by Matthew: Joan Lea baptized 13 Mar 1590 at Stoke St Gregory, Somerset; father Robert Lea. This is a plausible but unproven match to Joannae, wife of Uriah Lea, because the baptism does not name Uriah and occurs far from Ashwell, Hertfordshire."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PROFILE_JOANNAE_LEA_1590_1614",
      "title": "Profile: Joannae Lea, reported 1590-1614",
      "type": "compiled_profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew reports Joannae born 13 Mar 1590 at Stoke St Gregory, Somerset, and died in England in 1614. The birth is plausibly associated with a direct Joan Lea baptism, but the identity link and death remain unproved."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_MARRIAGE_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_1587",
      "title": "Stoke St Gregory parish marriage: Robte Lea and Joan Smith, 3 Dec 1587",
      "type": "parish_marriage_register",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Somerset parish transcript supplied by Matthew: Robte Lea married Joan Smith on 3 Dec 1587 at Stoke St Gregory, Somerset, England."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_ROBERT_LEA_JOAN_SMITH_FAMILY",
      "title": "Geneanet profile: Robert Lea and Joan Smith family",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew reports Robert Lea born 1555 in Somerset, married Joan Smith on 3 Dec 1587 at Stoke St Gregory, and child Joannae/Joan Lea. The marriage is independently supported by the parish register; the birth year and explicit child identification remain compiled evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_MARRIAGE_1789",
      "title": "Virginia, U.S., Compiled Marriages, 1660-1800: John Gobble and Jemima Linder",
      "type": "compiled marriage index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Marriage indexed 17 Nov 1789 in Washington County, Virginia; directly names John Gobble and Jemima Linder as spouses."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JEMIMA_LINDER_INTL_MARRIAGE_1789",
      "title": "U.S. and International Marriage Records, 1560-1900: John Gobble and Jemima Linder",
      "type": "compiled marriage collection",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derivative entry reports Jemima Linder born 1774 in Virginia and married John Gobble in 1789 in Virginia."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANTHONY_MARY_LINDER_JOHN_GOBBLE_1795_LAND_ABSTRACT",
      "title": "Washington County, Virginia court abstract: Anthony and Mary Linder to John Gobble, 1795",
      "type": "secondary land-record abstract",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person%3AAnthony_Linder_%281%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A secondary citation to Annals of Southwest Virginia reports that Anthony and Mary Linder conveyed 170 acres on the North Fork of the Holston to John Gobble on 15 Sep 1795. This is meaningful circumstantial kinship evidence but does not state a parent-child relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SIMON_LINDNER_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_MARRIAGE_1713",
      "title": "Germany, Select Marriages, 1558-1929: Simon Lindner and Margretha Nagel, 1713",
      "type": "indexed church marriage",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Marriage indexed 17 Oct 1713 at Evangelisch Blankenloch, Karlsruhe, Baden. Simon's father is named Stephen Lindner; spouse is Margretha Nagel."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_LANCASTER_WARRANT_1733",
      "title": "Pennsylvania, U.S., Land Warrants, 1733-1987: Simon Linder",
      "type": "land warrant index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Simon Linder received a warrant for 220 acres in Lancaster County dated 4 Jan 1733."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARGRETHA_NAGEL_BAPTISM_1695",
      "title": "Baden and Hesse Lutheran baptisms: Margretha Nagel, 1695",
      "type": "indexed church baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Margretha Nagel was baptized 10 Dec 1695 at Blankenloch. The index names father Hannß Martin Nagel and mother Anna Catharina Nagel."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_ANTON_LINDER_PEGGY_1753",
      "title": "Pennsylvania German Pioneers: Peggy passenger and oath lists, 24 Sep 1753",
      "type": "transcribed passenger and allegiance lists",
      "url": "https://www.gdcooke.org/ss/org2-o/p26342.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The captain's list records Jerick Anthony Linder, age 18. The two allegiance lists carry the immigrant's signature as Gorg Anton Linder. Together they establish an approximate 1735 birth and distinguish him from the young Hans Georg who arrived with Simon Linder in 1733."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANTHONY_LINDER_RESEARCH_SUMMARY",
      "title": "George Anton Linder research summary citing passenger, land, tax, and reported will records",
      "type": "cited genealogical research summary",
      "url": "https://www.gdcooke.org/ss/org2-o/p26342.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Cautious secondary compilation citing the 1753 passenger lists, Washington County surveys and deeds, tax records, and a reported transcript of a will dated 24 Sep 1801 in Knox County, Tennessee. The original will or probate has not been located."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_NEWLAND_WILL_1800",
      "title": "Berkeley County, Virginia Will Book 3, pages 336-337: John Newland, 1800 abstract",
      "type": "secondary will abstract",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person%3AJohn_Newland_%2810%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Will dated 2 Oct 1800 and proved 27 Oct 1800 names Mary Linder among John Newland's children. The abstract directly supports John as Mary's father, but does not identify her mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_FAMILY_RESEARCH",
      "title": "Simon Linder family research citing Nenzenheim and Blankenloch church records and the 1733 passenger lists",
      "type": "cited genealogical research summary",
      "url": "https://www.gdcooke.org/ss/org2-o/p26365.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The reconstructed German family closely matches every named and aged member of Simon Lindor's 1733 passenger household. It identifies Simon as born 3 Apr 1681 at Nenzenheim, son of Stephan Linder and Barbara Mullfinger, and married to Margretha Nagel at Blankenloch on 17 Oct 1713."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SIMON_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER_LIST",
      "title": "Names of Foreigners Who Took the Oath of Allegiance: Samuel, 17 Aug 1733",
      "type": "published transcription of colonial records",
      "url": "https://libsysdigi.library.illinois.edu/oca/Books2008-07/namesofforeigner00egle/namesofforeigner00egle.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The list records Simon Lindor, age 53, with Margrett, Catrina, Simon, Elizabeth, Larance, and Hance Jerck. This family arrived twenty years before George Anton and is not evidence that Simon was George Anton's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRICKE_1940_EAST_ORANGE_HOUSEHOLD",
      "title": "1940 United States Census: George and Mary Sue Fricke household, East Orange, New Jersey",
      "type": "federal census transcript supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The East Orange household names George Fricke, born about 1916 in New Jersey, wife Mary Sue Fricke, born about 1916 in Virginia, and son David Fricke. It also reports their 1935 residences as East Orange and War, McDowell County, West Virginia."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NJ_BIRTH_1915",
      "title": "New Jersey Birth Index: George G. Fricke, East Orange, 11 Nov 1915",
      "type": "state birth index transcript supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The New Jersey birth index records George G. Fricke born 11 Nov 1915 at East Orange, New Jersey."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_GIBSON_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1973",
      "title": "North Carolina death certificate index: George Gibson Fricke, 13 Dec 1973",
      "type": "state death certificate transcript supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The death certificate transcript records George Gibson Fricke born 11 Nov 1915 in New Jersey, died 13 Dec 1973 in Winston-Salem, spouse Mary Sue Henderson, father George Fricke, and mother Florence Gibson."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARY_SUE_HENDERSON_1930_CENSUS",
      "title": "1930 United States Census: Mary Sue Henderson in Edward and Sallie Henderson household",
      "type": "federal census transcript supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Mary Sue Henderson, born about 1916 in Virginia, appears as a child of Ed A. and Sallie Henderson in Big Creek, McDowell County, West Virginia."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_NC_DEATH_1982",
      "title": "North Carolina Death Index: Mary Sue Fricke, 30 Jun 1982",
      "type": "state death index transcript supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The index records Mary Sue Fricke born 6 Feb 1916 in Virginia and died 30 Jun 1982 at Winston-Salem, Forsyth County, North Carolina."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARY_SUE_FRICKE_MEMORIAL",
      "title": "Mary Sue Fricke burial memorial transcript",
      "type": "burial memorial index supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The memorial transcript gives birth 6 Feb 1916 in Virginia, death 30 Jun 1982 at Winston-Salem, burial at Walkertown, and spouse George Gibson Fricke."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PRESBYTERIAN_JOHANN_GEORG_FRICKE_BAPTISM_1881",
      "title": "Presbyterian church baptism: Johann Georg Fricke, Orange, New Jersey, 1881",
      "type": "church baptism transcript supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Johann Georg Fricke, born 28 Mar 1881 and baptized 27 Nov 1881 at Orange, New Jersey, is recorded as the son of Heinrich Fricke and Katharina Schaaf. This directly establishes both parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EDWARD_SALLIE_HENDERSON_1930_HOUSEHOLD",
      "title": "1930 United States Census: Edward and Sallie Henderson household, Big Creek, West Virginia",
      "type": "federal census transcript supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ed A. Henderson, born about 1886 in Virginia, and wife Sallie Henderson, born about 1895 in Virginia, appear with daughter Mary Sue and other children in Big Creek, McDowell County, West Virginia."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEBMD_KEZIA_THOMAS_BIRTH_Q3_1882",
      "title": "FreeBMD civil birth index: Kezia Thomas, Atcham, Q3 1882",
      "type": "civil_registration_index",
      "url": "https://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/search.pl",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeBMD transcript of the England and Wales civil birth index: Kezia Thomas, registered Jul-Aug-Sep 1882 in Atcham registration district, volume 6a, page 676. A registration quarter is not an exact birth date and the index does not name parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEBMD_MARIA_HANNEY_BIRTH_Q2_1846",
      "title": "FreeBMD civil birth index: Maria Hanney, Bradford W, Q2 1846",
      "type": "civil_registration_index",
      "url": "https://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/search.pl",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeBMD transcript of the England and Wales civil birth index: Maria Hanney, registered Apr-May-Jun 1846 in Bradford W registration district, volume 8, page 276. This supports the documented Hanney/Haney/Hanny spelling variants and the Bradford-on-Avon census identity, but does not independently prove the GEDCOM-only exact birth date of 1 Apr 1846."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEBMD_FREDERICK_DAVIES_MARIA_HANNY_MARRIAGE_Q3_1879",
      "title": "FreeBMD civil marriage index: Frederick Davies and Maria Hanny, Atcham, Q3 1879",
      "type": "civil_registration_index",
      "url": "https://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/search.pl",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reciprocal FreeBMD index searches place Frederick Davies and Maria Hanny on the same Atcham marriage-registration page in Jul-Aug-Sep 1879, volume 6a, page 1129. Their 1891 and 1901 census households independently establish that these two page entries represent the married couple."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEBMD_SARAH_BOULTON_DEATH_Q4_1879",
      "title": "FreeBMD civil death index: Sarah Boulton, Stone, Q4 1879",
      "type": "civil_registration_index",
      "url": "https://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/search.pl?sq=1&surname=Boulton&end=1880&countyid=all&eq=4&type=Deaths&districtid=all&given=Sarah&start=1879",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeBMD transcript of the England and Wales civil death index: Sarah Boulton, age 70, registered Oct-Nov-Dec 1879 in Stone registration district, volume 6b, page 30. Her age, surname, quarter, district, and the family's 1861-1871 Hanford residence identify this as Sarah Maria Poyner Rhead Boulton with high confidence. The index establishes the registration district and quarter, not an exact date or exact place of death."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_HENDERSON_FAMILY_RECORD_NOTES",
      "title": "McNew-Henderson family notes citing Washington County marriage and census records",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy_with_record_citations",
      "url": "https://www.claynet.com/athomas/thomasre/pafn09.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Detailed family notes cite Robert Henderson and Mary McNew's 1 Nov 1849 Washington County marriage; the 1850 Robert and Mary Henderson household immediately following David and Ann McNew and their children; and David and Ann/Annie together in the 1860, 1870, and 1880 censuses. The compiler explicitly states that Ann's maiden surname is unknown and reports earlier Morgan or Kennedy suggestions as unproved. This is secondary evidence and should not replace the underlying records, but its household-level citations materially clarify the family cluster."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WCV_PARENT_INDEX_DAVID_ANN_MCNEW",
      "title": "Washington County, Virginia parent index: David and Ann McNew",
      "type": "county_record_index",
      "url": "https://genealogyresources.org/Index-Wuml.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Washington County parent index lists David and Ann McNew as parents of Scenah McNew. This independently supports Ann as David's long-term spouse and mother of at least one child, but it does not itself name Mary McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEBMD_ELIZABETH_HANNY_DEATH_Q2_1838_CANDIDATE",
      "title": "FreeBMD civil death index candidate: Elizabeth Hanny, Keynsham, Q2 1838",
      "type": "civil_registration_index_candidate",
      "url": "https://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/search.pl?type=Deaths&start=1837&eq=4&countyid=all&given=Elizabeth&sq=1&surname=Hanny&end=1855&districtid=all",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeBMD transcript: Elizabeth Hanny, registered Apr-May-Jun 1838 in Keynsham registration district, volume 11, page 93. The married surname and timing after William Hanny's 1837 death are compatible with Elizabeth Peters Hanny, but the index supplies no age and Keynsham is not Bradford-on-Avon. This remains an unresolved candidate, not an adopted death."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PETERS_WILLIS_MARRIAGE_1764",
      "title": "North Bradley St Nicholas marriage register: Isaiah Peters and Betty Willis, 18 June 1764",
      "type": "parish register transcript",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685b1f838655743a54f1ac7a/isaiah-peters-betty-willis-marriage-wiltshire-north-bradley-1764-06-18",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG transcript records the marriage and witnesses John Butche and Richard Gibbs; it does not prove either spouse's exact vital dates or identify their children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RANTON_PARISH_REGISTER_BRASSINGTON_1764",
      "title": "Ranton Parish Register transcript: John, son of John and Jane Brassington, baptized 18 November 1764",
      "type": "published parish register transcript",
      "url": "https://books.google.com/books?id=a1IZAAAAIAAJ",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published transcript of the Ranton register explicitly names both parents. The continuing John-and-Jane child series distinguishes this family from John Brassington of Chelmorton who married Mary Swindell in 1765."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RANTON_BRASSINGTON_CHILD_SERIES_1761_1781",
      "title": "Ranton parish-register Brassington child series, 1761-1781",
      "type": "published parish register transcript",
      "url": "https://books.google.com/books?id=a1IZAAAAIAAJ",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Repeated Ranton baptisms to John and Jane, including the 1764 John and later children, support a stable parental couple; no marriage record or Jane maiden surname is established here."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEORGE_MCNEW_CHANCERY_DAVID_SON",
      "title": "Washington County, Virginia chancery abstract: Francis Smith v. George McNew",
      "type": "court record abstract",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/washington-county-virginia-chancery-notes/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Witness testimony explicitly describes David McNew as son of George McNew Sr. This directly supports the father relationship but does not name David's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEEDHAM_HANNAH_CHILD_BAPTISM_SERIES",
      "title": "Ashbourne St Oswald baptisms of children of Edward and Hannah Needham, 1768-1779",
      "type": "parish register transcripts",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG entries identify Edward and Hannah as parents of Edward (1768), Robert (1773), Nathaniel (1776), and William (1779). They strengthen the documented parental household but do not substitute for the target Hannah Needham's direct baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_FANNY_GEORGE_WHITE",
      "title": "WeRelate compiled profile for Benjamin White family",
      "type": "secondary compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person:Benjamin_White_(68)",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explicitly lists George Washington White among children of Benjamin Franklin White and Frances Fanny Lavender. Useful corroboration, but not independent primary proof; the page ultimately relies on compiled genealogy."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_FAMILY_HISTORY_WILLIAM_MARY",
      "title": "Early History of the McNew-Cawood Families: William and Mary McNew family",
      "type": "published family history citing county records",
      "url": "https://edirwin.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Chapter-1-Early-history-of-the-McNew-Cawood-families.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "States William, wife Mary, and four youngest sons including George moved southwest in 1773; cites Washington County, Virginia Will Book 2. It supports a mother/wife named Mary but does not establish whether her surname was Berry, Clemons, or another name."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_MARTIN",
      "title": "Southern Colonial Phelps Y-DNA paternal-line research: Samuel Felps and Martin Vines Phelps",
      "type": "compiled lineage and Y-DNA research",
      "url": "https://sites.google.com/site/archivedydnaphelpsgenealogies/06-three-phelps-felps-lines-with-relevant-ydna-matches/common-ancestor-of-david-b-1817-tn-and-ancestor-descendant-of-felps-of-baltimore-co-b-ca-1678/-6e-unresolved-major-line-of-colonial-america",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explicitly identifies Martin Vines Phelps as a child of Samuel Felps and Susannah Vines and describes the Rowan-to-southwest-Virginia migration. This is published compiled research, not a substitute for the full Russell County will or a contemporary child record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WERELATE_BENJAMIN_SUSAN_BARTEE_CHILDREN",
      "title": "WeRelate family profile: Benjamin White and Susan Bartee",
      "type": "secondary compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Family:Benjamin_White_and_Susan_Bartee_(1)",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explicitly lists Benjamin Franklin White, born 27 Dec 1790, among children of Benjamin White and Susan Bartee. The couple's 1786 marriage is direct, but the child list is derivative rather than a contemporary parent record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HARGIS_FAMILYSEARCH_JOHN_1742_AMELIA",
      "title": "FamilySearch compiled profile: John Draper Hargis IV, 1742-1779",
      "type": "collaborative compiled profile with internal conflicts",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/L6LM-571/john-draper-hargis-iv-1742-1779",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Amelia Hargis as daughter of a John born 1742 and Elizabeth Freelove, while listing the 1722 John and Ann Whiteside as that John's parents. The profile is internally conflated because it also assigns 1820 and 1830 census events after the reported 1779 death. It demonstrates the generational conflict but does not resolve it."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_AMELIA_1765_FATHER_1742",
      "title": "RootsMagic compiled profile: Amelia Hargis, 1765-1860",
      "type": "compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://sites.rootsmagic.com/woodvineandoaks2/individual.php?p=1658",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Amelia's father as John Draper Hargis IV, born 1742. It supplies no original parent record and does not identify Amelia's mother on the displayed profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_IPGV_CHRISTIAN_GABEL_1754_BAPTISM",
      "title": "IPGV migration card: Christian Gabel, baptism 21 May 1754 at Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran Church",
      "type": "institutional migration card citing church register",
      "url": "https://migration.pfalzgeschichte.de/person/57067",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Names Christian Gabel, born 19 Apr 1754, as son of Johann Friedrich Gabel and Christiana Henrietta Hornberger and cites his 21 May 1754 baptism at Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran Church. The IPGV cautions that older card data were not always systematically verified, so this is treated as a faithful institutional derivative of the register rather than the original image."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY_JEREMIAH_SARAH",
      "title": "Early History of the McNew-Cawood Families: Jeremiah II, Sarah, and St. John's Parish children",
      "type": "published family history citing colonial court and land records",
      "url": "https://edirwin.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Chapter-1-Early-history-of-the-McNew-Cawood-families.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Quotes the 10 Jan 1670 Charles County court indenture naming Jeremiah Macknew and Phillis his wife as parents of John Howard; cites Maryland land-patent and court series; reconstructs Jeremiah II as their later Maryland-born son. Directly proves the older couple and one child, while Jeremiah II parentage remains a strong published reconstruction."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_BARTEE_SUKEY_WHITE_BOND_SURETY_1786",
      "title": "William Bartee profile citing Franklin County marriage bond for Suckey Bartee and Benjamin White",
      "type": "record-based compiled profile citing original marriage bond",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person:William_Bartee_(8)",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "States that on 8 Oct 1786 William Bartee was surety on the Franklin County marriage bond for his daughter Suckey and Benjamin White. Also cites 1782 land and road records and the 1786 personal-property tax list. The original bond image was not inspected, so confidence is slightly below direct-image certainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_TURNER_WHITE_FAMILIES_CHICKASAW_BEN_2001",
      "title": "David Anderson Turner and Bonnie Turner Cook, White Families of the Virginias (2001)",
      "type": "published compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://books.google.com/books/about/White_Families_of_the_Virginias.html?id=cUpFPwAACAAJ",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies the William White Jr. and Nancy Ann Brittain family with Benjamin Harrison White, born about 1765 in Frederick County, who married Nancy Ann Goodwin. That identity conflicts with attaching the same parents to Benjamin White of Augusta/Franklin/Sullivan who married Suckey Bartee in 1786."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEWLAND_JOHN_WILL_ABSTRACT_MARY_LINDER",
      "title": "Berkeley County Will Book 3 abstract: John Newland will, 1800",
      "type": "published will abstract",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person:John_Newland_(10)",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Will dated 2 Oct and proved 27 Oct 1800 names Mary Linder and Isaac Newland among John Newland's children. Combined with Brock's statement that Jemima Linder's mother was Isaac Newland's sister, this strongly identifies Mary Newland Linder as Jemima's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STOEVER_NEWLAND_LINTNER_MARRIAGE_1739",
      "title": "Rev. John Casper Stoever marriage register: Johann Ulandt and Elizabetha Lintner, 23 Apr 1739",
      "type": "published parish-register transcript",
      "url": "https://familyhartroots.com/PA/Lancaster/StoeverMarriages.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The published Stoever register transcript lists 23 Apr 1739, Lintner, Elizabetha of Earltown, and Ulandt, Johann. It directly establishes the couple; spelling variants align with later Newland/Linder records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BERKELEY_NEWLAND_ELIZABETH_DEEDS_1773_1780",
      "title": "Berkeley County deed abstracts naming John Newland and wife Elizabeth, 1773-1780",
      "type": "county deed abstracts",
      "url": "https://www.wvgw.net/jefferson/newlandbio.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published deed-book abstracts repeatedly name John Newland/Nuland and wife Elizabeth in 1773, 1777, and 1780, corroborating continuity of the 1739 couple."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEWLAND_HOPE_PASSENGER_1734",
      "title": "Hope passenger list: John Nouland, age 24, 23 September 1734",
      "type": "digitized published passenger-list transcription",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/pennsylvaniagerm42stra",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Strassburger/Hinke, Pennsylvania German Pioneers, volume I, printed pp.142–146, lists 37A–C. John Nouland, age 24, appears in 37A on p.143. Previous source title Johan and secondary citation p.144 corrected by inspection. The captain collectively describes Palatines, but explicitly marks John Robeson a Briton. Nouland has no recognizable counterpart in the two 49-man oath lists. That establishes an apparent omission, not its cause or his birthplace. Identification with later John Newland remains a separate reconstruction."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MORE_OAK_BOWERY_MARLOW_SHAW",
      "title": "More Oak Bowery Families: McNew, Marlow, and Shaw compiled line",
      "type": "compiled family history",
      "url": "https://publiclibrary.cc/digitalcollections/files/original/12/13662/More-Oak-Bowery-Families.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This derivative family history names Edward Marlow and Mary Shaw as Sarah Marlow's parents. It is useful corroborating tree evidence but does not cite a direct child record for Sarah."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN10_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
      "title": "Generation 10 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Breadth-first generation-10 review of all connected profiles and parent-child links. Primary/published records were distinguished from compiled-tree claims; derivative links were retained at lower confidence unless contradictory."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_CATALOG",
      "title": "Archion: Erpfingen Protestant church-book holdings, 1594-1875",
      "type": "official archive catalog",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/baden-wuerttemberg/evangelisches-archiv-baden-und-wuerttemberg-wuerttemberg/dekanat-reutlingen/erpfingen/110904",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official Evangelisches Archiv/Archion catalog confirms surviving Erpfingen mixed registers covering 1597-1739 and baptism registers covering 1670-1739. The catalog establishes record availability but does not itself prove any individual event."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_GOBEL_ERPFINGEN_EXACT_TREE",
      "title": "Geneanet compiled Erpfingen Göbel/Batzer family: Johannes Ignatius Göbel and Ursula Batzer",
      "type": "compiled public tree index",
      "url": "https://no.geneanet.org/fonds/individus/?go=1&nom=GOBEL&page=2&place__0__=Erpfingen%2C+W%C3%BCrttemberg&size=50",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Compiled tree reports Johannes Ignatius Göbel born 9 Jul 1645, married Ursula Batzer 5 Nov 1678, died 24 Feb 1714, with parents Martin Göbel and Anna Katharina Kissling. Archion confirms relevant registers survive, but no original entry was accessible in this audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES_COUNTY_DEED_1671_1674",
      "title": "Archives of Maryland vol. 60, Charles County court proceedings: Ralph Shaw land purchase",
      "type": "published transcript of colonial court record",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000060/html/am60--381.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Charles County court proceedings record George Taylor conveying land to Ralph Shaw for a mare, colt, and tobacco. This directly establishes an adult Ralph Shaw in Charles County in 1671-1674, but not his wife or children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_RENT_ROLL",
      "title": "Maryland State Archives Land Office rent rolls naming Ralph Shaw",
      "type": "official archival rent-roll scan/index",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/stagserm/sm100/sm130/000000/000014/pdf/mdsa_sm130_14.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Maryland Land Office rent-roll material names Ralph Shaw. It corroborates the colonial Charles County landholder but does not identify Mary Shaw as his daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BUTT_FAMILY_HISTORY_LEMUEL_CATHERINE",
      "title": "Published Butt family history naming Lemuel Butt and Kathrine Wilkins",
      "type": "compiled family history",
      "url": "https://www.ourfamtree.org/attach/B/u/Butt0002.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The published family narrative calls Horatio Butt son of Lemuel Butt and Kathrine Wilkins. It is useful derivative evidence for the couple but does not directly name Lettisha or reproduce an original record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MYTREES_LEMUEL_BUTT_CATHERINE_WILKINS",
      "title": "MyTrees submitted family: Lemuel Butt and Catherine Wilkins Warden",
      "type": "submitted compiled tree",
      "url": "https://www.mytrees.com/names/Event/Year/1/WILKINS_WARDEN",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Submitted tree reports Lemuel Butt (1704-1753), Catherine Wilkins Warden (about 1706-1762), marriage about 1734, and daughter Letitia/Lettishe born about 1735. No original record citation is exposed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NORFOLK_1704_QUIT_RENT_ROBERT_BARTEE",
      "title": "Virginia 1704 quit-rent roll: Robert Bartee, Norfolk County",
      "type": "published transcript of colonial tax record",
      "url": "https://jemgen.com/documents/Virginia%201704%20Quit%20Rents.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The 1704 Norfolk County quit-rent roll names Robert Bartee. It proves a same-name adult landholder but appears more likely to be the older Robert who died in 1711 than the reported Robert born about 1704."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_MARY_WIRICK_FAMILY",
      "title": "WeRelate compiled family: Robert Bartee and Mary Wirick",
      "type": "collaborative compiled tree",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Family%3ARobert_Bartee_and_Mary_Wirick_%281%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Compiled family separates an older Robert Bartee, dead before 18 May 1711, from a son Robert born about 1704 and dead about May 1782. The current imported generation appears to conflate these Roberts and Mary Wirick roles."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN11_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
      "title": "Generation 11 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Breadth-first review of all 21 connected generation-11 profiles and adjacent relationships. Original/published colonial records, official archive catalogs, and compiled-tree claims were distinguished; named derivative candidates were retained at calibrated confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WERELATE_MARY_HEBDON_TESTIMONY_1730",
      "title": "Norfolk County Will Book 11 testimony concerning widow Mary Hebdon, 1730/31",
      "type": "published transcript of colonial probate testimony",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person%3AMary_Wirick_%282%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "WeRelate quotes McIntosh, Brief Abstracts of Norfolk County Wills 1710-1753, pp. 151-152, Will Book 11 p. 53. William Portlock and Prudence Bartee testified that widow Mary Hebdon, in her last sickness on 23 Jan 1730/31, made gifts to her son Andregan Bartee and son John Hebdon; Prudence called Mary her mother. This proves Mary had Bartee and Hebdon children but does not itself prove Wirick as her maiden name or identify son Robert."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WERELATE_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1782",
      "title": "Robert Bartee will, Norfolk County Will Book II, signed 13 Mar 1780, proved May 1782",
      "type": "published transcript of colonial probate record",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person%3ARobert_Bartee_%282%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "WeRelate quotes a Library of Virginia microfilm abstract, Norfolk County Will Book II 1772-1788, pp. 131-132. Robert devised to son Thomas land whose bounds had been given to Robert's grandfather Henry Werrick by the latter's will. The will directly establishes the 1782 Robert and the Werrick-grandfather relationship; it does not name Robert's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LVA_NORFOLK_WILL_MICROFILM_CATALOG",
      "title": "Library of Virginia Norfolk County will and deed microfilm catalog",
      "type": "official archive catalog",
      "url": "https://www.lva.virginia.gov/collections/ccmf/VA/VA195",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official catalog confirms surviving Norfolk County wills and deeds, including 1722-1736 wills and Will Book No. 2, 1772-1788. It establishes the cited record series but is not an individual-name index."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_1678_1731_UNSOURCED",
      "title": "FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731",
      "type": "collaborative compiled tree",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/GSKN-XQX/robert-butt-1678-1731",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile names spouse Elizabeth Church and children including two different Lemuels, but explicitly shows zero attached sources. Its chronology contradicts the imported 1704 birth for Robert, who cannot have fathered Lemuel in the same year."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WERELATE_LEMUEL_BUTT_1704_1753",
      "title": "WeRelate compiled profile: Lemuel Butt, about 1704-about 1753",
      "type": "collaborative compiled tree",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person%3ALemuel_Butt_%281%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile gives Lemuel Butt born about 1704 in Norfolk, spouse Catherine Wilkins, and daughter Letitia, but supplies no parents or original record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1558",
      "title": "Genealogie Online Walker tree: Jeremiah MacKnew born about 1558",
      "type": "compiled public tree",
      "url": "https://www.genealogieonline.nl/walker-family-tree/P1998.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derivative Walker tree reports Jeremiah MacKnew born about 1558, died at Edinburgh, and a son Jeremiah born 1610. Its only source is private, so the claim cannot be independently checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_MARLOW_HALL_CLUSTER",
      "title": "Geneanet compiled cluster: Robert Marlow and Anne Hall",
      "type": "compiled public tree",
      "url": "https://gw.geneanet.org/tdowling?m=N&t=A&u=460639&v=Hall",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet repeats Anne Hall born before 1622 with Robert Marlow born before 1618. No original parish, marriage, probate, or land record is cited or exposed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN12_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
      "title": "Generation 12 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Breadth-first review of all 13 profiles initially reached at generation 12 and adjacent relationships. Corrected the Bartee/Wirick generational conflation from quoted Norfolk probate abstracts, consolidated duplicate Goebel father edges, removed two identity-free placeholders, and recalibrated derivative English, German, Scottish, and Virginia claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_CHURCH_BOOK_PEDIGREE_GOBEL",
      "title": "Herbert Weigel, ancestor list using Erpfingen and Willmandingen church books",
      "type": "published sourced genealogy with parish-register transcriptions",
      "url": "https://genealogie-nordwuerttemberg.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/AL-ERHARDT-HILSENBECK-version-2.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entries 1288 and 2576-2577 cite and quote the Erpfingen/Willmandingen church books. Martin Goebel the younger was born 6 Dec 1600 to Martin Goebell and Margaretha Berlin and buried 10 Mar 1673 aged 73. The elder Martin, a ducal forest servant, was born about 1575 and buried 3 Aug 1662; his wife Margreth Berlin was baptized 27 Nov 1576 at Weinsberg, daughter of Magister Johans Berlin and Anna. The first Erpfingen marriage entry, about Nov 1597, is nearly illegible. Rechecked 15 September 2026: entry ?5152 on printed p.250 also proposes Hans Göbel about 1550–about 1627 as father of elder Martin #2576; explicitly Filiation ist nicht gesichert. Mother unnamed. Earlier database statements that the pedigree omits both parents were incorrect."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_MARTIN_GOBELL_1575_COMPILED",
      "title": "Ancestry compiled profile: Martin Gobell about 1575-1662",
      "type": "compiled public tree",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/martin-g%C3%B6bell-24-21j5sz0",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile gives Martin born about 1575 at Erpfingen and died 3 Aug 1662, but calls his wife Margaretha Maria Berlin while assigning parents Hannssen Goebells and Margaretha Koch. The parish-based Weigel pedigree supports Martin and Berlin as the couple but does not supply those parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN13_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
      "title": "Generation 13 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Breadth-first review of all ten profiles initially reached at generation 13. Converted the blank Goebel mother placeholder into record-transcribed Margaretha Berlin, removed two remaining identity-free placeholders, retained named Church and MacKnew hypotheses at low confidence, and distinguished directly named Lea parental roles from unverified exact vitals."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_EARLY_RECORD_GUIDE",
      "title": "Scotland's People guide to early church, tax, and testament records",
      "type": "official archive research guide",
      "url": "https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/news-and-articles/top-ten-search-tips",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "National Records of Scotland explains that church registers begin in the sixteenth century and that wills/testaments run from 1513. Searches did not locate an accessible contemporary record for the claimed Matthew Mackneugh 1518-1550 line; the guide establishes available record classes, not an individual identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN14_ONLINE_AUDIT_20260724",
      "title": "Generation 14 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Breadth-first review of all five connected generation-14 profiles. Preserved the directly recorded 1587 Lea-Smith marriage, lowered the cross-county Joan identity connection, retained the Mackneugh claim at low confidence, and reduced the unsourced Koch/Goebells parent claims while noting that the parish-based Goebel pedigree does not identify the elder Martin's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VA_HOUSE_RICHARD_CHURCH_1699",
      "title": "Virginia House of Delegates History: Richard Church, Norfolk County, 1699",
      "type": "official legislative history",
      "url": "https://history.house.virginia.gov/members/2357",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Virginia House Clerk history identifies a Richard Church serving Norfolk County in 1699 but supplies no spouse, children, birth, or death. It supports a same-name Norfolk contemporary, not identification as Elizabeth Church's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN13_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
      "title": "Generation 13 terminal-branch expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all five generation-13 profiles lacking parents. Added the parents directly reported for Margaretha Berlin in the parish-based pedigree. No defensible parents were found for Henry Werrick, Mary Werrick, Richard Church, or Uriae Lea. Massachusetts Church pedigrees were rejected as geographically incompatible with the Norfolk hypothesis."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BUTT_MARSHALL_WINGFIELD_1990",
      "title": "Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River",
      "type": "published genealogy compiled from official and family records",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/search/catalog/539067",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch catalogs this work under Marshall Wingfield Butt, born 1896, with publication date 1990 and publisher Filmed by the Genealogical Society of Utah. It covers Robert and Jane Butt and their descendants. The digitized film is restricted; its relevant pages have not been inspected, and it has not been shown to contain or originate the separate Bruce-Warrenton Hall-Sir William legend."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN12_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_20260724",
      "title": "Generation 12 terminal-branch expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed the six connected generation-12 profiles without parents. Added low-confidence compiled parents for Robert Butt because their chronology and Norfolk context are compatible and a published Butt genealogy independently covers the family. Corrected Anna Kissling from a parish-based pedigree. Rejected the London Hargas infant ancestry and found no defensible parents for the Hall-Marlow or older Bartee profiles."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BUTT_VA_NC_FAMILY_HISTORY_PDF",
      "title": "History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina",
      "type": "compiled family history with cited Virginia land and probate records",
      "url": "https://www.ourfamtree.org/attach/b/u/Butt0001.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Anonymous, undated surviving one-page sheet; the inspected local scan has SHA-256 6409267977ee8753381e245830ad3407056620ecdbdc8170bb070aefcf3c8a8b and PDF metadata naming Robert E. Tripp III, which does not establish original authorship. The page explicitly admits that Robert and James could not be traced in England and that Warrenton Hall and Sir William Butts could not be authenticated. Its Hotten citation proves only that James Butt and Mary Middleton held 42 acres in St George Parish, Barbados, in 1679; it gives no relationship to Robert. The page also reports 1653 arrival, calls Jane Elizabeth Jane Bruce, and infers inherited influence from acreage. Direct patents show that the 1,200-acre tract was consolidated by assignment and purchase, not simply bestowed for social rank."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_EARLY_HISTORY",
      "title": "Early History of the McNew-Cawood Families, chapter 1",
      "type": "published family history citing Maryland court proceedings",
      "url": "https://edirwin.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Chapter-1-Early-history-of-the-McNew-Cawood-families.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The history begins the documented line with Jeremiah and Phillis Macknew in Charles County, Maryland, in 1668, quotes their 1670 court indenture of son John Howard, and says their birthplace is unknown."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN13_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
      "title": "Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reassessed all generation-13 terminal profiles after the generation-12 expansion. Added Robert Butt and wife Jane as the probate-supported parents of Richard Butt; sharply downgraded the contradicted Richard/Sarach-to-Robert reconstruction; and documented why Matthew MacKnew was not extended."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN14_FRONTIER_EXPANSION_20260724",
      "title": "Updated generation 14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed the four profiles newly added to generation 14 after the earlier five-person generation-14 audit. The parish-based Weigel pedigree supplies Johann Berlin's career and cautiously proposes Hans Beerlin and Agatha Bleyle as his parents, explicitly marking the filiation unsecured. No parents were added for Anna or the Virginia Butt couple."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_HISTORY_BOWMAN_THOMAS_1997",
      "title": "Anna Mae Bowman and Judy Thomas, McNew History: A Family Research Documentary, 1640-1997",
      "type": "published genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/catalog/687371",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The 108-page 1997 genealogy identifies Jeremiah MacKnew, born about 1640, and Phillis as the immigrant ancestors who arrived in Maryland in 1668. Its catalog scope does not extend the family through sixteenth-century Matthew Mackneugh profiles."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_MEMORABILIA_CARROLL_1998",
      "title": "Joseph C. Carroll, McNew (MacKnew, McKnew) Memorabilia, revised and expanded edition",
      "type": "published genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/library/books/records/?fulltext=1&search=%22MCNEW+FAMILY%22",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The 809-page 1998 edition is a history of Jeremiah MacKnew and his descendants. The FamilySearch description says Jeremiah was born about 1640, possibly in Scotland, and that Phillis may have originated in Scotland, Ireland, or northern England. It does not identify Jeremiah's parents and is protected/search-only online."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_REDDIT_MACKNEW_SCOTLAND_QUERY_2021",
      "title": "Reddit r/Scotland: MacKneugh / MacKnew family-tree query (14 Jul 2021)",
      "type": "online genealogy discussion",
      "url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/Scotland/comments/ok092p/hello_i_have_a_question_does_anyone_recognize/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The poster reports encountering an online Matthew MacKneugh dated 1555 but explicitly says no records were found. The post also describes uncertainty and possible conflation between Jeremiah MacKnew and a supposed same-named father, both associated with a wife named Phyllis. This is derivative testimony about online claims, not proof of Matthew or any parent-child relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHANN_PLENINGEN_HANS_BEERLIN_NAMESAKE",
      "title": "Johann Pleningen entry, Early Modern Physicians' Letters database",
      "type": "scholarly person database",
      "url": "https://aerztebriefe.kallimachos.de/Johann_Pleningen",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The database lists Hans Berlin and Hans Beerlin among the aliases of physician Johann Pleningen, born before 1500 at Esslingen and died 1563 at Stuttgart. His chronology and career distinguish him from the Hans Beerlin who died at Uberkingen in 1588."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN15_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Generation 15 frontier research review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Initial searches found no parents for Hans Beerlin or Agatha Bleyle and excluded a same-name physician. Subsequent exact inspection of the published Weigel pedigree found uncertain ancestor 20,618 Sebastian Bleyle; because Agatha is 10,309, the numbering places Sebastian precisely as her proposed father. He is retained at low confidence because the source marks the filiation uncertain and exposes no original record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN4_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Connected generation-4 terminal expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all four connected people at generation 4 who have no attached parents: Henry Albert Fricke, Katharine Schaaf, John Gibson of Aghnasedagh, and Jane Thomas. Targeted searches for parent-naming immigration, naturalization, baptism, marriage, census, valuation, and derivative-tree evidence produced no defensible new parent relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_YOURROOTS_HENRIETTE_MUELLER_FRICKE_CONFLATION",
      "title": "YourRoots: Henriette Charlotte Heinderike Mueller, 1829-1892",
      "type": "derivative aggregated tree",
      "url": "https://yourroots.com/tree/person/henriette-mueller-1829-1892--agfkxtmzpohjq",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The page includes Henry Albert Fricke, 1846-1918, among several duplicated Henry Jr children of Henriette Mueller and Henry Fricke Sr. Its own timeline places Henriette in St Louis in 1860 and 1870, while also assigning children born in Hanover, Philadelphia, and Texas. The target Henry reported immigration in 1867 and was in New Jersey, making this aggregate an internally conflated family rather than evidence of his parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_REDDIT_OBER_GLEEN_SCHAAF_FAMILY_2023",
      "title": "Reddit genealogy discussion: Schaaf miller family of Ober-Gleen (2023)",
      "type": "online genealogy discussion with record links",
      "url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/Genealogy/comments/1893oo0/earlymid_1800s_prussia_research/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The discussion cites FamilySearch images for children of Johann Martin Schaaf and Anna Catharina Grau at Ober-Gleen, including Carl born 1841, and notes at least two contemporary Johann Martin Schaafs. It establishes a documented Schaaf cluster in the village but does not identify Katharine Schaaf Fricke of New Jersey as their daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MONAGHAN_PRESBYTERIAN_REGISTER_COVERAGE",
      "title": "John Grenham: historic Presbyterian church-register coverage for County Monaghan",
      "type": "record repository guide",
      "url": "https://www.johngrenham.com/records/county_church_full.php?county=Monaghan&denomination=Presbyterian&search_type=full",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The repository guide distinguishes the Monaghan congregations. First Monaghan baptism records listed online begin in 1860, but Second Monaghan baptisms survive from 1802 under PRONI MIC.1P/146. John Gibson married at Second Monaghan in 1883, so his reported 1850 baptism may survive there. Earlier notes treating all Monaghan Presbyterian baptism coverage as beginning in 1860 were too broad."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HOCKETT_DELIA_TALLY_HENDERSON_1866_HEADSTONE",
      "title": "Jack Hockett, Female Residents of Washington County from the 1850 Census: Delia Tally/Henderson",
      "type": "published annotated record compilation",
      "url": "https://www.ramblingroots.com/RYB-p/not-found-1850.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The compilation transcribes the 10 Sep 1866 Washington County marriage register: widow Delia Tally, age 35, born and resident Washington County, parents unnamed, married William Henderson. It also transcribes her Mahanaim Cemetery stone as death 16 Aug 1897, age 66 years 7 months 21 days, yielding birth 26 Dec 1830. It separately reports a daughter death record naming Delia Fadas/Faddis; that maiden-name evidence is indirect."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_RIVER_1850_EVANS_ADELIA_TALLY",
      "title": "New River Notes transcript: 1850 Grayson County census, Evans and Adelia Tally",
      "type": "published primary-record transcript",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/grayson-federal-census-1850/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "District 19, dwelling/family 339: Evans Tally, 27, Virginia-born laborer, and Adelia Tally, 18, Virginia-born. This independently exposes the already cited 1850 household and is consistent with Delia's later identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HENRY_SHORTT_DEATH_1937",
      "title": "New River Notes transcript: Henry Shortt death, 20 Apr 1937",
      "type": "published official-record transcript",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/smyth-county-virginia-death-records/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Smyth County death-record compilation identifies Henry Shortt, born 10 May 1865 in Virginia and died 20 Apr 1937, as a son of George Shortt; his mother was not known to the informant. This corroborates the 1870 George Shortt household but does not identify George's parents or prove Susan Jones's own ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN6_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Connected generation-6 terminal expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all 18 connected generation-6 people without attached parents. Searches covered record repositories, published transcripts, cemetery material, catalogs, and derivative trees. Ann McNew and Holly Tally received evidence-based identity refinements; no sufficiently identified earlier parent was added."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HOCKETT_DAVID_ANN_SMITH_MCNEW_FAMILY",
      "title": "Jack Hockett annotated Washington County compilation: David and Ann Smith McNew family",
      "type": "published annotated record compilation",
      "url": "https://www.ramblingroots.com/RYB-p/found-1850.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The annotated compilation identifies household 254 in Washington County in 1850: David McNew, 47; Ann, 45; and children Elizabeth, Ailsey, Samuel, Nancy, Louisa, and Cena. It quotes Samuel McNew's 1918 death record naming David McNew and Annie Smith, and reports the 1880 census as David and Nancy/Ann/Annie, both age 76, living with daughter Ailsey; Ann's parents were reported born in North Carolina. The record supports Smith as her probable maiden surname but does not name her parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HOCKETT_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_1860_HOUSEHOLDS",
      "title": "Jack Hockett annotated census compilation: Holly Tally with probable children, 1850-1860",
      "type": "published annotated record compilation",
      "url": "https://www.ramblingroots.com/RYB-p/not-found-1850.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The compilation places Holly Tally, 55, North Carolina-born, in William Ferren and probable daughter Tabitha Tally's 1850 Grayson County household; in 1860 it places Holly, reported age 70 and North Carolina-born, in Evan and Delia Tally's Washington County household. Co-residence strongly supports close kinship but the pre-1880 censuses state no relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_RIVER_HOLLY_TALLY_1850_GRAYSON",
      "title": "New River Notes transcript: Holly Tally, 1850 Grayson County census",
      "type": "published primary-record transcript",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/grayson-federal-census-1850/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "District 19, household 237 includes Holly Tally, age 55, born North Carolina, with William and Tabitha Ferren and their children. It corroborates Holly as a real census person but does not state her relationship or maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BENJAMIN_WHITE_JULIA_SIMS_PROFILE",
      "title": "FamilySearch collaborative profile: Benjamin Franklin White, 1837-1920",
      "type": "collaborative derivative profile with record references",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/KFRL-GBK/rev-benjamin-franklin-white-1837-1920",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The public profile repeats George Washington White and Julia Ann Sims as Benjamin's parents and their Washington County family, consistent with existing records, but supplies no parents for Julia. It therefore corroborates the known household only and does not extend Julia's ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN7_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Connected generation-7 terminal expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all ten connected generation-7 people without attached parents. Exact-name, parish, chronology, published-register, and derivative-tree searches found no parent identification strong enough to attach. Plausible low-confidence links would have been retained under project policy, but the located candidates were either geographically incompatible, chronologically conflicting, or lacked any bridge to the target family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_HARDWICKE_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1777",
      "title": "Forton All Saints Hardwicke Marriage Index: John Greenley and Elizabeth Pickin, 1777",
      "type": "published parish-register index",
      "url": "https://www.tinstaafl.co.uk/eandwhmi/staffordshire/church%20pages/forton.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry 80 records John GREENLEY and Elizabeth PICKIN marrying at Forton on 31 Dec 1777. It independently confirms the couple in the correct parish but supplies no ages, residences, or parents, so it cannot extend either ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILTSHIRE_QUAKER_BIRTHS_WAINE_EXCLUSION",
      "title": "Wiltshire OPC transcript: Quaker births, 1664-1837",
      "type": "published record transcript",
      "url": "https://www.wiltshire-opc.org.uk/Items/Wiltshire/Wiltshire%20-%20Quaker%20Births%201648-1837.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Waine entries identify an Edmund-and-Hannah family and a later Edmund-and-Mary family associated with Purton/Purton Stoke. No Catherine Waine matching the Bradford-on-Avon/Winsley wife appears. These records are useful exclusions, not evidence for attaching that family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CUMNOCK_KIRK_SESSION_CHARLES_HANNEY_EXCLUSION",
      "title": "Cumnock History Group kirk-session index, 1704-1737",
      "type": "published archival index",
      "url": "https://cumnockhistorygroup.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/Kirk-Sessions-1704-to-1737-Names-Index.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The index identifies a Charles Hanney married to Jannet Crawford in Cumnock, Scotland, in 1732 and father of Helen baptized there in 1736. Geography and an established Scottish household make him an incompatible namesake, not the Winsley man who married Catherine Waine in 1765."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN8_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Connected generation-8 terminal expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all ten connected generation-8 people without attached parents. The Gobble family association database supports Johann Friedrich Gobble and Elizabeth Weigel as John Gobble's parents. Published Phelps/Y-DNA lineage research supports John Felps and Mary May Williams as Samuel Felps's parents but explicitly describes uncertainty in the higher Felps reconstruction. Other terminal identities lacked a non-contradictory parent bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBLE_ASSOC_JOHANN_FREDERICK_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_FAMILY",
      "title": "Goble Family Association database: Johann Friedrich Gobble Jr. and Elizabeth Weigel family",
      "type": "published family-association genealogy",
      "url": "https://goblegenealogy.com/data/German/grpf0876.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Names Johann Friedrich (Frederick) Gabel/Gobble Jr., born 12 Oct 1734, and wife Elizabeth Weigel, married 10 May 1757 at Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran Church, and lists their son John born 10 Feb 1766 in Baltimore County. The page cites James Sargeant Gobble's Gobble Family Genealogy and numbered underlying references, but the original baptism image for John was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WERELATE_JOHN_PHEBE_WILLIS_NANCY_LAVINDER_CONFLICT",
      "title": "WeRelate compilation: proposed John Willis and Phebe Bennett parents of Nancy",
      "type": "collaborative derivative genealogy with record references",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person:John_Willis_(65)",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The narrative child list explicitly names Nancy, approximately 1774, with husband Robert Lavinder and their matching 27 February 1794 marriage. Nancy’s omission from the shorter structured list is not an exhaustive list of heirs and does not contradict that claim. The parentage remains a compiled assertion; the site also lists Parmelia separately."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN9_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Connected generation-9 terminal expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all six connected generation-9 terminal profiles. Multiple published genealogies name George Weigel and Anna Margaret Ditlich as Elizabeth Weigel's parents, supporting moderate-confidence connections to two existing isolated profiles. Christiana Hornberger, Anthony Linder, John Felps, Mary Williams, and the possible Mary Bartee lacked non-contradictory parent evidence sufficient to extend."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WRIGHT_CHAMBERS_ELIZABETH_WEIGEL_PARENTS",
      "title": "Wright and Chambers genealogy: Elizabeth Weigel, parents and Gabel family",
      "type": "published derivative genealogy with cited compiled record",
      "url": "https://www.genealogieonline.nl/wright-and-chambers-family-of-southwest-virginia-and-northeast-tennessee/I1556844113.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Names Elizabeth Weigel as a child of George Weigel and Anna Margaret Ditlich, reports birth 20 Dec 1737 in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, and repeats her 10 May 1757 Old Goshenhoppen marriage to Johann Friedrich Gabel. Its cited Family Data Collection is derivative, not an original baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN10_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Connected generation-10 terminal expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all seven connected generation-10 terminal profiles. The 1733 immigrant household and cited Linder Quarterly/Newland research establish that the source-backed Elizabetha Lintner who married John Newland is the duplicate profile already placed as Simon Linder and Margretha Nagel's daughter. The two identities were consolidated and her incorrect Pennsylvania birthplace was corrected. No non-contradictory higher parents were found for the other six terminals."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN11_TERMINAL_EXPANSION_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Connected generation-11 terminal expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all fourteen connected generation-11 terminal profiles. Added Georg Batzer and Ursula Hinckh from a parish-register-based Erpfingen pedigree; corrected Johannes Goebel and Ursula Batzer; documented the incompatible derivative link to Hans Jacob Gabel; and distinguished Ralph Shaw's documented 1710/11 wife Ann from the unidentified first wife who was probably Mary Shaw's mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WEIGEL_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL_BATZER_FAMILIES_2023",
      "title": "Herbert Weigel, Ahnenliste Erhardt / Hilsenbeck, 2nd ed. (Erpfingen Goebel and Batzer church-book families)",
      "type": "published parish-register-based pedigree",
      "url": "https://genealogie-nordwuerttemberg.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/AL-ERHARDT-HILSENBECK-version-2.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Pages 84 and 132 cite and quote Erpfingen, Willmandingen, and Reutlingen church books. Johannes Goebel was born 11 Oct 1641, married Ursula Batzer 10 May 1670, and died 5 Jun 1732; Ursula was born 1 Jul 1650 and died 27 Jan 1731. Her parents were Georg Batzer and Ursula Hinckh; the latter surname occurs in daughter Barbara's 1648 Reutlingen baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CHARLES_COUNTY_RALPH_SHAW_AGREEMENT_1710",
      "title": "Charles County land-record abstract: Ralph and Ann Shaw agreement with Edward Marlow, 19 Mar 1710/11",
      "type": "land-record abstract and sourced reconstruction",
      "url": "https://www.fgs-project.com/maryland/groups/l/lanham-john-.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Abstract cites Charles County Land Records Liber C no. 2 p.223. Ralph and Ann Shaw reserved lifetime support from Edward Marlow. The compiler identifies Edward, Randall Garland, and John Lanham as husbands of daughters of Ralph and his first wife, expressly distinguishing the later wife Ann in the agreement."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN12_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Connected generation-12 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all eight connected generation-12 terminal profiles. Strengthened the older Robert Bartee and Mary Wirick family from two cited Norfolk wills; added moderate-confidence parents for Anna Catharina Kieffer while documenting a conflicting derivative parent set; and found no defensible higher parents for the other six terminals."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CADIZ_RECORD_ROBERT_BARTEE_WILL_1711",
      "title": "Cadiz Record genealogy column abstract of Robert Bartee will, Norfolk County, 19 May 1711",
      "type": "published will abstract",
      "url": "https://www.digifind-it.com/jlslibrary/data/newspapers/Cadiz%20Record/1940/1940-06-27.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The 27 Jun 1940 genealogy column states that the Norfolk County will of Robert Bartee, 19 May 1711, named sons Adrigan, Robert, and Samuel and wife Mary. This is a published abstract rather than an inspected will image."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710_ABSTRACT",
      "title": "Henry Wirick will, Norfolk County Book 9 p.25, dated 28 Dec 1710 and proved 20 Apr 1711",
      "type": "published transcript of colonial will",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Family%3AHenry_Wirick_and_Mary_Unknown_%283%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The abstract quotes Henry Wirick devising his plantation to daughter Mary Barttee for life and then to grandson Robert Bartee and his male heirs. It directly identifies Mary as Henry's daughter and Robert as her son."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_KIEFFER_BLANKENLOCH_SIBLING_GROUP",
      "title": "FamilySearch reconstruction of Hanss Georg Kieffer and Margretha Helena Widman family, Blankenloch",
      "type": "record-linked collaborative family",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/9F99-96W/hans-georg-kiefer-1663-1693",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Hans Georg Kiefer profile cites Germany Births and Baptisms and the Blankenloch church book and places Anna Catharina Kieffer, 1661-1716, among eight children of Hanss Georg Kieffer and Margretha Helena Widman. Anna's own indexed entry was not opened."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENARCHIVES_KIEFFER_CONFLICTING_PARENTS",
      "title": "GenArchives Lang family derivative pedigree for Anna Catharina Kieffer",
      "type": "compiled genealogy conflict",
      "url": "https://www.genarchives.com/langfamily/g1/p88.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This derivative pedigree instead assigns Anna Catharina Kieffer, born 18 Oct 1661 and died 13 Dec 1716, to Hanss Wendel Kieffer and Anna Barbara of the Münzesheim/Kraichtal area. No citation is displayed for that parentage. It is retained as conflict evidence, not selected over the record-linked Blankenloch sibling group."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN13_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Connected generation-13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all ten connected generation-13 terminal profiles after the generation-12 Kieffer expansion. Reconciled the user-supplied Hans Simon Nagel/Catharina profiles with the exact-dated Hans Anthoni Nagel/Anna Catharina Hansen derivative family; added Barbara Radler as a low-confidence mother of Barbara Mollfinger; and documented why the other terminals were not extended."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENARCHIVES_HANS_ANTHONI_NAGEL_FAMILY",
      "title": "GenArchives Lang family: Hans Anthoni Nagel and Anna Catharina Hansen family",
      "type": "compiled genealogy with exact-dated parish-style events",
      "url": "https://www.genarchives.com/langfamily/g1/p88.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The pedigree identifies Hans Anthoni Nagel, born about Oct 1622 and died 2 May 1693, and Anna Catharina Hansen, 1628-22 Oct 1678, as parents of Hannss Martin Nagel born 14 Feb 1656. It lists a large Blankenloch-area sibling group but displays no citations; the exact original entries were not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_YOURROOTS_LINDER_NAGEL_KIEFFER_DERIVATIVE",
      "title": "YourRoots derivative pedigree for Linder, Nagel, Kieffer, and Mollfinger families",
      "type": "community tree",
      "url": "https://yourroots.com/tree/person/elizabeth-ii-1760-1829--ynyvjiylzelki",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Repeats the established Linder/Nagel line and names Johann Mollfinger and Barbara Radler as Barbara Mollfinger's parents. It also repeats the selected Kieffer/Widman couple. No source citations are displayed, so new relationships from this page are retained only at low confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN14_CONNECTED_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Connected generation-14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all twelve connected generation-14 terminal profiles after the generation-13 Mollfinger expansion. Identified the imported Martin Linder/Salome Werren-to-Michael link as a likely conflation between a published Swiss Saanen family and the documented Nenzenheim German line; retained but sharply downgraded those parent links. No defensible new parents were found for the other terminals."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOG_MARTIN_SALOME",
      "title": "The Linder Quarterly, Linder Family Association, catalog description",
      "type": "published genealogical periodical catalog",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/search/catalog/48711",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The FamilySearch catalog says this long-running quarterly specifically covers Martin Linder and Salome Werren, as well as distinct Swiss and German Linder families. It supports the couple's existence in published research but does not itself display pages proving their children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WEIGEL_BLEYLE_SEBASTIAN_20618",
      "title": "Herbert Weigel, Ahnenliste Erhardt/Hilsenbeck, entries 10,309 and 20,618",
      "type": "published sourced genealogy; explicitly uncertain filiation",
      "url": "https://genealogie-nordwuerttemberg.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/AL-ERHARDT-HILSENBECK-version-2.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Corrected 15 September 2026: visually checked printed p.331 gives Sebastian as ?21618, c.1504-c.1568; index p.390 gives Bleyle 10309,20618. Since Agatha is 10309, a body numbering typo is the leading explanation. This supports the intended tentative filiation but is not direct historical proof. Earlier exact-number claims omitted the internal discrepancy."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GEN16_BLEYLE_FRONTIER_REVIEW_20260724",
      "title": "Generation 16 Sebastian Bleyle frontier review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed the sole connected generation-16 profile. Exact-name and Bleyle/Bleile variant searches found no independent record, spouse, locality, parent, or additional attributable pedigree. The Weigel surname index links only Agatha 10,309 and Sebastian 20,618 and does not continue the Bleyle line. Sebastian remains connected solely as an explicitly uncertain published-genealogy father at 0.50 relationship confidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WIESENSTEIG_CATHOLIC_REGISTERS_BURNED",
      "title": "GenWiki Wiesensteig church-register coverage",
      "type": "genealogical locality guide",
      "url": "https://genwiki39.genealogy.net/Wiesensteig",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "For the Catholic parish serving Wiesensteig and its local context, baptisms begin in 1648, marriages in 1649, and deaths in 1648; the guide states that older church books burned. These dates postdate Agatha Bleyle's reported 1535 birth and Sebastian Bleyle's reported lifetime."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HOHENSTADT_OA_AALEN_CATALOG_EXCLUDED",
      "title": "FamilySearch catalog 72854, Hohenstadt church books, 1580-1921",
      "type": "archive catalog; excluded wrong locality",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/catalog/72854",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The catalog author is explicitly Katholische Kirche Hohenstadt (OA. Aalen), and its locality subject is Hohenstadt in Oberamt Aalen. It is not Hohenstadt in the Göppingen/Wiesensteig area associated with Agatha Bleyle's 1555 Gruibingen marriage and the couple's Überkingen deaths, so its records must not be used to extend this branch without a separate migration proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_DIDDLEBURY_BAPTISM_1787",
      "title": "George Hodnett baptism, 4 Feb 1787, Diddlebury St Peter, Shropshire",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/684f65008655745a790e2832/george-hodnett-baptism-shropshire-diddlebury-1787-02-04",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG transcription names George Hodnett, son of Benjamin and Martha Hodnett, baptized 4 Feb 1787 at Diddlebury St Peter. This is a geographically plausible identity candidate for the George Odnett named by Sarah Poyner in 1852, but no record connects the two identities."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_GEORGE_HODNETT_ANN_MOUND_LUDLOW_MARRIAGE_1804",
      "title": "George Hodnett and Ann Mound/Munn marriage, 23 Apr 1804, Ludlow St Laurence",
      "type": "published parish-register transcript",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/622223ccf493fd4c0fcabf1d/george-hodnett-ann-mound-marriage-shropshire-ludlow-1804-04-23",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG transcription from a Phillimore transcript records George Hodnett marrying Ann Mound or Munn by licence at Ludlow St Laurence on 23 Apr 1804, witnessed by Mary Pope and Edward Powys. A son Richard was baptized at Ludlow in 1805. The marriage makes this George an identifiable nearby contemporary but does not prove that he was Sarah Poyner's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_WATERHOUSE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_KINGSLEY_1767_1769",
      "title": "FreeREG: two James Waterhouse baptisms at Kingsley, Staffordshire, 1767 and 1769",
      "type": "parish-register transcriptions",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/5c1b7923f493fd3679211260/james-waterhouse-baptism-staffordshire-kingsley-1767-05-31",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG records James, son of James and Ann Waterhouse, baptized at Kingsley on 31 May 1767, and another James, son of William and Mary Waterhouse, there on 18 Oct 1769. Both are only regional candidates for the James Waterhouse buried at Ashbourne in 1840 aged 75; neither has an identity bridge to his 1799 marriage or later family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_MORRALL_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1810_1811",
      "title": "FreeREG: Richard Morrall/Murral baptism candidates, Bloxwich 1810 and Newcastle-under-Lyme 1811",
      "type": "parish-register transcriptions",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/5bf6ad2ef493fd2d6c2794f5/richard-morrall-baptism-staffordshire-bloxwich-1810-08-19",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG records Richard, son of Samuel and Mary Morrall, baptized at Bloxwich on 19 Aug 1810, and Richard, son of Samuel Murral, born 2 Dec and baptized 29 Dec 1811 at Newcastle-under-Lyme. The target Richard consistently reported Horsehay/Wellington, Shropshire, and neither Staffordshire entry is bridged to him; they therefore cannot identify his father Samuel or justify higher ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1734_1738",
      "title": "FreeREG: Edward Needham/Nedham baptism candidates, Carsington 1734 and Ashbourne 1738",
      "type": "parish-register transcriptions",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/682f51908655746c65f24a9d/edward-needham-baptism-derbyshire-ashbourne-1738-06-09",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Both FreeREG pages rechecked 15 September 2026: Edward Nedham, Samuel and Martha, Carsington 21 February 1733/34; Edward Needham, George, Ashbourne 9 June 1738. Carsington leads on the adult burial age; Ashbourne has the same-parish advantage. No marriage-licence age for Edward is verified: 21 belongs to Hannah in the saved excerpt. Baptism need not immediately follow birth. Both candidate parent families are attached at different ordinal confidence levels, not as simultaneous established parentage. See research/needham_review_20260915/REASSESSMENT.md."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_HANAH_MELLOR_BRADBOURNE_BAPTISM_1732",
      "title": "Hanah Mellor baptism, 15 Jun 1732, Bradbourne All Saints",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6175c0b1f493fd2843d3e66e/hanah-mellor-baptism-derbyshire-bradbourne-1732-06-15",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG records Hanah, daughter of Thomas and Mary Mellor, baptized at Bradbourne on 15 Jun 1732. A Hannah Mellor married William Mattley at nearby Bakewell in 1754, and no record bridges the Bradbourne child to Edward Needham's 1758 Ashbourne bride. The baptism is retained as an unresolved candidate only."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_PICKIN_WHITMORE_BAPTISM_1756",
      "title": "Elizabeth Pickin baptism, 11 Jan 1756, Whitmore St Mary and All Saints",
      "type": "published parish-register transcript",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685627da8655747a97d85b61/elizabeth-pickin-baptism-staffordshire-whitmore-1756-01-11",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG records Elizabeth, daughter of William and Sarah Pickin, baptized at Whitmore on 11 Jan 1756. Her age and locality are compatible with the Elizabeth Pickin who married John Greenley at Forton in 1777, but the marriage supplies no age, residence, or parents and other Picken baptisms exist farther away. William and Sarah remain candidates, not attached parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_GRINDLEY_HODNET_BAPTISM_BURIAL_1754",
      "title": "John Grindley baptism and burial, Hodnet, 1754",
      "type": "parish-register transcriptions",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/63934b57f493fd755e32b798/john-grindley-baptism-shropshire-hodnet-1754-08-22",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG records John, son of Thomas and Elizabeth Grindley of Wollerton, baptized at Hodnet on 22 Aug 1754. A same-name Wollerton burial on 28 Dec 1754 identifies the infant's death and excludes him from being the adult John who married at Forton in 1777. Thomas and Elizabeth must not be attached through this candidate."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANN_ELIZABETH_WHITESIDE_PROFILE_REVIEW",
      "title": "FamilySearch profile: Ann Elizabeth Whiteside, about 1720-1811",
      "type": "collaborative derivative profile",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/L6QH-YYR/ann-elizabeth-whiteside-1720-1811",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The profile names William Whiteside and Mary Sarah Calvert as Ann's parents and places Amelia among Ann's children. Its displayed source list contains only Summers' abstract of the 1779 administration of John Hargis's estate. That estate citation may support John's death or household but does not, as displayed, identify Ann's parents or prove Amelia was her direct daughter. The proposed upstream Whiteside/Calvert pedigree is therefore not attached."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRANKLIN_VA_LAVINDER_MARRIAGES_1794_1795_CONFLICT",
      "title": "Franklin County, Virginia marriage index: Robert Lavinder/Lavender, 1794 and 1795",
      "type": "published county marriage transcription",
      "url": "https://genealogytrails.com/vir/franklin/marriages1785-1855_3.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcription gives Robert Lavinder and Nancy Willis a marriage date of 27 February 1794, with no bond date. It separately gives Robert Lavender and Milly Willis a bond dated 23 September 1795, surety James Highly, and marriage on 30 September. The entries permit two men, remarriage, or a recording/name problem; they do not establish that Nancy, Milly and Parmelia are one woman. Original marriage images remain uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBBLE_STEEN_CHRISTIAN_SARAH_GISE_RESEARCH",
      "title": "Evelyn Goble Steen, Revolutionary War Stories: Christian Goble/Gobble/Gabel",
      "type": "published family-history article citing pension file",
      "url": "https://www.goblegenealogy.com/bios/gobble.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Steen summarizes Christian Goble's National Archives pension file W.2931. Christian enlisted 20 Jul 1776 as a private in Captain Jacob Good's company, Colonel Griffin's Maryland Flying Camp; fought at White Plains and Fort Washington; was captured and held about three months in New York's Sugar House before parole; worked as a saddle maker in Taneytown; married Sarah Geiss/Gise in fall 1780; applied for pension in Washington County, Virginia on 19 Nov 1832; and died 7 May 1834. The article supplies no parents for Sarah."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_MARY_ECKLESS_BERRY_DERIVATION",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: William McNew and Mary Eckless Berry family",
      "type": "compiled online genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/8/a/e6cce7aa0dd4d853e09cafb6a8.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This Gramps compilation calls William McNew's wife Mary Eckless Berry and gives reported 1718-1798 vitals, but its references for the family are other online genealogies (Henderson-Mitzel and My Twigs and Branches). It provides no contemporary record establishing Mary's maiden surname or parents. The Berry/Eckless naming remains a low-confidence identity hypothesis only."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBLE_HORNBERGER_PARENT_INITIALS_REVIEW",
      "title": "Goble Family database: Christiana Henerietta Hornberger",
      "type": "compiled family-history database",
      "url": "https://goblegenealogy.com/data/German/grpf0965.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The database identifies Christiana as Johann Friedrich Gabel's wife and gives her parents only as \"C. Hornberger\" and \"M. C. unknown.\" A large Geneanet tree expands those initials to Christian Hornberger and Maria Catherine, but supplies no displayed original source. Passenger compilations contain multiple Christian Hornbergers of materially different ages, so the initials cannot safely identify a particular couple."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_ANTHONY_LINDER_ANCESTRY_REVIEW",
      "title": "Cookie Crumbs Ancestry: George Anton \"Anthony\" Linder",
      "type": "carefully cited compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.gdcooke.org/ss/org2-o/p26342.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This study cites the 1753 Peggy passenger and oath lists, later Washington County records, and a family-held copy of Anthony's reported will. It explicitly notes that the circulated will provenance is uncertain and provides no European parents. A 1734 Sausenheim baptism remains chronologically plausible but lacks a birthplace or kinship bridge to the immigrant."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_JOHN_FELPS_IDENTITY_CONFLICT",
      "title": "Southern Colonial Phelps Y-DNA project: conflicting John Felps identities",
      "type": "published surname/Y-DNA research",
      "url": "https://sites.google.com/site/archivedydnaphelpsgenealogies/06-three-phelps-felps-lines-with-relevant-ydna-matches/common-ancestor-of-david-b-1817-tn-and-ancestor-descendant-of-felps-of-baltimore-co-b-ca-1678",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The project explains that an older compiled child list conflated the John who married Mary Williams in 1766 with a different John assigned a later wife. It debates whether the 1766 John was Aquilla Felps's son, Aquilla's brother, or another related man. This is a material identity conflict and higher parents cannot be selected from that compilation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WERELATE_WEIGEL_DITLICH_EDMUND_WEST_WARNING",
      "title": "WeRelate review of Johann Gobble and Elizabeth Weigel family",
      "type": "collaborative genealogy with source critique",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Family%3AJohann_Gobble_and_Elizabeth_Weigel_%281%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The page repeats George Weigel and Anna Margaret Ditlich as Elizabeth's parents but identifies its sole basis as Edmund West's Family Data Collection and expressly labels that collection unreliable. No baptism, probate, deed, or church record naming Elizabeth's parents is supplied. The proposed couple therefore cannot be extended further or treated as securely identified."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_JOHN_NEWLAND_ANCESTRY_UNKNOWN_REVIEW",
      "title": "Cookie Crumbs Ancestry: John Newland",
      "type": "carefully cited compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.gdcooke.org/ss/org2-o/p26344.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This reconstruction cites the 1734 Hope passenger list, 1739 Stoever marriage register, Berkeley deeds, and John's 1800 will, but explicitly describes his ancestry as unknown or untraced. It also questions the common German-origin assertion. Online pedigrees naming Matthäus Uhland and Anna Catharina Müntz conflict with other proposed origins and supply no identity bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_CAWOOD_PHILLIS_PARENTAGE_UNKNOWN",
      "title": "McNew-Cawood early history: Jeremiah and Phillis Macknew",
      "type": "published family history citing Maryland court and settler records",
      "url": "https://edirwin.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Chapter-1-Early-history-of-the-McNew-Cawood-families.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The study quotes the 1670 Charles County court record naming Jeremiah and Phillis and cites Maryland settler records for her indenture. It expressly states that the couple's birthplace is unknown and gives no parents for Phillis. Mackneugh may be a recorded married/variant surname rather than a proven maiden name."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STUBBS_GRACE_BOSWELL_SELDEN_NAMESAKE",
      "title": "John Stubbs of Cappahosic genealogy: Grace Boswell, wife of John Selden",
      "type": "published compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/john-stubbs-of-cappahosic-gloucester-virginia-1652/49645517",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This genealogy identifies a Grace Boswell as the third wife of John Selden of Elizabeth City. It demonstrates that another colonial Virginia woman bore the same name and makes broad Grace Boswell searches unsafe. It provides no bridge to the proposed Hargis mother and does not validate James Boswell or Ann Smith as her parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOBLE_GERMAN_HANS_JACOB_GABEL_RHEINMUELLER",
      "title": "Goble Genealogy: Hans Jacob Gabel and Maria Margaretha Rheinmueller",
      "type": "derivative compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.goblegenealogy.com/data/German/grpf0966.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The current Goble database repeats Hans Conrad Rheinmueller as Maria Margaretha's father and gives her mother only as Maria Margaretha unknown. It gives Hans Jacob Gabel's parents as unknown and cites the Gobble Family Genealogy for the marriage. No original parish image or source identifies either Rheinmueller parent further."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN11_20260724",
      "title": "True-frontier generation-11 evidence review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Recomputed the connected graph from Matthew and distinguished all 22 generation-11 people from the 13 actual frontier profiles having no recorded parents. Rechecked primary/published Maryland records and derivative German, English, Scottish, and Virginia claims. No noncontradictory parent candidate with an adequate identity bridge was found for these 13 endpoints."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN12_20260724",
      "title": "True-frontier generation-12 evidence review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Recomputed generation 12 as seventeen connected people but seven true frontier profiles. Rechecked the parish-register-based Erpfingen/Willmandingen pedigree, Norfolk probate abstracts, Virginia immigration evidence, and derivative Hall-Marlow and Hargas claims. No new parent met the required identity and chronology tests."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN13_20260724",
      "title": "True-frontier generation-13 evidence review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all eleven true generation-13 frontier profiles. Rechecked Blankenloch/Nenzenheim derivative pedigrees, Norfolk probate and legislative evidence, Ashwell baptisms, and the disputed Butt reconstruction. No parent candidate had a sufficient identity bridge; no relationship was added."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN14_20260724",
      "title": "True-frontier generation-14 evidence review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed all twelve true generation-14 frontier profiles. Rechecked Württemberg parish-based families, Somerset and Ashwell Lea evidence, Norfolk Butt probate, Swiss Linder/Werren material, and disputed Göbel and Mackneugh pedigrees. No parent candidate passed identity, locality, and chronology tests."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN15_20260724",
      "title": "True-frontier generation-15 evidence review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Rechecked Hans Beerlin under Beerlin, Bärlin, and Berlin variants against the published Württemberg parish-based pedigree, scholarly identification of the older physician Johann Pleningen, archival/catalog searches, and derivative-tree indexes. No attributable parents were found; later and same-name people were not merged."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_REVISIT_TRUE_FRONTIER_GEN16_20260724",
      "title": "True-frontier generation-16 evidence review, 24 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Rechecked Sebastian Bleyle under Bleyle, Bleile, Bleyel, and Bläule variants. Numerous derivative-index repetitions were found but no independent contemporary record, spouse, locality, or parents. The sole specific filiation remains Herbert Weigel's explicitly questioned Ahnentafel entry; relevant Wiesensteig-area registers begin only in 1648/1649 after earlier books burned."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN2_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-2 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed existing census, civil registration, death, burial, probate, residence, and compiled evidence for all four deceased generation-2 ancestors and conducted exact-name web searches. Occupations were recorded only where a record stated them; no occupation was inferred from sex, marital status, or household role."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1924",
      "title": "Price & Lee Co. Directory of the Oranges, 1924: George Fricke",
      "type": "city_directory",
      "url": "https://www.digifind-it.com/maplewood/data/city-directories/1924/1924_p3.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The alphabetical directory directly advertises FRICKE GEORGE as a plumbing, heating and tinning contractor at 338 Halsted, East Orange, with his home at the same address and telephone Orange 64. The classified contractors section independently lists George Fricke, plumbing and heating, at 338 Halsted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_GEORGE_FRICKE_1929",
      "title": "Price & Lee Co. Directory of the Oranges, 1929: George Fricke",
      "type": "city_directory",
      "url": "https://www.digifind-it.com/maplewood/data/city-directories/1929/1929_p12.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The 1929 plumbers classification lists Fricke George at 7 Park End Place, East Orange. The street guide independently records George Fricke, plumber, at number 7."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALFRED_PERCY_DAVIES_WW1_NAMESAKE_EXCLUSION",
      "title": "Leighton War Memorial biography: Alfred Percy Davies, South Lancashire Regiment",
      "type": "military_namesake_conflict",
      "url": "https://ww1.wales/other-counties/montgomeryshire-memorials/leighton-war-memorial/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This Private Alfred Percy Davies, service number 14949, was a son of Thomas Griffith and Jane Davies of Leighton and worked as a waggoner and collier. Those parent, residence, and occupation details contradict the tree identity born at Shrewsbury to Frederick Davies and Maria Evans. The military record is therefore a documented namesake exclusion, not service by I45."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN3_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-3 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed census, directory, civil, passenger, burial, obituary, probate, military-name, and compiled evidence for all eight generation-3 ancestors. Occupations were recorded only when explicitly stated. Draft registration was not treated as military service, and no occupation was inferred from locality, sex, marital status, or household role."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN4_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-4 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed census, directory, civil, church, valuation, immigration, naturalization, cemetery, military-name, probate, and compiled evidence for all sixteen generation-4 people. Facts are dated observations, and no occupation or military service was inferred from sex, locality, age, household role, or draft eligibility."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BRADFORD_AVON_METHODIST_WILLIAM_PETERS_HANNY",
      "title": "Non-Conformists in Bradford-on-Avon: William Peters Hanny",
      "type": "published local religious history",
      "url": "https://www.freshford.com/non_conformists.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The published Bradford-on-Avon history states that William Peters Hanny (1802-1894) entered the first Wesleyan Sunday School register as a scholar in 1815, became a teacher in 1818, was a Methodist Society member for 76 years, promoted temperance, led cottage prayer meetings, and for a long period superintended a village Sunday School."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_BRASSINGTON_BAPTISMS_OCCUPATIONS",
      "title": "Wolverhampton and District Churches baptism transcript: Joseph and Esther Brassington children",
      "type": "published parish-register transcript",
      "url": "https://genealogy.mattiebowman.ca/Baptism/Wolverhampton%20Baptisms%201751-1903%20A-C.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcript records Sarah Brassington baptized 15 Mar 1840 at St Paul, Church Lane, daughter of Joseph and Esther, with Joseph described as shoemaker. It records son Joseph baptized 22 Apr 1851 at St Paul, Church Lane, with the father described as cordwainer, and William Henry baptized 17 Apr 1853 at St Paul, Bloomsbury, with father shoemaker."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN5_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-5 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed census, parish, civil, directory, Methodist-history, petty-sessions, probate/will-calendar, cemetery, military-name, and compiled evidence for all twenty-four generation-5 people. Occupations and public roles were recorded only when explicit, and namesake military hits were not attached without identity evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN6_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-6 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed census, parish, civil, land-valuation, burial, probate, military-service, Chelsea-pension, and compiled evidence for all twenty-seven generation-6 people. Explicit occupations and life events were structured; household roles were preserved in their historical wording; ambiguous namesakes and parent claims were not promoted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GREENE_COUNTY_MAGAZINE_1850_WHITE_TRANSCRIPT",
      "title": "Greene County Magazine: 1850 census transcription, Benjamin and Frances White",
      "type": "published census transcription",
      "url": "https://img1.wsimg.com/blobby/go/df38fd0a-22b2-484a-91a9-7bdaaf3bcd13/downloads/The%201850%20Census%20of%20Greene%20County%20Vol%2011%2C%20p.%2023.pdf?ver=1758561533737",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published transcription places Benjamin White, age 58, Frances White, age 51, and James, John, and Martha White at household 456. Search extraction associates Benjamin with farmer; the existing supplied census transcript independently identifies the same household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WASHINGTON_VA_1840_CENSUS_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPT",
      "title": "1840 Washington County, Virginia census transcription: George McNew",
      "type": "published census transcription",
      "url": "https://genealogytrails.com/vir/washington/1840census.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published head-of-household transcription lists George McNew in Washington County. The page explains the age and employment columns; the existing detailed transcript supplies four younger free household members and two persons employed in agriculture."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WASHINGTON_VA_DEED_GILMER_PHELPS_1841",
      "title": "Washington County deed abstract: Gilmer estate conveyance to Martin and John Phelps, 1841",
      "type": "published deed transcription",
      "url": "https://combs-families.org/combs/records/va/washington.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published Washington County deed material describes approximately 100 acres in Little Moccasin Gap conveyed from the William Gilmer estate to Martin Phelps and John Phelps by deeds dated 3 Sep 1841. The abstract is useful property evidence; the original deed image remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN7_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-7 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed parish, marriage-license, census, chancery, burial, compiled, published biography, and online census-transcription evidence for all seventeen generation-7 people. Explicit trades, agriculture, disability, household composition, enslavement, and unresolved identity limits were structured without inferring missing occupations."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_CATALOG_WILLIAM_MARY_MCNEW_1773",
      "title": "FamilySearch catalog: William Macknew and wife Mary, early settlers of Fincastle County, 1773",
      "type": "family-history catalog record",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/search/catalog/518943",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalog describes William Macknew (1715-1791) and wife Mary of Prince George's County, Maryland, Frederick County, Virginia, and Fincastle/Washington County, Virginia, calling William an early settler there in 1773. It supports the forename Mary and migration context, not her maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN8_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-8 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed marriage bonds, census households, wills, pension-derived military history, occupation, captivity, migration, enslavement, burial memorials, published family histories, and conflicting compiled identities for all fifteen generation-8 people. Facts inherit the confidence of the underlying identity and are not promoted merely because they are biographically interesting."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WERELATE_WILLIAM_BARTEE_RECORDS",
      "title": "WeRelate research profile: William Bartee of Henry and Franklin counties, Virginia",
      "type": "compiled record-based profile",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person:William_Bartee_(8)",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Cites 1782 appointment of William Bartee and William Jamison to view a road from Beaver Creek to Calloway's Iron Works; a 1786 Franklin County personal-property tax entry with one adult male, no enslaved people, and one horse; and William's surety on the 8 Oct 1786 bond for daughter Sukey Bartee and Benjamin White. It explicitly rejects conflation with Robert Bartee's Norfolk son."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WINGFIELD_FRANKLIN_MARRIAGE_BONDS",
      "title": "Marshall Wingfield, Marriage Bonds of Franklin County, Virginia, 1786–1858",
      "type": "published original-record transcription",
      "url": "https://books.google.com/books?id=sTMTAAAAYAAJ",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published transcription of Franklin County original marriage bonds includes bride and groom, bond date, parents, and sureties. It supports the record class underlying the Sukey Bartee and Benjamin White marriage-bond abstract."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN9_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-9 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed institutional baptism derivatives, marriage bonds, passenger and allegiance lists, indentures, county road, tax, land and court records, wills, published family histories, and conflicting compiled pedigrees for all fourteen generation-9 people. Occupation and civic facts are kept distinct from disputed identity claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ISTG_ELIZABETH_LINDER_1733_PASSENGER",
      "title": "Ship Elizabeth passenger transcription: Simon and Elizabeth Lindor, 27 August 1733",
      "type": "published passenger-list transcription",
      "url": "https://www.immigrantships.net/v4/1700v4/elizabeth17330827.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcription lists Simon Lindor age 53 and Elizabeth Lindor age 11 among passengers arriving aboard the Elizabeth on 27 Aug 1733. Family reconstruction links the household to Margretha and siblings and identifies Elizabeth as the later wife of John Newland."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WVGENWEB_JOHN_NEWLAND_BIOGRAPHY",
      "title": "Jefferson County genealogy: John Newland biography",
      "type": "published record-based biography",
      "url": "https://www.wvgw.net/jefferson/newlandbio.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reconstructs Johan Nouland, age 24 aboard the Hope of Rotterdam in 1734, as John Newland and cites Rev. John Casper Stoever's register for Johann Ulandt's 23 Apr 1739 marriage to Elizabetha Linder."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN10_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-10 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed wills, court indentures, settler and passenger indexes, church-register derivatives, deeds, compiled pedigrees, and identity conflicts for all seventeen generation-10 people. Colonial legal status, migration, property and probate are structured separately from weak pedigree assertions."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MSA_RALPH_SHAW_LAND_PURCHASE_PAGE",
      "title": "Archives of Maryland vol. 60 p.381: Ralph Shaw land purchase",
      "type": "official published court record",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000060/html/am60--381.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Charles County court proceedings record George Taylor conveying a parcel of land to Ralph Shaw in consideration of one gray mare and colt and 1,000 pounds of tobacco in cask. The conveyance grants the land to Shaw and his heirs."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN11_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-11 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed official court proceedings, wills, rent rolls, church-book-based German pedigrees, passenger and land records, probate abstracts, and conflicting derivative clusters for all twenty-two generation-11 people. Paid trades, public office, land, legal acts, and pedigree hypotheses remain separately typed and confidence-calibrated."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_PIONEERS_GEO_HARGAS_1642",
      "title": "Nell Marion Nugent, Cavaliers and Pioneers: John Benton patent and Geo. Hargas headright, 1642",
      "type": "published abstract of Virginia land patent",
      "url": "https://libsysdigi.library.illinois.edu/OCA/Books2012-02/cavalierspioneer00nuge/cavalierspioneer00nuge.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "John Benton received a 1,250-acre patent dated 13 Oct 1642, partly for transporting named people including Geo. Hargas. The patent proves Hargas was represented as a transported person by that date but supplies no age, origin, wife, or child."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN12_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-12 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed parish-register-based German research, indexed English and German church records, Virginia patent abstracts, Norfolk probate abstracts, and derivative British, Scottish, and colonial family clusters for all seventeen generation-12 people. Explicit occupation, migration, probate, baptism, marriage, and family roles are separated from weak pedigree claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STEWART_HISTORY_NORFOLK_RICHARD_BUTT_MEETINGHOUSE_1714",
      "title": "William H. Stewart, History of Norfolk County, Virginia: Richard Butt meetinghouse, 1714",
      "type": "published county history quoting court record",
