Profile ID: HV4_JOHN_S_MCNEW_15_NOV_1806_1_JAN_1876. Status: source_backed.
burial — Recorded at the McNew Cemetery, Deepwater; died 1 January 1876 at an age transcribed as 70 years, 1 month, and 16 days — 1 Jan 1876–1 Jan 1876 — Henry County, Missouri, United States
Sources: Deepwater Cemetery transcription: John S. McNew and Sarah A. Willoughby; Cook Family Ancestry: John S. McNew, 1806-1876; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew
documented life span — Born 15 Nov 1806. Died 1 Jan 1876 in Henry County, Missouri, United States. — 15 Nov 1806–1 Jan 1876 — Henry County, Missouri, United States
Sources: Deepwater Cemetery transcription: John S. McNew and Sarah A. Willoughby; Cook Family Ancestry: John S. McNew, 1806-1876; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew
local historical context — Henry County was a prairie-and-farm county whose 1883 history describes early settlement and cultivated farms. This is community context, not evidence of this person's work or property. — Henry County, Missouri, United States
Sources: History of Henry County, Missouri (1883), chapter 1
This tree includes proposed relationships as well as established ones. Link confidence scores are research assessments, not calibrated statistical probabilities. A person in the directory may be a research candidate rather than an ancestor. Family roots describe historical context, not additional biological parents.
Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Nancy McNew and parents; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew; Grand River Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1850 census transcription
Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: William McNew and parents; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew; Grand River Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1850 census transcription; Osage Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1860 census transcription
Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: John Biser McNew and parents; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew; Grand River Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1850 census transcription; Osage Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1860 census transcription
Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Henry McNew and parents; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew; Deepwater Cemetery transcription: John S. McNew and Sarah A. Willoughby
Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Frederick McNew and parents; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew; Grand River Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1850 census transcription; Osage Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1860 census transcription
Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Elisha McNeil and parents; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew; Grand River Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1850 census transcription; Osage Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1860 census transcription
Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: James R. McNew and parents; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew; Osage Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1860 census transcription
Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Mary McNew and parents; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew; Osage Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1860 census transcription
Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Susan A. McNew and parents; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew; Osage Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1860 census transcription
Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Sally A. McNew and parents; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew; Osage Township, Henry County, Missouri: 1860 census transcription
Sources: Deepwater Cemetery transcription: John S. McNew and Sarah A. Willoughby; Cook Family Ancestry: John S. McNew, 1806-1876; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew
marriage — 8 November 1839 — Pettis County, Missouri; Sarah A. Lusby (reported; formerly Willoughby).
Sources: Deepwater Cemetery transcription: John S. McNew and Sarah A. Willoughby; Cook Family Ancestry: John S. McNew, 1806-1876; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew
John S. McNew is independently placed in the Deepwater, Henry County, Missouri family by a cemetery transcription and two genealogical reconstructions. They agree on death on 1 January 1876, the 8 November 1839 Pettis County marriage, and later Henry County residence. They disagree about his birth location and the surname of his wife.
The Nathan McNew page proposes John McNew and Sarah Athey as parents, but the stronger adult-identity evidence does not by itself prove that parentage.
burial: status source_backed; confidence 0.95.
The available source is a cemetery transcription rather than a marker image. It establishes the death date and Deepwater burial context, but the exact original inscription and transfer documentation have not been inspected.
residence_and_household: status circumstantial; confidence 0.86.
residence and household — Reported to have acquired land in Rives (later Henry) County in 1840 and to appear in Henry County censuses in 1850, 1860, and 1870 — 1840–1870 — Rives and Henry counties, Missouri, United States
Sources: Cook Family Ancestry: John S. McNew, 1806-1876; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew
These published reconstructions cite the underlying land and census records, but the original entries were not available for direct review in this pass. The claim is useful context for the established Deepwater identity and not proof of his earlier parentage.
parent_identity_evidence: status circumstantial; confidence 0.78.
parent identity evidence — Nathan McNew's genealogy proposes John McNew and Sarah Athey as the parents of John S. McNew — 1806–1806
Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew
The cited adult records support John S. McNew's later Missouri identity, but none reviewed here names John McNew or Sarah Athey as his parents. Both parent links remain visible as circumstantial claims.
birth_date_conflict: status circumstantial; confidence 0.75.
birth date conflict — Reported birth is 15 November 1806, but sources disagree between North Carolina and Claiborne County, Tennessee; the cemetery age also implies about 1805 — about 1805–15 Nov 1806 — North Carolina or Claiborne County, Tennessee, United States
Sources: Deepwater Cemetery transcription: John S. McNew and Sarah A. Willoughby; Cook Family Ancestry: John S. McNew, 1806-1876; Nathan McNew genealogy: John S. McNew
The reported 15 November date is retained as the best current claim, but neither location nor year is treated as settled. A birth, Bible, pension, or early census record is needed to resolve the discrepancy.
documented_life_span: status source_backed; confidence 0.94.
local_historical_context: status context_only; confidence 0.85.
Parent candidate / recorded parent: John McNew — Nathan McNew's genealogy proposes John McNew as parent of John S. McNew. John S.'s later Missouri identity is now well supported independently, but no reviewed record directly names this older John as his father; the 0.78 link remains circumstantial.
Parent candidate / recorded parent: Sarah Athey — Nathan McNew's genealogy proposes Sarah Athey as parent of John S. McNew. John S.'s later Missouri identity is now well supported independently, but no reviewed record directly names Sarah Athey as his mother; the 0.78 link remains circumstantial.
Child: Hugh McNew — Nathan McNew's genealogy names Hugh as John S. McNew's child. This remains a compiled family claim; the stronger evidence for John S.'s adult identity does not independently establish the child link.
Child: Nancy McNew — The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 census transcription places Nancy McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported.
Child: William McNew — The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place William McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported.
Child: John Biser McNew — The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place John Biser McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported.
Child: Henry McNew — The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The cemetery transcription records Henry’s birth on 22January1848 and death on 31December1848, with his grave moved from McNew Cemetery in1980 alongside the family graves. This supports his identity and family association, although that entry does not name his parents. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported.
Child: Frederick McNew — The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place Frederick McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported.
Child: Elisha McNeil — The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1850 and 1860 census transcriptions place Elisha McNeil with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The ages differ: two months in1850 and eight years in1860, against the compiled birth about1851. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported.
Child: James R. McNew — The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places James R. McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The1860 entry gives James R. as five and female; the compiled profile gives a male born about1853. The distinctive household favors the identification, but both discrepancies need checking against the manuscript. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported.
Child: Mary McNew — The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places Mary McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported.
Child: Susan A. McNew — The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places Susan A. McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported.
Child: Sally A. McNew — The individual compiled profile names John S. McNew and Sarah Lusby as parents. The 1860 census transcription places Sally A. McNew with John and Sarah in Henry County, Missouri, among the matching siblings. The censuses do not state kinship. The named parentage best explains the combined evidence; another relative or ward in the household remains possible without being independently documented. Sarah’s reported earlier Willoughby marriage explains that surname; her natal Lusby attribution is retained as reported.
Partner: Sarah A. Lusby (reported; formerly Willoughby) — All three sources place John S. McNew in a marriage at Pettis County, Missouri on 8 November 1839. The Nathan McNew tree calls the wife Sarah Lusby; the Deepwater cemetery transcription and Cook genealogy call her Sarah A. Willoughby. The relationship is retained as probable, with Willoughby currently the better-supported surname, pending the original marriage entry.