Profile ID: C_SCHAAF_JOHANNES_ABT1821. Status: candidate_harvested.
reported life span — This profile reports a birth about 1821 in Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany. — about 1821 — Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany
Sources: 1880 United States Federal Census: John Schaaf household, Newark
This tree includes proposed relationships as well as established ones. Link confidence scores are research assessments, not calibrated statistical probabilities. A person in the directory may be a research candidate rather than an ancestor. Family roots describe historical context, not additional biological parents.
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau: relationship-to-householder question began in 1880
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau: relationship-to-householder question began in 1880
Sources: 1880 United States Federal Census: John Schaaf household, Newark
Family roots: Schaaf
Historical context, not a parent.
Newark, New Jersey; Hesse-Darmstadt birthplace reported
John Schaef, a tailor aged 48 in Newark’s Sixth Ward in 1870, closely matches John Schaaf, a widowed tailor aged 59 at 390 Eighth Street in 1880. Both were born in Hesse-Darmstadt. The supplied census excerpts identify neither his parents nor a German birth village, so his ancestry currently stops with this immigrant household.
A German index names Johannes Schaaf and Anna Elisabetha Gunder as parents of Johannes Ludwig, while a New Jersey birth index names John Schaaf and a mother indexed as Gunter. These are concrete clues to a connected family, but the supplied index excerpts lack event dates needed to compare the children. The German father’s identity as the Newark tailor remains unresolved. A different Schaaf household is an alternative, not a documented contradiction; matching names alone cannot settle which household the indexes describe.
meaning: German Schaaf is a variant of Schaf, which the surname dictionary explains as an occupational name for a herdsman, derived from the word for sheep. This does not imply that this particular ancestor was a shepherd.
origins: John’s census birthplace supports a Hessian origin. The supplied German index is associated with Billertshausen, but that identifies the indexed record’s locality rather than proving where the Newark man was born. The independent Dutch surname explanation, from a carpenter’s plane, does not establish Dutch ancestry for him.
associations: In Newark the family name occurs as Schaef in 1870 and Schaaf in 1880. The matching tailor’s occupation, approximate age and Hessian origin support continuity across these spellings. Earlier Schaaf millers at Ober-Gleen belong to a separate candidate branch in the tree; no record yet joins the tailor to that household.
Johannes (John) Schaaf: identity-specific historical search limit — dates/local chronology unresolved — Newark, New Jersey; Hesse-Darmstadt birthplace reported — The root research record states: John Schaef, a tailor aged 48 in Newark’s Sixth Ward in 1870, closely matches John Schaaf, a widowed tailor aged 59 at 390 Eighth Street in 1880. Both were born in Hesse-Darmstadt. The supplied census excerpts identify neither his parents nor a German birth village, so his ancestry currently stops with this immigrant household. No separate earlier name-bearer or local historical event is attached here because the available evidence does not identify one for this person. — This row records the boundary of the current investigation; it is not evidence that no related bearer or event exists. — An undocumented namesake, spelling variant, or unsearched local record remains possible where the branch limit leaves the identity open. — The endpoint retains its explicit stopping reason and cited sources without adding an unsupported historical connection.
Sources: 1880 United States Federal Census: John Schaaf household, Newark; Schaaf: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003, 2006), via FamilySearch; Schaf: Dictionary of American Family Names (2003, 2006), via FamilySearch; Reddit genealogy discussion: Schaaf miller family of Ober-Gleen (2023)
Sources: 1880 United States Federal Census: John Schaaf household, Newark
The proposed identity with Johannes Schaaf, spouse of Anna Elisabetha Gunder and father of Johannes Ludwig, remains unproved. The 1870 John Schaef and 1880 widowed John Schaaf are a strong identity match: born about 1821-1822 in Hesse-Darmstadt, Newark tailor. Available records provide limited biographical detail.
reported_life_span: status reported; confidence 0.88.
This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates.
Child: Justin Schaef — Inferred child in the 1870 household. 15 September 2026 review: The supplied 1870 transcript infers a child from household placement; the original schedule did not ask relationship to head. Age, surname and household context support a plausible family, but do not directly establish this parent. Retain as supported circumstantial evidence. No new parent-identifying record was found in this search. Jost, age 26 in 1880, is a possible continuation of Justin, age 16 in 1870; identity and relationship must be checked in the full 1880 return before adding corroborative weight.
Child: Elizzie Schaef — Inferred child in the 1870 household. 15 September 2026 review: The supplied 1870 transcript infers a child from household placement; the original schedule did not ask relationship to head. Age, surname and household context support a plausible family, but do not directly establish this parent. Retain as supported circumstantial evidence. No new parent-identifying record was found in this search.
Partner: Anna Elisabetha Gonder — Lutheran index explicitly names Johannes Schaaf as Anna Elisabetha Gunder Schaaf's spouse.
Partner: Elizabeth Schaef — Elizabeth is John Schaef's inferred spouse in 1870; the probable same John was widowed in 1880.