Jane Butt

Profile ID: C_BUTT_JANE_WIFE_ROBERT_D1676. Status: source_backed.

Death
after 1 Nov 1675 — reported Norfolk County, Virginia

Biography

probate — Named wife of Robert Butt in his will — 1 Nov 1675–3 Jul 1676 — Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America

documented life span — Died after 1 Nov 1675 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia. — after 1 Nov 1675 — reported Norfolk County, Virginia

Sources: Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Updated generation 14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Connected generation-14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; True-frontier generation-14 evidence review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-14 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026; Provenance review of the Butt-Bruce-Warrenton Hall family legend; Frederick A. Virkus, The Abridged Compendium of American Genealogy, volume 1 (1925), pages 525 and 970; WikiTree profile Butt-441: Robert Butt of Lower Norfolk County; Colonial Williamsburg, object 1989-34: Sampler by Sarah Bruce Butt; Ted Butts, 10 July 2000 online report of a family tree on the reverse of Sarah Bruce Butt's sampler; Mary Elizabeth Cumming Bruce, Family Records of the Bruces and the Cumyns (1870), Bruces of Earlshall, pp. 332-333; User-supplied compiled biography of alleged Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce Butt

Historical context

local historical context — Her husband's will places her within the Southern Branch landholding household and names its four sons — 1675–1676 — Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America

Family relationships

This tree includes proposed relationships as well as established ones. Link confidence scores are research assessments, not calibrated statistical probabilities. A person in the directory may be a research candidate rather than an ancestor. Family roots describe historical context, not additional biological parents.

Family roots

Family roots: Name unresolved

Historical context, not a parent.

Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Lower Norfolk County, Virginia

Jane is securely identified as Robert Butt’s wife and chosen executrix in his will of 1 November 1675. Neither the inspected abstract nor the fuller published transcription names her parents or birth surname.

The proposed Earlshall identity depends on connecting Jane with Elizabeth Bruce, styled Lady Durie in an 1870 pedigree. That account places her father Alexander’s death around 1599–1600, while copied trees give her a 1605 birth. A mistaken date or remarriage remains possible, but no record inspected joins the Scottish woman to the Virginia household.

meaning: Butt is Jane’s married surname in the will. It cannot supply the meaning of her unidentified birth name.

origins: The record places Jane’s household on the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River. It does not state where she was born.

associations: Bruce appears in Sarah Bruce Butt’s name on an 1811 family sampler now at Colonial Williamsburg. This provides dated evidence for the naming tradition behind the later Scottish claim. The sampler’s published inscription names Sarah’s parents, not Jane’s.

Jane’s place in the Southern Branch household — 1 November 1675; will proved 3 July 1676 — Lower Norfolk County, Virginia — Robert’s will names sons Henry, Robert, Thomas and Richard and appoints Jane executrix. The fuller transcription gives her use of the movable estate during her life, followed by division among his children. — These provisions establish Jane’s role in this specific household. The abstract also names beneficiary Arthur Sayer and witnesses John Edwards, Margere Alexander alias Sharp, and Richard Odien. — The sons could all be Jane’s children, or some could come from an earlier marriage. The other named people could be relatives or associates. — The will directly establishes the marriage. Maternity and relationships to the witnesses need separate evidence; none of their surnames is adopted as Jane’s birth name.

The Bruce tradition and Sarah’s sampler — 1811; reverse-pedigree report attributed to 2000 — Virginia; alleged connection to Earlshall, Fife — Colonial Williamsburg identifies Sarah Bruce Butt as the daughter of Nathaniel and Frances Butt. An online report recorded in the earlier family research describes an undated pedigree on the sampler’s reverse associating Robert’s wife with Earlshall. — An inherited Bruce connection is one possible explanation for the repeated family name. — Bruce could have entered through another ancestor or a commemorative name. The reported reverse pedigree could preserve older knowledge or a later genealogical reconstruction. — The naming tradition is documented; its application to Jane remains uncertain. The reverse annotation’s wording, date and authorship would help distinguish those explanations. A reported list of two sons is not counted against the claim without knowing that it intended to list every child.

Sources: McIntosh: Robert Butt’s will, 1675–1676, abstract page 48; WikiTree Unknown-728366: transcription of Robert Butt’s will; Mary Elizabeth Cumming Bruce, Family Records of the Bruces and the Cumyns (1870), Bruces of Earlshall, pp. 332-333; Ted Butts, 10 July 2000 online report of a family tree on the reverse of Sarah Bruce Butt's sampler; Colonial Williamsburg, object 1989-34: Sampler by Sarah Bruce Butt

Sources

Sources: Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Updated generation 14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Connected generation-14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; True-frontier generation-14 evidence review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-14 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026; Provenance review of the Butt-Bruce-Warrenton Hall family legend; Frederick A. Virkus, The Abridged Compendium of American Genealogy, volume 1 (1925), pages 525 and 970; WikiTree profile Butt-441: Robert Butt of Lower Norfolk County; Colonial Williamsburg, object 1989-34: Sampler by Sarah Bruce Butt; Ted Butts, 10 July 2000 online report of a family tree on the reverse of Sarah Bruce Butt's sampler; Mary Elizabeth Cumming Bruce, Family Records of the Bruces and the Cumyns (1870), Bruces of Earlshall, pp. 332-333; User-supplied compiled biography of alleged Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce Butt; McIntosh: Robert Butt’s will, 1675–1676, abstract page 48; WikiTree Unknown-728366: transcription of Robert Butt’s will

Research notes

Robert Butt’s will names Jane as his wife and executrix. Sarah Bruce Butt’s 1811 sampler documents a later family use of Bruce.