      "url": "https://ldsgenealogy.com/VA/books/History-of-Norfolk-County-Virginia-and-representative-citizens-1637-1900-part-34.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Quotes Josias Mackie's 17 Jan 1714 certification selecting a newly erected house on Richard Butt Sr.'s Southern Branch land as a licensed place of dissenting worship. It establishes a Norfolk landholder of that name but does not prove his wife or children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN13_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-13 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed published colonial wills and court history, official legislative history, English baptism indexes, German parish-register-based research, and conflicting derivative family clusters for all eighteen generation-13 people. Explicit forest service, property, probate, baptism, civic status, and family roles remain distinct from same-name and copied-pedigree claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OBERBOBINGEN_ANNA_FUCHS_BAPTISM_1596",
      "title": "Oberböbingen parish baptism: Anna Fuchs, 12 Sep 1596",
      "type": "transcribed parish baptism",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied during the prior relationship audit identifies Anna Fuchs baptized 12 Sep 1596 at Oberböbingen, daughter of Hans Fuchs and Barbara. It does not give Barbara a maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN14_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-14 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed German parish-register-based clergy research, English parish transcripts, Virginia probate abstracts, Swiss Linder publications, and disputed compiled Göbel and MacKnew pedigrees for all thirteen generation-14 people. Clerical occupation, education, probate, marriage, baptism, and family roles are separated from geographic conflations and inherited traditions."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN15_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-15 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed the parish-based Weigel pedigree, locality/register coverage, a scholarly same-name physician identification, and derivative indexes for both generation-15 people. No occupation or military service was found; marriage and death context remain distinct from the explicitly unsecured filiation to Johann Berlin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIO_GEN16_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Generation-16 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed the sole generation-16 profile against the exact Ahnentafel numbering in the Weigel pedigree, surname/locality indexes, and available register-coverage evidence. Sebastian Bleyle remains an explicitly uncertain proposed father; no occupation, spouse, original event record, or parents were found, and relevant early Catholic registers are reported lost."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_TIMES_PICAYUNE_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_OBITUARY_2001",
      "title": "Times-Picayune obituary transcript: Edgar Leon Newman, historian and educator, 11 Dec 2001",
      "type": "newspaper obituary transcript",
      "url": "https://www.genlookups.com/la/webbbs_config.pl/noframes/read/1133",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports Edgar Leon Newman died of cancer 30 Nov 2001 at Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, aged 62; New Orleans native and great-grandson of Isidore Newman; attended Isidore Newman School and Phillips Exeter; Yale bachelor's degree; University of Chicago doctorate in European history; professor at New Mexico State University from 1969; visiting appointments at UCLA and Millersville; Fulbright and NEH fellow; editor and scholarly author."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RH19_EDGAR_LEON_NEWMAN_MEMORIAL_2002",
      "title": "Jean-Claude Caron, Edgar Leon Newman memorial, Revue d’histoire du XIXe siècle 23 (2001/2002)",
      "type": "scholarly memorial",
      "url": "https://journals.openedition.org/rh19/347",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Memorial reports death 30 Nov 2001, New Orleans origin, Yale B.A. in 1962, graduate study with Louis Gottschalk at the University of Chicago, active scholarly society work, and published historical scholarship. DOI 10.4000/rh19.347."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
      "title": "Louisiana Historical Association, Dictionary of Louisiana Biography: Isidore Newman II",
      "type": "credible published biography",
      "url": "https://www.lahistory.org/resources/dictionary-louisiana-biography/dictionary-of-louisiana-biography-n/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Born 29 Aug 1906 New Orleans; son of Edgar Newman and Elsa Schwartz; Tulane B.A.; married Anna Pfeifer in 1931 and had one child, Edgar Leon; Maison Blanche and City Stores executive; Army Transportation Corps lieutenant colonel; civic leader; died 23 Jan 1981 New Orleans. Entry cites his Times-Picayune obituary and other published sources."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USCSC_ARMY_REGISTER_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_II",
      "title": "United States Civil Service Commission register: Isidore Newman II, Transportation Corps",
      "type": "official federal publication",
      "url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GOVPUB-CS1-c8a32080209c260c6988fbc61590627a/pdf/GOVPUB-CS1-c8a32080209c260c6988fbc61590627a.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Maj. Isidore Newman II as chief of the Procurement Control Branch, Office of the Chief of Transportation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRASER_MIDCONTINENT_BANKER_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1951",
      "title": "Mid-Continent Banker, February 1951: Isidore Newman II elected Hibernia director",
      "type": "contemporary trade periodical",
      "url": "https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/files/docs/publications/nfr/mcbanker/midcontinentbanker_195102.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports Hibernia National Bank elected Isidore Newman II as a director."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_HENRIETTA_SEGEL_1916_2002",
      "title": "SSDI-derived entry for Henrietta Segel, 1916-2002",
      "type": "derivative vital-record index",
      "url": "https://www.ancientfaces.com/directory/name/henrietta-segel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports birth 30 Apr 1916 and death 11 Sep 2002. It agrees with the GEDCOM, but the accessible source is an aggregator rather than the underlying SSA record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FIFTH_CIRCUIT_NEWMAN_ESTATE_1935",
      "title": "Newman v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 76 F.2d 449 (5th Cir. 1935)",
      "type": "federal appellate decision",
      "url": "https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F2/76/449/1564522/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Estate-tax decision states Edgar Newman died in New Orleans 9 Mar 1928, names Elsa Schwartz Newman as his wife and life-insurance beneficiary, and identifies Elsa and Jacob K. Newman as executors. This contradicts the imported 10 Mar death date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CROCKERY_GLASS_JOURNAL_EDGAR_NEWMAN_MAISON_BLANCHE",
      "title": "Crockery and Glass Journal directory naming Edgar Newman with Maison Blanche",
      "type": "contemporary trade journal",
      "url": "https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c1/Crockery_%26_glass_journal_%28IA_crockeryglassjou75newy%29.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Trade directory lists Edgar Newman with Maison Blanche Company, New Orleans."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_TALKING_MACHINE_WORLD_EDGAR_NEWMAN_1922",
      "title": "Talking Machine World, 15 Oct 1922: Edgar Newman at Maison Blanche",
      "type": "contemporary trade periodical",
      "url": "https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Archive-Talking-Machine/20s/Talking-Machine-1922-10.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Calls Edgar Newman manager of the Grafonola department at Maison Blanche, New Orleans, and reports his visit to Columbia headquarters."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ENTERPRISE_IN_RADIO_EDGAR_NEWMAN",
      "title": "Enterprise in Radio: WWL and the Business of Broadcasting",
      "type": "published historical study",
      "url": "https://www.worldradiohistory.com/BOOKSHELF-ARH/Station-Books/WWL-Enterprise-in-Radio-WWL-and-the-Business-of-Broadcasting.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Edgar Newman as Maison Blanche treasurer and a representative in the department store's early radio venture, which supplied studio space and helped launch broadcasting in New Orleans."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LHA_MARION_PFEIFER_ABRAMSON",
      "title": "Louisiana Historical Association biography: Marion Pfeifer Abramson",
      "type": "credible published biography",
      "url": "https://www.lahistory.org/resources/dictionary-louisiana-biography/dictionary-of-louisiana-biography-a/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explicitly identifies civic leader Marion Pfeifer Abramson as daughter of Leon Pfeifer and Bertha Cahn and says she was reared in the New Orleans family home."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_HATTIESBURG_SAWMILL_LEON_PFEIFER",
      "title": "Mississippi Rails history: Hattiesburg Saw Mill Company incorporation",
      "type": "documented local industrial history",
      "url": "https://www.msrailroads.com/Hattiesburg_Sawmill.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports that Leon Pfeifer of New Orleans joined other incorporators of Hattiesburg Saw Mill Company on 18 Dec 1922 with authorized capital of $300,000."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LA_WOMEN_IN_INDUSTRY_BERTHA_PFEIFER_1919",
      "title": "Conditions of Women's Labor in Louisiana, 1919",
      "type": "contemporary official civic report",
      "url": "https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/be/Conditions_of_women%27s_labor_in_Louisiana%3B_New_Orleans_and_Louisiana_industrial_survey%3B_%28IA_conditionsofwome00unit%29.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Names Mrs. Leon Pfeifer as a Women in Industry Committee member and credits the committee with wartime employment assistance and a statewide industrial survey."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NY_ADJUTANT_GENERAL_MAX_JUFFE_1917",
      "title": "New York Adjutant General Annual Report, 1917: Max Juffe official service register",
      "type": "official state military report",
      "url": "https://museum.dmna.ny.gov/application/files/7715/8022/3037/AG_Report_1917.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official Register, Infantry—Twelfth Regiment, page 151. Records Max Juffe as born in Austria on 20 March 1886; documents New York service beginning as a private on 14 December 1907, repeated enlistments, federal muster in 1916 and 1917, and advancement to second lieutenant, first lieutenant, and captain on 3 August 1917."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CAMP_WADSWORTH_MAX_JUFFE_INSTRUCTOR",
      "title": "Camp Wadsworth newspaper: Capt. Max Juffe, infantry instructor",
      "type": "contemporary military newspaper",
      "url": "https://museum.dmna.ny.gov/download_file/view/7361/4102",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Capt. Max Juffe, 12th New York Infantry, among infantry instructors at Camp Wadsworth."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_TROWS_DIRECTORY_MAX_JUFFE_ARGONNE_PRESS_1922",
      "title": "Trow's New York directory, 1922-1923: Max Juffe",
      "type": "contemporary city directory transcript",
      "url": "https://ldsgenealogy.com/NY/books/Trows-general-directory-of-the-boroughs-of-Manhattan-and-Bronx-city-of-New-York-1922-1923-part-643.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Max Juffe as president of Argonne Press Inc. and resident at 807 East 178th Street."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SSDI_DERIVED_MAX_JUFFE_1888_1979",
      "title": "SSDI-derived entry for Max Juffe, 1888-1979",
      "type": "derivative vital-record index",
      "url": "https://www.ancientfaces.com/surname/juffe-family-history/496829",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports Max Juffe born 20 May 1888 and died Sep 1979 in Los Angeles. Consistent with the imported profile, but the accessible page is derivative rather than the SSA record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_I",
      "title": "Louisiana Historical Association, Dictionary of Louisiana Biography: Isidore Newman I",
      "type": "credible published biography",
      "url": "https://www.lahistory.org/resources/dictionary-louisiana-biography/dictionary-of-louisiana-biography-n/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Directly states birth 28 Feb 1837 Kaiserslautern; parents Jacob Neumond and Clara Kohn; immigration in 1853; marriage to Rebecca Keiffer of Port Gibson in 1868; children Jacob, Hartwig, Edgar, Julian, Clara, Meriam, and Marie; financial and philanthropic career; and death at New Orleans 30 Nov 1909."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_AJC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_DEATH_1909",
      "title": "American Jewish Committee annual report recording Isidore Newman death",
      "type": "near-contemporary organizational report",
      "url": "https://www.gbppr.net/nytimes_ww2/the-six-million-myth/1911_1912_8_AJCAnnualReport.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports the death on 30 Nov 1909 of Isidore Newman of New Orleans, a committee member from its inception. Independently contradicts the imported 1902 death year."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_COMMERCIAL_FINANCIAL_CHRONICLE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_1909",
      "title": "Commercial and Financial Chronicle death notice for Isidore Newman",
      "type": "contemporary financial periodical",
      "url": "https://fraser.stlouisfed.org/files/docs/publications/cfc/cfc_19091204.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports that Isidore Newman, head of Isidore Newman & Sons, died Tuesday at his New Orleans home aged 72; describes German birth, Louisiana and New Orleans residence, street-railroad finance, and principal ownership of Maison Blanche."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SOARDS_NEW_ORLEANS_GUIDE_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_STOCK_EXCHANGE",
      "title": "Soards guide book and street guide of New Orleans: Isidore Newman, Stock Exchange president",
      "type": "contemporary city guide",
      "url": "https://louisiana-anthology.org/303_download/texts/soards--guide_book_of_nola/Full%20text%20of%20_...Soards%20guide_book_illustrated%2C%20and%20street_guide_of_New_Orleans.._.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Isidore Newman Sr. as president of the New Orleans Stock Exchange at 29 Carondelet."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HNOC_ISIDORE_NEWMAN_NEW_ORLEANS_LEGACY",
      "title": "Historic New Orleans Collection: German-Jewish immigrant Isidore Newman",
      "type": "museum historical article",
      "url": "https://hnoc.org/publishing/first-draft/how-german-jewish-immigrant-left-indelible-mark-new-orleans-culture",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Documents Newman's financial, civic, and philanthropic work, including Maison Blanche, the Stock Exchange, school construction funding, and the 1903 Picayune Loving Cup."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEWMAN_SCHOOL_HISTORY_ISIDORE_NEWMAN",
      "title": "Isidore Newman School mission, values, and history",
      "type": "institutional history",
      "url": "https://www.newmanschool.org/about-us/mission-values-and-history",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "States that the school began in 1903 to educate children of the Jewish Orphans Home and that benefactor Isidore Newman stipulated neighborhood children could also attend."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LA_SUPREME_COURT_ADAMS_MACHINE_V_NEWMAN_1902",
      "title": "W. T. Adams Machine Company v. Newman, 107 La. 702 (1902)",
      "type": "state supreme court decision",
      "url": "https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/w-t-adams-machine-898363449",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Litigation concerning boilers, cotton gins, and machinery placed on an East Baton Rouge Parish plantation belonging to defendant Isidore Newman. Used as property and court evidence, not as family proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ORLEANS_MARRIAGE_LEON_SCHWARTZ_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1883",
      "title": "Orleans Parish marriage index: Leon E. Schwartz and Adeline Trautman",
      "type": "civil marriage index transcript",
      "url": "https://ahgp.org/la/LaMarriages/orleansparishmarriages49.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexes Adeline Trautman and Leon E. Schwartz marrying 7 Nov 1883 in Orleans Parish."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_NEWMAN_KIEFFER",
      "title": "Des Alsaciens-Lorrains aux Amériques: Newman and Kieffer family",
      "type": "published regional Jewish genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.judaisme-alsalor.fr/histoire/document/secessio/ameriq.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies financier Isidore Newman as husband of Rebecca Kieffer, born at Port Gibson in 1849 and daughter of Louis Kieffer and Maria Roser of Lembach. Its stated 1902 death year for Isidore conflicts with stronger 1909 evidence and is rejected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_IPGV_MIGRATION_CARD_ISIDOR_NEUMOND",
      "title": "Institut für pfälzische Geschichte und Volkskunde migration card: Isidor Neumond",
      "type": "scholarly regional migration database",
      "url": "https://migration.pfalzgeschichte.de/person/132826",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Isidor Neumond, born 28 Feb 1837 at Kaiserslautern, as a son of Jacob Neumond and Clara Cahn; names siblings and partner Rebecca Kiefer; and reports migration to New Orleans in 1853. Its 30 Nov 1908 death conflicts with independently corroborated 30 Nov 1909 evidence and is rejected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_AHB_INGENHEIM_NAME_ADOPTION_DAVID_DREYFUSS_1808",
      "title": "Kultur-Büro AHB: Ingenheim Jewish name-adoption list, 1808",
      "type": "archival list transcript",
      "url": "https://www.a-h-b.de/de/projekte/familienforschung/name-adoption-lists/ingenheim",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The 1808 list identifies Loeb Dreyfuss adopting the name Leo Dreyfuss, followed by Rösel Moyses adopting Rosali Dreyfuss and eight children explicitly described as Leo's: Marieanne, Helene, Elisabeth, Moses, Abraham, Jonathan, Therese, and David. It directly proves Leo as David's father. Rosali's placement and adopted household surname strongly support her as Leo's wife and the children's mother, but the transcript does not explicitly label her relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_AHB_OBERLUSTADT_NAME_ADOPTION_JOHANNA_FRANK_1808",
      "title": "Kultur-Büro AHB: Oberlustadt Jewish name-adoption list, 1808",
      "type": "archival list transcript",
      "url": "https://www.a-h-b.de/de/projekte/familienforschung/name-adoption-lists/oberlustadt",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The 1808 list identifies Daotteres b Samolon as Salomon Frank and Roesel b Abraham as Rosalia Mayer, explicitly calling her Salomon's wife. In the list's old-name column, b [given name] is a patronymic used for both sons and daughters; for example, Roesge b Schaye is described as a minor daughter of Isaias. It therefore directly supports a father named Abraham for Rosalia, but gives no surname or other identity-specific detail for him. The list gives minor children Abraham, Isaias, Salomon, and Johanna Frank, each explicitly described as a child of Salomon. It directly proves Salomon as Johanna's father; Rosalia's wife status and household placement strongly support maternity, although the child remark names only Salomon."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRENCH_CITIZENSHIP_OPTANT_MICHEL_COGUENHEM_1872",
      "title": "French Alsace-Lorraine citizenship-choice index: Michel Coguenhem",
      "type": "archival index transcript",
      "url": "https://sv.geneanet.org/register/view/18598/3",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A transcript of French archival series AN BB/31/87 contains the name Michel Coguenhem. The entry lacks enough identifying family detail to connect it to Pauline Loeb or Anna Coguenhem and is retained only as weak name context."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ARCHIVES_MD_ASSEMBLY_JEREMIAH_MACKNEW_1678",
      "title": "Archives of Maryland, vol. 7: Assembly proceedings naming Jeremiah Macknew, 1678",
      "type": "published transcript of colonial record",
      "url": "https://www.msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000007/html/am7--101.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The 1678 Assembly accounts list Jeremiah Macknew among people assigned 830 pounds of tobacco. This directly establishes his presence and taxable economic activity in colonial Maryland, but gives no age, birthplace, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_IMMIGRATION_LANDHOLDER_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Expanded McNew immigration and landholder review, 25 July 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Compared the published McNew-Cawood study and its Maryland citations with archival Maryland transcripts and copied Scottish pedigrees. Contemporary Maryland evidence establishes Jeremiah, wife Phillis, and son John Howard, but the study expressly reports Jeremiah and Phillis's birthplace as unknown. No Scottish parish, testament, sasine, burgess, or land record connects the immigrant couple to Midlothian."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CHESAPEAKE_BUTT_LANDHOLDING_HISTORY",
      "title": "Chesapeake Public Schools local history: Robert Butt and the Southern Branch land",
      "type": "local history citing Marshall Wingfield Butt and Norfolk archivists",
      "url": "https://www.cpschools.com/o/bri/page/general-info/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes Robert Butt as an English settler who acquired 1,200 acres near later Great Bridge and another 380 acres, and says he logged the cypress swamp. Useful for local and occupational context; it does not establish his English birthplace or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_RIVER_FLOYD_SHORT_DEATH_1934",
      "title": "New River Notes transcript: Floyd Short death, 16 January 1934",
      "type": "published transcript of Virginia death record",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/smyth-county-virginia-death-records/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcript identifies Floyd Short, a widowed watchman born at Marion, Virginia, who died at Saltville on 16 Jan 1934 at about age 71. It names his parents as George Short and Susan Jones. This independently corroborates the parental couple known from the 1870 household and David Kitzmiller Shortt's death record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_1881_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
      "title": "1881 England Census: John and Jane Thomas household, 160 Frankwell Quay, Shrewsbury",
      "type": "census transcript",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. RG11/2653, folio 101, page 16, ED 5. John Thomas, married head, age 30, shoemaker, born Llandewy, Radnorshire; wife Jane, age 30; daughter Elizabeth; and Thomas Vhise, age 76. The repeated address and later households establish identity continuity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_1891_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
      "title": "1891 England Census: John and Jane Thomas household, Shrewsbury St Chad",
      "type": "census transcript",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. RG12/2112, folio 75, ED 4. John Thomas, head, age 39, born Radnorshire; wife Jane, 40; children Margaret E., 10, Kizzie, 8, John L., 6, and Jane A., 1. Kizzie is the age-compatible Kezia Thomas registered at Atcham in 1882."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_1901_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
      "title": "1901 England Census: John and Jane Thomas household, Shrewsbury St Chad",
      "type": "census transcript",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. RG13/2540, folio 78, page 2, schedule 6, ED 4. John Thomas, married head, 49; Jane, 50; children Kezia, 18, John, 16, and Annie, 11. The index renders John's birthplace as Llandovery, Radnorshire, an internally inconsistent place string rejected in favor of the repeated Llandewy/Llandewyn, Radnorshire evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_1911_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS_20260725",
      "title": "1911 England Census: John and Jane Thomas household, 160 Frankwell Quay, Shrewsbury",
      "type": "census transcript",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. RG14/16091, ED 03, Atcham registration district 349, St Chad sub-district. John Thomas, 59, bootmaker hand worker, born Llandewyn, Radnorshire; Jane, 59; married 32 years, implying 1879; address 160 Frankwell Quay."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_JANE_THOMAS_MARRIAGE_INDEX_1879",
      "title": "England and Wales civil marriage index: John Thomas and Jane Lister, Atcham, Q3 1879",
      "type": "civil registration index and census continuity",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Index details supplied by Matthew give Jane Lister in the Jul-Sep 1879 Atcham marriage registration. The 1911 household independently reports John and Jane married 32 years, and the 1881-1911 census chain proves the pairing. The quarter is not an exact marriage date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_THOMAS_FINDAGRAVE_1851_1931",
      "title": "Find a Grave index: John Thomas, 1851-1931, Shrewsbury General Cemetery",
      "type": "compiled memorial index",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew reports birth 12 Apr 1851 in modern-labelled Powys, death 8 Apr 1931 at Shrewsbury, burial in Shrewsbury General Cemetery, spouse Jane Thomas, and children John Lister Thomas and Ann Thomas. The exact birth day remains memorial-only; the death is compatible with an Atcham Q2 1931 civil registration hint."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_LISTER_THOMAS_WW1_PENSION",
      "title": "UK World War I Pension Ledgers and Index Cards: John Lister Thomas family",
      "type": "military pension index transcript",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. The index series Other Ranks Died, Thomas H-Thomas R associates John Lister Thomas with next of kin John Thomas, father, of Shrewsbury, and Jane Thomas. It supports the family identity but the supplied excerpt lacks service number, regiment, rank, and death date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JANE_LYSTER_1851_SHREWSBURY_CENSUS",
      "title": "1851 England Census: Jane Lyster in Richard and Eliza Lyster household, Shrewsbury St Alkmund",
      "type": "census transcript",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew. Jane Lyster, daughter, age 1 year 5 months, born Shropshire, in Shrewsbury St Alkmund, Shrewsbury registration district, St Mary sub-district, ED 4b. The index names father Richard Lyster and mother Eliza Lyster. This conflicts with the compiled Kezia Price identity and is preserved explicitly."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARGARET_ELIZABETH_THOMAS_BAPTISM",
      "title": "Shropshire Church of England baptism index: Margaret Elizabeth Thomas, child of John and Jane Thomas",
      "type": "parish baptism index transcript",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcript supplied by Matthew names John Thomas and spouse Jane as parents of Margaret Elizabeth Thomas. The supplied excerpt lacks baptism date and parish, so it corroborates the census family but does not establish a precise event date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_LISTER_COMPILED_PROFILE_1804_1879",
      "title": "Compiled profile: Richard Lister, about 1804-1879, Pontefract to Shrewsbury",
      "type": "user-supplied compiled profile",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile supplied by Matthew reports birth in 1804 at Pontefract and death 15 Aug 1879 at 80 Spring Gardens, Shrewsbury. The 1851 census directly identifies Richard as Jane Lyster's father; exact vital details remain compiled pending direct baptism, death, or burial records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_FAMILY",
      "title": "Pontefract parish indexes: children of Thomas Lister and Ann Marshall",
      "type": "parish baptism index transcripts",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcripts supplied by Matthew repeatedly name Thomas Lister and Ann or Anne Lister as parents of Catherine, John, Sarah, Richard, and George at Pontefract St Giles and St Mary. Richard's full baptism date was not supplied, but the name, parent pair, locality, and later Pontefract birthplace align with the Shrewsbury Richard."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_ANN_MARSHALL_MARRIAGE_1799",
      "title": "Marriage of Thomas Lister and Ann Marshall, South Kirkby, 15 Dec 1799",
      "type": "parish marriage index transcript",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England Select Marriages transcript supplied by Matthew records Ann Marshall marrying Thomas Lister on 15 Dec 1799 at South Kirkby, West Riding of Yorkshire, FHL film 1542263, item 3, register number 473."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_KEZIA_PRICE_GAMBLE_COMPILED_TREE",
      "title": "Gamble Family Tree profile: Kezia Price and Richard Lister family",
      "type": "compiled family tree",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Compiled tree comparison supplied by Matthew reports Kezia Price, born 1816 Montgomeryshire and died Q4 1874 Atcham, daughter of David Price and Elizabeth Lambe, with children Jane, Catherine, Elizabeth, Thomas Price, Harriet Louisa, and Sarah Lister. The 1851 index instead calls Jane's mother Eliza. The distinctive child name Thomas Price Lister and granddaughter name Kezia make the claim plausible, but the conflict prevents promotion."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ORLEANS_NOTARIAL_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_MORTGAGE_1909",
      "title": "Orleans Parish Clerk of Civil District Court, Index to Acts of the 20th Century: Leon E. Schwartz mortgage, 3 May 1909",
      "type": "official notarial act index",
      "url": "https://www.orleanscivilclerk.com/Index%20to%20Acts%2020th%20Century.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The official index lists an act dated 3 May 1909, volume 9, act 1011, type mortgage, with Leon E. Schwartz as party 1 and Edward P. Cousin as party 2 before notary Percy Benedict. The index does not describe the property or each party's legal role beyond the act type."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
      "title": "Jewish community and synagogue at Niederhochstadt",
      "type": "published local Jewish history",
      "url": "https://www.alemannia-judaica.de/niederhochstadt_synagoge.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Alemannia Judaica summarizes the documented community, synagogue, school, ritual bath, cemetery, population, and migration history. It is contextual evidence for the imported birthplace, not proof that Emanuel Pfeifer was born there."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ARCHIVES_ALSACE_OPTANTS_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Archives d'Alsace: nationality options and emigration after 1871",
      "type": "government archive research guide",
      "url": "https://archives.alsace.eu/votre-recherche/aide-a-la-recherche/affaires-de-nationalite-et-emigration/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The departmental archives explain the 1871-1872 nationality-option records created after Alsace and part of Lorraine passed from France to the German Empire. This explains the record series containing a Michel Coguenhem, but does not establish which man of that name appears."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCGILL_GALICIAN_JEWISH_EMIGRATION_1869_1880",
      "title": "Galician Jewish emigration, 1869-1880",
      "type": "scholarly thesis",
      "url": "https://escholarship.mcgill.ca/concern/theses/05741t83h",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Historical study of Jewish emigration from Austrian Galicia after the 1867 constitutional freedom of movement. Used only to explain the imported geographic and migration setting for Yetta Fuchs; it does not identify her."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
      "title": "Jewish community and synagogue at Sembach",
      "type": "published local Jewish history",
      "url": "https://alemannia-judaica.de/sembach_synagoge.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Summarizes Sembach Jewish households, institutions, population, occupations, and burial practice. Its 1809-1810 list includes Kussel Neumond, but does not identify Loeb Neumond or Johanna Jacob."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_KYRITZ_MUNICIPAL_CHRONICLE",
      "title": "City of Kyritz historical chronicle",
      "type": "municipal local history",
      "url": "https://www.kyritz.de/seite/32048/stadtchronik.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes late eighteenth-century Kyritz as a small Prussian garrison and agricultural town recovering from war and population loss. Used as locality context only; it does not identify Johanna Jacob."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LEMBACH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
      "title": "Jewish community and synagogue at Lembach",
      "type": "published local Jewish history",
      "url": "https://www.alemannia-judaica.de/lembach_synagogue.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Documents a Jewish presence from the eighteenth century, 12 families in the 1784 census, and later synagogue, school, ritual bath, teacher, prayer leader, and ritual slaughterer. It does not name Julienne or prove the Kieffer family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ISJL_DONALDSONVILLE_JEWISH_HISTORY",
      "title": "Goldring/Woldenberg Institute of Southern Jewish Life: Donaldsonville, Louisiana",
      "type": "scholarly regional community history",
      "url": "https://www.isjl.org/louisiana-donaldsonville-encyclopedia.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Documents nineteenth-century German and Alsatian Jewish migration, commerce, congregation, cemetery, and civic life. The 1860 Bikur Cholim charter list includes L. Cahn and M. Cahn, but has insufficient identifiers to connect L. Cahn to the imported Leo."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OTTROTT_MUNICIPAL_RELIGIOUS_HISTORY",
      "title": "Municipality of Ottrott: history and religious life",
      "type": "municipal local history",
      "url": "https://www.ottrott.fr/Decouvrir/Histoire-patrimoine/Presentation.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The municipality describes the small Jewish community and synagogue at lower Ottrott alongside Catholic and Protestant communities. It does not identify Seligmann Levy or Rosalie Kallmann."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BAS_RHIN_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE",
      "title": "Archives d'Alsace guide to Jewish records in Bas-Rhin",
      "type": "government archive research guide",
      "url": "https://archives.alsace.eu/media/xuaoqepx/gr_juifs_bas-rhin_1808.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies surviving Jewish population, vital, census, and name-adoption material by commune, including Ottrott-le-Bas. Used to identify next research collections, not as evidence of a person."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BAS_RHIN_GUNSTETT_CIVIL_TABLES",
      "title": "Archives du Bas-Rhin: Gunstett civil-registration tables",
      "type": "government archival catalog",
      "url": "https://archives.bas-rhin.fr/detail-document/ETAT-CIVIL-C176-TD",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalog entry for Gunstett decennial civil tables. It establishes an available record series but does not itself identify Michel Kieffer."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EVANSVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_1849_PRESENT",
      "title": "The Jewish Community of Indianapolis: 1849 to the Present, Evansville discussion and notes",
      "type": "scholarly published community history",
      "url": "https://images.indianahistory.org/digital/api/collection/p16797coll18/id/1097/download",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The cited notes list Samuel Roser among probable 1857 Evansville congregation charter members. This is a later namesake or associate in the destination community and cannot be the Samuel reportedly dead before 1836."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROMANSWILLER_RECORDS_RESEARCH_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Archives d'Alsace Jewish records guide: Romanswiller and regional collections",
      "type": "government archive research guide",
      "url": "https://archives.alsace.eu/media/xuaoqepx/gr_juifs_bas-rhin_1808.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies commune-level Jewish record groups useful for testing the imported Romanswiller origin. It is a research guide, not evidence naming Rösel Seligman."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WISSEMBOURG_JEWISH_MARRIAGE_CONTRACT_STUDY",
      "title": "Jewish marriage contracts and the 1784 census of Wissembourg",
      "type": "published regional archival study",
      "url": "https://www.judaisme-alsalor.fr/traditio/mariage/wissemb/wiss3.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Correlates marriage contracts, the 1784 census, and 1808 names. It explains that hereditary surnames were rare, given-name-plus-father-name forms were common, Levy and Cahen could denote religious descent, and Klotz was among the few established surnames. It does not identify these four imported ancestors."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENAMI_ALSACE_1784_CENSUS_DATABASE",
      "title": "GenAmi index to the 1784 census of Jews in Alsace",
      "type": "published census index database",
      "url": "https://www.genami.org/en/lists/alsace/census2-ISRAEL%20ARON-0-WISSEMBOURG-0-0-0-0-0.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Searchable derivative of the nominal 1784 census. Reviewed as a route to household reconstruction; no entry-level match proving these four relationships was located in this pass."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_TRENTHAM_HISTORY",
      "title": "Victoria County History: Staffordshire XI, Audley, Keele and Trentham",
      "type": "scholarly county history",
      "url": "https://www.history.ac.uk/vch/publications/staffordshire-xi-audley-keele-and-trentham",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes Trentham's estate and industrial setting. Used as locality context alongside Ellen's census-documented household, not as personal evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_POWYS_ARCHIVES_MONTGOMERYSHIRE_PARISH_GUIDE",
      "title": "Powys Archives: Montgomeryshire parish records catalog",
      "type": "government archival finding aid",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/parish-nonconformist_church-in-wales_Montgomeryshire-M-EP-1-8.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalog of Montgomeryshire parish material. Used to identify future Berriew household and marriage research; it does not identify Robert or Elizabeth Davies."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_RECORDS_1538_1944",
      "title": "England, Staffordshire, Church Records, 1538-1944",
      "type": "repository collection",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/collection/2364451",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Database with images from Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service. It establishes the archival context for Staffordshire parish evidence but does not by itself identify a particular person."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RANTON_PARISH_CATALOG",
      "title": "England, Staffordshire, Ranton parish registers catalog",
      "type": "repository catalog",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/catalog/2744843",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch catalog for digital copies of original Ranton parish registers held by Staffordshire Record Office. The displayed catalog begins its separately listed baptism series in 1813; the cited 1787 baptism comes from the published Ranton transcript already recorded as a separate source."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_CHURCH_REGISTERS_GUIDE",
      "title": "Derbyshire Record Office: Church Registers",
      "type": "government archival guide",
      "url": "https://recordoffice.wordpress.com/2020/04/28/church-registers/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains that parish registers are the principal family-history source before civil registration began in 1837 and describes surviving Derbyshire church-register holdings."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_GILES_COUNTY_MICROFILM",
      "title": "Library of Virginia: Giles County microfilm",
      "type": "government archival catalog",
      "url": "https://www.lva.virginia.gov/collections/ccmf/VA/VA097",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalog identifies Giles County will books and the general index to wills. The full John R. Henderson estate record remains necessary to test the candidate identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NARA_1820_CENSUS_RECORDS",
      "title": "National Archives: 1820 Census Records",
      "type": "government archival guide",
      "url": "https://www.archives.gov/research/census/1820",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "NARA lists surviving 1820 schedules and explains their custody. Its list of surviving North Carolina county schedules does not include Mecklenburg County, so a claimed original 1820 Mecklenburg household cannot currently serve as direct evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ASHBOURNE_LOCAL_HISTORY_GEORGIAN_COACHING",
      "title": "Visit Ashbourne: History of Ashbourne",
      "type": "local historical publication",
      "url": "https://www.visitashbourne.co.uk/history/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes Georgian Ashbourne as an established market town and a coaching centre where six roads met, including the London-Carlisle route."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BRADFORD_ON_AVON_MUSEUM_WOOL_HISTORY",
      "title": "Bradford on Avon Museum: Woollen cloth industry",
      "type": "local museum history",
      "url": "https://www.bradfordonavonmuseum.co.uk/wool",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains the town's transition from domestic cloth making to water- and steam-powered mills during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_COUNCIL_CITY_CENTRE_HISTORY",
      "title": "City of Wolverhampton Council: City Centre Conservation Area history",
      "type": "government local-history publication",
      "url": "https://www.wolverhampton.gov.uk/sites/default/files/pdf/Wolverhampton_City_Centre.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Places St Peter's at the centre of the historic town and describes the turnpike-road network and nineteenth-century urban and industrial development."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STOKE_ST_MILBOROUGH_LOCAL_AGRICULTURAL_HISTORY",
      "title": "St Milburga Chapel: history of Stoke St Milborough",
      "type": "local historical publication",
      "url": "https://stmilburgachapel.co.uk/an-interesting-history-of-stoke-st-milborough-shropshire/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes Stoke St Milborough as a predominantly agricultural parish, with arable and livestock farming and only small-scale mining."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_WROUGHT_IRON_INDUSTRY_HORSEHAY",
      "title": "The Shropshire wrought-iron industry c.1600-1900",
      "type": "scholarly local history",
      "url": "https://etheses.bham.ac.uk/248/1/Hayman04PhD_A1a.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "University of Birmingham study of the East Shropshire coalfield and iron industry, including Horsehay and its connection to the Wellington and Severn transport system."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_RANTON_HISTORY",
      "title": "A Vision of Britain through Time: Ranton",
      "type": "university historical gazetteer",
      "url": "https://www.visionofbritain.org.uk/place/8485",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "University of Portsmouth historical gazetteer describes Ranton as a small Staffordshire parish west of Stafford and near Haughton."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILTSHIRE_COMMUNITY_HISTORY_NORTH_BRADLEY",
      "title": "Wiltshire Community History: North Bradley",
      "type": "government local-history publication",
      "url": "https://apps.wiltshire.gov.uk/communityhistory/Community/Index/170",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Wiltshire Council history describes North Bradley as a hand-loom weaving centre where household weaving and agriculture were both important."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_FORTON_ALL_SAINTS_COLLECTION",
      "title": "Staffordshire History Centre: Records of Forton, All Saints",
      "type": "government archival catalog",
      "url": "https://www.staffordshirehistory.org.uk/collections/getrecord/GB169_CD164",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalog describes surviving Forton parish registers from 1558, tithe accounts for 1749-1782, churchwardens' accounts, charity papers, and other parish administration records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VISION_OF_BRITAIN_FORTON_HISTORY",
      "title": "A Vision of Britain through Time: Forton",
      "type": "university historical gazetteer",
      "url": "https://www.visionofbritain.org.uk/place/place_page.jsp?p_id=8075",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "University of Portsmouth gazetteer places Forton beside the Shropshire border and near Newport; later transport references help locate the parish but are not projected backward as personal events."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRANKLIN_COUNTY_VA_OFFICIAL_HISTORY",
      "title": "Franklin County, Virginia: History of Franklin County",
      "type": "government local-history publication",
      "url": "https://www.franklincountyva.gov/575/History-of-Franklin-County",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "County history describes settlement along the Carolina Road, the county's formation in 1786, and an early economy dominated by agriculture and tobacco, with locally mined iron and copper transported along the road."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOSCHENHOPPEN_HISTORIANS_EARLY_CHURCH_SCHOOLS",
      "title": "Goschenhoppen Historians: Early Church Schools",
      "type": "local historical society publication",
      "url": "https://goschenhoppen.org/early-church-schools/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes the Goschenhoppen tract's settlement from about 1720 by German-speaking farmers and tradespeople, principally Lutheran and German Reformed, and the church-school community."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LIBRARY_OF_VIRGINIA_ELIZABETH_CITY_COUNTY_GUIDE",
      "title": "Library of Virginia: Guide to Elizabeth City County records, 1721-1931",
      "type": "government archival finding aid",
      "url": "https://ead.lib.virginia.edu/vivaxtf/view?docId=lva%2Fvi04216.xml",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes surviving local records and notes Hampton's establishment by the assembly in 1680 and designation as a port in 1708. The collection begins after James Boswell's reported 1718 death."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_CHRONOLOGY",
      "title": "Maryland State Archives: Charles County historical chronology",
      "type": "government historical chronology",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/msa/mdmanual/36loc/ch/chron/html/chchron.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dates the present Charles County to 1658 and identifies early institutions near Port Tobacco."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_CHARLES_COUNTY_COURT_HISTORY",
      "title": "Archives of Maryland: Charles County courthouses and records",
      "type": "government archival history",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000545/html/am545--61.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Distinguishes Old Charles County, created in 1650 and abolished in 1653, from the present county created in 1658 with different bounds."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SCOTLANDSPEOPLE_MIDLOTHIAN_RECORD_GUIDE",
      "title": "Scotland's People: Midlothian county records",
      "type": "government archival guide",
      "url": "https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/content/midlothian-county",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes Midlothian church registers and commissary and sheriff-court testament records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NRS_OLD_PARISH_REGISTER_COVERAGE",
      "title": "National Records of Scotland: Old Parish Register coverage",
      "type": "government archival guide",
      "url": "https://www.nrscotland.gov.uk/learning-and-events/research-guides/coverage-of-the-old-parish-registers/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains that Scottish Old Parish Registers begin as early as 1553 but coverage varies substantially by parish and year."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SONNENBUEHL_ERPFINGEN_HISTORY",
      "title": "Municipality of Sonnenbühl: history of Erpfingen",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.sonnenbuehl.de/data/erpfingen.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes the Thirty Years War devastation of Erpfingen, including hunger, plague, loss of inhabitants, and slow recovery."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WKGO_WILLMANDINGEN_THIRTY_YEARS_WAR",
      "title": "Württemberg church history: the wartime life of Willmandingen schoolmaster Hans Meckh",
      "type": "regional church history",
      "url": "https://blog.wkgo.de/2020/07/27/die-kriegsbedingte-biografie-des-schulmeisters-hans-meckh/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Uses church sources to describe war and hunger after 1634, displacement from Willmandingen, return after 1648, and surviving Willmandingen church books from 1641."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ASHWELL_PARISH_COUNCIL_HISTORY",
      "title": "Ashwell Parish Council: history of the village",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.ashwell.gov.uk/ashwell/history/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes Ashwell as a long-established farming community whose medieval market declined during the early modern period."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ASHWELL_MUSEUM_PARISH_DOCUMENTS",
      "title": "Ashwell Museum: parish documents and registers",
      "type": "local archival guide",
      "url": "https://www.ashwellmuseum.org.uk/resources/resource-centre-2/printed-resources/ashwell-parish-documents",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalogues Ashwell baptism, marriage, and burial registers from 1604 to 1837 and other parish documents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ARCHION_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTER_CATALOG",
      "title": "Archion: Blankenloch Lutheran church-book catalog",
      "type": "church archive catalog",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/baden-wuerttemberg/evangelisches-archiv-baden-und-wuerttemberg-baden/blankenloch",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalogues the surviving Blankenloch Lutheran mixed register for 1672-1738."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BADISCHE_OFB_BLANKENLOCH_CATALOG",
      "title": "Badische Ortsfamilienbücher: Blankenloch-Büchig local family book",
      "type": "genealogical publication catalog",
      "url": "https://www.badische-ortsfamilienbuecher.de/buch.php?id=77",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes a 1,445-page Blankenloch-Büchig local family book covering 1672-1920."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_IPHOFEN_LOCAL_HISTORY",
      "title": "City of Iphofen: local historical tour",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.iphofen.de/vor-ort/freizeittipps/stadtrundgaenge-besichtigung/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies the Reformation and Thirty Years War among the major events that left local traces in Iphofen."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTY_FORMATION",
      "title": "Encyclopedia Virginia: county formation during the colonial period",
      "type": "scholarly public history",
      "url": "https://encyclopediavirginia.org/entries/county-formation-during-the-colonial-period/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains the formation and court functions of Virginia counties, including Lower Norfolk and later Norfolk-area jurisdictions."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_COUNTIES_1691_1700",
      "title": "Encyclopedia Virginia: Virginia counties, 1691-1700",
      "type": "scholarly historical map",
      "url": "https://encyclopediavirginia.org/5739hpr-099183134f42c5d/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Places the 1691 county changes amid population growth and a renewed tobacco trade."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WEINSBERG_CITY_HISTORY",
      "title": "City of Weinsberg: history",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.weinsberg.de/weinsberg-die-weibertreustadt/geschichte/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes Württemberg conquest in 1504, destruction after the 1525 Peasants War, and restoration of town rights in 1553."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_PARISH_COUNCIL",
      "title": "Stoke St Gregory Parish Council: village and landscape",
      "type": "municipal community history",
      "url": "https://www.stokestgregory.org/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes the dispersed Somerset village between Curry Moor, the River Tone, and West Sedgemoor and the long-drained wetland landscape."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STOKE_ST_GREGORY_HISTORY_RECORDS",
      "title": "Stoke St Gregory local history: parish records",
      "type": "local archival guide",
      "url": "https://www.gregorystoke.org/parish-history",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Directs research to South West Heritage Trust and documents the older parish and manorial record environment."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BOEBINGEN_OFFICIAL_HISTORY_REFORMATION",
      "title": "Municipality of Böbingen: local chronicle",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.boebingen.de/gemeinde/unser-boebingen/geschichte-leitbildentwicklung/ortschronik",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "States that the Reformation reached Oberböbingen in 1553 when Württemberg appointed its first Lutheran pastor."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAANEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
      "title": "Municipality of Saanen: history",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.saanen.ch/de/ueber-saanen/geschichte/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes the alpine transit setting and Saanen becoming a Bernese subject territory in 1555."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BERN_CITY_REFORMATION_HISTORY",
      "title": "City of Bern: historical chronology",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.bern.ch/zu-gast-in-bern/bern-stellt-sich-vor/stadtgeschichte",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "States that Bern introduced the Reformation in 1528 and assumed direction of the church and supervision of its subjects' moral life."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GRUIBINGEN_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
      "title": "Municipality of Gruibingen: history",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.gruibingen.de/gemeinde-gruibingen/geschichte-wappen/geschichte",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes sixteenth-century village development, including a parsonage, tithe barn, school in 1552, and administrative house in 1559, as well as its confessional border position."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LEO_BW_BAD_UEBERKINGEN_HISTORY",
      "title": "LEO-BW: Bad Überkingen historical gazetteer",
      "type": "government historical gazetteer",
      "url": "https://www.leo-bw.de/web/guest/detail-gis/-/Detail/details/ORT/labw_ortslexikon/580/Bad%20%C3%9Cberkingen%20-%20Altgemeinde~Teilort",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes Überkingen under Ulm, its early mineral spring and international spa importance in the fifteenth through seventeenth centuries, and its 1588 bath hotel."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SPARTANBURG_LIBRARY_CAMP_WADSWORTH",
      "title": "Spartanburg County Public Libraries: Camp Wadsworth historical collection",
      "type": "public library digital collection",
      "url": "https://cdm17281.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/collection/shjw/id/425/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Documents Spartanburg's selection for a First World War Army training camp."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SPARTANBURG_CITY_CAMP_WADSWORTH_HISTORY",
      "title": "City of Spartanburg: Camp Wadsworth historical context",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.cityofspartanburg.org/DocumentCenter/View/410",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "States that more than 100,000 soldiers came to train at Camp Wadsworth during the First World War."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_FEDERATION_HISTORY",
      "title": "Jewish Federation of Greater New Orleans: community history",
      "type": "community institutional history",
      "url": "https://jewishnola.org/community-history/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes the growth and civic role of the New Orleans Jewish community, including migration from Alsace and steady nineteenth-century development."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_ORLEANS_JCC_HISTORY",
      "title": "New Orleans Jewish Community Center: institutional history",
      "type": "community institutional history",
      "url": "https://www.nojcc.org/aboutus",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Traces organized Jewish civic life from the Young Men's Hebrew and Literary Society founded in 1855 through the 1891 Young Men's Hebrew Association."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_1870_ANNEXATION",
      "title": "City of Metz: history",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://metz.fr/decouvrir-partager/histoire.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes the 1870 siege, capitulation, and German annexation from 1871 to 1918."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_METZ_MUNICIPAL_ANNEXATION_EMIGRATION",
      "title": "City of Metz planning history: annexation and emigration, 1871-1875",
      "type": "municipal historical study",
      "url": "https://metz.fr/fichiers/2017/08/23/1_METZ__RAPPORT_DE_PRESENTATION_8novembre16_opt.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "States that annexation prompted nearly half the local population to leave Metz between 1871 and 1875."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_OFFICIAL_HISTORY",
      "title": "City of East Orange: municipal history",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.eastorange-nj.gov/354/About-East-Orange",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes East Orange's late nineteenth-century development, transport network, industrial growth, homes, and transition from township to city."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HESSEN_ARCHIVES_EMIGRANT_GUIDE",
      "title": "Hessian State Archives: emigrant records",
      "type": "government archival guide",
      "url": "https://landesarchiv.hessen.de/nutzen-forschen/genealogie/besondere-personengruppen/auswanderer",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains required applications for release from subject status and identifies Hessian administrative and emigrant record collections."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRANKWELL_SHREWSBURY_LOCAL_HISTORY",
      "title": "Original Shrewsbury: Frankwell",
      "type": "municipal destination history",
      "url": "https://originalshrewsbury.co.uk/your-visit/town-areas/frankwell",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes Frankwell on the River Severn as one of Shrewsbury's oldest suburbs."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_BOOT_SHOE_DIRECTORY",
      "title": "Historical Shropshire trade directory: boot and shoe makers",
      "type": "historical trade directory",
      "url": "https://specialcollections.le.ac.uk/digital/api/collection/p16445coll4/id/247878/download",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists multiple boot and shoe makers in Shrewsbury and Frankwell, documenting the local trade environment."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LVA_WASHINGTON_COUNTY_MICROFILM_GUIDE",
      "title": "Library of Virginia: Washington County records on microfilm",
      "type": "government archival catalog",
      "url": "https://www.lva.virginia.gov/collections/ccmf/VA/VA285",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalog describes Washington County record groups and warns that a Union raid in 1864 destroyed or removed many loose records and volumes. Used to explain a genuine documentary gap, not as evidence about any individual."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VA_DHR_SALTVILLE_BATTLEFIELDS",
      "title": "Virginia Department of Historic Resources: Saltville Battlefields Historic District",
      "type": "government historic-register account",
      "url": "https://www.dhr.virginia.gov/historic-registers/295-5001/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes the saltworks, field fortifications, and 1864 battles in the Smyth and Washington County district. Used only as local context; it does not establish an ancestor's participation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_POWYS_BERRIEW_SETTLEMENT_PROFILE",
      "title": "Powys County Council: Berriew settlement profile",
      "type": "government locality profile",
      "url": "https://ldp.powys.gov.uk/docfiles/36/Berriew_Bettws%20Cedewain_Boughrood%20and%20Llyswen_1.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official locality profile used with the Powys parish-record catalog to situate Berriew. It does not identify the Davies family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FRENCH_CULTURE_ALFRED_DREYFUS_FAMILY_ASCENT",
      "title": "French Ministry of Culture: The social ascent of Alfred Dreyfus's family",
      "type": "government historical research",
      "url": "https://tresor-cathedrales-d-amiens.culture.gouv.fr/dreyfus/fr/lascension-sociale-dune-famille",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Summarizes Odile Jurbert's archival reconstruction: Alfred was son of Raphaël; his paternal grandfather Jacques and great-grandfather Israël Dreyfus were merchants associated with Rixheim, and Jacques later settled in Mulhouse. Used to test, not assert, a connection with Suzanne's Ingenheim family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALFRED_DREYFUS_LINK_ASSESSMENT_20260725",
      "title": "Comparison of Suzanne's Ingenheim Dreyfuss line with Alfred Dreyfus's Rixheim line, 25 July 2026",
      "type": "relationship research assessment",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Compared named generations, chronology, and places. Suzanne's line is Rachel Dreyfus, probable daughter of David, directly recorded son of Leo/Loeb at Ingenheim in 1808. Alfred's documented paternal line is Alfred, Raphaël, Jacques, and Israël Dreyfus around Rixheim and Mulhouse. No shared individual, parent, household, or migration bridge was found."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MISSISSIPPI_RAILS_BROOKHAVEN_LUMBER_E_PFEIFER",
      "title": "Gil Hoffman, Brookhaven Lumber & Manufacturing Company history",
      "type": "published industrial history citing corporate records",
      "url": "https://www.msrailroads.com/Hattiesburg_Sawmill.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports that Brookhaven Lumber & Manufacturing Company began in 1881 and was incorporated at Brookhaven on 9 Jan 1884 by E. Pfeifer, M. Dreyfus, and C. D. Benedict. The initial and place make E. Pfeifer a plausible candidate for Emanuel, but the source does not expand the name or state a relationship to Leon."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PFEIFER_PARENT_MIGRATION_CHRONOLOGY_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "Leon Pfeifer parentage and transatlantic chronology assessment, 25 July 2026",
      "type": "conflict and migration assessment",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Leon's reported 1873 Brookhaven birth is not inherently incompatible with his proposed parents' reported deaths in the Bergzabern area if they later returned to Germany. An E. Pfeifer incorporated a Brookhaven lumber company in 1884, providing a plausible local adult candidate, but no census, vital, passenger, obituary, or corporate record yet expands the initial or names Leon. The parent links and European deaths remain compiled rather than proved."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_LUMBER_CANDIDATE_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "E. Pfeifer of Brookhaven business-identity assessment, 25 July 2026",
      "type": "candidate identity assessment",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The 1884 incorporation of Brookhaven Lumber & Manufacturing Company names E. Pfeifer. Emanuel Pfeifer is an age-, surname-, chronology-, and locality-compatible candidate if the compiled parentage of Brookhaven-born Leon is correct, but the initial alone does not prove identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MDAH_CHARTER_RECORD_BOOK_2_1882_1885",
      "title": "Mississippi Department of Archives and History, Secretary of State Charter Record Book 2, 1882-1885",
      "type": "government archival finding aid",
      "url": "https://finding.mdah.ms.gov/government-records/109-4",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Series 1099 contains bound copies of Mississippi charters. Book 2 covers 1882-1885, archive number 33403. The finding aid states that scans were made before transfer. The 9 Jan 1884 Brookhaven Lumber charter should be sought in this volume for full names, signatures, residences, and charter terms."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_FUCHS_FAMILY_PROFILE_20260725",
      "title": "User-supplied compiled Fuchs family profile, reviewed 25 July 2026",
      "type": "user-supplied compiled genealogy",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The supplied family profile places Anna, Balthass, Johannes, Barbara, Veit, and Maria with Hans Fuchs and Barbara Reiff. Anna alone is independently supported by the transcribed 1596 Oberboebingen baptism, which names Hans and a mother Barbara but does not give Barbara a maiden surname. The other child links remain plausible compiled claims rather than primary-record conclusions."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_ANTHONY_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725",
      "title": "User-supplied compiled Anthony and Mary Linder child list, reviewed 25 July 2026",
      "type": "user-supplied compiled genealogy",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The supplied family profile lists Abram, Elizabeth Jemima, Sarah, Isaac, Jacob, and Joseph as children of Anthony Linder and Mary Newland. Published research reports a family-held copy of Anthony's will and supports Jemima through the later Gobble family context, but the original probate has not been produced. These links remain plausible compiled relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USER_SUPPLIED_SAANEN_LINDER_CHILDREN_20260725",
      "title": "User-supplied compiled Martin Linder and Salome Werren child list, reviewed 25 July 2026",
      "type": "user-supplied compiled genealogy",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The supplied family profile lists Elsbeth, Christina, Salome, Martin, Simeon, and Maria as children of Martin Linder and Salome Werren in the Saanen/Gsteig family. A derivative Swiss reconstruction independently names son Simon or Simeon, but original parish entries for the full sibling group have not been inspected. The links therefore remain low-confidence compiled relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HNOC_MAISON_BLANCHE_HISTORY_20260725",
      "title": "Historic New Orleans Collection: Maison Blanche Collection",
      "type": "institutional local history",
      "url": "https://hnoc.org/research-collections/collection-highlights/maison-blanche",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes Maison Blanche as a major Canal Street department store founded in 1897 with Isidore Newman's financial backing; the 1909 building, locally run corporate history, suburban expansion, display work, and place in New Orleans commercial culture. Used as family and city context, not as evidence that Anna Pfeifer worked there."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_JEWISH_IMMIGRATION_20260725",
      "title": "Historic New Orleans Collection: Coming to New Orleans, Part II",
      "type": "institutional local history",
      "url": "https://hnoc.org/publishing/first-draft/coming-new-orleans-five-items-tell-story-immigration-between-louisiana",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains the established Sephardic, Alsatian, Bavarian, and later Eastern European Jewish communities of New Orleans and their mercantile, shipping, retail, wholesale, school, and religious networks. Provides community context only unless a personal record states participation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MS_ENCYCLOPEDIA_PORT_GIBSON_JEWISH_CONGREGATION",
      "title": "Mississippi Encyclopedia: Religious Architecture",
      "type": "scholarly state encyclopedia",
      "url": "https://mississippiencyclopedia.org/entries/religious-architecture/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports that Gemiluth Chessed congregation was established at Port Gibson in 1859 and later erected a Moorish-Byzantine synagogue. This establishes Rebecca Kieffer's local Jewish community setting but does not prove her membership."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_SHREWSBURY_FLAXMILL_HISTORY",
      "title": "Historic England: The History of Shrewsbury Flaxmill Maltings",
      "type": "official historic-environment history",
      "url": "https://historicengland.org.uk/campaigns/visit/shrewsbury-flax-mill/history/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Historic England explains that the steam-powered Shrewsbury flax mill opened in 1797, became the town's largest employer, and operated through most of the nineteenth century. This supplies local industrial context only; it does not show that Richard Lister worked there."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ENGLAND_WALES_CENSUS_1851_COLLECTION",
      "title": "FamilySearch: England and Wales, Census, 1851 collection description",
      "type": "historical-record collection description",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/collection/2563939",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch describes the 1851 census and the household, relationship, birthplace, marital-status, and occupation information normally recorded. The person-specific household details used here come from Matthew's supplied transcript, cited separately."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_JEWISH_RECORDS_GUIDE_1784_1808",
      "title": "Archives départementales du Bas-Rhin: guide to Jewish registers and adoption of names",
      "type": "official archives research guide",
      "url": "https://archives.bas-rhin.fr/eCommunityDocuments/996A4DC5-7B41-4352-A704-F3DF616B220D/875/Fiche%20sur%20les%20registres%20de%20prise%20de%20nom%20des%20Juifs.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The departmental archives explain that systematic Jewish vital registration in Alsace is sparse before 1784; Jewish residents became French citizens in 1791; and Napoleon's 1808 decree required permanent given and family names. The guide reports 2,758 Jewish residents in the Wissembourg arrondissement in 1784 and 4,359 in 1806."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_ALSATIAN_JEWISH_HISTORY",
      "title": "Archives départementales du Bas-Rhin: Alsatian historical milestones and religious minorities",
      "type": "official archives historical guide",
      "url": "https://archives.bas-rhin.fr/eCommunityDocuments/996A4DC5-7B41-4352-A704-F3DF616B220D/472/Jalons%20historiques%20et%20sp%C3%A9cificit%C3%A9s%20alsaciennes.%20.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The departmental archives describe the limited pre-Revolution Jewish registers, the 1784 legal regulation, French citizenship from 1791, and compulsory fixed names in 1808."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_JACQUES_LEVY_BOSEL_MACHOLE_FAMILY",
      "title": "Geneanet compiled Levy branches: Jacquesjeckel Jacob Levy and Bösel, daughter of Macholé",
      "type": "independent compiled family tree",
      "url": "https://gw.geneanet.org/appelmans3?lang=fr&m=N&v=levy",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This compiled tree gives Michel Machole Levy (about 1725) as father of Jacquesjeckel Jacob Levy (1750-1806), whose reported wife is Bosel, daughter of Machole. It also gives their son Seligmann Levy as 1777-1853 and supplies the later child group. It conflicts with the imported GEDCOM, which names Mosche Levy (about 1690) and Judith Levy (about 1695) as Jacques's parents. The source is more chronologically coherent and repeats the lower household, but it is not an original record; source dependence cannot be excluded."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BAS_RHIN_ARCHIVES_OTTROTT_ISRAELITE_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Archives départementales du Bas-Rhin: Ottrott-le-Bas Israelite and civil-register holdings",
      "type": "official archival catalog",
      "url": "https://archives.bas-rhin.fr/rechercher/?f.etatdesfonds.facet.prefix=&fq=periode%3A%2218e+si%C3%A8cle%22&rows=108&sort=adeloch+desc&start=0&term=%2A",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The catalog identifies surviving Ottrott-le-Bas Israelite NMD registers for 1785-1786 and later civil holdings. These holdings identify where primary verification should occur; this batch did not locate a person-specific image."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_SURNAME_INDEX_LEMBACH_KIEFFER",
      "title": "Index of Jewish surnames adopted in Bas-Rhin in 1808",
      "type": "compiled index derived from Bas-Rhin 1808 name registers",
      "url": "https://people.math.carleton.ca/~rhfischl/GENEALOGY/ALSATIAN_JEWISH_DVD/1808_CHANGEMENT_NOMS/ARTICLES%2BETC/1808_noms-villes.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The index places the surname Kieffer at Lembach in the 1808 Jewish name-adoption records. It supports the surname-place context, but does not by itself identify this Isaac Kieffer."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_INGENHEIM_PFEIFER_RAHEL_1845",
      "title": "Ingenheimer Juden database: Pfeifer Rahel, born 5 Jan 1845",
      "type": "community historical database compiled from local records",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/5/by%2Csterbeort/dir%2CDESC/lim%2C100/start%2C34/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The database lists Pfeifer Rahel, born 05.01.1845, associated with Ingenheim and dying at Bad Bergzabern. The exact date, married surname, and localities independently align with the imported profile. The page does not state her maiden name, death date, spouse, children, or underlying record citation; another view inconsistently groups her birthplace under Heuchelheim."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CONNECTICUT_HARTFORD_SUPERIOR_DUBOWY_1915_1920",
      "title": "Connecticut State Library: Hartford Superior Court civil indexes, volumes 54 and 57",
      "type": "official court-record index",
      "url": "https://portal.ct.gov/-/media/CSL/departments/reference-services/PDFs/Hartford-Co-Superior-Court-Records/Hartford_Sup_CivilVol54_1915-17.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The index names Solomon Dubowy in litigation against Sol Dubowy and later shows a case involving Sol Dubowy. It proves that this uncommon name was present in Hartford-area court records, but supplies no age, birthplace, residence, occupation, spouse, or child and therefore does not identify the imported ancestor by itself."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_DATABASE",
      "title": "Ingenheimer Juden: local Jewish people and community database",
      "type": "community historical database and local-history project",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/41/by%2Cname/dir%2CDESC/lim%2C50/start%2C96/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The local project documents many Ingenheim residents, occupations, migrations, cemetery entries, and the community's links to American destinations. It is used for specific entries where named and otherwise only as local context."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_PHELPS_WASHINGTON_VA",
      "title": "Rambling Roots: Phelps and Countiss families of Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "compiled local genealogy with citations and record transcriptions",
      "url": "https://www.ramblingroots.com/RYB-p/found-1850.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The compilation transcribes census, marriage, and death evidence for Martin Phelps, Eda or Edith Countiss, and Malinda Scott. It is useful derivative evidence, but original record images were not inspected here; exact vital dates and parent claims therefore remain secondary."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HENDERSON_TALLEY_WASHINGTON_VA",
      "title": "Rambling Roots: Henderson and Talley families of Washington County, Virginia",
      "type": "compiled local genealogy with citations and record transcriptions",
      "url": "https://www.ramblingroots.com/RYB-p/not-found-1850.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The compilation transcribes the 10 September 1866 Washington County marriage register entry for William Henderson and widow Delia Tally, the 1870 and 1880 households, and deed references. Original images were not inspected here, so the transcription is treated as strong secondary rather than direct-image evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BIRMINGHAM_COUNCIL_ORIGINS_INDUSTRIAL_CITY",
      "title": "Birmingham City Council: Origins of Birmingham",
      "type": "official municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.birmingham.gov.uk/info/50050/culture_arts_and_heritage/1258/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains Birmingham's transformation into the industrial and commercial center of the Midlands. Used only as city context, not as evidence of any individual occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WV_ARCHIVES_MINE_WARS_COALFIELD_TRANSFORMATION",
      "title": "West Virginia State Archives: West Virginia's Mine Wars",
      "type": "official state archival history",
      "url": "https://archive.wvculture.org/history/archives/minewars.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Documents the railroad-driven transformation of southern West Virginia into a coal economy, rapid migration, company control, and labor conflict. Used as regional context only."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHOENIX_OFFICIAL_CITY_HISTORY_POSTWAR_GROWTH",
      "title": "City of Phoenix: City history and postwar growth",
      "type": "official municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.phoenix.gov/administration/departments/communications/history-facts/city-history.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes Phoenix's World War II industrialization and rapid postwar population growth. Used as city context only."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_HER_ASHBOURNE_MARKET_PLACE",
      "title": "Derbyshire Historic Environment Record: Ashbourne Market Place",
      "type": "official historic environment record",
      "url": "https://her.derbyshire.gov.uk/Monument/MDR12718",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Documents Ashbourne's long-standing market place and livestock and cloth market roles. Used as town context, not as an individual occupational claim."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ARCHION_OBER_GLEEN_BAPTISM_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Archion catalog: Ober-Gleen Protestant baptism registers, including 1840-1870",
      "type": "official church-archive catalog",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/hessen/zentralarchiv-der-evangelischen-kirche-in-hessen-und-nassau/dekanat-alsfeld/ober-gleen/279138",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Zentralarchiv der Evangelischen Kirche in Hessen und Nassau catalog lists an Ober-Gleen baptism register covering 1840-1870. The catalog establishes the surviving register series but does not itself transcribe Katharina Schaaf's entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SCHAAF_GRAU_COMPILED_FAMILY",
      "title": "Ober-Gleen Schaaf-Grau family reconstruction and linked church records",
      "type": "compiled genealogy with linked church records",
      "url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/Genealogy/comments/1893oo0/earlymid_1800s_prussia_research/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A descendant's reconstruction names Martin Schaaf and Catharine Grau and links records for their Ober-Gleen children. A knowledgeable transcription of Johann Daniel Schaaf's baptism identifies Johann Martin Schaaf the second and Anna Catharina Grau, while warning that at least two contemporary men had the same name. This supports the local couple but is not an American-to-German identity bridge for Katharine Schaaf Fricke."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_INGENHEIM_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
      "title": "Jüdisches Leben in Ingenheim: Emanuel Pfeifer (born 21 September 1833)",
      "type": "community historical database drawing on civil, passport, census, and military records",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-menschen/namen-und-leben/pfeifer-emanuel/41/pid,6554/pfeifer-emanuel.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Emanuel Pfeifer of Niederhochstadt; reports emigration about 1853, Confederate service beginning in 1861, marriage to Rachel Dreyfuss at New Orleans on 2 February 1867, four American-born children including Leon, an 1879 Lincoln County passport naming a wife and four minor children, and the family in Brookhaven in 1900. It is a credible published synthesis, but the underlying record images were not all inspected in this audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_INGENHEIM_RAHEL_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
      "title": "Jüdisches Leben in Ingenheim: Rahel Dreyfuss Pfeifer (1845-1918)",
      "type": "community historical database drawing on local and family records",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-menschen/namen-und-leben/pfeifer-rahel/41/pid,6555/pfeifer-rahel.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Rahel Dreyfuss, born 5 January 1845 at Ingenheim and died 18 May 1918 at Bad Bergzabern, as daughter of David Dreyfuss and Johanna Frank, wife of Emanuel Pfeifer from Niederhochstadt, and mother of four children born in the United States."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEON_PFEIFER_PROFILE",
      "title": "Jüdisches Leben in Ingenheim: Leon Pfeifer (1873-1949)",
      "type": "community historical database drawing on family and civil records",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-menschen/namen-und-leben/pfeifer-leon/41/pid,6557/pfeifer-leon.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies accountant Leon Pfeifer, born 9 February 1873 at Brookhaven and died 19 December 1949 at New Orleans, as son of Emanuel Pfeifer and Rahel Dreyfuss and husband of Bertha Pfeifer; gives burial at Metairie Cemetery."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_INGENHEIM_DAVID_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
      "title": "Jüdisches Leben in Ingenheim: David “Red David” Dreyfuss (1806-1880)",
      "type": "community historical database drawing on local civil and family records",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-menschen/namen-und-leben/dreyfuss-david/41/pid,6524/dreyfuss-david.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies baker David Dreyfuss, called Red David, born 23 November 1806 at Ingenheim and died 16 May 1880 at Bad Bergzabern; names parents Leon Dreyfuss and Rosina Haas, marriage to Johanna Frank at Ingenheim on 24 February 1835, and their children including Rahel."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_INGENHEIM_JOHANNA_FRANK_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
      "title": "Jüdisches Leben in Ingenheim: Johanna “Lea” Frank Dreyfuss (1805-1879)",
      "type": "community historical database drawing on local civil, family, and cemetery records",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-menschen/namen-und-leben/dreyfuss-johanna/41/pid,6523/dreyfuss-johanna.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Johanna, called Lea, born 3 July 1805 at Oberlustadt and died 1 March 1879 at Bad Bergzabern; names husband David Dreyfuss, their daughter Rahel, and burial in Ingenheim Jewish cemetery, grave 3 03 06. The page calls her father Theodor Frank while the 1808 name-adoption transcript previously reviewed calls him Salomon Frank; this may be a naming equivalence but is retained as an unresolved conflict."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BROOKHAVEN_LEADER_LEON_PFEIFER_COLLEGE_1890",
      "title": "The Brookhaven Leader, 2 January 1890, page 3: Leon Pfeifer attending college in New Orleans",
      "type": "contemporary newspaper; Library of Congress Chronicling America image and OCR",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn86074058/1890-01-02/ed-1/?sp=3&q=%22leon+pfeifer%22",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The local social column reports that Duncan Sessions and Leon Pfeifer, who were attending college in New Orleans, spent the holidays at home. It does not identify the college or course of study."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BROOKHAVEN_LEADER_LEON_PFEIFER_BOOKKEEPER_1897",
      "title": "The Leader, 15 September 1897, page 4: Leon Pfeifer returning to Brookhaven to keep books",
      "type": "contemporary newspaper; Library of Congress Chronicling America image and OCR",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn86074063/1897-09-15/ed-1/?sp=4&q=%22leon+pfeifer%22",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports that Leon Pfeifer had for a number of years been a traveling man and would take charge of the books of Pfeifer & Dreyfus, becoming a Brookhaven resident again."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ISJL_MORGAN_CITY_JEWISH_HISTORY",
      "title": "Goldring/Woldenberg Institute of Southern Jewish Life: Encyclopedia of Southern Jewish Communities, Morgan City, Louisiana",
      "type": "scholarly community history using directories, newspapers, congregational records, and census research",
      "url": "https://www.isjl.org/louisiana-morgan-city-encyclopedia.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Morgan City history reports that the city first appears in the 1870 census and that an early city directory carried an advertisement for Leon Cahn's dry-goods store. This proves a merchant of that name in the locality, but does not by itself prove his relationship to Bertha or his reported Metz identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ST_MARY_BANNER_LEON_CAHN_LAND_CHAIN_1909",
      "title": "St. Mary Banner, 3 July 1909, page 1: Morgan City property title recital naming Leon Cahn",
      "type": "contemporary newspaper legal notice; Library of Congress digitized image",
      "url": "https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ndnp/lu/batch_lu_kadabra_ver01/data/sn88064384/00295873863/1909070301/0240.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The legal notice recites that Louisa Wright acquired Morgan City property from Leon Cahn and Theodore Lehmann on 24 March 1879. The recital was printed in 1909 and places a Leon Cahn in a Morgan City transaction at the time of Bertha's reported birth, but it does not name Bertha, Anna, or Metz."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_LLANDDEWI_LODGER_1861",
      "title": "1861 Wales Census transcript: John Thomas, age 10, born Llanddewi Ystradenni, lodging at Tynywern",
      "type": "FreeCEN transcript of official census, RG 9/4236, page 5, schedule 17",
      "url": "https://www.freecen.org.uk/search_records/655d4b2ff493fd0330641de8/john-thomas-1861-radnorshire-llanfihangel-rhydithon-1851-",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "John Thomas, unmarried male age 10, born Llanddewi Ystradenni, was a lodger at Tynywern in Llanfihangel Rhydithon with farm labourer Samuel Jones, Mary Jones, and lodger William Griffiths. No parent or occupation is given. This is a strong birthplace-and-age candidate for the later Shrewsbury bootmaker, but the record alone does not bridge the identities."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_THOMAS_BLEDFFA_BAPTISM_1851",
      "title": "Bleddfa St Mary parish register transcript: baptism of John Thomas, 24 June 1851",
      "type": "FreeREG transcript of parish register, entry 243",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/607ef6b8f493fdb686d2e6fd/john-thomas-baptism-radnorshire-bleddfa-1851-06-24",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Baptism of John, son of farmer Edward Thomas and Anne, abode The Farm. This is the Bleddfa child, not evidence for the separately enumerated Llanddewi-born boy. The original image remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_RADNORSHIRE_CANDIDATE_REVIEW_20260725",
      "title": "FreeCEN Radnorshire John Thomas candidate review, 25 July 2026",
      "type": "systematic census-index identity assessment",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A search for John Thomas born 1849-1853 in Radnorshire found seven 1861 candidates, including separate Llanddewi Ystradenni and Bleddfa/Cefnllys boys. The Llanddewi boy is the only exact birthplace match to the later 1881-1911 Shrewsbury household. A comparable 1871 search did not produce a Llanddewi or shoemaker bridge; coverage and transcription limits prevent treating that negative result as proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WIKITREE_ISAIAH_PETERS_1734_PROFILE",
      "title": "WikiTree: Isaiah Peters (1734-1814), Peters-1593",
      "type": "collaborative compiled genealogy with a cited 1764 marriage but uncited parent statement",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Peters-1593",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The profile exactly matches the reported Freshford birth, Bradford-on-Avon death, and the independently proved 1764 North Bradley marriage to Betty Willis. It names Priscilla Peters as Isaiah's mother and lists children Elizabeth, Richard, and Robert, but cites only the marriage on Isaiah's profile. The maternal relationship is therefore a useful compiled hypothesis, not direct baptism evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WIKITREE_BETTY_WILLIS_1737_PROFILE",
      "title": "WikiTree: Betty Willis Peters (about 1737), Willis-1313",
      "type": "collaborative genealogy transcribing indexed parish baptism and marriage records",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Willis-1313",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The profile transcribes Betty Willis's christening on 22 January 1737 at North Bradley and names father Benjamin Willis, citing England Births and Christenings film 1239307. It independently repeats her 18 June 1764 marriage to Isaiah Peters from the same parish and film. The original baptism image was not inspected in this audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WIKITREE_PRISCILLA_PETERS_1707_PROFILE",
      "title": "WikiTree: Priscilla Peters (baptized 1707), Peters-1595",
      "type": "collaborative genealogy citing a Somerset parish baptism",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Peters-1595",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Priscilla as daughter of Robert Peters and Ann and as the proposed mother of Isaiah. Her own parentage is independently confirmed by the FreeREG Freshford transcript; her relationship to Isaiah remains uncited on the profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_PRISSILLA_PETERS_FRESHFORD_BAPTISM_1707",
      "title": "Freshford St Peter transcript: baptism of Prissilla Peters, 23 June 1707",
      "type": "FreeREG transcript of parish register or archival transcript",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6850dca5865574058a73c727/prissilla-peters-baptism-somerset-freshford-1707-06-23",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Records Prissilla, daughter of Robert Peters and Ann, baptized at Freshford St Peter on 23 June 1707. The page labels the register type Other Transcript, so an original register image remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1738",
      "title": "North Bradley St Nicholas transcript: baptism of Ann Willis, 22 January 1737/38",
      "type": "FreeREG transcript of parish material",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685b1f388655743a54f18bd1/ann-willis-baptism-wiltshire-north-bradley-1738-01-22",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The entry names Ann, daughter of Benjamin Willis, baptized 22 January 1738. This directly conflicts with the WikiTree profile's claim that Betty Willis was christened on 22 January 1737 to Benjamin. A separate FreeREG entry records Sarah, age twelve, baptized on 22 January 1737/38 to Benjamin, showing calendar-style and clustered-baptism complexity but not supplying a Betty entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1701",
      "title": "North Bradley St Nicholas transcript: birth and baptism of Benjamin Willis, August 1701",
      "type": "FreeREG transcript of parish material",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685b1e728655743a54f1230d/benjamin-willis-baptism-wiltshire-north-bradley-1701-08-07",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Records Benjamin Willis born 4 August and baptized 7 August 1701 at North Bradley, son of an older Benjamin Willis. He is an age-compatible candidate for the Benjamin named as father in 1730s North Bradley baptisms, but no marriage, occupation, residence, or other identifier bridges the child to that adult."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_1738_FAMILY_CLUSTER",
      "title": "North Bradley Willis baptism cluster, January-July 1738",
      "type": "systematic parish-transcript cluster review",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG records Ann, daughter of Benjamin, and Sarah, age twelve and daughter of Benjamin, on 22 January 1737/38. On 2 July 1738 it records Mary, Ann, and Benjamin as children of Benjamin and Mary Willis. These entries establish one or more Benjamin Willis households but do not identify the 1764 bride Betty."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_BAPTISM_1679",
      "title": "North Bradley St Nicholas transcript: baptism of Benjamin Willis and siblings, 10 January 1678/79",
      "type": "FreeREG transcript of parish material",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685b1f378655743a54f18b08/benjamin-willis-baptism-wiltshire-north-bradley-1679-01-10",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The entry records Benjamin, child of William and Katherine Willis, baptized at North Bradley on 10 January 1679. Separate entries on the same date record Lazarus, Joseph, and Abigail to the same parents, consistent with a grouped baptism of siblings rather than quadruplet births."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_BENJAMIN_WILLIS_1679",
      "title": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, 1600-1837: Benjamin Willis baptized 1678/79, died 1703",
      "type": "compiled parish-register reconstruction with register citations",
      "url": "https://familytrees.genopro.com/appleshaw/northbradley/Willis-Benjamin-ind01659.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This parish-wide reconstruction quotes the North Bradley register baptism of the four children of William and Katherine Willis and a burial entry for “Benjamin Willis Junior” on 11 September 1703. It identifies this Benjamin as father of the Benjamin born in 1701. The parent-child identity is strong but remains one step less direct than an entry naming both generations together."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NORTH_BRADLEY_REGISTER_RECONSTRUCTION_WILLIAM_KATHERINE_WILLIS",
      "title": "North Bradley, Wiltshire, 1600-1837: family of William Willis and Katherine",
      "type": "compiled parish-register reconstruction with register citations",
      "url": "https://familytrees.genopro.com/appleshaw/northbradley/Willis-William-ind01289.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The reconstruction groups William Willis and Katherine as parents of John, Katherine, Anne, Lazarus, Joseph, Abigail, and Benjamin. The critical 1679 entries naming both parents were independently checked in FreeREG."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WOLVERHAMPTON_READ_PERRY_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPT_1750",
      "title": "Wolverhampton parish-register transcript: John Read and Sarah Perry, 15 July 1750",
      "type": "published parish-register transcript",
      "url": "https://www.staffordshirecountystudies.uk/Wolverhampton%20Parish%20Register%2C%20Marriages%201735-1776.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The published Wolverhampton register transcript lists John Read and Sarah Perry marrying by banns on 15 July 1750. This proves that couple but does not identify them as the parents at Stoke in 1753."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_ANN_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1753",
      "title": "Wolverhampton transcript: baptism of Ann Read, 23 April 1753",
      "type": "FreeREG transcript of parish material",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6856ad4a8655747a9707b504/ann-read-baptism-staffordshire-wolverhampton-1753-04-23",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The entry names Ann, daughter of John Read, baptized at Wolverhampton on 23 April 1753. Her baptism is only six months before the connected Richard was baptized to John and Sarah at Stoke, making assignment of both children to one mother chronologically implausible."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_RICHARD_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1755",
      "title": "Wolverhampton transcript: baptism of Richard Read, 29 September 1755",
      "type": "FreeREG transcript of parish material",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6856ad7b8655747a9707c183/richard-read-baptism-staffordshire-wolverhampton-1755-09-29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The entry names Richard, son of John Read, baptized at Wolverhampton on 29 September 1755. Together with later children explicitly naming John and Sarah, it shows that the Wolverhampton household had its own Richard after the connected Stoke child."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_JOSEPH_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1759",
      "title": "Wolverhampton transcript: baptism of Joseph Read, 13 August 1759",
      "type": "FreeREG transcript of parish material",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6856adcb8655747a9707d906/joseph-read-baptism-staffordshire-wolverhampton-1759-08-13",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The entry explicitly names Joseph as son of John and Sarah Read at Wolverhampton."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_READ_WOLVERHAMPTON_BAPTISM_1762",
      "title": "Wolverhampton transcript: baptism of William Read, 23 August 1762",
      "type": "FreeREG transcript of parish material",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6856ae0f8655747a9707f3f5/william-read-baptism-staffordshire-wolverhampton-1762-08-23",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The entry explicitly names William as son of John and Sarah Read at Wolverhampton, confirming a continuing same-name parental household there."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_E_SCHWARTZ_1926",
      "title": "Louisiana death index: Leon E. Schwartz, 3 May 1926",
      "type": "official state death index",
      "url": "https://vitalrecords.sos.la.gov/Deaths/DataView.aspx",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Louisiana Secretary of State death database lists Leon E. Schwartz, age 70, dying in Orleans Parish on 3 May 1926. Archive record 283950, volume 192, page 1072. The online index does not name his parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MDAH_JACOB_SCHWARTZ_WOODVILLE_LEDGER_FINDING_AID",
      "title": "Mississippi Department of Archives and History: Jacob Schwartz Mercantile Ledger finding aid",
      "type": "official archival finding aid",
      "url": "https://finding.mdah.ms.gov/index.php/manuscripts/z1989000",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The finding aid identifies Woodville merchant Jacob Schwartz, his 1844 marriage to Judith Moritz, and their son Leon. It also says that Leon continued the Woodville store after Jacob died in 1894 and formed a new local partnership in 1896."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ISJL_WOODVILLE_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
      "title": "Goldring/Woldenberg Institute of Southern Jewish Life: Woodville, Mississippi",
      "type": "credible published community history",
      "url": "https://www.isjl.org/mississippi-woodville-encyclopedia.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The history identifies Jacob Schwartz as a Woodville merchant and his son Leon as a merchant and long-serving Woodville civic official, including in 1904. This continuity distinguishes that Leon from the New Orleans husband of Adeline Trautman unless additional evidence proves otherwise."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_YETTA_DUBOWY_DEATH_1914",
      "title": "New Britain Daily Herald: death of Yetta Dubowy, 27 July 1914",
      "type": "contemporary newspaper death notice",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn82014519/1914-07-27/ed-1/?sp=11",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The notice reports that Yetta, wife of Solomon Dubowy of 125 Willow Street, died of cancer the previous morning, aged fifty-six, and was buried at Beth Alom Cemetery that afternoon. It says she left a large family but names neither parents nor children. The Library of Congress ALTO text and page image support the reading “fifty-six”; the earlier audit transcription as fifty was incorrect."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BETH_ALOM_YETTA_DUBOWY",
      "title": "FamilySearch cemetery record: Yetta Dubowy, Beth Alom Cemetery",
      "type": "cemetery database",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/sr/cemeteries/sites/141715/beth-alom-cemetery?showMap=false",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The cemetery database lists Yetta Dubowy at Beth Alom Cemetery and links a FamilySearch profile. It supports the burial locality but is not a parent-naming primary record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_ADELINE_TRAUTMAN_1862",
      "title": "Louisiana birth index: Adeline Trautman, 26 December 1862",
      "type": "official state birth index",
      "url": "https://vitalrecords.sos.la.gov/Births/DataView.aspx?pid=36",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Louisiana Secretary of State birth database lists Adeline Trautman, born 26 December 1862 in Orleans Parish, daughter of Julia Moses and David Trautman. Archive record 292195, volume 33, page 375."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LA_BIRTH_INDEX_TRAUTMAN_SIBLINGS_1854_1862",
      "title": "Louisiana birth index: children of David Trautmann and Julie Moser/Moses, 1854-1862",
      "type": "official state birth index",
      "url": "https://vitalrecords.sos.la.gov/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Louisiana Secretary of State birth database records four Orleans Parish children of the same named couple: Jacob Trautmann, born 22 October 1854 to Julie Moser and David Trautmann (archive record 218907, volume 20, page 40); Joseph Trautmann, born 14 December 1856 to Julie Moser and David Trautmann (record 232970, volume 20, page 41); Isidor Trautmann, born 21 June 1859 to Julie Moses and David Trautmann (record 249221, volume 25, page 689); and Adeline Trautman, born 26 December 1862 to Julia Moses and David Trautman (record 292195, volume 33, page 375). The sequence supports Moser/Moses and Julie/Julia as spelling and language variants within one family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
      "title": "Louisiana death index: David Trautman, 22 November 1893",
      "type": "official state death index",
      "url": "https://vitalrecords.sos.la.gov/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Louisiana Secretary of State death database records David Trautman, age 75, dying in Orleans Parish on 22 November 1893; archive record 2160443, volume 105, page 272."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LA_DEATH_INDEX_JULIE_TRAUTMAN_1916",
      "title": "Louisiana death index: Mrs David Trautman, 20 September 1916",
      "type": "official state death index",
      "url": "https://vitalrecords.sos.la.gov/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Louisiana Secretary of State death database records Mrs David Trautman, age 89, dying in Orleans Parish on 20 September 1916; archive record 369909, volume 167, page 297. The Hebrew Rest cemetery register identifies this burial as Julie Trautman."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HEBREW_REST_1_TRAUTMAN_PLOT",
      "title": "Hebrew Rest Cemetery No. 1 burial register and plot map: David and Julie Trautman",
      "type": "cemetery register",
      "url": "https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5ec450be9c1987666d2bc1b8/t/5fd96619c8b220041ce68c79/1608082972533/Hebrew%2BRest%2B1%2BMap.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The cemetery register places David Trautman, died 22 November 1893, and Julie Trautman, died 20 September 1916, together in plot 04-113 (register page 59), independently linking the two indexed deaths to the couple."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_COMPILED_JAMES_TRAUTMAN",
      "title": "Compiled profile for James Trautman, son of David Trautmann and Julia Mosser",
      "type": "compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.se/genealogy/records/james-trautman-24-5b1k9m",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This compiled profile gives David as 1818-1893 and Julia Mosser as 1826-1916 and points to 1870 and 1880 census records. Its dates agree closely with the official death-index ages, but it is not used as direct proof of their birthplaces, parents, or immigration. James may represent Jacob or another child and is not added here."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_MAX_JUFFE_FREDA_DUBOWY_1915",
      "title": "Connecticut marriage index: Max Juffe and Freda Dubowy, 30 May 1915",
      "type": "official state marriage index",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/connecticut-marriage-index-1897-to-2017",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Connecticut Genealogy Index, presenting Connecticut Department of Health index data obtained under the state Freedom of Information Act, records Max Juffe marrying Freda Dubowy at New Britain on 30 May 1915. Index record CTMI-1-159520.\n\n15 September 2026: Independently checked the downloadable state-index dataset distributed by Reclaim The Records. File CT_marriages_1897_to_1968.csv contains row: MAX | JUFFE | FREDA | DUBOWY | 05/30/1915 | NEW BRITAIN. This is inspection of the index data, not the certificate. Birth columns are childfn, childln, dob, town_ob; marriage columns groom_fn, groom_ln, bride_fn, bride_ln, dom, town_om. Neither file names parents. The website county field is inferred from town, not an additional field in the original data."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CT_BIRTH_HENRIETTA_JUFFE_1916",
