Profile ID: I118. Status: candidate_harvested.
reported life span — This profile reports a birth reported about 1680 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia; a death reported about 1730 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia. — reported about 1680–reported about 1730 — reported Norfolk County, Virginia
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Generation 12 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-12 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026
This tree includes proposed relationships as well as established ones. Link confidence scores are research assessments, not calibrated statistical probabilities. A person in the directory may be a research candidate rather than an ancestor. Family roots describe historical context, not additional biological parents.
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; WeRelate compiled profile: Lemuel Butt, about 1704-about 1753; Generation 12 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Generation 13 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Generation 12 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Generation 12 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-12 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026; McIntosh, Norfolk wills: Richard Church and granddaughter Leddae Butt, pp191-192
See RN_OT26_CHURCH_BUTT_GRANDDAUGHTER.
No marriage, will, deed, or child record was located, and duplicate Lemuel sons make the maternity assignment uncertain. Evidence review: Elizabeth Church is repeated as Robert Butt's wife in an unsourced collaborative tree. This supplies a real Church-Butt family connection in the relevant locality, but does not name Leddae's parents or a daughter Elizabeth. The testator is an identity candidate for the proposed Richard; no identity merge or parentage upgrade made. The older wife Elizabeth must remain distinct from the proposed daughter Elizabeth. Follow-up 16 September 2026: a Norfolk Richard Church testator (Book7 p106; published abstract pp191-192) names granddaughter Leddae Butt and wife Elizabeth.
family_record: status conflicting_candidate; confidence 0.3.
family record — Reported wife of Robert Butt and mother of Lemuel Butt — reported; events unresolved — reported Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731
Church is not supported by a marriage, probate, deed, or baptism found in this review.
occupation_status: status unresolved; confidence 0.99.
occupation status — No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Generation 12 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-12 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026
This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant.
education_status: status unresolved; confidence 0.99.
education status — No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Generation 12 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-12 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026
This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training.
local_context_limitation: status unresolved; confidence 0.99.
local context limitation — A responsible place-and-period-specific local history cannot yet be assigned because the reported locality or identity is too broad, conflicting, or unverified — reported Norfolk County, Virginia
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Generation 12 online evidence audit, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-12 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026
A real locality must not be used to make an unproved identity appear documented. Context should be added when a parish, town, county, household, or other defensible location is established.
reported_life_span: status reported; confidence 0.38.
This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates.
Child: Lemuel Butt — Generation 12 audit: retained as a plausible named parent hypothesis, but the collaborative family contains duplicate Lemuel sons and no direct parent record.
Parent candidate / recorded parent: Richard Church — Generation 13 audit: retained as a weak named father hypothesis; no direct or independently sourced relationship evidence was found.
Partner: Robert Butt — Generation 12 audit: retained as a plausible compiled couple; no original marriage or joint record was found.