Her birth surname and parents remain unresolved. A reported reverse pedigree associates Jane with Earlshall, but its wording, date and author remain unverified. A wrong birth date or remarriage is possible, but neither identifies Jane. The reported two-son list is not used as contrary evidence without knowing whether it was exhaustive. The Earlshall table calls Alexander Bruce’s daughter Elizabeth, Lady Durie, and places his death around 1599–1600, incompatible with the copied 1605 birth if both dates are retained. Jane’s alleged death on 3 July 1676 is her husband’s probate date, not a verified death record for her.

probate: status source_backed; confidence 0.995.

The will does not support Bruce or any other maiden surname and does not explicitly state maternity.

local_historical_context: status source_backed; confidence 0.995.

The will proves she was Robert's wife but does not prove that she owned the land, mothered every son, or bore the surname Bruce.

frontier_stopping_point: status source_backed; confidence 0.91.

frontier stopping point — This ancestry line stops because Robert Butt's will calls his wife only Jane; later Bruce surnames are unsupported and the will does not explicitly establish that she was mother of every named son.

Sources: Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Updated generation 14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Connected generation-14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; True-frontier generation-14 evidence review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-14 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026

This statement records why no earlier parent relationship is currently attached; it should be revised if new documentary evidence resolves the limitation.

occupation_status: status unresolved; confidence 0.99.

occupation status — No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited

Sources: Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Updated generation 14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Connected generation-14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; True-frontier generation-14 evidence review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-14 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026

This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant.

education_status: status unresolved; confidence 0.99.

education status — No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established

Sources: Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Updated generation 14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Connected generation-14 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; True-frontier generation-14 evidence review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-14 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026

This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training.

disputed_origin_tradition: status disputed; confidence 0.15.

disputed origin tradition — An authentic 1811 sampler shows Bruce as descendant Sarah Bruce Butt's middle name; a 2000 message reports an undated reverse pedigree calling Robert's wife Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce of Earlshall — reported Fife, Scotland

Sources: Colonial Williamsburg, object 1989-34: Sampler by Sarah Bruce Butt; Ted Butts, 10 July 2000 online report of a family tree on the reverse of Sarah Bruce Butt's sampler; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Provenance review of the Butt-Bruce-Warrenton Hall family legend

The stitched sampler gives positive evidence of Bruce in the later family’s naming tradition. It does not identify which ancestor introduced that name. The reported reverse pedigree remains undated and unattributed in the available catalogue. Its selection of two sons is not a demonstrated contradiction to Robert’s four-son will.

alternative_identity_hypothesis: status disputed; confidence 0.05.

alternative identity hypothesis — Reported as Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce of Earlshall — reported Earlshall, Fife, Scotland

Sources: User-supplied compiled biography of alleged Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce Butt; Ted Butts, 10 July 2000 online report of a family tree on the reverse of Sarah Bruce Butt's sampler; Colonial Williamsburg, object 1989-34: Sampler by Sarah Bruce Butt; Mary Elizabeth Cumming Bruce, Family Records of the Bruces and the Cumyns (1870), Bruces of Earlshall, pp. 332-333

The Earlshall table styles the proposed daughter Elizabeth, Lady Durie. A remarriage could reconcile different husbands, but that possibility does not itself identify her as Jane Butt. Alexander’s reported death around 1599–1600 also conflicts with the copied 1605 birth. The particular Earlshall identification remains a low-confidence alternative; broader Bruce ancestry has not been disproved.

alternative_birth_hypothesis: status disputed; confidence 0.03.

alternative birth hypothesis — Reported born in 1605 at Earlshall Castle — reported 1605 — reported Earlshall Castle, Fife, Scotland

Sources: User-supplied compiled biography of alleged Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce Butt; Mary Elizabeth Cumming Bruce, Family Records of the Bruces and the Cumyns (1870), Bruces of Earlshall, pp. 332-333

No baptism or contemporary record identifies Robert Butt's wife Jane with this birth. The place and year should be used only when searching for the origin of the copied claim.

alternative_marriage_hypothesis: status disputed; confidence 0.02.

alternative marriage hypothesis — Reported marriage to Robert Butt circa 1629 in England — reported circa 1629 — reported England

Sources: User-supplied compiled biography of alleged Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce Butt

No parish or license is given. This date conflicts with other versions reporting marriage about 1643 and would make Robert only about fourteen or fifteen under the circa-1614 birth tradition.

rejected_death_claim: status disputed; confidence 0.01.

rejected death claim — Reported death on 3 July 1676 — reported 3 Jul 1676 — reported Norfolk County, Virginia

Sources: User-supplied compiled biography of alleged Elizabeth Jane Ann Bruce Butt

Robert's will was proved on 3 July 1676. That event does not establish Jane's death on the same day. Her documented endpoint remains alive when named in Robert's will on 1 November 1675.

documented_life_span: status source_backed; confidence 0.91.

Child: Richard Butt the Elder — Jane was Robert's wife when his 1675 will named son Richard. She is chronologically and contextually the likely mother, but maternity is inferential and her maiden name is unknown.

Partner: Robert Butt of the Southern Branch — The relationship is directly stated in Robert Butt's will made 1 Nov 1675 and proved 3 Jul 1676.