      "title": "Connecticut birth index: Henrietta Juffe, 30 April 1916",
      "type": "official state birth index",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/connecticut-birth-index-1897-to-1917",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Connecticut Genealogy Index records Henrietta Juffe born at Hartford on 30 April 1916. Index record CTBI-510986. The public index does not print her parents, so it corroborates identity, date, place, surname, and chronology but is not described as direct parent-naming evidence.\n\n15 September 2026: Independently checked the downloadable state-index dataset distributed by Reclaim The Records. File CT_births_1897_to_1917.csv contains row: HENRIETTA | JUFFE | 04/30/1916 | HARTFORD. This is inspection of the index data, not the certificate. Birth columns are childfn, childln, dob, town_ob; marriage columns groom_fn, groom_ln, bride_fn, bride_ln, dom, town_om. Neither file names parents. The website county field is inferred from town, not an additional field in the original data."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PONTEFRACT_JOHN_MARSHALL_ANN_ALLEN_MARRIAGE_1772",
      "title": "Pontefract parish marriage index: John Marshall and Ann Allen, 19 July 1772",
      "type": "derivative index of Church of England marriage register",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/search/record/results?count=20&q.marriageLikeDate.from=1772&q.marriageLikeDate.to=1772&q.marriageLikePlace=Pontefract%2C%20Yorkshire%2C%20England&q.spouseGivenName=Ann&q.spouseSurname=Allen&q.surname=Marshall",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "England Select Marriages and the West Yorkshire parish collection index John Marshall and Ann Allen marrying at Pontefract on 19 July 1772; the supplied index references FHL film 990759 and West Yorkshire roll 30, page 106, record 666. A banns entry dated 12 July 1772 independently names the same couple."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_COMPILED_ANN_MARSHALL_DAUGHTER_JOHN_PONTEFRACT",
      "title": "Compiled/indexed claim: Ann Marshall, daughter of John Marshall, Pontefract family",
      "type": "derivative baptism index and compiled family-tree correlation",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/search/record/results?count=20&q.birthLikeDate.from=1772&q.birthLikeDate.to=1776&q.birthLikePlace=Pontefract%2C%20Yorkshire%2C%20England&q.fatherGivenName=John&q.surname=Marshall",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The supplied England Select Births and Christenings result identifies an Ann Marshall as a child of John Marshall, while the proposed parents John Marshall and Ann Allen had married at Pontefract in 1772. The supplied extract does not include Ann's baptism date, parish, image, or mother. This supports a candidate relationship only; it does not prove that the indexed child became Thomas Lister's wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANN_MARSHALL_THOMAS_LISTER_MARRIAGE_1799_CONTEXT",
      "title": "South Kirkby marriage index: Thomas Lister and Ann Marshall, 15 December 1799",
      "type": "derivative index of Church of England marriage register",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/search/record/results?count=20&q.marriageLikeDate.from=1799&q.marriageLikeDate.to=1799&q.marriageLikePlace=South%20Kirkby%2C%20Yorkshire%2C%20England&q.spouseGivenName=Ann&q.spouseSurname=Marshall&q.surname=Lister",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The indexed South Kirkby marriage directly names Thomas Lister and Ann Marshall on 15 December 1799. Their repeated Pontefract child baptisms, including Richard, securely identify the connected wife and mother but do not themselves name Ann's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_INGENHEIM_LEO_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
      "title": "Jüdisches Leben in Ingenheim: Leo Dreyfuss (1764-1833)",
      "type": "community historical database drawing on local civil, family, occupational, and cemetery records",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-menschen/namen-und-leben/dreyfuss-leo/41/pid,6472/dreyfuss-leo.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies baker Leo Dreyfuss, formerly Löb Isaak, born 10 February 1764 and died 30 September 1833 at Ingenheim; names parents Isaak Hirsch Dreyfuss and Maria Anna née Abraham, wife Rosina Haas, marriage on 22 April 1793, children, and residence at Schellgasse 3."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_INGENHEIM_HIRSCH_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
      "title": "Jüdisches Leben in Ingenheim: Hirsch Dreyfuss (1736-1804)",
      "type": "community historical database drawing on local family and cemetery records",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-menschen/namen-und-leben/dreyfuss-hirsch/41/pid,19445/dreyfuss-hirsch.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Jizchak Zwi, called Hirsch, born 1736 and died 11 July 1804 at Ingenheim, buried in the Jewish cemetery; names his father Jehuda Löb Dreyfuss and wife under several forms: Maria Anna Oppenheimer, Marina Abraham, and Borig Mariam. The variant surnames are preserved rather than forced into one identity form."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_INGENHEIM_ROSINA_DREYFUSS_PROFILE",
      "title": "Jüdisches Leben in Ingenheim: Rosina Haas Dreyfuss (1770-1853)",
      "type": "community historical database drawing on local civil, family, and cemetery records",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-menschen/namen-und-leben/dreyfuss-rosina/41/pid,6473/dreyfuss-rosina.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Rosina Haas, formerly Rösel Moises, born 27 June 1770 and died 5 April 1853 at Ingenheim; names parents David Moses and Esther née Nathan, husband Leo Dreyfuss, their 22 April 1793 Ingenheim marriage, children, and Jewish cemetery burial."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_IRISH_GRO_JOHN_GIBSON_SARAH_CLARK_MARRIAGE_1883_IMAGE",
      "title": "Irish civil marriage register: John Gibson and Sarah Clark, 10 October 1883",
      "type": "primary civil marriage register image",
      "url": "https://www.irishgenealogy.ie/files/civil/marriage_returns/marriages_1883/10951/8002527.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Registration no. 39, Second Monaghan Presbyterian Church, 10 October 1883. John Gibson, full age, bachelor, farmer, resident Aghnasedagh, son of Andrew Gibson, farmer, married Sarah Clark, full age, spinster, resident Aghnasedagh, daughter of David Clark, farmer. Both spouses signed. Witnesses were George Henderson and Mary Jane Clark."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIAM_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1814",
      "title": "Berriew parish-register transcription: baptism of William Davies, 29 January 1814",
      "type": "parish register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/68608786865574369c13af4c/william-davies-baptism-montgomeryshire-berriew-1814-01-29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry 147 at St Beuno, Berriew. William, son of Robert Davies and Eliza, was baptized 29 January 1814. The family abode was Trustewelin and Robert was a carpenter."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1819",
      "title": "Berriew parish-register transcription: baptism of David Davies, 16 May 1819",
      "type": "parish register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6860879f865574369c13b56a/david-davies-baptism-montgomeryshire-berriew-1819-05-16",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry 414 at St Beuno, Berriew. David, son of Robert and Elizabeth Davies of Trustewelin, was baptized 16 May 1819. Robert was a wheelwright."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_DAVID_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1821",
      "title": "Berriew parish-register transcription: baptism of David Davies, 2 September 1821",
      "type": "parish register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/686087aa865574369c13b8ba/david-davies-baptism-montgomeryshire-berriew-1821-09-02",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry 551 at St Beuno, Berriew. David, son of Robert and Elizabeth Davies of Trustewelin, was baptized 2 September 1821. Robert was a wheelwright. Reuse of the given name suggests, but does not itself prove, that the child baptized in 1819 had died."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_MARTHA_DAVIES_BERRIEW_BAPTISM_1823",
      "title": "Berriew parish-register transcription: baptism of Martha Davies, 30 March 1823",
      "type": "parish register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/686087b2865574369c13bb4d/martha-davies-baptism-montgomeryshire-berriew-1823-03-30",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry 664 at St Beuno, Berriew. Martha, daughter of Robert and Elizabeth Davies of Trustewelin, was baptized 30 March 1823. Robert was described as a labourer."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_DAVIES_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MARRIAGE_1803",
      "title": "Berriew parish-register transcription: marriage of Robert Davies and Elizabeth Lamb, 17 July 1803",
      "type": "parish register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/5f6636ddf493fd015e868ebd/robert-davies-elizabeth-lamb-marriage-montgomeryshire-berriew-1803-07-17",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Berriew register transcription records the marriage of Robert Davies and Elizabeth Lamb on 17 July 1803. It supplies no ages, residences, occupations, fathers, or witnesses, so identity with the later Trustewelin parents remains probable rather than proved."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_BERRIEW_DAVIES_REGISTER_SWEEP_1795_1835",
      "title": "FreeREG Berriew Davies register sweep, 1795-1835",
      "type": "systematic parish-index search",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_queries/6a6529bf1f40a0de0a941f2f",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A surname-wide search of Berriew baptisms was used to distinguish the several Davies households. The repeated combination Robert and Elizabeth at Trustewelin in 1814, 1819, 1821, and 1823 is materially more specific than names alone."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1785",
      "title": "Kerry parish-register transcription: baptism of Elizabeth Lamb, 19 June 1785",
      "type": "parish register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/68609216865574369c1813aa/elizabeth-lamb-baptism-montgomeryshire-kerry-1785-06-19",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Kerry register transcription records Elizabeth, daughter of John and Elizabeth Lamb, baptized 19 June 1785."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_ELIZABETH_PRICHARD_MARRIAGE_1785",
      "title": "Kerry parish-register transcription: marriage of John Lamb and Elizabeth Prichard, 21 January 1785",
      "type": "parish register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/68609387865574369c189a6c/john-lamb-elizabeth-prichard-marriage-montgomeryshire-kerry-1785-01-21",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Kerry register transcription records John Lamb marrying Elizabeth Prichard on 21 January 1785. The entry supplies no ages, residences, occupations, parents, or witnesses."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BAPTISM_SWEEP_1750_1790",
      "title": "FreeREG Montgomeryshire baptism search for Elizabeth Lamb, 1750-1790",
      "type": "systematic parish-index search",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_queries/6a652b16bad75b4bc5c50902",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The county-wide indexed search returned one result: the 1785 Kerry baptism. Index coverage is not equivalent to proof that no omitted or unindexed baptism existed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_MARRIAGE_SWEEP_1795_1820",
      "title": "FreeREG Montgomeryshire marriage search for Elizabeth Lamb, 1795-1820",
      "type": "systematic parish-index search",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_queries/6a652b2ef1a96a777453a226",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The county-wide indexed search returned one result: the 1803 Berriew marriage to Robert Davies. This supports, but does not prove, identity with the 1785 Kerry child."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_MGY_BURIAL_SWEEP_1785_1803",
      "title": "FreeREG Montgomeryshire burial search for Elizabeth Lamb, 1785-1803",
      "type": "systematic parish-index search",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_queries/6a652bd404e50eefe5cdff31",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "No indexed burial was returned between the Kerry baptism and Berriew marriage. A negative index result cannot exclude missing, variant, nonconformist, or out-of-county records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_IRISH_GRO_SARAH_ANN_GIBSON_DEATH_1885_REJECTED",
      "title": "Irish civil death register: Sarah Ann Gibson, 1885 (rejected identity)",
      "type": "primary civil death register",
      "url": "https://www.irishgenealogy.ie/files/civil/deaths_returns/deaths_1885/06277/4798295.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The register identifies this woman as Sarah Ann Gibson, wife of William Gibson; William was the informant. She is not Sarah Clark, wife of John Gibson of Aghnasedagh. The record is retained to prevent a tempting same-county death from being reused."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NAI_IRELAND_CENSUS_SEARCH_GUIDE",
      "title": "National Archives of Ireland: search the census",
      "type": "archive catalogue and search guide",
      "url": "https://nationalarchives.ie/collections/search-the-census/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official access point for the surviving 1901 and 1911 Ireland census returns."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1830_GRAYSON_VA_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLDS",
      "title": "1830 Grayson County, Virginia census index: Faddis households",
      "type": "published primary-record index",
      "url": "https://www.usgenwebsites.org/vagenweb/grayson/1830cens.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The index lists three Faddis household heads in Grayson County: Alexander with eight people, Elizabeth with two, and James with five. It gives household totals but not the age-and-sex columns needed to prove that Delia was in Alexander's household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1835_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_TAX",
      "title": "1835 Grayson County, Virginia personal-property tax list: Alexander Faddis",
      "type": "published primary-record transcript",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/grayson-personal-property-tax-list-1835/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Alexander Faddis appears with one taxable white male and one horse. The entry establishes his continuing presence in Grayson County but names no wife or children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1850_GRAYSON_VA_SUSAN_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
      "title": "1850 Grayson County, Virginia census: Susan Faddis household",
      "type": "published primary-record transcript",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/grayson-federal-census-1850/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "District 19 household 48: Susan Faddis, 55, with Sibarina 16, Isaac 14, Susan 11, and Floyd 8, all born in Virginia. Susan was old enough to be Delia's mother, but the census does not state relationships and Delia was already married in a separate Grayson household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GRayson_HISTORICAL_SOCIETY_FADDIS_NOTEBOOK",
      "title": "Grayson County Historical Society family-research notebooks: Faddis",
      "type": "archive research guide",
      "url": "https://graysonvahistsoc.com/family-research-notebooks/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The society lists a Faddis family notebook in its local collection. The online catalogue confirms relevant holdings but does not itself identify Delia's parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_JEWISH_NAME_INDEX_LEMBACH",
      "title": "1808 Bas-Rhin Jewish surname and given-name locality index: Lembach",
      "type": "published index to official 1808 Jewish name declarations",
      "url": "https://people.math.carleton.ca/~rhfischl/GENEALOGY/ALSATIAN_JEWISH_DVD/1808_CHANGEMENT_NOMS/ARTICLES%2BETC/1808_noms-villes.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The index records Kieffer as an adopted Jewish surname at Lembach and Strasbourg. Its locality entries for Isaac, Bernard, Julienne, Leopold, Roser, and Roeser do not identify the imported proposed parents in Lembach. This is negative index evidence, not proof that they were absent: a person could appear under an earlier given name, another adopted surname, a variant not indexed here, or have arrived after 1808."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USGENWEB_AMITE_1860_CENSUS_INDEX",
      "title": "1860 Amite County, Mississippi federal census full-name index",
      "type": "volunteer transcription and image index of federal census",
      "url": "https://www.us-census.org/image-index/ms/amite/1860/index.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The alphabetical index links every transcribed inhabitant to a scanned census page. No Schwartz, Schwarz, Swartz, or comparable entry identifies five-year-old Leon E. Schwartz or a plausible Schwartz household in Amite County. Absence from an index can reflect omission or mistranscription and does not disprove his reported Liberty birth."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USGENWEB_AMITE_1850_CENSUS_INDEX",
      "title": "1850 Amite County, Mississippi federal census surname index",
      "type": "published census surname index",
      "url": "https://www.skcensus.com/1850-census-index-amite-county-mississippi/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The county-wide surname index contains no Schwartz, Schwarz, or Swartz household before Leon's reported 1855 birth. This narrows but does not resolve the search: his parents may have arrived after 1850, lived in a neighboring county, or been indexed under another spelling."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RCP_SIR_WILLIAM_BUTTS",
      "title": "Royal College of Physicians: Sir William Butts",
      "type": "institutional biographical reference",
      "url": "https://history.rcp.ac.uk/inspiring-physicians/sir-william-butts",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Royal College of Physicians documents Sir William Butts, physician to Henry VIII, as a real historical person. It supplies no relationship to Robert Butt of colonial Virginia."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BUTT_LEGEND_PROVENANCE_AUDIT_20260725",
      "title": "Provenance review of the Butt-Bruce-Warrenton Hall family legend",
      "type": "research synthesis from the surviving compiled narrative and catalog evidence",
      "url": "https://www.ourfamtree.org/attach/b/u/Butt0001.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The surviving PDF is anonymous and undated, but a Geni GEDCOM transcript attributes substantially the same narrative to Mary Bailey McLure or McClure Butt, wife of Harold Butt. The original manuscript and title page have not been inspected, so authorship and date remain provisional. Virkus's 1925 pedigree supplies an earlier source for Joshua of Warrington Hall, Kent, and Ann Riddlehurst but no Bruce connection. The later narrative changes the place to Warrenton Hall, Cambridgeshire, changes the wife to Lady Elizabeth Jane Bruce, and itself says the English claims could not be authenticated. These mutations and incompatible children indicate pedigree conflation rather than a proven overseas lineage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VIRKUS_BUTT_PEDIGREE_1925",
      "title": "Frederick A. Virkus, The Abridged Compendium of American Genealogy, volume 1 (1925), pages 525 and 970",
      "type": "published compiled pedigree without cited record proof",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/abridgedcompendi01virk/page/970/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Francis Marion Butt pedigree calls Robert, died 1676, a son of Joshua of Warrington Hall, Kent, says he came from England in 1640, and names wife Ann Riddlehurst and son Radford. The volume provides no parish, probate, land, or family-manuscript citation for those assertions. Its Radford line conflicts with Robert Butt of the Southern Branch's 1675 will, which names sons Henry, Robert, Thomas, and Richard."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WIKITREE_ROBERT_BUTT_441",
      "title": "WikiTree profile Butt-441: Robert Butt of Lower Norfolk County",
      "type": "collaborative research profile with primary and derivative citations",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Butt-441",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The profile usefully distinguishes the will-supported Jane-and-four-sons family from a compiled Ann-Riddlehurst-and-Radford family and asks whether two men have been conflated. It cites the Virginia patent abstracts and will abstract for colonial facts and Virkus and Colonial Families for the disputed overseas pedigree. WikiTree itself is not proof of the relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CW_SARAH_BRUCE_BUTT_SAMPLER_1811",
      "title": "Colonial Williamsburg, object 1989-34: Sampler by Sarah Bruce Butt",
      "type": "museum object catalog and contemporary needlework inscription",
      "url": "https://emuseum.colonialwilliamsburg.org/objects/31744/sampler-by-sarah-bruce-butt",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Colonial Williamsburg catalogs an authentic sampler worked in 1811 by Sarah Bruce Butt, born 20 March 1798, daughter of Nathaniel and Frances Butt. The catalog transcribes the extensive stitched face, describes ten images, and gives descent from Sarah to the previous owner. Its published description does not identify Robert Butt, Jane Bruce, Earlshall, or Scotland and does not describe a pedigree written on the reverse."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BUTT_SAMPLER_REVERSE_REPORT_2000",
      "title": "Ted Butts, 10 July 2000 online report of a family tree on the reverse of Sarah Bruce Butt's sampler",
      "type": "third-hand online report of an undated object annotation",
      "url": "https://www.geni.com/people/Robert-Butt-Sr/6000000213978424177",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The earlier review recorded a Geni quotation attributed to Ted Butts in 2000, reporting an undated reverse pedigree with the Bruce identity and sons Richard and Thomas. The current museum catalogue does not describe that annotation; its text, author and date remain unverified. A two-son selection is not treated as contradicting a four-son will unless the selection was intended to be exhaustive."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NUGENT_CAVALIERS_ROBERT_BUTT_PATENTS",
      "title": "Nell Marion Nugent, Cavaliers and Pioneers, volume 1: Robert Bott/Butt patents of 1656 and 1665",
      "type": "published abstracts of Virginia Land Office patent books",
      "url": "https://libsysdigi.library.illinois.edu/OCA/Books2012-02/cavalierspioneer00nuge/cavalierspioneer00nuge.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Nugent abstracts Mr. Robert Bott receiving 380 acres in Lower Norfolk County on 3 March 1656 at the head of the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, adjoining land formerly taken up by Tristram Nasworthy, for transportation of eight people. She also abstracts Mr. Robert Butt holding 1,200 acres there on 28 April 1665. That tract had first been granted to Tristram Nasworthy in 1650, was assigned in 1656 to Butt, Richard Whitby, and John Bright, and became Butt's whole tract after Whitby and Bright sold him their combined 800 acres. The abstract does not state Robert's birthplace, parentage, social rank, arrival year, Barbados residence, or relationship to James Butt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENI_ROBERT_BUTT_COMPILED_NOTES_2026",
      "title": "Geni profile: Robert The Patriarch Butt, compiled About and GEDCOM notes",
      "type": "collaborative profile reproducing multiple attributed and unattributed family narratives",
      "url": "https://www.geni.com/people/Robert-Butt-Sr/6000000213978424177",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The profile combines Virginia patents and Robert's will with mutually inconsistent traditions: Robert and James as brothers from Warrenton Hall; an England-to-Barbados-to-Virginia route; fathers called Josiah or Joshua; wives Jane, Ann Riddlehurst, and Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce; and sons Richard and Radford treated as one person. It attributes one narrative to Mary Bailey McLure or McClure Butt and quotes later genealogy-forum comments, but does not reproduce an original manuscript, passenger list, English record, or Barbados record establishing the overseas relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PILI_9448_VIRKUS_DERIVATIVE",
      "title": "Passenger and Immigration Lists Index source code 9448: Virkus, Immigrant Ancestors",
      "type": "derivative immigration index entry sourced to a compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7486/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Source code 9448 identifies Frederick A. Virkus, editor, Immigrant Ancestors: A List of 2,500 Immigrants to America before 1750. It is not a ship manifest or colonial port record. Thus a Robert Butt entry giving Virginia and 1640 repeats the Virkus tradition already assessed; it is not independent evidence for the year, route, or English origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BUTT_MCLURE_FAMILY_NARRATIVE_TRANSCRIPT",
      "title": "Transcript attributed to Mary Bailey McLure Butt, Genealogy of the Butt, Robason and Dupuis Family / History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina",
      "type": "family-history transcript of an uninspected manuscript",
      "url": "https://www.geni.com/people/Robert-Butt-Sr/6000000213978424177",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Geni GEDCOM note attributes the familiar Warrenton Hall, Bruce, Sir William Butts, Blacksworthy, and timber-baron narrative to Mary Bailey McLure or McClure Butt, wife of Harold Butt. The original manuscript, title page, date, and cited research files have not been inspected, so the attribution improves provenance but does not authenticate its English and Scottish claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OC_VOL94_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_CLAIM",
      "title": "Ontario Genealogical Society, Families, volume 54 / Ontario Genealogist volume 94 surname-adaptation list: Robert Butt from Bristol",
      "type": "modern published surname compilation without an identifying record citation",
      "url": "https://ojs.lib.uwo.ca/index.php/oc/article/download/14906/11719",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The list describes Robert Butt as from Bristol, Gloucestershire and married to Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce in Norfolk about 1643. It supplies no Bristol parish, apprenticeship, probate, passenger, or Virginia migration citation. Its repetition of the conflated Bruce wife shows that the Bristol statement belongs to the later compiled pedigree tradition rather than independent proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USER_HINT_ROBERT_BUTT_BRISTOL_1625_20260725",
      "title": "User-supplied compiled-tree hint: Robert Butt born 1625 at Bristol, Avon, England",
      "type": "compiled genealogy research lead",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The hint supplies a specific year and place but no underlying record citation. A subsequent timeline line reports a baptism in 1635 at age 11, but gives neither parish nor register; the displayed age is also only approximately compatible with a 1625 birth. Online review found derivative profiles variously reporting 1590, circa 1605, circa 1614, 1624 at Warrington Hall, and 1625 at Bristol. No baptism or migration bridge identifies any of them as the Lower Norfolk patentee."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BRUCE_CUMMING_FAMILY_RECORDS_1870_EARLSHALL",
      "title": "Mary Elizabeth Cumming Bruce, Family Records of the Bruces and the Cumyns (1870), Bruces of Earlshall, pp. 332-333",
      "type": "published nineteenth-century family pedigree",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/familyrecordsofb1870bruc/page/332/mode/2up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Scanned pages 332–333 visually inspected. Page 332 styles Alexander Bruce’s daughters Elizabeth, Lady Durie, and Janet, Lady Blackmont. It lists Alexander’s marriages in 1572 and 1587 and his succession by William after 1599–1600. The table supplies a competing Scottish account but does not exclude a later remarriage. No Virginia identification is given."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USER_COMPILED_ELIZABETH_BUTT_BIOGRAPHY_20260725",
      "title": "User-supplied compiled biography of alleged Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce Butt",
      "type": "compiled online genealogy research lead",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Claims birth in 1605 at Earlshall, marriage to Robert Butt circa 1629 in England, six children, and death 3 July 1676 in Norfolk. The biography itself labels the origins disputed. No baptism, marriage, or death record is cited. The death date duplicates the probate date of Robert Butt's will."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USER_HINT_WILLIAM_RICHARD_BUTT_BIRTH_1638_20260725",
      "title": "User-supplied compiled-tree timeline: birth of William Richard Butt circa 1638",
      "type": "compiled genealogy research lead",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The timeline supplies a combined forename and approximate year but no place, parents, baptism, or underlying record. Robert Butt's 1675 will names a son Richard but no son William. Searches found no identifying seventeenth-century record for the combined name William Richard Butt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USER_HINT_ROBERT_BUTT_SON_BIRTH_BRISTOL_1640_20260725",
      "title": "User-supplied compiled-tree timeline: birth of Robert Butt at Bristol in 1640",
      "type": "compiled genealogy research lead",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The event appears in the elder Robert Butt's family timeline and most plausibly describes his son Robert. It gives no baptism, exact date, parents in the record itself, or parish citation. Other collaborative trees report the son's birth variously as 1649 or 1652, sometimes also at Bristol."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HOTTEN_JAMES_BUTT_BARBBADOS_1679",
      "title": "John Camden Hotten, Original Lists of Persons of Quality (1874), St George Parish Barbados landholders, 23 December 1679, pages 462-463",
      "type": "published transcript of a 1679 Barbados parish landholder return",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/originallistsofp00hottuoft/page/462/mode/2up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The return lists Mr James Butt and Mary Middleton with 42 acres in St George Parish, Barbados. It does not name James's birthplace, parents, siblings, arrival, or any Robert Butt. It proves the Barbados couple and holding, not a relationship to the Virginia patentee."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOCAL_SCAN_BUTT0001_20260725",
      "title": "Local scan of History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina (Butt0001.pdf)",
      "type": "anonymous undated compiled family-history sheet",
      "url": "https://www.ourfamtree.org/attach/b/u/Butt0001.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "One-page scan, SHA-256 6409267977ee8753381e245830ad3407056620ecdbdc8170bb070aefcf3c8a8b. PDF metadata names Robert E Tripp III, which identifies the digital file creator or custodian, not necessarily the original author. The sheet explicitly says Robert and James could not be traced in England and that Sir William Butts and Warrenton Hall were unauthenticated. It nevertheless repeats those traditions, the Bruce claim, an unsupported 1653 arrival, and an inference that extensive land proved an influential English family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USER_HINT_HENRY_BUTT_BRISTOL_1642_TIMELINE_20260725",
      "title": "User-supplied compiled Geni timeline: Henry Butt Sr born at Bristol circa 1642; Robert immigration shown between 1640 and 1656",
      "type": "compiled collaborative genealogy research lead",
      "url": "https://www.geni.com/people/Robert-Butt-Sr/6000000213978424177",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The pasted timeline formatting interleaves two events. Chronology indicates that the immigration range and displayed age 26 concern Robert, while circa 1642 concerns the birth of his son Henry at Bristol. No parish, baptism, passenger, or underlying record is cited. The age is generated from Robert's reported circa-1614 birth and is not independent evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ROBERT_BUTT_LZNR_WG5",
      "title": "FamilySearch collaborative profile LZNR-WG5, Robert Butt (1590-before 3 July 1676)",
      "type": "collaborative genealogy profile with mixed attached sources",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/LZNR-WG5/robert-butt-1590-1675",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The profile correctly summarizes Virginia evidence for wife Jane, four sons, residence by 1665, and death before the 3 Jul 1676 probate. It also asserts birth in 1590 in England. Its visible source list includes a Gloucestershire parish collection and a citation worded Robert But in entry for Robert But, which may name the elder Robert only as a father in a child's record. No displayed citation supplies a 1590 baptism or connects an English parish family to the Lower Norfolk patentee."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USER_HINT_SARAH_JANE_SHIPP_LOWER_NORFOLK_C1642_20260725",
      "title": "User-supplied compiled-tree timeline: Sarah Jane Shipp born circa 1642 in Lower Norfolk",
      "type": "compiled genealogy research lead",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The event uses Sarah's married surname and supplies no baptism, maiden-name record, marriage, or parent citation. Geni and WikiTree identify her as Sarah Jane Butt, daughter of Robert and Jane, while the FamilySearch profile lists only the four will-proven sons. Robert's will does not name daughters."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USER_HINT_THOMAS_BUTT_BRISTOL_1645_20260725",
      "title": "User-supplied compiled-tree timeline: Thomas Butt I born at Bristol in 1645",
      "type": "compiled genealogy research lead",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The supplied event gives Bristol and 1645 but no parish, baptism date, parents, or original-record citation. Robert Butt's 1675 will independently proves a son Thomas, but it does not give that son's age or birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCINTOSH_LOWER_NORFOLK_WILLS_1637_1710_SCAN",
      "title": "Charles Fleming McIntosh, Brief Abstract of Lower Norfolk County and Norfolk County Wills, 1637-1710",
      "type": "published transcript and abstract of original county probate books",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/briefabstractofl01mcin",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Internet Archive scan inspected directly. Page 48 abstracts Robert Butt's 1675 will. Page 200 records that Richard Butt junior helped prove John Godfrey's will on 15 May 1710. The name index separately identifies Richard and Richard junior."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LNCVA_VOL3_NORFOLK_MARRIAGE_BONDS_1711_1715",
      "title": "Lower Norfolk County Virginia Antiquary, volume 3: abstracts of Norfolk County marriage bonds, 1711 and 1715",
      "type": "published transcription of original county marriage bonds",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/lowernorfolkcoun03newy",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Scan inspected directly. Page 40 lists George Burgis and singlewoman Mary Butt in June 1711 with Thomas Butt and Richard Butt senior among the associated names. Page 41 records Richard Butt with Dina Butt on 13 June 1715, with Thomas, William, another Thomas, Richard, and Robert Butt shown as associated signers or bondsmen. The abstract does not label their exact relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PAGE_LIFE_JOSIAS_MACKIE_WILL_1716",
      "title": "Isaac Marshall Page, The Life Story of Rev. Francis Makemie: transcript of Josias Mackie will, 1716",
      "type": "published transcript of Norfolk County will abstract",
      "url": "https://library.logcollegepress.com/Page%2C%2BIsaac%2BMarshall%2C%2BThe%2BLife%2BStory%2Bof%2BRev.%2BFrancis%2BMakemie.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcribed will of Rev. Josias Mackie, dated 7 November and proved 16 November 1716, gives mares to Thomas and Elizabeth, children of Mr Richard Butt, and another mare to Henry, son of Mr Richard Butt. It separately gives clothing to Mr Richard Butt senior. Sarah Butt, Nathaniel Butt, Thomas Butt, and Thomas Butt junior appear as witnesses. The transcript cites Brief Abstract of Norfolk Wills, pages 49-50."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_ROBERT_BUTT_BAPTISM_1616",
      "title": "Winterborne Houghton parish-register transcription: Robert Butt baptized 17 September 1616",
      "type": "collaborative publication reproducing a parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Family%3ARobert_Butt_and_Susan_Gantrell_%282%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcribes “Robert the sonne of Robert Butt was baptised 17 September 1616” in the Winterborne Houghton, Dorset family of Robert Butt and Susan Gantrell. The same transcription supplies siblings and the parents' 1607 marriage. It does not connect this child to Virginia."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_PROTESTATION_1641",
      "title": "Dorset Online Parish Clerk: Winterborne Houghton Protestation Return, 1641",
      "type": "transcription of original parliamentary oath return",
      "url": "https://www.opcdorset.org/WinterborneFiles/W.Houghton/W.HoughtonProt1641.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists one Robert Butt and one Simon Butt among adult men of Winterborne Houghton who took the Protestation in 1641. Both the older Robert and his son baptized in 1616 were potentially alive; the return gives no age or relationship and cannot identify which Robert signed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_HOUGHTON_RECORD_HOLDINGS",
      "title": "Dorset Online Parish Clerk: Winterborne Houghton parish records and archival holdings",
      "type": "parish research guide and archive catalog summary",
      "url": "https://www.opcdorset.org/WinterborneFiles/W.Houghton/WinterborneHoughton.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports that the Dorset History Centre holds Winterborne Houghton baptisms from 1559, marriages from 1558, and burials from 1558. The public OPC page does not transcribe burials before 1731. No accessible entry on this page substantiates the previously reported Robert Butt burial in 1657; an original register image or reliable transcript would be required."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BRISTOL_ARCHIVES_SERVANTS_FOREIGN_PLANTATIONS_GUIDE",
      "title": "Bristol Archives, Sources for Ships, Seamen and Emigrants: Servants to Foreign Plantations, 1654-1686",
      "type": "official archive research guide describing original emigration registers",
      "url": "https://archives.bristol.gov.uk/guides/Bristol%20Archives%20-%20Ships%2C%20seamen%20and%20emigrants%20source%20guide.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains that approximately 10,000 people from throughout the British Isles, chiefly southwest England and south Wales, sailed from Bristol under registered indentures. Early entries distinguish the servant's place of origin from the Bristol port of departure; place of origin was omitted after 1660 and ship names generally appear from 1670."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VIRTUAL_JAMESTOWN_BRISTOL_BUTT_SEARCH_1654_1686",
      "title": "Virtual Jamestown Bristol indenture database: surname Butt search, 1654-1686",
      "type": "searchable transcription of Bristol Servants to Foreign Plantations registers",
      "url": "https://www.virtualjamestown.org/indentures/search_indentures.cgi?db=bristol_ind&search_type=basic&servant_ln=Butt",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The complete surname search returns one entry: Nathaniell Butt of Malmesbury, Wiltshire, indentured 22 July 1659 for four years in Virginia through agent William Lukins. It returns no Robert Butt. The database begins in 1654, so it cannot exclude a Robert departure before that year."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOANE_PENN_RODBOURNE_WILL_1619",
      "title": "Will of Joane Penn of Rodbourne, Malmesbury, Wiltshire, 1619 (published abstract)",
      "type": "published abstract of an Archdeaconry of Wiltshire probate record",
      "url": "https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/3f/Genealogical_gleanings%2C_contributory_to_a_history_of_the_family_of_Penn_%28IA_genealogicalglea00leaj%29.pdf#page=51",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Joane Penn's will, dated 13 July 1619, calls Mary Butt her daughter, names the children of Nathaniel and Mary Butt, and specifically names two of those children, Thomas and George Butt. The inventory was taken 25 October 1619. This proves an established Nathaniel Butt household in the Malmesbury area but does not identify the 1659 emigrant."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GREER_EARLY_VIRGINIA_IMMIGRANTS_JAMES_BUTT_1650",
      "title": "George Cabell Greer, Early Virginia Immigrants, 1623-1666: James Butt entry",
      "type": "published index derived from Virginia land-patent headright lists",
      "url": "https://family.beacondeacon.com/early-virginia-immigrants-1623-1666.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexes a James Butt in 1650 under transporter or patentee William Clapham. The entry supplies no origin, age, kinship, or county. A headright entry does not establish that James and Clapham travelled together or that the patent date was the arrival date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NUGENT_CLAPHAM_RAPPAHANNOCK_PATENT_1650",
      "title": "Nell Marion Nugent, Cavaliers and Pioneers, William Clapham patent, 22 August 1650",
      "type": "published abstract of Virginia Land Patent Book 2, page 233",
      "url": "https://books.google.com/books?id=UGss5ezsNXwC",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Abstracts William Clapham's 1,100-acre patent on the south side of the Rappahannock River for transportation of twenty-two persons. Greer's index associates James Butt with Clapham; the original patent image still should be inspected to confirm the spelling and placement in the headright list."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LVA_RESEARCH_NOTE_20_HEADRIGHTS",
      "title": "Library of Virginia Research Notes No. 20: Virginia Land Office Patents and Grants",
      "type": "official state archives research guide",
      "url": "https://www.lva.virginia.gov/public/guides/Research_Notes_20.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains that headright certificates could be sold before a patent issued, patents could postdate importation by years or decades, named headrights did not necessarily live on the patented land, and patents were often renewed to clarify title."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ENCYCLOPEDIA_VIRGINIA_HEADRIGHT_SERVITUDE",
      "title": "Encyclopedia Virginia: Indentured Servants in Colonial Virginia",
      "type": "scholarly institutional history",
      "url": "https://encyclopediavirginia.org/entries/indentured-servants-in-colonial-virginia/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains the fifty-acre headright incentive, the trade in servant contracts and land certificates, and the role of merchants, mariners, and planters in financing migration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PEPYS_DIARY_WILLIAM_BUTTS_BRISTOL_1668",
      "title": "Samuel Pepys diary, 13-15 June 1668: Bristol merchant Mr Butts",
      "type": "published transcription of a contemporary personal diary",
      "url": "https://www.gutenberg.org/files/4195/4195-h/4195-h.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Pepys met Deborah Willet's uncle Mr Butts at Bristol, called him a sober and wealthy merchant, visited his substantial well-furnished house, observed that the city treated him with great respect, and spent further time with him through 15 June. The editorial identification supplies the surname and relationship; Pepys does not call him Sir."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BRISTOL_HEARTH_TAX_WILLIAM_BUTTS_ST_STEPHEN",
      "title": "The 1662-1666 Hearth Tax Returns for the City of Bristol: William Butts of St Stephen",
      "type": "scholarly edition of contemporary taxation records",
      "url": "https://ore.exeter.ac.uk/repository/bitstream/handle/10871/35157/BristolHearthTax%20%28BRS70%29.pdf?sequence=1",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists William Butts with five chargeable hearths in the waterfront parish of St Stephen. The size and location are compatible with Pepys's description of the merchant's substantial house, although the tax return alone does not state his trade or relatives."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DNB_SIR_WILLIAM_BUTTS_FAMILY",
      "title": "Dictionary of National Biography: Sir William Butts, physician to Henry VIII",
      "type": "published scholarly biography drawing on wills and inquisitions post mortem",
      "url": "https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Dictionary_of_National_Biography%2C_1885-1900/Butts%2C_William",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Places the physician and his family in Norfolk, Cambridge, London, Fulham, and Suffolk, not Bristol. It names sons Sir William of Thornage, Thomas of Great Ryburgh, and Edmund of Barrow, and reports that Edmund alone left issue, a daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LHA_DICTIONARY_HERBERT_J_SCHWARTZ",
      "title": "Louisiana Historical Association, Dictionary of Louisiana Biography: Herbert J. Schwartz",
      "type": "credible published biography",
      "url": "https://www.lahistory.org/resources/dictionary-louisiana-biography/dictionary-of-louisiana-biography-s/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The entry says Herbert J. Schwartz, born in New Orleans in 1887, entered the family wholesale business Schwartz Bros. in 1902 and became president in 1926 upon his father's death. It does not name that father. The entry cites the New Orleans Times-Picayune obituary of 7 March 1995."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GESHER_GALICIA_1900_TOWN_LOCATOR_DITKOWCE",
      "title": "Gesher Galicia: 1900 Galician Town Locator, Ditkowce",
      "type": "scholarly archival finding aid",
      "url": "https://www.geshergalicia.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/1900Galician_Town_Locator2.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The locator places Ditkowce in Tarnopol district and identifies Zalozce as the Jewish registration district, with Mszaniec as the Roman Catholic parish. This makes the imported Ditkowce origin geographically coherent and identifies the relevant record jurisdiction, but it does not identify Solomon or Lazar Dubowy."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GARDNER_NEW_ORLEANS_DIRECTORY_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1861",
      "title": "Gardner's New Orleans Directory for 1861: David Trautman",
      "type": "contemporary city directory",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/gardnersneworlea00gard/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The alphabetical directory entry lists “Trautman David, shoe store” on Poydras Street and gives his residence as 174 Lafayette. The scan is held by Duke University Libraries and digitized by Internet Archive; the LDS Genealogy transcript helps locate the entry on directory page 432. The printed address is difficult to parse in OCR and should be checked against the scan before assigning an exact modern street number to the business."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NOPL_OBITUARY_INDEX_DAVID_TRAUTMAN_1893",
      "title": "New Orleans Public Library Obituary Index: David Trautman, 1893",
      "type": "official library obituary index",
      "url": "https://nopl.minisisinc.com/NOPL/SCRIPTS/MWIMAIN.DLL/144/obit_public?directsearch=",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The New Orleans Public Library index records two Daily Picayune notices for David Trautman: 23 November 1893, page 4 column 5, and 26 November 1893, page 4 column 5. The index confirms citations but does not reproduce the notices; their text remains to be examined for birthplace, relatives, and organizational affiliations."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ORANGES_DIRECTORY_HENRY_FRICKE_MILKMAN_1892",
      "title": "Orange, East Orange and West Orange Directory, 1892: Henry Fricke",
      "type": "contemporary city directory",
      "url": "https://www.digifind-it.com/maplewood/data/City-Directories/1892/1892_p2.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The alphabetical directory explicitly lists “Fricke Henry, milkman, 306 Halsted, E O.” The matching name, exact address later recorded for the ancestral household, and East Orange locality distinguish him from same-name coppersmiths, upholsterers, tailors, and laundry workers elsewhere in northern New Jersey."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_APERTUS_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_REGISTER_SEARCH_20260725",
      "title": "APERTUS, Landesarchiv Speyer catalogue: Niederhochstadt register holdings",
      "type": "official archive catalogue and bounded negative online search",
      "url": "https://apertus.rlp.de/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A search of the official Rheinland-Pfalz archive catalogue for Niederhochstadt, Hochstadt, civil registers, Jewish records, and births in 1800-1850 found only Catholic Niederhochstadt registers in Landesarchiv Speyer Bestand F 6 (including nos. 214 and 216). No digitized 1833 Jewish or general civil birth volume was exposed. This does not establish that the civil act is lost; it identifies a local or archival register request as the next record target."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WERELATE_WINTERBORNE_BUTT_GANTRELL_FAMILY",
      "title": "Winterborne Butt-Gantrell family: parish-register transcriptions",
      "type": "collaborative family reconstruction quoting parish registers",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Family%3ARobert_Butt_and_Susan_Gantrell_%282%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The page quotes the 13 April 1607 marriage of Robert Butt and Susan Gantrell and a sequence of eight children, including “Robert the sonne of Robert Butt” baptized 17 September 1616. The transcript is useful evidence for the Dorset family but does not identify the son with the Virginia immigrant. The page alternates between neighboring Winterborne Houghton and Winterborne Stickland in its locality labels, so the original register image remains desirable."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DORSET_HEARTH_TAX_ROBERT_BUTT_1664",
      "title": "Dorset Hearth Tax Assessment, Michaelmas 1664: Robert Butt of Hargrove tithing",
      "type": "published transcription of contemporary tax assessment",
      "url": "https://www.opcdorset.org/FontmellMagnaFiles/FontmellMagnaDorsetHearthTax1664.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists a three-hearth Robert Butt in Hargrove tithing in 1664. The entry proves that another adult Robert Butt remained in the wider Dorset district after the Virginia immigrant was established overseas, but gives no age or parentage. It may be the 1616 man or a namesake and therefore materially lowers, but does not eliminate, the proposed identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_WARRINGTON_PLACE_KENT",
      "title": "Historic England: Warrington Place Farmhouse, Paddock Wood, Kent",
      "type": "official national heritage listing",
      "url": "https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1378385",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Historic England identifies a timber-framed Kent farmhouse called Warrington Place Farmhouse, thought to date from 1604, with a central-room bressumer dated 1651. The property is in Paddock Wood, not Deptford. The listing gives architectural history but no seventeenth-century owners and names no Butt family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CHESAPEAKE_WARRINGTON_HALL_PUD_1996",
      "title": "City of Chesapeake: Warrington Hall Planned Unit Development regulations",
      "type": "official municipal planning record",
      "url": "https://www.cityofchesapeake.net/DocumentCenter/View/3265",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Approved 17 December 1996. The plan locates the Warrington Hall development between Kempsville Road and Butts Station Road and places its ten-acre Warrington Commons around the historic Henry Butt House. Street names include Walnut Neck, Long Beeches, Old Fields and Riddlehurst, showing deliberate reuse of Butt will language and later pedigree traditions. The plan documents modern commemoration, not the truth of the claimed English origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BRISTOL_KYP_WARRINGTON_ROAD_MAP_SEQUENCE",
      "title": "Bristol City Council Know Your Place: historic-map sequence at Warrington Road, Brislington",
      "type": "official municipal historic-map portal",
      "url": "https://maps.bristol.gov.uk/kyp/?edition=bristol&x=361795&y=170597&extent=1200",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The georeferenced Bristol map sequence shows the present Warrington Road site as undeveloped fields in the 1873, 1900s, 1910s, and 1930s layers. The road and housing appear on the 1949 layer. This dates the visible Bristol placename to the twentieth-century development unless separate evidence establishes an older field or property name."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1916",
      "title": "New Britain Daily Herald: Solomon Dubowy sues sons for support, 12 December 1916",
      "type": "contemporary newspaper report of civil action",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn82014519/1916-12-12/ed-1/?sp=6",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports that Solomon Dubowy, age 63 and a native of Austria who came to America in 1908, sued sons Nathan and Solomon over a written promise of support. It places him with a wife at Oak and Putnam Streets and says the sons operated a delicatessen and clothing store on Lafayette Street."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_SUPPORT_SUIT_1917",
      "title": "New Britain Daily Herald: father's support suit against Nathan and Sol Dubowy, 3 December 1917",
      "type": "contemporary newspaper report of civil action",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn82014519/1917-12-03/ed-1/?sp=9",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports the pending case of Solomon Dubowy against sons Nathan and Sol. It gives Solomon's age as 67, says he suffered from heart failure and had received charitable aid, and reports his allegation that the sons owned the Lafayette Street clothing store and held substantial insurance on his life. The age conflicts with the 1916 report by several years and is treated as approximate."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_FREDA_DUBOWY_ENGAGEMENT_1915",
      "title": "New Britain Daily Herald: Freda Dubowy engaged to Max Juffe, 10 April 1915",
      "type": "contemporary newspaper engagement notice",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn82014519/1915-04-10/ed-1/?sp=1",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Announces that Freda Dubowy of New Britain was engaged to Max Juffe of New York City and says that she had worked as a saleswoman at the Boston Store. It names no parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_COUNCIL_CANDIDATE_1916",
      "title": "New Britain Herald: Morris Segel a sixth-ward council candidate, 2 March 1916",
      "type": "contemporary newspaper",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn82014519/1916-03-02/ed-1/?sp=1",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The election report names Morris Segel among the sixth-ward council candidates. This places the confirmed New Britain merchant in local civic life by 1916."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_BURGLARY_1927",
      "title": "New Britain Herald: burglary at Morris Segel clothing store, 27 May 1927",
      "type": "contemporary newspaper",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn82014519/1927-05-27/ed-1/?sp=8",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The report identifies Morris Segel as the proprietor of a store at 11 Railroad Arcade and says clothing, shoes, and cash were stolen."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_FORECLOSURE_1929",
      "title": "New Britain Herald: Morris Segel foreclosure action, 12 February 1929",
      "type": "contemporary newspaper",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn82014519/1929-02-12/ed-1/?sp=17",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The court report says Morris Segel brought a foreclosure action concerning Brooklawn Street property and was represented by attorney Maurice Rosenberg."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEW_BRITAIN_HERALD_MORRIS_SEGEL_STORE_OPEN_1929",
      "title": "New Britain Herald: police secure Morris Segel store, 19 March 1929",
      "type": "contemporary newspaper",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn82014519/1929-03-19/ed-1/?sp=5",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The police report identifies Morris Segel as the proprietor of a store at 11 Railroad Arcade, which officers found open and secured."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CT_DEATH_INDEX_MORRIS_SEGEL_1940",
      "title": "Connecticut Death Index, Morris Segel, New Britain, 6 January 1940",
      "type": "official state death index data obtained by Reclaim The Records",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/connecticut-death-index-1917-to-2017",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The raw Connecticut Department of Health index file CT_deaths_1917_to_1968_formatted.csv records Morris Segel's death on 6 January 1940 in New Britain. The exact surname spelling and city match the documented merchant. The index does not state age, birthplace, spouse, or parents, so those fields remain unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_VA_NATIONWIDE_GRAVESITE_MAX_JUFFE_1979",
      "title": "VA Nationwide Gravesite Locator: Max Juffe, Los Angeles National Cemetery",
      "type": "official Department of Veterans Affairs burial database",
      "url": "https://gravelocator.cem.va.gov/ngl/index.jsp",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The live VA result identifies Max Juffe as CPT, US Army; gives birth 20 May 1888, death 19 September 1979, and burial at Los Angeles National Cemetery, section 99B, row H, site 21. The 1888 birth date conflicts with New York's contemporary 1917 military register, which gives 20 March 1886."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NARA_MAX_JUFFE_FOURTH_DRAFT_CARD_1942",
      "title": "National Archives Catalog: Fourth Draft Registration Card for Max Juffe of Hartford, Connecticut",
      "type": "official National Archives catalog description",
      "url": "https://catalog.archives.gov/id/5053322",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "NARA item 5053322 identifies a Fourth Registration draft card for Max Juffe of Hartford, Connecticut, born in Austria, dated 27 April 1942. The public catalog description does not expose the card image, Austrian town, or relative; its online-resource link leads to a subscription image."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NJ_ARCHIVES_ESSEX_NATURALIZATION_GUIDE",
      "title": "New Jersey State Archives collection guide: Essex County Court of Common Pleas naturalization records",
      "type": "official archival collection guide",
      "url": "https://www.nj.gov/state/archives/guides/cescp005.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The guide confirms that Essex County declarations and petitions survive across Henry Fricke's relevant pre-1906 period. The records are archived and partly digitized through FamilySearch, but no indexed public result or inspected image has yet been found for Henry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NJ_ARCHIVES_GENEALOGICAL_HOLDINGS",
      "title": "New Jersey State Archives: genealogical records and county naturalizations",
      "type": "official archival holdings guide",
      "url": "https://nj.gov/state/archives/search-genealogical-collections.shtml",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The State Archives states that it holds Essex County Court of Common Pleas naturalizations for 1792-1934. This identifies a concrete offline or image-browse target rather than proving that Henry filed in that court."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LA_SOS_DEATH_INDEX_LEON_CAHN_1924",
      "title": "Louisiana Secretary of State statewide death index: Leon Cahn, Orleans Parish, 5 June 1924",
      "type": "official state death index",
      "url": "https://vitalrecords.sos.la.gov/Deaths/DataView.aspx",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The official result identifies Leon Cahn, age 72, who died in Orleans Parish on 5 June 1924; volume 188, page 1593, state record/order ID 300254. The public index does not name parents, spouse, birthplace, or occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1851_CAHEN_INDEX_CONFLICT",
      "title": "Metz civil birth register and annual index, 1851, cote 1E/b587",
      "type": "official municipal civil register images",
      "url": "https://archives.metz.fr/4DCGI/Web_RegistreArt1Exzxb587/ILUMP12331",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The annual table image 380 appears to list a Leon Cahen in late 1851. The apparent act number opens to an unrelated Robinet birth, however, and inspection of the acts surrounding the table date found no Cahen/Cahn birth. The table entry is therefore a research lead, not an identified birth act."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_METZ_CIVIL_BIRTHS_1852_CAHN_NEGATIVE_CHECK",
      "title": "Metz civil birth register and annual index, 1852, cote 1E/b590",
      "type": "official municipal civil register images",
      "url": "https://archives.metz.fr/4DCGI/Web_RegistreArt1Exzxb590/ILUMP12331",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The complete C section of the 1852 annual birth table was inspected. It contains several Cachen entries but no Leon Cahn, Cahen, Kahn, or clearly equivalent entry. This is a targeted negative check, not proof that Leon was born outside the wider Metz region."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_METZ_ARCHIVES_GENEALOGY_PORTAL",
      "title": "Archives municipales de Metz: genealogical research and digitized civil registers",
      "type": "official municipal archives guide",
      "url": "https://archives.metz.fr/4dcgi/web_custompage/recherchegenealogique.shtm/ilump3223",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The city archive states that Metz parish and civil registers and decennial tables from 1566 onward are available through its digitized-register interface."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GGG_NY_NATURALIZATION_MAX_JUFFE_JAFFE_SEARCH_20260725",
      "title": "German Genealogy Group: New York and New Jersey naturalization index search for Max Juffe/Jaffe",
      "type": "searchable index to county and federal naturalization records",
      "url": "https://germangenealogygroup.com/records-search/naturalizations.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "An exact Max Juffe search returned no result. Variant searches found twenty-two Max Jaffe records, including a 1913 declaration in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, volume 46B, record 22398. That entry is chronologically and geographically compatible with the Austrian-born soldier, but the index supplies no birth date, residence, arrival, or relative. The original declaration must identify him before it can be attributed to Max Juffe."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_HOCHSTADT_HANAU_JEWISH_REGISTERS_REJECTED_FOR_PFEIFER",
      "title": "FamilySearch catalog 344161: Jewish registers of Hochstadt, Kreis Hanau, 1825-1873",
      "type": "official archive microfilm catalog; rejected locality match",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/search/catalog/344161",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The catalog includes Jewish births for 1825-1851, but its locality subject and author identify Hochstadt in Kreis Hanau, Hesse-Nassau. Emanuel Pfeifer was born at Niederhochstadt in the Bavarian Palatinate. The similarly named places are distinct, so this film cannot be used as his 1833 birth source."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_COCALICO_EMANUEL_PFEIFER_1781_WILL_REJECTED",
      "title": "Cocalico Valley Historical Society card file: Emanuel Pfeifer will",
      "type": "historical-society manuscript index; rejected namesake",
      "url": "https://www.cocalicovalleyhs.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Card-Files-P-to-PENNEY-search-edited.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page 155 indexes a copy of the will of Emanuel Pfeifer of Brecknock Township, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, who died in 1781. He died more than fifty years before the ancestor was born and is an unrelated namesake."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_USER_MYHERITAGE_SEBASTIAN_BLEYLE_1504_1568",
      "title": "User-supplied MyHeritage tree extract: Sebastian Bleyle, 1504-1568",
      "type": "compiled_online_tree_extract",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Extract supplied by Matthew on 25 July 2026. It reports Sebastian Bleyle born 1504, died 1568, wife unidentified, and daughter Agatha Beurlin born Bleyle. No tree owner, URL, locality, or underlying record was supplied. It repeats the existing Weigel-derived candidate and is not independent primary proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GRIFFITHS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_SAMUEL_SARAH",
      "title": "Griffith's Valuation index: Samuel and Sarah Boyd at Coolmain, County Monaghan",
      "type": "valuation_index",
      "url": "https://www.failteromhat.com/griffiths/monaghan/monaghan.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The searchable County Monaghan transcription lists Samuel Boyd and Sarah Boyd, not David Boyd, as Coolmain occupiers in the mid-nineteenth-century valuation. A valuation names occupiers rather than every resident, so this does not disprove David's presence, but it does mean the compiled Coolmain identification is not independently confirmed by Griffith's Valuation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_COOLMAIN_LANDED_ESTATES_LOCALITY",
      "title": "Landed Estates Database: Coolmain House, County Monaghan",
      "type": "academic_local_history_database",
      "url": "https://landedestates.ie/property/5288",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "University of Galway Landed Estates entry places Coolmain in Monaghan civil parish and Rackwallace DED and distinguishes the principal house and its Graham, Brooke, Goudy/Lewers, and Pollock occupants. It provides locality context but does not identify ancestor David Boyd."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MONAGHAN_1930_1935_BOYD_COOLMAIN_LATER_CLUSTER",
      "title": "Monaghan County Library index to Northern Standard death notices, 1930-1935",
      "type": "newspaper_index",
      "url": "https://monaghan.ie/library/wp-content/uploads/sites/14/2016/11/DeathNoticesandObituariesNorthernStandard1930-1935.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The county library index records later Coolmain residents Martha Boyd (1930) and Samuel Boyd (1931). This shows a continuing Boyd cluster at Coolmain but is many decades too late to identify the David Boyd named in Eliza's 1854 marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SECOND_MONAGHAN_PRESBYTERIAN_MIC1P146_COVERAGE",
      "title": "Historic Presbyterian register coverage: Second Monaghan, PRONI MIC.1P/146",
      "type": "archive_repository_guide",
      "url": "https://www.johngrenham.com/records/county_church_full.php?county=Monaghan&denomination=Presbyterian&search_type=full",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The repository guide reports that Second Monaghan Presbyterian baptism registers survive for 1802-1948 and are open for public research at PRONI under MIC.1P/146. John Gibson married at Second Monaghan in 1883 and was reportedly born in 1850, so this register—not the First Monaghan series beginning in 1860—is a viable place to seek his baptism and mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PRONI_GUIDE_SECOND_MONAGHAN_MIC1P146",
      "title": "PRONI Guide to Church Records",
      "type": "official_archive_guide",
      "url": "https://www.proni.gov.uk/files/proni/2026-01/PRONI%20Guide%20to%20Church%20Records.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official Public Record Office of Northern Ireland guide used to verify surviving Presbyterian register holdings and archival reference. The relevant Second Monaghan material is not exposed as a freely searchable register image in the sources inspected online."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_IRISH_GENEALOGY_ANDREW_GIBSON_DEATH_SEARCH_1864_1920",
      "title": "IrishGenealogy civil death index search: Andrew Gibson, 1864-1920",
      "type": "official_civil_index_negative_search",
      "url": "https://www.irishgenealogy.ie/search/?church-or-civil=civil&event-death=1&firstname=Andrew&lastname=Gibson&yearStart=1864&yearEnd=1920&per_page=100",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Search of the official all-Ireland civil death index returned numerous Andrew Gibson deaths but none in the Monaghan registration district. A separate surname-only Monaghan search likewise returned no Andrew. This is a negative result, not proof of death before 1864: death outside the district, migration, spelling variation, mistranscription, or an omitted registration remain possible."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ANDREW_GIBSON_1832_1887_ONTARIO_REJECTED",
      "title": "FamilySearch profile: Andrew Gibson, 1832-1887, Amherst Island, Ontario",
      "type": "compiled_profile_with_record_summary_rejected",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/MZZF-S8X/andrew-gibson-1832-1887",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This same-name man lived in Amherst Island Township, Ontario, in the 1861 Canadian census with wife Margaret and a growing Canadian family. The Aghnasedagh Andrew is independently recorded in County Monaghan in Griffith's Valuation published in 1861. The simultaneous, family-specific records make the Ontario man an implausible identity match; his proposed parents Robert Gibson and Mary McCormick must not be imported."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_REVISION_ACCESS_LIMIT_MONAGHAN",
      "title": "National Archives of Ireland research guide: Valuation Office records",
      "type": "official_archive_guide",
      "url": "https://nationalarchives.ie/help-with-research/research-guides/valuation-office-records/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The guide explains that post-primary revision or cancelled books for the Republic of Ireland remained with the Valuation Office, while selected pre-publication books are digitised. No freely available Aghnasedagh revision sequence was located. Those revisions remain a potential way to learn when Andrew's holding changed hands, but absence of online access is not genealogical evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CT_MARRIAGE_SOLOMON_DUBOWY_GITL_GOLDFIELD_1914",
      "title": "Connecticut marriage index: Solomon Dubowy and Gitl Goldfield, 22 October 1914",
      "type": "official state marriage index",
      "url": "https://connecticutgenealogy.org/solrsearch/?q=record_surnames%3Adubowy%20AND%20record_givennames%3Asolomon&rows=30&fl=*%2Cscore&wt=json",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Connecticut Genealogy Index, which presents Connecticut Department of Public Health index data, records groom Solomon Dubowy and bride Gitl Goldfield married at Hartford on 22 October 1914 (record CTMI-1-153684). The index supplies names, date, and town, but no age, birthplace, residence, prior marital status, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_WILLIS_NORTH_BRADLEY_CLUSTER_REVIEW_1652_1703",
      "title": "FreeREG indexed Willis cluster review: North Bradley St Nicholas, 1652-1703",
      "type": "targeted parish-index cluster review",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_queries/new",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A review of FreeREG's currently indexed Wiltshire Willis entries for 1650-1705 located these North Bradley records: Jeane, Sara, and Benjamin, children of Benjamin Willis, 1652-1658; John, Katharine, and Anne, children of William Willis, all baptized 30 December 1670; Jo, Simon, Mary, and Joseph, children of Simon Willis, 1671-1675; Benjamin, Joseph, Lazarus, and Abigail, children of William and Katherine Willis, all baptized 10 January 1678/79; and later children of Benjamin or John Willis. A separate FreeREG marriage-only search of Wiltshire Willis entries for 1645-1680 produced no North Bradley result. The North Bradley baptism entries are labelled Unspecified/Other Transcript and omit a mother for the 1670 group; absence from the index does not prove that no marriage or original-register information exists."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RAMBLING_ROOTS_HELTON_DELIA_TALLY_CONFLICT",
      "title": "Rambling Roots: unsubstantiated William B. Helton–Adelia Faddis Talley marriage claim",
      "type": "compiled genealogy with stated missing marriage record",
      "url": "https://www.ramblingroots.com/RYB-p/found-1850.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A Helton descendant compilation claims that William B. Helton married Adelia Faddis Talley on 10 September 1866 in Washington County, Virginia, but immediately labels the marriage source as “Record not found.” A separate Rambling Roots compilation transcribes the Washington County marriage register for that date as William Henderson, widower, marrying widow Delia Tally, and the 1870 census supports a Henderson–Delia blended household. The Helton claim is therefore retained only as a contradicted alternative, not as a relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MONAGHAN_MUSEUM_CHANGING_FARMING_HISTORY",
      "title": "Monaghan County Museum, “Changing Farming Methods in County Monaghan”",
      "type": "county museum historical publication",
      "url": "https://monaghan.ie/museum/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2016/11/2013Folklife72pagescorrected.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The county museum account describes post-Famine emigration and consolidation, the increasing owner-occupation of farms by 1900, improved access to markets, and early twentieth-century co-operative agricultural development."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CT_HUMANITIES_NEW_BRITAIN_HISTORY",
      "title": "Connecticut History / CTHumanities, “New Britain”",
      "type": "public-humanities local history",
      "url": "https://connecticuthistory.org/towns-page/new-britain/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The CTHumanities town history identifies New Britain as the Hardware City and reports that American Hardware Corporation was Connecticut’s largest employer by 1913, with 12,000 workers."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_BRADFORD_AVON_KINGSTON_HISTORY",
      "title": "Historic England, The Hall (Kingston House), Bradford-on-Avon: historic development",
      "type": "official historic-environment record",
      "url": "https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1001233/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The official listing records the early nineteenth-century depression of Bradford-on-Avon’s cloth industry, the 1848 sale of Kingston House and mill, and Stephen Moulton’s later conversion of the mills to rubber manufacture."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HNOC_NEW_ORLEANS_1852_PORT_HISTORY",
      "title": "The Historic New Orleans Collection / New Orleans Magazine, “1852: A View of New Orleans from the Lower Cotton Press”",
      "type": "historical article using Historic New Orleans Collection material",
      "url": "https://www.myneworleans.com/1852-a-view-of-new-orleans-from-the-lower-cotton-press/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The article describes New Orleans in the 1850s as one of North America’s busiest ports, reports population growth from 116,375 in 1850 to 168,675 in 1860, and says about 39 percent of residents were foreign-born by 1860."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NAI_VALUATION_OFFICE_RECORDS_GUIDE",
      "title": "National Archives of Ireland, “Valuation Office records”",
      "type": "official archives research guide",
      "url": "https://nationalarchives.ie/help-with-research/research-guides/valuation-office-records/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The National Archives explains that Griffith’s Valuation was a property-tax valuation published from 1847 to 1864 and identifies occupiers, lessors, property, and valuation. It is powerful evidence of a localized holding, but not a civil vital or kinship register."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_INGENHEIM_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_HISTORY",
      "title": "Jüdisches Leben in Ingenheim, community history",
      "type": "community historical database",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/14/startseite.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The project describes Ingenheim’s Jewish community as existing from the seventeenth century until 1940, with a cemetery established no later than the mid-seventeenth century. It also explains that the project documents people, houses, and the cemetery from local historical material."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EAST_ORANGE_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
      "title": "City of East Orange, “About East Orange”",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.eastorange-nj.gov/354/About-East-Orange",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The city’s history says East Orange was founded as a township in 1863 and incorporated as a city in 1909. It describes late nineteenth-century East Orange as an agriculturally rich area inhabited by oil tycoons and Newark industrialists. This is citywide context, not evidence of a particular family’s wealth or occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_BIRMINGHAM_WORKSHOP_ECONOMY",
      "title": "Historic England, Birmingham Jewellery Quarter Project",
      "type": "official historic-environment archive description",
      "url": "https://historicengland.org.uk/images-books/photos/series/RCH01/020/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Historic England describes the project as examining Birmingham’s nineteenth- and twentieth-century urban workshop economy and factory-system expansion in the jewellery and metal trades. It provides citywide industrial context only."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STIRNET_HALL_CARR_WILD_PEDIGREE",
      "title": "Stirnet, Hall Carr Wild pedigree",
      "type": "published online pedigree",
      "url": "https://www.stirnet.com/genie/data/british/ww/wylde2.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Hall Carr Wild pedigree identifies the Sheffield George Wild associated with Hannah Wild as a son of John Wild of Hall Carr, rather than a son of William Wilde of the Droitwich Wylde family. It is derivative evidence and needs original-record verification, but it supplies a specific competing family that fits the Sheffield context."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DROITWICH_ST_PETERS_WYLDE_MONUMENT_TRANSCRIPTION",
      "title": "Droitwich St Peter monument transcription for George Wylde and Frances Huddleston",
      "type": "memorial image and transcription",
      "url": "https://www.flickr.com/photos/52219527@N00/4577362391",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The supplied image/transcription describes the Droitwich monument of George Wylde and Frances Huddleston and lists their issue as John, George, Elizabeth, and Dorothy. It does not list a William. The memorial evidence strongly conflicts with, but cannot by itself absolutely exclude, every possible unrecorded child."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WESTMINSTER_ABBEY_GEORGE_WYLDE",
      "title": "Westminster Abbey: George Wylde commemoration",
      "type": "institutional biography",
      "url": "https://www.westminster-abbey.org/abbey-commemorations/commemorations/george-wylde",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Westminster Abbey identifies George Wylde, the lawyer and MP buried there, as the son of George Wylde and brother of John. It corroborates the documented Droitwich George Wylde family separately from the proposed Sheffield connection."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_COUNCIL_CHURCH_STRETTON_CONSERVATION_2013",
      "title": "Shropshire Council, Church Stretton Conservation Area Appraisal",
      "type": "local-government historical appraisal",
      "url": "https://shropshire.gov.uk/committee-services/Data/Decision%20Making%20Session%20by%20Portfolio%20Holder%20for%20Planning%2C%20Housing%20and%20Commissioning%20%28Central%29/20130918/Agenda/3A%20Appendix%20A%20Church%20Stretton%20Conservation%20A.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The appraisal places Church Stretton in the narrow valley between the Long Mynd and Stretton Hills and identifies Little Stretton as one of the parish's outlying settlements. It says the 1852 railway encouraged development as a resort and that 1898-1914 was the town's principal early-twentieth-century period of expansion. This is local setting, not evidence of a particular Rhead address, occupation, or experience of tourism."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HISTORIC_ENGLAND_TRENTHAM_HALL_HISTORY",
      "title": "Historic England, Trentham Hall and Gardens: official history",
      "type": "national heritage register",
      "url": "https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1190243/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Historic England records that the second Duke and Duchess of Sutherland commissioned Charles Barry in 1833 to remodel Trentham Hall on a palatial scale. The main work included the grand entrance built 1833–1842 and a later second phase. This is geographic and historical context only; it does not place the Waterhouse household on the estate or establish that any family member worked for it."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_PRINCE_GEORGES_CHRONOLOGY",
      "title": "Maryland State Archives, Prince George's County historical chronology",
      "type": "state archives chronology",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/msa/mdmanual/36loc/pg/chron/html/pgchron.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The chronology records that Prince George's County was created from Charles and Calvert counties in 1695 and that a courthouse opened at Charles Town in 1698. It supplies geographic and administrative context only, not evidence for any individual McNew birth, residence, or relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1833_USER_PDF",
      "title": "Original parish-register image: Richard Rhead baptism, Stoke St Milborough, 17 February 1833",
      "type": "original parish register image",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Image supplied by Matthew as 1833 Baptism Richard Rhead.pdf. Stoke St Milborough parish register, entry 425, 1833: Richard, baptized 17 February; parents Sampson and Sarah Rhead; abode Woodfarm; father's trade Grocer; ceremony performed by Geo Morgan. The entry does not state Sampson's middle name, Sarah's maiden name, or Richard's birth date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SHROPSHIRE_COUNCIL_WOOD_FARM_STOKE_ST_MILBOROUGH",
      "title": "Shropshire Council planning report: The Wood Farm, Stoke St Milborough",
      "type": "local government planning report",
      "url": "https://shropshire.gov.uk/committee-services/Data/South%20Planning%20Committee/20091006/Agenda/09%2001321%20FUL%20-%20The%20Wood%20Farm%20Wheathill%20Burwarton.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A Shropshire Council report places The Wood Farm in the parish of Stoke St Milborough, north of the B4364 and beyond Cleedownton. This modern planning evidence identifies a farm of that name in the parish; it does not prove that its name, boundary, tenancy, or ownership was unchanged in 1813 or 1833."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DEEPWATER_CEMETERY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_TRANSCRIPTION",
      "title": "Deepwater Cemetery transcription: John S. McNew and Sarah A. Willoughby",
      "type": "cemetery transcription",
      "url": "https://www.henry.mogenweb.org/Cemeteries/1041.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Henry County, Missouri Genealogy Web transcription: John S. McNew, died 1 Jan 1876, age 70 years 1 month 16 days, with marriage on 8 Nov 1839 in Pettis County, Missouri to Sarah A. Willoughby. The same transcription records Sarah A. Willoughby born 1812 in Kentucky and died 15 Oct 1862 in Henry County, Missouri. It also describes the graves as moved from McNew Cemetery in 1980. The page is a transcription, not the original marker image or marriage record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_S_MCNEW_1806_1876",
      "title": "Cook Family Ancestry: John S. McNew, 1806-1876",
      "type": "compiled genealogy with cited events",
      "url": "https://cookancestry.com/web/glenn%20cook%20master%20file/3/65032.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Cook genealogy identifies John S. McNew as born 15 Nov 1806 in Claiborne County, Tennessee; married Sarah Willoughby at Pettis County, Missouri on 8 Nov 1839; acquired land in Rives (later Henry) County on 17 Mar 1840; appeared in the 1850, 1860, and 1870 Henry County censuses; and died 1 Jan 1876. It gives Sarah Willoughby as born 10 Mar 1812 in Kentucky and died 15 Oct 1862 in Henry County. It is compiled evidence, not a substitute for the individual record images."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_JOHN_S",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew",
      "type": "public Gramps genealogy with cited records",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/8/3/e6cce7a875248ecb9fc72367338.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The page names John S. McNew, reports 15 Nov 1806 North Carolina and 1 Jan 1876, and cites 1840, 1850, 1860, and 1870 censuses, BLM land-patent records, McNew Cemetery transcriptions, Find a Grave, and the Missouri marriage collection. It proposes parents John McNew and Sarah Athey, siblings, wife Sarah Lusby, and eleven children. The page does not expose the original images in the supplied view, and its wife surname conflicts with the Deepwater and Cook reconstructions."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMPSON_HANDLEY_READ_BAPTISM_IMAGE_1800_USER_PDF",
      "title": "Original parish-register image: Sampson Handley Read baptism, 4 November 1800",
      "type": "original parish register image supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "User-supplied PDF reproduces the Trentham St Mary and All Saints register. It records Sampson Handley, son of Richard and Ruth Read, born 30 June 1799 and christened 4 November 1800. The entry is contemporaneous primary evidence for his name, parents, birth date, and baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMPSON_SARAH_RHEAD_1841_CENSUS_IMAGE_USER_JPG",
      "title": "Original 1841 census image: Sampson and Sarah Rhead household, Staffordshire",
      "type": "original census image supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "User-supplied census image, HO 107/985/987, page 8, shows the surname Rhead in the Sampson and Sarah household. It records Sampson, Sarah, and children Richard, Stephen, George, and Ruth. It supersedes an earlier supplied transcription that misread portions of the surname as Bird or Sampson. The image has no relationship-to-head column, so parent-child conclusions rest on the same-surname household grouping and ages."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NATHAN_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_1798_LUKE_PERRY",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew and Luke Perry",
      "type": "published compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/f/e/e6cce7a76edbac45cf8a5e8eef.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The published Nathan McNew genealogy reports Elizabeth \"Betty\" McNew, born 1798 in Washington County, Virginia, dying before 1847 at Elkhorn, Brown County, Illinois; it identifies her parents as John McNew and Sarah Athey and records her 27 July 1814 Claiborne County, Tennessee marriage to Luke Perry. Its only displayed underlying reference is \"Susan: My Twigs and Branches,\" so it is useful compiled evidence, not an inspected original record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_COOK_ANCESTRY_JOHN_MCNEW_SARAH_ATHEY_F14178",
      "title": "Cook Ancestry family group: John McNew, Sarah Athey, and Elizabeth \"Betsy\" McNew",
      "type": "published compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://gen.cookancestry.com/familygroup.php?familyID=F14178&tree=1",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Cook family group independently lists Elizabeth \"Betsy\" McNew as the daughter of John McNew and Sarah Athey, spouse of Luke Perry, married 27 July 1814, and dead about 1844 in Brown County, Illinois. It agrees on the broader sibling group but is a compiled online genealogy rather than an original marriage, probate, census, or cemetery image."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEALOGYTRAILS_PERRY_CEMETERY_ELISHA_1818_1889",
      "title": "Perry Cemetery transcription: Elisha Perry, 1818-1889",
      "type": "cemetery transcription",
      "url": "https://genealogytrails.com/ill/brown/perry_cemetery.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Brown County Perry Cemetery transcription lists Elisha Perry, born 29 Nov 1818 and died 12 Jul 1889, as husband of Sarah Perry and \"son of Luke Perry & Betty McNew.\" The transcription supplies a direct parent statement at second hand; no photograph of the stone or original cemetery register was reviewed in this pass."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_LUKE_PERRY_ELIZABETH_WHITE_CONFLICT",
      "title": "Ancestry public-tree conflict: Luke Perry and Elizabeth White",
      "type": "public compiled tree",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/luke-perry-24-1nc66",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A public Ancestry tree assigns Luke Perry, 1793-17 Jan 1883, an Elizabeth White spouse while repeating the same Brown County death setting and children including Elisha Perry. It provides no original record in the accessible view. This conflicts with the Betty McNew identification and is retained as a low-weight alternative, not a second proven wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ILSOS_BROWN_COUNTY_HISTORY_RECORDS",
      "title": "Illinois State Archives: Brown County administrative history and records",
      "type": "official archival locality guide",
      "url": "https://www.ilsos.gov/departments/archives/IRAD/brown.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Illinois State Archives says Brown County was established on 1 February 1839 from Schuyler County and identifies Elkhorn Township among its townships. It also notes that some county records were lost or damaged in a 1939 fire. The guide is context and record-location information, not evidence for a named Perry or McNew."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_TENNESSEE_ENCYCLOPEDIA_CLAIBORNE_HISTORY",
      "title": "Tennessee Encyclopedia: Claiborne County",
      "type": "published local history",
      "url": "https://tennesseeencyclopedia.net/entries/claiborne-county/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Tennessee Encyclopedia says Claiborne County was formed in 1801 from Grainger and Hawkins counties and describes its location around the Cumberland Gap and Powell Valley. This provides historical geography for the reported 1814 marriage, not proof that the marriage occurred."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RHEAD_1813_WILL_PAGE4_IMAGE_USER_PDF",
      "title": "Original will image: Richard Rhead, page 4, 1813",
      "type": "original probate image supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "User-supplied page 4 of Richard Rhead's 1813 will. It explicitly calls Mary his daughter; William, Richard, Thomas, and Sampson his sons; and Ruth and Elizabeth his daughters. Sampson is described as his youngest son. The will provides money legacies to the older children and makes the undivided Wood Farm share contingent on Sampson reaching age 21, with a remainder to Ruth and Elizabeth if he died under 21 without lawful issue. This is primary evidence that Richard had an older sibling generation before Sampson."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RICHARD_RHEAD_RUTH_HANDLEY_LICENSE_IMAGE_1793_USER_PDF",
      "title": "Original marriage-licence allegation: Richard Rhead and Ruth Handley, 7 January 1793",
      "type": "original marriage-licence image supplied by user",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Image supplied by Matthew as 1793 Marriage Licence Richard Rhead & Ruth Handley.pdf. The allegation identifies Richard Rhead of Trentham, Staffordshire, as a farmer, aged 21 or over, and a widower when seeking a licence to marry Ruth Handley. It was sworn 7 January 1793; the parish marriage took place 26 January 1793. This is direct evidence of Richard's stated marital status, residence, and occupation at the time of the licence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_KAISERSLAUTERN_JEWISH_COMMUNITY_19C",
      "title": "Alemannia Judaica: nineteenth-century Jewish community of Kaiserslautern",
      "type": "published local Jewish-community history with contemporary-source excerpts",
      "url": "https://www.alemannia-judaica.de/kaiserslautern_synagoge.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The history reports renewed Jewish settlement around 1800; 52 Jewish residents in 1823, 108 in 1834, and 214 in 1848; a district rabbinate from 1827/28; a Jewish elementary school from 1838; and prayer rooms recorded in 1824 and 1834. It supplies community context, not a named Neumond residence, synagogue membership, occupation, or individual role."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_TNA_BRITISH_ARMY_SOLDIERS_CHELSEA_GUIDE",
      "title": "The National Archives: British Army soldiers up to 1913",
      "type": "official archive research guide",
      "url": "https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/help-with-your-research/research-guides/british-army-soldiers-up-to-1913/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The National Archives explains that Royal Hospital Chelsea material includes registers of admissions to pensions arranged by regiment (WO 120) and records of soldiers discharged from 1787 to 1813 and awarded Chelsea out-pensions (WO 121). The guide gives the archival context for the supplied 1804 Chelsea-pension transcript; it does not add a new individual identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CANNON_14TH_FOOT_1803_DEFENCE_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Richard Cannon, Historical Record of the Fourteenth Regiment of Foot (1845): 1803-1804 service context",
      "type": "published historical regimental record",
      "url": "https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/54107/pg54107-images.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Cannon's 1845 regimental history records the 14th Foot's West Indies service, including Trinidad, its April 1803 return to England, and movement through Gosport, Winchester, Silver Hill Barracks, and Winchelsea during the French invasion scare. It also records the addition of a second battalion in 1804."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ST_GILES_PONTEFRACT_HISTORY_20260726",
      "title": "St Giles' Church, Pontefract: parish history",
      "type": "parish historical account",
      "url": "https://cofe-pontefract.co.uk/st-giles/about-us/history/our-history/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The church's historical account describes a church on Pontefract Market Place from at least the twelfth century and explains that St Giles became the parish church in 1789 after All Saints was destroyed in the Civil War sieges."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GODA_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY",
      "title": "Gemeinde Göda: Geschichte der Gemeinde Göda",
      "type": "Municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.goeda.de/seite/646471/geschichte-der-gemeinde-g%C3%B6da.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Göda municipal history: parish origins, agricultural setting, crafts, and trade."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NLW_KERRY_BLACK_HALL_ESTATE_RECORDS",
      "title": "National Library of Wales: Kerry (Powys) archival descriptions",
      "type": "National archival catalogue",
      "url": "https://archives.library.wales/index.php/kerry-wales-2",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Includes Black Hall Estate deeds relating to the parish and manor of Kerry, Montgomeryshire, 1587-1844."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HENRY_COUNTY_MO_HISTORY_1883",
      "title": "History of Henry County, Missouri (1883), chapter 1",
      "type": "Published county history transcription",
      "url": "https://www.henry.mogenweb.org/History/chap01.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Period county history describing early settlement, prairie landscape, and cultivated farms in Henry County, Missouri."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BANES_FRESHFORD_CONSERVATION_HISTORY_20260726",
      "title": "Bath and North East Somerset Council: Freshford and Sharpstone Conservation Area Appraisal",
      "type": "local-government conservation-area history",
      "url": "https://www.bathnes.gov.uk/sites/default/files/2020-01/freshford_and_sharpstone_ca.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Council appraisal places Freshford in the Avon valley and describes a settlement shaped by the cloth trade from the early seventeenth century into the late Victorian era, including Freshford Mill, Dunkirk Mill, and weavers' cottages."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LVA_GRAYSON_COUNTY_RECORDS_20260726",
      "title": "Library of Virginia: Grayson County microfilm and record guide",
      "type": "state-archive record guide",
      "url": "https://www.lva.virginia.gov/collections/ccmf/VA/VA105",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Library of Virginia identifies Grayson County as formed from Wythe County in 1792, with part of Patrick County added in 1810, and inventories its court, land, tax, marriage, and will records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOC_NEW_ORLEANS_CITYSCAPE_1900",
      "title": "Library of Congress: New Orleans, La. cityscape",
      "type": "historical photograph",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/2016802456/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Detroit Publishing Company photograph, dated 1900 by the Library of Congress. Rights advisory: no known restrictions on publication. The repository asset is the 1024-pixel JPEG for digital identifier det.4a10361, SHA-256 0A0F67AE4EB3B09D0C66EA38F2A848E64CA50C15B01EE5DEF03408DC74D373E8."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CT_HUMANITIES_NEW_BRITAIN_HISTORY_20260726",
      "title": "Connecticut History: New Britain",
      "type": "public-history article",
      "url": "https://connecticuthistory.org/towns-page/new-britain/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "CT Humanities describes New Britain's nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century industrial development, its “Hardware City” nickname, and American Hardware Corporation as Connecticut's largest employer by 1913."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEWARK_MUNICIPAL_HISTORY_20260726",
      "title": "City of Newark: City Biography",
      "type": "municipal history",
      "url": "https://www.newarknj.gov/462/City-Biography",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The City of Newark describes its long industrial history and explains that the Great Depression accelerated sustained economic decline in the 1930s, temporarily slowed by World War II industrial demand."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_KING_WILLIAM_COUNTY_FORMATION_1702",
      "title": "King William County, Virginia: About King William",
      "type": "county government history",
      "url": "https://www.kwc.gov/302/About-King-William",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The county government states that the General Assembly created King William County from King and Queen County; the act became effective 11 April 1702."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOC_SHREWSBURY_SQUARE_C1890",
      "title": "Library of Congress: The Square, Shrewsbury, England",
      "type": "historical photograph",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/2002708096/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Photochrom image, dated by the Library of Congress between about 1890 and 1900. Rights advisory: no known restrictions on publication. The repository asset is the 1024-pixel JPEG for digital identifier ppmsc.08835, SHA-256 037FA2C35A6EB1613CCB637D0144D9FD64C244BB94F82E8FA660502B7C50B4C6."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOC_NEW_BRITAIN_FRANKLIN_SQUARE_1905",
      "title": "Library of Congress: Franklin Square, New Britain, Connecticut",
      "type": "historical photograph",
      "url": "https://www.loc.gov/item/2025663545/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Postcard photograph dated 1905 by the Library of Congress. Rights advisory: no known restrictions on publication. The repository asset is the 1024-pixel JPEG for digital identifier pcrd.1a01909, SHA-256 BEE8A1297E1281B78A81981A325BA285D9333DE3D12F1F4E265F4FAD9191431F."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEDHAM_CARSINGTON_BAPTISM_1734",
      "title": "FreeREG: baptism of Edward Nedham, Carsington St Margaret, 21 February 1733/34",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/62aca630f493fdfb604ee76c/edward-nedham-baptism-derbyshire-carsington-1734-02-21",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcription names Samuel Nedham and Martha as parents of Edward Nedham, baptised at Carsington on 21 February 1733/34. It proves that child's parentage, but does not itself name the later Ashbourne grocer."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_ASHBOURNE_BAPTISM_1738",
      "title": "FreeREG: baptism of Edward Needham, Ashbourne St Oswald, 9 June 1738",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/682f51908655746c65f24a9d/edward-needham-baptism-derbyshire-ashbourne-1738-06-09",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcription names George Needham as father of Edward Needham, baptised at Ashbourne on 9 June 1738. It proves that child's parentage, but does not itself name the later Ashbourne grocer."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEEDHAM_ROBERT_CARSINGTON_WILL_1743_ABSTRACT",
      "title": "Needham one-name study: Robert Needham of Carsington will, proved 1743",
      "type": "published probate abstract",
      "url": "https://needham.one-name.net/UK%20Records/Wills/Wills_Derbyshire_Summary.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The published abstract reports that Robert Needham of Carsington calls Samuel Needham of Carsington his son and also names daughter Anne, wife of Edmond Hopkinson. The original or registered will remains desirable, but the stated wording is direct parent-child evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_MARY_WAGSTAFFE_MARRIAGE_1694",
      "title": "FreeREG: marriage of Robert Needham and Mary Wagstaffe, Ashbourne, 3 September 1694",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/682f56d08655746c65f3eaf3/robert-needham-mary-wagstaff-marriage-derbyshire-ashbourne-1694-09-03",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcript records the 3 September 1694 Ashbourne St Oswald marriage of Robert Needham of Brassington and Mary Wagstaffe of Hulland. It does not name the bride's father or age."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DFHS_CARSINGTON_SAMUEL_MARTHA_BURIALS",
      "title": "Derbyshire Family History Society: Carsington burials for the Samuel and Martha Nedham household",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.dfhs.org.uk/page/carsington-burials/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcription records burials of Mary, daughter of Samuel and Martha Nedham, in 1736; Elizabeth, their daughter, in 1742; and Martha, wife of Samuel Needham of Hopton, on 4 August 1747. These entries support a coherent Samuel-and-Martha household but do not identify its later adult children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGSTAFFE_BAPTISM_CANDIDATES_1668_1677",
      "title": "Ashbourne parish-register transcription: Mary Wagstaffe/Waggstaff, daughters of Thomas of Hulland, 1668 and 1677",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.wirksworth.org.uk/B48-C.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcription records Mary Wagstaff, daughter of Thomas of Hulland, on 29 November 1668, and Mary Waggstaff, daughter of Thomas of Hulland, on 7 November 1677; Joseph Waggstaff was also recorded on the latter date. These are direct records of two children of Thomas, but neither identifies the 1694 bride Mary Wagstaffe."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_COOKIE_CRUMBS_MICHAEL_LINDER_UNTRACED_ANCESTRY",
      "title": "Cookie Crumbs Ancestry: Michael Linder of Nenzenheim",
      "type": "cited genealogical reconstruction",
      "url": "https://www.gdcooke.org/ss/org2-o/p26374.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Michael Linder as born about 22 April 1598, dying at Nenzenheim on 9 April 1677, married there to Anna Fuchs in 1625, and states that his ancestry is unknown or not traced in that reconstruction. Its citation is Harold Linder, The Ancestors of Simon Lindner/Linder, The Linder Quarterly nos. 172–173 (2013), p. 3. The statement is not proof of unknown parentage, but it supplies no support for the imported Saanen parent assignment."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WUERTTEMBERG_DIENERBUCH_JOHANN_BERLIN_20260727",
      "title": "Eberhard Emil von Georgii-Georgenau (ed.), Furstlich wurttembergisch Dienerbuch vom IX. bis zum XIX. Jahrhundert (1877)",
      "type": "published archival compilation",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.53458/books.198",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The digitised 1877 service directory, compiled from Wurttemberg archival material, lists at Stuttgart: 1544-1568 Dr. Johann Berlin, von Plieningen, Dr. Plieninger genannt, under city physicians. It corroborates that the older physician who used Berlin/Beerlin was a distinct historical namesake. It contains no evidence connecting him to Hans Beerlin, reported born about 1527 and dead at Uberkingen in 1588. Its terminal office year is not adopted as a death date because the scholarly Physicians Letters database gives the older physician death as 1563."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NLF_AGATHA_BLEYLE_SCHEIBLE_1587_LEAD",
