Archibald McElroy, claimed father of John

Profile ID: CANDIDATE_ARCHIBALD_MCELROY_PARENT_JOHN_1690. Status: candidate_compiled.

Family relationships

This tree includes proposed relationships as well as established ones. Link confidence scores are research assessments, not calibrated statistical probabilities. A person in the directory may be a research candidate rather than an ancestor. Family roots describe historical context, not additional biological parents.

Family roots

Family roots: McElroy

Historical context, not a parent.

Baltimore County through proposed son; Archibald’s residence unestablished

Archibald appears as John McElroy’s father in a compiled pedigree, while another pedigree gives Patrick MacElroy. No inspected record resolves whether these are alternate names, different men, or a mistaken family assignment. Archibald remains the displayed low-confidence candidate; his dates, birthplace and own parents are unidentified.

The Baltimore County records described below concern John’s later household. They locate the family under investigation without establishing where the proposed older generation lived. The later Archibald whose 1760 will names brother William must not be silently identified with this father candidate.

meaning: The Irish Mac Giolla Rua and Scottish Mac Gille Ruaidh underlie the Anglicized name: a patronymic referring to a red-haired young man.

origins: Both Irish and Scottish origins are recognized in the dictionary.

associations: The dictionary points to Gilroy and Kilroy as names to compare when examining the linguistic background.

meaning: McElroy is an Anglicized form of Irish Mac Giolla Rua or Scottish Gaelic Mac Gille Ruaidh, meaning son of the red-haired lad. The description belongs to the surname’s formation, not a documented physical characteristic of Archibald.

origins: The dictionary recognizes both Irish and Scottish origins for the name. The compiled Irish-origin claim for this candidate has not been tied to a specific parish, migration record or household.

associations: Gilroy and Kilroy belong to the dictionary’s comparison group for the same Gaelic name elements. These linguistic associations do not establish that families using the different spellings share a recent ancestor.

John McElroy’s Baltimore County family and land — 1713–1732 — Baltimore County, Maryland — Ed Phelps’s published research reports Rachel’s 1713 birth to John and Francis McElroy, John’s 1725 survey of Rachel’s Delight, and his 1732 sale of John’s Beginning, witnessed by Avinton Felps. — The daughter, land and witness network form a specific family cluster from which to investigate John’s origins and the proposed older McElroy generation. — Archibald or Patrick might belong to that family, or either parent name might result from a compiled-tree error. The later records do not name John’s father. — Useful family-and-place evidence reported from parish and deed records; it supports the research locality but does not select an older parent. The underlying originals have not been inspected in this review.

Sources: Compiled McElroy pedigree claims and internal conflicts; Nash family pedigree: Patrick MacElroy proposed father of John; Baltimore County Felps research: Rachel McElroy baptism and McElroy deed network; Arch Mackleroy will, Johnston County will book, pages 751–752; McElroy: Dictionary of American Family Names, second edition (2022) via Ancestry

Sources

Sources: Compiled McElroy pedigree claims and internal conflicts

Research notes

One compiled online pedigree calls an Archibald McElroy the father of the Baltimore County John McElroy who was later associated with Rachel McElroy and the Felps family. Archibald is shown only as the leading named candidate (ordinal score 0.12), not as established ancestry. Its reported Irish origin and dates are not retained because the tree conflicts with itself. It gives no parish, probate, deed, immigration, or other record linking the men.

Child: John McElroy — H1: Archibald was John McElroy's father. A compatible compiled claim preserves this candidate, with no inspected record identifying the parent. H2: the father was Patrick MacElroy, as named in another compiled pedigree; whether this is a different man, alternate name, or pedigree conflation is unresolved. A merged Archibald Patrick name elsewhere does not resolve the identity. Neither name claim independently establishes Irish origins. The later Archibald will names brother William but does not identify their father. Keep the parent link candidate_compiled at ordinal score 0.12; hypothetical namesakes and access failures are not negative evidence. Next discriminator: contemporary record identifying John's parent, plus tracing the underlying citations for both name claims.

Partner: Rachel Durham, claimed mother of John — The compiled pedigree presents Archibald McElroy and Rachel Durham as a parental couple. It supplies no marriage event or record. The alternative is that one or both names were copied from another McElroy family; this is a relationship hypothesis with ordinal score 0.10 only.