Elizabeth "Betty" McNew

Profile ID: HV4_ELIZABETH_MCNEW_1798_BEFORE_1847. Status: researched_candidate.

Birth
1798 — reported Washington County, Virginia, United States
Death
before 1847 — reported Brown County, Illinois, United States

Biography

reported life span — This profile reports a birth 1798 in reported Washington County, Virginia, United States; a death before 1847 in reported Brown County, Illinois, United States. — 1798–before 1847 — reported Washington County, Virginia, United States

Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Elizabeth "Betty" McNew and Luke Perry; Cook Ancestry family group: John McNew, Sarah Athey, and Elizabeth "Betsy" McNew; Perry Cemetery transcription: Elisha Perry, 1818-1889; Ancestry public-tree conflict: Luke Perry and Elizabeth White

Historical context

local historical context — The reported 1814 marriage was in a recently formed East Tennessee county shaped by the Cumberland Gap and the Powell Valley settlement corridor — 1814–1814 — Claiborne County, Tennessee, United States

Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Elizabeth "Betty" McNew and Luke Perry; Cook Ancestry family group: John McNew, Sarah Athey, and Elizabeth "Betsy" McNew; Tennessee Encyclopedia: Claiborne County

local historical context — Her reported final locality, Brown County, was created from Schuyler County in 1839; Elkhorn was one of its townships — 1839–before 1847 — Brown County, Illinois, United States

Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Elizabeth "Betty" McNew and Luke Perry; Cook Ancestry family group: John McNew, Sarah Athey, and Elizabeth "Betsy" McNew; Illinois State Archives: Brown County administrative history and records

Family relationships

This tree includes proposed relationships as well as established ones. Link confidence scores are research assessments, not calibrated statistical probabilities. A person in the directory may be a research candidate rather than an ancestor. Family roots describe historical context, not additional biological parents.

Sources

Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Elizabeth "Betty" McNew and Luke Perry; Cook Ancestry family group: John McNew, Sarah Athey, and Elizabeth "Betsy" McNew; Perry Cemetery transcription: Elisha Perry, 1818-1889; Ancestry public-tree conflict: Luke Perry and Elizabeth White

Research notes

Nathan McNew and Cook independently reconstruct Elizabeth "Betty" McNew as Luke Perry's wife. A Brown County cemetery transcription calls their son Elisha the son of Luke Perry and Betty McNew, strongly corroborating the couple. A public Ancestry tree instead calls the wife Elizabeth White while repeating the same apparent Luke Perry and children; it has no accessible original citation.

McNew is the better-supported identity, but the 1814 marriage and her proposed parents remain circumstantial until an original record is reviewed.

family_record: status circumstantial; confidence 0.88.

family record — Recorded as "Betty McNew," mother of Elisha Perry — 1818–1818 — Brown County, Illinois, United States

Sources: Perry Cemetery transcription: Elisha Perry, 1818-1889; Nathan McNew genealogy: Elizabeth "Betty" McNew and Luke Perry; Cook Ancestry family group: John McNew, Sarah Athey, and Elizabeth "Betsy" McNew

The cemetery transcription does not give Betty's maiden surname. Nathan McNew and Cook independently identify her as Elizabeth "Betty" McNew.

reported_vital_claim: status circumstantial; confidence 0.76.

reported vital claim — Reported born in 1798 in Washington County, Virginia, and dead about 1844 or before 1847 in Brown County, Illinois — 1798–before 1847 — Virginia and Illinois, United States

Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Elizabeth "Betty" McNew and Luke Perry; Cook Ancestry family group: John McNew, Sarah Athey, and Elizabeth "Betsy" McNew

The sources agree on the broad life framework but not the death year: Cook says about 1844; Nathan McNew says before 1847. These dates and locations remain reported rather than proven.

local_historical_context: status context_only; confidence 0.84.

This gives geographic context for the reported marriage location; it does not establish an exact residence, migration route, or socioeconomic status.

local_historical_context: status context_only; confidence 0.84.

The source explains the county framework and record setting. It does not prove that Elizabeth lived continuously in Brown County.

identity_conflict: status circumstantial; confidence 0.78.

identity conflict — One public tree calls Luke Perry's wife Elizabeth White; two compatible family reconstructions and a cemetery transcription instead support Betty McNew — 1814–1889 — Tennessee and Illinois, United States

Sources: Ancestry public-tree conflict: Luke Perry and Elizabeth White; Nathan McNew genealogy: Elizabeth "Betty" McNew and Luke Perry; Cook Ancestry family group: John McNew, Sarah Athey, and Elizabeth "Betsy" McNew; Perry Cemetery transcription: Elisha Perry, 1818-1889

The accessible Ancestry view has no original citation for White. The McNew conclusion is stronger but still awaits the original marriage, census, probate, or marker image.

identity_limitation: status source_backed; confidence 0.99.

identity limitation — The Luke Perry and Elisha Perry evidence is retained to assess Elizabeth's identity, but no new spouse or descendant profile is added during the current non-collateral pass — 1814–1889 — Tennessee and Illinois, United States

Sources: Nathan McNew genealogy: Elizabeth "Betty" McNew and Luke Perry; Cook Ancestry family group: John McNew, Sarah Athey, and Elizabeth "Betsy" McNew; Perry Cemetery transcription: Elisha Perry, 1818-1889

The documented family material remains available for a future collateral-relative pass. This current audit strengthens Elizabeth's existing profile and parent-link assessment without expanding the normal web tree.

reported_life_span: status reported; confidence 0.84.

This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates.

Parent candidate / recorded parent: John McNew — Nathan McNew and Cook both place Elizabeth with John McNew and Sarah Athey. The cemetery transcription corroborates Elizabeth's adult Perry identity, but it does not name her parents. Both parent links remain the best current circumstantial placement rather than direct proof.

Parent candidate / recorded parent: Sarah Athey — Nathan McNew and Cook both place Elizabeth with John McNew and Sarah Athey. The cemetery transcription corroborates Elizabeth's adult Perry identity, but it does not name her parents. Both parent links remain the best current circumstantial placement rather than direct proof.