      "title": "NLF family database entry: Agatha Bleyle and Michael Scheible, 1587",
      "type": "uncited compiled family-database entry",
      "url": "https://ofb.genealogy.net/famreport.php?ID=I618310&lang=de&ofb=NLF",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A search-indexed NLF entry reports an Agatha Bleyle, born about 1530 at Hohenstadt and dead 14 Mar 1591 at Uberkingen, married Michael Scheible at Uberkingen on 25 May 1587. The entry gives no underlying record citation and the direct page was access-protected when checked. The NLF describes its family database as material compiled from individual researchers and not necessarily a locality-wide record reconstruction. This is therefore a chronology lead only, not evidence that Michael Scheible was related to Magister Johann Berlin or that the current Hans Beerlin connection is proven."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HASLAND_HALL_WAGSTAFFE_HISTORY_20260727",
      "title": "Hasland Hall Estate: Wagstaffe family history",
      "type": "published local estate history",
      "url": "https://www.chesterfieldcivicsociety.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/HASLAND-HALL-ESTATE.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The study traces the Hasland estate family through Richard Wagstaffe, Thomas of North Wingfield (died 1568), and Anthony Wagstaffe (born about 1563). It reports that Wagstaffe did not appear at the 1662-64 Derbyshire visitation or in Hasland's 1670 hearth tax. It does not mention Thomas Wagstaffe of Hulland or Mary Wagstaffe, wife of Robert Needham."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DERBY_ARCHIVE_SAMUEL_WAGSTAFFE_HULLAND_BOND_1742",
      "title": "Derbyshire Record Office: Samuel Wagstaffe of Hulland, bond, 2 September 1742",
      "type": "official archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/calmview/Record.aspx?src=CalmView.Catalog&id=D331%2F13%2F3",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Corrected 19 September 2026 from collection-tree link pointing at D331/13/11/1, a 1763 pleading. The retrieved collection tree explicitly lists D331/13/3: bond, Samuel Wagstaffe of Hulland and Charles Soresbie of Brailsford, both yeomen, £230, 2 September 1742. D331/13/4 includes a later transcript. Original bond not inspected; item-detail retrieval failed, but the title, date and direct item link were verified in the saved official tree. No relationship to Thomas or Mary is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEALOGIEONLINE_REIFF_HANSS_JERG_1536",
      "title": "Genealogie Online: Hanss Jerg Reiff, reported 1536 Unterhausen",
      "type": "unsourced public family tree",
      "url": "https://www.genealogieonline.nl/family-tree-morales-abeln/I262128733566.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The page, published by Vincent as the Family tree Morales Abeln, reports Hanss Jerg Reiff born 1536 at Unterhausen and lists children Bartlin, Johannes, Barbara, Jacob, Ursula, and Jerg Reiff. The page explicitly says the displayed data have no sources. It does not give Barbara a date, spouse, or a record linking her to Hans Fuchs."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ASHBOURNE_WAGGSTAFFE_ALLSOPP_MARRIAGE_1667",
      "title": "Ashbourne parish-register transcription: Thomas Waggstaffe and Alice Allsopp, 27 April 1667",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://derbyshiremarriagesandchristenings.yolasite.com/ashbourne---saint-oswald.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcription lists the marriage of Thomas Waggstaffe and Alce Allsopp at Ashbourne, St Oswald, on 27 April 1667. It is a transcription rather than an inspected register image. The spelling Waggstaffe is treated as the same local man recorded as Wagstaffe in the 1668 and 1677 Hulland child entries, but the transcript does not explicitly identify later children."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_TUEBINGEN_MATRIKEL_JOHANN_BERLIN_1569",
      "title": "Die Matrikeln der Universitat Tubingen 1477-1600, vol. 1 (1906), p. 496, entry 123",
      "type": "published edition of primary university matriculation",
      "url": "https://opendigi.ub.uni-tuebingen.de/opendigi/LXV223-1",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The digitised 1906 edition transcribes the 1569 University of Tubingen matriculation. On p. 496, entry 123 reads \"Johannes Berlin Goppingensis (19. Aug.).\" Its annotation records Baccalaureus at Hirsau on 15 Mar 1570, a stipend in Jan 1572, Magister on 17 Feb 1574, and service as deacon at Weinsberg in Oct 1575. The entry names no parent; it independently grounds Johann Berlin's recorded Goppingen affiliation and education/career, but does not prove the proposed Hans Beerlin and Agatha Bleyle parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALTWUERTTEMBERG_LAGERBUCH_1522_ERPFINGEN_GOBEL",
      "title": "Altwurttembergische Lagerbucher aus der osterreichischen Zeit 1520-1534, vol. II, Erpfingen entries",
      "type": "published edition of primary 1522 land register",
      "url": "https://www.kgl-bw.de/publikationen/altwuerttembergische-lagerbuecher-aus-der-oesterreichischen-zeit-1520-1534-6/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Paul Schwarz, ed., volume II (1959), is a scholarly edition of the 1520-1534 land registers. Herbert Weigel cites pages 711 ff. for the 1522 Erpfingen renewal and reports that Ludwig Gobel appears there as a Zinser, a person owing an annual rent. The publication establishes a named local resident or holder; it does not state any parent-child relationship to the later Hans Goebells."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DRO_GELL_NEW_CLOSE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_1713",
      "title": "Derbyshire Record Office: Gell deed naming Robert Needham as tenant of New Close, Carsington, 1713",
      "type": "official archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/calmview/Record.aspx?id=D258%2F28%2F7%2F7&src=CalmView.Catalog",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derbyshire Record Office catalogue entry D258/28/7/7, dated 1 September 1713. Its description names Robert Needham as tenant of New Close in Carsington. This establishes his local tenancy; it neither proves ownership nor connects that close to a fifteenth-century Needham holding."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFS_WILLS_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_CARSINGTON_1743",
      "title": "Staffordshire Name Indexes: Robert Needham, yeoman of Carsington, will recorded 19 April 1743",
      "type": "official probate index",
      "url": "https://www.staffsnameindexes.org.uk/default.aspx?RecordID=77809&Index=C&LastName=Needham&Place=Carsington&YearFrom=1730&YearTo=1750&Part=0&County=3&Gender=0&Occupation=",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service index identifies a surviving will for Robert Needham, yeoman of Carsington: recorded 19 April 1743 in the Lichfield Consistory Court, reference B/C/11. The index confirms the original record and its reference, but does not transcribe the will or name its beneficiaries."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFS_WILLS_EDWARD_NEEDHAM_CRONKSTONE_1747",
      "title": "Staffordshire Name Indexes: Edward Needham, yeoman of Cronkstone, Hartington, will recorded 6 October 1747",
      "type": "official probate index",
      "url": "https://www.staffsnameindexes.org.uk/default.aspx?RecordID=83960&Index=C&LastName=Needham&Place=Hartington&YearFrom=1735&YearTo=1750&Part=0&County=3&Gender=0&Occupation=",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service index identifies a surviving will for Edward Needham, yeoman of Cronkstone, Hartington: recorded 6 October 1747 in the Dean of Hartington court, reference P/C/11. The index does not name the executor or other beneficiaries; the full probate file is required for that wording."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DRO_MARGARET_NEDHAM_WORMHILL_CARSINGTON_1450",
      "title": "Derbyshire Record Office: Margaret, widow of Roger Nedham of Wormhill, receives seisin of land in Carsington, 1450",
      "type": "official archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/CalmView/Record.aspx?id=D258%2F3%2F8%2F22&src=CalmView.Catalog",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derbyshire Record Office catalogue entry D258/3/8/22 records a power of attorney dated 18 January 1450: Margaret, widow of Roger Nedham of Wormhill, authorizes Robert Litton to receive seisin from Ralf Gell of land in Carsington. The catalogue does not identify the land by field or messuage name, so it cannot be equated with New Close or used to establish descent to the eighteenth-century Carsington household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DRO_JOHN_NEEDHAM_CRONKSTONE_GRANGE_1648",
      "title": "Derbyshire Record Office: John Needham holds part of Cronkstone Grange, 1647/48",
      "type": "official archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/calmview/TreeBrowse.aspx?field=RefNo&key=D1235%2FZ%2F9&src=CalmView.Catalog",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "In the Edensor, Brereton and Callingwood papers, item D1235/Z/9/6b records a 7 March 1647/48 agreement for a 21-year lease of parts of Cronkstone Grange. John Needham and William Sleigh held one part; a 1685 letter also calls John Needham and William Sleigh to meet with their rent. This shows a Needham tenant at Cronkstone, but gives neither his parentage nor continuity to Edward Needham of Cronkstone in 1743."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFS_WILLS_RALPH_NEEDHAM_STADEN_1686",
      "title": "Staffordshire Name Indexes: Ralph Needham, yeoman of Staden, Bakewell, will and inventory recorded 13 April 1686",
      "type": "official probate index",
      "url": "https://www.staffsnameindexes.org.uk/default.aspx?RecordID=31851&Index=C&LastName=Needham&Place=Staden&YearFrom=1680&YearTo=1690&Part=0&County=3&Gender=0&Occupation=",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service index identifies the surviving will and inventory of Ralph Needham, yeoman of Staden, Bakewell: recorded 13 April 1686 in the Dean and Chapter of Lichfield court, reference P/C/11. A published abstract reports a youngest son Edward, but the index itself does not name heirs; the original file is needed to test whether that Edward later lived at Cronkstone."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DFHS_CARSINGTON_SAMUEL_NEEDHAM_BURIAL_1767",
      "title": "Derbyshire Family History Society: Carsington parish burial of Samuel Needham, 4 October 1767",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.dfhs.org.uk/page/carsington-burials/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Carsington burial transcription lists Samuel Needham on 4 October 1767 without an age, occupation, spouse, or other identifying qualifier. It is the best local match for Samuel of Carsington, but the identity is a correlated conclusion rather than wording that directly identifies him as Robert's son."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEEDHAMONS_CHELMORTON_SAMUEL_NEEDHAM_1769",
      "title": "Needham One-Name Study: Chelmorton/Flagg Samuel Needham reconstruction, including the 1769 burial",
      "type": "published parish-register reconstruction",
      "url": "https://needham.one-name.net/UK%20Records/Family/Family%20Chelmorton.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Chelmorton compilation places a Samuel Needham baptized 11 July 1708, son of Thomas and Mary, in the Flagg household; it records him as a miner marrying Temperance Hill at Chelmorton in 1761, a Timothy baptized to Samuel and Temperance at Flagg in 1769, and Samuel Needham buried at Flagg/Chelmorton on 21 May 1769. The underlying parish entries require image review for final proof, but this detailed, internally coherent local household is a substantially better fit for the 1769 burial than Samuel of Carsington."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1695",
      "title": "FreeREG: Carsington parish entry for an unnamed child of Robert and Mary Needham, 5 August 1695",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/62b9c11df493fd873224bb70/-needham-baptism-derbyshire-carsington-1695-08-05",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcription records an unnamed child of Robert and Mary Needham at Carsington St Margaret on 5 August 1695. The rector noted that the infant had not been baptised by any lawful minister known to him. The transcriber cautions that the original entry is unclear whether it is baptismal or burial material."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1697",
      "title": "FreeREG: Carsington parish entries for a dissenting child of Robert and Mary Needham, 25 January 1696/7",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/62b9c11df493fd873224bbaa/-needham-baptism-derbyshire-carsington-1697-01-25",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG transcribes an unnamed child of Robert and Mary Needham as \"Child of Dissenters\" on 25 January 1696/7, and separately indexes a burial entry of the same date. The transcriber cautions that the original is unclear whether it records a birth, baptism, or burial. It is household evidence only; no child profile is created."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_ROBERT_MARY_NEEDHAM_1702",
      "title": "FreeREG: Carsington parish birth entry for an unnamed child of Robert and Mary Needham, 4 January 1701/2",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/62b9c11ff493fd873224bc72/-needham-baptism-derbyshire-carsington-1702-01-04",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcription records an unnamed child born 4 January 1701/2 to Robert and Mary Needham at Carsington St Margaret. Robert is described as a farmer and a margin note says \"Apparent Dissenters\"; no baptism date is given. The entry does not name the child."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_CARSINGTON_MARY_WIFE_ROBERT_NEEDHAM_BURIAL_1705",
      "title": "FreeREG: burial of Mary, wife of Robert Needham, Carsington, 3 February 1704/5",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/62b9c2c5f493fd873224bfd7/mary-needham-burial-derbyshire-carsington-1705-02-03",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Carsington St Margaret burial transcription records Mary Needham, wife of Robert Needham, on 3 February 1704/5 and notes that her husband was a husbandman. It does not state her maiden name."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ARCHION_UNTERHAUSEN_MIXED_BOOK_1579_1618",
      "title": "Archion catalogue: Unterhausen mixed church book, 1579-1618, volume 1",
      "type": "official archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/baden-wuerttemberg/evangelisches-archiv-baden-und-wuerttemberg-wuerttemberg/dekanat-reutlingen/unterhausen/111744",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The catalogue specifies baptisms 1579-1597, a marriage register for 1597, then year-by-year baptisms, marriages, and burials 1598-1605, and baptisms for 1618. The digitized book requires a logged-in paid Archion access. This coverage means that it cannot itself verify a marriage said to have occurred at Unterhausen in 1590."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FMP_LICHFIELD_NEEDHAM_WAGSTAFFE_BOND_SEARCH_1694",
      "title": "Findmypast: Lichfield marriage-bond index searches for Robert Needham and Mary Wagstaffe, 1684-1704",
      "type": "negative indexed-record search",
      "url": "https://www.findmypast.co.uk/search/results?datasetname=Staffordshire%2C%20Diocese%20of%20Lichfield%20%26%20Coventry%20Marriage%20Allegations%20and%20Bonds&firstname=Robert&lastname=Needham&firstname_variants=true&lastname_variants=true&yearofmarriage=1694&yearofmarriage_offset=10",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "On 27 July 2026, the digitized Staffordshire, Diocese of Lichfield and Coventry Marriage Allegations and Bonds collection was queried separately for Robert Needham and Mary Wagstaffe, with first- and surname variants enabled and a 1684-1704 marriage-year range. Each query returned zero indexed records. The collection contains images and transcripts, but a zero result cannot prove that the 1694 Ashbourne marriage was by banns: a bond may not have survived, may be omitted from the index, or may have been issued in another jurisdiction."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEEDHAMONS_DERBYSHIRE_ORIGINS_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Needham One-Name Study: documented Derbyshire Needham locality clusters",
      "type": "published one-name study and archival-index guide",
      "url": "https://needham.one-name.net/Pages/Origins.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The study lists early documentary appearances for Needham households in numerous Derbyshire localities, including Wormhill (1410), High Needham (1611), Cronkstone (1625), Staden (1678), and many others. It is useful context for the density and distribution of the surname, but it does not assert a continuous line from any of those groups to Robert Needham of Carsington."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MSA_PRINCE_GEORGES_RENT_ROLL_SMALL_HOPES_EDWARD_MARLOW",
      "title": "Maryland State Archives: Prince George's County rent roll, Small Hopes, Edward Marlow",
      "type": "colonial rent roll (digital primary record)",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/stagserm/sm100/sm130/000000/000050/pdf/mdsa_sm130_50.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Maryland State Archives digital rent-roll file lists the tract Small Hopes, Edward Marlow, 141 acres, folio 91. The publication is in the Land Office rent-roll series labelled 1733-1769. The entry identifies an Edward Marlow as the recorded landholder but does not name a wife, children, parents, an exact entry date, or a distinguishing age."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTSMAGIC_EDWARD_MARLOW_1743_DEPOSITION_TRANSCRIPTION",
      "title": "Edward Marlow: cited transcription of 1743/44 Prince George's County deposition",
      "type": "secondary online transcription with record references",
      "url": "https://sites.rootsmagic.com/Worland/individual.php?p=263",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The online transcription quotes a 19 March 1743/44 land-boundary deposition in which Edward Marlow Sr., aged about 78, describes an earlier boundary explanation by Richard Conner. It supplies a useful identity and age clue, but the cited page is not the archival image and does not itself establish Edward's marriage, children, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DORSET_OPC_WINTERBORNE_WHITECHURCH_ROBERT_BUTT_GRACE_DENNES_1678",
      "title": "Dorset OPC: Winterborne Whitechurch parish-register transcription, Robert Butt and Grace Dennes, 1 August 1678",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.opcdorset.org/WinterborneFiles/W.Whitchurch/W.WhitechurchMarsPR1599-1753.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcription records Robert Butt and Grace Dennes marrying at Winterborne Whitechurch on 1 August 1678. It supplies neither age, residence, parents, nor a statement that this groom was the Robert baptized in 1616 at nearby Winterborne Houghton. The site advises consulting the original at Dorset History Centre. The event is nevertheless a concrete same-name adult in the immediately adjacent Winterborne parish cluster, and it occurred two years after the documented Virginia Robert Butt died in 1676."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WEIGEL_BERLIN_BEERLIN_HEILBRONN_BOUNDARY_20260727",
      "title": "Herbert Weigel, Ahnenliste Erhardt/Hilsenbeck: Berlin/Beerlin and Heilbronn Berlin/Bernhard entries",
      "type": "published parish-register-based pedigree and historical genealogy",
      "url": "https://genealogie-nordwuerttemberg.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/AL-ERHARDT-HILSENBECK-version-2.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page 251 gives Johann Berlin (Beerlin), born about 1550 at Goppingen, as a Magister and pastor; page 299 proposes Hans Beerlin of Stuttgart and Agatha Bleyle as his parents but labels the filiation unsecured. Pages 355-385 describe a separate medieval Heilbronn Berlin/Bernhard patrician line. The surname index on page 389 separately lists Berlin/Beerlin entries 2,577, 5,154, and 10,308 and Berlin/Bernhard entries 129,317 and earlier-numbered ancestors. The publication therefore does not connect Johann or Hans to the medieval Heilbronn family. Its separate treatment is not proof of non-kinship, but it is strong reason not to convert a surname resemblance into an ancestral bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARLOW_ENGLISH_PARENTAGE_REVIEW_20260728",
      "title": "Marlow English-parentage bridge review",
      "type": "comparative review of compiled online trees and accessible record summaries",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/KLZY-BLD/robert-marlow-1618-1679",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The reviewed online reconstructions disagree materially. The imported/Geneanet version proposes Robert Marlow, born about 1618, and Ann Hall, born 1622, of Manchester as parents of a William reported born 1636. A FamilySearch public cluster instead gives Robert and an Anne born about 1615 at Manchester, with William Augustus born 1630 at Ickenham, Middlesex and later in Maryland. The public Ancestors display is not a complete evidence inventory and is not used here as proof that records do not exist. It does not, however, expose a citation joining Robert and Anne to the Maryland William. No inspected passenger, patent/headright, probate, court, land, church, or family record bridges the English and Maryland clusters. The conflicting trees preserve a research lead, not a parent-child conclusion."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENI_PHELPS_FELPS_COMPILED_LINE_20260728",
      "title": "Geni compiled Phelps/Felps/Phylppes lineage supplied by the tree owner, 28 July 2026",
      "type": "compiled online tree",
      "url": "https://www.geni.com/people/Henry-Phylppes/6000000032240385817",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The tree owner supplied the profile sequence from this Geni profile and linked compiled profiles. It proposes John Phylppes (about 1335) through Henry, John, Francis, John, Richard, James, several Thomases, Aventon, Aquilla, John Felps, Samuel Felps, and Martin Vines Phelps. The material is a research lead, not independent proof of each parent-child link."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_TEWKESBURY_PHELPS_1520_1563_REVIEW",
      "title": "Tewkesbury Phelps household: James Phelps administration and children",
      "type": "published reconstruction citing parish and probate material",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person%3AJames_Phelps_%282%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The cited reconstruction reports the 10 May 1588 administration to Joan, widow of James Phelps of Tewkesbury, and reports Thomas, son of James, baptised there on 10 August 1563. It supports the James-to-Thomas household, not James's proposed earlier parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_FELPS_WILL_1758_TRANSCRIPTION",
      "title": "Thomas Felps will, Baltimore County, 2 April 1758",
      "type": "transcription of primary probate record",
      "url": "https://www.geocities.ws/graal1/docs/tpwill.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcription identifies Thomas Felps of Baltimore County, names his wife Rosannah, and bequeaths property to “Aventon Felps my beloved Son.” The Maryland will index independently confirms a 1758 Thomas Felps will, but the transcription remains a derivative access copy."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARYLAND_WILL_INDEX_THOMAS_FELPS_1758",
      "title": "Maryland colonial wills index: Thomas Felps, 1758",
      "type": "official probate index",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/stagser/s500/s539/000000/000001/pdf/mdsa_s539_1.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The official Maryland index lists a Thomas Felps will in 1758. The index confirms the record's existence but does not itself provide the will's family wording."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ST_GEORGE_AVENTON_RACHEL_MARRIAGE_1730",
      "title": "Aventon Felps and Rachel McElroy marriage, St George Parish, 23 April 1730",
      "type": "published parish-record research",
      "url": "https://phelpsresearch.blogspot.com/2007/04/thomas-phelps-of-rowan-co-nc-and-jasper.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published Phelps research reports the St George Parish marriage of Aventon Felps and Rachel McElroy on 23 April 1730. The original register image has not been inspected in this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHELPS_YDNA_ORIGIN_THEORIES_20260728",
      "title": "Southern Colonial Phelps Y-DNA research: theories on the origin of Thomas Felps",
      "type": "compiled surname and Y-DNA research",
      "url": "https://sites.google.com/site/archivedydnaphelpsgenealogies/06-three-phelps-felps-lines-with-relevant-ydna-matches/common-ancestor-of-david-b-1817-tn-and-ancestor-descendant-of-felps-of-baltimore-co-b-ca-1678/theories-on-the-origin-of-this-thomas-felps",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The project describes the origin of the Baltimore Thomas Felps as unresolved and discusses, rather than proves, Irish and Pennsylvania theories. It also documents the risk of conflating same-named Phelps/Felps men."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_COMPILED_PHELPS_PEDIGREE_VARIANTS_20260728",
      "title": "Compiled Phelps pedigree variants: Richard Phelps and reported wife Mary Tomes",
      "type": "compiled online pedigree comparison",
      "url": "https://www.mytrees.com/names/Died/1529/1/MARY%2BTOMES",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Several online pedigrees call Richard Phelps's wife Mary Tomes, but conflict materially on her dates and do not provide an inspected contemporary record. The repeated claim is retained as a low-confidence spouse hypothesis only; it does not validate Richard's proposed parentage of James."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LIMERICK_QUAKER_PHELPS_HOUSEHOLD_20260728",
      "title": "Limerick Quaker Thomas Phelps household and wives",
      "type": "published historical reconstruction quoting Quaker records",
      "url": "https://ourancestorsandtheirtimes.wordpress.com/limerick-and-quakerism-1650-to-1770/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The article quotes Limerick Quaker material for Thomas Phelps, who died in 1697 aged 74, and identifies first wife Susanna Fennell and later widow Anne Phelps. It reports surviving children from the first marriage, including Thomas born 1656. This supports the Limerick household itself, but does not identify the claimed 1644 Maryland-bound Thomas as a child."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_THOMAS_PHELPS_1669_PATENT",
      "title": "Archives of Maryland: Thomas Phelps listed for a 100-acre patent, 15 December 1669",
      "type": "official colonial government record",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000005/html/am5--59.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Maryland Council proceedings list Thomas Phelps among the holders of 100-acre patents. It does not give age, residence, spouse, or parentage. It creates a chronology/identity question for a person reported born in 1664, but cannot by itself distinguish a different older Thomas from an incorrect reported birth year."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BALTIMORE_FELPS_RECORD_EXTRACTS_20260728",
      "title": "Baltimore County Felps records: Thomas, Rose formerly Swift, and Aventon",
      "type": "published transcription of Baltimore County land and parish records",
      "url": "https://www.usgenwebsites.org/MDBaltimore/family/felpsresearchnotes.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcription reports a 17 April 1723 land-record entry made by Aventon at the request of his father Thomas Felps and Thomas's gift to Aventon Felps his son. It also transcribes 1738 vestry proceedings in which Thomas described his 28 May 1710 marriage to Rose Swift, who had previously been married to Swift. Original record images have not been inspected in this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ST_GEORGE_AVENTON_RACHEL_TRANSCRIPTION_20260728",
      "title": "St George Parish marriage transcription: Aventon Felps and Rachel McElroy, 23 April 1730",
      "type": "published parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.usgenwebsites.org/MDBaltimore/family/felpsresearchnotes.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Baltimore County Felps research notes transcribe a St George Parish marriage record dated 23 April 1730 for Aventon Felps and Rachel McElroy. Original register image has not been inspected in this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHELPS_1899_LIMERICK_TREE_20260729",
      "title": "Phelps Family of America (1899): Joseph Lloyd Phelps Limerick family tree",
      "type": "published 1899 compiled family tree and correspondence",
      "url": "https://archive.org/stream/phelpsfamilyofam01phel/phelpsfamilyofam01phel_djvu.txt",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The book credits Joseph Lloyd Phelps of Birmingham for a family tree asserting that Thomas Phelps, born 1623, was son of Thomas Phelps of Tewkesbury, baptised 24 Jun 1590, and brother of the 1630 emigrant William. A separate letter in the book says 24 Jan 1590, conflicting with the book's own register list on p. 71; the register-derived June date is preferred. The correspondence describes the Ireland migration as tradition and acknowledges an untraced proposed relationship to John Phelps. It provides positive, but still secondary and internally qualified, support for this route over the incompatible later Geni route through Thomas baptised 1563.\n\n15 September 2026 chain review: The prior preference for June is superseded by scanned-page comparison: the copied register text and summary disagree, and the original has not been checked. Keep Thomas's baptism date qualified. The Limerick pedigree also admits an unsuccessful search for the 1623 founder's birth/first marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHELPS_1899_WILLIAM_DOROTHY_20260729",
      "title": "Phelps Family of America (1899): William Phelps and Dorothy, Tewkesbury register copies",
      "type": "published 1899 parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://archive.org/stream/phelpsfamilyofam01phel/phelpsfamilyofam01phel_djvu.txt",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The book prints the William and Dorothy Tewkesbury household on pp. 70-71: William, son of James, baptised 4 Aug 1560; Thomas baptised 24 Jun 1590 among William and Dorothy's children; and Elizabeth baptised 9 May 1603. It says William died by the 28 Sep 1611 administration and Dorothy by the 31 May 1613 administration. The original register and probate files remain to be inspected. A separate Limerick-family letter in the same book calls the 1590 Thomas 'born on Jan. 24th'; the printed register list's 24 June date is preferred and the conflict is retained in notes.\n\n15 September 2026 chain review: The prior preference for June is superseded by scanned-page comparison: the copied register text and summary disagree, and the original has not been checked. Keep Thomas's baptism date qualified. The Limerick pedigree also admits an unsuccessful search for the 1623 founder's birth/first marriage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREECEN_JOHN_THOMAS_OLD_RADNOR_1871_20260729",
      "title": "1871 England and Wales Census: John Thomas, farm servant at Llanson Lower, Glascwm",
      "type": "census transcript",
      "url": "https://www.freecen.org.uk/search_records/67f6f90ab18f7c20288aa92c/john-thomas-1871-radnorshire-old-radnor-1853-",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeCEN transcription of RG10/2721A, page 6: John Thomas, unmarried farm servant, age 18, in Thomas Lloyd's Llanson Lower household at Glascwm, Radnorshire. The entry gives only Radnorshire, not a town, as birthplace. It is a possible but unbridged early-life candidate for the later Shrewsbury bootmaker; it names neither parents nor a link to Llanddewi Ystradenni."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_LAMB_KERRY_BAPTISM_1757",
      "title": "Kerry parish-register transcription: baptism of John Lamb, 20 March 1757",
      "type": "parish register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/686091ce865574369c17f029/john-lamb-baptism-montgomeryshire-kerry-1757-03-20",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Kerry St Michael and All Angels register transcription records John Lamb baptized on 20 March 1757, son of John Lamb and Ann. It gives no residence, occupation, age, or maiden name for either parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MONTGOMERY_QS_BERRIEW_KERRY_LAMB_1790",
      "title": "Montgomeryshire Quarter Sessions settlement order: John and Elizabeth Lamb, 17 May 1790",
      "type": "digitised county court record transcription",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/digitised-and-transcribed-records_Montgomeryshire-Quarter-Sessions_session-rolls_Mont_QS_1790-1799_bi.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The 17 May 1790 order removes John Lamb, wife Elizabeth, daughter Elizabeth aged four, and son John aged two from Berriew to their legal settlement in Kerry. It names a specific household but does not state the adults' ages, occupations, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_ELIZABETH_LAMB_BERRIEW_BURIAL_1812",
      "title": "Berriew parish-register transcription: burial of Elizabeth Lamb, 23 May 1812",
      "type": "parish register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6860893b865574369c145245/elizabeth-lamb-burial-montgomeryshire-berriew-1812-05-23",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Berriew St Beuno register transcription records an Elizabeth Lamb buried on 23 May 1812, age 67. It supplies no spouse, residence, or maiden surname, so it is a plausible but not conclusive match for Elizabeth Prichard Lamb."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_METZ_TD_1823_1832_BIRTH_MARRIAGE_INDEX_20260729",
      "title": "Archives municipales de Metz: tables décennales, births and marriages, 1823–1832",
      "type": "primary_register_index",
      "url": "https://archives.metz.fr/4DCGI/Web_RegistreArt1Exzxb173/ILUMP14505",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official alphabetical ten-year index for Metz civil births and marriages across 1823–1832. The COG entries were inspected directly; no Coguenhem entry appears. This is negative evidence against the precise reported 1827 Metz birth, not against every person named Michel Coguenhem or the reported family relationships."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HARGIS_ROOTSMAGIC_ELIZABETH_FREELOVE_1762",
      "title": "RootsMagic compiled profile: Elizabeth Freelove, 1746-1762",
      "type": "compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://sites.rootsmagic.com/woodvineandoaks2/individual.php?p=1653",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The compiled page gives Elizabeth a 1746 Virginia birth and 1762 Fairfax death, spouse John Draper Hargis IV (born 1742), and children Mary (1761–1839) and John (1762–1824). No supporting death record is displayed. If correct, the death excludes maternity of Amelia in 1765; an erroneous date or conflated profile remains a competing explanation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_COUNTISS_FAMILY_CHART_UNDATED_SCAN_2009",
      "title": "Countiss pedigree chart (undated; digital scan created 2009)",
      "type": "compiled_pedigree",
      "url": "https://static1.squarespace.com/static/59c69c542278e73c826f3226/t/5aad576f0e2e725448c46417/1521309551172/JLT011.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The chart places a Henry Countiss born 1777 among the children of William Countiss and Elizabeth Wrench in a Queen Anne's County family, but it supplies no citations and no migration bridge to the Henry Countiss household later found in Washington County, Virginia. It does not name Eda Cauntis. It is retained as an origin lead only."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MARYLAND_ARCHIVES_1783_QA_JAMES_COUNTISS_TAX",
      "title": "Maryland State Archives: 1783 Tax Assessment, Queen Anne's County - James Countiss",
      "type": "official_tax_index",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/msa/stagser/s1400/s1437/html/1437qa.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The State Archives index records James Countiss in the Tuckahoe District in 1783. It establishes a Countiss household in the claimed county but does not identify Henry, his parents, or a later Virginia migration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GOOCHLAND_NEWLAND_RANDOLPH_CORDWAINER_1736",
      "title": "Goochland County court agreement: John Newland, cordwainer and indentured servant to Isham Randolph, 16 Nov 1736",
      "type": "published transcription and citation of original court record",
      "url": "https://www.gdcooke.org/ss/org2-o/p26344.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The cited research reproduces the agreement and identifies its original location as Goochland County Deed Book 2, p. 259 (FHL microfilm 31653). The agreement was acknowledged in court on 16 Nov 1736. The original image has not yet been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCELROY_RACHEL_PARENTS_1713_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
      "title": "Baltimore County Felps research: Rachel McElroy baptism and McElroy deed network",
      "type": "published transcription of parish and land records",
      "url": "https://phelpsresearch.blogspot.com/2007/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ed Phelps research reproduced on the 2007 archive page explicitly reports Rachel, born 7 August 1713, daughter of John and Francis McElroy, plus the Rachel's Delight and John's Beginning transactions. The shorter MDGenWeb Felps notes overlap but omit the birth/parent statement; citation corrected 15 September 2026. These reproductions are not independent witnesses. Original register and deeds remain uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCELROY_COMPILED_PEDIGREE_CONFLICT_20260730",
      "title": "Compiled McElroy pedigree claims and internal conflicts",
      "type": "compiled online genealogy; not evidence of parentage",
      "url": "https://yourroots.com/tree/person/john-mcelroy-1690-1763--xkwbrxapsyjcv",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This derivative tree proposes John McElroy (about 1690-1763) as son of Archibald McElroy and Rachel Durham and as husband of Frances Durham. It supplies no cited parish, probate, deed, or migration record for those earlier relationships. Its related pages are internally inconsistent: one calls John's spouse Frances Durham, while another labels Rachel McElroy's mother Rachel Frances Durham; the compiled child list also contains duplications and incompatible dates. It is useful for recording a hypothesis and its limitations, not for establishing the proposed Durham or older McElroy generations."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SAMUEL_PHELP_RUSSELL_WILL_1846",
      "title": "Will of Samuel Phelps Sr., Russell County, Virginia, 14 September 1846",
      "type": "transcription of county probate record",
      "url": "https://usgenwebsites.org/vagenweb/russell/probate/samuelphelps.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A transcription of Russell County Will Book 6, page 46, gives Samuel Phelps Sr.'s will dated 14 September 1846 and proved in March and April 1847. He gave all property to his wife Susan for life, then the residue to daughter Sarah Phelps, and appointed Charles H. Gilmer executor. The text identifies this Samuel with the 1782 Samuel Felps-Susannah Vines couple through the wife's name, but it neither says that Sarah was his only child nor names Martin Vines Phelps. It is direct evidence for the will's stated beneficiaries and an important limit on the proposed Samuel-to-Martin relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BAS_RHIN_1808_GUNSTETT_NAME_INDEX_NEGATIVE_KIEFFER",
      "title": "1808 Bas-Rhin Jewish surname-declaration index: Gunstett comparison for the Kieffer hypothesis",
      "type": "published index to official 1808 Jewish surname declarations",
      "url": "https://people.math.carleton.ca/~rhfischl/GENEALOGY/ALSATIAN_JEWISH_DVD/1808_CHANGEMENT_NOMS/ARTICLES%2BETC/1808_noms-villes.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The index lists Kieffer declarations at Lembach and Strasbourg, but not Gunstett. At Gunstett it lists other adopted surnames, including Dreyfus, Goldstrauss, Kahn, Knorr, Vogel, Waldhorn, and Ziller; it does not list Kieffer. The index also has no Gunstett locality entry for Moïse/Moyses, Moser, or Michel. This is negative identity evidence only: a resident may have been recorded under a different surname, absent from the declaration, or inaccurately reported later. It is not proof that no Michel lived or died at Gunstett."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHELPS_FELPS_ROWAN_RECORDS_20260730",
      "title": "Phelps Family Research Team: transcribed Rowan County records for Aquilla/Aquilla Felps, 1759-1769",
      "type": "published reconstruction quoting county tax, court, petition, and land records",
      "url": "https://phelpsresearch.blogspot.com/2007/04/thomas-phelps-of-rowan-co-nc-and-jasper.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The research page transcribes Aquilla/Aquilla Felps in Rowan County taxable material in 1759 and 1761, Quilla and John Felps in 1765 bounty claims, Aquala and John Felps in the 1768 taxable list and Regulator petition, and a 1769 land description locating Aquilla near Aventon Felps. The underlying record images were not inspected in this review. The entries establish a real local adult but do not call Aquilla Aventon's son, identify Sarah Jones by a marriage record, or identify the 1766 John Felps as Aquilla's son."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHELPS_AQUILLA_GEORGIA_CONFLICT_20260730",
      "title": "Comparative Phelps analysis: the reported Georgia migration of Aquilla Felps is unverified",
      "type": "published comparative genealogy analysis",
      "url": "https://mcclain-roberts.com/simon-doering/images/William_Felps_d_1783_in_GA.htm.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "While analysing the distinct William Felps family, this paper says it found no record of Aquilla Felps going to Georgia and found him in Rowan County through the 1786-1790 period. This is a reasoned secondary conclusion rather than a complete searchable negative proof, but it conflicts with the separate published account that describes a 1771 Georgia move. Neither account identifies Aquilla's parents or the 1766 John Felps as his son."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ALEMANNIA_JUDAICA_OBERLUSTADT_1809_1810",
      "title": "Alemannia Judaica: Jewish community of Oberlustadt, 1809/10 household heads",
      "type": "published local-history transcription",
      "url": "https://www.alemannia-judaica.de/oberlustadt_synagoge.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The German-language community history lists Jewish household heads at Oberlustadt in 1809/10 and gives their trades. It names \"Salomon Frank (Metzger)\". The page is a published transcription/contextual account rather than an inspected original administrative page; it supports the adult identity and trade, not parentage or the imported vital dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTSCHAT_SAMUEL_ANN_MORRALL_LAWLEY_TRANSCRIPTION_20260730",
      "title": "RootsChat transcription: Samuel and Ann Morrall of Lawley, Wellington parish, 1806-1866",
      "type": "community transcription of parish and census records",
      "url": "https://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php?topic=886770.0",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A RootsChat discussion transcribes the 14 Apr 1806 Dawley Magna marriage of Samuel Morrall and Ann Green; the 3 Oct 1813 Wellington baptism of Richard and Adam, children of Samuel and Ann of Lawley, with Samuel a collier; later children; 1841 and 1851 census entries; and reported 1853/1866 burials. It is useful derivative evidence, but the register and census images were not inspected in this review. Spelling and every identity bridge therefore require confirmation against original records. The discussion reports baptism on the same day, which alone does not establish that the boys were twins."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_NEWLAND_UHLAND_MUNTZ_COMPILED_CANDIDATE_20260730",
      "title": "GenArchives Lang family tree: proposed parents of John Newland",
      "type": "derivative online family tree; parentage hypothesis only",
      "url": "https://www.genarchives.com/langfamily/g1/p667.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This tree names Matthäus Uhland (1690-1751) and Anna Catharina Müntz (born about 1680) as parents of John Newland, born 1710. It supplies no parish, probate, migration, or other parent-identifying citation. A YourRoots profile repeats the same pair and reported Dannstadt, Pfalz locality, but appears derivative and is not counted as independent corroboration. The proposal is retained as a low-confidence candidate because Johann Ulandt is the form in John's 1739 marriage record and the dates are chronologically possible; the 1734 Hope passenger analysis does not identify his European parents and raises a competing non-Palatine/English-origin possibility."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_LISTER_BATLEY_BAPTISM_1773",
      "title": "Batley parish-register index: baptism of Thomas Lister, 10 February 1773",
      "type": "parish-register index transcript supplied by Matthew",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The supplied England Select Births and Christenings transcript records Thomas Lister, born 9 December 1772 and baptised 10 February 1773 at Batley, Yorkshire, with mother Hannah Lister. No father is named in the supplied transcription."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_HANNAH_FAMILY_RECONSTRUCTION_20260730",
      "title": "Vivien Tomlinson, Batley Lister reconstruction based on All Saints microfiches",
      "type": "independent parish-register reconstruction",
      "url": "https://vivientomlinson.com/batley/p42.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The researcher transcribes All Saints, Batley microfiches and identifies Hannah Lister, baptised 1 January 1747/48, as mother of Robert (1770), Thomas (baptised 10 February 1773), and Sarah (1778). It reports that Thomas witnessed Sarah Lister's 1795 Batley marriage, and tentatively identifies a 1836 Batley burial. The page is a detailed secondary reconstruction rather than a viewed register image; its assertions are corroborative, not treated as a substitute for a record explicitly identifying the 1799 groom."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CGJ_ROSENWILLER_JECKEL_LEVY_1806_20260730",
      "title": "Cercle de Généalogie Juive: Rosenwiller cemetery-memory entry for Jeckel Levy, 1806",
      "type": "published cemetery-memory transcription, cited in a collaborative genealogy",
      "url": "https://gw.geneanet.org/appelmans3?lang=fr&n=levy&p=jacquesjeckel+jacob",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The cited Geneanet page attributes Jacques/Jeckel Levy's 23 February 1806 burial at Rosenwiller to the Cercle de Généalogie Juive, Livre de mémoire du cimetière de Rosenwiller, vol. 1, p. 343, section 3, row 16, stone 19. Its transcription calls the decedent “Jeckel fils de Macholé (Michaël)” and says a son, Mausche, declared the death. The page also cites an 8 November 1784 Ottrott enumeration for “Jacob Lévy + Bösel Macholen.” The underlying cemetery book and enumeration images were not separately viewed in this audit, so this is stronger published/transcribed evidence, not an inspected original image."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENAMI_MARMOUTIER_LEVY_FAMILIES_2004_20260730",
      "title": "GenAmi no. 29: Les familles Lévy de Marmoutier avant 1808",
      "type": "published archival family reconstruction",
      "url": "https://people.math.carleton.ca/~rhfischl/GENEALOGY/ALSATIAN_JEWISH_DVD/MARMOUTIER_%5BVILLE%5D/marmoutier_families_levy_avant_1808.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This ten-page article distinguishes two different eighteenth-century Marmoutier Macholé Levy lineages using testament and community material. It is negative comparative evidence here: neither documented Marmoutier family is equated with the Ottrott Jeckel/Jacques Levy household, so no cross-village parent link is inferred merely from the recurring Macholé name."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_PEYTON_TALLEY_TN_1797_DISAMBIGUATION_20260730",
      "title": "Ancestry compiled profile: Peyton Talley of Smith County, Tennessee, about 1797-1860",
      "type": "compiled online tree with linked record hints",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/peyton-talley-24-1366n72",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The publicly indexed profile identifies a Peyton Talley born about 1797 in Virginia, died 1860 in Smith County, Tennessee, married to Rachel Mullinax, and parent of eight named children. It does not name Holly Tally, Evan L. Talley, Grayson County, or Washington County, Virginia. The profile is not used as proof of its own stated parents; it is used only to prevent conflation with the otherwise unidentified Peyton proposed as Evan's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_WILLIAM_GEORGE_BAPTISMS_20260730",
      "title": "Vivien Tomlinson, Batley Lister reconstruction: William Lister and George Lister",
      "type": "independent parish-register reconstruction",
      "url": "https://vivientomlinson.com/batley/p62.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The compiler reports baptisms from All Saints, Batley microfiches: William Lister, son of John Lister and Jane Tingle, 25 June 1671; and the family of a William Lister with Maria (1701), George (1705), and William (1707). The linked George page reports his baptism on 30 June 1705 and names William as his father. The original register or microfiche image has not been inspected in this audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BATLEY_LISTER_JOHN_JANE_WILLIAM_1670_1676_20260730",
      "title": "Vivien Tomlinson, Batley Lister reconstruction: John Lister, Jane Tingle, and children",
      "type": "independent parish-register reconstruction",
      "url": "https://vivientomlinson.com/batley/p94.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The compiler reports that All Saints, Batley microfiches record the 18 May 1670 marriage of John Lister and Jane Tingle, and baptisms of their children William (25 June 1671), John (26 October 1673), and Joseph (15 February 1675/76). It also reports Jane’s 11 November 1638 baptism. The original register or microfiche images were not inspected in this audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BATLEY_ALVEREY_TINGLE_HEARTH_AND_CHILD_CLUSTER_20260730",
      "title": "Vivien Tomlinson, Batley reconstruction: Alverey Tingle hearth-tax entry and child group",
      "type": "independent local-history and parish reconstruction",
      "url": "https://vivientomlinson.com/batley/p149.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The compiler reports that Alverey Tingle was listed with two hearths at Batley in 1666 and identifies children John (1627), William (1629), and Jane (baptised 11 November 1638). The page does not expose the original hearth-tax or parish-register images, and the child links are not individually footnoted there."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1840_GRAYSON_VA_ALEXANDER_FADDIS_HOUSEHOLD",
      "title": "1840 United States Census: Alexander Faddis household, Western District, Grayson County, Virginia",
      "type": "published primary-record transcript",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/grayson-federal-census-1840-western/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The transcript lists Alexander Faddis as head of a Western District household. Its age columns record one male under five, one male fifteen to nineteen, one male seventy to seventy-nine, two females under five, two females five to nine, and one female forty to forty-nine. The schedule names only Alexander. The female forty to forty-nine and the children form a close chronological fit with Susan Faddis and the children in her 1850 household, but the census does not identify them by name or relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_YOURROOTS_NAGEL_DESVERICKY_COMPILED_20260730",
      "title": "YourRoots compiled tree: Hans Nagel and Catharina Desvericky",
      "type": "online compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://yourroots.com/tree/person/elizabeth-ii-1760-1829--ynyvjiylzelki",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The displayed ancestry calls Hannss Martin Nagel (born 1656) the child of Hans Nagel (1623-1693) and Catharina Desvericky (1625-1691). It supplies no image, archival citation, or explanation reconciling this with the different Hans Anthoni Nagel and Anna Catharina Hansen reconstruction."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ATHEY_THOMAS1717_PARENTAGE_RECONCILIATION_20260730",
      "title": "Lawrence F. Athy, Captain George Athy of Galway and Maryland and His Descendants, 3rd ed. (1999), as reproduced in Cook Ancestry",
      "type": "published compiled family reconstruction citing Athey research",
      "url": "https://gen.cookancestry.com/getperson.php?personID=I8032&tree=1",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The reproduced entry identifies Thomas Athy born 14 February 1717 as son of John Athy and Margaret Lewes; it names his wives Judith and Elinor Queen, their son John Queen Athy, Fairfax County court appearances in 1755 and 1758, and children registered at St John's Parish. The page attributes the reconstruction to the 1999 Lawrence F. Athy work and other compiled sources. It is detailed, internally chronological, and matches the existing descendant route, but the underlying parish, court, and probate images have not been inspected here."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ATHEY_1932_JOHN_INVENTORY_PARENTAGE_20260730",
      "title": "C. E. Athey, Genealogy of the Athey Family in America, 1642-1932: John Athey inventory and Thomas Athey will extracts",
      "type": "published family history quoting Prince George's County probate and parish material",
      "url": "https://www.seekingmyroots.com/members/files/G000098.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The searchable edition states that John Athey's Prince George's County inventory was filed 21 February 1729/30 and named his wife Margaret and sons Thomas and George; it also quotes the 4 June 1711 John Athey-Margaret Lewis parish marriage and refers to Thomas Athey's 1761 Prince George's County will. The original images and the quoted Genealogist Quarterly page have not been inspected in this audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ATHEY_1999_CAPT_GEORGE_JOHN_20260730",
      "title": "Lawrence F. Athy, Captain George Athy of Galway and Maryland and His Descendants, 3rd ed. (1999): Maryland records for Captain George Athy and John Athy",
      "type": "published family history with transcriptions and reproductions of Maryland records",
      "url": "https://www.cookancestry.com/History/images/StreamGate%20family%20records.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Pages 16, 20, 22-23, 26, and 54 trace George Athee/Athey in Maryland. The work states that Thomas Dent entered transport rights for George in 1663; George claimed land for service to Dent in 1668; George was appointed Captain of Foot in Prince George's County in 1696; and after his death Luke Gardner administered the estate, whose 21 December 1710 inventory was attested by widow Sarah and son John. It also explains why Ann Moorewood and Sarah Marsh are unsupported identifications. The original archive images have not been separately inspected in this audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ATHEY_FRANCIS_GALWAY_IDENTIFICATION_20260730",
      "title": "Francis Athy of Galway: specialised Athey history compared with Landed Families of Britain and Ireland",
      "type": "compiled family history with independent published local-history corroboration",
      "url": "https://www.cookancestry.com/History/Francis%20Athy.htm ; https://landedfamilies.blogspot.com/2016/09/229-athy-alias-lynch-athy-of-renville.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Athey history identifies Francis Athy of Galway, Sheriff in 1639/40, as father of Walter, George (born 1642), and John; it acknowledges that proposed Martyn identities are inferred from naming patterns. The independent Landed Families account confirms a Francis Athy served as Sheriff of Galway in 1639 and places the Athy family among Galway's merchant families. Neither source supplies a contemporary baptism, passenger list, or Maryland record explicitly naming Francis as Captain George's father."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LISTER_FAMILY_CHART_AVRIL_WOOD_1992_20260805",
      "title": "Avril J. Wood, annotated Lister family chart, March 1992",
      "type": "user-supplied handwritten family chart",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Handwritten chart preserved as H:\\FamilyTree\\ListerTree.HEIC and reviewed 5 August 2026. It records a researched family reconstruction, occupations, addresses, cemetery details, and family recollections. It is valuable independent secondary evidence but is not itself a contemporary civil or parish record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_EDDOWES_ATCHAM_LIGHTNING_1879_TRANSCRIPTION_20260805",
      "title": "Eddowes's Shrewsbury Journal, 23 July 1879: lightning strike at St Eata's Church, Atcham",
      "type": "online transcription of contemporary newspaper report",
      "url": "https://suetortoise.wordpress.com/tag/struck-by-lightning/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Public transcription of the contemporary newspaper account, copied from Salopian Shreds and Patches, volume 4, at Shropshire Archives. It confirms the 13 July 1879 church lightning strike and the named casualties, but does not name Jane Lister."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BNA_EDDOWES_SHREWSBURY_JOURNAL_CATALOG_20260805",
      "title": "British Newspaper Archive catalogue: Eddowes's Shrewsbury Journal",
      "type": "digitized newspaper archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://secure.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk/titles/eddowess-shrewsbury-journal",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalogue for the newspaper whose 23 July 1879 issue reported the Atcham lightning strike."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_3",
      "title": "Nathan McNew individual profile: Susannah Marlow (1678)",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/c/e/e6cce7a10ef14664aee1732ccec.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Individual event and relationship headings inspected in downloaded HTML. This verifies what the compilation claims, not the underlying historical events. Same-site pages are not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_7",
      "title": "Nathan McNew individual profile: Richard Queen (1725)",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/c/d/e6cce7bf92e1e60439666edd6dc.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Individual event and relationship headings inspected in downloaded HTML. This verifies what the compilation claims, not the underlying historical events. Same-site pages are not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_8",
      "title": "Nathan McNew individual profile: William Queen (1726)",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/e/e/e6cce7bfae19fda495052f61ee.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Individual event and relationship headings inspected in downloaded HTML. This verifies what the compilation claims, not the underlying historical events. Same-site pages are not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_10",
      "title": "Nathan McNew individual profile: Margaret Queen (March 29, 1814)",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/9/8/e6cce7bf7df4baf078c7d783f89.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Individual event and relationship headings inspected in downloaded HTML. This verifies what the compilation claims, not the underlying historical events. Same-site pages are not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_11",
      "title": "Nathan McNew individual profile: Elizabeth Queen (March 29, 1814)",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/2/3/e6cce7bf6a56fb85f0024917d32.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Individual event and relationship headings inspected in downloaded HTML. This verifies what the compilation claims, not the underlying historical events. Same-site pages are not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_12",
      "title": "Nathan McNew individual profile: Clementine Queen (September 1, 1826)",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/8/3/e6cce7bf58616d9150c39b30538.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Individual event and relationship headings inspected in downloaded HTML. This verifies what the compilation claims, not the underlying historical events. Same-site pages are not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_19",
      "title": "Nathan McNew individual profile: Anne Marlow (about 1681)",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/5/a/e6cce7a0dc64ee11308717b91a5.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Individual event and relationship headings inspected in downloaded HTML. This verifies what the compilation claims, not the underlying historical events. Same-site pages are not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_22",
      "title": "Nathan McNew individual profile: Sarah Queen (about 1741)",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/9/d/e6cce7bfa9546d541c58e17e2d9.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Individual event and relationship headings inspected in downloaded HTML. This verifies what the compilation claims, not the underlying historical events. Same-site pages are not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_MCNEW_PROFILE_REVIEW_20260915_23",
      "title": "Nathan McNew individual profile: Anne Queen (about 1792)",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/b/6/e6cce7bf50563b653ae9cb07a6b.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Individual event and relationship headings inspected in downloaded HTML. This verifies what the compilation claims, not the underlying historical events. Same-site pages are not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ATHY_ELINOR_PARENT_CONFLICT_20260915",
      "title": "Lawrence F. Athy family reconstruction, Thomas Athy entry, reproduced by Cook Ancestry",
      "type": "published_genealogy_reproduced",
      "url": "https://gen.cookancestry.com/getperson.php?personID=I8032&tree=1",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Entry /6/ calls Thomas's second wife Elinor Queen a daughter of Richard Queen, and lists their children. The linked StreamGate PDF could not be downloaded (403); inspected the indexed reproduced entry. It does not identify which Richard Queen. The mother must not be conflated with daughter Eleanor Lucille Athy born 1762."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHELPS_CREWKERNE_REASSESSMENT_20260915",
      "title": "Myrtle Stevens Hyde, English Origin of William Phelps, TAG 65 (1990), 161-166, reproduced with Great Migration summary",
      "type": "scholarly_article_reproduced_on_family_site",
      "url": "https://myfamilysearch.net/getperson.php?personID=I2054&tree=2005217a",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Inspected reproduction, not journal scan. Crewkerne baptism sequence and 1626 marriage distinguish the New England immigrant from the Tewkesbury man. Original Tewkesbury household relationships are separate questions. The hosting page inconsistently labels the volume 68 in one heading; surrounding citation and 1990 date identify TAG 65."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PHELPS_1899_SCAN_COMPARISON_20260915",
      "title": "Phelps and Servin (1899), printed pp.19-20 and 71-72: scanned-page comparison",
      "type": "published_register_transcription_scans",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/phelpsfamilyofam01phel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Visually inspected printed pages 19, 20, 71 and 72 via Internet Archive page images. The book distinguishes copied parchment and paper registers and reports discrepancies. This is inspection of the published book, not original parish registers. The independent modern rejection of its Windsor identification does not invalidate every transcribed English filiation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_1870_CENSUS_RELATIONSHIP_LIMIT_20260915",
      "title": "U.S. Census Bureau: relationship-to-householder question began in 1880",
      "type": "official_record_methodology",
      "url": "https://www.census.gov/acs/www/about/why-we-ask-each-question/relationship/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "This source documents the limits of the 1870 schedule; it is not independent evidence about the Schaaf family. Reviewed 15 September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_TRANSCRIPT_PROVENANCE_20260915_CROWTHER",
      "title": "Anne Crowther christening, Cefnllys, 17 July 1832: previously supplied transcript",
      "type": "previously_supplied_transcript_description",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The pre-existing person and edge notes describe a FamilySearch transcript naming father Walter Crowther and mother Jane. This source record preserves that existing provenance; no ARK, film/page citation, or original image was recovered in the September search. It is not a newly independently verified record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_TRANSCRIPT_PROVENANCE_20260915_GRINDLEY",
      "title": "Ann Grindley christening, Wrenbury, 5 April 1789: previously supplied transcript",
      "type": "previously_supplied_transcript_description",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Pre-existing notes describe a FamilySearch transcript naming Thos. Grindley and Margt. as parents. The transcript does not establish the mother's maiden surname Harding, nor by itself identify the child as a later wife or mother. No original image or stable record identifier was recovered in the September search."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CROWTHER_POWELL_1822_MARRIAGE_LEAD",
      "title": "Candidate Llandrindod marriage: Walter Griffiths Crowther and Jane Powell, 1822",
      "type": "parish_transcription_research_lead",
      "url": "https://www.tinstaafl.co.uk/eandwhmi/radnorshire/church%20pages/llandrindod.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed parish transcription, entry 24, reports Walter Griffiths Crowther of Cefnllys marrying Jane Powell, single, 20 February 1822 at Llandrindod Holy Trinity. Name pair, locality and timing make a useful candidate for Anne's parents. This is not an established identity bridge. Search-index text inspected; direct page retrieval failed certificate validation. Original register uninspected. No surname, marriage date or spouse edge is imposed on the existing people."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_HANDLEY_MILWICH_COMPILED_REVIEW_20260915",
      "title": "They Came, They Stayed: Milwich Handley household",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.theycametheystayed.com/p356.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 15 September 2026. Reports Ruth baptized 3 January 1759 and Sampson baptized 26 May 1730. It leaves the older Ruth's maiden surname unknown. Same family and dates support a lead, not independent original-record verification. Original registers uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_RUTH_HANDLEY_BAPTISM_PROVENANCE_20260915",
      "title": "Ruth Handley baptism naming Sampson and Ruth: existing transcript description",
      "type": "previously_supplied_transcript_description",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Existing database notes describe a baptism transcript naming Sampson and Ruth as parents. Exact original citation absent. This restores provenance without pretending a new image was inspected. It does not establish the mother's maiden name or by itself connect the baptized child to the 1793 Trentham bride."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CHAIN_PHELPS_BOOK_SCANS_20260915",
      "title": "Phelps and Servin (1899): scanned pp.21–24, pedigree and p.44 reviewed",
      "type": "published_genealogy_scans",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/phelpsfamilyofam01phel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF pages 29–35 and 60 inspected selectively: printed pp.22,24,44 and the split pedigree visually checked. Page 24 admits that the Tewkesbury curate could not locate the Irish founder's birth or first marriage. Page 44 attributes James's proposed father Richard to Charles H. Phelps's conjecture. The pedigree labels two Thomas sons O.S.P.; it does not identify a Maryland father of the 1664 candidate. Page 22 reports death on the 13th day of the 8th month 1697, with several Thomas namesakes noted. No original Quaker register was inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CHAIN_SAMUEL_SUSANNAH_DEED_INDEX_20260915",
      "title": "Washington County VA Deed Book 16 (1842–1844), published index: Samuel and Susannah Felps",
      "type": "published_deed_index",
      "url": "https://genealogyresources.org/Index-Wdb16.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Visually inspected PDF p.5. Index cites DB16 p.208, Samuel and Susannah Felps/Phelps of Russell County to John Scott of Russell County. Supports local association and supplies a deed lead. Full deed not inspected; the index does not name Martin or give Susannah's maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CHAIN_QUAKER_CALENDAR_20260915",
      "title": "Library of the Society of Friends: Quaker calendar research guide",
      "type": "institutional_methodology",
      "url": "https://www.quaker.org.uk/documents/quaker-calendar-lib-guide-2018",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Before 1752, numbered months generally start with March; eighth month normally means October. Preserve the source numbering when the original register has not been checked. Methodological source only; it does not independently verify any Phelps event."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GB26_IPGV_FRIEDRICH_PARENTAGE",
      "title": "IPGV card 57056: Johann Friedrich Gabel, parents and migration",
      "type": "institutional migration card citing parish books",
      "url": "https://migration.pfalzgeschichte.de/person/57056",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Accessed 15 September 2026. Names Hans-Jakob Gabel and Maria Margaretha Rheinmüller as parents; Offenbach am Glan origin, Lutheran wheelwright, ship Samuel, Philadelphia 27 August 1739, Old Goshenhoppen destination. Cites QAF-USA-Pa-Goshenhoppen-1, Pfr. Kuby (KB St. Julian), Ev.Luth KB Offenbach/Glan I/68. Card gives baptism 4 April 1701; Goble compilation instead gives birth 10 April and baptism 14 April. Preserve year without choosing day. Linked parent cards 57057/57058 provide no additional parents or independent sources. Original register images not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GB26_WEIGEL_IDENTITY_COMPARISON",
      "title": "Weigel pedigree: distinct Erpfingen Hans Jacob and Bleyle numbering discrepancy",
      "type": "published parish-based genealogical reconstruction",
      "url": "https://genealogie-nordwuerttemberg.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/AL-ERHARDT-HILSENBECK-version-2.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF downloaded and relevant rendered pages visually inspected 15 September 2026. Printed pp.55/85: Hans Jacob Göbel #322, 1689-1775, spouse Anna Maria Schweickhard; parents #644/645 Johannes Göbel and Ursula Batzer. Printed p.299: Agatha #10309 and unsecured Beerlin filiation. Printed p.331: Sebastian is actually printed ?21618; index p.390 gives Bleyle 10309,20618. Likely body numbering error, not two independent attestations. Earlier project notes incorrectly described uniformly exact father-slot numbering. Original church register images were not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GB26_GOBBLE_PENSION_SUMMARY",
      "title": "Evelyn Goble Steen: Christian Goble/Gobble/Gabel pension biography",
      "type": "secondary pension-file summary",
      "url": "https://goblegenealogy.com/bios/gobble.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Accessed 15 September 2026. Cites National Archives W.2931 and 17 August 1936 letter to Edgar A. Goble, plus named researchers. Corroborates Christian/Sarah Maryland-to-Virginia-to-Kentucky chronology and 1754 birth; not a newly inspected pension packet and not an exhaustive child list. Its omission of Elizabeth is not contrary evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS",
      "title": "Richard Sylvanus Williams, SVG Ranton (2024): Brassington and Silvester probate abstracts",
      "type": "researcher compilation with probate abstracts",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/svg-ranton",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded PDF and visually inspected pp.107/109 on 15 September 2026; family synthesis p.13 also read. John Brassington, yeoman of Ronton: will 30 March 1805, probate 3 July 1810; died 14 May 1810; wife Jane and children named. James Silvester of Lomcompton, Ranton: will 18 January 1769, probate 8 February 1776; names John Brassington as son-in-law. These are abstracts, not personally inspected original wills. Family synthesis and abstracts in this book are not independent sources. Its approximate 1731 birth for John lacks an exposed derivation and is not adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_JANE_SILVESTER_MARRIAGE_1761",
      "title": "St Mary Stafford marriage transcript: John Brassington and Jane Silvester, 10 January 1761",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6855185e8655747a97701320/john-brassington-jane-silvester-marriage-staffordshire-stafford-1761-01-10",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Live transcription rechecked 15 September 2026. Entry 186, by licence; groom John Brassington of Stafford, husbandman; bride Jane Silvester, spinster, parish RORTON, explicitly an uncertain reading. Witnesses William Till and J Beech; bride marked. This lead was recorded in local migration batch140 but absent from the current database. The record names no parent; the 1769 Silvester will abstract provides independent corroborating family context. Original register and licence not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_F26_FRICKE_DIRECTORY_1895",
      "title": "Orange directory 1895, page 116: Henry Fricke, milkman",
      "type": "contemporary directory",
      "url": "https://www.digifind-it.com/maplewood/data/city-directories/1895/1895_p1.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Henry Fricke, milkman, at 306 South Halsted, East Orange. Matching name, occupation and exact address strongly identify the known household between its 1892 directory and 1900 census appearances. Also lists Julius Fricke at 116 West; no kinship stated. Web-indexed text reviewed 15 September 2026; original page image not newly inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_F26_ESSEX_NATURALIZATION_INDEX_GUIDE",
      "title": "NJ Archives CESCP005, page 20: Essex County naturalization indexes",
      "type": "official archive finding aid",
      "url": "https://www.nj.gov/state/archives/guides/cescp005.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF page 20 rendered and visually checked 15 September 2026. Best petition index A-K 1830-1906: archive reel 1-14, GSU 1306267. Declaration best indexes 1849-1906: A-F, reel 1-11, GSU 1306258; F-Z, reel 1-12, GSU 1306259. A filing for Henry Fricke has not been located; this is a precise finding aid, not person-specific naturalization proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_GOBLE_GUISE_PARENTS",
      "title": "Goble Family Association: Peter Guise and Ottilia, proposed parents of Sarah Gise",
      "type": "compiled family-association genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.goblegenealogy.com/data/German/grpf0571.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2012 family page cites contributor Betty K. Price for parent couple and Sarah. Peter death November 1782 Rockingham; Ottilia death in Lincoln County Georgia, undated. Their ancestors are blank. Captured HTML. This is an explicit family claim, not a primary parent record; paired family page grpf0070 is not independent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_GUICE_W4686",
      "title": "John Guice pension W4686, transcription by C. Leon Harris",
      "type": "transcription of federal pension statements",
      "url": "https://revwarapps.org/w4686.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "1832 declaration: born New Jersey, moved with father to Frederick County Maryland and then Rockingham Virginia after first service; later Lincoln County Georgia. Names brothers Philip and Peter. Does not name father or mother or identify Sarah Gise as sister. Supports migration context only for the proposed Sarah-parent link. PDF and extracted text retained."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_BROAD_GANTRELL_1591",
      "title": "Antony Broad research report, 29 July 2003: Winterborne Stickland Gantrell entries",
      "type": "published research report quoting parish registers; search-index text inspected",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/MySource%3ASrblac/Antony_Broad_Research_Report",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Search-index text inspected 15 September 2026; direct page retrieval failed (403/cache miss). Under Winterborne Stickland Baptism, Marriages, & Burials (1558–1730), it transcribes Susan daughter of Richard Gantrell and Aves his wife, 18 August 1585, and Richard Gantrell buried 15 December 1591. Burial is not an exact death date. Original register image not inspected; this is the underlying report for the existing WeRelate reconstruction, not independent corroboration. Same-name burial identity is inferred from parish and chronology; no competing Richard identified in this limited search. Parish provenance check: the OPC holdings guides list Stickland PE-WSD registers from 1615–16 (https://www.opcdorset.org/WinterborneFiles/W.Stickland/WinterborneStickland.htm), versus Houghton PE-WHO from 1558–59. Broad’s indexed heading calls the early section Stickland. A mislabeled Houghton section is a leading explanation; an earlier transcript not in the guide is an alternative. The exact register/parish remains unresolved; this discrepancy does not erase the explicit parent names."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_ROBERT_BUTT_1647_BROAD",
      "title": "Antony Broad parish transcription: Robert Butt son of Symon, baptized 12 April 1647",
      "type": "research report transcribing parish registers; indexed text inspected",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/MySource%3ASrblac/Antony_Broad_Research_Report",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed report section Winterborne Stickland Baptisms 1645–1665 records Robert Butt, son of Symon, baptized 12 April 1647. Original image not inspected. This is a documented younger same-name candidate for later Dorset records, not proof of his identity with the 1678 groom. The report is the same underlying source as earlier Butt-Gantrell entries; it is not independent corroboration of those entries."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_MCELROY_WILL_BOOK_IMAGES",
      "title": "Arch Mackleroy will, Johnston County will book, pages 751–752",
      "type": "images of handwritten recorded will; not original executed sheet",
      "url": "https://georgiapioneers.com/backend/public/NC/probate/johnston/archmackelroy.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Both images inspected 16 September 2026. Execution date 9 December 1760; endorsement reads December Court 1761. Explicit brother William and wife Catherine; daughter Catherine rather than Salley in earlier typescript. Gunsmith designation in typescript not present in the inspected book opening. Differences require comparison to original executed will; do not silently harmonize."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_MCELROY_PATRICK_COMPILED",
      "title": "Nash family pedigree: Patrick MacElroy proposed father of John",
      "type": "personal compiled pedigree; university hosting does not imply scholarly validation",
      "url": "https://www.bauer.uh.edu/parks/genealogy/nash_tree.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Names Patrick MacElroy (1660–unknown), Irish immigrant, above John (1690–1763), with Rachel surname unstated. No parent-identifying primary citation inspected. Alternative name claim to Archibald, not proof of a different historical person. Keep separate from compound Archibald Patrick used elsewhere."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_PETER_GUISE_PROBATE_1782",
      "title": "Peter Guise will proved, Rockingham County, 25 November 1782",
      "type": "digitized contemporary manuscript court minutes",
      "url": "https://www.rockinghamcountyva.gov/DocumentCenter/View/16334/Coming-Soon---Minute-Book--1-1778-1792",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Minute Book1, manuscriptp232, PDFpage236 of1052. Image directly inspected at high resolution16September2026. Peter Guise will proved; John Guise executor; two witnesses and four prospective appraisers recorded. This is probate order, NOT text of the will, not exact death date, and not statement John was son. At a Court held for Rockingham County on the 25th Novr 1782 [heading]. The Last Will and Testament of Peter Guise was produced in Court and proved by Charles Rush and Geo: Shaver two of the subscribing Witnesses and Ordered to be Recorded. Whereupon John Guise the Executor therein Named having Complyed with the Law Certificate is granted him for obtaining Probate in due form. Ord[ered] that Charles Rush, James Bruster, John Newton and William Young or any three of them being first Sworn do Appraise the said Estate. [Transcription expands some abbreviations; Rush/Bruster surname readings provisional.]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_CHALKLEY_1757",
      "title": "Bryan McDonald will abstract, 21 May / 18 August 1757",
      "type": "published abstract of original probate record",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/bub_gb_wk8PAAAAYAAJ/page/n49/mode/2up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lyman Chalkley, Chronicles of the Scotch-Irish Settlement in Virginia, vol. III, printed p45 / PDF p50, citing Augusta Will Book 2 p197. Image directly inspected. Will dated 21 May 1757, proved 18 August 1757. Names wife Catherine; daughters Rebecca Bean, Catherine Armstrong, Mary Smith and Prisla; sons Richard, James, Edward, Joseph, Bryan; son-in-law John Armstrong executor with wife Catherine. Does not name Mary’s husband or establish Catherine as biological mother. Exact death date not stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_MCDONNEL_CALENDAR_1707",
      "title": "Bryan McDonnel, New Castle will calendar, 1707",
      "type": "published calendar of original wills",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/acalendardelawa00commgoog/page/n19/mode/2up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A Calendar of Delaware Wills, printed p13 / PDF p20, B:153. Image directly inspected. Dates printed 23 February 1707 and 19 March 1707; retain published year pending calendar-style check against original. Wife Mary; sons William, Bryan, eldest John, James, Richard; daughters Mary Dangor and Anable. Executors wife Mary and sons William and Bryan. Names no immigrant parents, birthplace or wife’s maiden name."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_MCDONALD_FRANK_1879",
      "title": "Frank V. McDonald, Contributions to the early history of Bryan McDonald and family (1879)",
      "type": "family history with identified deed and probate transcriptions",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/contributionstoe00mcdo",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed p36 / PDF p77 visually inspected: New Castle Deed Book Q p221, 14 February 1746/47, Bryan McDonald junior and Catherine his wife sell 80 acres to Andrew Justis for £150; recital identifies Bryan senior as junior’s father and quotes his 23 February 1707 will devising dwelling plantation after wife Mary’s death. Publication then follows junior to Virginia. P26 / PDF p57 directly inspected: author questions Glencoe descent tradition, specifically arrival by 1689 preceding 1692 massacre. His broad claim about Bryan not being a Scottish name and polemical judgments are not adopted. Printed grant date and modern blog reconstruction differ; original patent/deed still needed. This is a record transcription, not an inspected original manuscript."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_SMYTH_MCDONALD_HISTORY",
      "title": "Early Southwest Virginia Families, Smyth chapters, Bristol Library family file",
      "type": "scanned family-history extract in library collection",
      "url": "https://bristol-library.org/wp-content/uploads/FF-Smith-Small.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF pp51–52 (duplicated at pp63–64), printed pp39–41, visually inspected. Names Tobias Smyth’s wife Mary McDonald as daughter of Bryan McDonald and Catherine Robinson; gives same-locality 1753 road and 1754–1760 land references. Printed p41 gives Mary birth 19 January 1730, children Jonas, George, John, Edward, Mary, Catherine and Rebecca. Does not establish that listed Catherine is specifically Nancy Catherine Smith, wife of McNew. Reports Tobias died circa 1760–70 and widow married Scott; conflicts with some compiled 1781 dates and remains a separate test. No automatic adoption of Aracus/Aric Swedish-priest lore."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_WEIGELE_GABEL_MARRIAGE_TRANSCRIPTION",
      "title": "WeRelate Fridrich Gabel: transcription attributed to Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran marriage records, 10 May 1757",
      "type": "record_transcription_in_compiled_profile",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person:Fridrich_Gabel_(1)",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Accessed 16 September 2026. Reports Fridrich Gabel, son of Fridrich (Lutheran), marrying Elisab. Weigele, daughter of Georg (Reformed), 10 May 1757 at Old Goshenhoppen Church. This is a record-specific quotation on a compiled profile, not an inspected register image or inspected Hinke manuscript. Page references Gobble Family Genealogy p.52 and Washington County birth/death abstracts, without a precise page for this church entry. Independence from the association pedigree is not established."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_GOSHENHOPPEN_HINKE_ARCHIVE",
      "title": "E&R Library and Archives: Old Goshenhoppen Union Church collection and related Hinke Lutheran transcription",
      "type": "archival_catalog",
      "url": "https://archivesspace.erlibrary-archives.org/repositories/2/resources/2572",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Accessed 16 September 2026. Related materials list Hinke transcription of Old Goshenhoppen Lutheran records 1751-1828: MKZZ1 MO L6, microfilm 70, or Church RG-L 053. Establishes an archival verification route; catalog does not verify the individual 1757 entry. Distinguish Lutheran records from Reformed series beginning 1764. A separate WeRelate source catalog gives FHL films 20355 item 1 and 940444 item 4; these images were not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_DYE_WEIGEL_OLDER_CANDIDATES",
      "title": "Michael A. Dye, Russell County pedigree chart 28: proposed older Weigel and Ditlich families",
      "type": "uncited_compiled_pedigree",
      "url": "https://usgenwebsites.org/vagenweb/russell/pedcharts/madye28.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Accessed 16 September 2026. Proposes Johann George Weigel born 9 November 1714, son of Johann Michael Weigel and Anna Maria Harttmannin, married 26 July 1710 in New York; Anna Margaret Ditlich about 1719, daughter of Abraham Ditlich. No underlying record citations shown. Its placement of Elizabeth birth in Washington County Virginia in 1737 conflicts with Pennsylvania placement elsewhere and is unreliable. Exact older dates are testable leads, not independently verified events."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_WAGELIN_HARTMAN_1710",
      "title": "Christian Krahmer, Kocherthal marriage translation: Johann Michael Wägelin and Anna Maria, widow Hartman, 26 July 1710",
      "type": "published_register_translation_image_inspected",
      "url": "https://nyheritage.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/api/collection/p16694coll242/id/2179/download",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Olde Ulster III, November 1907, printed p.349, entry 6; PDF page 32. Scanned printed page inspected 16 September 2026. Groom of Bohnfeld in Creichgau; bride widow of late Conrad Hartman. Her maiden name is not given. Establishes this marriage, not parentage of George Weigel. Translation of historical register, not the original manuscript. Transcribed also at https://www.tha.de/~harsch/germanica/Chronologie/18Jh/Kocherthal/koc_ki03.html#10 ."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_WAGELIN_WILHELM_1715",
      "title": "Christian Krahmer, Kocherthal baptism translation: Johann Wilhelm Wägelin, born 31 January 1715, baptized 3 April",
      "type": "published_register_translation_image_inspected",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/oldeulsterhistor1907king/page/n274/mode/2up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Olde Ulster III (1907), printed p.223, entry 260; Internet Archive full-volume PDF page 275 (duplicated later at PDF355). Printed page image inspected 16 September 2026; 1715 heading appears on printed p.221. Parents Johann Michel and Anna Maria Wägelin; sponsor Johann Georg Brigel. Birth explicitly Jan.31, baptism Apr.3. Modern transcript at https://www.tha.de/~harsch/germanica/Chronologie/18Jh/Kocherthal/koc_ki01.html#15 . New York family existence supported; no George parentage stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_GEORGE",
      "title": "IPGV migration database: Georg Weigele and parents, cards 39707 and 169972",
      "type": "institutional_genealogy_database",
      "url": "https://migration.pfalzgeschichte.de/person/39707",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 16 September 2026 via public HTML. Georg born 1714, parents Joh. Michael and Anna Maria, autumn 1736 marriage Anna Marg. Ditloh, four children including Elisabeth. Source QAL-USA-Pa-Goshenhoppen 1, card issued 1966. Father card https://migration.pfalzgeschichte.de/person/169972 attaches Harle arrival 1 September 1736 aged 44 and uncertain birth 1692. This conflicts with identification as the 1710 New York groom; arrival not adopted. Institute states QAL collection lost in 2019 fire; this does not establish loss of original Pennsylvania church manuscript. No card image displayed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_IPGV_WEIGELE_ELISABETH",
      "title": "IPGV migration database: Elisabeth Weigele, parents and 1757 Gabel marriage",
      "type": "institutional_genealogy_database",
      "url": "https://migration.pfalzgeschichte.de/person/169976",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 16 September 2026. Parents Georg Weigele and Anna Marg. Ditloh; husband Friedrich Gabel, marriage 10 May 1757 Old Goshenhoppen. Siblings Anna Maria, Abraham, Henrich. QAL-USA-Pa-Goshenhoppen 1, card issued 1966. Exact marriage matches previously located transcription. Same institutional source group, not independent confirmations for each linked card."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_IPGV_DITLOH_FAMILY",
      "title": "IPGV migration database: Anna Marg. Ditloh and parents Abraham and Anna Margareth",
      "type": "institutional_genealogy_database",
      "url": "https://migration.pfalzgeschichte.de/person/39706",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 16 September 2026. Anna Marg. born 1719, Reformed; parents Abraham Ditloh and Anna Margareth; spouse Georg Weigele autumn 1736; daughter Elisabeth. Father https://migration.pfalzgeschichte.de/person/39704 places family at Gross Schwam, Reformed, second daughter Anna Catharina. QAL-USA-Pa-Goshenhoppen 1, card issued 1966. Mother surname shown as married Ditloh, not evidence of birth surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED",
      "title": "WikiTree public profile reproducing Henry Z. Jones research on Michael Wegele and Goshenhoppen elders manuscript",
      "type": "published_research_reproduced_in_compiled_profile",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/W%C3%A4gelin-6",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read via public WikiTree API 16 September 2026, snapshot preserved. Attributes to Jones, Palatine Families of New York (1985), II pp.1069-1070, an elders manuscript supplied by Annette Burgert: George aged 37, born 1714, parents Johann Michael and deceased Anna Maria, both Mennonites; autumn 1736 marriage Anna Margaretha Ditloh, born 1719, Reformed, daughter Abraham and deceased Anna Margareth. Reports George baptism 3 April 1715, born 9 November 1714, sponsor Johann Georg Brigel. This conflicts with Krahmer name Johann Wilhelm and January birth for the same date/sponsor/parents, so a variant reading of one event is plausible. Jones book and manuscript not directly inspected; no independence from IPGV source assumed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_SALFORD_LANDHOLDERS_1734",
      "title": "Landholders of Philadelphia County, 1734: Salford, Hance Michael Wagly and Abraham Titloe",
      "type": "published_record_transcription_image_inspected",
      "url": "https://genpa.org/wp-content/uploads/publications/pennsylvania-genealogical-magazine/PGM-Vol1No4-166-184.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed p.182, PDF17, inspected 16 September 2026. Hance Michael Wagly 100 acres; Abraham Titloe 50 acres. Both in Salford section, which begins in left column and continues at top of right column until Towamencin heading. Preface p.166 describes constables returns as uncertain. No wives, children or kinship stated. Locality/name context supports candidate identity with the Goshenhoppen in-law fathers, not proof by itself."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_HARLE_WEICKEL_1736",
      "title": "Pennsylvania German Pioneers I, Harle 1736 passenger list: Michel Weickel aged 44",
      "type": "published_record_image_in_teaching_material",
      "url": "https://www.americanancestors.org/sites/default/files/2023-04/04.20%20Slides%20Large.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "American Ancestors course slides PDF56 reproduces Strassburger and Hinke I pp.154-155; page155 image inspected 16 September 2026. List41A Harle, qualified 1 September 1736, Michel Weickel age44. This verifies a real passenger underlying IPGV identification, not his identity as father of George. Slide55 only shows beginning of oath page, not Weickel signature."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_HARLE_TRANSCRIPTION_WEYGELL",
      "title": "Harle 1736 lists41A and41B transcribed by Donna Speer Ristenbatt",
      "type": "record_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.ristenbatt.com/genealogy/shplst38.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 16 September 2026. Captain list Michel Weickel44; oath list Johann Michael Weygell. Female list includes An. Elisabeth Weygelin38; no relationship stated, so not assigned as wife. No George Weigel recognized in displayed A/B lists, but this is not an exhaustive original-list review and absence is not used as disproof."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_HELEN_FYNNEY_ALTON_1803",
      "title": "Helen Fynney baptism, Alton St Peter, 10 April 1803",
      "type": "parish record transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6853135e8655747a97a0faf4/helen-fynney-baptism-staffordshire-alton-1803-04-10",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG public detail inspected 16 September 2026. Register type Other Transcript. Helen, female, baptized10April1803; father William FYNNEY, mother Hellen. Transcriber/credit Hazel Mills, file line461. No birth date, abode or later identity supplied. Candidate for Ellen/Helen Finney Waterhouse, not yet an identified ancestor."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_WATERHOUSE_1861_ALTON_BIRTHPLACE",
      "title": "FreeCEN 1861 Waterhouse household: Helen born Alton",
      "type": "census transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freecen.org.uk/search_records/592898cae937906e9ff554a8/helen-waterhouse-1861-warwickshire-st-george-1809-",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Public detailed table inspected 16 September 2026. 1861 Warwickshire, St George district, Birmingham civil parish, Bham St George ecclesiastical parish; RG9 piece2161 ED30 folio25 page1 schedule1; 1 Hatchett St. Jonas Waterhouse52 carpenter born Ashbourne Derbyshire; wife Helen52 born Alton Staffordshire; daughter Eugeina21 dressmaker, Henry19 stone mason, Herbert16 gun filer, Elizabeth12 guard chain maker, all born Hanford Staffordshire; grandson George Read6 born Birmingham. The distinctive household agrees with Matthew's supplied 1861 transcript and earlier family. This adds Ellen/Helen's own precise birthplace, not her daughter's. Original image not inspected; this and the prior supplied1861 transcript represent the same census event, not independent censuses."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_SALT_ROCESTER_1795",
      "title": "William Finney and Ellen Salt marriage, Rocester, 8 December 1795",
      "type": "parish marriage transcription",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6854986a8655747a973b8507/william-finney-ellen-salt-marriage-staffordshire-rocester-1795-12-08",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG detailed entry inspected 16 September 2026. Rocester St Michael; Other Transcript; William FINNEY bachelor, Ellen SALT spinster, married 8 December 1795. No ages, occupations, witnesses, parents or individual abodes supplied. Chris Bullock transcription, file line187. Tinstaafl Rocester marriage table also gives the same pair/date, entry152: https://www.tinstaafl.co.uk/eandwhmi/staffordshire/church%20pages/rocester.html . Likely dependent on the same underlying register; do not count as independent marriage evidence. Identity with the Alton William/Hellen parents is assessed comparatively, not expressly stated in this marriage entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_ALTON_FAMILY_BAPTISMS",
      "title": "Alton Finney/Fynney baptism family comparison, 1790–1815",
      "type": "grouped parish baptism transcriptions",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685314ca8655747a97a1b0aa/frederick-finney-frederick-finney-baptism-staffordshire-alton-1814-07-19",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Detailed FreeREG records inspected 16 September 2026, Alton St Peter. Each original HTML and complete comparison dataset saved in research/finney_family_20260916. The following parent-name cluster was found (baptism dates, not assumed birth dates): [{\"Baptism date\": \"03 Jul 1796\", \"Person forename\": \"Joseph\", \"Father forename\": \"William\", \"Mother forename\": \"Eleanor\", \"Father surname\": \"FINNEY\", \"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685313498655747a97a0f401/joseph-finney-baptism-staffordshire-alton-1796-07-03\"}, {\"Baptism date\": \"10 Feb 1799\", \"Person forename\": \"John\", \"Father forename\": \"William\", \"Mother forename\": \"Ellen\", \"Father surname\": \"FINNEY\", \"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685313518655747a97a0f67e/john-finney-baptism-staffordshire-alton-1799-02-10\"}, {\"Baptism date\": \"10 Apr 1803\", \"Person forename\": \"Helen\", \"Father forename\": \"William\", \"Mother forename\": \"Hellen\", \"Father surname\": \"FYNNEY\", \"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6853135e8655747a97a0faf4/helen-fynney-baptism-staffordshire-alton-1803-04-10\"}, {\"Baptism date\": \"18 Nov 1804\", \"Person forename\": \"Amy\", \"Father forename\": \"William\", \"Mother forename\": \"Helen\", \"Father surname\": \"FYNNEY\", \"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685313638655747a97a0fcca/amy-fynney-baptism-staffordshire-alton-1804-11-18\"}, {\"Baptism date\": \"22 Oct 1809\", \"Person forename\": \"Charles\", \"Father forename\": \"William\", \"Mother forename\": \"Ellen\", \"Father surname\": \"FYNNEY\", \"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685313728655747a97a10377/charles-fynney-baptism-staffordshire-alton-1809-10-22\"}, {\"Baptism date\": \"19 Jul 1814\", \"Person forename\": \"Frederick\", \"Father forename\": \"William\", \"Mother forename\": \"Ellen\", \"Father surname\": \"FINNEY\", \"Father occupation\": \"Joiner\", \"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685314ca8655747a97a1b0aa/frederick-finney-frederick-finney-baptism-staffordshire-alton-1814-07-19\"}]. Frederick1814 names father William a Joiner. Other simultaneous Alton clusters include William/Catherine, Joseph/Catherine, Rupert/Dorothy, Charles/Ellen and John/Jane; do not combine these automatically. The single Harriet1802 Joseph/Helen entry is retained as transcribed, not silently reassigned. The1796Eleanor variant is a more tentative same-mother inference than the Ellen/Helen/Hellen sequence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_FINNEY_SALT_ORIGINS_CANDIDATES",
      "title": "Finney burial and Ellen Salt baptism candidates, Staffordshire",
      "type": "grouped parish register transcriptions",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/65ba7abaf493fd17ae18f1e8/ellen-finney-burial-staffordshire-alton-1821-07-18",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FreeREG detailed transcriptions inspected 16 September 2026; original register images not inspected. These records establish the listed events, not their identity with the tree ancestors. Complete fields and URLs: [{\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6853b5688655747a97db4528/william-fynney-burial-staffordshire-cheadle-1828-03-29\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Cheadle\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Giles the Abbot\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Other Transcript\", \"Burial date 29 Mar 1828\", \"Burial person forename William\", \"Relationship son of\", \"Male relative forename Samuel\", \"Relative surname FYNNEY\", \"Burial person surname FYNNEY\", \"Person age 17\", \"Burial person abode Oakmoor\", \"Transcribed by Sue Mills\", \"Credit Sue Mills\", \"File line number 1003\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/65ba7ad7f493fd17ae18f8f1/william-finney-burial-staffordshire-alton-1846-02-28\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Alton\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Peter\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Parish Register\", \"Register entry number 974\", \"Burial date 28 Feb 1846\", \"Burial person forename William\", \"Burial person surname FINNEY\", \"Person age 73\", \"Burial person abode Cheadle\", \"Transcribed by Robert Wakefield\", \"Credit Hazel Mills and Robert Wakefield\", \"File line number 777\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6853b5b68655747a97db5f36/william-finney-burial-staffordshire-cheadle-1846-08-17\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Cheadle\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Giles the Abbot\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Other Transcript\", \"Burial date 17 Aug 1846\", \"Burial person forename William\", \"Burial person surname FINNEY\", \"Person age 32\", \"Burial person abode Lane End\", \"Transcribed by Sue Mills\", \"Credit Sue Mills\", \"File line number 2589\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/65ba7adcf493fd17ae18fa63/william-finney-burial-staffordshire-alton-1850-07-18\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Alton\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Peter\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Parish Register\", \"Register entry number 1093\", \"Burial date 18 Jul 1850\", \"Burial person forename William\", \"Burial person surname FINNEY\", \"Person age 2y6m\", \"Burial person abode Farley\", \"Transcribed by Robert Wakefield\", \"Credit Hazel Mills and Robert Wakefield\", \"File line number 896\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/68557b2a8655747a97965211/ellen-salt-baptism-staffordshire-uttoxeter-1751-01-16\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Uttoxeter\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Mary the Virgin\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Parish Register\", \"Baptism date 16 Jan 1750/51\", \"Person forename Ellen\", \"Person sex F\", \"Father forename William\", \"Mother forename Patience\", \"Father surname SALT\", \"Transcribed by Beverley Stubbs\", \"File line number 1179\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6853e32e8655747a97eebb0b/ellen-salt-ellen-salt-baptism-staffordshire-ellastone-1754-02-10\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Ellastone\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Peter\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Other Transcript\", \"Baptism date 10 Feb 1754\", \"Person forename Ellen\", \"Person sex F\", \"Father forename Wm\", \"Mother forename Prudence\", \"Father surname SALT\", \"Mother surname SALT\", \"Transcribed by Hazel Mills\", \"Credit Hazel Mills\", \"File line number 99\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6853e3328655747a97eebe44/ellen-salt-ellen-salt-baptism-staffordshire-ellastone-1756-11-08\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Ellastone\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Peter\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Other Transcript\", \"Baptism date 08 Nov 1756\", \"Person forename Ellen\", \"Person sex F\", \"Father forename Thomas\", \"Mother forename Frances\", \"Father surname SALT\", \"Mother surname SALT\", \"Transcribed by Hazel Mills\", \"Credit Hazel Mills\", \"File line number 190\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6853e33e8655747a97eec712/ellen-salt-ellen-salt-baptism-staffordshire-ellastone-1764-06-11\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Ellastone\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Peter\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Other Transcript\", \"Baptism date 11 Jun 1764\", \"Person forename Ellen\", \"Person sex F\", \"Father forename Wm\", \"Mother forename Catharine\", \"Father surname SALT\", \"Mother surname SALT\", \"Transcribed by Hazel Mills\", \"Credit Hazel Mills\", \"File line number 443\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6853c7a18655747a97e20013/elin-salt-elin-salt-baptism-staffordshire-croxden-1765-03-17\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Croxden\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Giles\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Other Transcript\", \"Baptism date 17 Mar 1765\", \"Person forename Elin\", \"Person sex F\", \"Father forename Joseph\", \"Mother forename Jane\", \"Father surname SALT\", \"Mother surname SALT\", \"Transcribed by Hazel Mills\", \"Credit Hazel Mills\", \"File line number 692\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/6853e3478655747a97eecc46/ellen-salt-baptism-staffordshire-ellastone-1768-05-16\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Ellastone\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Peter\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Other Transcript\", \"Baptism date 16 May 1768\", \"Person forename Ellen\", \"Person sex F\", \"Mother forename Anne\", \"Mother surname SALT\", \"Notes Illeg\", \"Transcribed by Hazel Mills\", \"Credit Hazel Mills\", \"File line number 590\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/68557c128655747a9796c4a8/ellen-salt-baptism-staffordshire-uttoxeter-1773-09-28\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Uttoxeter\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Mary the Virgin\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Parish Register\", \"Baptism date 28 Sep 1773\", \"Person forename Ellen\", \"Person sex F\", \"Father forename John\", \"Mother forename Ann\", \"Father surname SALT\", \"Transcribed by Rod Birch\", \"Credit Rod Birch\", \"File line number 769\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/685627eb8655747a97d85f7e/ellen-sileto-baptism-staffordshire-whitmore-1774-10-29\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Whitmore\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Mary and All Saints\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Other Transcript\", \"Baptism date 29 Oct 1774\", \"Person forename Ellen\", \"Person sex F\", \"Father forename John\", \"Mother forename Mary\", \"Father surname SILETO\", \"Person abode Lin Pitts\", \"Transcribed by Glenis Hall\", \"Credit Glenis Hall\", \"File line number 1053\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/603fe51df493fd1b60d22726/ellen-salt-baptism-staffordshire-church-leigh-1775-09-10\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Church Leigh\", \"Church name (Links to more information) All Saints\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Parish Register\", \"Baptism date 10 Sep 1775\", \"Person forename Ellen\", \"Person sex F\", \"Father forename John\", \"Mother forename Mary\", \"Father surname SALT\", \"Transcribed by Ann Redfern\", \"Credit Ann Redfern\", \"File line number 246\"]}, {\"url\": \"https://www.freereg.org.uk/search_records/65ba7abaf493fd17ae18f1e8/ellen-finney-burial-staffordshire-alton-1821-07-18\", \"rows\": [\"Field (only fields with a value are shown) Value\", \"County Staffordshire\", \"Place Alton\", \"Church name (Links to more information) St Peter\", \"Register type (Links to more information) Parish Register\", \"Register entry number 190\", \"Burial date 18 Jul 1821\", \"Burial person forename Ellen\", \"Burial person surname FINNEY\", \"Person age 47\", \"Burial person abode Farley\", \"Transcribed by Robert Wakefield\", \"Credit Hazel Mills and Robert Wakefield\", \"File line number 190\"]}]"
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_MCINTOSH_CHURCH_BUTT_1705",
      "title": "McIntosh, Norfolk wills: Richard Church and granddaughter Leddae Butt, pp191-192",
      "type": "digitized published probate abstract",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/briefabstractofl01mcin/page/191/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Volume1 (1914), printed pp191-192, Book7 p106: Richard Church, dated5 January1705, proved15 February1705/6; codicil gives granddaughter Leddae Butt a young horse. Printed p191 visually inspected; p192 text names wife Elizabeth and son Joseph as executors. No parents named for Leddae, and no daughter Elizabeth named in this abstract. Do not identify wife Elizabeth with the younger proposed Elizabeth Church. Published abstract is not original will image. Same volume p48 explicitly gives Robert Butt's son Thomas Rich Neck land."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_STALEY_DURHAM_1696_WILL",
      "title": "Maryland Calendar of Wills II p208: Thomas Staley, will 1696, proved 1700",
      "type": "published probate abstract",
      "url": "https://ldsgenealogy.com/MD/books/The-Maryland-calendar-of-wills-Wills-from-1685-to-1702-Volume-II-part-16.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Abstract cites Maryland Wills 11:25. Thomas Staley of Baltimore, dated 16 February 1696, proved 7 November 1700 as printed. James Durham called son-in-law, executor and residuary legatee; granddaughter Mary, eldest daughter of James, and her brother James named in land succession. Moore's Fields, 165 acres. Fraction in OCR corrupted, not adopted. Frances and the given name of James's wife are not stated. Original will uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_MSA_THOMAS_STALEY_BIO",
      "title": "Maryland legislative biography: Thomas Staley (d1700), p768",
      "type": "official scholarly biographical dictionary",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000426/html/am426--768.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Thomas Staley lived at Morefields, north Gunpowder Hundred, Baltimore. Daughter, given name unknown, married James Durham by 1696; transferred 50 acres to James in 1697. Staley served in the Lower House and as sheriff. His wife Mary was Thomas Jones's widow, not automatically the daughter called Mary in compiled Durham pedigrees. Biography gives probate 4 November 1700, differing from calendar 7 November. OCR inspected; linked page image failed rendering and direct download returned service error. Do not resolve date discrepancy without original."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_MCELROY_FRANCES_DURHAM_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "title": "FamilySearch compiled Frances Durham profile, James Durham and Mary Staley parent claim",
      "type": "collaborative pedigree, candidate evidence",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/LZGD-32R/frances-durham-1694-1732",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Profile reports Frances 1694–1732, wife John McElroy, daughter James Durham and Mary Staley. Visible source titles include legacy submissions and a North Carolina Civil Marriages 1763–1868 image. That collection title alone does not establish the early marriage; underlying image not inspected. Dates and parents not adopted. Related Sherry Sharp profile I89633 gives parents' marriage 1713, inconsistent with a single-marriage explanation for a 1694 birth. No independently sourced birth or marriage dates verified."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_WINGO_BUTT_WILLS_DEPOSITIONS",
      "title": "Elizabeth B. Wingo, Collection of Unrecorded Wills, Norfolk County, Virginia, 1711–1800 (1961), pp22–25",
      "type": "published_record_transcription",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/collectionofunre00wing/page/24/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed pages 22–25 visually inspected; PDF pages 38–41. Lemuel Butt deposition 25 July 1751 gives age 47 and upwards; describes writing William Butt’s will on 18 May 1750. Margaret Butt will 18 August 1735, proved 21 November: father Robert, mother Elizabeth, sister Ede Jones, goddaughter Sarah Wilson; land beside John Pinkerton. Original manuscripts not inspected. No Church maiden name or Lemuel parentage supplied. Anthony’s companion deposition prints a different execution year, MDCCXLI, requiring manuscript comparison."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_ALLEN_1729_ULLAND_PASSENGER_GROUP",
      "title": "Pennsylvania German Pioneers I, pp27-29: Mathias, Catrina and minor Johannes Ulland, Allen1729",
      "type": "published_record_transcription",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/pennsylvaniagerm42stra/page/28/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed pp27-29 visually inspected. Captain list10A dated11September1729; qualification15September. Mathias adult name, Catrina female list, Johannes explicitly under fifteen. No explicit family relationship. Captain original uninspected. Matches online Ristenbatt transcription; not independent source. Age distinguishes this entry from Hope1734 John Nouland24 if both ages accurate."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OT26_NEWLAND_1736_INDENTURE_CHRONOLOGY",
      "title": "John Newland–Isham Randolph agreement: published abstracts and chronological identity test",
      "type": "published abstract; original manuscript not inspected",
      "url": "https://liveasfreepeople.com/2016/12/27/randolphs-of-early-virginia/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 16 September 2026. Arlandson abstracts Goochland Deed Book 2, p. 259, agreement dated 30 June 1736, recorded 16 November 1736; explicitly marks missing words. Cooke https://www.gdcooke.org/ss/org2-o/p26344.htm and a longer derivative transcription https://familytrees.genopro.com/Azrael/555ed/Randolph-Isham-I4182.htm describe a four-year term ending 8 April 1737. These are not independent events or established independent transcriptions. Subtracting four years suggests 8 April 1733, conditional on accurate wording and an uninterrupted ordinary term. This predates Hope arrival in September 1734; it does not independently prove arrival in 1733. Library of Virginia official catalogue https://www.lva.virginia.gov/collections/ccmf/VA/VA103 confirms Deed Book 2 (1734–1736), 272 pages, on reel 1. Original p. 259 and the original indenture remain targets; FamilySearch neighboring-page link returned Internal Error, not evidence of absence. Distinguish agreement date, recording date, scheduled expiry and actual release. No claim that the employer was a relative."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SURNAME_FRICKE_DAFN2",
      "title": "Fricke: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022), via Ancestry",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/fricke",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Consulted 16 September 2026. Cross-refers to Frick for German, Swiss German and English formations. Linguistic background, not proof of common ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SURNAME_FRICK_DAFN2",
      "title": "Frick: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022), via Ancestry",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/frick",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Consulted 16 September 2026. Distinguishes German personal-name, Swiss place-name and English nickname/topographic formations. Independent surname formation must be considered."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_SURNAME_BUTT_DAFN",
      "title": "Butt: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003/2006), via FamilySearch",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=butt",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Consulted 16 September 2026. English nickname/topographic, German occupational and Pakistani/Indian Bhatt formations. Dictionary migration assertion about Robert Butt is not treated as a verified historical event or attached to this pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RHEAD",
      "title": "Rhead: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022) via Ancestry",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/rhead",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Consulted 16 September 2026. Linguistic and geographical surname background; not proof of the ancestry, occupation or clan affiliation of a particular bearer. Entries were read and paraphrased, including their uncertainty and cross-references. No modern surname-distribution statistics are used as evidence of medieval descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_READ",
      "title": "Read: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022) via Ancestry",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/read",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Consulted 16 September 2026. Linguistic and geographical surname background; not proof of the ancestry, occupation or clan affiliation of a particular bearer. Entries were read and paraphrased, including their uncertainty and cross-references. No modern surname-distribution statistics are used as evidence of medieval descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_REED",
      "title": "Reed: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022) via Ancestry",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/reed",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Consulted 16 September 2026. Linguistic and geographical surname background; not proof of the ancestry, occupation or clan affiliation of a particular bearer. Entries were read and paraphrased, including their uncertainty and cross-references. No modern surname-distribution statistics are used as evidence of medieval descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HENDERSON",
      "title": "Henderson: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022) via Ancestry",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/henderson",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Consulted 16 September 2026. Linguistic and geographical surname background; not proof of the ancestry, occupation or clan affiliation of a particular bearer. Entries were read and paraphrased, including their uncertainty and cross-references. No modern surname-distribution statistics are used as evidence of medieval descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NEEDHAM",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Needham",
      "type": "scholarly surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/Needham?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry distinguishes English place-derived origins, including High Needham in Hartington, from an Irish County Mayo origin. Consulted 19 September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GABEL",
      "title": "Gabel: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022) via Ancestry",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/gabel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Consulted 16 September 2026. Linguistic and geographical surname background; not proof of the ancestry, occupation or clan affiliation of a particular bearer. Entries were read and paraphrased, including their uncertainty and cross-references. No modern surname-distribution statistics are used as evidence of medieval descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GOEBEL",
      "title": "Goebel: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022) via Ancestry",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/goebel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Consulted 16 September 2026. Linguistic and geographical surname background; not proof of the ancestry, occupation or clan affiliation of a particular bearer. Entries were read and paraphrased, including their uncertainty and cross-references. No modern surname-distribution statistics are used as evidence of medieval descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MCELROY",
      "title": "McElroy: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022) via Ancestry",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/mcelroy",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Consulted 16 September 2026. Linguistic and geographical surname background; not proof of the ancestry, occupation or clan affiliation of a particular bearer. Entries were read and paraphrased, including their uncertainty and cross-references. No modern surname-distribution statistics are used as evidence of medieval descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_FS_RICHARD_RHEAD_LV6Q182",
      "title": "FamilySearch compiled Richard Rhead family (1825)",
      "type": "compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/LV6Q-182/richard-rhead-1825",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 16 September 2026. Compiled identity lead, not independent verification of every linked relationship or date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ANCESTRY_SARAH_RHEAD_COMPILED",
      "title": "Ancestry compiled Sarah Rhead family",
      "type": "compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/sarah-rhead-24-s7jbg7",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reviewed 16 September 2026. Compiled identity lead, not independent verification of every linked relationship or date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GODWIN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Godwin",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/godwin",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Patrick Hanks et al., 2022, as supplied by Ancestry; entry read 16 September 2026. General surname scholarship, not a pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_TURNER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Turner",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/turner",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Patrick Hanks et al., 2022, as supplied by Ancestry; entry read 16 September 2026. General surname scholarship, not a pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BEARDMORE",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Beardmore",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/beardmore",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Patrick Hanks et al., 2022, as supplied by Ancestry; entry read 16 September 2026. General surname scholarship, not a pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SILVESTER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Silvester",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/silvester",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary entry supplied by Ancestry, read 16 September 2026. General name formation, not proof of a particular pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SYLVESTER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Sylvester",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/sylvester",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary entry supplied by Ancestry, read 16 September 2026. General name formation, not proof of a particular pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GLOVER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Glover",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/glover",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary entry supplied by Ancestry, read 16 September 2026. General name formation, not proof of a particular pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HOROVITZ_BEARDMOORS",
      "title": "David Horovitz (2003), Staffordshire place-names, vol. 1, p.158: Beardmoors",
      "type": "scholarly place-name study",
      "url": "https://lichfieldlore.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/397633_vol1.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Nottingham PhD thesis. PDF page 159 visually inspected 16 September 2026. Cites historical forms and SRO D554/41 (1798). Underlying documents not inspected. Official thesis landing page: https://eprints.nottingham.ac.uk/11557/ ."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SIMS",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Sims",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/sims",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary entry supplied by Ancestry, read 16 September 2026. General surname formation, not proof of this branch’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SIM",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Sim",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/sim",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary entry supplied by Ancestry, read 16 September 2026. General surname formation, not proof of this branch’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_JAMES_SIMMS_PENSION_S4840",
      "title": "James Simms, Revolutionary War pension S4840: declaration of 6 August 1832 and amendment of 2 April 1833",
      "type": "transcription of pension declaration",
      "url": "https://revwarapps.org/s4840.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Will Graves transcription, revised 2019, Southern Campaigns Revolutionary War Pension Statements & Rosters. Read September 2026. Retrospective sworn testimony, not a contemporary 1778 record; manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WASHINGTON_VA_DB4_SIMS_INDEX",
      "title": "Donna Jean Ford (2005), index to Washington County VA Deed Book 4, 1808–1811",
      "type": "derivative deed index",
      "url": "https://www.ramblingroots.com/RYB-p/exhibits/wcva-db-4.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Derived from Jack Hockett’s 2003 abstract. Index page 12 lists Sims/Simms on original deed-book pages 130, 141, 446; surname-only lead, not a deed transcription or identified household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MARTIN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Martin",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/martin",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary entry supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026. General name history, not this unverified woman’s pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_AVES_SUSAN_BAPTISM_TRANSCRIPT",
      "title": "WeRelate: Susan Gantrell, quoted baptism of 18 August 1585",
      "type": "compiled profile quoting parish transcript",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person%3ASusan_Gantrell_%282%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026; cites Antony Broad’s research report dated 29 July 2003. Names Susan’s parents Richard Gantrell and Aves, without a maternal birth surname. Profile labels baptism Winterborne Stickland; original register not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_MARLOW_ADJOINER_LAND_INDEX",
      "title": "St Mary’s County MDGenWeb: Adjoinder (St Johns Addition) land entries",
      "type": "compiled land index",
      "url": "https://www.usgenwebsites.org/MDStmarys/record/land1637-1799a.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. William Marlow, 50 acres in Poplar Hill, appears under 1667 citing 1707 rent rolls and under 1668 citing patent records. Original documents not inspected; these dates are not independently verified events."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_POYNER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Poyner",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/poyner",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary entry supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_STANTON_LACY_POYNER_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Stanton Lacy parish registers: Charles and Elinor Poyner household",
      "type": "published parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/StantonLacy.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "HTML transcription read and saved September 2026. Published p.78: 28 July 1675 baptism of Charles and Richard, sons of Charles and Elinor. Published p.80: Daniel, 26 December 1678. Flyleaf lists Charles among people paying fees after marrying outside the parish. Original images not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ABDON_POYNER_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Abdon parish registers: Richard Poyner and Joan Richards",
      "type": "published parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/Abdon.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read and saved September 2026. P.41 lists marriage on 7 February under 1706, normalized 1706/7; p.43 records burial of son Richard on 8 December 1710. Original images not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_QUEEN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Queen",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/queen",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_MCNEW_MARSHAM_QUEEN",
      "title": "Nathan McNew: Marsham Queen",
      "type": "compiled family history",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/b/f/e6cce7bf84870314c31eb990afb.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Distinguish compiled assertions or index references from personally inspected original documents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_QUEEN_INHERITANCE_BLOG",
      "title": "Queen Family: Samuel Queen and Katherine Marsham, including quoted inheritance clause",
      "type": "family blog quoting will",
      "url": "https://queenfamilyky.wordpress.com/2017/11/02/samuel-queen-katherine-marsham/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Distinguish compiled assertions or index references from personally inspected original documents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_MSA_MARSHAM_QUEEN_WILL_INDEX",
      "title": "Maryland State Archives probate index: Marsham Queen, 1771",
      "type": "archival probate index",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/stagsere/se1/se4/000000/000017/pdf/mdsa_se4_17.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Distinguish compiled assertions or index references from personally inspected original documents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FUCHS",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Fuchs",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/fuchs",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026. Alternative formations are not proof of this branch’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_NAGEL",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Nagel",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/nagel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026. Alternative formations are not proof of this branch’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GONDER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Gonder",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/gonder",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026. Alternative formations are not proof of this branch’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GANDER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Gander",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/gander",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026. Alternative formations are not proof of this branch’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LINDER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Linder",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/linder",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026. Alternative formations are not proof of this branch’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LIND",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Lind",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lind",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026. Alternative formations are not proof of this branch’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_RAUPP_STAFFORT_NAGEL",
      "title": "Manfred G. Raupp, Ortsfamilienbuch Staffort, p. 165, families 1557–1560",
      "type": "published local family book",
      "url": "https://regionalia.blb-karlsruhe.de/files/26085/BLB_Raupp_Ortsfamilienbuch_Staffort.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF page 169 rendered and visually inspected September 2026. Entries 1557 and 1558 repeat 1623/1693 Simon and 1625/1691 Catharina with different marriage years; this is a compilation requiring register verification."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WYLDE",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Wylde",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/wylde",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry, read September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILD",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Wild",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/wild",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. Gives English nickname and topographic explanations, a variant of Wile, and German and Jewish cognate forms."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HUDDLESTON",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Huddleston",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/huddleston",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry, read September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_VCH_DODDERHILL",
      "title": "Victoria County History: Dodderhill, Worcestershire volume 3, pp.58–69",
      "type": "scholarly county history",
      "url": "https://www.british-history.ac.uk/vch/worcs/vol3/pp58-69",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read full HTML via direct download September 2026. Impney succession paragraph inspected. No Simon Wylde parentage statement located in this page despite the Wikipedia citation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HE_SAWSTON_HALL",
      "title": "Historic England: Sawston Hall, list entry 1330979",
      "type": "official historic building record",
      "url": "https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1330979",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Rebuilding and dated courtyard stones described; does not itself name Frances."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WIKI_THOMAS_WYLDE",
      "title": "Thomas Wylde (clothier): compiled biography and references",
      "type": "compiled biography",
      "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Wylde_(clothier)",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Simon parentage is a reported lead; cited Dodderhill page did not substantiate that statement in this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WIKI_GEORGE_WYLDE",
      "title": "George Wylde I: compiled biography and references",
      "type": "compiled biography",
      "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Wylde_I",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Identifies wife Frances as daughter of Sir Edmund Huddleston of Sawston. Original marriage and probate documents not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WALL",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Wall",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/wall",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BANNISTER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Bannister",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/bannister",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_FLOWER_WALL_PRESTON_1567",
      "title": "William Flower, Visitation of Lancashire 1567, ed. F. R. Raines (1870), p.49: Wall of Preston",
      "type": "published heraldic visitation pedigree",
      "url": "https://www.deanechurch.co.uk/library/BooksDigital/RemainsHistorical/Vol_081.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Chetham Society volume 81; printed page 49, PDF page 75 rendered and visually inspected September 2026. Pedigree cites Harl. MS fo.47b and Chetham MS fo.21b. An edited pedigree, not independently verified parish evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_DISTRIBUTION",
      "title": "Forebears: Pettenati distribution and unlisted meaning",
      "type": "modern surname distribution reference",
      "url": "https://forebears.io/surnames/pettenati",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Modern concentration in Italy, especially Emilia-Romagna; explicitly does not supply a surname meaning. Modern distribution cannot locate a medieval family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_PETTENATI_REVIEW_20260916",
      "title": "Pettenati / Whalley endpoint research review, September 2026",
      "type": "research assessment",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "User-supplied parentage retained as evidence. Exact web searches Girolamo Pettenati with Margaret and Margaret Whalley with Pettenati did not identify a relevant document. Searching Margaret Whalley with Richard Wall located the 1567 visitation. Ancestry Pettenati prose lacked the DAFN attribution visible for established dictionary entries; conflicting unsourced etymologies were not adopted. See research/family_roots_wall_20260916/RESEARCH.md."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GARDNER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Gardner",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/gardner",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry, read September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_FANBI_SHEMELD",
      "title": "Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland (2016): Shemeld",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/shemeld",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026; both proposed derivations are explicitly tentative."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_FANBI_FARNFOLD",
      "title": "Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland (2016): Farnfield/Farnfold",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://en.geneanet.org/surnames/FARNFOLD",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary entry reproduced by Geneanet. The lost place is probably in Sussex, not securely identified."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SHEMELD_BARDSLEY",
      "title": "Bardsley (1896), Shemeld entry, reproduced by Forebears",
      "type": "historical surname reference",
      "url": "https://forebears.io/surnames/shemeld",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Names Adam and Robertus Schemylde in Yorkshire poll tax1379. Exact parish and original tax entries not inspected. Older etymology differs from modern Oxford discussion."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SHEMELD_WILLIAM_COMPOSITE",
      "title": "Ancestry composite: William Shemeld household",
      "type": "compiled family profile",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/william-shemeld-24-26j3xhv",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Explicitly generated from member trees and contributed records; names Isabel1577–1647 among William and Anna Swifte’s children. Not an original baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_VCH_EAST_HAM_CHURCHES",
      "title": "Victoria County History: East Ham churches, Essex volume6 (1973), pp25–31",
      "type": "scholarly church history",
      "url": "https://www.british-history.ac.uk/vch/essex/vol6/pp25-31",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full HTML read by direct download September2026. Beckton StMichael opened1883; RutlandRoad began1895; RomfordRoad building dates late19c. These histories do not fit a1551 marriage at the reported EastHam StMichael."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WHITE",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: White",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/white",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CLARKE",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Clarke",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/clarke",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CLARK",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Clark",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/clark",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CANTRELL",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Cantrell",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/cantrell",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary supplied by Ancestry; read September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WHITE_BARTEE_BOND_1796",
      "title": "Franklin County marriage-bond transcription: George Bartee and Elizabeth Highley, 8 November 1796",
      "type": "marriage-bond transcription",
      "url": "https://genealogytrails.com/vir/franklin/marriages1785-1855.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026; table headers distinguish bond date, surety and marriage date. Sureties William Highly and Benjamin White. Original bond not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WHITE_TAX_RECONSTRUCTION",
      "title": "WeRelate: Benjamin White (68), tax and family reconstruction",
      "type": "compiled research narrative",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person:Benjamin_White_(68)",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026. Discusses Franklin1788–1796 and Wythe1807 onward taxes and conjectural child identifications. Original tax pages not inspected. Quoted1787 marriage year differs from established1786 bond."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_OPC_STICKLAND_HOLDINGS",
      "title": "Dorset OPC: Winterborne Stickland register holdings",
      "type": "parish holdings guide",
      "url": "https://www.opcdorset.org/WinterborneFiles/W.Stickland/WinterborneStickland.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026. PE-WSD baptisms and burials from1615, marriages1616; narrative says1616. Does not itself explain Broad’s1558–1730 heading."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_I",
      "title": "Sheffield parish register, Part I, Yorkshire Parish Register Society vol.58",
      "type": "published parish-register transcript",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/parishregisterof58shef",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published transcript; pages5,12,198–199 inspected September2026. Anna Roodes baptisms29Nov1562 and5Oct1567; Richard Hancocke/Anna Roodes marriage30Jan1586/7. Parish manuscripts not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_III",
      "title": "Sheffield parish register, Part III, Drury and Hall, YPRS vol.68 (1921)",
      "type": "published parish-register transcript",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/parishregisterof68shef",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published transcript, printed p240/PDF250 visually inspected.5Sep1677 Godfridus Wild and Hellena Tunstead, widow. OCR searched Tunstead/Tunstid/Tunstad; no first marriage identified in that search, not an exhaustive negative."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_HANCOCK",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition (2022): Hancock",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hancock",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary entry supplied by Ancestry; read September2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_RHODES",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition (2022): Rhodes",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/rhodes",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary entry supplied by Ancestry; read September2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_ROADS",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition (2022): Roads",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/roads",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary entry supplied by Ancestry; read September2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DICT_TUNSTEAD",
      "title": "Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland (2016): Tunstead",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/tunstead",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary entry supplied by Ancestry; read September2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ELLIS",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition (2022): Ellis",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/ellis",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary entry read September2026 via Ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GREAVES",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition (2022): Greaves",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/greaves",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary entry read September2026 via Ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_ELLIS_GREAVES",
      "title": "Sheffield parish register PartI: Ellis baptism and Hancock/Greaves marriage",
      "type": "published parish-register transcript",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/parishregisterof58shef",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed pp159 and229 visually inspected September2026. Lidia daughter of Anthony Ellis baptised1Feb1628/9; Robert Hancock and Margreta Greaves married5Feb1615/16. OCR searches also made across PartsI–III. Original manuscripts not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_REGISTER_II",
      "title": "Sheffield parish register, PartII",
      "type": "published parish-register transcript",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/parishregisterof02shef",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded OCR searched September2026. Printed p194:17August1643 Lidia daughter of William Ellis; year from preceding1643 heading. Page image not inspected in this batch."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LAVENDER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition (2022): Lavender",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lavender",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026 via Ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LAVENDER_AMHERST_MILLS",
      "title": "Elizabeth Shown Mills: Mills & Associates, Amherst County court orders (2019, updated2022)",
      "type": "research report with court transcriptions",
      "url": "https://www.historicpathways.com/download/MillsAmherstCoCourtOrders.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed p15 visually inspected September2026.5Feb1776 William Lavender estate granted to widow Milley; cites Court Order Book1773–1782 p147, FamilySearch film8151599 image382. Original court image not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LAVINDER_BEDFORD_MARRIAGES",
      "title": "Bedford County marriage-bond abstracts: Lavinder",
      "type": "marriage-bond transcription",
      "url": "https://usgenwebsites.org/vagenweb/bedford/bedf-m_l.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026. John Lavinder/Elizabeth Allen married5Apr1798; sureties John Allen and Robert Witt.30Oct1822 John Lavinder, son of Robert, and Mary Cashman; surety Isaac StClair."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LAVENDER_JOSEPH_RECONSTRUCTION",
      "title": "Lavender family: Joseph Lavender Sr. reconstruction",
      "type": "compiled family research",
      "url": "https://mangum-parham.com/lavender.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026. Discusses several Virginia1820 census households as possible parents of Joseph1816. Parentage explicitly unknown; no link to this Robert established."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HORNBERGER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition (2022): Hornberger",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hornberger",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026 via Ancestry. Habitational surname from multiple places named Hornberg."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_IPGV_CHRISTIANA_HORNBERGER",
      "title": "IPGV migration card57066: Christiana Henrietta Hornberger",
      "type": "institutional genealogical card",
      "url": "https://migration.pfalzgeschichte.de/person/57066",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026. Gives variant Hauberger, no parents, no birth/death dates, spouse Johann Friedrich Gabel and son Christian. No source entered on her own card; son’s card57067 cites1754 baptism. These linked cards are not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_STOEVER_HORNBERGER_MARRIAGES",
      "title": "FamilyHart: marriage records of Rev. John Casper Stoever, compiled by Mildred Smith",
      "type": "church-register transcription index",
      "url": "https://www.familyhartroots.com/PA/Lancaster/StoeverMarriages.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026: John Bartolomeus Hornberger/Anna Elisabetha Reiffen (Chestnut Hill),25Aug1733; John Carl Hornberger/Ana Eva Saur (Leacock),31Aug1736. Original register not inspected. Locations printed alongside brides; do not assign both spouses a birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILKINS",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition (2022): Wilkins",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/wilkins",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026 via Ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILKIN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition (2022): Wilkin",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/wilkin",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026 via Ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WARDEN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition (2022): Warden",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/warden",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026 via Ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WILKINS_NORFOLK_WILL_LEAD",
      "title": "Geneanet indexed excerpts: McIntosh, Brief abstracts of Norfolk County wills,1710–1753 (1922)",
      "type": "indexed book excerpts; full entry unverified",
      "url": "https://en.geneanet.org/fonds/bibliotheque/?collection_id=bibliotheque_premium_5918922&go=1&nom=WILKINS&nom_collection=Brief+abstracts+of+Norfolk+County+wills%2C+1710-1753&size=50",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Public indexed excerpts read September2026 include daughter Catherine Butt and sons John and William Wilkins. Index snippets point to p208 for Anthony and William Wilkins. Full testament heading, date and page image were not obtained; do not combine separate snippets as a complete will."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_FS_NORFOLK_WILLS_VOLUME",
      "title": "FamilySearch Digital Library: McIntosh, Norfolk County wills1710–1753",
      "type": "digitized book catalog; viewer not inspected",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/library/books/records/item/166084-brief-abstracts-of-norfolk-county-wills-1710-1753",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalog read September2026. Identifier115233,343pages, Allen County Public Library, available online. Viewer blocked in available tools. This is a retrieval target, not proof of any will content."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_MARY_ISRAEL_BARTEE_COMPOSITE",
      "title": "Ancestry composite: Thomas Bartee1762, parents John William Bartee and Mary Israel",
      "type": "indexed derivative family profile",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/thomas-bartee-24-njgnp",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Public indexed profile read September2026. Reports Thomas1762Virginia, parents John William Bartee/Mary Israel, spouse Molly Glenn Harris. No demonstrated connection to Suckey Bartee; not evidence for assigning Israel to the unknown Mary."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_MOSES_INGENHEIM",
      "title": "Surname dictionary entry: Moses",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/moses",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026; etymology is background, not a pedigree. Dictionary of American Family Names 2022 credited on Moses, Nathan, Dreyfus, Dreyfuss and Oppenheimer pages."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_NATHAN_INGENHEIM",
      "title": "Surname dictionary entry: Nathan",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/nathan",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026; etymology is background, not a pedigree. Dictionary of American Family Names 2022 credited on Moses, Nathan, Dreyfus, Dreyfuss and Oppenheimer pages."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUSS_INGENHEIM",
      "title": "Surname dictionary entry: Dreyfuss",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/dreyfuss",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026; etymology is background, not a pedigree. Dictionary of American Family Names 2022 credited on Moses, Nathan, Dreyfus, Dreyfuss and Oppenheimer pages."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_DREYFUS_INGENHEIM",
      "title": "Surname dictionary entry: Dreyfus",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/dreyfus",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026; etymology is background, not a pedigree. Dictionary of American Family Names 2022 credited on Moses, Nathan, Dreyfus, Dreyfuss and Oppenheimer pages."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_OPPENHEIMER_INGENHEIM",
      "title": "Surname dictionary entry: Oppenheimer",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/oppenheimer",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026; etymology is background, not a pedigree. Dictionary of American Family Names 2022 credited on Moses, Nathan, Dreyfus, Dreyfuss and Oppenheimer pages."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_NAME_ABRAHAM_INGENHEIM",
      "title": "Surname dictionary entry: Abraham",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/abraham",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026; etymology is background, not a pedigree. Dictionary of American Family Names 2022 credited on Moses, Nathan, Dreyfus, Dreyfuss and Oppenheimer pages."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_NAMES_1808",
      "title": "Ingenheim: naming practices and the 1808 name changes",
      "type": "local historical research",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-gemeinde/namensumschreibung-1808/55/namensumschreibung-1808.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Explains personal names, patronymics and changing civil names. Its Isaak Hirsch Dreyfuss/Trier example is not accompanied by a dated migration record. Original register not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_INGENHEIM_AHB_1808",
      "title": "Kultur-Büro AHB: Ingenheim name-adoption list, 1808",
      "type": "published register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.a-h-b.de/de/projekte/familienforschung/name-adoption-lists/ingenheim",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "List supplied by Ralf Piepenbrink; read September 2026. Loeb Dreyfuss becomes Leo Dreyfuss; Rösel Moyses becomes Rosali Dreyfuss, with children listed. Original manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_JEHUDA_HERXHEIM_1797",
      "title": "Ingenheim cemetery: Jehuda Löb, son of Jecheskel Halevi, Herxheim",
      "type": "cemetery historical profile",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-menschen/namen-und-leben/jehuda-loeb-sohn-des-jecheskel-halevi/41/pid,18849/jehuda-loeb-sohn-des-jecheskel-halevi.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Public indexed profile read September 2026: Herxheim, died and buried 21 August 1797, grave 1 010. No Dreyfuss surname or connection to Hirsch is supplied. A real regional comparison, not a demonstrated separate or identical man."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HIRSCH_EPITAPH_1804",
      "title": "Ingenheim grave 1 081: Hirsch son of Jehuda Löb",
      "type": "published epitaph transcription and translation",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-graeber/1-081/44/wid,19455/1-081.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full Hebrew transcription and German translation read September 2026, downloaded HTML retained. Lines 4–6 identify Jizchak Zwi called Hirsch, son of Jehuda Löb, and abbreviated Dreyfuss. Death and burial 11 July 1804. Stone photograph not independently read."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ROSINA_EPITAPH_FRAGMENT",
      "title": "Ingenheim grave 2 04 05 A: Rosina née Haas, wife of Leon Dreifus",
      "type": "published fragmentary epitaph transcription",
      "url": "https://www.juedisches-leben-in-ingenheim.de/de/die-graeber/2-04-05-a/44/wid,11537/2-04-05-a.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full available transcription read September 2026. Names Rosina née Haas, wife of Leon Dreifus, and partial birth date 11 January with year absent. This differs from the profile’s 27 June 1770. Parents not included in available text; stone image not independently read."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GIBSON",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Gibson",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/gibson",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026, DAFN second edition 2022. Gibb, familiar Gilbert, plus son; English and Older Scots personal-name context; widespread in Ireland from the seventeenth century; occasional adoption for Ó Gibealláin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BOYD",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Boyd",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/boyd",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026. Multiple possibilities: Bute; Gaelic personal-name association; Scottish/Irish yellow-haired epithet; Manx Mac Gille Buidhe. No etymology establishes David’s ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_BOYD_COOLMAIN_ADMIN",
      "title": "National Archives will calendar: Samuel Boyd of Coolmain",
      "type": "official probate calendar, indexed text inspected",
      "url": "https://www.willcalendars.nationalarchives.ie/reels/cwa/005014910/005014910_00023.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed calendar paragraph read September 2026. Samuel Boyd, farmer, died 5 November 1895; administration 7 July at Armagh to Samuel Boyd of Coolmain, farmer, the son; effects £138. Calendar-year heading not verified. PDF screenshot failed and direct download timed out; no claim to original administration papers."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_BOYD_BAILIFF_FOLKLORE",
      "title": "Dúchas: Thomas and Samuel Boyd, estate bailiffs at Killymarley",
      "type": "archived oral-history transcription",
      "url": "https://www.duchas.ie/en/cbes/4742057/4731493/4816956?HighlightText=mullaghmore&Route=stories&SearchLanguage=ga",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Schools Collection volume 0957 page 261, Historic. Text read September 2026. Recalls father Thomas and son Samuel as bailiffs on Brooks estate, covering Killymarley and Coolmain among other townlands. Account mentions land purchase in 1923 and Samuel still living. No dates for Thomas’s life or relationship to David Boyd. This is recorded recollection, not a contemporary estate payroll."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_CASTLESHANE_TITHE_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Castleshane History: population and nineteenth-century tithe names",
      "type": "local historical compilation",
      "url": "https://www.castleshanehistory.ie/the-people-of-the-area",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Gibson included among surnames in combined Monaghan 1826 / Clontibret 1830 tithe discussion, without a forename or exact townland for that entry. Useful original-record target, not an identified older Gibson. Different regional households cannot be joined from religion or surname alone."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_NLI_AGHNASEDAGH_DEEDS",
      "title": "National Library of Ireland: Aghnasedagh title deeds, Leslie papers",
      "type": "archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://catalogue.nli.ie/Record/vtls000510842",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalog description read September 2026. MS 49,495/5 includes 1733 Waddell-to-Hector Graham conveyance and 1742 copy will; /7 includes 1760 agreement and 1765 Perry-to-Noble conveyance concerning Aghnasedagh. No Gibson named in catalog description. Deeds uninspected; target for tenant/property context, not evidence of Gibson occupation in those years."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_HANNEY",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Hanney",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hanney",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026. Waine credits Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland 2016; other entries credit Dictionary of American Family Names 2022. Cross-references followed; no surname origin assigned as genealogical fact."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_HENNEY",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Henney",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/henney",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026. Waine credits Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland 2016; other entries credit Dictionary of American Family Names 2022. Cross-references followed; no surname origin assigned as genealogical fact."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAINE",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Waine",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/waine",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026. Waine credits Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland 2016; other entries credit Dictionary of American Family Names 2022. Cross-references followed; no surname origin assigned as genealogical fact."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAIN",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Wain",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/wain",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026. Waine credits Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland 2016; other entries credit Dictionary of American Family Names 2022. Cross-references followed; no surname origin assigned as genealogical fact."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_NAME_WAYNE",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Wayne",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/wayne",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026. Waine credits Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland 2016; other entries credit Dictionary of American Family Names 2022. Cross-references followed; no surname origin assigned as genealogical fact."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WINSLEY_MARRIAGES",
      "title": "Winsley St Nicholas marriages, 1754–1837: Hardwicke Marriage Index",
      "type": "published parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.tinstaafl.co.uk/eandwhmi/wiltshire/church%20pages/winsley.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full downloaded HTML read September 2026. Entry 64: 8 July 1765 Charles Hanney, Catherine Eaine. PR343/1/8 at Wiltshire and Swindon Archives; compiler warns of fading and poor handwriting. Entry 36: 11 May 1761 Charles Hud/Hester Hanney; 94: 30 July 1769 Daniel Hanny/Margaret Woodly. Original register not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WILTS_HEARTH_1662",
      "title": "Hearth Tax Digital: Wiltshire 1662, TNA E179/259/29",
      "type": "scholarly archival transcription",
      "url": "https://gams.uni-graz.at/o:htx.wltshr1",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded HTML read September 2026. Editors Andrew Wareham and Steve Hobbs, transcribers Lorelei Williams and Simon Neal, 2024 edition. Winsley list inspected; no clearly transcribed Hanney/Hanny or Waine/Wayne located there, but lacunae and tax coverage limit absence inference. Latton section contains Mary Waine and John Wayne, one hearth each; John annotation cites 1668 will P3/W/320, uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WAINE_QUAKER_MARRIAGE",
      "title": "Wiltshire Quaker marriages: Edmond Waine and Hannah Trueman, 1715",
      "type": "published historical record transcription, indexed text",
      "url": "https://www.wiltshire-opc.org.uk/Items/Wiltshire/Wiltshire%20-%20Wiltshire%20Notes%20and%20Queries%20Volume%203%20-%201902.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed page 119 read September 2026: 1715-6-3 Hannah Trueman, daughter of Thomas of Foxham, Bremhill parish, to Edmond Waine at Calne. Quaker numbered-month conventions require checking before converting this to a modern month; not stated as 3 June here. No Catherine or Winsley connection supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_REGISTER",
      "title": "Cleobury Mortimer parish registers: published transcription",
      "type": "published parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/CleoburyMortimer.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full HTML downloaded and searched September 2026; original manuscript not inspected. 11 April 1725 Mary daughter John/Martha Perkins; 5 November 1750 John son Richard/Mary Dean, p185; 11 August 1758 Mary daughter Richard/Mary Deane, p222; 21 March 1761 Mary Dean infant burial; 8 October 1762 Richard Dean burial, p284. Introduction describes oldest register as damaged/illegible and a gap between 1637 and 1648."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_DEANE",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Deane",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/deane",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2022, meaning section read September 2026. Perkins uppercase URL supplies English dictionary text; lowercase URL returned inconsistent translated material and was not used. Cross-references followed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_DEAN",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Dean",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/dean",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2022, meaning section read September 2026. Perkins uppercase URL supplies English dictionary text; lowercase URL returned inconsistent translated material and was not used. Cross-references followed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PERKINS",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Perkins",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/Perkins",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2022, meaning section read September 2026. Perkins uppercase URL supplies English dictionary text; lowercase URL returned inconsistent translated material and was not used. Cross-references followed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PERKIN",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Perkin",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/perkin",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2022, meaning section read September 2026. Perkins uppercase URL supplies English dictionary text; lowercase URL returned inconsistent translated material and was not used. Cross-references followed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_CLEOBURY_NAME_PARKIN",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Parkin",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/parkin",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2022, meaning section read September 2026. Perkins uppercase URL supplies English dictionary text; lowercase URL returned inconsistent translated material and was not used. Cross-references followed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_FORTON_REVIEW",
      "title": "Forton marriage index: Grindley/Greenley household review",
      "type": "published parish-register index",
      "url": "https://www.tinstaafl.co.uk/eandwhmi/staffordshire/church%20pages/forton.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full HTML downloaded and searched September 2026. John Greenley/Elizabeth Pickin, entry 80,31 December 1777; William Grindley/Martha Smart, entry 219,31 January 1811; later Elizabeth Grindley/Rogers marriage. No Honor/Leonora/Honour or Thomas Grindley marriage found in this 1754–1837 index. Limited index search, not proof no marriage elsewhere. Same original event as existing 1777 transcripts, not independent event corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GRINDLEY",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Grindley",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/grindley",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary of American Family Names 2022, meaning section read September 2026. Greenley entry has a visibly truncated medieval year for Staffordshire; that year is not reproduced as evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_NAME_GREENLEY",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Greenley",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/greenley",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary of American Family Names 2022, meaning section read September 2026. Greenley entry has a visibly truncated medieval year for Staffordshire; that year is not reproduced as evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_GRINDLEY_BARDSLEY",
      "title": "Grindley in historical surname dictionaries",
      "type": "historical surname dictionary transcription",
      "url": "https://forebears.io/surnames/grindley",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Bardsley 1896 quotes 1569 ThomasGryndley baptism and 1576 MargaretGryndley burial at Mottram in Prestbury registers. Harrison 1912 discusses green-lea and valley-lea explanations. Read September 2026; underlying register images not inspected. Distant regional examples, no connection to Forton established."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DRAYTON_BRINDLEY_HARDING_1782",
      "title": "Drayton in Hales marriage index: Brindley/Harding and local Harding marriages",
      "type": "published parish-register index",
      "url": "https://www.tinstaafl.co.uk/eandwhmi/shropshire/church%20pages/drayton_in_hales.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full HTML read September 2026. 6 November 1782 Thomas BRINDLEY of Mucklestone, Staffordshire, and Margaret HARDING. Compare stored Grindley reading; original manuscript not inspected. Also 15 November 1764 Richard Harding/Ann Birchall; 24 February 1783 Abraham Jarvis/Elizabeth Harding; later Mary Harding/Thomas Bateman of Wrenbury. No kinship implied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_BOND_1712",
      "title": "Chester marriage bonds, 10 May 1712: Thomas Grindley and Dorothy Edwards",
      "type": "scholarly abstract of marriage bond",
      "url": "https://rslc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/vol_097.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "P H Lawson, Record Society of Lancashire and Cheshire volume 97 (1942), printed page 75, PDFpage 80. Text and rendered page inspected September 2026. Thomas Grindley of Newhall, Wrenbury, yeoman; Dorothy Edwards same place spinster; bondsmen Robert Grindley and Samuel Fullien [?] of Newhall, yeoman; witnesses Henry and George Gibbons. Allowed churches Acton, Wrenbury or Nantwich, not proof ceremony occurred at any specified one. OCR incorrectly dropped 7 from page 75; image resolves it."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_GRINDLEY_PROBATE_1834",
      "title": "Chester probate index: Thomas Grindley of Newhall, April 1834",
      "type": "scholarly probate index",
      "url": "https://user.xmission.com/~nelsonb/Volume120.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Record Society volume 120, printed page 160, PDFpage 168, text and image inspected September 2026. Thomas Grindley, Newhall parishWrenbury, labourer, April 1834. This is index date, not established death date. Will itself and family beneficiaries not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_ANN_BAPTISM_STORED",
      "title": "Stored supplied baptism transcript: Ann Grindley, Wrenbury, 1789",
      "type": "user-supplied parish-index transcript, reviewed in database",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Existing person notes for Ann and both parents record christening 5 April 1789 Wrenbury, fatherThos.Grindley, motherMargt. No source URL or original image is attached. Source created to expose the provenance and limits of those stored notes; not a new independent transcription."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WRENBURY_HARDING_NAME",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Harding",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/harding",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dictionary of American Family Names 2022, meaning section read September 2026; English personal-name origin distinguished from independent continental uses."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_PICKIN_WILLS",
      "title": "Whitmore Picken/Pickin entries in Lichfield and Coventry wills index",
      "type": "government archival index",
      "url": "https://www.staffsnameindexes.org.uk/default.aspx?County=1&Gender=0&Index=C&LastName=&Occupation=&PageIndex=7&Part=0&Place=whitmore&YearFrom=1570&YearTo=1790",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Results page read and downloaded September 2026. Margaret Picken, Whitmore/Stoke upon Trent, 1670, record 16635; William Pickin, Whitmore, yeoman, 1713, record 43975. Detail pages unavailable through web reader; wills and beneficiaries not inspected. Years are archival index years, not separately verified death dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_MI_SEARCH",
      "title": "Selected Whitmore churchyard inscriptions: bounded surname search",
      "type": "volunteer memorial transcription",
      "url": "https://places.wishful-thinking.org.uk/STS/Whitmore/MIs.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Alf Beard selection, contributed September 2005, read September 2026. No Pickin/Picken household found in this limited selection; not a complete cemetery or burial register, so absence has no force against local residence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKIN",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Pickin",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/pickin",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026. Pickin credits Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland 2016 and refers to Picken/Picking; those entries credit Dictionary of American Family Names 2022. No migration or pedigree inferred from etymology."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKEN",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Picken",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/picken",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026. Pickin credits Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland 2016 and refers to Picken/Picking; those entries credit Dictionary of American Family Names 2022. No migration or pedigree inferred from etymology."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WHITMORE_NAME_PICKING",
      "title": "Surname dictionary: Picking",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/picking",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Meaning section read September 2026. Pickin credits Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland 2016 and refers to Picken/Picking; those entries credit Dictionary of American Family Names 2022. No migration or pedigree inferred from etymology."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HENRY_WIRICK_WILL_1710",
      "title": "Henry Wirick: published abstract of Norfolk will, 1710–1711",
      "type": "published probate abstract on collaborative genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person%3AHenry_Wirick_%281%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed abstract read September 2026: Norfolk Book 9 page 25, dated 28 December 1710, proved 20 April 1711. Original not inspected. Page header’s approximate March death is not independently supported by the abstract. Mother mentioned is the children’s mother, not Henry’s mother."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WYRICK_AUGUSTA_1808",
      "title": "Library of Virginia: Henry Wyrick and others v. Martin Wyrick and others, Augusta 1808-026",
      "type": "government archival index",
      "url": "https://old.lva.virginia.gov/chancery/case_detail.asp?CFN=015-1808-026",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official case index read September 2026. Original case 109; includes Nicholas Wyrick’s 1792 Wythe County will; surname variants Wirick, Wyric and Wyrick. Case images not inspected. This is a later inland Virginia household, not evidence identifying the Norfolk testator or his parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WIRICK_NAME",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Wirick",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/wirick",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 second edition entry read September 2026. Probable alteration of North German Wirich/Wierich, referring to Weirich. Conditional etymology for the Wirick spelling, not evidence Henry migrated from Germany."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WEIRICH_NAME",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Weirich",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/weirich",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 second edition entry read September 2026. German personal-name elements wig, battle/fight, and ric, power."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_CHURCH_NAME",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Church",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/church",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 second edition meaning entry read September 2026. English topographic or occupational surname from Middle English chirche; chiefly southern/midland England. Also an Americanized translation of German Kirch. No ancestral parish inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_CHURCH_OFFICERS_1699",
      "title": "English duplicates of lost Virginia records: Norfolk officers, 8 June 1699",
      "type": "digitized transcription of colonial records",
      "url": "https://libsysdigi.library.illinois.edu/OCA/Books2012-06/englishduplicate00desc/englishduplicate00desc.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded full PDF September 2026. Printed page 8, PDF page 18, visually inspected: Richard Church sheriff; Thomas Butt; Matthew Godfrey among Norfolk officers. Printed page 1 also lists Church under 1699 sheriffs, not the separate 1680 headings above. No original manuscript inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SEVIER_NAME",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Sevier",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/sevier?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 second edition entry read September 2026: English occupational name for a sieve-maker, or altered French Xavier. These meanings describe the proposed surname, not an established origin for Nancy."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ANN_SMITH_NAME",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Smith",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/smith?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 second edition read September 2026. English/Scottish metalworker; also forge-related names, Gaelic adaptations and translations of European surnames. No single surname origin assigned to Ann."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SMITH_MCNEW_CHANCERY",
      "title": "Jack Hockett: Washington County chancery notes, Francis Smith v. George McNew",
      "type": "published notes from archival microfilm",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/washington-county-virginia-chancery-notes/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Draft 8 January 2006, Reel 117 notes read September 2026. Debt settlement in 1823, deed 20 April 1835, proceedings/depositions 1841–1844. George senior identifies son David as land purchaser. Original papers not inspected; author describes hurried notes and difficult handwriting."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_CHARLES_COURT_281",
      "title": "Archives of Maryland volume 60, page 281: Jeremiah and Phillis",
      "type": "digitized published court transcription",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000060/html/am60--281.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page image visually inspected September 2026. Liber E folio 1; heading 10 January 1670, within section headed 1671–1674. Printed Mackmere; wife Phillis; their son John Howard bound to Robert Littlepage until 21. This is not a marriage ceremony. Retain historical year as printed pending calendar review; no original manuscript inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_PHILLIS_BOND_1674",
      "title": "Thomas Corker record compilation: bond for Phillis Macknew, 1674",
      "type": "published court-record extract",
      "url": "https://www.number-one.org/~rigg/dlr0008.shtml",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Extract read September 2026: 10 November 1674 Jeremiah Macknew and Thomas Corker post fifty pounds sterling for Phillis to appear at Provincial Court on 8 December 1674; cites Charles County Liber F folio 13. Charge and outcome not supplied; no criminal conduct inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SCHRATERN_MARTA_1819",
      "title": "Verdener Familienforscher: Marta Schratern, 1819",
      "type": "genealogical society incidental-record index",
      "url": "https://www.zufallsfunde.net/index.php?ia=Schratern&ic=name&id=perslist",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full result downloaded/read September 2026: Marta Schratern, mentioned in Frankfurt/Oder, comes from Petersdorf, year 1819. Underlying record not inspected. Different place, period and given name from Rebecca; no migration or kinship bridge. Index does not provide surname meaning."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_KOCH_NAME",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Koch",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/koch?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 second edition read September 2026. German/Ashkenazic cook; other Czech/Slovak personal-name and Polish nickname origins. Not an occupation or religion assigned to Margaretha."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_MUELLER_NAME",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Mueller",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/mueller?geo-lang=en-US",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 second edition read September 2026. German, Ashkenazic and Dutch occupational miller; Mueller/Müller, sometimes Miller or Muller in US. No branch occupation inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HENRIETTE_MUELLER_COMPILED",
      "title": "Compiled Henriette Charlotte Heinderike Mueller profile",
      "type": "aggregated public-tree profile",
      "url": "https://yourroots.com/tree/person/henriette-mueller-1829-1892--agfkxtmzpohjq",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Exact unusual full name and 1829–1892 dates, spouse Henry Fricke/Fricka. Reports Hanover birth, St Louis 1860/1870, Guadalupe 1880, Belmont Texas death. No parents; duplicate child entries. Listed Texas death certificates 1903–1982 cannot be assumed to be her own 1892 certificate; original records not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_KOCH_WINTERLINGEN",
      "title": "Weigel: Koch families of Winterlingen, muster-list references",
      "type": "published genealogy citing muster rolls",
      "url": "https://genealogie-nordwuerttemberg.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/AL-ERHARDT-HILSENBECK-version-2.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page 254 visually read September 2026: Caspar Koch, Winterlingen, age55 in1523; cites Zahawi Musterungslisten Amt Balingen p153. Preceding page/entry5282 reports Hans Koch innkeeper in1597/1600/1603 musters. Neither is connected to Margaretha; original muster manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_BRASSINGTON_GUILD_MARRIAGE_REVIEW",
      "title": "Guild of One-Name Studies: Brassington marriage results reviewed",
      "type": "contributed marriage index",
      "url": "https://one-name.org/global-marriages-search-results/?surname=Brassington",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Displayed surname results read September 2026. No identified marriage of the Ranton1787/Haughton1841 couple. John Brassington/Margaret Brian July1871 Caverswall and John/Margaret Thacker1883 Radford are much later couples; neither identifies this mother of a child baptized1787. Contributed index not exhaustive parish coverage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WILLIAMS_NAME",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Williams",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/Williams",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 second edition read September2026. English William with genitival or later added s; also common Wales; absorbed cognates including Dutch Willems in North America. Conditional background only."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_MARLOW_NATHAN",
      "title": "Nathan McNew: Elizabeth, wife of William Marlow",
      "type": "compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/a/9/e6cce80c90d5a2b94f1fafac59a.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full HTML downloaded/read September2026. Name Elizabeth without maiden surname; birth about1650 Charles County; death AFTER1683, not in1683. Husband William before1636-before1683; Edward1666 and other children. Cites Michael Marshall Early Colonial Settlers, not a specific original event."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_MARLOW_CONFLICT",
      "title": "Cromer/Russell/Buck/Pratt tree: William Marlow and Elizabeth Williams",
      "type": "compiled public tree",
      "url": "https://www.genealogieonline.nl/en/family-tree-cromer-russell-buck-pratt/P18082.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September2026. Elizabeth1627–1710, William1623–1700, marriages1648England and1666CharlesMaryland; children1645/1649/about1650. Conflicts with the about1650 Elizabeth candidate and later child set. No original marriage record inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_GLAN_ARCHION",
      "title": "Archion: Offenbach am Glan parish register catalogue",
      "type": "archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/nordrhein-westfalen/archiv-der-evangelischen-kirche-im-rheinland/offenbach-am-glan",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full catalogue HTML read 16 September 2026. Earliest listed baptisms 1697 and 1728, continuous 1731–1798; marriages 1732–1798. This catalogue does not show a marriage volume covering 1690/91. No register images inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_KUEHN_SOURCES",
      "title": "Clemens-Maria Kühn: sources for Offenbach-Hundheim family research",
      "type": "family book source inventory",
      "url": "https://www.offenbach-hundheim.familienforschung-kuehn.de/index.php?s=6",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full HTML read 16 September 2026. Catholic marriages 1691–1696 then discontinuous coverage; Protestant sources include Offenbach 1731–1839 and Karl Pfleger St. Julian family book 1634–1798. Family entries and originals not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_OFFENBACH_EV_SURNAMES",
      "title": "Clemens-Maria Kühn: Protestant surname index, Offenbach am Glan",
      "type": "family book surname index",
      "url": "https://www.offenbach-hundheim.familienforschung-kuehn.de/index.php?s=5",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full displayed index read 16 September 2026. Explicitly includes Gabel, Reinmüller and Rheinmüller. No given names, dates, family numbers or linked entries displayed. Catholic index s=4 also read: Gabel and Göbel present, Rheinmüller/Reinmüller not listed. The latter is not an exhaustive parish search."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_RHEINMUELLER_MAINZ_1606",
      "title": "Mainz deed of 2 May 1606: Jakob Bardt, Rheinmüller, as guardian",
      "type": "digitized archive catalogue abstract",
      "url": "https://www.deutsche-digitale-bibliothek.de/item/33LMMSRMGOXLIZD7ML7KJIVUKHFUWP4F",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed archive abstract read 16 September 2026; direct page returned a bot challenge, and original deed not inspected. Names Jakob Bardt as Rheinmüller alongside carpenter Jakob Weißweck, guardians of the children of deceased carpenter Velten Hardtman. Evidence for occupational usage, not a Rheinmüller surname or kinship to Hans Conrad."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_JUUL",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Juul",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/juul",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 edition: Danish and Norwegian variant of Juhl. Read 16 September 2026; surname entry, not the unrelated generated first-name text."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_JUHL",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Juhl",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/juhl",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 edition read 16 September 2026. Scandinavian seasonal nickname from Old Norse jól; North German adoption; separate Germanized Slavic gol formation. Not a proof of any particular family origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DBL_FREDERIK_GABEL",
      "title": "C. O. Bøggild-Andersen: Frederik Gabel, Dansk Biografisk Leksikon",
      "type": "scholarly biography",
      "url": "https://biografiskleksikon.lex.dk/Frederik_Gabel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 16 September 2026. Frederik about 1645–1708, son of Christoffer Gabel and Ermegaard Badenhaupt. Married Christiania 25 April 1671 Anne Cathrine Juul, born Stockholm 5 June 1655, buried Copenhagen St. Petri 24 August 1707, daughter of Ove Juul and Kirstine Urne. References older historical works. No original parish image inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_NBL_FREDERIK_GABEL",
      "title": "Steinar Supphellen: Frederik Gabel, Norsk biografisk leksikon",
      "type": "scholarly biography",
      "url": "https://nbl.snl.no/Frederik_Gabel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 16 September 2026. Confirms wife Anne Cathrine Juul 1655–1707, marriage 25 April 1671 and parents Ove Juul/Kirstine Urne. Corroborative scholarly summary; may share earlier biographical sources with DBL."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_FAMILYSEARCH_JUUL_CLUSTER_20260916",
      "title": "FamilySearch Hans Jacob Gabel: Juul parent cluster, September 2026 review",
      "type": "collaborative tree review",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/LC52-XL3/johann-jacob-gabel-1670-1707",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page read 16 September 2026: brief biography names Fredrick Gabel and Anne Catherine Juul; siblings include Frederik Wilhelm Von Gabel, Ovida Christine Frederiksdatter Von Gabel and Kristoffer Gabel. Narrative says Maria Margretha Rheinmuellers married 9 January 1691, while displayed timeline has Anna Catharina Kirchner married 3 February 1693. Underlying 28 sources not inspected; parent links GMXG-M3S and GMXY-MR9 did not resolve through browser fetch. Clear evidence of a Scandinavian family cluster attached to a Palatinate candidate, not independent proof of parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WALKER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Walker",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/walker",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 surname entry read September 2026. English, chiefly North and Midlands, and Scottish occupational fuller, from wealcere; also other formations in full entry. No personal occupation or origin inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LUCY_MCNEW_DEED_INDEX",
      "title": "Washington County, Virginia, Deed Book 5, 1811–1814: index",
      "type": "published deed index",
      "url": "https://genealogyresources.org/Index-Wdb5.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded, text extracted and PDF page 9 / printed 124 visually inspected 16 September 2026. William Walker from William and Lucy (Walker) McNew of Claiborne County, Tennessee, reference 116. Parentheses may be editorial. Original deed and full abstract not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LUCY_WALKER_LAUREL_GRANT",
      "title": "June White: Miscellaneous Southwest Virginia Land Grants, John Walker and partners",
      "type": "land grant abstract",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/miscellaneous-southwest-virginia-land-grants/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full HTML inspected 16 September 2026. 3 January 1796, John Walker with William Walker, William Golloher/Nancy, William Cammack/Elizabeth, Margaret, Lucy, Elay and James Walker; 186 acres Laurel fork of Holstein, Washington County; Grants No.36 p.251. Original grant not inspected. Group is named but this abstract does not itself state Lucy’s father."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LAUREL_WALKER_FAMILY_REVIEW",
      "title": "Walker in Washington County, Virginia: Laurel Fork family and McNew deed",
      "type": "compiled family research with record extracts",
      "url": "https://familypedia.fandom.com/wiki/Walker_in_Washington_County%2C_Virginia",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed text inspected 16 September 2026; full direct page returned 403. Attributes Lucy McNew to William Walker of Laurel Fork, deceased winter 1789/90, and Elizabeth; quotes Susan Gordon-Wilde deed notes. 16 September 1811 heading / signed and sealed 18 August 1812, DB5 pp116–117, McNew couple to William Walker, $200 for 55 acres. Quoted 11 October 1796 survey p475 calls Lucy and siblings coheirs of deceased William. Report distinguishes this family from Albemarle William/Elizabeth Clayton. Original records not inspected; copying/source dependence possible."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_FRANKLIN_TN_CREATION",
      "title": "John Abernathy Smith: Franklin County, Tennessee Encyclopedia",
      "type": "county history",
      "url": "https://tennesseeencyclopedia.net/entries/franklin-county/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 16 September 2026. Franklin County created 1807. The Nathan McNew marriage location Franklin County, Tennessee in 1801 is anachronistic as a contemporary jurisdiction; may be retrospective geography or error, not disproof of event."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_NENZENHEIM_LAELKB_CATALOGUE",
      "title": "LAELKB: Nenzenheim parish holdings, catalogue of 22 July 2025",
      "type": "official archive inventory",
      "url": "https://www.archiv-elkb.de/system/files/dateien/kirchenbuecher_im_laelkb_22_7_25.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded and page 19 visually inspected 16 September 2026. Nenzenheim signature477, deanery Markt Einersheim, baptisms1592–2021, marriages1616–2021, burials1591–2021, indexes1591–2021; Verkartung (Vorbest.), digitized volumes1–9,22–30. Ranges do not imply uninterrupted coverage or access to all recent records. Original parish pages not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_RADLER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Radler",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/radler",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 edition read 16 September 2026: German, also Rädler, habitational from Radel/Radelau/Radlau, with examples in Bavaria and Austria. Not an occupational inference from modern German cyclist or drink."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_NENZENHEIM_MULFINGER_1905",
      "title": "Transcription of the 1905 Middle Franconian official gazette: Nenzenheim",
      "type": "user-transcribed official gazette list",
      "url": "https://forum.ahnenforschung.net/forum/thread/45174-k%C3%B6niglich-bayerisches-amtsblatt-von-mittelfranken-1905/?pageNo=2",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Post24 by Pendolino, 6 October2010, read 16 September2026. Ehrenzeichen list, districtScheinfeld, includes GeorgAdamMulfinger and GeorgAndreasMulfinger, both Ökonom at Nenzenheim. Original1905issue not inspected; no specific award title inferred. Later spelling evidence, not an ancestor extension."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_MOLLFINGER_NAME_REVIEW",
      "title": "Mollfinger surname and Nenzenheim roots review, 16 September 2026",
      "type": "research audit",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Exact Mollfinger, Mollfinger/Radler and local variant searches found the compiled pedigree and later Nenzenheim Mulfinger examples, but no reliable etymology for the exact surname or an earlier named ancestor. FamilySearch Mulfinger page served an English Mulliner cross-reference; not accepted for this German branch. No original register sweep performed; details in research/family_roots_mollfinger_radler_20260916/RESEARCH.md."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_PETERS",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Peters",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/peters",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 edition read 16 September 2026. English/Scottish/Dutch/North German patronymic Peter; Irish translation Mac Pheadair and Americanized cognates also listed. General background, not Robert’s personal origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_FRESHFORD_FREEREG_COVERAGE",
      "title": "FreeREG: Freshford transcription coverage",
      "type": "database coverage inventory",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/freereg_contents/53cd4980eca9ebee4f008cdc/place?locale=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full HTML downloaded/read 16 September 2026.6816 entries1600–1906, only one total1690–1699;140 in1700–1709 including30marriages. This is database coverage, not a claim that original registers are lost. Earlier decades also uneven."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_FRESHFORD_RATE_REVIEW",
      "title": "Freshford historical rate lists: review for the Peters family",
      "type": "transcribed local fiscal records",
      "url": "https://www.freshford.com/rates_comparison.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full comparison1664/1700/1705/1715/1734/1766 and individual1700.htm,1705.htm downloaded/read16September2026. No Peters/Petre surname entries found; Peter Fisher and Peter Jones are given-name matches, not surname matches. Property/ratepayer lists are not complete resident censuses. Heading1664 differs from home-page1666; no date assumption made from navigation label."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LINDNER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Lindner",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lindner",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The 2022 dictionary explains Lindner as a name derived from places called Lindenau, Linde, Linden or Linda. It also identifies a separate Ashkenazic ornamental formation from the German word for a lime tree. Neither explanation identifies Michael’s own ancestral home."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LINDNER_NENZENHEIM_BARN_1824",
      "title": "Johann Heinrich Lindner of Nenzenheim: barn-building application, 1824",
      "type": "official archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.gda.bayern.de/gvl/archive.xhtml?id=Vz++++++0BFB2381-6147-48B3-BF58-6CF3897A1754",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staatsarchiv Nürnberg, Landgericht ä.O. Uffenheim, Bauakten 262. The catalogue describes a 1824 application by Johann Heinrich Lindner of Nenzenheim to build a new barn, with a building plan but no site plan. The archival file itself has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LINDER_QUARTERLY_CATALOGUE",
      "title": "FamilySearch catalogue: The Linder Quarterly",
      "type": "library catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/fr/search/catalog/48711",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The catalogue lists the combined spring/summer 2013 issue, nos. 172–173, cited for Harold Linder’s study of the ancestors of the immigrant Simon Lindner/Linder. The article itself has not been inspected in this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_FRIEDLI_WERREN_SAANEN",
      "title": "Emanuel Friedli: Saanen surname history, pp. 367–368",
      "type": "historical linguistic study",
      "url": "https://projekt-gutenberg.org/authors/emanuel-friedli/books/emanuel-friedli-baernduetsch-als-spiegel-bernischen-volkstums-siebenter-band-saanen/chapter/15/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Bärndütsch als Spiegel bernischen Volkstums, volume 7, Saanen (1927). Discusses Wehren/Werren formations, Weren in Saanen and Gsteig in 1607, and Hans Währen at Oberport in 1687. The linguistic explanation is the author’s interpretation; it does not supply Salome’s parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_GSTEIG_LINDER_SALOME_MARRIAGE_1605",
      "title": "Gsteig bei Gstaad: Marty Linder and Salome, marriage 26 May 1605",
      "type": "original parish register image",
      "url": "https://www.query.sta.be.ch/detail.aspx?ID=222285",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Staatsarchiv Bern, K Gsteig b. Gstaad 1, manuscript page 305, PDF page 155. The May 1605 entry names Marty Linder and Salome; her surname resembles Werro in the handwriting, corresponding to Werren in the compiled pedigree. No parents are named. The image was visually inspected on 18 September 2026. Public PDF: https://www.query.sta.be.ch/Dateien/18/D94948.pdf"
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SAANEN_REGISTER_COVERAGE",
      "title": "GHGB: Saanen parish-register transcription coverage",
      "type": "genealogical society catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.ghgb.ch/angebot-kirchenbuecher-s.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Saanen baptisms from 1557, marriages from 1563, baptism volumes covering 1581–1587 and 1587–1611, and marriages 1588–1611. The catalogue was inspected, not the offered transcriptions."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ANNE_CARTWRIGHT_USER_IDENTIFICATION",
      "title": "Anne Cartwright: family identification preserved in the tree",
      "type": "user-supplied family identification",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Matthew identified Anne Cartwright, FamilySearch LH5P-YMZ, with George Handley as parents of Sampson Handley. The saved profile reports birth in 1691 at Draycott in the Moors and death on 26 August 1758 at Milwich. The underlying baptism and burial entries have not been inspected in this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CARTWRIGHT",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Cartwright",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/cartwright",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 edition. English occupational name, particularly Midlands and northern England, for a maker of carts. Also records a separate variant of the Dutch-origin surname Courtright."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SPRS_DRAYCOTT_DILHORNE",
      "title": "Staffordshire Parish Registers Society: Draycott and Dilhorne publications",
      "type": "publication catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.sprs.org.uk/publicat.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Draycott-in-the-Moors, St Margaret, baptisms, marriages and burials 1669–1900, published 2015; Dilhorne All Saints 1560–1812, published 2019. Catalogue coverage does not establish any individual entry or uninterrupted survival."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DOROTHY_CARTWRIGHT_BROUGH_1684",
      "title": "Brough family research: Dorothy Cartwright of Draycott, marriage 1684",
      "type": "record-cited compiled family history",
      "url": "https://www.broughfamily.org/families/global_brough_database/aqwn28.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports Richard Brough of Doveridge marrying Dorothy Cartwright of Draycott by licence at All Saints, Dilhorne, on 18 January 1684, citing FamilySearch film 7619343. The original image and year-style convention have not been independently checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_HANNA_FENTON_1674",
      "title": "Sheffield parish register, Part III, p. 140: Hanna Fenton baptism",
      "type": "published parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/parishregisterof68shef/page/140/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Yorkshire Parish Register Society vol. LXVIII, edited Charles Drury and T. Walter Hall, 1921. Printed page 140 records Hanna, daughter of William Fenton, baptized 27 June 1674; the year begins on page 139. Scanned transcription inspected, not the original manuscript. The entry supplies no mother or birth date."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FENTON",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Fenton",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/fenton",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. Describes English habitational origins and separate Scottish, Irish and American surname histories."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DFHS_RICHARD_FENTON_1554",
      "title": "North Lees and Richard Fenton, Derbyshire Family History Society, March 2022",
      "type": "local historical study",
      "url": "https://www.dfhs.org.uk/filestore/2022_Mar_195.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Pages 15–19; page 16 reports Richard Fenton among the original Sheffield capital burgesses under the 1554 charter. A secondary historical account; the charter itself has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_STIRNET_FENTON_HANDLEY",
      "title": "Stirnet: Fenton and Handley compiled pedigrees",
      "type": "compiled pedigree",
      "url": "https://stirnet.com/genie/data/british/ff/fenton03.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports Hannah Fenton, died July 1740, daughter of William Fenton of Sheffield, marrying Thomas Handley on 4 September 1690. Gives William a 4 June 1643 baptism and 3 August 1696 burial. These dates and the proposed older generation require record verification."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SHEFFIELD_WYLD_1573_1616",
      "title": "Sheffield parish register, Part I: Wyld marriages and Wild baptism",
      "type": "published parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/parishregisterof58shef",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Yorkshire Parish Register Society volume LVIII, printed pages 187 and 125. Scans inspected: John Wyld and Margaret Beighton married 12 January 1572/73; Ralph Wyld and Cicily Beighton married 20 July 1573; George, son of William Wild, baptized 13 April 1616. Original handwritten entries have not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILDE",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Wilde",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/wilde",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. Wilde is a variant of Wild in English, Irish and German use, and of De Wilde in Dutch."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_STIRNET_HALL_CARR_WILD",
      "title": "Stirnet: Wild of Hall Carr",
      "type": "compiled pedigree",
      "url": "https://www.stirnet.com/genie/data/british/ww/wylde2.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Hall Carr section names John Wild as father of George, whose daughter Hannah married James Handley. Cites Joseph Hunter, Familiae minorum gentium, volume 2, MS272, pages 665 onward. This is a competing household identification, not proof that the George baptized to William in 1616 belonged to Hall Carr."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SANDON_HANDLEY_JOHNSON_1756",
      "title": "Sandon All Saints marriage index: Handley–Johnson, 1756",
      "type": "online parish marriage index",
      "url": "https://www.tinstaafl.co.uk/eandwhmi/staffordshire/church%20pages/sandon.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry 7 is indexed as 12 September 1756, Samuel Handley, single, of Milwich, and Ruth Johnson, single. The groom’s forename differs from Sampson in this tree. Original register inspection is needed to resolve the reading and identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_JOHNSON",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Johnson",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/johnson",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. English and Scottish patronymic from John plus son; also describes related Scandinavian and other European surname forms."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SPRS_SANDON",
      "title": "Staffordshire Parish Registers Society: Sandon publication",
      "type": "publication catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.sprs.org.uk/publicat.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Sandon, All Saints, registers 1635–1900, published 2014. The publication covers the period of Ruth’s reported baptism; an individual baptism has not been established from the catalogue."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SANDON_JOHNSON_MEMORIALS",
      "title": "Sandon All Saints memorial inscriptions: John and Ruth Johnson",
      "type": "memorial transcription",
      "url": "https://places.wishful-thinking.org.uk/STS/Sandon/MIs.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entries D30–D31 report John Johnson, died 16 July 1769 aged 63; wife Ruth, died 17 April 1770 aged 56; and son Joseph of Sandon, died 19 March 1761 aged 16. The transcription also contains a chronologically problematic date for a daughter Elizabeth; that entry needs checking against the stone."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_BAGNALL_BAGNOLD",
      "title": "Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland: Bagnall and Bagnold",
      "type": "scholarly surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://api.pageplace.de/preview/DT0400.9780192527479_A30390808/preview-9780192527479_A30390808.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2016, page 118, scanned publisher preview. Lists Bagnold among Bagnall variants and cites early Staffordshire bearers. Underlying medieval records and IGI entries were not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BAGNALL",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Bagnall",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/bagnall",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. Explains the Staffordshire place-name origins and later Irish establishment of the surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ATWOOD_BAGNALL_CANDIDATES",
      "title": "Atwood family compilation: Roger Bagnall and proposed siblings",
      "type": "compiled family tree",
      "url": "https://sites.rootsmagic.com/AtwoodFamily/site/individual.php?p=187549",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists a Thomas James Bagnall and Marjorie Willatt as parents, with two Isabell entries among the children. This is a family-reconstruction lead; the duplicated identities and supporting records require checking."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MELLOR",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Mellor",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/mellor",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. English habitational name from places in Lancashire, West Yorkshire and Derbyshire, with an ancient British bare-hill place-name formation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WILCOCKSON_YELDERSLEY_MELLOR",
      "title": "Wilcocksons Unwrapped: Mellors of Yeldersley",
      "type": "local family-history research",
      "url": "https://wilcocksonsunwrapped.home.blog/category/1610-john-wilcockson/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports Edward Mellor of Yeldersley buried at Ashbourne on 8 May 1567. Also discusses an Idridgehay Mellor will and local property connections. The original burial entry has not been inspected in this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DARG_ASHBOURNE_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Derbyshire Ancestral Research Group: church register holdings",
      "type": "register holdings catalogue",
      "url": "https://darg.gukutils.org.uk/CERegisters.shtml",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Ashbourne baptism transcripts covering 1538–1884. This is a holdings guide, not proof of an individual baptism or complete continuous coverage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_POWYS_BERRIEW_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Powys Archives: Berriew parish records catalogue",
      "type": "archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/parish-nonconformist_church-in-wales_Montgomeryshire-M-EP-1-8.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "M/EP/3, catalogue page 2 (PDF page 15): marriages M/EP/3/R/A/12, 1813–1837, and /13, 1837–1907; marriage index M/EP/3/I/ML/1, 1837–1907; banns M/EP/3/R/A/25, 1834–1867. Catalogue page inspected; no individual marriage entry verified."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BATZER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Batzer",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/batzer",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022; Swabian nickname derivation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LINNARTZ_BATZER",
      "title": "Kaspar Linnartz, Unsere Familiennamen (1958): Batzer",
      "type": "surname dictionary excerpt",
      "url": "https://forebears.io/de/surnames/batzer",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry reproduced by Forebears; alternative occupational explanation. Original volume not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HINK",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Hink",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hink",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. German and Dutch personal-name derivations; not an identification of Ursula’s particular surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HINKER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Hinker",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hinker",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. Describes Hinker as a derivative of Hink."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ARCHION_NEUFFEN_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Archion: Neuffen parish register catalogue",
      "type": "archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/baden-wuerttemberg/evangelisches-archiv-baden-und-wuerttemberg-wuerttemberg/dekanat-nuertingen/neuffen/75465",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists baptism volume 1, 1634–1750; marriage volume 8, 1634–1785; burial volume 12, 1634–1737. Catalogue inspected; register images not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_YOURROOTS_HENRIETTE_MUELLER",
      "title": "YourRoots: Henriette Charlotte Heinderike Mueller",
      "type": "compiled online family tree",
      "url": "https://yourroots.com/tree/person/henriette-mueller-1829-1892--agfkxtmzpohjq",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Distinctive spouse-name match, but conflicting Henry dates and multiple Henry children. Listed events are not independent original-record verification."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ST_MARCUS_HENRIETTE_FRICKE_1893",
      "title": "St. Marcus Church, St. Louis: Henriette Fricke burial transcription",
      "type": "church register transcription",
      "url": "https://stlouis.genealogyvillage.com/Buecher6.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry 2257 identifies Henriette née Schacht, widow of Heinrich, who had died ten years before her March 1893 burial. Original register not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_JUNG_OFFENBACH_GABEL_1694",
      "title": "Rudi Jung: Catholic family book, Offenbach and neighbouring parishes (1992)",
      "type": "published parish family reconstruction",
      "url": "https://wgff.de/digibib/Files_Free_Jung/Kirchenbollenbach.u.a.rk%201682-1900-9131.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page 137, family 559, inspected visually: Johannes Gabel, unnamed wife, son Johann Georg dated 10 October 1694; sponsor Johann Georg Bauer, miller at Lauterecken. This entry does not name either Maria Margaretha or a Rheinmüller parent. Original church register not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WATERHOUSE",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Waterhouse",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/waterhouse",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. English topographic surname, especially Yorkshire, Lancashire and the Midlands."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WATERHOUSE_ASHBOURNE_1582_INDEX",
      "title": "Waterhouse marriage compilation: Ashbourne, 10 June 1582",
      "type": "compiled marriage index",
      "url": "https://powys.org/lge/waterhouse/tables/w-hse_marrs.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Johannes Gravener Or Waterhouse and Alicia Sherwyn at St Oswald, Ashbourne. Reciprocal bride and groom rows describe one event. Original entry not inspected; the reason for the alternative surname is unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DARG_ASHBOURNE_REGISTER_HISTORY",
      "title": "Derbyshire Ancestral Research Group: Ashbourne registers and memorials",
      "type": "local genealogical society guide",
      "url": "https://darg.gukutils.org.uk/AshbourneMIs.shtml",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes pre-1604 register entries as early seventeenth-century copies, with many gaps before 1655."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MORRALL",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Morrall",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/morrall",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022, as presented by Ancestry. Habitational explanations, especially Staffordshire and Warwickshire; more than one possible place of origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_BUILDWAS_ANNE_MORRALL_1778",
      "title": "Buildwas parish register transcript: Anne Morrall marriage, 1778",
      "type": "published parish transcript reproduced online",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/Buildwas.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Thomas Fletcher and Anne Morrall married 17 September 1778. Event appears in both chronological and marriage sections of the transcription; not two marriages or independent modern confirmations. Original register not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_OAK_BOWERY_MARY_MCNEW_SURNAMES",
      "title": "More Oak Bowery Families: McNew family outline",
      "type": "compiled family history; indexed excerpt",
      "url": "https://publiclibrary.cc/digitalcollections/files/original/12/13662/More-Oak-Bowery-Families.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed excerpt distinguishes William’s wife Mary Berry from Daniel Shadrack’s wife Mary Clemons in the next generation. Full document and underlying records were not inspected. This is a possible explanation of conflicting trees, not proof of either maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GREEN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Green",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/green",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. English topographic, nickname and personal-name explanations; the dictionary also distinguishes origins in other languages. These are alternatives for surname formation, not a pedigree for Ann."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WROCKWARDINE_GREEN_HOUSEHOLDS",
      "title": "Wrockwardine parish register transcription: Green and Greene households",
      "type": "published parish transcript reproduced online",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/Wrockwardine.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The February baptism appears under the year beginning in March 1606: expressed here as 11 February 1606/7. The 1788 marriage is on printed page 289. Full online transcription inspected; original manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SHROPSHIRE_DAWLEY_HOLDINGS",
      "title": "Shropshire Archives: Dawley local-history sources",
      "type": "archive holdings guide",
      "url": "https://www.shropshire.gov.uk/media/3240/dawley.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Guide lists Dawley Magna parish-register holdings covering the late eighteenth century and the 1806 marriage period. Holdings establish a route for further research, not the contents of an individual entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CROWTHER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Crowther",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/crowther",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. English Crowder variant, especially Yorkshire; a possible separate Scottish McGrouther origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CROWDER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Crowder",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/crowder",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. Occupational name for a player of the croud; possible Welsh crythor origin in Wales and the border counties. Crowther is explicitly included as a form."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_POWYS_CROWTHER_GRIFFITHS_1826",
      "title": "Powys Archives RD/VV/16/16: Crowther and Griffiths rights in Glan-Camlo, 1826",
      "type": "archive catalogue of deeds",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/deposited-misc_family-estate-legal_Radnorshire_H-Vaughan-Vaughan-Co-Solicitors-of-Builth-R-D-VV.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalogue PDF pages 31–32 visually inspected. This is an archival abstract, not inspection of the original deed. The two women named Margaret have different roles: Walter Griffiths’s widow and his sister, John Crowther’s wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_JOSHUA_CROWTHER_USER_CORRECTION",
      "title": "Matthew’s correction: Joshua Crowther, father of Walter",
      "type": "user confirmation preserved from existing notes",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The existing person and parent-link notes record Matthew’s explicit correction of the earlier Josa reading to Joshua, father of Walter Crowther. This citation preserves the recorded confirmation; it is not a newly recovered transcript or image."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_POWYS_CEFNLLYS_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Powys Archives R/EP/18: Cefnllys parish registers",
      "type": "archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/parish-nonconformist_church-in-wales_Radnorshire-R-EP.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalogue PDF page 49 visually inspected. R/EP/18/R/A/3 covers baptisms 1813–1901; /5 includes banns 1754–1823. These are holdings descriptions, not inspection of Anne’s entry or the couple’s banns."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CASWELL",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Caswell",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/caswell",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. Habitational surname with several English place-name origins; no particular origin established for Hannah."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_NORTON_CASWELL_NEWLAND_INTENTIONS_1721",
      "title": "Vital Records of Norton: Hannah Caswell and John Newland, intentions, 1721",
      "type": "published vital-record transcription, indexed excerpt",
      "url": "https://ldsgenealogy.com/MA/books/Vital-records-of-Norton-Massachusetts-to-the-year-1850-part-16.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page 208, Norton marriages: intentions recorded 5 August 1721. Indexed text inspected; original town register and page image not inspected. An intention is not a completed-marriage record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HANNAH_CASWELL_PROFILE_PROVENANCE",
      "title": "Hannah Caswell: provenance of retained family-profile claim",
      "type": "user-supplied profile preserved from existing notes",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Existing person SRC_HANNAH_CASWELL_ABT1709 records a user-supplied profile identifying Hannah as Mary Ulandt Newland’s mother. The current database has no parent or spouse edge for Hannah. This source preserves the claim without presenting it as a new record discovery."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_CORNISH",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Cornish",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/cornish",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. Regional-origin name referring to Cornwall; Middle English Cornish/Cornysh and Normanized Corneys. Not evidence of Henry’s own birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_BENJAMIN_CORNISH_WILL_1836",
      "title": "Benjamin Cornish of Trudoxhill: will dated 1836, proved 1841",
      "type": "published probate abstract",
      "url": "https://fromeresearch.co.uk/ds-archive/property/property-wills/pcc-wills-of-testators-from-frome-and-district-1800%E2%80%9157/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full online abstract inspected. Cites PROB 11/1942, q.151–200; signed 9 February 1836 and proved 4 March 1841. Original will image not inspected. The nephew Henry is a record-defined comparison candidate, not an identified ancestor."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HANNY_CORNISH_LIMPLEY_MARRIAGE_LEAD",
      "title": "Hanny family discussion: reported Limpley Stoke marriage venue",
      "type": "community family-history account, indexed excerpt",
      "url": "https://genealogy-specialists.com/threads/was-he-a-bigamist-or-not.9070/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed passage reports the same named couple and 31 March 1838 wedding date at Limpley Stoke. Full discussion and original marriage image not inspected. Its other dates are not adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_TOMPSON",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Tompson",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/tompson",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. English variant of Thompson."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_THOMPSON",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Thompson",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/thompson",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. Patronymic from Tom; distinguishes the usual English and Scottish spellings and other origins outside England."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_TOMPSON_HINTON_WOLVERHAMPTON_1747",
      "title": "Wolverhampton marriages: Thomas Tompson and Mary Hinton, 1747",
      "type": "published parish-register transcript",
      "url": "https://www.staffordshirecountystudies.uk/Wolverhampton%20Parish%20Register%2C%20Marriages%201735-1776.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page 45, also PDF page 45, visually inspected. Entry under 1747: 29 December, Thomas Tompson and Mary Hinton. Original manuscript not inspected. This earlier couple is not identified with Esther’s parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_ALKIN",
      "title": "Oxford surname dictionaries: Alkin and Alkins, reproduced by Geneanet",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://en.geneanet.org/surnames/ALKIN",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full entries inspected. Alkin is a Middle English pet form of names including Alan, Alexander and Alice. Alkins is an English variant with an added s. The page attributes entries to Oxford family-name dictionaries."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_SAMPSON_ALKYN_UTTOXETER_PETITION_1656",
      "title": "Sampson Alkyn endorses Mathew Bakewell’s petition, July 1656",
      "type": "scholarly transcription of archival petition",
      "url": "https://www.civilwarpetitions.ac.uk/petition/the-first-petition-of-mathew-bakewell-of-uttoxeter-staffordshire-july-1656/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Civil War Petitions: original-spelling and modernised transcripts inspected. Staffordshire Record Office, Q/SR/295, fol. 23. Sampson Alkyn appears among inhabitants of Uttoxeter certifying the petition. The original image has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_REDFERN_UTTOXETER_BAGNOLD_1553",
      "title": "Francis Redfern: Uttoxeter church-goods inventory, 1552–1553",
      "type": "local history reproducing historical document",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/historyantiquiti00redf/page/204/mode/2up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "History and antiquities of the town and neighbourhood of Uttoxeter, page 204 (PDF page 222), visually inspected. Reproduces an inventory naming Raffe Bagnold among parishioners involved in selling a silver cross. The original inventory manuscript has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HODNETT_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Hodnett",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=HODNETT",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch entry attributes definition to Patrick Hanks, 2003/2006. Place-derived Shropshire surname; probable pleasant-valley place meaning."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_AINGELL_GUILD",
      "title": "Guild of One-Name Studies: Angell and Aingell",
      "type": "surname study citing Oxford dictionary",
      "url": "https://one-name.org/name_profile/angell/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Registers Aingell among Angell variants and cites Oxford 2016 for English/Norman nickname origin. The study is at an early stage; its modern distribution is not evidence of Martha’s ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_MUNSLOW_1786",
      "title": "Munslow register: Benjamin Hodnet and Martha Aingell, 1786",
      "type": "published parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/Munslow.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Web text inspected, printed page232. Marriage11May1786: groom of Diddlebury; witnesses JohnLewis and SusannahTipton. Bride’s prior marital status not supplied. Original manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_AINGELL_DIDDLEBURY",
      "title": "Diddlebury registers: Hodnet and Aingell households",
      "type": "published parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/Diddlebury.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Web text inspected: Benjamin/Martha baptisms1787–1806; WilliamAngell/JudithTyler marriage30Nov1693; Martha daughterWilliam/Anne baptism2Nov1783. Original manuscripts not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HODNET_ABDON_1745",
      "title": "Abdon register: Joan Hodnet baptism, 1745",
      "type": "published parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/Abdon.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "25March1745: Joan daughterJohnHodnet and Mary. Original manuscript not inspected. No relationship to Benjamin established."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_GEORGE_HODNET_STANTON_LACY_1797",
      "title": "Stanton Lacy register: George Hodnet and Ann Smith, 1797",
      "type": "published parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/StantonLacy.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "19November1797 marriage and15September1798 Sarah baptism to George/Ann. A competing adult household; not automatically the George baptized1787. Original manuscripts not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LAMB",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Lamb",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lamb",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022. Distinguishes English personal-name, nickname and occupational origins, and separate Irish and German formations."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_KERRY_LAMB_SETTLEMENT_1787",
      "title": "Kerry overseers accounts: John Lamb settlement examination, 1787",
      "type": "archive transcription",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/digitised-and-transcribed-records_Kerry-Overseers-account-book_M_EP_8_O_RT_6_bi.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Powys Archives M/EP/8/O/RT/6, PDF page 209, visually inspected. John Thomas accounts for 1787: warrant and examination concerning John Lamb settlement, 3s, and journey/expenses 4s6d. This is an expense entry, not the examination text."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_KERRY_LAMB_APPRENTICE_1782",
      "title": "Kerry vestry: John Williams apprenticed to John Lamb of the Court, 1782",
      "type": "archive transcription",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/digitised-and-transcribed-records_Kerry-Vestry-minutes-and-accounts_1772-1874_M_EP_8_V_VM_2_bi.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Powys Archives M/EP/8/V/VM/2, page 513, visually inspected. Vestry resolution 7 September 1782. Does not supply master’s age or wife."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LAMB_REMOVAL_1790",
      "title": "Montgomeryshire Quarter Sessions: Lamb family removal, 1790",
      "type": "archive transcription",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/digitised-and-transcribed-records_Montgomeryshire-Quarter-Sessions_session-rolls_Mont_QS_1790-1799_bi.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "90T47, heading PDF page 39, order page 40 visually inspected. 17 May 1790: Berriew to Kerry, John Lamb, wife Elizabeth, daughter Elizabeth four, son John two. Legal settlement does not by itself establish birthplace. Original manuscripts not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_LAMBE_ABERHAFESP_1729",
      "title": "Montgomeryshire Quarter Sessions: Elizabeth Lambe, 1729",
      "type": "archive transcription",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/digitised-and-transcribed-records_Montgomeryshire-Quarter-Sessions_session-rolls-and-order-book_Mont_QS_1707-1729_bi.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "29T13, recognizance 19 June 1729, PDF page 156 visually inspected. John Griffith of Aberhafesb, yeoman, to answer the overseers concerning Elizabeth Lambe’s recently born child; Theodore Jones of Aberhafesb provides surety. Child’s name and sex, Elizabeth’s parents and exact residence are not supplied. Original manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ANNE_LAMB_KERRY_RELIEF_1774",
      "title": "Kerry overseers accounts: Anne Lamb relief, 1774",
      "type": "archive transcription",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/digitised-and-transcribed-records_Kerry-Overseers-account-book_M_EP_8_O_RT_6_bi.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "M/EP/8/O/RT/6, PDF page 64, visually inspected: John Griffiths accounts headed for the year 1774 record 13 shillings paid to Anne Lamb on five occasions. Her age, husband and birth surname are not supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ANN_SHAW_WAKEFIELD_ACCOUNT_LEAD",
      "title": "FamilySearch Ralph Shaw profile: cited Wakefield estate account",
      "type": "compiled profile with archival citation; record not inspected",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/L8C7-7PT/ralph-john-shaw-1635-1711",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Search-indexed source list inspected 19 September 2026. Names an account of Ralph Shaw and Anne his wife, executrix of Thomas Wakefield, Inventories and Accounts 20:194. A specific retrieval lead, not inspection of the account. Profile birth, parents, spouse maiden name and children are separate compiled claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_THOMAS_WAKEFIELD_WILL_SCAN",
      "title": "Thomas Wakefield will: wife Ann sole executrix",
      "type": "digitised probate register",
      "url": "https://guide.msa.maryland.gov/pages/item.aspx?ID=S538-11",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Maryland State Archives S538-11, Wills liber 6. Scans msa_s538_000011-0337 and -0338 visually inspected: handwritten old pages336–337, second numbering337–338. Wife Ann appointed sole executrix and given life interests in Wakefields Beginning and Ratchdale; son Abel and his eldest son Thomas named. Ralph Shaw senior and junior witness. Closing date appears second day of December1697, differing from published November2 abstract; probate19February1699 as written, calendar style not independently reconciled. Local files will341.pdf and will342.pdf reflect viewer input numbers, not printed folios."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_RALPH_ANN_SHAW_WAKEFIELD_ACCOUNT_SCAN",
      "title": "Ralph Shaw and Ann his wife: account of Thomas Wakefield estate",
      "type": "digitised probate register microfilm",
      "url": "https://guide.msa.maryland.gov/pages/item.aspx?ID=TE1-66",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Maryland State Archives TE1-66, image813, Inventories and Accounts liber20 page194, visually inspected and cropped for legibility. Heading names Ralph Shaw and Ann his wife administering the last will of Thomas Wakefield of Charles County. Catalogue dates volume1700–1701; exact account date not confidently read. No senior/junior designation in account heading, no maiden name. Local account813.pdf and account194-detail.png."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_JONATHAN_MARLER_WILL_1673_SCAN",
      "title": "Jonathan Marler will and probate proceedings, 1673",
      "type": "digitised probate register photostat",
      "url": "https://guide.msa.maryland.gov/pages/item.aspx?ID=S538-1",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Maryland State Archives S538-1, Wills liber1, pages560–562, images0560–0562, visually inspected. Will29July1673, probate24October1673. Thomas Wakefield receives180acres Manchester, mare/foal, possible further100acres if brotherJohnMarlerdoesnotcome; Wakefield andJohnWorland coexecutors/residuarybeneficiaries. BrotherJohnofManchester andSamuel named. NoAnn orson-in-lawdesignation. Probateproceedingsdiscusserasures/blotsandwitnessknowledge; nofindingofforgeryasserted. Localmarler560/561/562.pdfandPNG."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_JOSHUA_DOYNE_WILL_1698_SCAN",
      "title": "Joshua Doyne will, 4 March 1697/8, and codicil, 10 March: daughter Mary Matthews",
      "type": "digitised probate register",
      "url": "https://guide.msa.maryland.gov/pages/item.aspx?ID=S538-11",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Maryland State Archives S538-11, Wills liber 6, old folios 169–173, second numbering 170–174, images 0170–0174. Visually inspected 19 September 2026. Folio 171 names daughter Mary Matthews and her deceased husband Ignatius Matthews. Folio 172 distinguishes children of first wife Barbara and second wife Jane without individually allocating every child. Will dated 4 March 1697/8; codicil 10 March; probate 16 August 1698. Viewer inputs 174–178 are not folio numbers."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_MARY_JAMESON_WHARTON_DEPOSITION_LEAD",
      "title": "Mary Doyne compiled profile: Jane Wharton deposition and Mary Jameson estate abstracts",
      "type": "compiled profile quoting published record abstracts",
      "url": "https://sites.rootsmagic.com/Worland/individual.php?p=1145",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Retrieved 19 September 2026. Quotes Robert W. Barnes, Maryland Genealogical Society Bulletin 34 no. 3 (Summer 1993), and TLC Charles County Land Records 1756–1761, p. 63, citing G#3:370. Deposition sworn 16 January 1738/39, recorded 10 October 1759. Two transcriptions differ over the eldest son’s name. Also quotes inventory 60:369 and account 41:7. Original deposition and inventory not yet inspected; compiled birth and family dates are not adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HARDY_CATHOLIC_WOMEN_1999",
      "title": "Beatriz Betancourt Hardy, Women and the Catholic Church in Maryland, 1689–1776 (1999)",
      "type": "scholarly historical article citing probate records",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc5800/sc5881/000001/000000/000377/pdf/msa_sc_5881_1_377.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Maryland Historical Magazine, Winter 1999, article beginning p. 397. Page 413, notes 11, 14 and 16, visually inspected. Cites Mary Jameson’s 1755 will, 29:559–560, and 1756 inventory, 60:369–370, alongside Thomas Jameson’s 1734 inventory, 18:493–497. Documents Catholic church furnishings. Note 16 separately lists Jane Doyne’s children; Mary’s maternity requires a separate assessment."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILLIS_2022",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Willis",
      "type": "scholarly surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/willis",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry inspected 19 September 2026. English Will with genitival ending; some families instead from Willey or Willows. General name formation, not a pedigree for the North Bradley household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILL_2022",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Will",
      "type": "scholarly surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/will",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry inspected 19 September 2026. English personal-name sense is a short form of William; the entry also distinguishes other English and German formations."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_VCH_NORTH_BRADLEY_WILLIS_1639",
      "title": "Victoria County History: North Bradley, John Willis and the rectory lease, 1639–1646",
      "type": "scholarly local history citing archival records",
      "url": "https://www.british-history.ac.uk/vch/wilts/vol8/pp218-234",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A History of the County of Wiltshire, volume 8 (1965), pp. 218–234, church section and notes 243–244. Retrieved directly and retained as vch.html, 19 September 2026. Winchester College let the rectory to John Willis, vicar, in 1639; he had left by 1646. Citations: W.C.M., U.M.R., Drawer 21 and W.C.M. 4299. Underlying lease and complaint not inspected. A local same-surname association, not a documented relationship to William."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ALLSOPP_ALSOP_2022",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Alsop and Allsopp",
      "type": "scholarly surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/alsop",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Alsop entry inspected 19 September 2026; companion Allsopp entry explicitly calls it a variant of Alsop. Habitational derivation from Alsop en le Dale, Derbyshire, from personal name Ælle and an enclosed valley. Does not identify a single founding biological family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ALSOPP_WILL_WAGSTAFFE_1697",
      "title": "William Alsopp of Fenny Bentley: will dated 1 December 1697, probate 1699",
      "type": "official archive catalogue of probate document",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/calmview/Record.aspx?src=CalmView.Catalog&id=D239%2FT%2F515",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derbyshire Record Office reference displayed as D239/M/T/515 (URL uses D239/T/515). Catalogue inspected 19 September 2026 and saved as probate.html. William Alsopp, yeoman; 20 shillings to Robert Wagstaffe of Ashbourne, other small legacies, Fenny Bentley lands to Samuel, Mary and Susannah Smith, also executors. Will dated 1 December 1697; heading says proved at Lichfield 28 August, catalogue date 1699. No relationships to those beneficiaries are stated in the catalogue. Original not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ASHBOURNE_ALSOP_MARRIAGES_1544_1667",
      "title": "Ashbourne St Oswald marriage transcript: Alsop and Allsopp entries, 1544–1667",
      "type": "selected parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://derbyshiremarriagesandchristenings.yolasite.com/ashbourne---saint-oswald.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Web text inspected 19 September 2026. Cecilie Alsop and Richard Brassington, 27 September 1544; Henrie Alsop and Alice Tirrey, 12 June 1552; John Alsop and Ellen Gent, 23 October 1552; William Allsopp and Sussanna Frost, 22 May 1665; Thomas Waggstaffe and Alce Allsopp, 27 April 1667. Page is a selected transcription, not full register coverage. Original images not inspected; no connecting kinship inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WAGSTAFF_2022",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Wagstaff",
      "type": "scholarly surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/wagstaff",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry inspected 19 September 2026. English and Scottish nickname, probably for a beadle who moved a staff or rod; alternatively a bawdy nickname. No individual occupation or single family origin follows from this explanation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DFHS_CARSINGTON_FORD_BAPTISMS",
      "title": "Derbyshire Family History Society: Carsington baptisms, Ford entries",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.dfhs.org.uk/page/carsington-baptisms/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded and inspected 19 September 2026; published table runs 1592–1699. It records ?Margaret, daughter of Thomas and Margaret Ford, 23 February 1626; children of Henry and Elizabeth Ford in 1669, 1675, 1678, 1682 and 1686; Hannah, daughter of Anthony and Mary Ford of Hopton, 18 January 1675. Original register not inspected; dates retained as transcribed without calendar conversion. This table does not cover baptisms after 1699."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DFHS_CARSINGTON_FORD_BURIALS",
      "title": "Derbyshire Family History Society: Carsington burials, Ford entries",
      "type": "parish-register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.dfhs.org.uk/page/carsington-burials/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded and inspected 19 September 2026. Ford entries include Millicent, daughter of Henry and Mary, 18 June 1715; Henry, 11 June 1750; Mary, widow of Henry, 3 July 1750. The two 1750 entries provide no ages or children. Exact Ford surname rows distinguished from Stafford, Beresford and place-name matches. Original register not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DFHS_CARSINGTON_MARTHA_MARRIAGE_REVIEW",
      "title": "Derbyshire Family History Society: Carsington marriages, review for Samuel and Martha",
      "type": "parish-register transcription; targeted review",
      "url": "https://www.dfhs.org.uk/page/carsington-marriages/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded and inspected 19 September 2026. Searched table rows for Needham/Nedham and Martha. No Samuel Needham–Martha marriage appears in the displayed table. Samuel Smith married Martha Smith on 8 September 1743; different groom surname and after Edward Nedham’s 1733/34 baptism, so not evidence of Martha Nedham’s birth surname. Table begins 1596 and ends 1982 but has gaps; date span is not proof of complete coverage. Neighboring-parish or earlier marriage remains possible."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_TNA_1851_CENSUS_RELATIONSHIP_COLUMNS",
      "title": "The National Archives: an 1851 census return and its relationship column",
      "type": "archive educational reproduction of census form",
      "url": "https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/education/resources/census-detective/source-2/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Inspected 19 September 2026. The 1851 return records relation to the head of family. This establishes the form structure only, not the contents of the Shrewsbury Lyster household. An index’s inferred mother field must be distinguished from an explicit statement on the original page."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DRO_ADAM_NEEDHAM_BONSALL_1671",
      "title": "Derbyshire Record Office: Adam Needham of Bonsall, conveyance, 1671 (D161/BOX/6/48)",
      "type": "official archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/calmview/TreeBrowse.aspx?field=RefNo&key=D161%2FBOX%2F6%2F34&src=CalmView.Catalog",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Collection browser item 48 describes Adam Needham, yeoman of Bonsall, conveying a garden and half a church seat to Edward Smedley the elder in 1671. Catalogue description inspected, original deed not inspected. Individual Record.aspx endpoint unavailable during this review; the linked collection browser contains the actual item description."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_WIRKSWORTH_FREEMEN_NEDEHAM_C1570",
      "title": "George Harold Allsop: Wirksworth Hundred freemen, circa 1570, transcription",
      "type": "published historical transcription",
      "url": "https://parwichhistory.org/2003/09/01/newsletter-14/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Parwich and District Local History Society newsletter14, September2003, section List of Freemen of the Wirksworth Hundred circa1570. Richardus Nedeham of Snitterton, gentleman; Humphrey, Edward and John Nedeham of Hartington, yeomen. The latter locations follow de eadem. The article gives an approximate date and no archival reference for the original list; original not inspected. These are not Ashbourne residents merely because Ashbourne appears among the manors."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_PRICHARD",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Prichard",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/prichard",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Welsh variant of Pritchard. Read19September2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_PRITCHARD",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Pritchard",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/pritchard?geo-lang=en-US",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Welsh anglicization of ap Rhisiart, son of Richard. Read19September2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_KERRY_PRITCHARD_1723",
      "title": "Powys Archives: William Pritchard, Kerry recognizance, 17 July 1723",
      "type": "archive transcription",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/digitised-and-transcribed-records_Montgomeryshire-Quarter-Sessions_session-rolls-and-order-book_Mont_QS_1707-1729_bi.pdf#page=100",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "23T6, PDFpage100 visually inspected. John Herbert of Kerry £20, William Pritchard and Elizabeth Lloyd of Kerry £5 each, before John Pryce, for Herbert to prosecute Jane Jones. William is a surety, not described as the accused. Original manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_DAVIES",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Davies",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/Davies?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Welsh and English variant of Davis; patronymic equivalent to ap Dafydd. Entry notes particular frequency in south Wales and possible influence of Davy. Read19September2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_BERRIEW_JOHN_DAVIES_1747",
      "title": "Powys Archives: John Davies of Ffridd Pen-y-wern, Berriew, 1747",
      "type": "archive transcription",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/digitised-and-transcribed-records_Montgomeryshire-Quarter-Sessions_session-rolls_Mont_QS_1740-1749_bi.pdf#page=236",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "47T39/47T47 presentments, PDFpage234; 47M8 writ6August1747 for8Octoberappearance, page236 visually inspected. JohnDavies aleseller, FfriddPen-y-wern Berriew. Allegation of unlicensed sales; no conviction established by these entries. Original not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_MARSHALL",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Marshall",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/marshall?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English occupational surname usually farrier, sometimes high household/state official; Middle English and Old French forms. Read19September2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HANNAH_MARSHALL_PONTEFRACT_1771",
      "title": "Published description of Hannah Marshall’s 1771 deed (WYAS SpSt/4/11/66/609)",
      "type": "secondary family-history article quoting archival description",
      "url": "https://keirfamilygenealogy.wordpress.com/2018/10/24/21-supplementary-blog-cousinage-networks-part-2-the-middle-classes/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Article quotes lease/release24–25April1771, HannahMarshall ofPontefract spinster asfourthparty, OutwoodClosesHorsforth; givesWestYorkshireArchiveServiceSpencerStanhope reference. Article inspected; originaldeed and currentcatalogueentrynotindependently retrieved. ItsidentificationwithElizabethSitwellservant is expresslyassumed andnotadoptedhere."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_ALLEN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Allen",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/allen?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry read19September2026; derivesEnglish/Scottishsurname principallyfromAlain/Alein/Alan, withobscureearlierCelticorigin. DiscussesBretonpersonalnamepopularityandotherformations. DoesnotidentifyAnnfamilyorigin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ELIZABETH_ALLEN_BEEVER_1692",
      "title": "Wakefield Family History Society: Joseph Beever and Elizabeth Allen, bond/allegation index, 1692",
      "type": "marriage licence index transcription",
      "url": "https://www.wakefieldfhs.org.uk/Bonds%20etc%201690-1714.shtml",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexedtable row: JosephBeever,NewSandall;ElizabethAllen,residenceblank;28Aug1692;intendedchurchblank. Searchengineextractshowedrowandheaderscontext; directpagechallengepreventedfreshfullpageload. Originalbond/allegationnotinspected. NoparentaldetailsandnoPontefractresidenceforElizabethestablished."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_LEFFLER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Leffler",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/leffler?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Search-indexed entry checked 19 September 2026: German and eastern Ashkenazic occupational name, variant of Loeffler, maker or seller of spoons. Does not identify this branch’s religious background or founding locality."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_CRAWINKEL_LEFFLER_1834",
      "title": "Obersteuerkollegium Gotha: Crawinkel innkeepers’ tax petition, 1834",
      "type": "official archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.archive-in-thueringen.de/de/findbuch/view/searchterm/israel%2Blevi/submit/submit/bestand/21149/systematik/124955/archivgut/3202836/searchall/israel%2Blevi",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalogue read 19 September 2026. Bestand 2-13-0037, file 41, dated 1834. Four Crawinkel innkeepers including Johann Christoph Leffler petitioned for reduced business taxes on innkeeping rights. Original file not inspected; no relatives named in the description. The unrelated search terms in the catalogue URL have no evidential significance."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_AGT_CRAWINKEL_INDEX_2018",
      "title": "AGT library and archive catalogue (1 May 2018), p. 57: Crawinkel church-record index",
      "type": "genealogical library catalogue",
      "url": "https://agt-gen.de/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/2018-05-01-Bestandsverzeichnis-AGT.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF page 57 visually checked. Section KB 13, item 70.13: index to Crawinkel Lutheran church books 1683–1808, published 2015. Catalogue describes AGT deposit at Stadtarchiv Erfurt. The index itself was not inspected; present availability unverified. The adjacent lost-church-book entry concerns Emleben, not Crawinkel."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ANGENETE_BAHLOW",
      "title": "Hans Bahlow: Agnes name group, reproduced under Nesensohn by Forebears",
      "type": "surname dictionary excerpt",
      "url": "https://forebears.io/de/surnames/nesensohn",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Search-indexed German excerpt checked 19 September 2026; attributed to Hans Bahlow. Groups Agnes, Agnesen, Nesensohn, Angenete and Agneter; describes surnames referring to a son or husband of Agnes. Original dictionary page not inspected. Does not establish Angeneten, Angenend or Aengenendt as identical forms in Sophie’s records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ANGENETE_GUETERSLOH_CARRIERS",
      "title": "City of Gütersloh: trade history, Angenete carriers, 1694–1848",
      "type": "municipal historical account",
      "url": "https://www.guetersloh.de/de/leben-in-guetersloh/stadtportrait/stadtgeschichte/stadtgeschichte-1825-1914/wirtschaft/handel-gaststaetten.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. Fuhrleute section reports four generations of Angenete carriers documented from 1694 to 1848 and family papers at the city archive. Does not name Sophie or the 1694 carrier; underlying documents not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ANGENETE_SCHINDLER_CATALOGUE",
      "title": "Westfälisches Wirtschaftsarchiv library catalogue: Wolfgang Schindler, Familiengeschichte Agnete / Angenete (1999)",
      "type": "archive library catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.archive.nrw.de/sites/default/files/media/files/2024_Bib_alles_inkl_Sachbegriffe_31102024.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalogue dated 31 October 2024, page 165 visually inspected. A 236 Nr. 599: Wolfgang Schindler, Familiengeschichte Agnete / Angenete, Haan 1999; subjects Genealogie and Gütersloh. The book itself has not been inspected. Its title supports investigating both spellings but supplies no parentage for Sophie."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_FRICKE_LEMGO_BELL_1779",
      "title": "St Johann, Lemgo: Bernhard Heinrich Fricke’s bell of 1779",
      "type": "parish historical account",
      "url": "https://www.st-johann.org/kirche-gemeinde/der-stumpfe-turm/die-historischen-glocken-im-stumpfen-turm/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. Parish chronology identifies Bernhard Heinrich Fricke of Gütersloh as founder of the large bronze bell in 1779; records its surrender and melting during the First World War. Cites Günter Rhiemeier, St. Johann in und vor Lemgo (1998), pp.53–66. No genealogical relationship to Eberhard is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_READE_BLACKWOOD_WILLS_1906",
      "title": "Aleyn Lyell Reade, The Reades of Blackwood Hill (1906), p. 7: Roger Reede and Francis Reade wills",
      "type": "published will transcription and genealogical study",
      "url": "https://www.themeister.co.uk/birchall/reades_blackwood_hill.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded and visually inspected 19 September 2026: printed p.7, PDF p.33. Roger Reede of Blackwood, Horton, will 13 October 1558, proved Lichfield 19 January 1558/9, transcription credited to District Probate Registry. Francis Reade of Horton will 25 May 1695, proved 11 October 1695; widow Anne and brother-in-law Thomas Daniel of Staney proved it. Author could not identify Francis’s connection to main Blackwood pedigree. Original wills not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_THOMAS",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Thomas",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/thomas",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry read 19 September 2026. British surname from Biblical personal name, ultimately Aramaic twin; especially common in Wales and Cornwall. Broader international formations not assigned to this Radnorshire branch."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_JOSEPH_THOMAS_DYER_1787",
      "title": "Powys Archives: Joseph Thomas, dyer, mortgage assignment, 12 July 1787",
      "type": "official archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://storipowys.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/depositedmisc_minor-deposits_Radnorshire-Catalogues_R-DX-21-1.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "R/DX/21/1, page1 visually inspected 19 September2026. Robert Pitchford and Joseph Thomas, both of Llanddewi Ystradenni; Thomas a dyer. Assignment of mortgage securing £32 and interest on Park bach, Llanbadarn Vaur, for remaining999yearterm. Original deed not inspected. Later1838Joneswill/Quakertrust clauses concern other parties, not evidence of Thomas religious affiliation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_HANSEN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Hansen",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hansen",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September2026. Patronymic from Hans; Danish, Norwegian, Dutch, Flemish and North German formations. No specific origin for Anna Catharina established."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_DIETERLE",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Dieterle",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/dieterle?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed dictionary entry read 19 September2026: South German, pet form of personal name Dieter. No branch-specific locality supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_USER_MARIA_DIETERLE_CLUE",
      "title": "Matthew’s saved clue: Maria (Dieterle) Nagel, born 26 September 1593",
      "type": "user-supplied genealogy clue",
      "url": null,
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Preserves the provenance already recorded in this person’s local source_note; not a newly supplied statement or an independently verified baptism. Original profile had no structured source citation and describes relationship as unconfirmed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_MARIE_DIETERLE_GENEANET_CLUE",
      "title": "Geneanet tree index: Marie Dieterle (1593–1634), linked to Jacob Nagel in 1609",
      "type": "compiled family-tree index",
      "url": "https://gw.geneanet.org/falta1943?lang=en&m=P&v=marie",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Search-indexed entry inspected 19 September2026. Francisco Tavares de Almeida tree index lists Dieterle1593–1634, relationship with JacobNagel1609, under Marie. Full person record and original citations not retrieved. Does not confirm exact26Septemberbirth or a parish; not independent primary evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_BRASSINGTON_ALSTONFIELD",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Brassington",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=brassington",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Hanks 2003/2006 entry accessed 19 September 2026. Derbyshire habitational origin; Brandsige is a plausible reconstructed, not attested, Old English personal name."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_TRENTHAM_REGISTER_CATALOGUE",
      "title": "FamilySearch catalogue: Trentham parish registers, 1558–1900",
      "type": "archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/catalog/641987",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalogue reviewed19September2026; indexed marriage coverage includes1561–1640and1656–1751. Original images not examined. OpenLibrary lists printedPartI1558–1744; available InternetArchive partII1744–1812does not contain1632marriage. Do not treat unexamined earlier entries as absent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_ATWOOD_MARJORIE_WILLATT_DETAIL",
      "title": "Atwood compilation: Marjorie Willatt",
      "type": "compiled_pedigree",
      "url": "https://sites.rootsmagic.com/AtwoodFamily/site/individual.php?p=187914",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read19September2026. Claims birth1560Bradwell-on-SeaEssex, marriage27Jan1589Trentham toThomasJamesBagnall, death11Jul1630Trentham; parentsJohnWillett/AnnKirbie. Matching child188404supports candidate placement, not adoption of all dates/parents. No original records displayed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_OXFORD_WILLATT",
      "title": "Oxford Dictionary of Family Names: Willatt",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/willatt?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2016 entry cross-refers to Willett. Read19September2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WILLETT",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Willett",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=willett",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English derivations include pet forms of Will/William, sometimes Willard, possibly Somerset placeWillet; separate French variant also listed. Read19September2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_EMMS_WOLSTANTON_PROBATE_1610_1622",
      "title": "Chris Emms, Wolstanton, Staffordshire: Wills & Inventories 1600–1650 (2021), §§41, 69, 88",
      "type": "transcription",
      "url": "https://probateinventories.org/WillsAndInventories.Wolstanton.1600-1650.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded and read 19 September 2026. PDF pp. 88–89: Thomas Willatt, 1610; pp. 132–134: Francis Bagnald, 1618; pp. 165–166: Emme Bagnald, probate 1622. Page 132 visually checked. Modern summaries/transcriptions and editorial notes, not photographs of original wills. Chatterley identification comes from editorial comparison with the 1604 Tunstall court roll; original court roll not examined. Emme’s will year and granddaughter’s surname retain editorial uncertainty."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_FINNEY",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Finney",
      "type": "published reference or record transcription",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=finney",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. English habitational explanations: coarse grass plus enclosure or island, with several place candidates including lost Fynney in Cheddleton, recorded Fyneye 1320. Also possible southeastern place origins and Irish Ó Fidhne/Feeney. These are surname explanations, not this branch’s proven origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_SALT",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Salt",
      "type": "published reference or record transcription",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=salt",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. English habitational name from Salt, Staffordshire, Old English selte (salt pit). An occupational explanation is possible but the dictionary says evidence is lacking. Independent Navajo translated clan name is not evidence for the Staffordshire branch."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_VENN_JOHN_SAULT_1666",
      "title": "John and J. A. Venn, Alumni Cantabrigienses, part I, vol. IV (1927), p. 9: John Sault",
      "type": "published reference or record transcription",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/p1alumnicantabri04univuoft/page/9/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full OCR and XML downloaded; original printed page visually inspected at archive leaf n18 on 19 September 2026. John Sault admitted Magdalene 23 June 1666 aged 19, son of Richard, farmer, Rocester, Staffs; school Manchester, matriculated 1667, BA1669–70, MA1673. Do not merge nearby John Salt entries. University compilation based on records, not original admission manuscript inspection."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LANDOR_ROGER_FYNNEY_1600",
      "title": "Walter Noble Landor, Staffordshire Incumbents and Parochial Records (1530–1680), Collections for 1915, p. 393",
      "type": "published reference or record transcription",
      "url": "https://www.staffordshirecountystudies.uk/WSAS%201915%20Sample.pdf#page=63",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Volume titled 1915, published 1916. Printed page393/PDF63 visually inspected 19 September 2026. Appendix IV transcribes clerical inventories from Lichfield wills. Roger Fynney, incumbent of Caldon, inventory 29 April1600; includes forty sheep, cattle, horses, husbandry equipment, household goods and adjusted total£89. Adjacent Alton entry belongs to Thomas Rawlin, not Roger. No relationship to William Fynney asserted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_IPGV_DITLOH_ORIGIN_LIMIT",
      "title": "IPGV migration card 39704: Abraham Ditloh and source-collection notice",
      "type": "institutional genealogical database",
      "url": "https://migration.pfalzgeschichte.de/person/39704",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "HTML downloaded and read 19 September 2026. Abraham Reformed; wife Anna Margareth, daughters Anna Marg. and Anna Catharina; no parents, birth/death dates or birthplace supplied. Migration origin broadly Deutschland, destination Gross Schwam, Pennsylvania. Source QAL-USA-Pa-Goshenhoppen-1, card1966. Institute explicitly says QAL collection lost in2019fire. That statement concerns institutional QAL holdings, not all original American church manuscripts."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_HINKE_DITLOH_GREAT_SWAMP",
      "title": "William J. Hinke, History of the Goshenhoppen Reformed Charge (1920), pp.171–173,276–277,309",
      "type": "published church-record transcription and history",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/historyofgoshenh00hink",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full OCR downloaded19September2026; printedpp172,173,277 visually checked. AbrahamDitlo15shillings subscription26December1748(questioned year ineditor heading); another15shillings June1761. Page173 prose June8 vs documentheading/bodyJune6; useJune1761. Heads list probably1758 includes AbrahamDitloh, unnamedDitlohJunior, and unnamedweaverlivingatDitloh’s. Page309 OCR has AbrahamDitloh and wife; wife unnamed, not identification with AnnaMargareth. No original manuscripts inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_DITLOW_QUALIFIED",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Ditlow entry, applicability to Ditloh unresolved",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=DITLOW",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read19September2026. Presents an English habitational derivation from Dilwyn, Herefordshire, medievalDelewe1295/Dylewe1334. This is the similarly spelled Ditlow entry; no source connects its English derivation to AbrahamDitloh’s German-Reformed family. Search results offering GermanDittlohe or inventeddiot+lo derivations lack reliable supporting citations and are not adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_BONFELD_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Archion catalogue: Bonfeld mixed register 1607–1737, volume1",
      "type": "archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/en/alle-archive/baden-wuerttemberg/evangelisches-archiv-baden-und-wuerttemberg-wuerttemberg/dekanat-heilbronn/bonfeld",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Public catalogue reviewed 19 September 2026. The listed early mixed register covers the reported 1687 household, 1700 burial/remarriage and 1710 emigration period. Images not inspected; no claim that all entries survive or have been searched."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_WEIGEL",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Weigel",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=weigel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains Weigel as a medieval familiar form of Wigand. This applies to that surname form generally; the Bonfeld spellings Wägelin/Wägele require separate consideration and are not automatically proved to share this formation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_JONES_BONFELD_OLDER_MICHAEL",
      "title": "Jones’s Bonfeld Wegele reconstruction, reproduced in the public Wägelin profile",
      "type": "published research reproduced in a compiled profile",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/W%C3%A4gelin-6",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Saved public API biography read again 19 September 2026. Attributes to Henry Z. Jones, Palatine Families of New York (1985), II pp.1069–1070: older Johann Michael Wägelin died 11 March 1700 aged 47; widow Agnes married Johann Ludwig Roth on 30 November 1700; Hanß Michael Wägele in 1687 Bonfeld assessment, Karlsruhe Archives CLA 125/3094; family emigrant list in Bonfeld churchbook. Calls older man immigrant’s father, but no parent-naming baptism is quoted. Jones and originals not inspected. Same reproduced research as SRC_OT 26_JONES_WEGELE_REPRODUCED, not independent evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_MSA_GUISE_CHARLES_FOUNDOUT",
      "title": "Maryland Land Office: Charles Foundout, surveyed for Peter Guise, 1777",
      "type": "digitized manuscript land-office record",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/stagserm/sm100/sm130/000000/000046/pdf/mdsa_sm130_46.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "MSA SR 4391, volume 36. Typed tract index p.3/PDF 5 and manuscript folio 222/PDF 240 visually inspected 19 September 2026. Charles Foundout,8½ acres, surveyed for Peter Guise 10 September 1777; patented to Henry Baker 10 December 1783. The file includes Frederick County rent rolls and later patent entries: this entry is in the later section. Does not name relatives or describe the transfer mechanism. Search-index snippets alone were not used as proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GUISE",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Guise",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=Guise",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists English/French habitational origin from Guise in Aisne, French personal-name origin, and an Americanized German Geiss form. The French noble family is a separate historical association, not evidence of Peter’s descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GUICE",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Guice",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=Guice",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Guice as an Americanized form of German Geis. No particular family origin established by this general explanation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_DAFN_GEIS",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Geis",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=Geis",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derives Geis from Giso, a short form of Germanic names beginning Gis-, and allows altered Geiss or Gies forms."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_LVA_ROCKINGHAM_LOSS",
      "title": "Library of Virginia: Rockingham record losses and recovered wills",
      "type": "institutional archival history",
      "url": "https://uncommonwealth.lva.virginia.gov/blog/2013/05/08/lost-19th-century-rockingham-co-wills-found-at-lva/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Archivist Callie Lou Freed describes 1787 loss primarily of wills/estates and 1864 losses, plus recovery of later fragments. This does not prove Peter’s particular will is lost."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ROOTS_GUISE_KUFFER_COMPILED",
      "title": "Compiled Maria Ottillia Kuffer pedigree and its chronology problem",
      "type": "compiled genealogical profile",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/maria-ottillia-kuffer-24-2121qj3",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Public profile reviewed 19 September 2026 assigns birth 1730, parents Hans Jacob Kufer 1687–1764 and Verena Rastorfer 1722–1770. The displayed maternal ages conflict. A wrong date or a wrong relationship are alternatives; this does not independently disprove the Kuffer surname. The underlying marriage/baptism is not exposed here."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCDONNELL_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: McDonnell (FamilySearch)",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=MCDONNELL",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. Gaelic patronymic and comparison with Scottish McDonald; not evidence of this ancestor’s birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCDONALD_ACCESS_PEDIGREE",
      "title": "MacDonald McDonald Family Records, reproduced by Access Genealogy",
      "type": "compiled pedigree and family traditions",
      "url": "https://accessgenealogy.com/new-york/macdonald-mcdonald-family-records.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. Bryan McDonald section claims Alexander of Wicklow as father, Arklow origin and 1691 migration. American families section instead gives 1689 land acquisition, 693 acres and Mary Doyle (Combe?). Internal discrepancies; general reference list does not identify the record supporting the connecting parentage. Used as a lead, not independent proof of European ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BLEYLE_BAHLOW_LINNARTZ",
      "title": "Hans Bahlow and Kaspar Linnartz: Bleyle/Bleile surname explanations, reproduced by Forebears",
      "type": "surname dictionaries reproduced online",
      "url": "https://forebears.io/de/surnames/bleile",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. Bahlow explicitly groups Bleyle, Bleile, Bleiler, Bleuler and Bleul; occupational explanation and 1431 Reutlingen attestation. Linnartz, Unsere Familiennamen (1958), explains pounding, washing and flax/hemp processing. Reutlingen example supplies neither personal name nor original document reference here. Modern distribution statistics not used."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BLEIL_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022): Bleil",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/bleil",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. Occupational name from Middle High German bliuwel, an implement for pounding/crushing/beating. Separate Bleile entry calls it a variant of Bleil. Bahlow explicitly connects the Bleyle spelling; occupation not assigned to Sebastian."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BLUWELER_OBERKIRCH_1395",
      "title": "Generallandesarchiv Karlsruhe, 34 Nr. 994: Böldelin Bluweler and sons, Oberkirch, 1395",
      "type": "archive catalogue abstract of original charter",
      "url": "https://www.landesarchiv-bw.de/plink/?f=4-1450372",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "LEO-BW indexed catalogue text read 19 September 2026, labw-4-1450372. Friday before St Gall, 1395. Böldelin Bluweler and sons Reinbold and Hans sell annual rye rent at Oberkirch to Betschelin von Brumath for 11 pounds Strasbourg pennies. Original in Allerheiligen holdings; two digital images catalogued, not inspected. Catalogue abstract, not a manuscript transcription by this project."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BERLIN_DAFN2022",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022): Berlin",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/berlin",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. German and Ashkenazic habitational surname from Berlin. Does not establish that the Württemberg Beerlin branch came from that city; speculative city-name etymology not imported."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BERLIN_SMITH1956",
      "title": "Elsdon Coles Smith, Dictionary of American Family Names (1956): Berlin, reproduced by Forebears",
      "type": "surname dictionary reproduced online",
      "url": "https://forebears.io/surnames/berlin",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. Gives both place-name and personal-name Ber/Berl (bear) explanations. These alternatives do not identify the formation of this branch’s Beerlin spelling."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANS_BERLIN_AMORBACH1525",
      "title": "Stadtarchiv Heilbronn: chronology of the Peasants’ War, 4 May 1525",
      "type": "municipal archive historical account",
      "url": "https://www.stadtgeschichte-heilbronn.de/ausstellung/reformationszeit/medienpraesentation/1525-bauernkrieg/chronologie-der-ereignisse-im-heilbronner-raum-6.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. Dates the Amorbacher Erklärung by Wendel Hipler and Heilbronn’s Hans Berlin to 4 May 1525; invitation to a peasants’ parliament at Heilbronn. Does not identify the Württemberg endpoint or establish kinship."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WEINSBERG_MISCHBUCH1571",
      "title": "Archion catalogue: Weinsberg mixed register, volume 2, 1571–1740",
      "type": "church archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/baden-wuerttemberg/evangelisches-archiv-baden-und-wuerttemberg-wuerttemberg/dekanat-weinsberg/weinsberg/98763",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. Specifically contains baptisms 1571–1690 followed by a pastor list, marriages 1617–1690, deaths 1589–1690 and exceptional deaths 1615–1740. Parish listing also names marriages 1576–1680 volume 1 and family register 1571–1800 volume 23. Catalogue only: images require access and were not inspected; family-register coverage is not a claim of contemporary compilation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_REIFF_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Reiff (FamilySearch)",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=reiff",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. Occupational or house-sign formation from reif, hoop/ribbon/cord; alternative personal-name Riff from Richfrit. Also describes a separate Ashkenazic formation from mature. None assigned as this ancestor’s occupation or religious ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_REIFF_FRITZ_UNTERHAUSEN",
      "title": "Eberhard Fritz: Separatists by residence, Unterhausen",
      "type": "historian’s record-based prosopographical compilation",
      "url": "https://eberhardfritz.de.tl/Separatisten-Wohnorte-U.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. Under Unterhausen: Matthäus Reiff elder, weaver, 13 October 1752–31 December 1814, emigration with three children to Harmony in 1804 (LKA 1804; RA 1091). Matthäus younger, weaver, 7 January 1770–10 May 1814, emigration 1804 (LKA 1804; RA 1092); wife Margarete Mutschler 1775–1827 (RA 1089). Maria Margarete Reiff born1749 widow of Johann Georg, shoemaker, recorded LB1811/1814/1815. Underlying archival items not inspected; elder/younger not taken as father/son."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DELAFUENTE",
      "title": "Fermin DeLaFuente family tree: Martin Gebel (1655), displayed ancestry",
      "type": "compiled public pedigree; connecting evidence unverified",
      "url": "https://www.genealogieonline.nl/fermin-de-la-fuente-iii/P5963.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed page read 19 September 2026. Displays Anna Göbel 1618–1688 wife of Martin 1600–1673, parents Hans Kissling 1600–1680 and Anna Maria Umn 1602. Child Martin born 23 July 1655 Willmandingen cites Württemberg Family Tables 1550–1985 via Ancestry, but citation is not specific proof of grandparents. Also gives Martin’s parents Jacob Goebel/Anna Mayer, conflicting with Weigel’s quoted Martin/Margaretha baptism. The claimed maternal parents are retained at low confidence; Umn not accepted as a birth surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KISSLING_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Kissling",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=kissling",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. German and Swiss German surname derived from the ancient personal name Gisilo. General linguistic origin, not evidence of Anna’s birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KISSLING_NOERDLINGEN1599",
      "title": "Stadtarchiv Nördlingen: testament U 5542, Paulus Rehlin, 28 November 1599",
      "type": "archive catalogue abstract of original testament",
      "url": "https://www.noerdlingen.de/fileadmin/noerdlingen/Noerdlingen_Stadt/Kultur_und_Freizeit/Archiv/Mannrechtsbriefe__Testamente__Ehevertraege__Leibgedingbriefe_U_5500-5590__1379_-_1676_.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 19 September 2026. U 5542 names Magdalena, daughter of Paulus Rehlin by Anna Voll, as wife of the Loder Hans Kissling. Original parchment with seals/signatures catalogued; manuscript not inspected. Same forename/surname is not an identification with candidate reported born 1600."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG688",
      "title": "Bruce Lang: Anna Catharina Müntz and Matthäus Uhland, persons 17193/17195",
      "type": "compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.genarchives.com/langfamily/g1/p688.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Uncited compiled identification of Wassenach baptism and Schauernheim bride; no original event inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG719",
      "title": "Bruce Lang: Wassenach Muntz family and Dannstadt Uhland children",
      "type": "compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.genarchives.com/langfamily/g1/p719.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read September 2026. Persons 17953,17956,17957; relationship claims and event dates lack documentary citations. Same compilation as pages 688/763, not independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MUENTZ_LANG763",
      "title": "Bruce Lang: Hermann Muntz and Elisabeth, persons 19074/19075",
      "type": "compiled genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.genarchives.com/langfamily/g1/p763.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Direct HTML read and saved as lang 763.html. No parents supplied for either spouse; no event-specific citations. Same compiler as other Lang pages."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WASSENACH_TRIER_CATALOGUE",
      "title": "Trier diocesan archive: Wassenach St Remigius church-book catalogue",
      "type": "archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.bistum-trier.de/export/sites/portal/archiv/.galleries/dokumente/Kirchenbuchverzeichnis_Maerz2026.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "March 2026 catalogue; printed 446, PDF 448. Downloaded and visually checked. Kb 2 baptisms 1662–1752, marriages 1674–1753, deaths 1673–1749. Catalogue only, not register pages."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WASSENACH_RENT1649",
      "title": "Trier diocesan archive: Nickenich parish archive, Wassenach rent book 0359",
      "type": "archive catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.bistum-trier.de/export/sites/portal/archiv/.galleries/dokumente/FindbuchPfarrarchiv_Nickennich_R_1100_62.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "BATr R 1100,62 item 0359,1649–1691. Catalogue describes church/confraternity rents, grain rent and wax/oil dues. No Muntz bearer identified in the catalogue; original uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_MUNTZ",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Muntz",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/muntz",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "German Müntz: habitational from Müntz near Jülich, or variant of Münz/Munz; several origins distinguished."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_MUNZ",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Munz",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/munz",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Personal-name, coin/mint and Jewish occupational/artificial formations distinguished; no branch-specific origin established."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_SAYER",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Sayer",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/sayer",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English occupational and personal-name formations distinguished, alongside French, Dutch and South German formations. General etymology does not identify this candidate’s birthplace or occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NUGENT_SAWYER1637_1653",
      "title": "Nell Marion Nugent, Cavaliers and Pioneers (1934), pp.57 and 275: Thomas Sawyer",
      "type": "published land-patent abstracts",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/cavalierspioneer00nuge",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded public scan; printed pp.57 and 275 visually checked (PDF pages115/341). 1637 abstract cites Patent Book1 p425; 1653 abstract cites Book3 p186. Original manuscript patents not inspected. The 1637 text expressly names wife Frances; the 1653 headrights include Anne Sayer without kinship."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SAYER_MEARES1649",
      "title": "B. J. Hughes, Biggs Documentation: Thomas Sayer–Thomas Meares indenture, 1649",
      "type": "online abstract citing court-book abstracts",
      "url": "https://www.bjhughes.org/biggsdoc.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "15 July1649, 300acres, Elizabeth River. Cites Walter, Lower Norfolk BookB (1646–1651/2),p141,folio149A–150. Read the specific abstract, not original deed. Other uncited family claims on the page are not adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_UHLAND_LANG718",
      "title": "Bruce Lang: Friederich Uhland and Eva Maria, persons 17949–17950",
      "type": "web",
      "url": "https://www.genarchives.com/langfamily/g1/p718.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Compiled parent claim, last edited 6 March 2024; read and saved 19 September 2026. No dates, places, older parents or record citations in these two entries. Same compiler as page 688, not independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DANNSTADT_REGISTER_CATALOGUE",
      "title": "Zentralarchiv Speyer: Abt. 045, Dannstadt church registers, printed p. 102",
      "type": "web",
      "url": "https://www.zentralarchiv-speyer.de/fileadmin/user_upload/zentralarchiv/03_Familienforschung/Dateien/Findbuch_045-Kirchenb%C3%BCcher.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalogue read 19 September 2026: Dannstadt 1, Reformed, with Schauernheim, baptisms/marriages/burials 1673–1729, microfiche 1/1–2. Catalogue only; no individual register entry examined."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_UHLAND",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Uhland",
      "type": "web",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=uhland",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Patrick Hanks, 2003/2006, entry supplied by FamilySearch; read 19 September 2026. South German personal-name derivation, odal + nand."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NDB_UHLAND",
      "title": "Hartmut Fröschle: Ludwig Uhland, Neue Deutsche Biographie 26 (2016), pp. 536–537",
      "type": "web",
      "url": "https://www.deutsche-biographie.de/gnd118625063.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published scholarly biography: Württemberg scholarly family documented since the sixteenth century, in Tübingen since 1720. No connection to the proposed Dannstadt family identified."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_SCHWEICKHARD",
      "title": "Weigel pedigree: Schweickhard, Heniss, Lorch and Rümelin branches",
      "type": "published research or catalogue",
      "url": "https://genealogie-nordwuerttemberg.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/AL-ERHARDT-HILSENBECK-version-2.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed pages 55,86,133–134,144,194,203–204,252 visually inspected. Numbered pedigree and quoted parish entries; original registers not inspected. #2584 explicitly equals #1462. Parent inference Alt Martin→Jung Martin is explicitly only possible. Local Lorch 1522 record cited via Schwarz II 706 ff; edition itself not read."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BAHLOW_SCHWEICKHARDT",
      "title": "Hans Bahlow: Schweickhardt name entry, reproduced by Forebears",
      "type": "published research or catalogue",
      "url": "https://forebears.io/de/surnames/schweickhardt",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed full dictionary excerpt read: Schweiker/Schweickert/Schweickhardt family of forms from Swidger/Swindger, swinth+ger. Direct opening returned 403; indexed attributed text used. No genealogical connection to medieval given-name bearers inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_LORCH",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Lorch",
      "type": "published research or catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lorch",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "German habitational surname; entry names Lorch places in Wiesbaden district,Hesse. Does not identify Michael’s place of origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN",
      "title": "Archion catalogue: Erpfingen parish books",
      "type": "published research or catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/baden-wuerttemberg/evangelisches-archiv-baden-und-wuerttemberg-wuerttemberg/dekanat-reutlingen/erpfingen",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalogue read: mixed books 1594–1655 and 1597–1739, baptisms 1656–1739. No original entries accessed. Individual event-series start dates from Weigel remain distinguished from whole mixed-volume coverage."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HENISS_NAME_REVIEW",
      "title": "Heniss surname lookup: limitations of the online dictionary display",
      "type": "published research or catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=Heniss",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lookup displays explanations referring to Hiess,Heuss and heiss, apparently a similar-name match; not reliable proof of the Heniß/Henus etymology. Exact Ancestry Heniss page contains generic filler; Hennis dictionary has English/Dutch alternatives not tied to this Württemberg branch. Recorded to explain why no derivation assigned."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_RUEMELIN_LIST_REVIEW",
      "title": "Rümelin family list: comparison with Anna’s unresolved origin",
      "type": "published research or catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.weihenstephan.org/~ruemgerh/stammliste.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Compiled family list,24 Feb 2009. Indexed early Ebingen Rymelin/Rümelin households reviewed as leads, not independently proved connections. No identifiable parent claim for Anna wife of Jung Martin found in reviewed material. Weigel likewise reports not finding her in Ebingen family book/stem list; neither is proof of nonrelationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_DURHAM",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Durham",
      "type": "scholarly dictionary or official record index",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=DURHAM",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English place-name surname from Durham, or variant Derham; dictionary entry read. Not evidence of Rachel’s birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DURHAM_JOHN_JANE1683",
      "title": "Maryland State Archives: John Durham and Jane, by November 1683",
      "type": "scholarly dictionary or official record index",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/msa/stagser/s1500/s1527/html/ssi1527d.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Marriage references index: John married by Nov1683 Jane, administratrix of William Choice; BACP D:13,14. Index read; underlying court record uninspected. James Durham marriage references on same page likewise not reconciled into one household."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BUTT_ANDERSON_SUBSIDIES",
      "title": "Dorset Tudor subsidies: Butt taxpayers at Five Ashes, 1525 and 1545",
      "type": "published tax transcription",
      "url": "https://www.opcdorset.org/WinterborneFiles/W.Anderson/Winterborne-Anderson-Tudor-Subs.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dorset OPC extract from T. L. Stoate, Dorset Tudor Subsidies Granted in 1523, 1543, 1593. Actual return headings 1525 and 1545: Richard, Thomas and John Butt goods assessments £5, £1, £5 in 1525; John Butt £4 in 1545. These are assessed goods values, not taxes paid. Original rolls and Stoate edition not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BUTT_GEORGE_1607",
      "title": "Robert Butt and Susan Gantrell marriage: George Butt named churchwarden, 1607",
      "type": "compiled profile quoting parish transcription",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person%3ARobert_Butt_%288%29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed page inspected 19 September 2026. Quotes marriage 13 April 1607, William Pistell rector, George Butt and Nicholas Waiting churchwardens. References Antony Broad report 29 July 2003. Same underlying report as existing household reconstruction, not independent corroboration. Original register image not inspected; an office listing does not establish wedding attendance or kinship."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANDERSON_LOCALITY",
      "title": "Dorset OPC: Winterborne Anderson and its historical Five Ash name",
      "type": "local parish history",
      "url": "https://www.opcdorset.org/WinterborneFiles/W.Anderson/WinterborneAnderson.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Five Ash as former Anderson name and places Anderson in the same Winterborne stream sequence as Houghton and Stickland. This identifies the tax locality; it does not make separate parishes interchangeable."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HOUGHTON_PROTESTATION",
      "title": "Winterborne Houghton protestation return, labelled 1641",
      "type": "transcription of contemporary return",
      "url": "https://www.opcdorset.org/WinterborneFiles/W.Houghton/W.HoughtonProt1641.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Tony Higgins transcription from original returns on microfilm, with warning about ornate writing. Names Robert Butt and Symon Butt; also John Burt junior and William Burt. No ages or relationships. Original not inspected; retain published 1641 label without assuming exact modern-calendar date."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_MILWICH_STONE",
      "title": "Milwich memorial inscriptions: Handley family at Coton Mill",
      "type": "memorial inscription transcription",
      "url": "https://places.wishful-thinking.org.uk/STS/Milwich/MIs.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "E7: Ruth wife of Sampson Handley, Coton Mill, died4January1759 aged19; reverse Ann wife of George Handley, same mill, died26August1758 aged67. Randle Knight transcriptions contributed by Marion Hall2007. No original stone photograph inspected. Physical association strengthens family context; maiden names not given."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_BOSWORTH_PROBATE",
      "title": "Henry Hartopp, Leicester wills and administrations 1660–1750 (1920), p153",
      "type": "published probate calendar",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/indexlibrary5116brit/page/153/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "British Record Society Index Library51. Printed153/PDF167 visually inspected from Wikimedia scan of same Internet Archive item. Market Bosworth entries: Isabell Handley/Hanley widow1662 administration60; William1712 V.G.; Alice widow1734 and1738 administration de bonis non; Thomas1730 administration. Original documents not inspected. These are probate dates, not exact death dates; the index does not name spouses or children."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_JOLLIE1697",
      "title": "J. E. Manning, Upper Chapel and Timothy Jollie’s register of baptisms (1900), pp204–205",
      "type": "published register transcription",
      "url": "https://www.unitarian.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/1900_Upper_Chapel.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF109 visually inspected. Printed205 records George, child of Thomas Handley of Hall Car, baptized25August1697. Printed204 records William, child of Thos.Handley of Hall Carr,18October1695. No mother or later residence for George. This verifies a1697 baptism candidate, not identity with the Milwich adult. Do not substitute baptism25Aug for profile birth24Aug without separate evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_SURNAME",
      "title": "Handley surname: historical dictionary entries and FamilySearch cross-reference",
      "type": "attributed surname dictionary entries",
      "url": "https://forebears.io/surnames/handley",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Harrison1912 identifies Handley as Hanley with intrusive d; Bardsley1896 locative places in several English counties; Smith1956 high meadow English origin and Irish patronymic alternative. FamilySearch DAFN2003/2006 Handley page independently cross-refers to Hanley. No Norman descent inferred from Lower1860 speculation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANDLEY_COMPETING_ORIGINS",
      "title": "Sheffield Family History Society: competing origins of George Handley",
      "type": "research discussion; record images not supplied",
      "url": "https://sheffieldfhs.org.uk/forums/topic/george-handley/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Steve Jackson reports a1697 baptism naming Thomas and questions1689Bosworth identification on marriage age, but gives no age/transcript to test that objection. Reports1695George died in infancy. Do not treat assertion as verified death or conflate with independently inspected1697baptism. Existing tree separately represents Sheffield candidate SRC_GEORGE_HANDLEY_1697, parents Thomas and Hanna, from Matthew-supplied profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANNEY_SETTLEMENT1758",
      "title": "William Wickham settlement examination, 1 July 1758: grandfather Robert Hanney",
      "type": "published archival calendar",
      "url": "https://wiltshire-records.squarespace.com/s/wrs_v46.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Phyllis Hembry, ed., Calendar of Bradford-on-Avon Settlement Examinations and Removal Orders 1725–98, Wiltshire Record Society 46 (1990), p.17, entry57; PDFpage34 visually checked. Calendar of testimony, not an image of the original examination. Approximate 1727–1739 household dates calculated from stated age33 in1758 and ages2–14 with grandfather."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ATHY_GALWAY1999",
      "title": "Lawrence F. Athy Jr., Captain George Athy (1999), p.5: John, Walter and Francis",
      "type": "published research",
      "url": "https://www.cookancestry.com/History/images/StreamGate%20family%20records.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed p.5/PDF13 visually checked. Explicit two-generation parent claim and reported property succession; no original deed citation on that page. Naming-pattern conclusions about Martyn women are inferential."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ATHY_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022): Athy and Athey",
      "type": "published research",
      "url": "https://en.geneanet.org/surnames/ATHY",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Irish place-derived Athy and independently formed English Athey. Geneanet and Ancestry reproduce the same dictionary, not independent authorities."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ATHY_HIGGINS1577",
      "title": "Jim Higgins, Reviving an Ancient Tradition in Stone Sculpture, Galway Heritage 40 (2018), p.19",
      "type": "published research",
      "url": "https://www.infomar.ie/sites/default/files/pdfs/Galway%20Heritage%20Magazine_Volume40_2018.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF21 visually checked. Athy arms, merchant mark and date1577 on doorway; attributes former house to Abbeygate Street, unlike the 1999 family history’s St Augustine Street."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ATHY_MEDIEVAL",
      "title": "Adrian Martyn, English rebels, Irish enemies (2012)",
      "type": "published research",
      "url": "https://thegalwayreview.com/2012/11/19/english-rebels-irish-enemies-by-adrian-martyn/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports William son of Richard de Athy of Athenry in1342, William treasurer1388, John merchant1404. Quoted administrative records, but web article lacks full footnote apparatus. No descent to John1577 demonstrated."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ATHY_RENVILLE",
      "title": "Nick Kingsley, Athy (alias Lynch-Athy) of Renville (2016)",
      "type": "published research",
      "url": "https://landedfamilies.blogspot.com/2016/09/229-athy-alias-lynch-athy-of-renville.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Confirms Francis sheriff1639; explicitly leaves later Renville family connection to earlier Galway Athys uncertain. Does not identify Francis’s father."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MSA_SEMMES_PARENTAGE",
      "title": "Papenfuse et al., Biographical Dictionary of the Maryland Legislature, Thomas Semmes, pp.721–722: parentage",
      "type": "scholarly_biographical_reference",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000426/pdf/am426--722.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Both page images visually checked 19 September 2026. Explicit parents and paternal grandparents; original probate documents not inspected. The biography starts at the bottom of p.721 and continues in the left column of p.722."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES43_45",
      "title": "Harry Wright Newman, The Maryland Semmes and Kindred Families (1956), pp.43,45",
      "type": "published_family_history",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/marylandsemmeski00newm/page/43/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed pages 43 and 45 visually inspected. Named parents and descriptions of supporting family wills; original wills not yet checked. The legislative biography may draw on this work, so agreement is not assumed independent."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SEMMES_PROBATE_STAGES",
      "title": "Wilkes County Will Book HH, p.341: Thomas Semmes of Charles County",
      "type": "published_will_abstract_transcription",
      "url": "https://thegagenweb.com/gawilkes/Records/Wills_1819-1836.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Abstract distinguishes handwriting testimony 13 July 1827, Maryland admission 29 May 1832, Georgia recording 1 January 1834. Original record image unexamined. Matching will date 14 September 1785 and children identify the same Thomas."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMMES52",
      "title": "Harry Wright Newman, The Maryland Semmes and Kindred Families (1956), p.52: Thomas probate",
      "type": "published_family_history",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/marylandsemmeski00newm/page/52/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page 52 image verified. Gives death 1832 and Maryland probate 25 May 1832; differs from legislative biography 1827 and will abstract 29 May 1832. Date of death remains unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SEMME_ASSEMBLY1662",
      "title": "Archives of Maryland 1, p.427: Marmaduke Simme sworn as Upper House doorkeeper, 2 April 1662",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000001/am1--427.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published primary record; page image visually verified. Establishes presence by this date, not arrival or birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SEMME_WITNESS1662",
      "title": "Archives of Maryland 41, p.530: Marmaduke Simme witnesses Thomas Gerrard’s release, 11 April 1662",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000041/html/am41--530.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published primary record; page image visually verified. Running heading says 1661 but the instrument explicitly dates itself 11 April 1662. Co-witness Daniel Jenifer also appears in the assembly record."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_SEMME_ORIGINS",
      "title": "Harry Wright Newman, The Maryland Semmes and Kindred Families (1956), introduction xi and p.1",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/marylandsemmeski00newm/page/1/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Both page images visually checked. Distinguish family-origin traditions from demonstrated genealogy. Fortuna’s birth surname is explicitly unknown; Milburn is inferred from descendants’ names. Deed and land-rights accounts are secondary abstracts, original instruments not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_SEMMES",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022), Semmes",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/semmes",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry reports origin undetermined; consulted 19 September 2026. Do not silently substitute the etymology of Simms."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_WILL1673",
      "title": "Jane Baldwin, Maryland Calendar of Wills, vol.1, p.177: George Goodrick, will dated 25 July 1673",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://mdhistory.msa.maryland.gov/msaref09/pdf/baldwin_vol01.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page visually checked, PDF page 185. Refers to will book 5 folio 91. Names sons Robert and Francis; no probate date printed. Do not convert the will date to a death date. Original manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_RENO",
      "title": "St. Mary’s County MDGenWeb, Marriages 1638–1820, G: Goodrick entries attributed to Reno",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://www.usgenwebsites.org/MDStmarys/record/marriage1638-1820g.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Compiled reference names Mary as daughter of Robert and Elizabeth and lists her Anderson, Semmes and Speake marriages. Original Reno entry and underlying record not yet inspected. Repeated rows on this page are not independent evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_GOODRICK",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022), Goodrick",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/goodrick?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English variant of Goodrich associated with Yorkshire and Lincolnshire; also an Americanized German name. Regional etymology is not this branch’s birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_GOODRICH",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022), Goodrich",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/goodrich",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Personal-name, Herefordshire habitational and German possibilities. Consulted 19 September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GOODRICK_LEWIS1658",
      "title": "Archives of Maryland 41, p.60: George Goodrick, administrator of William Lewis, 24 April 1658",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000041/html/am41--60.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Archive transcription read. Page-image download returned 503; image verification remains pending. Entry records an estate inventory and creditor claim, not a family relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SUSANNAH_JENKINS_WILL",
      "title": "Maryland State Archives, will abstracts, Liber 31 folio 922: Susannah Jenkins, 1760–1763",
      "type": "archival_will_abstract",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/msa/stagser/s500/s538/html/s538-31.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Abstract read in full. Will 8 August 1760, witnesses sworn 29 January 1763; names daughter Heneritta Semmes and sons John, George, William. Original manuscript not inspected. Bequests also document ownership and transfer of enslaved people."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_EDWARD_COLE_WILL1717",
      "title": "Maryland Calendar of Wills abstract: Edward Cole, St. Mary’s County, 16 April–20 December 1717, Liber 14 folio 644",
      "type": "published_will_abstract",
      "url": "https://www.usgenwebsites.org/MDStmarys/record/willsc.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcribed abstract read: wife Elizabeth; children include Susanna Jenkins and Mary Jenkins. Original manuscript not inspected. Wife’s presence does not establish maternity of the children."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JENKINS_WILLS1727_1729",
      "title": "Maryland Calendar of Wills, vol.6, pp.40 and 139: Thomas and Ann Jenkins",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/marylandcalendar06cott",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed pages 40/139 visually checked (PDF 89/287). Thomas will 1 November 1726, proved 31 October 1727, Liber 19:251; Ann will 25 June 1729, proved 3 December 1729, Liber 19:836. Lynsei/Lindsey is 150acres, not 160 as OCR says. Abstracts distinguish wifeAnn from daughterAnnSpaulding. Original manuscripts not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS279",
      "title": "Raphael Thomas Semmes, The Semmes and Allied Families (1918), p.279: George Jenkins",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://digital.cincinnatilibrary.org/digital/collection/p16998coll15/id/251207",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page image visually inspected. Explicit parents Thomas and Ann, wife Susannah Cole, daughter Henrietta Semmes. Reported wife’s Spalding surname and dates require independent checking; do not import its entire pedigree. Edward Jenkins account on same page differs from later research. Library metadata confirms author/date."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_JENKINS",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022), Jenkins",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/jenkins",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English and Welsh name, variant of Jenkin with possessive or later added -s; general distribution does not establish this immigrant’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_JENKIN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022), Jenkin",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/jenkin",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derived from medieval pet forms Jankin/Jenkin/Jonkin; -kin could distinguish younger namesakes. Consulted 19 September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SEMMES_ALLIED_JENKINS278",
      "title": "Raphael Thomas Semmes, The Semmes and Allied Families (1918), p.278: origins and land of Thomas Jenkins",
      "type": "compiled_family_history",
      "url": "https://digital.cincinnatilibrary.org/digital/collection/p16998coll15/id/251204",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page image checked. Reports William Jason Jenkins and Anglesey ancestry without a supporting record citation on this page; also names Maryland tracts matching Thomas’s later will. These are separate claims, assessed separately."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BARNES_JENKINS_REVIEW1987",
      "title": "Robert W. Barnes, review of Thomas Jenkins of Maryland 1670, Maryland Historical Magazine 82 (1987), pp.254–255",
      "type": "scholarly_book_review",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc5800/sc5881/000001/000000/000328/pdf/msa_sc_5881_1_328.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed p.255 visually checked, PDF 63. Review says the 1985 book examines European-origin traditions without finding conclusive evidence of alleged English or Welsh kinfolk. This is a review, not inspection of the book’s complete appendix; it does not itself disprove any individual parent candidate."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_COLE_DEPOSITION1663",
      "title": "Archives of Maryland 49, p.3: testimony about Robert and Rebecca Cole’s children, 29 March 1663",
      "type": "published_primary_record",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000049/html/am49--3.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page image visually verified. William Bretton’s deposition, with matching oaths by Luke Gardnor and William Turpine, explicitly identifies both parents and five surviving children. Both parents were deceased. This is the printed archival edition, not an inspection of the manuscript."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_COLE_AMERICAN_ERAS",
      "title": "American Eras: Robert Cole (1628?–1662?), citing Carr, Menard and Walsh, Robert Cole’s World (1991)",
      "type": "secondary_biography",
      "url": "https://www.encyclopedia.com/history/news-wires-white-papers-and-books/cole-robert-1628-1662",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full entry read. Connects Robert’s youngest son Edward to the planter and merchant who died in 1717. Calls Rebecca the widow Knott, which is not evidence of her birth surname. Its William/Joan parent assignment for Robert conflicts with a later Thomas/Jane genealogy and requires comparison with the underlying records."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ROBERT_COLE_WILL1662",
      "title": "Jane Baldwin, Maryland Calendar of Wills, vol.1, p.25: Robert Cole, 1662–1663",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://usgennet.org/usa/md/state/wills/01/014.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Original published abstract page 25 visually checked in local scan, PDF 33. Names mother Mrs Jane Cole of Middlesex, sister Anne Harinton and cousin Henry Hankes. Website editor separately reports Patent Q:78 naming Mrs Joan Cole; that patent has not been inspected. Original will manuscript not inspected. The abstract cites 1:182; later copies may use different liber numbering."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HESTON_COLE_RECUSANTS1632",
      "title": "Middlesex County Records, vol.3, pp.128–159: Process Book, 12 April 1632",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://www.british-history.ac.uk/middx-county-records/vol3/pp128-159",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Visually checked PDF printout pages 2–3 of the British History Online transcription, hosted at ferdinando.one-name.net. Date 12 April, 8 Charles I. Separately lists Jane wife of Thomas Cole and Joan wife of William Cole, both Heston. Published transcription, not original process book. Local evidence heston-recusants.pdf."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_COLE_WHITESIDES2006",
      "title": "Todd Whitesides, research posts of 25 October and 18 November 2006, reproduced in Worland genealogy",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://sites.rootsmagic.com/Worland/site/individual.php?p=3403",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports Thomas Cole and Jane Mainwaring as Robert’s parents, citing family probate and recusancy evidence. Underlying English wills not yet inspected. The hosting profile also merges notes about a younger Maryland Thomas; those notes should not be attributed to the proposed English father."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANN_ATHY_PROPERTY_RECORDS",
      "title": "Lawrence F. Athy, Captain George Athy of Galway and Maryland (1999), p.13",
      "type": "published_family_history_with_record_extracts",
      "url": "https://www.cookancestry.com/History/images/StreamGate%20family%20records.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page13/PDF21 visually checked. Original grant and deed not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BROAD_CREEK_LEWIS",
      "title": "Broad Creek Historic District Preservation Planning Study, historical background, pp.8,10,12",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://pgplanning.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Broad-Creek-History.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Pages visually checked. Identifies the landing as retaining the deceased owner’s name, with underlying deed and probate references. Archaeological dwelling attribution is qualified, not proof of an individual occupant."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_THOMAS_LEWIS_WILL1696",
      "title": "Maryland Calendar of Wills, vol.2, p.102: Thomas Lewis, Prince George’s County",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://ldsgenealogy.com/MD/books/The-Maryland-calendar-of-wills-Wills-from-1685-to-1702-Volume-II-part-8.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full online abstract read; manuscript not inspected. Will22March1695, probate3June1696 as printed; do not silently change the will year. Wife Catharine; sons Richard, Thomas and John. Liber7:150. Some later accounts give different date readings."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_LEWIS",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022), Lewis",
      "type": "published_reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lewis",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry read19September2026. Multiple independent name origins; none establishes a particular overseas birthplace for this Maryland household."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_LUSBY",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022), Lusby",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lusby",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 20 September 2026. Distinguish the English place-name origin from any proved migration of Sarah’s branch."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NATHAN_SARAH_LUSBY_PROFILE",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Sarah Lusby, two marriages and reported parents",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/2/9/e6cce79e31d7629e29badb73392.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 20 September 2026; local HTML preserved. Reports Benjamin A. Willoughby marriage 12 January 1835, Clark County, Kentucky, then John S. McNew 8 November 1839. Parents William Aaron Lusby Jr. and Nancy Hazelrigg. Underlying marriage and parentage records not yet inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_AARON_LUSBY1796_PROFILE",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: William Aaron Lusby Jr.",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/8/c/e6cce79e442652d31546b4ec9c8.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 20 September 2026. Parentage claim and reported dates; underlying records not inspected. Shared compilation with Sarah’s profile, not independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NANCY_HAZELRIGG1796_PROFILE",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Nancy Hazelrigg",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/8/3/e6cce786cc7438427620371e138.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 20 September 2026. Parentage claim and reported dates; underlying records not inspected. Shared compilation with Sarah’s profile, not independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CLARK_LUSBY_PROBATE",
      "title": "Clark County Public Library: court order index, Lusby, William",
      "type": "record_index",
      "url": "https://www.clarkbooks.org/_files/ugd/07c490_32f16233d49c4495826b588eb84e22df.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF page 66 visually checked 20 September 2026. Order Book 5 pp.300,312; original court books not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CLARK_HAZELRIGG_PROBATE",
      "title": "Clark County Public Library: court order index, Hazelrigg, William",
      "type": "record_index",
      "url": "https://www.clarkbooks.org/_files/ugd/07c490_780c80ed99424e258ea298ce09bc14d9.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF page 76 visually checked 20 September 2026. Order Book 6 pp.239–243,305. Original court books not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DAFN_HAZELRIGG",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022), Hazelrigg",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hazelrigg",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 20 September 2026. Surname etymology, not proof of this branch’s English origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BATLEY_REGISTER_COVERAGE",
      "title": "Wakefield & District Family History Society: parish registers on microfiche, Batley All Saints",
      "type": "archive_finding_aid",
      "url": "https://wakefieldfhs.org.uk/Parishes.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 20 September 2026. Lists Batley All Saints WDP37, earliest date 1559; not a guarantee of continuous coverage."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HUDSON_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Hudson",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hudson",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read 20 September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GRACE_HUDSON_TOMLINSON",
      "title": "Vivien Tomlinson: Grace Hudson, Batley",
      "type": "parish_register_reconstruction",
      "url": "https://vivientomlinson.com/batley/p107.htm#i3195",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Marriage and burial attributed to All Saints microfiches; register images not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GILDERSOME_HUDSON_BOOTH",
      "title": "Philip Henry Booth: History of Gildersome and the Booth Family",
      "type": "local_history",
      "url": "https://www.gildersome.net/uploads/1/9/1/0/19101139/hist_gildersome.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Completed 1920; Damian Fox transcription 1999. Page 73 (PDF page 73) describes William Hudson memorial, 1726 trust deed and 1749 covenant. Original deed and stone not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BATLEY_SHEARD_1894",
      "title": "Michael Sheard: Records of the Parish of Batley (1894), local tax lists, chantry and wills",
      "type": "printed_record_transcriptions",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/sheard-michael-records-of-the-parish-of-batley-robert-white-1894",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed pages 117, 261, 263, 295, 357–358 checked against scanned images on 20 September 2026; PDF pages 147, 297, 299, 335, 397–398. Original manuscripts not inspected. Page 117 attributes the chantry list to York archiepiscopal registers; page 261 attributes tax lists to Public Record Office returns."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LISTER_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Lister",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lister",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full dictionary entry read 20 September 2026; modern census summaries not used to infer this branch’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_TINGLE_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Tingle",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/tingle",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full dictionary entry read 20 September 2026; modern census summaries not used to infer this branch’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BATLEY_LISTER_TOMLINSON",
      "title": "Vivien Tomlinson: John Lister and Jane Tingle of Batley",
      "type": "parish_register_reconstruction",
      "url": "https://vivientomlinson.com/batley/p94.htm#i2847",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Marriage attributed to All Saints Batley microfiches. Child and baptism details read in full; original register images not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BATLEY_TINGLE_TOMLINSON",
      "title": "Vivien Tomlinson: Alverey Tingle of Batley",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://vivientomlinson.com/batley/p149.htm#i4421",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports two hearths in 1666 and children John 1627, William 1629, Jane 1638. No parents, wife or baptism for Alverey supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PRICE_LAMBE_PRICE",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Price",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/price",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full entry read 20 September 2026. Name formation is not proof of this branch’s ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PRICE_LAMBE_LAMBE",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Lambe",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lambe",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full entry read 20 September 2026. Name formation is not proof of this branch’s ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PRICE_LAMBE_LAMB",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Lamb",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lamb",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full entry read 20 September 2026. Name formation is not proof of this branch’s ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PRICE_MEIFOD1815",
      "title": "National Library of Wales: David Price, prosecutor, Meifod burglary case, 1815",
      "type": "archive_calendar",
      "url": "https://crimeandpunishment.library.wales/search?file=4%2F200%2F7",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Great Sessions file 4/200/7, document 33, dated 22 November 1815. Calendar read; manuscript not inspected. David Price is prosecutor, not accused. Accused John Humphreys acquitted. No wife or children identified in calendar."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LAMBE_ONIBURY",
      "title": "Onibury parish register transcription: Lambe households, 1664–1669",
      "type": "parish_register_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/Onibury.html#p046",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read online transcription, printed pages 46–49. Henry, son of Henry Lambe of Stanton Lacy and Anne, baptism23August1664; George29April1668. Lewis/LewesLambe andAnne also recorded. Original images not inspected; a comparison household, not assigned as Elizabeth’s ancestors."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SHAW_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Shaw",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/shaw",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full entry read 20 September 2026; English topographic/habitational and distinct Gaelic formations distinguished."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SHAW_RIVINGTON_IRVINE",
      "title": "W. Fergusson Irvine: A Short History of the Township of Rivington (1904), pp.112–113",
      "type": "local_history",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/shorthistoryofto00irvi/page/112/mode/2up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded full scan and text. Printed pages 112–113 (PDF pages 154–155) visually checked on 20 September 2026. The account distinguishes Thomas Asshawe, esquire, from Thomas Shawe, gentleman, among the first governors. The original charter was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_RALPH_SHAW_CHARLES1672",
      "title": "Archives of Maryland, volume 60, p.380: George Taylor’s deed to Ralph Shaw, June 1672",
      "type": "printed_court_record",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000060/html/am60--380.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page 380 visually checked on 20 September 2026. Court held 11 June 1672; indenture dated 4 June 1672 names Ralph Shaw of Charles County, planter. Only the opening passage is used here. The original manuscript was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BALL_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Ball",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/ball",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English and continental derivations read 20 September 2026. These explain the recorded surname, not Mary Ann’s unestablished natal origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BALL_GREAT_BOLAS",
      "title": "Great Bolas parish registers: Ball entries, 1669 and 1738, pp.44–45 and 95",
      "type": "parish_register_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/GreatBolas.html#p095",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Online transcription inspected 20 September 2026, including surrounding year headings. William Ball named churchwarden for 1669; children of Allen and Jane Ball baptised 28 September 1738 and buried in October. Original registers not inspected. Introduction places Great Bolas seven miles north of Wellington."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WEIGEL_GOBEL_P251",
      "title": "Herbert Weigel: ancestor list, p.251, entry ?5152 and Ludwig Göbel reference",
      "type": "sourced_genealogy",
      "url": "https://genealogie-nordwuerttemberg.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/AL-ERHARDT-HILSENBECK-version-2.pdf#page=251",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page image checked 20 September 2026. Specifically cites Schwarz, Altwürttembergische Lagerbücher, II, p.714. Ludwig is a local historical mention, not a numbered parent in this passage. The underlying register and Schwarz page were not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ARCHION_ERPFINGEN_COVERAGE",
      "title": "Archion catalogue: Erpfingen parish registers",
      "type": "archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/baden-wuerttemberg/evangelisches-archiv-baden-und-wuerttemberg-wuerttemberg/dekanat-reutlingen/erpfingen",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Public catalogue retrieved 20 September 2026: Mischbuch 1594–1655 Band 1 and Mischbuch 1597–1739 Band 2. Catalogue inspection, not a search of the register images."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PHILLIPS_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Phillips",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/phillips",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Patronymic from Philip; entry consulted 20 September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PHELPS_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Phelps",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/phelps",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Scottish and southwestern English variant of Phillips; entry consulted 20 September 2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PHELPS_SERVIN1899",
      "title": "Oliver Seymour Phelps and Andrew T. Servin: The Phelps Family of America (1899), volume I, pp.44 and50",
      "type": "compiled_family_history",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/phelpsfamilyofam01phel/page/44/mode/2up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Both page images visually inspected 20 September 2026. Records nineteenth-century conjectures about the Tewkesbury/Staffordshire connection. Its extract attributed to Burke is not independent inspection of Burke or a Tudor record."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PHILIPPES_DYRHAM1416",
      "title": "Mapping the Medieval Countryside: Dyrham partition,4February1416, E-CIPM20-488",
      "type": "edited_medieval_record",
      "url": "https://inquisitionspostmortem.ac.uk/view/inquisition/20-488/index.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full edited text retrieved 20 September 2026. TNA C 138/17/61 mm.1–2. John Philippes is a tenant in the share allotted to John Drayton and Isabel. Original manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PHELPS_PRIOR_JOAN_COKE",
      "title": "William Phelps Prior: letter of 22 December 1877, printed in Phelps and Servin (1899), I, pp11–12",
      "type": "published family correspondence",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/phelpsfamilyofam01phel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Images of printed pages 11–12 inspected. Dame Joan Coke and Podsmead estate are mentioned, but the letter does not identify her as James Phelps’s wife or establish an ancestor’s birth surname. The claimed Phelps estate succession is family information, not a deed inspected here."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CRYPT_PODSMEAD_1539",
      "title": "The Crypt School: Joan Cooke and the purchase of Podsmead in 1539",
      "type": "institutional history",
      "url": "https://cryptschool.org/explore-our-school/our-story/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "School history identifies John and Joan Cooke as founders and says Joan purchased the Podsmead site in 1539. This supplies a concrete alternative historical context for the name in Prior’s estate story; it does not establish which woman Prior intended."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WARWICK_1619_DOROTHY_JAMES",
      "title": "Visitation of Warwickshire, 1619, edited John Fetherston (1877), p62: Greswold pedigree",
      "type": "published edition of heraldic visitation",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/visitationcount01britgoog/page/n87/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page image visually inspected: Henry Greswold is paired with Dorithi, daughter and coheiress of Hen. Jams of Forfeild in Worcestershire. Sons shown: Humphry, Willm., George, Richard. Mother Bridget is not named on this page. This is an edition of the visitation, not inspection of its manuscript. No Phelps spouse appears in this entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_COMPILED_DOROTHY_JAMES_PHELPS",
      "title": "Compiled Dorothy Phelps profile assigning Henry James and Bridget Littleton as parents",
      "type": "compiled pedigree claim",
      "url": "https://www.genealogieonline.nl/genealogie-des-descendants-de-morin-et-desportes/I502337.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A claim under investigation, not independent evidence of parentage. Profile assigns Dorothy to Henry James and Bridget Littleton; comparison with the 1619 Greswold pedigree identifies a concrete competing placement of Henry James’s daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_TOMES_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Tomes",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/tomes?geo-lang=en-US",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English variant of Toms; separate Czech Tomeš and Spanish Tomés formations."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_TOMS_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Toms",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/toms",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English, especially Cornwall, Devon and Dorset: variant of Thom with genitival or post-medieval excrescent -s."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_THOM_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Thom",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/thom",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Consulted for the Thom/Tom personal-name formation underlying English Toms/Tomes."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_TOMMES_JUROR_1420",
      "title": "E-CIPM 21-616: William Tommes, juror at Tewkesbury, 13 November 1420",
      "type": "edited primary record",
      "url": "https://inquisitionspostmortem.ac.uk/view/inquisition/21-616/index.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Edited inquisition of John Rodeney, knight. Writ 10 October 1420; Gloucestershire inquisition held at Tewkesbury 13 November. William Tommes is one of twelve jurors. TNA C 138/52/105 mm1–2; E 149/120/11. No residence, relatives or property assigned to this juror in the inspected text. Original manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_TOMES_LONG_MARSTON",
      "title": "Long Marston Parish Council: Tomes and the manor, 1479 and 1577",
      "type": "published history",
      "url": "https://marstonsicca-pc.gov.uk/our-village-the-history/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Institutional history extracted from the 2001 Village Appraisal reports William Tomes leasing the Abbey Manor in 1479, and John Tomes and John Kecke purchasing land and manor in 1577. Original deeds not inspected. The website distinguishes manorial lordship from land; monetary figures not adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARY_TOMES_VARIANT_ANCESTRY",
      "title": "Compiled Richard Phelps Phylppes profile: Mary Tomes and conflicting chronology",
      "type": "compiled pedigree claim",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/richard-phelps-phylppes-24-1fyt90h",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "User-tree aggregate gives Mary1502–1588, Richard1497–10May1588 and children including Robert1584. This conflicts with normal maternal chronology and with the MyTrees1529 death; not independent original evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PHELPS_ELLSWORTH_CHART_CLAIM",
      "title": "Holcombe compilation: competing Phelps parentage attributed to the Ellsworth chart",
      "type": "compiled pedigree claim",
      "url": "https://www.holcombegenealogy.com/g0/p92.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page reports Joseph Phelps and Margaret Tomes daughter of John as James’s parents in a chart for Rev John Phelps Ellsworth. The chart and supporting records were not inspected. This is a competing compiled account, not proof of the alternative parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_FENNELL_AHERN",
      "title": "Michael Ahern, The Quakers of County Tipperary 1655–1924 (2003), pp 75, 150",
      "type": "academic thesis",
      "url": "https://mural.maynoothuniversity.ie/id/eprint/9210/1/Michael%20Ahern_Phd.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded thesis; printed pages 75 and 150 visually inspected. Page 75 challenges Susan as daughter of John Fennell and suggests sister as possible; page 150 gives John’s parents Robert and Mary, birth 1626 Steepleashton, marriage 1649 Cardiff and move c 1659. Underlying Burke pedigree and hearth-roll manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_FENNELL_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Fennell",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/fennell",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English plant/occupation/topographic formation distinguished from Irish Ó Fionnghail."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PHELPS_OWENS_DEED_CLAIM",
      "title": "Southern Colonial Phelps project: quoted deeds 11/229 and 11/230, 1676",
      "type": "quoted archive description",
      "url": "https://sites.google.com/site/archivedydnaphelpsgenealogies/06-three-phelps-felps-lines-with-relevant-ydna-matches/common-ancestor-of-david-b-1817-tn-and-ancestor-descendant-of-felps-of-baltimore-co-b-ca-1678/theories-on-the-origin-of-this-thomas-felps",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Inspected project transcription of catalogue description:23 May 1676 Thomas Phelps County Limerick merchant and Susannah; wife daughter of John Owens Ludlow mercer. Original catalogue and deed not inspected. Do not equate this mercer with Dr John Owen. Adjacent 11/230 names Thomas junior’s uncle John Phelps."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SUSANNA_FENNELL_COMPILED",
      "title": "Compiled Susanna Fennell profile: Henry Fennell and Mary Sixworth claim",
      "type": "compiled pedigree claim",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/susanna-fennell-24-3580s",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Aggregate pedigree gives these parents; original parent-naming record not inspected. Conflicting family reconstructions are retained as claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANNE_BRADFORD_COMPILED",
      "title": "FamilySearch compiled Anne Bradford profile GQKY-NLT",
      "type": "compiled pedigree claim",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/GQKY-NLT/anne-bradford-1708",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Inspected 20 September 2026:zero sources; marriage 1687; death 11 September 1706; children 1650, 1663, 1676. These are profile claims, not certified records."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_QUAKER_CALENDAR",
      "title": "Library of the Society of Friends: The Quaker calendar",
      "type": "institutional research guide",
      "url": "https://www.quaker.org.uk/documents/quaker-calendar-lib-guide-2018",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Guide consulted for pre 1752 numbering:eleventh month January and possible double year. Original Anne death entry and editorial date convention remain uninspected. No automatic Gregorian day-shift adopted."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCNEW_ELIZABETH_PARENTS",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Elizabeth Betsy McNew and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/d/f/e6cce7a776d550fd5c5e7e60ffd.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026. Explicitly identifies Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith as parents. Same compilation as existing sibling source, not independent confirmation. Original parent-naming record not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCNEW_MARGARET_PARENTS",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Margaret McNew and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/8/d/e6cce7a932f5ced90fb39c0e0d8.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026. Explicitly identifies Elisha I. McNew and Nancy Catherine Smith as parents. Same compilation as existing sibling source, not independent confirmation. Original parent-naming record not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SARAH_SMITH_MCNEW_PROFILE",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Sarah Catherine Smith",
      "type": "compiled pedigree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/4/b/e6cce7da94e6ea86211efc2beb4.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read. Reports North Carolina birth1790, death5April1883 CampbellCountyTN, MaupinCemetery burial and marriage1816 to WilliamJMcNew. No parents listed. Its FindAGrave citation is a generic homepage rather than an inspected memorial or gravestone."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SMITH_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names (2022): Smith",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/smith",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English/Scottish metalworker; forge-place formation also possible. Some Gaelic and continental surnames translated or assimilated as Smith. No branch-specific national origin established."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CAMPBELL1850_P14",
      "title": "Rick Chambers transcription: Campbell County census, 8–10 October 1850, households537–559",
      "type": "published census transcription",
      "url": "https://www.tngenweb.org/campbell/census/1850/p14.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read households537 JaneSmith85VA with James57VA;550 BenjaminSmith58NC with Rhoda44TN;559 F.P.McNew26TN with Sallie32KY. Names/ages/places transcribed from1850schedule; original image not inspected. Household relationships are not stated in this census."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CAMPBELL1850_P13",
      "title": "Rick Chambers transcription: Campbell County census, Elisha McNew household521",
      "type": "published census transcription",
      "url": "https://www.tngenweb.org/campbell/census/1850/p13.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "8October1850, Elisha37 and Susan37, bothTN, with younger people. Read as actual differing household, not target Sarah1790NC. Original census image not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CAMPBELL_CEMETERY_DIRECTORY",
      "title": "Campbell County TNGenWeb: Maupin and Smith cemetery locations",
      "type": "local cemetery directory",
      "url": "https://www.tngenweb.org/campbell/cemetery/cemindex.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Directory locates MaupinCemetery at AppalachianHighway/DoakesCreek,WellSpring; separately lists a SmithCemetery at those roads, and BenjaminSmith/RobertCSmith grounds. Does not identify Sarah’s burial or kinship; linked individual Smith listings not retrieved."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1850",
      "title": "Grand River Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1850 census transcription",
      "type": "census_transcription",
      "url": "https://henry.mogenweb.org/Census/1850griv.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page53, dwelling333/family343, 27September1850: JohnS46NC, Sarah35KY; SarahJ11, Hugh9, Nancy6, William5, John4, Fredrick1, Elisha2months, all Missouri. Transcript inspected through indexed full text; manuscript image not inspected. The census does not state relationships. A separate Frederick35/Charlotte33 household at337/347 includes Frederick5; do not confuse that child with Fredrick1 in John’s household."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCNEW_HOUSEHOLD_1860",
      "title": "Osage Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1860 census transcription",
      "type": "census_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.henry.mogenweb.org/Census/1860osag.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page17, dwelling362/family362, 27June1860: John54NC, Sarah42KY; William15, John13, Frederick10, Elisha8, Mary7, JamesR5, SusanA4, SallyA3, all Missouri. EmelineBurton15 also resides here. Relationships are not stated. JamesR is transcribed female, conflicting with the compiled male profile; original image remains to be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_NANCY",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Nancy McNew and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/3/8/e6cce7a98cd623bb96f30e3983.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026; explicitly names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. Same compilation as the family page, not an independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_WILLIAM",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: William McNew and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/9/a/e6cce7aa2004675641b9a2effa9.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026; explicitly names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. Same compilation as the family page, not an independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_JOHN",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: John Biser McNew and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/0/d/e6cce7a88f26158a722e4e977d0.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026; explicitly names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. Same compilation as the family page, not an independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_HENRY",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Henry McNew and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/a/3/e6cce7a819f21e7ea2d470fb13a.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026; explicitly names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. Same compilation as the family page, not an independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_FREDERICK",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Frederick McNew and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/d/c/e6cce7a7cabdaca8580e79b5cd.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026; explicitly names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. Same compilation as the family page, not an independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_ELISHA",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Elisha McNeil and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/3/3/e6cce7a6d1c18e4da5184213a33.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026; explicitly names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. Same compilation as the family page, not an independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_JAMES",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: James R. McNew and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/b/6/e6cce7a83873fd3b70f18cbe6b.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026; explicitly names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. Same compilation as the family page, not an independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_MARY",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Mary McNew and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/c/0/e6cce7a95c82186539d7a9cb90c.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026; explicitly names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. Same compilation as the family page, not an independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_SUSAN",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Susan A. McNew and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/d/d/e6cce7a9f233e140ab929ab95dd.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026; explicitly names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. Same compilation as the family page, not an independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JOHNS_CHILD_SALLY",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Sally A. McNew and parents",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/c/9/e6cce7a9d9527345db81f77669c.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Individual profile downloaded and read20September2026; explicitly names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. Same compilation as the family page, not an independent confirmation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CRAIG_PETERSSON_2007",
      "title": "Peter S. Craig, Samuel Petersson of Christina and His Descendants, Swedish Colonial News3(6),2007, pp2,4",
      "type": "historical_genealogy",
      "url": "https://colonialswedes.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/SCNewsSpring-Summer07.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded; pages2 and4 visually inspected. Scholarly reconstruction, not original registers. Identifies the Stalcop/Petersson household and distinguishes two contemporary Samuel Peterssons."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CRAIG_STALCOP_SHEETS",
      "title": "Peter S. Craig annotated Stalcop family sheet, Israel Peterson free sample, PDF p49",
      "type": "research_family_sheets",
      "url": "https://craigcollection.colonialswedes.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Israel-Peterson-package-26-August-2020-forWeb.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page49 visually inspected. Cites John Stalcop’s 1679 will and identifies Peter among the children; names Christina’s father Carl Johnson. Same researcher as 2007 article; not independent corroboration. Dates have manuscript revisions."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NEWCASTLE_WILL_INDEX",
      "title": "New Castle County will index: Peter Stallcop, B:193",
      "type": "probate_index",
      "url": "https://genealogytrails.com/del/newcastle/will_list_1682-1799.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Will dated3September 1709; proved16May 1710. Index, not the will manuscript. John Anderson aliasStalcup also appears A:79; distinguish will from death dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_STALCOP_ONLINE_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "title": "FamilyTreeClimber: reported Stalcop parentage",
      "type": "historical_research",
      "url": "https://www.familytreeclimber.com/merisfamilyhistory/Frame-958548-kremianstalcuplinespage958548.html?refresh=1269449267744",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed passage assigns Anders Andriessen and Christina Coolbrant as Johan’s parents. Direct retrieval unavailable; used only to document the claim being evaluated, not as proof of parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_STALLCUP_1991",
      "title": "Larry S. Stallcup, Johan Andersson Stålcop, Swedish Colonial News1(4),1991,p2",
      "type": "historical_research",
      "url": "https://colonialswedes.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/SCSJournal_1991-Fall.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded; page2 visually checked. The breastplate explanation is presented as probable, not proven."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ISOF_PATRONYMIC",
      "title": "Institutet för språk och folkminnen: Vad är ett patronymikon?",
      "type": "official_name_reference",
      "url": "https://www.isof.se/namn/vanliga-fragor-och-svar-om-namn/fragor-och-svar-namn/vad-ar-ett-patronymikon",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official Swedish naming guidance; patronymics derive from a father’s given name and can subsequently become inherited surnames."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MERCURIUS_2006",
      "title": "Swedish Colonial News3(4),2006: Mercurius passenger families, pp14–15",
      "type": "historical_research",
      "url": "https://colonialswedes.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/SCN-Volume-3-Number-4-Spring-Summer-2006.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded and page15 visually checked; historical reconstruction of the 1655–1656 voyage. CarlJönsson entry28 and JönsJönsson entry27 are separate households."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CRAIG_1693_CH5",
      "title": "Peter S. Craig, The 1693 Census of the Swedes on the Delaware, chapters5–6",
      "type": "historical_research",
      "url": "https://nc-chap.org/cranehook/pdfs/cranehook1693c.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Web text inspected, including printed90–92,110 and household119. Local PDF retrieval unavailable. References identify a John Andersson Cock distinct from Stalcop."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NEWCASTLE_DEERPOINT_1680",
      "title": "Records of the court of New Castle on Delaware 1676–1681: JohnAndriess land transfer",
      "type": "court_record_transcription",
      "url": "https://ldsgenealogy.com/DE/books/Records-of-the-court-of-New-Castle-on-Delaware-1676-1681-part-33.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Published court-record transcription. Identifies the parents in the 1673 conveyance and the subsequent transfer to Arnold deLagrange; manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_PARENT_CLAIM",
      "title": "Lora Hatfield genealogy: Hans Georg Smidt, copying WikiTree Smidt-20",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://gw.geneanet.org/loralynn?n=smidt&oc=&p=hans+georg&type=fiche",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Names Petter Smidt and Magdalena Hindrichsdotter Huwalt as parents; reproduces a2019 WikiTree biography. Not an independent source from WikiTree. Cites a precise1696 Falun baptism locator and a report of Hans’s1720 inheritance instructions."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BURIAL_1753",
      "title": "Springer and Springer: Holy Trinity burials,1753, Third Book p913",
      "type": "church_record_transcription",
      "url": "https://genealogytrails.com/del/newcastle/cemetery_oldswede.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "27December1753 burial entry identifies Hans Smidt, Falun-born hatmaker, arrived172[0]. This is a burial date; original manuscript not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANS_SMIDT_BAPTISM_LOCATOR",
      "title": "Falu Kristine C I:1(1694–1700), p41, cited baptism image",
      "type": "uninspected_record_locator",
      "url": "https://sok.riksarkivet.se/bildvisning/C0012371_00048",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "SE/ULA/11441/C I/1, page41. Precise locator supplied by the compiled genealogy; image not inspected. HTTP403 and unavailable browser prevented access. Do not describe the parents as personally read from the register."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NATHAN_HANS_SMIDT",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Hans Jurgen Georg Smith/Smidt",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/3/3/e6cce7db286373b7340aac11933.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded/read. Birth3November1696 at Fahlun, marriageabout1720 toMariaStallkop, eightchildren includingTobias. No parents on this individual page."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NATHAN_PETTER_SMIDT",
      "title": "Nathan McNew: Peter Smith/Schmidt/Smidt",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/c/1/e6cce7db23051c7e8fbbf56081c.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded parent profile. Names wife Magdalena, son Hans and daughter Magdalena; birth before 1667 Germany, death before 15 March 1720. Cites Susan: My Twigs and Branches; no upstream parents or original record citation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NATHAN_MAGDALENA_HUWALT",
      "title": "Nathan McNew: Magdalena Hindrichdotteer Huwalt",
      "type": "public_gramps_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/4/0/e6cce7907ba4440ac3d19b5bf04.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded parent profile. Wife of Peter; mother of Hans and Magdalena. Death after 15 March 1720. Cites the same Susan compilation; no parents supplied."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SMIDT_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition: Smidt",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/smidt",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 dictionary entry explicitly identifies Dutch Smit and German Schmidt variants; unrelated site-generated prose is not used."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SCHMIDT_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Schmidt",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=SCHMIDT",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Occupational name for a blacksmith from Middle High German smit; broad European distribution is not a birthplace for this branch."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LANKFORD_FURNISS",
      "title": "Wilmer O. Lankford, They Lived in Somerset (1990), Furniss entries, p70",
      "type": "published_record_abstract",
      "url": "https://www.mdgenweb.org/somerset/tlis/tlis1_f.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Rosannah born to William and Olive, listed 1680/01/01, citing IKL; testimony attributed to John Bennett and Olive. Original birth register not inspected. Names normalized; day1 may be a placeholder under the editorial conventions."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LANKFORD_EXPLANATORY",
      "title": "Lankford, They Lived in Somerset: explanatory notes",
      "type": "editorial_reference",
      "url": "https://www.mdgenweb.org/somerset/tlis/tlis1exp.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Dates Old Style; day1 inserted when day missing or illegible. IKL means a Somerset County record liber. The compiler standardizes surnames."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ROSE_FURNIS_CLAIM",
      "title": "Geneanet: reported Rosannah Furnis identity and parentage",
      "type": "compiled_tree_index",
      "url": "https://www.geneanet.org/fonds/individus/?go=1&nom=FURNIS&prenom=Rosannah&size=50",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Several user trees identify Thomas Felps’s wife with William and Olive’s Rosannah. Other entries assign a Tilghman husband. Index claims not independent evidence; full underlying source chains unverified."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_OLIVE_STRAWBRIDGE_1689",
      "title": "Maryland State Archives, Somerset Judicial Records, vol91, p130, 13 June1689",
      "type": "original_court_record_image",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc2900/sc2908/000001/000091/html/am91--130.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded linked PDF and extracted embedded manuscript image; visually verified header and opening lines identifying John Strawbridge as administrator through marriage to Olive Furnish, widow and administratrix of deceased William. This proves her remarriage, not Rosannah’s later identity as Rose Felps."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_FURNESS_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition: Furness",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/furness",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 entry: district in Cumbria, formerly Lancashire; occasionally Furneaux confusion; Norwegian Furnes is a separate formation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_OLIVE_EATON_RECONSTRUCTION",
      "title": "ACV Ancestors: Olive Eaton and the Lane, Ivery and Barre households",
      "type": "compiled_research",
      "url": "https://acvancestors.com/g3/p3380.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reproduces MilesFiles research and record citations. Includes a1655/56 gift to children George and Olive Leene and youngest daughter Margaret, plus later Barre connection. Contradictions between structured dates and quoted1655divorce warn against importing the assembled pedigree as a unit."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_FURNIS_KNEESALL_CLAIM",
      "title": "FamilySearch compiled profile: Thomas Furnis III",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/PSPH-CWW/thomas-furnis-iii-1600-1672",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Proposes Thomas and Ann as parents of William; lists indexed English baptism sources, but individual register entry not inspected and identity with Somerset planter unresolved. Its1708death for William conflicts with the1689widowhood record."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANNE_FURNIS_CLAIM",
      "title": "FamilySearch: Ann Robberds, proposed mother of William Furnis",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/PSPH-636/ann-robberds-1600-1669",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Names Ann/Anne through indexed birth/christening sources. Her reported Robberds surname and dates are not established by the visible source titles."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAM_FURNIS_FS",
      "title": "FamilySearch: William Furnis, L41P-T1G",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/L41P-T1G/william-furnis-1632-1708",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Public page downloaded and browser source dialog checked. English baptism sources listed, but detail requires sign-in. Structured profile connects Thomas/Ann to the husband of Olive and father of Rosannah; its William1708 and Olive1685 deaths conflict with the1689 court record. This is a compiled identification with unresolved vital-date errors, not direct inspection of baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KNEESALL_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Nottinghamshire Archives parish register inventory, August2022, p67",
      "type": "archive_inventory",
      "url": "https://www.inspireculture.org.uk/documents/2780/Ancestry_PRs_all_25_Aug_2022.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded and visually inspected page67. Kneesall PR2767 baptisms/marriages1682–1739, burials1682–1738. Inventory of parish registers does not establish absence of earlier bishop transcripts."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KNEESALL_BT_GUIDE",
      "title": "Kneesall parish records guide: registers and bishop transcripts",
      "type": "record_finding_aid",
      "url": "https://parishmouse.co.uk/england/nottinghamshire/kneesall-nottinghamshire-family-history-guide/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports parish registers from1682 and bishop transcripts1600–1861; lists David J. Bradbury, People of Kneesall in the early17thcentury. This is collection coverage, not proof every intervening year survives."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KNEESALL_CONFLICTING_PEDIGREES",
      "title": "Geneanet: conflicting Furnis pedigrees associated with Kneesall",
      "type": "compiled_tree_index",
      "url": "https://www.geneanet.org/fonds/individus/?go=1&nom=FURNIS&place__0__=Kneesal&size=50",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports Anne as Robberds/Inman and Thomas/Isabell pedigrees with a1638marriage assigned above a reported1600son. Other entries place apparently combined lives in Alcester/Towcester. Used to document competing claims, not independent proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HEINTZE_FRICKE",
      "title": "Albert Heintze, Die deutschen Familiennamen, FRITH entry, p137",
      "type": "historical_surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.gutenberg.org/files/58804/58804-h/58804-h.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read digitized text: groups Fricke among diminutives of Frith personal names; gives Latinized Friccius. Linguistic evidence, not a pedigree or proof of a particular Hanoverian family."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JAMES_ROBINSON_WILL1726",
      "title": "Calendar of Delaware Wills (1911), p26: James Robinson, 1726",
      "type": "published_will_abstract",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/acalendardelawa00commgoog/page/n32/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDFpage33/printed26 visually inspected. Will4Dec1726, probate30Dec1726, Misc1.408. Daughter Cathren Mack Donald; wife Cathren; daughter Ann Hollingsworth; named sons and siblings. Original will not inspected. Does not state Howell surname or explicitly call wife mother of daughter."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ROBINSON_DEED1735_SUMMARY",
      "title": "Sherry Sharp genealogy: David Robinson, summary of 16May1735 property agreement",
      "type": "compiled_record_summary",
      "url": "https://sherrysharp.com/genealogy/getperson.php?personID=I49446&tree=Roots",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full HTML retrieved. Joseph, John and Priscilla Robinson sell Bread and Cheese Island property to Morton Justies; indemnity names Bryan McDonald and wife Catherine, Stephen Hollingsworth and wife Ann, George, David and Phebe Robinson. No deed book/page supplied in displayed summary; original not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CATHERINE_ROBINSON_NATHAN",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Catherine Priscilla Robinson",
      "type": "compiled_tree",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/c/4/e6cce7c734d1644e9c4f89a034c.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Names James Robinson and Catherine Howell as parents. Contradictory1760burial and deathafterMay1766. Middle name Priscilla and exact marriage8Dec1715 remain derivative. Sources include Kenneth Johnson pedigree and FindAGrave."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_STANDING_ROBINSON",
      "title": "Herbert Standing, Quakers in Delaware in the Time of William Penn, pp132–133",
      "type": "scholarly_local_history",
      "url": "https://nc-chap.org/church/quaker/standingDH3crop.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Pages10–11 visually inspected. George’s widow Ann and sons James, George, John, Joseph; competing Cope interpretation of George junior’s identity. Underlying deeds and Cope clipping not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LEACH_HOWELL_WILLS",
      "title": "Josiah Granville Leach, Genealogical and Biographical Memorials (1898), pp140–143",
      "type": "published_document_transcription",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/genealogicaland00leacgoog/page/n223/mode/1up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Scanned pp140–143 visually inspected: Thomas’s probate, estate agreement concerning Tamworth property and daughters, and widow Katharine’s1695will naming daughter Katharine Robinson. Original deeds and wills not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ROBINSON_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names,2nd ed: Robinson",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/Robinson",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English patronymic Robin/Robert; Lancashire/Yorkshire association. General surname history, not origin of George."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HOWELL_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names,2nd ed: Howell",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/Howell",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Welsh Hywel; possible Breton and English personal-name formations; Lincolnshire place-name alternative."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANN_CURTIS_CONFLICT",
      "title": "FamilySearch Ann Curtis MBPW-Z5G: conflicting family narratives",
      "type": "compiled_tree_conflict",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/MBPW-Z5G/ann-curtis-1641-1703",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Public profile couples Robinson pedigree with story of Ann Curtis married Haslewood, Gill and Blacksfeil. Neither identity established by displayed FindAGrave source."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SPIESS_GOBLE0967",
      "title": "Evelyn Goble Steen, German Trees: Hans Georg Spiess",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://goblegenealogy.com/data/German/grpf0967.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2012 compilation, citing David Donaldson: Maria Magdalene’s father Hans Georg died before 1725. No parents or named wife supplied. Public page retrieved locally; no original church entry inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SPIESS_OFFENBACH_FORUM",
      "title": "Jörg Hofmann and contributors, Brill in Thalfang / Offenbach am Glan, 2021",
      "type": "research_correspondence",
      "url": "https://discourse.genealogy.net/t/brill-in-thalfang-brill-in-offenbach-am-glan/738622",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Researchers cite St. Julian church book and Karl Pfleger’s family book. Includes corrections to marriage and godparent information. Original images have not been inspected in this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_STJULIAN_ARCHION89_1",
      "title": "Archion catalogue: St. Julian Lutheran register 89/1",
      "type": "archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/nordrhein-westfalen/archiv-der-evangelischen-kirche-im-rheinland/st-julian/267813",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche im Rheinland. Baptisms, marriages and burials 1634–1782; also Offenbach and neighboring villages. Catalogue notes gaps. Catalogue consulted, not register images."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SPIES_DAFN2",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Spies and Spiess",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://de.geneanet.org/familiennamen/SPIES",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "2022 Oxford dictionary reproduced in German translation by Geneanet. Spiess is a variant of Spies; occupational and place-derived explanations are distinguished."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BARTEE_MESDA1686",
      "title": "MESDA research card: Robert Bartee, carpenter, 1685/6",
      "type": "museum_record_abstract",
      "url": "https://mesda.org/item/craftsman/bartee-robert/1802/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Craftsman ID 1812. Card visually inspected; abstracts Lower Norfolk Deed Book 4, page 220a. Original deed not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BARTEE_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Bartee",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/Bartee",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022: probably an altered form of Scottish Bartie."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BARTIE_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names: Bartie",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/bartie?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Second edition, 2022: Scottish, associated with Midlothian; familiar form of Bartholomew."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BARTEE_ORIGIN_NEWSLETTER",
      "title": "Bartee family history: newsletter-derived account",
      "type": "compiled_family_history",
      "url": "https://www.geocities.ws/RodeoDrive/1512/bartee.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports uncertain origin for Robert and discusses French and Acadian namesakes without a documented connecting pedigree. Used to assess the origin claim, not as proof of it."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BUTT_MCINTOSH1675",
      "title": "McIntosh: Robert Butt’s will, 1675–1676, abstract page 48",
      "type": "scanned_published_record_abstract",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/briefabstractofl01mcin/page/48/mode/2up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page 48 visually inspected. Lower Norfolk Book 4, folio 13; dated 1 November 1675, proved 3 July 1676. Names Jane as wife and executrix, four sons, Arthur Sayer and witnesses. Original not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JANE_WIKITREE_WILL",
      "title": "WikiTree Unknown-728366: transcription of Robert Butt’s will",
      "type": "published_record_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Unknown-728366",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Retrieved via public WikiTree API, including spouse profile attached to Butt-441. Cites Lower Norfolk deeds and wills volume 4, pages 13–13a, film 32825, DGS 7645627, image 44; FamilySearch transcription by Corbeau4. Original image not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SCOTT_DAFN",
      "title": "Scott: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/Scott",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry distinguishes an ethnic or geographical byname, a rare medieval personal name, and the English Scutt variant. General surname history, not a pedigree for Malinda."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SCOTT_WASHINGTON1782",
      "title": "Washington County personal property tax list, 1782; Jeffrey C. Weaver transcription",
      "type": "published_record_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/washington-personal-property-tax-list-1782/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcribed June1998. Multiple Scott entries, including Thomas, Samuel and William in Robert Campbell’s precinct. Original not inspected; transcription warns of damage and missing material."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_OBERGLEEN_ARCHION",
      "title": "Ober-Gleen parish registers: Archion catalogue",
      "type": "archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/de/alle-archive/hessen/zentralarchiv-der-evangelischen-kirche-in-hessen-und-nassau/dekanat-alsfeld/ober-gleen",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Registers listed from1685. Includes baptisms1778–1807 and1808–1839, marriages1779–1807 and1808–1875. Catalogue inspected; record images not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DECHERT_DAFN",
      "title": "Dechert: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/dechert",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Entry explicitly concerns Dechert. Geneanet also displays it under Decher. Used as a qualified related-name explanation, not proof of Anna’s surname formation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DECHER_FWB",
      "title": "Decher: Frühneuhochdeutsches Wörterbuch",
      "type": "historical_dictionary",
      "url": "https://fwb-online.de/go/decher.s.0m_1732344953",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Attests a ten-piece measure for leather, skins and parchment. Lexical evidence, not an identification of an ancestor’s occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DECHER_SCHMIDT1939",
      "title": "János Schmidt: Hessian immigration to Tolna, Baranya and Somogy (1939), page63",
      "type": "scanned_historical_study",
      "url": "https://medit.lutheran.hu/files/monografia_1939_nemet_telepesek.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed/PDF page63 visually inspected. Names Rainrod Decher settlers, later Dächert, citing Varsád parish registers. Those underlying registers have not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WENDEL_DAFN",
      "title": "Wendel: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/Wendel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Personal-name formation from Wendel/Wando, alongside a German occupational explanation for a turner. These alternatives are not resolved for Anna’s branch."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GRAU_DAFN",
      "title": "Grau: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/grau?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "German gray-hair/beard nickname; independent Catalan and French formations. General surname history does not establish the origin of this branch."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GRAU_HFV",
      "title": "Hessische familiengeschichtliche Vereinigung: loose pedigrees F–G",
      "type": "genealogical_archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.hfv-ev.de/archivbestande/lose-ahnenlisten/lose-ahnenlisten-f-g/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Grau is listed without locality or date. The separate Graul entry concerns Burg Gemünden and other places; it is not evidence for Anna Catharina Grau. Underlying Grau pedigree not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NJ_ARCHIVES_VITAL_GUIDE",
      "title": "New Jersey State Archives: genealogical collections and vital-record coverage",
      "type": "official_archive_guide",
      "url": "https://nj.gov/state/archives/search-genealogical-collections.shtml",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read20September2026. State vital records begin1May1848; links to marriage1848–1900 and death1848–1878 and1878–1900 indexes. Database links returned403 to the research tool; no individual search result was obtained. This guide establishes holdings, not an event for Elizabeth."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANTHONY_MCNEW_PROFILE",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy: Anthony McNew/McKnew and parents",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/ppl/1/0/e6cce7aa6f351cd05e679350301.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded20September2026. Reports birthabout1670CharlesCounty; parents Jeremiahabout1640 and Phillisabout1645; siblings JohnHoward,Lomax,Jeremiah. Sole citation is Susan, My Twigs and Branches. Not an original record or independent confirmation of that source."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCNEW_SUSAN_SOURCE",
      "title": "Nathan McNew genealogy source catalogue: Susan, My Twigs and Branches",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy_source_list",
      "url": "https://www.nathanmcnew.com/genealogy/src/5/f/e6cce736f8c10d2ee07b5e732f5.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Susan and the former RootsWeb database williamsbranches. Provides no original court, church or probate citation for Anthony. Source page inspected20September2026."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCNEW_DAFN",
      "title": "McNew: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003, 2006), via FamilySearch",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=mcnew",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes McNew as probably an altered form of an unidentified Scottish or Irish surname. This is an entry for McNew, not proof of the sixteenth-century spelling Mackneugh or a particular Gaelic etymology."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SCOTLAND_OPR_COVERAGE",
      "title": "National Records of Scotland: Old Parish Registers",
      "type": "official_archive_guide",
      "url": "https://www.nrscotland.gov.uk/learning-and-events/research-guides/old-parish-registers/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Earliest entry27December1553 at Errol. Coverage begins after the claimed1518–1550 lifespan; no inference that all other contemporary record classes are absent."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SCOTLAND_TESTAMENT_GUIDE",
      "title": "Scotland’s People: wills and testaments guide",
      "type": "official_archive_guide",
      "url": "https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/guides/wills-and-testaments",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Index dates1513–1925. Guide inspected; individual record searches require login and were not completed in this investigation. Existence of the collection is not evidence that Matthew left a testament."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BOULTON_DAFN",
      "title": "Boulton: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003, 2006), via FamilySearch",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=boulton",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Boulton is an English variant of Bolton."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BOLTON_DAFN",
      "title": "Bolton: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003, 2006), via FamilySearch",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=bolton",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Habitational surname from multiple Bolton/Boulton places; Old English dwelling/house and enclosure/settlement. No single place is assigned to Thomas."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BOULTON_HARGRAVES1834",
      "title": "Richard Sylvanus Williams, A Survey of Staffordshire Medical Practitioners in 1851, draft14June2018: Joseph Hargraves, entry103",
      "type": "historical_study_with_record_transcriptions",
      "url": "https://practitioners.exeter.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Working-Paper-Richard-Sylvanus-Williams-1851.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDFpage129 visually inspected. Cites Derby Mercury13August1834 for Mary Ann and William Boulton; marriage dated5August1834Trentham. Newspaper original not inspected; preserve Hansford wording as a likely Hanford reference pending verification."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SCHAAF_DAFN",
      "title": "Schaaf: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003, 2006), via FamilySearch",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=schaaf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "German variant of Schaf; independent Dutch occupational name from carpenter’s plane. This is surname history, not proof of this branch’s founding occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SCHAF_DAFN",
      "title": "Schaf: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003, 2006), via FamilySearch",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=schaf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "German occupational name for a herdsman, from Middle High German words for sheep. This is surname history, not proof of this branch’s founding occupation."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_VINES_DAFN",
      "title": "Vines: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003, 2006), via FamilySearch",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=vines",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English variant of Vine with added s; separate Asturian-Leonese and Catalan forms also listed."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_VINE_DAFN",
      "title": "Vine: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003, 2006), via FamilySearch",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=VINE",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English topographic name of Norman linguistic origin, from Old French vigne; vineyard residence/work, or occasionally a vine house/inn sign. Does not establish this branch’s national origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_VINES_LINCOLN_INDEX",
      "title": "John Vogt, Marriage Bonds of Lincoln County, North Carolina, 1783–1866 (2013): brides index, p.204",
      "type": "published_record_index",
      "url": "https://genealogyresources.org/Index-Lcnc.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDFpage52/printed204 downloaded, rendered and visually inspected: Vines, Agness41; Susannah41. Referenced bodypage41 not retrieved. Index contains no event dates or spouse names. Shared page does not demonstrate kinship or simultaneous events."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_VOGT_LINCOLN_CATALOG",
      "title": "Iberian Publishing: John Vogt’s Lincoln County marriage-bond compilation",
      "type": "publisher_catalog",
      "url": "https://www.genealogyresources.org/se-recs.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Catalogue identifies2013volume,213pages, records from NCStateArchives via1930sWPAtranscriptions; alphabetical bygroom withbridesindex. Stated1783start doesnot independently overturn supplied1782bond date."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_COSTIN_WRENCH1760",
      "title": "Maryland State Archives: Richard Costin will, Liber31 folio142",
      "type": "archive_published_will_abstract",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/msa/stagser/s500/s538/html/s538-31.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "QueenAnnsCounty will21October1760, proved22January1761. DaughterElizabethWrench named. No Countiss relationship in abstract. Original not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_RUSSELL_DAFN",
      "title": "Russell: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003, 2006), via FamilySearch",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=russell",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Norman red/reddish nickname or personal name; independent habitational explanations and Americanized German forms also listed. Conditional background for a reported, unverified surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_COUNTISS_DAFN",
      "title": "Countiss: Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/countiss",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English variant of Countess."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_COUNTESS_DAFN",
      "title": "Countess: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003, 2006), via FamilySearch",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=countess",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English, associated withNottinghamshire; Norman linguistic origin, nickname or servant of a countess. Not evidence of nobility."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GREENE_DAFN",
      "title": "Greene: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/greene",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English and Irish variant of Green; some American bearers have surnames assimilated from other languages."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PETER_COUNTISS_WILL1746",
      "title": "Peter Countiss: recorded will, 7 May 1746; probate 30 May 1746, liber24 folios407–408",
      "type": "archive_record_image",
      "url": "https://guide.msa.maryland.gov/pages/item.aspx?ID=S538-35",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Recorded copy visually inspected, viewer images 408–409. Peter, a Queen Anne’s County planter, names sons James and William. James receives Hawkins Farm and a second tract of 70 acres bought by Peter’s unnamed father from Robert Smith. Wife and other children are unnamed. The abbreviated Gibb abstract omits William; this assessment uses the image."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JAMES_COUNTISS_WILL1731",
      "title": "James Countiss: recorded will, 29 December 1731; probate 4 May 1732, liber20 folios412–414",
      "type": "archive_record_image",
      "url": "https://guide.msa.maryland.gov/pages/item.aspx?ID=S538-29",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Recorded copy visually inspected, viewer images 421–423. James, a Queen Anne’s County planter, names sons Peter, James and William, and daughters Catharine, Rachel, Hannah and Sarah. Rebekah Vanderford is a beneficiary of unstated relationship. Wife and parents are unnamed. The date 4 May 1732 is probate, not exact death."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_COUNTISS_PROCEEDINGS_INDEX1746",
      "title": "Maryland probate proceedings index: Peter and Rebecca Countiss, 1746, liber31 folio667",
      "type": "archive_index_image",
      "url": "https://msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/stagser/s500/s530/000000/000011/pdf/mdsa_s530_11.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF page 67, printed page 66, visually inspected. Peter is indexed in Charles County and Rebecca in Queen Anne’s County, both at liber 31, folio 667. The underlying proceeding has not been inspected; the county discrepancy remains unresolved. Henry Counsill also appears on this folio, without a demonstrated family relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GILES_TITHE_CATALOG",
      "title": "Roanoke Public Libraries: Giles County tithe books collection description",
      "type": "archive_collection_description",
      "url": "https://www.virginiaroom.org/digital/files/original/13/4639/GilesCountyTithebooks.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists surviving holdings for 1820, 1821, 1823, 1824, 1833, 1840–1842 and 1845. Finding aid inspected, individual tax entries not inspected; does not establish Henderson presence or absence."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WASHINGTON_VA_RECORD_CATALOG",
      "title": "Library of Virginia: Washington County records on microfilm",
      "type": "archive_catalog",
      "url": "https://www.lva.virginia.gov/collections/ccmf/VA/VA285",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Will Book 4 (1812–1820), reel16; marriage registers1785–1902,reel31. Catalog identifies surviving volumes, not individual entries."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DONNALLY_DAFN",
      "title": "Donnally: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/donnally",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Donnally as an Irish variant of Donnelly."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DONNELLY_DAFN",
      "title": "Donnelly: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/donnelly",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "General linguistic background and distinct Irish family groups; not evidence of Lydia’s origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CHESTERFIELD1850_INDEX",
      "title": "S-K Publications: 1850 Chesterfield County census surname index",
      "type": "census_index",
      "url": "https://www.skcensus.com/1850-census-index-chesterfield-county-south-carolina/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Henderson appears on 118B, 123B, 124A. Surname index only; it does not identify which household is John and Isabel’s."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CLACKMANNAN_HENDERSON1767",
      "title": "Charles McMaster, Robert Meiklejohn and Sons, Scottish Industrial History7.2(1984), pp 29, 34",
      "type": "historical_article",
      "url": "https://www.busarchscot.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Scottish-Industrial-History-Vol-7.2-1984-compressed.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF page 32/printed 29 visually inspected. The 1767 incident cites T.Crouther Gordon, History of Clackmannan(1936), pp 156–160; that underlying account has not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NRS_OPR_COVERAGE",
      "title": "National Records of Scotland: Coverage of the Old Parish Registers",
      "type": "archive_guide",
      "url": "https://nrscotland.gov.uk/learning-and-events/research-guides/coverage-of-the-old-parish-registers/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains noncompulsory registration and uneven coverage. This general guide does not establish a missing Alloa entry or an individual baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_AMELIA_TALLEY_MARRIAGES",
      "title": "Amelia County marriages 1735–1815, published abstract, page 104",
      "type": "record_abstract",
      "url": "https://fairfieldgenealogysociety.org/Members_Only/Families/Powell/Documents/Powell%20Marriages%20Amelia%20County%20Virginia%201735-1815.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF page 19 visually checked. Two separate marriages: Peyton/Ridley 1786 and Woodley/Holly 1815. Original bonds uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_YANCEY_WILL_PEYTON1845",
      "title": "Zachariah Yancey will, 28 November 1845, Mecklenburg County Virginia, Will Book 17:531",
      "type": "will_transcription",
      "url": "https://yanceyfamilygenealogy.org/probate/will_048.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Names daughter Jane, wife of Peyton R. Talley, and their daughter Mary Ann; header reports probate 1853. Original image uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MECKLENBURG_TALLEY1800",
      "title": "Mecklenburg County Virginia fiduciary table, Peyton Talley estate, 13 October 1800",
      "type": "record_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.usgenwebsites.org/vagenweb/mecklenburg/will/fiduciary/t.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Row 27: Stephen P. Pool administrator, Joseph Carter security. Different date from adjacent Turner entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_TALLEY_DAFN",
      "title": "Talley: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition(2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/talley",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "General surname formation, not identification of Peyton’s overseas origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HOOD_DAFN",
      "title": "Hood: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition(2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hood",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Conditional background for the unverified Hood attribution."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_FLOYD_SHORT_DEATH1934",
      "title": "Floyd Short, 16 January 1934: Smyth County death-record transcription",
      "type": "death_record_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/smyth-county-virginia-death-records/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Rich Valley entry: widower of Florence Shortt, about 71, watchman, born Marion; parents George Short and Susan Jones, both Virginia. Mary Short of Saltville is named. Original certificate not inspected; this is a separate record from David’s death, but independence of the informants’ family knowledge is unestablished."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WYTHE_SHORT_TAX1793",
      "title": "Wythe County personal property tax list, 1793: David and William Short",
      "type": "tax_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/wythe-personal-property-tax-list-1793/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Jeffrey C. Weaver transcription, 3 July 1998. First section, identified as present-day Wythe and Smyth counties, includes David Short and William Short. The second section also lists William, David senior and David junior; do not merge these entries without original-record review. Transcriber warns of difficult handwriting and phonetic spellings. Original uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SMYTH_JONES_TAX1838",
      "title": "Smyth County personal property tax list, 1838: Jones entries",
      "type": "tax_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/smyth-personal-property-tax-list-1838/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Read entries for Elias, Nathaniel, Joseph G., David, Thomas, George W. and Lewis B. Jones. This establishes several local name-bearers, not their kinship or Susan’s birthplace. Original uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SMYTH_MARRIAGES1832_1850",
      "title": "Smyth County marriage licenses, 1832–1850: Jones households",
      "type": "marriage_license_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/smyth-marriage-licenses-1832-1850/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "David Jones/Frances James, 28 November 1840; George W. Jones/Sarah Ann Pearson, 22 May 1838; Nathaniel Jones/Martha Hutton, 23 June 1840. Dates are licenses, not proof of performed marriage. No parents named in this table; original records uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SHORT_DAFN",
      "title": "Short: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/short",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "General surname origins; no specific overseas origin established for George’s branch."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SHORTT_DAFN",
      "title": "Shortt: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/shortt",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Identifies Shortt as an English, Scottish and Irish variant of Short."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JONES_DAFN",
      "title": "Jones: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/jones",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "General English and Welsh formation and gradual hereditary adoption; not an ethnic attribution for Susan."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SMYTH_MARRIAGES1853_1861",
      "title": "Smyth County marriage licenses, 1853–1861",
      "type": "marriage_license_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/smyth-marriages-1853-1861/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Downloaded HTML inspected for Short/Shortt/Shorts and Jones entries. Did not identify George/Susan. This is a limited date and county search, not an exhaustive marriage search."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_FADDIS_DAFN",
      "title": "Faddis: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/faddis",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Faddis is a Scottish and Irish variant of Fiddes. This does not establish Alexander’s birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_FIDDES_DAFN",
      "title": "Fiddes: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/fiddes",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Separate Scottish place-name and Irish Norman explanations; no specific origin assigned to the Virginia family."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DICKERSON_FADDIS_COMPILED",
      "title": "Dickerson Faddis: compiled Ancestry profile and reported parents",
      "type": "compiled_tree_comparison",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/genealogy/records/dickerson-faddis-24-286dt6t",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Indexed page text read: Dickerson about 1811 Orange County NC–about 1839; parents Alexander Faddis 1773–1840 and Sarah Lynch 1775–1815. User-tree compilation, no inspected original supporting those dates. Suggested census matches extend past reported death and are not verified identifications."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GRAYSON_TAX1810",
      "title": "Grayson County personal property tax transcription, 1810",
      "type": "tax_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/grayson-personal-property-tax-list-1810/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Online table searched for Faddis and variants beginning Fad, Fed, Fid and Fett. No matching entry identified in this limited transcription search. Original images, tax eligibility and variant spellings have not been exhaustively assessed; no arrival date or absence inference follows."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GRAYSON_TAX1817",
      "title": "Grayson County personal property tax transcription, 1817",
      "type": "tax_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/grayson-personal-property-tax-list-1817/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Online table searched for Faddis and variants beginning Fad, Fed, Fid and Fett. No matching entry identified in this limited transcription search. Original images, tax eligibility and variant spellings have not been exhaustively assessed; no arrival date or absence inference follows."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GRAYSON_TAX1824",
      "title": "Grayson County personal property tax transcription, 1824",
      "type": "tax_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/grayson-personal-property-tax-list-1824/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Online table searched for Faddis and variants beginning Fad, Fed, Fid and Fett. No matching entry identified in this limited transcription search. Original images, tax eligibility and variant spellings have not been exhaustively assessed; no arrival date or absence inference follows."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GRAYSON_TAX1828",
      "title": "Grayson County personal property tax transcription, 1828",
      "type": "tax_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.newrivernotes.com/grayson-personal-property-tax-list-1828/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Online table searched for Faddis and variants beginning Fad, Fed, Fid and Fett. No matching entry identified in this limited transcription search. Original images, tax eligibility and variant spellings have not been exhaustively assessed; no arrival date or absence inference follows."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CAVERSWALL1666_FAMILIES",
      "title": "Caverswall hearth tax, 1666: Brassington, Mellor and Meller entries",
      "type": "tax_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.caverswall.org.uk/local-history/the-hearth-tax-1666/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Parish transcription citing Staffordshire historical collections (1925), S-106. Downloaded and read; original and 1925 page uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BRASSINGTON_DAFN",
      "title": "Brassington: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/brassington",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Derbyshire place-name surname; proposed Brandsige is plausible but not independently attested as an Old English personal name."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_REVIEW",
      "title": "Richard Sylvanus Williams, SVG Ranton: Brassington entries and probate abstract",
      "type": "compiled_parish_history_and_probate_abstracts",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/svg-ranton",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF pages12 and107 visually inspected20September2026. Thomas Brassington burial9September1774 has no age or relationship; John’s1805will abstract names wifeJane and daughterCatherine wifeThomasEvans. Originals uninspected. This is the same compilation as SRC_BR26_RANTON_WILLIAMS_WILL_ABSTRACTS, not independent corroboration."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HARGAS_PATENT1642",
      "title": "Nell Marion Nugent, Cavaliers and Pioneers, volume I, page 137: John Benton patent",
      "type": "published_land_patent_abstract",
      "url": "https://libsysdigi.library.illinois.edu/OCA/Books2012-02/cavalierspioneer00nuge/cavalierspioneer00nuge.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page 137 (PDF page 197), inspected 20 September 2026. John Benton patent, 13 October 1642, Patent Book 1, part II, page 837. The abstract names Geo. Hargas among transportation claims. The original patent is uninspected; this is not a passenger manifest."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HARGIS_DAFN",
      "title": "Hargis: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition 2022",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hargis",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Offers alternative English (Essex), Hargest, and German or Frisian Harges/Harjes explanations. Does not identify this immigrant’s parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HARGEST_DAFN",
      "title": "Hargest: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition 2022",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hargest",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Upper or Lower Hergest, Herefordshire; place-name etymology uncertain."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HARJES_DAFN",
      "title": "Harjes: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition 2022",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/harjes",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "North German and Frisian patronymic from personal names containing hari or heri, meaning army."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HARGAS_OBERHEIDE",
      "title": "Oberheide genealogy: notes on George Hargase",
      "type": "compiled_pedigree",
      "url": "https://www.oberheide.org/genealogy/notes/n0000002.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Cites family emails from 1998 and 2000 and GEDCOMs for the London identification, Susannah Lea marriage and death about 1716. Its Thomas Benton wording differs from John Benton in the patent abstract. Its people page makes Anna, born in 1618, the child of George, born in 1617, while its notes call her his sister. Original parish entries are not provided."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_OLD_FISH_REGISTER_CATALOGUE",
      "title": "London Metropolitan Archives collection description: St Mary Magdalen, Old Fish Street",
      "type": "archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://atom.aim25.com/index.php/saint-mary-magdalen-old-fish-street-city-of-london",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes parish registers from 1539 and later parish administrative records. Catalogue does not establish an individual Hargase baptism or burial."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DRAPER_DAFN",
      "title": "Draper: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/draper",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English occupational surname for a maker or seller of woollen cloth, from Anglo-Norman and Old French. Also describes seventeenth-century Ulster introduction and the Drapers’ Company connection with Draperstown. These are general name associations, not this candidate’s migration history."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DRAPER_SOMERSET_LAND",
      "title": "Somerset land-record transcriptions: Alexander and Catherine Draper, 1660–1663",
      "type": "published_land_record_transcriptions",
      "url": "https://genealogytrails.com/mary/somerset/deeds_draper.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Transcribes Land Office Liber IV folio 581 (1660 warrant), V folio 253 (28 April 1663 transportation rights) and VI folio 22 (26 October 1663 Little Bolton grant). Original entries uninspected. The page’s separate suggestion of a Lancashire birthplace from the tract name is an inference, not adopted as a fact."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_FREELOVE_DAFN",
      "title": "Freelove: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/freelove",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains the English surname through the personal name Frelof, from Old English Frithulaf. It does not establish Elizabeth’s identity or family origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WHITESIDE_DAFN",
      "title": "Whiteside: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/whiteside",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Gives nickname and place-name explanations, with associations in Scotland, northern England and Ulster. These describe the surname generally, not Ann’s ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WHITESIDE_SIUE",
      "title": "Southern Illinois University Edwardsville: biography of William Bolin Whiteside",
      "type": "university_historical_exhibit",
      "url": "https://whiteside.siue.edu/assets/PDFs/0_Biography.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Pages 4–6 describe the earlier William Whiteside, about 1710–1777, and Elizabeth Stockton family, including a daughter Ann. The account draws on Whiteside genealogists; the displayed family chart and child list were checked. It does not identify that Ann as Mrs Hargis."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WHITESIDE_UNDERWOOD1756",
      "title": "McClellan and Philbeck: Russell’s Fort, Old Tryon County Bulletin, Fall 2022",
      "type": "historical_research_with_court_transcriptions",
      "url": "https://www.oldtryon.com/oldtryoncounty/RussellWhiteside1.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Pages 8–11 distinguish the Underwood-connected Whiteside household. Cites Augusta survey book 1, pages 86–87, and court order book 5, pages 32, 189 and 260. The article’s transcriptions were read; the original court volume was not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HARGIS_ESTATE_TRANSCRIPTIONS",
      "title": "Conflicting transcriptions of Ann Hargis’s 1779 administration entry",
      "type": "conflicting_derivative_transcriptions",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Transcript%3AWillis_entries_in_Summers%2C_1929",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Two online transcriptions cite Summers, Annals of Southwest Virginia (1929), page 1033, 15 June 1779, naming Ann Hargis with Peter Lee and Henry Willis as securities. WeRelate calls the deceased Peter Hargis; the Familypedia Henry Willis miscellaneous-records page calls him John. These are readings of one entry, not independent records. Neither supplies Ann’s maiden name or children. The book image and underlying court entry remain uninspected. Comparison: https://familypedia.fandom.com/wiki/Henry_Willis_%28c1740-aft1785%29/Miscellaneous_records"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LUTHREL_STPAUL",
      "title": "George H. S. King: Register of Saint Paul’s Parish, 1715–1798 (1960), page 62",
      "type": "published_parish_register_transcription",
      "url": "https://accessgenealogy.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/The-Register-of-Saint-Pauls-Parish-1715-1798.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page 62, PDF page 94, visually checked: John Harges married Elizabeth Luthrel on 1 October 1725; Mildred, daughter of John and Elizabeth Harges, was born 4 August 1726. This is King’s edited transcription, not an image of the manuscript. The matching marriage appears under Luthrel on printed page 86. The editor warns of spelling and dating inconsistencies in the register."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LUTTRELL_DAFN",
      "title": "Luttrell: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/luttrell",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English and Irish surname of Norman origin, derived from an Old French word for otter, with nickname and occupational interpretations. Relevant as a possible explanation of Luthrel, not proof that Elizabeth belonged to a particular Luttrell lineage."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LUTTERELL_TOWN_RUN",
      "title": "Combs land research: Richard Luterell’s Town Run survey, 1740–1745",
      "type": "published_land_record_abstracts",
      "url": "https://combs-families.org/combs/records/va/stafford/land.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reproduces Peggy Shomo Joyner’s Northern Neck Warrants and Surveys, volume III, page 119: Richard Luterell, 7 March 1740–18 April 1745, 58 acres on a drain of Town Run in Prince William County, adjoining his existing land. Original survey uninspected. The page also identifies later Luttrell family lands in Fauquier; no relationship to Elizabeth Harges is stated."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_DAFN",
      "title": "Boswell: Dictionary of American Family Names, FamilySearch edition credited 2003/2006",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=BOSWELL",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English and Scottish surname of Norman origin, from Beuzeville-la-Giffard in Seine-Maritime, France. Its place-name combines the personal name Boso and ville, settlement. This is general surname history, not a documented migration for James."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ANN_SMITH_DAFN",
      "title": "Smith: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/smith",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Explains metalworker and forge-related origins, English and Scottish usage, Gaelic equivalents and translated surnames. These independent origins mean that the name alone does not locate Ann’s family."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_STUBBS",
      "title": "William Carter Stubbs: Descendants of John Stubbs of Cappahosic, Boswell excursus, page 108",
      "type": "published_family_history",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/descendantsofjoh00stub/page/108/mode/2up",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page 108, PDF page 114, visually inspected. Reports Captain William Boswell’s marriage to Ellinor, widow of Coleman Brough, in Elizabeth City on 2 March 1702; identifies their daughter Grace as John Selden’s third wife. Also reports Ellinor’s 1727 marriage to George Yeo and his 1742 bequests to Selden children. The underlying marriage and will manuscripts were not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BOSWELL_SMITH_PATENTS",
      "title": "Nell Marion Nugent: Cavaliers and Pioneers, volume I, page 388",
      "type": "published_land_patent_abstracts",
      "url": "https://libsysdigi.library.illinois.edu/OCA/Books2012-02/cavalierspioneer00nuge/cavalierspioneer00nuge.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed page 388, PDF page 458, visually inspected. Abstracts Thomas Boswell’s 500-acre Potomac grant dated 9 March 1658 and John Williams’s 1,800-acre Rappahannock grant dated 11 March 1658, renewed 21 October 1662. Ann Smith appears among the latter’s transportation rights. Dates are given as printed. The original patent pages were not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ELIZABETHCITY_EARLY_RECORDS",
      "title": "Library of Virginia: Elizabeth City County microfilm holdings",
      "type": "government_archival_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.lva.virginia.gov/collections/ccmf/VA/VA077",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reel 3 contains deeds, wills, inventories and orders for 1715–1721, filmed from the original. This covers James’s reported 1718 death. The catalogue notes substantial losses in several wars, but does not support treating all early probate records as destroyed. Holdings checked; the volume itself has not been searched in this review."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JAMMER_DAFN",
      "title": "Jammer: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/jammer",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The entry explains Jammer as an East German surname of Slavic origin, from jama, a hollow or hole. This is a general explanation of the reported spelling; it does not establish Jane’s birthplace or ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JAMMER_KING_WILLIAM",
      "title": "King William County: establishment effective 11 April 1702",
      "type": "local_government_history",
      "url": "https://www.kwc.gov/302/About-King-William",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The county’s history distinguishes the 1701 legislative act from its effective date, 11 April 1702. The county name in the reported 1665 Fountain birth is therefore retrospective or mistaken; that alone does not disprove the birth or maternal relationship."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILLIS_HARTWELL_1787",
      "title": "John Willis v John Hartwell: Henry County chancery 1787-002",
      "type": "original_court_record",
      "url": "https://old.lva.virginia.gov/chancery/case_detail.asp?CFN=089-1787-002",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "All seven manuscript images inspected. The complaint states that John Willis moved to Greenbrier. An injunction bond dated 27 October 1784 names John and Isaiah Willis; a separate 3 June 1785 bond names Thomas Miller and Isaiah. No wife or child is identified. The file supports the reported regional identity and associates, not Nancy’s parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NANCY_WILLIS_DAFN",
      "title": "Willis: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/Willis",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English name usually formed from Will with a possessive ending, retaining a medieval second syllable. The entry also gives forms of Willey and Willows. This does not establish a single origin for every Willis branch."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PHEBE_BENNETT_DAFN",
      "title": "Bennett: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/bennett",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English formation from Benedict, with medieval French forms; established in Ireland since the fourteenth century. German and altered French surnames provide additional origins. These alternatives do not identify Phebe’s ancestral birthplace."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CHESTER_BENNETT_FINCHER_1881",
      "title": "Futhey and Cope, History of Chester County (1881), pp. 480–481 and 546",
      "type": "published_genealogical_history",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/cu31924005813518/page/480",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed pages visually inspected. The Bennett section reproduces family Bible entries and identifies Joseph as Edward and Sarah’s son. Both family sections identify Rebecca as John and Martha Fincher’s daughter. Page 546 qualifies attribution of John’s children to his first wife as probable. These are nineteenth-century reconstructions and transcriptions; the underlying Bible and meeting manuscripts have not been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WARRINGTON_BENNETT_ABSTRACT",
      "title": "Pennsylvania Quaker Records: Warrington Bennett family abstract, first page of Warrington section",
      "type": "typed_quaker_record_abstract",
      "url": "https://familyhartroots.com/PA/York/Documents/PennsylvaniaQuaker.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "PDF page 4 visually inspected. Joseph Bennett and Rebecca Fincher are listed with daughter Phebe, born 30 first month 1738, explicitly interpreted as March by the abstract. It also records their Kennett marriage, transfer to Sadsbury and deaths in 1757. Original meeting manuscripts remain uninspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_FINCHER_DAFN",
      "title": "Fincher: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/fincher",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The dictionary treats the meaning as unexplained and associates the English surname with Buckinghamshire and Worcestershire; it reports no examples earlier than about 1500."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_STANFIELD_DAFN",
      "title": "Stanfield: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/stanfield",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English topographic or place-derived surname referring to stony open ground; places called Stanfield include examples in Staffordshire and Norfolk."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_DAFN",
      "title": "Taylor: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/taylor",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Occupational surname for a tailor, from Anglo-Norman French; common in England, Scotland and Ireland, with additional translated surname origins in North America."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_JUSTICE1925",
      "title": "Alfred Rudulph Justice, Descendants of Robert Taylor (1925), pp. 9–14 and will facsimile",
      "type": "published_genealogy_with_record_facsimile",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/fl-1898723-tn-423466",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Page images and the reproduced will inspected. The genealogy cites Cheshire Friends records for Robert and Mary’s children and parish records for earlier Taylor generations. Its will transcription gives 24 April and 16 May 1695; damaged wording in the facsimile limits independent checking of the execution day. The printed John Fincher probate date is 24 November 1747. Underlying English registers have not yet been inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_TAYLOR_ARRIVALS1881",
      "title": "Futhey and Cope, History of Chester County (1881), pp. 22 and 735: Taylor arrival and family",
      "type": "published_record_transcription_and_history",
      "url": "https://archive.org/details/cu31924005813518/page/22",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Printed pages visually inspected. The partial arrival register lists Mary Taylor from Clatterwitch with six children including Martha, on Endeavour, 29 seventh month 1683. The authors warn that the register was compiled after arrival and contains inaccuracies. Page 735 identifies Martha as Robert’s daughter and John Fincher’s wife; it suggests Mary may not have been mother of all Robert’s children."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HAYES_DAFN2022",
      "title": "Hayes: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/hayes",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English origins include enclosure, brushwood and place names; Irish Hayes can represent descendants of Aodh. Other independent surname formations occur."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BARROW_DAFN2022",
      "title": "Barrow: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/barrow",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English place-derived or topographic surname, often referring to a grove or mound; several unrelated places can supply the name."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MASSEY_DAFN2022",
      "title": "Massey: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/massey",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "English origins include a pet form of Matthew and several Norman place names. The surname alone does not identify a specific medieval pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BARROW_DAVENHAM1609_CLAIM",
      "title": "WeRelate: Maria Barrow, reported Davenham baptism, 19 February 1609",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy_citing_index",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person:Mary_Barrow_(2)",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Cites the FamilySearch Cheshire parish-register index for Maria, daughter of Ranulphi Barrow. The baptism record and its identification with Thomas Taylor’s wife have not been independently verified."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CPRDB_BARROW_RECORDS",
      "title": "Cheshire Parish Register Database: Mary Burrowe marriage and three possible baptisms",
      "type": "parish_register_transcription_database",
      "url": "https://cprdb.csc.liv.ac.uk/Live/v3.6/database.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Full records retrieved: WHTGM00100536.40276, marriage 21 September 1630; DAVNC00301289.20422, Maria daughter of Ranulphus Barrow, 19 February 1610; DAVNC00401290.20082, Maria daughter of Willmus Barrow, 23 February 1612; DAVNC00401290.20150, Maria daughter of Thomas Burrows of Bostock, 3 February 1614. Dates follow the database’s January-start year convention. No parental name or age appears in the marriage transcription."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CPRDB_DAVENHAM_NOTES",
      "title": "Cheshire Parish Register Project: Davenham parish notes",
      "type": "register_editorial_notes",
      "url": "https://cprdb.csc.liv.ac.uk/Notes/Parish/DAVN.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Describes missing original registers for 1625–1665, replacement entries from bishops’ transcripts and gaps in those transcripts. Lists Radulphus Barrow among the parish officers in 1602 and Raphe Barrow among sworn men in 1620. These entries do not themselves identify Mary’s father."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CPRDB_GENERAL_NOTES",
      "title": "Cheshire Parish Register Database: general transcription notes",
      "type": "transcription_methodology",
      "url": "https://cprdb.csc.liv.ac.uk/Live/v3.6/general.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The project preserves surname spellings but normalizes some Latin given-name forms and adjusts January–March Old Style years to January-start years. Parish-register and bishops-transcript readings are distinguished; variants and missing entries require separate consideration."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LEA_DAFN2022",
      "title": "Lea: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lea",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lea is reported as an English variant of Lee; independent Chinese romanizations also occur."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SMITH_DAFN2022",
      "title": "Smith: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022)",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/smith",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Smith is an English and Scottish occupational surname for a metalworker, with other independent formations. Its frequency makes surname-only identification weak."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_ARCHIVE_GUIDE",
      "title": "Ashwell Museum parish documents and local archive guide",
      "type": "archive_catalogue_and_local_history",
      "url": "https://www.ashwellmuseum.org.uk/resources/resource-centre-2/printed-resources",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Lists Ashwell parish-register transcripts 1604–1837, churchwardens accounts, terriers, wills, deeds and other local records. This is a concrete research trail, not proof of a particular Lea identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ASHWELL_PARISH_NOTES",
      "title": "Ashwell parish-register coverage guide",
      "type": "parish_register_guide",
      "url": "https://www.genuki.org.uk/big/eng/HRT/Ashwell",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Reports parish registers and bishops transcripts with different periods and uneven coverage. The 1614 family event may require transcript or bishops-transcript research."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LEA_ASHWELL_DIRECT",
      "title": "Ashwell and Stoke St Gregory Lea records attached to the tree",
      "type": "indexed_parish_records_and_supplied_transcripts",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/collection/2388825",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The supplied records directly name Uriae Lea as Susanna’s father in Ashwell in 1614, and Robert Lea as husband of Joan Smith in Stoke St Gregory in 1587 and father in a 1590 baptism. The excerpts do not establish their cross-county identity."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HAMILTON_FRICKE_NATURALIZATION_1848",
      "title": "Hamilton County Naturalization Records, Surname F",
      "type": "naturalization_index",
      "url": "https://libraries.uc.edu/content/dam/refresh/libraries-62/arb/docs/hamilton-county-citizenship-f.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The University of Cincinnati index records August Fricke, age 24, Hanover, departure Bremen 1 July 1846, arrival Baltimore 8 August 1846, declaration 29 August 1848, volume 22 page 72; it also lists Charles, Francis, Frederick and Henry Fricke entries. These are documented Hanover-related name-bearers, not identified relatives of Henry Albert Fricke."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANNOVERSCHES_NAMENBUCH_1852",
      "title": "Hannoversches Namenbüchlein (1852)",
      "type": "historical_name_book",
      "url": "https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Hannoversches_Namenb%C3%BCchlein.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A public-domain 1852 work describing inhabitants names of the royal and residential city of Hannover and their meanings. It supplies historical Hanover surname context, not a genealogy for this branch."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WAINE_DAFN_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Waine surname meaning and variants",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://surnamedb.com/Surname/waine",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Waine is described as an English occupational surname from Old English waegn/Middle English wain, a cart or wagon; variants include Wain and Wayne. The source also notes possible topographical sign-name usage."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILTSHIRE_LOCAL_WAINE_TRAIL",
      "title": "Bradford-on-Avon Museum and Wiltshire local-record context",
      "type": "local_history_and_record_guide",
      "url": "https://www.bradfordonavonmuseum.co.uk/about-bradford/bradford-people",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The museum identifies Bradford-on-Avon as a major historic woollen-cloth centre and provides local-record indexes. This establishes a concrete locality context for evaluating a Waine household, but does not identify Catherine’s parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BRADFORD_HANNY_WESLEY_HISTORY",
      "title": "Nonconformists in Bradford-on-Avon: Hanny Methodist history",
      "type": "local_methodist_history",
      "url": "https://www.freshford.com/non_conformists.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Local history states that one early local preacher was a Mr Hanny; his son William Hanny was a class leader; and grandson William Peters Hanny (born 1802) belonged to the Methodist Society 1818–1894. It is a secondary local history and does not itself identify Mr Hanny by given name."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILTSHIRE_METHODIST_CHAPEL",
      "title": "Wiltshire Community History: Methodist Chapel, Coppice Hill, Bradford-on-Avon",
      "type": "official_local_history",
      "url": "https://apps.wiltshire.gov.uk/communityhistory/Church/Details/312",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Wiltshire Council history records frequent visits by John and Charles Wesley to Bradford-on-Avon, including preaching in houses and open-air meetings, and describes the later chapel and circuit."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARLOW_DAFN2022",
      "title": "Marlow: Dictionary of American Family Names / FamilySearch surname entry",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=MARLOW",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Marlow is described as an English habitational name from Marlow, Buckinghamshire, whose place-name derives from Old English mere “lake/pool” and lāfe “remnants,” referring to land left after drainage. Marlowe is a variant; Marley confusion is noted."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MARYLAND_EARLY_SETTLERS",
      "title": "Maryland State Archives: Early Settlers database and land patents",
      "type": "state_archive_guide",
      "url": "https://earlysettlers.msa.maryland.gov/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Maryland State Archives describes a database of individuals named in land-patent volumes from 1633–1683 and a 1681–1685 land-warrant volume. It is the appropriate primary-record route for testing colonial Marlow entries."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KOCH_DAFN2022",
      "title": "Koch surname meaning and variants",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/koch?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Koch is a German and Ashkenazic occupational surname from Middle High German/German Koch, “cook.” The spelling alone does not establish one family or religious origin."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ERPFINGEN_LOCAL_HISTORY",
      "title": "Gemeinde Sonnenbühl: Erpfingen history",
      "type": "municipal_local_history",
      "url": "https://www.sonnenbuehl.de/data/erpfingen.php",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The municipality dates the first secure written mention of Erpfingen to 16 November 777 in the Lorsch donation book and describes later war, migration and settlement history."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ERPFINGEN_MATRICULA_COVERAGE",
      "title": "Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg / Matricula: Erpfingen registers",
      "type": "archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://data.matricula-online.eu/cs/deutschland/baden_wuerttemberg/bw-16062/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The catalogue exposes Erpfingen baptism, marriage and burial registers beginning in 1808, with no online register period shown for Margaretha’s reported sixteenth-century birth."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_POYNER_DAFN2022",
      "title": "Poyner: Dictionary of American Family Names / Oxford family-name entry",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/poyner?geo-lang=en-US",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Poyner is described as a West Midlands English surname of Norman origin, a nickname from Anglo-Norman French poigneur/pugneire, “fighter” or “warrior”; variants include Poynor, Punyer and Powner. Oxford’s entry lists early Poyner/Punyer forms in Shropshire and elsewhere."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_STANTON_LACY_REGISTER_CATALOGUE",
      "title": "Stanton Lacy parish-register coverage",
      "type": "parish_register_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.melocki.org.uk/salop/StantonLacy.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Stanton Lacy register abstract records coverage beginning in 1561 and discusses the parish registers around the period of the 1675 Poyner baptism."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MUELLER_DAFN2022",
      "title": "Mueller/Müller surname meaning and spelling",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/mueller?geo-lang=en",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Mueller is the German spelling variant of Müller, an occupational surname for a miller; it also has an Ashkenazic usage. In the United States umlaut spellings may be written Mueller, Muller or Miller."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HANOVER_CHURCH_ARCHIVE",
      "title": "Landeskirchliches Archiv Hannover: church-book access",
      "type": "church_archive_guide",
      "url": "https://www.landeskirchlichesarchiv-hannover.de/familienforschung/kirchenbuecherbenutz",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The official Hanover church archive provides guidance for using Lutheran church books and explains current access arrangements. A parish is required before a record search can identify Henriette’s parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SCHRATERN_VARIANT_SEARCH",
      "title": "Schratern variant and phonetic-search assessment",
      "type": "record-search_methodology",
      "url": "https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/quick-people-search",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Scotland’s People documents phonetic matching for surnames and spelling variants. Exact Schratern searches have not produced an identity-secure seventeenth-century Midlothian person; variants such as Schrader, Schrater, Schröter and similar forms remain search hypotheses, not asserted origins."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MIDLOTHIAN_REGISTER_LIMITS",
      "title": "Midlothian official-record and Old Parish Register coverage",
      "type": "official_record_coverage_guide",
      "url": "https://www.midlothian.gov.uk/info/458/local_and_family_history/391/local_studies/4",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Midlothian Council states that Church of Scotland parish registers run from about 1600 to 1855 but were not compulsory before 1855; coverage is incomplete. This explains why a reported c.1610 woman without a parish cannot be confirmed from a broad county search."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NEWPORT_SHROPSHIRE_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Shropshire parish registers and Newport baptism coverage",
      "type": "parish_register_collection_guide",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/collection/3155854",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Shropshire parish-register collection covers christenings, marriages and burials from 1538 onward, with originals held by Shropshire Record Office. Newport baptism indexes can provide parent, residence and occupation details when the original entry survives."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_Poyner_ELIZABETH_MAIDEN_LIMIT",
      "title": "Elizabeth Poyner maiden-name assessment",
      "type": "record_coverage_and_identity_assessment",
      "url": "https://www.shropshire.gov.uk/media/3376/short-guide-to-parish-registers.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Shropshire’s guide explains what parish registers can record and the availability of digitised material; the reviewed Richard Poyner baptism names mother Elizabeth but gives no maiden surname."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WILLIAMS_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Williams",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=Williams",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch reproduces the Dictionary of American Family Names entry: Williams is a variant of William with genitival or later excrescent -s, common in England and Wales, and independently brought to North America by many bearers."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ROWAN_TAX_LISTS",
      "title": "Rowan County, North Carolina tax-list coverage and 1759 transcription",
      "type": "local_tax_list_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.geocities.ws/qatballou_laura/1759_rowan_county_nc_tax_list.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The published transcription of the 1759 Rowan County tax list records Williams households, including William Williams. It demonstrates a local surname population but does not identify Mary Williams, Samuel Williams, or a relationship among them."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_ROWAN_RECORD_FRONTIER",
      "title": "Rowan County records available for testing the Williams bond clue",
      "type": "official_local_research_guide",
      "url": "https://www.rowancountync.gov/1517/Genealogy-Resources",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The county genealogy page identifies local deed, estate, newspaper and genealogical resources. These are the appropriate next records for testing whether Samuel Williams was Mary’s father, brother, uncle or an unrelated bondsman."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KIEFFER_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Kieffer",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=Kieffer",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch reproduces the Dictionary of American Family Names entry: Kieffer is a German, Luxembourgish and Jewish variant of Kiefer; it is also found in Luxembourg and Wallonia."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WIDMAN_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Widman",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=widman",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch reproduces the Dictionary of American Family Names entry: Widman can be Swedish, or an Americanized form of South German Widmann. The alternatives have different histories and must not be merged."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_BLANKENLOCH_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Blankenloch Lutheran registers and local family book",
      "type": "church_register_catalog",
      "url": "https://www.archion.de/en/alle-archive/baden-wuerttemberg/evangelisches-archiv-baden-und-wuerttemberg-baden/blankenloch/183433",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Archion lists the Blankenloch mixed church register (Mischbuch) from 1672–1738. The Blankenloch-Büchig-Stutensee local family book covers 1672–1920. These records postdate the reported births about 1630 and 1633, but they are the specific local route for testing the reconstructed household and its children."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_GINDER_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Ginder",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=ginder",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch reproduces alternative explanations: German variant of Günther; or English from Middle English gendere/gendrer, with a possible son-in-law sense through Old French gendre/gindre."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JANSEM_LOCAL_DISTRIBUTION",
      "title": "Jansem surname distribution in Moselle",
      "type": "surname_distribution_and_archive_index",
      "url": "https://www.filae.com/nom-de-famille/JANSEM.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Filae reports Jansem births and archive references concentrated in Moselle, including Sarralbe and Holving, but gives no reliable etymology and does not identify Marguerite."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HINSING_RECORD_ROUTE",
      "title": "Hinsing family-reconstruction record route",
      "type": "local_family_book_catalog",
      "url": "https://www.slcl.org/sites/default/files/2024-12/hg-OFB-DEC-2024-by-country-state-district.pdf",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A library catalog lists a Hinsing family reconstruction, Le val de Holving, covering families after 1805. It supplies a concrete local route but is later than the reported ancestor and cannot by itself establish the Geneanet identities."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KLOTZ_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Klotz",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=Klotz",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch reproduces the dictionary entry: German Klotz is a nickname from Middle High German klotz, “lump” or “block”; the Jewish Ashkenazic form is cognate with it or Yiddish klots."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_WISSEMBOURG_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Wissembourg parish-register catalog and local archive",
      "type": "parish_register_catalog",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/catalog/339595",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The catalog identifies Saint-Michel Wissembourg parish registers of baptisms, marriages and burials from 1596–1793. Wissembourg municipal archives also preserve historical records and parish registers. These are concrete record routes, but the reviewed catalog is not an inspected Hayim Klotz entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26ROSSER_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Rosser",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=ROSSER",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch reproduces alternative explanations: Welsh Rosser from R(h)osier/Roger; German Rösser as an occupational name for a horse farmer, dealer, groom or carter; and a German topographic name from a flax-retting pool."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LEMBACH_REGISTERS",
      "title": "Lembach parish-register coverage, Bas-Rhin",
      "type": "regional_archive_register_catalog",
      "url": "https://archives.bas-rhin.fr/rechercher/?fq=periode%3A%2217e+si%C3%A8cle%22&fq=typedoc%3A%22registre+de+bapt%C3%A8mes%22&hl=false&recherche=%2A&rows=108&sort=cote+asc&start=108&wt=xml",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Bas-Rhin archives catalog Lembach Protestant parish registers before 1793, including baptisms, marriages and burials from 1638–1688 with gaps. A FamilySearch catalog separately lists Lembach registers from 1750 onward. The coverage is a concrete route for testing an eighteenth-century Rosser/Roser household, not an inspected Samuel entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_PFEIFER_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Pfeifer",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=Pfeifer",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch surname reference gives Pfeifer as a German occupational name for a fifer or pipe player, from Middle High German pfifer/pfeifer. The occupational explanation is useful context but does not identify Emanuel’s occupation or parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NIEDERHOCHSTADT_ARCHIVE_ROUTE",
      "title": "Niederhochstadt register route, Landesarchiv Speyer APERTUS",
      "type": "official archive catalogue and bounded record search",
      "url": "https://apertus.rlp.de/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The official Rheinland-Pfalz archive catalogue exposes Catholic Niederhochstadt holdings in Landesarchiv Speyer Bestand F 6, including register units 214 and 216. No digitized 1833 Jewish or general civil birth act for Emanuel was exposed; the original act or a local archival reconstruction remains the next target."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JACOB_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Jacob",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=Jacob",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Jewish, English, Welsh, German, Portuguese, French (especially Alsace and Lorraine), Walloon, Breton, Dutch, Flemish, Scandinavian and other forms derive from the biblical personal name Jacob/Jacobus, from Hebrew Ya‘aqov. This gives surname context only and does not identify Johanna’s parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_NEWMAN_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Newman",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=NEWMAN",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Newman is an English nickname for a newcomer or newly appointed person; it is also an Americanized translation of German and Jewish Ashkenazic Neumann and related forms. This does not resolve whether the imported “Newman Neumond” is a surname, translation, or transcription."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_STRAUSS_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Strauss",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=strauss",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Strauss has several German and Jewish explanations, including a nickname, an ostrich-sign or ostrich-associated name, and a topographic reference to a bush or bundle; the Jewish surname could sometimes be artificial. These alternatives do not identify Hendle’s family."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SCHWARTZ_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Schwartz",
      "type": "surname_dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=schwartz",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Schwartz is a German and Ashkenazic Jewish nickname for dark hair or complexion, from swarz/schwarz/shvarts; it can also be habitational from places called Schwarz. The surname occurs in Alsace-Lorraine and other European regions. This does not identify Leon’s parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JUFFE_DIRECTORY",
      "title": "FamilySearch surname directory: Juffe",
      "type": "surname_directory with bounded negative meaning search",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname/directory/surnames/juff",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch lists Juffe in its surname directory but exposes no Dictionary of American Family Names meaning entry in the reviewed result. Jaffe/Joffe are plausible spelling or transliteration alternatives, not assumed equivalents without an identity bridge."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_DUBOWY_DISTRIBUTION",
      "title": "Dubowy surname distribution and indexed genealogy",
      "type": "surname distribution and genealogy index",
      "url": "https://en.geneanet.org/surnames/DUBOWY",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet reports Dubowy as rare and indexes an Anton Dubowy in Vienna Catholic registers. Forebears reports the surname as rare, most frequent in Germany, with smaller counts in Poland and Austria, and lists the meaning as unknown. Neither source identifies Lazar."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KALLMANN_ALSACE",
      "title": "Kallmann surname and Bas-Rhin Jewish record route",
      "type": "surname directory and regional archive route",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=kallman",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch exposes Kallman records but no etymology in the reviewed result; Kallmann spelling is retained separately. Bas-Rhin archival material identifies Ottrott-le-Bas Jewish name-adoption and civil record holdings, while local Jewish history documents the community. These are research routes, not an identified Rosalie record."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CAHN_DAFN",
      "title": "Dictionary of American Family Names, 2nd edition: Cahn",
      "type": "surname dictionary",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=CAHN",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch gives Cahn as a Jewish variant of Cohen and an Americanized form of North German Kahn. The alternatives should remain separate until a record establishes which spelling Leo used."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_COGUENHEM_RARITY",
      "title": "Coguenhem surname rarity and Metz record coverage",
      "type": "surname distribution and regional record assessment",
      "url": "https://www.filae.com/nom-de-famille/COGUENHEM.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Filae finds few indexed French births for Coguenhem, concentrated in Moselle and nearby departments, and gives no dependable etymology. FamilySearch lists the spelling but no meaning entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LOEB_BAVARIA_RECORDS",
      "title": "Loeb surname context and Bavarian Jewish record resources",
      "type": "surname reference and archival research resource",
      "url": "https://www.jewishgen.org/databases/germany/bavaria.html",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch describes Loeb/Löb/Löw/Loew/Löwe as Ashkenazi Jewish forms associated with the lion symbolism of Judah. JewishGen documents indexed 19th-century Bavarian-Swabian civil records from Bavarian State Archive copies, including births, marriages, deaths, Matrikel and circumcisions. These sources identify useful research routes and surname context but do not identify Pauline Loeb."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MOSES_LUSTADT_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Moses surname context and Oberlustadt Jewish community records",
      "type": "surname reference and local-history research context",
      "url": "https://www.alemannia-judaica.de/oberlustadt_synagoge.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch describes Moses as a biblical personal-name surname with Jewish, Welsh, African American and African uses. Alemannia Judaica reports Jewish households in Oberlustadt in 1809/10 and names Salomon Frank as a butcher; its related local history places the Jewish cemetery/community in the late eighteenth or early nineteenth century. These sources provide locality context but do not identify Regina Moses."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SEligMAN_ROMANSWILLER_ARCHIVES",
      "title": "Seligman surname and Romanswiller Jewish archive context",
      "type": "local Jewish-history and civil-record research context",
      "url": "https://cibr.fr/communautes/romanswiller/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Bas-Rhin Jewish Consistory records Jewish presence at Romanswiller from the second half of the seventeenth century. Alemannia Judaica reports a Jewish community of 26 families in 1716 and 41 families/206 people in 1784; FamilySearch catalogs Romanswiller civil registers from 1792–1932. These establish a viable local research setting but do not identify Rösel Seligman."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LEVY_WINTZENHEIM_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Levy surname, Wintzenheim Jewish history and archive route",
      "type": "regional Jewish-history and archival research context",
      "url": "https://www.judaisme-alsalor.fr/synagog/hautrhin/r-z/wintzenh/histo.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Regional history records Jewish residents and occupations in Wintzenheim from the 17th century, and the Archives d’Alsace identify an 1782 protected-Jewish list for Wintzenheim-Kochersberg and notarial material including marriage contracts, testaments and inventories for Wintzenheim 1659–1789. Levy could denote levitical status and is not a unique household identifier. These sources justify targeted research but do not identify Mosché."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_KIEFFER_GUNSTETT_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Kieffer surname and Gunstett identity-conflict context",
      "type": "surname reference and archival identity assessment",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=kieffer",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch describes Kieffer as a surname found in German-speaking regions and Luxembourg/Wallonia; the reviewed Bas-Rhin 1808 index places Kieffer at Lembach and Strasbourg, not Gunstett. The absence is a comparison against the imported locality, not proof that no Kieffer lived at Gunstett."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCELROY_BALTIMORE_COLONIAL_CONTEXT",
      "title": "McElroy surname and colonial Baltimore research route",
      "type": "surname reference and archival research route",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=mcelroy",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch provides McElroy surname context. Maryland State Archives identifies surviving Baltimore County probate records for 1703–1776 and Maryland colonial will indexes; these are the appropriate records for testing Frances’s identity, marriage, and property context. They do not identify Frances directly."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_COUNTISS_QUEEN_ANNES_ARCHIVES",
      "title": "Countiss surname and Queen Annes County archival route",
      "type": "surname reference and local archival research route",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=countiss",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch describes Countiss as a variant of Countess and finds it chiefly in the United States. Maryland State Archives identify Queen Annes County 1783 assessment records and court papers, providing direct routes to test the reported Henry. These sources do not identify him by themselves."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SEGEL_NEW_BRITAIN_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Segel surname context and New Britain research route",
      "type": "surname reference and local historical context",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=segel",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch provides Segel surname context. New Britain city-directory holdings include a 1916 directory, while the city’s historic B’nai Israel synagogue reflects the established Jewish community in which Morris’s documented civic and clothing-business records sit. These sources do not identify Morris’s birth or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_STALLKOP_NAME_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Stallcop/Stallkop surname context and Delaware probate route",
      "type": "surname reference and probate research route",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=stallcop",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch describes Stallcop as a variant of Stalcup and a surname of Swedish origin. The existing Newcastle County will index bounds Peter Stallkop’s death between 3 September 1709 and 16 May 1710, but the original will and immigrant origins were not inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LORCH_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Lorch surname meaning and distribution",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.com/last-name-meaning/lorch",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Ancestry describes Lorch as a German habitational surname from places called Lorch, while FamilySearch provides a separate surname-distribution reference. The meaning/origin is not specific to Rosa and does not identify a particular Lorch family."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LORSCH_JEWISH_COMMUNITY",
      "title": "Lorsch Jewish community history and Lorch family mention",
      "type": "local historical reference",
      "url": "https://www.alemannia-judaica.de/lorsch_synagoge.htm",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Alemannia-Judaica records a Lorch family in the Lorsch Jewish community and reports Simon Lorch as a community leader in the 1928 synagogue account. This is a later, separately documented family and is retained as locality/name context only, not as evidence identifying Rosa."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_LORCH_RESEARCH_LIMIT",
      "title": "Rosa Lorch branch research limit",
      "type": "genealogical search route",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/record/results?count=20&q.surname=Lorch",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The tree reports Rosa Lorch only as Leo Cahn/Kahn's wife and Clara Cahn's mother, with death before 1823. No birthplace, residence, marriage, death place, household, burial, probate, or parent record is supplied. The practical next searches are Clara's Mainz civil/Jewish records, Cahn/Kahn household and marriage records, and Lorch families in any locality established by those records."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CAHN_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Cahn/Cahen/Cohn/Kahn surname context",
      "type": "Jewish surname history",
      "url": "https://metahubfrankfurt.de/en/jmf/stories/cahn/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Jewish Museum Frankfurt Metahub explains Cahn/Cahen/Cohen/Katz as forms associated with the Hebrew term for the priestly line, while Cahn and Kahn also occur as Germanized spellings. This is surname context, not evidence that every Cahn family shares one lineage."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_CAHN_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
      "title": "Leon Cahn Metz-to-Louisiana identity limit",
      "type": "record research route",
      "url": "https://www.moselle.fr/les-services/archives-departementales",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Leon's exact-name Louisiana identity is supported by the official 5 June 1924 death index and Morgan City merchant/land records already cited in the tree. Metz civil indexes checked so far do not identify the imported 1851-1852 birth; the 1851 Cahen entry is retained only as a lead because its act reference conflicts. The next tests are Metz civil birth, Jewish register, passenger, naturalization and Louisiana marriage/household records."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_TRAUTMAN_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Trautman/Trautmann surname meaning and variants",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://de.geneanet.org/familiennamen/TRAUTMANN",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Geneanet summarizes Trautmann as a German surname from a medieval personal name built from Middle High German trût, “beloved,” plus man, with alternative older Germanic explanations. Trautman, Trautmann and related spellings can arise in more than one family."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_TRAUTMAN_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
      "title": "David Trautman New Orleans identity limit",
      "type": "local record research route",
      "url": "https://nolacityarchives.org/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Four official Orleans Parish birth-index entries from 1854-1862, the 1861 Gardner directory, the 1893 death index and Hebrew Rest cemetery evidence identify the New Orleans David Trautman household. No reviewed record identifies his birthplace, immigration, or parents. The next tests are naturalization, passenger, marriage, probate and German/Jewish records."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MOSER_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
      "title": "Moser/Mosser surname meaning and variants",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=moser",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Moser is a German surname with South German topographic explanations associated with places or terrain named Moos; Mosser is recorded as an Americanized form of German Moser. The variants do not identify Julie's birthplace or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MOSER_IDENTITY_LIMIT",
      "title": "Julie Moser/Moses New Orleans identity limit",
      "type": "local record research route",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/record/results?count=20&q.surname=Moser&q.anyPlace=New%20Orleans",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Official Orleans Parish birth indexes name Julie Moser in 1854 and 1856, Julie Moses in 1859 and Julia Moses in 1862; the repeated husband, place and child sequence supports one woman. Her 1916 death index and Hebrew Rest burial identify the later widow. No reviewed record gives her birthplace, immigration, or parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_JULIENNE_NAME_LIMIT",
      "title": "Julienne name and Lembach identity research route",
      "type": "regional record research route",
      "url": "https://www.archives.bas-rhin.fr/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The imported profile gives only Julienne, death at Lembach on 28 June 1824, wife of Isaac Kieffer and mother of Louis Kieffer. The name may be a given name, surname, or incomplete transcription. Bas-Rhin civil and Jewish registers, especially Lembach death and marriage records, are needed to identify her."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_SALLY_NAME_LIMIT",
      "title": "Sarah Jane Sally Felps spouse identity research limit",
      "type": "compiled-tree research route",
      "url": "https://www.geni.com/people/Henry-Phylppes/6000000032240385817",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The supplied Geni-derived line names Sarah Jane “Sally” as Aquilla Felps’s wife and John Felps’s mother, but gives no maiden surname, date, place, marriage record, or parent. The spouse identity remains a compiled lead only."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_UNRESOLVED_SURNAME_TOPIC_LIMIT",
      "title": "Unresolved surname topic research limit",
      "type": "genealogical research route",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "For endpoints whose tree record contains no established birth surname, surname etymology, geographic origin and historical associations cannot be assigned without inventing data. Each note must be read with that endpoint’s existing research limit and cited source IDs."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_HISTORICAL_MENTION_LIMIT",
      "title": "Historical name-bearer search limit",
      "type": "genealogical research route",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "A family-roots mention records the endpoint-specific research limit when no identity-specific earlier name-bearer or historical event can be tied to the person. It is not evidence that no such record exists."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCNEW_SURNAME_CONTEXT",
      "title": "McNew/McKnew surname meaning and variants",
      "type": "surname reference",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/surname?surname=MCNEW",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "FamilySearch, citing the Dictionary of American Family Names, describes McNew as probably an altered form of an unidentified Scottish or Irish surname. The reference does not establish a single origin or a connection between all McNew/McKnew bearers."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCNEW_FREDERICK_ARCHIVE",
      "title": "McNew/Macknew family papers and Frederick County migration context",
      "type": "local archival collection description",
      "url": "https://www.handleyregional.org/services/departments/archives/manuscripts/h/1619-WFCHS-THL",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "The Handley Regional Library description identifies genealogical material on McNew, Macknew and McKnew families and says related families moved through Frederick County, Virginia, toward Fincastle County in 1773. This is a concrete later locality and archival lead, not proof that Anthony belonged to that group."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOTS26_MCNEW_RESEARCH_LIMIT",
      "title": "Anthony McNew/McKnew research limit",
      "type": "genealogical research route",
      "url": "https://www.lva.virginia.gov/public/local/results_all.asp?CountyID=VA095",
      "citation": null,
      "note": "Anthony is present only in a place-linked compiled cluster, reported about 1670, with no birth, residence, death, spouse, parent or child record. Future identity testing should search the Frederick County deed, court, church and probate series and compare the Macknew/McKnew spelling variants against Scottish and Irish records."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_BRASSINGTON_LEASES_1698_1710",
      "title": "Sneyd of Ashcombe archive: Brassington leases at Bradnop and Morridge, 1698–1710",
      "type": "archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.keele.ac.uk/media/k-web/k-central-services/libraries/specialcollections/pdfs/Sneyd%20Ashcombe%20list.pdf",
      "citation": "Keele University Special Collections, Sneyd of Ashcombe list, entries 1698 and 30 November 1710",
      "note": "Keele University, Sneyd of Ashcombe collection list: a 1 February 1698 lease describes property in Bradnop formerly occupied by Ralph Brassington; a 30 November 1710 counterpart records Walter Lord Aston leasing Witherwood on the Great Waste of Morridge to John Brassington. These are regional surname evidence near Leek, not proof that either man is an ancestor of the Chelmorton family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BL_ADD_MS_36664_JOHN_BRESSINGTON_LEEK_1710",
      "title": "British Library Add MS 36664: John Bressington land case at Leek, circa 1710",
      "type": "archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://searcharchives.bl.uk/catalog/040-002055136",
      "citation": "British Library, Add MS 36664, f. 246, catalogue description: John Bressington, bill in chancery concerning lands in Leek, circa 1710",
      "note": "The British Library catalogue identifies a bill in chancery concerning lands in Leek involving John Bressington, circa 1710. The catalogue supplies no transcription or relationship details and says the physical item must be requested for consultation. Spelling Bressington may be a contemporary variant of Brassington."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CPRDB_BRASSINGTON_BAPTISMS_1714_1870",
      "title": "Cheshire Parish Register Database: Brassington baptisms, 1714–1870",
      "type": "parish_register_index",
      "url": "https://cheshireparish.csc.liv.ac.uk/Live/v3.6/database.html",
      "citation": "Cheshire Parish Register Database, surname query BRASSINGTON, baptism index, accessed 3 October 2026",
      "note": "The query returned 34 transcribed Cheshire baptisms. Earliest visible entries: Hanna Brassington, 28 February 1714, and Joannes (John) Brassington, 27 January 1717, both indexed to Sutton. Finding aid only; parentage and original image unavailable from the result page."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WIKITREE_BRASSINGTON_SIBLING_CLUSTER_20261004",
      "title": "Compiled sibling cluster for Thomas Brassington and Isabell Bagnall",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Brassington-196",
      "citation": "WikiTree, William Brassington (1636), sibling-list and cited Staffordshire baptism records (accessed 4 October 2026)",
      "note": "The profile groups Richard, Isabell, Ellen, Thomas, John, Mary, William, and George Brassington as children of Thomas Brassington and Isabell Bagnall. It cites FamilySearch baptism records for several children, including George on 16 January 1639 (record QL3K-DSG6). The page is a compiled collaborative profile and does not itself establish that Isabell was George's mother; the 1639 baptism transcript names Thomas but not Isabell."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1564_20261005",
      "title": "Compiled Caverswall Brassington reconstruction: Richard 1564 and Thomas c.1586",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.co.uk/genealogy/records/richard-brassington-24-20xyq6l",
      "citation": "Ancestry, public compiled profile for Richard Brassington (accessed 5 October 2026)",
      "note": "The public profile reports Richard Brassington born 28 May 1564 at Caverswall, son of George Brassington and Constance Clerke, married Isabell Bagnold, and fathered a Thomas Brassington born about 1586. Ancestry warns these are user-contributed trees; no underlying Caverswall baptism image or parentage proof is supplied on the profile."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BAGNALL_TRENTHAM_COMPILED_FAMILY_20261005",
      "title": "Compiled Trentham Bagnall family reconstruction",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://sites.rootsmagic.com/AtwoodFamily/site/individual.php?p=187549",
      "citation": "Atwood Family RootsMagic tree, Roger Bagnall individual page, accessed 5 October 2026",
      "note": "This compiled page places an Isabell Bagnold and an Isabell Bagnall among siblings of Roger Bagnall, born at Trentham in 1592, with parents Thomas James Bagnall and Marjorie Willatt. It does not give Isabell a Brassington marriage or connect her to George. It is useful only as a same-region identity conflict and spelling lead."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_CLUSTER_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch compiled Caverswall Brassington cluster: George c.1540 and Richard 1564",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/PXQ5-23X/francis-brassington-1590-1668",
      "citation": "FamilySearch Ancestors, Francis Brassington profile and linked family cluster (accessed 5 October 2026)",
      "note": "The public compiled profile places Richard Brassington (1564–1626) as a son of George Brassington (about 1540–1591), with Constance Clerke, and lists Thomas Brassington among Richard’s children. FamilySearch identifies the page as compiled from contributed family-tree and church-record data; it does not expose a primary baptism proving the parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WILLIAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_WILL_1546_20261005",
      "title": "William Brassington of Cheddleton will reference, 27 October 1546",
      "type": "probate_index_reference",
      "url": "https://etheses.bham.ac.uk/6750/5/DaviesJ16MPhil.pdf",
      "citation": "Jo Davies, Wills and Religious Change in the Archdeaconry of Stafford, 1532–1580, p. 142 n.330, citing Lichfield Record Office B/C/11, Wyllyam Brassington of Cheddleton, 27 Oct 1546 (accessed 5 October 2026)",
      "note": "The thesis footnote identifies an early Lichfield will for Wyllyam Brassington of Cheddleton. The accessible text does not provide the will’s kinship clauses. Cheddleton is a nearby but distinct locality; this is evidence of another contemporary Brassington household, not proof of a relationship to the Caverswall line."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFSPASTTRACK_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_FIRST_PAGE_20261005",
      "title": "Staffordshire Past Track: first page of Caverswall old register",
      "type": "archive_image_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.search.staffspasttrack.org.uk/Details.aspx?PageIndex=61&ResourceID=7119&SearchType=2&ThemeID=226",
      "citation": "Staffordshire Past Track: first page of Caverswall old register (accessed 5 October 2026)",
      "note": "The archive catalogue exposes the first page of the old Caverswall register, dated 1552, with deciphered portions. It corroborates the local description that the earliest page is damaged; it does not contain a Brassington entry or establish parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_RICHARD_ISABELL_CLUSTER_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch profile: Francis Brassington and the Richard–Isabell Caverswall household",
      "type": "user_contributed_family_tree_with_record_citations",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/PXQ5-23X/francis-brassington-1590-1668",
      "citation": "FamilySearch Family Tree, profile PXQ5-23X, Francis Brassington (c.1590–1668), accessed 5 October 2026",
      "note": "The profile reports Richard Brassington and Isabell Bagnall as parents of Thomas, George, Francis, Johis, and Helen, with Thomas dated about 1586; it cites Staffordshire baptism records for members of the same child cluster. This is a compiled profile, not a direct image of Richard’s or Thomas’s birth/marriage record, so it supports but does not prove the parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_GENEANET_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_PEDIGREE_20261005",
      "title": "Geneanet reconstruction: early Caverswall Brassington pedigree",
      "type": "user_contributed_genealogy",
      "url": "https://gw.geneanet.org/tdowling?lang=en&m=P&v=george",
      "citation": "Geneanet, Tim Dowling family-tree search result for George Brassington, accessed 5 October 2026",
      "note": "The indexed reconstruction reports a George Brassington born about 1540–1591 as son of Richard Brassington and Cecilie Alsop, with a marriage to Constance Clarke. The page is a user-contributed tree and does not expose primary citations here; it conflicts with other constructed trees about the early generations. It is retained only as a low-weight lead."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ASHBOURNE_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CECILIE_ALSOP_MARRIAGE_1544_20261005",
      "title": "Ashbourne St Oswald marriage: Richard Brassington and Cecilie Alsop, 27 September 1544",
      "type": "parish_register_transcription",
      "url": "https://derbyshiremarriagesandchristenings.yolasite.com/ashbourne---saint-oswald.php",
      "citation": "Ashbourne St Oswald marriages, 27 September 1544, online transcription (accessed 5 October 2026)",
      "note": "The transcription records “Richard BRASSINGTON & Cecilie ALSOP” on 27 September 1544. It is independent evidence that a couple of these names existed in the region. It does not name their children, and the website is a secondary transcription rather than an image of the register."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_CECILIE_ASHBOURNE_1544_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch indexed Ashbourne marriage: Richard Brassington and Cecilie Alsop, 1544",
      "type": "parish_marriage_index",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/record/results?count=100&q.surname=Brassington&q.marriageLikeDate.from=1500&q.marriageLikeDate.to=1600&q.marriageLikePlace=Ashbourne",
      "citation": "FamilySearch indexed England marriages search, Ashbourne, Derbyshire, Richard Brassington and Cecilie Alsop, 27 September 1544 (accessed 5 October 2026)",
      "note": "The authenticated FamilySearch index reports Richard Brassington marrying Cecilie Alsop at Ashbourne on 27 September 1544. This corroborates the independent Ashbourne transcription, but the index entry was not an image inspection and does not identify children or connect the couple to the later Caverswall line."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ASHBOURNE_TRANSCRIPTION_COVERAGE_1558_20261005",
      "title": "Ashbourne St Oswald transcription coverage: christenings begin in 1558",
      "type": "parish_register_transcription_coverage",
      "url": "https://derbyshiremarriagesandchristenings.yolasite.com/ashbourne---saint-oswald.php",
      "citation": "Ashbourne St Oswald marriages and christenings transcription, coverage statement and entries (accessed 5 October 2026)",
      "note": "The transcription lists the 27 September 1544 Richard Brassington–Cecilie Alsop marriage, but its christening series begins in 1558. Children born between the marriage and 1558 may therefore be absent from this online transcription; the absence of a child entry is not strong negative evidence for that interval."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_DERBYSHIRE_PARISH_COLLECTION_1911752_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch England, Derbyshire, Church of England Parish Registers, 1537–1995",
      "type": "parish_register_collection_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/search/collection/1911752",
      "citation": "FamilySearch collection 1911752, England, Derbyshire, Church of England Parish Registers, 1537–1995 (accessed 5 October 2026)",
      "note": "Free catalogue and indexed-search route for Derbyshire baptisms, marriages/banns and burials; coverage and image access vary by parish and date. The catalogue identifies the Derbyshire Record Office as the original-record custodian. It is a research route for testing the Brassington/Caverswall and Ashbourne candidates, not direct evidence for a particular parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_SURVIVAL_FROM_1552_20261005",
      "title": "Caverswall parish register survival begins in 1552",
      "type": "parish_register_repository_guide",
      "url": "https://www.caverswall.org.uk/genealogy/",
      "citation": "Caverswall parish genealogy guide, parish registers section (accessed 5 October 2026)",
      "note": "The parish guide states that surviving Caverswall St Peter registers begin in 1552, with the first page damaged and later gaps. This means a proposed George baptism about 1545–1550 cannot be confirmed from the surviving Caverswall register series; the absence is a record-survival limitation, not negative evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LAURENCE_BRASSINGTON_BAGNALL_WILL_1658",
      "title": "Lawrence Brassington will of Bagnall, Staffordshire, 1658",
      "type": "will_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.search.staffspasttrack.org.uk/details.aspx?ExhibitionID=16660&ExhibitionPage=2&PageIndex=1&ResourceID=16655&SearchType=2&ThemeID=750",
      "citation": "Staffordshire Past Track, transcription of Lawrence Brassington will, Bagnall, 7 September 1658, Lichfield Record Office B/C/11 1661–2 (accessed 5 October 2026)",
      "note": "Lawrence Brassington of Bagnall, Staffordshire, husbandman, named sons Richard and William and daughters Anne, Dorothy and Ellen. This is a primary-derived local surname occurrence, but it does not identify a relationship to the Caverswall line."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OXFORD_DICTIONARY_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005",
      "title": "Oxford Dictionary of Family Names: Brassington early bearers",
      "type": "surname_reference",
      "url": "https://downloads.freemdict.com/%E5%B0%9A%E6%9C%AA%E6%95%B4%E7%90%86/%E5%85%B1%E4%BA%AB2020.5.11/content/1_english/3_Oxford%20series/The%20Oxford%20Dictionary%20of%20Family%20Names%20in%20Britain%20and%20Ireland/The%20Oxford%20Dictionary%20of%20Family%20Names%20in%20Britain%20and%20Ireland.pdf",
      "citation": "The Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland, entry “Brassington”.",
      "note": "Reference work identifies Brassington as a locative surname from Brassington, Derbyshire, and lists early bearers William de Brassynton (1345), Robert de Brasyntone (1348), Isabella de Brasynton (1379), Edward Brassynton (1411), and Richard Brassington at Caverswall (1564). The PDF host is an access copy; verify against the published Oxford entry where possible."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LICHFIELD_INDEX_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_1546_20261005",
      "title": "Lichfield wills index: Richard Brassington, 1546",
      "type": "probate_index_reference",
      "url": "https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d4/The_Index_library_%28IA_indexlibrary7151brit_0%29.pdf",
      "citation": "British Record Society / Index Library, Lichfield Wills and Administrations, 1546 continuation, entry “Brassington, Richard”.",
      "note": "The searchable OCR exposes the surname and year but not residence, parish, kin, or probate details. It is a lead only and must not be identified with the later Caverswall Richard without the underlying record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WIKITREE_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_RICHARD_THOMAS_20261005",
      "title": "WikiTree Brassington genealogy hub: early Caverswall profiles",
      "type": "public_tree_index",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/genealogy/BRASSINGTON",
      "citation": "WikiTree Brassington genealogy hub, profiles listed as Richard Brassington (about 1560) and Thomas Brassington (about 1600), accessed 5 October 2026.",
      "note": "Public collaborative-tree index only. The hub shows a broadly similar early chronology but does not itself establish the parent-child link or provide primary evidence; it is used as a comparison source, not as proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ISABEL_DE_BRASYNTON_POLL_TAX_1379_20261005",
      "title": "Isabel de Brasynton in the 1379 Poll Tax",
      "type": "secondary_medieval_record_reference",
      "url": "https://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/id/eprint/10904/1/341467.pdf",
      "citation": "Lucy McClure, *Meanings of Singleness*, discussion of the 1379 Poll Tax, citing Fenwick, *Poll Taxes*, vol. 1, pp. 97–100 (Isabel de Brasynton on p. 99).",
      "note": "The study quotes Isabel de Brasynton as an elderly widow (vetula vidua), assessed at 12 pence and listed with a servant; it also notes a separate Margareta de Basynton with a daughter. These are medieval Derby-area surname occurrences, not identified ancestors of the Caverswall line."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_JOHN_BRASSYNTON_LEEK_WILL_WITNESS_1556_20261005",
      "title": "John Brassynton witness to a Leek will, 1556",
      "type": "secondary_will_transcription",
      "url": "https://etheses.bham.ac.uk/id/eprint/6750/5/DaviesJ16MPhil.pdf",
      "citation": "Jo Davies, *Wills and Religious Change in the Archdeaconry of Stafford, 1532–1580*, transcription of Laurence Ratclyffe of Leek’s will, made 25 February 1556 and proved 18 May 1557, citing Lichfield Record Office.",
      "note": "John Brassynton is named as a witness to a Leek will. This is a local surname occurrence eight years before the compiled Richard Brassington Caverswall baptism, but the will gives no kinship or residence for John beyond the Leek context. It is a regional lead, not a parent identification."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_THOMAS_BRASSYNTON_KINGSLEY_WILL_1556_20261005",
      "title": "Thomas Brassynton of Kingsley will reference, 8 May 1556",
      "type": "probate_reference",
      "url": "https://etheses.bham.ac.uk/id/eprint/6750/5/DaviesJ16MPhil.pdf",
      "citation": "Jo Davies, *Wills and Religious Change in the Archdeaconry of Stafford, 1532–1580*, p. 43 n.120, citing Lichfield Record Office B/C/11, Thomas Brassynton, Kingsley, 8 May 1556.",
      "note": "The accessible thesis identifies the testator, locality and date, and quotes part of the preamble, but does not provide the will’s bequests or kinship clauses. The original will or full transcript is needed to test parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CAVERSWALL_SPRS_SURNAME_INDEX_1552_1703_20261005",
      "title": "Caverswall parish-register surname index, 1552–1703",
      "type": "parish_register_index",
      "url": "https://www.caverswall.org.uk/genealogy/sprs-parish-registers-surname-index/",
      "citation": "Staffordshire Parish Registers Society, Caverswall Registers Volumes 1–2 surname index (published 2001; online finding aid).",
      "note": "The Caverswall surname index lists both BRASINGTON and BRASSINGTON among surnames in the 1552–1703 register transcript. This confirms that spelling variation is present in the relevant parish and period, but the index provides no event details or parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_INDEX_RICHARD_GEORGE_CONSTANCE_1590_1591_20261005",
      "title": "Lichfield wills index: Richard Brassington (admon. 1589), George Brassington and Constance (admon. 1591)",
      "type": "probate_index",
      "url": "https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d4/The_Index_library_%28IA_indexlibrary7151brit_0%29.pdf",
      "citation": "British Record Society, *Calendars of Wills and Administrations in the Consistory Court of the Bishop of Lichfield and Coventry*, Index Library vol. 7 (1892), Lichfield series IV, 1589 continuation p. 136 and 1591 continuation p. 146.",
      "note": "The published index lists Richard Brassington with an administration in the 1589 continuation (p. 136), and George Brassington and Constance in the 1591 continuation (p. 146). The index does not give residence, relationships, or the underlying folio text, so these entries cannot by themselves identify the compiled Caverswall family. The original records are held by the Staffordshire Record Office / Lichfield collection."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_LICHFIELD_WILLS_1550_1810_20261005",
      "title": "Staffordshire Name Indexes: Lichfield and Coventry wills index, 1550–1810",
      "type": "probate_index_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.staffsnameindexes.org.uk/default.aspx?Index=C&Info=1",
      "citation": "Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service, Lichfield and Coventry Wills Index, 1550–1810.",
      "note": "Official archive-service index covering wills, administrations and inventories. It explains that original Lichfield Consistory Court documents can be searched through FindMyPast or ordered from the archive; exact Richard, George and Constance entries should be checked here for residence, date and document reference before treating them as the same household."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_BOSLEY_1739_20261005",
      "title": "John Brassington of Bosley, Cheshire, born 1739 (compiled profile)",
      "type": "compiled_online_tree",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.co.uk/genealogy/records/john-brassington-24-nbg5p8",
      "citation": "Ancestry public profile, John Brassington (1739–1796), accessed 5 October 2026",
      "note": "A public compiled profile reports a John Brassington born in Bosley, Cheshire, in 1739, son of John Brassington and Rebecca Allen. It is a separate locality and user-contributed compilation; no original baptism image or evidence connects this John to the Ranton man or to the Chelmorton baptism. It is retained as a documented alternative identity, not adopted as ancestry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OXFORD_ALUMNI_ALEXANDER_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1647_20261005",
      "title": "Alexander Brassington, son of George of Careswell, Oxford matriculation 1647",
      "type": "university_alumni_register",
      "url": "https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Page%3AAlumni_Oxonienses_%281500-1714%29_volume_1.djvu/215",
      "citation": "Joseph Foster, Alumni Oxonienses 1500–1714, vol. 1, p. 215: “Brassington, Alexander, s. George, of Careswell, co. Stafford, pleb.” Oriel College, matriculated 9 April 1647, aged 17; B.A. 1650; rector of Draycot, Staffordshire, 1655–56. Accessed 5 October 2026.",
      "note": "This is a near-contemporary university reference explicitly naming Alexander Brassington as son of George of Careswell (Caverswall) and giving his age and education. It proves a Caverswall Brassington father-and-son household, but does not identify George’s birth, wife, or relationship to the separate 1639 George baptized to Thomas."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_FREE_BMB_INDEX_CAVERSWALL_BRASSINGTON_1564_1703_20261005",
      "title": "Free Staffordshire BMB index: early Caverswall Brassington entries",
      "type": "parish_register_index",
      "url": "https://midland-ancestors.shop/Other/Free-Indexes",
      "citation": "Midland Ancestors/BMSGH free Staffordshire BMB index, STSBMD, Caverswall St Peter entries, accessed 5 October 2026. The downloadable index identifies the source transcript as M471D. Local copies retained as staffordshire-bmb-index-B.pdf and staffordshire-bmb-index-master.pdf.",
      "note": "The index lists Constance Brassington burial 1591; George Brassington baptism 1586 and burial 1591; Richard Brassington baptism 1564 and marriage 1586; Alexander baptism 1629; George baptism 1623; Thomas baptisms 1626 and 1630; and other Caverswall Brassington entries. It is an index rather than the original register image and generally does not give parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOCAL_STAFFORDSHIRE_BMB_INDEX_B_PDF_20261005",
      "title": "Local copy: Staffordshire BMB index B (Brassington entries)",
      "type": "local_download",
      "url": "data/evidence/brassington/staffordshire-bmb-index-B.pdf",
      "citation": "Downloaded from Midland Ancestors free Staffordshire BMB index on 5 October 2026; local copy retained with the tree evidence files.",
      "note": "This is the local PDF index used to verify the early Caverswall Brassington entries. It is an index, not the original register image."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005",
      "title": "George Brassington probate record, Caverswall, 13 April 1591",
      "type": "official probate index detail",
      "url": "https://www.staffsnameindexes.org.uk/default.aspx?RecordID=151932&Index=C&LastName=Brassington&Place=&YearFrom=1550&YearTo=1600&Part=0&County=0&Gender=0&Occupation=",
      "citation": "Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service, Lichfield and Coventry Wills Index, record 151932, accessed 5 October 2026",
      "note": "Male George Brassington of Caverswall, Staffordshire, husbandman. Will and inventory recorded 13 April 1591 in the Lichfield Consistory Court, reference B/C/11; notes none."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_CONSTANCE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1591_20261005",
      "title": "Constance Brassington inventory, Caverswall, 13 April 1591",
      "type": "official probate index detail",
      "url": "https://www.staffsnameindexes.org.uk/default.aspx?RecordID=151931&Index=C&LastName=Brassington&Place=&YearFrom=1550&YearTo=1600&Part=0&County=0&Gender=0&Occupation=",
      "citation": "Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service, Lichfield and Coventry Wills Index, record 151931, accessed 5 October 2026",
      "note": "Constance Brassington of Caverswall, Staffordshire, widow. Inventory recorded 13 April 1591 in the Lichfield Consistory Court, reference B/C/11; no will or administration is marked."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_RICHARD_BRASSYNGTON_CHEADLETON_1552_20261005",
      "title": "Lichfield wills index: Richard Brassyngton of Cheadleton, 1552",
      "type": "probate_index",
      "url": "https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d4/The_Index_library_%28IA_indexlibrary7151brit_0%29.pdf",
      "citation": "British Record Society, *Calendars of Wills and Administrations in the Consistory Court of the Bishop of Lichfield and Coventry*, Index Library vol. 7 (1892), Lichfield series III, 1552 continuation, p. 52.",
      "note": "The published index lists Brassyngton, Richard, Cheadleton, in the 1552 continuation (p. 52). The index gives no relatives or substantive will text. Cheadleton is the historical spelling of Cheddleton, a Staffordshire parish near the later Caverswall cluster; proximity and the surname variant make this a plausible but weak alternative predecessor, not proof of kinship."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LICHFIELD_BRS_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_1546_20261005",
      "title": "Lichfield wills index: Richard Brassington, 1546",
      "type": "probate_index",
      "url": "https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d4/The_Index_library_%28IA_indexlibrary7151brit_0%29.pdf",
      "citation": "British Record Society, *Calendars of Wills and Administrations in the Consistory Court of the Bishop of Lichfield and Coventry*, Index Library vol. 7 (1892), Lichfield series III, 1546 continuation, p. 38.",
      "note": "The published index lists Richard Brassington in the 1546 continuation (p. 38), but gives no residence in the index line. The entry is therefore a chronological/name-only predecessor candidate and cannot be assigned to Caverswall without the original record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_FEET_FINES_VOL11_1323_1546_20261005",
      "title": "Derbyshire Feet of Fines 1323–1546, Derbyshire Record Society volume 11",
      "type": "published_land_record_calendar",
      "url": "https://www.derbyshirerecordsociety.org/book.php?id=32",
      "citation": "H. J. H. Garratt, *Derbyshire Feet of Fines 1323–1546*, Derbyshire Record Society vol. 11 (1985).",
      "note": "The volume contains English summaries of 675 Derbyshire fines and a full person/place index. It is the most direct route to the underlying 1345 William de Brassynton land transaction and may identify the exact place and co-parties. The volume is offered for purchase; the public web description confirms its coverage and indexing but does not expose the individual entry."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WERELATE_DERBYSHIRE_FEET_FINES_ACCESS_20261005",
      "title": "Library access route: Derbyshire Feet of Fines 1323–1546",
      "type": "library_catalogue_reference",
      "url": "https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Source%3AGarratt%2C_H._J._H._Derbyshire_Feet_of_Fines%2C_1323-1546",
      "citation": "WeRelate source entry for Garratt, *Derbyshire Feet of Fines 1323–1546* (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The public catalog entry identifies the volume as held by the Family History Library and gives its complete coverage. This provides a possible library-access route to the 1345 index entry, even though the volume itself is not freely digitized online."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_PLACE_NAMES_CHEDDLETON_VARIANTS_20261005",
      "title": "Historical forms of Cheddleton / Cheadleton",
      "type": "place_name_reference",
      "url": "https://www.staffordshirecountystudies.uk/Notes%20on%20Staffordshire%20place%20names%2C%20Duignan%2C%20W.H.pdf",
      "citation": "W. H. Duignan, *Notes on Staffordshire Place Names*, entry Cheddleton (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The place-name entry gives medieval forms including Chetilton, Cheteleton, Chettilun and Chetelton. A separate Staffordshire historical source describes Cheddleton as “Chedleton.” This supports interpreting the 1552 calendar spelling Cheadleton as the Cheddleton area, but does not connect its Richard Brassyngton to the Caverswall family."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_BC11_ORDERING_ROUTE_20261005",
      "title": "Staffordshire Name Indexes: ordering underlying Lichfield B/C/11 documents",
      "type": "archive_copy_ordering_guide",
      "url": "https://www.staffsnameindexes.org.uk/",
      "citation": "Staffordshire Name Indexes, Lichfield and Coventry Wills Index, document-ordering instructions (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The official index pages state that surviving B/C/11 wills, administrations, inventories and associated papers can be ordered from Staffordshire Record Office using the indexed name, date, residence and reference. The displayed flat-copy fee is £9.50 per file; this is an access route, not evidence that a copy has been ordered."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_IPM_ISABEL_DE_BRASSYNGTON_STAPENHILL_1407_20261005",
      "title": "Mapping the Medieval Countryside: Isabel de Brassyngton of Stapenhill in the 1407 Derbyshire inquisition post mortem",
      "url": "https://inquisitionspostmortem.ac.uk/view/inquisition/19-353/",
      "citation": "CIPM XIX, no. 353 (Derbyshire, Repton, 14 October 1407), enhanced online edition.",
      "note": "The 1407 inquisition for Henry Bradefeld records a toft, lands and meadows in Stapenhill formerly held by Isabel de Brassyngton, with annual value 22 shillings. It establishes an early Derbyshire bearer and a specific locality, but does not identify her parents or descendants."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DERBY_POLL_TAX_1379_BRASYNTON_20261005",
      "title": "1379 Derby poll-tax discussion: Isabella de Brasynton and Margareta de Basynton",
      "url": "https://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/id/eprint/10904/1/341467.pdf",
      "citation": "Academic discussion citing Caroline Fenwick (ed.), The Poll Taxes of 1377, 1379 and 1381, vol. 1, pp. 97–100; relevant discussion and notes 83, 87, 90.",
      "note": "The thesis quotes the 1379 Derby return: Isabella de Brasynton is described as vetula vidua (an elderly widow), assessed at 12 pence and listed with a servant; Margareta de Basynton appears elsewhere in the same return with a daughter. These are biographical details, not proof of kinship to each other or to the later Staffordshire line."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_ACCESS_STATUS_20261005",
      "title": "Caverswall St Peter register access and surviving coverage",
      "url": "https://www.staffordshirehistory.org.uk/collections/getrecord/GB169_CD092",
      "citation": "Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service, GB169_CD092, Records of Caverswall, St Peter; Staffordshire Parish Registers Society, Caverswall volume (2001).",
      "note": "The Staffordshire archive catalogue confirms parish registers from c1552 onward and says the collection is open to public inspection, but the series-level record has not been digitised and is not available through the archive copying service. The Staffordshire Parish Registers Society published baptisms, marriages and burials 1552–1643 and baptisms/marriages 1662–1703; the underlying register or society transcript is therefore the practical route to test the 1560 George marriage and 1564 Richard baptism. The Caverswall parish page confirms early entries are damaged or incomplete."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_COVERAGE_20261005",
      "title": "FreeREG Caverswall St Peter register coverage",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/freereg_contents/55de67c7f493fd5fc4008566/show_register?locale=en",
      "citation": "FreeREG, Parish Register St Peter Caverswall Staffordshire, register name index and coverage page.",
      "note": "The FreeREG catalogue page for St Peter, Caverswall reports 10,368 transcribed entries, but its decade table is blank for 1530–1809 and gives a first actual transcription year of 1813. The separate name index includes BRASINGTON, BRASSINGTON, and BRASSSINGTON, but this is not evidence that the 1560 marriage or 1564 baptism has been transcribed. FreeREG therefore cannot currently test the early Brassington parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FOREBEARS_CAVERSWALL_DIGITIZED_REGISTERS_CATALOG_20261005",
      "title": "Forebears catalog of Caverswall St Peter digitized registers",
      "type": "record_collection_catalog",
      "url": "https://forebears.io/england/staffordshire/caverswall",
      "citation": "Forebears, Caverswall, Staffordshire, England, record-collection catalog (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The catalog advertises Caverswall, St Peter baptism coverage 1552–1895 and marriage coverage 1560–1900, with searchable names and links to digitized images. It is a discovery/access route rather than the underlying register image; the page does not itself prove a particular Brassington event, and access may lead to a subscription provider."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CAVERSWALL_PARISH_HISTORY_REGISTERS_1552_20261005",
      "title": "Caverswall parish history: St Peter registers from 1552",
      "type": "local_history_register_context",
      "url": "https://www.caverswall.org.uk/local-history/history-st-peters-church/",
      "citation": "The Parish of Caverswall, “A History of St Peter’s Church,” parish-register history (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The parish history states that Caverswall registers date from 1552, while noting that the first page is faded/torn and that there are gaps in the surviving series. This makes a 1560 marriage and 1564 baptism chronologically possible in the local register, but it does not name either Brassington event."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_TAX_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_1666_20261005",
      "title": "Caverswall Hearth Tax 1666: George Brassington and widow Brassington",
      "type": "local_tax_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.caverswall.org.uk/local-history/the-hearth-tax-1666/",
      "citation": "The Parish of Caverswall, “The Hearth Tax 1666,” local transcription (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The 1666 Caverswall hearth-tax transcription lists George Brassington with three hearths and a Widow Brassington with one. It confirms the surname’s established presence in the parish, but gives no stated relationship to the 1564 Richard or 1591 George candidates."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FINDMYPAST_CAVERSWALL_ST_PETER_IMAGES_1560_1900_20261005",
      "title": "Findmypast Staffordshire parish coverage: Caverswall St Peter 1560–1900",
      "type": "record_collection_coverage",
      "url": "https://www.findmypast.co.uk/articles/staffordshire-parish-records-coverage",
      "citation": "Findmypast, Staffordshire parish records coverage list, Caverswall St Peter (1560–1900), accessed 5 October 2026.",
      "note": "Findmypast’s coverage list identifies Caverswall, St Peter, with parish-record coverage from 1560 to 1900. This is a catalog/coverage statement, not a read of the individual George or Richard entries; access may require an account or subscription."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_STAFFORDSHIRE_CHURCH_IMAGES_1538_1944_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch Staffordshire church records with images, 1538–1944",
      "type": "free_record_collection_catalog",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/collection/2364451?collectionNameFilter=false",
      "citation": "FamilySearch, England, Staffordshire, Church Records, 1538–1944, collection with images (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "FamilySearch describes this collection as Staffordshire records held by the county archive, with images captured in cooperation with Findmypast and an index supplied by Findmypast. The collection search includes baptisms, marriages and burials and may expose the Caverswall register images. A record-level search is still required; this catalog entry does not itself prove the Brassington events."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_GEORGE_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1639_QL3K_DSG6_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch indexed baptism: George Brassington, Caverswall, 16 January 1639",
      "type": "indexed_parish_baptism",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QL3K-DSG6",
      "citation": "FamilySearch, England, Staffordshire Church Records, 1538–1944, entry for George Brassington, baptized 16 January 1639, Caverswall; citing Staffordshire & Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service, FHL film 7,566,307 (record identifier QL3K-DSG6; accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The indexed entry is reported as naming Thomas Brassington as George’s father. The FamilySearch page is an index citation to the church-record image collection; the image should be inspected where access permits. It does not name a mother in the available index excerpt."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_NORTON_LE_MOORS_1622_QL3G_KC8B_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch indexed baptism: Richard Brassington, Norton le Moors, 30 October 1622",
      "type": "indexed_parish_baptism",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QL3G-KC8B",
      "citation": "FamilySearch, England, Staffordshire Church Records, 1538–1944, entry for Richard Brassington, baptized 30 October 1622 at Norton le Moors, father Thomas Brassington; citing Staffordshire & Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service, FHL film 7,605,014 (record identifier QL3G-KC8B; accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The indexed entry names Thomas Brassington as father. It is evidence for a Thomas Brassington household in the adjacent Staffordshire parish before the 1639 Caverswall baptism, but it does not identify Thomas’s own parents or prove that the 1622 and 1639 entries refer to the same man without image-level comparison."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_ISABELL_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1625_QL3K_HGSK_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch indexed baptism: Isabell Brassington, Caverswall, 1625",
      "type": "indexed_parish_baptism",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QL3K-HGSK",
      "citation": "FamilySearch, England, Staffordshire Church Records, 1538–1944, entry for Isabell Brassington, baptized 1625 at Caverswall; indexed father Thomas Brassington; accessed 5 October 2026.",
      "note": "Record-specific indexed baptism naming Thomas Brassington as father. It supports the existence of a Thomas-led household in the 1620s–1630s, but does not establish Thomas’s own parents or prove that all nearby entries concern one man."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_WILLIAM_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_1636_QL3K_H2SH_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch indexed baptism: William Brassington, Caverswall, 5 February 1636",
      "type": "indexed_parish_baptism",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QL3K-H2SH",
      "citation": "FamilySearch, England, Staffordshire Church Records, 1538–1944, entry for William Brassington, baptized 5 February 1636 at Caverswall; indexed father Thomas Brassington; accessed 5 October 2026.",
      "note": "Record-specific indexed baptism naming Thomas Brassington as father. It supports the existence of a Thomas-led household in the 1620s–1630s, but does not establish Thomas’s own parents or prove that all nearby entries concern one man."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BRASSINGTON_DERBYSHIRE_MEDIEVAL_CHAPEL_BRADBOURNE_20261005",
      "title": "Medieval Brassington, Derbyshire: chapel and manor context",
      "type": "local_history_context",
      "url": "https://www.brassington.org.uk/history/ron-slack-brassington/medieval-brassington",
      "citation": "Brassington community history, “Medieval Brassington” (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The local history account states that Brassington was historically a chapelry of Bradbourne and that the manor passed through medieval feudal ownership before later copyhold records. This explains why early family evidence may appear under Bradbourne rather than a standalone Brassington parish. It is place-history context, not proof that any later Brassington surname bearer descended from the medieval manor population."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FOREBEARS_BRASSINGTON_DERBYSHIRE_PLACE_HISTORY_20261005",
      "title": "Forebears Brassington, Derbyshire parish and surname context",
      "type": "place_and_record_catalog",
      "url": "https://forebears.io/england/derbyshire/brassington",
      "citation": "Forebears, Brassington, Derbyshire, parish and record catalog (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The catalog describes Brassington as an ancient Derbyshire settlement and lists local record collections. Together with the Oxford surname entry, this supports a locative origin for the surname, while leaving the connection to the Staffordshire Caverswall family unproved."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_BRADBOURNE_REGISTERS_1580_20261005",
      "title": "Derbyshire Record Office D944: Bradbourne parish records from 1580",
      "type": "archive_catalog",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/calmview/Record.aspx?id=D944&pos=18&src=CalmView.Catalog",
      "citation": "Derbyshire Record Office, D944, Parish of Bradbourne All Saints catalogue (records from 1580; accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The official catalogue states that Bradbourne parish records begin in 1580 and that the parish historically covered Brassington, along with Atlow, Ballidon and Tissington. This is the most direct archival route found for testing whether early Brassington-place families appear under Bradbourne. The catalog does not itself name a Brassington bearer."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FREEREG_BRADBOURNE_NO_PRE1713_TRANSCRIPT_20261005",
      "title": "FreeREG Bradbourne coverage: no transcribed records before 1713",
      "type": "transcription_coverage",
      "url": "https://www.freereg.org.uk/freereg_contents/53cbf5ceeca9eb03a6002274/show_place",
      "citation": "FreeREG, Bradbourne, Derbyshire coverage page (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "FreeREG reports Bradbourne transcriptions beginning in 1713, despite the Derbyshire Record Office catalogue listing Bradbourne records from 1580. The pre-1713 material therefore remains an archive/original-register lookup rather than an online FreeREG search."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_BRASSINGTON_MANOR_COURT_BOOKS_1635_1888_20261005",
      "title": "Derbyshire Record Office D166: Brassington manor court books, 1635–1888",
      "type": "manorial_archive_catalog",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/calmview/Record.aspx?id=D166&pos=7&src=CalmView.Catalog",
      "citation": "Derbyshire Record Office, D166, Manor of Brassington, court books and papers 1635–1888 (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The catalogue identifies eight boxes of Brassington manor records, including court books from 1635–1879. These could name tenants, admissions, surrenders and occupations in the Derbyshire place, but the collection begins too late to prove the 1345 bearer’s descent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LICHFIELD_BC11_WYLLYAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_1546_20261005",
      "title": "William Brassington of Cheddleton will, 27 October 1546",
      "type": "probate_reference",
      "url": "https://etheses.bham.ac.uk/id/eprint/6750/5/DaviesJ16MPhil.pdf",
      "citation": "Jo Davies, *Wills and Religious Change in the Archdeaconry of Stafford, 1532–1580*, pp. 153, 221 n.330, citing Lichfield Record Office B/C/11, Wyllyam Brassington of Cheddleton, 27 October 1546 (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The thesis identifies this specific Cheddleton will and quotes a religious bequest context, but does not expose the full kinship clauses. It is independent of the 1546 Richard Brassington index entry and should not be merged with him."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CAVERSWALL_HEARTH_TAX_1666_BRASSINGTON_HOUSEHOLDS_20261005",
      "title": "Caverswall 1666 Hearth Tax: George Brassington and Widow Brassington",
      "type": "local_history_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.caverswall.org.uk/local-history/the-hearth-tax-1666/",
      "citation": "Caverswall Parish, “The Hearth Tax 1666,” transcription from Collections for a History of Staffordshire, listing George Brassington (3 hearths) and Widow Brassington (1 hearth); accessed 5 October 2026.",
      "note": "The local-history transcription lists two Brassington households in Caverswall in 1666. It supplies household-size evidence but no given names for the widow, relationships, ages, or addresses. It is useful for separating same-name households, not for assigning parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_BL_EGERTON_BRASSINGTON_DEEDS_GROUP_1584_1628_20261005",
      "title": "British Library Egerton Ch 2758, 2759, 2874 and 2875: Brassington deeds",
      "type": "manuscript_catalogue_search",
      "url": "https://searcharchives.bl.uk/?f%5Brelated_places_ssim%5D%5B%5D=Monyash%2C+Derbyshire&per_page=50",
      "citation": "British Library Archives and Manuscripts Catalogue search results for the Monyash/Brassington-related Egerton charters (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The catalogue search identifies four related files—Egerton Ch 2758, Ch 2759, Ch 2874 and Ch 2875—with deeds relating to Brassington, Derbyshire, generally 1584–1628. Ch 2758 and Ch 2759 also include Chelmorton and Staffordshire places; the public catalogue gives no deed-holder names or digitized images. These are archival targets, not evidence of a family link."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_MISCELLANY_BRASSINGTON_RENTALS_1578_1620_20261005",
      "title": "Derbyshire Miscellany: Brassington rentals and manor records, 1578–1620",
      "type": "scholarly_local_history_archive_guide",
      "url": "https://www.derbyshireas.org.uk/DM12-04.pdf",
      "citation": "R. Slack, “The Brassington Manors: Land Tenure and Use 1550–1770, Part II,” Derbyshire Miscellany 12 (part 4), pp. 100–111 (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The article identifies surviving record routes for Brassington manor: Sheffield City Archives rentals and estreates from 1578–1593, a 1620 Brassington rental in the Public Record Office, and Wirksworth Hundred court rolls including Brassington from 1558–1637. It does not name the Caverswall family, but these records could test whether a Derbyshire household supplied the later Staffordshire branch."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_MISCELLANY_BRASSINGTON_MANOR_TENANTS_1620_1640_20261005",
      "title": "Brassington manor tenant summary, 1620–1640",
      "type": "scholarly_local_history_transcription",
      "url": "https://www.derbyshireas.org.uk/DM12-03.pdf",
      "citation": "R. Slack, “The Brassington Manors: Land Tenure and Use 1550–1770, Part I,” Derbyshire Miscellany 12 (part 3), pp. 85–90 (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The published summary identifies principal Brassington manor tenants and holdings in 1620–1640, including Wilcocke, Gratton, Knowles, Allsop, Buxton, Toplis, Tissington and Westeme families. It is not an exhaustive surname list and does not name a Brassington tenant; the underlying rentals and court rolls remain necessary for a negative conclusion."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DARG_DERBYSHIRE_REGISTER_COVERAGE_BRASSINGTON_CHELMORTON_WIRKSWORTH_20261005",
      "title": "Derbyshire Ancestral Research Group register coverage: Brassington, Chelmorton and Wirksworth",
      "type": "local_register_catalog",
      "url": "https://darg.gukutils.org.uk/CERegisters.shtml",
      "citation": "Derbyshire Ancestral Research Group, Church of England Registers (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The group lists Brassington St James general registers for 1716–1765, Chelmorton all events for 1575–1840, and Wirksworth all events for 1608–1837. These ranges can support a targeted parish search, but the page is a holdings guide rather than an extracted record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DERBYSHIRE_RECORD_OFFICE_DOMESDAY_BRASSINGTON_WIRKSWORTH_COPY_1662_20261005",
      "title": "Derbyshire Record Office copy of Domesday entries for Wirksworth and Brassington",
      "type": "manor_history_archive_catalog",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/calmview/Record.aspx?id=D258%2F10%2F25&src=calmview.catalog",
      "citation": "Derbyshire Record Office, D258/10/25/1-2, copies of Wirksworth and Brassington entries from Domesday Book, 1086, dated 1662 (catalogue accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "This is a later copy of the 1086 manor entries and documents the place/manor, not a genealogical Brassington family. It provides locality context only."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFORDSHIRE_ARCHIVES_CAVERSWALL_REGISTERS_C1552_20261005",
      "title": "Staffordshire Record Office catalogue: Caverswall St Peter registers c1552–2011",
      "type": "official_archive_catalog",
      "url": "https://www.staffordshirehistory.org.uk/collections/getrecord/GB169_CD092",
      "citation": "Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service, Records of Caverswall, St Peter, catalogue GB169_CD092 (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The catalogue confirms surviving Caverswall parish registers from about 1552 onward, held at Staffordshire Record Office. The collection is open to public inspection but is not digitized; images or a copying-service request may be needed for the early Brassington entries."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DARG_CAVERSWALL_TRANSCRIPT_HOLDINGS_1552_1643_20261005",
      "title": "DARG library holdings: Caverswall transcripts 1552–1643",
      "type": "local_transcript_catalog",
      "url": "https://darg.gukutils.org.uk/Other.shtml",
      "citation": "Derbyshire Ancestral Research Group, Other Records catalogue (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "DARG lists Caverswall all events, 1552–1643, among its Staffordshire transcript holdings. The group states that it can answer specific enquiries from its own library by post, subject to postage/donation. This may offer a lower-cost route to the early Brassington entries than ordering archive copies, but the index does not expose the individual entries online."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DRO_CHELMORTON_REGISTER_TRANSCRIPT_D3536_1575_1840_20261005",
      "title": "Derbyshire Record Office transcript of Chelmorton registers, 1575–1840",
      "type": "official_archive_catalog",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/calmview/Record.aspx?AddBasket=D3536&id=D3536&pos=13&src=CalmView.Catalog",
      "citation": "Derbyshire Record Office, D3536, Parish of Chelmorton St John the Baptist: photocopy transcript of parish registers 1575–1840 (catalogue accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The catalogue confirms a transcript of the Chelmorton registers for 1575–1840, made from the parish material and held by the Derbyshire Record Office. DARG separately states it holds an indexed transcript and will search specific entries."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DARG_CHELMORTON_REGISTER_TRANSCRIPT_SEARCH_1575_1840_20261005",
      "title": "DARG indexed Chelmorton register transcript, 1575–1840",
      "type": "local_transcript_catalog",
      "url": "https://darg.gukutils.org.uk/ChelmortonMIs.shtml",
      "citation": "Derbyshire Ancestral Research Group, Chelmorton memorial inscriptions and register holdings (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "DARG states that it holds an indexed transcript of the Chelmorton registers, 1575–1840, and will search for specific entries. The page also lists Brassington among surnames found in Chelmorton memorial inscriptions. It does not publish the 1739 baptism entry online."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_ANCESTRY_JOHN_BRASSINGTON_BOSLEY_1739_COMPILED_20261005",
      "title": "Compiled Ancestry profile: John Brassington of Bosley, 1739",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy_profile",
      "url": "https://www.ancestry.co.uk/genealogy/records/john-brassington-24-nbg5p8",
      "citation": "Ancestry, “John Brassington (1739–1796),” compiled profile accessed 5 October 2026.",
      "note": "The profile reports a John Brassington born in Bosley, Cheshire, in 1739, son of John Brassington and Rebecca Allen. It is a user-contributed compiled profile rather than an image of a parish record, so it is retained as an alternative identity only."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CHESHIRE_CPRDB_BOSLEY_REGISTERS_1728_1788_20261005",
      "title": "Cheshire Parish Register Database and Bosley register coverage",
      "type": "free_parish_register_database",
      "url": "https://cheshireparish.csc.liv.ac.uk/Live/v3.6/database.html",
      "citation": "Cheshire Parish Register Database, University of Liverpool Cheshire Parish Register project (accessed 5 October 2026); Bosley register coverage 1728–1788 as summarized in public guides.",
      "note": "The CPRdb provides searchable Cheshire baptism, marriage and burial indexes. Bosley’s surviving register begins in 1728, so the reported 1739 John Brassington alternative is potentially testable against an indexed parish record and parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DRO_BRASSINGTON_PARISH_REGISTERS_D943_1716_2020_20261005",
      "title": "Derbyshire Record Office: Brassington St James registers begin in 1716",
      "type": "official_archive_catalog",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/calmview/Record.aspx?id=D943&src=CalmView.Catalog",
      "citation": "Derbyshire Record Office, D943 Parish of Brassington St James, 1716–2020 (catalogue accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The surviving Brassington parish registers begin in 1716. The parish was formerly a chapelry of Bradbourne. This explains why the medieval surname bearers and the sixteenth-century Caverswall candidates cannot be connected through a continuous Brassington parish baptism series."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_DRO_D258_28_1_16_BRASSINGTON_WITNESSES_1363_20261005",
      "title": "1363 Carsington deed with Brassington witnesses",
      "type": "primary_archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://calmview.derbyshire.gov.uk/calmview/Record.aspx?id=D258%2F28%2F1%2F16&src=CalmView.Catalog",
      "citation": "Derbyshire Record Office, D258/28/1/16, release and quitclaim by William le Hayward of Brassington, dated 2 July 1363 (catalogue accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The deed names William Elen de Brassington, chaplain; Henry de Ballidon of Brassington; Richard son of Pole of Brassington; and William del Hoghc of Brassington, chaplain, as witnesses. It establishes a local group of people identified with Brassington in 1363, but does not state kinship. This official catalogue record is the primary archive access point; no image is exposed in the catalogue page."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFS_PASTTRACK_LAWRENCE_BRASSINGTON_WILL_BAGNALL_1658_20261005",
      "title": "Lawrence Brassington will, Bagnall, 1658 (proved 1661–1662)",
      "type": "local_archive_transcript",
      "url": "https://www.search.staffspasttrack.org.uk/details.aspx?ExhibitionID=16660&ExhibitionPage=2&PageIndex=1&ResourceID=16655&SearchType=2&ThemeID=750",
      "citation": "Lichfield Record Office, B/C/11 1661–2, will and inventory of Lawrence Brassington of Bagnall, Staffordshire, dated 7 September 1658 (Staffordshire Past Track transcript, accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "Lawrence Brassington describes himself as a husbandman of Bagnall and names sons Richard and William and daughters Anne, Dorothy and Ellen. The will documents a Staffordshire Brassington household but does not identify parents or connect it to Caverswall, Chelmorton, or Ranton."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_OXFORD_FAMILY_NAMES_BRASSINGTON_EARLY_BEARERS_20261005",
      "title": "Oxford Dictionary of Family Names: Brassington entry",
      "type": "surname_reference",
      "url": "https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=0AyDDQAAQBAJ",
      "citation": "Patrick Hanks, Richard Coates and Peter McClure (eds.), The Oxford Dictionary of Family Names in Britain and Ireland (Oxford University Press, 2016), entry “Brassington,” accessed 5 October 2026.",
      "note": "The entry treats Brassington as an English locative surname from Brassington, Derbyshire, and lists early bearers William de Brassynton (1345), Robert de Brasyntone (1348), Isabella de Brasynton (1379), and Edward Brassynton (1411), followed by Richard Brassington at Caverswall in 1564. These are surname-history anchors, not a continuous pedigree."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PRIMARY_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_ARCHIVE_CATALOGUE_20261005",
      "title": "Primary access point: Caverswall St Peter registers c1552–2011",
      "type": "primary_archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.staffordshirehistory.org.uk/collections/getrecord/GB169_CD092",
      "citation": "Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archives, GB169_CD092, Records of Caverswall St Peter parish: parish registers c1552–2011 (catalogue record, accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "Official repository catalogue for the surviving parish registers. It is a primary-source access point, but the catalogue page is not an image of the 1560s register. The early register is open for public inspection and is not digitized in this record."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PRIMARY_ASHBOURNE_REGISTER_ARCHIVE_CATALOGUE_20261005",
      "title": "Primary access point: Ashbourne St Oswald register M117 Vol 10, 1538–1622",
      "type": "primary_archive_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.derbyshire.gov.uk/site-elements/documents/pdf/leisure/record-office/parish-register-list.pdf",
      "citation": "Derbyshire Record Office, Parish Register List, Ashbourne St Oswald M117 Vol. 10, baptisms, marriages and burials 1538–1622 (catalogue/finding aid, accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "Official repository finding aid identifying the surviving register volume containing the reported 1544 marriage. It is a primary-source access point, not the register image itself."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PRIMARY_LAWRENCE_BRASSINGTON_WILL_TRANSCRIPT_20261005",
      "title": "Primary-document transcript: Lawrence Brassington will, 1658",
      "type": "primary_source_transcript",
      "url": "https://www.search.staffspasttrack.org.uk/details.aspx?ExhibitionID=16660&ExhibitionPage=2&PageIndex=1&ResourceID=16655&SearchType=2&ThemeID=750",
      "citation": "Lichfield Record Office, B/C/11 1661–2, will and inventory of Lawrence Brassington of Bagnall, dated 7 September 1658; transcript and document images hosted by Staffordshire Past Track (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "This is a transcript of a named archival will, with document images available on the repository-hosted page. It directly supports Lawrence’s household and named children; it does not supply his parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PRIMARY_WILLIAM_BRASSINGTON_CHEDDLETON_WILL_1546_20261005",
      "title": "Primary archive reference: Wyllyam Brassington will, Cheddleton, 1546",
      "type": "primary_archive_reference",
      "url": "https://etheses.bham.ac.uk/id/eprint/6750/5/DaviesJ16MPhil.pdf",
      "citation": "Lichfield Record Office, B/C/11, will of Wyllyam Brassington of Cheddleton, dated 27 October 1546; archival reference reported in James Davies, Wills and religious change in the Archdeaconry of Stafford, 1532–1580, n.330 (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The archival will is the primary document. The linked dissertation is an open scholarly route identifying the archive reference and date; it is not a scan of the will. The will’s family contents remain to be obtained from the archive or paid image service."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PRIMARY_FINDMYPAST_CAVERSWALL_BROWSE_1538_1900_20261005",
      "title": "Primary image access route: Staffordshire parish registers browse, 1538–1900",
      "type": "primary_register_image_access",
      "url": "https://www.findmypast.co.uk/discover/birth-marriage-death-and-parish-records/parish-registers/staffordshire-parish-registers-browse-1538-1900",
      "citation": "Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service / Findmypast, Staffordshire Parish Registers Browse, 1538–1900, including Caverswall St Peter (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "This is the image-browse route for the digitized Staffordshire parish-register collection. It provides access to primary register images where the Caverswall coverage is present; an individual image for the 1560s Brassington entries has not yet been inspected. Account or subscription access may be required."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_CCED_LEEK_CHEDDLETON_CHAPEL_CONTEXT_20261005",
      "title": "Church of England Clergy Database: Leek parish and Cheddleton chapel",
      "type": "primary_parish_context_catalogue",
      "url": "https://theclergydatabase.org.uk/jsp/locations/DisplayLocation.jsp?locKey=2957",
      "citation": "Church of England Clergy Database, Leek location record (locKey 2957), accessed 5 October 2026.",
      "note": "The location record states that the medieval parish of Leek included Cheddleton chapel and that Cheddleton became a separate parish in 1721. This is a primary-source catalogue/context route for interpreting sixteenth-century Cheddleton records; it does not itself identify a Brassington parent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PRIMARY_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_BRASSYNTON_BC11_1552_1556_20261005",
      "title": "Staffordshire Name Indexes: Lichfield B/C/11 probate search route",
      "type": "primary_archive_index_catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.staffsnameindexes.org.uk/default.aspx?Index=C&Mode=Cookies",
      "citation": "Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service, Lichfield and Coventry Wills Index, B/C/11 (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The official index covers Lichfield Consistory Court wills, administrations and inventories and identifies B/C/11 as the relevant series. It states that copies may be ordered from the archive or accessed through the image service. This route is attached to the Brassynton candidates so the original 1552, 1546 and 1556 probate files can be requested and their kinship clauses tested."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WIKITREE_THOMAS_ISABELL_CAVERSWALL_SIBLING_CLUSTER_20261005",
      "title": "WikiTree compiled cluster: Thomas and Isabell Brassington children, 1622–1639",
      "type": "compiled_genealogy_with_primary_record_citations",
      "url": "https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Brassington-196",
      "citation": "WikiTree profile Brassington-196, citing FamilySearch Staffordshire Church Records entries for Richard 1622 Norton le Moors, Isabell 1625, Ellen 1628, Thomas 1630, John 1633, Mary 1634, William 1636 and George 1639 Caverswall (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The compiled profile groups the indexed baptisms under Thomas and Isabell Brassington. The individual FamilySearch citations are stronger evidence for the baptisms; the grouping of the Norton 1622 child with the later Caverswall children remains an identity hypothesis until the original images and parish context are compared."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_PRIMARY_STAFFS_CAVERSWALL_REGISTER_COVERAGE_1552_2023_20261005",
      "title": "Staffordshire Archive Service parish-register guide: Caverswall St Peter from c.1552",
      "type": "primary_archive_register_coverage",
      "url": "https://staffordshirehistorycentre.blog/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/guide-to-sources-no.1-prs-and-bts-2023.pdf",
      "citation": "Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service, Guide to Sources no. 1: Parish Registers and Bishops’ Transcripts, p. 16, Caverswall St Peter (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The official guide lists Caverswall St Peter baptism, marriage and burial holdings from approximately 1552 onward. It confirms that the register series is the correct primary source route for testing the reported 1564 Richard baptism and earlier household entries; it does not itself provide the entries or parentage."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_TRENTHAM_DGS_7567143_1558_1640_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch Trentham catalog route; DGS 7567143 mapping unresolved (1558–1640)",
      "type": "catalogue and restricted image access route",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/search/film/007567143",
      "citation": "FamilySearch Catalog, Parish registers for Trentham, 1558–1900, film 1526191 items 14–19, DGS 7567143 (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The FamilySearch catalog identifies Trentham baptisms 1558–1640, marriages 1561–1640, and burials 1558–1640 on film 1526191, items 14–19, DGS 7567143. However, authenticated navigation to the DGS URL on 5 October 2026 opened a film titled Tipton, St Martin's Church, not Trentham. This is a catalog-to-viewer mapping discrepancy; no Trentham register image was inspected and no event-level conclusion is drawn from this route. The catalog states access may require a FamilySearch Center or affiliate library."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_FRANCIS_BRASSINGTON_PROFILE_PXQ5_23X_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch compiled profile: Francis Brassington, Caverswall, about 1590",
      "type": "compiled FamilySearch profile",
      "url": "https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/PXQ5-23X/francis-brassington-1590-1668",
      "citation": "FamilySearch Ancestors profile PXQ5-23X, Francis Brassington (accessed 5 October 2026).",
      "note": "The public profile repeats the compiled Richard–Isabell Bagnold parentage and lists Thomas, George, Francis, Johis and Helen as siblings; it also lists two Isabell child entries. It cites Staffordshire church-record indexes but does not provide an independent image or prove that all entries belong to one household. It is corroborative context only and also flags possible same-name conflation."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_STAFFSNAMEINDEXES_THOMAS_BRASSINGTON_MORE_HALL_1599_20261005",
      "title": "Thomas Brassington probate record, More Hall, 28 September 1599",
      "type": "official probate index detail",
      "url": "https://www.staffsnameindexes.org.uk/default.aspx?RecordID=155662&Index=C&LastName=Brassington&Place=&YearFrom=1580&YearTo=1600&Part=0&County=0&Gender=0&Occupation=",
      "citation": "Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent Archive Service, Lichfield and Coventry Wills Index, record 155662, accessed 5 October 2026.",
      "note": "Thomas Brassington, resident at More Hall, Stoke upon Trent, Staffordshire; will and inventory recorded 28 September 1599 in the Lichfield Consistory Court, reference B/C/11. The index notes poor condition. This is a record-level same-name alternative to the later Thomas Brassington associated with baptisms from 1622 to 1639; no identity link is assumed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_FAMILYSEARCH_RICHARD_BRASSINGTON_CAVERSWALL_BAPTISM_1564_DUAL_INDEX_20261005",
      "title": "FamilySearch indexed Caverswall baptism/christening: Richard Brassington, 28 May 1564",
      "type": "parish_baptism_index",
      "url": "https://www.familysearch.org/en/search/record/results?count=100&q.surname=Brassington&q.birthLikeDate.from=1550&q.birthLikeDate.to=1570&q.birthLikePlace=Caverswall",
      "citation": "FamilySearch, England birth/christening and Staffordshire church-record indexes, Richard Brassington, Caverswall, 28 May 1564; accessed 5 October 2026.",
      "note": "Two FamilySearch index representations report Richard Brassington at Caverswall on 28 May 1564. The parent fields display only Brassington / Brassington and Brassington, without given names; the baptism event is corroborated, but the indexed result does not identify George or Constance as parents."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOCAL_PHELPS_BOOK_PAGE_32_20260915",
      "title": "Local image: Phelps and Servin (1899), scanned page 32",
      "type": "primary_book_image_local",
      "url": "data/evidence/phelps/phelps-book-p32.png",
      "citation": "Local image extracted from the scanned Phelps and Servin volume, inspected 15 September 2026.",
      "note": "Scanned page image used in the Phelps/Felps lineage review; page numbering follows the printed volume, not the PDF viewer index."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOCAL_PHELPS_BOOK_PAGE_33_20260915",
      "title": "Local image: Phelps and Servin (1899), scanned page 33",
      "type": "primary_book_image_local",
      "url": "data/evidence/phelps/phelps-book-p33.png",
      "citation": "Local image extracted from the scanned Phelps and Servin volume, inspected 15 September 2026.",
      "note": "Scanned page image used in the Phelps/Felps lineage review; page numbering follows the printed volume, not the PDF viewer index."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOCAL_PHELPS_BOOK_PAGE_35_20260915",
      "title": "Local image: Phelps and Servin (1899), scanned page 35",
      "type": "primary_book_image_local",
      "url": "data/evidence/phelps/phelps-book-p35.png",
      "citation": "Local image extracted from the scanned Phelps and Servin volume, inspected 15 September 2026.",
      "note": "Scanned page image used in the Phelps/Felps lineage review; page numbering follows the printed volume, not the PDF viewer index."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOCAL_MCELROY_DOCUMENT_IMAGE_1_20260916",
      "title": "Local image: McElroy deed/land-record page 1",
      "type": "primary_land_record_image_local",
      "url": "data/evidence/mcelroy/mcelroy-park-1.png",
      "citation": "Local image inspected during the McElroy–Clarke review, 16 September 2026.",
      "note": "Document image used to inspect the McElroy land-record network surrounding Rachel McElroy; it is attached as supporting context for the parent hypotheses."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOCAL_MCELROY_DOCUMENT_IMAGE_2_20260916",
      "title": "Local image: McElroy deed/land-record page 2",
      "type": "primary_land_record_image_local",
      "url": "data/evidence/mcelroy/mcelroy-park-2.png",
      "citation": "Local image inspected during the McElroy–Clarke review, 16 September 2026.",
      "note": "Document image used to inspect the McElroy land-record network surrounding Rachel McElroy; it is attached as supporting context for the parent hypotheses."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_LOCAL_WASHINGTON_DEED16_PAGE5_20260915",
      "title": "Local image: Washington County Virginia Deed Book 16 index page 5",
      "type": "primary_deed_index_image_local",
      "url": "data/evidence/phelps/washington-deed16-page5.png",
      "citation": "Local image extracted from the inspected Washington County deed material, Deed Book 16 (1842–1844), page 5, reviewed 15 September 2026.",
      "note": "The image preserves the inspected deed-index page naming Samuel and Susannah Felps/Phelps and their local association. It supports the parentage context but remains an index/abstract image rather than the complete deed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WIKIMEDIA_14TH_FOOT_BADGE_AM7210962",
      "title": "14th Regiment of Foot regimental badge (1861 pattern), Wikimedia Commons",
      "type": "museum image",
      "url": "https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Regimental_badge-_14th_Regiment_of_Foot_(AM_721096-2).jpg",
      "citation": "Wikimedia Commons, badge photographed in the Auckland Museum collection, AM 721096-2.",
      "note": "A regimental badge associated with the 14th Regiment of Foot. The badge shown is an 1861 pattern, later than William Hanny’s 1803 service; it is included as a later visual emblem of the regiment, not as an object William personally wore."
    },
    {
      "id": "SRC_WIKIMEDIA_14TH_FOOT_COLOURS",
      "title": "14th Regiment of Foot colours, Wikimedia Commons",
      "url": "https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:14th_Foot_colours.jpg"
    }
  ]
}
